Discussion Locked

Ethics of watching children's computer screens

0 helpful
223 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

223 replies

by pado

I agree with you whole heartedly, Joe.
My children grew up knowing that I expected the level of
maturity from them to increase as they grew up. I treated (treat)
them with respect and I get that same respect back.

There's only a problem if children treat their parents as 'the
enemy' or 'the boss' - when they're at a level of understanding
that allows them to make their own, well-nurtured, decisions.

Doesn't mean you don't keap an eye out for anything untoward -
but reading kids diaries and closely observing every internet site
they choose to visit is intrusive and degrading. Children may not
behave irresponsibly AT HOME when treated this way, but will
pander to their curiosities elsewhere - outside parent's nurturing
care.
I kinda agree with your approach - and it has enabled my own
children into responsible adulthood too.

by tory

It is very nice to believe that because you have discussed something with your daughter, she's following it to a T. In fact, that may be the case with the very RARE child. I'm a high school teacher and I have the ear and lend an ear to my kids. In my 13 years as a teacher I've talked to parents who will stand with their right hand on a stack of Bibles and swear up and down that their child would NEVER do ______ and they WHOLEHEARTEDLY believe it. Yet the child will tell me (and provide proof) that they are engaged in dangerous activities right under their parents' noses.

Is it important to talk to a child about the dangers? Yes, of course it is. Is it immportant to talk to them over and over again. You betcha. Is it important to WATCH THEM...it is even MORE important to watch them to ensure that your message is sinking in than it is to send the message.

Kids are kids. They are smart, funny, exasperating, and intelligent but they simply do not have the scope that adults have. "It won't happen to me" is practically a mantra in a teenager's mind. After all, "I know him really well...I met him online and he's really really nice, and we've known each for MONTHS" to them is reasonable enough of an argument to meet him in a coffee shop at 11 p.m. "My parents wouldn't understand" is reasonable enough an argument to not tell the parents...that is in the mind of a child.

Your daughter is, I'm sure, a very together young lady but never ever let it leave your mind that she is a CHILD. God made parents to guide and protect their children. That means talking to them, providing a safe secure environment, setting FIRM boundaries, watching over their shoulders, monitoring them when they are in areas where their experience will not allow them to make the most informed decisions, etc.

If you're not willing to do that, or if you are so naive as to think that just because you have talked to a child about something that it's a done deal, then you are not fulfilling your duties as a parent. Period. Doesn't mean you don't mean well, nor that you're "bad", or that you don't love the child. It just means that you're not doing what you can do, and monitoring her actions when she is in a new/dangerous situation is an absolute MUST, to keep her as safe as you can.

Watching a child is providing a safety net. My parents were EXTREMELY strict and guess what...I knew beyond a shadow of a doubt that if I tried drugs, drank, got in the car with a stranger, etc. that I would be killed...ressurected, and killed again. That was a MAJOR safety net for me! When a peer approached me with "Hey, do ya wanna..." I would say with surety that if I did my mother would kill me. I resented it at times, but when the chips were down I was glad that I could use mom as a scapegoat.

By all means, give kids some freedom, but mete it out carefully and in measured doses. Would you drop your child off in downtown Manhatten and say "See you in a few days...have fun!" Of COURSE not! Yet the Internet is very much like that. There are some wonderful, educational, and entertaining possibilities. However there are also a lot of dangers. Use common sense and don't expect that a child with a mere 16 or 17 years of experience to be able to make the same kinds of decisions that an adult with 30+ years of experience can.

by tjfarley

If my offspring is using a computer I paid for, under my roof, there is no question. I have a right to know what they are up to. When they are mature enough to move out and get their own computer then they can do whatever they like.

by slog

As a parent of three children and someone who runs a Sunday School bus route I am shocked to find out that we can just trust our kids to do the right or smart thing. All this time I thought doing the right or smart thing required experience and that we as parents had to train them (not tell them) how to do the right thing. Funny when I was a kid I knew stealing was wrong but I did it a few times until I got caught and punished by my parents. I also snuck out real late at night with my friends until I got caught and punished - I knew it was wrong and that my mother thought it was dangerous but I did it anyway. I did some really stupid things growing up as a kid and it is only God's grace that I am not dead. While I was doing these things I was surrounded by a whole slew of other kids many of whom were straight A students. Unintending adults get trapped by the lure of pornography on the internet and you think kids can avoid it if you just tell them, "don't go there?". You may have a very compliant responsible daughter but she may have you looking at kids with Rose colored glasses on. Most kids are not compliant and responsible. Most kids want to do exactly what you tell them they aren't supposed to do. Everyday people do things they KNOW are wrong but they do it anyway. Children are particularly susceptible to doing what they KNOW is wrong. It is our job as parents to train them and protect them. Give them the ability to make some bad decisions if the consequences are not too great but when the consquences are great such as getting addicted to pornography or being raped and murdered by some internet weirdo you protect them from it by hook or by crook until they are mature enough to really understand the consequences.

by it pro.

You are responsible for that child until he/she is 18yo. If they are residing in your home and you are taking care of he/she, it is your moral duty to ensure that as much negative information as possible is shielded from young eyes. Society today is sick enough...it's our duty as parents to try and protect our children as long as possible. It's not called spying, it?s called caring, and if you consider this spying do you consider spending the day with your kids babysitting? No, they are your children. I have 3 boys that live in this house. The rules that govern this house are followed by ALL OF US not just them. Those rule stay for as long as you reside in this house. So if your 21 and going to college, you need to find somewhere else to view or surf negative material.

by luke4k

If you just glance at this, here are some basics on my feelings. This is long but sharing what I've learned may help someone out there... Kids are smarter and getting smarter every day.

First and foremost ITS YOUR RESPONSIBILITY to monitor your children. They have no rights to do as they please. You MUST monitor their activities. Don't assume they are good kids and will behave online. They learn stuff from kids at school.

Since I'm an I/T professional, Network and PC Expert, etc. My kids are VERY good at it too. They have both helped me for a long time.

Two kids 15.5 (B) and 12 (G). The boy now in H.School, and he is slick and always trying to out do Dad and get around the monitors. At one point once when caught doing something I asked him if he thought I hadn't considered that he would try to create a new ID or change the password to one of the adult admin IDS (he WAS admin). He sorta frown because he hadn't expected there were things he didn't know. Kids think they know it all. Fact is, I hadn't really thought he would change the password on and adult account. But, I had auditing turned on all and was watching him from places he had never thought about. He lost admin authority. ALL ADULT id's are monitored just not blocked. He almost beat me and it would have been a bad loss for HIM not me.... And, I thought I had covered all the angles. Go figure....

Second,

Hormones being what they are, I have shut the boy down 2-3 times for 30-days at a time. The last incident he was out there after being warned that I could see everything, doing cyber with different people.. including posting his cell phone in public and giving it to a 26-year old man from Calif. who offered to come to our house the next morning (drive through the night). SERIOUS!! YOU BET!! He didn't accept the visit invite but apparently the guy called him. He said he hung up and didn't talk to him. But, he lost his laptop and all PC Internet access for 45 days and all chat permanently. And when returned to him, the laptop was never again allowed in any room but kitchen and computer room, not Internet access until after 5:30 PM when parents are generally home.

And this is a REALLY GOOD KID into martial arts (3 year black belt), volunteers his time for rescue animal organization, donates his own money, is great with kids, can teach adults. But way different on the Internet. So DON'T think you know what your children will do on the Internet. Sex and chat are addictive. There are stats that will scare you out there.

Basics I recommend

1. Monitor using software that sends you email logs EVERY DAY.
2. Read the log EVERY DAY if possible (save them and review later if you have to).
3. Make sure the software monitors CHATS and logs them. WORD FOR WORD. (more below)
4. Monitor EVERY ID on the computer. Some let you put them in a group that can access anything but still monitor. If the little cyber burglars get around security say and get Mom's or Dad's acct password (cause it?s the DOG's name for heavens sake), your software still clues you in to them being on as someone else (say after school).

* He wanted admin authority for some installations so he changed the password to a family friend that also has admin but rarely uses his id. He logged onto that id and started chatting with it. He didn't think it was monitored just because it could chat and was admin. He still couldn't get into admin panels.

5. Use the software that prevents them from going on the Internet when you're not home (say RIGHT) after school.
6. Put the PC in a public area of the house. We have a study room/computer room (was a playroom when they were little tiks)>
7. Ensure your software has a separate admin panel and make SURE you use a DIFFERENT password that they will NEVER EVER guess. Remember, next to your spouse, they know more about you and what your password might be than anyone on earth. "Remember that they hear EVERYTHING"

8. Use software that lets you choose categories to all them to access

9. Most provide constant updates for blocked sites.

10. Chat is much more dangerous than most websites.

11. Make sure their friend's parents monitor their kids Internet activity too. If not, forbid them to use the computer at friend?s houses. Try to convert the other parents to monitoring parents. And, don't allow sleep overs if no monitoring. Talk about TROUBLE.. all night on the Internet at a friend's house just screams for trouble.

12. TALK to your kids about the dangers of the Internet, show them newspaper articles of real world horror about such topics (pretty easy to find), explain WHY you need to do it. Its not about trust, it?s about safety.

Oh, and I'm pretty liberal and trusting parent. But, being in the business shows me the dangers and it?s a good thing.

I prefer CyberSitter because:

1.Sends email every day.
2.Admin control ID/Panel access can not be overridden with WinXP Admin authority. The email or call to them must come from YOU AND YOU ALONE to over ride password.
3. Can not be uninstalled completely without Cybersitter password, WinXP admin authority.

I have also used CyberPatrol and Content Protect. I reviewed the rest.

Content protect is nice but you have to go TO the website to check it. People WON"T do it except on rare occasions. Nice about it is that you can reach out and shut them down anywhere on the planet if they are doing something wrong. It will send you "warned" and "blocked" web page visits but still better to get the email for me.

The email in cybersitter sends the content of the chats. So you can see their "net attitude" as well as what they are doing.

Being an I/T specialist in networking, security, etc. for a very long time has helped. I don't honestly know what other parents do if they are not knowledgeable. I advise all my clients that are parents to get to a class, read a book, etc. I have a bunch of a security book from Symantec and I have 3-4 papers on the topic that I give out. Kids are smarter then parents in tech that we EVER were as kids and for most, light years ahead of the average parent.

So, what to do??? BUY the best monitoring software available. There are constant reviews.

Stay in the top 5 and then MONOITOR IT. Installing it and not looking at the logs, not putting in a password, letting your kids know the security passwords to the software or WORSE, letting your kids logon to YOUR account are all BIG mistakes.

Trusting your kids not to lie about stuff is a mistake. They are kids, they may not lie about much but if they can get around your security or go online and lie to you, THEY WILL. And, my kids are great and very well behaved kids.

Well... dear dad here has taught him well but he can't possibly know all my tricks (yet anyway) and I have to keep learning new ones.

by lemeilleurdumonde

Stop monitoring your children if you don't trust them, go throw your computer in the river. By doing that your children won't be exposed to that bad Mr Internet.C'mon I am 15 like your son and I'am not sure he likes to be watched all the time even if it is for his "security". D@mn let him alone don't spy his life or he will get away.You have like 20 differents monitorings programs it's a little bit excessive.

Trust them even if they are smarter then you.

sorry for this poor English.

by robbi_ia

I got about halfway through all of the posts already on this thread when I decided enough was enough and it was time for my viewpoint. My apologies in advance to those whose posts I have yet to read - for duplicating anything you might already have said.

Monitoring our children's access to the internet is a necessary task in this day of the modern pedophile. This has little to do with kids' ability to access inappropriate material, and everything to do with what information they put forth about themselves on the internet and with whom they chat.

Take a look at websites like MySpace and Xanga... even though those sites specifically restrict personal information by policy, the information is still there. Even if the kids don't post their own personal information, their information could wind up on a friend's page - as they blog information about going places and hanging out with this friend or that friend. MySpace has become the pedophile's newest shopping ground. They gather information off the site about a kid, then approach that kid either through leaving messages on their space or through other contact information the kid has left. This doesn't just affect girls - boys make easier targets than girls because they are less likely to tell...

I teach courses for parents in how to protect their children from online predators. I also have helped create some online learning tools for organizations such as Predator-hunter.com and am currently working on a project specifically for the folks at Perverted Justice. At parent presentations, I've been approached many times about the possibilities of using keyloggers and other spying software. I tell parents that when it comes to keeping their kids safe from predators, as far as I'm concerned, anything goes! We have a duty to protect our children and keep them safe just as long as we possibly can.

Many parents are not as technologically savvy as those of us who frequent this site. They need all the help they can to stay one step ahead of their kids. Personally... I got into the IT business because I was learning all I could to stay ahead of my teen and preteen children. They are now grown - and I have a new generation of children to protect - my grandchildren. I will do so as fiercely as I protected my own children. Maybe more so since I've been involved in this work and have seen the dark side of the internet.

by jdclyde

I see parents that refuse to discipline their children, at home or in public. Don't they see what HORRIBLE people their little angel is going to turn into? Don't they see all the future problems they will face when the get out of the house into the "real world" and discover suddenly that they can't get away with doing anything they want, and the gravy train has ended?

These kids are being hung out to dry, just because a pathectic parent won't say "no" when it is needed.

We have an obligation to know what our children are doing, and to correct them when they go out of acceptable bounds.

At least SOME people are doing something to help the problem (robbi), instead of be the problem.

EVERYONE OF YOU that said this was NOT ethical to do, YOU ARE THE PROBLEM.

by jcolon

I think being a techie you should give your client every option out there. You have to realize that they rely on you to inform them because they dont know what options are out there. The internet is a wonderful place filled with great information on the world, hobbies news etc. They provide games and other fun things to do. BUT, it also has dangerous information that can be harmful and dangerous. Yes kids have rights, great, but parents have the right to protect their kids from harm this is more important than whatever rights a child has. Yes this is pretty much spying on your kids so what it is better to know what is going on than not know and have that chance to step in before it is too late. Stepping in can maybe save the kids life. When do you stop doing so, it is hard to ever stop being a parent and to stop worrying about them? But I go by this expression ...... as long as you are living in my house .......
Suffice to say i think that answers that question!!!!!

by pete1978

Too many parents make one of two mistakes. The First is NOT monitoring. It is essential for the safety of the child. Also, since you own the PC, you have an interest in seeing that it isn't visiting places prone to problems. The second common mistake is monitoring without telling the child. Tell them and tell them why. If you don't tell them, you really are spying! A child doesn't call it spying when you go to the park with them "to watch" because they know you are watching. Don't treat computer monitoring any differently. Tell them you are watching and tell them what you are watching for. If they know up front, it isn't spying and they'll tend to avoid the activites you don't want -- they'll tend to behave more.

When to stop, when the child has demonstrated that you don't need to monitor anymore, or when she/he moves out and get her/his own set of bills paying for her/his own PC and PC activity. Never any sooner.

That's when my wife and I will stop monitoring our son's PC activity (and, yes, he knows we are watching).

by angelohl

Why are you asking this question???! eric.greer said it correctly, they are "YOUR" kids... Not to sound harsh but as with mine, we set aside rules and trust is earned, NOT given, we do this by being open and honest with everything. I know who they talk to (on the phone or off), who they chat with, etc.. This is your responsiblity to raise your kids and GUIDE them, helping them steer clear of the hazzards in the road - this is a FOREVER task, but while their under your roof they have to regardless; filters, rules, triggers, etc. - every country/organization has a tip of the pyrimid that makes the final say-so - YOU ARE IT.

by jdclyde

I already used the "trust is earned, not given" and have copyrighted it! Please send all nickles C/O TR. After they take their agreed on percentage, the rest will be forwarded on to me.

With that remaining money, I will go out and buy more "spy" software to monitor my kids with.

They already swollowed the tracking GPS modual I put in their breakfast, so I know WHERE they are. They noticed the tracking collars I put on them a while back, so had to go with something smaller.

by pete1978

Your question "When is it appropriate, or is it ever, to tell parents that software exists that would allow them to observe what their children do on their computer?"

I think that the better question is "is it ever appropriate to NOT tell the parents about the software?" The answer I would give to this question is "No!" You said they are friends. Then treat them as friends and show you care by telling them about the software.

Just by telling them about the software doesn't force the parent to actually use the software. You are simply giving them an option based on experience and education in computers.

When is appropriate for your doctor to tell you you need to exercise? Every time you visit your doctor, it is appropriate.

When is it appropriate to tell parents that software exists that would allow them to observe what their children do on their computer? Every time you see them, tell them or remind them about the software. Since you addressed this as being friends, they'll tell you when/if they don't want to hear about it anymore. But they will respect that you cared enough to tell them.

by pete1978

AFter telling them about the monitoring, and telling them about the good, bad and ugly of the internet, there is another step. At some point, you need to let the reigns go a little. Let the surf when you are not there (remember that you have the monitoring software YOU TOLD THEM ABOUT still running, so you can review what they did). The important part is that you need to let them learn what to do and what to NOT do. They haven't learned that if they only apply it when you are present.

by snlsm

My nieces frequently IM me at work. One day the younger one, 11 at the time was logged in at a friends house when she contacted me. In the following days when she IM'd me something seemed off. As I talked I started a line of questions that she would skirt the answers and then say she needed to go. The third time this happened I immediately called my sister to see if my niece had been online. She had not. The next day I was IM'd again, and this time I immediately contacted my sister while chatting with "my niece". However, she was not who I was chatting with. What had happened was, when my niece logged into her friends machine, the save ID and password was checked. Now her friend was logging as her and contacting me pretending to be my niece. I copied the text of the dialog and emailed it to my sister, who then went to the friends house. Initially the girl denied doing it, but as soon as the brother saw the wording of the chat, he knew it was his sister. Eventually the girl broke down crying and admitted to the ruse. Both girls where giving a strict talk about keeping the contact information secret and the potential for real danger on chat sites when you don't know who you're talking to. The friend was told how lucky she was that it was "her friends" uncle and not some sicko on the other end.
So make sure that your children aren't leaving behind IDs and password on systems outside your home that would allow someone else to assume their identity and get them in trouble.

by tharmagon

Any responsible parent would not let their child play somewhere potentially dangerous without being present to keep an eye on them. Most parents will stop their children from going to very dangerous places at all. The Internet is the same. You have to watch them and even better stop them going there in the first place. I'm not advocating spying. Just like you wouldn't peak around a fence when your child is playing. You take them and sit in the open watching them. Same with the Internet. You tell them their computers are being monitored and some areas blocked. That is waht being a parent is about ensuring they are safe. Anything else is not being a parent.

by gitmo

I conduct regular audits of my kids' computer time. This is a time to note sites they visit that I would like to encourage as well as spotting inappropriate internet behavior.

Sometimes they are present, and we discuss what we see. But they know I can trace their activities.

I believe a parent must take a page from President Reagan, "Trust but verify". I know a lady who accidently discovered that her trusted teenage daughter had been sending letters to S&M sites about becoming an 'actress'. She hadn't a clue there were issues going on until she found a printed email.

I also get up at night, check the locks on the doors, peek in on my kiddos, and I periodically test my fire alarms and my security systems. It's called responsibility.

by thestorys

Parents have the responsibility to protect their children morally and spirtually from the many dangers and evils that exist.

Kids still living at home should respect their parents' wishes in terms of what they do and view. If they don't like it, they are free to move out, work, get a place and live as they please (although all will give an account before God some day).

Parents shouldn't want their kids to be hitting porn sites or talking to child molesters unaware, etc. and surely shouldn't have to allow it on their dime, and in under their roof.

Child training and communication ahead of time would seem to be the key issue here.

by carljschueler

I work for a school district and part of my job is to watch where students go. It is a double edged sword. Being under protective can result in bad things happening to children who are nieve. Being over protective results in a child who will not be able to appreciatte what you are doing until they are parents themselves. The choice is yours. The results will probably be some place in the middle

Regards,
Carl

by tomacelli

First and formost.IF You have establist an communication dialogue with your child and built up trust and instilled worth while character building blocks . No There wont be a need to do so.For your own children.
for your friends children
You wrote
their parents were concerned, and that it was only to keep them as safe as possible from predators?
my response seek assistance from your local police dept. on this issue . IT is a nationl problem. (pedophile)+ there are parental [ CONTROLS]from your INTERNET SERVICE PROVIDER. RESEARCH THEM.
MY ADAVICE TO THE CHILD NEVER POST YOUR NAME,ADDRESS,TELEPHONE NUMBER. PERIOD.

my answer to the question ....NO NEVER.

DO parents have rights yes but ...
As for helping your neighbor... think twice . its called liability.

by jdclyde

liability from?

Liable for what and from who?

Nothing in your post covered this point.

Explain?

by geekchic

not intrusion, not being nosy, not spying....PARENTING! Sorry don't mean to yell but recently a friend of mine had a teenage daughter that got talked into meeting one of her "online friends" from her My Space site at the local mall. The next thing you know, she is missing for over two weeks and the police found her in another town about 200 miles from where we live. She wasn't sure how she got there, how long she had been there or even why she was there....

I say...spy, get nosy, install sneaky software whatever it takes because talking just doesn't do. This could have been so much worse...what happened to her was bad enough but at least she is safely back home having learned a very hard lesson.

As for how long you keep this up...as my daddy used to say "as long as you are under my roof, you'll do as I say" of course he never really stuck to that but it was tough talk!

Once you have children, you must take responsibilty for them and their welfare.

by jdclyde

It really does my heart good to see someone more concerned with the well being of kids than of being politically correct.

Well done. :x

by geekchic

I love my children more then my own life and if they hated me for a little while when I was "in their business" so be it. They got over it and they are both wonderful young adults. My daughter has a little pin on her purse that says "I am the product of parental supervision" and my son just recently sent me a text message on my cell that said "I couldn't have been raised by better parents".

They make me proud to say that I am their mother!

by dmambo

I'm like Saanta Claus. I see them while they're at school, I see them when they're at friends' homes or when they're knocking around in the woods behind the house. Then I pull this little number on them: "I see you because part of me is inside you and always will be for as long as you live. And part of my dad is in you because he's in me. And a part of you will be in your kids." It's amazing how they react to that. It's kind of my version of a mother's guilt trip.

Oh, and I tell them that they're stuck with the parental control software until they're on their own.

by jdclyde

do you monitor, block, or both?
What do you use?

Girls you have to watch for different reasons. Boys are drawn to porn (we can't help it!) no matter how "well they are raised".
Girls do the chat room and have crazy fantasies (they can't help it!) and go off to mean this "really nice guy".

I have done just the monitor, and after tripping the one up, they have done real good.

They now know that there is NOTHING going on that computer that I don't know about.

Back in 4th grade a nasty site was floating around the school. I found this out when it trashed my system with malware.

Since then, they only trash their mothers computer as she doesn't know how to monitor a computer, and doesn't have the benifit of the software I purchased to find out about her being an adulterousWhore. :O She STILL doesn't know just how much I really found out. Helps to keep HER in line! B-)

by robbi_ia

Just remember - as they get older and smarter, they will figure out how to circumvent that parental control software. That's why so many parents ask me to teach them how to use keyloggers and why it is so important to use every means possible, not just software, not just education, and not just trying to keep an eye on them.

Just as we use a multilayered approach to protect our networks on the job, we must also use a multilayered approach when it comes to protecting our kids.

by ibitguy

When it comes to something like the wonderful no-holds-barred, anything-goes realm of the Internet, I don't think the question is "if" to monitor, but "how often". I Have three boys from 10-18 in age, and they access the Internet with firm and enforced guidelines.

I have monitoring software which I use occasionally to check on their compliance to the rules, but do not monitor absolutely every second. Of course, they
A) don't access the Internet when we are not around... ever (they have to log in to a server and it is set for allowable logon times, and group policies are in effect, but prior to that I had the DSL router on a simple electrical timer in a locked toolbox). The computer they use is also centrally located, and they know that we can at any time walk by and see what they're doing
B) they have to clear all new websites with us in order to have access to them. Once we have cleared it with a password, they are able to access it from that point on. (You wouldn't take them to a bookstore and let them wander around in the porn section would you?)

They also have a set of rules about what they are allowed and not allowed to give out in the way of information about themselves and where they live, and we have explained the possible consequences (including a few rather vivid new stories as examples). For the younger boys, chatting online is limited to IM, and only to approved persons. The older boy is not limited because he has earned our trust through his actions.

To some, our rules/actions may seem "draconian", but the key we've found is to explain to them *why* the rules are what they are, and that thought out, intelligent, reasonable requests for increased/relaxed access are considered. The more maturity and responsibility they demontrate, the more access they get, and the more trust they earn from us.

The bottom line is that they know that we are responsible for their wellbeing and safety, but also for guiding their development until such time as they are experienced and mature enough to warrant appropriate freedoms and privileges. Children are not born knowing everything (even though sometimes they think they do...) and our children understand that until they are of legal adult age our responsibilities will remain, and as *they* mature and become more responsible, we will decrease our hold/control. We've always taken great pains to explain in detail the reasons behind our actions, and the things that they could do to modify those actions on an ongoing basis.

Our children are polite, well balanced, good students, drug free, and thoughtful, and it's *because* we monitored and controlled and made them demonstrate appropriate behaviours to us in order to earn the freedoms that they enjoy. They also feel good about themselves because they've *earned* these freedoms.

Our children were never bothered about their initial levels of monitoring and access, as they knew right up front that *they* were responsible for the controls we put on them through their actions... The faster they became responsible the faster they got the freedom. Yet they know that we *still* monitor their access occasionally to verify their adherance to the current rules... and they're OK with that...

by techinfo.sj

I kept logs of all internet activity when my children were living at home (both now over 21 and left home).
Everyone knew that logs were kept, and where they were, they could read them but not delete them.
They accepted that It was not spying or breach of trust but the same as telling me where they are going and what time to expect them home.
In fact the most useful aspect of this was the ability to enable them to revisit sites they had stumbled upon and found interesting but couldn't remember the URLs

by papawhiskey

A friend of mine was asked by a neighbor who is a single mom to fix a computer that was virtually unusable due to spyware. Apparently her boys had been visiting pornographic website's that just by visiting those site's, had installed spyware on the computer. He reformatted the HD and reinstalled the OS. She also asked what was the best way to monitor her boys activity on the internet. Knowing that her kids were computer savvy, he suggested a keylogger that was virtually indetectable. She agreed and he installed it. When she got the computer back, she told her boys never to go to any pornographic website's.

Sure enough, it wasn't long that she detected that they had gone to pornographic website's again.

If a child, or teenager want's to do something bad enough, he/she will do whatever it takes to deceive a parent.

Building trust with your child is essential, but let me quote a line used by the late President Ronald Reagan, citing an old Russian proverb, told Soviet Premier Mikhail Gorbachev that the foundation for the new US-Soviet relationship surrounding arms control would be:

"Doveryay, no proveryay": Trust, but verify.

by jdclyde

supervise without spying. Nice use of the newest negative buzz word going around now.

It is NOT spying to monitor the usage of your computer. It is just using tools to help you supervise.

Go back and read my posts. I CLEARLY stated that the kids should be talked to and INFORMED that the monitoring software is loaded. If people KNOW they are being watched, they are even more likely to obey the rules of the house.

Trust is earned, not given. Also knowing just how dangerous the internet really is for kids, I will error on the side of caution. I don't let my kids play in the street either. Awful of me to "spy" on them when they are playing to make sure they are safe.

I also watch for weird guys in trench coats at the parks as well.

Same is true for chat rooms where kids are WAY too trusting.

I play Diablo2, and you can chat with your "friends". Had someone come on regularly that I would help, but had to tell her to watch herself when she started telling me about herself. I don't WANT a 13 year old girl telling me their name and what city they live in! States is close enough and come up with a nickname, for cryingoutloud! The next guy might not be as nice as I am, and you hear about the people that want to end up meeting up with the little kids. I QUICKLY set her straight that I was NOT her boyfriend and no one else on the net SHOULD be. That fact that my boys were the same age as her helped me to try to guide her away from this behavior.

A MONTH ago in Detroit, they did a sting operation. Cops posed as a 12 year old girl with parents out of town. They had FIFTY guys taken into custody in two hours for showing up to have sex with the little girl.

Tell me I am over reacting or not being reasonable? Maybe someone will imply you don't care enough or are smart enough to know to be concerned?

by bfilmfan

Okay I was stretching there a bit on making Spock a doctor, but maybe he was and they just never mentioned it?

by maldain

My example comes from my own childhood. It was my sister and myself. My parents believed that I needed to be watched closely or I would get in trouble. They believed that my sister would come to them with the most uncomfortable questions and they could discuss things with my sister openly and frankly. The odd thing was that by the time my sister was 16 she was in jail for GTA and had a problem with seconal (reds). The difference between my sister and myself is my sister learned very early on to tell my parents what they wanted to hear and I just told them what I thought without filtering it. With my own kids, I watch them like a hawk, I monitor their activities and try to remember I'm not their friend I'm their dad and act that way. The world is dangerous and the best any of us can do for our kids is to teach them how to navigate it whether it's the internet or the LA freeway system. I'd rather they suffer a little grief from me not allowing them to do certain things than spend time at hospitals or police stations because of my kids or worse the morgue.

by jdclyde

is something you should be hearing a lot of.

At the age of 15, things all seem so clear and these ranting old people are just out of touch.

It isn't that we don't understand you or what you are going through. It is BECAUSE we DO remember what it was like that we are concerned. We know all the times that the cops never told the parents what had happened at XYZ or all the times you just never got caught.

Again, a reason I am glad I had boys. After thinking about what i have done to other peoples daughters, there is NO WAY on earth no daughter of mine would EVER go out with a guy like me! Just wouldn't be happening! :D

Lem, you WILL see this differently in another ten years. Until then, have fun, be a kid, and respect your parents.

by heml0ck

After all these years the kind of trouble I was getting into... I'm not talking kid stuff here!

Lem, I KNOW what kind of things 15 yr old boys are into... because I was after the same things 20 yrs ago...

Ever heard the expression "been there, done that?"

by dr_zinj

1. Parents are 100% legally responsible for conditions a child is raised in, and for the actions the child takes, up until the child reaches adulthood.

2. Children have no ownership in a household beyond their personal belongings (and even that is arguable). Therefore, parents have the right to dictate how any household resources are utilized.

3. Parents are the executive branch in a household. as such, they have 'law' enforcement authority. Which means they have to have the ability to observe their children's behavior. Computer-usage of any kind is a behavior.

4. You start to lose that option when the kids start renting their rooms, buying their own equipment, paying for their electrical use, and paying for the connection fees.

5. And it does become unethical when you start using it to observe other adults in the household (like your spouse).

by rboucher

I am the parent of an 18 year old who when 16 was involved in explicit conversations with young ladies. After finding this out from another horrified parent, I added "In The Know" to his system and told him about it. This was enough to stop the problem from happening again. We parents must monitor the online activities of our kids. Even if you believe that your kid won't do it, another might be sending disturbing messages/content to them.

by charles

We have our computer (shared by family of six) in the laundry room just off a hallway and next to the kitchen. It is a very central part of our home since our house is only 1080 sq.ft. in size. My oldest son started to dabble in pornography and that was a real wake up call to me that teaching a child to avoid such things, trust, etc. was not going to work. I installed Net Nanny and that brought a great amount of relief. I now could see where they have been (to some extent) and prevent them from being bombarded by porn. As we all know, porn and questionable material still seems to find them. We have talked till we are blue in the face and constantly had to deal with our oldest boy who developed an addiction to hardcore pornography. I since have installed 007 Spy Software, let it operate for several days and held a family council in front of the computer with the entire family. I then showed each of the children the various logging functions of the software, in great detail so they would know that I am watching them and I do spend time seeing where they have been and what they spend their time on while on the computer. I was discrete and made sure not to embarrass anyone. I told them if they did not like the software then tough! They do not get computer time, school or no school. The greatest complement I received was when I was checking through the screen shot log of a period of time when my oldest son was on the computer, he had opened the Windows Paint Program and wrote, "DAD I KNOW YOUR WATCHING, LOVE YA". From that point on I knew I had done the right thing.

by j_s_d

As a parents my wifer & I are 100% responsible for my childrens safety and for raising them to be good citizens. The Internet is a very dangerous place - and they are children.

From our childrens perspective (2 boys aged 9 & 5) our home is a benevolent dictatorship, not a democracy. We ask their opinion when making some decisions but are often not concerned with their opinion. If we have sought their opinion, we take it into account. We explain our decisions but they are not up for negotiation. We constantly move the line as they mature.

We want my 9 year old to grow & learn, but in a safe constructive way. With this in mind we participate in some of his 'on-line' time and allow him some unsupervised Internet access. We have explained some of the dangers but at 9 there are still subjects that our eldest is not yet equipped to grapple with.

We put him on trust to follow the rules we have set down for unsupervised Internet time. We have also explained that I have installed software on this computer that allows me to see EVERYTHING that he does - all emails, all web sites, all IMs, everything.

One of the non negotiable rules for Iinternet access is that we can see anything he does on the computer - no secrets. Had he not agreed to these terms, there would have been no Internet access - simple.

Thus we have rules and trust and limits. If he abuses our trust, we will know and there will be consequences. Likewise, if we abuse his trust (by abusing our ability to monitor his activity) we will suffer consequences. This arrangement is working well.

by robbi_ia

JD - boys can be lured into a predator's clutches just as easily as girls. And there are quite a few predators who target boys because "boys don't tell".

you didn't spy on your ex, did you? for shame!

by jdclyde

and having the few things I DID show her are all that kept me from having to pay child support.

We have joint physical custody, meaning I have them physically half the time.

I informed her I would not give her lovers wife a "care package" if she just walked away and let me carry on with my life.

I won't stand in the way of her "happiness" and she stays out of my pocket. Sounds like a deal to me! B-)

[i]readers digest version, hard cover edition was in the divorce discussion last summer that you probably missed. After all, it was only the second largest discussion in the history of TR. ;\

by inknpaper

What a mess.. You can't believe anyone would reply to this post,
yet you yourself posted a reply. Then you reply with that kind of
response.
I visited your website, If I were a business looking for help, I
would most likly avoid your company for the simple fact that it
looks very messy and unorganized. Too many ad's.. very bad for
business. I would recommend getting a "REAL" host for your site.
I wouldn't recommend your services to anyone unless they were
enemies !
I would think twice about replying to a post in that way and
claim to be a professional. You will save yourself the humility!

Just my 2 cents

by tory

.the perspective of an adult. You may think you do, and your post belies a belief that you are much wiser than this man who has light years more life experience than you do.

Wait until it is your child.

by lemeilleurdumonde

First of all, sorry if my post seen to tell that I was wiser than this man.Yes, he probably have more life experience than me but why is he spy,block and restric his computer in place of sharing his life experience with his children.Why hide the reality when it's sure that someday he will see it (and what a shock he will have).By the way I'm not saying that "Supervision" on the internet is a bad think but too many lead to the rebellion.I have parent, they do not spy all my moves and it's one of the reasons why I respect and trust them.

by luke4k

Some people (kids too) are naturally responsible and perhaps would never give out their email, telephone number, etc. or meet a stranger on the web. Now... Lem, perhaps you've seen a few of the so many stories of kids who did meet people, get killed, raped, assaulted, etc., and people do get addicted to internet porn, chat, cybersex, etc. IT'S A FACT. READ and you will see it all out there in cyber space! (probably not on "My Space" but you never know ;-). I don't have the stats in front of me but most porn is view by kids under 20. The stats are impressively BAD - very scary. Most kids get first hard porn experience at 14.

And, by the way, the trusted psychologist, top in his field, says that my son is getting much to much exposure to such things at much too early an age. It will cause development issues for a natural sexual development. But, he only has three Phds. on the board of AZ Psch board, etc. So, we can discount him too?

Remember that my son KNEW the program was running. He was trusted with an admin ID. But he went to the sites, did the distrustful and unacceptable. He changed a user password to access where he didn't belong. So, now you say, I should trust him. He's not trustworthy. He needs to EARN trust.

Now, I don't expect you to have parenting skills at 15. Your perspective is immature, your logic is flawed and simple. It would be like just sending kids off into the night without having them tell you where they were going.

There are dangers in the world. Parents have to figure out how to protect their kids. I bet my 15 year old has more freedom than you, has been more places, done more things and can relate with adults AS an adult. BUT, he's still a kid.

As well, internet porn, chat, sex, etc. are all addictive behaviour. Perhaps we should let all the police officers go since we might just as well TRUST EVERYONE to obey the laws. We can let the judges go, use the court rooms for basketball or something.... If a few die, oh well... they should have know.

Of course we would NEVER do that. But isn't that the same logic.

My son is learning to respect his elders (not just parents). Consider Japanese Karate, no matter what your rank or my rank, I always outrank you until you become an adult,and you will always be required to treat me as such even if I am just a white belt to your black no matter what level...

Sam Clemens says it best....

"When I was a boy of 14, my father was so ignorant I could hardly stand to have the old man around. But when I got to be 21, I was astonished at how much the old man had learned in seven years. "

By the way, Sam Clemen's pen name is Mark Twain... just in case you haven't read it quite yet ;-).

by tory

See I do have your perspective. But what I think you're thinking and what we're thinking are two different things. Your perspective is "Someday they will see so why not let them see it now?"

Well there are a few reasons. First of all, you may not even be aware of all the things that are out there. I'm sure I know most of them, but there are probably a few things that would curl my hair even at my ripe "old" age.

Second of all, there is such a thing as age appropriate. We're not talking bad slasher movies where the first girl to show her hoo hoos gets axed. We're talking about some pretty raunchy stuff, and/or dangerous stuff that many young teens just plain do NOT need to be exposed to.

Then there is the issue of, whether we like it or not, on the Internet there are some "not nice people." Those not nice people prey on kids your age and YOU may be savvy enough to see right through them, or maybe not. A predator hones his craft. So this "nice guy" that your average low-self-esteem teenage girl meets in a chat room may be one of those "not nice people" and may very well manipulate her into doing something that no one would DREAM she'd ever do. I know adults who had fallen prey to people in chat rooms, so I'm not going to make the mistake with a child of mine that it might happen to him/her.

I do think you're right about spying. I don't think it needs to be spying. I think it needs to be "Hey, here's the computer. It's in the office. I can and will check on what you do any time. I'm sorry if you don't like it, but here's why I'm doing it. If you want to try to get around it, I'll lock up the computer and send you back to Amish land!" (Last part was a joke, of course.)

I use a program to monitor students in my classroom. They know it...therefor it isn't spying. We actually have some fun with it and it helps them to stay on the straight and narrow and not waste time surfing the net. They know a few ways around it but I know how to get around that (it is an ongoing challenge to them to try to get around me...I may be a thin, blonde, older, and of the female persuasion but I know my stuff when it comes to computers and I've yet to find a kid who could get around me).

It isn't that I don't trust them, it is that I know kids and I know that they can get into trouble, sometimes even without trying, and that they don't always make the wisest decisions. That's okay...that's what being a teenager is all about. Thing is, some of the mistakes that can be made on the "net" are deadly. I'd hate to think that for want of proper supervision that a child makes a fatal mistake!

by x-marcap

Since you are in rebellion, but a subtle one, I would homeschool you and wake you to reality Stalag Sanko.

M-F
5:00 A.M. Calesthenics
5:30-6:00 Shower,shave,etc
6:00 - 2:00 education with a breakfast and lunch
one of the two meals you will cook...
2-4:30 personal reading time...
4:30-6:00 Dinner and dishes...
6-9 Somewhat free time. Music lessons, special classes,(Math above Integral Calculus,Physics C++, Smalltalk, etc.) No driving privs until you are 18...

Within the education time and free time are things like Karate class, Trombone/trumpet/piano/guitar/ bass lessons. 1/2 hour practice per instrument.

I suspect you need better, tougher activities...

by jeff the project manager

What is the definition of a parent? Someone who makes the hard choices and helps the child become an adult. That means making the important choices for your child until they are ready to.

That means until my children are out of the house, I will monitor all of their computer activity. It's a dangerous world, and I will make sure that I am helping shape their values, and not a stranger to my house. And that includes anyone who puts up a web site.

But it's not just about installing monitoring software. Our computers are out in the open, where anyone can walk by and see what's going on at any time. Evil loves darkness (out of sight), and keeping everything out in the open is the best policy.

That's my job as a parent, and to do any less would be a violation of my responsibilities.

by matthew.persico

I sum it up like this:

Would you let your child out of your car in Times Square (plug in your home-town downtown section here) unsurpervised for any length of time? Then why would you let your child loose on the Internet without supervision?

by mrironleg

Until the child is out of the house, the parent is completely within there rights spying on them.

by richard

then I agree to using "spy ware" to monitor what is going on. After all, this is your system and they are only users. Besides, we owe it to our kids to protect them.

The predators are out there and they are getting slicker everyday.

This is no different than checking up on the kids a few years back by asking neighbors and friends if they had seen the kids while they were out on a date.

I remember when I was the kid and mom found out things that I thought she would never find out about. Thank goodness she did.

With the profileration of web blogs today it is easy for them to get in up over their necks in trouble by not adhearing to the basic principles of safe practice on the web.

Just my view point...take it or disagree with it.

by mholdcraft

If you have concerns, then yes you should monitor your children's internet use. How long? Until you feel they are mature enough and have the good judgement to protect themselves. The threat is not just from internet predators, but also from easily available pornography on the internet. Age doesn't matter. If they live under your roof and they are still naive, curious or rebellious, then you should watch what they do. If after a while you see that they are not misusing the computer, then you can back off of the monitoring.

by mholdcraft

You should talk to your children about the dangers on the internet and how you expect then to use the computer(what type of sites to avoid), but I don't believe you should necessarily let them know you monitor their internet use. You can't be there all the time, and kids are curious. If something is forbidden, they will look when you are not looking. So my advice is monitor them, without their knowledge for a while. If you don't see any misuse after a while then you can drop the monitoring or use it only occasionally just to check. Some kids will always folow the rules, others will immediately go where they are told not too. Until you know which type you are dealing with - keep the monitoring a secret. Trust works both ways and is built over time, not up front. Checking up on them makes good sense until you have some level of confidence they can be trusted not to access areas you specifically dispprove.

by mholdcraft

Every kid is different. You have built up a rapport and hopefully that will continue. Not all Parents are in your position. If you are not sure you can trust you son or daughter to follow rules to protect themselves, then monitor them. I have two children, one was like you and your son, the other was just the opposite. If you discussed areas that he should avoid, he would be there that same day. His personality was just the type that was going to challenge any limitations on his freedom - even from the age of 4 he always pressed the envelope to see how much he could get away with. Candy and soft drinks were his first abuse items, then as he aged it became adult magazines, alcohol, the experimenting with drugs. I constantly received emails inviting me to this porn site or that one. I could not understand how my address got on their lists. By accident I discovered he was going to these sites (many are free)and signing up. I finally had to stop him from using my computer totally. I could not control what he watch at other locations, but I could at my home. He didn't agree with me or his mom. Thank God at age 22, married and with his own child coming, he finally matured enough to see and understand what we were doing. So I say secretly monitor until you have some confidence that you can trust their judgement.

by jdclyde

just because you have the ABILITY to monitor everything they do, doesn't mean you have to go over everything with a fine tooth comb.

Load the software, and if something comes up, you can see what is there. Much better than just sitting around wondering.

by dbucyk

I had a stepson who decided to go on the computer one day. We had trusted him that he could go on the internet and do some research for his schoolwork.

Low and behold. I had Windows's 98 on the hard disk drive and I still have the same copy on it today.

When I went to do regular maintenance to the computer, I found out that there was a explicit link embedded on the startup menu. Also, after checking the temporary internet files the stepson who was the only person home at the time was searching on the internet by typing in explicit words to check it out. I caught him red handed and he still denied it!

At that point I spent countless hours researching registry tweaks, security tweaks, patches, and enabling content advisor, adding popup toolbar 3.0 to internet explorer, zonealarm, and adaware se and other tools to fight this problem.

Now I realise kids are getting smarter and smarter and it's up to the parents to decide when is enough because, I feel if they still live in your household, they still have to comply with all the rules.

It is also the responsibility of the parent to look into the problem and take appropriate action.

by driv101

Its good to see some one takeing their parent hood like it should be go get em...

by steve-nyeoka

Our son still lives with us, and his PC is in the living room where we can still keep an eye on it.

If he don't like it there are plenty of appartments in the paper....

by anom_amos1

Over protecting children only causes them greater harm.
Spying on a childs web habits won't help you protect them from preditors. You'd need to spend twice as many hours reading and studying every detail of there activity as they spend on the net. Then there are text messages on phones and many other ways they can avoid being noticed by you.
The best approach would be to simple teach the childern what may be harmful to them than try to hide it from them. A couple of nightmares is far less harmful than what may befall them if they are taken by a predator.
What I suggest in the way of technological monitoring if you still want to do that, is a modified spam filter that instead of blocking the dangerous sites and emails flashes a warning to the child and sepreately to the parent a Stranger Danger Alert! If a child knows that the 13 year old girl / boy they are chatting to is really or likely to be a 40 year old peadaphile they will probably seek help to identify the person as genuine or bogus instead of defying their aprents and continuing to talk to the preadator thinking they have a friend that understands them etc.
There is a line from the bible "god helps those who help them selves" this applies to children if you help them to protect them selves they are far less likely to fall prey to a peadaphile than if you try to block all knowledge of such creatures from them.

by genphil

You B**tards!

As much as I love South Park, anyone who thinks it's OK for a six-year old to watch it is seriously lacking in grey matter. Come to think of it they probably shouldn't even be watching it himself, as he shows that he can't put the content in the right context, see one of my earlier posts.
On the other hand I would see no harm when a well-adjusted, well-behaved teenager would watch it. Because he can appreciate that the behaviour in the show is so out of whack that it's fun, but not to be replicated in real life. Never the less the show points out some idiosyncracies of our societies by exagerating them which can make you think about them, also a good pastime for soon-to-be-adults.

but I'd like to give Mr Garrison the final word:
"South Park in combination with little kids is bahd 'mkay?"

by jdclyde

My boys are 13, and I still haven't shared South Park, the movie with them yet.

It is easily my most watched dvd and was the second I ever purchased. (the first being The Matrix).

We DID watch Bevis and Butthead, Do America not long ago, but I hesitate with the SP. The whole Uncle F'er song, I don't think I would like them singing that....

They are getting closer, but I haven't decided when to make the jump.

Note: they LOVE The Holy Grail, and finally understand why the crazy old man would say some things and then giggle. Now that they are in on the joke, "It's just a flesh wound" is MUCH more amusing.... :D

by andy

If there's one question guaranteed to get people all fired up its this one. Thats because there is no right or wrong answer to it. Little Johnny could be the curious type who's going to look at all kinds of things his parent dont want him to see because thats the kind of kid he is. Little Jimmy isnt like that and never goes beyond his favourite comic site. Little Joanie is naive to the ways of the world and has a could chance of being taken advantage of by others incyber space.

My point is people are different. What works for one doesnt work for another. You have to remember that computers are everywhere and what they done look at at home they could easily peruse elsewhere. SO saying no just means "not here".

The simplest solution is to have the computer in a central place, like a family room where everyone hangs out. Its unlikely little johnny is gonna go look at porn-is-us.com while the family are sat around watching tv. In his own room away from casual glances Little Johnny can get away with whatever he wants.

Chances are if your kids dont want you to see what they are doing its because you wouldnt approve, and they would probably be right. So dont play into their hands, keep the PC where everyone can see whats going on and your problems, at home at least, will be resolved.

I take great exception to those that think spying on your kids is ok. You dont follow them to school, you dont follow them when they go out and you dont read their diaries. You give them trust, you teach them responsibility. Yet because its a computer and YOU dont understand it you think it gives you the right to monitor their every keystroke. In the same way that the courts allow kids to divorce their parents its only a matter of time until a child brings an invasion of privacy type lawsuit against an adult for installing "spyware for your kids" on a PC.

Trust your children, reduce the risks by keeping the family PC where the famly can see it, lay down the rules on what is and isnt acceptable and the penalties if those rules are broken and if having a computer in the house is making you that paranoid, get rid of it.

Would you let your children play with anything else that gave YOU this much angst?

by unclerob

You can take as much great exception as you like, I don't call paying attention to what my kids do as spying, I call it parenting. Maybe it's just me but I happen to take great interest in my kid's lives and take great pride in their growth & development.

When a kid divorces his parents, do you really believe it's because of spying, or is it maybe because of some form of child abuse, either mental, emotional, sexual or physical. Let's get real here, I don't see kids divorcing their parents at such a great rate for any other reason. A privacy lawsuit especially one concerning spyware (yes I know this was just an example) against a parent from his child isn't going to make it anytime soon, I haven't heard of anything similar to this myself lately - have you?

Another thing, FYI - If I don't drop them off at school, I know the bus is taking them there. I don't read their diaries but I do speak to their teachers, monitor absences & lates, review their report cards, help with homework and ensure they're succeeding and growing up properly. Religion in all it's forms, ie. christianity, muslim, hebrew, etc. (something I won't bring up for discussion in this forum) also helps with another facet of their development, their spirituality and all the benefits that it provides those that follow a faith.

Trusting your children and being absent in their daily lives are two different things, don't compare the two as it doesn't work. You're either a parent or a housemate, which are you? Being friends with my kids is important but being a parent is ultimately more important as I'm responsible for seeing them grow up,develop & mature into adulthood.

Just to give you an example of what happens when parents don't take an active role in their kid's lives: How about those kids that brought firearms to school and hurt/killed several classmates (ex. Columbine anyone?). I'm sure their parents "trusted" them enough to not take any type of involvement in their kids daily lives, that means school work, friends, internet & pc use, what's in their rooms, finding out if their kids smoke, drink or do drugs, so on & so forth. Was this type of problem commonplace 30 years ago - I think not, unfortunately it seems to be almost commonplace nowadays in school systems across the U.S. - maybe explain that to me if you can because I'm at a loss to explain it any other way. Consider the type of difference that could have been made if the parents of these troubled teens took a more active role in their kids lives and had a clue as to what they were doing.

If I have to agree with you on one point just to show that I was listening to your argument, I would wholeheartedly agree with your solution on having a computer in a common place, ex. family room where everyone does hang out and it's much harder to hide your online activity that way & I also agree on implementing penalties for illicit use of the computer (ie. revoking use privileges for a set period of time or maybe indefinitely, depends on what they did).

Don't make kids out to be mysterious enigma's, although kids are different, rules & routines work with all kids - that isn't a question, it's pretty much a fact. The only thing that is questionable, is the amount of effort a parent puts into their children, this is definitely the 'X' Factor in a child's development and it is something that definitely changes from household to household.

- just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree.

by too old for it

You forgot little Lolita, who thinks her parents don't give a d@mn, and is also of the opinion that any guy under 35 is a child.

Scary kids are out there ...

by tech.docs

Whether you believe it or not, God clearly outlines in His word (the bible) that we are responsible, and will be judged based on how our children turn out. I'm not saying you rule with an iron fist, no, that would be wrong. I'm saying that you should be involved in their lives, and help them to build their own integrity and ability to make valid choices. Monitor them, and tell them they are being monitored and tell them it's not easy so you're going to do everything in your ability to help them turn out to be productive members of society. If more parents cared about their children and became an active part of their lives, right from birth, we wouldn't have near the problems in this world that we have now. Love them first...

by blueknight

"Train up a child in the way he should go [and in keeping with his individual gift or bent], and when he is old he will not depart from it."
[i]Proverbs 22:6 (Amplified version)[/i]

by geekchic

I agree that love and giving some attention is the most important part in raising children. However, I attended a Woman's Conference in Texas recently and started up a conversation with a young lady that was about to give birth to her first child. We were discussing things like reading to/with them at an early age, rocking them to sleep, cuddling and playing games, the importance of regular bed times, doing homework together, long walks to hunt for cool stuff, etc.

Another woman came up and started talking about what she felt was important in the "raising up" of children. Her opinion was that "God told her" that she should use a stick that she "lovingly" called "Mr. Stick" to "rule over" her children. In fact she was very proud to say that even though her son was in his middle 20's and married with children of his own, if she called for him come to her across the baseball field where he coached children, he would be there in about 10 seconds...still to this day! Out of fear....I really don't think that is what God had in mind. Discipline yes...scare tactics and physical abuse no. Not that I am against an ocassional pop on the rear but I am not a big fan of using sticks...even if God came down and personally told me too!

by jdclyde

on your nutcase mother there! :D

a weapon should never be needed by a parent to discipline a child. If the flat of your hand across the bottom isn't enough, then you have much bigger problems to worry about.

by jdclyde

it seems as far as my 13 year old boys are concerned, [b]I[/b] haven't hit the stupid stage yet.

by lemeilleurdumonde

I agree with you, there are Psychos who kills kids , drug who kills kids and sex which does kill if you don't take a bath often :-D . But there is not only psycho on Internet
and there are not only crazy in the streets. Same thing for the drugs, just need to avoid them and judgement can do that.You do not follow your son in all the
streets of the neighbourhood. You do not spy him when he is at school then why make it when he is on the computer. If you give to your son as much liberty
it is that in a ways you have trust and you know that he have a good judgement.You say that he had a monitoring program on his computer before he try
to change the admin pass but why did you put a program if before this incident you trust him.You believe that my perspective is imature but it is simply because it
is not in your value and in what "simple" is a lack ,why alway makes things complex. But their is a thing where you have reason, I'am not an adult or a parent, I'am not
in your shoes, you know things that I still don't know. Learning to respect his eldes is a good value but you dont have to spy him to teach that.

Finally I find more imature your way of turning my statements in something unreasonable.

by jdclyde

So you don't lock your car, your house, your office, no passwords on your computer, and so on?

Glad that your trust has seemed to be paying off for you.

by unclerob

Parents are responsible for the safety, well being & ultimate development of their children until they become adults. Ethics are not even a factor when it comes to what their children are doing on computers inside their own home. Who provided the computer to the children, I'm sure they didn't go out & purchase it themselves (unless Daddy Warbucks is handing out unreal allowances to his kids - that's another topic of discussion altogether).

If we implement strict firewall restrictions, usage monitoring & logging along with internet & email content/spam filters along with antivirus & antispyware real-time protection at work without any fear of ethics infractions why should it be any different at home. Of course you should definitely restrict what they do on their computers & monitor what they do on their computers - anything less would make you a lazy & irresponsible parent in my eyes.

Definitely talk to your kids about computer & internet usage, explain to them that aside from the many positive aspects a computer offers, it also allows access to content that isn't suitable for children and that they shouldn't attempt to access that type of material at all regardless of the reason or circumstance. I would also talk to them and let them know that you would be monitoring their computer usage to ensure that they aren't using this resource that you've provided to them for anything that would be considered immoral, unethical, irresponsible or illegal. For example, explain the dangers that chat rooms can pose, that the internet grants a type of anonymity to it's users, they may think that they're talking to another young person when in fact they could be communicating with some type of child predator or worse. You should always explain both the positive & negative aspects of using a computer & the internet. We have tv & radio commercials sponsored by the local police that talk about this very situation and how parents should take an active (not reactive) role in monitoring their kid's computer usage.

In fact you should be more restrictive in your home. You shouldn't allow your kids to do whatever they want until they are adults who understand what real responsibilities are and have a good idea of where they're moral obligations lie.

Let me tell you something, my immediate moral obligation to my kids is to ensure that they don't access any type of content on their pc's/internet that would be considered questionable even for someone who is legally considered to be an adult. That means they won't illegally download software, music any any other content which would constitute some form of software/music piracy or copyright infringement. They won't access access inappropriate adult sites containing content not suitable for children (or adults for that matter).

Just like it's my responsibility to ensure that my kids don't view any type of tv program that may contain questionable content, implement any type of v-chip controls in my tv's if possible to ensure that when I'm not around that they can't access that type of content even if they try to. Viewer's discretion is always advised, that means parents should always make sure that the content being accessed is age appropriate and suitable for their children, the same rules apply to computer/internet usage - User's discretion if you want to call it that, is ALWAYS advised.

What kind of parent would give their kid 'carte blanche' to do whatever they wanted. Kids learn best by rules & routine, if you don't believe me speak to the best parents, teachers, doctors, child psychologists/psychiatrists & even Dr.Phil himself. Who in the world would ever think that their kid (or any kid for that matter) should be allowed to do what they want on their computer? What's next, hand the keys to the SUV to the kid when he turns 16?

If you are a parent, you're responsibility is to make sure your kid grows & develops into a responsible adult and reaches adulthood. Being the kid's best friend although admirable, is not even 2nd on the list. If you're a parent and don't already know that, you may have some problems, pick up a few books on good parenting skills, speak to a family therapist, do something but get a clue. Giving your kid everything they want without installing some sense of right & wrong & responsibility will lead to a lazy kid without any type of moral identity and at that point, you have kissed any type of ethics out the window.

When does this monitoring stop? Good question, even when the kids leave home one day when they're adults, you'll always be a parent to them but obviously at that point, you have to rely on the fact that the upbringing you've provided to them will carry them throughout the rest of their life.

If you have to pin an age number on it, how about until they stop living at home or up until 18. At that point, you have to assume they're old enough to make the right decisions, if you haven't done your parenting job & raised a responsible person, nothing else you do after that age will matter a whole lot. Just remember, nobody is asking you to be a totalitarian nazi about this but you shouldn't be non-existent either, your presence should always be known and if you've raised them right, they'll be able to come to you and discuss anything with you and you'll be able to do the same with them.

.... just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree.

by blueknight

I totally agree with you. Your comments are worth much more than 0.0176376 USD (exchange rate sucks) ;-)

by unclerob

it's awesome to hear that someone else values their children and understands that active parenting makes a real difference in their lives.

I tend to be verbose sometimes (even I get tired of reading my posts), I'm surprised someone actually read my post, let alone replied to it.

Thanks for listening, I appreciate the feedback.

by blueknight

In today's society it is very definitely appropriate to let parents know about any tools that can help them keep their children safe.

Give them the information and let them decide whether to install and use it.

My thinking is that if you install such a tool, you also need to sit down with your kids and tell them about it and that the only reason you have it is to make sure they stay safe. Explain to them the perils of the Internet. If you don't know about what can happen to your kids online, go talk to Investigators at your local police department. I knew there was a lot of bad stuff out there, but after taking a computer forensics and internet crimes class at the police academy, I was amazed at how much potential there is or kids to be exploited. [b]You need to stay involved with your kids.[/b] If you don't have the time, don't even think about having kids.

Being one who grew up in the 50's and 60's, I would be inclined to limit computer use for general surfing to certain hours each evening. Surfing to do research for homework assignments wouldn't apply to the "quota."

I would also make sure I spent time with my kids to stay involved with them. If you spend quality time with them (even show them some cool web sites you've found) they will appreciate you for it. You also need to let them have some time for themselves. By staying involved, you show them that you love them and you also [b]foster mutual trust.[/b] That trust is worth its weight in gold because if they trust you, they'll be much more likely to talk to you about problems as well as good times.

Now, back to the spy software. If you plan to use it, tell your kids and be very clear. If you find that they don't visit questionable web sites and are responsible in their use of the Internet, you can cut down on your spying activities - or even stop. Remember that trust thing? Be honest with them. They'll trust you, and you'll find you can trust them. But it all starts with your staying involved and interacting with them. They are family, not objects or possessions.

Do it right, and I won't have to help locate your missing child.

by unclerob

... and I couldn't have said it better myself, I'm assuming since it would seem that you're professionally involved in helping keep people safe & help in maintaining law & order , I would say you have alot more than a educated clue or hunch on this topic.

I hope other people read your post and get a clue as to how serious this topic really is.

by mlayton

What are the ethics of watching the children's tv screen? Of course you monitor what they watch. That's why you are the parent. Of course you implement appropriate controls, even if your version of appropriate controls is you sitting in the room when they watch tv. Why is it different if the screen is connected to the Internet?

by unclerob

You're absolutely right,
I don't see how why some people can't make the same association. If some tv programs contain adult material which may not be suitable for children and advise that Parental/Viewer discretion is advised, why wouldn't you apply the same type of thinking when it comes to computer/internet usage?

I guess some parents are content to let their children raise themselves and then wonder why they turn out the way they do when something goes wrong.

My question is this, if people are not willing to take an active parenting role in their kid's lives, why did they become parents to begin with? If some would blame it on unplanned pregnancies, they would only be making my argument for me as it would still lead back to the original question of why parents aren't actively involved in their kids lives - irresponsible parenting leads to irresponsible children who become parents & repeat the cycle.

by dboxman7

These are children unless they are emancipated and on their own. This country has warped the concept of parental rights and the "rights" of children. If the need exists: "spy" away. The parent/adult should, again SHOULD, be the better judge of what is appropriate. No, I am not a parent, but I am a teacher and have too often seen the results of hands-off parenting.

by too old for it

(Disclaimer: I had my chance to get a degree in sociology once, and decided on IT instead - silly me!)

I wish I could land the funding to compare other countries ... let's say Denmark, The Netherlands, The Czech Republic, Cambodia, and Singapore for starters ... to the U.S. as far as crimes that could be prevented by, oh let's say, a little education and parental involvement?

(I'm still convinced schools and parents need to be on the same page, or it just gives rise to other conflicts ... but that's me.)

by amcol

I'll save you the trouble of my usual long-windedness in replying because Tory and Slog have both said it far better than I ever could.

It is precisely because kids are smarter than you think that you MUST monitor their use of the Internet. No matter how cogent and wonderful your explanations to your children, by not monitoring them you're relying on their ability to process your explanations on a rational adult level. They're kids...they can't do that. I can cite you medical chapter and verse on this if you like.

A parent's job is to draw a box around their children. That's called setting boundaries. The child's job is to push against those boundaries...that's called growing up. A smart parent allows the child to push and keeps moving the boundaries back until they're no longer needed. A responsible parent knows which parts of the box have to remain stronger and longer than others, and Internet usage is one area that highly qualifies.

by steve

Ok, first yes I trust my kids. I do not trust anyone else out there on the internet. I have told the kids since they have been using the PC that everything they do is recorded. Everything they type, they read or see. Every webpage (either they type in, or popup) is recorded. There is a screen shot every 10 seconds. It also looks for keywords. Does not matter if it is typed, viewed or copied to the clip board. Do I look at them? Yes. Every day? No. I look at them if I get alerts from the software. I think is vital to have that on every pc that a child has access to. I will stop the day they move out and get their own PC. If that PC is on my network in my house, it is monitored.

by brigand

Would you bring a pedophile / sexual predator into your home to have a private chat with your kid?

Do you have a internet connection and allow our kids to participate in unmonitored chat?

CONGRATULATIONS! You just brought a pedophile / sexual predator into your home to have a private chat with your kid!

Oh, buy the way, after you get done with the police report, expect a visit from social services, if you have any kids that survived, you may never see them again ether. Just a thought.

They are your children, you have a legal responsibility to protect them, PERIOD!

So, should you monitor your children?

by asimmons13

The idea that looking in on childrens computer activities is the equivalent of spying is in the same category of believing that changing a babies diaper and wiping their bottom is pedophilia. Children are NOT small adults. Medical science can show anyone that the brain does not reach maturity until 22 or 23 and lets not forget the hormonal rages of puberty which can vary as much as 5 years in onset and duration. If you cannot monitor your childs activities, computer related or otherwise, you have no business having children. It is a responsibility not a right.

by ali40961

I think that if the parents are going to use any logging sw, the kids should be told. Straight up.
Secondly, the kids of today have been raised using computers -at school or at home, and many are more technologically savy than their parents -especially teens. So this kind of sw is pretty useless if u have teens.

For younger children, parents must periodically (meaning FREQUENTLY)check out what their young children are doing while on the computer/internet.
BE ESPECIALLY wary of chat rooms, whatever the site.

I have two teenage sons, 17 and 13. They both have their own pcs, and have had them since they were very little. (Mom is a geek) While I did not use Net Nanny or any of the others, I did check their histories and temp files to see what they were viewing. We discussed chat rooms (esp the dangers)as soon as they were at the age to enter them. TALK to your kids. If you are open minded and non judgemental, you will learn a lot. They think they are invincible. You are the parent. You have a responsibility to TRY to keep them safe. My youngest chatted with a possible predator but because I FREQUENTLY checked what he was doing, I caught the suspect and was able to report him. I took control of the conversation immediately, without the suspect knowing I did. MONITOR your kids as much as you possibly can. If you can't be there, limit their access to the internet. There are many ways this can be done without software.

Yes my boys went to porn sites. Their pcs became infected very rarely as I use several spyware, etc protection programs. I would rather have spyware/trojan/pest protection than monitoring sw.
And we talked about the dangers of that. But kids will be kids. And if they want to do something badly enough, they will find a way.

Lastly, never underestimate your kids. The world they are growing up in is filled with much more information, both good and bad, than the world we were raised in.

by techiewayne

Why is this such a moral issue when it IS the SAFTEY of our children we are talking about? Business do this on a regular basis every day 24/7 for the so called data integrity and to make sure employee's are productive during business hours. There are absolute horror stories of all kinds of after affects of chat and my space encounters that go bad. So why do we monitor and block tv and internet content we dont want our kids exposed to, to protect them. So why take the most proactive approach possible, utalize the resources/programs available to you. Protect your children whatever it takes.

by bsb_lib

I don't think it is a double standard at all...I think the problem is far more complex than this. As an example of the difference, I choose where to work and what level of personal information etc to give to that employer. If I don't mind being drug tested I work in one area. If I do, I limit my career to areas not yet testing. Obviously, kids can't make that decision. I think, personally, that I come down pretty heavily on observation and transparency for everyone...but I can hear many kids in the background (depending on their age) saying "is it okay then if I have the ability to watch what you do?" And I would have to say, at least up until an age that would be determined by each child, that it's my job as a parent to "know best". I DO think that transparency and communication are so important because I think that overall this really does make sense, but that it also could create serious psychological issues. Many of us know an intrusive parent. What is healthy to them may not be to us. How will their kids be affected by these issues?

by nicknielsen

I agree with you that an active involved parent is the best approach. However, events conspire and we can't always be there for our kids. Would I install tracking software for those occasions? I don't know. But I would defenitely install NetNanny or some other screening software.

What age to stop? When you determine they are old enough to browse & surf responsibly.

If they complain? Your house, your rules.

by steve

First we have a 7 year old girl, 11 year old boy and a 13 year old girl. Second, I have told the kids that everything they do is recorded. A screen does pop up when ever they log in and reminds them.

OK I have posted on this topic a few days ago. I have come back and looked and seen a portion of the people are against it. I just sat down with our 11 year old boy and asked him about the monitoring. He is aware that I monitor everything they do on ALL (7) PC's in our house. The software that I use is installed on their computer. This software will search all text on a page, as well as text that is typed or received via email or chat. If certain 'Keywords' are found, then an alert is sent to me via email. At that time when I get an alert, I will look into their logs. The alert tells me what time certain words were detected, so I look at only the logs around that time. If the keywords are bad (example the word SEX is one of the key words. Sometimes I get an alert and I look at the word Sex Scandal is on MSN.com) then I will step in and either talk to them or if the situation warrants pull their PC access.

Example- A few months ago I got an alert that the 13 year old girl typed our address. I looked into this and found she was talking to a college boy and lied to him about her age. She told him she was 17 years old. Luckily I was at my PC when this alert came in. I went to her and talked to her about it. I then showed her on the internet about the danger of doing that. My question is, what would have happened if I had no clue. If she talked to him for awhile and then one day they agreed to meet? Was he really a college student? Was he some older man/women that was looking for young girls? I will never know what could have happened, but I can lay my head down on my pillow each night knowing that I have helped to keep my child safe.
I also know this is not fool proof. The younger we start our kids on PC, the more knowledgeable they get.
I can not really say at what age I will stop monitoring them. I think I will keep doing this as long as they have access to any computers in my house.

In a perfect world we would never have to do this. In a perfect world you would never have to lock your car our your house. In a perfect world we would never need to worry about anybody harming us or stealing from us. We insure our cars, boats, bike, houses etc.., why not have piece of mind insurance on our kids? Just a little bit that helps.

These are my thoughts on this. Agree if you want or disagree. That is your choice. Do understand that if any of your kids come over and use my computers, they will be monitored.

by aaron a baker

It is not only ok.
In today's hyped up and crazy "Sick" world, its mandatory.
If you don't know what your child is up to, how can you steer him/her from wrong to right? How can we defend them?
We all know of the pit falls on the web, not to mention the attractive traps that the unsuspecting teens fall for or perhaps worse all that "wonderful" Porn that is so freely handed out to entice and attract.
Then what about the part where the chat rooms come in and you meet some really strange and seriously deranged types on there, who will protect you child if you don't?
These then are only some of the questions that must be answered.
When does it end?
It ends when the "Child" has reached an age where he/she knows the difference and "acts accordingly".
It ends when the parent feels that the child is no longer bait for the creeps.
The numbers don't matter, being thirteen or eighteen, doesn't make a person dumb or brilliant.
If he's Eighteen and still going to sick porn sites, something is very wrong and as a parent we have a clear duty to determine the level of danger to our child regardless of age. If we are doing our jobs, that is.
It finally ends when the kid is observed to be using the Net, "A Very Dangerous thing" Wisely.
That's where it ends.
This isn't about invasion of privacy.
In your parent's home, the only privacy that you are entitled to is the privacy that your Parents grant you, that's it, that's all.
This is about "Protection".
Protection of the children that we love above life and the means to defend them, even if it means defending them against themselves.
When they finally grow up, they usually see the light, and then, it ends.
Thank God :)
Warmest Regards
Aaron ;)

by aaron a baker

Ah Yes, DR Spock !!
Thanks to this Jerk, a lot of parents took sick leave back in the 70s and80s. They got sick of thier kids.
This nonsense of "A child must be allowed to display his/her emotions unfettered really started something.
Suddenly DR Spock was the King of the hill.
How many parents copped out on his advice, what have we got for kids today thanks to him and there are still fools out there dumb enough to quote him.
When He stated that children should be allowed to "express themselves", he left out the part about how.
There is a way to display your emotions and express your thoughts. It's called manners, knowing how to live and it used to be the job of every parent to teach his kid Manners,consideration and above all Respect.
Then along come DR Spock and parents went on vacation.
We see the results today in young parents who have no idea how to properly raise children, let them get away with bloody blue murder, and all suffer from the philosophy of "Not MY Child"
Thanks what that jerk DR Spock has done and the parents who went along are equally to blame.
So when children begin to show a little more respect,and consideration towards each other and their elders will I consider the parents real. Until then, they are just feeders and don't give two hoots about their own kids. Here's your pizza get outta my face.
That is a great part of the reason that the world has become so dangerous.
Kids go anywhere but Home, and now it's the Net, the most attractive and yet the most dangerous place on the globe.
And what do we get with today's kids? Attitude, arrogance, in your face antagonism and if you knock them on their ass your the one to blame, I'll take the blame.
With all this they still have the temerity to say trust us, like hell. You want respect, consideration, give it first.
Prove it, them I for one will trust you. I've raised six girls and I'm one of the lucky ones, they are respectful,considerate and caring and rest assured, wise to the ways of this world including the Net. They're also in their mid 30s with their own kids.
So I wouldn't scream independence too loudly if I were some, in order to recognized as responsible, you have to act the part first. As for privacy in your parent's home, you have No right of expectancy.
Take what you are granted and shut up. You want better, move and get ready for the real world.
Thank you all, for allowing me to rant.
Please accept my apologies for the length.
Regards
Aaron ;)

by heml0ck

Azul said it right;"as long as I have any responsibility for them."
Under the law in most countries, while a child is under the age of majority, it is the parents duty and responsiblilty to protect them.
I find astonishing that this needs to be said. You the parent MUST monitor your children on the internet, because as we all know, it is far too easy to wind up looking at something you weren't expecting.
You wouldn't your children play with power tools without direct supervision, would you?

by x-marcap

My daughter and older son I trust with my very life.

The two young'uns not yet...

by unclerob

KaptKozmicki or whatever you call yourself, I don't understand where you get the idea that your response offers any type of productive input to the discussion at hand. If you don't feel like participating then please refrain from posting remarks of a questionable nature as your current remarks say more about your character than the discussion itself.

Plus your website, needs a bit a tweaking, I'm no expert but hey it's 2006, get a clue, your website has an early 90's feel to it, like it hasn't been updated in the past 15 years. Aside from all the advertising & pop-up windows (thanks again, appreciate the workout you gave my pop-up blocker - at least I know it's working), you advertise for a rentacoder.com, why don't you place an ad for someone to revitalize your website, I would suggest that it needs a bit of sprucing up. And if you can't do that, how about using a spellchecker before posting to the web, I'm pretty sure you have one hidden on your 'puter somewhere, tends to make a website look more professional than a wavy header banner at the top of a page. Use some current world apps when designing your site, if you're going to use a website space provider like 50megs.com, don't put up a crap site with 100% advertising, clean it up, if you have to list ad sponsors on your site, dedicate a page for them and for goodness sake get them off your main page, what a turn off, since you're in the "k"onsultin' biz, you should have a clue about websites, something like the first 10seconds of looking at a website determines whether or not a "k"ustomer will continue looking at the site or move on to another, I gave your site more than 10 seconds to give you the benefit of the doubt, unfortunately it appeared to be a waste of time.

... just my 0.02 cents cdn, feel free to agree or disagree.

by heml0ck

Parenting IS a fulltime, lifelong job!
You can never relax your vigil, because it only takes one moment of stupitiy to alter a life forever. This I know from experience.