Discussion Locked

Ethics of watching children's computer screens

0 helpful
223 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Several friends of mine have young children with computers connected to the internet. These parents are typical in that they know how to use their computers basically, but not much beyond that.

My question is: when is it appropriate, or is it ever, to tell parents that software exists that would allow them to observe what their children do on their computer? If I should tell them about it, is it okay to install it and show them how to use it? I realize that I'm basically talking about spying here, but what if the kids were told why their parents were concerned, and that it was only to keep them as safe as possible from predators?

Sitting down with a child and going online into chat etc and discussing what happens after that would be the best approach, or at least a part of the approach, but let's face it, most kids do what they want after their parents are gone.

If you feel that installing and using such software is ok, then when does it stop? Do parents have the right to do this until their children are 17? 18? 21? Out of the house?

223 replies

by azul

Those are adjectives...

I am a parent of 3 children, 2 are girls. When the first was born I joked that she would never go any where or do anything with out me untill she was 32.

As time has passed and I have had more kids, it is less of a joke.

There is a very real, clear and present danger for any one on the internet, especially for kids. No parent worth one poopy diaper would let their kids play in a place known to be dangerous. The internet is a dangerous place.

I don't really care what others think or say, I don't care if my kids hate me for it, as long as I have any responsibility for them, I will be actively involved in everything they do. I will exert as much control as neccessary in any way neccessary to ensure that they are safe.

Currently my oldest is 5, my middle child is 3. Both are familiar with their computer and the internet. When they use their computer I am right there with them the whole time. The PC only has access to the internet when I turn it on. I talk to them about what we are doing, what the dangers are and how to deal with them.

My wife and I do our best to keep them aware and informed as is appropriate for their age. Kids are often smarter than they are given credit for, they are better informed than they let on to.

I think that if the parents are your friends, you owe it to them to tell them about monitoring software AND the dangers. They can then decide for themselves and make an informed decision.

Mainstream society seems to work against parents, any and every parent needs all the help they can get keeping children safe.

As I said, I am a parent. I hope that helps and answers your question.

by deadly ernest

as is being physically present. I think unknown remote monitoring is wrong as it leads to a total break down of trust. Doing as you are by talking with them and then being there to show them is the best approach.

by amcol

Your approach sets up parents to fail.

It would be wonderful if we could all spend oh so much time watching our kids do everything, but we can't. Saying that the only way to effectively provide supervision when children are online is to look over their shoulders can't possibly work...no one has that kind of time.

And if you're saying that parents should sit down with their kids and educate them on the dangers of the Internet, then allow them to go about their surfing with occasional supervision secure in the knowledge that the kids can now protect themselves, you're kidding yourself.

Watching over our children to make sure they don't fall down too hard isn't an abrogation of trust. It is, in fact, quite the opposite...when a child knows Mom and Dad are there, watching over them, they have a higher level of trust in Mom's and Dad's ability to be a good parent. As kids grow older and enter the teen years they naturally rebel against that constant supervision, and wise parents know how to rachet it down without swinging the pendulum too far in the other direction.

I'm not talking about nosing around their rooms and reading their diaries when they're off wherever. For the same reasons you as a parent monitor who your child's friends are, what parties they go to, what they're doing when the hang out at the mall, and all the other things you want to know about, you also need to monitor their use of the Internet. That doesn't mean logging their keystrokes or reviewing logs, but it does mean observing what websites they visit (especially chat rooms) and what they do when they get there.

Have you ever visited some of the websites the teens like to go to, like Xanga? It's disturbing how much personal information they reveal about themselves, and how much they're setting themselves up for trouble. You can't help them avoid that with a friendly pat on the shoulder and a pep talk about responsible Internet usage, then go away "secure" in the knowledge that your child will do exactly as you say.

by im_pro_rfid

I am a parent of 4 children ages 4 thru 20and I have found in the 10 plus years that I have been online, that the only truly dangerous thing about the internet is ignorance. As long as you remain honest friends with your children, and do not alienate them, they will never do things just to spite you, nor hide things from you. I taught my children that a parent is the ultimate data base utility, and they tend to come us when they have doubts or their logic system fails. Software will NEVER take the place of good parenting.
Of course a rfid chip might!

by jessie

and as far as I'm concerned, they can have privacy in the bathroom, anywhere else privacy is earned. When I know, through their actions, that they are capable of conducting themselves in a safe and thoughtful manner, they are allowed a bit more privacy/responsibility/trust... in graduating levels. The more they show me they're capable, the more leeway they are given. I'm not going to give my 16 year old the keys to the car without ever having seen him handle the car, and I'm certainly not going to leave him alone with the internet until I've seen how he handles my computer.

by abel46

This may work for now when they are five, but just wait to they turn 13 or so. Then you will have a full time job, doing this.

by faradhi

NO
and follow it with, you can't right now, I have something to do.

It won't kill them. If your are saying No because your watching American Idol or something then there is something wrong there as well.

Raising a child is a full time job.

by ou jipi je

I disagree with "spying approach". Most of the parents today "do not have the time" due to their busy careers to educate their children properly. Thus, media like TV and Internet are pretty much what children have in terms of life education. By spying and restricting, parents think that they will prevent "these nasty things" that occure every day on the internet...

imho, if you need to spy on your children then you got a serious problem on your hands, instead, spend some more time with them to teach them about values, respect, explain right and wrong and reasons behind it. It is called education. Every minute you spend adding your input into this forum (especially on this subject) could be spend better if you choose to educate your children instead.

by caryxander

That's an excellent response. I agree that mainstream society seems to work against parents, but we parents who take that responsibility seriously should feel compelled to do whatever it takes to safeguard theire children. I think the issue may boil down to motive. Is the 'spying' done out of love, or is it a curiosity/control motive?

by amcol

Nor is it a question of right or wrong, or appropriateness.

Parents have a responsibility to protect their children. That's their job. Everyone can't be equally knowledgeable in all things, so if there's an area where you have some expertise that would help a parent protect their child there's no question you should offer assistance.

You're not making the parent do something, you're simply offering information the parent can act upon. It's then up to the responsible parent to do so.

Parents not only have the right to monitor their childrens' Internet usage, they have an obligation to do so on many levels. Children, especially younger children, are incapable of distinguishing many of the dangers that can lurk in the shadowy corners of the Internet. Many adults can't do it...if they could, phishing scams wouldn't generate billions of dollars annually.

If you have information that can help parents protect their children I'd go so far as to say you have a societal, moral obligation to share it. You ask if it's ethical to do so...I ask you in turn if it's ethical not to. I can't imagine any parent who, in response to your providing any special knowledge you have that would assist them in protecting their children, would respond with anything other than "thanks very much".

by master3bs

Parents have to protect their children. If their children are using the internet, that includes protecting them from the dangers they will face there.

I don't think there is any shady area in letting parents know their options.

by akalinowski

but i also believe in letting the child know that they are being monitored, for thier own protection.
i belive this will prevent trust issues

by faradhi

Yes it is appropiate to tell parents that there is monitoring software. And Yes the parents should discuss it with the child. It stops when the parent is comfortable that the child is mature enough to handle situations on their own. This will vary from child to child.

by bfilmfan

Raising a child is a benevolent dictatorship.

One part George Patton to one part Dr. Spock. (depending on your patience and imagination, you can pick the one with special ears or not...)

by jdclyde

you first, explain about the internet to the kids.

Second, you TELL them that you have software loaded that lets you know EVERYTHING they do. (this sometimes works without ever loading the software).

Third, but restiction on where they can go. Lots of software that will do that and it goes hand in hand with kids and computers.

Fourth, do NOT put a computer in a private room where they can close the door. Make sure you have an "open door" policy.

It is YOUR computer, and you have EVERY ethical and moral RIGHT to know EVERYTHING that the computer does.

Your children have NO RIGHT to privacy as long as they live in YOUR home. They want privacy, they can get their own place.

Do you ever watch them play with their friends? is THIS spying? Of course not. The computer is no different, except it is FAR easier for kids to get in trouble on the internet than playing with their friends.

This is as much to protect them from preditors and it is to keep them from doing anything inapropreate.

Show them how to use the software. Also tell them to talk to their kids about it. running this in secret is a betrail.

by genphil

"It is YOUR computer, and you have EVERY ethical and moral RIGHT to know EVERYTHING that the computer does.

Your children have NO RIGHT to privacy as long as they live in YOUR home. They want privacy, they can get their own place."

Hysteria and paranoia are not the best counsellors one can imagine.

I prefer to see the home I provide for my child as a test lab: enough freedom to try out new things, make mistakes and even get into trouble, but secure enough to contain the dangers to a minimum. Your child should understand clearly that you as a parent are responsible for their well-being and the consequences of their actions, and because of that have the final word on what goes and what not. But having said that, a parent shouldn't set such restrictive boundaries that their children can't learn to make independent decisions and live with their consequences. If you want your children to become mindless drones, or rebellious firebrands in reaction to their oppressive upbringing by all means adopt this mentality. If on the other hand you want to raise fine upstanding citizens that will be an asset to their community because of their inner sense of what is right and wrong, I'd recommend a more liberal approach.

by jdclyde

Surely you have never read my postings here on TR... :D

I don't let my children play in the streets, I don't let them view wild porn out of curiosity.

This isn't like the good old days of sneeking a peek at dads playboys. Playboy has always treated the female form as the work of art it is.

The internet on the other hand is as quick to show you chicks with dogs ans it is any other oddity you can think of, and none of it is helpful for young boys in forming positive images of women.

In the fourth grade (a few years back now) there was a link for "gimmeteens.com". I found out about this when I discovered the system what full of malware and barely operational. Checking into the system I found out where the one boy had gone and we have had a few discussions about this, and why this is not a healthy way to think of women, let alone the disappointment he will get when he finds out that REAL women don't REALLY like you do THAT, THERE! :O

Since then I have informed them that working in the field, there is NOTHING they can do on my computer that I will not know about.

I am NOT a strict person, and have MUCH less rules than the ex-wife does as they DO just give them something to rebel against.

There is just too much trouble kids can get into on the internet.

If you think that a little pep talk will keep kids (especially boys) from surfing exotic porn, then you have forgotten what it is like to be a kid. I feel sorry for any kid that has a parent that doesn't care enough for their well being that they would monitor internet useage.

I also don't allow RAP "music" in my house, as I don't feel someone talking over music about beating their whoes is "art".

I ALSO forbid any and all video games that glamorize being a scumbad. Grand Theft Auto? Not in this lifetime bucko. Sorry, but playing a scumbag does NOT fall under "healthy" role models.

No hysteria, no ranting and raving. Just trying to steer them away from the scumbag lifestyle and towards a healthy productive lifestyle. indulging unhealthy behavior is condoning it.

They also will never be allowed to smoke while they live in my house either.

Want to live in my house, got to follow basic rules.

Do your homework and do it well.
Clean up after yourself.
Bath.
Be a good person.

Not asking too much in exchange for free room and board, huh?

Want to play a video game? As long as your homework is done, knock yourself out. Grades slipping? Ok, no games on week days until the grades come back up. (this did wonders a year ago).

by marketingtutor.

Firstly,

Whether you notify the child or not, you as a parent have every right to know what is going on, and what they do. As long as the law can hold you liable for their actions, then you have every single little right to even stick bugs to their lunch boxes and tag them with GPS transmitters if you so desire.

With all of that said, your children will become the spitting image of their role models. No, not you parents that think you are great role models, rather, the role models THEY consider role models...enter MTV...Jackass...Brittany Spears...you name it. So inevitably, your children become what you allow them to become. Sure, both parents go ahead and work day jobs and wonder when they hit 13 that you find yourself saying "I just don't know them...". Why didn't you ask this 10 yearas earlier when you we're dropping them off at pre-school to make the extra income?.

I recently saw a story on a local news channel about a 6 year old child that got angry at his teacher, so he left the class, and jumped into an empty, but idling, school bus and took it for a spin. Afterwards...you guessed it...he blamed his teacher for his actions. I can only imagine what his ebonically challenged parents were like. Hmm...perhaps on the wheat check gubment cheese dole, and blamin' the MAN for thier misfortune. I woulda axed (ebonics for the correct english word ASKED) em, but they didn't be givin they name out ovuh duh air.

ANYHOW, in light of today's parenting deficiency, is it any wonder that these products exist. Parents are too busy to spend time with their kids, and be the role model to beat. We now live in a "bottom line" world. I know millionaires and I know some homeless guys, and ya know, the majority of the homeless guys are happier than most of the millionaires I know.

So uninstall the spyware and spend time with your kids. That is, if they don't already hate you. DAMN, that word liberal nearly had me hurling, but when I realized you were using it correctly instead of as a reference to a political affiliation, I was lead into agreement with you. Sure give them room, but don't give them room without you there most of the way. Also, don't smother.

Another piece of insight, in a socially sterile environment (read: Homeschooling), the children will adapt an outlook and behavior that closely mimics the way the Mother responds and acts towards the childs Father. That is of course barring any heavily negative peer influences. So you "Type A" women that treat men like they have the cunts and you have the sausage, knock it off, or prepare for a helluva ride through adolescence, and ultimately sexual deviancy and possible flipping of their ol' sexual compass to start pointing south. (read: ButtBuddies or MuffMaties)

Also, no personal offense intended Dr. Phil. I was looking for a pun, and you just happened to walk in front of the bus...better get after that 6 year old in the bus...his parents have government funded insurance, maybe you can get your extorted tax money back...

Later All,

ITGuy

(not a cynic, not bitter, just pissed off that I want to pull the flush lever on today's post-modern society, and I'm not the one making the calls on whether or not to flood this forsaken world again)

by sql_joe

Um....excuse me, but where do you think that "Inner Sense" comes from?

Can you say parents?

Children need to be taught right and wrong, by example as much as by anything else. How do we do that?

*We set limits, and explain why they are there.
*We tell the child exactly what will happen if they violate those limits.
*We pay attention to ensure the limits ar enot violated - and when they are, we do what we said we would do if they were violated.
*We get involved with our children so that we aren't just rules makers and disciplinarians - that way our child can see that you can live and enjoy life while living under a set of rules.
We make it clear to our child that some thigns are for ADULTS, and when they are an adult, they can decide for themselves if they will enjoy them or not (such as "M" games, "R or NC or X" movies, alcohol, etc etc) - in the meantime, I teach my child the maturity to be able to make decisions regarding those things when they do reach adulthood (no, not that they are "bad" - but to think about why they beleive things are "bad" or "good").
*In cases where its a "do as I say not as I do" we explain, and teach them why it is that way (such as "adult" stuff above). We also ensure that we are a good example in regard to those things - for example, I drink, but I drink responsably and this lesson is impressed upon the kids who absorb everything going on around them.

I agree that boundaries should be adjusted, but they must be rigid and the parent must adjust them as the child matures; BUT right from wrong...how can one know what is right and what is wrong, unless they are shown that and that information is reinforced? They really can't, just like you don't know how to behave at work until you are taught the culture.

A long time ago as an adult I went and saw "South Park: the Movie". The theater was PACKED with children! Yes, that's right, parents had taken their kids to see this movie. The majority of the seats were taken up by children. Dare we say what lessons those kids learned while watching that movie? What lessons do our kids learn while playing "M" games? oh, some say, "My kids know what is real and what isn't" - but in truth, THEY DON'T! That's what being a kid is all about! The world is new to children, they are still learning truth from fantasy. As an adult, we can separate those things because we have been through the formative, learning years. Exposing our kids to stuff like that so their "inner self" can separate right form wrong is like "talking wrong" in front of your kids. Will they have an inner sense of what speaking correctly is? Nope, they will leanr how to talk wrong because they will be mimicking obsorved behavior. And yes, this mimicking continues through the teen years.

We guide and teach our children, and the culture of tommorow is being decided by the parents of today.

George

by keyguy13

I totally agree. If you can't trust your kids to make sound choices, then you can't expect them to obey you either. You can supervise without spying. And yes, it takes time and patience to have that kind of trusting relationship with your kid. Those of you who say you don't have the time are frankly full of crap. Everyone has the same 24 hours of time every day. How you spend it is what makes the difference. If your priority is working so much that you can't supervise or spend time with your kids, then why make time to read through all of the logs to spy on them? I think if you look at this rationally, you'll see it makes no sense.

When you actually make a commitment to your kids and set aside the time for them, these kinds of issues don't even come into play.

That's how it works for me anyway.

by genphil

I think we understand each other, nice to have been able to sound off against you. It was nice to take a step back and think out aloud about the way I want to raise my child. I wish you good luck and happiness with your boys.

GenePhil

by lipl1

I disagree. As they get older and wiser (hopefully) you have to trust them to some extent. But monitoring is a necessary evil. My son (13) is very good about where he does and does not go but I still find the ocassional questionable site that I wind up block his access on. Remember no matter how you look at it they are still kids and still need guidance.

by deadly ernest

All age groups full and frank discussion - note discussion not lecture - is extremely useful re dangers and the like. For young children restricted access times with direct supervision for the most of the contacts, and all of the early usage is best. Net nanny programs may be useful but I have not yet heard of any that work well, some schools here have stoppd recommending them as too often they block access to websites recommended for homewok and studies.

With older children like teens you have to accept that you cannot control or monitor all their activities. If you have established a good level of trust and good training then you can trust them to be unmonitored; you cannot monitor what usgae they make of the Internet when out of the home; schools, friends' places, libraries, Internet cafes all provide them with access outside of your control and monitoring range.

If you feel that you have to use monitoring programs then tell them about them and the fact that you are - losing their trust is going to be much worse when the fidn out, and they will find out and then not talk to you at all.

NB My teenage son and I have had several discussion about some websites that peers have referred him to, he speaks to me and discusses what he finds because he trusts me to be open and frank about the content and not abusive or controlling. What is interesting is how often he reports back to his peers that those sites are shit and not worth visiting.

I do not expect him to do everthing I say but I do expect him to make informed and intelligent decisions based on what I have taught him.

by master3bs

As I stated earlier in the discussion, there is nothing wrong with parents protecting their children.

I recommend Eblaster software by the way - http://www.spectorsoft.com/products/eBlaster_Windows/index.html

It includes keystroke software. In the liscense, you are required to let any users know that it is on the system. If using it, I recommend changing the default keystrokes for entering the system as this could be easy to find on the internet and disable.

by powerit

It probably depends largely on the age of the "children" involved. If we are talking about 5-12 year olds then I believe it is our responsibly as parents to do all one can to protect them from the hazards that exists in this evil World. Once a child enters the terrible teenage era, then monitoring activities need to be retracted somewhat. They are exposed to all sorts of language and vocal topics that are beyond are control, which will probably introduce resistance to severe monitoring activity from a concerned parent. I believe once they have transistioned to young adulthood (16 onwards) there is not a lot they do not know, but it is still important to ensure that they are safe whilst using computer equipment in our houses.

There is no substitute for parental supervision but this can be impractical for older children. As my computer literate child in 8 years old she has not yet entered into the World of MSN like chat ( thank God), but does use the Internet on numerous occasions. In my particular setup I have two Internet browsers installed, I.E 6.0 and Firefox 1.5. I have setup Firefox to use a proxy of 0.0.0.0 and included in an exception list the sites that she can access. IE is for our use and this works quite well. If there is a new site she wishes to access then we vet it and then add it to her list if appropriate.

This works for us so far and I have no qualms in this protection mindset, I even go so far as to view this as mandatory behaviour. We as a society can be over-protective and usually common sense will prevail.

Teach your children common sense computer usage or get them on a course. Coupled with this, moderate parental guidance and monitoring and everything should work out fine.

by tonythetiger

You can't put a concrete number on the age at which a child is ready to be, well, not trewated like a child. I've known kids who are responsible enough to pretty much do for themselves at age 12, and I've know 15-year-olds who still go down to the creek to catch frogs.

Over-protective? Well, if something bad happens that you could have prevented but didn't because you thought it was "over-protective", then your thought was obviously wrong, wasn't it?

I think that some parents look at the world and say "There are a lot more dangers than there were when I was a kid." That's probably not true. You were looking at it through a child's eyes then and adult eyes now. Likely the reason you were safer back then was your parent was on you all the time "Where are you going?", "Who are you going to be with?", etc.

If you hear "Aw, mom!" or "Aw, dad!" at least once a day, you're probably doing it right :)

by onbliss

...right for the parents to watch what their kids are doing. Drawing the freedom and limits on kids' lifestyle has to be a decision by the parents, the boundaries of which will expand and/or shrink as the children grow.

As far as the question of when does it stop. I would'nt approach this with an arbitrary cut-off age. It depends on the child and the parent (case to case basis). For some it could be out of the house, for some it could be when they get married, for some a never ending saga.
In my point of view, the watching/monitoring/snooping (in short Parenting) is a never ending aspect of human relationship. One can not cut it like the umblical chord in one go. Some things have to end, and some things have to continue till the death.

by tink!

I agree it's not a question of ethics. You being the knowledgeable tech should let the parents (who are your customers) anything that can make their computer more useful/efficient/or better for them.

As far as monitoring the kids, I am a mother of 3 kids..ages 10, 8, and 4. My 4 year old knows more about how to play games on the computer than my husband. I installed the kids' computer in the living room so it's in a highly visible area. Currently it's not connected to the internet but eventually will be as the kids need to do research for school. I do not plan on giving the kids internet access anywhere else except on this computer. Right now, if they need the internet they use our computer which is in our bedroom, and they know they're not allowed to use it without a parent in the room.

Education is the first tool. Good 2-way communication is the second. And responsibility by both parties is the 3rd.

The parent cannot possibly control their child outside of the home, but if they provide good education and open communication they increase their chances that the child will not stray down the wrong paths. It's the same principle with smoking, drinking and drugs. Internet access should be treated the same.

by wallowamichael

It's nice to see that so many of us techies are parents, and that when we're not talking OS, we're all kind of on the same page.
My three boys are 8, 5, and 2. We don't use the Internet much at home (dialup is the only affordable access we have in our rural location), so I take my laptop to work and download things we're interested in and look at them offline at home.
I completely agree that it is the responsibility of parents to monitor Internet access, as well as any other media. To repeat from other posts above, you watch them play with friends, you don't let them watch movies without first watching them yourself, and you have age appropriate discussions about all of those things.
As a consultant, it is your responsibility to tell parents about monitoring software when you find out that children (of any age) are using the computer. What would happen if a parent found out that you knew about filtering software AFTER their child had been solicited by a 42 year old man?
I use the white list model when people ask me about how to filter the Internet for their kids. This is similar to the IE/Firefox setup that someone else posted, where Firefox can only get to sites that are discussed and pre-approved by the parents. Of course this assumes the parents can manage this type of system, which is not always the case, but in most instances it works well.
I also agree that CONSTANT communication and discussion of what the internet is and what it can be used for is important. Highlight the dangers, but don't go overboard, it is still a great tool for finding information on just about anything.

by too old for it

I took the "never" approach with my daughter, and she is turning out just fine.

My only worry is that she will have difficulty finding a date in college, as she has a dim view of childish boys who only want to get drunk or high and make out.

by jrh300

My daughter is now 17, and we have had ongoing discussions about internet safety since she was a pre-teen and first accessing the internet. She knows that chat rooms are off limits, and why. She DOES utilize instant messaging, which is a much safer way of communicating with her friends - she has to know the user names of those she communicates with, and add them to her 'buddy list'.

Also, having the computer in an open location is a wonderful idea. By not hiding what you do on the internet from your child(ren), it promotes trust in both directions, and makes it easier for them to abide by the rules.

As an aside, we don't watch any R rated movies, or any television (cable) programs that are not family oriented. By teaching (and trusting) your children when they are younger, you encourage good behavior as they older. My 17 year old lips off a little, but is never openly defiant. I chalk this up to the fact that we have had an open, trusting relationship her whole life (I was a single mom with her until 4 years ago). I have my values, and I stick to them no matter what society says, and she has learned to be the same way.

by too old for it

Amcol, nice to see you out here again.

I got a late start in having kids. Hence, I've found too many parents who grew up latch-key with the TV as a babysitter. These same parents see no problem with letting the internet be the babysitter, while they work late, go out to eat, or otherwise ignore their offspring.

(Yes, I said "work late". If you have a child at home, under the age of 14 or, "I'm sorry, I can't work late tonight." is the correct answer.)

(But I digress.)

Yes, it is dangerous out there. Kids run away or get kidnapped, and wind up missing or dead.

Sometimes I think the law of unintended consequences takes over, tho without the hours to research per-capita teen kidnapping and death rates in a few countries outside the US, I think I'll have to leave that question out there for discussion.

by amcol

Literally. I've been out of the country a lot, and buried under a mountain of work while in town.

Your reference to unintended consequences is perhaps being too kind. The consequences are indeed unintended but at the same time are entirely avoidable, assuming parents take their responsibilities seriously. My kids grew up safe, because my wife and I created a safe environment for them, just as your daughter grew up safe for the same reason. That takes eternal vigilance, an abiblity to say "no", a willingness to make unpopular decisions, and an understanding that the key goal of parenting is not to be your kid's pal. All of those things are consistent with monitoring Internet usage, whatever and however it takes.

by tink!

All too often we are seeing that parents today have a complete inability to say "no" to their kids. This begins when they are toddlers and progresses all throughout their growing years.

If you don't start saying no when they're little, it's very hard to begin when they blossom into pre-teens and further.

Parents today need to grow-up and accept their responsibility which means handling the difficult task of saying "no" to their children (tantrums included). Children will not develop the necessary boundaries if they are given everything. This principle covers all areas in parenting a child.

by firstpeter

The answer is that as long as I'm responsible for my children's activities and/or what takes place on that computer in my home I have every right to install that software and monitor their activities.

To the extent that a child becomes legally "on their own" but still uses my computer absolutely - if I don't want pornography in my house I have every right to monitor the activity and if I see something I don't like - WHAM...cut off.

by jdgretz

I own the DSL service to our place (by way of paying for and having it in my name) and I do put limits on what the "kids" do here.

One of the kids is my girlfriend's 21 year old daughter who thought it was OK to download music off the internet using one or more of the popular file sharing networks - this after there had been a family discussion about this. She now knows better (again) after I removed the software from her computer gave her a formal repremand in front of her mother and let her know that if it happened again, I would block her internet access at the router and she could go back to dialup.

One of the boys was found to have downloaded porn on their shared computer - I have now put filters on their computer to keep that slip form re-occuring, even though it causes them some difficulty with some of the sites they want to cruise. Sorry - not as long as the static IP they use is traced back to me.

We started out with full trust - they have earned the restrictions.

jdg

by aldiefenbach

If you have a 13 yr old daugther as I do may be you can understand why it's necessary to monitor their activity. Even with letting her know I had installed certain software to track her activities, I still had problems with the people who were contacting her. The culture of today is such that "buddies" or "friends" from AIM, MS Messenger or Myspace to name a few are collected like trophies - sort of a status symble by young ones. Within one week of being on AIM, my daughter, who was 12 at the time had 75 Friends, the majority whom she had never met. So I had to painstakingly go down the list one by one to ask her who each friend was. The fact that she din't know them all didn't mean anything to her because that is what kids do - they accept invitations to chat with anyone and throw caution to the wind. I eventually was able to trace some of her friends to other sites like myspace where their personal pages told me more than I wanted to know - many were 17 to 18 years old. trying to explain that she nothing in common with 18 yr old boys fell on deaf ears. The fact is that screen names are traded the way phone numbers used to be - anyone can get someone elses screename and start up a chat. The fact is that most kids do not exercise proper judgement - it is more important to be popular - and having lots of buddies and friends is one way to do it. So until there is a better way to protect children from internet predators, we have to observe thier on-line habits from time to time. Like it or not.

by gsg

Let's just start by saying, I'm not a parent. However, as an adult, I would put keystroke loggers, anything and everything on there that could block "bad" sites, and anything that would record what they are doing. That said, I would tell the child it's there and explain that it's not a matter of trusting them, but that it's a matter of trusting the billions of other people out there.

It reminds of something my Dad said when I got my car taken away for a week. Driving is not a right, it's a privelege, and I reserve the right to take it away at any time, for any reason, or for no reason at all.

Kids are very trusting, and innocently will post all sorts of info on the net. As an adult, it's you responsibility to monitor everything. After all, you bought the hardware, you're paying for the connection, and the kid is darn lucky to have it.

by techiemikee

Mention the software and let the parents decide what is right for their kids. It is not your choice to make, your job is to present options.

Unfortunately though, too often parents are busy building a wall in hopes that it will protect their kids from harm and they wind up placing too much faith in this facade that they neglect to prepare the kids to make difficult decisions on their own.

As a youngster I was taught not to open the door to strangers, not tell callers when my parents were not home and at an early age was able to understand why it was important.

I?d hate to think all those times I rode my bike to the park to meet my friends for a game of soccer, basketball or to simply be a kid that my mom was peering through the bushes with binoculars. Yeah, sometimes I rode my bike past a liquor store or a bar and knew what they were, but that didn?t mean I had an early interest in drinking or tipping dancers.

Point is I trust my kids to be good kids and I have enough faith in my parenting that I will not let my kids do things they aren?t actually ready for. The Internet is an evolutionary process much like swimming. I don?t just throw the kids in the pool and tell them swim, I first teach them how to swim. It may not be until they are teenagers that I?d let them swim or surf the Internet without an adult present but I will gauge the situation and judge their maturity before making that decision. If I?m not comfortable letting them swim alone I?m not going to be in the house dividing my attention between TV and a Nanny Cam, I?m going to be poolside, same goes with the Internet.

by genphil

First of all your children don't have a choice whether or not to live in your house, they don't have do anything to earn their keep. You've put them into this world and it is your responsibilty to provide them a food and shelter. Your next responsibility is to provide them a stable and loving family. It's your responsibility towards society to raise your children in such a way that they will be able to contribute to it as adults. I will repeat that for you: it YOUR duty to society to raise responsible adults, it not their obligation to give you any compensation for your expenses, financial and emotional. A parents' reward is a very delayed one, when your children have grown up into responsible adults you can relish the fact that it was you who guided such upstanding members of society on their path.

I can tell from firsthand experience, I have been a son and I am raising one, that a parent faces multiple challenges when he tries to convey his convictions to his child. As a parent you're not the only influence on your child's development family, school, friends, sportteams and the wider community all leave their mark on your childs' development. Even in the best of scenario's there are bound to be conflicting messages and dangers to which your child is subjected, a parent should help his child to make sense of the world around him. To be able to do this the parent should not be seen as a strict taskmaster but as a mentor someone who will correct unwanted behaviour, but most of all someone who will guide him toward answers.
It is interesting that you should mention Playboy as opposed to for example Gimmeteens.com or Gangsta rap. Both sides are dead wrong in their portrayal of women. Women are neither angelic creatures that bestow their affection on us undeserving males nor are they bitches that can be slapped around at will.
Women are our counterparts, different (vive la difference!) but neither better nor worse men. Sex isn't something a man inflicts upon a woman it's an act that both partners enjoy, if that isn't the case it's called rape.

Being a good person is more than doing what you're told to and not doing what is prohibited, robots can do that. Being a good person involves sometimes going out of your way to help someone, taking the risk of failure to achieve something worthwile, questioning authority when the powers that be seem to misuse their power, avoiding a fight when possible but standing your ground when it it's unavoidable and sometimes even blindly following a friend because you trust his motives, but also have the courage to try to stop him from doing wrong.

Rule number one is: "Avoid doing harm to others" Your job as parent should be to explain how the behaviour of your child affects others. Rule number two to is: "Be the best you can be" help your child find his talents and encourage him to develop them for his own gain, but also the good of his community.

by jdclyde

that the few things I outlined that I DO don't equate me to being a task master.

Children should learn to pick up after themselves.

Children should learn to be responsible for their own actions.

Children should NOT be allowed to go anywhere a random click may take them.

If emphasising good, moral behavior is bad, then bad I be.

If discuraging and forbidding bad immoral behavior is bad, then again, bad I be.

And there are reasons given. Almost never do they get an "because I said so" as justification. It will happen when someone decides they would rather play a video game than change the kitty litter, and they want to know why they have to do it NOW. It needs to be done, it is your cat, get it done.

You don't check where your boy goes on the internet?

This is as big of a crime as not knowing who their friends are and what they are like.

This is as big of a crime as not knowing what your kids are doing, and where.

A good parent teaches AND monitors their children.

A good parent teaches that there are consequences for bad actions.

You don't think women are angels?

by genphil

Children need to be taught responsible behaviour, that includes doing their chores, and of course the need to be told where it's safe to go and where not either in the physical world or on the internet. And of course a responsible parent will monitor his children, it's usually as simple as taking interest in what occupies, them getting to know their teachers and perhaps even volunteering to do work at their school or sportclub. Further encourage your children to bring their friends home and try to get to know their parents, you can help each other raising your children.
You seem to emphasize morality and moral behaviour, well your moral system might not be the same as mine but as long as the basic tenets are respect for everyone, and freedom to differ in opinion then that's fine with me. You might even teach your children that sometimes even well-intended actions may have unpleasant consequences for them.

Of course I try to shield my boy from things he can't handle, there are things on television or on the 'net he is not ready to see or books he can't read, yet. But I'm a firm believer that a young man or woman can handle just about anything the media dish out as long as they are given a solid context in which to judge the information for themselves. And I think that it is my responsibility as a parent to provide such a context for my child.

It is my opinion that your child put into your care by the adult it will one day be. And the best thing that can happen to a parent is when that adult feels you have done a good job on him or her, and will keep loving and respect you for the rest of his life.

I think we agree on a lot of what what we do and wish for our children and we can probably spend a lifetime arguing the points we disagree on, but that room for argument is what makes our societies worth living in. And I hope that our kids will grow up lovers and staunch defenders of our freedom of opinion.

On a parting note I truly believe women are not angels, sometimes the light, other times the bane of my my life, but always an equal counterpart. And until I see my better half flying past above me (now there's a scary thought) I will maintain this opion.

by jdclyde

I am not the only one to think this way! Even if some of the people that think the same way are the same angelic creatures that we are discussing! :D

Women can be the single most wonderful creature to walk the earth, as well as be the darkest creature to torment our souls. All depends on which one you come across! I have seen both, but only married the second kind..... :O

by genphil

We should invent them.
But at the risk of sounding like Yoda: Worship begets disenchantment, disenchantment begets desillusion, desillusion begets hate and hate begets destuction. We human always end up destroying the people we worship when they almost invariably can't live up to our high excpectations of them. So keep in mind that as wonderful as the object of your affection seems to be he or she is only human and will disappoint you at sometime, even when he or she didn't intend to. But if the basis for the relationship are mutual love and respect, then it is easy (sometimes less so) to forgive each others mistakes and live a long and happy life together.

I tell my better half regularly she the worlds' loveliest creature, if I didn't, she'd kick my sorry derri?re, and she regularly strokes my ego by telling me I'm the strongest, smartest man in the world. But we've lived together long enough and have fought with each other enough to know each others' weaknesses.

Women, hate 'em love 'em you can't ignore 'em

by jdclyde

I think maybe my first post just came off sounding harsher than intended?

As for not being prepared to see on the net. I STILL find things that I am not prepared to see... :O

side note about being bored. was just a friendly poke as you had made that comment right off in your blog, and then never posted again. Meant no harm and wasn't judging in any way. :D

The woman I am looking for to share my life with will be someone to walk beside me as my equal, but will still have the pedestal thing going.

flying past? I always told my ex-wife if I EVER bought a car with DRIVERS airbags, watch it! ]:)

by frip

Just as with any corporation providing access to the internet it is the bill payer who is responsible for the users. As a parent and the bill payer you have every right to decide for yourself how to monitor all the users in your home.

If children want un-monitored access to the internet they should be happy to wait until they have their own home, or at least pay for their own internet access. Age then isn't an issue.

If they don't like it they don't have to use it.

by rparkersec

I have an adult daughter which I don't have to worry so much about now... But, I do have 2 teenage nieces that for the most part are pretty straigtforward with me, when it comes to the internet useage at my house. I know it may not sound like much, but I've found a couple of simple solutions for at least part of the problem with the kids surfing on the internet. First, I use AOL Security Edition for my ISP with their screen names on it. It keeps them from signing online unless they use their own screen name. Then when they do, I have the Parental controls set to an appropriate level for their age. Secondly, I encrypted Yahoo Messenger and Internet Explorer so that they can't by-pass the AOL software. They don't like it sometimes and they may ask me to allow them to go to certain sites at times, but for the most part they understand why I do it. I have often read them articles about teen girls getting lured into a trap... So, when they complain about it, I just remind them about the girls that "didn't think it could happen to them."

by peter hers

Good question, should be discussed by more people, not just techs.
Let's compare the online situation to some other common situations.

For example, if my child wishes to go a public library I might perceive a direct benefit. But there is also a risk that he/she will be exposed to books / magazines / people / traffic that I don't like. I need to make a judgement call on the balance of benefits. I would also take into account the maturity of the child, and his ability to make sensible judgements for himself.
I would NOT follow him to the library; watch what he reads; see who he talks to; etc.

Now, what about going to a party? As a responsible parent, I would do some investigation, compare notes with other parents, etc. and then decide on whether the benefit outweighs the risks. What would be very important to me would the standards I have developed in my child, to help him/her to handle situations which may arise.

Now enter the internet. What is different? There is tremendous value to be had, both educational and social. And also serious threats. If I am unhappy about my child's ability to handle the threats then I have to act in a positive way. For younger children, this could mean limiting access, and using software to limit access. For older children this becomes more difficult, but I would follow the same rules. If I am worried about a particular activity, such as chat rooms, then it should be prevented until I am sure that the child can handle it responsibly. There is no easy answer, but the basic principles still apply: Equip the child to live life, make his own decisions, and provide a moral framework to guide him.

But to monitor his activity, with or without his knowledge? Only under very abnormal circumstances would this be justified. It could destroy all the trust that you build up over the child's lifetime - And this is your only real weapon.

by mubdi

The legality of this issue is easy - parents have that right until their children reach the age of majority (or are emancipated, but let's not go there).

However, I don't think that this is the interesting question. It's a kin to asking for how long is it legal to put off the "birds and the bees" discussion with your kids - there's the legal limit and then the not-so-idiotic limit. I think this is more of a case of parenting.

I became net-savvy at an early age and far before anyone else in my family - and there were things that I was doing online at that early of an age that I know my parents would not approve of - and moreso, I don't approve of. I think that's what my parents did right - It wasn't about them preventing me from acting in ways that they disapproved - it was about developing restraint from within myself from doing such things. It's more of a question of parenting than technology.

At the end of the day, parental protection software is only part of the entire protection system. It's great for keeping kids that inadvertantly stumble onto adults sites away - but it does effectively nothing for kids that actively seek adult sites (for instance).

From a tech standpoint - I'd go into this assuming that these packages will not work and that kids will be able to pretty much whatever they want. I'd tell concerned parents that this is simply insurance - and not very good insurance at that.

So, when's the right age to stop using these packages? When your child is ready to fly solo. If you don't know when your child is at that stage, then the least of your worries should be using parental safety software.

by michael_orton9

If they are small, its probably a good thing, but when they are teens I am sure that they will be learning from their geeky friends how to defeat it. It reminds me of when the Kinsey Report was in the Sunday papers. We had copies hidden in school and we all read the extracts!
Yes you may be able to stop them sending an e-mail to their aunt in Scunthorpe, but *10w-*0b will still get through the filters. And of course every Physics student used to miss-pronounce the German name "KUNDT" as in Kundt's Tube, sound wave experiment. And what about using brackets to make the naughty words look like algebra?
I remember when I was at a minor Public School in Sussex that I learned the "naughty words" in over a dozen languages.
When my son, who was six at the time, was in Israel, I remember him swapping "four lettered words" with Israeli kids, then he disn't speak Ivrit and they had these words in common.

If there had been computers when I was at school, I am sure it would have been great phun finding how2 get naughty words through the filters!

I am sure that the only benefit to content filtering is to the makers of the software!

Perhaps they also give parents the (false) impression that they are doing something.

by emar1000

I can appreciate the concern you have with this. However, sometimes it just amazes me that parents wonder if ?it?s ok? to watch their children in this respect. I watch my kids? computers and what they do on it. Some things with their knowledge and other things without. I have all emails sent to them copied to me automatically. I have explained that they are growing teens and they will be curious and that?s normal and that?s why I watch you like I do. I make no apologies and they also know that if they don?t really like it I`ll pack up the PC and stick it in my closet. So does this sound harsh? If it does then take the chance of the other option ?pedophiles?. I have a proxy server setup and I track everything. I know some wont be able to go to the extent I have but you do have other options, Why is it a question to wonder if it is ok to use them? It is YOUR responsibility to raise your kids.
Why is it so hard for parents to take a stance with their children?

If I pay the bills and it is in my house, it is MY rules. I dont care if they are 30 and living at home.

by tweakerxp

I'm a computer repair tech and I have seen things on peoples computers that even surprised me. I had a single mom wanted to know what her son had downloaded on her computer. Well, at least her son wasn't gay. There was so much stuff and some of it shocked me, the graphic violence of some pictures. I told her what I had found. She suspected something but didn't know how to go about finding it. I showed her how.
The internet is a dangerous place. Look at the girls that get lured away and killed. YES, by all mean monitor at all cost. The kids can get mad and later on when they look back and least you cared enough to say..."NO."

by cwa4050

I suppose if you do not have kids then this is a difficult question. However, if you have kids and care about them then this is a no brainer. Of course its ok to spy on your kids. With all the negative stuff on the web and harm that your kids can get into without even knowing it - Parents have to know what's going on. Especially since they are responsible for anything the kids may do while on the net. If its against the law - like everything else it falls to the parents to know about it or face the judge. Anyone living in the house should know they can be watched if using our computers.
Its just like employers, right?

by mr_fox_rox

Spying on your kids is perfectly acceptable, and I believe a part of our duty as parents. For some kids, simply knowing you are watching them like a hawk will keep them in line. Lackluster parenting skills, or the absence of parental intervention, is one of the reasons corporations need to spy on their employees and monitor their activities on a computer.

Children and teens really have no right to privacy beyond their bathroom door. Kids are human and will make bad choices, as all humans do. They should find out from their parents, while they are still at home, that someone is always watching and there can be dire consequences to making wrong choices or defying the rules.

As long as they live under your roof, regardless of age, you are responsible for setting boundaries and defining what is acceptable behavior in your home. When they get old enough and can afford to leave the nest, they will. Birds and children fly away.

When they are minors, breaching those boundaries should subject them to swift and meaningful, but loving discipline. Once they become an adult, refusal to abide by house rules is reason for eviction. As an adult, they will find no love in the discipline they will receive from the state.

Leaving our kids to set their own boundaries, monitor their own behavior, and "find" themselves, is a huge cop out and a sure-fire way to ensure you are a failure at parenting. It also greatly increases the likeliness they will be social retards, perverts, self-centered or dysfunctional in other ways as an adult.

by pado

Hmm...
I can see your point with younger children. I think the very
young DO need guidance and protection, but as they get a little
older the measure of your success as a parent will be the degree
to which they have learnt good judgement.
There comes a time when one has to 'let go a little' and allow
ones children to excercise that good judgement. One slowly
releases the firm grip.
Net nannying is fine for the very young, and maybe even the
young teenager. After then I feel it should really be eased-up on.
Monitoring continues but less intrusively. And honesty with your
children is a prerequisite to any degree of hosesty from them
back.

You seem to advocate hierarchal power to an extreme degree.
Would you now accept your own parents monitoring YOU if they
were to be staying and living in your household with you?If not,
then when did this become unnacceptable? At what age were
you? Or would you monitor them?
Further to that - you may have no problem with the Chinese
governmental approach over the individuals' right to free
expression and choice also?
I think you are right that the very young need to EARN a sense of
privacy in some things - very young children can accept the
need for full supervision. But this, surely, has to be modified as
they get older or they will never 'learn'.
Let them make 'mistakes' but monitor them just enough that
those mistakes will never be dire...

by sql_joe

Hmmm....

Well, My home is NOT a democracy. Now, as an adult in my home, there are things I no longer monitor on my daughter...however, it has been made very clear to her that it is MY home, and therefore I am the one responsable legally and liability-wise for anything that happens in it - therefore, there are still certain rules and modes of behavior that need to be adhered to. Besides, why should anyone have to put up with behavior that they find reprehensable in their own homes? Even when I visit MY parents (and I'm in my forties) I know there are rules and modes of behvior to follow. Why? Because that's that how adults behave, we respect others (supposedly).

Now, all of this comes naturally to kids if you've been parenting them all along. In other words, its never even been an issue in my home! Yes, I make mistakes as a parent, and yes I admit them to my child when I do. But by being involved all along with her, now that shes an adult it goes without saying to respect my feelings, my beliefs, my protperty, and to not do anything that would get me in trouble.

So, if you've been parenting all along, their is no issue of heirarchical power, or monitoring, or establishing rules for adult children, or anyting. Hopefull by the time your child reaches adulthood, they've become the kind of adult that you want them to be, and those thigns are no longer an issue. If you have to monitor your adult child in your home, then there is REALLY a problem going on....

George

by lobster-man

I believe that if you instill high morals into your children they will know what is right to do. I have two daughters who both access the Internet have done so for years. I have complete faith in their judgement to view what is right and not view what is questionable. I hae occassionally monitored their visited sites and found nothing that was questionable. I do believe that you must be close to your kids. Talk to them and let them know what you expect. Communication is sometimes lost with teens at a time when it is most important. If you communicate with them, they will know what you expect. When all of the publicity about myspace.com came up, they both removed their information from that site.... without me saying anything.

by dr. tarr

I haven't read the other comments yet, but basically I treat the internet access in my home the same way my employer treats the internet access at work: My wife and I pay for it, we are legally responsible for it, and we reserve the right to monitor any and all traffice that is passed on it. I have five children, 4 daughters, three of whom have moved out and are either married or on their own, ong girl still living at home while going to college, and a son who has not yet graduated from high school. I explained all of this to everyone in my family, and that's the just the way it is. It's called being a parent.

I gave up on the nanny software early on: one, because I can't see the sense in posing an artificial challenge for my kids to overcome, and two, because I got tired of being called to the computer to OK research on the Bikini Atoll and teenage drug use prevention (two examples of topics that the protection software would not allow to be viewed with the filters set to teens.) My son is a pretty smart cookie, and he sees programs like that as a challenge to be overcome of and by themselves. He hasn't learned enough IOS to be able to hack the router and firewall yet, and by the time he can, he'll be on his own with the ability and judgement to decide what is and isn't appropriate for him.

I've chosen instead to stay involdes with my kids, try to teach them how to make good decisions, and them trust them to go out and make mistakes, and ask for help when they need it. I also provide that help as non judgementally as I can, (after all, they are MY children) and occasionally have to be the heavy when the boundaries of common sense and intelligence fail. For instance, when my son has friends over for LAN parties, I kill the publis internet access to that part of the network. That way my son doesn't have to be the cop for his friends, and I dont have to explain how Bubba came to be in possion of those pictures of (insert name of whatever it is that ticks you off).

I don't pretend that I am smart enough to prevent my son, who started using the computer at two, from looking at pictures of unclothed young women, and I think I am happy about that. I chose instead to try to give him the tools to make good decisions, and the trust and support to allow him to develop the ability. After all, he has access to all of that same information in places like the public library, so he needs to learn how to use his judgement rather than rely on an arbitrary crutch imposed from outside. "Well Dad, I thought if the blocking software let it through it must be OK." isn't an excuse I'm prepared to accept. In just a few years he will be another hardworking citizen and I won't be there to hold his hand. I believe that my most important job it to prepare him for that day. If I don't, I have failed him, myself, and the future of our way of life.

I know I'm a little 'soap boxy' on this topic, but it is one of my core principles. When my children were young, when they were in the net, so was I, right there beside them. Now that they are teens and adults, I give them their space and privacy where appropriate, and intrude on that privacy wheen necessary. I make a point of asking my son about web sites that he has visited from time to time, and I have added some of those sites to the black ACL. I have also forwarded chat logs tot the local polict that have resulted in arrests and at least one conviction for an internet predator. BTW, my son brought those logs to me, i didn't have to find them myself. I guess maybe it's working.

by tantor

Just like you said, my house, my rules.

I will not allow my kids to have computers in their rooms behind closed doors. Not because I don't trust them, it's because I don't trust what's out there. And I get involved with my kids (if you read the fine print of the job description for "Parent" it's in there). They clearly know what's expected.

The Internet is a privilige not a right. Food, clothing, shelter are rights.

I also think it's important to teach my kids safe practices. Like not using your real name (not even your first name) in any login or email address. Not answering gender or age questions when possible. Teaching them how to use white lists for email and blocking in IM.

You hear all these parents who want to shut down myspace because their kids are getting harassed. It's not the website's fault that some idiot kid put their real name and cell phone number on their profile along with pictures of them. If they would just teach their kids how to be smart online, a lot of it wouldn't happen.

Would you send your kid to a mall in a bikini with their cell phone number written on the butt?

Simple. If it's stupid to do in the physical world, it's stupid to do it in cyberspace. And you should probably, I don't know, be a parent and teach them instead of spying on them and blowing up when you catch them doing something wrong.

by sql_joe

And....if the parents were involved, do you think those kids would have posted sexually suggestive pictures of themselves on the web?....

Myspace is not the parent....we are....

Your points are great!

George

by sql_joe

How as a parent can you NOT monitor your child's activity in a place that's been proven to be as dangerous to children as the Internet is?

The Internet is a great tool, and like most tools, there are unsafe ways to use it. It is the responsability of every parent to teach their children the safe ways to use tools AND TO ENSURE THEY AREN'T USING THE TOOLS UNSAFELY. Yes, this could also mean monitoring.

My daughter has her own room, and from day one we've made it very clear that her room is subject to search by us at any time for any reason (or no reason) with her there or not. Now, her mother and I have only did this once or twice in 18 years BUT she did not know that. Instead she did not know if we were checking or not, and therefore had to act as if we were there - in other words, behave the way she would if she were in front of us.

We handled the Internet the same way. She had a PC in her own room, but was not allowed to access the internet with the door closed. She was told that she ever closed a browser window when we walked by or in, we would assume she had something to hide, and she would lose the priveledge. In fact, it always been made clear that the Internet is a priveledge NOT a right and whenever she got grounded it was always one fo the first things to go (if she needed it for homework at these times, it was supervised). She was also notified that while I may have taught her all the tricks she knew, I did not teach her all the tricks I knew on PC's and that her PC was subject to search at any time for no reason - so again, she generally had to behave in a way that mimicked constant observation.

Did she still try and get away with stuff? Yes, what kid doesn't, and when she did, the priviledge was lost for a time and other appropriate punishements administered - like the time she appropriated my credit card and used it on the net - she had to repay me thrice what she charged. At times that I perceived she was trying to get away with stuff after hours, I just reset the router to lock her PC out from internet access after bedtime.

Now that she's 19 and in college, I do not do these things. She's an adult and I've spent the last decade teaching her how to be safe on the net. She has either gotten by now, or she hasn't. However, she still lives in my house, so there are still some restrictions.

Yes, all of this does take time, but when one becomes a parent, this is the responsability they have agreed to accept. When parents stop paying attention, we get tragedies such as Columbine, where those boys had been charging thousands of dollars of equipment needed to make explosives to the parent's credit cards and the parent's never checked. Was the child's right to privacy worth theirs (and many others) deaths? Would the parent checking on what was going on have possibly revealed there were problems and let them seek help? Probably so! You know, sometimes there isn't anything we can do - but it is our job to try and try and try and never give up. We shape the future of our world by the kinds of adults we let loose into it.

My wife and I made a huge effort to introduce our child to the things we enjoyed, and we got her very involved. Now we have a great friendship with her as an adult because we all do things together we enjoy doing. Yes, we are her parents and that came first, but we also discovered we could be her friends without sacraficing being parents by never letting friendship get in the way of parenting.

So, when I am asked by non-computer savvy parents how to protect their children on the internet, I tell them about every tool I know about, including monitoring because it is my ethical and moral obligation as a parent to do no less.

George

by sjeffreys

It is important that those of us with information, inform those without. Education should be a daily part of life, whether it's children or adults. I believe very strongly in educating my clients - home or business users. Many, many people still do not have clue about the pervasive dangers lurking on the internet! Yes, I believe that they should be up front with the fact that usage is being monitored whether at home or at work, unless specific issues dictate drastic measures.

It takes only one session of inappropriate viewing on the internet to begin rewriting the moral code and values we try to instill in our children. Why shouldn't that be avoided at all costs? Yes, they will be exposed to foul language, etc. through other sources, but that's not okay with me either and I let my children know that. And when I find out about it, I deal with it and that may involve letting other parents know what their children are doing.

Children and teens are bombarded with so many messages - I make sure that mine is very clear and very consistent. Children/teens want boundaries. They want to know that a "no" is always a "no". Yesterday, today and tomorrow and that it's a "no" for everyone in the family. My 13 year old wants IM and his computer connected to the internet - "no" was my reply with a lengthy conversation (he can connect with mine if needed). I explained that it was not him that I don't trust, but the millions of other people out there. It is my job to protect him, and protect him I will from anyone who wants to fill his mind with garbage.

One of our frequent conversations is about viewing your actions and decisions with regard to the results that you want to achieve. What does it add to your life? I'm a "mean mom" sometimes, but my children know that I love them completely. They point out examples to me of children that are left to do whatever they want and surf the internet viewing porn, etc. Even my 8 year old understands that these parents aren't setting them up to succeed.

I don't make all the decisions for my children and don't want to cripple them like that(no parent could do it and children need to be able to make mistakes, but there are some mistakes they can make these days that they can't possibly be prepared for). Every day they walk out the door and go to school or activities. It is then that have to filter things using the moral education they were given at home. Home should be the safest place on earth for a child and if I can give a parent the tools to help achieve that then I should. Kids need to be kids for as long as they can be.

by rahammers

Parents have a responsiblity to watch over their children under the age of 18. Watching over them protects them AND helps guide their development into upstanding members of the community.

Over the age of 18 you have a responsiblity to the community in how a resource you have is being used. If you have a child in the house over the age of 18 and suspect a problem, it is your right and responsibility to monitor how YOUR resource is being used. My computer, My ISP, My right to monitor. Should the child be paying for the computer and the connection, your responsibility and rights are and should be limited. Now it is their computer, their ISP, their right and responsibilty to use it appropriately.

by jdclyde

even if they are using their computer with their ISP, if it is in YOUR house you are still responsible for what happens.

When they are out on their own, then and ONLY then do they have the "right" to all the privacy they want.

by steven.berher

As a parent of a teenager and in the SW development, I know there are just too many chances for kids to get into trouble on the web. Even the most innocent search of white house using .com vs .gov for a kids research can get too much.

In my house, my kids know that I have software watching them. If they don't want me to know what their doing, then they'd had better have the good sense not to do it or to put it into words. I have good kids, but continually have to watch and help govern how they use the PC-- a fantastic tool but full of hidden adult only areas and/or a needed maturity factor. With instance message, e-mail, blogs, multiple accounts, etc. kids can assume any idenity.. this is true for the others they may be communicating (perv's and others).

There is also the need to govern the time spend in cyberspace -- limiting access so that on a school night your child doesn't stay up until 2am chat'ing with other kids. You really don't believe a child can govern themselves. It's like drugs, it's addictive.

I may give latitude as a child matures... truely matures whereby you trust their judgement and they become more responsible. It's just like putting a large sack of candy in front of a 10-12 year old, they'll eat it all gone. Whereas a 16/17 year old would still have the same bag a week or two later. Each kids going to be different. Or another example would be driving. At age 15, kids get a learns permit cause they have to learn sometime. Kids are just not handed the keys to the car at 15 without supervision. When they do get the keys to the car, do you still not supervise by setting down initial rules for a period of time (e.g., no driving at night, or curfew, etc.). Just like a car, the internets has A LOT of stuff; most good, some bad--needing governing, and some that just needs supervision until their old enough.

For providing tools to "spy" on internet activity for other parents, I help all my friends understand there are tools available. If they want my help, I will help them load and understand how to use them. I'm seeing that more of my friends take me up on the request when their kid gets around 12 -13yrs old.

They need to have access for all the good reasons, you want them to have access for all the good reasons. As a parent I feel you must govern/supervise them like you do anything else, providing more freedoms as they mature.

Anyway... my opinion!

by 35rjt

I take full responsibility for all internet activity on my computer, and as such it is not spying!

by issinho

the network administrators. We have broadband (like most families nowadays) and we have our computers networked to go to the internet. When my daughter is old enough to play on the computer, You can bet that her system (or account) will be locked down as tight as possible. After all, it is my wife's and mine responsibility to protect her, whether she agrees with it or not.

Furthermore, that is MY network! I pay for it, I administer it! It is also my responsibility to guard it against any threats, to the best of my ability. I have a firewall installed with Proxy services that has a very extensive set of blacklists. It automatically blocks certain content from being viewed, plus it logs it whenever content is requested that it blocks!

I think that the software used to view what your kids are viewing is just fine to use. I feel, however, that there SHOULD come a time where that needs to stop. 18 at the latest as they are considered an adult, I would say. They will, however, subject themselves to my network administration rules as long as they are connected to it, regardless of age. Hey, if we can't view some of that content at work (and it is of questionable moral content) and we don't want younger audiences viewing that stuff by accident, then our children, 18 or otherwise, won't see it. I will not have that stuff in my home.

"That's [my] opinion, [I]'d like to hear yours"

by el guapo

Face it, regardless of how much you 'talk' to children about the hidden dangers of the internet, there's no real guarentee that they won't visit inappropriate sites whn you're not looking.

My take is as long as your children is living under your roof, you have every right and responsibility to maintain their well being, even if it means spying to protect them.

Your kids are using YOUR PC's, you have every right to install these types of software. They're living under your household, you have every right to monitor their activities online.

Parents just have to be more assertive enough to do these things.

BTW, who has heard of parents involving 'ethics' to teenagers in regards to where to go in the internet??

by mek804

You should see more "Bernie Mac". He explains child care to his
wife in simple terms: "these are children, not human beings. You
have to treat them like CONVICTS or they will take over!"

If your child knew up front that impropriety on the PC or telly
would result in much unpleasantness, they wouldn't do it.

They're curious. They'll do it at least once. But live up to your
threats and then some, and it won't happen again. If that proves
to be wrong, well, no more computer access. Pretty simple, eh?

by jdclyde

we are protecting our children from in the first place.

Good call Joe, and thanks for being a timely example kkosmicki.

Glad you don't work with me. I have a low tolerance for id10t's such as yourself.

First, this twit refers to himself in third person in his profile, then his web site loaded even slower than TR while viewing the EL thread! On top of that, it is all ADs! Once the Java started loading up (after a minute or so) I had enough and closed the window. Because of the dozen or so ads, I strongly recommend NOT going there yourself. X-(
[b]
Note, if you are a working professional AND want to be a foul mouthed punk, don't post as much personal information, "Mr. Kosmicki". :O

by dr. tarr

Wow, what originality. You created your own personal substitution code for a socially unacceptable word, not once but twice! I am so impressed - not. Perhaps a ten year old would be, which is what the original poster realized. You have provided a prime example of the type of random, uncouth, uncalled for behavior that permeates much of modern society.

For the sake of discussion, did you mean the original post that started the discussion thread, the post that is immediately in front of yours chronilogically, or another post that appeared earlier in the thread but is not immediately in front of yours because of the timestamp order in which the replies were received at the blog site?

by toddah

The internet is not a good or bad place. there are good and bad people in every situation your children are going to experience in life and it's your job as a parent to teach them the values that will guide them through this thing called life.
Installing this type of software has some value if you are going to monitor the outcome and use it as a teachable moment, however I have seen this tool used more and more as a tool to stage an attack on an unruly teen (thus widening the parent/ child gap)than to truly teach them a value lesson in life.
I have two fully grown children and three grand children all of whom are very active internet citizens and I am truly tired of listening to these parents of 3 year olds pontificate on the facts of rearing children when they are still in basic training for the job.
You cannot effectivly monitor your children from a position of ignorance. The average parent I deal with has a hard time getting their email let alone trying to interpet the outcome of thousands of incidents of captured information.
I think this is alot like virus scanners in that uneducated parents think the sum of the game is to buy this software and install it and then their children are safe on the internet. Now we can go on with life safe in the knowledge we have done our job and spent money to safegard our children.
Your children will never be safe anywhere in life and the only thing you can teach them is the age old fight or flight response that all living things have used as survival tools for eons.
Take the time to educate the parents and the children not shopping for the turnkey solution.

by longennamer

Anybody seen the dateline on this? It's scary what sick people are out there, and kids are naive. Dateline even caught a rabbi coming to the house with the bad intents. crazy. As a parent, you have to do everything possible to protect your kids.

by fsirmons

As a parent you are responsible for your child/children until they are 18. I inform my clients and friends of all of the alternatives but I start with the simple fact that they should not have internet access in a childs room, this eliminates several issues. Beyond this they should closely monitor all activity, logs etc as anything else is abdicating their responsibility. In other words, you get what you ask for.

by tnunetworksupport

I believe it is an act of service to inform others of such solutions, although they are not foolproof. I believe the child will act on their own free will when no one's around. However, we all have consequences for our actions, whether negative or positive. In my experience, part of being a parent is to teach about consequences. In my opinion, there's not a black & white rule as to "how old is child when we stop monitoring". I believe that depends a lot upon the child.

I believe that if we, as parents (and adults in general), model accountability by being accountable to others ourselves, be willing to help others (when asked) to be accountable, it becomes natural for our children to learn about accountability first-hand.

[Warning! I don't do this perfectly!] I share this to give an example of accountability. Several weeks back, I'd left my favorite water bottle at a friend's house one weekend. When I realized this, I took my daughter's pink water bottle from the cupboard and proceeded to use it for the week. Sometime around Friday or Saturday, my daughter (who's 3 yrs old) asked me "Daddy, did you ask if you could borrow my water bottle?" My knee-jerk reaction was to think "I'm the dad here. I paid for water bottle. Therefore, I don't have to ask YOU to borrow it." I didn't say anything to her. A few days later, this had been bothering me. A friend and I were talking about this, when she asked me "Did you make an amends for not asking?" I immediately went to my daughter and made an amends for not asking her if I could borrow her water bottle. Her response ... "Daddy, it's okay. All you have to do is ask." We try to practice things of this nature in our home regularly, teaching that we need to be accountable for our actions (or inactions).

by kj7gs

I'm a ham operator, and the assumptions are the same as with my radio equipment. You have to assume that the entire world as listening to what you're doing. It's not private. Also, when anyone uses my equipment, it's my license to operate that they're using, which basically means that my responsibility for the proper operation of the station has not gone away. My stuff, I will know when they use it and how they use it. They are not "licensed" to just turn the equipment on and operate whenever they like. And that doesn't just go for my child; anyone in my house gets the same treatment. They are my guest, but the computer equipment is mine, and mine only. It's password-protected, and I monitor her activity on a regular basis. If she doesn't like it, she may wait four more years until she's 18, move out, purchase her own computer, and live her life as she pleases, without my protections. For now, she doesn't have to realize that I'm doing this because I love her.

by wacker42

My equipment to do with what I want. If that's not acceptable then buy your own and by the way, pay for your own internet connection too.

by dr. tarr

IMHO, (as if I've ever had a humble anything of my own volition) it should read something along the lines of "It's our home, and when you have become an adult and have the maturity and wherewithal to own your own home and accept those responsibilities, it's my equipment to use as I see fit" As long as my children are living in my home they must accept that I will exert my power as parent. My twenty-one year old daughter is not my tennant, she is my child, and she follows my rules. I will discuss those rules, and modify them based on age, maturity, experiance, and occasionally whim, but the bottom line is it runs my way. All of the girls have, and all but one have exercised the option of "or the highway."

"If that's not acceptable then buy your own and by the way, pay for your own internet connection too." assumes, at least for me, that you have already chosen the highway option, since the children bringing their own anything into my home and my not having veto authority just isn't going to happen.

by professorcurt

Nothing - no technology or software or legislative action - beats the Mark 1 Eyeball of a concerned parent.

When my 2 kids were growing up, the only computer in the house was in the living room where I could see it while watching TV. I KNEW what the kids were looking at when they were on-line, and I got to recognize the "names" of their on-line friends. If I didn't recognize a name - I'd ask. The system was powered-off and blocked at the boot level when I wasn't home, and we had no hesitancy in checking the history, cookies, and temp files from the kids on-line activities.

In the debate over childrens privacy versus on-line security there is no argument; safety for the children wins every time. As to when they should have full unmonitored access, my 2 children finally got their unrestricted access when they went away to college.

by rstachelrodt

I work as a network administrator at the local high school. I get to see kids trying all sorts of crap with the computers and the Internet every day. We have filtering software, per CIPA, yet the best way to 'protect' the kids here is the simplest: put the computer and, more importantly, the monitor where they are always visible. I have more problems in classrooms where teachers have the monitor facing a corner than anywhere else. The teachers who listen and re-arrange the furniture so that the monitor is visible to someone at the front of the classroom have no problems. At home, the answer is equally simple.Take the computers out of the kids room. Put the computer in the same room as the TV, and position it so that you can see the monitor from the same place where you watch the TV. By putting the computer in a 'public' place, you take away the presumtion of privacy. After all, if the Secret Service comes to your door with a warrant, it's your butt on the line, and all of your computing equipment as well.

by goodolepop

For me it is not a question of controlling children's behavior. There are some things I do not allow in my home. Pornography being one of those things. I don't filter just my children (all 4 of whom are over 18) on my home network. I filter ANYONE on my home network. I provide the computers, I provide the internet service and aDSL line. I control who uses them and what comes in on it. It has nothing to do with children, per se. It has everything to do with what I will allow in my home. I find the Simpson's, King of the Hill, etc. not only to be mostly Pablum for the brain (like most network television) but generally offensive as well. They are not watched on the TV's in my home. No one watches porn on my computers. You can't set a double standard. If porn is bad for the kids, it is bad for the parents. When raising children you can not say "Do as I say, not as I do." The kids will always do as you do.

by keyguy13

Amcol says "It is, in fact, quite the opposite...when a child knows Mom and Dad are there, watching over them, they have a higher level of trust in Mom's and Dad's ability to be a good parent."

Since when has supervision ever inspired trust? That's just ridiculous, Amcol. I'm sorry but when has someone looking over your shoulder ever given you a warm fuzzy feeling of trust. I submit that has never been the case. But maybe I'm wrong. I can concede that.

Personally, I think it is MORE than possible to sit down with your kids and explain the dangers, how to avoid them and what to do. Kids ARE smarter than you think. If you give them the freedom and credit to actually think for themselves, you'll find they more often than not exhibit remarkable common sense. At least that has been the case with my daughter. I've seen other parents try the spying routine and all it does is cause resentment and rebellion, no matter what age. Not only that but it tells your kids in no uncertain terms that you don't believe they can be trusted to do the right or smart thing. Spying is just a bad idea in general and can backfire badly.

by dr. tarr

Although that work spying keeps getting bandied about, it really isn't what has been suggested in any of the posts to this thread. Spying is surreptitious, and isn't what was intended. Im my supervisory relationships at work I make sure that my subordinates are aware that I review their work, yet that all know that I trust them to competently discharge their duties. My job includes knowing what is done, and ensuring that it is done correctly, as much if not more to protect my workers from undeserved critism than to catch them at something wrong.

The same follows for the children. My son knows I monitor the network access logs. He trusts that, if I find things that should not be there, be they porn, illegal downloads, or what ever, I will act. He trusts me discuss things with him when I find them, and he trusts me to make a rational decision based on the facts, and he trust that my actions will be fair, and consistent with what he has been taught is acceptable and unacceptable behavior. Note that I never said that he enjoyed any of this, or that it made him like me more, or that it doesn'y occasionally really anger him. I sadi that he could trust me to do what I said I would.

If he chooses to believe that this means I do not trust him in return, he is at mistaken. I do trust him. I trust him to be a fourteen year old boy in a world that is frequently insane. I expect him to push against the boundaries I have established to see if I really believe in them, or if I will cave in. I trust that the vast majority of his decisions will be sound ones, and that his judgement and instincts are sound. I trust him to make mistakes, and to occasionally need some help in rectifying them. Too many children have been taught that if we trust them we will let go forth into the world without watching over them. I, for one, have always felt a little better knowing that when I have had to venture into the jungle there was someone else out there watching. When that someone actually has the power to intervene it's even better.

by keyguy13

One of the definitions in the dictionary of trust is: Firm reliance on the integrity, ability, or character of a person or thing.

Another is: Reliance on something in the future; hope.

Either way, when I say I trust my daughter, I mean that I believe she will be smart, prudent and cautious when she is on the internet. I know this because I spend a lot of time with her. We discuss the things she sees and does online openly, no matter what it is. She has come to me with some of the most uncomfortable topics I can imagine and I have had to dig deep down for the courage to explain some of the things she asks. But she trusts that I will always give her straight answers.

That's what I consider a healthy trusting relationship. I realize it's extraordinary. Not many people can claim the same thing. And I am not implying that parents who relate to their kids differently are wrong either. What I am saying is what works for me.

by vtassone

We are supposed to be preparing kids for the real world aren't we? At the last place I worked we were told the computers were company property and that they were monitored. That means email, Chat and every other thing you could do with a computer. The company also owns the phone system. Conversations are also monitored to assure customer satisfaction. Kids, GET USED TO IT!!!!! This is the world we live in. We were told in advance and people still tryed to get around it. Shopping online during work hours and such. How about the parents that are getting big bills from the music industry because The children wanted to get free tunes? How about the virus or trojan they downloaded while getting those free tunes? You know, the one that logged YOUR key strokes and stole YOUR passwords and credit card numbers and identity. What about the day YOUR daughter turned up missing, Whould you like to have the chat logs of who she was online with to show the police?

Keep the computer in the family room.

Install the software and tell them it's installed.

Talk TO your kids, not AT them.

I realize they can still go to their friends house and use the computer. I was not the perfect child either. My parents thought they caught me at everything I did wrong. If they only knew!!!!!!!

by x-marcap

She has a better temperment and homeschools our children. The homeschooling environment has been described as Stalag Sanko by my niece, who after fostering with us, went back to her druggie lifestyle. 4 kids at age 21, and on welfare, Jen's mother wishes she were as observant as her sister and I are.

I am very aware of my kids internet usage. I use a firewall on a linux box and sieve all the crap out... My wife needed a XXXL blouse for her friend, and had to go to the library to buy it online... We run a tough house here.

My daughter 21 & son 20 are in the dental field and my son is going to be a Chiropractor and a Gunsmith. My sons 9 and 6 are taking Karate, tapdance, piano, drums, chess as well as an acedemic load... My wife could have made more money than I could, but she is tougher on the kids than I am. She is Germanic extraction. Sieg Heil!

The point is that kids need loving discipline, and tender care. I am more stoic, she is a living flame... Together we raise our brood... Would I stoop to read a diary, Yep. Found out who my neices drug connection was in Virginia, and helped him get off drugs. He has stayed off drugs. (God Bless the USMC)

There is no need to be unobtrusive. If a kid puts something in a diary, they expect to be caught or think you are stupid.

I review all history lists, logs, etc. I will tell my kids why I don't want them looking at stuff they shouldn't. Why get excited, when all the women who look that good know it and have the worship me attitude...

by microrub

You need to show that you are interested in their on-line activities the same way you show interest in their school work, sports and what they do when they go out. This serves two purposes 1) that they know you are watching - all children need to know this, call it their conscious. That little person telling them this could be wrong and questions them whether to do something or not; and 2) as with other activities your interest tells them you care about them. This is very important. It tells the child or teenager they are important to you and in so doing you will protect them if necessary. Show them how to browse the Internet safely, how to deal with Pop-ups, and how to spot the scams. This is true with teenagers on down. I have used the Net since its early days with Chat Rooms on Compuserve. I have reviewed AIM?s logs to see who and what the kids were talking about. I don?t do this often and I do install tracking software. Show them you are interested and that you care ? this can go a long way. Who knows you both might learn something from each other and that could be very valuable.

by ludedude25

Even if you are to sit down and have a chat with them I would still keep my eyes on them. Let them know that there are programs out there to both monitor and recover where they have been and what they are doing and if you have a suspision there into things they shouldn't be you will use those programs.

I wouldn't be sneaking around with the subject. If you sneak, and catch them they will just try to sneak harder.

by jdclyde

My ex-sister-in-law was watching my twin boys one evening. When I went to pick them up, there they all were, sitting around watching South Park... (my kids were 6 and her daughter is just a month younger).

I made the statement (that got me in a LOT of trouble with the now ex-wife) about how pathetic the example was of watching that with very little babies, and the boys would NOT be needing to be watched again, thank-you-very-much.

(you may not have noticed, but I am not one for candy coating issues. This MAY come as a surprise to you, but I can be a LITTLE abrasive at times.... :D )

Oh, the boys were NEVER watched by her again, and no, sorry but you can't go stay the night with Aunt Cindy. Why? We have other plans, but maybe your cousin can stay HERE the next night?

Aunt Cindy, by the ripe old age of 27 is on marriage number 4, with three other random guys in the mix that all were called "daddy" by the little girl. I feel so sorry for that girl, AND EVERY guy that every tries to have a healthy, stable relationship with her.

Can't pick your relatives, but you sure can divorce from them! B-)

by roskonet

Here?s the way it is at our house: I am the parent, you are the children. You may be my best friend but you?ll never be my peer. I want you to grow up to be a healthy, happy, productive citizen because I love you. There are many things on the internet that will prevent you from becoming a good person. I wouldn?t drop you off alone at a street corner in a bad part of town, and I?m not going to do essentially the same thing on the internet. You can whine and complain all you like and it won?t stop me from loving you. It will be this way until you graduate high school or if I suspect wrongdoing.

I have installed Spector 5.0 on the kids? machines and I regularly tell them I can see everything they type and receive. Nobody connects to the internet behind a closed door. I have programmed a list of banned words in URLs and banned websites into our router. They have an hour on the internet unless they have schoolwork. I nag them to talk to their friends in person instead of through faceless IM conversations. We have a good relationship because everybody knows the rules of engagement.

You have an obligation to ensure that parents are more equipped than their children. I strongly recommend Spector as it logs internet activity, screen shots, email and IM conversations. I watched over my toddlers in the bathtub, and I watch over my teens on the internet - both are in dangerous places for their age. Parents need to stop being manipulated and start being caretakers. Turn off the television and get to know your kids.

by kovalj

I am the father of 5 children ranging in age from 15 down to 6. It is absolutely my responsibility as a parent to protect my children from harm, including from cyberspace. This includes setting clear limits on what, when, and how my children use the Internet. If my wife and I felt that current limits were insufficient, then it would be not only our right, but our responsibility to use software that would allow us to see what our children view on the Internet. This right and responsibility would extend right up to adulthood. Currently, none of my children are allowed to enter a chat room, and the parental controls on our ISP are set accordingly. Now, if my belief is naive that this barrier is sufficient to prevent them from entering a chat room, then I will investigate other options.

The bottom line for me, as a parent, is that I may use any means at my disposal that is moral or legal to protect my children from harm in cyberspace or any other environment.

by Member 28631002

Is it not okay to keep your children from playing in the middle of a busy highway? It takes more than just suggesting behavior and limits. Children will always test those limits. Its just human nature. Sometimes, even adults test limits, (and get speeding tickets, parking tickets, etc.)

I don't consider monitoring my children's activities to be spying. They know that we keep tabs on their activities. Not just online, but in life. You can't just give a child a stack of books and say get yourself educated in the next 12 years. They need guidance and teachers, and yes - tests!

As for the internet, even adults get scammed or worse. Sometimes it is very difficult even for an adult to pick stay safe from online preditors, so do you expect your children to be smarter than most adults without any help from you?

But you don't just install spyware on the computer and walk away. You observe and make use of anything unusual that might require intervention.

I had a recent situation with our 16-yr old daughter, because any emails to her that were not from approved list of people I know would also be sent to my inbox. I have told her many times that I could find out anything she does online, so it should not have been a shock when I had to talk to her about the dangers of what she was doing - even just giving out private information about herself & our family online. She did not know there was anything wrong with it because "all her friends were doing it". Even though we have talked many times about dangers of visiting bad websites or "chatting" with people you don't know, still she was tricked by a website that looked ok. Without monitoring, I would not have known. It wasn't just a matter of restricting her, but in this case, filing reports with proper authorities, especially when I contacted the source and informed them she was a child and to stop sending her the adult content emails, but they continued to send them even 2 months later. I didn't contact them by email, I called on the phone to be sure I spoke with a person and that they fully understood my intent.

We always tell her that the restrictions and rules are there because we love her and care what happens to her. If we didn't love her, she could just do whatever and we wouln't care.

Too many parents are afraid of a little 2-letter word "NO". As much as we'd like to be their friends, they have friends, what the need are parents!

Now if you still feel a need to monitor them at 20 or older, then it's time for them to get out and pay they're own bills and be responsible for themselves. As long as my children live in my house, I will have some control of what goes on in my house. My kids will not be bringing drugs, etc, in my house even if they're 30, and they won't be going out the door looking like hoodlums or worse as long as they live in my house.

by purecoffee

As a parent you have the right to deploy such software but I also feel you have the responsibility to tell them you do this. This is a trust issue. As they mature and understand more and have gained your trust, then each parent can decide to "loosen" the reigns a little. If they screw up, the screws come down again.

Telling other parents about KeyLogging software is o.k. Why wouldn't you want your friends to know about it? I am all for protecting our kids. Has anyone seen some of the recent DateLine investigations?