Discussion Locked

Cheap servers : are they making fun of us or thinking we are stupid ?

0 helpful
1 reply
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Last days I was looking to buy 2 small servers for 2 remote offices.
Since the offices are small , I need nothing fancy, just 1 proc, 1-2 GB RAM, and a small RAID .
So I went shopping for " cheap servers " offers. I started with the first ones, under 1000 euro, or 1200 USD ( if you are living in USA, I live in Germany ).
Soon enough, looking on offers from : DELL, Siemens-Fujitsu , HP ( the most sold servers here in Germany ) I went crazy.
ALL advertized models of " cheap servers " are , in the standard configuration, like this :
1 proc ( ok ) , 256 MB RAM?! , 1 HDD , optional HW RAID controller, NO OS :-), etc...
I was buying servers 10 years ago, and then, a " server ", even a cheap one, was ... a server. The amount of RAM was according with the OS of that time, ( which was included in the price ), there were AT LEAST 2 HDDS , an HW RAID controller was mandatory, etc . Ok, they were not 1000 euro then.
Just put Win 2003 server on 256 MB RAM, make a sw RAID and expect performance from it. For 500 euro you receive 1 ( one ) HDD . BTW, HW RAID is always optional. They are pointing that you can always make sw RAID. Nice, isn't it ?
If you start configuring your server , meaning to put a decent amount of RAM , a decent number of HDDs, HW RAID, etc, you will triple ( not double, triple ) the price in an instant.
And you will reach very fast the price of a " decent server " who has everything from the beginning. Or more :-).
I remember last month , when I went to buy a new car. Except basic functions that you must have in a car, everything else was an option. And the price just went up more than 30 % only with the options . Which, BTW, are nothing else than things everyone of us wants to have today in his car. At the end, I was amazed that all 4 wheels were in the basic , not in the options package.

We all know the stories of the used cars salesman.
I knew from some years that they apply them on new cars also. But I see them now also on servers.

Are DELL, HP, etc, making fun of us with this " cheap servers " ? Or thinking that we are stupid ?
Is selling a new server becoming also an " used cars salesman " mentality for HP, DELL, et co. ?
If you keep you eyes open, good for you, if not , your problem ?

1 reply

by stress junkie

I agree that the configurations that you listed would make a barely adequate desktop machine. A server should generally be a bit beefier. That depends on its role, though. A print server doesn't have to be overly powerful but it should have a lot of RAM. A DNS server can be pretty modestly endowed. In those cases, though, you would be better off finding the weakest computer in the business, taking that for your server, and giving the person who just lost their desktop machine a high performance machine.

Things have changed a lot in the desktop arena in the last 25 years but the big server makers haven't caught on. This is probably because their customers haven't caught on. It was only three years ago that I had to add a couple of CPUs to a Sun Enterprise 450 server. These CPUs were 296MHz 32 bit UltraSPARC machines. They cost about $1500 each. Amazing. I also added some RAM to this machine. I don't recall the price but I do recall that it was rated at 60ns response. 60 nanoseconds!!! I had personal computers running that RAM at speed in 1990, yet this was the RAM available for a Sun mid-line server in 2003!!! Yet the Sun Enterprise 450 is a pretty expensive box.

This example isn't unusual. I ran servers from Digital Equipment Corporation for 20 years. Some of the last machines that I ran were rated at 300 MHz!!! Sure it was a 64 bit machine with a 64 bit operating system but the price was very high. Now you can get a 64 bit CPU from Intel or AMD running at 1.8GHz for $150. Yet these older machines would still cost you thousands of dollars for replacement parts.

On the one hand I am always amazed at the computing power available for very little money in the Intel/AMD arena. Everybody can afford the CPU, RAM, and disk space that was reserved for only the largest corporations a couple of decades ago.

I hear that Sun has just released a new CPU called the T1/Niagra. I haven't checked out the specs or the price. My guess is that it will be something like a high end Intel/AMD CPU at many times the price. Some customers just believe that a Sun computer will always outperform any Intel/AMD computer. Those people are wrong and they will still spend 20 times more for their computers than they really need to spend. And that is even funnier than the specs that you quoted for "server" computers.

This discussion is closed to new replies.