Discussion Locked

Being a Libertarian in Today's United States

0 helpful
236 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

In a recent discussion tangent, another TR member (thank you, vanessa@...) posted a link to a Libertarian Web site .....

http://www.theihs.org/category.php/142.html

.....that offered definitions and explanations of how different people viewed what it means to be a libertarian. I think it's a great Web site, and probably not a coincidence that it's sponsored by an organization hosted by George Mason University, home to one of my favorite "libertarian mentors", the distinguished professor of economics, Dr. Walter Williams. And George Mason, himself, for those who may not know, is probably the oft' forgotten "founding father"; his efforts were not only instrumental, but absolutely vital in writing and including what is probably considered the most important part of the U.S. Constitution, the first ten amendments, formally known as the Bill of Rights. George Mason's [i]Virginia Declaration of Rights[/i] was the model for the [i]U.S. Bill of Rights[/i]. He not only wrote the aforementioned document, but insisted its contents be included in the new United States Constitution. Without George Mason, who knows how the United States would have progressed?

(Note and disclaimer: An entire book could be written on the origins of any "Bill of Rights" document, and this is not intended to explore that avenue. Feel free, however, to include any information you think is missing and/or could be of interest. I will say this, however, as clarification and a disclaimer. George Mason modeled his Virginia Declaration of Rights (1776) on the [i]English Bill of Rights (1689),[/i] which was modeled, in part, on the Magna Carta, and perhaps other historical documents as well. The difference, however, at least as I understand it, is that the [i]English Bill of Rights[/i] suggested that such individual liberty is endowed to the people by the crown, while the [i]United States Bill of Rights and Constitution[/i] suggested that such individual liberty is endowed to the people by the Creator, and that no "man-formed" government or monarchy could ever deny those rights. A person or government, in essence, can't take away that which it does not have the power or the authority to give.)

The definition that I believe is the closest to defining the true libertarian principle is this: [i][b]"The libertarian, or 'classical liberal', perspective is that individual well-being, prosperity, and social harmony are fostered by 'as much liberty as possible' and 'as little government as necessary'."[/i][/b] Obviously, the sentiment most debated and/or viewed differently is, [i]as much as possible,[/i] and [i]as little as necessary[/i]. I wonder if George Mason, himself, or Thomas Jefferson, or James Madison ever uttered such a sentiment? If they didn't say those exact words, their actions (and other words) certainly enforced and emulated them. (See quotes below.)

For the first 150 years of its existence, the United States of America dedicated itself to the principles of individual liberty. Even in considering the nation's historical shortcomings, such as slavery and the suppression of women's rights, the underlying principle of individual liberty was the driving force that instituted change. Unfortunately, today, while there are no slaves to individual "masters", we are all slaves, of sorts, to all the other masters. When the fruits of one's labor is taken, by force, only to be given to another who did not labor, that's tantamount to institutionalized slavery. In the very least, it's contrary to the basic principle of individual liberty.

Being a true libertarian in today's United States (and today's world, or so it seems) is like being the odd-man out. I've debated the issue on numerous occasions, and have heard things like, [i]no man is an island[/i], or other such sentiments. Or I've heard things like, [i]what will happen if all taxes are abolished?[/i] But these retorts only show how being a libertarian is misunderstood. Of course, it goes without saying, greater things can be accomplished together rather than alone; but that's doesn't mean teamwork is synonymous with a collective. In fact, any "collective" society throughout history has either faltered or failed. And any "individualist" society throughout history has excelled -- until, that is, it became a collective. And, of course, no rational libertarian is advancing the abolition of all taxes, but only those that support social programs, not the ones that support the true functions of government and the defense of our nation. And then there's the "caring" argument. People advocate government give-away programs under the guise of "caring". These people don't really "care", however, but instead they only want to maintain the appearance of "caring", or they've been duped into such a false sense of "caring".

Any and all collective systems in the United States have either failed or are well on their way to failing. Do you believe, for example, for even a minute, that the current Social Security system is either fair or equitable (not to mention "right")? Have you considered that poverty, in both real numbers and percentages, was in a continual decline, every decade of the country's existence, until the "war on poverty" was created? Have you considered that government dependency only creates more government dependency, not less? A democracy (or republic) is doomed to fail, or so it is said, when the people figure out they can vote themselves favors from the public treasury. And one only has to look at all the "favors" Americans have voted themselves over the past six decades to see how individual liberty in America is doomed. I say it's high time we not only reject the growth of any and all "collective" systems in the United States, but turn them around and strive for their eventual elimination.

I sure do feel like the odd-man out, however, and resistance is indeed futile. I will be assimilated, whether I want to be or not. (So much for the concept of individual liberty.)

George Mason, we've failed to uphold the principles upon which our great nation was founded. We've failed to honor the sacrifices made by you, your family, and your countrymen. We've failed to continue the true spirit of the great experiment called the United States of America. And to paraphrase Yogi Berra, George Mason would be turning in his grave if he was alive today to see how we've ruined what he (and others) started. If I could ask you one question, Mr. Mason, it would be this. Is it too late to turn back now; and if not, how can we do it?

More questions:

Why are so many people so afraid to take full advantage of individual liberty?

Why are so many people determined to deny others their individual liberty?

By what right or authority does one person take the fruits of another's labor? (Any time you vote in favor of ANY social program, that is, in essence, exactly what you are doing.)

Who might be the current day "George Mason"?

Is it too late to turn back? If not, how could it be done?

And consider this. If a person stands up for such a principle, and absolutely refuses to "be assimilated" into the "collective", he will not only be considered an odd-ball, and he will not only have lost his individual liberty, but he will also lose his freedom, as he will be arrested and locked up. (So none dare do it, for fear of the government.)

How is it possible we've fallen so far?

Quotes:

[i]When the government fears the people there is liberty; when the people fear the government there is tyranny. - Thomas Jefferson[/i]

[i]"That government is best which governs the least, because its people discipline themselves." - Thomas Jefferson[/i]

[i]"I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them." - Thomas Jefferson[/i]

[i]"To compel a man to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical. - Thomas Jefferson[/i]

236 replies

by maxwell edison

I strongly suspect, in fact I'm convinced (without proof), that the current immigration debate (the "silent debate") is tied into the probability of a total Social Security system collapse. Our illustrious elected officials don't dare touch the social security problems. For if they do, our equally illustrious voters will remove them from office (or not put them there to begin with).

I've heard estimates upwards of tens of millions of people being redefined from illegal to legal immigrant status. Am I the only one who suspects that this unprecedented allowance for immigration is for the sole purpose of shoring-up the eventual failure of Social Security? The "boomer generation", people who have paid the most but stand to gain the least, will be retiring in droves in the coming years. They (we) will all be expecting an equitable return on their (our) investment. (See note below.) It has to come from somewhere, lest it be denied as promised.

At its beginning, there were upwards of 35 people paying into the Social Security system for every one receiving from it. Today, the ratio is three (or four?) to one. Moreover, their approximate three percent tax was (is) nowhere close to the current fifteen percent SS tax rate. In the very near future, it will be two to one (and at what rate?). When will it be one to two? And who will pay for those people?

If I'm correct in my suspicion, that most politicians favor some sort of amnesty and legalization for those illegals who are already here for the purpose of adding to the tax-base (primarily for the support of Social Security), it will fix nothing, but rather only delay the inevitable.

This is a classic illustration of how a collective system is doomed to fail, and how an "individualist" system, although not perfect, is better than any other alternative.

Note: If I had a choice, I would accept today, a full Social Security refund, in the form of a one-time cash payment, of every dollar I paid into Social Security (plus the dollars paid by employers on my behalf), plus a very reasonable 5 percent annual rate of return, for the understanding that I would never receive ANY Social Security benefits for the rest of my life, regardless of how long that might be. Give me back what I paid, don't take any more, and we'll just call it even.

by stephencairns

I liked your note. Very magnanimous. Reminds me of a Blues song "I never said I was a millionaire, what I said was I have spent more money than a millionaire. If I'd kept all the money I'd spent, I'd be a millionaire a long time ago" sorry cant remember where exactly thats from.

What you are suggesting sounds like utopia. A land where everyone is successfull and can stand on there own 2 feet. Truly the American Dream.

But I see no provision for people that can't. Lets ignore the people who won't work for a moment. ( there will always be some) But what about the people who can't?

lets have a really contrived example.
The sucessfull entrepreneur who has worked his way out of the orphanage built up a great company and then is hit by a car and has a stoke on the way to hospital(Paralysed, cant speak), his company goes bankrupt and so inexplicably does his insurance company, he finds his financial adviser has been a bit too entreprenerial and his investments go bad. He 's been too busy with his company to ever get married.
So where does that leave him in your ideology? (hey, I said it was contrived)

by maxwell edison

...and that's the premise on which we might disagree.

I don't see it as the role of government to "provide" for ALL people who either can't or choose not to provide for themselves.

Charities used to provide for people who can't, and kind souls made those charities possible. And necessity forced those others to provide for themselves, the ones who would otherwise choose not to if they didn't have to.

Your way forces others to be "charitable" on your terms. My way makes it a choice for people to be charitable on their own terms.

Your way gives people an excuse to not provide for themselves. My way compels people to provide for themselves.

What did James Mason, Thomas Jefferson, and James Madison say on this issue? Go ahead, answer THAT question. What did they say about it? Were they right, or were they wrong? And why?

by mjwx

But seeing as you did, let me explain max to you (if you don?t know already). This is the same as the "important questions" thread he started a few weeks ago. Different words but the intent is the same. Max either didn?t get the answers he wanted or wants more. Either or, I didn?t want to feed him.

As for your example, Maxwell cares not. But this is the kind of person welfare is there to support. Adsorbing the undesirables (those who don?t want to work) is a necessary evil of helping those who need it.

Max is opposed to any kind of welfare or social program, such as support for University/Collage students and the farm subsidy programs.

I'll for Maxwell's benefit, explain why I think these programs are beneficial. They are not redistributions in wealth as much as investments in the economy. I'll start with students. A well educated workforce produces more high technology goods which have a greater profit margin than low technology goods which need to be produced in large quantity to produce a significant profit. High technology goods are worth more because you need highly educated people to produce them. Higher education means higher wages must be paid which in turn filters back in to the economy as goods and services are purchased. Clear, good.

Farm subsidies. When a primary producer has a bumper crop they have no need for subsidies but when harvests are less than perfect what happens. A farmer gets paid once a year, when he sells his crop. That single payment has to purchase everything he needs for his next crop, pay the wages of his workers for the year (or term of employment) and fill the tank with petrol/put food on the table for a year. What will happen to farms if they go bankrupt? It will become cheaper to import most of if not all food. Now this would mean a boost for Australia?s agricultural industry but it means that it takes 2 to 3 times as long to get food from Aussie farms to Maxwells plate and the price of that plate of food goes up for Maxwell. Let me explain how, regardless of the base product cost it will take longer to import, it has to spend longer in customs and takes away jobs from hard working Yanks. Longer freight = costs more. Longer time in transit = more quality is lost from perishable goods. Fewer jobs in US = less money added to your economy. Buying food from outside US = money leaves US. Still confused?

I'd like to see Social program spending Vs military spending since 1965. War cost more than peace and I'm quiet sure Vietnam racked up quiet a bill (not counting human life, which Mr Edison cannot have a price associated with it). There is one redistribution program that I believe should be abolished which you have made no mention of. Fuel subsidies. The US govt subsidizes the fuel you put in your car, I would very much like the US to pay as much for fuel as other countries (I don?t care weather your fuel price goes up or ours comes down).

by tonythetiger

That's the problem. The bureaucrats can't tell the difference between "can't" and "won't". That's why the decision, and the means, should not be in their hands. There's also the efficiency issue. By the time the money goes into the government and back out, over half of it is gone!

"So where does that leave him in your ideology?"

At the mercy of the good people of the community, exactly where he should be.

by oz_media

More reasons not to support the Bush administration.
[i] When the government fears the people there is liberty; when the people fear the government there is tyranny. - Thomas Jefferson[/i]
The entire planet rightly fears the current US administration and their tactics at seeking what they deem peace.

[i]"That government is best which governs the least, because its people discipline themselves." - Thomas Jefferson[/i]
the current administration believes big brother should monitor the people, not too much rom for self governance when the Electric Eye is always there.

"You think you've private lives
Think nothing of the kind
There is no true escape
Im watching all the time

Im made of metal
My circuits gleam
I am perpetual
I keep the country clean

Im elected electric spy
Im protected electric eye

Always in focus
You cant feel my stare
I zoom into you
You dont know Im there

I take a pride in probing all your secret moves
My tearless retina takes pictures that can prove" - JP - Electric Eye

[i]"I predict future happiness for Americans if they can prevent the government from wasting the labors of the people under the pretense of taking care of them." - Thomas Jefferson"[/i]

I am assuming that you don't find an unjustified invasion utilizing thousands of your military's finest and billions of your citizens tax dollars to be wasting people's labo(u)rs under the pretense of saving them.

"To compel a man to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors is sinful and tyrannical." - Thomas Jefferson

But to take billions in tax dollars from the millions who oppose the war so as to fund the war, is not compelling men to furnish funds for the propagation of ideas he disbelieves and abhors.

Why? Because, it's the USA dammit, the government overrules all, no matter how twisted the story.

I dont see how you could have voted for him twice, especially when you support so many values that Bush doesn't. As you say, you oppose many of his policies, now you support the philosophies he has opposed too.

Yet you call this most unevolved display of blind patriotism your 'CORE VALUES',d that you based your life upon. To further the Bs, you insist others are inconsistent, are on teh fence, are not sure of thier thoughts etc. One thing I am dead form on, I have not supported the war since the beginning because of how it was justified. You can't seem to figure out whether you support the right or left, maybe it's teh middle, hang on...what middle ground?

It was Kerry that you suggest 'flip-flopped' isn't it?

by maxwell edison

I support the Bush administration and what they're doing in the realm of foreign policy and the war on Islamo-Fascism. On the other hand, there's very little that I support on the domestic front. But it's not just the current Bush administration, but Clinton before him, and Bush (41) before him, and even Ronald Reagan, and Jimmy Carter, Gerald Ford, Richard Nixon, and especially Presidents Johnson and Franklin Roosevelt. And the congresses, both Democrat and Republican. And the courts who make policy from the bench instead of interpreting the rule of law of our land as it was intended to be.

So no, I don't "blame" President Bush or the Bush administration as much as I "blame" the aforementioned people -- and the following:

American voters for their narrow-sightedness, and their greed and selfishness for presuming to be entitled to that which they did not earn, and for the short-sightedness they possess for failing to see the stage of failure they have set for future generations.

I "blame" the media for perpetuating such an agenda.

I "blame" the past forty years of Democrat insistence, and Republican capitulation to instill more and more collectivist programs.

I "blame" the rest of the world (Most of it, that is. See note below.) for continuing to try their socialist and collective societies, even though they have failed time and time again.

Note: It's interesting that most of the nations of eastern Europe, the ones who have only recently been freed from the clutches of communism, are almost all following a road that advances more individual liberty and less collectivism.

Your message is a clear illustration of what's wrong with politics and governance today. You look for anything and everything to criticize the "Bush administration"; however, it's not founded in core principle, but rather partisanship, contempt and hate. Why can't people just rest on their principles, and let the chips fall where they may? Maybe it's because they have no principles. Or maybe they haven't really thought about them -- or been taught to think that way. Or maybe it's because they can't justify articulating them.

I'm not a bit surprised that no one is willing to challenge mine with opposing views of their own. Admitting that a person feels justified in taking, by force, if necessary, something that does not belong to them is not only difficult to justify, but probably painful to admit.

by mjwx

as the old say goes "the buck stops here" or more so it stops with the man in charge and that man is Dubya.

Remember that it was Dubya that started the war and wants to start another.

So each man who has died in the conflict has his death attributed to GWB.

As for collectivist societies, the Ancient Greeks conquered the ancient world. They were so collectivist that Alexander had his troops marry the local women to integrate them into Greek society. Militaristic societies destroy other societies Max. Also please explain why china, a communist state is the worlds biggest economy. Go and visit Eastern Europe and see how inaccurate your ?facts? are.

Now I don?t care which side of the political spectrum the US elects, to me they are as bad as each other but get rid of Dubya and his cronies.

Also Max, don?t blame the rest of the world because they don?t agree with you. The US is not under foreign influence. Any hole you are in now is one dug with your own hands.

by oz_media

you are the only one who has principles because you vote for what you believe in. Everyone else is blind and uneducated enough to make rash, thoughtless decisions.

I don't know what country you are hoping to be living in, but you shoul drealize, majority opinion is all that is needed in your most valued system of government. That majority will not always favour your views, in fact I think you will find you are the mionority more often than not.

But hey, it's people's personal hatred for America, all the other countries full of safe, happy citizens that support their government's focus that is the problem.

Since when do other countries have an impact on the US? You do what you want to do when you want to so it and just attack anyone (verbally of physically) who feels otherwise.

Ever heard of democracy, Max? Your core values decribe a dictatorship, of course not your government's dictatorship (that's what you oppose), that wouldn't allow you freedom to do as YOU want, but a dictatorship in that YOU get to decide how you live, what constututional rules you are obligated to follow, what funding and support you should personally ofer your country (I think next week I'll give them nothing, I need more money fo myself) because YOUR system of government is the best yet.

What you demonsatrate as libertarian views are simply self-centered ways to look after Maxwell and f*** anyone else who can't make it on their own.

by jdclyde

[i]" When the government fears the people there is liberty; when the people fear the government there is tyranny. - Thomas Jefferson
The entire planet rightly fears the current US administration and their tactics at seeking what they deem peace."[/i]

The "entire planet" are NOT [b]the people[/b] so what they fear or don't has nothing to do with this statement. But good attempt at a Bush slam. You tried. Maybe next time.

by maxwell edison

I am a coward. I feel like a coward.

I believe with all my being that it's wrong, immoral, and contrary to both the intent and spirit of our "American experiment", and it's at odds with the intent of the original constitution, that our government -- the government of Jefferson and Madison -- will take the fruits of one person's labor for the purpose of giving those fruits to another who did not earn them.

If I wasn't a "coward", I'd stand-up for my principles and ABSOLUTELY REFUSE to be assimilated. (But I'm not alone. There are a lot of us out there.)

If I had the courage of Jefferson, Madison, and Mason, I'd refuse to participate.

However, I would spend the rest of my life rotting away in prison. So am I really a coward, or just a realist?

I ask this, however. How does that (rotting in jail for refusing to capitulate) fit the definition and the spirit of guaranteeing the rights of individual liberty?

The answer: It doesn't.

by oz_media

There seem to be more opposed than for these days, but they don't matter because they are ALL left wing loonies I suppose.

When your country plays it's retarded games on a a national playing field, guess what, it IS everyone's businss, that's the point you idiots just don't seem to comprehend.

Good try at a Bush slam? Nobody needs to TRY to slam Bush, hes a global laughing stock, a scary one but a laughing stock all the same.

No wonder nobody takes America seriously anymore, at one time you were like the big, dumb cousin that was good for putting up the tire swing, now you are just a menace to the world while the everyone looks on at you shaking their heads and wondering when you'll wake up.

by mjwx

Relies on people choosing to be charitable. The Current US society doesn?t inspire me with confidence.

What happens if people choose not to be charitable? (You may wish to look at medieval Europe).

by maxwell edison

...of American society. You are not an American. If you think Americans are not charitable, you think incorrectly. You have probably never even been here. You weren't educated in the true sprit and intent of "America". You cannot possibly understand, unless you strive for the same things I do. In short, you are not part of the solution, but rather part of the problem.

America IS NOT a land bordered by two oceans. America is the principle that individual liberty should NEVER be compromised.

Bottom line: I don't care what kind of society you want for yourself in Australia. But this is not Australia. Moreover, you don't know or understand the first thing about me.

by mjwx

by what I have read and it does not paint you as a charitable person, quiet the contrary. The American (US) society is not portrayed as one of selfless charity but one of indulgence which in itself is a selfish act (this I know from experience) for proof of this watch a popular American movie (I might suggest American Pie but I would not wish that kind of torture upon anyone, even you Max :) ).

As for a totally selfless culture to use as an example, I can?t provide one. I have a premise that humans are selfish animals.

by tonythetiger

US society is VERY charitable to those who are genuinely needy. It is not charity, however, to subsidize laziness. In fact it is a disservice, not only to yourself and the lazy person, but to all of society!

It used to be that communities took care of their own. (taking care of means providing what is needed. Not necesarily cash.) They were uniquely qualified to determine the needs, as they were there and could see it. People who had genuine needs were taken care of. People who were simply lazy were told to get a job! People generally did not try to scam this system, as it would be difficult for a community member to pull it off, and the result would be that you were cut off. These people who were cut off started travelling around to take advantage of other communities' good will and they would for awhile and get cut off.

This went on until they ran out of places to go where people were not on to them so finally they turned to the government, who didn't know these people and how they were, and Welfare was created.

Naturally, the tax burden created by this Welfare left the communities less able to help as many truly needy as they would have liked, so they got added to the system too, which in turn caused taxes to be raised even higher, etc.

This obviously must stop, but it's already long past the point where it can be stopped painlessly. There's no avoiding it: some hard decisions are going to have to be made, and some people are going to be offended. That's just too bad. As was stated in another thread not too long ago, "You do not have the right to not be offended".

I will ponder some potential solutions and get back to you.

by maxwell edison

...let me ask you this. If I can show that "social spending" in the USA, has not only been more than "military spending", in both real dollars AND the percentage of GDP, but many, many times more, would you change your opinion and/or admit that you're ignorant and wrong?

(Hint: Be very careful before you answer this question. I know what I'm talking about, while you, an Australian, don't know diddly squat about our budget.)

by mjwx

and I would wager that you know as much as me about you nations budget.

If you bothered to read my post I said "I'd like to see"

by maxwell edison

...then don't take my word for it, but LOOK IT UP.

Hint: Internet search key words.

Budget of the United States 1965.

Budget of the United States 1995.

In 1965, 60 percent of the USA budget went to military spending, while 15 percent went to social prgrams. In 1995, 15 percent of the USA budget went to military spending, while 60 percent went to social programs. Want that in real dollars? Do the math.

Look it up for yourself. You wouldn't believe me anyway!

by maxwell edison

I don't really care what you think or believe. I'm discussing issues that have an affect on people living in the United States, on American citizens, not those who neither know us, understand us, or are not one of us. I'm not looking for your opinion, Julian's, Neil's, Oz's or any other non-American.

You will probably follow your standard operating procedure, however, and try to take your usual ignorant and stupid digs at me. But I don't really care. In short, bug-off, mate. You're nothing but a royal pain in the ass. (But that's your intent, isn't it?)

by mjwx

that makes him my problem.

If you are only looking for american opinions dont post on an international forum.

by maxwell edison

...who's not invited to a party, but insists on making his presence known.

I don't care about you, what you think, or what you say. Get a clue, loser.

by oz_media

While his country is screwing itself up and takign from it's own, nobody else cares or even has a right to voice an opinion. In fact, I care VERY little who runs America or what the socialist standards are in America, that's not my problem and I didn't vote for it anyway.

But when the US administration is performing its dog and pony show in an international forum, costing lives of those in other countries, guess what, it IS other people's business.

If the US kept to itself it wouldn't matter, but they don't. They make their business everyone elses business, and feel that is just fine ('If they don't like it, screw them' attitude)but if anyone utters anythign about America (unless it's praise) they get all pissy and say it none of their business.

Hypocrisy, makes the US go around.

by maxwell edison

You are doing it AGAIN!

You have ADMITTED that you gain your knowledge of America and Americans through its MOVIES!

HAAAAAA HAAAAAAA HAAAAAAA!

What a JOKE!

You just proved your TOTAL ignorance, dude.

Oh yea, you're the guy who formed ALL your opinions about Vietnam on .... which movie was that? Apocolipse Now?

Ignorance epitomized = YOU.

by stephencairns

Your country was born out of revolution, of people who would stand up and say no!
So you claim their ideals but not their actions.

But you say there are others with exactly the same feelings as yourself. Its a shame that your principles will not let you assimalate with them and do something about it.

by maxwell edison

How to find those others with exactly the same feelings as myself, and find a way for my principles (our principles) to convince and/or work (not assimalate) with them and do something about it.

I know who we are, but we keep getting out-voted? It's like two wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner? And we're the sheep!

by jdclyde

people with no sense of personal responsiblity learned that they could vote to get your money. They trade being subserviant to a politican in exchange for THEM using the "government" to forcibly take what they have no right to.

This also saves the people with NO sense of personal responsiblity from having to come directly to you and beg or steal directly from you, so they don't have to be embarrassed in public for being leaches on society rather than being a productive part of it.

by jardinier

as do Poms, Aussies, Kiwis and anyone else who lives under a two-party system but cannot align comfortably with either party.

There IS no easy solution. Australia doesn't have your problems because -- while I am no great fan of John Howard or his treasurer Peter Costello -- they do keep coming up with budget surpluses.

History is most definitely not one of my strong points, but I think I can say with some degree of validity that things will only get better when they become so bad that there is a revolution of some kind.

What form this revolution might take, or how far it may be into the future, of course I don't know. But you are most certainly stuck with your current political situation -- I might even refer to it as an impasse -- until things get so bad that people ARE prepared to give their lives to make a significant change.

Would you put your life on the line for what you believe, if it came to the point of a revolution? If you would not, then you are no more than a balloon full of not air.

by tonythetiger

Give enough (money, time, work) to help, but not so much that you hurt your ability to help in the future.

by Former member

I agree with you completely. I know there has to be some form of government, some services have to be provide. national security, roads, waste disposal etc. but using tax dollars to provide for those that are unwilling to provide for them selves is a waste of money. I am not an expert on any of this, and don't claim to be, but I would love to have all the social security i have paid refunded to me. while there at it they could end the income tax and change it to a national sales tax.

by maxwell edison

...as his "proof" to what life in the United States is really like.

Oh my. I must stop laughing. I'll give myself a heart attack if I don't stop laughing.

Are ALL people in Australia this stupid?

Stop laughing, Max. Stop ..... Stop ..... Stop .....

by stephencairns

As an English Australian I dont know what you had before your social security system or even when it was introduced. I can only judge what happened from the english perspective and I'd assume that the english and american were different as I think that the american system would be different from then and now.
In england we had work houses, asylums, debtor prisons, slumms, soaring crime rates, and good doses of disease to keep the population down and if anyone got too upity we'd ship em off to Oz.

So what was America like pre social security ?

by maxwell edison

Families were both the strength and cornerstone of life in America. I had both the pleasure and the advantages of being perhaps the last generation of American children who were raised in a home with both parents and a grandparent. When my grandparents could no longer care for themselves, their kids (my parents) paid them back for all their hard work by taking care of them. That's just how it was done.

Also think of China or Japan. How do you see them having done it? Families are the strength of a nation, not social programs.

1940s, 1950s America, before all of those "social programs", was nowhere close to what you described.

by stephencairns

I agree with you families are a great strength.

The big family unit seems to have fractured these days. People move rounds so much keeping the family together is hard. As the number of children decrease the burdon on them to support prior generations increases.
Incidently I was talking to a Nigerian guy on work experience in England once. He had decided to take another wife when he got home. When I asked him why he explained it as this. More wifes gives more children, when we are old and cant work then the burden of supporting us on each child is less.

But do you think that it would work to return to a pre welfare system, without the family unit to support it?
Do you think the family unit would come back because of it?
What is the reason (telling me to mind my own business is perfectly ok on this one) that you have not continued the multi generation family yourself?

by maxwell edison

...in America is that it is endowed by the Creator, not by man, not by government. (Perhaps that's why most "socialist" societies lean towards godlessness. See note.) Therefore, by what authority does a person presume to be entitled to the fruits of another's labor. That's the basis of the question. Not any anecdotal stories or examples.

Note: Even if a person does not believe in a Creator, a person is born into the world with certain inherent rights, the most basic of which is the right of control over him or her own self. Who dares to presume otherwise? And by what authority? That's the very basic, underlying principle.

An individualist, with such a belief, can live his or her own life without forcing anyone else to capitulate. The collectivist-thinker, however, when he/she presumes to assimilate ALL people into the collective, must, by definition, force others who disagree into capitulation. How can this not be seen as absolutely abhorrent?

by tonythetiger

that they claim that the religious are trying to shove religion down people's throats, yet they use exactly the same methods to force people into their collective.

by mjwx

did I miss something,

How did the loss of life become a childish issue?

Then again I'm not the one who started two threads because I don?t agree with the world. Childish Indeed.

4 Australians along with 2500 US service people, a senseless waste of human life. I truly am sorry if my humanity confuses or irritates you but you?re just going to have to deal with it.

Clue indeed, Human life indeed has a price in Maxworld.

by mjwx

As Neil said "How Ironic".

Max, if you don?t like the way American society is portrayed by [b]American[/b] media, do something about it. I for one would like to see far less "American Pie" type movies but people still keep watching them.

How have you tried to dissuade me of my ill opinion of US culture (there?s an oxymoron in there somewhere). By insults not by fact, you have not offered me any reason to believe differently. Time and time again you have posted selfish and self righteous comment (I have done the same) but then turned around and demanded we recognise you as a saint (I will admit to being as arse at times).

Now I know the difference between a people and a person. You are a person, not a very nice person but still a person, the USA population are a people. Many Americans here have given me good opinions of the US, JD, Mae, even TJ who after getting off on the wrong foot to begin with manages to come across as a sincere and genuine person. Whist I don?t necessarily agree with everyone here I can have a civil discussion with them (Deepsand and I have a disagreement on civil armament, heated but civil), you on the other hand seem to get off on winding people up. Maxwell Edison if that is your real name, you are little more than an enlightened troll and are quickly losing the enlightened part

If you want to convince me I'm wrong provide evidence I am quiet open minded, insults only prove me right and good sir, the burden of evidence is on you.

All this being said, I'll say again. I don?t hate Americans, I seriously dislike your president most Americans I have met are good people. I?d like to make it known that I see a distinction between Max and the US in general.

by mickster269

I find myself being pulled by all camps.

Let me preface this, by saying that I was raised by parents that many of you would considere "Hippies". My Dad was a draft dodger, and I spent some time in Canada because of that. I participated in anti-Vietnam War marches as a child. I worked for Ted Kennedy during his run for Presidency in 1980. I was (and still am) a Buddhist.

I also enlisted in the US Army. I was trained to be a Software Programmer - But I spent time in Haiti whne we were called in in '93.

So I've been all over the spectrum.

" When the government fears the people there is liberty; when the people fear the government there is tyranny." - Thomas Jefferson

I fear the Bush Administration. They are running rampant over the common man's Rights, according to the Bill of Rights. They are ignoring the 4th Amendment (The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no Warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by Oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized.) If they think you might be suspected of "terrorist" actions, then they don't need no warrant. They'll search your house, tap your phones, examine your bank accounts. You are guilty, until proved innocent.

Bush and his cronies want to tell me who I can love (Marriage Amendment), How I can protest (Flag Burning Amendment), and who I can worship (Faith-based program support.. If I ain't Christian, I ain't getting Federal Monies).

Then, the freakin' Dems want to hand money out to every sot that can't figure out how to survive on thier own. I'mm all for extending a helping hand to those that have troubles - Breakfast for school kids, etc. But good grief, if they can't find a job in 90 days, cut their damn welfare off.

I want to help those that need a hand up - but I don't want to tell them how to run thier lives. I want to support soup kitchens, but I don't want to make that a person's way of life.

I want to preserve the National Parks, and I don't want a "Bridge to Nowhere" in Alaska.

Before I ramble on more... I think the two biggest problems with the USA (internally) is that we don't want to take the blame for our actions, and we want to tell others how to live.

::sighs::

by tig2

Max has consistantly been exactly what he says he is. The meaning of "charitable" is not to carry someone along but rather to encourage someone to their own feet. Give a man a fish and you feed him one time. TEACH him to fish and you feed him forever. That there is some ill-conceived notion that "charity" can only be performed by doing FOR rather than doing WITH is outrageous.

When, in another thread, I mentioned that I have been fundraising for a cancer foundation, Max was right there at the table as we plotted something to sell for fundraising purposes. Did he send a check? None of your business! That is private information between myself and my supporters. What he PUBLICALLY chose to do was get behind an EFFORT. What Max has been saying is that he will HELP- not HANDOUT. I don't see any problem with that. He has also said that it must be a choice. I agree. I don't care to support certain types of charities. But I am FORCED to support them through taxation. I believe that I should have the right to direct my charitable donations to those efforts that I wish to give my support to.

Max's facility with language may cause someone without equal facility to see him as hard. That would be wrong as well. In my experience, he has always been willing to explain himself or further clarify IF HE IS ASKED. He will however give as good as he gets when attacked. And frankly, that looks like survival around here to me.

Finally, Hollywood has no true depiction of what it is to be an American. To use a REALLY bad movie as an example is, at best, laughable.

by jardinier

wasting your time and ours by ranting on in these forums where very few people take you seriously any more. In fact I am amazed that there are still a few people who actually think you are rational and honest.

Although many great reforms have been effected by people "rotting in jail," I would not expect you to inconvenience yourself to that extent. However you have a highly paid job and you hate the media.

Simple solution. Publish your own newsletter. You can easily afford to get it started and you will easily attract advertising revenue from other conservatives or libertarians.

If you spent the time you waste here actually reaching out to people who live OUTSIDE the cosy TechRepublic cacoon, you might start to get a few converts and support.

I believe it was Lao Tzu who said "A journey of 1,000 miles begins with a single step." (or words to that effect).

You have not demonstrated that you are prepared to take even the first step. Rant and rave here all you like, but you are achieving nothing.

Max, several years ago I decided to be a part of the solution and not just an onlooker. This eventually led to me publishing my own news and current affairs website (currently dreadfully out of date) which I happen to know reaches many people around the world.

If you don't have the technical knowledge to build a website, I would guarantee that Oz would be more than happy to build it for you, and gratis.

DON'T waste your time criticising the media. Publish your own media. I am deadly serious about this. It is something that is completely within the bounds of your financial situation and available time.

In other words, get up (off your ass) or shut up.

by maxwell edison

Your first paragraph is just one of those "discredit" or "distract" retorts I mentioned in another message. You may believe those things about me, but not only do I ignore such criticisms, I actually get quite a bit of support from others, both in these forums and by private email. A lot of people, most importantly yours truly, simply disagree with you.

As to the rest of your message, I have no reply, except to say that you are absolutely correct. I will say this, however. My "ranting" on this particular Web site, although perhaps not the best use of my time, hasn't been a total waste of it, since I do know, without a doubt, that I've touched some people, given others cause to think about such things, and, perhaps, even changed a mind or two. And it might speak for itself to point out, as an example, that yours isn't the only Web site to reprint some of my writings.

Besides, there may be a reason for my "ranting" on this site. There's a lot to be said for preparation and practice for the real thing. When the opportunity presents itself, and when the time is right, I believe I'll be prepared.

by maxwell edison

I'm not accusing you of this, jd (since you're not doing it), but so many people in these threads use the "selfish" charge against me, or other such nonsense, and obviously believe that my motives are to protect "my money". What a crock! What I'm trying to protect is the financial stability of the United States. And what I'm also trying to protect is the last realistic hope for individual liberty to maintain some semblance of a foothold in the United States. If the United States falls to socialism (under any misleading name or justification one wishes to call it), what hope is there for the future of our country? Russian Premier Nikita Kruschev was right. We're destroying ourselves from within. (And for people who don't know what I'm talking about, that's proof that our illustrious public school systems are not teaching history, as it should be taught, and are not teaching the true concepts of individual liberty's struggle against global socialism. If anything, the public school systems have been advancing socialism, not rejecting it.)

We have, in the United States, at least according to the last estimates I've heard, upwards of 20 TRILLION dollars in unfunded mandates. That means money we've promised to pay, but by carrying forward current budget projections, those funds aren't available. Social Security spending will absolutely skyrocket in the next decade or two, not to mention Medicare. Add on to that all the other social give-away programs -- funding for every aspect of a person's life from womb to tomb -- wasteful and unnecessary pork projects, and other voter bribes ..... I mean promises to voters to give them something, and the United States government is committed to spending an absolutely astounding amount of money on domestic social programs. The money spent on the war in Iraq, as a comparison, is a mere fraction of what we're facing. And what people just refuse to acknowledge is that these funds must first be taken from a person who earned them. Am I selfish? Well, if wanting to leave a financially sound country to my kids and grandkids is selfish, then you bet your ass I am. And if anyone is not "selfish", by that definition, then their either stupid or a bona fide socialist -- or both.

We're losing the fruits of our labor.

We're losing our right to speak freely.

We're losing our right to worship as we see fit.

We're losing our rights to personal property.

We're losing our rights to self-determination.

We're losing our rights to make personal decisions.

And on and on it goes. But when a person brings these things to light, he's faced with a plethora of criticism in every way possible except as it pertains to the REAL argument. No one will retort the principle of this issue, and no one can provide a valid counter-argument. I admit it, I'm trying to come across as the preverbal big brute who walks into a bar looking to pick a fight, knowing that he'll kick anyone's butt who tries. NOBODY will debate me on the true and genuine principle of individual liberty, and how it's being totally trashed in the United States to the point of becoming non-existent. Instead of debating the REAL issue, people divert, try to discredit, deny, and/or distract. The "selfish" retort is all of them. The "blaming Bush" (for something else) argument is a distraction ploy. Come on, you big-bad socialist thinkers. Put up your mental dukes and let's have it out! I challange any one of you to stay on-track, and debate the merits of socialism versus the merits of individual liberty -- no distractions, no diversions, only true and genuine debate. And I want to debate an American, because I don't care what they do in Canada or Australia.

I would spend every penny I have or will ever earn, to restore, for my kids and grandkids, and for your kids and grandkids, the true concept of individual liberty in the United States. Perhaps we need another revolution. How could such a revolution be orchestrated, but one without a shot being fired in anger? We've all heard the rhetoric (usually from the left) about wanting to "take our country back". Well, what they want "back" wasn't even close to what our country ever was or intended to be. It is I who want to take our country back -- back to the true concept of individual liberty being the law of the land.

by jdclyde

this stupidity of trying to blame the President for any and everything that has gone wrong in any walk of life is going to cost Michigans Gov Granholm her re-election bid. We have one of the WORST unemployement stats in the country, and she has passed this off that it is "All since President Bush took office". Sorry sweetcheeks, but Bush doesn't run the state, you do. And how does that account for the NATIONAL rate to be GREAT?

It will be good to have her gone. She ran on two platforms, schools and the environment. They were also the first two things she cut when she got elected.

I know Max, maybe if you use more :D and :x in your posts, people would like you better? ;\

by maxwell edison

I've never used one, not even once. And it's not by accident, either. I want my words to accurately reflect any emotion or feeling behind them. If I don't come across as intended, I need to work on how I string my words together. Something's not as funny, for example, if I have tell someone it's intended to be funny.

Some people might misunderstand my intent, from time to time, but all too many of them are just using divert or distract tactics. (Notice how many people "diverted" to Bush, when this discussion topic is unrelated to any one person.)

So no, I don't think you'll see any emoticons in my messages any time soon. Besides, how can I accurately point out that someone is being an idiot if I put a smiley face behind it?

by ontheropes

to tax dollar stupidity over I-94 too. :) :) :) Ah... who cares 'f anyone likes ME. That's why I've got dogs!

by tig2

Yes- deliberatly mis-spelled.

I appreciate the clarification, Max. It was precisely as I anticipated from you.

I cannot believe that people don't get this. Worse, instead of engaging in debate by viewpoint, what I have seen rampant in this thread has been knee-jerk, "I disagree, now I shall flame you", HORESH*T! What did I miss? When did the customs regarding intellectual debate devolve to this?

It is sickening to me that everyone brought their preconceived notions to this discussion based on their personal opinion of a man they have never met but didn't bother to READ and UNDERSTAND what he wrote.

Perhaps if you have never lived in the US, you cannot appreciate that there WAS a time when the social programs weren't necessary because society was self sufficient. I am hearing other Americans in this thread agree with Max that we shouldn't have to fund programs that we don't believe in. Is it a cultural thing?

Quit with the attack posts, already. Max's original post spoke eloquently about what being a Libertarian is and why it is important. For anyone unaware, I asked Max about it to begin with. The only reason that I didn't post immediately was because he gave me so much good material to read and understand FIRST.

by maxwell edison

I started this discussion by saying, "In a recent discussion tangent, another TR member (thank you, vanessa@...) posted a link to a Libertarian Web site ....."

That was one of your tangents, vanessa@... posted that link for you, and you did ask me to expand on my libertarian views. This discussion was intended to do just that.

by Former member

don't understand what you mean. They should pick up the book "Crimes Against Logic"

by tig2

I find that the person that started me thinking down that track was likely correct. What I find baffling is that Libertarian of today reads very similar to Republican of 20 odd years ago. Somewhere along the line, something fundamental shifted in the party.

Incidentally, I can give you some pretty raw stories about how "social support" programs really work. I will never again advocate social programs as a result.

by tonythetiger

don't have to go around parading their charity to obtain laurels, which they then rest upon. apparently you are accustomed to dealing with those who do. How very sad.

by tonythetiger

Charity is (voluntarily) giving a needy person what they need, and sometimes what they need is a kick in the ass! :)

by tig2

...that is probably the best paraphrase there is.

I think that it is just useless to keep carrying the load for those who don't wish to pull themselves up. I think it is a dis-service. And I refuse to see someone who has made no effort whatsoever to help themselves as somehow noble or worthy. I guess that means I am not a nice person. I'm over it.

Darn, thought it would take longer! (Thanks NeverBusted- love the quote!)

by jdclyde

then they will get lots of warm fuzzies while they are being shown they are being id10t's. :D

See how nicely that works?

by j.lupo

can re-enforce a particular point without using Caps, which I find very helpful when I can get them to work. I too work very hard to write effectively; however, I find I use the cruch (sp?) of emoticons. I have been told my humor is very dry and so without a little help people can't always tell I am joking. ;)

They also can't tell when I am being sarcastic, angry - oh yeah that one they get. :)

by jdclyde

is hard to convey.

I just think Max needs some fuzzy little bunnies all over his posts. That will distract the [b]REAL[/b] wingnuts long enough to read what he wrote BEFORE going off on a rant completely unrelated to what he wrote. :D

by stephencairns

Social security was meant as a safety net. To catch those that all other means missed. Its kind of evolved since as people have assumed that 'they can go on the social, i dont need to help' and so there has been a bigger burden on it than was ever expected.

But look in your local area, in your community, that bum on the corner begging, (no not the one that goes back to a his house every night, the other one that lives in the park, with the broken nose and the drie blood on his face) what happened to him? how did all these systems fail?
Your there, is he a cant or wont?
Have you shown him any mercy?

Human nature has a strong 'me first' drive. Bet when you go shopping you look for the best quality at the cheapest price? me too. Did you think of the shop owner or the producer? no? me niether.
But we also have a strong 'Humanitarian' drive (always think that word is a bit of an oxymoron).
we dont want to see people dieing for lack of food. We want to help. Do you always do something about it? no? me niether.

so its always a battle between the 2 sides.
Left to its own devices I wonder with enforcement I wonder which side would win?

by maxwell edison

You asked how the "system" failed the guy on the corner with dried blood on his nose, blah, blah, blah...."

THE "SYSTEM" DID NOT "FAIL" HIM!

He failed himself.

Bottom line" People ARE RESPONSIBLE, in the very least, for themselves (if mentally and physically able). To think otherwise, presumes that other people are. And then, if you consider the burden of being "responsible" for others who choose to shun that responsibility makes it harder for a person to take responsibility for himself, then the answer is obvious.

You're working backwards, man. Don't start with a conclusion and then try to find ways to justify it, but rather rest firmly on a basic principle, let it be your guiding light, and just let the chips fall where they may.

(By the way, I once offered a job to a guy holding the sign, [i]will lwork for food.[/i] He never showed up the next day for the job, but he did scam me out of 20 bucks to "hold him over".)

by jdclyde

i offered to take him in the shop across the road, he just wanted the money, so he turned it down.

didn't even ask him to do work. was going to just buy him lunch.

and it is also a FACT that the people on the streets are not there because of any lack of system to provide assistance. there ARE shelters that get you off the street and on your feet. if they choose not to use them, oh well. can't save someone that doesn't want to be saved.

by tonythetiger

Social security began as effectively a rich-man's program (the average working stiff died before being able to collect, the pampered rich typically lived longer). It was a bad program when it was created, and it still is.

"Your there, is he a cant or wont?
Have you shown him any mercy? "

Funny you should mention that, what with me living right across the street from a park and all.

First, since we (the neighborhood) rid the park of the drug dealers, the bums don't get beat up any more.

Second, I provide what is needed, in the amount needed, insofar as is within my ability to provide (which is greatly hampered due to the government theft of 60% of my wages!).

"Human nature has a strong 'me first' drive. Bet when you go shopping you look for the best quality at the cheapest price? me too. Did you think of the shop owner or the producer? no? me niether."

It depends. For services and durable goods, I typically stay in the same places for loyalty's
sake... they treat me well, and I appreciate it and want businesses with those values to stay in my community. A lot of things aren't avbailable here though (it's a small town), and when I'm out of town, I shop price and value, as you said.

"We want to help. Do you always do something about it? no? me niether."

I ALWAYS do something. But it DOESN'T always involve money (mine nor someone else's).

by jdclyde

the difference between saving a few bucks going to borgmart and visiting the locally owned shops. Once the locally owned ones are gone, there will no longer be a NEED for low prices to get you into borgmart. Are people really that stupid that they can't see this? Yes, they are that stupid.

You can't save everybody, and giving every penny I earn away would not solve the worlds problems, but it would add another family in need of assistance.

Raising my family to be productive members of the community is the single best thing I can do for the community. Provide a future workforce with morals and standards. This workforce is the future tax base.

by tig2

That if personal responsibility were more prevalent, one might see a return to the family unit. Not holding my breath, however. The things that have grown up in place are too pervasive.

Not all of us are able to bear offspring. This is a hardship in that we who do not, also do not have the family unit to fall back on. I am fortunate that my partner's family CAN provide that- he has a son from a prior marriage. And we have each other.

A return to a pre welfare system is almost a requirement at this point. The current system is rewarding irresponsible behaivior and has little incentive for the individual to grow to a point where they can survive without welfare. A single mother almost CAN'T go through the stages to better herself because the minute that she makes a dime more than the welfare allows, she loses her benefit. If she is only making enough to pay the rent but not the utilities, she is screwed.

And I KNOW from personal experience how the system works. Poorly at best. Emergency aide for the individual who needs assistance immediately and for only a short time does not exist in any meaningful fashion. But if you have a history of irresponsibility, the State will pick up your tab.

by maxwell edison

.
The following message applies here as well.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=195659&messageID=2049140

JD proved your insurance claim was bogus, and I can show that the rest of your argument is bogus.

I learned to drive before seat belts were standard accessories in cars. (well, I learned in an old car that didn't have them.) When it became mandated in the mid to late 60s, I remember the public awareness campaign encouraging people to use them. The little jingle is still with me today, after all these years.

"Buckle up for safety, buckle up. Buckle up for safety, always buckle up. Keep your seat belt snug, give an extra tug. Buckle up for safety, buckle, buckle, buckle up."

And do you know what? People DID buckle up. Especially when it became obvious that by using them, one's life was placed in less risk.

Then it became mandated that kids be buckled up.

Then it became a secondary offense if the driver didn't.

Now it's a primary offense if you don't.

This is an extremely egregious violation of a person's right to choice, right to self determination, right to privacy, and to one's individual liberty.

It's being used, not to "save lives", but to generate revenue and to control the population. Once a person is pulled over for a "seat belt" violation (and, of course, it's one person's word against another's), anything is open to "investigation".

You are an absolute fool if you are willing to give up your personal rights under the guise of "protecting you from yourself".

The same people who are up-in-arms (disingenuously, in my opinion) about the NSA infringing on personal rights in order to protect the nation from another terrorist attack, have no problem, whatsoever, with the egregious violations of personal rights under the guise of protecting an individual against himself. How crazy is that?

by Member 25348569

(with reservations, of course).

I believe that wearing a seatbelt is likely to decrease the level of my injury in any crash - less so in these days of airbags, admittedly - so I tend to be in favour of wearing them. Rear seat belts prevent my passengers, especially children, from becoming missiles in the event or a shunt - and rear airbags are not common over here.

So, I never drive without my seatbelt and if you are a passenger in my car you buckle up or I don't start - particularly if you're a rear seat passenger sitting behind me! But that is my choice in my car and so my rules. If you are so stupid as to want to drive [b]your[/b] car unbelted, then go ahead. I'll even be a passenger if I can buckle up. I will worry a little about your common sense unless you have an airbag.

I was biker for twenty years and I (nearly) always wore a helmet, but, you want to ride a motorbike and feel the wind in your hair, then go ahead.

I want traffic cops to be spending their time stopping [b]other[/b] people doing things that are dangerous to [b]me[/b] - driving under the influence, talking on hand-held cellphones, running red lights, etc, etc.

Even with our centrally-funded social medical system - where you might argue it justifiable to target groups who contribute to their own misfortune - government shouldn't start to legislate as it doesn't know where to stop. The UK government have done smokers and car-drivers and are now kicking off against fatties.

[b]I know![/b] I really would like to lose some weight but stopping crisp adverts on TV before 9pm isn't going to do it.

OK. Now for my questions. You'll probably think them a bit stupid, but try to answer them.

How, in general, do you feel about making seat belts/harnesses/child seats or whatever compulsory by law for children?

Does a Libertarian father make his children wear a setbelt or does he allow them the freedom to choose not to wear one?

Is there an age at which your childrens' Libertarian right to choose to be stupid outweighs your parental right to protect them?

just asking...

by jdclyde

Children arguably are a different story. They are not mature enough to understand the "what if's", so can not make a rational choice on their own.

Child safety seats and such are good ideas.

I can't claim to say when your personal rights to stupidity overweight child protection laws, but then again, I am not a Libertarian (yet). The beliefs are in line with most of my thinking, more so than many in the Republican party, but I am realistic enough to know that all a third party does is take votes away from the party it is closest to and hands the election to the other end of the spectrum. This IS how Wild Bill Clinton go in office in the first place. Ross took enough votes from Bush sr. to hand it over.

by maxwell edison

Sorry that you agree with me, Neil, but it?s bound to happen from time to time.

Your questions:

[i]"Does a Libertarian father make his children wear a seatbelt or does he allow them the freedom to choose not to wear one?"[/i]

It?s my political philosophy that leans libertarian, not my parenting philosophy. As a parent, to put it in political terms, I believe in a dictatorship. (See parenting note below, which is included in my answer to your last question.) Since I'm responsible for my kids, I decide, not the kids. Some things are non-negotiable. My son wears his seatbelt -- end of story. (Besides, now that it?s ?the law? in my state, I don?t want to be inconvenienced and/or taxed .... I mean, fined, when our local Police Department decides to launch one of its revenue generating drives .... I mean one of their ?click it or ticket? efforts.)

[i]"How, in general, do you feel about making seat belts/harnesses/child seats or whatever compulsory by law for children?"[/i]

Regardless of which way a person answers this question, some sort of undesirable outcome will result. Which bad choice do you want to make? Do I want innocent children to be placed at risk? Of course not. Do I want the government determining what is risky and/or what a parent may or may not do? Of course not. Therefore, this is a case where I don?t ask what I want, but what I want more.

It?s a difficult question, because when we have a society in which other people decide how one's kids should be raised, protected, cared for, etc., it runs the risk of opening the floodgates of government interference in child rearing, and it means that someone else gets to decide what may or may not be "the responsible" thing to do, regardless of the issue. Do we protect kids from the actions and behaviors of their stupid parents? Who gets to define what may or may not be stupid? And what about those people, the lawmakers and/or the voters, who do decide such a thing? Are there any ?stupid parents? among that group of people? Of course there are. Do we give those other people, some of whom are obviously stupid, decision-making power over every parent just to make sure they have decision-making power over stupid parents -- especially considering these people just might be stupid parents themselves? I don?t think so.

The emotional way to answer your question is to make it a law to buckle-up children. The rational way to answer the question, however, is to acknowledge that it?s just not their decision to make. Doing something ?for the children? has become a common battle cry of the political left. Doing it ?for the children? seems to be their reason for everything. The Kennedys didn?t do a great job raising their children, unless you think dysfunctional drunks and debauchers is a good outcome. Those people have no business sticking their noses into my business. If it means we give stupid parents the right to be stupid parents, then so be it.

Different parents allow their kids to take different risks. It?s not only with seatbelts, but bicycle helmets and skateboards as well. What about the kids who ski or rock climb? What about playing sports, such as the American version of football? If we let the government and the voters (some of whom are stupid, you know) decide that some things are too risky, then we open the door for allowing them to decide about all things that might be risky. Therefore, it gets to my initial question, what do I want more? And while I want innocent kids to be protected from their stupid parents, I want more for all parents to be protected from stupid lawmakers.

Disclaimer: While I?m against a law, I?m all in favor of encouragement, public service announcements, and so on. Most ALL parents will be responsible. Don?t punish, stigmatize, or insult the responsible ones, in order to deal with the irresponsible ones.

[i]"Is there an age at which your childrens' Libertarian right to choose to be stupid outweighs your parental right to protect them?"[/i]

This answer falls under the category of my basic parenting philosophy. Yes, a dictatorship, of sorts, but one that also gives responsibility to the kids as they become capable to handle such responsibility. A parent has (or should take) full and total responsibility for their kids from the start. The challenging aspect of that, however, is not ALWAYS taking and keeping that responsibility, but letting it go, knowing when to let it go, and, perhaps, even reigning it back in when necessary.

In the early stages of development, that child isn't capable of taking enough responsibility to even feed himself or go to the bathroom by himself. Eventually, a parent relinquishes that kind of responsibility to the kid. Pretty soon, the kid becomes responsible enough to cross the street, to ride his bike without supervision, and so on. If gets especially challenging with teenagers, because they want all sorts of leeway to be responsible for themselves, but sometimes they just can?t handle it yet.

I even explain it in these terms to my own son (and to the other teenage boys that I work with in the scouting program). The goal of a parent, at least in my estimation, is to reach the point when ALL responsibility can be passed on to the kid, so that when the kid reaches adulthood, he/she is released into society as a responsible adult. Personally, I probably have a tendency to give more, not less. I?ve found that kids, generally speaking, will try to meet the expectations placed upon them. (And this is why you should NEVER expect a child to fail!) I?ll give (relinquish) as much responsibility as the kid shows he?s not only willing to accept, but also capable of accepting.

If my son, for example, wants to take full and total responsibility for managing his own schoolwork without checking and monitoring from me, fine, I?ll give it to him. However, I expect him to get ALL A?s and B?s, keep his GPA at around 3.2 or better, and not get any bad reports from his teachers. If he does that, it?s all his. If he falls short of what?s expected of him, I?ll reign it back in and start monitoring what he does and how he does it. I have this approach with just about everything.

In the case of seatbelts, the rule is that when he drives my car, he wears a seatbelt. If he ever gets a ticket for not doing it, he knows he?ll lose the right to drive my car. I have another rule, by the way. He will never get into a car when the driver has been drinking ? NEVER. And I?ve made a deal with him. If he ever finds himself in such a position, regardless of the circumstances, he should call me to come and get him, regardless of where he is or the time of day/night; and if he does, he will never get into any trouble for doing it, regardless of the circumstances.

Personally speaking, I think I?m well on the way to releasing a responsible adult into society. At sixteen, he takes on a lot of responsibility himself, and although not perfect, he handles it pretty well. And I think he'll always choose to wear his seatbelt.

by maecuff

That is crazy. I don't like being told what to do to protect myself. I'm all grown up and can make those decisions for myself, thank you.

With that being said...

I cannot STAND to see a moving car with a child standing in the back seat or sitting on someone's lap in the front seat. If the parent can't or won't protect these children, then someone should. I'm sure an argument can be made regarding individual parent's responsibility toward their children and accepting responsibility when their children shoot through the windshield of a car. But these kids aren't objects. They are humans, they aren't owned by their parents. And when they are so very young, they CAN'T make the decision to be safe. I guess, the parent could be tried and sent to jail if their kids launches from the car and splatters on the road, but that doesn't do much for the little human being who didn't deserve to have that happen in the first place.

As far as adult go, If its your choice to not protect yourself, I say don't wear a helmut, safety belt, whatever. Same goes for choices regarding alcohol, drugs..unless you are impaired and harm another person, have at it.

by tonythetiger

Look up "Libertarian" and "Liberal" in the dictionary. The definitions aren't that far apart. The real world is obviously not a dictionary though :)

by jamesrl

It was "pro business", as the status quo was the landed gentry aristocracy. The Liberals in England were those who sought to open up commerce and create a free and open market. The conservatives were mostly the titled and rich who did not want change.

So the position vis a vis change isn't different, just the goalposts have moved for the ideals of liberty.

James

by maxwell edison

I never said that. Why did you make such an assumption?

The fracturing on the family unit is not "because" of everything else, but rather "everything else" has caused the family unit to fracture.

Your reasoning is bass-ackwards.

by mjwx

I am not above admitting when I have been an arse :) . Max?s attitude gets under my skin and can easily send me flying off the deep end. Although your post was pretty tongue in cheek, there is a lot of misunderstanding about Australia.

Starting on the Aussie film industry, we have many great films that have just never had the backing to go international like "The Castle" and "Crackerjack". I'm sure there are many great canuk films I have never seen. American Pie, I chose this because I see people emulating what they see in the movie, in Australia (remember that I'm a lot younger than you blokes so I am closer to the damage). We've recently released Kadoka, which is an Australian war movie, I think you'll find it the equal of "Saving Private Ryan" with regards to the Australian spirit. "Saving Private Ryan" was a good movie and I would say the same about "Patton" but that movie was more about the man than the American spirit. And don?t get me started on Steve Irwin, we can?t stand him.

As for charity, Perth Western Australia gave 3 mil AU$ to charity last year. Considering we have a population under 1 million. We give just as much per capita, just remember we're one tenth your size. Australia has many good philanthropists, just not as many glory hogs.

To a member of the eastern bloc, a state line had guards at it that fired real ammunition (a state line to them was the border between East Germany and Poland) so no wonder they were amazed.

It was Russia?s policy of giving guns and money to everyone who said they were a communist that bankrupted the Soviet Union, the US just took the glory.

The first time we trusted the Americans to launch an Aussie into space the shuttle blew up. Australia is currently the world leader in biotech and agricultural technology.

Ahh, the beach if only I could find one without sand. The thing I like most about Australian beaches is that I can find one with absolutely no one else on it even if I have to go 1500 KM's to get there. Lakes are fun too, but the weather in Michigan leaves a little to be desired (for some reason I don?t like swimming in sub-zero temperatures).

Buying a gun at wal-mart? OK this is something I'm glad we don?t do that in Australia. Over here you need to get a license for firearms (Not difficult to get mind you, as long as you?re a mentally stable person). Deepsand and I have had this discussion and I think you will be from the same camp so let?s agree to disagree from the start. Never felt the need to carry a weapon concealed or otherwise. I did used to own a few weapons myself, until I moved into the city and just didn?t use them anymore (I can?t take pot shots at pedestrians).

I'm not really anti-gun just anti-idiot so some basic restrictions I see as necessary. This being said I believe that if you give an idiot anything, the humble spoon for example he will do something idiotic with it.

My main problem with the current US administration is how they have handled Iraq, I just can?t see bush taking any responsibility. I wouldn?t have a leg to stand on if bush had of said "OK people we screwed up, now lets just get on with the task of fixing things" which pretty much sums up what I think of the war in Iraq. I'm not the kind of person who likes to rub things in (I know a lot of people don?t think like that). Before Iraq I didn?t give two hoots about GWB.

Well, as for travel. I eventually intend to visit the US. I actually want to bike it (Harley not push bike) across the US. At the moment however I would probably visit Europe before the US (two reasons, I am somewhat paranoid about surveillance but mainly because there?s just more things I want to see in Europe).

by jdclyde

We DO have a lot of restrictions.

(speaking from personal knowledge in Michigan)
If you wish to purchase a handgun, you have to go to the local cop shop and get a "purchase permit". They do a full background check BEFORE you get the permit. You then have 15 days to purchase your handgun. If you do not purchase this handgun, you are STILL REQUIRED to come back with the permit, used or not and turn it back in. If you get a handgun, it is inspected, and the numbers are run to make sure it isn't stolen. IF it all passes, they register that handgun to you.

If someone wants to use your handgun, they have to be right with you. If they are NOT with you, they have to go through and get a purchase permit, fill it all out, and within the 15 days bring it back and turn in the unsued purchase permit.

We now have a "shall issue" policy to get a concealed carry permit. You have to take training classes, and then can carry your handgun. There are many public places this gun can still not go, and there is a ZERO tolerance rule on booze. One drink and you are in jail.

Rifles, they do that at the store. You fill out a form, they electronicly submit it to the feds, and you will hear back within three days, but often if your record is clean (like mine) you get your reply within an hour.

Transporting a firearm. If you do not have a carry permit, it HAS to be locked in your trunk, unloaded, with the ammunition NOT stored with the firearm. You can also ONLY have this with you if you are directly on your way to or from hunting or a valid shooting range.

The USA is NOT the wild wild west, and the vast majority of all shootings are NOT done by the lawful gun owners. With more and more places giving the concealed permits, the crime rate has gone down as the crooks don't know who has a gun and who doesn't, so it takes away the easy marks.

There are many more restrictions, but these are the main ones.

If you are thinking about that assnugget M Moores movie where he shows himself walking into a bank, signing his name and walking out with a rifle, he VERY convenently neglects to mention that he had all his paperwork filled out three days in advance so it was all cleared with all the background checks. AND who is going to VERYIFY who they are, take that empty rifle, and then hold up the bank? Shows the stupidity of that fat bausterd, and the stupidity of his followers. He will NOT give you an accurate view of the US.

How this clears up some of the confusion, peer me if you have ANY questions you would like more background on.

by jaqui

naw a true libertarian would say will work to earn the priviledge of living ;)

You are right jd, I have spent 6 years doing volunteer work with groups helping homelss people.
The majjority choose not to go into the "system" to get themselve into a better place, they are exactly where they want to be.
outside and addicted to at least one narcotic, most likely infected with both H.I.V. and Hepititis C.

I have no sympathy for their placement, and the best they will get from me is a meal.
[ try, I cooked christmas dinner for 400 of them with one group I volunteered for. Yup, I did 1/2 the cooking usually, but that day I was the only cook. ]

by stephencairns

I apologise Max
you said that "I had both the pleasure and the advantages of being perhaps the last generation of American children who were raised in a home with both parents and a grandparent. "
The "had" fooled me I stand corrected and I will take your answer as 'mind your own business'

I was not suggesting why the family unit has fragmented only that it seems to have fragmented.

but you did not answer my question of do you think that it would work to return to a pre welfare system, without the family unit to support it?

way back in the mid 1800's people in England were realising that Family, Church and Charity could not provide adequate support for everyone. Ok thats England and I belive that America probably has a tighter community spirit, but do you think welfare could be just swiched off?
We all know it has to be switched of at some point.
We all know its broke.
The question is more of how do we switch it off and what consequences would you put up with?
Or how can we fix it?

by maxwell edison

I just wanted to clarify that I didn't fit your conclusion. My generation of kids was, perhaps, the last to have a grandparent living with them, at least it was pretty common in the late 50s and early 60s. Soon thereafter, all the way to the present day, it's almost unheard of.

My parents are both living (both ~90), and still live in the same house we grew up in. My brothers and I have actually had discussions about where one or both of them might go when they are no longer capable of caring for themselves. And now, we all spend a significant amount of time doing things for them. I drive about 600 miles (one way) every other month (or more) and spend 5-6 days just hanging out with them, doing whatever might be needed. Any of us would take them in and do whatever is necessary to provide for their care and comfort. It's just that it hasn't come to the point where that kind of decision has had to be made. If we can't do it ourselves, for some reason, we'd pay the cost of providing the care.

I will admit, however. With people living longer, they are faced with ailments that make it most difficult, and at times impossible, on their care givers, nothing like when I was a boy. My grandmother died in her early 70s, so we weren't faced with those kinds of things. She was confined to a wheelchair, though, and we had to get "creative" around the house so she could navigate her way around. The upside, of course, was that we got to play in her wheelchair when she wasn't using it!

When I suggested what I did, I do realize there are exceptions. Generally speaking, however, families caring for each other has become a thing of the past, or so it seems. And that just adds to the problems facing society as a whole. Society caring for people should always be the last resort, not the first expectation.

by stephencairns

Like I say some are cant some are wont.
There are genuine cases and there are not.

Maybe all your hostels are free over there. Across here they cost money. I cant see anyone getting far on a half eaten burger and cold coffee.

So why are they on the streets?
some are there because they have mental illness and are benefitting from care in the community.
Some are there becuse they can make more money begging thsan they can be bothered working in any other way. Probably some are there because they LIKE eating out of bins and sleeping on cold concrete.
And some are there because they have just got too use to it.

So these people are not taking advantage of what the state provides? Is that not what you are wanting? Are these people not the very essence Libetarian?

by stephencairns

Should always be the last resort. I agree.
600 miles away from you folks, thats hard. I'm 12000 miles away, only get to see them once a year.

I'm wondering if economic necessity, work availability or family ties kept families together. Have our expectations of personal freedoms changed? is that why families are not so tight knit?

by mjwx

We'll swap him for a hot dog and a coke.

JD, Here we have to go through the pistol procedure for rifles and shotguns as well (been through it twice myself, pistol, rifle but not shotgun), you get profiled to see if your dangerous as well as an eye test. What may surprise people is that I disagree with some of the restrictions on weapons. For example I agree with the ban on assault rifles (AK's and M16) but some weapons like the M14 (I understand there is a version for semi-auto mode only) and historical weapons. What person in there right mind would rob a bank with a SMG their dad got in WWII (not someone in their right mind).

As for Moore, I find his films political infomercials. I do so hate adverts, especially one that goes for 2 freaking hours.

NeverBusted, I'll admit the glory hogs comment was a bit below the belt.

If anyone over there wants to see a good example of the Aussie film industry I recommend "The Castle" and "Crackerjack", both comedies that anyone with a sense of humour should enjoy. I didn't mean it to be condescending, just informative. I think the quote "a people divided by a common language" applies to the pacific as well.

[i]"You probably won?t see NeverBusted in too many political discussions."[/i]

Your are a far smarter man then I, I should stay out of political discussions but sometimes I can?t help it. "We can?t talk about politics, I guess we'll have to talk about religion ". :)

by tonythetiger

One of the other problems is that when the do-gooders see someone who doesn't live to what they think are appropriate standards, they must be mentally ill.

"You can't live in a shack in the woods, killing rabbits and squirrels and eating them, growing vegetables, and harvesting nuts and berries from the forest! That's not civilized! There must be something wrong with you! You need a government program to help you! And if you don't want it, then you are obviously mentally ill and we will force you to take it! It's for you own good, you know!"

Did you ever think that some people might just want to be left alone?

Also, isn't is much easier to be a do-gooder when you're doing it with someone else's money?

by jdclyde

The "Assult weapons" bans are political and meant to show the mindless masses that they are doing something.

There is NOTHING more assulting in close range than a 12gage shotgun firing 00buck. It isn't called a "room clearer" for nothing. You get it in a hallway, forget about it.

The final thought is that it isn't the law abiding citizen that goes through the legal process to get these firearms that are the problem. It is the person that buys them on the street, which is already illegal. How does this alledged ban on the legal sale of firearms stop the illegal sale?

You would take mine from me because some criminal (that the police should already have locked up) MIGHT break in and steal them? You should not own a car, because someone might steal it and use it in a crime. Most getaway cars ARE stolen cars, don'tchaknow?

I hope you see how silly the chest beating about this all is by the politicians.

by tonythetiger

Once your children are on their own, you may think your job as a parent is over. It's not. It's just beginning :)

by maecuff

I agree, opening the floodgates to allow lawmakers dictate how we raise our children is frightening.

However, couldn't this (seatbelt issue) fall under a negligence category? I don't think there is any doubt that a parent who leaves a toddler alone should be charged with a crime. Or parents who take spanking to a physical abuse stage. What makes this so different? All these things can lead to serious injury or death.

It takes so little for a child to be injured in a car. A few months ago, we went out to dinner and after we pulled in the parking lot, my son took his seatbelt off. Neither his father or I noticed that it was unbuckled. Now, we're traveling at 'parking lot' speed, and someone whipped their car around and was nose to nose with us. My husband slammed on the brakes and Joey flew into the back of my seat. Fortunately, he was just shook up and not hurt. Had he been more toward the middle, he could have flown between the seats and been seriously injured. Needless to say, he understands now that the seatbelt stays fastened until the car is parked.

Max, I really do understand and agree with most of what your saying. I just don't think requiring carseats and seatbelts for infants and children is in the same league with extreme sports.

by tonythetiger

Most laws involving children are simply methods that the government can use to get more money out of us (after all, it can't be bad..... it's "for the little children"). That's why, for example, the overwhelming majority of the time, the custody of the children in divorce is given to the parent with the lowest income (that way there will be more child support ordered, and the government's cut will be bigger).

If they were really interested in the safety of children, they would remove abused and neglected children from their parents and never give them back! But, like many other phases in the law books "the best interest of the child" is just lip service (in this case it really means "best interest of the state").

by oz_media

When GWB decided to offer 5cent gas in Iraq, it was at a cost of $1.50 epr gallon to Americans.

the current estimated cost of fuel for teh military vehicles in Iraq is $100.00 per gallon, as it is shipped into Iraq and not purchased there. So with a Humvee getting 5MPG, it costs the US tax payers $500.00 to get across town.

Spending 500 billion to blow up a forein country that was supposedly becoming an imminent danger to the USA (based on false intelligence), is far more acceptable to people like Maxwell than paying for Grandma Hapshaw's hip surgery because her family is unable to eke out a fair living, or educating the morons that are running tomorrow's America. But hey, that's Maxwell's America, good thing the rest of teh country does feel that way.

One day the people will get control of the country again and self servient zealots like Max will again become a thing of the past. Until one day the right will rise again.

by oz_media

Others are supposed to be concerned about who you are what you think and what you do? Loser???

Why, Max? Do your global policies and f-ups now only apply to Americans that share your opinion? You're gettign too old for this, time to bronze your keyboard and call it a day.

by tonythetiger

"A return to a pre welfare system is almost a requirement at this point. "

I think so to. And yes, it's [b]going[/b] to be painful (so is having a rotten tooth extracted). But none of our country's documents that I know of declare that a pain free life is a basic human right.

"Emergency aide for the individual who needs assistance immediately and for only a short time does not exist in any meaningful fashion."

It used to, until the government came in and took away much of our means of providing it.

by tig2

This discussion was an exploration of what constitutes the Libertarian party. There are plenty of Bush Bash threads, this was never intended to be one of them.

If you want to engage in a discussion regarding Mr. Bush, I would apreciate it if you did so in a forum focused on that discussion.

Thank you.

by tonythetiger

"I was not suggesting why the family unit has fragmented only that it seems to have fragmented."

One of the big reasons was the designation of the male as being not important to a family except as a source of income... the "Walking Wallet Declaration"! This had a secondary benefit to the government since keeping as many men as possible down lessens the chance they'll be able to rise up and overthrow this failed excuse for a "Great Society".

by jdclyde

because we have a government were we do something called "voting" (you may have heard of it) there are not more people against the current administration than for it. The "left wing loonies" are just more shrill, and mimicking what your ranting about, so that is all you hear.

Had you been actually a part of this conversation, you would have seen that the quote is talking about the citizens of a country, and how they feel about their government. You are right, because this is what the quote is about, you and the rest of the world DON'T matter.

Are there other aspects that you have a valid place to speak up? Of course, and you take them and more. This is not one of those cases.

No wonder people don't take YOU seriously anymore? You can't even follow along with a simple discussion.

I accept your apology for speaking out of line on something you are not versed on.