Discussion Locked

Being a Libertarian in Today's United States

0 helpful
236 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

236 replies

by ontheropes

Do you need references and links? I don't think you do.

Where's that blog? (poke)(prod)(kick)

Tomorrow, Tomorrow
I love you, Tomorrow.
You're only a day a-waaaaaaay!

(I had to do it. It's the caffeine.)

by colonel panijk

It occurs to me that the reason we have shifted over the burden of taking care of those less fortunate from charity to government may be this: as our personal wealth has increased (in general), we become more and more uncomfortable with those we see begging in the streets. We are more comfortable with (or perhaps, resigned to) the government dipping into our pockets (taxes) to pay social benefits than having to face the guilt over our good fortune and dip into our own pockets to pay directly for the needy (charity). That is, we're another step removed from having to deal with the needy.

I'm not saying that public social welfare programs are better than private charity, or vice-versa. I really don't know how to call this one. Certainly, only some far-out fringe type is happy to pay for those who simply [i]refuse[/i] to work. For the rest of the [i]truly[/i] needy, we can ask, "Why were social welfare programs put in place?" The answer, most probably, is that private charity was unequal to the task. This may have been an artifact of the widespread destitution in the Great Depression, and no longer valid.

If we were to eliminate welfare, food stamps, Social Security (try touching [i]that[/i] third rail, Mr. Politician!), and all other entitlements, could private charity pick up the burden? Are we going to put anyone who refuses to work up against the wall and ventilate them? What constitutes "able but unwilling"? If I'm trained as a programmer, but unable to find work because my job has gone to India, should I be forced to do some work I can't stand ("Would you like fries with that?")? Should the government pay to retrain me into some other professional work, or is that forbidden by Libertarian principles?

What if people were not willing to donate sufficient amounts to charity to take care of the needy? Do we let them starve? What constitutes "sufficient" -- enough to leave them clothed in rags and barely alive, or enough to have a somewhat "decent" standard of living? I get the impression that pre-welfare state, the former condition was more likely, especially if someone didn't have close family to take them in. Is the Libertarian Credo "God wills your suffering" or is it "There but for the Grace of God go I"?

I'm not happy about paying taxes, and I'm furious about waste, fraud, corruption, and mismanagement in government social welfare programs. Can they be cleaned up and run efficiently, limited to those who truly deserve help, and helping only to the point of a "decent" lifestyle (plus help in (re)training to get a good job)? Or should we dump the whole burden on private charity and expect people to dig into their pockets voluntarily? What happens if they don't? Do [b]you[/b] want to face swarms of hungry beggars?

I just don't know what the answer is. Would I pay the same amount out-of-pocket for the two systems? Would tax deductions continue for charitable donations? Is one system more or less demeaning to the recipient than the other? Does anyone care? If charity handouts are more demeaning, does that drive better behavior (i.e., getting out there and looking for a job)? After 70 years of New Deal and 40 years of Great Society, could it be done? Or have our "lower" classes rotted away like Russian society did under 70 years of Communism?

by jdclyde

To start, it is convenent to have this lable "less fortunate". Your fortune is based on YOUR efforts, correct? People that do not put forward that same effort do not DESERVE the same fortune.

Guilt? No one in their right mind should EVER feel guilty for doing something well. If you lied and cheated your way to wealth, ok, you got some guilt to deal with. Those of us that busted out butts to get what we have DESERVE everything we can get.

Would we give away as much if the government wasn't TAKING it away from us? Again, way off the point. If you have more money, you SPEND more money. If you spend more money, people that sell the services you buy are prosperous and THEY spend money.

Us keeping the money flowing in our communities is what creates jobs for those that want them. Those that don't want them, you throw them a life saver. They don't grab that life saver, they sink.

If you notice, back in the fifties and sixties, there were a lot of poor people. They were hard working people and proud people that did what it took to get by and raise their families. Not with welfare, but hard work.

Now there is a handout to every bum, so is it any wonder that americans ARE becomeing the laziest people in the world? ANYONE out there that is unemployed that watches migrant workers out in the feels should be deeply ashamed of themselves. Anyone on ANY form of government support because they "can't find a job" while there are jobs americans are too friggen lazy to take? Disgusting.

And it is DIRECTLY the Democrats FAULT for this loser mentality that is rotting this GREAT country, by instilling the vicitimization syndrom on them. It isn't their fault they are complete failures and didn't finish school and now can't/WON'T get a job.

The NEW DEAL is a raw deal, and things have gotten worse, not better.

by colonel panijk

Calm down, JD. You're frothing at the mouth.

[i]less fortunate[/i] Well, that's the conventional, uh, euphemism for "lazy bastards". If someone won't [i]try[/i] at all, I agree that they should starve to death. But if they have various "problems" and handicaps, even someone smart and ambitious may well find themselves out in the cold. These P&Hs may include being the "wrong" race, going to crummy schools, having rotten parents, being mentally ill to some degree, etc., etc. There [i]are[/i] people out there facing huge hurdles. They deserve at least a little sympathy. That doesn't cover everyone without money -- some are just lazy and deserve to be screwed over.

[i]Normal[/i] people tend to feel a bit uncomfortable when confronted with disadvantaged people. Call it guilt, or call it something else, but if you see a beggar in a wheelchair don't you feel a bit sorry for them? NOWHERE did I say that someone should feel guilty simply for doing a good job! Some people [i]are[/i] vastly overpaid for what they do (most any CEO, for example) and should feel guilty , especially if their huge and unwarranted paycheck means that the mailroom clerk has to survive on minimum wage.

[i]If you have more money, you SPEND more money.[/i] Ah yes, how good it is that trickle-down economics (Reaganomics) is still alive and well. I suppose that if you buy a Rolls-Royce instead of a Chevy, the homeless veteran down on the corner will magically be showered with money? If all that extra wealth tended to flow into the local economy, where it would do the "little people" some good, I would agree with you. However, extra wealth tends not to end up in local hands. Sad, but true. If you [i]do[/i] spread it around locally, that's wonderful. My observation is that if you have twice as much money as the next guy, you're not going to buy twice as many cheeseburgers at the local burger shop. Instead, you'll spend it on upscale stuff and actually [i]reduce[/i] local spending.

I can't disagree that the welfare state [i]as presently implemented[/i] has destroyed traditional personal values and work ethic. People [b]do[/b] need to get an education, get trained, and get their butts out there to do an honest day's labor. Sure, there are plenty of jobs -- picking lettuce, for example. Does that mean that anyone who's been laid off should head for the Imperial Valley and work alongside the Mexicans for sub-minimum wage? I don't think anyone should be forced to take [i]any[/i] available job, but should try to get something fitting their skills, and get retrained if there's nothing available. Of course, that retraining would likely be paid for with taxpayer dollars, wouldn't it?

[i]DIRECTLY the Democrats FAULT[/i] Yawn. How many years have we had Democratic administrations in the last half century, versus how many Christian-Nazi (oops, I mean Republican)? You can't pin all the blame on the Demos. The overall culture has its problems too.

by tig2

That they may chose to find finer stuff in them.

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=196739&messageID=2051512

I know from direct experience that social programmes do NOT accomplish what they set out to do and in fact create people who learn how to play the system through personal irresponsibility. It is the responsible person that pays their way.

If real values are taught from the cradle, the "needy" become people in hardened circumstance for a short time. They are the ones tht have the wherewithal and the drive to make a better life for themselves. As long as the system rewards laziness and sloth, that is what we will continue to see.

Please take the time to read the link and then tell me if I am wrong.

Edited for typo

by tonythetiger

"I know from direct experience that social programmes do NOT accomplish what they set out to"

... that they accomplish [b][i]exactly[/i][/b] what they set out to (though that is entirely different than what they [b][i]claim[/i][/b] they are trying to accomplish).

by maxwell edison

Define "the needy". Now identify people who are recipients of government social programs (any program that gives money, goods or services paid for by other people) who are not "the needy". If you want to have a reasonable conversation on the matter, those two things must be differentiated between, because they fall under completely different categories.

Our government spends in the neighborhood of 1.5 trillion dollars (or more), combined, on both groups of the aforementioned people. Divide our 300 million population into that number, and you'll come up with an average of $5,000 (or more) spent on every man, woman, and child in the United States -- each and every year -- on "social programs". Now I can't answer this question, but how many of the 300 million could be eliminated from being defined as "needy"? I might eliminate 90 percent -- or more, probably eliminating 95 to 99 percent. After all, 95 percent of our population is working and/or are dependents of those working people. And out of our 130 million (give or take) tax return filed every year (many of which are joint returns), did you know that about 40 million of them don't pay any federal income taxes at all?

We could go on and on illustrating the lunacy of our social programs, especially when people (like you?) try to pigeon-hole all of them into programs for "the needy". If only "the needy" were recipients of such funds, they'd be receiving somewhere in the neighborhood of $150,000 a year in money, goods or services. The point being, obviously, more than just "the needy" are recipients of government dollars.

Back to my first question. Define "the needy", and how many "needy" people live in the United States -- AND are U.S. citizens (do we even want to go there)?

My definition of "the needy" might be, any person who would die, or runs a high risk of dying, without assistance from others. And I might guess (no numbers to substantiate it), that might be one percent of our population. Wait a minute, it's probably more than that because the government, by taking SO much of people's hard-earned dollars, actually creates more "needy" people because they restrict (or make impossible) a person's full ability to care for him or her self. And consider this: We actually have less money, as a society (whether that be through government or private organizations) to provide for "the needy" because so much of it is taken and given to those who are not.

My point, however, is to illustrate that those who group ALL government social programs into "the needy" group are either EXTREMELY naive' or EXTREMELY dishonest and disingenuous. Which one are you, or do you want to change your story?

by tonythetiger

$5,000 is what the needy person gets. The other $45,000 is administrative costs :)

[oops! That should read $145,000]

by colonel panijk

Most welfare goes to corporations, big farmers, military contractors (remember $600 toilet seats?) and other wealthy owners of the government. Relatively little gets to people who genuinely need help because they've been dealt a bad hand in life. For "social welfare" programs, it's true that some amount too much goes to those who don't deserve it. Note that no one was ever able to track down the "welfare queen" that Ronnie liked to rant about. Does money get wasted? Sure. It was just reported that a huge chunk of the money passed out by FEMA after Hurricane Katrina went for things other than basic food and shelter. I don't like it, and obviously you don't either, but at least I'm not foaming at the mouth.

This society needs to strike some sort of balance between giving a helping hand to those who [i]truly[/i] need it, while not handing out taxpayer dollars to outright thieves. I wouldn't mind paying taxes so much if I knew that it was being spent efficiently, and going only to those who needed it and not to fat cats. I suspect that's the real reason you libertarians are so heated up -- not that the destitute are being helped but that so much is wasted in the process. At least, that would be the [i]rational[/i] way to look at it.

by tonythetiger

we need a new kind of deduction.

What if when you gave $100 directly to a needy family (all properly documented, of course) that it would reduce by $100 the amount that family could get in government assistance, and would also reduce your tax bill by $100?

by jingle2

I would like to sign up to receive $100 from at least 10,000 people. I will properly receipt all monies received and provide documentation. This way you can assuage your guilt and make me wealthy, all in the same move. What more could you ask for - absolution for you, big bucks for me. I also have a few kids who need to sign up...

by themonster

"And what about those people, the lawmakers and/or the voters, who do decide such a thing? Are there any ?stupid parents? among that group of people? Of course there are. Do we give those other people, some of whom are obviously stupid, decision-making power over every parent just to make sure they have decision-making power over stupid parents -- especially considering these people just might be stupid parents themselves? I don?t think so."

This is the one that's always stumped me. I have gone so far as to name it "The Fundamental Contradiction of the Democratic Nanny State", and it is basically your above line of questioning boiled down to this:

How can a person who is not competent to make decisions in his own life, or on behalf of his children, walk into a polling place and through some mystical transubstantiation become an infallible judge of how EVERYONE's life should be lived, whether via direct enactment of the laws in question via referenda, or be electing representatives to do it on his behalf?

It seems to me that there are two broad classes of people who buy into this mentality:
1. Those who have been persuaded that they truly aren't competent to make these decisions, and need Nanny to keep them safe and secure.
2. Those who think they'd make good Nannies.

Lest anyone interpret this diatribe as a partisan attack against Big-D Democrats (who want the government to be your Mommy), the exact same logic applies to the Big-R Republicans (who want it to be your Daddy). I would prefer that people just grow the hell up.

In closing, I'll leave you with the money line from Sunshine, by Jonathan Edwards: "He can't even run his own life; I'll be damned if he'll run mine!"

by tonythetiger

Children's services gets a report of abuse or neglect, severe enough to warrant removal of the children. It goes to court and the court declares the mother unfit. The court then asks the mother [i][b]"Is there a relative or someone else you prefer the children be placed with?"[/b][/i]

Does anyone see the logical flaw(s)?

by mjwx

The Taurus CH85 (.38 cal revolver?) would be totally legal in AU as long as you have sat your pistol license and have a safe to keep it in. But that?s beside the point.

I am a cynical person but that only makes me want a better world more.

Jules explained our Medicare system well enough, but the point I am trying to make is that not all social programs are the evil wealth distribution schemes that max makes them out to be. Some are investments in industries to promote growth (agriculture, technology, R&D) and some are economic stabilization (preventing a section of your economy from falling over from drought or shortage for example).

I do not agree that welfare should be abolished but the system needs to be redesigned completely not to benefit the bludgers. It's on my list of thing to overhaul.

I'd make a lot of changes if I were PM. a few amongst them would be. Reform IP laws, if a lawsuit can?t be sorted out in three days (devices/software may be torn apart to prove/disprove the case) the case should be thrown out of court. Movie and music rights remain in the hands of the artists and distributors "rent the rights" from them. I would also start a few armament industries in AU to supply our army, $1 each for a 5.56 is far too much its no freaking wonder we have a bullet shortage.

Well that?s my rant for today.

by jingle2

As America slides closer and closer to the edge of socialism, many of us are becoming alarmed at the lackadaisical attitude of much of the populace. Our troubles are compounded by the overwhelming rush of illegal aliens giving birth at our hospitals and walking the tab, getting free schooling and health care and making demands of our system that they didn't even earn the right to argue over. Combine that with the awful results of President Johnson's War on Poverty, with the re-enslavement of the majority of blacks in the nation, and the loss of the sense of responsibility to understand our country, how we got here and how we can keep it. It's amazing that we managed to keep it together long enough for the Soviet Union to fall to pieces. We can only hope that the average American is fed up enough with this mess that we clean out the House and Senate these next election cycles, and that we put in some clear headed businessmen and thinkers that are FOR our country instead of FOR lining their pockets from their vantage point in Washington. Full speed ahead.

by maxwell edison

You are so far from understanding my point, that it's a waste of time to continue this discussion. You are either a total and complete idiot, or so far down the denial trail that there's no hope for you.

Hint: Spare us the usual rhetoric. Try reality for a change.

by maxwell edison

It appears to me that your rhetoric IS your reality. If so, you are living in a fog.

Question: For argument's sake, consider me one of the "fat cats" to whom you refer. And for argument's sake, consider YOU one of the "needy". By what authority, and by what justification, should I be forced to give anything to you? And by what authority, and by what justification, should you be entitled to receive anything from me?

Another hint: Did you know that Warren Buffet personally (not business) receives dollars taken from you and me?

by viztor

What are some of the things people complain about today? Outsourcing and excessive compensation to CEOs. These are problems because we live in an oligarchy, with government for sale to the highest bidder. Adam Smith did not believe in a totally unfettered market. There needs to be a series of checks and balances in society. Now that the capitalists have neutered government, we're seeing the consequences. Libertarians have noticed the desire of "conservatives" for total social control, and tried to distance themselves from that, but still buy most of the old arguments. The tax-and-spend liberal is dead! Long live the borrow-and-spend conservative!

And now, back to your normally scheduled discourse.

by tonythetiger

CEOs are merely a distraction... one of many demons created by (mostly) liberals to draw attention away from what's really going on. You could take the entire salary of every CEO in the country and it wouldn't make one percent of what the government steals from the people. They will continue to do so as long as the people take the bait.

by tonythetiger

"This society needs to strike some sort of balance between giving a helping hand to those who truly need it, while not handing out taxpayer dollars to outright thieves."

You should bone up on your social history. The truly needy were having their needs met by their local communities all along. Welfare was invented for those who either took advantage of the good will of their comminities to the point where they were cut off, or didn't like the kind of help they were getting from the communities.

Then, later, needy people were added to the program because due to the increase in taxation, communities no longer had the resources to help the truly needy, and it's been snowballing ever since.

Eventually government services will consume every dollar made in this country unless something is done. And frankly, the longer we wait, the harsher the solution is going to have to be.

by jingle2

I repeat a portion of my earlier posting - Mr. Lyndon Baines Johnson and friends were architects of the greatest set of enslavement laws our country has ever seen. In the name of improving the lot of "the needy" we turned a large portion of African-American families into "the needy" in order to assuage the guilt of a handful of rich senators and congressmen. we piled them into the ghettos of the future - we told them that if they had more children we would give them more money - we told them that if the father left they would get a bigger check. What did we get? A harvest of large, fatherless families, with no role-models, no breadwinners and more reasons for the rich senators and congressmen to feel guilty. These young, fatherless men with no clue of how to be a man gathered together to become thugs and criminals, crackheads and lost. Is it any wonder that the influx of illegal aliens has been so easy. We train people not to work, not to excel, not to care about each other. As far as the reins of govt under the Democrats - they started all this mess. John Kennedy today would be considered a moderate Republican - he and Zell Miller would likely agree on a lot of issues. Jimmy Carter, for all his self-effacing was a miserable failure as president - he just added his white man's guilt to the pile and kept the nightmare going - more ghettos, more poor and more anger stoked by the white man's guilt. Reagan was a breath of fresh air by comparison. Unfortunately, in the meantime, Republicans forgot their zeal and discovered the joys of prostitution. They continue today with almost as much cluelessness as the Democrats. The only difference between the R's and the D's today is the mess of sickos that ride the coattails of the D's who want to rule over you and me - because they understand their own superiority and realize they are the saviors of the world. When the man on the street finally got a chance to stir things up - what did he get? Ross Perot...great. It is time to turn the Senate and the House - pretty much completely. They are so incestuously ingrown that they are unable to know right from wrong, up from down, or even remember why they were sent to Washington in the first place. It's not too late - but it's awfully close.

by tonythetiger

He was actually trying to undo some of the damage created by FDR after the depression and it's my personal suspicion that that played as big a role in his assassination as anything else. Brother Bob was of a similar mind and sufferred a similar fate. Brother Ted saw the writing on the wall and started leaning more to the left hoping he'd be spared. It worked.

Disenfranchising men (as many as possible) is a big part of their plan to maintain the status-quo. Take them down, keep them down, and they're less of a threat. They've done a good job of it. They've drained them of the resources to do things the "right" way, leaving it so that if they try to do what they can, they look like crackpots or criminals, demonizing them in the minds of those who [b]can[/b] do something.

Men are like dogs in some respects. They are generally loving and loyal to a fault.... unless you kick them. They'll only take so much abuse before they lose their reason to be loyal and lovable. Then they start roaming around in packs, with the obvious dangers and consequences.

People are worried about the gang situation now. What are they going to do when the problem is a hundred or a thousand times bigger?

I'll tell you exactly what they'll do. They'll declare that these thugs and criminals should be eradicated because they do not belong in our society.... they're not productive, they consume resources that could be put to better use, etc.

Ironic isn't it?

by jdclyde

that I had misjudged you, and I am sorry.

You had seemed like a total wacko, and it appears not to be entirely the case.

[b]"directly the Democrats Fault"[/b] to back that up, what party is it that pushes the welfare state? That is what I was refering to. This welfare state does not lift people up, it keeps them down and trading welfare checks for votes. An intentionally created peasent class, if you will. Where do you think the "overall culture" that you speak up CAME FROM?

Mind you, the Republicans have many problems of their own, but that is not one of them. I am disgusted with both, for different reasons.

In Michigan, if you are a "displaced worker" (shop closes down) you CAN get FREE retraining paid for by the state. That is an investment in the workforce that is a very valid expense.

We have many worker programs for people that are mentally retarded. They get REAL jobs, and learn to live a real life on their own.

sub-minimum wage? What is that? I think you should WANT ANY JOB that allows you to pay your bills. After you have that taken care of, then you have the luxury of looking for bigger and better. I got to where I am now, raising a family of four, working in a shop for $6.50 an hour, and whatever side jobs I could pick up. Oh yeah, put myself through college at the same time. My no means am I from a silver spoon family, and now have a fairly comfortable life. Oh yeah, at $6.50 an hour, it turned out I made too much money to get any kind of help from the government. I know people making more that got assistance, but back then I seemed to have too fair of skin. Things were really messed up, and the hard working people that just needed a HAND, are denied. People sitting on their a$$es though get a full ride. Time to put a time limit on that free ride.

Trickle down. Buying MORE local products is good. Sorry, I don't go for the fancy imports, and I don't do my shopping at Borgmart. I even hit the local pharmacies over the chains, and local markets over the chains. A trait I am teaching my boys.

by dr_zinj

Government, Federal, State, and Local, should be reduced to the absolute minimum.

The government should NOT be in the social welfare business. Politicians complain that people don't save enough. Well, why should they when their rich Uncle Sam will bail them out? Government in the U.S. has done it's best to turn people into dependents on the government. The old, "dog not biting the hand that feeds it" gambit. The anti-gun lobbiests doing their damnest to ensure that said dog's teeth are pulled. And court system rulings married with psychobable from experts basically saying that people aren't responsible for their actions. Sounds like a perfect recipe for making an entire nation of impotent people.

Our current president has done more to damage world opinion of the United States than any group of people since the creation of our nation. And he, and our elected federal representatives have done more to destroy personal liberty than any other group in the history of our nation too. The saddest part is that the American people not only let them, but in many cases urged them to do so. America, well on its way to becoming a nation of people who will never become responsible adults.

by jingle2

...would have been John F. Kerry presiding over this mess. He thinks you're incapable of thinking for yourself - he and Hillary would make a great Pres/VP combo - they both think you are stupid and can't take care of yourself. George has his issues and the loss of freedoms is much more severe with John F and company than with Bush. The govt snooping into my banking habits and cell phone calls is not so un-nerving to me as the collection of guns at gunpoint by National Guardsmen in the aftermath of Katrina. I saw a video of some law enforcement/guard types wrestle a .38 away from a little old lady (in her own home) - "for her own protection." Yeah, right. So many of our problems wouldn't be problems if our elected reps had been doing their jobs. Govt needs to get back to basics and get out of micro-managing our lives.

by cryan2457

Nice rant. Not that I don't agree with the first half, but the non-sequiter of the second is astounding.
There are Nice Little Theoretical viewpoints possible as revisionist little "l" libertarian ways of commenting on the ways to conduct a war. Like "if we weren't then they wouldn't have " - useless. We are at war, and unless you have an idea how to allow complete domestic freedom and liberty while denying information or cover to the enemy, then learn to compromise. And get over it.
Intellectual purity is the justification of all the "great" freedom movements - like the Pogroms of the Czar, the Cheka (USSR), even the French Terror.
Gee, I used to be an intellectually pure small & big "L" libertarian. Until I had children, and worries began about the world I would leave them.

As for world opinion, let them reproduce with themselves. I will trade with them, and not ask that they like me or insist that I like them. And I am fully willing to kill them if they won't respect my right to be left out of their issues or problems. The old "your right to swing your fist wildly ends at my nose".

Lastly, don't even begin to blame G.W.Bush unless you want to get into a discussion about Jimmah Carter and Billy-Bob Clinton and Johnny Kennedy and Lyndon Johnson and Tricky Dicky. The "government" is a collection of people and an accumulation of actions. The issues started long ago and the system has been perverted to permit us to live our lives without having to face consequences.

by tonythetiger

You have exactly displayed the nature and scope of the current problem, as well as the mentality that led to it.

Well Done!

by Former member

i don't give the guy on the corner any money. How do i know the previous 9,999 people didn't.

by tonythetiger

That's why the resources for giving help should be under community control. The community [b]knows[/b] who in their community needs help, what kind of, and how much help they need.

by jamesrl

Cause if he has an abuse problem, giving him money is facilitating his addiction.

I give to United Way and similar groups. They will give him food and shelter.

James

by oz_media

Too often yu are quick to discredit with no basis to support your claims. I proved where you had done some flaming, you feel that wasn't trying to flame/discredit/banish what I had said?

Sho wme how your comment was not a flame, I showed you how it was. Your only reply is the witless, 'whatever dude'.

I can only say you concede the point and I was correct in my post, yet you try so hard to make it not seem that way. A fear of being corrected or not always right, well done nice retort.

by mikiel

Mjwx,

Not sure what marrying the subjugated has to do with collectivism, but you?re right that militaristic governments tend to be very heavy-handed with the citizenry and individual rights ? the opposite of what you?d think a libertarian would want.

(I?ll purposely not touch the hot Bush topic.)

I think China is the world?s biggest economy because it has, like, one fourth the world?s population. At that size, it?s hard to go wrong with any government economy-wise. I do see its economy getting better and better as it becomes more capitalist. It?s only just now going through its industrial revolution.

As for European socialist systems ? I share Maxwell Edison?s bias. I think that the massive socialist bent leads to many people working under the table and/or not working as hard as they could due to not getting much more take home pay when their salary increases (due to high taxation). There?s not much (or as much) incentive to try to work/earn more.

The socialist medical system seems to yield the same or similar levels of quality (as the U.S. capitalist medical system). However, it also seems to yield very, very long waiting lists. (You see a similar result in rent-controlled apartments ? anywhere that free trade is perverted. Well, with rent control you also have a drop in quali...) However I?m still wrestling with a good solution to the U.S.?s many un- or under-insured (of which I used to be one). Perhaps that?s just a necessary side-effect of capitalism (or insurance companies).

Not sure why Maxwell seems to dismiss comments from people outside the U.S. I think it?s very enlightening to hear from people working under alternate economic systems ? especially when discussing economic and social systems.

This discussion is closed to new replies.