Global warming is real, and caused by humans.
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
by deepsand
by absolutely
You global warming advocates often claim that it's a forgone conclusion that there is general consensus within the scientific community that human activity is indeed causing global warming.
1. Define "scientific community" by describing those "scientists" who are both educated and experienced in whatever fields which would qualify them as being a person who can offer an expert opinion -- make that an expert conclusion based on their own findings or the review of other's findings. And, of course, define the field in which those particular scientists work. A nuclear scientist, for example, who works for the Atomic Energy Commission wouldn't qualify.
2. Show me the results of reliable poll conducted by a reliable polling organization which showed that the "scientists" you described above -- and ONLY the scientists you described above -- agreed that human activity was causing global warming, and that concluded there was a "general consensus" among those people that human activity is causing global warming.
3. Define "general consensus". Would that be at least 50 percent of those scientists polled? 60 percent? 76.8 percent? 100 percent? The poll results are necessary to reach this conclusion.
4. And as a matter of full disclosure, who do these "scientists" work for, and who pays their salary and/or provides their means of income?
You continually cite these people and presume to speak for them. How about defining and identifying who they really are?
by deepsand
by absolutely
Being published in [i]Science[/i] and/or in [i]Nature[/i] is my criterion for taking seriously any researcher, on a topic of such broad interest as global warming. For the very latest on efforts toward unbreakable encryption, I might look at a more specialized technical publication specializing in optical physics, but global warming is such a popular topic that I wouldn't include the "specialist" publications for the most subtle questions in climatology. But if you want to propose some climatology mags, I'd consider them.
For myself, I read [i]Science[/i] & [i]Nature[/i], the two publications most read by professional researchers to stay informed of the [b]most important[/b] developments in all fields of scientific research.
Just because something is published in a magazine or a newspaper, does that make it automatically credible? Or do you distinguish between particular magazines and newspapers? Do you simply give blanket-approval to all magazines and newspapers, or just the ones that publish stories that support your desired outcome -- or just certain ones? What if they publish something that can't be proven or supported -- like the questions I asked? What then?
If Science Magazine is given automatic crediblity, then is Mother Jones Magazine also credible? If not, why not?
If something is published as "fact", then there should be support for it somewhere. Don't you agree?
Where's the support? That's all I ask.
Just answer my questions, and don't deflect a difficult question by stating you read it in a magazine. That's contrary to absolutely everything else you claim to be.
My position is very simple, it could be true.
I can find scientists that say it isn't, I can find scientists that say it is. Both groups have their own agenda or are funded by people with their own agenda. Hence in terms of making an informed decision they are useless.
Other's position is that only they are right, and they wheel out their expert witnesses to justify a position they have ALREADY taken. Anything put forward by treehuggers or the moneyhuggers is prejudiced. That prejudgement has to be taken into account, you can't point the finger at one side without pointing it at the other.
So given no one can prove that we are or we aren't, I choose to operate on the basis that we are.
The reasoning is a simple cost benefit analysis.
If we cut our environmental impact, we lose some environmental impact, which set of scientists and interest groups are correct does not matter.
If we don't cut our environmental impact the nay sayers have to be right.
To accept the posibility and act on it risks the profit of those parts of the economy that can't adapt. To discount the possiblity, so you don't have to act, risk's the survival of a significant proportion of the entire biosphere.
In other words I'm not making my decision based on our knowledge of the situation, but on our ignorance of it.
It's nice when ethics and pragmatism march hand in hand though. I'm biased not prejudiced, there's a big difference.
by deepsand
I've pointed this out to him on several previous ocassions, but he persists in holding that remedial responses to a clear and present danger are somehow vastly superior to preventive responses to reasonably possible ones, to the extent that the latter are wholly unworthy of consideration.
Presumably, therefore, he has no type of insurance, health, disability, auto, homeowners or other, so as to be logically consistent with his position on the matter here at hand.
by oz_media
And that's what Max has refused to see.
[i]'If we do not change our direction, we are likely to end up where we are headed.' [/i]
I think the reason is that it is logical, as are most other issues he seems to refuse to see.
Global warming? Could be increased by man.
Emissions killing us? Undenicable reality.
Our emissions make us ill or kill us now, that is an absolute fact. Reducing our emissions of CO a deadly gas, will save lives, TODAY. Fact.
But, as there are many people in denial like Max, who don't want the inconvenience of emisisons control and industryial resourcefulness, that will simply ignroe the facts and focus on the questionable areas instead.
Just like suporting the Iraqi war, ignore, dismiss facts that are 'uncomfortable' to face, and replace them with questions that are focused on something else that is unknown, in order to create doubt.
Tiring, these days, just tiring.
by absolutely
I define a scientist as "both educated and experienced in whatever fields which would qualify them as being a person who can offer an expert opinion -- make that an expert conclusion based on their own findings or the review of other's findings" when they have their own findings published in [i]Science[/i] and/or [i]Nature[/i], for reasons I implied above, and will now clarify.
[i]Science[/i] and [i]Nature[/i] are the two most important publications in research science. They do not focus on one branch of science to the exclusion of others. Instead, they publish scientific results in all fields that are judged to be of greatest interest to the general scientific community. Which results are of greatest interest is the only "judgment call" these two magazines make regarding the experiments they publish, and experimental results are presented without comment, although they are usually summarized. One or both magazines also publish occasional opinion pieces, but in any given issue, the vast majority of pages are devoted to simple publication of experimental results, verbatim.
I look forward to addressing #2-#4, but I see no point in taking the time to do so until we agree on #1. As I tried to imply before, but will now say more literally, I'm willing to incorporate your input in order to facilitate discussion, in order to finalize proof.
by protiusx
Look, you read the NYT and believe what they write. You regurgitate what you have read as fact and the source of this information that you spew is the NYT. NYT's source is the Royal Society. My point is regardless of what the Royal Society did or did not say the NYT will spin it to their leftist agenda and print this propaganda for people like you to belly up to and drink deeply of.
As to the suite that the Royal Society is bringing against Exxon - so what? You have a group of people who "believe" something to be true and will not tolerate any dissension from anyone or anything and it just so happens that the UK has a law that will allow them to bring suite against the company in order to squelch the descent.
This is classic leftist strategy which is to not address the argument or the facts but stand on ones laurels and attempt to quell any opposition or debate.
by absolutely
"This is classic leftist strategy which is to not address the argument or the facts but stand on ones laurels and attempt to quell any opposition or debate."
What argument, and what facts, am I ignoring? Or, are you disappointed that I do [b]not[/b] ignore the absence of any contradictory facts, and of any meaningful counterargument? Would you like to try to contact the British Royal Society directly, then?
Do you have [b]any[/b] evidence to support your assertion that "regardless of what the Royal Society did or did not say the NYT will spin it to their leftist agenda and print this propaganda for people like you to belly up to and drink deeply of"? Can you show, in the article posted, any example of "spin" that contradicts the literal meaning of the facts? You have made an assertion. Now, let's see you try to support it with facts.
Dont' mind hearing your answer either, I'll even try not to take how much the guy is irritating me, out on you.
May be shift to one of Deepsand's current threads though. This one has gone well off topic in places.
by deepsand
The point being that there is no proof, short of a divine revelation, of the issue at hand that is or will be acceptable to you.
In this respect you differ not from those who cling to the "Creation Science" belief.
by deepsand
You demand "absolute" proof, where the appropriate measure is the preponderance of evidence.
And, by the way, where's the "proof" for your position?
by deepsand
black. You show more bias than I do.
The guy is about as credible as Al Gore when he invented the internet, he'd change his tune in a heartbeat if he wasn't going to get voted in or have his campaign chest filled, he's a politician!
No point in holding him up to me as some sort of example, my principles can't be bought for mere money.
You know the place, I couldn't find out.
Who puts the money up for his campaigns, which lobbying groups is he most cosy with?
I can excuse your lack of knowledge when it comes to our U.S. Senate and Senators. Heck, many Americans don't even understand the body. Why would I expect a Brit to understand?
What I know about the members of the British Parliament, you could shove into a thimble and it would rattle like a bee-bee in a boxcar. What you know about the U.S. Senate is probably comparable. I, however, don't presume to know such things, while you apparently do. I wonder why? Are you suggesting that you're more an expert on our Senate than I am?
And on "bias". There is nothing wrong with bias, unless one tries to hide it, and unless it's not based on basic principles. I always admit mine, while others evade and try to hide theirs. Look at these silly people building their global warming position on something they call a "fact", but when pressed on their "fact", they can't even come close to proving it. My "global warming" bias, for example, is that I do not trust the people (always politicians and activists) advancing the claim, and all I ask for is proof that their credible sources (scientists) have really formed a "general consensus" among themselves and are in agreement -- a very simple premise that they are simply lying about. And what's their retort? Prove that it's not true. How silly is that? Asking to prove such a negative? It's like asking one to prove aliens don't exist, and if I can't, then we need to prepare for their inevitable destruction of Earth.
By the way, if I were a U.S. Senator, I'd be saying the same thing the gentleman from Oklahoma has been saying. (A little U.S. Senate lingo for you.)
Whether or not we - Tony or myself - know anything about the workings of the US Senate, you are putting this guy forward as a commentator on climate change so I think we can feel free to comment.
A quick Google on senator James Inhofe and we find that, amongst other stuff, in a Senate speech, Inhofe said that America should base its Israel policy on a text of the Bible. This guy is a right-wing religious fundamentalist flake and, if you want him on your team, you have him.
As far as I can see, he's an End Times Fundamentalist with all that is implied in terms of an irrational belief in the imminent Apocalypse. If The Good Senator believes that the World Will End in the next ten years or so then he's hardly going to have an even slightly "normal" approach to a problem twenty or fifty years down the line!
Inhofe is the US environmentalist's - and posssibly the world's - worst nightmare. He makes major policy decisions based on heavy corporate and theological influences, flawed science, and an apocalyptic worldview - and he chairs the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee! Wow! You Yanks can pick 'em!
Do me a favour Max and stop taking the piss by holding up the likes of Inhofe as a supporter of your stance. It does you nor your platform any credit!
Neil
by absolutely
"What I know about the members of the British Parliament, you could shove into a thimble and it would rattle like a bee-bee in a boxcar. What you know about the U.S. Senate is probably comparable. I, however, don't presume to know such things, while you apparently do."
Whatever you "don't presume to know" will remain true, or remain false, regardless of your ignorannce of it, and regardless of your presumptuous assertion, implied by the choice to use the word "presume", that there is some sort of virtue in your ignorance.
Your argument is "stupid" so logic dictates you should be as well.
Logic
LOL
by deepsand
What "argument?"
Was this post mis-placed?
by deepsand
That's some of the stupidest tripe ever spouted.
Let's now turn to the good Republican Congressman from Florida, Tom Foley. Surly you'll want to claim him as your champion as well.
by deepsand
'One degree and we're done for'
27 September 2006
From New Scientist Print Edition.
Fred Pearce
"Further global warming of 1 ?C defines a critical threshold. Beyond that we will likely see changes that make Earth a different planet than the one we know."
So says Jim Hansen, director of NASA's Goddard Institute for Space Studies in New York. Hansen and colleagues have analysed global temperature records and found that surface temperatures have been increasing by an average of 0.2 ?C every decade for the past 30 years. Warming is greatest in the high latitudes of the northern hemisphere, particularly in the sub-Arctic boreal forests of Siberia and North America. Here the melting of ice and snow is exposing darker surfaces that absorb more sunlight and increase warming, creating a positive feedback.
Earth is already as warm as at any time in the last 10,000 years, and is within 1 ?C of being its hottest for a million years, says Hansen's team. Another decade of business-as-usual carbon emissions will probably make it too late to prevent the ecosystems of the north from triggering runaway climate change, the study concludes (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, vol 103, p 14288).
The analysis reinforces a series of recent findings on accelerating environmental disruption in Siberia, northern Canada and Alaska, underlining a growing scientific consensus that these regions are pivotal to climate change. Earlier this month, NASA scientists reported that climate change was speeding up the melting of Arctic sea ice. Permanent sea ice has contracted by 14 per cent in the past two years (Geophysical Research Letters, vol 33, L17501). However, warming and melting have been just as dramatic on land in the far north.
A meeting on Siberian climate change held in Leicester, UK, last week confirmed that Siberia has become a hotspot of global climate change. Geographer Heiko Balzter, of the University of Leicester, said central Siberia has warmed by almost 2 ?C since 1970 - that's three times the global average.
Meanwhile, Stuart Chapin of the University of Alaska Fairbanks this week reported that air temperatures in the Alaskan interior have risen by 2 ?C since 1950, and permafrost temperatures have risen by 2.5 ?C (Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, DOI: 10.1073/pnas.0606955103).
In Siberia the warming is especially pronounced in winter. "It has caused the onset of spring to advance by as much as one day a year since satellite observations began in 1982," says Balzter. Similarly, Alaskan springs now arrive two weeks earlier than in 1950, according to Chapin.
The Leicester meeting heard that the rising temperatures are causing ecological changes in the forests that ratchet up the warming still further. Vladimir Petko from the Russian Academy of Sciences Forest Research Institute in Krasnoyarsk says warm springs are triggering plagues of moths. "They can eat the needles of entire forest regions in one summer," he says. The trees die and then usually succumb to forest fires that in turn destroy soil vegetation and accelerate the melting of permafrost, Petko says.
In 2003 Siberia saw a record number of forest fires, losing 40,000 square kilometres according to Balzter, who has analysed remote sensing images of the region. Similar changes are occurring in Alaska. According to Chapin, warming there has shortened the life cycle of the bark beetle from two years to one, causing huge infestations and subsequent fires, which destroyed huge areas of forest in 2004. "The current boreal forest zone could be so dried out by 2090 that the trees will die off and be replaced by steppe," says Nadezhda Tchebakova, also at the institute in Krasnoyarsk.
Melting permafrost in the boreal forests and further north in the Arctic tundra is also triggering the release of methane, a powerful greenhouse gas, from thick layers of thawing peat. First reports published exclusively in New Scientist last year (13 August 2005, p 12) were recently confirmed by US scientists (Nature, vol 443, p 71).
"Large amounts of greenhouse gases are currently locked in the permafrost and if released could accelerate the greenhouse effect," says Balzter. Hansen's paper concludes that the effects of this positive feedback could be huge. "In past eras, the release of methane from melting permafrost and destabilised sediments on continental shelves has probably been responsible for some of the largest warmings in the Earth's history," he says.
We could be close to unleashing similar events in the 21st century, Hansen argues. Although the feedbacks should remain modest as long as global temperatures remain within the range of recent interglacial periods of the past million years, outside that range - beyond a further warming of about 1 ?C - the feedbacks could accelerate. Such changes may become inevitable if the world does not begin to curb greenhouse gas emissions within the next decade, Hansen says.
Meanwhile, another new study underlines that the boreal peat bogs, permafrost and pine forests are not just vital to the planet as a whole, they are major economic assets for the countries that host them. A detailed study of the northern boreal forests by environmental consultant Mark Anielski of Edmonton, Canada, puts the value of their "ecosystem services" at $250 billion a year, or $160 per hectare.
These benefits include flood control, water purification and pest control provided by forest birds, plus income from wilderness tourism and meat from wildlife such as caribou. Anielski presented his findings to Canada's National Forest Congress in Gatineau-Ottawa earlier this week.
The value of these ecosystem services is more than twice that of conventional resources taken from the region each year, such as timber, minerals, oil and hydroelectricity, Anielski says. "If they were counted in Canadian inventories of assets, they would amount to roughly 9 per cent of our gross domestic product - similar in value to our health and social services."
You can add to that figure the value of having such a huge volume of carbon locked away. "The boreal region is like a giant carbon bank account," he says. "At current prices in the European carbon emissions trading system, Canada's stored carbon alone would be worth $3.7 trillion."
And if Hansen is right that the carbon and methane stored in the boreal regions has the potential to transform the world into "another planet", then the boreal region may be worth a great deal more than that.
From issue 2571 of New Scientist magazine, 27 September 2006, page 8-9
by deepsand
Stratfor Public Policy Intelligence Report
Strategic Forecasting
PUBLIC POLICY INTELLIGENCE REPORT
07.27.2006
"Science, Policy and the Media"
By Bart Mongoven
Panels of journalists and scientists gathered July 25 at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington to discuss the mainstream media's reporting on climate change. The consensus was that the media have not covered the issue well. According to both panels, the greatest shortcoming has been in persistent portrayals of the issue as one of contentious scientific debate: In reality, the assembled scientists said, man-made climate change is generally accepted throughout the scientific community as a reality.
Most of the time at the conference was dedicated to examining the media's portrayal of the issue and explaining how it came into being. The root of the problem, most participants agreed, is that climate change has been covered primarily as a political rather than a scientific issue -- and thus, the media have focused on the political debate rather than the science behind it.
In the background of this discussion loomed a larger issue: The mainstream media, recognizing that there is more to the story, now are struggling with ways to change their portrayal of the climate change issue. Arguments are emerging that the scientific debate has now been concluded, "industry" has lost and the new debate is about policy options. Though this line of thinking is nearer to the truth, it does not entirely close the gap. The fact is that industry all but stopped contesting the premise of man-made climate change two years ago, but the media's preoccupation with the traditional battle lines -- industry versus environmentalists -- continues to obscure the complexity of the issue and the positions of various players.
The issue is worthy of examination because the media portrayals have some impact as public policy is formed. To be sure, the media are consumers of a complex discussion between mainstream scientific institutions, industry and activists -- each of whom approaches scientific debates with completely different outlooks, values and goals. At the same time, however, the "fourth estate" is positioned to break the complicated scientific matters into terms that both the public and politicians can understand. Reporters' ability to do so, as well as any tendencies to overlook or oversimplify aspects of the debate, can be felt down the road as regulations are formed. As editors and reporters come to recognize this, the media likely will assume a more important role in the shaping of public discourse and policy development.
The Importance of Scale
The portrayal issue is becoming particularly relevant at this time because the regulatory questions that are emerging at the nexus of science and politics are unlike any that have come before. Scientific knowledge and human ingenuity are producing technologies and results of incredible power and scale: Industrialization has reached a point at which the Earth's protective ozone layer has been threatened, and the planet's climate is likely being affected. At the same time, chemists are finding ways to work on an incredibly small scale -- developing nanotechnologies that could revolutionize medicine, consumer products and lifestyles.
With this remarkable scale (at both ends of the spectrum) comes unprecedented complexity -- and new challenges for the media that report on these issues. A layman easily can grasp the notion that vapor feedback mechanisms contribute to the Earth's climate (and even that these mechanisms counteract some of the warming that likely results from increased carbon in the atmosphere); however, the details of how these feedback mechanisms work are beyond the understanding of most nonspecialists. Meanwhile, sciences like toxicology are undergoing quiet revolutions: The interactions of specific substances and specific genes are being studied to determine whether some substances can have particularly beneficial or (more emphatically) particularly damaging effects on people with certain genetic makeups. These types of investigations (known as "toxicogenomics") are as complicated and involved -- yet as important in the scientific debate -- as climate feedback loops.
In the middle of all this, lawmakers, regulators and (increasingly) consumers are being asked to draw conclusions about such issues as the threat of climate change and the risks posed by nanoparticles. In addition to making these assessments, with the continuing trend toward deregulation, consumers and businesses are also being asked to weigh these risks against the benefits of cheap energy and emerging technologies.
The media play an important role in this process: Ultimately, they have the power to translate scientific debates and findings into words consumers and their representatives in government can understand. The way these issues are reported often dictates how certain issues are addressed in public policies.
To be fair, editors at major news organizations in industrialized countries appear to take this role very seriously. While not unheard of, unjustified consumer scares are surprisingly rare in industrialized countries, and when they do occur they generally result from intricate intentional campaigns to fool the media. Still, the media are in a difficult position as they report on complicated scientific issues: Their challenge is to navigate through the interplay between the scientific establishment, industry and policy advocates. And, it is important to note, the approaches and roles of these groups are changing in new and interesting ways.
The Industry Stance
Industry's view of the science behind public policy has changed markedly in recent years. As institutions, businesses crave stability and certainty. The regulations by which they are governed are important, but the predictability of the regulatory system is even more important in their eyes. Industry historically has preferred that public policy be determined by national governments and that policies give clear guidance as to what will and will not be allowed in the future.
For the most part, industry wants regulation that is based on firm unchanging scientific grounds -- and it wants regulatory language to be as unambiguous as possible. In most cases, it also wants regulations to be protective of health or the environment. For some companies, this is a very highly held social ethic. For others, it stems merely from fear of U.S. tort law. In either case, the tendency has been for companies to call for deliberate scientific investigation that justifies a regulation, while simultaneously acknowledging the importance of regulation.
This traditional approach is changing, however. As the problems of scale we already have discussed increasingly come into play, the trajectory of regulation is growing uncertain and difficult to chart. Further complicating matters is the deregulatory ethic in Congress and within the Bush administration, which has allowed issues to be debated in the public sphere but left businesses to work out the resolutions in private. The climate change debate in the United States, for example, shifted as it became clear to many companies that policies likely were forthcoming -- but the nature of these regulations remained opaque. The uncertainty this produced stymied company planning, research and development efforts. Uncertain which way the regulators would go, businesses erred on the side of conservatism and began to adopt very stringent self-regulatory policies in efforts to move past the impasse.
The perspective extends to more than just climate change, however. To cite another example, computer manufacturers have begun to phase certain substances out of their products -- not because the substances are illegal or because they have been found to cause health problems, but because allegations that the substances may be harmful might crop up. Rather than fight these allegations or potential class-action lawsuits, manufacturers prefer to build products and design processes with the certainty that their substances will not become controversial. The revolutions in medicine, genetics and toxicology that are now under way will only drive more of this kind of thinking as companies conclude that the regulatory stability they crave can be created only by taking extremely precautionary approaches.
Activists and Science
The activist organizations that advocate regulatory change -- whether increased regulation or decreased regulation of industry -- were established to change the world in a specific way. Activist groups on both sides of the political and ideological spectrum tend to view science as a tool: They use it only when it is helpful to their cause. Many groups spend a great deal of time and money looking at scientific questions, but their objectives nonetheless are political, not scientific.
For example, think tanks and activist groups created to fight regulatory action on climate change sometimes make scientific arguments; at other times, they try to move beyond science to place the issue in economic, ideological or political terms.
Consider the array of nongovernmental organizations that previously have pressed for stringent national regulations: Many of these have shifted their approach in light of the emerging concerns about scale. As expressed in both the climate risk and chemical risk issue debates, groups are beginning to play up uncertainty -- scientific and regulatory -- and press for businesses to adopt new management styles that effectively amount to self-regulation.
Because the media continue to write about these matters as political issues -- debates between two interested parties -- the scientific questions at the center of campaigns on climate change, the relative risk of various chemicals and substances and the risks posed by genetically modified organisms have been relegated to the backburner. Rather than being the focus in the policy debates, the science is used as a tactic in a communications and public relations battle.
Enter the Media
As the journalists and scientists who attended the Wilson Center event agreed, the mainstream media in the United States have not kept pace with the changes that are under way. Though they have been responsible in avoiding massive consumer scares, there is still a tendency for the media to report on scientific issues as they pertain to policy change -- using traditional terms that pit industry against activists in a fight over the interpretation of very complex science. The back-and-forth makes headlines.
At its root, the politicization of the scientific debate closely resembles the mainstream media's election reporting -- and the criticisms of it are much the same as well. In politics, the standard criticism is that the media focus on the horse race (polls, one-line zingers and sound bites) rather than on the issues and candidates' positions. In regulatory battles and politics, mano-a-mano sells -- complexity does not.
For the news media, much is at stake in this discussion -- particularly if deregulatory trends continue. As science-based policy battles continue to play out on the field of consumer opinion rather than in regulatory agencies and courts, the media will face the decision of whether -- and how -- to change the way they report on the issues. The decision will not be an easy one, particularly since journalism is itself a business: In de-emphasizing the political and focusing on the technical aspects of the issues, a news outlet runs the risk of boring the public and losing sales.
On the other hand, a shift in this direction also could dramatically increase the media's relevance in the policymaking process.
Send questions or comments on this article to analysis@stratfor.com.
Middle East Crisis ? Get Regular Updates and Breaking Intel at www.stratfor.com
Stratfor analysts are currently on full alert, offering expanded 24/7 coverage on the current Middle East crisis between Israel and Lebanon. From a potential expansion of the conflict to a full military engagement that could extend into Syria, to economic and security ramifications for the region and globally, this situation presents many risks and uncertainties.
Frequent updates, situation reports and in-depth analyses will be posted online 24/7 for subscribers, as well as special podcast briefings by George Friedman and the analyst team. Become a member today to get access to this coverage and more by visiting https://www.stratfor.com/services/online-subscriptions.php.
Distribution and Reprints
This report may be distributed or republished with attribution to Strategic Forecasting, Inc. at www.stratfor.com .
? Copyright 2006 Strategic Forecasting Inc. All rights reserved.
by absolutely
"At the same time, however, the 'fourth estate' is positioned to break the complicated scientific matters into terms that both the public and politicians can understand."
Politicians who don't already understand science well enough to interpret the summaries in science journals can spend their incessant pay raises on hiring science advisors to dumb it down for them. The failure of the "fourth estate" on global warming has been to break the two-year-old news that industry has entered a plea of "no contest" to being responsible for global warming: "The fact is that industry all but stopped contesting the premise of man-made climate change two years ago, but the media's preoccupation with the traditional battle lines -- industry versus environmentalists -- continues to obscure the complexity of the issue and the positions of various players." This discrepancy between [b]current[/b] fact & media portrayal allows industry to continue to lean on our politicians to continue the public pretense that global warming, caused by humans, is less than certain.
by deepsand
by deepsand
Stratfor Public Policy Intelligence Report
Strategic Forecasting
PUBLIC POLICY INTELLIGENCE REPORT
09.27.2006
Corporate Campaigns Find a Peak
By Bart Mongoven
The Interfaith Center on Corporate Responsibility's (ICCR) annual meeting of investors, shareholder activists, religious activists, issue advocates and business representatives took place Sept. 21 and 22 in New York. Participants usually discuss new or emerging issues concerning such things as corporations' labor practices, environmental policy and performance, and so forth. This year, however, participants spent very little time on discussions of how to encourage corporate change -- traditionally their focal point -- and spoke instead about root issues (such as AIDS in Africa and access to health care in the United States), and politics (the midterm election and goals for the next Congress) without regard to corporations and their role in policy.
ICCR pioneered the use of shareholder activism as a means of swaying companies to voluntarily change corporate policies, and it has been among the most influential corporate campaigning groups of the past two decades. It excelled during the corporate campaigns of the 1990s and first years of this decade -- before a recent wave of market campaigns convinced corporate managers that a new era was dawning. In the previous era, campaigns usually caught corporations by surprise; activists often made a barrage of allegations against a company to capture the attention of media and shareholders, and strove to keep the corporation off-guard and on the defensive. ICCR representatives would step into this controversial and occasionally acrimonious environment and chart a reasonable path the corporation could follow to satisfy its critics. In the ensuing negotiations, ICCR often elicited significant concessions from targeted corporations.
We noted in June that shareholder activism has reached a plateau, and that winning new levels of support from shareholders is a growing challenge for such activists. It now appears this problem goes even deeper. Corporate campaigning appears to be nearing its zenith, and soon could become a less powerful tool for winning policy changes.
Several factors have acted as catalysts for this change. These include the development of measurement systems to track corporations' social performance and progress, the creation of management structures that are designed to deal with social controversies and growing adoption of voluntary codes of conduct by corporations. In short, corporations are changing their behavior adroitly, but they are also doing so in manageable increments. The businesses are doing the driving, rather than being driven -- and activists, as a result, are looking for other venues through which to bring change.
The Rise of the Market Campaign
During the past six years, the number of nongovernmental activist groups that criticize corporations, in attempts to push corporate policy changes, has boomed. Corporate campaigning is as old as the modern corporation, but the surge of campaigns in recent years was intended to augment the government's de jure regulatory structure with a public policy regime developed and enforced by a vocal political minority.
[b]This trend was driven by two coinciding factors. First was the perception that a new era of globalization had begun. Activists in the United States and Europe who wanted to change the way business was conducted in far-off developing countries found it was difficult or impossible to effect change through the governments of those countries -- and that it was critical to change the activities of corporations instead.
The second factor was frustration among activist groups who were unable to achieve their key objectives through normal political processes. This was most acute in the United States, where liberal activists found little opportunity to instigate regulatory change during a period of Republican control in the House, Senate and White House. Activist groups saw the marketplace as their best alternative venue for bringing change. That said, as market campaigning proved effective, the trend was not limited to the U.S. political left; it was picked up by conservative groups as well. Over the past three years especially, groups from the religious right have waged a number of high-profile corporate campaigns against corporations they view as supporting corrosive or damaging moral values.[/b]
Corporate campaigning of all types has slowed in recent months, and new approaches and relationships are developing among corporations and activist groups. Large companies have adjusted to the new campaigns, and consequently, the way activists run corporate campaigns is shifting.
Changing Business
[b]One of the most significant outcomes of the trends of recent years among nongovernmental organizations (NGOs) is the fact that companies now have infrastructure for dealing with corporate campaigns. Large corporations have offices and staff who specialize in dealing with these challenges. As professionals whose job is to work on broad issues of corporate social responsibility have emerged in the market, there also have come waves of innovation in measuring and tracking a company's progress on these issues. The development of management systems and rules for the measurement of social performance has been the most significant driver of the recent changes in corporate-NGO relations.
The most significant innovation has been the monitoring and management systems developed through the Global Reporting Initiative (GRI). Initially drafted by the corporate social responsibility group Ceres, GRI is an effort to promulgate uniform guidelines for corporate reporting on a wide array of environmental and human rights issues. More than 1,000 major companies, including more than half the Fortune 100, follow GRI's guidelines, and they are rapidly emerging as the basis for a common language for discussions of companies' environmental and social performance.[/b]
GRI was initially written by activists for their own purposes, and most NGOs accept reporting that follows GRI requirements. Herein lies its power for corporations: Management systems developed according to the guidelines are generally considered credible. This means that corporations following GRI can set a benchmark based on rules that activists established and constantly measure their performance against that benchmark. Though it is expensive to implement and is still flawed in many ways, GRI -- by providing objective measures, using universally agreed-upon systems and setting out clear management standards -- provides a new level of insurance against activist allegations that have no basis in fact. For those allegations that do have a strong factual basis, corporations, working with NGOs through other management systems, are adept at addressing problems.
Meanwhile, an effort to provide measures for broader corporate social responsibility is in the works at the International Organization for Standardization (ISO). These standards, known as ISO 26000, will be complete by 2010. This standard will usher in a new era in corporate-NGO relations and, in so doing, bring new challenges for major corporations. Over the next few years, however, the attention being paid to measuring performance will provide some peace on the corporate campaign front.
From Measuring to Certification
A second important set of steps that corporations have taken in response to the increased use of corporate campaigns involves the development of certification systems -- or at least agreements to develop them. These systems, developed by corporations and their activist critics working together, usually rely upon quantifiable variables and dictate an acceptable set of corporate behaviors. As the number of corporate campaigns has increased, so has the demand for certification systems.
The number of certification systems in place is growing rapidly, and few major industries are not covered by at least one significant code of conduct or certification regime. Activists have been instrumental in developing certifications for the ways companies and banks:
* Market infant formula
* Test and sell drugs in developing countries
* Harvest timber
* Lend to development projects in poor countries
* Catch fish
* Mine gold
* Trade diamonds
* Market alcoholic beverages and tobacco
* Manufacture palm oil
* Grow soybeans
* Recycle computers
* Test products on animals
* Source textiles
and perform other functions.
Most of the certification systems in these examples began with a single corporation reluctantly coming to the negotiating table, under pressure from activists. A code of conduct can take years to develop, but when complete it usually sets a standard that satisfies activists' key concerns and that most corporations can reach while remaining competitive.
The development of codes of conduct and certification systems accelerated when many businesses recognized that if a certification system was being built, it was better for them to be involved than remain passive.
For instance, when the code of conduct on computer recycling was introduced in 2004, a critical issue for the activists at the Computer Take Back Campaign was whether companies would recycle all computers made after a certain date or whether they would be responsible for all the computers they ever sold (products referred to as "legacy waste"). Dell Computer Corp. was the first to begin negotiating the code of conduct with activists, and its interest in the legacy waste issue was clear: It had a distinct advantage if it could develop an industry code that saddled rivals HP (which had merged with Compaq in 1998) and IBM with responsibility for recycling all of their old machines, as well as products that would become waste in the future.
Similarly, in the 1980s Nestle was reluctantly brought to negotiate a code of conduct on the marketing of infant formula. After a decade-long market campaign, the company's brands were beginning to suffer and Nestle's business focus was distracted. Suing for peace, the company pledged in negotiations with activists and the World Health Organization not to employ a number of marketing tactics, many of which it had used in the past -- and many others that Nestle had never used, but which its competitors did. In essence, the company used the fact that it was brought to the negotiating table alone to some advantage.
Almost every significant certification regime contains similar opportunities to wrest out a competitive advantage, and as a result, new movements toward a code of conduct bring most of the large corporate players to the negotiating table. As a result, corporations are beginning to write rules almost as quickly as activists raise issues. This has been clearly seen in the debate over regulation of nanotechnology; industry is working with NGOs and government to write rules proactively, before opportunistic groups use any lack of regulation as a foundation for a broad market campaign. It is also visible in the reaction of Wal-Mart, which has begun to react quickly (usually by making significant concessions) to complaints leveled against the company.
Looking Forward
[b]Any element of society that is as large and as powerful as multinational corporations will be subject to criticism. The question now is whether the trend will be toward continued use of market campaigns to make increasingly incremental changes, or whether activist groups will return to relying primarily on the government to regulate the behavior or corporations.[/b]
Corporations' heightened attention to standards and certification regimes has allowed them to enter into negotiations with activists groups with confidence that they will, to a large extent, be using the same language and factual foundations. Critically, because companies are agreeing on the fundamental terms of the debate, the truth of any allegations leveled by activists are not at issue as often as they were in the past. Corporations therefore no longer rely solely on public relations staff to resolve the issues raised by activists, but assign technical experts to lead negotiations and work closely with the activists as well.
As a result, corporate-NGO negotiations take place on far more realistic grounds than ever before. At the same time, the changes that companies agree to come with slow deliberation. Because the corporation's negotiator knows the technical details of the company's products and processes, campaigns seldom end with massive concessions in which management sues for peace and only later tries to figure out how to abide by its agreement.
In light of these shifts, corporate campaigns as we know them seem to be waning. Companies are better equipped for dealing with them; they have developed standards for measuring performance and progress, and when a controversy appears inevitable, they are acting quickly to preempt and satisfy the key demands likely to be raised by activists. With these changes emerging, it is little surprise that the professional corporate campaigners who meet at ICCR's annual event were looking for different ways to achieve their objectives. The playing field is changing -- they have changed it -- but now they have to adjust.
Send questions or comments on this article to analysis@stratfor.com.
Distribution and Reprints
This report may be distributed or republished with attribution to Strategic Forecasting, Inc. at www.stratfor.com . For media requests, partnership opportunities, or commercial distribution or republication, please contact pr@stratfor.com.
Newsletter Subscription
? Copyright 2006 Strategic Forecasting Inc. All rights reserved.
by deepsand
1) Past causes of temperature flucuations are irrelevant; and,
2) Earth's climate is [b]not[/b] self-regulating. It is, in fact, susceptible to runaway in either extreme.
by deepsand
Your position now stands in contrast to that accepted by the scientific community in general.
[i]"Panels of journalists and scientists gathered July 25 at the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars in Washington to discuss the mainstream media's reporting on climate change. The consensus was that the media have not covered the issue well. According to both panels, the greatest shortcoming has been in persistent portrayals of the issue as one of contentious scientific debate: In reality, the assembled scientists said, man-made climate change is generally accepted throughout the scientific community as a reality."[/i]
See https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=200777&messageID=2102173
At this point, it is your burden to proof that they are wrong!
by deepsand
See https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=200777&messageID=2102142 .
Or, StratFor?
See https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=200777&messageID=2102173 .
You and Max are now in the position of having to attempt to proof that the majority of the scientific community is wrong.
Should you or any of your IM force be captured, ... Good luck.
The only politicians I have any respect at all for are those who give up political power in favour of principle. Needless to say they are rarer than rocking horse turds.
They aren't fit to wipe your arse on, don't bother with them.
because believing in global warming is meant to be stupid , you should be gullible enough not to spot that the opposition are asking you to prove it exists, neglecting the fact they hadn't proved their contention that it doesn't.
I'll add tags next time.
Lets face the risk of your house burning down is quite small, no one thinks insurance is a bad idea.
The possibility is small,but if you are unlucky or careless the consequences are drastic. Seeing as the cost is small you mitigate it.
Stuff the science and the politics, just look at the pros and the cons.
After that it's a no brainer.
by deepsand
What should be the minimum IQ to qualify as an elected official, I'm thinking 140. Smarter than me but not so smart I can't understand them.
Hmmm wait, may be there should be a maximum, I don't understand them now!
No doubt I'll post something that needs forgiveness sooner or later.
I wasn't going to get drawn into this thread but I just found Inhofe such a wonderfully alien character when I checked him out that I had to comment.
We have [b]nothing[/b] like him over here.
...a politician might say just because of other stupid things he/she might say, and if you apply that sentiment equally and across-the-board, then we should discount everything that every politician says. Right? All of them say something stupid some of the time, don't they? I assume we're in total agreement thus far. If not, please explain why not.
Therefore, we must simply dismiss all of this global warming nonsense, because it's ALL advanced by politicians. By dismissing the gentleman Senator from Oklahoma (That's how they talk in the U.S. Senate, you know.) just because of other things he said, we must also dismiss the Senators (and Representatives) who make the human-caused global warming claim because of other stupid things they have said.
All is not lost for you guys, however, because you can still redeem yourselves and prove the notion of human-caused global warming is a consensus among qualified scientists. I've been saying all along, let's get politics out of the issue, and I'll listen and talk to anyone about it.
Which leads me to my latest question:
You global warming advocates often claim that it's a forgone conclusion that there is general consensus within the scientific community that human activity is indeed causing global warming.
1. Define "scientific community" by describing those "scientists" who are both educated and experienced in whatever fields which would qualify them as being a person who can offer an expert opinion -- make that an expert conclusion based on their own findings or the review of other's findings. And, of course, define the field in which those particular scientists work. A nuclear scientist, for example, who works for the Atomic Energy Commission wouldn't qualify.
2. Show me the results of reliable poll conducted by a reliable polling organization which showed that the "scientists" you described above -- and ONLY the scientists you described above -- agreed that human activity was causing global warming, and that concluded there was a "general consensus" among those people that human activity is causing global warming.
3. Define "general consensus". Would that be at least 50 percent of those scientists polled? 60 percent? 76.8 percent? 100 percent? The poll results are necessary to reach this conclusion.
4. And as a matter of full disclosure, who do these "scientists" work for, and who pays their salary and/or provides their means of income?
You continually cite these people and presume to speak for them. How about defining and identifying who they really are?
----------
Neil, is that really too much to ask?
by absolutely
Then, you have come to expect better quality from my replies than what you perceive above?
;)
Seriously, I only attempted to address your point #1, with the intention of addressing the rest after agreeing on the sources to consider authoritative. I apologize for not making my intended approach clearer. I agree, your questions are the type I ask on every topic, and I replied as acknowledgement of that. But, I'd like to take them one by one if you don't mind. This way, we can more accurately (& constructively?) identify the point(s) on which we agree & disagree.
The following is a cut-and-pasted story from:
http://biz.yahoo.com/ibd/060929/issues01.html?.v=1
Environment: The country is drowning in wild alarums warning of impending doom due to global warming. Yet there has risen -- from the U.S. Senate, of all places -- a lone voice of rational dissent.
While Al Gore drifts into deeper darkness on the other side of the moon, propelled by such revelations as cigarette smoking is a "significant contributor to global warming," Sen. James Inhofe is becoming a one-man myth-wrecking crew.
Inhofe, a Republican from Oklahoma, took to the Senate floor two days last week to expose the media's role in the global warming hype. This is a man who more than three years ago called the global warming scare "the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people" and has made a habit of tweaking the left-leaning environmental lobby.
One member of the media, Miles O'Brien of CNN, responded last week to Inhofe's criticism of the media with a piece criticizing Inhofe and challenging his arguments. If anything, it seems that O'Brien's reply simply motivated Inhofe to continue his effort to undress the media's complicity and bring light to the issue.
We hope so. The "science" on global warming and the media's propaganda campaign need to be picked apart.
The assumptions made by gloomy theorists should be revealed for what they are: mere conjecture.
The lies and carefully crafted implications, many of them discharged like toxic pollutants by a former vice president, deserve a thorough and lasting deconstruction.
What the public needs -- and deserves -- is a credible voice to counter the sermons from Gore, on whose behalf cigarettes were distributed in 2000 to Milwaukee homeless people who were recruited by campaign volunteers to cast absentee ballots. Inhofe could be that voice.
He's no John the Baptist crying out in the wilderness. What he is, in fact, is a thrice-elected senator, a former member of the House and, before that, a state senator and representative.
For those not impressed by a political background -- after all, Gore, far out of proportion to his qualifications, rose to the second most powerful position on Earth -- consider that Inhofe is an Army veteran and longtime pilot, and has actually worked in the private sector.
Unlike most in the Senate, Inhofe is willing to stand on a soapbox and expose his head to his opponents' rhetorical stones. Name another in that august body who would dare label as a hoax the premise that undergirds the day's most trendy pop cult. Is there anyone there who would want to try to stand up to the likes of O'Brien?
O'Brien's biased report is not exactly the type of exposure global warming skeptics hope for, though. The goal, say the skeptics, should be to teach and inform, to provide an alternative to the flood of hyperbole and intentionally misleading thunder that's passed off as settled science.
There are enough scientists to fill a fleet of Humvees who can express scepticism over global warming, despite Gore's claims that the matter has been resolved in favor of his conclusions. But none has the forum a U.S. senator can command. With rare exceptions, scientists can marshal media attention on the climate change issue only by spouting the party line that man-made emissions are causing Earth to warm. That's the sort of stuff the press laps up like a starving dog.
Without the wind of a compliant media at his back, Inhofe nevertheless got his message out to America, primarily through C-Span and the Drudge Report, which linked to his speeches at the Web site of the Senate Committee on Environment and Public Works.
Among those responding to Inhofe's first speech included a scientist and a meteorologist. Both hold views on global warming that are in line with the senator's -- which puts them at odds with the environmental lobby's assertions of "consensus" that have been relentlessly beaten into the masses for more than a decade.
The most important audience, though, is among the Americans who have no links to science. They're the ones who have a lot to learn and will benefit the most from someone who has mass access to the public and is willing to challenge the widely -- and often uncritically -- accepted claims about climate change.
I thought that you might give this guy up as he's
a) A religious flake,
b) Bought and paid for by oil and gas companies: Inhofe has received almost $300,000 in campaign donations from oil and gas interests and nearly $180,000 from electric utilities. In the 2002 election, he received more oil and gas contributions than any senator except one.
I could go on.
A bit of consensus: The 2001 report by the US National Academy of Sciences, commissioned by the Bush administration, confirmed the reliability of the earlier studies by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change. In its opening sentences, that report stated point-blank, "Greenhouse gases are accumulating in Earth's atmosphere as a result of human activities, causing surface air temperatures and subsurface ocean temperatures to rise. Temperatures are, in fact, rising."
So, that's the fifteen years research findings of a body established in 1988 by the World Meteorological Organization (WMO) and the United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) to assess the "risk of human-induced climate change" confirmed by the premier scientific body in the United states.
But, of course, that amounts to nothing when compared with the Bible-inspired ravings of the oil companies' top pimp.
Maxwell! Be ashamed...
A. I suppose anyone who is a devout Christian would fall under the definition of a "religious flake" to a devout Atheist. So I'll take your comments through the filter of your Atheism.
B. Oklahoma is an oil state, and it's right and proper for a Senator to not only represent those interests, but even possibly -- heaven forbid -- to receive campaign donations from them. For better or worse, that's how our system works -- for ALL Senators.
C. Oh, never-mind. You didn't go on.
Even in the tripe posted by the tripe-hound, deepsand, it eluded to the fact that the issue is driven by the media and politicians, not the scientific community, per se, which falls in line with my biggest objection.
Oil and coal are at issue. Go ahead, all you environmental nut-cases. Just do it! Just develop an alternative to oil driven vehicles, market those vehicles, and not only solve "your problem", but put those conniving oil barons out of business by competing with them . And why do these same environmental nut-cases continually block attempted alternatives to coal, such as nuclear and wind?
Why? BECAUSE IT'S A POLITICAL ISSUE, NOT AN ENVIRONMENTAL ISSUE!
As long as you people use this issue as political leverage, it's YOUR motives that are in question, not the ones resisting. Why can't you understand that?
P.S. I find it interesting that you continually trash President Bush and his administration, except in this one case where you find support for your issue. What happened to automatically discrediting and dismissing "religious nut-cases"? Neil! Be ashamed!
The media and political hype around the issue is not helping.
Whether it's the radicals and reformists trying to scare people into being environmentally friendly, or the conservatives trying desperately to keep their status quo.
Why have these tactics been resorted to?. Because both sides are scared by their ignorance.
You're an intelligent bloke, can you say hand on heart that there's no chance at all of us impacting our climate, never mind the whole environment.
No one is saying you have to go out and hug a tree, adopt environmentally friendly policies as good business if you want.
In the UK. The big retail chains are now selling solar panels and wind turbines. ?1500 a pop, theoretically they'll cut energy use off the national grid by 30% for a household.
At the moment out of something like 30 million houses in the UK they think about 82,000 have the technology. So there's a potential ?450 billion to aim at, and 30% isn't too hard to improve on either.
That's just the UK, your energy is cheaper though rising in cost, but the market is HUGE.
It's cheap because it's self financing for the customer, there's a decent profit to be made, the market is enormous and you need a sizable service industry to support it.
A capitalist's wet dream if your marketing is good, you can even do a deal with a finance company for the initial capital outlay to ease the sales.
Wish I'd have thought of it.
Environmentally friendly is only anti-capitalist, if you want it to be.
Have a cleaner environment, make money and mitigate the possible danger of human caused global warming. How can you argue against it ?
A fun thought may be all the scare tactics is a way to beef up the market potential so someone can make a killing.
I've said it dozens of times in these "global warming" threads. There are tens of millions (or perhaps hundreds of millions) of you global warming advocates who want some sort of change. WELL CHANGE! JUST DO IT!
Oil and coal are at issue. Go ahead, all you environmental nut-cases. Just do it! Just develop an alternative to oil driven vehicles, market those vehicles, and not only solve "your problem", but put those conniving oil barons out of business by competing with them . And why do these same environmental nut-cases continually block attempted alternatives to coal, such as nuclear and wind?
As long as you people use this issue as political leverage, it's YOUR motives that are in question, not the ones resisting. Why can't you understand that?
By the way, Tony, I concede that "environmentally friendly is not anti-capitalist", and I've even suggested as much myself. I'm an environmentally friendly advocate -- but by personal choice, not by political force or coercion. And the longer you people try to force and coerce, and the longer you, yourselves, DO NOTHING, the more resistant I will be, and the more I will seriously question your own motives.
by deepsand
And, you're still ignoring the fact the the scientific community as a whole tkes a stand counter to your position; and, the the good Senator is [b]not[/b] a scientist.
Again, I refer you to
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=200777&messageID=2102173
and
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=200777&messageID=2102142 .
If you're going to persist in ignoring facts that counter your position, then you have nothing to offer but mere obfuscation.
Politicians are in it for what they can get, they might represent us, but not out of some form of altruism, but because it's it good way to set up a situation where they get paid. That is their goal !
All politicians need funding, the people who provide the funds call the shots, not the people who voted for them.
I don't mind self interest in fact I trust it, doesn't mean I have to agree to serve their interests though does it, I'm serving mine.
by absolutely
by absolutely
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=200777&messageID=2102332
Is publication in a professional publication a fair criterion for establishing professional expertise or isn't it? If not, why not, and do you have any counterproposal for establising professional credibility?
by deepsand
Your explanation confirm my initial take based on a quick reading. However, on a more careful re-reading, I found myself questioning my inital appraisal.
Just goes to show that sometimes your gut reaction is the correct one!
.
http://www.canadafreepress.com/2006/harris061206.htm
Professor Bob Carter of the Marine Geophysical Laboratory at James Cook University, in Australia gives what, for many Canadians, is a surprising assessment: "Gore's circumstantial arguments are so weak that they are pathetic. It is simply incredible that they, and his film, are commanding public attention."
But surely Carter is merely part of what most people regard as a tiny cadre of "climate change skeptics" who disagree with the "vast majority of scientists" Gore cites?
No; Carter is one of hundreds of highly qualified non-governmental, non-industry, non-lobby group climate experts who contest the hypothesis that human emissions of carbon dioxide (CO2) are causing significant global climate change. "Climate experts" is the operative term here. Why? Because what Gore's "majority of scientists" think is immaterial when only a very small fraction of them actually work in the climate field.
Even among that fraction, many focus their studies on the impacts of climate change; biologists, for example, who study everything from insects to polar bears to poison ivy. "While many are highly skilled researchers, they generally do not have special knowledge about the causes of global climate change," explains former University of Winnipeg climatology professor Dr. Tim Ball. "They usually can tell us only about the effects of changes in the local environment where they conduct their studies."
This is highly valuable knowledge, but doesn't make them climate change cause experts, only climate impact experts.
So we have a smaller fraction.
But it becomes smaller still. Among experts who actually examine the causes of change on a global scale, many concentrate their research on designing and enhancing computer models of hypothetical futures. "These models have been consistently wrong in all their scenarios," asserts Ball. "Since modelers concede computer outputs are not "predictions" but are in fact merely scenarios, they are negligent in letting policy-makers and the public think they are actually making forecasts."
We should listen most to scientists who use real data to try to understand what nature is actually telling us about the causes and extent of global climate change. In this relatively small community, there is no consensus, despite what Gore and others would suggest.
Here is a small sample of the side of the debate we almost never hear:
Appearing before the Commons Committee on Environment and Sustainable Development last year, Carleton University paleoclimatologist Professor Tim Patterson testified, "There is no meaningful correlation between CO2 levels and Earth's temperature over this [geologic] time frame. In fact, when CO2 levels were over ten times higher than they are now, about 450 million years ago, the planet was in the depths of the absolute coldest period in the last half billion years." Patterson asked the committee, "On the basis of this evidence, how could anyone still believe that the recent relatively small increase in CO2 levels would be the major cause of the past century's modest warming?"
Patterson concluded his testimony by explaining what his research and "hundreds of other studies" reveal: on all time scales, there is very good correlation between Earth's temperature and natural celestial phenomena such changes in the brightness of the Sun.
Dr. Boris Winterhalter, former marine researcher at the Geological Survey of Finland and professor in marine geology, University of Helsinki, takes apart Gore's dramatic display of Antarctic glaciers collapsing into the sea. "The breaking glacier wall is a normally occurring phenomenon which is due to the normal advance of a glacier," says Winterhalter. "In Antarctica the temperature is low enough to prohibit melting of the ice front, so if the ice is grounded, it has to break off in beautiful ice cascades. If the water is deep enough icebergs will form."
Dr. Wibj?rn Karl?n, emeritus professor, Dept. of Physical Geography and Quaternary Geology, Stockholm University, Sweden, admits, "Some small areas in the Antarctic Peninsula have broken up recently, just like it has done back in time. The temperature in this part of Antarctica has increased recently, probably because of a small change in the position of the low pressure systems."
But Karl?n clarifies that the 'mass balance' of Antarctica is positive - more snow is accumulating than melting off. As a result, Ball explains, there is an increase in the 'calving' of icebergs as the ice dome of Antarctica is growing and flowing to the oceans. When Greenland and Antarctica are assessed together, "their mass balance is considered to possibly increase the sea level by 0.03 mm/year - not much of an effect," Karl?n concludes.
The Antarctica has survived warm and cold events over millions of years. A meltdown is simply not a realistic scenario in the foreseeable future.
Gore tells us in the film, "Starting in 1970, there was a precipitous drop-off in the amount and extent and thickness of the Arctic ice cap." This is misleading, according to Ball: "The survey that Gore cites was a single transect across one part of the Arctic basin in the month of October during the 1960s when we were in the middle of the cooling period. The 1990 runs were done in the warmer month of September, using a wholly different technology."
Karl?n explains that a paper published in 2003 by University of Alaska professor Igor Polyakov shows that, the region of the Arctic where rising temperature is supposedly endangering polar bears showed fluctuations since 1940 but no overall temperature rise. "For several published records it is a decrease for the last 50 years," says Karl?n
Dr. Dick Morgan, former advisor to the World Meteorological Organization and climatology researcher at University of Exeter, U.K. gives the details, "There has been some decrease in ice thickness in the Canadian Arctic over the past 30 years but no melt down. The Canadian Ice Service records show that from 1971-1981 there was average, to above average, ice thickness. From 1981-1982 there was a sharp decrease of 15% but there was a quick recovery to average, to slightly above average, values from 1983-1995. A sharp drop of 30% occurred again 1996-1998 and since then there has been a steady increase to reach near normal conditions since 2001."
Concerning Gore's beliefs about worldwide warming, Morgan points out that, in addition to the cooling in the NW Atlantic, massive areas of cooling are found in the North and South Pacific Ocean; the whole of the Amazon Valley; the north coast of South America and the Caribbean; the eastern Mediterranean, Black Sea, Caucasus and Red Sea; New Zealand and even the Ganges Valley in India. Morgan explains, "Had the IPCC used the standard parameter for climate change (the 30 year average) and used an equal area projection, instead of the Mercator (which doubled the area of warming in Alaska, Siberia and the Antarctic Ocean) warming and cooling would have been almost in balance."
Gore's point that 200 cities and towns in the American West set all time high temperature records is also misleading according to Dr. Roy Spencer, Principal Research Scientist at The University of Alabama in Huntsville. "It is not unusual for some locations, out of the thousands of cities and towns in the U.S., to set all-time records," he says. "The actual data shows that overall, recent temperatures in the U.S. were not unusual."
Carter does not pull his punches about Gore's activism, "The man is an embarrassment to US science and its many fine practitioners, a lot of whom know (but feel unable to state publicly) that his propaganda crusade is mostly based on junk science."
In April sixty of the world's leading experts in the field asked Prime Minister Harper to order a thorough public review of the science of climate change, something that has never happened in Canada. Considering what's at stake - either the end of civilization, if you believe Gore, or a waste of billions of dollars, if you believe his opponents - it seems like a reasonable request.
Despite the fact that for every scientist that you can put forward we can put forward a dozen, you stay firm in your position. I realised several threads ago that argument wasn't really worthwhile except as an exercise in debate.
The UK's Meteorological Office seems to believe in Cimate Change and I've read a lot of what they published and it's enough for me at the moment.
You have a look.
http://www.metoffice.gov.uk/research/hadleycentre/index.html
by deepsand
baffle them with bullshit. That may work with lesser minds, but not here.
Try reading the NASA report above, and providing a [b]substantive[/b] response, if you dare.
I always give credit where credit is due. There just happen to be very few occasions in these discussions where I feel Bush is worthy of credit. Most of my serious anti-Bush feelings have been vented over Iraq. I see no reason to change [b]that[/b] view!
"Religious flake". My point - in an earlier post - was that Inhofe is not just religious but is an "End Times" fundamentalist. This flavour of Christian has a proven track record of basing their actions on the belief that The Apocalypse is imminent and that long-term planning is therefore a waste of time.
The fact that Inhofe is a religious flake [b]and[/b] is at every level bought and paid for by the Oil and Gas industries and yet is set as Chairman of The Senate Environment and Public Works Committee is something that we foreigners have trouble getting our heads round. It may be the "way that you do it" but it doesn't seem particularly rational! It just makes it [b]far[/b] more political than it needs to be.
To be honest, after a bit of Googling around Senator Inhofe, I found myself laughing out loud.
The climate debate is nowhere near as political in the UK as it is in the US. We [b]do[/b] have a consensus. And our scientists are equally as competent as yours.
by deepsand
by deepsand
The fact is, you've no logical ground for your position, so that you are forced to resort to obfuscation and [i]ad hominem[/i] retorts in order to avoid capitulation.
In that respect, you are no different from ippirate in the EL discussion.
by absolutely
"Why would I expect better?"
Irrational exuberance, or just irrational optimism. Or simple charity.
by deepsand
One earns charity by not knowingly and willingly contributing to one's plight.
Deliberate stupidity deserves nothing but to be held up to scorn and public ridicule.
by deepsand
by deepsand
you convinced a sufficient number of people to [b]not[/b] vote for your opponent(s); at worst, that you had the means to buy the office.
It is you who should be ashamed of your persistent intellectual dishonesty.
by deepsand
While you are correct re. the "color" of the sky, the rest of your post is gravely in error.
1) The "greenhouse gas" is CO2, [b]not[/b] CO;
2) There is nothing "supposed" about it; and,
3) We are [b]not[/b] living during a period of the greatest amount of animal life ever.
Next time, get your facts straight before you attack.
by deepsand
by deepsand
I posted my reasoning in
"I don't. maybe I'm not a global warming advocate"
rebuttals from 'no global warming advocates' have been conspicuously absent.
If you went back and read it then you'd know how fatuous I found this response
I have ONE motive, I want my grandchildren to be able to stand under a tree, breathe the air and survive long enough to have children of their own.
Politics should go where the sun doesn't shine not my family.
If that motive means you have to rework your investment folio, so be it.
Possibly because you take such an extreme position yourself, you see all the oposition as at the other end of the spectrum. I would never block a wind farm. In fact I might have one in my back yard if I can get planning permission and the finance, it's windy enough up here for it.
In the UK we call wind farm opponents who claim to be eco-friendly NIMBies not in my backyard. Strangely enough it's a good name for people who like nuclear fission but don't want to live near where they dump the waste.
Nuclear power is a whole different ball game, you want to research and set up fusion plants, micro black holes or whatever fine. I'm eco-friendly though, so nuclear fission is out unless we put the plants in space.
Don't try and convince me how safe it is. Keeping the waste for forty years in a tank before you can vitrify it, dump it miles down on the sea bed in a form that will last 200,000 years yet still sterilises the entire area, doesn't sound all that safe to me. Maybe I'm not seeing the big picture eh?
by deepsand
Funny, isn't it, how many people there are in the world who have trouble dealing with substantive rebutalls to their positions. It's as if they can't understand why anyone would not agree with them.
Re. windmill farms, one does need to be fully cognizant of [b]all[/b] the environmental impacts. For example, it's an observed fact that many birds end of being the equivalent of road-kill owing to their being struck by the blades. Here, in Pennsylvania, we've a problem convincing some that placing them atop certain mountains is a very bad idea, as the very winds which are suitable for windmills are also those which make for this area being a spectacular fly zone for soaring birds in general, and birds of prey in particular. In fact, the winds here are so great for soaring, that glider pilots seeking flights with the longest durations and greatest distances launch from here.
As for nuclear energy, breeder reactors, which would have replaced the conventional ones now in use, were very near to being to being viable when the Three Mile Island scare hit, with the result that Congress killed the research, leaving us stuck with 50 year old technology.
Wind farms aren't the answer to our problems, they are simply one of the simplest and cheapest forms of renewable to implement.
I don't even feel renewables as they are currently defined are a long term solution.
We need to look at fusion, at space based generation, at super tech possibilities like unipoles, micro holes.
Even if we had these now we still have massive problems, increased longevity, medical advances that increase potential fertility coupled with a steadily growing population with a steadlty growing requirement for more and more energy.
Long term solutions, we should be talking in millenia not time in office.
The only difference between fission and fossil is the polution is more localised and therefore more concentrated. I don't want to be in a position where I have to choose between coughing or glowing in the dark. Calling fission renewable is a bad joke anyway, the real financial cost keeps getting hidden.
Decomissioning alone cost billions, who pays for it. In the UK, the tax payer!. That's just plain wrong.
by deepsand
Your suggestion falls in what is known as the near genuis range; this I know because it's where mine is. (No, that's not bragging. Most people have no idea how difficult it is being known as a "genius." On one side lies the ridicule of one's peers; on the other, the greatest of all expectations of one's elders.)
Still, I agree that, to the extent that IQ is relevant, it's probably a good range for politicians to be in, as it is described as being the range in which one is intelligent enough to not have to follow, but not so intelligent that one is forced to lead.
The fly in the ointment is that being in possession of a fine intellect is no quarantor of a character of equal quality.
I'd wager that there are quite a few near geniuses here at TR, though I'd vote for none of them on that basis alone.
by hal 9000
I picked this up today and thought it interesting.
[b]Flies feel the heat[/b]
Fruit Flies on three contents have independently evolved identical genetic changes within just 2 decades - and they?ve almost certainly done it to cope with Global Warming.
?Global warming is leaving its imprint on genes.? says Raymond Huey of the University of Washington in Seattle, a member of the team that made the discovery. ?For this to happen in such a short time in so many parts of the wold is very disturbing.
The researchers analyzed DNA from Drosophilla subobscura from 26 different sites in Europe, South America and North America. They where looking for particular chromosomal changes that tally with latitude and by implication , with ambient temperature.
The Result? Changes once found only at warmer latitudes have spread as temperatures have risen further away from the equator {Science, DOI:10.1126/science.1131002}.
[i]New Scientist 9 September 2006 page 19[/i]
And to those who may believe that Man has no impact on anything at all I found this very interesting.
[b]Weeds shall Inherit the Earth[/b]
Huge numbers of species are doomed to extinction, no matter what we do, says Stephen M. Meyer. We need to think ahead to a very different world.
For more than a decade, Scientists have been warning of an impending collapse of global biodiversity - the sixth great extinction. Adverting this massive species loss and the resulting pauperization of ecosystems demands immediate action, they argue.
What they don?t realise is that this ?extinction crisis? is no more preventable than previous extinctions caused by asteroid impacts or the detonation of tens of thousands of volcanoes. In the century ahead upwards of half of all species will functionally, if not literally vanish. In this respect, the crisis is over.
The cause of the sixth extinction is well known: human selection [what might be termed as unintelligent design] is systematically replacing natural selection as the engine of evolution. ?Weedy Species? [those organisms that thrive on the disturbances that we create] are experiencing rapid population growth, accelerating dispersal and maybe augmented speciation - the development of additional species from an existing one. The great many ?relic species? - those not equipped to live alongside us - are being shoved to the margins of existence. Many of these have become ?ghost species?: they are on the brink of extinction. The net effect is global homogenisation and ecosystem simplification - the end of the wild.
Human selection is particularly insidious for 2 reasons. First it is driven by an otherwise innocuous aspirations, actions and choices of ordinary people pursuing a better life. You might wonder how my taste for Swordfish for tonight?s dinner could affect the tropic balance of sea life. Let alone drive the species to the brink of extinction. Yet hundreds of published studies document how the cumulative pressure of over 6 billion people systematically transforms the landscape, alters global biogeochemical processes, demolishes geophysical barries thereby facilitating the free flow of alien species, consumes natural resources beyond their capacity for regeneration, and motivates us to intentionally eliminate those organisms we deem inconvenient. For weedy species, such as the English house sparrow and the Asian Tiger Mosquito, we are building paradise. For relics and ghosts like the Polar Bear and the Chilean monkey puzzle tree, the new world is a graveyard.
Second the very actions we take to forestall the ?extinctions crisis? and blunt the force of human selection serve to amplify its distorting effects. Species-based regulatory regimes such as the Endangered Species Act in the US preferentially allocate protective resources to organisms that are charismatic, symbolically important, and do not pose a serrious serious social or economic conflicts. Conservation goals are set by social carrying capacity - what people will tolerate - rather than what is of evolutionary value.
Human considerations are equally decisive in the design and operation of bio-reserves and refuges, which become agents of human selection. Bio-reserves are isolated islands of landscape, or marine-scape, embedded in a sea of human activity - remnants of what were once expansive ecosystems. Often a country?s last undeveloped places, these areas are ripe for economic development, natural resource exploitation and homesteading, as in Mexico?s Montes Azules Biosphere Reserve, where 25% of jungle habitat has disappeared. As human activity seeps in, weedy species crowd out relics and ghosts. The resulting balance among the menagerie of what remains is neither ecological nor self sustaining. Similarly, experiments in sustainable development are fundamentally about human needs. Ecosystem tolerance is a residual concern.
Restoring natural selection to its dominant place - bringing back ?the wild? - requires unprecedented changes to human aspirations and societal organisation. Lacking a global spiritual epiphany of unimaginable proportions, this is simply not possible in the world as it is now. The grossly mistaken belief that we can halt - if not reverse - the ongoing extinction fuels our preoccupation with saving relics and ghosts and steers us further away from preservation strategies based on ecological and evolutionary value.
We need a new approach. We must turn our attention to the new assemblages of organisms that are emerging as a result of ?Unintelligent design?. The huge loss in global biomass caused by previous great extinctions will not happen this time; the Earth will continue to teem with life as the expansion of weedy species occurs simultaneously with the decline of relics and ghosts. Net bio-mass might actually increase. What will change is the complexity of how life is organised and how the biotic and abiotic worlds interact. Understanding and engaging this transformation should be the focus of conversation efforts in the years ahead.
[i]New Scientist 9 September 2006 Page 21[/i]
If man kind can have such a devastating impact on the various species living what's so hard to believe that Humans can have an adverse impact upon the Atmosphere as well?
Col
by deepsand
by hal 9000
Apathy is what many in both Government & Big Business need to stay in power. :D
It's extremely hard to overcome Apathy and not many are willing to even attempt it. :(
Col
It's all part of the evolutionary process, we wipe ourselves out and the Cockroaches begin the next great evolutionary transformation. ;)
(*sorry, this was really an entirely pointless quip*)
That is quite interesting. Thanks for sharing. I've seen a fair amount of 'evidence' for and against Global Warming, and human involvement in said event, I can't say I am firmly on one side of the fence or the other (leaning towards for), but it seems to me, whether you belive it or not, there is no doubt that we humans are a key variable int he ecosystem equation, and uniqe from other species in that we have the ability to consciously do something about it. Doesn't common sense suggest that we should be actively looking for better, cleaner, more efficient, and more renewable sources of energy? Doesn't it just make basic sense that we should try to reduce the amount of unrecycleable waste we create? If you had to personally store are your waste on your piece of property, I suspect you would be highly motivated to reduce your waste output.
Hmmm.. there's an idea, charge people by the pound for waste disposal, a significant higher rate for unrecyclable/unrecycled waste, a much lower rate for recycled. Then it becomes an economic exercise, which seems to be everyone's favorite motivator.
...What did that publication warn us about in 1976? Global COOLING perhaps? And the looming "little ice age"?
If that publication is so credible, tell us what became of that warning.
And let's project ourselves to 2036. I wonder if another "Maxwell Edison" will be asking some other fear-monger the same kind of question.
by absolutely
of this one error, which you attribute to [i]Science[/i] without citing the issue & page? The practice of science does not operate on unsupported assertions. If you wish to undermine the authority of the most authoritative sources of science research, you're going to have to get specific: when exactly did [i]Science[/i] warn us about "Global COOLING"? Who wrote the article? What data were used to support that assertion in that article, and [b]how widely was that assertion ever accepted by the scientific community?[/b] The bottom line: you cannot blame scientific researchers for the failure of "journalists" to accurately convey the conclusions of science, in the vocabulary of the masses.
No insult to "the masses" is intended nor implied: there are plenty of topics I don't know in enough detail to understand highly technical discussions. Art, for example, is "like Greek to me", except that I at least can identify most letters of the Greek alphabet! So, discussions of post-modernism vs. surrealism are as near meaningless to me as discussions of chemistry and thermodynamics seem to be to the writers of the [i]New York Times[/i], [i]Newsweek[/i], etc. But, when I read an article about art, I would at least [b]expect[/b] that if a "journalist" uses the word "paintbrush", it would describe something very similar to what I know a "paintbrush" to be. Hopefully, this gives a meaningful indication of how badly I believe the popular media have miscommunicated the [b]relevant[/b] facts about global warming, and the conclusions that may be reasonably inferred from those facts, and how those inferrences are, in fact, based on rigorous logic, and facts establised [b]within a sufficiently small margin of uncertainty[/b] to state, with confidence, that global warming [b]is[/b] happening, and that it [b]is[/b] caused by human activity. That statement is based [b]entirely[/b] on peer-reviewed scientific research, found by peers to be accurate.
My premise with regard to politics is that personal lifestyle choices, and policy decisions, are a [b]separate[/b] issue, to be discussed on the basis of these facts, and that policy preferences cannot change the laws of chemistry & thermal physics.
"...how widely was that assertion ever accepted by the scientific community?"
That's exactly what I asked about this current assertion, to which you relied on the validity of Science Magazine!
Talk about an exercise in circular logic, you take the cake on this one -- whether the cake is cooled or warmed!
by deepsand
why are you still speaking?
One again, where, when and as convenient, you've arbitrarily chosen a standard that suits your own purposes.
Are there no limits to your intellectual dishonesty?
No really.
I'm mean inarguably right.
Can't possibly win an argument with a debating champion like yourself on top form with logic like that, I give up.
No really.
by absolutely
"The fly in the ointment is that being in possession of a fine intellect is no guarantor of a character of equal quality."
The only guarantor of integrity of character is that the system rewards integrity. When The People decide that their desire to cheat the system is less important than their desire to not be cheated by the system, they will return to that system established by the Constitution's original meaning. Until then, we can only wait patiently for the light of intellect to flicker on, one mind at a time.
by absolutely
"In other words I'm not making my decision based on our knowledge of the situation, but on our ignorance of it.
It's nice when ethics and pragmatism march hand in hand though. I'm biased not prejudiced, there's a big difference."
Were I to grant your basic premise - our ignorance - I would agree with your reasoning. But, I do not grant the premise that global warming is sufficiently in doubt to resort to your pragmatic argument.
PS Please explain this "big difference" between bias and prejudice. I'm familiar with the use of the word "bias" in electrical circuit theory, but I can't follow the analogy to human interactions in any way that doesn't coincide with the meaning of "prejudice".
This is the one I've always held. All theis yes a nd no camp stuff in politics and science is getting us nowhere. Appealing on an ethiical basis, well we knew that wouldn't work before we said it. So lets go straight to not so common sense.
Too much eco-friendly = left = bad going on for me.
Did you know you are a left winger by the way, a damn commie. I was almost ready to send you red welcome comrade mug, then I realised they were talking about Abs, not happening is it.
Definitions, bias is a desire to decide in favour if the evidence allows you to, prejudice means you don't give a crap what the evidence is, you've already decided. Which is why people use Inhofe as an arguments against us, they think we are prejudiced too.
by absolutely
"All theis yes a nd no camp stuff in politics and science is getting us nowhere."
Among an audience capable of rational thought, the existing scientific proof would [b]have already decided the outcome of this discussion[/b], not only here on TR, but in the public. Until then, I suppose the pragmatic argument is the only one to bother presenting.
by absolutely
"You mean what I know."
Meanings derive from facts, and only from facts. I do not mean to say that meanings & facts are exactly equivalent. I thought we already clarified, and reached agreement on this point weeks ago. Just taking the pi$$, aren't you?
by absolutely
by deepsand
by deepsand
Just kidding, of course.
I've momentarily gotten the alligators off my ass, and can now return my attention to draining the swamp, but I've no illusions about their remaining at bay for very long.
by deepsand
Do you not know the difference between a [b]prediction[/b] and [b]fact[/b]?
Global cooling, as sited by you, was the former; the present observable warming, the latter.
Perhaps you thought us to dim witted to notice your attempt at slight of hand.
Now who has cake on their face?
by x-marcap
It is sadly... It is also a haven of very far left wing political people.
They renamed the engineering center after John Glenn. Oh the shame... It was named after an engineer, Oh the horror!
Made from water, returns to water. I really can't see a downside to it. The only challenging part is the momentum bit. Who is going to pay to introduce Hydrogen pumps to all our fuel stations? Safe to say the fuel companies won't, unless there is a demand, but to be a demand there must be cars that run on Hydrogen, and for those to exist there has to be a supply. I wonder how much money the various world govt. are giving to Big oil in the form of subsidies, etc.? Perhaps if that was all made avaialble ONLY to those companies who had Hydrogen at their stations?
Is it even possible to retrofit a Gasoline car to run Hydrogen? Obviously a new Fule tank is required. Cna any part of the engine be re-used?
by absolutely
"Anyone 'gaining' from me accepting their position on anything is immediately treated with extreme suspicion. Works for me anyway."
That makes perfect sense.
Sort by Trending