Discussion Locked

Global warming is real, and caused by humans.

0 helpful
407 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

407 replies

by too old for it

... back before the present ice age, which we are just now coming out of.

Trust me, it's cow farts if anything.

by absolutely

Humans were unable to have any impact beyond the range we could throw a spear, "back before the present ice age, which we are just now coming out of." Today, we have much more power than in any previous period, to make global changes. Those changes can be improvements, if we choose to act deliberately, with the results of our actions in mind, or they can be detrimental, if we choose to act on the range of the moment. It's that simple.

"Trust me, it's cow farts if anything."

Some might find that funny, but it isn't even ironic. Cow flatulence [b]is[/b] another major source of CO2 emissions, and the average American diet includes far more than a healthy amount of beef. Cattle overpopulation is killing us at least two ways, and I haven't even started describing the damage done to fish in streams near cow pastures. Maybe some of you have heard about the recent spinach problem, though, and the direct link to nearby cattle who are fed straw instead of their natural diet of grass? I'm not saying that cows themselves are evil, but having too many of them around is certainly harming the environment, in terms of its capacity to support healthy humans.

by deepsand

It's the dried remains os the stalks of various grasses.

A cow's normal diet includes many plants, including alfalfa, timothy and clover, which are the most common plants harvested as hay. If suitably cut, they will also eat corn stalks and the like, which are commonly stored as silage.

The problem that you allude to is that some farmers are now using whole grains, which is the fruit [i]only[/i] of various grasses.

by jcitizen

I understand that methane is more a greenhouse gas offender that CO2. With my experience in the natural gas industry I know that mining activity probably releases a tremendous about of this into the atmosphere. Earthquakes also release large amounts from under the ocean especially.

Makes me wonder if extracting methane from the atmosphere and/or burning it would be more affective than focusing on CO2. Anyone have any links out there to compare?

by deepsand

Seriously though, past causes of the state of anything are immaterial and inconsequencial with respect to the present causes of such; their only relevance is in that they may [i]suggest[/i] possible current causes.

by tony hopkinson

There are more cows than there used to be.

as eco friendly as I am I'd miss my steak.

The only article I could find that stated the exact cause of the ice ages was one that suggested it was god arranging Noah's cruise holiday. It seemed to be lacking from a scientific point of view though.

These two were tad more scientific, but still nowhere near definitive.

http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/ice/chill.html

http://culter.colorado.edu:1030/~saelias/glacier.html

Are you arguing for the lets make a profit before we all drown scenario then ?

by deepsand

As neither Max or Protius has yet to reply, there's a good chance that they've been captured ... by aliens. Oops, that was earlier, which explains their odd behavior.

As for NASA, you're quite right. No one in full possession of their senses would dare to have such a logical reason for so naming a building; unless, that is, they had no interest in currying polical favor. It's an egregious display of naivete.

by deepsand

when I used [i]to[/i] instead of [i]too[/i].

Max would have jumped on that as a sign in diminished capacity. I think that I'll leave it un-edited, just to give him the chance at a feel-good moment. How's that for charity?

by deepsand

With his finely honed analytical skills, and his unsurpassed grasp of the facts, he's likely to take that to mean that you really do concede!

Then he'll be lording it over all of us.

by absolutely

I think leaving your errors unedited, reflecting negatively on yourself for the sake of another's feel-good moment, would be charitable of you, and if so, would be immoral. Giving the undeserved usually takes from someone who deserves it, and in the best case diminishes the social perception of the value of any and all who have earned the value being given as charity. But, it is just grammar, and since criticizing your grammar was too petty four me, I conclude that criticizing your grammatical charity, other than facetiously, would be beneath me as well.

Good premises.

by absolutely

I have never worked on, or anywhere near, a farm, and heard this factoid on the radio while puttering around the house. What I am certain that I remember is that the common diet of industrial-scale beef cattle is not what their digestive system evolved to digest, and leads to an unnatural excess of poisonous E. coli bacteria. Apologies for all inaccuracies.

by deepsand

Grain feed cows have a ph level in their digestive tracts that is sufficiently different from those fed whole grasses so as to favor specific entero-bacteria that are more hostile to humans if consumed.

The human gut, like all animals, contains a myriad species of bacteria, which are essential to our digestive system's ability to extract nutients from our food. [i]Escherichia coli[/i] (E. coli) is a particularly common one found in all humans.

However, simply because any bacterium is found naturally in the gut does not mean that it is benign when introduced into other bodily systems. Take E. coli from your gut, swallow it, and the upper GI tract views it as an invader!

Furthermore, like all bacteria, E. coli has many variations, some of which evoke little or no immune response, while others can be quite life threatening to humans. The E. coli produced by grain fed cows are an example of the latter.

by deepsand

It is common, here in the east coast, for municipalities to charge a fee for the collection of trash; some use a flat annual fee, based on the average annual weight per household, while others charge for the actual weight collected from each household.

Materials that are collected for recycling, such as glass, aluminum & steel containers, paper, and selected plastics, are collected at no fee, with the revenues realized from the sale of such going into the community coffers.

Those items which contain heavy metals and other toxic materials, such as electronics, are collected at an additional fee specific to the size and type of item.

by hal 9000

Though you use Hydrogen rather than LPG which here is about 28 Cents a Litre as apposed to unleaded at $1,09 a Litre and we consider that cheap. A few weeks ago it was up around the $1.30 a Litre mark.

Now the down side of Hydrogen you need much more to produce the same amount of energy and the Fuel Air mix is much richer as well. Currently the Petrol or LPG powered engines have somewhere near the ideal 15:1 ratio of 15 Parts Air to 1 part Fuel but Hydrogen requires a much richer mix to burn so you would be looking closer at a 2.5 or 3 :1 Fuel Air Mix Ration.

Probably not good enough for the current cars on the roads but a great idea for Hybrid cars that have a small engine driving a generator and then everything else is electric.

There would be a few problems with Unsprung Mass in the wheels as you would have electric engines in there which are heavier than conventional wheel carriers. But on the up side you could do away with brakes as Regenerative Braking would act to stop the vehicle and at the same time feed power back into the batteries.

That's a proven technology that is used on every one of the Solar Racers in the Darwin Adelaide race that is held here annually and has been used in all hybrid vehicles since WW11 where that Field Gun that Dr Porsche designed could move about and hurl a 24 inch shell over the horizon. The main problem with the entire unit was it's weight and the slow speed that it could travel at but if you wanted more ammo you just hitched on more waggons with the electric engines in the wheels and they all drove the entire thing around.

Converting that technology to smaller vehicles is long overdue as to date it's mainly been confined to extremely heavy vehicles like Diesel Electric Trains where you are talking about the primary motive unit weighing in at several Hundred tons. Theoretically it's possible to have an engine not much bigger than the average Lawn Mower driving an electric generator to provide long distance travel for a new breed of Hybrid Vehicles. If you where looking at that type of engine size it would be very economical to use Hydrogen as a fuel along with Regenerative Braking and microprocessor controlled recharging of the batteries.

You could keep the engine speed fairly constant while varying the actual road speed of the vehicle by altering the flow of electricity into the motors in the wheels. You could even in theory use a small Gas Turbine engine to drive the generator and this would be far more economical to power than a conventional Internal Combustion Engine and if you went with the Bypass design you could cut down dramatically on the number of moving parts while retaining a good fuel economy rating.

Col

by hal 9000

Here is about $3,000.00 AU and there is a waiting list of about 6 months before you can get one installed.

As a New Option they add about 2K to the cost of the car but then the dealer and auto maker are getting a fair rake off as well with the option.

The ideal that I've seen was a Converted VW Beetle that had an electric motor that replaced the normal petrol motor so it acted like a real car drove somewhere around the 120 miles before needing recharging. The down side was the then available batteries the old Lead Acid just don't cut the mustard with the drain that is placed on them but the newer sealed Jell Batteries are a great improvement. They'll even continue to work if you shoot them with a high velocity large calibre projectile and basically destroy the external casing. Though naturally with reduced power output.

With Hydrogen replacing LPG you would need a bigger tank to provide the same power output and you would get a slightly lower range before refills but again the fuel should be much cheaper. Though if you where to do away with Internal Combustion motors and go with a Hydrogen Fuel Cell that would be a totally different matter.

Where this system would come into it's own is on a new design that has a small fuel engine driving an electric generator and charging the on board batteries. There have been a lot of prototypes built over the last 30 or so years along these lines though many used Petrol as the primary fuel up until recently. But as yet none have been produced as the Auto Makers have always claimed that they wouldn't sell but they do enjoy showing them off at car shows all around th world.

This started in Germany after the rebuilding as a result of WW11 and is continued to this day with Hybrid vehicles coming out of Korea and China now as well as all the existing Automotive Manufacturing Companies.

Actually I don't think price is a major issue at the moment as all the current car makers will gladly spend $12,000,000.00 retooling to allow a slightly different Tail Light assemble and mounting piece of metal and minor changes to the bonnet and headlights so they can flog off the [b]New Model[/b] which is exactly the same mechanically as the previous model. Currently they just lack the incentive to produce a decent Hybrid vehicle and the first to market will I think break the Oil Companies monopoly on the lack of availability of these vehicles.

Currently the projected prices are way too expensive but that is based on small scale production that could be totally consumed if there was a mass market appeal for these vehicles. If the current car manufactures will spend 12M just to make some minor cosmetic design alterations to give a slightly different look for what is effectively a very complicated piece of technology they would actually be saving money by producing a composite constructed Hybrid Car that had the potential of being safer and capable of being driven an indefinite distance without a second thought. After all how many Diesel Electric Trains do you hear of only travelling a short distance before needing to be refuelled?

Col

by hal 9000

I suppose that the Crocks will get bigger feet to stamp on the Roaches. :D

That might help to control their numbers. :^0

Col ]:)

by hal 9000

In the days of my grandfather's [b]Bugger All[/b] was ever thrown out as rubbish. Everything was reused. Be it the Tea Can that was used for something else or food scraps used to feed the animals or Compost Heap so he could grow better crops or at the very least the House Hold Veggie Patch was always well cared for.

Then today places like Japan's idea of being environmentally conscientious is to eat at fast food places off disposable plates with plastic knives & forks that way there is no cleaning to do afterwards and everything ends up in the local Land Fill.

We've made some major advances but we've also taken quite a few wrong turns in our approach to life.

The idea of everything being Disposable or Planed Obsolesce isn't one of the better ideas either.

Col

by deepsand

by banning disposable wooden chop sticks.

It seems the powers that be finally noticed that their forests were rapidly vanishing.

by absolutely

It's easy to find wingnuts who claim that environmentalism is a scheme to defraud productive people of the value we've earned, but the fact is that the human population of Earth has increased by several orders of magnitude in a period that is [b]VERY[/b] short compared to the time scales of "natural" climate changes, and it would be [b]INSANE[/b] to assume that such a rapid increase, and the technological advances that have both made that increase possible, and resulted from that increase, will have [b]NO[/b] deleterious side effects.

by tony hopkinson

Get populace to pile up all waste. As they die from being poisioned or simple asphyxiation, redfine them as waste. Drive airtight SUV up pile into orbit.

by tony hopkinson

he's been presenting on the issue for as long as I've been here have been proved false both scientifically and ethically.

Hence the desperation tactics, avoidance of serious debate, rational investigation of the real issues and severe emotional clouding of whatever judgement remains to him on this matter.

Personally I think his entire 'reasoning' comes from his perception that being eco-friendly is an attack on standard business practices therefore left wing therefore bad.
Until he can examine his own motivation and follow the train of this logic to the underlying fallacious assumptions, he can never be a useful contributor on the real issues.

There are some as well, the major loons like the luddite types who oppose anything simply because it was sponsored by the free market are just as blind as he is.

Someone of Maxwell's ilk should know something about that actually, austerity measures are one of their favourite rescue packages for the thing they think important.

by hal 9000

The Airtight SUV will require bottled air straight to the engines intake or it will stop before you get into orbit. :p

If you where to use a Hybrid vehicle to do the same thing I should warn you that as batteries get colder they become less efficient and when cold enough shut down completely so that wouldn't even work all that well but it would allow you to get slightly higher than just on the petrol engine alone. :D

Col ]:)

[i]Edited to add[/i] Don't you just hate it when some Smart A$$ Mechanical Engineer jumps in to ruin a perfectly good idea. :(

Oh well I think Douglas Adams had it right in HHGTTG when he described the way that the inventor of the Infinite Improbability Drive was treated by his fellow scientists [b]Nobody Likes a Smart A$$[/b] :^0

by tony hopkinson

methane conversion kit, plenty coming off the decomposing muck you are driving up.

Some big intakes on the front, sort of a low tech bussard ramjet.

by tony hopkinson

We have a bin for paper, glass, metal, compostible and the rest. Toxic materials must dumped in a controlled fashion, large items paid for.

The biggest cost in recycling is sorting, getting the producers of the waste to do it for you with the minimal amount they have is simple and very cost effective. Even with the extra collection cycles and bins etc, still paid for it self easily.

When you put the aluminium out you have to guard it though, otherwise gangs steal it and take it to the scrappy themselves.

But the sorting is the important bit.

by hal 9000

http://tinyurl.com/oezof

[b]Caution if you are easily offended DO NOT OPEN!!!!!!!!!!!!!!![/b] You've been warned so don't come complaining to me when you claim to be so shocked. :D

Now Tony this would work better the higher you go and while the thrust would remain the same the lower the atmosphere density the more movement you would achieve. :^0

Although I'm not sure if this is a contributer to the Green House Effect or something environmentally friendly. :p

Col ]:)

by deepsand

of the survivors who man the SUV!

As an alternative, why not simply have the next to the last survivors carry the final survivors to the apex?

by deepsand

Although, they generally pass by the containers of beverage cans, and go for the larger items, such as lawn and patio furniture, window screens, lawn mowers, etc..

by absolutely

Industry, diligence, determination (aka stubbornness!) - at least, if one's great expectations are of oneself, as is rational and ethical.

by deepsand

The never ending struggle between man's inseparable rational and irrational selves is the basis of life itself, without which we would have no imigination, and therefore neither art nor exploration.

Maintaining that delicate balance between the 2 is, at best, an ongoing and arduous task. For some, it is Herculean; for others, Sisyphian.

Max appears to one of the many who resolve their inner conflict by declaring the irrational the victor by default in those instances when the challenge raised by the rational proves too threatening to deeply held beliefs.

In this respect he differs not from those who vigorously deny and vehemently deride facts that assail their deeply held religious belifs.

by absolutely

"The never ending struggle between man's inseparable rational and irrational selves is the basis of life itself, without which we would have no imigination, and therefore neither art nor exploration."

The urge to create ("imagination") and to cure one's own ignorance ("exploration") are both attributes of the rational faculty, not of the reflexes, including emotion.

by deepsand

enjoy a beautiful sunset, or like the smell of lilacs?

Why, if grounded in logic, is fragrence the most powerful evocator of memories & past felt emotions, followed by music?

And, why do all the philosophers and psychologists whose works I've read (no, do not ask me for quotations; remembering names is my weak suit) seem to support my statement?

by absolutely

The fact that certain reactions are so deeply incorporated into the psyche that they are nearly automatic does not [b]logically imply[/b] that they are [b]contrary[/b] to logic.

"enjoy a beautiful sunset, or like the smell of lilacs?

Why, if grounded in logic, is fragrence the most powerful evocator of memories & past felt emotions, followed by music?

And, why do all the philosophers and psychologists whose works I've read (no, do not ask me for quotations; remembering names is my weak suit) seem to support my statement?"

I won't ask for quotations. Undoubtedly we've read several of the same ones. Emotions frequently operate more quickly than conscious calculation, but when they operate [b]contrary[/b] to conscious calculation, insanity or cognitive dissonance is the prognosis. So, psychologists tend to contradict their own assertions, and should thus be dismissed out of hand. Philosophers may be taken seriously - some of them, at least, though we needn't name names.

by deepsand

That an emotion may not be illogical does not, does not mean that such must of necessity be borne of logic; i.e., [i]not illogical[/ib] is [b]not[/b] the same as [i]logical[/i].

Furthermore, observations of other animals, including those close to use on the evolutionary tree, clearly show that logical thought is not required for the existence of emotions.

by absolutely

"The never ending struggle between man's inseparable rational and irrational selves is the basis of life itself, without which we would have no imigination, and therefore neither art nor exploration."

If you meant that the source of imagination, art & exploration, is an internal struggle and not irrationality itself, then I misunderstood & do not disagree at all. Back to global warming?

by deepsand

Preface: Note that (ir)rational and (il)logical are [b]not[/b] interchangeable terms.

1) It is our irrational self that drives us; our rational self controls said such, as best it can.

2) Our rational self is not always capable of controlling the irrational.

3) Max's stand re. global warming, and mans' role in such, serves to illustrate the conflict between the rational and irrational selves. In his case, his beliefs, born of the irrational, are so strongly felt that he rejects facts which run contrary to such; i.e., his irrational self trumps his rational self.

We observe the same behavior in many who hold strongly felt regigious beliefs. These we cannot change by the mere presentation of facts and logical arguments; only personal epiphanies, of a nature that forces them to deeply question their beliefs, will suffice to effect such change.

by yardbyrd

The panic spearheaded by Al Gore and empty-headed sycophantic clones is tragic because the so-called science he uses isn't. Read "Unstoppable Global Warming: Every 1,500 Years" for some REAL Science.

by deepsand

as were countless other works. You need look no further back than to "Creation Science" for evidence of such "scientific claims."

For starters, let's look at a Hudson Institute's review of the book that you cite.

---------------------------------------------

Featured Book of the Month
Unstoppable Global Warming: Every 1,500 Years (Rowman and Littlefield, 276 pp., $24.95)

The Earth?s recent warming trend isn?t a product of human activity, but rather caused by a solar-linked cycle that creates harmless, naturally warmer temperatures approximately every 1,500 years, write Dennis Avery and Fred Singer in their controversial new book Unstoppable Global Warming: Every 1,500 Years.

During the course of their research Avery, an agricultural economist and senior fellow at Hudson Institute, and Singer, a climate physicist, assemble considerable physical and historical evidence of the natural climate-change cycle that ranges from ancient Roman, Egyptian, and Chinese temperature records, to harvests of historic wine grapes?which are the most accurate and sensitive indicators of temperature, the authors explain. Avery and Singer also examine and analyze Vikings? tooth enamel in Greenland?s cemeteries, ice cores, seabed sediments, tree rings, fossil pollen, and cave stalagmites to document their research.

The authors show that the science of the natural cycle runs counter to what many believe and fear will happen as a result of man-made global warming. They debunk such climate-change myths as the looming extinction of polar bears; the possibility of rising sea levels drowning New York; and famine caused by warming.

The book is written in an accessible style, designed for both the lay person and for policy experts.

---------------------------------------------

Let's begin at the end; "[i][b]designed for[/b] both the [b]lay person and[/b] for [b]policy experts[/b][/i]." Hmmm; no mention of hard scientific data or proof here - just as is to be expected of someone who's seeking to avoid the close scrutiny of an informed eye.

Well, then, how about the referenced data sources? How about those "[b][i]ancient Roman, Egyptian, and Chinese temperature records[/i][/b]?" I'll bet that those are real accurate! Please tell us how said temperatures were then measured, what the accuracy was, and how such records can be reliably translated into today's temperature systems.

But, surely the authors of this work must have [i]some[/i] champions. Well, of course they do, people who have not a clue as to what real science is, people such as Michael Medved and right-wing Christian Conservative groups. And, apparently, now you as well.

To quote Albert Einstein (a [b]real scientist[/b], by the way), "[i]The difference between stupidity and genius is that genius has its limits.[/i]"

by deepsand

State of denial

04 November 2006
NewScientist.com news service

Fred Pearce

KEVIN TRENBERTH reckons he is a marked man. He has argued that last year's devastating Atlantic hurricane season, which spawned hurricane Katrina, was linked to global warming. For the many politicians and minority of scientists who insist there is no evidence for any such link, Trenberth's views are unacceptable and some have called for him step down from an international panel studying climate change. "The attacks on me are clearly designed to get me fired or to resign," says Trenberth.

The attacks fit a familiar pattern. Sceptics have also set their sights on scientists who have spoken out about the accelerating meltdown of the ice sheets in Greenland and Antarctica and the thawing of the planet's permafrost. These concerns will be addressed in the next report by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC), the global organisation created by the UN in 1988 to assess the risks of human-induced climate change. Every time one of these assessments is released, about once every five years, some of the American scientists who have played a part in producing it become the targets of concerted attacks apparently designed to bring down their reputations and careers. At stake is the credibility of scientists who fear our planet is hurtling towards disaster and want to warn the public in the US and beyond.

So when the next IPCC report is released in February 2007, who will be the targets and why? When New Scientist spoke to researchers on both sides of the climate divide it became clear that they are ready for a showdown. If the acrimony were to become so intense that American scientists were forced to stop helping in the preparation of IPCC reports, it could seriously dent the organisation and rob the world of some significant voices in the climate change debate.

One of those who knows only too well what it is like to come under attack from climate change sceptics is Ben Santer of the Lawrence Livermore Laboratory in California. The lead author of a chapter in the 1995 IPCC report that talked for the first time about the "discernible human influence on global climate", he was savaged by sceptics and accused of introducing this wording without consulting colleagues who had helped write the chapter. One sceptic called it the "most disturbing corruption of the peer-review process in 60 years". Another accused him of "scientific cleansing" - at a time when the phrase "ethnic cleansing" was synonymous with genocide in Bosnia. The IPCC investigated and dismissed the allegations as baseless.

Another scientist to suffer the ire of the sceptics was Michael Mann of Pennsylvania State University in University Park. He was attacked after the IPCC assessment in 2001, which highlighted his "hockey stick" graph showing that temperatures began a rapid rise in recent decades and are now higher than at any time over the past thousand years. The sceptics accused Mann of cherry-picking his data and criticised him for refusing to disclose his statistical methods which, they claimed, biased the study to show recent warming (New Scientist, 18 March, p 40). Last year, Texas Republican Congressman Joe Barton, chair of the House Committee on Energy and Commerce, ordered Mann to provide the committee with voluminous details of his working procedures, computer programs and past funding. Barton's demands were widely condemned by fellow scientists and on Capitol Hill. "There are people who believe that if they bring down Mike Mann, they can bring down the IPCC," said Santer at the time. Mann's findings, which will be endorsed in the new IPCC report, have since been replicated by other studies.

Santer says, however, that he expects attacks to continue on other fronts. "There is a strategy to single out individuals, tarnish them and try to bring the whole of the science into disrepute," he says. "And Kevin [Trenberth] is a likely target." Mann agrees that the scientists behind the upcoming IPCC report are in for a rough ride. "There is already an orchestrated campaign against the IPCC by climate change contrarians," he says.

The "contrarians" include scientists and politicians who are sceptical of the scientific evidence for climate change. Some of those who spoke to New Scientist insist that they are not planning character assassinations, and intend merely to engage in robust scientific debate, not least by challenging the IPCC's status as the arbiter of truth on climate change.

Many of the IPCC's authors, some of whom asked not to be named, say this is a smokescreen. They claim there is an extensive network of lobby groups and scientists involved in making the case against the IPCC and its reports. Automobile, coal and oil companies have coordinated and funded past attacks on them, the scientists say. Sometimes this has been done through Washington lobby groups such as the Competitive Enterprise Institute (CEI), whose officers include Myron Ebell, a former climate negotiator for George W. Bush's administration. Recently, the CEI made television advertisements arguing against climate change, one of which ended with the words: "Carbon dioxide, they call it pollution, we call it life." CEI's past funders include ExxonMobil, General Motors and the Ford Motor Company.

The money trail
Some sceptical scientists are funded directly by industry. In July, The Washington Post published a leaked letter from the Intermountain Rural Electric Association (IREA), an energy company based in Colorado, that exhorted power companies to support the work of the prominent sceptic Pat Michaels of the University of Virginia, Charlottesville. Worried about the potential cost of cleaning up coal-fired power plants to reduce their CO2 emissions, IREA's general manager, Stanley Lewandowski, wrote: "We believe that it is necessary to support the scientific community that is willing to stand up against the alarmists... In February this year, IREA alone contributed $100,000 to Dr Michaels."

So what is this money buying? For one, an ability to coordinate responses to the IPCC reports. Michaels told New Scientist that a flashpoint in the upcoming report could be hurricanes. Trenberth, who is the head of climate analysis at the National Center for Atmospheric Research (NCAR) in Boulder, Colorado, has angered the IPCC's critics by supporting the idea of a link between global warming and the intensity of hurricanes. The sceptics insist there is no published evidence to back this up. Trenberth says he is simply putting two established facts together: "Sea-surface temperature is rising because of global warming, and high sea-surface temperatures make for more intense storms."

In the aftermath of hurricane Katrina, and with a US administration that has a record of hostility to concerns about climate change, Trenberth's statements are political dynamite. "I suspect the sceptics will want to try and dismantle the argument that there is a link," Mann says. Santer agrees: "If I was an industry-funded sceptic, I'd hit that area hard, for sure." Trenberth himself fears the worst. "I would not be surprised if the hurricane aspect of the report is targeted, along with my own role," he says. "But I am proud of what we have achieved."

One lead author of the chapter on hurricanes told New Scientist that it will include discussion of two papers published last year in Science and Nature, both of which showed that the frequency of the most intense hurricanes has increased in recent years. Even if Trenberth and his co-authors do not directly attribute this to global warming, the mere mention of these papers in the context of climate change is likely to provoke criticism.

Trenberth's opinions have already alienated his co-author Chris Landsea of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's Atlantic Oceanographic and Meteorological Laboratory in Florida. Landsea disputed Trenberth's view, arguing that older measurements made before the era of satellite observation were not reliable enough to make the claim stick (New Scientist, 3 December 2005, p 36). When IPCC chiefs refused to censure Trenberth for his remarks directly linking last year's hurricanes to climate change, Landsea resigned, claiming that the IPCC had been "subverted, its neutrality lost".

Another sensitive area is the concern that existing models of ice sheets on Greenland and Antarctica massively underestimate future melting and consequent sea-level rise. "Our understanding of the dynamics of ice-sheet destruction has completely changed in the last five years," says Richard Alley of Penn State University, a lead author of the chapter on ice sheets who expects to find himself in the firing line over this issue. "We used to think it would take 10,000 years for melting to penetrate to the bottom of the ice sheet. But now we know it can take just 10 seconds," he says.

The rethink has come from the discovery that when surface water from melting ice drains down though crevasses it can lubricate the join between ice and bedrock. This mechanism appears to explain the faster discharge of ice from Greenland into the Atlantic, but it has yet to be incorporated into ice-sheet models, which still assume that the limiting factor is the rate at which heat penetrates through solid ice.

Michaels dismisses the idea of more rapid loss as "hysteria", and has thrown down a challenge to the IPCC to justify any change to the ice-sheet models. "[The IPCC] criticise people like me for saying the models are wrong, so it's going to be really interesting to see how they respond when their own people say the models are wrong." Alley, however, points out that leading glaciologists mostly agree that the current generation of ice-sheet models are wanting, whereas climatologists are mostly happy with their models.

A third focus for debate will be the way the IPCC treats recent reports of climate change disrupting the natural carbon cycle more than anticipated. This has to do with the release of large amounts of CO2 from rainforests and soils, and methane from permafrost and beneath continental shelves, possibly speeding up global warming. "These are factors not included in the current models, which may cause us to underestimate warming," Mann says.

Some insiders suggest that the IPCC may be more cautious in its upcoming report than it has been in the past, but this is unlikely to placate climate-change sceptics. Roger Pielke of the University of Colorado, Boulder, accuses the IPCC leadership of "seeing their role as political advocates rather than honest brokers". And Michaels has set out to prove this (see "A taste for bad news?").

For the majority of climate scientists, who are convinced that global warming is a real and present danger, the most alarming outcome of this discord is that federal funding could be withdrawn from those who work on IPCC reports. Here too Trenberth may find himself caught in the headlights. The US Senate's Environment and Public Works Committee under its chairman James Inhofe has begun investigating NCAR, Trenberth's employer. Inhofe has repeatedly written to NCAR and other agencies demanding details about financial and contractual arrangements with their employees and with federal funding agencies such as the National Science Foundation (NSF). In a letter to the NSF in February, Inhofe said he needed the information to help him in "researching, analyzing and understanding the science of global climate change". Inhofe has a record of hostility to the idea of climate change, having asked on the Senate floor in July 2003: "Could it be that man-made global warming is the greatest hoax ever perpetrated on the American people? It sure sounds like it."

NCAR is not commenting on Inhofe's investigation, but many climate scientists contacted by New Scientist regard it as a tactic designed to intimidate those working on the IPCC report. "Inhofe's actions appear to be an effort to discourage leading US scientists from being involved in international scientific assessment processes such as the IPCC," Mann says.

This is potentially disastrous for the IPCC. Out of 168 scientists listed as lead authors or reviewers involved in assessing the science of climate change, 38 are from the US - more than twice as many as the second-largest national grouping, the British.

IPCC scientists who spoke to New Scientist insist they are not trying to turn science into politics or to shut down genuine debate. They do, however, worry that their conclusions might be drowned out by some politically motivated and industry-funded sceptics. "I'd hate to see hundreds of people putting years of their lives into producing a report that is then trashed by these people for political ends," says Santer. "That is what happened in my case, and I felt very bad about it."

A taste for bad news?
Pat Michaels of the University of Virginia, Charlottesville, claims that climate research is biased towards pessimistic conclusions, and says he can prove it.

Michaels has analysed publications by climate scientists in the journals Nature and Science between mid-2005 and mid-2006. He found 115 articles of which 83 said that the likely impact of the greenhouse effect was going to be worse than previously suggested, 23 saw no change and only 9 said that things were not as bad as previously thought.

To most researchers this is solid evidence that the prognosis for the planet is worsening as new science comes in. Michaels rejects this interpretation. To have any faith in the forecasts of climatologists, he argues, "we should expect that new research should have an equal probability of being better or worse [for Earth's climate] than previous research."

His explanation for what he calls "this highly skewed result" is that scientists and journal editors are more interested in bad news. "The literature is intrinsically biased," he says. "And that means that the IPCC - which is largely a literature review process - is also biased." Michaels aims to publish his work in February, when it is likely to distract attention from the IPCC report expected at that time.

From issue 2576 of New Scientist magazine, 04 November 2006, page 18-21
Close this window
Printed on Thu Nov 02 22:55:39 GMT 2006

by absolutely

"Another sensitive area is the concern that existing models of ice sheets on Greenland and Antarctica massively underestimate future melting and consequent sea-level rise. "Our understanding of the dynamics of ice-sheet destruction has completely changed in the last five years," says Richard Alley of Penn State University, a lead author of the chapter on ice sheets who expects to find himself in the firing line over this issue. "We used to think it would take 10,000 years for melting to penetrate to the bottom of the ice sheet. But now we know it can take just 10 seconds," he says.

The rethink has come from the discovery that when surface water from melting ice drains down though crevasses it can lubricate the join between ice and bedrock. This mechanism appears to explain the faster discharge of ice from Greenland into the Atlantic, but it has yet to be incorporated into ice-sheet models, which still assume that the limiting factor is the rate at which heat penetrates through solid ice.

Michaels dismisses the idea of more rapid loss as "hysteria", and has thrown down a challenge to the IPCC to justify any change to the ice-sheet models. "[The IPCC] criticise people like me for saying the models are wrong, so it's going to be really interesting to see how they respond when their own people say the models are wrong." Alley, however, points out that leading glaciologists mostly agree that the current generation of ice-sheet models are wanting, whereas climatologists are mostly happy with their models."

In fact, H2O undergoes a phase change at 32F, and exhibits different physical behavior above this threshold than below it. Above 32F, water flows, and quantities including gravity, average geometrical parameters of cracks in ice sheets, and tendency of flowing water to contribute to melt along these cracks would have to be included in a thorough model. Since said complexity requires a degree of mathematical sophistication unattainable to mediocre climatologists, it should be denied, so as not to discriminate against the incompetent.

[edit: replaced "variables" with "quantities" because the acceleration of gravity would not be treated as a variable in this model]

by deepsand

As with the Dennis Avery and Fred Singer book cited above by greg.walker - I don't expect he'll be back to defend his thesis - much of what the sceptics here publicly say and/or publish is deliberately dumbed-down so as to produce a seemingly substantive statement while making it understandable and seemly reasonable to the least educated and most indiscrimating of minds.

This very tactic has been used repeatedly throughout history to pillary countless persons, peoples, institutions, beliefs, and causes.

by absolutely

"A taste for bad news?
Pat Michaels of the University of Virginia, Charlottesville, claims that climate research is biased towards pessimistic conclusions, and says he can prove it.

Michaels has analysed publications by climate scientists in the journals Nature and Science between mid-2005 and mid-2006. He found 115 articles of which 83 said that the likely impact of the greenhouse effect was going to be worse than previously suggested, 23 saw no change and only 9 said that things were not as bad as previously thought.

To most researchers this is solid evidence that the prognosis for the planet is worsening as new science comes in. Michaels rejects this interpretation. To have any faith in the forecasts of climatologists, he argues, "we should expect that new research should have an equal probability of being better or worse [for Earth's climate] than previous research."

His explanation for what he calls "this highly skewed result" is that scientists and journal editors are more interested in bad news. "The literature is intrinsically biased," he says. "And that means that the IPCC - which is largely a literature review process - is also biased." Michaels aims to publish his work in February, when it is likely to distract attention from the IPCC report expected at that time."

Just as "we should expect that new research should have an equal probability of being better or worse [for Earth's climate] than previous research" we should likewise expect that the President of any nation should possess at least above average intelligence. Obviously, then, George Walker Bush's widely published, commonly "known" record of academic mediocrity must also be a fraud.

by deepsand

Here, it's "everyone but me and those who agree with me are biased, as witnessed by the great number who oppose me/us."

How wonderful it must be to whole heartedly believe one's own tripe, to be able to turn vice into virtue at whim.

by deepsand

And, it's cheaper than what PECO's charging me for gas, not to mention being immune to any sort of market shocks.

by absolutely

... people (tend to) rise (or sink) to (match) what is expected of them. (The same holds true in the marketplace of ideas.)

Explain science to them in idiots' terms, and they conclude that science is truly simplistic enough for idiots to comprehend. Accordingly, they act logically on the premise demonstrated to them, and cease to attempt to understand the math and logic used to derive the facts that "science beat" journalists never understood, but reported as though they did.

[edit: in () above]

by absolutely

I don't think it possible that [i]mis[/i]-informed people can exist, without mis-informers. Of course, there will always be people who are [i]un[/i]-informed, about some things, until we all become omniscient. Being ignorant of some things is not a problem. The problem occurs when, whether through one's own arrogance or another's malice, one gets the belief of knowing more than one does, and acting on untrue premises.

by deepsand

You guys really need to re-visit your auto-censor; the indiscriminate blocking of text without regard to context is not acceptable.

by deepsand

If we include the instance in which one is in possession of correct facts alone, but lacks all of the requisite facts for reaching a particular conclusion, and does in fact reach such conclusion, he may be said to be mis-informed, although, strictly speaking, his conclusion is owing to ignorance.

Nonetheless, he has [b]not been mis-informed by another.[/b]

Perhaps it would be better to say that such person was [i]ill[/i]-informed.

Those who are given correct information, but not [b]all[/b] of the relevant information, as is often the case under discussion here, have not perforce been mis-informed, but are most assuredly ill-informed.

by hal 9000

I used something that I thought would be immediately censored and it went through without a problem, so I had to do a quick Edit to not offend anyone.

But I'm not sure about some of the words that are Blacklisted unless that have a totally different meaning in th US to other parts of the world that I'm unaware of.

Like Wild Pu$$y if spelt the correct way would be blocked out but Beaver would go through perfectly OK. I'm told that the latter has several meanings in the US but to me it's just a water rat that dams up rivers.

Col

by absolutely

But I'll bet I [i]can[/i] say that "Dick ejaculate laude".

Shame, shame, TR! You are not even competent censors.

by absolutely

The three-letter variant, with the non-sexual Latin meaning, gets blocked, but the longer word, which leaves no ambiguity about the sexual context of the usage, does not get blocked. Hardy frickin' har.

by absolutely

Your argument is clever, and more of less internally consistent, but it does not apply to the situations being discussed.

by deepsand

The content of the "Recent activity on your discussion subscriptions" remains uncensored.

So, it appears that it's ok to risk offending those who subscribe to a discussion, but not the casual participant or reader.

Can you say [b]incompetent hypocrisy[/b]?

by deepsand

Quite frequently the husksters, in this case of junk science, present a carefully selected set of facts, all of which are true, which appear to support their stated conclusion. Absent errors of [i]commission[/i] on their part, it cannot be truthfully held that they have [i]mis[/i]-informed their audience.

However, their errors of [i]omission[/i] have most certainly resulted in their audience being [i]ill[/i]-informed, in a manner that is wholly non-obvious to said audience.

Husksters employ such tactic as it is not always easy, or even possible, to both identify errors of omission as well as prove that such were knowingly and intentionally committed.

by hal 9000

This is as useful as [b]Tits on a Bull[/b] which is actually the correct way of saying it but apparently the Tit's bit is not accepted by TR Black List no matter the context of the meaning so I've now altered this to [b]Teats on a Bull[/b]

Col

by absolutely

In the examples that come to mind, a period of warming, and/or changes in greenhouse gas levels, is cited without an explicit, untrue assertion, and I find the implication to be false only by conducting further research, usually chasing down the same variables, over a longer timeframe. This is omitted data, not commission of falsifying. You're right.

by absolutely

You haven't told me one thing about this book. Why would I bother to investigate its contents? Your say so? Ha!

by deepsand

You have yet to respond to earlier rebuttal; and, you now expect us to bow down in blind faith?

What a small mind you have.

by ralphclark

The nuclear winter claim specified that dust & ash particles from nuclear groundbursts would collect in the upper atmosphere and block out the sun's rays thus causing the Earth to cool. It is still thought to be the case. Please note that "particles" in this sense may well contain carbon and even oxygen but they not CO2, they are solid and a lot bigger than individual gas molecules.

The global warming hypothesis is that CO2 gas in the atmosphere - regardless of origin - blocks infrared (i.e. heat) but passes light and ultraviolet. Hence it lets sunlight in, which heats the Earth, but doesn't let heat out. So it works just like the glass in a greenhouse (hence "greenhouse gas", "greenhouse effect"). As a result the more CO2 lingering in the atmosphere, the more the Earth heats up.

What the Vostok ice core studies established as a matter of incontravertible fact is that since the start of the industrial age (when, coincidentally, humans started burning fossl fuels on an industrial scale, ha ha) CO2 levels shot up from 180ppm to 360ppm which is far above anything seen during any ice age or any interglacial period going back as far as we have data for (about half a million years).

So we have three things here that we know for sure:
1. Atmospheric CO2 levels have grown continually ever since human fossil fuel usage began to increase when we started burning fossil fuels to power our machines.
2. There is a simple theory that predicts how increased CO2 in the atmosphere would contribute to a rise in average global temperature.
3. The average Ocean temperature is in fact rising.

The ONLY valid question there ever was about this, was how much of number 3 is down to numbers 1 and 2.

The article which this thread is discussing is about a study which showed how the various explanatory models were testing - both the ones beloved of the treehuggers and the ones beloved of the gas guzzling dont-take-my-car-away right wing, and the only models that resulted in the effects so far observed were the ones that included human-caused CO2 output. So 1 and 2 really do lead to 3.

Anyone still contending otherwise clearly has no clue what they are talking about. Fortunately such people are a dwindling minority. Most of the loudmouth right wing corporate apologists have suddenly gone unusually quiet on this subject.

by absolutely

The twit had it coming. These pompous, theocratic wanna-be tyrants all need to be insulted back into their proper places, much more often. Religious extremism can only take hold when stupid ideas are treated as "respectable", merely because they are asserted in the guise of religion. I issue no free passes for stupid ideas, including stupid religious ideas. Since the rest of society is failing to do its part to properly & sufficiently ridicule those stupid ideas which happen to be "religious" in origin, I [b]target[/b] stupid religious ideas for extra ridicule, whenever they cross my path. It's a sh!tty, thankless, monotonous job, but dammit it's important to do.

by deepsand

I recently had a peer-to-peer e-mail from another member inquiring as to why I continued to repeat myself; and, that did I not risk appearing to be the fool for such.

My reply was that if it were the case that the posts of the miscreant in question never be read by anyone other than those who were already aware of his behavior, then all would be well; but, as there will always be newcomers, any and all specious bullsh!t flowing from said miscreant needed to be addressed for the benefit of those newcomers.

"It's not my job to please them, but to wake them up."

by ralphclark

All of you who've been saying that a blue object isn't really blue are just misusing the accepted definition of words.

The colour attribute of a surface is defined by the frequencies of light that are emitted, transmitted or reflected from that surface. If the frequencies of the light are predominantly blue then the surface and the object it is considered part of, are blue.

It's meaningless to say that an object is red because it absorbs red light. That's just not how we define colour. If we did then to be consistent we would have to rename every colour to its opposite, complimentary colour.

Life would instantly become more complicated as we would then be naming colours not for themselves, but for what was known to be missing. What would be the frickin' point of that? Imagine having to teach colour to a child, then!

by ralphclark

Utterly and completely. Mainly thanks to deepsand who called your bluff.

1. The scientific community are shown to have reached a solid consensus on global warming and climate change.
2. Most of industry capitulated two years ago.
3. Only the oil industry still pretends the question hasn't been settled, since the necessary reduction in oil consumption must hurt their profits.
4. The only person you can find to champion the head-in-sand position is the oil industry's paid shill. And all he can come up with is empty rhetoric.

Game over, dude.

by jcitizen

I concur Tony. The thing that amazes me about this whole argument is one simple fact. The fossile fuels that we're burning were, at one time, in the air.

Now I don't think anyone would argue that the Precambrian epoch wasn't hot; but the Carboniferous period that followed was the one that trapped all that carbon under ground. Looks like carbon was good for life! If the Cambrian explosion is any yardstick.

So DUH! I am really worried about a new explosion of life! There may be more of the species that like hot weather, that we don't like; but BOO HOO! I'm not too worried about it.

Now if you want to talk about energy independence; thheeennnn you will get my attention. This is more important to me. I don't want to depend on fossile fuel for my nation. I think there is room for compromise on this, no matter what a guy believes; because energy independence equals freedom and no more wars over fuel.

by jcitizen

A natural gas concern used to supply it's own fleet with CNG which has the same technical conserns as hydrogen. They did very well with it through the '80s and had infrastructure scattered throughout- from north Texas to Wyoming and Nebraska. Used both pickups and cars using ordinary welding bottles as tanks. The pumps were very expensive because of the fire hazard safety design. When you ran out of CNG, all you had to do was flip a switch and you were running on regular gasoline. The price of gasoline got so (relatively) cheap, they abandon the system though.

by deepsand

1) All of the CO2 trapped in fossil fuels, the now frozen tundra, etc., was [b]not[/b] all in the atmosphere [b]at the same time[/b].

2) While the Cambrian period may have been "good for life", I doubt that it was a "life" that either you or your descendants would view as "good."

It's easy to say that you don't care; but, you've no right to impose the results of your indifference on future generations.

by jcitizen

Please reference my earlier answer to this same solution to your earlier post. If a small company in the Midwest US can afford it, the mass production capability of the world could easily do it.

The price of gasoline NOW is already motivating people to find their own solutions. There are many blogs and RSS feeds on the current technology out there. I think that individuals will end up bypassing their governments and the energy companies soon.

In fact solutions will be as plentiful as Linux distros for the individuals who are initiated enough to get up of his/her duffs and apply them. I have already designed a solar powered four wheel electric bike that goes 15 to 30 miles on a 2 hour charge(less time with plug in). Bear in mind that the new tech makes 5 minute charges for 40 mile treks already a reality with full sized PHEVS.

by jcitizen

I am more worried that ocean species will not adapt soon enough to climate change. Arthropods were adapted to glean oxygen from the water, and they had no problem leaving the water and adapting to land; yet their size didn't change to smaller body types until the oxygen levels were higher? Why?Notice that very little geologic science enters into most of the arguments in the media. Like how much CO2 was in the air through the periods of prehistory and what kind of life was supported above water?

Just after the Carboniferous period there was a global warming period. Why? Paleontologists claim, during this period, that even a lighting strike could light the forests for miles because the oxyten was so high! There is a lot of mixed messages in the science. Perhaps an enlightened individual such as yourself could set us straight - opposed to all these other experts. Who are we to beleive?

Besides if you read the end of my statement there; you'll notice that I want an end to fossil fuel dependence anyway. Also I feel there are economical ways to absorb the excess CO2 from the atmosphere even if we kept using fossile fuels - which I am NOT in favor of (once again).

by jcitizen

Both your statements are correct. I guess I better read the rest of your posts to verify just what stand (if any) you take on any action or lack thereof society should initiate.

by deepsand

Be prepared for a lengthy read; this is but [u]one of many[/u] discussions re. global warming. And, just so it is clear to you, my interest here is first & foremost in the scientific facts, with matters of policy to be based on such; i.e., form follows function.

You say that you hail from Palmer, [b]AQ[/b], which presumably is [i]not[/i] within the U.S.. And, since TR's system does not comport well with non-US addresses, those of you outside the U.S. are forced to use various kludges re. your location.

What does [b]AQ[/b] denote?

by absolutely

Please comment on the application of that same principle to the government as sponsor of research into effects of 'greenhouse gases' on climate. How does the observed form of the government's role as sponsor follow government's valid function? Or, do you see the role of sponsor as axiom, with form following that function, above question?

by deepsand

Since both government & sponsorship are functions, I'm uncertain as to the meaning of your question. Are you asking if the sponsorship of scientific research is a legitimate exercise of government?

by jcitizen

Sorry deepsand I don't like to divulge my exact location in open online forums but I would be happy to email anyone willing to give up their email address. Or if requested give out mine.

I find this discussion fascinating and I try to stick to the facts as well. It goes without saying that probably not all the "facts" I have are accurate; as they are only as good as the source and my brain damaged memory.

But speaking of chaos; would you not agree that without a good knowledge of the "attractant" in climate modeling anything you do to the environment could cause an undesirable affect, including the control of CO2? Perhaps we could end up with wild harmonic responses in our weather; which may already seem to be the case. But I am not confident that there is enough verifiable facts to draw a conclusion from modern history.

by deepsand

Given the problem mentioned with foreign addresses, taking "AQ" to be a non-USA designation rather than a means of obscuration, and having, for example, seen "NS" used for something other than Nova Scotia, mine was a question born of simple curiousity. If you're in the US, a better way to achieve you desired end, while still giving other members an idea of your nationality, would be to use the correct State code with a fictious City, as many here do. Given the many cultural differences represented here at TR, it is oft times the case that knowledge of a member's nationality is not merely useful, but necessary for a proper understanding of his post.

As regards climate, chaos, etal., by "harmonic" I assume that you mean "cylical." If so, it must be noted that cylical systems are [b]not chaotic[/b], but rather are highly organized responses to positive feedback.

Now, an increase in the levels of atmospheric greenhouse gases does, of physical necessity, result in a positive feedback loop. Therefore, as a reduction in the rate of said increase serves also to reduce the rate of increase of said feedback, such [b]cannot[/b] serve to foster oscillation.

Weather systems are driven by thermal energy; the greater the amount of such energy, the more violent and volatile, or chaotic, the weather. As a reduction in emissions of greenhouse gases is, as explained above, a counter-cyclical force, such reduction will [b]not[/b] serve to increase thermal energy, and therefore cannot result in more "chaotic" weather, but can only have an opposite effect.

by jcitizen

Thank you very much for you time and interesting input. The acronym is short for Palmer Station Antartica (US)

by deepsand

those of CO2, its contribution to radiative forcing is less than one-third that of CO2. Furthermore, CO2's atmoshperic lifetime is roughly 20-40 times that of CH4. For data, see
http://cdiac.ornl.gov/pns/current_ghg.html
and
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Greenhouse_gases .

As for the disposal of CH4 via combustion, given that the products of such are H2O & CO2, which have longer lifetimes & cause more pronounced increases in radiative forcing than CH4, such disposal of CH4 would clearly result in undesirable consequences.

As you yourself earlier noted, beware the Law of Unintended Consequences.

by absolutely

It's not fair!!

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=102&threadID=211418&messageID=2172861

[i]I'm in the middle of a "new SAN" project which involves creating and transferring the data on several hundred disks. This involves an awful lot of watching files go by...

To keep from going insane with boredom, I do things that are completely stupid so that I suddenly get a rush of adrenalin - WHAT ARE YOU DOING? - that wakes me briefly.

Reading MrMiamiGeobubIs2BadCozHesA[b][u]Fuckwit[/u][/b]'s posts and attempting to answer them rationally is one of those.

I even answered a question from a newb about the IF function in Excel without being in the slightest sarcastic. It was only after submitting the answer that I stapled my thumb to the desk as punishment.

Tomorrow, I will have to ramp up the adrenalin buzz and - maybe - see if I can get enough nerve to get Mae really mad at me. Now THAT can get the adrenalin flowing almost as much as the black gear and dark red lippy mental picture...![/i]