Discussion Locked

Global warming is real, and caused by humans.

0 helpful
407 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

407 replies

by maxwell edison

...that he's obsessed with the numerous times I've slapped him down in the past for pointing out his inconsistency, ignorance and lunacy, and he can't even start a discussion without thinking about it. It's really sad, if you think about it.

by maxwell edison

Silently Tormented, Fretful (and) Unnerved.

Still Twisted, Freakish (and) Unbalanced

Still Thinking Fallaciously (and) Unsoundly

Still Thoroughly Fixated Unreasonably

Still Totally (and) Fatuously Upset

Spanked Thoroughly, Fading Uncontrollably

Still The Flaky Urchin

Silly, Tiresome, Foolhardy (and) Unreasonable

Still Throbbing From (Maxwell's) Upper-hand

Still Tormented From (Maxwell's) Utility-Hammer!

by absolutely

The "S" is for "shut", and "TF" is for emphasis.

The reason I told Maxwell to STFU until he is ready to quantify his assertions scientifically is that he has a habit of changing the subject to irrelevancies such as his least favorite personality traits of famous people who acknowledge the reality of global warming. Nothing about Albert Gore or any scientist's personality has anything to do with whether or not the known, increasing levels of CO2 in the atmosphere are having a negative impact on the climate of Earth, making it less habitable.

by protiusx

The problem is that this argument is not yours. You copied it from someone else who, more than likely, was intellectually capable of carrying on a debate or discussion on the topic. You, on the other hand have not demonstrated the ability to present original thought or put forth your ideas in a manor that is neither childish nor belligerent.

by inbox.com

Let's abort all unborn babies in the world and start killing off everyone. Save the Earth!

by protiusx

Everyone knows that he was responsible for Hurricane Katrina and the intentional blowing of the levies in certain places in order to protect the white neighborhoods at the expense of the black neighborhoods.
I am not even going to put the sarcasm tag. If you can't read the dripping sarcasm I don't know what to say.

by hal 9000

That's Potential Politicians. Without them the world would just be so much better off.

So lets start by sterilising any current Polly their Spouses and either kill off their children or sterilise them and have them commented because they have [b]Delusions of Grander[/b] and then we can start the drive by shootings of any new people who poke their heads up at the next Election.

Without these people we would all be so much better off world wide. :D

Col

by absolutely

Human brains are capable of [b]creating[/b] working one-to-many relationships in relational databases. I pardon no person so ignorant that it cannot [b]understand[/b] one-to-many relationships of meaning to facts, and a zero-to-any relationship of meanings to myths.

by protiusx

If humans are to blame for global warming then what was to blame for the global warming that occurred prior to the 20th Century?
What caused the Climate shifts which caused the mini-ice age of the 19th Century?
From what I have read and learned (I am not a scientist but I do dabble) it can be stated that the earths climate is changing. The earth's climate has always been in a state of flux and is self regulating. The question that has not been answered definitively is "what is the level of mankind's influence had on the global climate". I think it would be perversely naive to say that humanity has had no impact but it would be equally perverse to say that humans are so powerful as to sway the climate of the planet with a few decades of activity.
By the way - Your disparaging remarks to Maxwell are a bit out of line. If you wish to argue with someone do so but to preempt their responses with such childish banter detracts from your argument.

by hal 9000

Remember the CFC's and the Hole in the Ozone Layer? Well Humans where responsible for that and once the CFC's where removed the Hole started to close up to such an extent that it's no longer an issue.

Now are you trying to say that Mankind was not responsible for that one and it was a Natural Occurrence?

Col

by protiusx

I did not say that humans have no effect on their environment. I merely stated that the effect is not as great as being reported by the left wing propaganda machine and regurgitated on forums such as this.

by absolutely

Do you mean to imply, by contradiction, that you also have access to his time machine, and know what these scientists said more than 17,000 years from now?

by protiusx

Please describe the "ERA before Global Warming"? This is not a new thing. The earth has been warming and cooling cyclically since its inception (when ever that was [the topic for another discussion]).

by protiusx

Much like your last post. Try not to obfuscate the issue. Better yet, try using simple words and simple sentences to get your point across and stop trying to sound smart. You'll go a long way in helping your argument.

by absolutely

But I prefer to use the most exact word available in my repertoire, not the one most accessible to the most people. I always preferred literature that required me to use a dictionary occasionally to understand it. The universe is big, and learning new words to describe its many phenomena is a worthwhile use of time.

The last post was [b]intended[/b] to asymptoticaly approach meaninglessness, and to be so pompous it would be nearly indecipeherable. I was exchanging a joke with Tony Hopkinson, with whom I have disagreed vehemently about political economy in the past. Sorry my attempt to smooth relations with him annoyed you. But, if you re-read the post to which I replied, and the humorous discussion of fact vs. meaning between his post & mine, and my first joking reply, "Table your counterargument", hopefully you will also see the humor.

by tony hopkinson

The simplest words carry the biggest semantic loads.
Anti-disestablishmentarianism has very few connotations, faith, good, evil too many to count.

If I said someone was an anti-disestablishmentarian, we are being fairly precise, if I said he was evil though, what would I mean?

That I thought anti-disestablishmentarianism was evil and because he believed in it, he was evil?

If I only said he was evil, would you say oh he's an anti-disestablishmentarian, obviously!

You'd need a lot of context for that to be an accurate conclusion about waht I meant wouldn't you. Probably a long string of words that would mean something different to you anyway.

by oz_media

CO is but one greenhouse gas, CO is also the most toxic gas that we emit into our breathing air at low level altitude every day. Carboxyhemoglobin is something you'd like to take note of, it is caused by our extensive burning of fossil fuels.

Thus removing such fuels or driving more efficient fuel burning vehicles, our lives are healthier from the get go. Don't even start me in on CO and vehicle emissions, I am an alternate fuels specfialist (former mechanic) and have spent a lot of time studying fuels and emissions effects.

As for the lgobal warming factor, your reply intones that you really havent got a clue what global warming is about or its effects.

First of all you state it doesnt exist, a firm statement, then you quetsion your own comments by saying "if there were". Actually global warming is a fact, nobody has ever denied it and can't the Earth has warmed and cooled naturally for millions of years. What's the problem then? WE are increasing those natural effects (again fact) with our emissions and wasteful use of our natural resources. Sure, our planet will live for many millenia after humans exist, but why make that existence shorter?

You prove you have nothing but a very elementary concept of the subject yet speak with such voracity, perhaps you should try learning about it first.

by oz_media

Neil, I have performed lectures for science classes at the science center here on how our eyes interpret colours. I understand the sky reflections but that really isn tho wthis all started at all. I used a figreu of speech, a la, "as right as the sku is blue".

That figure of speech has been dragged out into a science class by some geeks with absolutely no ability to comprehend the subject and see the difference in the focus of the thread.

As for Co2, yes that is a greeenhouse gas. But CO, Carbon MONoxide is the really harmful emission, to us, right now, as we live and breath everyday. CO is the reason I support clean air emissions standards etc. That's what kills us.

by maxwell edison

.....[i]There's a sucker born every minute.[/i]

And to prove that point, how many [i]"suckers"[/i] believe that Mr. Barnum ever uttered those words? No, he never did. In fact, Mr. Barnum had too much respect for the public to ever view them in such a light. Unfortunately, we can't say the same for those who are the driving force behind the "Global Warming" scare. And also unfortunately, it only goes to show that if a lie is repeated often enough, everybody will begin to believe it as truth.

"The noblest art is that of making others happy, honesty, sobriety, industry, economy, education, good habits, perseverance, cheerfulness, love to God and good will toward men. These are the preeminent requisites for securing health, independence, or a happy Life, the respect of mankind and the special favor of our Father in Heaven", or so says Mr. P.T. Barnum.

None of the traits of which Mr. Barnum spoke seem to apply to today's Democrat Party and the people advancing the notion that human activity is causing the earth to warm at an alarming and dangerous rate. Everything they advanced is based on the premise of doom-and-gloom, class envy, race-baiting, dependency on others, pessimism, advancing the facade of wide-spread misery, and the false notion of human-caused global warming.

It's a factopinguess that close to 99 percent of the American population doesn't know the first thing about greenhouse gasses, CO2 emissions, historical temperature fluctuations, global warming and cooling cycles, and so forth; but the American public is so stupid and helpless in every aspect, or so says the leftist propaganda machine -- and so believes the leftist power mongers -- that they can be convinced of anything. Yep, they realize that the American public can indeed be duped into believing the earth is being invaded by beings from Mars, as Orson Wells showed, or that the earth is being destroyed by man himself. And now the ignorant are even presenting arguments of proof, although most of them don't know the first thing about the subject.

Wake up, people! P.T. Barnum was a master showman, but all he did was to put on a show. It's the leftist global warming crowd that's attempting to dazzle you with the illusion that man is more powerful than the forces of nature. We never have been and we never will be. If you believe otherwise, well, just go have a sucker and watch [i]The Sky is Falling[/i] show.

by oz_media

I often visualize clowns, with red noses and giant, funny shoes and hear Kaliope music when reading your posts.

"Ice cold Coke heeeeeeear! Git yer hot buttered popcorn!"

(boo-boo-booddle-oo-do-do-doop-doop-doo-doo)

"shhhhhh, Max is about to tell us about his politcal views from the right ring. There he is with all the other Republicans in that little car"

Aw c'mnon Max, now that was funny.

by maxwell edison

....much of the so-called "right-wing" has also bought into the notion that human activity is causing the earth to warm.

Be careful when you try to be funny. Sometimes it just comes across as being stupid.

by tonythetiger

belief I have that pertains to this subject is that there is far too little evidence to come to [b]any[/b] conclusion.

by tonythetiger

that according to conjecture, large amounts of CO2 in the atmosphere could cause a global cooling (which had been described as [b]like[/b] a 'nuclear winter')

by hal 9000

That would mean that Life was evolving to continue to live in the changing climates wouldn't it?

Are you now saying that the [b]Monster EL Lie[/b] thread was wrong?

by protiusx

You?re being silly. How does climate change cause speciation? Adaptation is a biologic function that has been reproduced many times and is well understood. Darwinian evolution has to do with speciation where organisms change into completely different species by way of genetic mutation which has never been reproduced, observed or evidenced in the fossil record.

by hal 9000

Is the Great Barrier Reef off the coast of QLD constantly suffering from Bleaching and dieing off in massive amounts over he past 10 or so years?

If the increased Ocean Surface Temperature which is causing this problem was a natural process it should be much slower to allow for the species involved to adapt to the changes which they clearly are not! The only thing that has helped the Great Barrier Reef recently was Larry which introduced a lot of Cold Water into that part of the reef and allowed the coral to recover from the heat stress that it had been exposed to. Unfortunately it didn't affect a large enough area of the reef to have the required impact on the reef but the area that was affected is now better off for the Cyclone than those areas that remained unaffected.

Col

by absolutely

Would a [b]fossil[/b] of both species' DNA be required to convince you that one species had mutated to another?

by tonythetiger

Where do most people like to vacation? There are far more tickets sold to St. Thomas or Cancun, than to Reykjavik or Yakutsk :)

by absolutely

I should have been more specific: I meant, but neglected to specify, the era before [b]human-caused[/b] global warming, which means before the Industrial Revolution. Nice catch.

by absolutely

Earth has indeed had changes in average temperature that have not been catastrophic. But these changes occurred over longer periods than the temperature changes cause by human-built combustion engines and the CO2 emitted. In tech terms, it's like sending 9 Terabytes of data to be processed immediately, to a system with 512 MB of system memory. The planet just can't continue to change temperature so quickly.

by absolutely

"You, on the other hand have not demonstrated the ability to present original thought or put forth your ideas in a manor that is neither childish nor belligerent."

I have no incentive to prove anything about my manor (sic) to anybody, here or elsewhere.

by oz_media

Remove ALL gases and impurities and light reflection from the air and it becomes a colourless/odourless gas.

What you claim is black would actually be outer space, unlit and black of course.

by oz_media

Yes I know the right wing has many GW supporters. You really missed that post completely.

It's nearly impossible to offer light banter with technically minded people.

Take the upper thread for example, I use a common figure of speech, such as 'as sure as teh sky is blue' and it turns into a scientific discussion about the physical characteristics or the sky and human optics.

That's what happens when you talk to nerds, they just don't see the forest througth the trees. It happens in nearly all threads here, what some say is misunderstanding is simply someone not being able to see the gyst of a topic because they are trying to analyze it one word at a time, as if they don't they won't get it, which is what actually happens by overanalysis.

But seeing as you had no comeback, I'll accept your irrelevant poke, whether it works or not.

by absolutely

"Take the upper thread for example, I use a common figure of speech, such as 'as sure as teh sky is blue' and it turns into a scientific discussion about the physical characteristics or the sky and human optics.

That's what happens when you talk to nerds, they just don't see the forest througth the trees. It happens in nearly all threads here, what some say is misunderstanding is simply someone not being able to see the gyst of a topic because they are trying to analyze it one word at a time, as if they don't they won't get it, which is what actually happens by overanalysis."

Without nerds the rest of you would still be fleeing from tigers, if not extinct altogether. If the literal meanings of your words do not effectively communicate your intended "gyst", the fault belongs to you for choosing the wrong words (an din you're case4 miss tie ping most uvthem!), not to your audience for taking you at your words.

Every second of your life that you spend [b]not[/b] running for your life, you owe directly to nerds for inventing the devices that bestow on you the luxury of pursuing happiness instead of fleeing terror and suffering from predators. Quit trying to pretend that there is any better type of person than an intellectual. The epithet "nerd" does not diminish the importance of human intellect, which is the only reason [b]any[/b] of us are alive instead of killed by faster, stronger, venomous species with sharper claws or teeth. Nerds are [b]better than average[/b] people, and the rest of you will be much better for it when you stop trying to pretend that you haven't noticed this fact.

by oz_media

First of all, you obviously place yourself into this group of 'nerds' and then imply that you are a superior to everyone else as nerds have invented everything since the dawn of time? Really? No....reeeealy?

That's the most insanely inaccurate comment I think I've ever read on TR.

No inventions or advances in man's world have ever been discovered or created by pure accident. NO workingclass,middle class person has ever invented anything of any importance to the advancement of mankind?

"Nerds are better than average people, and the rest of you will be much better for it when you stop trying to pretend that you haven't noticed this fact."

Uh, ooookay then. Tell you what,the day 'nerds' realize that they aren't making the world rotate is probably the time when they will be accepted by the mainstram and not become overly defensive and unable to socialize with the rest of society.

Oh my gawd he's lost it. Whatever you stupid dork, that comment alone should see you baished from your secret society. LOL, that's too dumb for a nerd. Get over yourself and realize your just a stupid human like anyone else on this big blue ball, except unable to function in a social situation. I can't believe you actually said that, it really is laughable. :) What an idiot! :p

by tony hopkinson

But if you take a position to keep on the way we are based on the fact that the evidence for changing isn't incontavertible, then by way of action you are saying it's wrong.
The consequences of being wrong about global warming and not taking action are far greater than those of being wrong about it and doing something.
One hurts a few people's pockets temporarily, the other, everybody permanently. So simple pragmatism says you should operate on the basis that human caused global warming is fact until proven otherwise.

Any argument that says we should do nothing until it happens and is therefore too late to do anything is flat out self serving, short sightedness as best

by eclypse

What a bunch of crap. Twenty-five years ago we were all going to freeze to death from global cooling. Now we're all going to die from global warming. The idea that everything bad that happens is because of human beings is stupid.

Let's throw away all of our technology and live in caves again or just kill ourselves to save the planet and the environment. My philosophy is, simply stated, screw the environment. This whole global warming "scare" is just to keep people rolling in government grant money. Without global warming, they have no reason to exist. Just wait a few more years and it'll be something else that we're all responsible for.

And I don't worry about STFU because I didn't address the science - I addressed the money. That's where you should be looking.

by absolutely

Sum the total magnitude of petroleum and auto industries, and you have the financial incentive to deny global warming, regardless of any evidence.

by absolutely

SHOW...ME...THE [b]MONEY[/b]!!!

While you're saving up the money you want me to see, you can tell me who has ever espoused the "idea that everything bad that happens is because of human beings."

Agreed:

"The idea that everything bad that happens is because of human beings is stupid."

It's also stupid for you to expect me to incorporate your straw man to my argument. My position is that humans can in fact solve almost every problem we face, and there is no reason to dismiss global warming, because that can be solved too.

"Let's throw away all of our technology and live in caves again or just kill ourselves to save the planet and the environment."

You're free to dispose of your technology, and as far as I'm concerned to dispose with your life, as you please. I would prefer to switch to a battery-powered vehicle and other technologies that don't pollute. Caring about my environment doesn't make me the technology hater you're imagining.

by Member 25348569

Pielke seemed the more reasonable to me. Hardly trying to rape your economy:

"There are uncertainties. It?s not like you change your light bulbs today, you?re going to have better weather tomorrow," he said. "It?s even better if those actions you?re taking make sense for other reasons, like getting off Middle Eastern oil or saving money."

Strikes me as more "reasonable" than:

"Why do it if it?s not going to make a difference anyway?" he [Gray] said. "Whether I?m right or wrong, we can?t do anything about it anyway."

Given that if he's wrong then why should we take Gray's advice on whether we can mitigate the effects?

by absolutely

"Why do it if it?s not going to make a difference anyway?" he [Gray] said. "Whether I?m right or wrong, we can?t do anything about it anyway."

The best thing I can still say about Maxwell Edison is that if economics were the topic, he would never espouse an opinion that humans lack the talent or wherewithal to change our own situation. I know that talent and wherewithal can also produce cleaner technology than the internal combustion engine, but that battery-powered cars don't require nearly such frequent replacement of oil, filters, hoses, belts, and a host of other parts that wear relatively because of higher temperatures and more moving parts, compared to an electric engine.

Follow the money, indeed!

by maxwell edison

...that global warming, or climate change, or whatever else they might want to call it these days, is not an environmental issue, but rather a political issue designed to frighten (or dupe) the electorate into voting for certain people. That's why these people are all talk and no walk. Al Gore is an easy example to consider. If he really believed (or was really committed) in what he said, he wouldn't drive an SUV or even have any for his staff, and he wouldn't fly around the country in a planet-destroying private jet; he wouldn't be investing in radio and television stations whose only purpose is to advance a political agenda, but rather in alternative energy technologies. Look at his lifestyle, and compare it to the lifestyle he espouses for others, and that alone is sufficient reason to disregard everything the hypocrite says.

Coupled with the most obvious fact that it is not "scientists" who are coming out in droves -- and in concert -- warning about "global warming", but rather politicians seeking votes. If this was as dire a situation as those advocates would like us to believe, we would be seeing a million-scientist-march on Washington!

The following is a cut-and-pasted excerpt:

[i]On the floor of the U.S. Senate during debate on Senate Bill 139 back in 2004, Arizona Senator John McCain described his affection for the writings of Ernest Hemingway, especially his famous short story "The Snows of Kilimanjaro." Then, showing photos of the magnificent landmark taken in 1993 and 2000, he attributed the decline of glacial ice atop the mount during the intervening years to CO2-induced global warming, calling this attribution not only a fact, but a fact "that cannot be refuted by any scientist."

In subsequent debate on the same bill, New York Senator Hillary Clinton echoed Senator McCain's sentiments. Displaying a second set of photos taken from the same vantage point in 1970 and 1999 - the first depicting "a 20-foot-high glacier" and the second "only a trace of ice" - she said that in those pictures "we have evidence in the most dramatic way possible of the effects of 29 years of global warming."

Sadly, and despite the absolute certitude with which the two senators expressed their views on the subject - which allowed for no "wiggle room" whatsoever - both were as wrong as they could possibly be, according to the conclusions of six of the best scientists ever to study the legendary mountain and its once majestic ice-capped peaks.[/i]

http://www.co2science.org/scripts/CO2ScienceB2C/articles/V9/N38/EDIT.jsp

In my opinion, this is the absolute biggest scam in the history of mankind. And I'm amazed at the otherwise intelligent people who have bought into it lock, stock, and barrel.

http://www.co2science.org/scripts/CO2ScienceB2C/Index.jsp

by protiusx

I don't think TR's forums are liberal but I do think that there are more leftists who post than conservatives. The problem is that liberal ideology is so warped and perverse that it is impossible to argue these points intelligently. So, when a liberal posts something it comes off as either the angry ranting of the lunatic fringe or is obviously cut and pasted from another source of liberal propaganda.

by tony hopkinson

I bet on several isues you are more 'liberal' than I am.

Calling Abs a left winger because he feels global warming is a fact is like calling you one because you believe in freedom of religion!

Me and Abs do agree on global warming , I guarantee we would't agree on methods of attacking it.
I find myself in total agreement with Apotheon on edcuation and IP , yet he's a free market capitalist and I call it feudalism writ large.

To dismiss an argument on one issue because of your own idealogical posturing on other issues is foolish in the extreme.

It will cut profits so therefore you are a commie and it is bollocks. That isn't insane?

by absolutely

How much money is paid every year in automobile repairs, for parts & labor? How much less would it cost to maintain a car with an electric motor powered by batteries? That amount is the economic incentive to tell the lie that global warming is not a fact. I don't assert this amount (which I haven't researched, but everybody who owns a car knows it's a lot) as proof that automakers, parts manufacturers and mechanics are deliberately conspiring to keep electric cars from assembly lines. But, I do assert that such a situation is [b]more[/b] plausible than the situation that professional scientists with the intellect and discipline to earn PhD's are unable to find productive work, and have fabricated the concept of global warming caused by gases produced by incomplete combustion, in order to create jobs perpetuating a fairy tale.

by absolutely

"I merely stated that the effect is not as great as being reported by the left wing propaganda machine and regurgitated on forums such as this."

Quantify your assertion and submit it to peer review, or it is dismissed out of hand. That is how science works.

by absolutely

"That's what happens when you talk to nerds, they just don't see the forest througth the trees. It happens in nearly all threads here, what some say is misunderstanding is simply someone not being able to see the gyst of a topic because they are trying to analyze it one word at a time, as if they don't they won't get it, which is what actually happens by overanalysis."

Right there, you defined a nerd as somebody who is able to analyze your words, one at a time, and see that there is no substance or cohesion to your argument. People who are able to articulate our intended meanings, one word at a time, are really better than those of you who cannot articulate your "gyst" to others using the literal meanings of words.

by absolutely

"You, on the other hand have not demonstrated the ability to present original thought or put forth your ideas in a manor that is neither childish nor belligerent."

Whether a thought is original and whether that thought is correct are entirely separate questions. I endeavor to be correct. Originality is irrelevant.

by protiusx

Okay Rabbit I'll be your Alice and chase you down this rabbit hole. How are you measuring your "correctness"? You posted a thread that began this debate; the very idea of which was neither created by you nor penned by you. You have not attempted to substantiate your position in any way and have had many opposing comments that refute the basis of your argument. So how are you, by any definition, correct?

by absolutely

What I said about originality is that originality is [b]not[/b] a criterion of correctness.

"You posted a thread that began this debate; the very idea of which was neither created by you nor penned by you."

I accept those statements as factual.

"You have not attempted to substantiate your position in any way and have had many opposing comments that refute the basis of your argument."

What do you suppose my "argument" to be? Where has its basis been refuted? When you, or anybody else, can present any facts that can reasonably be interpreted so as to cast doubt on the fact of global warming, or partial combustion as its primary cause, I will address them.

Until then, I restate my position on "original thought": the truth of a premise is determined by its consistency with reality, not in any part by the identity of the first person to express the premise.

"So how are you, by any definition, correct?"

Methodologically, I am correct by checking every premise I hold, if I ever find it to be contradicted by reality. The nature of reality is such that contradictions among facts cannot exist. Therefore, the perception of any contradiction must be a result of some misunderstanding, in other words, one or more incorrect premises.

"So how are you, by any definition, correct?"

I have already cited easily understandable data that proves, with 84% certainty, that at least two-thirds of measured increase in sea surface temperatures can [b]only[/b] be explained by greenhouse gases emitted by human processes. Competing models, including volcanic activity, were also part of the comparison cited in the opening post, and those [b]failed[/b] to explain the measured increases in sea surface temperature. So, if because the claims did not originate with me, you conclude that [b]I[/b] am not correct, fine. But the assertion that two thirds of measured increase in sea surface temperature is due to human activity, with 84% certainty, has not been refuted by any alternative explanation even once, let alone many times.

by protiusx

Why must you always begin your posts with a question? Especially a question that has absolutely nothing to do with the post it's attached to. How does the bleaching and dieing off of choral correlate in any way to speciation or biological adaptation? The choral was not able to adapt to the toxicity of the water or the temperature changes and so it died. Death was a result of a failure to adapt to the environmental conditions. This happens all the time. How does this prove or disprove man's involvement with global warming?

by hal 9000

Dump Gasoline as a Fuel a use Hydrogen which is both plentiful & clean to use. Currently LPG Powered cars are common because the cost of LPG is much lower than petrol in all it's forms. So a switch to Hydrogen wouldn't be a major step that requires massive changes to the current technology that is being used and would have no harmful byproducts of combustion.

Of course better materials would be required in Exhaust Systems and there would be no need for Catalytic Converters so there may be a slight Legalisation issue involved here but all in all it would be a cleaner easy to introduce alternative fuel that is constantly replaceable as it will never run out.

If you then go with the better Man Made Lubricants which have somewhere around 100,000 KMS between Oil Changes revert back to using multiple belts instead of one to do it all there should be very little pollution produced by the current crop of motor vehicles.

Granted in the interim the change would result in a lot of rusted out Exhaust Systems but that's only Iron Oxide which can be reused and initially a lot of the conventional Lubricants would be required to be disposed of when the initial change was made but again these can be re manufactured into something better.

Dr Porsche had it right all those years ago when he wanted to use Hybrid vehicles for mass transport his original idea was to have a fuel consuming engine powering a Electric Generator to charge batteries and incorporate Regenerative Braking to help recharge the batteries and do away with any form of brakes as we currently know them so there would be no pollution arising from there as the electric motors would when in the Over Run situation be generating power that is feed into the batteries to be stored till required. Unfortunately while the idea was perfect the current technology of the time was sadly lacking in Storage Capacity so it was impractical for anything but big units like the Diesel Electric Trains that are so widely used now days and some extremely heavy Artillery used by Germany in WW11.

It's only been with recent advances in Storage Technology that his ideas have been realistically possible and it's not currently in the Fuel Companies Best Interests to see these vehicles developed particularly if they where to burn Hydrogen and no fossil fuels.

The new Ceramic Constructed fully sealed Graphic lubricated engines burning hydrogen would of course be a much better use as they would produce no pollutants other than when they where destroyed and special precautions would have to be undertaken in the proper disposal of these items.

Col

by hal 9000

But it does prove that the Coral in this case which is dieing because of increased water temperature is not adapting so that provided that this is a Natural Occurrence something is going wrong!

If this was natural it would be slower and allow the Coral to evolve/Change/Adapt or whatever which isn't happening.

As far as Toxicity goes this is directly attributabled to man by the overuse of fertiliser & pesticides that is allowed to run off and flood the rivers and then pollute the reef so there can be no debate about Man's involvement in this particular issue it is incontrovertible proof that Man is Responsible for a build up of Toxins in some localised areas of the Great Barrier Reef.

However the original question here was not about man polluting the Reef but weather or not man has some input into making the Oceans Hotter and causing this problem to occur.

Incidentally I wasn't the one to raise any issue with Toxicity caused by man I only made reference to the Heat Issue that is one of the current things that is happening, the toxicity issue has mostly been handled by proving to the farmers that they can actually save money by not using the chemicals in the quantises that they where previously.

Col

by oz_media

And give it a good shake. Somethin' aint right up there?!

The ability to define individual words is not considered more clever than ability to comprehend meaning. Breaking everything down into the smallest pieces so you can understand them is actually considered a neurosis that requires professional help. This is called neurotic behaviour, it's a clear sign of a damaged mind.

Being able to read something into a message that simply is not there at all is actually a hinderance and is not helpful to anyone at all.

As you can see in this thread alone, your simple inability to conprehend a comment has resulted in your endless drivel about how you feel nerds are so much more clever than other humans. I mean, its not even remotely LOGICAL and you're basing your entire argument on it??? Even the REAL self proclaimed 'nerds' on TR woul dthink you are insane by stating nerds are moreintelligents than others. Your complete lack of social activity proves that you are not only a nerd, but one who completely fails to see society for what it is. So next time your car breaks down, remember, nerds didn't engineer it, nerds didn't design it and nerds sure as hell aren't about to fix it.

But didn't they invent everything worthwhile for mankind?

To claim anything else, is pure insanity, not being clever but sheer madness. There is a BIG difference between being ahead of your time, eccentric and yet still considered mad while actually being a genius, and what you claim to be, that's for sure. In your case it really is madness, eccenticity, and being so far behind everyone else that you completely see something that nobody has presented.

Like I said, give your head a good shake, you really need a wake up call.

by maxwell edison

ProtiusX, [i]"I did not say that humans have no effect on their environment. I merely stated that the effect is not as great as being reported by the left wing propaganda machine and regurgitated on forums such as this."[/i]

Tony said, "This is a left wing forum ? Why am generally in the minority then ?"

Sorry, Tony, but I can't see where your response accurately addressed what ProtiusX actually said. He said that the human-caused global warming claim is something started by, advanced by, and perpetuated by the left wing propaganda machine. I agree; and it's something I've also suggested. He went on to say that the rhetoric is repeated in forums like these. I did not see where he called this a "left wing forum".

He then said, [i]"I don't think TR's forums are liberal but I do think that there are more leftists who post than conservatives. The problem is that liberal ideology is so warped and perverse that it is impossible to argue these points intelligently. So, when a liberal posts something it comes off as either the angry ranting of the lunatic fringe or is obviously cut and pasted from another source of liberal propaganda."[/i]

I also agree. There do seem to be more left-thinking people who post in these political discussions than right-thinking people. He sees the liberal ideology as warped and perverse, and he finds it impossible to argue these points intelligently. Again, I agree. How often have I suggested that a left-leaning emotional argument is difficult to counter with a right-leaning reasoned argument? And the left-wing (in the USA) does indeed come across as angry ranting. I've also seen all sorts of people simply repeat the same silly left-wing rhetoric that only gets repeated over and over again.

You called that "That is trite and insulting".

Well, personally speaking, I find it to be the epitome of insulting when one person presumes to tell another person how to live. I find it to be the epitome of insulting when one person presumes to vote himself (or another) the fruits of another person's labor. Who should be insulted when a person votes himself the property of another?

ProtiusX also never did call Abs a left-winger. He called human-caused global warming left-wing propaganda -- and it is. Besides, if you want to try to label Abs, look for the message in which he says that in the absence of a Libertarian candidate on the ballot, he searches for the most liberal Democrat to vote for. Personally speaking, I'm not sure what that makes him.

You concluded by saying, [i]"To dismiss an argument on one issue because of your own ideological posturing on other issues is foolish in the extreme. It will cut profits so therefore you are a commie and it is bollocks. That isn't insane"[/i]

I appears to me that you read too much into what ProtiusX actually said -- and way too much into what he didn't say.

The bottom line on global warming is this. It IS NOT a forgone conclusion that human activity is causing the earth to warm. The "left-wing propaganda machine" is advancing the issue as though it is, but it's not. Therefore, any solution or cure is not only premature, but silly and unwise.

by protiusx

I doubt your first statement but unless we do the comparison one will never know.
I have never dismissed an argument outright as is the modus operandi of those who can not form a cogent argument. My point is that all to often my liberal TR brethren will spew forth some dribble like "Bush lied and kids died" or "That's the way it is. It's a fact and if you don't believe it then STFU". I don't say these things at all! I encourage those who disagree with me to form their arguments and present them in a cohesive and well constructed way.
There have been a few (such as Neil and Oz and sometimes HAL9000) who have posted some very interesting arguments without resorting to personal attacks, outright dismissal or throwing epithets.

by absolutely

SUVs & ad hominem attacks are both more [b]convenient[/b] than their alternatives. Stupid commie!

by absolutely

Do you see the humor yet? Irony, and essential agreement with Tony's statement about facts & meaning, are all I was trying to convey there. I'm sorry for anybody who took the time to read that, and wasn't amused.

by protiusx

Ocean Cooling Confounds Climate Models
Climate Science, August 14, 2006
A new study of ocean temperatures indicates significant cooling over the years 2003-2005. This unexpected result has implications for climate models. As Roger Pielke SR of Colorado State University says, "The explanation of this temporal change in the radiative imbalance of the Earth?s climate system is a challenge to the climate science community. It does indicate that we know less about natural- and human-climate forcings and feedbacks than concluded in the IPCC Reports." The abstract reads,

?We observe a net loss of 3.2 (? 1.1) X 10**22 J of heat from the upper ocean between 2003 and 2005. Using a broad array of in situ ocean measurements, we present annual estimates of global upper-ocean heat content anomaly from 1993 through 2005. Including the recent downturn, the average warming rate for the entire 13-year period is 0.33 ? 0.23 W/m2 (per unit area of the Earth?s surface). A new estimate of sampling error in the heat content record suggests that both the recent and previous cooling events are significant and unlikely to be artifacts of inadequate ocean sampling.?

Selected excerpts from the article read,

?From 1993 to 2003, the heat content of the upper ocean increased by 8.1 (? 1.4) X 10**22 J. This increase was followed by a decrease of 3.2 (? 1.1) X 10**22 J between 2003 and 2005. The decrease represents a substantial loss of heat over a 2-year period, amounting to about 21% of the long-term upper-ocean heat gain between 1955 and 2003 reported by Levitus et al., [2005].?

?From 1993 to 2005, the average rate of upper-ocean warming as determined by a linear least squares fit is 0.33 ? 0.23 W/m2 per unit area of the Earth?s surface.?

?The recent decrease in heat content amounts to an average cooling rate of -1.0 ? 0.3 W/m2 from 2003 to 2005, and results in a lower estimate of average warming from 1993 to 2005 than that recently reported for the 1993 to 2003 period [Willis et al., 2004].?

?The cooling signal is distributed over the water column with most depths experiencing some cooling. A small amount of cooling is observed at the surface, although much less than the cooling at depth?..The maximum cooling occurs at about 400 m and substantial cooling is still observed at 750 m?..The cooling signal is still strong at 750 m and appears to extend deeper?

??.the updated time series of ocean heat content presented here (Figure 1) and the newly estimated confidence limits (Figure 3) support the significance of previously reported large interannual variability in globally integrated upper-ocean heat content [Levitus et al., 2005]. However, the physical causes for this type of variability are not yet well understood. Furthermore, this variability is not adequately simulated in the current generation of coupled climate models used to study the impact of anthropogenic influences on climate [Gregory et al., 2004; Barnett et al. 2005; Church et al. 2005; and Hansen et al., 2005]. Although these models do simulate the long-term rates of ocean warming, this lack of interannual variability represents shortcoming that may complicate detection and attribution of human-induced climate influences.?

This is a very important observational study of changes in climate system heat content. While the models predict a general montonic increase in ocean heat content (e.g. see (Figure 1) ), the new observations in Lyman et al 2006 show an important decrease. The explanation of this temporal change in the radiative imbalance of the Earth?s climate system is a challenge to the climate science community. It does indicate that we know less about natural- and human-climate forcings and feedbacks than concluded in the IPCC Reports. "

How about that?

by tonythetiger

[i]The "left-wing propaganda machine" is advancing the issue as though it is, but it's not. Therefore, any solution or cure is not only premature, but silly and unwise.[/i]

is not what they propose or try... it's [b]who's going to be paying for it![/b]

What it boils down to is: They're not out anything if they're wrong!

by absolutely

"Child" you say? Fine, I won't dispute that. I know my age, and your opinion won't change that.

Key words like "left wing propaganda machine" can falsely give the impression to many readers, without proof, that your opponents' claim(s) is/are false. Because I am not a leftist, I do not take that particular epithet personally. But your response (criticism of the style of my delivery instead of the substance of the research I initially presented) is the basic reason that I continue to request quantified arguments, which you and Maxwell both continue to not provide.

I'll try to be less confrontational now, and return to the text of the message directly up the vertical line from this one:

"I did not say that humans have no effect on their environment. I merely stated that the effect is not as great as being reported by the left wing propaganda machine and regurgitated on forums such as this."

How great does "the left wing propaganda machine" report the human effect on the environment? How "great" or not great do you say the effect [b]is[/b]? Please do me the courtesy of treating me as though I am not part of any "left wing propaganda machine" and that I honestly believe the facts as I have cited them. In fact, I am not running for any elected office, and have no other reason to hope for any material gain, other than keeping the Earth habitable for myself and other humans, if I successfullynconvince people of the reality of globabl warming caused by combustion of fossil fuels.

by absolutely

My initial reaction is that a pattern of 3 years is cause for hope that temperature trends will stabilize in a range survivable for the human species, but that a single period of 3 years is not enough to start printing invites to the "Global Warming Was A Total False Alarm Party". Also, if a lot of Antarctic ice melts, that might reduce the temperature of the oceans, without implying that "global warming" is not continuing, or even accelerating. But primarily, I appreciate the effort to quantify your counterargument. Numerical measurements, published journals, and named researchers are exactly what I meant. Finally, a counterargument worth addressing!

by maxwell edison

Tony - That's not the point

They want the issue, not the "solution", so to speak. I've been following these global warming arguments since they started with the global cooling arguments. They want to gain power and control, not to "protect the environment". They're using it as a chip in the game for power so they can advance the rest of their agenda.

Why didn't Al Gore and Bill Clinton ever propose anything to seriously develop alternative energy sources? They even had a Democrat controlled Congress for their first two years. They campaigned, in part, on a global warming issue, but what's the first thing they did? Advance a national health care program. And why don't the Democrat faithful JUST DO IT? If Europe is so gung-ho about "solving global warming", go ahead. Just do it. They don't need the USA. Go ahead, Europe. Lead the way and show everybody how to do it. Go ahead, Tony. If you want to solve "global warming", just do whatever you need to do -- and the same to ALL of you. Nothing ever gets done because there's NOTHING TO DO! They want the issue to gain power and control, no more, no less.

by maxwell edison

...Become the change you see in the world.

In all ways, that's exactly how I live my life. One example is that I espouse self-responsibility, so I become responsible for self. Whatever it is I espouse and believe in, I just do it. I don't try to force anyone else to, but I'm constantly at battle with people who try to force me to live a certain way -- their way. I'm constantly at battle with people who try to deny me the right to take self-responsibility. I'm constantly at battle with people who try to take responsibility from me! (Social Security is a prime example.)

And all these "global warming advocates" are only trying to force others to capitulate to their will. But all they would have to do is become the change they see in the world. Why don't they?

It's a factopinguess that 150 million Americans and 1 billion Earthlings believe that human activity and human behavior -- presumably THEIR OWN activity and behavior -- is causing global warming. All they have to do is become the change they see in the world, regardless of what the rest of us do, and their "problem" will be "solved". That many people can do anything. But they don't do it. Why is that?

(I like this "factopinguess" word!)

by hal 9000

Shock Horror!!!!!!!! :^0 :D :^0 :D

What do you honestly expect he is a politician after all you only have to get really worried when he tells the truth and that applies to any Polly. The moment that they start telling the truth not washed though their lack of reality filters they get scary and stay that way! :p

Col

by absolutely

"Become the change you [b]want to[/b] see in the world." ?

I think I get your drift, and it's an admirable sentiment.

I see that bumper sticker at least twice a day in this hippie town. I don't really know much about Mister Gandhi, although I do remember that the movie makes him look like somebody who belongs on my top 10 list of historical figures I would have liked to meet, competing with Thomas Jefferson, Thomas Edison, Richard Feynman, James Clerk Maxwell, Aristotle, Louis Pasteur, Ayn Rand, James Madison, and a couple others.

Anyway, I agree that nobody who doesn't want one should be [b]in any way[/b] coerced to have an electric car. But I think that global warming [b]is[/b] caused primarily by the internal combustion engine and that car makers have a vested financial interest in continuing to build combustion engines, with a lot of parts that need frequent replacement. I further hypothesize that their interest is based on the ability to sell the same number of cars they do now, with a built-in [b]need[/b] in the market for replacement parts that we would all not need if our engines were purely electric instead of combustion-powered. My general hypothesis is that all liars, in this case the automobile industry, lack the industry, talent and wherewithal to adapt to a new, better motive force.

by maxwell edison

...is what I meant. As with any such quote, one could find a dozen variations, but the sentiment is the same.

Nonetheless, unlike you, I don't think that global warming is caused primarily by the internal combustion engine; and unlike Al Gore, I don't think the internal combustion engine is the greatest threat to mankind (source: [i]Earth in the Balance[/i], 1992). Regardless, on that one point, it's as simple as agreeing to disagree.

But also, unlike you, I don't "blame" the current crop of car makers for continuing to build it, nor do I espouse forcing them to change their ways. If you, and Al Gore, and every other "global warming advocate" quit buying them, quit driving them, quit riding in them, and even took it a step further and did whatever was necessary to compete with them by offering an alternative to their product, "your problem" would be half way solved -- perhaps even totally solved.

Your "general hypothesis is that all liars, in this case the automobile industry, lack the industry, talent and wherewithal to adapt to a new, better motive force." Well guess what, dude? All you global warming hypocrites and liars ALSO "lack the industry, talent and wherewithal to adapt to a new, better motive force". Who in the hell is stopping you? Nobody is stopping you. Like I so accurately pointed out, there are hundreds of millions of you "global warming advocates" who are doing NOTHING except crying in your beer about what other people are doing and/or not doing, sitting on your hands doing NOTHING. It's YOU people who are more despicable; it's YOU people who are the greater LIARS; and it's YOU people who are NOT becoming the change you (want to) see in the world.

Practice what you preach, or (as you love to say) just STFU. And don't say you can't do it, because you -- and especially the collective you -- can indeed do it if you really wanted to. And if you really can't, perhaps because it's impossible (or for whatever other reason), then everything you say is the epitome of disingenuousness and dishonesty. Either way, it's you guys who are blowing smoke out of your own exhaust pipe.

P.S. But then again, you guys (the collective leftists ..... the usual suspects behind the global warming scam) actually WANT to blow smoke, because it's the smokescreen you actually want; it's the smokescreen that you hide behind so you can advance your REAL agenda of power and control. It' not about global warming; it's not about protecting the environment; it's ALL about power and control. And YOU, Absolutely, have bought into it -- have been DUPED into it -- even if it means compromising your very own libertarian principles.

by jellimonsta

Abs, a big problem I see with the battery powered vehicle is the charge time. If I can get around 350 miles to a tank, and I can fill a tank in 5 minutes, it is convenient.
Say I want to drive 1000 miles, I don't want to stop overnight 3 times to recharge the car when I could do the trip in 16 hrs, ya know?!?! :D

by maxwell edison

....what about some sort of magneto devices, or electrical generators, incorporated into the axles of a vehicle, through which the batteries are recharging as the vehicle is moving? But the bigger question is this. Why haven't some of these "smarter-than-everybody-else" global warming advocates figured it out by now?

by tonythetiger

[i]what about some sort of magneto devices, or electrical generators, incorporated into the axles of a vehicle, through which the batteries are recharging as the vehicle is moving?[/i]

It would require breaking the laws of physics to put back as much energy as was taken out (same thing with a windmill on top of your electric car.). They [b]do[/b], however, use a variation of this theme when braking to capture some of that, otherwise wasted, energy. Now if we could get the highway department to make all roads go down hill :)

by protiusx

Hybrid cars do use this technology. I have a co-worker who has a hybrid car and I have shared a ride with her from time to time. There is a cool display that shows energy flow as it goes to the wheels from the battery or from the axels to the battery.

by jellimonsta

I know there are some dynamo/ magneto devices to influx otherwise wasted energy. However, it does not seem like the technology has been advanced to the level that would be acceptable for any kind of prolonged travel. IMHO.

by maxwell edison

...is putting his money where his mouth is.

http://www.breitbart.com/news/2006/09/21/D8K9AML02.html

This reminds me of a previous global warming discussion we had in which I suggested that global warming advocate investors should spend 10 to 40 billion on "their cause", to find and develop alternative energy sources, instead of trying to force other people and governments to spend it. One person's retort was, Maxwell, when was the last time you tried to raise 10 billion dollars? (How silly was that?)

Well, Richard Bransen just doled out 30 percent of it.

And you can be sure that he realizes the HUGE profit potential at the end of the road.

You'll find another thread in which I suggested to young people in their twenties to find jobs in the alternative energy sector.

I'm amazed at all the complaining we see around here, but nobody is willing to actually do anything and walk their own talk.

Abs, if you're driving a combustible engine automobile, you have no principle. (And now is when you blame other people for it.)

by absolutely

I hope his investment will be effective.

"Abs, if you're driving a combustible engine automobile, you have no principle. (And now is when you blame other people for it.)"

No, I don't blame other people for my combustion engine automobile. I bought it myself, knowing it's not the cleanest vehicle in existence, but I judged it to be the best vehicle for me right now based on a combination of personal safety, reliability, fuel efficiency, aesthetic appeal and affordability, in no particular order. I'm enough of a realist to know that becoming a zero-emissions individual could only reduce the total CO2 emissions of the planet by about one part in a Billion. But if I can convince a few people that electric cars are truly feasible, that would represent a more substantial contribution to climate stability.

Doesn't a similar principle motivate you to occasionally extol the virtues of capitalism publicly, during time you might otherwise spend in the pursuit of capital?

by absolutely

Charging time would be a limitation, at least for the early adopters. Once the free market chooses a standard battery type (or a small enough number of variations), the best idea I have heard is that drivers would exchange our drained batteries and a (reasonable?) fee for charged batteries at charging stations.

edit: put the "y" in "battery"

by absolutely

THE NEW YORK TIMES, THURSDAY, SEPTEMBER 21, 2006

British Science Group Says Exxon Misrepresents Climate Issues

By HEATHER TIMMONS

LONDON, Sept. 20 -- A British scientific group, the Royal Society, contends that [b]Exxon Mobil[/b] is spreading "inaccurate and misleading" information about climate change and is financing groups that misinform the public on the issue.

The Royal Society, a 1,400-member organization that dates back to the 1600's and has counted Isaac Newton and Albert Einstein as members, asked Exxon Mobil in a letter this month to stop financing these groups and to change its public reports to reflect more accurately the opinions of scientists on the issue.

There is a "false sense somehow that there is a two-sided debate going on in the scientific community" about the origins of climate change, said Bob Ward, the senior manager for policy communication at the Royal Society.

The reality is that "thousands and thousands" of scientists around the world agree that climate change is linked to greenhouse gases, he said, with "one or two professional contrarians" who disagree.

Dozens of lobbying groups, some of them receiving financing from Exxon Mobil, are relying on these contrarians as experts, Mr. Ward said. Meanwhile, he said, Exxon Mobil writes in documents it distributes to the public that it is difficult to determine the extent to which climate change can be attributed to human actions, a view that, he said, the vast majority of scientists do not share.

In a statement, Exxon Mobil said the Royal Society had "inaccurately and unfairly described our company." It added: "We know that carbon emissions are one of the factors that contribute to climate change -- we don't debate or dispute this."

Exxon Mobil said it was taking steps to minimize emissions of carbon dioxide and other greenhouse gases from its operations.

In a letter sent to Exxon Mobil this month, the Royal Society said it was "very difficult to reconcile the misrepresentations of climate change science in these documents with Exxon Mobil's claims to be an industry leader."

The letter states that Exxon Mobil pledged in July, after a meeting with the society, to stop financing organizations that spread information the society considers misleading, and it asks for proof that the financing has stopped.

in 2005, Exxon mobil sent $2.9 million to 39 groups active in the United States that spread misleading information about climate change, Mr. Ward said, including the Competitive Enterprise Institute, the International Policy Network and the Center for the Study of Carbon Dioxide and Global Change.

Exxon Mobil said in its statement that it gave financial support to organizations that "research significant policy issues and promote informed discussion on issues of direct relevance to the company." These organizations do not speak on the company's behalf, nor does it control their views and messages, Exxon Mobil said.

by protiusx

I hate to discount the source outright but we are talking about the New York Times. They're one of the progenitors of this whole mess. The NYT skips hand in hand with Al Gore and Hillary Clinton down the merry road of totalitarian communism. They may as well change the name of the paper to Pravda West.

by tony hopkinson

See if you can find someone else eh, given his history, I'd be as likely to accept the arguments of the CEOs of the top five lignite mining companies.

I loved comparing global warming to the third reich 'the big lie'

The Animal and Earth Liberation Front's being the biggest terrorist threat to the US was even funnier.

Perhaps he should organise an invasion and force a regime change.

ROTFLMAO

by maxwell edison

I'm amazed at you Brits (and Australians) who claim to know a person serving in our U.S. Senate based on reading a few select Internet stories, and then summarily dismiss his argument by dismissing him. What a dweeb!

As to your laughing at his suggestion that the Earth Liberation Front was, as you said, "the biggest terrorist threat to the U.S.", it might also humor you to know that those organizations were indeed listed by our FBI, at one time, as being the biggest terrorist threat to the U.S. And they probably are still listed as the biggest domestic terrorist threat.

"John Lewis, the FBI's deputy assistant director for counterterrorism, said animal and environmental rights extremists have claimed credit for more than 1,200 criminal incidents since 1990. The FBI has 150 pending investigations associated with animal rights or eco-terrorist activities, and ATF officials say they have opened 58 investigations in the past six years related to violence attributed to the ELF and ALF."

http://www.cnn.com/2005/US/05/19/domestic.terrorism/index.html

You're looking pretty foolish, Tony.

Edited addition:

It might also be interesting to note that any right-leaning organization that claimed responsibility for 1200 criminal/terrorist acts over the last 16 years might just get more negative press coverage than these left-leaning organization have. I wonder why most people don't realize the scope and frequency of their destructive activities?

by Former member

But I think I'd have to take Puppy's side on this. I don't have the faith in human nature that you do, perhaps. People don't drive (close to) the speed limit because it is the considerate, safe thing to do, they do it because they don't want to pay the fines. 1/4 million (+/-) may in fact be (relatively) philanthropic, and choose to recycle, drive economic cars, etc..., but the other many billions of people aren't going to pay more to recycle witout some 'incentive'.

by tony hopkinson

Ho hum.

You don't have to use epithets to insult people, you can used arguments so obviously flawed, that only a complete idiot would swallow them.

I find the imputation that I'm some sort of gullible thicko who can't keep his issues straight far more insulting than being called tree hugging commie liberal pinko.

Much more insulting !

Do you admit to the possibility that global warming might be caused by humans ?

Yes Or No !

by maxwell edison

You asked, [i]"Do you admit to the possibility that global warming might be caused by humans? Yes Or No?"[/i]

If you're asking me, the answer is no. That's the most ludicrous notion I've ever heard.