Discussion Locked

Global warming is real, and caused by humans.

0 helpful
407 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Excerpt from http://sciencenow.sciencemag.org/cgi/content/full/2006/911/2

For the entire article, purchase a membership to www.sciencemag.org

"Hurricanes are born in the warm waters of the tropical Atlantic and Pacific oceans, which are both getting warmer. Over the 20th century, ocean surface temperatures increased by between 0.32 degrees Celsius in the Pacific tropical region and 0.67 degrees C in the Atlantic tropical region. This has correlated with a twofold increase in category-4 and -5 hurricanes over the last 30 years (ScienceNOW, 17 August). Some researchers maintain that these changes in sea surface temperature (SST) are within the natural variability of climate. Others say that the human-caused climate change is the culprit.

"To figure out just how much people are to blame, atmospheric scientist Ben Santer of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California and colleagues compared observed SSTs with the predictions of 22 global climate models. They ran the different models under various physical scenarios, including changes in solar irradiance, volcanic eruptions, and increased sulfate aerosols and greenhouse gas emissions. Only model simulations that included the known human-caused increases in greenhouse gases replicated the observed rise in SST. In total, the team found an 84% probability that two-thirds of the observed temperature changes were caused by human activities. "There is no way of explaining the observed increases without positing a large human impact on these ocean temperatures," Santer says."

Maxwell, don't even start with your BS about political bias: Ben USED the competing models, and they all FAIL to account for the measured change. Address the science, or STFU, please.

407 replies

by absolutely

Science magazine does not require membership for all articles, and this is a free one, at this time at least. My mistake.

by oz_media

A documentary on that same observation. It left a few questions but was still most conclusive, probably due to something I missed or was edited due to time restraints. They did show a computer graphic of the Earth had there been NATURAL only compared to what they find is Human contamination.

Quote a big difference really, I have never really questioned it too much though. The naysayers just don't have any relevant facts to counter the rest. Simple, outside the box obervations, but no real scientific facts.

by mjwx

And ice cores are pretty accurate. I'm talking about the Vostok ice core which has been completely analysed as of last week.
This is a press release from a few years ago
http://www.cnrs.fr/cw/en/pres/compress/mist030699.html

It states that that the natural variance in CO2 levels is between 180 and 280 PPMV (Parts Per Million Volume) but the maximum was recently amended to 320 PPMV in a BBC report last week (which I cant seem to find) as the full results of the analysis were published. The level of CO2 in our atmosphere stated in the above link was 360 PPMV in 1999. In 2005 it was 380 PPMV as stated in this BBC article
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/science/nature/4215881.stm

20 PPMV in 6 years is an increase far steeper than that recorded in the ice core.

Heres a Reuters story on the subject also it states the maximum CO2 level to be 300 PPMV.
http://tinyurl.com/lx6yb

Whist there is some confusion over the exact maximum CO2 level it is nowhere near our current CO2 level.
But there is a global warming hoax of sorts. Those who continue to perpetuate that global warming either
1. Does not exits
2. Is happening within natural limits
3. Humans are not affecting the environment
I call it the "global warming hoax hoax".

by tonythetiger

CO2 is at the highest level we've ever estimated it to be.

Temperatures are [b]not[/b] the highest we have ever estimated it to be.

Therefore the link between temperature and CO2 levels is obviously [b]not[/b] what these scientists are claiming it is.

by jalefevre

***CO2 is at the highest level we've ever estimated it to be. Temperatures are not the highest we have ever estimated it to be. Therefore the link between temperature and CO2 levels is obviously not what these scientists are claiming it is.***

What your observation indicates is that CO2 is not the only contributor to the warming. No one argues that it is. Several contributors (. . . including changes in solar irradiance, volcanic eruptions, and increased sulfate aerosols and greenhouse gas emissions . . .) were reviewed. CO2 is just the most obvious human contribution, and a significant contributor to the current warming.

by tony hopkinson

No it's not you claim they are claiming it is.
No reputable scientist would claim there is any link between CO2 levels and temperature regardless of other factors.
The most they would claim is that at a certain point in certain situations it would become the dominating factor based of the drastically simple model they are using.

by absolutely

"CO2 is at the highest level we've ever estimated it to be.

Temperatures are not the highest we have ever estimated it to be."

Therefore, what?

"Therefore, the link between temperature and CO2 levels is obviously not" the [b]only[/b] factor involved, nor is that "what these scientists are claiming it is."

From the article, emphasis added now to make [b]crystal clear[/b] that TonytheTiger doesn't know science from his azzho1e:

"To figure out [b]just how much people[/b] are to blame, atmospheric scientist Ben Santer of Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory in California and colleagues compared observed SSTs with the predictions of 22 global climate models. They ran the different models under various physical scenarios, [b]including[/b] changes in solar irradiance, volcanic eruptions, and increased sulfate aerosols and greenhouse gas emissions. [b]Only model simulations that included the known human-caused increases in greenhouse gases replicated the observed rise in SST.[/b](sea surface temperature) In total, the team found an 84% probability that [b]two-thirds of the observed temperature changes were caused by human activities.[/b] "There is no way of explaining the observed increases without positing a large human impact on these ocean temperatures," Santer says."

Go find yourself another strawman, loser, I'm out of your league.

by oz_media

Funny how everyone wants to debate global warming but ignore the facts and findings. LOL. :)

by absolutely

I'm not at all amused by morons who want to discuss any topic, "but ignore the facts and findings."

The only things in the universe that mean anything are facts.

by tony hopkinson

Facts have no meaning until you use them to illustrate what you mean.

I mean if you ignore the facts that mean you are wrong, it seems to mean you are right.

Or if you only consider the facts that mean you are right , it seems to mean you are not wrong.

No I mean , what exactly are the facts and who says so. I don't agree with you , your facts are wrong, therefore it means I'm right.

The fact is what the facts mean isn't what you say they mean but what they I say they mean, otherwise it would mean I was wrong.

and that's a fact.

LOL

by puppybreath

Let's assume for the moment that this one scientist is correct and that he has proven beyond a shadow of a doubt that man is causing global warming.

What now? How are you going to save the Earth?

What rules/policies/laws are you going to put into effect?

How will they be enforced?

Which ones will be voluntary and which ones will be mandatory?

by john.a.wills

climate-heating activity is connected with other kinds of pollution. Make the polluter compensate those affected by the pollution. Each kind of petrol shouldm be taxed according to the poisons it causes the car to spew out and the health-care providers should be paid for treating those made sick. That should get the pollution rate down, and with it the global-warming rate.

by tony hopkinson

around the planet at great speeds and then use my super breath to cool everything down.

If for some reason that can't be done, then my second option is to relocate to Mars, because warming it up is step one to making it habitable.

Until we accept there is a problem there will never be a solution. The fact that the solutions we can think of at the moment are unpalatable doesn't mean the problem doesn't exist and therefore a solution need not be found. It means we need to think up something better quick, or even better try something now, while we think up something better.

Make being tanned unfashionable.
Make home grown food fashionable.
Make out of season food unfashionable.
Make pollution unprofitable.
...
Make Al Gore the president, only joking.

The change has to come from us, our governments won't ever try to get us to do something that will upset their sponsors.

by oz_media

Conveniently in the same thread, I get to support our FACT comments.
You said: "The fact that the solutions we can think of at the moment are unpalatable doesn't mean the problem doesn't exist "

Now THAT isn't a fact at all.

What can YOU do? That isn't unpalatable?
http://www.davidsuzuki.org/NatureChallenge/

Now THAT's a fact proven by science.

by absolutely

What does that mean?

"The change has to come from us, our governments won't ever try to get us to do something that will upset their sponsors."

by oz_media

This isn't some new cutting edge science. It is a new confirmation of what for years has been scientific speculation, denied by the unqualified.

What can be done to 'save the earth'?
Have you been in a box for the last 10 years or what?
You want to do YOUR part? Your own personal change that will ensure that YOU have helped as best you can? a VERY small personal sacrifice?

Take the challenge. If not, please explain to me how taking such a minor personal responsibility is not applicable to yourself.

http://www.davidsuzuki.org/NatureChallenge/

Instead of asking what LAWS and legislation should be applied, think about what you can do instead. If you are not prepared to do YOUR little part, then you are not serious in your question.

Take time to visit the 10 links and discover just how easy it is to do your part.

by puppybreath

I'm very serious about my question. If the situation is as critical as you claim, then evryone needs to do something immediately.

Looking at the site you provided shows that only 222k people have signed up for his challenge.

IMHO You aren't going to be able to get enough people involved unless they are forced into it.

So the question remains: How are you going to convince/require/force people to accomplish your goals when they really don't care.

by jellimonsta

Let's put an additional 50c on all gas prices per gallon, that is contributed to scientific means for finding alternate fuel sources, or other means of 'green' energy!! :p

by oz_media

the rich woul dcontinue to drive gas guzzling machines and the poor woul dbe crammed onto buses. Therefore the richer get a care free life while the poor pay for it?

Wouldn't work. :p

Yes, I know you weren't serious, even you aren't THAT dumb.

by absolutely

Eliminate all transportation taxes except to pay for road maintenance. Eliminate all other "sin taxes", and let people pursue our own happiness, not beg and petition the government to provide it to us.

Exit once and for all the vicious circle of citizens electing officials to pass taxes to coerce the same citizens to alter their behavior, in the interest of ... the citizens themselves? All sides need to agree: no person has the right to [b]assert[b] their point of view by force, including via their elected representatives. The only just role of law is to [b]prevent[/b] coercion, not to initiate it, for any utopian pipe dream. Civilization means that the ends cannot justify the means. Initiating coercion is wrong, even for the sake of clean air.

by hal 9000

Douglas Adams said it best in one of the old Dr Who series when he was the script writer way back when instead of using Gasoline use Hydrogen No major conversions to be made to the cars and very little redesign required with a inexhaustible source of fuel and no nasty by products of combustion.

We had the correct answer back in the 60's and still nothing has been done about it. Could it be that the [b]Oil Companies[/b] contribute way too much to reelection campaigns to see any improvement in fuel usage policy?

For 5 days after 9-11 with no aircraft flying the air cleared immensely but now that the no flying has been revoked we are back to our dirty ways and increased pollution.

This entire thing reminds me of the debate about CFC's and the Hole in the Ozone Layer when it was first put forward it was laughed at and eventually we had to act to stop the problem. Now only a few years latter that's simply no longer a problem.

The fact that places like China are investing heavily in Wind Power should be a dead give away on where we should be heading instead of continuing more of the same things as we've been doing for centuries.

If I remember correctly even in thew BBC series [b]The Goodies[/b] they did a skit of the melting of the polar Ice Caps and decided that the water level rise would be immense. Now that we are beginning to see this happen I'm wondering who will take responsibility when all the low lying islands in the oceans become flooded and the people there have to move to higher ground just as most of us who live close to the coast will be placed in the same position.

If I was to be alive in about 50 years I will have a Ocean Front View though with the changes in the Oceans Water Chemistry I'm not quite sure what I would be able to see or what ocean animals would survive. We are already seeing the signs of the beginning of the end with Ice Caps Melting Coral Reefs Bleaching and not recovering because of higher than normal water temperatures stronger and more frequent storms and longer droughts.

Col

by absolutely

I didn't say [b]anything[/b] about any "rules/policies/laws" I'm "going to put into effect" because to do so would be contrary to my beliefs, which include the right to control one's personal property. I have information that I believe is relevant. If you're interested in more information about the present state of battery-powered vehicle technology, I am most impressed by the company AC Propulsion.

www.acpropulsion.com

The T-Zero prototype gets just a moment in the movie "Who Killed the Electric Car", but I enjoyed that movie nonetheless.

by tony hopkinson

Hold on, I seem to have caught something.

Nothing like a bit of virtual angling if you can't get any of the real thing.

by oz_media

A fact is not a thesis or a theory, it is not speculation. Facts are proven discovery.

The sky is blue on a clear, sunny day...FACT. You can say it isn't but you sure as hell wouldn't be correct by denying such a fact.

Round tires roll better than square tires. FACT.
Again deny it all you like, you are not in ANY way right though because FACT 'proves' you wrong. This is of course based on friction, agitation etc. Scientific and proven fact.

So no, facts are not deniable, you can 'pretend' facts don't exist or you can question the science behind a fact. But unntil proven otherwise, a fact is a fact, whether you agree or not.

by tony hopkinson

But the sky on my pluton is not blue on a clear and sunny day.
What colour is blue and can I have some more clarity in the definition of clear please and exactly how sunny does the sun have to be to get this unclear clear sky to resolve to this significant proportion of the visual spectrum known as blue.

I wish you was right Oz, but facts are all too easily denied. The meaning attached to the facts, even more easily.

Did I mention my new company Square that makes the roundest rolliest tyres ever, by the way ?

by oz_media

Your train of thought is somewhat amusing here, if not a little tiring.

When you are describing 'your' view of teh sky as somewhat smoggy, that is SMOG you are viewing not the sky. The sky beyond the smog is being inhibited BY the smog.

What s clear? Without smog, pure without tainted tint due to human intervention.

Water in a pool is clear too until you pee in it, that doesn't mean 'water' is not clear though.

YO uare playing a stupid game, it's not even worth it really, just a bit tiring. YOu really don't have a point, just a poor understanding of what makes fact a fact, it has nothing to do with what YOU believe or what YOU think. IN the case of Square, go for it, just don't invest your kids tuition money in it, because it won't fly. People understand facts and logic, because YOU feel square tires roll better , that is neither a fact nor logical in any sense of either word.

by zx2zx

"The sky is blue on a clear, sunny day...FACT. You can say it isn't but you sure as hell wouldn't be correct by denying such a fact."

You are only seein grefraction of blue light waves. So technically the sky is colorless, you putz.

No on to Global Warming... there is no such animal. And even if there were, so what? I hate the winter and prefer summer. Teh increase in CO2 is caused by the highest level of animal life on this planet ever. We produce CO2 when we exhale! The supposed GREENHOUSE GAS is CO, so why study the wrong gas as proof of global warning?

Statistics and facts never lie, it is those who use them taht do.

by Member 25348569

The sky on a sunny day is obviously blue simply from the way we define "sky". We define the daylight sky as the blue bit that isn't ground and isn't clouds. How else would anyone define it?

Oz! Take note!

The blue colour of the sky is due to Rayleigh scattering. As light moves through the atmosphere, only the shorter, blue wavelengths are absorbed by gas molecules and these are then then radiated in different directions. Since you see the blue light from everywhere overhead, the sky looks blue. Closer to the horizon, the sky appears much paler in colour as the scattered blue light must pass through more air. As an aside, that's why the setting sun appears redder than the noonday sun.

The greenhouse gas really is carbon [b]dioxide[/b] you know.

As living animal life on this planet is mostly protein and carbohydrates, it's a nett carbon [b]sink[/b]. The source of the increase in CO2 is easily provable by isotopic ratios to be fossil carbon.

Wrong from start to finish. Ah well, never mind... :)

by tony hopkinson

language difficulty. The use of the word putz suggests american after all. LOL
No such thing as global warming?
So the globe isn't getting warmer?
I don't want to rain on your parade, after all that would decrease the amount of sun you get, but winter is sort of necessary.

Even more amusing of course is, if we do get a runaway green house effect it will be less sunny. Venus is a good example.
By the way, no one would complain about there being too much CO in our atmosphere, we'd all be dead. CO2 is poisonous after a certain level as well, except to plants of course, the take it in and push out a waste product oxygen. That's the O in CO and CO2.

by nicknielsen

But what if my facts are different from your facts?

Are these real facts we are dealing with or only factual facts?

by oz_media

They are not facts unless factually proven, infact most facts are not facts at all but just mere conclusion based on speculation, such as Tony's comment, 'fact of the matter is'. Now that's a fact.

So technically, and logically, a blue sky my ipso-facto blue NOT be?!

I suppose what Tony is TRYING to say is that if He sees a different conclusion then there is an alternate fact, his own fact.

But we are not talking about speculation, which teh previous comment shows.

We are talking fact, if something has occurred, it is a fact. I don't care who believes or disbelieves it, the Twin Towers collapsing is a fact.

Stating thta if you light a match and hold it to a can of gasoline will most likely result in fire or expolosion is a fact, no matter what you believe it just IS.

So yes, there are fecta in life, undeniable facts, unless someone is stupid of course., but that still doesn't chanege the facts.

How seemingly educated or intelligent people can claim otherwise is just hilarious, no amount of pseudo psychiatry changes facts,some poeple think the play on words is even clever but it really isn't because it is not at all logical; which it would need to be in order ot hold water. And THAT is a fact. ;)

by tony hopkinson

fact are not meanings.

Meanings are value judgements, facts are brought into support meanings. Seeing as values are usually in place before facts are discovered some people have a distressing tendency to pick and choose them to keep the long standing comfort of the value they hold.

Here's a fact, you seem to have taken the fact that I disagreed with ABS that facts are meanings to mean that I am Mr Edison's camp in relation to the 'global warming issue'

Nothing could be further from fact than that.

I find all arguments against action on the possibility of human engendered global warming specious and self serving.

I'm talking survival of the planet they are talking personal profit, which facts they choose to support their argument or ridicule mine is immaterial. Their values, on this issue at least, are utterly incompatible with mine.

by tony hopkinson

What about the energy companies, you can't chop 10% of the pofits off our best entrepreneurs. They'll do something else and not contribute to my political campaign.

Walk or bike to work, it's two hundred miles away. Nothing wrong with my challenger anyway it's got very good fuel economy for a tank and I have no partking problems at all.

No pesticides, we'll be infested with green fly, ladybirds will wear out their mandibles and die.

Perhaps I should have said unpalatable to those we have handed decision making power to. It sounded a bit stilted though, and I knew what my fact meant.

ROTFLMAO

by oz_media

Nobody is willing to accept personal responsibility. As long as it's HIM that makes changes and I don't need to do anything to adjust my wasteful lifestyle than all is well.

No wonder nobody can solve issues when at summits with the US.

by tony hopkinson

until the day after the biblical disaster happens.

I do what I can in terms of energy saving because it saves me money. I use public transport, I recycle. I even argue the issue pragmatically.

After all if we treat it as an issue and we are wrong we get a cleaner planet, if we don't treat it as an issue and we are wrong we'll be building arks in our back gardens out of the forests we haven't burnt yet, to put on pairs of species we have failed to extinguish.

No brainer really isn't it.

Course making fuel expensive won't get you voted for and cutting down the availablity of cheap flights won't get you voted in to power, being in favour of either won't get you a very big campaign chest to get into power.

We need global legislation. If you pollute you pay, sliding scale % of net profit. Fine starts at 100% for one incident, slides down as you put some effort into stoppping. That'll stop their farting in church.

That is a bit radical isn't it.

by tony hopkinson

Facts have actuallity, they have no inherrent meaning whatsoever.
The words we use to describe them, give context and we derive meaning from that.

Yes I was playing a game. I thought that was goddamn obvious, if you don't want to play, don't !

by jellimonsta

Isn't the sky simply solar radiation viewable as a result of being scattered by air molecules, cloud particles or other particles?

If so, could not the SMOG be considered in this all encompasing definition of 'Sky'?

Just my 2c ]:)

[edit: because I type like a spazmo :p ]

by oz_media

If you really want to get into it. The Sky woul dactually be every colour BUT blue as we only see the colours that are not absorbed and that are reflected back to our eyes. When something is red, it is in reality every colour BUT red, as it reflects red and does not absorb it as it does with every other colour of the spectrum.

But it's funny how a serious discussion that counters what MANY people sepw here is completely iognored or segued due to people's inability to accept facts they don't believe.

The sky as we see it is generally Blue because yes, the reflection of the sun off off our planet, oceans etc. combined with the particles of gases in the air make it appear blue, yet the atmosphere is for the most part made up of colourless gases.

The point is, 'the sky' as most normal people see it, is blue. Takes a real dork to see anything beyond that (sorry, nothing too personal intoned there), but really that is just geekspeak to avoid the focus of the comment.

by onbliss

... Homer Simpson: Facts are meaningless, they can be used to prove anything. :-)

by absolutely

My approach is to sing the praises of the T-Zero.

It reaches 60 mph from a standstill in around 4 seconds, and its ability to accelerate rapidly is a simple consequence of using electricity instead of chemical combustion, not of some outrageous engineering that will have to be incredibly expensive. Much of the acceleration time of a vehicle with an internal combustion engine has to do with the limitations of a chemical reaction, which cannot exceed a rate determined by kinematic equations. A battery-powered circuit, on the other hand, reaches full power within a fraction of one second. The other factor in determining acceleration potential is the size of the vehicle compared to the total output of its engine, in the case of internal combustion and battery-powered alike. So, in the case of an identical combustion vehicle, you're waiting for the engine's force to reach its maximum value, F(max), while the battery-powered car's engine switches from zero to F(max) in -- literally! -- the time it takes a light to turn on when you flip the switch. In both cases, the magnitude of F(max) compared to the mass of the car (m) determines the acceleration (a) according to the equation F/m=a. In a T-Zero, F = F(max) the [b]instant[/b] you floor the accelerator pedal. Your Challenger will have to wait for the gasoline/air/electricity mixture to reach equilibrium, so you'll be pushing against the same mass with less force for some time. Clearly, battery power is [b]superior[/b] for drag-racing and freeway entry applications.

This car costs about $100,000 -- [b]custom-made[/b]. Major car companies have [b]higher[/b] per-vehicle production costs for [b]their prototypes[/b], but in every conversation about electric cars, I hear complaints about the electric cars' high prices compared to [b]assembly-line[/b] models. The major companies just never devoted the same assembly-line resources to their electric cars (GM's EV1, Toyota's RAV4 EV, Ford Think), so comparisons of their electric cars' prices is also not valid. The lower production cost of a T-Zero to a Detroit prototype is also a feature of any electric car: electric motors are just simpler.

The only reason that electric cars haven't been as practical in the past as they are now is that the lithium ion battery is a new invention.

by absolutely

If the color that the sky "is" describes the color(s) of the light frequencies that [b]reach[/b] our eyes, then the sky is blue, but if the color that the sky "is" means the frequencies of light that the atmosphere [b]does not[/b] emit, reflect, or refract to the surface of Earth, then the sky is some other color.

Ha!

by oz_media

Have actuially registered and signe dup for the nature challenge. I know several, including myself, who follow several of these guidelines and haven't signed up though.

NOw lets look at the issue.
Is it imperative that something is done overnight? Yes.
Doi we need to clean the air overnight? No.

Do we need to start taking action and increasing aareness now? Yes.

Is 227 thousand people a drop in teh bucket, yes and no.

Th econdcept is that each person folowing these guidelines to better resource management, will save an average of 1 tonne of emissions each year. Thus a quarter of a million TONNES of emissions will be reduced over the next year.

Now if everyone had your mindset, which I must agree is very common, then NO, nothin gwill happen. When it does get 'enforced' by teh government ,there will be protests, human rights issues, republicans screaming about big brother watching, personal liberties etc. NOTHING gets done that way.

If people suchj as yourself were prepared to accept personal responsibility, as at least a quarter million peopl ehave already, then there will be time to help reduce th eeffects of global warming. Will we STOP it? Of course not, it's natural, will we slow the harmful effects of our emissions on th eatmosphere? Damn straight we will and that's all it takes. Not some radical law to enforce. Cleaning up emissions and governmentregulations started in California in 1986, with the clean air act. It was HEAVILY opposed and at the time people complained about wimpy new cars that didn't burn $50.00 of gas between gas stations. No HP, death traps etc. These people have since been proven wrong, and I am confident a good share of them now drive far more economical cars.

It's fear of change, it happens to everyone who is somewhat insecure or living in a confort zone. We only progress as a nation/society/race when someone steps outsde of that zone or takes a chance and finds a better way.

Anytime I mention clean air or global warming to ANYONE it is accepted with full interest, mention it in the US and you get every single irrelevant issue you can conceive, and then some, thrown in your face as to why they are different than the rest of the world.

Clean up you OWN act, don't wait for everyone else to do it. If you are a sheep or a simply follower peon I can understand, but you guys are always claimng how you are upstanding and righteous and strong and independant and not controlled by your government and all the opther BS you guys sling here daily.

Yet when it really comes doen to it? "Leave it for someone else to do, or have the government enforce it." What a whimpy piss-ant reply, and when I contest that I don't know how you became and held on to super power status, you all get riled and start on again about your strength and independence. Give me a break, nobody buys that cop out hypocrisy anymore.

by puppybreath

must you be so rude and vehemently criticize me when you don't even know me? I happen to be doing MY part and am probably just as "green" as you are if not more so. I just don't have to brag about it to make myself feel superior as you do.

I asked a simple question because we both know that it would be extremely difficult to get many people to change their mindset because of their selfish ways. Instead of listing possibilities, you throw out a bunch of insults and go off on one of your Anti-US rants again.

You really are a sad piece of work.

by absolutely

Like any fashion, there is a point when "weirdos" reach a critical mass and become "trend-setters". The more a "green" lifestyle can be portrayed as apolitical, arbitrary, and/or frivolous, the more likely it will "catch on".

[edit: your -> you're]

by oz_media

You've got a long way to go here before you realize those are not even remotely close to being personal insults thrown at you.

You raised the same question evertyone else does that doesn't want to be personally responsible and take personal action.

THAT is the problem. If you do take action yourself and follow good guidelines to lower emissions, reduce driving by buying locally etc. Then all the power to you, why even raise the question then?

the point it, you stated the common "what about everyone else" comment, lead..dont' follow, that's the difference.

by local support

I would not think to insult anyone of you.

In about 500 years, we we would not recognize the Earth as we see it today.

I will be gone in 20 years from now, and I aint got no children.

Does not mean I don't care though.

\Local Support

by oz_media

What is 'IT'? You know, 'IT' what is 'IT' all about? F**ck 'IT', screw 'IT', forget 'IT' what is 'IT'? Okay that was good acid and wild youth.

Anyhow,the PIGMENT that an object retains is not the colour WE see. Therefore a red chair is not actually red, we just see it as red.

A blue ball is actually every pigment BUT blue, but our eyes tell us it's blue because we simply see what the actual pigment reflects. Thus we identify objects by the reflected colour, not the actual colour.

by maxwell edison

.....that the summer of 2007 won't break the record either. Where could I place such a bet? I go to Las Vegas often, but I haven't seen any global warming book makers. Hey Neil, are there any in London? I hear a person can bet on anything over there.

http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2006/s2700.htm

Oh my, I forgot! It's not called "global warming" anymore. It's called "climate change", something that's caused a storm of controversy. Rational thinking people must have rained on their parade, showing they're full of hot air, so they changed their wind direction to something more vague. Their heads are still in a fog, however.

by absolutely

Records have been kept since 1895. Are you willing to play book maker, and offer payout to reflect the odds that 2007 will be the hottest, assuming pure random chance? 113:1 is the probability that 2007 will be the hottest ever, assuming no global warming. How confident are you really? What odds will you offer that the hottest year won't occur in the next decade? In the next two decades? Are you willing to place any bets that the frequency of hurricanes will decrease? That they will stop increasing?

by tony hopkinson

that the term 'climate change' came out when those who'd said global warming wasn't a fact had to admit that the globe was getting warmer. This was a disaster until one read an article about the thermal pulse and sun spots and stuff.

I 'm wagering some unnecessary economic upheaval on being wrong.

You are wagering the biosphere

If I'm right WE get a bisophere.
If you're right SOME get a dividend.

I like my bet more, it risks less and gains more.

by zx2zx

All this whining was to get the PC Lefties into office, hell Global Warming was supposed to kill us off 20 years ago when they fist started bitching about it.

Then after the commie PC party got into power they took away all mention of Christioan religion (ie Christmas, BC, St. Valentine's) to cleanse the world for secularism (holiday tree, BCE, and valentines day).

Hell even the Pope can't read a 13th century quote in an academic venue about the only way Islam can be spread is by the sword without having an apology demanded by global leaders.

Sheesh drink your mocha latte and get a grip!

by tony hopkinson

spread chistianity by the sword for centuries, he did sort of stab himself in the foot with that one.

One of a long line of apologies the pope has had to make for the catholic church. Don't worry though there is a much longer line of things to apologise for. Makes you wonder why he tacked another onto the list, habit I suppose.

by absolutely

"Then after the commie PC party got into power they took away all mention of Christioan religion (ie Christmas, BC, St. Valentine's) to cleanse the world for secularism (holiday tree, BCE, and valentines day)."

If the god in which you claim to "believe" were anything other than a figment of your wish to evade the real fact of your insignificance, the beliefs and actions of [b]other people[/b] would not be your primary concern.

I am no commie, and your inability to differentiate scientifically proven fact from your Stone Age superstition does not make you significant, nor do any epithets you utter based on your many inabilities. Don't flame me back! Instead, prove your faith by obeying the mandates of your superstition: turn the other cheek and endure the ridicule of this infidel with SILENT humility.

I do not believe in faeries, easter bunnies, resurrections, santa claus, dialectical materialsim, nor a Free Lunch by any name.

Democrats were the small government party in the days of Thomas Jefferson. While Bill Clinton was in office, government spending shrunk from over 20% of GDP to less than 19%, the first reduction in ... a long GODDAMNED time. Under George Walker Bush, who claims he hears the voice [b]of god[/b], not Sam (why should I put faith in him? GWB is certainly not God!), in his head, spending has increased to more than it was when Bill Clinton moved into the White House, and spending grew [b]more rapidly[/b] than under Lyndon Baines Johnson or Tricky Dick Nixon.

I, like all Good Libertarians & Objectivists, don't care whether a person is associated with a jackass or an elephant. I know that in the [b]real[/b] world, my pursuit of happiness is best secured by a government that taxes me less and concentrates more on preventing & punishing coercion than on initiating it. A change toward smaller government has happened only once in my lifetime, when we had the lucky combination of an influential Republican in Congress (Newt Gingrich) who campaingned with promises of small government and a Democrat President (Bill Clinton) with middle name Jefferson. We citizens cannot count on good luck to keep government within the bounds defined in the Constitution. We can only ensure that government does not remove both Atheist & christian of the right to practice our respective beliefs FREELY in our respective homes by respecting the others' right to live as they choose, so long as nobody interferes with another individual's ability to earn happiness, and to enjoy the happines that individual has earned.

capitalize whatever Word you want, but when you deal with me, you had better remember that you have no right to religion beyond my right to irreligion. Don't even THINK about treading on ME!

by tonythetiger

It's more like the press... and "bad news sells" (It also pays (as in grant money)). Examples:

The press doesn't jump all over themselves to announce to the world that 3,834,451 children got all "A"s on their report cards this grading period.

Scientists don't spend billions of dollars on finding out why my great grandfather lived to be 113 years old, smoking for the last 100 of those years.

You know why? There are three reasons.

1. Because they don't involve something that can be [b]blamed[/b] on someone else and used to get even more money from them.

2. They [b]contradict[/b] the "facts" they want the public to know (If it becomes too widely known though, and they cannot explain it away using "known facts", they have to fall back on the "It's a scam", "It's a hoax", or "It's a con" explaiations).

3. Politicians and scientists together decided that breeding stupid people was an excellent way to make money to fund research projects (they even discovered that they could teach some of them a few big words that are meaningless, but will make the other ones believe they know what they're talking about), so instead of allowing them to die off naturally by their stupidity at age 10, they kept them alive long enough to breed and now the world is overrun with them :)

by absolutely

A lot of people in a lot of professions find scapegoating more comfortable than admitting, then choosing to either overcome or to accept and live with, personal shortcomings.

by absolutely

It's the nitrous oxide (another greenhouse gas, aka "laughing gas") in the atmosphere that makes me feel funnier than I really am.

:D

by absolutely

If the market chooses to buy from polluters, from where does that very same market acquire the right to act, as "voters & citizens", to punish the companies it rewards for providing us conveniences? Isn't that about the most hypocritical act you can imagine?

by tony hopkinson

The most hypocritical act is to manipulate your market to get what you want, then when the consequences come home to roost, say it's the fault of those you manipulated for being gullible twits.

Especially when you've spent their lives indoctrinating, grooming and educating them to create a massive blindspot, you could exploit to your personal advantage.

Hypocrisy <> ignorance and ignorance is definitley not bliss, just easier.

by jellimonsta

I was being facetious.
As Oz pointed out, the additional 'tax' (or whatever you want to call it) on top of gas prices would only affect the lower and middle class, while the wealthy would stay largely unaffected by such measures.
Although, as blunt as Oz was about my reply, he must have neglected to see that his scenario of 'lower class being crammed onto buses' is exactly what is being suggested anyway for the American population en masse, is it not?
Or do we believe that just getting rid of the trucks and SUVs will right all that is wrong? And maybe it will even promote peace in the middle east, ease tensions in war torn African countries? :p

by absolutely

If people make bad choices, the existence of advertising does not absolve us of responsibility.

by absolutely

Just kidding, only wanted to get your attention! Did it work?

This is starting to get interesting:

"Here's a fact, you seem to have taken the fact that I disagreed with ABS that facts are meanings to mean that I am Mr Edison's camp in relation to the 'global warming issue'

Nothing could be further from fact than that.

I find all arguments against action on the possibility of human engendered global warming specious and self serving.

I'm talking survival of the planet they are talking personal profit, which facts they choose to support their argument or ridicule mine is immaterial. Their values, on this issue at least, are utterly incompatible with mine."

In what way do you think I'm talking personal profit before survival of the planet? I've argued before that wealth is worthless without a habitable environment, and I think this fact is self-evident. If I've forgotten it somewhere, please tell me.

by tony hopkinson

I disagreed with you because you said only facts have meaning, we were getting on the semantic freight train again.

Oz took my disagreement with you on that issue to be disagreement with you on global warming and tried to argue the position all three of us agree on with arguments based on the one I don't.
That got a little confusing.

The 'Maxwell Edison - Al Gore the early years' position is profit before survival.

What I tried to point out that in that case I don't care what facts are chosen for either argument. None of us are 100% sure of the facts after all. What some of us can be sure about is that the biosphere is worth a heck of a lot more than the ability to upgrade your PC or buy a new toaster.

Less interesting now, unless you want to jump into what would be an off topic sidebar on actuallity and context and how both get blurred by semantic disconnect.

by absolutely

I agree to drop our semantic argument about meanings, which is not the subject I started this thread to discuss.

by croeiii

To truly determine the color of any sky one must first remove ALL impurities. When that is done the true color of any sky would be.....Black!

by oldboydave

The increase in numbers of hurricanes is caused by global warming or so it is claimed for the past years when the numbers increased. However, this year so far the number and intensity of hurricanes has decreased. Did someone drop an ice cube into the oceans? Or is the decrease also caused by global warming?

by Member 25348569

Not many respectable climate scientists have stated that Climate Change will cause an [b]increase[/b] in hurricane frequency. They state that if hurricanes form they will be more intense because of the increased sea surface temperatures - this being the energy source for hurricanes.

As for this year; it isn't over yet. We've had Florence, Gordon and Helene in the last week or so. Weather conditions have meant that none of those three has moved into waters close to the US.

That's why statistics are gathered and interpreted from extended time periods by anyone who has half an ounce of sense.

by jdclyde

guess that leaves out all the people in the US that have been going on about this.....

by absolutely

"They state that if hurricanes form they will be more intense because of the increased sea surface temperatures - this being the energy source for hurricanes."

Which can be stated, equally accurately, as an increase in Category 4 & 5 hurricanes (accompanied by a useless, corresponding [b]decrease[/b] in Category 3 & lower hurricanes). Net change: more disasters. Who will vote [b]for[/b] that?

by absolutely

"However, this year so far the number and intensity of hurricanes has decreased."

Decreased compared to what? Is this decreased number in comparison to "the past (unspecified by you number of) years when the numbers increased"? Is it compared to the era before global warming, as would be appropriate to a true counter-argument?

YOU cannot have it both ways: YOU cannot contradict a scientific study (and have such contradiction taken seriously!) without QUANTIFYING your conclusions.

by tonythetiger

but yes, it's possible that the same warming that increases the number of hurricanes can also decrease them. Not only is very warm water required for the formation of hurricanes, but a [b]difference[/b] in temperature between the water and the air is also required. So as the water temperature goes up, the chances go up, but as the air temperature catches up, the chance drops somewhat.

This is, however, extremely simplistic, since it does not take into account other important factors, such as how many Republicans are in congress :)

by absolutely

http://www.noaanews.noaa.gov/stories2006/s2699.htm

Temperature changes vary with currents, and there is a variation to ocean temperatures with periodicity of more than one year. The heating & cooling trends are characterized by the terms "El Ni?o" & "La Ni?a", and are well known to people qualified to comment on climate change. Read up, and until you have, I'll waste no more of my time on you.

by tonythetiger

And all this time I thought it was a continent.

Hey, maybe when global warming raises the oceans and takes out all the costal cities, those displaced can move there!

by colonel panijk

Nor do two. 2004 and 2005 were nasty years for hurricanes, but [i]by themselves[/i] do not prove a trend. 2006 has been a pussycat of a year (so far), but does not mean that 2004 and 2005 were abberations. You have to look at long term [i]trends[/i], where year-to-year noise has been smoothed out. If we choose to do nothing about GG emissions, we'll find out for sure by mid-century if the world's climate is going to hell in a handbasket. The trouble is, by then it may be too late to stop the warming and its effects. Hey, at least we'll all die [i]really[/i] rich!

by Member 25348569

The availability of warm surface water with a temperature of over 26?C is an absolute requirement for the formation of hurricanes. That's not enough on its won. The amount of wind shear MUST be low - the difference in speed and direction of winds within the vertical column of air in which the hurricane will form. They can only form under conditions which are warm and where weather fronts are rarely found.

So, if Global Warming is a reality and warm water masses expand further North or South, they will reach areas with strong winds in the upper atmosphere and the formation of hurricanes will be prevented.

As a working example, the Caribbean water temperatures are sufficient for the formation of hurricanes all year, but only in late summer and autumn do low shear conditions prevail enabling the formation of hurricanes.

See. If I know that then surely most meteorologists do. The UK Met office does and so does your NOAA.

:D

If you do get 'em though - they'll be BIGGER!

by tonythetiger

the periods of warming that were higher than this one?

All of those things you mentioned (except for the solar irradiance, of course) could be results of global warming, rather than the cause of it. But that possibility won't be investigated (at least not at the scale the other possibilities are), because that is a result they (the politicians who fund the research) don't want to find!

They can run all the models they want, but if all of those models start with a (possibly) false premise (that something on earth is causing global warming), they are going to come to a (possibly) false conclusion. Mankind has a long history of setting out on witch-hunts, and finding witches. Trouble is, by their own belated admissions, witches don't exist.

It reminds me of a joke that made the rounds shortly after the Rodney King trial:

The FBI, the CIA, and the LAPD are all trying to prove that they are the best at apprehending criminals. The President decides to give them a test. He tells them there's a rabbit in the forest and they have to find it. First the CIA goes in. They place animal informants throughout the forest. They question all plant and mineral witnesses. After three months of extensive investigations they conclude that rabbits do not exist. Next the FBI goes in. After two weeks with no leads they burn the forest, killing everything in it, including the rabbit, and they make no apologies. The rabbit had it coming. Finally the LAPD goes in. They come out two hours later with a badly beaten bear. The bear is yelling: "Okay! Okay! I'm a rabbit! I'm a rabbit!"

by tonythetiger

I think you may have hit it on the head with the second sentence. I don't think reputable scientists [b]are[/b] making the claims. It is the press and certain politicians who are claiming that reputable scientists are saying that.

by tony hopkinson

Big science requires funding, serious funding. To get it you have to support your sponsors reasons for giving you it. The treehuggers 'want' global warming, the money huggers don't. You come out with evidence that doesn't support their view point, they'll squash it, rubbish it, and never fund you again.

The only way those of us without a preset agenda can proceed, is to read all the science and pay special attention to what they don't say, the conclusions they don't draw and the methods they don't use.

Your argument is valid, but for both sides 'scientists', not just those who come out with evidence that supports your beliefs.

by tonythetiger

of trains made it their destination without crashing, I'll be damned if I'd get on one. You can stay on yours though. Have a nice ride.

by absolutely

If you have ever taken ... Excuse me, I mean, if you had ever [b]passed[/b] a statistics class, you would understand that the probability is higher than 84% that at least 60% of the observed increase in SST is caused by human greenhouse gas emissions, and that the probability that human greenhouse gas emissions is directly responsible for at least half of the observed temperature change is higher still. Of course, you don't know a confidence interval from your own azzh0le, either.

by absolutely

No person is responsible in any degree for the uncoerced choice of any other person. If citizens have chosen to buy and use substances that we later learn is "pollution", or which we knew at the time to be pollution, the ease with which we acquired those substances in no way shifts responsibility for our choices to buy them from us to those who provided to us what we, in our roles as part of an economic market, told them we wanted.

Once you buy that gasoline, or Twinkie, or cigarette, you [b]own[/b] it, and have [b]100%[/b] of the responsibility for what you choose to do with it, including any harm your property does to yourself or others.

by tony hopkinson

Effectively both of us believe continuing in ignorance is voluntary. If we addressed that argument then those who wish to gain from the perpetuation of ignorance would defeat themselves. Everytime they tried to progress their agenda, it would be a spur to do the exact opposite.

Anyone 'gaining' from me accepting their position on anything is immediately treated with extreme suspicion. Works for me anyway.

by absolutely

Any asserted "meaning" whose basis is anything other than fact(s), must be based instead on fiction, aka lie(s), or on nothing. Either way, such an asserted "meaning" is baseless, and therefore, in FACT, [b]meaningless![/b]

by tony hopkinson

I knew you would'nt be able to resist !
To be fair people illustrate what they mean with facts and they attach meanings to facts. Given anything we say meaning something is the summit of whole series of assumptions or at least acceptance of 'facts', it's extremely hard, if not impossible to disentangle the two.

Attach a meaning to a fact, act on that meaning making it a value, and then that colours your perception of subsequent facts. Which is why many try to counteract facts posited by those with different values.

I believe this
Why
Because of that
Are obviously that is wrong.

The only one to one relation is with those facts we choose to back up our values with.

Total objectivity, would suggest that you shouldn't be guilty of this, but in my opinion you often are. You and I often simply finish up agreeing to disagree on values not facts.

Course it could be just be me, couldn't it.

by m.daspit

Yes the earth may in a warming trend at this time but if you look at the trends over the life span of the earth, several million years the 20th/21st centuries are a speck in Tech terms worth about a bit of memory on a gigabit hard drive.

We the earth has gone through ice ages and warming periods some long some short. The last mini ice age ended in the mid to late 1800s, less than 200 years ago. So what should be occurring when we come out of an ice age but to warm up.

Looking at recorded history, that there was an ice or cooling period occurred the range of 400 AD period during the decline of the Roman Empire. It was recorded the Rhine freezing over allowed the Germanic trips to cross. The Dark ages have little recorded but what can be put together is that it was bleak and one can assume the weather was the same. The middle age marked a significant Tempe true rise as can be noted by the increase in agriculture production and the development of new improved systems. I wonder if the people of the middle ages were the cause of this trend?

Slowly the cooling period started again resulting in the last mini ice age that just ended, (in the time frame of the earth).

Bottom line if we are no warming we are cooling, if we are static then I worry the earth is really dying then. Personally having lived in the artic for 2 years I prefer the warmth then another ice age. Yes realize that the powers of the natural elements are stronger then what mere mortals can do.

by tony hopkinson

were called the dark ages because nothing was recorded, we could shed no light on what happened during them.

I recommend a bit a reading for you, James Gleick's Chaos. It's a good book anyway and the concept of chaos will blow a hole right through the simplistic model you seem to be using to extrapolate your conclusions.

I hasten to add it's not a tree huggers bible or anything, it's pretty much apolitical, except for the academic infighting.

by m.daspit

In the 19080s many of these same scientist were proclaiming the Co2 particals from nuclear explosions would cause a nuclear winter.

What is really correct seems that "Natural Science is today Polical Science

by tony hopkinson

Nuclear winter would be caused by multiple ground bursts throwing dust particles in to the high atmosphere, ther by blocking sun light from reaching the earths surface. The only person I've heard make the claim you did is in fact you, personally I'd be wary of making any more, this one wasn't too clever.

by maxwell edison

You're conversing with the one of the most severe resident nut-cases around. Absolutely has absolutely lost all grasp of reality.