Question Locked

Can you image for backups?

0 helpful
25 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Oh, here I am, thrown out of the safety and security [i](and stability)[/i] of a linux environment and into the world of Windows servers.

I have a buffet of OS's to deal with here (all server) Win2k, win2003, and win2008.

The 2003 has a DAT72, but is can not backup the systems AND the data due to size constraints, but it is working for now.

My concern, the other two servers don't HAVE a tape backup, and the one on the 03 is an internal drive.

There is not any real data that changes on the other two, so all I care about is being able to recover without having to reconfigure.

I know people use Ghosting technology for loading systems, but does anyone use this as a way to recover their systems?

I did some googling but was only finding sales crap, and not real life information of people doing this.

Will this work? If so, got a good link you can recommend?

If not, can you recommend another good option?

I have a company also that is going to provide me with a managed tapeless system that is suppose to via virtulization, within 20 minutes of a failure, setup and run a virtual server. ($300 a month). Is that typical or overpriced?

Thanks for your input.

jd

25 replies

by cg it

If nothing changes, then you don't need to image on a regular basis. Security patches from MS will automatically be detected and downloaded so you could get away with just one image.

Desktops with my documents redirect are the best candidates for imaging [or store stuff on a file server] for backups.

The real issue is size and storage space. A server with all patches can take upwards of 15 GB or more. When you ghost the image, you need to store the thing somewhere. you can do multiple DVDs to store the image but that's not ghost, thats the DVD burning software. You could buy a 64 GB or large flash drive to store the image on.

Can the small business you work for afford $300.00 per month for virtual server stuff? I personally think virtual servers or virtually anything is just all dog and pony show to sell virtual technology. Why should I run it virtually when I can simply run my O/S and not have a $300.00 a month payment. The only time I found virtual technology to be useful is merging 2 companies together. Deploy virtual desktops overnight and the next day workers are on the new network. [Do this for Banks that are merging]. Other than that, virtual stuff is just good for test networks imo.

by jdclyde

if the 300 can fly or not. My direct boss seemed to think it was a reasonable insurance policy, but don't know what his boss will think. I kind of doubt $3k a year will be in our future.

It does come down to "can we afford to NOT do it?"

My two big focuses is making sure I have all the data setup and disaster recovery for the servers.

And the visualization is just for IF the server crashes, the SAN would take its place until the server can get fixed.

The big thing is the two servers that don't HAVE the drive. I am thinking the disk image would be the ticket. could save it to an external harddrive.

The newer imaging software allows for you to drop on different hardware, right? Drop the image and then add in the new drivers?

What package do you use, and which do you recommend?

by cg it

disaster recovery is a tad different than the de facto standards. Since we have all the media and licensing, the only things that are backed up is the information that can not be restored from media. Typically all user created documents. While large enterprises can't do this, small business can. Restoring by reinstalling, either to new hardware or same hardware, dumping saved user created information back in saves on backup costs. While it might take a weekend to bring the network back up nothing business critical is lost. Disaster Recovery can end up a big money pit. While expediency in recovery often is of prime importance to large businesses, oftem Small Businesses aren't that constrained.

Most argue that even small businesses have complext networks, therefore this approach doesn't sound possible, this is where good documentation comes in. mapped drives, share folders, etc can all be recreated. GPOS and other configurations can be backed up[import export]. critical data if backed up can be restored to folders. User rights can be established. While it is administrative effort, I don't think that less admin effort ought to be the driving force with disaster recovery. Getting it right is. My network documentation is basically how to create the network and all that goes with it from scratch [with the exception of user created information and network specific configurations like GPOs, those are backed up].

Some here will argue, losing SIDs user preferences, email, the lot but that's all just admin effort to recreate. With a small number of users, it doesn't matter. You have what? 12 people? and 12 workstation? With the right documentation, not much of a problem if you know what your doing.

by shasca

"And the visualization is just for IF the server crashes, the SAN would take its place until the server can get fixed".

You have a SAN on site???? Big enough to hold backups from the servers? If it will backup to it. I would still ghost the servers for quick rebuilds if OS gets gerflunked. It is a good disaster recovery tool but not much for a backup solution. The Ghost images could also be stored on the SAN.

by oh smeg

Is related to what you are backing up for. If it is just Corrupted OS then it works a treat. But the big problem occurs when you need to recover to different Hardware it most likely [b]Will Not[/b] work then.

But instead of using DVD Media or Flash Drives I clone to HDD's and have a couple of Backups in the event of OS Corruption. It's much faster to recover which saves money and more importantly doesn't inping on production time as things like that don't happen when you have heaps of time to muck around. Well not to me at least. :0

You should get your hands on [b]Administrators Guide to DR Planing and Recovery[/b] published by TR. I have the 2 Volumes and they are really good. ;)

Col

by jdclyde

As far as different hardware, don't you run into the same issue if recovering from a tape backup?

by oh smeg

It all depends on how you structure your Backup's and what you are trying to protect against.

I work on the theory that the Hardware will not be available and if there is Data only that whatever was used to create the Backup will not function on a New/Different OS that may have become available since the DR Plan was put in place and not looked at again. To that end for Long Term Backup things like Optical Disc's are likely to be readable for a long time and even better HDD's are likely to be usable in computers even longer.

For Archival Purposes I just store Plain Data with no Software used to Backup or any Encryption involved. For shorter Term the stratagem is different with software used to Backup & Encrypt Data but in the event of some catastrophic event occurring I don't count on that Backup being usable. ;)

The other thing you need to look at as well is the type of Business that the company does and are there any Compliancing Issues involved referring to Data Security. Some Compliancing requires that the Data Stay within the business ans more importantly you need to have some Legal Guarantee of what will happen to your Data in the event of the Hosting Company going broke or being taken over.

When things like that happen the new owner or Liquidator may sell on your Data in an attempt to recover money. When you don't physically hold your own Data things like that are always possible.

Col

by brenton keegan

"But the big problem occurs when you need to recover to different Hardware it most likely Will Not work"

Simply not true. It really depends on the software that you use. Developers of some of the imaging software out there do support loading images to different hardware. Some even support Physical to virtual imaging.

I don't know every solution out there, but the one that we use is: http://www.ultrabac.com/

Their solution also allows you to take an image of a server while it is running.

by oh smeg

But the $250,000.00 question is do you trust that Software Enough to stake your Business Data on it for Long Term Purposes?

I've seen systems previously that it was guaranteed that you could recover that just do not work on New Hardware which is more than 3 generations newer than what was destroyed. When that happens the cost of getting the Data back is considerably more than most places are willing to pay and they simply don't unless there are some Legal Implications Involved.

Personally I wouldn't be trusting my Data to something that may or may not work latter and I know that I may be up for .25 Million to recover my Data. But maybe I'm just silly and plan for something far worse than others do. Could be why I have yet to loose any Important Data and why others pay me lots of money to recover theirs. ;)

Col

by balge

hi
I only use it 'at home' but I've got an SBS2003 server and use Acronis Trueimage as an emergency backup/restore app, its been really useful a few times and 'pretty' reliable. (didn't like Ghost but again only saw 'home' version, ymmv)
I think the 'enterprise' versions are more robust and have all the whistles and bells
you need for commercial use, different hardware, network restore etc.
expensive but so is $300/month...or losing your server lol
worth a look maybe
cheers!

by cg it

for servers.

I'm using an older version of Ghost, 9.0 because I don't like the new version of it. While restoring to new hardware can be a pain, I've really not had to much problem other than having to load up chipset drivers and other drivers . The biggest problem comes with RAID arrays. Depending on what type of RAID array you use, getting the server backup from an image is almost impossible unless you've got something like Acronis universal restore.

dollar for dollar, Acronis with universal restore at around $900.00 USD per license probably is the best value for disaster recovery if you run RAID arrays and need to go to new hardware. Ghost works well if you don't have RAID arrays and will work with new hardware provided that you know how to fix NTDLR and boot.ini problems.

Note: Ghost 9.0 doesn't work well with Vista. Use it for XP and Server 2003 without RAID arrays.

by notsochiguy

I was once doing a long-term consulting gig at a SMB that was using disk imaging as their means to backup/restore the servers. When the time came to restore something, it worked out fine.

However, I had a separate client that was also using Ghost, and it failed horribly. The image jobs were being executed and reportedly succeeding. However, attempts to restore anything all failed for every single image we had on hand. Long story short was that the hard drive (one being imaged...not where the image was stored) had bad sectors on it, and the images were corrupted due to this. Eventually, the original drive and a handful of images had to be sent to Symantec for assistance in restoring. Bear in mind, though, this was a couple years back. So newer versions of imaging software may be better with handling such issues.

As for the $300 per month service fee...I've seen solutions such as that go for much higher. I'd say just make sure you don't sign anything too long term; since you never know when you'll get the capital freed up to optimize the backups as you see fit.

by computechdan

of course on a win2k3 box have it at least mirrored as a frontline defense

most of wat i do is support for smaller companies, and in recent years i've i gone almost 100% to hdd based backup.

in my opinion for the money u can't beat acronis w/universal restore

by jdclyde

hell, I don't even know what/IF raid is used on the dang server as I haven't had the chance to take it down long enough to find out.

by Member 25348569

disaster recovery and backups and what it means to your organisation.

How do you restore a corrupted database or a a deleted file?

How do you deal with a failed server?

How do you deal with an office fire?

Neil :)

My thoughts? For the static servers you can ghost and then put it on tape and get it out if the office.

How often do you reckon the key server will fail? Equipment gets more and more reliable and $3K can buy you a bigger tape drive! Big enough for your Ghost images! Or maybe an HDD backup system. Tape is faster!

by jdclyde

and different angles.

I almost choked when he said $300 per month, and at the end of the meeting, I told him up front I didn't see that being a working solution. He emailed back a $100 solution, but I didn't get a chance to look it over.

I am looking at the images because I can't see buying drives for the two servers that dont' store data.

Between the last backup question and this one, I am learning quite a bit on the topic, and I really appreciate it. :D

by w2ktechman

Here, when we had some servers, we had a ghost image of each for quick recovery, along with regular backups. Images were created every month unless major changes were afoot, then it was imaged before/after the change.

by oh smeg

I was told that HAL showed you what it was like going through several Days/Weeks [b]@ith Out Oxygen.[/b] How did you survive that and much more importantly how come Scummy doesn't know that you are still around?

Col

by the scummy one

Hmmm -- W2k has been hiding well I see!

Or -- You logged in as W2k to mess around with me :0

either way -- I am now on a quest to find and finish him off :^0

by rob miners

You should be able to use ImageX to Capture the C:\> drive and save it as a Backup. I've been doing it with XP and Vista. Just use DiskPart to remove the Partition, recreate it, Format it and make it Active. Re-apply the wim that you created and you should be good to go.

Don't try to use SysPrep! You want to Capture the current Image.

http://www.911cd.net/forums//index.php?showtopic=19355

Quick and dirty guide to create PE boot key and capture/apply images using imagex

guide to create PE boot key

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc749003.aspx

What is ImageX?

http://technet.microsoft.com/en-us/library/cc722145.aspx

Automated Installation Kit

http://www.microsoft.com/downloads/details.aspx?FamilyID=C7D4BC6D-15F3-4284-9123-679830D629F2&displaylang=en

by mdhealy

For disaster recovery one should think through and test the possible scenarios. Image backups are the quickest way to recover from disk failure or OS corruption, but as others have pointed out may not be optimal for recovering data onto different hardware. File-level backups are the quickest way to recover critical data files onto a different system, but as others have pointed out may not be optima for recovering from disk failure or OS corruption. So the first step is to define all plausible recovery scenarios and make a plan to handle each of them.

Having defined scenarios and devised plans, the next key step is testing them. For file level backups, testing is fairly straightforward: recover key files from backup media onto a different machine that also has the required applications, then try reading those data files.

But testing an image backup presents a challenge. What I like to do is the following:

1. purchase a brand-new hard drive.
2. run an image backup.
3. take the old hard drive out of the computer and put it in a safe place; if all goes well this drive may never again be powered up.
4. put in the new hard drive.
5. perform a bare-metal restore just as though the hard drive removed in step 3 has died.

If you have a working system after this, then you have gained some important benefits. You know your image is good, you have practice doing an actual restore, AND the old hard drive represents a known-good emergency boot disk for that computer.

Note that if you standardize the configuration of your client systems then recovery can be dramatically simplified. At many companies today, users are told "if you care about a file, then put it on a server, because we don't back up client systems." When a client system dies, that user gets a replacement computer.

by wrouse

I have use Trueimage to recover full hdd, partitions or just individual files from the same image. Clone partitions from RAID. Nice thing is to image to tape. You may create an image across multiple tape carts. I do suggest a tape upgrade to maybe an LTO drive. I have two on may server (LTO2 and LTO4).

by oh smeg

And I was under the impression that HAL 9000 was the nasty one here. :0

Looks like [b]The Scummy One[/b] is a lot nastier than HAL. That must be true because I've just seen it on the Internet. Good to know who I need to avoid though so I'll give Scummy a wide berth in the future. :^0

Col

This discussion is closed to new replies.