[b]Now it's final. I will [i]NEVER[/i] upgrade to Vista.[/b]
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by apotheon
First: I agree with a central tenet of your post, 100%. Even though you only clearly mention it at the end, I figured I'd quote it at the top of my reply and respond to it, because it's important that this is not lost in the noise of the rest of my response.
"[i]Product activation sucks. No doubt, but it is Microsoft?s right. It's your right to choose not to use their products, which some have done and that's fine.[/i]"
That's absolutely true.
There is no reason in the world that Microsoft should not be allowed to use product activation schemes to attempt to prevent unauthorized copying. Whether or not that copying is ethical or legal is, in fact, completely irrelevant to that simple fact. Microsoft has a right to try to limit your use of its software, through technological means, any way it likes -- as long as it doesn't use violence, threat of violence, or fraud to do so. If it is up-front, honest, and straightforward about the operation of its software, you have no room to complain about its operation on any ethical grounds.
It still sucks, as you rightly point out. It's still a very good reason to avoid Microsoft's offerings, if "product activation" bothers you enough to seek out alternatives. It still devalues the software for us, the consumers, in everyday use. We would rather not deal with it, and to the extent that it is a disincentive to using MS software, we have every right to let it push us into using MS Windows less and less.
Boycotting MS software is a perfectly reasonable solution, if you find its product activation "features" that odious. I avoid MS software whenever at all practical, for this reason among others. Just as Microsoft has a right to impose these convenience costs on users of its software, its users have a right to abandon it like rats leaving a sinking ship when those convenience costs overcome the convenience opportunities associated with the software.
"[i]First, I do not work at Microsoft. I do not know anyone who does.[/i]"
I do. Very nice girl. Smart, creative, and good at what she does. That doesn't alter my ability to see what Microsoft does for what it is, though.
"[i]However, I also understand their desire to protect their intellectual property and right to profit as a business.[/i]"
Microsoft doesn't have any such right. It has a right to [b]pursue[/b] profit -- nothing wrong with that. It doesn't have a right to [b]actually[/b] profit. Only the success or failure of its business model can determine whether it profits. Rights don't come into that part of it.
"[i]Can you tell me how they're supposed to prevent the millions of users in these places from pirating their software?[/i]"
They can't. That's all there is to it. Ultimately, there's no way to prevent "piracy". All that stuff like product activation does is make things more difficult for people who follow Microsoft's rules, and those who only violate Microsoft's rules out of laziness (because product activation makes following the rules the more-lazy option). Product activation doesn't prevent (nor does it even markedly slow down) "piracy", though.
"[i]Just like you don't like the idea of someone stealing your friends car or CD's or whatever, neither should you like the idea that someone is stealing their software.[/i]"
That's a broken analogy in a major way. If someone steals my friend's CDs, my friend doesn't have those CDs any longer. My friend doesn't even have the music that was on them any longer, unless he violated the RIAA's rules and made MP3s of them for his own use. When people "pirate" software, however, the creators of that software lose nothing. They claim that future profits are "lost", but future profits aren't anything they already possessed.
Legally and ethically speaking, software "piracy" isn't theft. There's no stealing going on. Theft is depriving someone of a possession, not copying something without permission. The law calls the latter "copyright infringement", not theft. If you want to construct analogies to illustrate your points, you should be comparing apples to apples, or perhaps apples to oranges -- and not apples to Buicks.
"[i]Many think it's OK to steal software.[/i]"
Wrong! Many think it's okay to infringe software copyright. That's [b]not[/b] stealing. It's copyright infringement. Please stop spreading the all too deceptive "piracy is stealing" meme. It leads to absurd misapprehensions about the effects of copyright infringement, the relation of it to property law, and so on.
"[i]Almost all vendors require some sort of activation. Because you're dealing with the OS it seems rather heavy handed that MS can disable your entire system, but what else are they supposed to do? Say please don't rip me off? Pretty please?[/i]"
Here's an idea:
First, actually think about what you're doing, and think about how effective it is on the whole. Second, think about how you might be introducing unintended, negative consequences by pursuing a particular means of trying to achieve those effects. Finally, think about whether the fact that you're fighting an uphill, unwinnable battle against "piracy" might be a sign that your business model is [b]broken[/b]. Economic laws do not take the day off just because you want to use "product activation" -- that's a little like Congress trying to change the laws of nature by voting on a bill.
"[i]Also, MS will, in just about every case, bend the rules if you call and explain the situation.[/i]"
. . . which doesn't solve all the potentially disastrous problems that might arise, such as simply being incommunicado when the damned thing decides to deactivate itself.
"[i]Microsoft has the right to protect their property. If you can think of a better way I?m sure Microsoft is all ears.[/i]"
Actually, it's not. Microsoft doesn't care to hear the harsh economic truths of the matter. Microsoft wants to keep things as close to the way they are as possible, and solving this problem would involve massive changes in the Microsoft business model. The first step would be to stop thinking of something as being Microsoft property [b]after it has been sold[/b]. Only by taking that step can you start to address the matter of "piracy" in a truly effective manner, because "piracy" is going to happen as long as you think of something you've already sold as your "property", and there's nothing you can do about it. Period.
by slydder
by apotheon
"[i]Last i checked, your computer has to be turned on for the 3(30) day activation timer to countdown. Otherwise it sits in a sort of stasis.[/i]"
Last I checked, [b]my[/b] work schedule doesn't get put on hold just because [b]your[/b] business hours don't match up with mine. Assuming you're right about the way the countdown operates (big if, I think), that doesn't help if I have to get a presentation or project done, or at least to a particular completion milestone, and end up having to work over that three-day weekend. Some systems can't be shut down for a three day weekend, such as servers or systems running a build or rendering cycle (I guess you haven't done much work in heavy graphics or development shops if that didn't occur to you).
"[i]If you can not find internet in 3 days, then you probably shouldn't be using a copy of an OS that is not yours.[/i]"
I guess you're just falling back on the ol' straw man with this one, and ignoring the simple fact that what TechExec2 described might easily refer to perfectly legal OS installs. Nice friggin' job.
"[i]From reading your post and looking at your screenshot, I will take the intuitive leap and say you have never activated Vista to begin with.[/i]"
You'd be wrong. If I can tell this from the original post, you should be able to do so as well.
"[i]QQ[/i]"
Uh, what? I know what qq() means in Perl. I know, vaguely, about Tencent QQ, but that's a noun and not a verb as you're using it. What are you talking about?
"[i]The reason a lot of open source OS' do not have security issues is the rest of the world doesnt care about them.[/i]"
[b]FALSE![/b] I gather you are a security idiot. You clearly don't have a clue what you're talking about. At a guess, I'd say you've never directly used an open source OS in your life on a desktop system or PC-compatible server of any kind. Even if you have, I'm pretty sure it wasn't enough to really count for determining whether you have enough experience to say [b]anything at all[/b] relevant about them based on that experience. Read and learn about some of the realities of [url=http://articles.techrepublic.com.com/5100-10877-6064734.html][b]open source security[/b][/url]. That's really just the social aspects of security as related to open source development, and doesn't even touch on the direct architectural advantages of a unixlike system design over the broken, tightly coupled, crufty, integrated, monolithic design of Microsoft's OSes.
The real reasons for Microsoft's piss-poor security reputation are made clear in statistics like the time to patch vulnerabilities in some of its most popular software -- the absolute [b]fastest[/b] time to patch a vulnerability for [b]any[/b] Microsoft software [b]ever[/b], for instance, is [b]longer than the normal patch turn-around time for Firefox[/b]. That's a pretty bad record.
by ms owns you.
You said: "Last I checked, my work schedule doesn't get put on hold just because your business hours don't match up with mine."
Ok, the blatant offender that everyone is spewing about is a game... it has no reason to be on a business machine at your work. So, I really do not think you are taking a tract here that will do you any justice. Secondly, my reasoning for the 3/30 rule is I installed it on 2 machines on the same day. One I used everday, the other I used sporadically. when the 30 days were up on one, I looked at the less used one and it had 12 days left of usage. Hence, I am leaping to the conclusion that it is days actively used, not days since installed.
I will say, it is sad that this happens, but people should maybe point the finger at the game developer and not just Microsoft.
""QQ"
Uh, what? I know what qq() means in Perl. I know, vaguely, about Tencent QQ, but that's a noun and not a verb as you're using it. What are you talking about?"
QQ mean cry more. That is all I see as the core of the OP, crying.
Open source systems?
They serve the purpose of spurring companies like MS to try new things, but you are correct in saying I do not spend time on them. I have more important work to do than stroking my ego by saying I spend all my free time trying to figure out a way do things any way but the MS way. I do run a few UNIX boxes, but that is it.
I agree MS has had craptastic service, support, and security. I choose not to let it get to me, as just about every major software vendor out there releases buggy software. I just take it as it is and roll with it.
Firefox... Does it work? Yes. Has it worked better than IE? Yes. Is it better than IE7? Debatable. I personally do not pay attention to the patching habits of Firefox developers as I quit using it because of its slower startup time. That may have improved lately, I do not know.
by slydder
leave it to techrep to flush out the endangered species now days. I mean the rare and ever fleeting MS/Vista supporters. With tyler here I've spotted 2 here on TR alone.
that's 2 more than I've seen since the announcement of Vista.
chuck
by slydder
I've found ubuntu and PClinux to be the best for new *nix users (ymmv). once you get beyond the curve you will automatically find one that better suites you. "NO FEAR!!" make the move. you won't regret it.
chuck
by apotheon
by intj-astral
And set the bail at 100 Trillion Dollars. Quite simply, Microsoft must not be allowed to neither buy its way out nor make any appeal. No, I'm not joking. What is happening with Vista is white-collar crime. It's so obvious. Throw them in jail. it's the strongest, angriest suggestion I can make without having the FBI hang around outside my house. If you feel this embodies the unresolved anger of putting up with 20 years of b.s. from Microsoft, then say so.
TechExec2, more power to you. I have
dual-booted XP and Linux Since last August.
by techexec2
.
Although I don't like Gates and Ballmer at all, I don't think they should be thrown into jail.
I appreciate your supportive comments.
The problem is really with the U.S. government. Even though Microsoft was convicted of violating antitrust law, the government merely scared Microsoft to death, then left them intact to continue acting badly within the software industry. One thing that DID come out of that trial however, was that Microsoft should completely forget about using their monopoly in computer operating systems and software to dominate OTHER businesses such as online banking, online stock trading, or computer generated movies, etc. That is exactly the direction Microsoft was headed in, but they have completely backed off from that since then.
It is clear that the government has given Microsoft a free hand to dominate computer software for Windows. For example: Microsoft was convicted of violating antitrust law in the Internet Explorer vs. Netscape Navigator case. What is the difference between that and what Microsoft has done with Virtual PC? They bought the Virtual PC asset from its developer and put it up on the Internet for free download by anyone. This is killing VMWare. I don't see any difference there.
I'm angry at what Microsoft is doing also. But, I channel it. I am going to leave Windows and be happy on Linux and Macintosh now. So, I will put aside my anger and move on. Living well is the best revenge. I highly recommend it.
Thanks again for your support.
by ole man
And the best way to get to them is with silence. Like you say, just turn your back on them and walk away, without a word. That infuriates them.
Trouble is, I can't keep my big mouth shut.
Ciou
by noelrd
by apotheon
by intj-astral
Pure and simple. It's not innovation,
that's a PR buzzword and their using it
is a slap in the face to all in the
world who genuinely innovate. It's not
quality, otherwise there would be less
OS issues. It's not customer service,
otherwise activation issues would not be
a problem. It's greed, plain and simple.
by intj-astral
Mount the inaccessible drive in a Linux
machine. Linux is able to mount NTFS in
read-only mode, so go ahead and copy
your files and transfer them elsewhere.
Also, try knoppix. With Knoppix you
can get to the files on any computer
as long as it can boot from a DVD.
That way you can have your files and
dump Vista without losing your stuff.
by boony
by slydder
do me a favor though. once you start the move be sure to document everything and afterwards do a write-up of your move. once it's finished come by and post it on my site. www.itadmins.net.
thanks,
chuck
by stalphonzo
by stalphonzo
Deviant? Dastardly? Good god man! Nope, they?re just an aggressive capitalistic company ? the best, or one of the best at what they do (which ISN?T writing software code by the way).
No argument with that. My point in mentioning the huge profits they are already making is that they are not starving. It isn't like they need the money. So, I find it particularly offensive that in spite of huge profits that most COUNTRIES would kill to have, they are hurting legitimate customers in an effort to get more.
The only thing in that above statement that isn?t from the manual of socialism 101 and has any legitimacy in the business world is your closing sentence. I won?t disagree except to say I?d add ?they are POTENTIALLY hurting legitimate customers.? This may be the case but the fact they profit more than most countries is a GOOD THING. Wake up pal ? this is AMERICA. And don?t forget how much of that money has ended up at the Gates Foundation ? more than the GDP of most of those same countries. ANOTHER GOOD THING that wouldn?t be possible if Microsoft wasn?t so damned profitable.
The rest of your rebuttal is clearly based on the fact that you can?t stand the fact that they?re a highly profitable company. My advice for you ? move to Sweden. Socialism may work there but doesn?t work on a large scale like the US.
Your closing statement is correct and that was my point all along. It?s only when people like yourself who are blinded by some crazy hatred of big bad Microsoft forget about the business facts. Ask your CIO ? maybe he or she can help educate you on how businesses are run in the United States and why they have to make the choices they do.
by rkuhn040172
by noelrd
You can tell by their comments that most of these Linux zealots are not concerned with Vista, or factual accuracy. They just want to whine about Microsoft and evangelize about Linux.
This problem, (if there ever was one, since it was eliminated very quickly) was recorded with frame by frame captures -- like it was maybe, all planned out ahead of time.
by so.cal guy
by ole man
by apotheon
It's nice to see that, true to form, you've come to offer an in-depth, comprehensive analysis. You've definitely introduced some new facts into evidence there, such as
. . .
such as
. . .
Well. I'm sure there's something of value in your post. Must be.
by noelrd
These people who are critical of your reasoning are Linux zealots, not anything else. Linux and Unix have long had security problems from the ground up. Add in open source, and it's a complete nightmare. Sure, they've tried to patch Linux, IBM has worked on it diligently. But its deeply flawed, and everyone knows it. Also, some people with distros like BSD will almost disavow any association with Linux.
I understand your reasoning. You are sick of the Vista whiners and so am I. I say let them go their way and laugh about it later.
by apotheon
That's absurd. Are you completely buying all of Microsoft's marketing and FUD without question? Are you delusional? Are you so invested in the money you've spent on software that you can't admit the software in question isn't the best thing since sliced bread, no matter what happens? Are you just a pathological liar?
I don't think it's any of those things. I think you're just a troll.
by noelrd
by ole man
The only thing you've said is you think Microsoft a nice guy and they have every right to stick it to their customers, under the guise of preventing "piracy".
Answer if you can, how they managed to make hundreds of billions of dollars and become the biggest company in the world all the while millions of "pirates" were robbing them blind and walking all over them?
If I was making that much money, I wouldn't care whether you called it piracy or what, i'd say give me some more of that wonderful stuff.......not trying to stamp it out and screw over all the people who made me filthy rich.
by ole man
by techexec2
.
You have a career on the stand up circuit if you ever want one! As I read your post, I could barely stay on my chair! What a funny guy you are!
Ok, let's stop laughing for a minute. I'll make some clarifications for you.
[b][i]"...they?re just an aggressive capitalistic company ? the best, or one of the best at what they do (which ISN?T writing software code by the way)..."[/i][/b]
Right. Microsoft is "just an aggressive capitalist company". They just happen to be in the very rare club of those companies that have been convicted by the U.S. Govt. of violating antitrust law. They have paid many many billions of dollars in fines, penalties, and settlements because they violated the law. They have misappropriated intellectual property belonging to many other companies and lost many patent infringement lawsuits in court. They are constantly in court all around the world defending themselves, and they often lose. Yup! They're the best!
You don't have any f****** idea what you are talking about.
[b][i]"...I won?t disagree except to say I?d add ?they are POTENTIALLY hurting legitimate customers..."[/i][/b]
One: You better do your research before you repeat that. Real customers ARE having problems with WGA. And, it is outrageous that Ed Bott could merely install a game program and it triggered deactivation of the operating system with 3 days notice.
Two: Let's see. The manufacturer makes their product with a bomb inside it. And, they assure customers that there are strict safeguards in the product. [u]The bomb will only explode if the product is ever stolen[/u]. Legitimate customers have nothing to worry about. And, this manufacturer has one of the worst product quality records in their industry.
Right. I am going to trust that company and buy that product. Are you out of your f****** mind?!!
I don't care if Ed Bott is the only person on the face of the earth for whom the bomb has ever exploded. I will never buy a product with a "bomb" in it from a company like Microsoft. That is a mistake in judgment that I will never forgive.
[b][i]"...The only thing in that above statement that isn?t from the manual of socialism 101..."[/i][/b]
I'll try it one more time, a little slower, just for you.
I advocate market capitalism and private enterprise, not socialism. The [u]only[/u] reason I mentioned the huge $18 BILLION annual profit, is to illustrate the incredible greed it must take to put "bombs" in Vista that can hurt legitimate customers so that Microsoft can make even more profit. That is all. I don't care how much money Microsoft makes and would never presume to take it away from them to give to the poor people or any such thing.
[b][i]"...ANOTHER GOOD THING that wouldn?t be possible if Microsoft wasn?t so damned profitable..."[/i][/b]
You act as though the Earth would stop spinning if there were no Microsoft. Without Microsoft in the picture, there would be a great many other companies that would step up and provide software and services, countless jobs, profits, and shareholders. The world would be just fine, thank you very much.
[b][i]"...The rest of your rebuttal is clearly based on the fact that you can?t stand the fact that they?re a highly profitable company..."[/i][/b]
No. I don't care if Microsoft makes $100 BILLION profit each year, so long as they do it ethically and within the law. My beef with Microsoft is the unethical and illegal business practices they use. That is all.
You should explain how great you think Microsoft is to the former stockholders of Netscape Communications who lost money because Microsoft broke the law and destroyed their company. And, when you do, choose an old widow whose pension fund was invested in Netscape. I'm sure you'll get a lot of sympathy from her for how great you think Microsoft is.
And, don't give me any socialist or liberal crap on this either because I am neither one. While her pension fund was "at risk" in the market just like everybody elses, hers was adversely affected by Microsoft's [u]illegal[/u] conduct. That makes a difference to me, and it sure as hell should to you.
[b][i]"...And don?t forget how much of that money has ended up at the Gates Foundation..."[/i][/b]
Bill Gates does not get a pass from me because he is giving away billions of dollars now. I've watched Microsoft and Bill Gates with great interest for over 20 years now. As far as I am concerned, all those monies are tainted by the unethical and illegal business practices Microsoft used to make them.
I don't expect you to agree.
[b]In closing[/b]
You go ahead and keep on admiring Microsoft. And, after 15 years, I am no longer going to use Windows and Microsoft software because the company is now putting "bombs" in their products that could easily "go off" even though I am a legitimate customer. Those "bombs" are going to be targeted by malware. Count on it. Microsoft is just not satisfied with "only" making $18 BILLION and "only" being one of the most profitable companies in the history of man. They have to put my operating system at risk to get more from the pirates.
Finally, if you choose to reply, I'll expect you to use a properly respectful tone with me. You assume too much and have no f****** idea who you are speaking to.
And to top it all off, they intend to sell the Vista a piece at a time.
What is being passed off now as the Ultimate is only the most basic of Vistas, then the time comes when you want the add-ons, clock,notepad,etc they will charge you for it.
Then they have the nerve to Validate you and then remain connected to you so as to shut you down if they decide your a thief.
This is only the beginning of the Vista Nightmare, and anybody foolish enough to fall for it and Dumb enough to call it Great, "DESERVES WHAT He/She Get's"
I'm definitely with you on this one.
MS should be investigated if the Justice Dept had any Guts,and Sued an Mass,for invasion of privacy and client manipulation.
Regards
Aaron
by now left tr
Again - last time I checked (2 minutes ago) these items were still sitting in the correct location on my Vista Ultimate Machine. Where are you getting this false information from Aaron?
I also do not see these as 'add-ons', they are and have been part of the MS OS since the early days.
So are you trying yo tell me that they will suddenly dissapear...or start asking for money when I use them???
I think not.
Perhaps it is you that should be investigated for providing false information?
Unless MS can use port 80 and 443 over two NAT connections to keep tabs on me I'm safe I guess. The Firewalls and staefull inspection will do the trick I hope!
Hot in here today - Baking Again...
Check the reports of George OU.
I have a Beta copy [Vista RC1]and also have the peripherals.
I am also a beta tester for Microsoft. and I DO read all that is around me.
But that's not what is being touted now.
Before question my resources and integrity, check your facts.
Read and read again, some might actually get through.
By the way, it's not just YOUR system that counts, it's the millions of other people who are going to get it down the line.
So before you accuse me of falsehoods, check your facts and stop relying on your Own System. Take a look around, you're not the only one in the world.
Didn't get screwed over yet?
Lucky You, so far
Aaron
by ole man
by ms owns you.
by ole man
by ole man
by ole man
by ole man
by ole man
by ole man
by apotheon
You call him a liar -- making a pretty serious accusation -- then admit that you have no actual evidence to back it up. Not only do you not have any evidence to offer us for verification, but you cannot even provide claims of convincing evidence in your possession that you have no way of presenting. You have [b]nothing[/b] of worth to dispute his statement.
Yeah. Vicious, calling him a liar under those circumstances. Downright unethical. Libelous, even. If your statement had any credible chances of damaging his professional reputation, he'd almost have grounds for a lawsuit.
Good job.
by tyler70006
Yes I do not believe the orginal artcle is a lie, that Vista doesn't deactivate. MS admitted it does happen. I beleve the lie is that Vista is not usable because of this one instance when installing a game, expecally since the fix is known and stated in the original article.
I run into problems all the time with installing new software on all platforms, PC's, Macs and Linux (mostly Linux dependences) but I will not ever stop using them because of problems I encounter. I work through it.
I also hate the idea of having to register software also. But I guess this is the future of all software.
by techexec2
[b][i]"...I run into problems all the time with installing new software on all platforms, PC's, Macs and Linux (mostly Linux dependences) but I will not ever stop using them because of problems I encounter. I work through it..."[/i][/b]
Yes. But, the problems are never the operating system capriciously deactivating itself, sometimes with 3 days notice.
You can submit to this. That is fine. I will never submit to this.
by techexec2
.
Steve Ballmer, CEO, Microsoft Corporation #1
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wvsboPUjrGc
Steve Ballmer, CEO, Microsoft Corporation #2
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NSIMeRtVebM&mode=related&search=
Steve Ballmer, CEO, Microsoft Corporation #3
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KMU0tzLwhbE&mode=related&search=
by ambercroft
by techexec2
by ole man
by ole man
by techexec2
I always enjoy finding a wise and smart person here on TR.
All the best!
by kyledaniels
Well, I decided to attempt the move to Vista, checked the microsoft site on compatibility, everything checked out 100% compatible. Checked the manufacturers site, they said it should work on my system. Went through a 4 hour install of Vista, to find out that the sound driver within Vista are messed up and kept giving me a blue screen error every time no matter what I did to fix this, even trying to disable sound through the bios.
After about another 4-5 hours of trying to fix it, I decided to do the revert. I worked fine, but took about 2-3 hours to complete, but I am glad the revert worked great.
by slydder
but like i tell most of my clients. download a ubuntu live CD and give it a spin. the live CD's are at times a bit limited (space restrictions), however, if you actually install on the drive (which goes fast in most cases) then you become full access to the software repositories and can install to you hearts content.
and if you don't like gnome the try kubuntu (with KDE instead).
Like i tell all clients. there is a curve but you will be happy you went the distance once you realize what you have on you system afterwards.
chuck
www.itadmins.net
by techexec2
.
Some suggestions and comments for you:
- It is unfortunate that Vista is choking so hard on a mere sound card driver, but there are a lot of changes inside Vista vs. XP. Sound was greatly changed and improved in Vista.
- Check the sound card manufacturer's website for updated drivers for Vista. Or, if on the motherboard, check the motherboard manufacturer's website. Your hardware may be listed as compatible, but may need the new drivers.
- When you attempt to install Vista again, I suggest you try to do it on a separate hard drive. That way, you can quickly go back to your old hard drive with Windows XP if things don't go well. This kind of flexibility is well worth the relatively small additional cost.
I am not surprised at all that you had some problems with Vista. It works great for some people, and "feels" like a disaster for others like you. It's not REALLY a disaster, but a BSOD "feels" pretty bad no matter what the cause is. After resolving your driver issue, Vista could feel quite solid for you.
Vista is not merely an upgrade from XP. It is almost like a new operating system. Problems like yours will be resolved in the coming months. I expect that eventually Vista will be essentially as solid as XP is now when it comes to hardware support. It will probably take 9-12 months to get there though, and even then, some hardware will never be supported well in Vista (e.g. some video cards with HDTV output and Vista Media Center features). The "Vista SR-1" CD (Service Release 1) that includes the first Service Pack should be a lot better.
You know what I've chosen to do. Each of us must make up our own mind about Vista. If you want to use Vista, don't give up. It will get better.
All the best to you!
by joergsattler
It is heartening to see that Microsoft has managed to stay in character.
That character is so well established that it is probably impossible for Microsoft to "detoxify" , change away from it.
We on the other hand have been told, by a publicity champaign to expext the impossible, i.e. perfection, no problems, a seamless transition from point a (xp) to b (Vista). Never mind the accelerated hardware requirements that in effect force the overwhelming majority of users to do some serious surgery to their computers if not an outright replacement of entire systems.
Never mind that 3/4 of the existing software will have compatibility problems that will force their brand new "prefect" OS to crash or at least deactivate, and pending a probably exessively long phonecall on hold waiting, waiting, waiting, to reactivate.
NO WAY as imperfect as XP is i'll keep it.
by kyledaniels
by slydder
To be honest I have always (since windows 2) supported MS to a degree. They did more to move the PC into the home than any other company in history. Have to give them credit for that. I stopped providing my clients windows support when XP came out and I have not regretted it.
Back then I ran a site called IT Admins and posted (during the XP betas) that there would be a big move to Linux/BSD due to the new "protection" in XP. I was right. I wish I still had a copy of the old site so I could repost on my new site. lol
Anyway, a large majority of my clients are all Linux now and happy that they don't have the issues anymore. It was a bit of a learning curve but it is also worth it.
I, personnally, am crowing because it is happening again. All the new version of Windows means to me is that I will have more clients in the future (server clients) as more Windows servers are phased out.
chuck
by ole man
I too was hesitant to to move to XP because of the product activation threat, but after a year or so, when it SEEMED that Microsoft would be more or less fair about it, I was suckered into it. Didn't really have any problems (only had to call Microsoft once, and then they were nice as pie), until.....they came out with WGA. Won't go into details, but that's when the stinky brown stuff hit the proverbial fan. So much for Microsoft and Mr Nice Guy.
I now have six different Linux systems installed (although i'm still using the Windows that i've already paid for), and if Microsoft thinks i'll pay a fortune for another pile of garbage that they can remotely monitor, shut down, or even refuse to activate if I need to reinstall or upgrade my hardware, they're in for an education, regardless of how smart they are.
So I am crowing with you and the Microsoft shills are whining.
by shraven
"moved all the features around and changed their terminology so I can no longer find them"
My chief complaint for several recent versions of Windows. Nothing nex except locations and names -new ways of doing the same things.
MS needs to adopt dashboards for their OS. I could choose to run the latest splashiest, or I could choose the W2K dashboard, the XP dashboard, the advanced user dashboard, the 5 year old dashboard...
I understand the need to dumb down the product and computers become more mainstream, but not at the cost of crippling people who know how to use the product and have a history of doing things a certain way. Change for change's sake is NOT IMPROVEMENT!
You're right, it's pure greed. I'm all for companies making their millions, but when they get to their billions just what use is all that money doing sitting in a bank. As soon as their profits drop 10%, you can bet that some of their workers will be laid off, despite still having billions in the bank. These big corporations are evil.
As for Vista, it's bloated, it's expensive and I'm not going to use it. Why do Microsoft need to treat us all as software pirates? If they want to reduce software piracy, why don't they slash the costs of Windows and not have all of this activate this and activate that nonsense that annoys us all.
If anyone from Microsoft is reading these comments start listening to the people. (You probably are reading this, just like your people scan Ebay every day to make sure a second hand copy of Windows 98 isn't being sold!)
Couldn't agree with you more
Well said, Indeed.
Regards
Aaron
by techexec2
As you know, I completely agree with you. You are making the right choice.
Take care!
by shraven
by phlcarp
Why bother with Windows (either Vista or XP) when you
can get a Mac and enjoy :
- a rock solid OS (Unix BSD), exempt of viruses
- a clever and easy to use GUI
- plenty of applications, coherent with each other, so
easier to run
- a nice machine which can also run Linux and (if you are
fool enough) Windows
- free (yes, FREE) and very efficient development tools
- and no hassle with GSI or WGA
I have been using Apple computers for 29 years now,
Windows and Unix (and Linux). Now I run almost only Mac
OsX, and I'm happy...
Philippe Lecarpentier
France (76360)
by techexec2
Right you are! The new x86 Macintosh is an excellent choice. Before switching to Windows in 1992, I used to run Macintosh. And, I am heading back!
Thanks.
by techexec2
.
As you know, I have decided that I will NEVER upgrade to Windows Vista. But, having made that decision, what's next? I cannot stay on Windows XP forever. There is a very serious realization to face here:
Refusing Vista means [i]LEAVING WINDOWS[/i] :0
Of course, this is quite a shock. Windows and I have been friends since 1992. I need a project to deal with this.
So, I now have a project I call "Leaving Windows" (1), and I thought I would share it here on TR in the hope that it might be helpful to some of you. I [i]KNOW[/i] there are a lot of you out there dealing with the same problem that I am.
I hope you find it helpful. Take care...
-------------------------
(1) The [i]LEAVING WINDOWS[/i] Project
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=213495&messageID=2185615
by techexec2
.
Ballmer has repeatedly threatened patent infringement lawsuits on Linux users and distributors. They are gearing up for it. You can be sure that if sufficiently large numbers of people switch to Linux, Microsoft will make the RIAA look tame by comparison.
by arron25
by codebubba
>> I'm afraid to "upgrade" to Vista because I don't want a never-ending stream of problems... It looks like MS peaked at XP Pro. Pretty stable and doesn't require a lot of activating and authorizing. <<
That's pretty much how I view it right now. I've been using XP Pro since it came out and it really has been excellent. Everything works.
I've been slow to upgrade in the past because I generally get my systems tweaked the way I want them - but this is the first time that I'm completely resistive to the idea of upgrading. I have 5 systems at the house all running either XP Pro or XP Home. Aside from the cost to upgrade all five of those licenses I just can't see the point of upgrading - absolutely everything I plug into these systems works with little or no fuss.
I loaded Vista Ultimate onto a laptop system I have here at the office which is an expendable machine right now. Vista ran OK but after tinkering with it for a couple of weeks I was still at a loss as to why it's an upgrade. I understand that there will be a period while the drivers fill-in and some patches come out to correct things - but I just could not sell myself on why it was any better than XP Pro. I'm very likely to stay put on XP for a long time this time.
I've been developing to Microsoft patforms since the early 80's - make a good living at it, too. Still ... as I said earlier this is the first time that I really don't see the new O/S as an upgrade path in any way. Aero? Who gives a rip?
-CB
by tyler70006
You are so right... It seems they have their own agenda for doing this. Stating half truths as justification for their hate. Kind of what all prejudice people do.
Prejudice is, as the name implies, the process of "pre-judging" a particular thing for the way it acts,looks,or even a group it is involved in. It implies coming to a judgment on a subject before learning where the preponderance of evidence actually lies, or forming a judgment without direct experience.
by techexec2
I am a disgruntled Microsoft user (15 years), not a Linux zealot with an agenda.
I'm switching away from Windows because of the capricious self-deactivation code that exists in Vista. Since I have to go somewhere, it is ending up being Linux (and Macintosh). But, Linux is actually a good place to go to these days.
I simply find it unacceptable to use Vista. It ships with a "bomb" in it that can go off, even though I am a legitimate customer.
Check out the links in my original post for information about how the Vista system got deactivated.
It's perfectly OK for you or anyone else to user Vista if you want. I'm not trying to convert anyone.
Take care...
by noelrd
by jmgarvin
My Vista box, on boot, claimed that my key was in use the other day. Ok, no biggy, it has 30 days to re-validate.
So I install Half-Life 2: Episode 1, to see how it will play. Well, that turned out to be a bad idea. I had to reboot after install and now Vista claims my key is invalid.
I'm done. I don't need the hassle of WGA and I really don't care to spend anytime with MS tech support trying to get this squared away.
No wonder I moved to Linux and use Cedega to play games, eh MS?
by techexec2
It is pretty pathetic that WGA breaks down so easily like that. I instantly knew from the moment I heard about this last week that I was never going to upgrade to Vista. And, refusing Vista means leaving Windows. XP is not going to last forever. So, there's no point in prolonging the conversion to full-time Linux.
I expect this sad WGA story is going to get a lot bigger. It will probably reach mainstream media.
by so.cal guy
by jmgarvin
I'm done. I've been a Linux users for about a decade, but now, I don't even want to go near a Windows box.
Not only am I frustrated with the assumption that I am a pirate and I'm going to steal their software, but the pirates have an easier time because they DON'T have to validate.
Bah...MS must be trying to drive away consumers...
by ambercroft
by techexec2
My decision to leave Windows completely was more correct than I knew at the time then.
I still have my Windows 2000 CDs. I'll go back to that if necessary.
Microsoft and Windows do not matter to me anymore. That is ancient history.
by ole man
Not a problem to be refused patches and updates. I don't want them, even. Where the problem arises is when you need to reactivate ..., then...gotcha! "Sorry, you must install this critical update before activation can be completed". Now your goose is cooked. If you don't install WGA, your OS is dead, dead, dead. If you do install WGA, Microsoft has gotcha. Your OS might as well be dead (as to be under the control of Microsoft).
I tried to point this out when everyone was discussing the XP "kill switch". They don't need a kill switch. It's already there, concealed in their activation scheme.
What to do? what to do?
Fire up Linux!
by noelrd
You can't argue. I don't work for Microsoft and I didn't buy the software. I have no investment that way. I have invested time in learning about Microsoft's products and a huge amount of time learning about Linux. I run a web server with Solaris 10 and Apache and I'm very familiar with opensource. I can also program Cisco routers from the command line. That's where I'm coming from.
You on the other hand are such a Linux zealot that you are advising newbies to run Wine and play their games on Linux. What a hoot!
So, go back to your corner and whine away!
by apotheon
"[i]I can also program Cisco routers from the command line.[/i]"
Really? Program them? What programming language?
"[i]You on the other hand are such a Linux zealot[/i]"
Actually, I'm not anything like a Linux zealot. I don't run Linux on my primary machine, and I'm planning to turn a server in my home (currently running Linux) into a desktop (not running Linux), because issues with Linux are starting to annoy me (and because I need the machine as a workstation). Try basing your accusations on facts rather than the assumption that you know me just because I disagree with you -- or would, if you provided coherent, salient points for your arguments. Rather than disagreement, all that can apply to most of your statements is incredulity and distaste.
"[i]advising newbies to run Wine and play their games on Linux.[/i]"
That is patently false. I didn't say "Run your games on Linux with Wine!" I just pointed out to people who were discussing games on Linux that it's possible, and that using Cedega can make it easier than using Wine alone. In none of my posts here was I "advising" any "newbies" as you claim.
by w2ktechman
Bit-tech.net got the Microsoft view on the numbers of activations possible with a copy of retail Vista before further action is required. The number comes in at 10 and it seems a little low. However, Vista will differ from XP in that it thankfully will not need reactivation as often. In fact, it will take changing a hard drive and one other component to do it. That?s less stringent than needing reactivation after changing three components from a wider list in a set period like it is in XP. I cannot remember the exact duration of the period in question but 60 days seems to ring a bell.
taken from this site
http://technologytales.com/2007/02/15/is-vista-licensing-too-restrictive/
by tkeyser
by ole man
You set your behind pretty high in the clouds to think you, or Microsoft, have the right to dictate what one can or cannot have on their computer, under any circumstance.
Just goes to show how flawed your reasoning (if any) is.
Microsoft may own you, but not everyone comes as cheap as you do.
by ole man
by now left tr
light on any facts!!!!!!!
I Have a RETAIL Copy - BETA Means Nothing!
My Beta Car had no brakes - WHAT...NO CARS HAVE BREAKS!!!
However...I too have Beta tested for MS until I thought - why should I do their work for them (Stopped at Exchange 2003)
Still get all the Betas through the 1000000 DVD's a year Technet+ my company subscribes too however.
You Say:
"So before you accuse me of falsehoods, check your facts and stop relying on your Own System. Take a look around, you're not the only one in the world."
Don't I know it - have many users keep happy around the globe. Did I say my 'system' is rather large and spans across the UK and the EU?
Listen, I'm not out to get at you personally - I just feel your facts may be a little off...
Later AB!
by techexec2
.
[b]Capricious DE-activation is coming to Windows XP also![/b]
From (1):
[i]"...A ZDNet.com blogger reported earlier in the week on a conversation between a Windows user and a Microsoft support staffer, who allegedly admitted that users who refused to install the WGA update would be given 30 days before their copies of Windows would stop working.
ZDNet.com said that Microsoft refused to deny the report at the time. But later, Microsoft appeared to sing a different tune.
"No, Microsoft antipiracy technologies cannot and will not turn off your computer," said a spokeswoman with Waggener Edstrom, Microsoft?s public relations firm. "The game is changing for counterfeiters. In Windows Vista, we are making it notably harder and less appealing to use counterfeit software, and [u]we will work to make that a consistent experience with older versions of Windows as well[/u]..."[/i]
Translation: WGA on Windows XP is going to work the same as it does on Windows Vista. We know how Vista does WGA now. Capricious DE-activation is coming to Windows XP also.
[b]Conclusion[/b]
I have a valid Windows XP license that I paid for. I will not tolerate capricious DE-activation by WGA and all of the hassles and wasted time associated with that.
I refuse Vista. I'm moving to Linux and will use portable applications. Windows XP is going to be used only for certain things. If XP ever looks sideways, I'll install my old Windows 2000 CDs.
I will not buy products from a vendor that treats me and my company like that.
I think the management at Microsoft has made a really big mistake with how they are doing WGA.
-------------------------------
(1) Microsoft denies WGA kill switch in Windows XP
Company says it plans to tighten honor system for corporate volume licenses
http://www.computerworld.com/action/article.do?command=viewArticleBasic&articleId=9001559
by now left tr
by now left tr
"Their IT contacted me, asking if we have a linux port; I suggested they try wine or crossover."
That would not be a good enough answer for me when asking about porting apps. May I suggest you start to support under Linux if what you say is true!
by w2ktechman
The place I work at is IT unfriendly, especially for a technology company. My job was supposed to go away last Oct. but I was kept on by pleading employees and lots of feedback to management. The rest of my team has been let go, and my job is no longer in IT.
Because I am no longer in IT but doing IT things, I have to 'hide' what I am doing constantly. I rearranged my cubicle and hid some of my comps that are needed for certain tasks. I was told that I am only here long enough to 'ween' the dept off of having its own IT, and that they need to contact the regular IT.
Because of this, my position here is probably not going to last much longer as is, and since I want to have nothing to do with Vista, I have decided to look for a position that is platform independant and/or not customer service related. Preferably I would be using SUSE 10 or PCLinuxOS at this point in time, but it may be a different OS.
This is a good time to start to move on. I have seen many jobs posted asking for Win XP/Linux skills. If I learn more about Linux, then I should be able to fill in one of these roles just fine.
Other than that, I am studying in Wireless technologies to leave the support field and move on.
So it is not really regretful that I pass up on MS for the near future, or have to find a new job, as I was planning on it anyway. I was going to wait until I was all certified first. But, this has just made me start moving along a little sooner, that's all.
Vista wasnt the only factor involved, just a big nudge to move on.
by techexec2
.
It works like this:
1. Microsoft wipes out the independent software vendors by creating "competing" products and bundling them into Windows.
2. Windows users get "free" applications in Windows and no longer have to buy from the independent software vendors.
3. The independent software vendors go out of business.
4. Microsoft implements WGA and charges higher and higher prices for Windows. Users are not happy, BUT THERE IS NO WHERE ELSE TO TURN.
-----
THAT is what is wrong with monopolies.
What the hell ever happened to that $89 Windows 95 upgrade? And the $149 full license? Why the hell is a Windows Vista upgrade $279 and a full operating system license $399?
-----
There is only one solution: Stop using Windows.
I am not a Linux Zealot. But, I am leaving Windows and moving to Linux. Thank goodness for the people who worked so hard to make Linux so good. Where would we be without them?
by so.cal guy
i don't use built in windows app's i uninstall them even the hidden ones i don't use windows media player to watch DVDs i don't use word pad or not pad i don't use windows firewall if you want to get rid of windows app's go to search and find "sysoc.inf" and back it up and then open it and every where you see hide remove it and then open add remove programs and then click on add/remove windows components
then you can get rid off all the bloat you want and theres a lot of it
by techexec2
.
I wasn't speaking about bloat. I was speaking about competition in the marketplace between software vendors and Microsoft that abuses its monopoly power. Apparently MS is being allowed to do this by the feds, even though they were convicted of antitrust violations.
Microsoft uses this technique over and over and systematically wipes out independent software vendors one by one. Starting a new software business that develops applications for Windows today is plain stupid.
Examples: These applications that are included in Windows wiped out the independent software vendors that developed them because the Microsoft ones were included for free with the operating system:
- Microsoft Internet Explorer (killed Netscape Navigator)
- Microsoft Virtual PC (hurting VMWare)
- Windows FAX (killed WinFax)
- Widnows XPS (hurting Adobe PDF)
- Windows Media Player (hurting Real Player and QuickTime)
- Windows Backup (hurting and killing many backup programs)
- Windows HyperTerminal (killed ProComm and QMODEM)
- Windows DriveSpace (killed Stacker)
- Windows Defender (hurting Symantec, McAfee, and CA)
- Windows P2P Networking (killed LANtastic)
By including "competing" applications in Windows for free, the independent software vendors must reduce their prices to zero, find other sources of revenue with other products, or go out of business. It's not competition. It's a slaughter. ISVs have no chance to win here.
- Netscape: Acquired greatly discounted by AOL
- VMWare: Acquired by EMC
- WinFax: Acquired by Symantec
- Real Player: Still independent and struggling
- QuickTime: Apple has other sources of revenue and is OK
- ProComm: Gone (and also irrelevant as plain terminals are out of vogue)
- QMODEM: Gone (and also irrelevant as plain terminals are out of vogue)
- Stacker: Stac Electronics is out of business
- Symantec: Under pressure from security software in Vista.
- McAfee: Under pressure from security software in Vista.
- CA: Under pressure from security software in Vista.
- LANtastic: Out of business
by apotheon
"[i]Ok, the blatant offender that everyone is spewing about is a game... it has no reason to be on a business machine at your work.[/i]"
So what? Maybe next time it'll be a word processor, a DBMS, or an IDE. The fact that the example application was a game in no way indicates that this can only happen with games.
"[i]I will say, it is sad that this happens, but people should maybe point the finger at the game developer and not just Microsoft.[/i]"
Say what? Now you claim that third-party application developers are to blame for the fact that Microsoft decided its OS should shut down sometimes based on what applications you install. That's asinine. It's the OS that causes the OS to shut down, not the third-party software. Third-party software should not destroy the OS's functionality, directly or indirectly, temporarily or permanently. To the extent that it can do so, the OS designers have [b]failed[/b].
"[i]QQ mean cry more. That is all I see as the core of the OP, crying.[/i]"
I kinda figured that out from context, but -- where did you get "QQ" as a term meaning to "cry" or "whine"?
"[i]They serve the purpose of spurring companies like MS to try new things, but you are correct in saying I do not spend time on them. I have more important work to do than stroking my ego by saying I spend all my free time trying to figure out a way do things any way but the MS way.[/i]"
Meanwhile, some of us have better things to do with our time than try to make MS software work properly when an open source unix system just keeps on working without problems, and enhances productivity (as compared with MS software) while it's at it. You choose to save a little up-front time cost by not learning how to do things differently. I choose to save a whole lot of time cost further down the line by learning how to do things in a way that won't slow me down nearly as much while I'm working.
My point, by the way, was that you were running off at the mouth about things that are beyond your experience and knowledge. Either learn about the subject, or stick a cork in it, unless you just want to look like -- well, like someone who runs off at the mouth on subjects about which he knows [b]nothing[/b].
"[i]I agree MS has had craptastic service, support, and security. I choose not to let it get to me, as just about every major software vendor out there releases buggy software.[/i]"
Yeah, I try to keep it from bugging me, too. I do so by using software that doesn't suffer the same frequency and magnitude of problems.
Sure, all software has issues, but when one piece of software has about one percent of the issues another has, you can probably guess what I choose to use.
"[i]I personally do not pay attention to the patching habits of Firefox developers as I quit using it because of its slower startup time.[/i]"
If you're running a computer capable of making full use of Vista's functionality, you have a computer on which Firefox should start up pretty much instantly.
I can understand having a problem with Firefox on something other than a modern MS Windows system because of startup time, but on any high-performance beast capable of running a modern MS Windows release at a level of performance above "dog slow", you shouldn't even notice the startup time for Firefox.
by gentlerf
Sort by Trending