[b]Now it's final. I will [i]NEVER[/i] upgrade to Vista.[/b]
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by apotheon
by apotheon
. . . considering that the Vista-defenders in this thread tend to be issuing strident complaints about how evil the Linux advocates are, and have never (or barely) touched Linux, while the Linux advocates tend to be people who use MS Windows at work and Linux at home, or who use both MS Windows and Linux at work and/or at home, or (like me) who originally built a career on MS Windows, branched out into Linux, found Linux more productivity-enhancing (and secure, and stable, and so on), started using it at home, and eventually discovered that FreeBSD provided even better advantages than Linux. (That was a vast oversimplification of my experience with various OSes, but it should get the point across for now.)
I probably know more about MS Windows architecture than nine out of ten MS-centric professionals here at TR, thanks to my long history of working with it. Prejudging? No, I'm post-judging, based on long experience -- not only with MS Windows, but with a number of alternatives as well.
Speaking of prejudice -- how much experience do [b]you[/b] have with Linux?
by so.cal guy
Netscape killed it self it was in the Begining a nice slim fast browser even if you had to buy it witch i did. then they started adding a bunch of crap that slowed it down and back in them days when we only had dial up i was not going to pay for a slow browser when one came with windows 98 and if you wanted you could order an msn cd and get a free version of ie.
real player is killing it self by trying to take over your computer at one time spying on your browsing habits i bought my first copy of real player i don't use it any more because of what i stated i only need a media player running when i am watching or listening to media.
and as far as quick time go's i have never liked it why because it wants to run all the time to and it wants or now I've heard you have to install itunes with it i don't have an ipod i use another mp3 player.
i use a player i downloaded from the internet to play everything i have all the codecs needed and it works fine on the web and on my desk top
as far as McAfee and Symantec go's i don't use them not because i trust Microsoft to protect my computer it's because they are bloatware Symantec has it's own activation schem that works half the time and thats taking a big chunk of there business away bad installs activations or activations that die and no support thats got Symantec.
and what has everyone been crying about sine the days of dos how Microsoft is to lax on security so they are giving the ppl what they want all be in entry level tools it's better than the crap that gets installed by the OEM's you know the demo anti virus and firewall that work for 15 or 30 days and then crap out and most ppl think they are still protected.
me i like Linux and i like windows and i have an old mac laying around i don't use it much because i just don't like them but thats just my preference I'm not putting them down if someone like them fine.
but Microsoft give ppl what they ask for and most ppl who buy prebuilt computers have quick time installed and other software that is mot Microsoft's.
it's a free market if you have a good product thats coded by some good coders it will make it it does not matter what Microsoft does.
just like i use Firefox and Thunderbird Firefox is slim and fast and i just like Thunderbird for email. thats what makes it all good choice if ppl don't want to use Microsoft's crap they won't no one is twisting there arm. i use windows but i find my own software and i think most others do to an less they are a total noob
by nicknielsen
While I agree with you (at least I think I do), I had one h3ll of a time trying to figure out what you were saying. You have good opinions, but it's so hard to make out what they are, most people will blow you off. It took me the better part of an hour to make sense of what you posted.
Remember all those things your English teachers tried to get you to learn? Spelling? Punctuation? Capitalization? Grammar?
It's time to start using them!
by so.cal guy
by techexec2
.
I'll try this a different way, in the form of a "challenge" (no disrespect intended).
Ok, you say:
[b][i]"...it's a free market if you have a good product thats coded by some good coders it will make it it does not matter what Microsoft does..."[/i][/b]
So here's the "challenge":
If this is really true, you should be able to name some ISV commercial software products for Windows that have been commercially successful (profitable, business-sustaining) in spite of the Microsoft business practices that I have labeled as anti-competitive. So, "challenge" is:
Name three (3) ISV for-profit (not free) commercial software products for Windows that are currently being sold, that have successfully survived competition from Microsoft, such that the competing Microsoft software program is either (1) Bundled into Windows (e.g. Microsoft Fax), or (2) Offered as a free download (e.g. Virtual PC).
------------------
Notes:
1. Quicken does not fit this. Microsoft Money does not meet either criteria (1) or (2).
2. VMWare doesn't fit this either because VMWare is now a wholly owned subsidiary of EMC, we don't know if VMWare for Windows is profitable anymore or not (I seriously doubt it), and there hasn't been enough time to see the affect of the free Virtual PC yet. I think it is going to kill VMWare on Windows. In fact, I think that Microsoft is making changes to WGA that will make it impossible to activate Windows XP or Vista in a VM except Virtual PC. Justification: Piracy, not to kill VMWare on Windows.
by rkuhn040172
Virtually anything competing against MS Movie Maker, Diskeeper, soon to be Adobe's PDF programs, tons of backup software, many, many VPN clients, System Mechanic, all the spyware/adware removal programs, etc etc etc.
Microsoft has plenty of programs built into Windows that suck compared to 3rd party solutions. Almost all are for-profit and almost all are making lots and lots of money.
by magpie_z
and it is not documents and settings in Vista, it is Users. No different than XP with the one warning that you have to have administrator privileges.
And your point is what?
by magpie_z
you were "playing around with it". Also, the problem with the activation window was not the game as much as the technology and method of installation that caused the problem.
To secure Vista properly requires preventing users from installing programs that require root access on the system with administrator privileges. And companies that write software should stop using installations that require that level of authorization to install.
With UAC, it is a heads up that a poorly written piece of software is trying to go where no mear user should be going, or malware for that matter. Should you decide to install a poorly written software program after UAC has warned you, then you deserve to jump through hoops.
The public can't have it both ways. You cannot expect an OS to survive if every piece of junk is writing to an area that should be sacrosanc. Mac doesn't allow it, Linux or Unix doesn't allow it, nor should MS allow it.
Cry about your freedom of choice because it is yours, but don't blame the company or its product if you violate the inner sanctum.
by magpie_z
I pointed out that it was user error, not MS trying to hose the person with bad software.
For all of you experts out there, let's make this clear. If attempting to install a program pops up UAC and informs you that the program requires administrator privileges to install to root and you accept, then it is on your head. Period.
You wouldn't install to the root on Linux, or Unix, or Mac, or any other secure OS. You have been warned.
If you must, please check out the company and their support for Vista before you do. Quickbooks is a perfect example of a lazy, won't spend money to fix a problem company that refused to correct writing to the OS areas that were known to be susceptible to exploitation. And once MS locked it down in Vista so they couldn't then the fit hit the sham and they had to rewrite their 2007 version.
by apotheon
While I can understand the position that installing a piece of software that doesn't behave itself is your own fault, I don't understand the position that this should cause [b]legal[/b] problems. That's really the crux of the matter.
It's not that the operating system is broken by the software -- it's that Microsoft has decided that you're [b]not allowed to use the OS[/b] any longer, unless you beg for the privilege.
. . . and as I've pointed out elsewhere, Microsoft has a right to cripple the software it sells any way it likes, but I have the right to think that's a really crappy way to build software.
by magpie_z
But once again, when companies write software that imitates an attempt to circumvent anti=piracy features, who should be taken to task? MS for including anti-piracy features, or the numbnuts that should know better before selling software that is poorly written.
Once again, I see your point about how the OS appears to make criminals out of people when this happens but...
Everyone go out and buy an automobile with anti-theft devices and tracking device. If this stuff goes off while you are operating it due to cruddy equipment attached to your auto, do you blame the car maker or do you blame the company that made the security device. If you get pulled over by the law enforcement, they are going to assume that you are driving a stolen car until you prove otherwise. Just a little bit of contortted logic for you.
by adinsabic
With Mac, WGA like validation is not needed as the OS is sold with the hardware. A classic lock in environment.
Windows has far more apps and its easier to run alternate OS's within windows or outside windows, on the bare PC. Buy a Pc and you can choose what to boot without any 3rd party software. Oh the software and hardware options are endless, the PC world is fantastic. PC's (Windows Linux combo on your hardware of choice) kill Mac. Do not lock yourself into the limiting Mac scenario.
by techexec2
MacOS X does not deactivate. There is no known logic that looks for piracy and deactivates the operating system. That is the point. Were it not for that, I would have no problem with Windows Vista.
Activation is fine.
DE-activation is unacceptable.
by magpie_z
by magpie_z
and how long have you owned it? How may people do you employe, and are you a sole-proprietorship, an LLC, a Corporation, or maybe a partnership?
As an owner, it must be hard making all of the aquisition decisions, technology implementation plans, and so on...
by techexec2
.
and how many years have you been seeing him? How much lithium do you take? Have you tried Thorazine? Clozapine?
As a psychotic, it must be difficult to behave politely with people you have never met before, and so on...
by magpie_z
and a bad case of injured hands, I only have this for a reply.
A responsible admin would never implement a software change that could cause a failure without lab testing first. And if he did install without verifying before implementing then he should pack up and go work at Taco Bell.
by magpie_z
your testing of Vista and the target test systems and their hardware configurations along with the test results and the system utilization rates to back up your statements.
Thank you from the people who wants facts.
by jmgarvin
by apotheon
http://www.tomshardware.com/2007/01/29/xp-vs-vista/
Conclusion: Vista is marginally slower than XP on high-end hardware in general. For professional graphics work, avoid Vista if at all possible.
http://www.thepcspy.com/articles/other/what_really_slows_windows_down/5
Conclusion: Avoid operating systems that need AV software, because they run like dogs and consume all your system resources.
by magpie_z
by apotheon
by noelrd
about CLI on Cisco routers, I'm not going to explain it to you. Let another Cisco guy help you. It is true that I don't have much patience with people giving lousy advice. I probably won't be posting usually. But this thread was so full of nonsense that I got involved. The original post was so stupid on so many levels. People are posting here that have no first hand experience with Vista and evidently not much knowledge about Microsoft above a hobbyist level.
So, I'm done wasting words on you.
by apotheon
by alex.bailey
Aaron,
It sounds like you do know what you're talking about and I would liket o believe you. Would you mind expanding a little on these claims? Could you site a real and current example?
by alex.bailey
It's quite obvious that MS won't respond to the various "slap on the wrists" they've had in law. But they will respond to customers not upgrading en masse and they will respond to falling sales numbers.
Don't get me wrong, I've always been an MS fan right from the beginning when they were the little dog and IBM was the big one. I like the software style, presentation, documentation and developer assistance. BUT...they are going off in the wrong direction now. This big brother attitude to piracy and dumming down of the software is wrong and we have to tell them. After all its a lot more 'our Microsoft' than theirs because there's a lot more of us out here using it than them creating it. What happened to a bit of people power?
How should we go about telling them Vista is not what we wanted?
by jbb1
...the people power you are talking
about.
by alex.bailey
YES! Changing the UI around and new fancy graphics is not improvement and cannot justify 25 billion dollars in development costs!
As an IT professional, this dumming-down has been worrying me for a few years. Of course I understand the need for user-friendliness so that my neighbour and parents can join the IT revolution BUT we in the support industry are starting to struggle because we look stupid when we can't work out what on earth MS are talking about when they pop up a message that says something like "Would you like Windows to mess up all your networking settings because we think you might not want to expose a couple of file shares?".
Can't we just have a single switch somewhere in the registry that says "User knows he/she is doing so leave them alone and show all available options". Windows Professional should be just that. Take out all the games, stupid wizards and options like "Hide file extensions (recommended)" !
by rkuhn040172
"Take out all the games, stupid wizards and options like "Hide file extensions (recommended)" ! "
Have you never done a custom install? Ghosted PC's? Used the unattended installs?
There are so many tools out there to do exactly what you are talking about, some made by Microsoft itself.
Just because MS doesn't hold your hand and do it for you, doesn't mean what you are asking for here doesn't already exist.
by jck
try getting something like Kubuntu 6.10 Desktop.
Here at work, we call Windows Vista "KDE Redmond"...it looks almost identical, short of some title bar shading and what not.
If it werent for my stubborn USB-based 11.g wireless on my new mobo, I'd already be up and running Linux...and...by Christmas...all my machines (all except my laptop, that is) will be dual boot and I will be majority using Linux in some form...whether *Ubuntu or openSUSE or Mepis.
Good luck :)
by jbb1
See the story referenced below. Vista activation is now more apparent than real, but it's not an unalloyed good thing. Personally, I think that the whole activation idea is a very bad idea, bad for users, and eventually bad for Microsoft -- who might try a sensible pricing policy instead.
JBB
by codebubba
Not sure I understand the problem with WGA. Seems to me the only ones hurt by a validation utility like that would be pirates. I've never run into any issues with it under XP - works fine.
Same thing with Activation. I don't like the idea that the S/W could DE-Activate (which is another reason not to consider Vista) but have never had trouble with any of my XP installations.
Nevertheless - I'll stick with XP for the forseeable future. It just works.
I played with some Linux distros (Ubuntu, etc.) out of curiosity. They seem nice - but for me it would be like throwing the car in reverse at 80Mph to retool everything when nothing is broken.
Later!
-CB
by codebubba
Hi guy ...
I'm not sure why everyone is so upset by WGA. It's been on my XP systems for awhile now (not sure how long - a few months maybe?). Anyway ... as far as I can tell all it's really there for is to make sure you're not patching a non-certified version of Windows. Seems to me that only a pirate would be upset over this one. Am I missing something?
Take care.
-CB :)
by codebubba
>> What the hell ever happened to that $89 Windows 95 upgrade? And the $149 full license? Why the hell is a Windows Vista upgrade $279 and a full operating system license $399? <<
OK ... yeah, it hurts to spend a little money - sure. Putting aside the problems that Vista is having (let's assume for a minute that it isn't having problems - that it's a "good" upgrade). Why is $279 considered such a high-priced upgrade? Let's face it - prices go up over time don't they? My wife can barely buy groceries for the 4 of us for 2 weeks for $300. You can't buy a really good set of tires for your car for much less than $300.
However ... when it comes to software - everybody wants it cheap or for free. If you factor in the cost of R&D for Vista (or XP or any major software release) you can be pretty sure that it cost far more than $300 per license to develop - at least during the first few years.
I think we're losing perspective here - just a little bit, folks.
No, I don't plan to upgrade to Vista right now either - because XP Pro is very solid and works - but bitching about paying for the upgrades even at 300 bucks. Come on now! You probably spend more than that to buy a fish-finder for your bass boat!
Try upgrading anything else high-tech and see what kind of pricing there is. Let's face it, folks - it costs MONEY to drive this industry. You should see the prices involved with upgrading equipment in private aircraft, boats, cars or anything. Why do we all-of-a-sudden get sticker shock when it's software?
Beats me!
Cheers,
-CB :)
by jbb1
1. You are obviously better paid than most of us if you think Vista is a bargain.
2. If R&D is so costly, and so necessary commercially, why is Linux so good and available so cheaply?
3. The list price increases on Vista far exceeds the rate of inflation. It's feature set does not.
4. Microsoft has never hurt for profits even at the former prices.
5. Excessive profit is just as much at the heart of inflation as any other input cost such as raw material or labor (which is lagging inflation).
6. If I am making almost the same in constant dollars as when Win 95 came out, why should I pay so many more of those precious bucks to keep Microsoft's stock price up?
by dawgit
or maybe FreeDOS, ?:| as it is the pre-loaded OS on the non-M$ computers and NB's being sold now.
I think maybe people are just now starting to wake up to the fact that there are choices out there. And that's not a bad thing at all. -d
by jmgarvin
by r0ckh0pp3r
Your "howl" of never using VISTA was said before by previous users of new M$ Operating System, getting 'familiar' with the registration changes from M$.
Eventually (and sooner than you will want to admit), you will use VISTA.
by jbb1
by apotheon
I'll probably end up using Vista a few times, too. I won't spend any money on it, though. If I use it, it'll be on someone else's computer. I'll do my best to avoid having to support it for a living. I'll continue using FreeBSD at home.
While it's probably not 100% true to claim I'll never use Vista, it's still probably true in all the ways that matter.
by techexec2
.
[b][i]"...Eventually (and sooner than you will want to admit), you will use VISTA..."[/i][/b]
Did you copy that off the white board in the WGA project room in Redmond?
My post here is not a toothless tiger. I'm not ranting, howling, or whining. I'm leaving. I'm completely serious (1). And, unlike yourself, I [u]NEVER[/u] use the terms "M$" or "Windoze" or any such. I'm not fond of Microsoft anymore (haven't been for a bunch of years), but I don't need to express it with silly-assed name calling and insults (not intended to be a major insult to you, I hope you understand).
That said, I may use Vista for something. If things get "bad" enough, I might even buy a copy of Vista. Example: There might be a client, or partnership, or contract, or whatever, where Vista is required. I don't "hate" Vista. It's not against my "religion". But, it will never be on the primary computers that I rely on every day. I won't be running Vista Server as my server either.
Quite honestly, I think a lot of people dislike Vista and Vista-style WGA enough that there will be significant defections this time. You know Vista WGA is much more aggressive than the previous Windows XP WGA. And, Windows XP WGA is going to be "upgraded" to work like Vista in SP3. There is no escape, except going backwards to Windows 2000. Going backwards. What an appropriate way to describe all of this.
-------------------------
(1) The [i]LEAVING WINDOWS[/i] Project
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=213495&messageID=2185615
by now left tr
There might be a client, or partnership, or contract, or whatever, where Vista is required.
So you end up buying it - MS have now won until the next time.
by jmgarvin
I won't *use* Vista. Why? As a testbed it stinks. Not only does it cause problems, but the whole deactivation thing leaves a bad taste in my mouth. The worst part is that Ballmer is claiming that WGA is going to be more locked down in the near future.
As a corporation, you cannot have one desktop magically deactivate because that could be a critical desktop. You can't have one laptop deactivate, because it will make you look like a fool in a sales meeting.
While product activation is nothing new, the schema that WGA uses is. Not only is it nagware, but it makes it impossible to know if your systems will be up the next day or x of them will be deactivated.
at the very least I'll have to prove the software works on it.
No choice, customers will buy the OS, the software they buy off us has to work on it.
So I've no choice and I can be de-activated on a whim, with absolutely no redress.
Can someone please explain in simple words why I'm meant to happy about this, because I'm just not getting it.
There are plenty of people who are happy with it apparently, surely one of you can explain it to this poor thicky why I should be skipping round my desk shouting yippee I got vista.
by jbb1
by jmgarvin
Microsoft deactivated my LEGITIMATE copy of Vista through WGA. It's been documented over and over and over, that WGA has deactivated legitimate XP boxes and now Vista is suffering the same problem.
Also, why should the pirates not have to worry about WGA and make life easy on them, when I have a legit copy, yet I can't use it?
by jmgarvin
by techexec2
.
[b][i]"...Seems to me that only a pirate would be upset over this one. Am I missing something?..."[/i][/b]
Sure, pirates might be upset. But, since they're pirates, they'll probably find a way around it. If they cannot, then it is even MORE likely that lots of legitimate customers will be advserly affected by WGA DE-activation. That is the only way to "get" all the pirates is by also "getting" some innocent people.
I've paid for every copy of Windows I have ever used all the way back to 1992. I never pirate software. Vista might not ever self-deactivate one me. But, as I said in my original post, I find the uncertainty unacceptable and I won't stand for it. DE-activation can happen merely by installing the "wrong" software now.
Piracy is Microsoft's business problem. But, how big of a problem is it really? They sold $44 BILLION and made $18 BILLION in profit last year. I wouldn't call that an important enough problem to damage MY operating system with capricious self-deactivation.
Microsoft has every right to police piracy and they deserve to get paid for Windows. But, I will not stand for them putting a "bomb" in my operating system that they say is never supposed to go off except when the product is stolen, even though it does sometimes.
Missing something? Yes you are.
1. WGA on Vista is much much more aggressive than on Windows XP. Like night and day.
2. Microsoft is working to implement the same WGA aggressiveness on Windows XP. It will be introduced in SP3 (1).
Microsoft apparently thinks that they can do this dastardly thing and get away with it because people have no choice but to accept it.
Well, they might "get away" with it because a lot of people are submissive to a lot of things. But, there are other choices now and they are dead wrong about that part.
----------------------
(1) Windows XP DE-activation is coming
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212977&messageID=2185978
by techexec2
by jbb1
by gentlerf
From EETimes:
Apple is continuing to enjoy momentum in the PC space. During the last quarter of 2006, Apple's shipments of Macintosh-based computers jumped by more than 31 percent and the company's market share increased to 4.7 percent in the U.S., up from 3.6 percent the year earlier.
Here:
http://www.eetimes.com/news/latest/showArticle.jhtml?articleID=197800838
'Nuff said.
by apotheon
Let's add a third criteria:
Make sure you're naming something for which Microsoft's competing offering has been out long enough to affect the market.
Plus, y'know, you completely missed the "name some ISV commercial software products" part there. Actually [b]name[/b] something, please.
It also helps if you don't think "produces PDFs" is equivalent to "offers credible competition for Acrobat".
by techexec2
.
Let's take your point and examine it. How do you test install on Vista? OK. You install on a separate test machine, find out that the installation of the software triggers DE-activation, and so you don't do it on all of the workstations in your network. For sake of argument, let's assume the DE-activation occurs immediately, and not a month later. [Hope you sleep well not knowing if this assumption is correct, or not.]
But, you still have a DE-activated test system to reactivate. Online RE-activation isn't so painful. But, it won't always work. Sometimes you'll have to call Microsoft, wait on hold, explain, argue, and beg, to get RE-activated. Maybe, the person you reach will call you 'PIRATE!' and refuse to RE-activate you altogether. What next, write a letter to BillG calling him a "poo poo head"?
[Of course, that was and obnoxious, childish comment. I did it on purpose.]
Microsoft's new WGA in Vista, and soon to be added to Windows XP in SP3, puts all adults into a position of potentially having to ask or beg for RE-activation of the product they legally acquired and paid money for. Ed Bott's game install shows very clearly how little it takes to get DE-activated with 3 days to get it fixed.
That is enough for me. I am going to run a different operating system.
by magpie_z
I would have thought that this is something that you would have insite into.
From your reply it is obvious that you are not involved in testing at the company where you work or a real response would have been forth coming.
But I do understand your position based on your experience and I am not into denegating someone based on their opinion.
by apotheon
I think his point is that testing a new system install is an iffy proposition with MS Windows, because all too often the worst effects (outside of not being able to install the thing effectively in the first place) don't arise for months.
I find that the best way to test an MS Windows release is to wait until SP1 has been "in the wild" for a few months. Let others test it for you.
by techexec2
.
I was replying to this point from you:
[b][i]"...A responsible admin would never implement a software change that could cause a failure without lab testing first..."[/i][/b]
First: The issue is capricious DE-activation by WGA, nothing else.
I presume you are speaking about "lab testing" that a "responsible admin" does before he rolls out a new program or an update to a bunch of workstations he is responsible for on a corporate network. No?
My points were:
1. If the test fails (vis-a-vis DE-activation), he still one DE-activated workstation to reactivate with Microsoft. That's one too many for me.
2. If the test succeeds (vis-a-vis DE-activation), and he rolls out the software to all of the workstations, he really doesn't know if it will trigger DE-activation on them immediately, or at some later point in time.
Testing software/updates for DE-activation issues really cannot be done sufficiently well.
Further: I would not be surprised at all to hear about people experiencing "spontaneous DE-activation" with no apparent action having caused it.
Think about it: The purpose of WGA is to beat the pirates at hacking into Windows and stealing it. In order for that to have even a remote chance of working, there must be triggers for the DE-activation "bomb" hidden all over the place inside millions and millions of lines of Windows code. Without that the whole thing would be easily defeated and moot, right? With that many triggers, I guarantee that Microsoft has not made it the "bomb" 100% safe (easy claim...look what happened to Ed Bott). Further, with that many triggers, I would not trust ANYBODY to make the "bomb" 100% safe. Only simple things ever get to that level of safety, not complex things like WGA. The computer and software that controls your anti-lock brakes is very simple. No WGA. No fancy code. It just works. WGA, like so much that Microsoft turns out, is incredibly complex, and has lots of bugs. The "bomb" is not safe. Ask Ed Bott. Microsoft knows this. [u]That is why they have human operators to handle manual RE-activations[/u].
Look. As far as I am concerned, this is a REALLY STUPID extremely arrogant thing Microsoft has done. There are enough issues with keeping automated systems up and running. Adding capricious DE-activation to it is absurd. It's the kind of mistake I would expect in a shareware program.
I'm not going to participate in this absurdity.
[b][i]"...From your reply it is obvious that you are not involved in testing at the company where you work or a real response would have been forth coming..."[/i][/b]
Did I get it right?
I'm unsure if my last two posts responded well to your last two posts. If not, please try again and I will try again. I'm certainly not intending to denegrate you in any way. Thanks.
---
BTW: Don't be confused by job role indications. They say nothing about skill and experience. My decades of experience tell me very clearly that I should not be running Windows anymore. Only people who are too young, with too little experience, and too little knowledge, and too much GREED, would ever do what Microsoft has done with WGA and capricious DE-activation.
by now left tr
LMAO.
The argument you are making for aggressive capitalisation could also be used to justify slavery, human trafficking, drug trafficking, child labour, employing illegal immigrants, organ farming, pollution dumping.....
These are all against our laws, MS have broken our laws and benefited financially from doing so, you wouldn't be happy if it was the columbian mafia getting away with it, so why MS?
You do know that it was a standard for mob dons, to contribute heavily into charities. Not suggesting we should call Bill Capo Di Capo, but he could be doing it for much the same reasons, and because his income is 'legal' he gets to write off his tax as well.
Why should we pay to safeguard MS's profits, the only possible reason for that to be to our benefit, is if MS were to drop their prices on successfully combating piracy.
If you believe that is going to happen I have a piece of land I want to sell you. Us socialists need spending money as well, you know.
No competition = captive market = monopoly. Monopolies are good for those who hold them, but bad for the market, so if you are in favour of the market (I being a true socialist am less enamoured of it), why are you in favour of a company that is damaging it.
Personally I think MS's profits are obscene and should be curbed, I'd prefer to do that by sponsoring and supporting competition until the playing field levelled out, but if that alternative was precluded, then I would have no choice but to be everything you accused TechExec of.
It's called ethics and doesn't feature anywhere in Business 101.
by techexec2
Great reply, Tony!
Microsoft's extreme profits are truly obscene and embarrassing to a capitalist like me who also has a conscience.
by techexec2
.
That is an interesting answer. And, I credit you with ONE product that passes the challenge. Very good rickk. This is certainly miles better than SO CAL GUY's so far. I have some counterpoints for you.
[b]Diskeeper[/b]
I was aware of Diskeeper.
[u]THE WINDOWS BUNDLED APPLICATION[/u]
- Windows Defragmenter is the free bundled application the comes with all copies of Windows 2000 and XP.
- Developer: Windows Defragmenter was developed by Executive Software for Microsoft. [u]Executive Software is the former name of Diskeeper Corporation[/u]! So, Diskeeeper is competing with itself! Pretty good deal, huh!! :^0 :^0 :^0
[u]ABOUT DISKEEPER CORPORATION[/u]
- Diskeeper Corporation is a privately held corporation in California. Financial records are not public. But, I strongly suspect they are a highly profitable independent commercial software vendor.
[u]WHO BUYS DISKEEPER[/u]
- This product is purchased principally by companies that run Windows servers. It provides for automatic defragmention of NTFS file systems in order to keep servers running optimally. It provides advanced features that are not present in the free version that comes with Windows.
[u]SALES TERMS OF WINDOWS DEFRAGMENTER[/u]
- I don't know what the terms were. But I guarantee you that Diskeeper Corp. got next to nothing in cash payments from Microsoft for the privilege of donating a very complex piece of software to Microsoft. I know that Microsoft never does per-copy-of-Windows royalty deals with "partner" ISVs.
- What did Diskeeper Corp get? (#1) I bet they got a handshake agreement that Microsoft would never enhance Windows Defragmenter and Diskeeper Corp would be "given" the high end of the market. Also, I'll bet Diskeeper Corp is responsible for maintaining Windows Defragmenter...for free (or certainly without any significant profit for their time spent).
- What did Diskeeper Corp get? (#2) According to Diskeeper Corp (1), they have sold 20 MILLION copies of Diskeeper since the product was first released. That is a success story, to be sure. This is not a cheap product.
- What did Diskeeper Corp lose? Disk defragmentation is essential for an NTFS file system. According to this website (2), there have been 855 MILLION Windows PCs sold worldwide between 2001 and August 2006, all of them running Windows 2000 or XP. Diskeeper Corp gave up the potential sales to 835 MILLION customers in order to get the 20 MILLION they did get (the 20M goes back before 2001 though). Oh what could have been!!
[u]RESULT[/u]
This one is very wierd, and it is probably the ONLY way an ISV can exist in the Microsoft ecosystem while competing with a bundled product without being destroyed. I guarantee there is an illegal collusion agrement in there, but certainly not on paper. It isn't like Microsoft is really trying to beat Diskeeper because the two companies are intimitely tied together and the ISV is competing with itself. But, a win is a win. This is a successful company.
This one PASSES the challenge. Very good rickk.
[b]System Mechanic[/b]
This product does performance configuration, problem detection and repair, IE popup suppression, IE work file and cache deletion, and spyware protection. Except for Vista and IE7 (just released), there is no product available for free from Microsoft that competes with this product.
[u]RESULT[/u]
This one FAILS the challenge.
[b]The other things you mentioned[/b]
The other things you mentioned are not products. So, you really cannot "pass" the challenge with general categories and unsubstantiated claims of profitability even though there are free products provided by Microsoft.
I know the kind of products you are thinking of, and I could comment on them, but they don't pass the challenge. If you disagree, please name them.
--------------------------
(1) DISKEEPER SELLS 20 MILLION LICENSES
http://www.diskeeper.com/press/releases.aspx?F=2006080701.htm
(2) 25-year PC Anniversary Statistics
http://www.c-i-a.com/pr0806.htm
(3) PCs in-use: 900M in 2005
http://www.c-i-a.com/pr0506.htm
(4) Projection: 1.3B Cumulative PC Sales Over Next 5 Years (2006-2010)
http://www.c-i-a.com/pr0606.htm
by now left tr
Other OS's don't have security issues (not true) because of there low volume (not true)
vs it's easier to pick on the mindless masses (far too true).
Now I personally wouldn't call them mindless, not up to speed for the technical issues surrounding security, very true.
Windows is easier to attack to simply because it was designed to be more accessible so it would appeal to technical newbies. It got a bigger market share because it was more approachable, therefore more people got insecure software, so therefore the bad guys got more potential victims.
Vista is actually more secure and therefore less approachable than any other version of windows, you know this from all the whinging about incompatibilities, UAC etc.
To make the software more secure for technical novices, they had no option but nannying. That alone, tells you more about what's gone on than anything else.
Windows security is more of a product issue, 'nix security is more of an educational one.
Some Linux distros are becoming less secure ,though they start from a much better architectural base. Newer versions of windows have become more and more secure, though they start from a much much poorer architectural base.
Maybe one day windows will be as hard to attack as a 'nix box, the keyword for those of us who use them is hard though no volume and not usable.
Security is always an approachability constraint, by definition.
by now left tr
I have installed (8) and played quite a few games on the Vista platform now. Not once has this issue come up. All games installed are new or only a year old.
So I say that this looks to be rubbish on the software installation / activation issue.
Are we still basing the facts around RC2 again???? - If so WHY??????????????...it was an RC not a GOLD release.
by techexec2
.
[b][i]"...So I say that this looks to be rubbish on the software installation / activation issue..."[/i][/b]
I think there is not general problem with games and DE-activation, per se. There was something that particular game did that triggered the DE-activation.
The troubling thing for me is: What was it? Why is it that ANY application software, either installing or executing, can trigger DE-activation with 3 days notice? What is to stop malware from doing it?
I believe what happened is a real problem. There is a forum with hundreds of people who are having WGA problems. To be sure, some of them could be pirates stirring up trouble. But, I really believe there is a problem here. At the very least, I believe Ed Bott of ZDNet did not "rig" this. And, I know that Microsoft has issued a patch to "fix" the problem that Ed Bott found.
I don't care if it is considered "fixed" now. There is still a "bomb" in Vista's WGA. I won't use a product with an unpredictable "bomb" in it.
tell me a linux a security fault due to it being open source.
Come on one will do. The tell me how they found it. Then tell me who fixed it, then tell me who made a profit out of letting it through.
What about linux is deeply flawed, it's modular, by definition it can't be deeply flawed, architecturally it's almost flat, it's a one molecule thick line compared to any version of windows.
In one paragraph you just demonstrated your ignorance for all to see, Owned by MS is at this moment cursing you for supporting him.
FYI I use windows almost exclusively, however I have on occasion used other OSes in multi platform environments. I've coded for them, I've administered them and implemented them, which is why I know you are spouting just as much rubbish as those linux zealots you would have us be.
You want to try me?
Setting up cisco routers from the command line is as much programming as typing
del *.* at a dos or vms prompt (rm * for nix people :D)
Creating a script to run various commands on execution is programming though how complex depends on the language involved.
So along with your other ignorance, you don't know what programming is either!
Apotheon has demonstrated his knowledge on many occasions, you have simply demonstrated your ignorance, so what value should I place on your opinions?
by now left tr
by now left tr
"When I installed a beta version of Acclaim's 9Dragons role-playing game"
It was a BETA. Hence anything like this happening is why the BETA was created. Once the final version comes out there will be no such problem.
Once AGAIN comments are being made about BETA software interactions as if they are FACTS!
by techexec2
.
I don't care. Vista GOLD CODE has a "feature" inside it that will capriciously DE-activate the operating system with 3 days notice because of what software does. I don't care if it is beta software, GA software, or malware.
I am not going to bring home any product that has a "bomb" in it, even if the vendor promises that the "bomb" will only explode if the product is ever stolen.
The vendor cannot really promise that anyway (this is software, [u]Microsoft[/u] software). And, the vendor doesn't have to clean up the mess when the "bomb" goes off. I do. I [u]hate[/u] waiting on hold to speak to someone in Bangalore. I just hate it.
It's not like there aren't very good alternatives that do not have "bombs" in them (Linux and Mac). I'm going to use one of the "bomb-less" alternatives.
It's OK if you want to use Vista. Really. :-)
The added security is not a reason to whinge, that fact that a lot of software including MS's requires some fixing in order to cope with it is not a reason to whinge. Though it would have been nice if more of that had been done, before they started arm twisting.
The price is, the hardware requirements are, the continuance of a feeble witted monolithic architecture is, DRM is and being deactivated because you installed a piece of 3rd party software most definitely is.
The thing that amazes me is after they dropped almost every change in longhorn that would benefit business, they the market it to us an a productivity improvement worth the price of the 'upgrade'. So not true, it borders on a soundbyte from Al Gore.
by techexec2
.
I'm in a position to control whether my company moves to Vista or not.
In a large corporation, if you are not the decision-maker, you'll just have to accept what they decide.
You know, I expect the problems in Vista to be worked out in time. The bugs in the operating system will be fixed. The driver problems will be fixed. The application compatibility problems will be resolved. All of this will take about a year to really get there (to about where Windows XP is now). I was planning to upgrade to Vista in about a year. But then Ed Bott's article appeared and it was the last straw for me.
This WGA DE-activation nonsense will still be there. You know, they are going to put Vista-style WGA DE-activation into Windows XP in SP3! I've had a problem with Microsoft for a while but it has never been enough. Now it is. I simply choose to not engage with Microsoft on this WGA nonsense. I hate waiting on hold to speak to someone in Bangalore. I won't do it. There is no reason to. Linux is a really good platform today, and it will be even better next year.
Upgrading to Vista is not without cost: Vista itself, upgraded or replacement hardware, application upgrades. Hundreds of dollars per seat with no value added whatsoever. Is anyone on your staff going to be more productive on Vista vs. XP? If you're going to change platforms, NOW is the best time there has ever been.
Furthermore, I am sick and tired of this nonsense with Microsoft. Like a lot of people in Europe, I am going to take advantage of the very high quality open source software that is now available. Lots of money will be saved. Absolutely no computing value or productivity will be lost. It is a friggin' no brainer. Why should ANYONE put up with so much nonsense and cost with Microsoft and Vista. That company is so arrogant that they actually think they can FORCE the entire world to do what they want, and pay them $44 BILLION dollars per year in the process.
In my world, Microsoft's nonsense is O-V-E-R.
P.S. If my car maker gave me this much trouble, I would never buy a car from them again. I simply do not understand why people tolerate so much nonsense from Microsoft when it is not necessary.
that's his opinion.
The poster feels that the fact that a de-activation of a perfectly valid, paid for an legal copy of an OS, constitutes an unwarranted risk to business and an unjustifiable flouting of his rights as a consumer.
How can that be a lie?. Are you saying he's secretly posting from his fifty vista workstations and just posted this to get some attention?
He said it does and he said why he thinks it does, your rebuttal is "liar".
If you feel there's enough value in vista to manage the risk of being de-activated, just say so. You could even add what you think adds value, presumably you don't want to be judged as an unthinking MS zealot, any more than I would like being judged as an unthinking 'nix zealot.
Registering software is not a problem as such, being assumed a pirate by default, most definitely is.
this is a current MS trend. SQL 2005 is 30% slower than 2000 for adhoc queries prepared or otherwise. MS's stated advice is do everything with stored procedures and or .net extensions.
In other words multiple back end implementations, vendor lock in or crap performance compared to your competitors.
Let me see now, eenie, meenie, mysql, postgresql.
by apotheon
Since MS Windows became actually usable in '93 with v3.1, and useful (there's a distinct difference between "usable" and "useful") with v3.11, there has not been a single new MS Windows release that outperformed its predecessor at the time. Any performance benefits to an upgrade have always taken effect a couple years later, when the hardware caught up with the massive resource requirements of the new MS Windows release.
This points out two distinct, and startling, deficiencies in MS Windows design:
1. The older release version was targeted at the foreseeable hardware availability at that time, without putting much thought into scaling upward with future hardware advancements. As hardware advanced, there was no way to make the OS advance with it in terms of taking advantage of increasing resources at its disposal as well as it should have.
2. The newer release version assumed greater system resources to such an extent that it ran more poorly than its predecessor on the hardware currently available at its release date.
This isn't a one-time issue. This didn't just happen once or twice when an "upgrade" in MS Windows release occurs.
It happens [b]EVERY . . . SINGLE . . . TIME[/b].
sort of like getting grit in your eye, you only notice after a while when you rub it.
Any competent client server developer tries to make the client and server as agnostic as they can, I mean that's a good part of the reasoning behind the split ffs.
This particular maneouver has bitten them in the ass though, because our CTO just picked MySQL to be the backend for all our flagship products. MS gave us a fu, so he gave them one back that's going to save us and our customers money and it will be faster and use less resources.
Redmond is where all the software and business brains are, yeah right.
Could n't lead a dog to a bone, the lot of 'em.
by techexec2
.
[b][i]"...I beleve the lie is that Vista is not usable because of this one instance when installing a game, expecally since the fix is known and stated in the original article..."[/i][/b]
I don't think anyone has said Vista is "not usable" because of this. I certainly don't think that way. Even if someone said that, it wouldn't be a lie, it would only be their opinion.
For me, Vista's WGA capricious DE-activation feature is "not acceptable" though.
For instance: Down the road there will be a Vista Server. Will it DE-activate itself also? If it does, will you be notified before or after you lose business? What if the servers involved are running the Police 911 system? An airline reservation system? A hospital database? Will you trust Microsoft if they tell you it won't ever cause disruption to your business? That it will only disrupt Ed Bott's silly game? I won't, I can tell you that. Microsoft has [u]woven[/u] a bomb into the heart of Vista. It is designed to be hard for pirates to mess with and get away with it. That means the bomb triggers are all over the place. Frankly, I don't believe they have made it safe. I don't think it's possible to make it safe.
Look. As far as I am concerned, this is a REALLY STUPID extremely arrogant thing Microsoft has done. There are enough issues with keeping automated systems up and running. Adding capricious DE-activation to it is absurd.
[b][i]"...I also hate the idea of having to register software also. But I guess this is the future of all software..."[/i][/b]
I see the as submission to Microsoft's obscene $44 BILLION dollars per year arrogance. It's only "the future of all software" if you let it be. It is not the future of all software in my world.
But, like I've said. You are free to use Vista. It doesn't mean you are a bad guy or are making a bad choice. You said it yourself. You have 50 Vista installations and all of them are up and running for you. That means something.
Take care.
Moving low tech corporate users over to linux is easy. Click on the word icon, type, click the save icon, type in a name, click the OK button.
Trained.
My progression into linux was much more difficult. Not more difficult than the one to DOS, to MPE-XL, to Windows, to NT, to VMS, to straight unix, to HP-UX...
Windows does have mass appeal, it does have an enormous user base, it is used at home and school and then business. Why do you think they are so successful, because it's technically better?
I'd say for a basic appliance type user the switch to vista is no bigger a training requirement than that to say Mepis or Ubuntu or some of the other mass appeal distros.
The only reasons administering and implementing windows is more of a problem, is Linux never started out to be approachable in that regard and far too much emphasis in terms of education and training has been how to do this in windows XX, instead of why and when and what it means.
Adding a user to a system, is adding a user, giving them privileges is doing that. From a role based point of view why should the OS matter more than the actual task and the reasoning behind it?
Home users are a different kettle of fish, because they are admins, power users and users rolled into one, yet the bulk know next to nothing about being the first two.
No secretary is going to give a toss about what OS they are on, which word processor they are using is the issue.
Is retraining to say Open Office that much more of a hurdle than Office 2007. No they have the same basic functionality, some of the icons are different and the menus have moved around, that's it, same with Office pre 2007, every damn version.
by jbb1
by techexec2
You know, this WGA DE-activation nonsense will be a test of the language in the license. If the operating system self-deactivates, and there is some economic damage to the customer, he has good grounds to sue Microsoft for just compensation.
I could easily see a massive class action lawsuit here.
Gee. What a surprise. Microsoft having to defend itself in court. :^0
by gentlerf
by jbb1
by karmashock
MS doesn't understand how easy it is to just hack their stupid OS. By being so insane with their activation and anti piracy bs all they're doing is making sure that a MUCH larger percentage of users have hacked OS's.
Why would you not hack your OS? I can't think of a single reason besides having to redo it every time you installed an update that messed with the hack.
Here's a truism that MS clearly doesn't understand:
Anything created by a human mind can be beaten by a human mind.
So what they're doing is telling the users of Vista "to use this software properly you need to break our activation"... well... one of two things are going to happen there... either people will break it and MS will be completely boned as their OS's piracy security is shredded... or they won't and the brand will be destroyed.
Frankly, I already know that Vista's piracy security has been shredded... and it's only going to get more shredded.
So, I'll probably upgrade to vista at some point... I don't know what version of it I'll buy... but one thing is for sure, I'll hack my OS so that it NEVER gives me a message like that. Ever.
by apotheon
by jbb1
by apotheon
"[i]when companies write software that imitates an attempt to circumvent anti=piracy features, who should be taken to task? MS for including anti-piracy features, or the numbnuts that should know better before selling software that is poorly written.[/i]"
Both -- when those "anti-piracy features" result in reduced quality of software and user experience.
"[i]Everyone go out and buy an automobile with anti-theft devices and tracking device. If this stuff goes off while you are operating it due to cruddy equipment attached to your auto, do you blame the car maker or do you blame the company that made the security device.[/i]"
Both.
by apotheon
Context was ambiguous, so I asked what you meant.
edit: By the way, I guess I'm not surprised. While I disagree with some of what you say, I find that the way you construct arguments and the points you make tend to be much more reasonable than the way people like rickk, MS Owns You, and (probably worst of all -- a tough title to earn against competition like rickk) noelrd, even if you're kinda on the same side of the fence.
You have my sympathies. I know what it's like to have people nominally on my side of a debate constantly undermining my position by being wankers.
and I could put linux on and use it.
It would be interesting to see a court action for say loss of earnings through improper de-activation. Could easily happen to a contractor or a consultant, perhaps even a more standard small business. Could be a large one if it took a server out or deity forfend a cluster.
by rkuhn040172
Why limit this to just ISV's?
Microsoft faces competition in all areas of their business. I don't see the point of limiting it to just ISV's unless you intentionally want to win the debate before it has even started.
Microsoft gets beat day in and day out in lots of areas:
Backup
Disk Defragmentation
Tasks Scheduling
CD/DVD Burning
PDF Creation
Instant Messaging
Web Creation
Multi-Media Creation, Editing, Playing
Malware Detection and Removal
Compression/Decompression
The world is a huge place. Why limit this to ISV's?
Yes, the ISV argument may hold true in the open source world, however, open source and commercial software are like apples and oranges.
I don't like how you framed the premise of the question to begin with.
Microsoft has plenty of competition in plenty of areas.
by rkuhn040172
Before you (a graphics artist) begin spewing FUD like:
"Never mind that 3/4 of the existing software will have compatibility problems"
Do you actually have any proof of that number? Facts before fiction please!
by techexec2
.
He said:
[b][i]"...Never mind that 3/4 of the existing software will have compatibility problems that will force their brand new "prefect" OS to crash or at least deactivate..."[/i][/b]
You're right, rickk, he is going too far by connecting software compatibility problems to Vista crashing or DE-activating.
But, there ARE a lot of compatibility problems with existing software. The very short list of "Made for Vista" approved applications is clear evidence of this. For a variety of reasons, including UAC, MANY MANY apps require an upgrade to work properly, or at all, on Vista.
by w2ktechman
may not disappear, but they may have 'upgraded add-ons (for a small fee).----lol
I think Aaron was just trying to make a point, I do not think that he meant actually clock and notepad (but I may be wrong entirely).
by rkuhn040172
Where do you draw the line?
For christsakes, we have Democrats running for office in the US who are the supposed champions of rights for the little people, you know, the John Kerrys, Hillary Clintons, etc. yet they have multi-millions "sitting in the bank".
Or how about Hollywood. You know, the know it alls, the global warming champions, the protectors of endangered species.
The same Hollywood that lives in 20,000 sq ft mansions (by the way, Al Gore's average electric bill per month is about 10 times the national average here), the fur wearing, private jet flying, garage full of SUV driving, morons that are trying to tell me how to live my life?
Econ 101 dude, that's the American way.
If you don't like it, don't buy their products, don't live in a society setup like that (I'm sure there's plenty of commie/socialist dictators that'd be glad to offer you a job), and don't knock it as millions upon millions of people around the global don't have a problem with it.
by rkuhn040172
All man made products have flaws by the very definition they were made by man.
In this case, all software has flaws. Even, gasps, Macs and Linux.
How about that new Linux/Thunderbird bug. That's a real nice one.
Enjoy your over priced Mac where software selection is limited, everything is at least a magnitude of 10 fold more propietary than MS, support is harder to come by and the iPod service is a pain in the arse (talk about limiting choice and DRM issues).
by rkuhn040172
And we'll check back with you in a few months.
You'll still be on XP and thinking more and more seriously about Vista.
Your anger induced hangover will be over soon and reality is about to bite you in the rear end.
by rkuhn040172
First off, too expensive.
Second, to much bad PR. A move like that would only make the situation worse for MS.
I can see lawsuits against larger distributors, but lawsuits against individual users? Put the potato down and and light a cigarette instead.
Companies, yes, large distributors, yes, individual users, never.
by rkuhn040172
Like news organizations?
They are only supposed to report the news. Too much of this is FUD (on both sides).
Besides, Anna Nicole Smith just died. The news shows are too busy right now.
Sort by Trending