Discussion Locked

Cat5e vs. Cat6 new network

0 helpful
6 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is a very basic networking question..I just need some good additional input. I am trying to convince my boss that Cat6 will be the best route to go. My company just built a new office, this building will have 25 drops no more that 91 ft at the longest run. With the advancements in technology I think that the Cat6 will be more efficient in the long run compared to the Cat5e. Any input i can get on this, will be greatly appreciated!!

thanks

6 replies

by hal 9000

Both are 4 Pair twisted cable the only difference is the number of twists per foot. CAT has 5 twists per Foot and CAT 6 had 6 twists per foot.

I've used both and not seen any difference between the two and the only thing that I've seen with the CAT6 patch cables that are made up is that the Crossover and straight through are the same colour with a piece of sticky paper on the Crossover. Not my idea of a good idea but maybe that was just the one cable maker. Many years ago when we had to make all our own cables one of the apprentice's just grabbed a conventional CAT5 cable and made up a Crossover cable which was eventually used somewhere else and cost me several days of diagnostic work to find. Of course the tech in house insisted that no changes had been made so it made the repair much harder to find.

A 91 ft run with either will work about the same with a Gigabite LAN and if you want extra speed you're only alternative is to go to Optical Fibre which is blindly fast.

Col

by jj2000

Well... You can get Cat6 cables from various manufacturers in an assortment of colours (just like Cat5). Generally we standardize on red for crossovers, but you can get anything in any colour.

As for Cat6... I'll pass along something I heard recently that made me rethink the whole Cat6 thing. By the time you get it run, there will be something new out with a new standard...

jj

by ssampier

Is there any particular reason he wants to continue using 5e? The general standard is to use the best cable available.

by cmarsh

If you have not made a decision... Cat 5e is plenty form most applications..

For a small LAN of 25 drops you will not be able to take advantage of the performance of CAT 6. Unless your users are working with Video or as stated in reply 2.. Gigabit applications.. In fact multi-gig apps.. my guess is you are not and my money would be better spent on

1 - QUALITY Cable and components Belden, Panduit, Carol Cable and the likes.. to save a few cents or dollars here is a mistake

2 - Installation - Pay a contractor that will certify the installation and back up the work. Once it is installed it should look clean with cable ties and labels.

3 - Make sure the cables aviod any power sources as much as possible. Eliminate any excess cable - DO NOT ROLL IT UP and hand it there for future.

by a_kujur

Currently there is a great deal of confusion among Ethernet cable buyers concerning whether to purchase Cat5e, or to use Cat6. Most of this confusion comes from a misunderstanding by the buyer that buying Cat6 cable will give them an "all gigabit" network. This is not the case. Unless every single component in the network is gigabit rated, then you will never have a gigabit network, because your network will always run at the speed of your slowest device. Cat5e cable of good quality can run near or at gigabit speeds, it just cannot be "certified" for this use. By comparison, Cat6 is designed especially for gigabit use, and is certified to operate at said speed. It becomes a matter of whether or not you want to pay all that extra money, for little or no noticeable improvement in the performance of you network. In most cases, it makes more sense to go with Cat5e. It is for this reason that most of your new installations in the private sector are going with Cat5e. It is more economical, performs well, and is readily available in many colors. Many IT professionals when asked about why they specified Cat6 for a specific job, often responded stated that they "wanted the best they could get." This is the line of thought behind many purchases of cable. The average consumer often times is not aware that there is no real benefit to them to use Cat6, so they let someone talk them in to buying it

This discussion is closed to new replies.