Being a Libertarian in Today's United States
In a recent discussion tangent, another TR member (thank you, vanessa@...) posted a link to a Libertarian Web site .....
http://www.theihs.org/category.php/142.html
.....that offered definitions and explanations of how different people viewed what it means to be a libertarian. I think it's a great Web site, and probably not a coincidence that it's sponsored by an organization hosted by George Mason University, home to one of my favorite "libertarian mentors", the distinguished professor of economics, Dr. Walter Williams. And George Mason, himself, for those who may not know, is probably the oft' forgotten "founding father"; his efforts were not only instrumental, but absolutely vital in writing and including what is probably considered the most important part of the U.S. Constitution, the first ten amendments, formally known as the Bill of Rights. George Mason's [i]Virginia Declaration of Rights[/i] was the model for the [i]U.S. Bill of Rights[/i]. He not only wrote the aforementioned document, but insisted its contents be included in the new United States Constitution. Without George Mason, who knows how the United States would have progressed?
(Note and disclaimer: An entire book could be written on the origins of any "Bill of Rights" document, and this is not intended to explore that avenue. Feel free, however, to include any information you think is missing and/or could be of interest. I will say this, however, as clarification and a disclaimer. George Mason modeled his Virginia Declaration of Rights (1776) on the [i]English Bill of Rights (1689),[/i] which was modeled, in part, on the Magna Carta, and perhaps other historical documents as well. The difference, however, at least as I understand it, is that the [i]English Bill of Rights[/i] suggested that such individual liberty is endowed to the people by the crown, while the [i]United States Bill of Rights and Constitution[/i] suggested that such individual liberty is endowed to the people by the Creator, and that no "man-formed" government or monarchy could ever deny those rights. A person or government, in essence, can't take away that which it does not have the power or the authority to give.)
The definition that I believe is the closest to defining the true libertarian principle is this: [i][b]"The libertarian, or 'classical liberal', perspective is that individual well-being, prosperity, and social harmony are fostered by 'as much liberty as possible' and 'as little government as necessary'."[/i][/b] Obviously, the sentiment most debated and/or viewed differently is, [i]as much as possible,[/i] and [i]as little as necessary[/i]. I wonder if George Mason, himself, or Thomas Jefferson, or James Madison ever uttered such a sentiment? If they didn't say those exact words, their actions (and other words) certainly enforced and emulated them. (See quotes below.)
For the first 150 years of its existence, the United States of America dedicated itself to the principles of individual liberty. Even in considering the nation's historical shortcomings, such as slavery and the suppression of women's rights, the underlying principle of individual liberty was the driving force that instituted change. Unfortunately, today, while there are no slaves to individual "masters", we are all slaves, of sorts, to all the other masters. When the fruits of one's labor is taken, by force, only to be given to another who did not labor, that's tantamount to institutionalized slavery. In the very least, it's contrary to the basic principle of individual liberty.
Being a true libertarian in today's United States (and today's world, or so it seems) is like being the odd-man out. I've debated the issue on numerous occasions, and have heard things like, [i]no man is an island[/i], or other such sentiments. Or I've heard things like, [i]what will happen if all taxes are abolished?[/i] But these retorts only show how being a libertarian is misunderstood. Of course, it goes without saying, greater things can be accomplished together rather than alone; but that's doesn't mean teamwork is synonymous with a collective. In fact, any "collective" society throughout history has either faltered or failed. And any "individualist" society throughout history has excelled -- until, that is, it became a collective. And, of course, no rational libertarian is advancing the abolition of all taxes, but only those that support social programs, not the ones that support the true functions of government and the defense of our nation. And then there's the "caring" argument. People advocate government give-away programs under the guise of "caring". These people don't really "care", however, but instead they only want to maintain the appearance of "caring", or they've been duped into such a false sense of "caring".
Any and all collective systems in the United States have either failed or are well on their way to failing. Do you believe, for example, for even a minute, that the current Social Security system is either fair or equitable (not to mention "right")? Have you considered that poverty, in both real numbers and percentages, was in a continual decline, every decade of the country's existence, until the "war on poverty" was created? Have you considered that government dependency only creates more government dependency, not less? A democracy (or republic) is doomed to fail, or so it is said, when the people figure out they can vote themselves favors from the public treasury. And one only has to look at all the "favors" Americans have voted themselves over the past six decades to see how individual liberty in America is doomed. I say it's high time we not only reject the growth of any and all "collective" systems in the United States, but turn them around and strive for their eventual elimination.
I sure do feel like the odd-man out, however, and resistance is indeed futile. I will be assimilated, whether I want to be or not. (So much for the concept of individual liberty.)
George Mason, we've failed to uphold the principles upon which our great nation was founded. We've failed to honor the sacrifices made by you, your family, and your countrymen. We've failed to continue the true spirit of the great experiment called the United States of America. And to paraphrase Yogi Berra, George Mason would be turning in his grave if he was alive today to see how we've ruined what he (and others) started. If I could ask you one question, Mr. Mason, it would be this. Is it too late to turn back now; and if not, how can we do it?
More questions:
Why are so many people so afraid to take full advantage of individual liberty?
Why are so many people determined to deny others their individual liberty?
By what right or authority does one person take the fruits of another's labor? (Any time you vote in favor of ANY social program, that is, in essence, exactly what you are doing.)
Who might be the current day "George Mason"?
Is it too late to turn back? If not, how could it be done?
And consider this. If a person stands up for such a principle, and absolutely refuses to "be assimilated" into the "collective", he will not only be considered an odd-ball, and he will not only have lost his individual liberty, but he will also lose his freedom, as he will be arrested and locked up. (So none dare do it, for fear of the government.)
How is it possible we've fallen so far?
Quotes:
[i]When the government fears the people there is liberty; when the people fear the government there is tyranny. - Thomas Jefferson[/i]
[i]"That government is best which governs the least, because its people discipline themselves." - Thomas Jefferson[/i]
[i]"I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them." - Thomas Jefferson[/i]
[i]"To compel a man to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical. - Thomas Jefferson[/i]