Discussion Locked

Ethics of watching children's computer screens

0 helpful
223 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

223 replies

by too old for it

... who treat the first signs of computer literacy by thier kids as a "concentration-camp" offense make me laugh.

Of course I am also amused by those e-mail forwards about everyone over 40 should be dead (we stayed out until the street lights came on, we said "hi" to the old couple at the end of the block, painted the crib with shiny lead-based paint, rode in cars without safety seats, etc)

by jdclyde

can you say "jail time"? Good thing I didn't get caught (often).

Nothing violent or of a theft nature, just running VERY wild.

The few things the parents DID know about made them nervious as hell. can't really imagine if there would have been full disclosure what they would have done. Military school? :O

sex, drugs, and rock n' roll. (not so much of the drugs though. Takes too much time away from the sex!)

by don'tquityourdayjob

It's unethical not to monitor your children - and I'm not just talking about their Internet usage either! Parents that do not monitor their children should be held accountable for said child's actions.

Anyone who would not want you monitoring your child's Internet usage is probably up to something that a parent wouldn?t like one of their children being involved in.

I monitor who my children "hang out" with, what they watch on TV, what they say, what they do, what they eat. I tell them when to go to bed, when to wake up, when they are allowed to talk (little hard sometimes). We even tell them what to wear!

What in the wide world of sports would make someone think I (or my spouse) shouldn?t be allowed to monitor what they do on the Internet?

by jdclyde

There are people here that think that paying attention to what their children do is "spying".

These are people that are poor parents, or have never been parents themselves.

Shame on you. Hope your kids survive the experience DISPITE you and your poor parental skills.

by rlwmis

Too many parents today are so worried about being their kid's friends that they are actually doing them a disservice as parents. Our jobs as parents is to protect and discipline (which basically means to teach; root word disciple, not beat), if we do that, not only will I children be our friends, they will more importantly love and respect us. I have a son and as long as he lives in my house he follows my rules. One of the guys is worried about his kid not talking to him because he's mad, that just proves that there is no respect in that relationship. I agree with amcol do whatever it takes to protect your kids.

by steelehawke

I think that it's ok to spy on your kids in any manner until they are 16! After 16 it's just an invasion of their privacy! Just don't let them find out about it!! At the same time teach them right from wrong- combined with the spying, you could determine, dynamically, how much more or less spying is necessary. All parents, who care, never stop spying on their kids (34-year olds often get the odd phone call to "find out how they're doing") but the clever ones make sure that it does not become intrusive!

by marketingtutor.

Yes!!! The spying must never be told, except in the most extreme circumstances. I do, however, believe like you said, that its a really great way to see how you as a parent are doing in your guidance of your child. The sad part is that I believe that most parents are using it as a last resort to find out what thier children are up to (cause the children are already clamming up and not communicating).

In my experience, as well as the cumulative experience of others, spying has not been necessary, but when indulged in it really did provide a stellar review of the parents in how they had created a morality within the child, by sheer example alone, with a little loving direction.

From my understanding of the sexuality of young children, there are different forms of spying needed for boys vs. girls. Boys usually are headed for a web page with bad content, and girls for the IM, IRC, or some form of chat room. Guys want the nude pics, bomb making specs, and just general naughtiness. Girls, well, they like relationships, interaction with people, feelings, *connection*. And while boys do get into the chat rooms, and in many cases need monitoring too, must more of the the male time is spent serving the testosterone in thier veins.

by ydesrosiers

Okay, I am responding as both a parent, grandparent, teacher and tech liaison at our high school. In these roles it is your duty to protect and monitor your kids or charges. Assuming that kids have the rights and privilages of adults is, in my opinion, a mistake and irresponsible. You are correct in assuming that most kids "out-knowledge" their parents when it comes to technology. As a result, they have assumed a position of power over the adult supervisor. They have the expertise but in many cases, not the savvy to stay safe. Do parents have a right to enter their kids rooms and search for contraband etc? I say yes, they have the right and whether or not they use it is up to the parent and the level of trust developed. The same goes for the use of monitoring software. Who wants that knock on the door by the Feds because your kid has been scamming, downloading, threatening, or participating in other illegal activity? Worse yet who wants the horror of a child gone missing because some predator laid a trap. If that child is a minor, who will ultimately be blame? Face it, many kids are great, altruristic and wise beyond their years, but many are also out of control and spend more effort towards negative activities than positive. As far as age is concerned, if they are minors you have the right and responsibility to control their behaviors. Will the kids like it? Heck no, at least not now. In retrospect perhaps they will. Parents need to parent. Since monitoring software is a new tool for the digital age, parents need that tool to even the playing ground. Should you help that parent set up the software and teach them how to use it? If you choose not to help, how would you feel if their unmonitored kid did something illegal or became a victim of a predator and you could have provided the power to potentially prevent the situation?

by porttech

I am a parent of small children and I intend to make it clear that any site they visit or anything they write on the web is public. Either their parents can install spyware, or a peer could make it public. I will probably install spyware and monitior it if I think there is a need to, or randomly. They shouldn't do anything that would make them uncomfortable if thier parents or their entire school knew about. I used to work in real estate and would see other realtors dissing someone's house or badmouthing the owners during an open house. I always went on the assumption that I should act as if a nannycam was installed in every house I visited. Occassionally the owners did install nannycams to see what the prospective buyers had to say. Now I work in IT and try never to write anything that I wouldn't want to see in the local newspaper or my bosses desk the next day. Just as at work, the computer belongs to the parents or the company who are responsible for its security. I consider any online activity to be public. As other's stated it is a parents duty to keep their children safe. Would you let your child walk down to the corner porn shop with a bunch of 50 year old guys? The virtual world is real, with real people and real danger.

by heml0ck

we were into it....
the parents still don't want to know what we were doing... seeing the resulting behaviour was bad enough!
That being said, I know what kind of trouble young people can get into.
The only thing you can do, like has been said often in this thread, is communicate and educate. Even then that is no sinecure. That's why you have to watch (monitor, spy, call it what you will...)
It isn't really about trust, it's more like 'age vs. experience.' I trust that you will try things for youself. I will pay attention and try to raise a warning when you get close to something dangerous.
If you've got communication with your child, this should be all it takes to avoid a potentially dangerous encounter.
If you don't, you have a bigger problem.
To sum up- communication is the key.

by x-marcap

There are just a couple of adult jokes in the whole movie...

Ann-Margret is always watchable...

by librarygeek

Rereading the quote, the mom in this example failed to inform her kids that she will be monitoring the computer. I agree that many kids will seem to listen but will go against the teaching/requests/instructions down the line. However, if the kids *knew* that mom would find out...it is less likely!

They may have been savvy -- however, I'm sure the mom could have been shown a way to check to be sure the key logger was still uncompromised.

>>>Knowing that her kids were computer savvy, he suggested a keylogger that was virtually indetectable. She agreed and he installed it. When she got the computer back, she told her boys never to go to any pornographic website's.<<<

It seems that too many posters are swinging between talk and trust or monitor secretely. Monitor, by all means, but be honest about it.
There *are* problems with monitoring software . Many programs do not give easy access to the black lists -- thus you are trusting strangers to determine what is and is not ok for your children. Some programs block websites based upon percentages of color (perceived as likely to be skin tone). However -- again -- they are not perfect and have been shown to be blocking legitimate sites.

by silversidhe

I remember being young and I would have hated some adult spying on or watching or trying to control me. Now I am the enemy a "Grump" and along with this time spent being alive I have seen many ugly things - PROTECT YOUR CHILDREN. Once the damage has been done you cannot go back. I don't think there is much worse than trying to deal with or even look in the eyes of an innocent that has been abused, damaged, beaten or otherwise destroyed and I have heard that the damage is permanent. I have friends who were molested as children and known others who lived through this and from what I have learned from them I don't think it ever goes away or fades or what the rest of us would like to believe - that such a person can be healed - they survive some of them but I think they are forever damaged. If I thought a child or even a teenager was behaving in a dangerous manner on the internet I would cut them off without a second thought. But then I will never forget the private investigator I used to know trying to drink himself to death and telling me about how he finally found a missing child but was too late (usually the case) but this time the child was found in a laundromat dryer. I wont give you the rest of the details - they are truly horrible. This child had been sucked into a precarious game that could not end well and didn't. Predators know how to manipulate and control children - this is what they do and unfortunately the internet has opened up a world of opportunity for them that could have never been imagined in the past and parents are cluless of the danger until they lose a child. This situation is out of control and as adults we are all responsible for the safety of any child that crosses our path. So I say YES!

by bschaettle

bsb_lib, you don't have children of your own, do you? One of the few rights that children have is the right to expect that their parents will protect them. This starts with good prenatal care and car seats and typically never ends, although after about age 20 or so most parents will back off a little. Monitoring and correcting childrens' behavior is what good parents DO.

"A parent's job is to raise adults, not children."

by too old for it

is proof positive that your can have a theory, an accepted practice .. yea, even a religiion and it can still be (a) made up from whole cloth and (b) be absolutely, utterly wrong.

My parents (and uncles and aunts) were firm believers in "spare the rod, spoil the child" and trust me: There wasn't a child-spolier in the whole wooden spoon, hickory switch, leather belt, "board of education", leather razor strop weilding bunch. Sure, we got out of line, but then our butts hurt for a week thereafter. My dad was particularly fond of whipping us for whatever, then whipping us for crying because crying was "embarassing".

And we all turned out ok ...

by skingan

I have a simple opinion as a parent, my house, my rules. As long as my children live under my roof they are subject to my rules. As for internet use, I do not consider it spying to keep track of what they are doing on the internet. The internet can be a dangerous place for anyone. It is not just teens that are putting way too much personal data out there for others to see. I make it simple. If you use a computer that I own then you can expect it to be monitored. If you go where you don't belong then shame on you. Too many people today act as though they owe their children the world. Sure we would like to give them every advantage possible but everything beyond a safe loving home is a privilege. There is a difference between the right to something and having the privilege to it.

by phatdragonlady

My kids have had their own computers since they were 3 years old, with internet access, with supervision. We talk about predators on "My Space" and surfing accidentally onto porn sites. I'm sure they're no angels but talking to them and letting them know that we can an will track their usage and chats. So far, so good. Mommy and Daddy giveth and Mommy and Daddy will taketh away if need be!

by dbucyk

If you own the internet and the computer, and you do not live with your parents, then when they move out and are on their own, what they do is their business. You can only guide them.

by inertman9

my older sister has a daughter she holds frank and honest discusions with. she believes her daughter trusts her and is completely honest with her. the truth is her daughter lies and manipulates her through this trust. you can expect whatever you want, but you'll still get whatever they give you, and if you expect them to make intelligent, informed decisions, you have to start by being intelligent and informed. and if you think they will not lie to you and don't expect it sooner or later, then you are neither inteligent or informed. as a parent, what your child does is your responsibility. even if all you do is tell them you're installing a net monitor if they give you reason to, it will make them think about the sites they visit.

by zclayton2

I agree, but parental control can go several other ways. Trust is a fragile thing. You can spend years building it up and then destroy it in a second with an example of "I don't trust you" rigid control freak behavior. My experience with this was I set the expectations for my kids and discussed my values with them and what the parameters were. This was way before the internet was an option for anyone in our house. after we got access, we had the same kind of discussions about that use. I only had one instance where I had to revisit the issue with my son. My practice was to check the cache and found several porn sites once after a friend had been over. I talked about it with my son and explained that I was dissapointed he had visited those sites (without telling him how I had fond out.) and that he was responsible for the computer use even when someone else was doing it - they were his guest and the punishment was his as a result. He got grounded from the computer for two weeks as there was no homework needing it for that period. I cleaned those sites out of the cache and continued monitoring and there were no other problems. I also noticed that particular friend didn't come over as often and didn't use the computer when he did. BTW - my first wife freaked out and wanted to put a net nanny type program on the computer. I indicated if whe wanted to set it up and set the controls - goat ahead. She was not technical so it didn't happen. That probably would have gotten into defiant "I'll show you" behavior with our kids at that point - net loss of trust and cooperation for all sides.

This places the onus on the parent to actually be involved in their kids lives (Whoda thunk?) but isn't that what being a parent is about?

I am on my second family now and am having the same sort of conversations with my new wife's kids. she is in alignment with this approach and had operated this way with them before I remarried. It works, and the benefit is they internalize the idea of appropriate behavior which has a glimmer of hope to work even if they aren't at home on our computer. You can't control access at someone else's house so if there is a ghost of a chance to protect there, it has to be self control by your children.

I find that if you set your exectations high and communicat them with your kids, they will step up to the plate and meet them within their abilities.

by duraman

In my view parents have all the rights to snoop on their children. The internet is a good thing but considering the dangers froth with and the vulnerability of some children it is very fair to know what they are up to when using the internet. After all it is you that feed,clothe and take care of their needs. And in any case, should something happen to them by using the internet, it is you that would suffer the consequence. A child is a child and not an adult. Children must be protected and it is not about children's rights, it is all about responsibility. Protecting your child certainly does not mean infringing their rights.

This discussion is closed to new replies.