Being a Libertarian in Today's United States
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
...could be punished (fined) for being forgetful or distracted. In my state, you'd be fined $100 for what you described. I'm sure you don't deserve such a thing.
I can't argue against the logic of using a seatbelt. Of course it makes sense. I use them myself. But this nannyism imposed on people by government has to stop somewhere, or it'll never stop. Actually, it's already gone too far -- and that's why we're having this discussion.
....I never did spank my son, not even once. I don't believe in it.
Actually, come to think of it, I don't think anybody should spank their kids. You never know when a parent might go too far, so we must not allow it to happen at all.
I think I'll start a petition drive and/or lobby my lawmakers to have a law to outlaw spanking, and that would define any and all forms of spanking as child abuse.
It's "for the children", you know.
by maecuff
Like you, I do not believing in spanking. I think it's bullying and lazy, there are better and more productive ways to discipline. And I think people who spank very small children should stick their hands in a blender.
With that being said, if you DO choose to spank, then you also make the choice of going from discipline to abuse. (although personally, I don't think that's a far stretch). However, the seatbelt issue is different. If you don't put your infant in a car seat and an accident, totally out of your control, causes your infant to turn into a little baby rocket and crash through the windshield, then you are guilty of neglect. No different than leaving a two year old unattended for a week, or something of the sort. Maybe that's not the best comparison, but it's in the ballpark.
And yes, had Joey been injured(or not)and we were fined, I would have paid it without complaint, the fact that we didn't notice he had already taken off his seatbelt doesn't make us any less responsible.
by x-marcap
I have rarely resorted to spanking.
I believe that several times it was necessary for my kids to be spanked for their own good.
I have 4 very good kids.
The daughter (oldest) refused to stop biting younger brother (12 months 2 weeks younger) She would go berserk and bite him wickedly. She was punished repeatedly by many other means. Until she was 6 we didn't spank her, even biting back wouldn't do it. (John tried) Mel was 5'5" 155# at age 10. John was small and 70 pounds at 10th birthday. (now a 20 yr old 6'+ 150# still growing) It took several episodes with the belt to convince her not to bite. Son John one year for endangering
all of us. Temper tantrums in two year olds are dangerous, only to themselves. Adults, and adolescents others can hurt or kill others.
Just because someone gets more attention, or is smarter than you it is no reason to bite.
Sorry OZ. That goes for you too. I'd take the belt to you, but you'd probably get arroused.
The purpose of discipline isn't to enforce your will on your child, it is to build a foundation of discipline that will bless them their entire life.
by tonythetiger
point to the successful people in the community and ask "Were you ever spanked as a child?"
Yes, it, like anything else, can be overdone. A good parent doesn't overdo it. A good parent also shouldn't be restricted from doing something a bad parent does.
I remember second grade... if one kid got caught with chewing gum, we all stayed in from recess... it was bad policy then, and it's worse when the government does it to adults.
by jdclyde
of the WAY the government does MOST things, I HAVE to believe that MANY of the programs really are intended to be good?
Support, the "friend of the court" wanted me to give the EX a token amount of support, even though we have equally shared physical custody. Why? Because they get money based on the number of claims they handle. I KNOW that the best interest of the children is NOT what these agencies are looking at. To give full custody to a welfare mother over a working dad (I have seen this) because with her not working, she has TIME to take care of the kids? How about which is a more healthy environment for the child to grow up in?
Thank GOD that at least in Michigan things are changing because of major lobbying groups for mens rights.
Specifically to seatbelts and car seats for babies, do you think that is in THEIR best interest? I do.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
"is that why families are not so tight knit?"
The world is a much busier place than it used to be. You have to schedule the visits to grandma's between karate practice and soccer practice. And grandma actually has to be home (as opposed to galavanting around the country as grandparents seem to do more of than they used to :) ).
by oz_media
or perhaps have become so used to you are blind to it, is the hypocrisy of Max's statements here in comparisson to his suport elsewhere. MAx, decided to bring up all the famous quotes that discount his common opinions. I pointed out his hipocrisy, now you see that as Buch bashing?
Gawd, ANYTHING not in total agreement with Americans is seen as bush bashing now?!
He stands here and spews his pro republican crapo day in and day out, then he claims he has a libertarian viewpoint, that completely counters what he claims ar ehis core values and opposes teh government which he defends.
Sorry mate, but that was not off topic at all. You just can't seem to see how a political standpoint would have any relation to your current government's actions?
by tig2
I NEVER wore a seatbelt when I was a kid. In fact, I even - GASP - rode in the back of pickup trucks! One of the highlights of my childhood is when I was flying down the highway in an MGA convertible (a 1958 model, I believe), with an older sister driving, and FOUR of us kids piled inside. Of course, the top was down, even though it was the dead of winter, and the car was designed to only hold two passengers, but who cares? It was a blast!
Damn, if all these protections are to save the children, how in the heck did any of my generation survive? We weren't saved. We should all be dead!
by maecuff
and no one wore head gear when riding a bicycle, either. I don't know any statistics on this, but I'd be willing to bet that a lot of children have escaped serious injury since they've become more popular.
And just because we escaped serious injury, doesn't mean that precautions are worthless. As far as I'm concerned, there is no excuse for neglecting the safety of your children.
by jamesrl
I remember when it was legal to ride in the back of a pickup, but illegal to sit on tailgate (when it was down) while the truck was driving down the road. Some of us did anyway. Darwin would have something to say about that.
But it gets better....I rode on a plow once. Was helping a farmer with the field and needed more weight on the plow to get through thick muck. Instead of going back for a few concrete blocks, I sat on the plow. If I had fallen forward there is no doubt in my mind that I would have been sliced in two.
Does anyone remember a Volkwagen 411? Bigger than a Beetle, but still small. In high school one of my friends had one, and we packed 11 of us into it for a 8 block drive to a local pizza place.
Growing up in farm country you learn to have respect for heavy equipment and big animals. Otherwise we would be dead.
James
by rob mekel
We could play on the streets, seek and hide blind-man, football, hockey, etc etc.
2 or 3 bicycles every ten minutes, 1 bike every 20 minutes, a car every hour. Yes streets were crowded in those day's. :D
Well I remember we had a station-wagon where the back windshield could be down. We hanged out on the bar, while dad drove us to the beach, with our dog next to us. Had lots of fun and all went well. If you would try to do it these days we all would be like mashed potatoes by the time we reached the beach.
Times have been changing very quickly. And things we did as kids can't be done now-a-day's. Some for the good some for the bad but I think that none of the kids of now nor then will look back and think "what a rotten childhood I had".
Rob
by oz_media
"Had you been actually a part of this conversation"
Sorry, do we now title posts and invite certain like minded peers only? Better let teh editors of TR know so they can monitor the boards for nonAmerican comments. It makes it easier to feel like your comments are supported that way too , right?
You go on about voting, what a laff, what do Americans know about voting other than they can't seem to do it without screwing up the entire system. Next time, think of somethng you have been proven good at, that would be a brief post too wouldn't it? TR's shortest thread.
I offer no apology at all for anything I have said now or ever on TR. I have no reason to apologize for having or sharng an opinion, regardless of whom or what it was with respect to.
As for suggesting this is an American only thread, try again and give your head a good shake you arrogant putz. If I was to post something for 'Canadians only' you would all go to town on it, 'this is a public forum' 'if you dont' want my opinion, too bad, STFU', 'you posted in a ppublic forum,waaaaa'. So don't even begin to put the initial touches on suggesting this does not concern me nor is any of my business.
Ever heard of peer mail or even email? Judging by your comments here, I would not be shocked to hear you hadn't.
You also samake comment as Max used ot back in the day, third patry comments suggesting you and 'all the others' think this or that about me. Guess what, I have a newsflash for you, I get those letters about you and many others here too. Don't be so f****n' arrogant as to think you are the only one who has side conversation with peers here. We have even had one peer here that woul dplay two people against each other just to watch them flame each other. For someone who claims to know what's going on, you sure dont come across as very bright, or at least that's what everyoe tells me about YOU, LOL. What a fool.
by jdclyde
I never said you COULDN"T join the discussion, just that obviously you were a part of a different discussion because that was NOT the context of the quote that was being discussed. HAd you decided to read what the conversation was about and commented on that, find and dandy.
The qoute was not an amercian quote either, but you weren't paying attention enough to know that. It was about the population of ANY country, and how THEY feel about their government.
And I am the one that needs meds?
I will even repost it for you so you won't have to take so much effort to get back on track.
[i]When the government fears the people there is liberty; when the people fear the government there is tyranny. - Thomas Jefferson[/i]
You know, as in "We the people"?
Hmmm, I make a comment that directly reflects a handful of people opinion about you, compared to you making a comment on the ENTIRE WORLDs opinion of the ENTIRE UNITED STATES OF AMERICA? First, it doesn't surprise me that you didn't catch that, and second it shows you to be a bigger a$$ to think your arrogant statement makes you any brighter than me? At least I am not the only fool around here.
[i]You also samake comment as Max used ot back in the day, third patry comments suggesting you and 'all the others' think this or that about me[/i]
You mean like you just did about the world opinion?
Or did you forget you just got done writing that a few minutes ago?
...I present a flawless argument, one that nobody can possibly disagree with, one based on sound principle and reasoning, but it's not convincing enough to change someone's mind.
I think it shows that we've become an issue driven society, not a principle based society. It shows how emotion can trump reason. It doesn't matter that two different issue decisions might be in contradiction to a common principle.
Kinda' like stealing. Is it right or wrong? Or does it depend on the circumstances?
The role of government is not to be the parent of the nation's children. I'm sure you would agree. I'm willing to rest on that principle, and let the chips fall where they may. You're not. But you're not alone, and that what makes these kinds of debates frustrating. I think it's sad, however, when principle loses to issues. And I think that's why our country is in such a domestic mess. (And global mess as well, for that matter.)
by tonythetiger
by maecuff
I took you at your word. Oh well, Max, this will just have to be something else we disagree on..
Of course, on my spreadsheet, the columns are titled "I'm right" and "he's wrong" :)
Please note..smiley face added..
by jamesrl
I hear all the time from other riders that they don't need a helmet because they ride well and they dont fall.
Well about 15 years ago(in my late 20s) I was riding down a road with a large number of parked cars along it. Someone backed out of a laneway without seeing me, and I had nowhere to go since there was a car in the oncoming lane. I hit the car and then fell to the pavement. My head was last to hit but smacked down hard, shattering it on the sidewalk. I walked away with a sprain and some road rash, and a throbbing headache. Could have been much worse.
I am with you on making kids wear helmets and seatbelts - if they haven't reached the age of consent, then they don't have the capacity to make their own rational decisions, and I would prefer not to make them pay for their parents mistakes.
And while I am in favour of adults making rational choices, and paying for the consequences of their actions, I'd have to see other laws change before repealing the laws.
How about this. No mandatory laws. But give the insurance companies (boo hisss) the ability to descriminate. If you are wearing your seatbelt - fine and dandy. If you aren't you are on your own. Cause I don't want to pay higher premiums for YOUR stupidity. I feel the same way about smoking by the way. If you get lung cancer, dont charge the insurance company and raise my rates.
Well perhaps I exagerate for effect. I'm more of the love the sinner, hate the sin type.
But there are doctors in Canada who will exclude smokers from transplants because smokers have a lower rate of transplant success. If I were on the transplant list for an organ more precious than any material good, and I am given this gift, shouldn't I do everything I can to make it a success. If I don't want to do that, shouldn't I let someone who will - after all they don't give kidney transplants to people who drink heavily.
Something to think about.
James
by maecuff
Okay. If a parent leaves an infant or toddler alone, is that neglect? And if so, are the laws regarding that neglect valid? Or is that intruding?
If you believe that it is the parents right to leave a child to fend for themselves, I will accept what you are saying. I might not agree, but I will accept it. If you agree that there SHOULD be laws against neglecting a child, why on Earth would requiring a carseat or seatbelt be excluded?
By the way..I KNOW I'm not going to 'win' this debate, I will freely admit that I am not at your level when it comes to debating skills..but that doesn't mean I'm gonna quit.
by maecuff
Mr. Edison, you are confusing me. Did I misread something? Argh.
I'm going to change my mind about spanking. You need a good one.
And the first person to turn that into a sexual thing gets a thump on the head..
by tig2
Unfortunately, regardless of the laws that are made, or the social programmes designed to protect children, or anything else, bad parents abound.
When I was teaching High School I had a student that had been molested by a family member. Obviously against the law- but it was a family member.
She was the perfect student, 4.0 GPA, graduated first in her class, full ride scholarship to a UC (University of California), and bulemic through High School. And suicidal after her first semester in college.
And I have to say, her parents were guilty of not understanding, not knowing the core issue, feeling helpless to do anything because they honestly feared that they would lose their daughter because SOMEONE ELSE had done something wrong. And they did what they thought was right- got her psychiatric help, tried to be supportive. She tried to kill herself over Spring Break anyway. Not (Praise God) successfully- she was found in time.
Sometimes the laws do more harm than good. You can't legislate good parenting. But you can make laws that are so frightening that the average person doesn't understand them, doesn't understand that THEY won't be held accountable for another person's actions.
My former student is doing well, majored in International Business, speaks French, Italian, Spanish, German, Japanese, and Phillipine. Found a wonderful man, has a couple of cats and is a rising star in her work world. She tells me that she wants to get her MBA. I am thankful that she was able to get the help she needed.
You KNOW to protect your son. So many, despite programs, don't or won't. As has been pointed out regarding gun control, the law abiding citizen will care and comply. They would have anyway. The non law abiding citizen will simply NOT care.
by x-marcap
I say that the Local VFW hall is a better place to get the real skinny than any movie.
The other places you should visit are churches, and the town halls. Get away from the cities and watch neighbors helping people. I took a 48" xp394 Husquevarna and helped a neighbor take down a 50 foot maple tree.
American's are extremely generous with time and money. We are willing to help those who are trying, or truly unable, but we are not willing to help those who will not help themselves. As a religious quote it is: "He who will not work shall not eat." The welfare for incorrigibles is a violation of my (and many others) religious beliefs.
by jdclyde
by x-marcap
Most of the assault weapons that were banned used a .223 slug which hits with very little power. It isn't good for Big Game. My .55 with 435 Grain slug is much more effective, and dangerous weapon. even with a very slow cyclic rate of fire.
Only people who don't know weapons think of what most people think of as assault weapons as really dangerous M16s,AR15s, and CAR15s. I'd take an old M1 or M14 with its 7.62X59mm and 158 grain slug, and put more lead in the air, with 6 shots than a 30 round clip of .223. Precision fire with my old bolt action Springfield 1903 from 1000 yarda is more effective than 20 M16s at the same distance. I can shoot 5 rounds in 10 seconds and hit all targets from that distance with no wind. If the wind is against the M16s and I have the 1803, I can just add notches to the buttstock.
by oz_media
ee I was being somwhat restrained. You woul dhave very different opinions if you had been here a couple of years ago, it was insane.
I was offering my reply in more of an astonished tone. 'Not another one' if you get my drift.
by oz_media
'We the people', yes that's exactly what I meant.
The people of America, the people that make up the country.
As far as the entire world, I have yet to meet mroe than a handful of people globally that would think otherwise. The resent of anything American is far greater than the American's resentment of France or even teh Middle East for that matter. America is just a bad word in most places, yes MOST places, around the ENTIRE WORLD.
When is the charge of racism not really racism? Well, in today's world, about 99 percent of the time the charge is made.
When is neglect not really neglect?
Too many things are being placed under the umbrella of something else in order to justify a desired end result or, in this case, a flawed argument.
Do I think leaving a toddler home alone for three days and three nights is neglect? Of course I do. Do I think leaving a toddler alone in a backyard with nothing but grass and a six foot privacy fence for three minutes constitutes neglect? Probably not. How about if there's a swimming pool in the back yard? Well, that probably is, but if the child drowns in the pool, the parent probably wouldn't be charged with neglect.
A home has stairs, but the parents don't buy a gate to prevent the toddler from falling down the stairs. There ought to be a law, right?
A home has an electrical socket and a screwdriver laying on the coffee table (quite a visual!). There ought to be a law, right?
A home has a cabinet under the sink that holds some very inviting-looking cleaning solvents, but there's no block on the cabinet. There ought to be a law, right?
Stupidity does not equal neglect. Failing to buckle-up a child is stupidity, not neglect.
If we had a law against everything stupid, we'd all be in jail.
by mjwx
a soldiers weapon and a good hunting weapon.
Now to explain Australia?s ban on assault weapons. Yes this was a political move but it has some sense to it (at least to Aussies). The ban came after the Port Arthur massacre
http://www.crimelibrary.com/serial/bryant/
where 35 people were shot and killed by one not so sane Martin Bryant with an AR15 assault rifle. Australia had never seen a massacre so indiscriminate and violent that action had to be taken to prevent it happening again. In the 10 years since Port Arthur we have not had another 30 people spree killing, I don?t even think we have has a 10 people spree killing.
Hopefully I have adequately explained our perspective on the ban. I understand that Americans think very differently about gun laws and I respect that (I'd be a bit hypocritical about asking you to respect our laws and perspective if I did not do the same). I've had discussions regarding this ban with Americans before to no avail for either side so I'm going to file this one under cultural differences.
In my opinion the difference between a hunting rifle and an assault rifle is the difference between a car and a tank, one is a mode of transport for everyday use and the other is a weapon of war.
I really don't want you to change your mind. People like you make sure that too many things don't fall through the cracks. People like me make sure the cracks don't get too big. Finding balance is the challenge. And out of all the people who disagree, I have no problem with the balance you and I seem to have found.
(I'm not exactly sure what that means, but it sure sounded good. ...... Place a smiley face here.)
by x-marcap
The real issue is freedom. The 2nd amendment was supposed to be the reset button on the Constitution. With every law passed at the federal level, we wave bye-bye to freedom.
The assault rifle is not a long distance rifle. the shooter had a modified weapon. The point is I have legal weapons. An M14 with full auto of 300 rpm is legal with 15 rounds of 7.62X59MM. with 20 round mags it requires a different license.
An M14 is about 10x more powerful than a M16/AR15 type weapon. The problem isn't guns, it is the people who use them improperly.
For example, if someone walks in my door unexpectedly, they would find themselves greeted with multiple shotguns, .45s, etc. not to mention the dog... Big Dog, a rottie... I have escorted an unwanted census taker, several local police and sheriff patrol members and several FBI agents off the property. All of them understand private property much better after I had them reminded in court.
The local judge said I was a major league jerk, but I was right by the letter and spirit of the law. He fined the FBI guys $40.00 & cost for tresspassing, however, he let the locals go. Each time he reminded, and remanded them that they can't just enter someone's house or come on someones property without permission, cause, or warrant.
Some things are for the better, but others are not. I'm not sure, however, how to tell them apart.
I grew up in a mid-sized city in the mid-west. (Hint: The city and state often got confused!) When I was 10 years old, I would ride the bus, alone, dozens of miles, clear over to the farthest suburb or to the town at the end of the line, just to explore. (Another hint: I could have walked up to Harry Truman's front porch, knocked on his door, and had a little chat with the former president -- if only I knew then what I know now.) I got my first real job when I was in the 5th grade. I got my second real job when I was in the 7th grade. At times, I did both jobs simultaneously. I was driving a car at fifteen, one that I bought with my own money; and I worked on it myself to keep it going. I got picked-up by the local cop as well (who knew me by first name), when I was fifteen for driving without a license. He called my parents to come and get me -- after, of course, he gave me the chewing out of a lifetime.
It's amazing what we did as kids, things that are almost unheard of today -- and things that might even get our parents arrested and land us in foster homes! Like I said, I don't know how to tell the difference between what's good about that and what's bad.
by x-marcap
They usually don't show up, or give up within 3 hours and they only do 15-20 minutes of real work...
I have went out and done as much in 5 -15 minutes as they do in 3 hours, and they want $20,00 for booze or drugs...
by mjwx
The ones I have the most problems with are the ones based on "morals" which dictate that certain movies cant be watched. Now I'm all for an advisory commission to put ratings on the cover to help parents decide what is and is not suitable. Most of these moralistic nanny laws are based in Christian ideals (but let?s not get into a religious argument here). The government has no business restricting the sale of literature (movies books and music) based on their moral code.
Now as for personal stupidity, this used to be punishment enough for itself. Then people started crying about (helmets seatbelts ect...) and for the most part it was not the victims or parents of victims that did the crying. The phrase "the empty can rattles the most" applies to these people. I find stupidity can separate the wheat from the chaff. Oddly enough I agree with you, I think anyone with half a brain would.
Now, I find regulation of products, such as your car for safety is needed as not all companies can be trusted to work in the customer?s best interest. Rules must be set for things to ensure manufactures aren?t making a dangerous product (not wealth distribution amongst the industry).
"A return to a pre welfare system is almost a requirement at this point. "
Agreed
"I think so to. And yes, it's going to be painful."
Agreed
So how would you dismantle it?
1. Would you slowly reduce the taxes and the payments (possibly not at the same rate) allowing society to pick up the pieces.
or
2. Would you switch it off overnight?
I think no 1 is possible but it must be slow, we are talking years.
Option 2 I think would lead to riots. (might be a win win win. save money, reduce population, employ people to carry out the dead. JOKE!!)
So, do you think it could be done? which method would you suggest?
by mjwx
Democracy in action, well at least constitutional monarchy in action. This wasn?t a political stunt to win votes both parties supported the ban. Most Aussies I know agree with the ban. To us (Aussies), the freedom to own guns is leveraged against someone else?s freedom to live.
Shooting deaths and shootings in general are very rare here in Australia, and the rate of homicides has remained steady of the decade of 1990 (the ban on assault weapons was in 1995).
Contrary to popular opinion Australians don?t live in the tyrannical grip of criminals, very few places in Australian cities are unsafe to visit. I have said before, this is just anther difference between our two countries and in the different ways we live our lives. I don?t think I have much of a chance of convincing you that the ban is good and I can say you have no chance convincing me it is bad. We can argue the point or agree to disagree.
The reasons to own guns in the USA are for self-protection and/or to take them up against an invading enemy (the latter not as significant in today's world), but to also take them up against a government that gets tyrannical.
[i]"The strongest reason for the people to retain the right to keep and bear arms is, as a last resort, to protect themselves against tyranny in government."[/i]
-Thomas Jefferson
Not that it'd make a hell of a lot of difference against the likes of smart bombs and today's military weaponry, but in such a drastic case, a lot of the military and national guard units would switch sides anyway -- weapons and all.
Disclaimer: No, I don't own any guns, nor have I ever. (But I sure do wish a teacher at Columbine High School would have had one.)
....two wolves and a sheep voting on what's for dinner.
No person should be oppressed or otherwise infringed upon by a vote of the electorate.
Your message is dripping with distractions, distortions, and lame attempts to discredit, avoiding the issue entirely (as usual).
by oz_media
by mjwx
That I already know but thanks for taking the time to explain it all the same. We seemed to have gone off on the gun control tangent again.
Ironically in regards to gun laws we both view each other as being liberal, I view the US as being too liberal (as in libertarian) and a few Americans view Australia as too liberal (as in democrat). Don?t mean anything by it max, I just find the semantics to be a bit humorous.
Australia and the US. I think we will always do a few things differently. Well if you (US) like to have guns around well that?s your choice (and would much appreciate the same kind of respect in return).
BTW, I once was a gun owner, still have a rifle license too. Just don?t get out of the city much these days.
by maecuff
Not a chance. Why would I when I'm right?
You make a good point with your electrical outlets and screwdrivers and such, you really do. And I agree, leaving a child in a fenced in back yard for a few minutes probably isn't a bad thing. (would never happen at my house, because my husband is an over-protective freak) However, I still contend that neglect is neglect. That being the car seat/seat belt issue being in the same ballpark as leaving a child alone. And there isn't ANY way anyone could convince me that people don't know how important it is to secure children while in a moving vehicle. Hell, they have programs to GIVE away car seats if you can't afford one.
I think the difference is, accidents happen. Even car wrecks can't always be avoided, however, NOT securing your child is not an accident, it's willful neglect.
by tonythetiger
First step is to completely overhaul the tax system. Make it conducive to business (Businesses don't pay taxes anyway, they just pass along the cost to the consumers). The friendlier to business it is, the more business will grow (or start), the more employees they'll need, etc. As employment picks up, proportionally reduce the number of government employees in "human services" fields as the number of "customers" drops.
Next we have to begin breaking cycles. Enact or modify policies to emphasize the unnacceptability of child neglect, defining specific minimum standards for living conditions the parents must be able to provide if they wish to remain parents.
Violation of this policy as a result of criminal acts by the parent should be treated as additional criminal acts.
(to be continued...)
by x-marcap
The could have defended themselves or revenged their loved one immediately.
The chance of a murderer getting executed is slim unless they are in Texas. Their they now have an express lane!!!
If you shoot a lawyer it should be for public health reasons.
by x-marcap
Look before you leap.
In this case what is popular, gives us immorality and a biased repression of the people who say that acting immorally is wrong. People don't appreciate being told that they are immoral or wrong. Just because it is popular, it may be very well be wrong.
Bill Clinton is an ordained minister as is Jimmy Carter. From Bill's actions his religion didn't even make it skin deep. It was his alternative avenue to political power. Can anyone say with a straoght face that Clinton's actions were moral or honest? Bush is at least apparently hones and moral.
Carter I am hoping is repenting for his past indescretions. I suspect that he may live a long time if he has to atone for his recent oral utterings.
by tonythetiger
by jamesrl
I rarely spank, I think using too often and it has less impact. But I reserve the right. And I do think some peopel take it too far and injure the child, physically or mentally.
I have 3 good kids. But one got in the habit of undoing their seatbelt and opening the door when the car was moving. After escalating up the punishments, we went to spanking and the lesson stuck. Same thing with fighting.
I haven't spanked one of them in 3 or 4 years. They are currently 12, 10 and 8.
Its one of those things, before I was a parent I swore I would never spank. I still try to keep it as a last resort, and never in anger. But as long as its used judiciously, I think it can be a benefit - like many things it can be abused in the wrong circumstances.
james
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
.
http://www.grandforks.com/mld/grandforks/14926060.htm
What does that say?
It's a good thing for the mother that the baby died in a car seat. If there wasn't a car seat, this mother would be in deep doo-doo. (Yes, sarcastic, but intended to make a point.)
by oz_media
I had no idea, they could come and live with me anytime. How's cousin Paul? I haven't heard from him in a while, I had no idea he was trying to get into the USA, nor anyone else for that matter. WHICH of my cousins, aunts, uncles etc are trying to get into the US to no avail? I call Bullspit because I know as a fact you are wrong.
I don't know what sources you get this info from but believe me, just because people somewhere in the world appear to be clamboring for America, they do the same for Canada, Australia and heaps of other countries too. We just don't get it in our heads that the entire world wishes they were Canadian.
P.S. When you say AMERICA to most Europeans, they think NORTH AMERICA, and not necessatily the USA.
The US is the US, America is seen as Canada/USA/Mexico, NORTH AMERICA.
Anyone I have known who actually did move to teh US from Europe (it was worthwhile in the late 70's and early 80's)has since moved elsewhere stating it was not what they had expected at all.
It's a great dog and pony show, but the truth and reality soon sinks in.
Is America not a desireable country? NOOOOO of course not. America is a great country, with some great people. There are so many other places to go too though. Don't kid yourself by thinking America is the place to be and everyone wishes they were there, I think they must spew that garbage to you guys to keep you from seeking refuge somewhere else.
I suppose that's why so many returning soldiers have since moved to Canada and started peace organizations in an attempt to get other GI's to speak out when they return. Sure some of the gun toters have a blast, but there are many coming back with stories abotu how people are allowed to shoot civilians and not be reprimanded.
There's a whole lot of things you have no reason to be proud of these days, I'd be pretty quiet if I was American, but I certainly wouldn't be shouting from the treetops about how great the country is.
So you are going for the slow reduce the population till you get back to full employment approach? Could take a long time but it could work.
Just want to clarify a few things.
"completely overhaul the tax system. Make it conducive to business"
do you mean by that to simplify or lighten the tax load on business (and tax payer?) by transfering (some of?) the burden to consumers? taxed at the rate you spend?
Or do you mean just reduce the taxes, take the hit that the government will not be able to fund anything and wait till the economy catches up?
or just just reduce the tax level at the same level the economy improves?
"defining specific minimum standards for living conditions the parents must be able to provide if they wish to remain parents"
"remain parents" does that mean removing their children or stopping them becoming parents?
if remove then where to?
Who defines the minimum standards?
Surely the minimum standards are a loving supportive environment? How would you legislate or even measure that?
or do you define the minimum standards as food clothes, shelter, $x spending money, provision of health and pension and empoyement insurance?
"Violation of this policy as a result of criminal acts by the parent should be treated as additional criminal acts"
lost me here.
Do you mean that if you attempt to raise children in a sub standard environment you are a criminal or do you mean that if you do something criminal and have children there will be an additional charge?
Does being in jail automaticaly confer neglect of the family? even if the family is financially (and emotionaly) sound otherwise?
Do you feel that this second step in any way conflicts with the Libitarian view point?
I like your step 1 depending on how you implement it. I have huge reservations on step 2. In Australia what you are suggesting has been tried. They ran a policy up till quite recently of removing children from there families for "their own good". There are a lot of very angry people and broken families as a result.
Incidentally, do you know of any first world countried that do not have some form of social security?
by mjwx
that if Martin Bryant had a Winchester 303 instead of a AR15 he would have only killed 5 or 6 and not 35. What would he have done if he had an AK 47 or MP 5. Just to keep it in perspective 35 is roughly 300% of Tasmania?s (state where you'll find Port Arthur) total murders per year.
By popular, I meant it had the support of the people which as I understand it is how a democratic society works. Perhaps I used the wrong word. I have been down the Assault weapons road before, but I'll go down it again.
A well armed populace would just lead to more Port Arthur-like massacres. As I have said Martin Bryant was [b]not[/b] a stable individual, but he was able to easily obtain an assault weapon which he then used to kill 35 people.
There are more Martin Bryant?s unfortunately, what this ban has done is prevent the future Martin Bryants from doing as much damage. It would be far more invasive to ones freedoms to psychologically profile every Australian and weed out/remove any potential spree killers than to restrict the sale of firearms. More people with guns in public area's mean more people get shot. I don?t view more people dead as a better solution. People who kill don?t think about their actions until they are sitting in a jail cell so giving them more dangerous weapons is asking them to do more damage before they can get to that cell.
Firearm restrictions in Australia have not been used to prosecute the farmer (or other type of general citizen) who keeps an old semi-auto in his gun cabinet. It has been used to prosecute the gang member or bikie who has 5 AK 47's. Whilst it may look restrictive to you, we are not a people that go overboard and so it doesn?t worry us.
I have plenty of ammunition on the subject but I am trying to be friendly, we have our solution for our "Bryants" and we find it works quiet well. The USA is a different state and you have your solution for your "Bryants".
by nicknielsen
Libertarianism is also about responsibility, both personal and social.
How, you ask?
My personal responsibility is to take care of myself and plan for the future. If I wish to have a nice home, eat daily, and buy all those neat toys, then I must work. If I wish to retire before I die, then I must save and invest. It is flat wrong that my earnings are taxed to support somebody who will not or cannot work.
My responsibility to society is to give back what I have been given. Do I give to charity? Yes. Do I help when possible? Yes. Should I be [b]forced[/b] to support people unwilling or unable to support themselves? No. Like Max, I believe that coersion to charity is wrong.
As for your basing your view of American society on American media, you obviously forget that Rupert Murdoch has been here...the media is no longer about news, but about entertainment.
by tonythetiger
[i]"completely overhaul the tax system. Make it conducive to business"
do you mean by that to simplify or lighten the tax load on business (and tax payer?) by transfering (some of?) the burden to consumers? taxed at the rate you spend?[/i]
Transfer ALL of the burden to consumers (they pay it ALL anyway... business just includes it in the cost of their product or service). Read more about it at www.fairtax.org . Keep current funding (for now).
[i]or just just reduce the tax level at the same level the economy improves? [/i]
Effectively... because once employment picks up, consumer spending will increase, and more money would be going to the government. Some combination of reducing the 'rate', paying debt, and refunding the excess would be in order.
[i]"defining specific minimum standards for living conditions the parents must be able to provide if they wish to remain parents"
"remain parents" does that mean removing their children or stopping them becoming parents?[/i]
I meant the former, but I can imagine if the problem gets much worse, the latter will become an acceptable and appropriate remedy.
[i]if remove then where to?[/i]
Foster care. Temporary in the case of misfortune, permanent in aggregious cases.
[i]Who defines the minimum standards?
Surely the minimum standards are a loving supportive environment? How would you legislate or even measure that?
or do you define the minimum standards as food clothes, shelter, $x spending money, provision of health and pension and empoyement insurance?[/i]
There can be a broad national standard... a guideline, so to speak, but locally it would be determined by the board. You can't put a $ amount on it, one because the cost of living varies greatly from one area to the other, and two, some families will choose to pool resources, live with grandparents, etc. Certainly conditions which would qualify legally as neglect or child endangering could be construed as substandard without much thought.
[i]"Violation of this policy as a result of criminal acts by the parent should be treated as additional criminal acts"
lost me here.
Do you mean that if you attempt to raise children in a sub standard environment you are a criminal or do you mean that if you do something criminal and have children there will be an additional charge?[/i]
Perhaps an example is in order. Your kids haven't eaten in three days because you were mugged and all of your money taken. In this case the failure to feed your children would not be a criminal act. However if you spent the food money on illegal drugs, it would.
[i]Does being in jail automaticaly confer neglect of the family? even if the family is financially (and emotionaly) sound otherwise?[/i]
No.
[i]Do you feel that this second step in any way conflicts with the Libitarian view point?[/i]
No. Adults have the right to choose to be stupid all they want, but they don't have the right to impose the consequences of their stupidity onto someone else (not even their own children).
[i]I like your step 1 depending on how you implement it. I have huge reservations on step 2. In Australia what you are suggesting has been tried. They ran a policy up till quite recently of removing children from there families for "their own good". There are a lot of very angry people and broken families as a result.[/i]
I would submit that the families who would fail these minimum standards is already broken. Naturally, there would have to be some leeway for genuine misfortune, but the only way you're going to break these cycles of generations of abuse and neglect is to actually break them. As I said before, nobody said it was going to be painless.
by tonythetiger
by nicknielsen
I also like your steps, but there are two requirements that must be met for them to work:
First, the "sperm donor" mentality that infects society as regards the father must be eliminated (I think you called it the "walking wallet"). No matter what the sociologists and feminists say, male children emulate after the available male role models. Need proof? How many gang members came from two-parent families where neither parent was a gang member? Statistics here:
Second, much as people laughed at Hilary, it does take a village. Children are society's responsibility. There were a lot of things I could have done as a child/teenager that I didn't do because I knew it would get back to my Mom.
by tig2
Gun control is not the point. The point is defining rules of responsible behaviour. Martin Bryant was a powder keg looking for a place to go off. And while I sympathise deeply for the loss of life, the gun in his hand did not make him a killer. HE made HIMSELF a killer with a DEVICE in his hand. I have owned a hand gun since 1992 or so. .38 cal, Taurus 85CH. Never found it necessary to kill any one or anything with it. Thank God.
A couple-few years ago I was diagnosed with a particularly virulent type of cancer. I had also been out of work for awhile. I had been doing odd jobs but nothing that would get me more than hand to mouth. They decided to slash my unemployment to nothing at about the same time that someone stole my identity and put me so deeply in debit that I will never see my way out. Came the day that I lost my home- on my 41st birthday (literally) and had to throw myself on the mercy of the State.
I was told that they would provide medical services that they would bill me for later- they did and are- I couldn't pay them fast enough, they garnish my wages- but I was on my own for a place to live as there were no places I could go- I had earned too much in the preceeding five years. Within the next 30 days, I lost one breast, my home, my cats, and my self respect. I had an interview the day they did emergency surgery on my breast. I had to decline. I was told that emergency surgery wasn't a good enough excuse to decline an interview.
Does this sound like a classic case of what we put social programmes in place FOR?
I was told when I went to ask for assistance that if I had a child or two out of wedlock, they would have paid my rent and my medical expenses (hefty) for as long as I met the requierments. All I had to do was produce some children. I have NEVER been able to have children.
I spent a year LITERALLY on the street, while in chemo and trying to find my feet. I dug ditches for a days wage, I detailed cars, I baled hay I washed dishes. I determined who I am and what I am made of and CHOSE to live. I found myself surrounded by those that the "social programmes" are there to help. They play this country like a violin. And it disgusts me.
I will NEVER support another "social programme" as long as I am able to live. I pray that I am able to understand with clarity when something is right or wrong. I hope to never confuse issues.
I owned that Taurus until a few months ago when I needed to give the State more than I had after rent and heating (I live in the Midwest- heating is an issue when the temps are 40 below). I sold it to a respectable dealer that I researched.
For all that I had been through, it never occurred to me to use that weapon to harm another living person. It never occurred to me to use that weapon on myself.
The Martin Bryants of the world will not be stopped by laws. People like me are.
I am so very sorry that Austrailia has had to endure the Columbines. We do understand what you have been through. A loss of 35 people is rough- they were friends, neighbours, people of people you knew. I understand it. But consider- I went through h3ll in a way that few will ever understand. And you don't know my name beyond my TR ID. Nor would you. I have done nothing wrong- gun or no.
Edited- because...
Wish there were more levels available here.
""Do you feel that this second step in any way conflicts with the Libitarian view point?""
"No. Adults have the right to choose to be stupid all they want, but they don't have the right to impose the consequences of their stupidity onto someone else (not even their own children)."
and the children do they have a say in this?
by tig2
this earlier post:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196739&messageID=2051512
Only because I can't say it all agian.
Until someone goes there, you truly have no idea.
by x-marcap
by maecuff
by tonythetiger
"and the children do they have a say in this?"
Not in the literal sense, obviously (most 5 year olds would then demand ice cream for dinner every night :) ), but the community must hear and heed their cries for help.
by tonythetiger
Yes, I can see where that didn't come out exactly right.
How about:
A good parent shouldn't be restricted from doing something responsibly that a bad parent does irresponsibly.
(something similar could be said about most of the restrictions the government places upon us.)
by maecuff
what you meant..I just couldn't help myself. :)
I definitely have my opinions on spanking, but to each his own. I don't think a person's views on the subject makes a good or bad parent and I think children can grow up happy and healthy either way.
I STILL contend that parents who don't secure their children in a moving vehicle are negligent..
by tonythetiger
by jardinier
referring to an obviously understandable typo to avoid addressing the question.
So I will ask you again. Would you put your life on the line for what you believe?
by jardinier
Before you dismiss welfare systems altogether, I should tell you that if you had lived in Australia, you would have been entitled to, in order one after the other:
1. Unemployment benefits.
2. Sickness benefits.
3. Disability pension.
On any of these government benefits, the Medicare program introduced by the Whitlam Labor Government more than 30 years ago would have paid for almost all your medical expenses. Yes paid outright -- not paid for by yourself after the event.
Two and a half years ago I was admitted to hospital suffering heart failure. I was in hospital for 10 days and it didn't cost me a single cent. Surgery was recommended but I did not consider it to be necessary at that time. However if I had undergone surgery, that too would have cost me nothing.
I live in one of the wealthiest and most politically conservative areas in Sydney. I have NEVER heard a single individual suggest that welfare programs should be abolished. I have NEVER heard a financially secure person complain about subsidising, through their personal income tax, people on welfare.
So I would suggest that you don't reject the concept of government welfare altogether, but rather compare America's system with that of other Western countries and see how they differ.
by tig2
I understand that there are differences in the delivery systems between Austrailia and the US. But that is not the point of this discussion nor the point of my previous post.
That I am a living example of the point that Max is making regarding personal liberty is really moot.
What CAN and SHOULD be gleaned from all that is that I can state unequivically that (a) a person with a gun and NO desire to harm others, likely WON'T- regardless of circumstance and (b) no social programme will impact one way or another a person who is determined.
Laws and programmes are not the determining factor. Individual character IS.
My character is not the result of any political mandate or social programme. It is the result of parenting that taught me personal responsibility. Perhaps that is the point. That we are each responsible for ourselves and our lives.
An odd final thought- I cannot give to another what I do not first have. Yet the State, in its wisdom TAXED my day wages- even though those wages were LESS than poverty level.
Editd for typo
by maecuff
by oz_media
I didnt say you flamed ME, per se, but said " How could you possibly reply without some flaming instead, it's not in your nature."
Now, what do I consider some flaming that you simply couldn't resist?
[i]"Your message is dripping with distractions, distortions, and lame attempts to discredit, avoiding the issue entirely (as usual)."[/i]
Sorry, I must have misread, you were merely slamming and discrediting my comments, not "some flaming instead"
Yoru comprehension skills have proven to be the root of most of your poorly worded comments or knee jerk replies, perhaps you should start reading and understanding what you are reading before claiming to be so 'in the know'.
Perhaps if you understood what you read more often, you would have entirely different political views too.
No, I'm not flaming you or anything else, just adding observations and suggestions.
by tig2
I don't remember anyone telling me that by my existance I was entitled to a pain free life. I do recall my father working three jobs while he attained his engineering degree- he had five children and a wife who had to be a stay at home mother (those five kids). He never backed off from a challenge. I learned by his fine example.
And there is the crux of the matter. To an advocate of social programme- I am pathetic. I believe that "tragic" was actually the word used. To you, I am an example of what a person is able to accomplish when faced with adversity. I prefer that view.
That which does not kill us makes us stronger. One thing that came from all that was that I could indeed accomplish anything I chose to.
Thank you for hearing the intended message- we ARE each responsible for ourselves. Law does not change us, but rather we are changed by the way we choose to live.
by oz_media
Because there is an noticable influx of immigrants to teh USA, then the USA is where everyone wants to live???
What kind of bassackward mentality is that? What a retarded conclusion!!!
this fits my favorite idiotic conclusion from Monty Pythons, 'All fish swim, therefore all that lives in the ocean is a fish."
Man you guys are priceless sometimes! What a self infatuated lot you all are. :)
by oz_media
Here's an interesting article from an American Expat now living in teh Canary Islands.
Apprentrly there is all this talk about teh immigration as that is tracked, but emigration is not. They don't note how many people EAVE America for a better life.
Of course, you can take the easy way out. Ignore the comments, flame the writer and the fact that he left America fr a better life, but then again there's reality.
Why is it always one sided with America and never three dimensional, do they not teach people to look at multiple angles there? It just doesn't mke sense how his mass loss of a thought process has taken over your population.
by j.lupo
I heard you too. For the religous here, I was taught not only "that which doesn't kill us only makes us stronger" but that "god never gives us more than we can handle". Ok, I had to add it and I see nothing wrong with that view.
TT is living proof of it and I wish more would take that approach. Having watched my Mom raise 3 girls by herself after my "father" walked out, sold the house out from under her (I don't want to elaborate on that one), and so many other hardships, including Cancer, cataracs (sp?), knee replacement, diabetes, high blood pressure (I wonder why?), and now the beginning of altzheimers, it just is obvious that you not only are a survivor of such but you are a terrific person who gives more than they ever receive.
To me, people like TT and my Mom are the role-models we should be looking toward. They teach us about staying positive, finding solutions, not dwelling on problems, and so many more things.
My sincerest respect to TT.
by tonythetiger
by x-marcap
As a Mud person I would slap you so hard that my hand would hurt. (Mud people slap to show respect for each others strength, harder the slap, more respect,) Since I am not, I merely say "Character is its own just reward. and you are blessed very abundantly."
God Bless you Tig.
by x-marcap
Weather he knew it or not. He put his country above his own safety. He could have run to Canada or Australia, but he served.
When did you put your butt in harm's way?
by jdclyde
when you consider who many of those countries are, and what their financial stake was to appose any and everything.
Again, look at the countries that are in charge of human rights in the UN and tell me we should give a rip about what they think?
We keep hearing OZ railing about the Americans not seeing more than one side, but we don't ever hear more than one side from him either. Just happens to always be on the OTHER side, is all.
Consistantly.
by tonythetiger
of the US, but not for the reasons they state. They are afraid because they think that our success means their failure. Especailly the socialist types. They (and most of us too actually) haven't caught on to the fact that a country's strength is not in its government (no matter what form), but in its people. All forms of government are inherently evil. That's not to say than anarchy should rule everywhere, but that government must be tightly controlled so that it cannot move contrary to the will of its people. Obviously we're not quite there yet.
I truly have every confidence that 'people' will eventually win out. The only questions are how long will it take, and how bumpy the road will be.
by oz_media
Nobody opposes spreading democracy, nobody opposes helping another country disarm terrorists and build a democratic nation...at least I don't if that's what you were suggesting.
People do oppose FORCING democracy by initiating wat on all citizens good friend or foe. People do oppose invading a country and no tonly disarming terrorists but in some cases repeating their horros and killing thousands of innocent citizens also. Peope do oppose forcing you rway of governingn on another country...at least I don't if that's what you were suggesting.
Especially when democracy is not the whole reason nor the justification given and supported for years now, to invade Iraq.
Your own president went against his own word when he invaded Iraq, he had previously agreed to the use of force if needed to finish inspections.
Your comments were refreshing in comparison to the usual flames though, thank you.
If you were talking to someone else, oops, my bad. :)
by tig2
There are way too many who truly believe that they have some "right" to define your life and how you will be allowed to live it.
I learned a long time ago to steer clear of such people as the concept of agree to disagree is not in their lexicon.
Their biggest problem is that they want capitulation on their terms and only on their points. Unfortunately that veiw is generally short sighted.
I don't DO assimilation. I refuse to conform to what is referred to as "the norm". I believe I can do better than that.
by oz_media
Actually everyone was basically on the same side until you went against your word and invaded Iraq.
As far as one side vs teh other.
I am definitely on the majority vote here, and if we were to take the world and govern it with democratic principals (like the UN was supposed to be) that you feel are so important to have, then you would not be at war. the democratic vote would have been against th einvasion and perhaps, now several years later, it woul dhave been decided that an invasion was necessary....an allied invasion. this may have happened even in a few weeks/months, but you just couldn't wait, oh well, have fun in Vietnam again. Your troops weill be there until they get tired and too thin, when they leave Iraq will slowly resort back to the nation it chooses to be, as has Afghanistan.
You need to look back every now and then. The troops in Afghanistan are experiencing problems with the Taliban just as if the war had just began. The Afghan government (that was so trumphantly left in charge) has ousted the women, and does little to stop the Taliban. in their eyes, it's better to have the Taliban in control than America.
Will this repeat after 10 years of war in Iraq with tens of thousands dead? Well done.
And actually, at the time I was in the service (1972 through 1978), my life was at MORE risk in the United States. I used to ride a motorcycle (in uniform) to base, and TWICE I was harassed and literally run off the road by hippie-types shouting anti-war crap at me. Another time, while I was minding my own business having dinner at a bar and grille (again, in uniform, but at a different duty station, one with no base support), I was "strongly advised" by the bartender to hurry and finish eating because most people there did not like GIs, and I should leave for my own safety. Contrast that to today, where I have actually gone to a restaurant manager, gave him a $50 bill, and told him to "advise" that GI and his family that somebody else paid for his dinner.
The types I encountered in the 70s are the same types of people who, today, are actually helping our enemy.
And get this, while Julian wonders if I am willing to put my life on the line for the things I believe in, the one thing I espouse the most is doing that very thing, living one's life without the "presumed safety" of dependency on the government. If you ask me, it's the government-dependency proponents, like Julian, who are the real chicken-$hits -- afraid to go through life without their crutch.
Don't you just love his smarmy messages?
by tig2
I find it facinating that Julian would even ask this question.
But then, in my personal opinion, he is a weasel. But that's just MY opinion.
Max, I am so sorry that for all that you did to serve this country, it was at a time when the country was too stupid to realise what that meant to them. You wearing the uniform meant that others had the freedom to do idiotic things- like try to run you off the road.
I, for one, am d@mned grateful to anyone who wears that uniform, past and present. Without them, we would have no ability to stand as a nation.
Incidentally- I did notice that Julian has never been in the service. As far as I am concerned, that kind of disqualifies him in this discussion.
by faradhi
I am just barely old enough to remember that time. I was five when my father was stationed in Virginia Beach. It was the worst duty station that he was assigned.
My mother had a very diffcult time finding a job because she was the wife of a sailor. (which was needed raising 5 kids on an enlisted mans salary) My parents had to send my older sister, brother and me to private school because the public schools treated the children of military badly. It is the only time I remember my father coming home with bruses.
I heard stories of some people not bring their families because they did not have room in Military housing and they could not find an affordable apartment. Luckly, that was our shortest station.
My father has told me dozens of other stories.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
.
.
.
.
by tig2
Between the site issues and my own need to think, I apologise that it took me so long to get to this post.
I appreciate your positive and caring support. Writing that post was very difficult but seemed the only way I could clarify why I believe that social programmes are not the answer in this society and why banning something (in this case weapons) doesn't work to modify behaivior.
I was sickened that Julian only read tragedy in all of that and I had to take that thought into a corner and wrestle with it. Makes me sad really that someone only sees why the social programme should be extended instead of seeing that I became a better person for the experience. It is just so WRONG to rob someone of the experience that may be the epiphany of their life.
I am so truly grateful for your enncouragement. Thank you so much for your kindness.
by tonythetiger
Max,
Being a Libertarian is a losing proposition. This is and probably always will be a two-party system, and as others have said, the best that can be hoped for is a role as spoiler. I think the thing to do instead, is join the one of the two parties that is closest to your beliefs, and lobby hard for adoption of the best of the Libertarian platform into the platform of your chosen party. Perhaps then, the middle majority will actually have a say in things.
by ontheropes
by jevans4949
- Ask any Moslem who becomes a Christian. The pressure placed on them to conform is incredible.
Not that Moslems are unique in this respect.
A thing I find fascinating about American society is that, while the libertarian principle does provide an environment where people can set up their own communities with their own rules (although within limits), these communities quickly develop sytems forcing conformity to these norms. E.g., the Pilgrim Fathers left Europe to find religious freedom, but the state they founded was responsible for the Salem Witch Trials. At one level, the US Civil War itself was the imposition of (Northern) values on the Southern states. Then there was the pressure on the Mormons to abandon polygamy.
Not to say that I am in favour of slavery or polygamy, just that a libertarian should be able to cope with them.
Sort by Trending