Discussion Locked

[b]Now it's final. I will [i]NEVER[/i] upgrade to Vista.[/b]

0 helpful
1,352 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,352 replies

by rkuhn040172

That's what your profile says.

Anyways, depending on what types of apps you develop, if you don't see the advantages of moving to Vista as far as application development goes, it's time to retire buddy.

It a hell of a lot more than just Aero. Go out and educate yourself for once.

by techexec2

.
This isn't about Microsoft not having competition from somewhere. Of course there are things like Linux, Macintosh, and open source that compete with Microsoft products. Linux and Mac are separate platforms (this is about ISVs building Windows applications, the monopoly platform where the money is). Open source applications are not commercial products. They make inroads on Windows, but they are free. There is no revenue stream sustaining an ISV business behind them.

This is about Microsoft providing unfair monopoly competition that wipes out independent software vendors who develop and sell software products for Windows. Creating a company that makes and sells software for Windows is a losing game. If your product fails with customers, you lose. If your product succeeds with customers, Microsoft will, sooner or later, create or buy a competing product, and bundle it into Windows, or offer it for free download. And, you STILL lose.

Example: This is exactly what is happening to VMWare right now.

- Microsoft bought Virtual PC, and immediately put it up for free download.

- VMWare had to respond by coming out with free products, or lose ALL of their users.

- VMWare used to be a very successful independent company. It sold itself to EMC, undoubtedly because it would go bankrupt otherwise.

- Furthermore, Microsoft is making changes to Windows that enable WGA to appropriately enforce licensing restrictions, even when Windows runs in a VM. It is giving 3rd party VM vendors (VMWare, Parallels, etc) a very hard time about being permitted to sell VM software that Windows WGA will activate on.

The next ISV casualties on Windows are going to be VMWare and Parallels.

Check the news. VMWare/EMC and Microsoft are having a war in the press over this right now.

by rkuhn040172

Half Life 2 performs about as good in Vista as it does in Cedega...pathetic.

Out of the box, you get maybe 10 fps.

Sure, you can tweak it and get pretty damn good performance, but most newbies to Linux wouldn't be happy with the out of box performance nor be able to tweak it.

by techexec2

.
By "Linux users", I was referring to both businesses and individual users, not only the individual users. I agree it would be a PR nightmare...like say...WGA capricious DE-activation perhaps?

I think Microsoft is so arrogant, that they might surprise both of us.

by techexec2

.
One: Technically-speaking, Vista doesn't do anything important that XP, or other platforms (Linux, Mac) cannot do.

Two: There is an upgrade surge with Vista that ALL Windows ISVs should take advantage of, yes. But...

Three: If you develop commercial apps for Windows, your business is not going to thrive the way it should and it is going to die a premature death. See (1).

Microsoft does not allow ISVs for Windows to grow and thrive in the global market for software. Period. Anybody who is still around, is suffering and not being allowed to grow the way Microsoft is allowed to grow, and have hundreds of millions of paying customers.

----------------------

(1)
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=212977&messageID=2187758

by tony hopkinson

MS have tried to compete with my firm and failed miserably. All they did was annoy the hell out of their 'partner' for trying and make us laugh our asses off at the feeble attempt they made.

Anyone who tries to out windows windows is indeed doomed.

by rkuhn040172

Yes, MS crushes some of their competitors. But dude, please come up with "newer" technology as examples.

LANtastic (give me a break), Netscape (killed themself), Symantec (resource hog), WinFax (oh my, multi-functions are cheap and enterprises have servers for that), ProComm and QModem (how old are you?), Stacker (well before my time), McAfee (crapware), Real Player (should be classified as malware), Windows Backup (stinks to high heaven), Adobe PDF (bloatware).

The only one I'll concede to you is VMware. But then again, times are a changing. It isn't about virtualization anymore, that's dime a dozen. It's now about manageability, replication, porting, etc.

MS has plenty of competition, but to think for a second that once a 3rd party corners a market that MS should sit around and let them rack in the millions instead of themselves is foolish.

by techexec2

.
I really have to thank you. I got a [i]GREAT[/i] laugh out of reading your post!!

[b][i]"...Yes, MS crushes some of their competitors. But dude, please come up with "newer" technology as examples..."[/i][/b]

OF COURSE they are mostly all old companies, you idiot!! They are all FRIGGIN' DEAD!! :^0 :^0 :^0

The dead are such a problem like that! They were usually born, and have definitely died, before all of the rest of us!!

That is so damn funny! A friggin' laugh riot! People nearby are concerned about me! :^0

[b][i]"...The only one I'll concede to you is VMware. But then again, times are a changing. It isn't about virtualization anymore, that's dime a dozen..."[/i][/b]

Of course virtualization is cheap now! Microsoft acquired one of the top competitors and is now offering Virtual PC for free download! You see the affect of Microsoft abusing its monopoly power. You've taken the first step.

---

You clearly do not understand the importance of controlling the power of monopolies and the problems they cause. Things are different for monopolies. The antitrust laws say so. Of course, they are selectively enforced, depending on who is in power in Washington D.C.

by rkuhn040172

You said, "selectively enforced, depending on who is in power in Washington D.C."

Are you really trying to connect the dots back to Bush? If you are, give me a break.

Hopefully, I read too much between those lines.

Bill Gates contributes almost equally to both political parties (in order to cover his azz no matter which party wins) and actually probably gives more to the Democrats.

So, how one can say who is in power at the time is beyond me.

by rkuhn040172

Considering how long they've been around.

And 31% jump means nothing. If I have a 1% market share and I get to 2%, the headline could read I've doubled my market share. Big deal, 1%.

If Microsoft were to move by 1%, it would mean tens of millions even hundreds of millions of more copies.

by gentlerf

If one is looking solely at the operating system and not the machine running it, you'd be correct. But then many server OS's are in the under 5% category too. Now as far as brands of computer manufacturers go, Apple is doing well.

Now if I had a 31% return on investment for one year, I would be dancing in the streets despite my bad knee. If the selling trend for Apple continues for this year, it may well be the wake up call MS needs to clean up its products. I happen to like a computer that just works when I take it out of the box without having to input cryptic numbers to get it going.

by gentlerf

If he does, would you be gracious enough to admit your error? I know earlier when I posted about market share, I asked the gent who asserted one figure to look up figures in support of his claim. I further stated I would do so while he was. I never got a reply since it would appear his figures were based on nothing more substantial than emotion. I, on the other hand, posted both a figure and a source for that figure where I was only .3% off on my estimation.

What might be nice on your end would be to research the actual figures and use as many sources as possible. In that way, you can prove your assertions in a logical, reasonable manner.

by gentlerf

Good reply. Also check out mine for ways of making a positive refutation to the 3/4 claim.

by rkuhn040172

If you use Vista for 3 years (36 months), at $300 it costs you $8 a month or 26 cents a day to operate one of the best operating systems in the world.

For 26 cents a day you can browse the web, make movies, listen to music, download to your heart is content, etc.

Sounds like a deal to me. $8 a month. Netflix costs about $10 a month doesn't it? I get more use out of my PC than I do my DVD player, that's for sure.

26 cents a day. I spend more than that on chewing gum every day.

by apotheon

Have you heard the term "astroturfing"? It refers to a fake grass-roots movement, typically created by a corporation or political organization paying people to pretend to be independent parties lending "popular support".

In 2001, a landslide of letters were sent to mass media news outlets expressing disgust with the US DOJ's antitrust suit against Microsoft. It was discovered that:

A) the letters were almost identical

B) some letters were sent from nonexistent addresses

C) some letters were sent by deceased people

The Los Angeles Times reported on this, and discovered that "Americans for Technology Leadership" was behind it all. Microsoft is one of the founding members of the ATL -- and by far the most politically and financially powerful of them.

Astroturfing was traced back to the "Freedom to Innovate Network", whose website is on Microsoft servers.

links:
[url=http://www.usatoday.com/tech/news/2001-08-23-microsoft-letters.htm]USA Today[/url]
[url=http://www.newsfactor.com/perl/story/13046.html]NewsFactor Network[/url]
[url=http://www.internetnews.com/bus-news/article.php/871631]InternetNews.com[/url]

edit:
Of course, I doubt that Microsoft is actually paying any of the people in [b]this[/b] discussion. I suspect these little tangles on TR are beneath Microsoft's radar.

by rkuhn040172

And you get to decide what is obscene and what isn't?

For christsakes, the US Supreme Court couldn't even decide on what is obscene (sexually) but you can decide on obscene (financially).

by techexec2

.
The problem is, the vast majority of people refuse to do any research and cite actual information sources, even when asked, as your post notes.

Doing research before posting kind of slows the "coversation" down. I try to do it whenever I can to give the post credibility and substantiation and to avoid being asked. Sometimes I just post what I remember to be true without it. But, when challenged or asked appropriately, I always find and post a reference. I think that people who don't do that are just throwing mud around at each other, some right, some wrong. Nobody reading can tell the difference because everyone is covered by mud.

Some here are [i]NOTORIOUS[/i] for throwing mud. :-)

by rkuhn040172

I don't he "fixed" this either, but face it, whether it be TR or ZdNet, they are looking to stir up trouble.

It's all about page hits, ads, etc. and we're feeding his kids right now.

by techexec2

Just throwing out that comment does not make a point that anyone can believe or disbelieve. They'll just ignore you.

by tony hopkinson

and got no hits!.
So no, not nuff said. :D

There's only one reason to mention open source being a security issue and that's the dumbass argument that the bad guys can see the code, so they could deliberately introduce a weakness into a once 'secure' code base. Only someone who knows f'all about open source could come out with bollocks like that.

Don't help this guy out, he isn't worth it, he does every sensible argument you could make for your case a disservice.

by tony hopkinson

Doesn't say it was introduced because the code was open source though. MS have made similar types of mistakes so it's an example that proves nothing in terms of the FUD that open source is less secure than closed.

Thanks for the link though, no wonder I didn't find it.

Ubuntu and Thunderbird are conspicuous by their absence.

by jmgarvin

I keep hearing about how Linux is just as insecure as MS products, but I've yet to see the proof.

As a matter of fact, check the SANS Top 20...Gee, only one generic *nix "issue." How many does MS have?

by techexec2

.
No. I get to decide what "I" think is obscene, just like you and everybody else.

You're making up a completely false allegation here. And, I think you're intelligent enough to know that.

by cruiser2000

There are many policies that MS have that are unexceptable .. but people seem to just get on buying it..
So lets not forget WIndows 98! The last operation system from MS the the user was sitll in control!

The fact that XP can only be loaded "played" on one machine is crazy. It's like buying a music CD and be limited to playing it on one CD player. If I use one copy of the software on any machine, at a time, then it's still one copy of software. If I move a hard drive to different motherboards, it's still the same user. MS doesn't have any problem with Windows Media Player copy one music cd to many machines!

And lets not forget their product life cycle policy. Could you imagine if Ford Motor Co. said "we no longer service your 5 year old car" We upgrade the software that runs your car, because we sold you something that never really worked in the first

Oh MS customers . don't you love it? Keep buying defective products.. Will get it right someday.

by now left tr

They don't after the 3 year or X miles warranty runs out - then you have to pay. You can PAY MS to support old software you know.

by cruiser2000

MS will no longer publish patches for WIN 98, only some secrity fixes. Check their product life cycle policy. YOu'll only see a daylight saving fix from some third party vendor..
That's ok the product life cycle on MS is coming to an end!!

by tig2

The powertrain is warrantied for a minimum of 5 years and many auto manufacturers offer 6 and 7 year warranties.

Either way, even if I have to make a repair to the vehicle to keep it road worthy, I have the option of doing so and still have the ability to drive on the same roadway as a newer vehicle. I may not have all the same options that the newer vehicle has- cassette versus CD player, etc., but I am not barred from driving.

I think that it is reasonable that people are feeling empowered to make individual choices that are workable for them. I don't get why it is that every time someone says that they are done with Microsoft, it ends up being a huge fight. Microsoft is nothing more than a software vendor. Many people re-select vendors. It is not a new thing.

by rkuhn040172

1) In what SPECIFIC ways am I not in control of my PC which has Win XP?

2) Did you know Windows can be moved from PC to PC if you purchase the correct version, namely, the retail copy as opposed to the heavily discounted OEM version?

AND, if all you do is say replace a faulty motherboard, you're OEM version is still good.

3) Do you really think comparing Ford to Microsoft is fair?

Does your toaster manufacturer cover you 5 years later? TV manufacturer? Hell, my house is only under warranty for most things for 1 year. Only exceptions are things like the roof.

I know what your response will be. You're not asking for it to be warrantable, just that they'll work on it. Well, think about my examples above.

Your TV breaks 5 years after purchase. The repair bill comes in at $350. A new TV is only $500 and has all the new bells and whistles.

Compare to Windows. YES, after 5 years MS will still work on it but for a crazy rate somewhere in the thousands and thousands of dollars but no different than a $350 repair bill for your $500 TV. Keep in mind MS supports their software for 5 years under mainstream support and another 5 years after that.

So, instead of "fixing" your old Windows just like your TV, you go out and get the new latest and greatest with all the new bells and whistles.

Now, you may not like it this way, but man, news flash, this is the trend of the future and not just for MS, but all electronics.

So get used to it.

by jmgarvin

1) Can you tell me what information WGA is sending back to MS? Can you tell me why my VALID Vista key was suddenly deactivated?

I have no control of my PC if MS wants to turn me off, they can...plus I've no idea what WGA is sending back other than taking MS's word for it.

2) Duh?

3) Yes. See Ford has recalls. So if I buy a Ford and something in CRITICALLY wrong with it, I get it fix for free, even if it is 5 years old. Same with TVs, same with your house.

MS has fixed so many CRITICAL flaws in just XP, that it makes the Ford Pinto look like it had a flawless safety record.

by cruiser2000

Well if XP is portable, that's good news. But that not what many computer techs say.
I'm always suspect of OEM software and rather buy the retail version, and you've just given me another reason why!
As far as motherboard replacement, most techs say that your F'd. At any rate there is a process to change your software over, but as I understand it you have to call MS to do it.
But none of that address the concept of portablity. I can play my music in any machine of my choice, at anytime I want.My car player during the day and my home system at nite, etc, etc.

Yea I have many products that have lasted for more than 20yrs. There are many 1980 Cars around.( and Model T's for that matter) The defference is that you don't have to bring the car in to the shope every tuesday(MS tuesday's bug releases)so the car will run correct.

And yes the repair bill maybe high .. but it's my choice to fix or buy. Not the company. An the car company doesn't give me a repair that stops the car from operating all together.

Hey enjoy your built in obsolesance! You'll be at the mercy of MS for the rest of your life!

The Rats are winning!!

by apotheon

I like jmgarvin's answers, but he missed one:

"[i]Now, you may not like it this way, but man, news flash, this is the trend of the future and not just for MS, but all electronics.[/i]"
We're talking about software, not electronics.

Of course, not all software is going that way. In fact, the opposite is happening: thanks to the increasing market penetration of open source software, the trend in some parts of the IT industry is toward free upgrades and fixes in perpetuity.

by rkuhn040172

1) You're a moron adding nothing to this conversation. If it is so easy to "hack" their software and you are just so incredibly knowledgable on this, share something to prove it. And I'm not talking about downloading some bit torrent.

2) I can think of a lot of really good reasons to not use their software illegally. One, I have morals and apparently you don't. Two, legally you can get sued. Three, you can get your company sued. Four, if three happens you're also out of a job.

3) Give some examples of Vista's security being "shredded". Yes, there are a few, but not too many just yet.

So, end of story. Your lack of professionalism here is quite apparent.

by rkuhn040172

Everytime you do some Windows Vista consulting, you have to "borrow" one of their PC's. Nice!

Sure, that works out fine for server related issues, but c'mon, you'll end up buying a Vista license and you know it. It bread and butter income.

by apotheon

When someone asks me to do work on a system I don't personally own, I expect to have needed systems provided -- either as a loaner, or compensated. Typically, compensation is what I get. That's why I have two XP Pro CDs, one 2k Pro CD, and, well, I forget how many 98 CDs, lying around here.

Most of the time, if I have to provide support for something, I just do so on-site. If they expect me to do work elsewhere with systems I don't own, I'm not going to go spend 50% of my pay on software licenses, and they know better than to expect that.

These days, I don't do the sort of work that requires that sort of thing so much, so it's not an issue any longer. It's entirely possible that someone will want me to do extensive software testing on a Vista box at some point in the next five years, though, so I'll probably have a Vista installer added to my collection.

I can only assume you haven't done independent consulting, much. It's not much different from being provided a computer as a corporate employee.

by apotheon

Microsoft doesn't have competing products for Desktop Authority or Double-Take (as in: there's nothing that comes close to being in the same category of functionality), and Microsoft's forays into antispam are very tentative and new so far, so Messaging Ninja doesn't really have enough competition from Microsoft yet for it to be a credible example either.

by apotheon

Unfortunately, that doesn't take into account the additional costs associated with it. For instance, in a job where I managed a network that was 85% Linux and the rest Windows except for a couple of SunOS and Solaris boxes, 60% of my time was consumed by Windows system maintenance.

Manpower is more expensive than licensing and hardware. Of course, the software licensing for Microsoft's offerings has already overtaken hardware costs, and it seems intent on overtaking manpower costs as well.

by techexec2

.
Refusing Vista really means leaving Windows eventually. And, you cannot stay on Windows XP forever. The same rules apply to Windows Server 2003, SQL Server and Oracle, MS Exchange, and middleware you might have invested in.

If you are running an IT infrastructure based on Windows Server (and especially middleware with MS SQL Server), you really don't have the option of "refusing" Vista and leaving Windows. And, I would NOT recommend it, unless you define a strategic project to accomplish the migration. You are kind of stuck with your prior decision to invest in your Microsoft-based IT infrastructure.

However, I would introduce Vista on my own terms. I would wait at least until SP1. I would wait until all drivers that I need are available. I would wait until all applications that I use are updated and working well on Vista. I would wait until all of my custom internal apps were updated and working correctly. I would test heavily before rolling out. And, I would wait until the timing was right for my company. I would probably wait at least a year, or two, or more.

Getting off the "hook" is largely dependent on how deeply you have swallowed it. If you have an IT infrastructure based on Windows Server, the hook is pretty deep.

Good luck!

by now left tr

Depends on where you come from

Million, Million
or
Thousand, Million

As the Song Says...

Well did you hear, there?s a natural order.
Those most deserving will end up with the most.
That the cream cannot help but always rise up to the top,
Well I say: Shit floats.
If you thought things had changed,
Friend you?d better think again,
Bluntly put in the fewest of words,
Cunts are still running the world,
Cunts are still running the world.

Now the working classes are obsolete,
They are surplus to societies needs,
So let ?em all kill each other,
And get it made overseas.
That?s the word don?t you know,
From the guys thats running the show,
Lets be perfectly clear boys and girls,
Cunts are still running the world,
Cunts are still running the world.

Oh feed your children on Cray fish and Lobster tails,
Find a school near the top of the league,
In theory I respect your right to exist,
I will kill ya if you move in next to me,
Ah it stinks, it sucks, it?s anthropologically unjust,
But the takings are up by a third, Oh So
Cunts are still running the world,
Cunts are still running the world.

Your free market is perfectly natural,
Or do you think that I?m some kind of dummy,
It?s the ideal way to order the world,
Fuck the morals, does it make any money?
And if you don?t like it? Then leave.
Or use your right to protest on the street,
Yeah, use your rights but don?t imagine that it?s heard, Oh no no,
Cunts are still running the world,
Cunts are still running the world

by tony hopkinson

that's why your supreme and every other court struggles with an objective or even communal subjective definition.

If they don't struggle, emigrate immediately, you'll be having your ears and nose cut off, or getting cremated while still alive.

by now left tr

Are you migrating your Servers all to Open Source or is the whole rant / plan about leaving windows Smoke & Mirrors?

by tony hopkinson

How else do you explain Steve Warren. :D

Mind you he tends to stay out of this sort of thing and good old George had been slating MS to the point where nix.zealots.org are quoting him as a source.
Not saying either are or were paid by MS, but they probably deserved to be.

by tony hopkinson

and the environment. I've seen a few occasions where that wasn't done and an arse was made of the job.

It cuts out a lot of unknowns. We are talking about plugging in strange kit here.

Oh it worked on my machine isn't an excuse you want to give your client when it all goes nipples up!

by now left tr

without me entering the cryptic numbrs just to get my own cash. Face it - this will never happen

by apotheon

. . . but I still have my doubts.

I'm pretty sure that George Ou would be in trouble with his bosses at CNET if he was taking money on the side from Microsoft to be an MS mouthpiece on TR and other CNET sites. I'm pretty sure that, as inept as Steve Warren is at sounding like a professional who actually knows anything, Microsoft would fire his butt if he was actually being paid for this sort of thing.

So, no . . . I still don't think people are getting paid (directly, at least) to astroturf here.

I've been wrong about one or two things in my life, though, and this one has a relatively high possibility of being wrong.

by tony hopkinson

it wasn't worth the effort of calculating it out.

Office 2007, SQL 2005 and VS 2005 would have set me back ?3k, if I was still contracting.

It would have made more sense to buy an MSDN subscription.

Upgrade both my PCs, might still need XP, so that's ?700. My desktop would choke on vista and I have no idea whether my laptop is compatible, or whether it will be.

Got to be looking at 5k, before I could earn the money to recoup the outlay.
Still I welcome the wonderful opportunity that is Vista, glad I went back to permanent.

by rkuhn040172

"Office 2007, SQL 2005 and VS 2005 would have set me back ?3k, if I was still contracting.

That's the cost of doing business. Any other line of work would also incur costs.

"Upgrade both my PCs, might still need XP, so that's ?700. My desktop would choke on vista and I have no idea whether my laptop is compatible, or whether it will be."

So don't upgrade. Right now, Vista is a want and not a need for 99% of the PC world.

by tony hopkinson

What about Bill and Steve, they need the money.
:D
Just pointing out it's not just the OS that's the new thing, change one thing at a time has always been a good idea in our game. Not something that MS buy into, though.

If I had been faced with this and MSDN subscription would have probably have been my best bet.

by codebubba

That's obvious - and after reading your original post and most of this thread it's obvious that you're making an intelligent decision. If you've used derogatory language, called Windows "crap" or anything else I haven't noticed it.

The trouble with the discussions on this (and a lot of other boards I've been on) is that people get very "relgious" and defensive about all this. The bottom line is simply this: does the product you're using do the job you need to do? That's it. If it does, then use [or keep] it.

These partisan discussions over operating systems and vendors is worse than watching idiots fight over a college football game!

Cheers,

-CB :)

by techexec2

.
Smoke and mirrors? Surely you jest. Trust issues, Mr. TechMale? :^0

So...You want me to "prove" that I'm refusing Vista and moving from XP to Linux over the coming months? That's pretty funny! :^0

You really need to take what I've posted here at face value. I'm not going to "prove" it to you. Here and in the other thread, I've explained why I won't upgrade to Vista, and how and why I will move from XP to Linux. The rationale either makes sense to you or it doesn't.

This is about clients: XP and Vista. I'm not talking about servers.

And, you have used up all of your "20 questions", Mr. TechMale. Game over. :-)

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...First off, too expensive..."[/i][/b]

I don't understand how you keep missing how things work. I would be embarrassed if I kept posting like you do. Of course, some people might be embarrassed if they posted like I do...but at least I usually don't miss the big picture... :-)

The main purpose of the RIAA lawsuits is not to recover monetary damages in a profitable way. The main purpose is to intimidate the hell out of millions if music pirates with a very few lawsuits. Each RIAA lawsuit that drives a family in a suburb to settle for $5000 because their 14 year old son downloaded some pirated music online will intimidate MANY other people to stop doing it, and to motivate parents to police their children better.

The exact same thing would work for Microsoft suing individual Linux users. It would not stop the Linux zealots, but it would have a very chilling effect on regular users who are Windows customers.

But, I wouldn't do it if I ran Microsoft. They have already won. The smart move is to be benevolent now. If they keep it up as they have been, eventually they are going to motivate a sufficient backlash that it WILL hurt the bottom line.

They just pushed me too far with this WGA capricious DE-activation nonsense. And, I revered them at one time.

by techexec2

.
I agree with you. The religious discussions are not very helpful to anyone. Honest fact-based discussion of pros and cons is helpful. And, if you have a solution that works for you, you are winning the battle.

P.S. So...which truck is better? Ford or Chevy? ]:) :^0

P.P.S. Just kiddin'. I NEVER discuss which truck is better.

by jmgarvin

CodeBubba has a point, but at the same time, so much FUD has gone around about Linux lately, that it has to be squashed.

It's irritating to hear the same FUD on open source over and over...they boil down to:
1) It's open source, so "bad" code can be inserted
2) It's obscure, so therefore it must be more secure
3) MS products are more secure because...uh...just because

by aaron a baker

Thank You;
I was indeed just trying to make a point.
At last count, I think there are now something like 6 or 8 versions of Vista.
At what point does this get ridiculous?
Where does it stop and when can we buy and entire program without the Microsoft Big Brother attitude, arrogance and runaround?
At First Opportunity I shall come back and list them all.
This is not a good way to do Business, in my opinion.
As it is now, if I crash and have to re-install my XP, I now have to contact Microsoft "Every Time" to get a new number.
When I asked, I was told I would have to this from now on, i.e. forever or as long as I am running XPPro.
Isn't this just a bit much? And that's with XPPro.
Now Vista will have a Kill switch.Imagine, you pay outrageous amounts of money for a program that can shut down at Microsoft's whim and discretion. What ever happened to Privacy and integrity [Ours].
I think Microsoft has lost on both counts.
Now they seek to corner the market on just about everything and carefully couch the hypocrisy. That is the real point.
It's also why, although I don't mind Beta Testing the Vista.
I will NEVER purchase one and will stick with My XPPro for as long as I can.
With the nonsense with Validation and Activation, I may even go as far as to get a bootleg older version of XP, just to getaway from MicroBig-Brother.
Not my style but I am feeling a little annoyed at the presumptive arrogant attitude that Microsoft has taken.
All this without regard or consideration for the client, although they claim the contrary.
I will NEVER buy Vista.
I'll learn Linux first.
Regards
Aaron

by rkuhn040172

"If one is looking solely at the operating system and not the machine running it, you'd be correct."

Yes, that is the topic here.

"But then many server OS's are in the under 5% category too."

You lost me.

"Now as far as brands of computer manufacturers go, Apple is doing well."

Define "well". Sure, they're profitable, but only for some of the same reasons Microsoft is profitable. How do they stack up against someone like HP or Dell?

by rkuhn040172

1) There is good documentation out there already on taking the Win 2000 DST patch and modifying it for Win 98 (hint...it's only a registry hack to begin with).

Since you are retired, I'm assuming you have at least the 20-30 minutes to figure that one out.

2) As for Win 98 and MS. They are doing exactly as promised years ago. 5 years mainstream support plus 5 more if you pay.

You're lucky you're getting security patches. Consider those a freebie.

Win 98 has been in use for about 9 years. It cost about $150 at the time. That's 108 months or $1.38 per month or a little over 4 cents a day (good god, Linux may be free but your version of Windows is close too!) you've paid for that software since then.

That's not worth it to you? You're still driving your original Model T Ford aren't you?

by rkuhn040172

You said, "At last count, I think there are now something like 6 or 8 versions of Vista.
At what point does this get ridiculous?"

And just how many versions of Linux are there?

And, I think you are being overly deceptive here. There really are only 4 versions for 99% of PC users: Home Basic, Home Premium, Business, and Ultimate.

To throw in Vista Starter and Vista Enterprise is misleading on your part in my opinion.

You said, "As it is now, if I crash and have to re-install my XP, I now have to contact Microsoft "Every Time" to get a new number."

Why is this?

As a matter of fact, I just reinstalled my OS (Win XP Pro) last week. I added a new hard drive and swapped out the sound card as well as re-partitioned this a bit better and I didn't have to call MS.

You said, "that can shut down at Microsoft's whim and discretion."

Incorrect. Not at MS's whim and discretion. Only if they suspect it is pirated software. That isn't a whim.

You said, "I may even go as far as to get a bootleg older version of XP."

Says a lot about you! You're becoming the exact reason why MS has to do what they are doing.

I have to admit, I deeply respect those in the open source community that don't agree with MS's pricing or practices so they use Linux instead of using bootleg copies.

You or anyone else who uses illegal copies of Windows (or any software for that matter)are immoral and breaking the law, period.

by rkuhn040172

Here he goes again.

Construct the question so that the person answering the question can't win based on the nature of the question itself.

1) Name a competitor MS hasn't crushed
2) Exclude any product MS has that's new

One question for you Apotheon. Isn't it a goal of all businesses to beat or even eliminate their competitors?

Oh, I know, you're some kind of enlightened type where you enjoy successfully co-existing with your competition. Oh well, I routinely try to eliminate mine.

by techexec2

.
I constructed the question that way on purpose.

It proves the point that it is futile for independent software vendors to create products for Windows. Microsoft easily crushes successful ISVs by either (1) Bundling a competing product into Windows (e.g. Internet Explorer), or (2) Buying or building a competing product and giving it away for free (e.g. Virtual PC).

The U.S. Congress created the antitrust laws that make such conduct illegal for a business that is classified as a monopoly. Microsoft was convicted of breaking those laws. And, it is clear that the government has been looking the other way since then. It's up to the Executive branch to enforce them. It's political.

When Microsoft actually does compete, I am all for it.

Example 1: MS Money is still on the market at $49 per copy. This gives Intuit Quicken a chance to keep selling their product. The consumer gains benefits from the competition including better features each year. Why doesn't Microsoft bundle MS Money into Windows? I guarantee you that the U.S. Govt would drag Microsoft into court, that's why. MS tried to buy Intuit outright some years back and the U.S. Govt blocked the sale.

Example 2: If Microsoft bought Virtual PC and kept it on the market, even at a more competitive reduced but not ZERO price (and not below the cost of manufacturing), I would think that is fine. If Microsoft improves Virtual PC and beats VMWare in the marketplace (because customers choose it), and kills VMWare, that would be completely fine.

I would not be surprised if EMC/VMWare sues Microsoft over antitrust eventually. I also would not be surprised if they won a huge settlement over it. And, they would deserve it. It has happened to Microsoft many times already. Microsoft has paid out MANY BILLIONS of dollars to settle those suits. They clearly view this as merely a cost of doing business and they can afford it. They clear $18B per year.

But, in the end, the consumer, you and I, lose the choice to buy the competing product (VMWare). We have to accept the Microsoft product whether we like it or not, or stop using the monopoly operating system used by 90% of the world and use something else.

[b][i]"...Construct the question so that the person answering the question can't win based on the nature of the question itself..."[/i][/b]

Now you understand the futility of independent software vendors creating products for Windows:

...Construct the marketplace so that the ISV entering the market can't win based on the nature of the marketplace itself...

It's called abuse of monopoly power. And, it's illegal (for good reason).

by techexec2

.
[b][i]"...Are you really trying to connect the dots back to Bush?..."[/i][/b]
.
Yes and no. It's not partisan. But, it is directly affected by who runs Washington D.C. (i.e. [u]people[/u]). Microsoft money flowing to both parties IS designed as part of the antitrust defense.

But, you will notice that the antitrust suit was brought against Microsoft by the Clinton administration. And, the weak enforcement that followed has been during the Bush one.

I don't want to engage in a political discussion here. Talk about futility! I only reluctantly mentioned this because it was necessary to explain why a convicted company is allowed to continue violating.

by hal 9000

There are up to possibly 4 different versions per maker and that covers the Basic Free versions in 32 & 64 Bit versions and the Paid For Version that you can buy complete with 99% on most peoples software needs.

Now look at Vista there are 7 versions available in the 32 Bit Configuration another 7 Versions available in the 64 Bit Configuration all of which cost more than the most advance Brand of Linux on the Market and then M$ is currently about to introduce a Vista Server as soon as they can get them to work again in several different packages that will be a total of over 20 Products that M$ is selling just in the OS market.

And don't be a total idiot an claim that most users can get away with Vista Home Basic it just lacks way too much of the necessary parts of an OS to be usable for anyone but a gamer who has no need to backup their data. MS accepts that there are only 2 versions of Vista that will be useful to a Business Environment and as such are only offering one of there with Software Assurance and 2 with a Volume License ability in the 32 Bit Range and 1 in the 64 Bit Range.

Currently if you want to get real there are 14 different versions of Vista Available and comparing these 14 different versions to Linux is like saying well General Motors makes 26 Models of Cars today but how many others can you buy new on the market from all the different makers.

Linux/Unix/BSD are made by different makers who may chose to follow the set standard or ignore it completely so you can not reasonably add up all the different makes available from all the different makers of Unix/BSD & Linux and then claim that they are far more different versions of these OS's available and the fact that they all come from different makers has no impact on the argument.

Sorry my friend but it is you who have lost the plot here with your ridiculous argument that is fostered by M$ in a constant attempt to discredit Linux as a real Possible different OS to their offerings which are by the way substandard that is the M$ Offerings not the Linux Offerings.

I have had a Volume License of Vista since it was available and I can not use it to run any of my [b]Mission Critical Business Applications[/b] and while I accept that I have not actually purchased Vista from M$ but only bought a License that gives me the right to actually use it if I can to do my business on I can not accept M$ remotely shutting down my OS's because they have now decided that they don't want me to use their products any longer without any notification.

They have already stacked the EULA in such a way that they are not responsible for their shoddy coding so any losses that I suffer because their OS is at fault they are protected from but now they can also withdraw my ability to use their OS & Software without warning or notice and not be in a position to have to recompense me for losses that are brought about by their actions or reimburse me for the money that I spent on the Licenses that I have purchased.

If you want a very good reason why so many people are looking elsewhere for an OS just look at M$ Business Practises they are the ones who are [b]Pissing People Off[/b] and until you can accept this or more importantly the Top Management at M$ accept this they are bound to continue to loose market share and have their Share Price reflect their actions.

Col

by techexec2

.
Thanks, but that is just a bug, not a Linux architectural problem nor a weakness of open source. The guy who floated the claim said: "...Linux and Unix have long had security problems from the ground up. Add in open source, and it's a complete nightmare...". Tony is right. That is simply not true.

By the way. While both are important, I count "exploits in the wild" as more important than mere "vulnerabilities fixed". This was merely the latter.

You'll notice that there is more of the former attacking Windows and apps on Windows than on other platforms. I don't see this so much as a security weakness of Windows/apps per se (although there is some of that), but rather the number of criminals who are attacking Windows. Either way, Windows "lives" in a bad neighborhood with lots of break-ins.

by hal 9000

M$ currently has a Plug In for Office 2007 which is an accounting package. Currently it doesn't work on Vista but when it eventually does and as it's free at the moment what is the need to buy Accounting Packages like Intuit or MYOB who have the lions share of the market now?

The reason is that M$ wants to Dominate the world with it's products and they are not concerned in how they achieve this. They have previously blatantly broken laws and when they loose the Court Battle they act all sorry and pay the fine out of the Petty Cash Tin and then continue on exactly as they where previously the only difference is that now there is no competition as they have gone broke so it is the End User and those who support them who suffer.

While Competition is good a complete monopoly is bad for business and M$ in particular as they have now grown so Big and Cumbersome that they are unable to change direction at a moments notice and proceed down a new path as technology develops hence we are still using 32 Bit OS & Software when there have been 64 Bit CPU's and M'Boards out for years that work quite well. When we moved from 16 to 32 Bit computing M$ was a leader of the pack but ever since they have been floundering in the wake of the technological advancements which have occurred, The main reason where there is not currently more 64 Bit Software available is that M$ has crushed the opposition to such an extent that they are not capable of developing any 64 Bit Software until it becomes the norm. In the meantime M$ is incapable of producing any 64 Bit software because they are too busy building their existing 32 Bit software and proceeding along blindly.

M$ today is what IBM was in 1985 and it will be to their disadvantage this situation continuing.

Col

by techexec2

.
That was an outstanding post, Col.

I am actually sad, and angry, and determined all at the same time. WGA capricious DE-activation is simply the last straw.

by techexec2

.
Maybe something good might come out of Microsoft's apparent short memory of their near-death experience in the antitrust case. The way I see it, Microsoft is clearly over the line in a number of ways. All it will then take is a new administration in Washington D.C. that goes after them over it. It could happen. A Hilary Clinton administration would probably do it, right after taking money away from Exxon. :0 :^0

Microsoft bundling a personal accounting package into Office 2007 would not have made me stop using Quicken. I stopped upgrading Office at Office 2000. I just didn't see any good reason to spend the money. And, it's completely moot now. I switched to OpenOffice full-time last week (very happy so far, the MS Word and Excel bits on the HDD are getting lonely) as part of my project to permanently move to Linux full-time.

by so.cal guy

eceryone was whineing about WGA inagrated into windows vista and i was just letting them know that it is or now is a part of XP

i did not say a word about being upset over it you need to read a post before calling someone a pirate

by jbb1

...is that you have to buy the software (or license) before you get a chance to even read the EULA. If consumers were forced (Ha!) to read and understand the EULA before plunking down their dollars, a lot fewer commercial software products would be sold. They all say, in effect, we take your money and you get this product, which may or may not work, but either way, if it harms you or your business, you can't blame us. If people ever read or understood EULAs, there would be howls of outrage because they deprive the consumer/end-user of all protection. But nobody ever bothers to read them, they just click "accept" and charge ahead blindly.

by apotheon

You're absolutely right -- there's a huge difference between architectural flaws and exploits or vulnerabilities. There's more to it than that, too:

[b]Exploits[/b] are usually more of an indication of there being more security crackers focusing on your software than there are friendly developers helping find and fix vulnerabilities (as you sort-of indicate). This is common for Microsoft because there's a very limited number of developers (it being proprietary software, so that open source developers can't help find and fix vulnerabilities), but Microsoft's software is very popular and widely used (thus attracting more malicious security crackers). Zero-day exploits in particular are an indication of security cracker activity.

[b]Vulnerabilities[/b] are found as a combination of the efforts of malicious security crackers and friendly developers, so a high number of known vulnerabilities indicates that there are a lot of security crackers targeting your software, a lot of friendly developers have access to your source code, or both.

[b]Rapid fixes[/b] indicate both many friendly developers and commitment to security. [b]Long fix times[/b] indicate some or all of the following:

1. The software is too complex and crufty to facilitate quick fixes.

2. Many of the discovered vulnerabilities are endemic to a poor software architecture.

3. There isn't a sincere commitment to security.

4. The activity of malicious security crackers is overwhelming the number of friendly developers.

[b]Based on all of that[/b], compare exploit rates, frequency of zero-day exploits, and time to produce fixes, to get a really good idea of what sort of security value you're getting for your software. Rate of vulnerability discovery is almost useless as a security metric, all by itself. Only in the context of a comprehensive understanding of the rest of the security-related factors, and an analysis of the source of vulnerability discovery, does rate of discovery actually amount to anything useful. Because proprietary software vendors -- especially Microsoft -- are so loath to disclose vulnerabilities, let alone their source, there's really no simple way to come up with an effective comparison of security based on vulnerability discovery rates.

After all, depending on context, [b]a high rate of vulnerability discovery can mean either that the software sucks and is not secure of that it is improved quickly by its developers[/b]. It more likely means some combination of the two, to varying degrees.

It's much easier to come up with a worthwhile analysis for open source software than for proprietary software, because open source project development tends to be much more transparent so that useful information can be gathered. Good luck coming up with something equivalent for proprietary software.

As a result, you have to fall back on comparisons of fix times and exploit rates to come up with any kind of meaningful security comparisons most of the time.

by apotheon

I'll ignore the stuff that doesn't actually even come close to addressing what I said in a substantive manner. I mean really -- what do you expect from TechExec2's question? Do you think he's trying to prove something by saying that the [b]very instant[/b] Microsoft products hit the market all competition evaporates? That's not just absurd. It's asinine. No, his point is that Microsoft eliminates competition via anticompetitive practices, and it's just about futile as an ISV to attempt to establish a long-standing market for software meant to run on MS Windows. If you violate the spirit of the question with your answers that seek loopholes in the phrasing of the question, I'll point out where your answers are clearly not particularly responsive to the intent of the question.

"[i]One question for you Apotheon. Isn't it a goal of all businesses to beat or even eliminate their competitors?[/i]"
It's a goal of many businesses, to be sure, but that's only because they've confused their own success with others' failure. The real goal should not be destroying competition, but rather profiting. If competitors fall by the wayside because they fail to maintain a profitable business model, so be it -- but taking spiteful aim at the competition just because destroying other companies seems like "success" to you is kind of a losing strategy in the long run.

"[i]Microsoft has plenty of programs built into Windows that suck compared to 3rd party solutions.[/i]"
That's the only reason the third-party improved software stays in business -- and even then it doesn't always work out for them, if Microsoft sets out to destroy them for having the temerity to catch Microsoft's attention, as TechExec2 pointed out.

by apotheon

Do you think Presidents are the only public officials that have any say in the matter?

Obviously, the Bush administration has had much more unpleasant ideas on its agenda than dealing with Microsoft, so it's not terribly surprising that the DOJ didn't put much effort into enforcing terms of judgments and settlements during the Clinton Administration. It would be much easier for Microsoft to grease the right palms, eight or nine tiers down from the Presidency, and get away with it, while the higher-ups are distracted by stuff like the USA PATRIOT Act and Military Commissions Act, anyway.

Corruption need not always involve the President. I'm not saying it doesn't involve the President in this case -- but whether or not it does is something we really have no way of knowing.

by techexec2

.
I completely agree. I'm glad you took the time to post this. The rest of the story is very important.

I once had a go-around with someone here over this, and the importance of measuring the amount of time at risk to unpatched known vulnerabilities and unpatched exploits in the wild (1). I'll bet this person would be on your short list for such a thing: George Ou. It was another one of those famous pieces seeking to "...dispel the popular myth...", about Firefox in this case.

Great post!

------------------------------

(1) Internet Explorer is more dangerous to use than Firefox
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=203307&messageID=2114815

by techexec2

This is a DST test. The timestamp on this message should be about 3:05 AM PDT.

[Update: Passed! Good job TR!]

by rkuhn040172

First off, listen to what I'm saying and stop being an egotistic, know it all, prick.

Go to Best Buy, Circuit City, Fry's, etc. Oh wait, you're not from the US. Insert your stores.

99% of all home consumers will see 4 basic flavors of Vista for sale.

1) Vista Home Basic
2) Vista Home Premium
3) Vista Business
4) Vista Ultimate

Now, you can parse my words anyway you want, but I in no way shape or form proposed most people needing only Vista Home Basic.

I would actually recommend to 99% of home consumers that they buy Vista Home Premium.

Nice rant, but show me where I said that.

Second, 32 bit vs 64 bit is of minor concern. Most home consumers will only see, only need, or can only run the 32 bit version for the time being.

Third, if you are talking about businesses (I was mentioning home users above), having multiple different flavors (7 or so) shouldn't be confusing and if it is, you don't qualify as a member of IT. Period.

Now, even if you see confusion with 14 different versions, how the hell do you even start to pick a Linux distro. C'mon, what are there nowadays? Hundreds? Thousands?

You're making a case that Windows users will be confused about 14 possible choices when Linux confuses people merely on where to get it, how to get it, how to install it, and which one of the distros to use.

by rkuhn040172

I know you'd marry the first 64 bit motherboard you could if it were legal, but Hal, get over this obsession. Every post you have on here somehow goes back to 64 bit.

There are far too many reasons why 64 bit computing hasn't caught on than to merely blame MS.

by rkuhn040172

"The difference is that you don't have to bring the car in to the shop every Tuesday"

Wrong. The difference is in the complexity of the product. Not fair to compare a car with Windows.

And by the way, just how often does Linux need to be repaired so it runs correctly?

"And yes the repair bill maybe high .. but it's my choice to fix or buy."

You're right. It is your choice. I ran Windows 98 on an old laptop until just recently. What's stopping you?

"Hey enjoy your built in obsolescence!"

News flash! Planned obsolescence is a part of virtually any and all products you buy.

by rkuhn040172

"free upgrades and fixes in perpetuity"

None sense. Most open source projects only provide fixes, upgrades, etc for as long as the community deems the project still useful.

Yes, since the code is open source, someone else could take over, but in reality, this rarely happens.

One of the difficults of open source is choosing software that will be supported long term. Hence, the success of companies like Novell, Red Hat, etc.

by tony hopkinson

Closed source companies go bust, you don't get support then. They upgrade and use enforced obsolescence to get another purchase. You can have support on something different, whether you wanted it or needed it.

If you go open source, you can't rely on the contributors, unless you choose to become one. Too many take the free in open source as I get this for nothing. If you don't contribute, you are guaranteed nothing. You can ride on the back of a community for so long, don't be surprised if they shrug you off or you end up somewhere else though.

Closed source and support is simply a way of extending the revenue stream past the initial purchase.

Free open source and support is a way of getting a revenue stream.

With one you buy the support to get a return on the investment you've already made, the other you don't invest in unless you are going to get a return.

Discounting implementation costs of course, which isn't something I'd advise anyone to do in a real life scenario.

by techexec2

.
Marry the motherboard? I would expect to hear a comment like that from a 14-year old. You really belong on MySpace if you're going to post like that. You could offer a lot more adult-level input here. I know you could.

by rkuhn040172

Just because ISV's, and that was my point, struggle, is neither here nor there.

Microsoft faces competition from all areas. To construct the question so that only MS ISV Partners count, is deceiving at best.

Aside from Win XP, Office 2003, SQL and VS 2003, I don't know if I have a single piece of MS software on my PC.

Virtually all of my utilities and various all pieces of software are non-MS. MS typically has something to address my needs, but I have found other companies do a better job.

So, that being said, where is all this all dominating, competitor crushing MS?

by aaron a baker

I don't care What your point of view is, nor do I care about your so-called facts.
I do however find your expletives disturbing.
In case your not aware of it, you're dealing with a great class of people here.
There is no need to use vulgar language and name calling as you have done.
You have your points, I have Mine and Col has his, that's the way it's supposed to be at Tech Republic.
So for you to refer to Col as you did only show's what a low life self-serving scumbag attitude you must have.
Man you must be a blast to work with.
Col is a man of Class & Distinction and has excellent points of view.For you to disagree is one thing, to call him what you did was inexcusable. There are many fine and excellent IT Techs here and almost ALL have class enough not to get into low-life name calling.
I for one will never acknowledge you again, or at least until you clean up your act.
This is Tech Republic,not some Cheap Yahoo Forum.
Get it together Man or Move on.
Or better yet, when that's the way you must express yourself?
S.T.F.Up.
As for me,you don't exist any longer.
Good Luck Growing Up
Aaron

by tony hopkinson

just NoelRD who was talking completely out of his ass.

A secure pc is a powered down one in a safe, that's been bricked over, before you got amnesia and forgot you hid it.

Open Source has the potential (often realised) to be more secure closed source. There's no law that says the potential will be achieved though, and only the feeble minded would claim security has been achieved.

After all Tom Cruise could dig in the back of your safe and take the hard drive.

by fxef

The Vista that many users now see is their computers running smoothly and rock solid on Linux. Because of Vista's poor performance, Linux is gaining market share in all directions.