Question Locked

Duplicate email arrives once an hour for up to 96 hours

0 helpful
4 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Hey All,

Any useful idea (no, not I'm not implementing SendMail) would be welcome.

Characteristics of the duplicate email:
1) Repeats every hour or half hour for 30-96 hours
2) Affects a different set of 2-3 users at the same day and time AND domain (@newcastlegolf.com)
3) Email is formated either ASCII or ISO, never Windows or UTF.
4) Occurs almost every week
5) Has affected only 12 of 300 employees over the past two months
6) No email items in any Exchange queue
7) 99% of the time the duplicate is a REply or FWard

Environment:
Dell PowerEdge 2900 with Windows Server 2003 R2, SP2 with up to date security, and critical updates.
Exchange Server 2003 R2 (v6.5 SP2) - current patches
Outlook Web Access on the Exchange server
Outlook 2002 - 2007
Windows Terminal Server
Symantec Corporate Edition 10.x
Symantec Mail Security 6.x
Watchguard Firewall (X750e) with SpamBlocker
HP Procurve 2650 switches

What I've tried:
1) Patched Windows and Exchange
2) Ran integrity checks with ESEUTIL and ISINTEG
3) Disabled both Symantec products during an incident (didn't stop the attack)
4) Disabled Anti-Intrusion firmware on the Watchguard
5) Verified the Exchange and Watchguard settings repeatedly
6) Every device and server has been rebooted

What I've eliminated:
1) Symantec - was Disabled, duplicates were still received
2) The exchange server queue - if it was the exchange server why sometimes repeat every half hour for some, every hour for most?
3) Watchguard Spamblocker - if it was the spam filter causing timeouts we'd see one or two duplicates...not NINETY-SIX.

Having elimintated everything, I am open to suggestions.

Best,
Pete Hansen
IS Manager
Oki Developments

4 replies

by fregeus

Is this happening to mail only coming from the Internet or is this happening with strickly internal Emails?

TCB

by mcter123

Yes, just email received from the Internet. Also, all of email items that duplicate have the same Message ID - so this is something about Exchange rather than the firewall or spamblocker.

Best,
Pete

by mcter123

Okay, did five hours on with Microsoft PSS. Using ExMetabaseCheck we found some artifacts that we removed with MetaEdit. Did something quickly with mfcmapi that allowed us to recreate \exchsrvr\mailroot from scratch.

One step I had missed, on my Symantec, I had excluded *.EDB and X:\exchsrvr but had not also excluded C:\inetpub and C:\windows\system32\inetsrv. However, I hung up with him, excluded these additional directories, and before I had finished starting the services I was told we had duplicates.

I disabled all of the Symantec services yesterday around noon however two employees are receiving duplicates each hour as of this morning.

Not sure where this will go next, and would still like input, but will also keep updating it.

This discussion is closed to new replies.