Discussion Locked

Has this group of FireFox supporters gone too far?

0 helpful
208 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

A group calling themselves "Explorer Destroyer" has undertaken an active campaign to get users to download FF via the Google Toolbar.

While there is nothing wrong with their goal, I take issue with their tactics on 2 points, both of which treaten net neutrality.

1) The referenced "dead serious" approach creates a de facto split in the net along browser lines; and,
2) Google seems to being a willing participant.

Read the article & give us your comments.

==================================================
Topics > Internet & Networking > Browsers > Mozilla >

[b]Firefox Backers Create 'Destroy IE' Campaign[/b]

'Explorer Destroyer' movement takes aim at Microsoft's browser.

Elizabeth Montalbano, IDG News Service
Tuesday, April 25, 2006

SAN FRANCISCO -- A group of self-titled "political activists" in Massachusetts has started an aggressive campaign to get browser users to switch from Microsoft's Internet Explorer to Mozilla's Firefox.

Taking advantage of a new program by Google, the campaign, called Explorer Destroyer, pays users $1 for each referral to Firefox made through Google Toolbar, according to the group's Web site.

"You already want people to switch to Firefox. Now's the time to get serious about it," according to the site. "Google is paying $1 for each new Firefox user you refer....Now you can advance your ideals, save people from popups and spyware hell, and make some serious money."

Google did not return calls seeking comment for this story, but the search giant offers a standard $1 per user referral fee to Web sites that generate new downloads of Firefox with the Google Toolbar.

How It Works
According to the Explorer Destroyer Web site, the group offers Web-site owners scripting technology that detects whether a visitor is running IE. If so, an alert will appear advising the visitor to download Firefox so they can either view the site better or view it at all. Whenever a visitor to a Web site using the group's technology switches to Firefox from IE, the owner of the Web site will get the referral fee if they have signed up for Google's AdSense program.

There are three types of alerts site owners can put on their page--"gentle encouragement," "semi-serious," or "dead serious."

If a Web site owner chooses "gentle encouragement," site visitors who are using IE will see a banner across the top of the page that encourages them to download Firefox. A "semi-serious" site will put up a splash page encouraging a user to download Firefox, with a link for downloading Mozilla's browser as well as a link to the Web site.

Those who choose the "dead serious" alert actually block users with IE from viewing the page, informing them they must install Firefox to view the site. View a demo of what happens when a user clicks on a site with this rating.

Why Attack IE?
In addition to the Explorer Destroyer Web site, where users can download the scripts for their sites and get more information, the group also has launched another Web site that parodies IE and provides users with reasons why they should switch to Firefox.

One reason for switching, according to the site? "It will make Bill Gates soooooooooo mad." "Seriously--super, super mad," the site goes on to say. "And even more than Bill, let's think about Steve 'I'm going to ... kill Google' Ballmer for a second. If there's anyone that's going to absolutely blow a gasket when they see this Web site, it will be him."

Other reasons the site offers for switching from IE to Firefox include: "Reduce your weekly family and friends tech support load to eight hours"--a reason that pokes fun at various problems users encounter when using IE--and "If we knew Web designers would hurl themselves off it, we wouldn't have put the Golden Gate bridge so close to San Francisco," which cites developer difficulties in making Web sites IE-compatible.

The Explorer Destroyer group did not immediately respond to an e-mail requesting an interview Tuesday.

A Mozilla spokesperson declined to comment on the group's efforts, and Microsoft did not immediately respond to requests for comment.

208 replies

by jaqui

the download should be to lynx not firefox, then they could kill this multimedia shite on websites as well.

and yup, I actually sent them an email stating that until the link is available for lynx, the campaign is a waste of time, since no real website requires anything but basic text capability in a browser.

by deepsand

In fact, let's go even further, and return to the days of BBS's, and FIDO!

Long live DOS.

by deadly ernest

How do they transmit the smells with those "stinkin' peectures"? And how do you replicate them locally from your computer?

Must be a real hassle with some of those pictures of garbage dumps and political speeches (most of that hot air really stinks).

by deadly ernest

compulsory bundling with new hardware and the like.
It will be interesting to see the MS response to this as it is nowhere near as aggressive and intrusive as the MS methods.

by deepsand

Consider the ramifications.

At the least, a user whould be faced with the need to install and maintain multiple browsers.

Driven to extremes, the net would devolve into a Tower of Babble.

by nicknielsen

I prefer to use Firefox, but am required to use IE to do business with certain companies and Netscape to do business with other companies.

Sounds a lot like Balkanization to me...

by deadly ernest

however, I also believe that when one organisation uses methods to pressure people into using their non-standard stuff they cannot complain about someone else using similar processes to counter them.

As to the net being a tower of babble - IT ALREADY IS. How many web pages, and web site, require you to download corporate copyrighted plug ins to be able to view it all? How many use Java, PDF, Flash, Media Player files tec that use non-standard protocols and code to work the site. And if you don't have them loaded, well you can't see them.

What really gets up my nose is when some hairbrained, idiot with a minus IQ uses some fancy program to build a web site in Java and each page has a scripts that call scripts that call scripts that call scripts and 75% or more are the same bloody scripts on every page. So ehwn you change pages you have to reload 75% or more of what you have just seen. Why don't they learn to write code and use frames, or similar, so that crap stays there and only the new stuff is loaded.

Why do they need 345 KB of scripts to load a page that takes 50 KB when converted to HTML?

Yeah it already is a tower of babble.

by pennatomcat

don't get me started on the multiple CSS hacks that it takes to display IE6 properly. I suspect that IE7 will initiate a whole new set of problems.

by deepsand

site developers who fail to adhere to standards.

Far too many have become enthralled with cute little tricks that work on one browser only, with the result that their sites fail to function properly under all browsers.

It's the not unusual case of people forgetting that form is supposed to [i]follow[/i] function, not the other way around.

In addition, many businesses settle on a standard browser for their operations, [b]not[/b] for the purposes of denying content based on one's browser of choice, but so as to minimize support costs..

by absolutely

What is more likely to remind web page kiddies that form [i]follows[/i] function than users who have a bit more knowledge of browsers, html, scripts, etc.? My impression is that the average MS customer doesn't notice or have the technical knowledge to understand your comment that form is not following function, thus don't care about that or most of the techs' arguments about the best browser. Why should they? I hope $1/Firefox download reduces FUD a tad.

by deepsand

I [b]do[/b] have a problem with those sites offering the downloads that refuse to provide content if I'm not using FF at the moment!

And, it is not the users' responsibilty to insure that form follows function, it is that of the developers.

by absolutely

I don't see it. Many sites & programs already require Microsoft's ActiveX controls, including my security software suite by Symantec. Evidently, any business (and by assumption individual or any other collective) is permitted to present their data in whatever format they like. What's the diff?

by deepsand

It is one thing to not use/not use a particular BHO. It is quite another to carte blanche deny content on the basis of the browser that one is momentarily using.

As an analogy, the gas station attendant will not pump gasoline into your diesel driven vehicle, for reasons of compatibility; however, he will not refuse to fuel you vehicle because of the make, model, color, etc..

And, the Mozilla download sites are hoist on their own petard, for requiring Active X in order to be able to download FF!

See

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=193963&messageID=2002543

by apotheon

By requiring functionality (such as ActiveX) that only works with one browser (such as IE), you are effectively blocking people out based on what browser they use. So, again -- what's the difference?

by absolutely

:D

I think the gas station attendant will pump any type of fuel you request into your vehicle, and merrily charge you the market rate, then laugh at you when your engine melts if you use the wrong stuff. It's your responsibility to RTFM and get the right fuel for your engine.

I understand irritation at Mozilla, especially when you're unable to download their browser using the competitor's browser, unless you enable the competitor's notoriously insecure ActiveX controls! But, in answer to the question have they gone [b]too far[/b], I say no, they are using convenience and money to motivate use of a tool that is [b]not[/b] made by Microsoft, for a curious role-reversal. It's not as if they're requiring PC manufacturers to use their browser, and only their browser, or else be denied use of the single most popular operating system in existence. THAT was going too far.

by kniht

I'm impressed with the credentials of the respondents to this article. I am no IT Pro. or the like, but I do like to learn from those more knowledgable than I. My only credentials come from the fact that I am still picking shrapnel out of my body from the Nam war.
According to Secunia FF has it's share of vulnerabilities (not to mention it's a resource hog). What gives this group, or M$ for that matter, the right to force it's ideals on me!
Although, seeing as to where this group is headquartered, it is no surprise.
Definition of a liberal: Someone who knows what's best for you, even better than you do.
I guess I'll get some reaction to this.

by absolutely

Sure, welcome to the fray. Instead of shrapnel, you'll be peppered with BS. Probably less painful, but possibly more difficult to identify & remove! ;)

When you ask what gives this group the right to force its ideals on you, I assume you mean to refer to the organization promoting Firefox, as well as your clear reference to Microsoft. I respond, what gives you the idea that they are attempting to force anything on you? They have posted [b]their[/b] data on the Internet at [b]their[/b] expense. If they want that data only accessible via one browser, isn't it [b]their[/b] right to choose how to do business, and even to have silly (to some people) requirements that will reduce their business volume?

Did you fight defending freedom or communism in Nam?

by deepsand

that is not really the issue at hand.

Sites that are ill designed are quite a different problem from those that [b]refuse to serve content[/b] simply because they do not endorse the browser that you are momentarily using.

And, yes, I fault MS as well, for making Updates inaccessible if one's not using IE. And, Mozilla's download sites are equally guilty.

I've a client with 2 XP machines that got clobbered by NAV, such that scripting, including Active X, and cryptographic services worked inder some apps but failed for others. The owner was not willing to pay to have the drives re-imaged, so I decided to install FF so that the users could at least complete most of their usual tasks with minimal disruption.

All attempts to download FF failed because Active X was blocked!!!

I was able to finally install FF only by remoting into another client's machine, downloading FF to his box, and transferring the download via the remote connection.

Why do I need Active X in order to get FF???

by deadly ernest

I have three XP boxes and two Linux boxes. Two of the Windows boxes have SP1 only and one had SP2 on it. Neither the Linux or the Xp SP1 boxes have Active X running and they all downloaded FF no worries from the Mozilla site. The one with SP2 had major issues until I added some MS security upgrades and turned Active X on.

I have no idea why accessing the same site on the same day requires Active X on the box with Win XP Pro SP2 but not the ones with Win XP Pro SP1. However, this result points more to an operating system function than a site function.

by deepsand

For the Mozilla site, the problem that I ran up against seems to be JScript related.

With scripting busted, the

by apotheon

It sounds like Microsoft is intentionally sabotaging the ability of users to access the competition. It's just more of the same ol' anticompetitive business practices, I'd guess.

by jaqui

I just went there with lynx and it allowed me to download all versions no problem.

by deepsand

Different download sites have different requirements.

The download page at http://www.mozilla.com/ contains the following source, whose function is to display the "Download Firefox" panel to the left of the image of a monitor.

On the machines for which scripting was broken by NAV, not only was the

by jaqui

I used both the mozilla.org and getfirefox.com to test it.

and the nosspan link looks fine. :p
[ btw, javascript doesn't run on my browsers, I remove that functionality, so the javascript on the page had no functionality for me either, I just never got the code spit at me. :)

by deadly ernest

and it is easily viewed once you turn the light on - currently 4 am.

Wave length stuff moves quick as it moves the length of the waves.

Speaking of speed.

Four men were sitting around a conference room table being interviewed for a job. The interviewer asked, "What is the fastest thing you know of?"

Pointing to the man on his right.

The first man replied, "A thought ... It pops into your head, there's no forewarning that it's on the way ... It's just there. A Thought is the fastest thing I know of."

"That's very good!" Replied the interviewer. "And now you .... Sir," He asked the second man.

"Hmmm . Let me see, a blink! It comes and goes and you don't know it ever happened. A blink is the fastest thing I know of."

"Excellent!" Said the interviewer. "The blink of an eye . That's a very popular clich? for speed." He then turned to the third man who was contemplating his reply.

"Well, out on my Dad's ranch, you step out of the house and on the wall there is a light switch ... When you flip that switch, way across the pasture the light at the barn comes on in an instant. Turning on a light is the fastest thing I can think of."

The interviewer was very impressed with the third answer and thought he had found his man. "It's hard to beat the speed of light." He said. Turning to the fourth man, a Newfoundlander, he posed the same question.

"After hearing the three previous answers ... It's obvious to me that the fastest thing known is diarrhea," Said the Newfie.

"What!" Said the interviewer ... Stunned by the response.
"Oh ... I can explain," Said the Newfie. "You see, the other day I wasn't feeling so well and ran for the bathroom. But, before I could think, blink, or turn on the light ... I shit my pants. .

He got the job!

by deepsand

have been coming from! They've been driving me and the dog crazy.

I finally decided that some kind of wildlife had taken shelter somewhere within the walls of my house and perished there.

You saved me the grief and aggrevation of having to call in a specialist to locate and remove it.

I owe you big time for the heads up.

by nicknielsen

Sorry, I had no idea you were attempting to do this with no scripting support whatsoever. While I don't use ActiveX, DirectX, Flash, or Shockwave, I do have both Java & javascript active.

by apotheon

Why should it bother you if some people don't want IE traffic? Frankly, it occurs to me that blocking IE traffic might be considered a security configuration, since IE users are far more likely to have infected computers that could be used to further spread malware to web servers and otherwise cause problems for webmasters. This ad campaign is a lot better than its absence, even for IE users, because simply blocking access without a word won't let them in: at least the ad campaign gives them the opportunity to get a browser that's not blocked.

If you insist on using IE, just don't visit those websites. It's their loss, if you would have provided them traffic and business they want.

Finally, of course, there's this: you don't have to block IE users from your site to participate in this ad campaign. There's an option to do nothing but stick a prominent banner on the page that only shows to IE users and doesn't interfere with use of the website at all. What's the big deal?

There's no reason to make a mountain out of a molehill over this.

by absolutely

Developers do what their bosses tell them to do. Software companies take their cues from users' wishes, or from users' indifference and the ability of the marketing profession to manufacture "demand", depending on the nature of the users in general. As a user, I have the option of switching to a better browser, or trying to make one. I'd like to have a good browser made for me, but that doesn't appear to be one of my options.

]:)

by mustangj369

If any IE supporters were to try something like this against Firefox, the cry FOUL would be heard around the world. These same infantile creators of Explorer Destroyer would be hiring lawyers by the carload, doing their best to implicate MS (deeper pockets you know) and suing everyone in sight of Redmond.
It's things like this that shake my faith in the 1st Amendment.

by beilstwh

The correct way to handle this problem is to talk to the company that is using IE centric code. My bank's web site could only be used if you were using IE. I contacted the web site support division and explained that they were blocking 25% of their customers by using microsoft specific web scripting. I explained the dangers of using VBscript. They recently released a new web site that ONLY used web standards and works with everybody. No company wants to lose business and when you explain it to them, most will change.

by deepsand

That experts in web design, particularly with regard to usability, have been counseling against the use of browser-centric features, along with the overuse of bells & whistles such as Flash for several years now, with little change visible, leads me to suspect that the only ones paying attention are those outside of IT, and frequently outside the company, who are tasked with the job of improving a sites ROI.

Given the number of new sites that blatently place form [b]before[/b] function witnessed by me, it seems clear that site developers still hav'nt gotten the message.

A large part of the problem is that a large portion of developers are wet behind the ears, and either lack experienced guidance or choose to ignore it.

by deepsand

You are, of course, quite right. It seems that it is one thing for the challenger to play fast and loose with the accepted rules of engagement, but quite another should the champion respond in kind.

There is a word for this - "hypocrisy."

My congratulations for pointing out the obvious to the others; I had begun to wonder if anyone was going to mention it.

by jmgarvin

No matter who does them, I hate them. It is not only immature, but pointless and a good way to drive away those that actually WANT to support your product.

by eastexpert

The more people go on 100% stupid "Kill IE" campaign, trying to TELL ME what to do, the more I'm firm in my determination to not touch FF with a bargepole and making everything I can to make it die instead. BY other means.

by deadly ernest

things much worse than this as part of their routine predatory marketting practices. At least this bunch of twits are giving you an option - more than MS often does.

by kniht

This is true, I guess if they want to reduce their own buisness volume they have a right to cut their own throats.
As far as what I fought for in Nam, neither freedom nor communism, I fought to keep myself and the men that were with me alive. Looks like the next fight for freedom may occur within our own borders if we don't stop the lawyers we elect to Capitol Hill from violating our Constitution.

by deepsand

I've no problem with options 1 & 2; and, I've said nothing to suggest that I did.

As for IE users vs FF users, I take issue with the suggestion that FF users are [i]inherently[/i] more security conscious. Bear in mind that many, if not the larger portion, have downloaded it simply because it's free, it's new, and/or they dislike MS.

Furthermore, it's easy to chant the anti-MS mantra, but, in practice, most people who require the net for executing their job related responsibilities do [b]not[/b] have a choice as to which browser they use.

by deepsand

"[i]Software companies take their cues from users' wishes[/i]???"

We're talking about web [b]site design[/b], not applications. Since when did site designers start seeking user input before they loaded their sites up with every bell & whistle imaginable?

The sad fact is that far too many developers never learned anything about usability. Why? Because most of them of are wet behind the ears, and either lack experienced guidance, or choose to ignore it.

by deepsand

Your suggestion of a deliberate attempt by MS to block FF downloads pales in the light of the facts.

by apotheon

If your website requires ActiveX, then [b]nobody using a non-MS browser can access your website[/b]. Your statement is categorically false.

by deepsand

Firstly, just to get it out of the way, if the gas station pumped gasoline into your diesel car, he would be both in violation of safety regulations and legally negligent.

As for Mozilla, I have made no suggestion that they are in any way responsible for the campaign under discussion.

My posts re. problems with FF downloads were made to point out that those who seek to sever themselves from MS are, when they require MS features in order to procure their alternative offerings, guilty, no matter their intent, of practicing hypocrisy.

by apotheon

Most of the people I know using Firefox got it without allowing ActiveX to run just any old crap on the Web. I've seen people download it with a number of browsers that don't even support ActiveX, even on OSes that don't have ActiveX.

If Microsoft is now preventing some IE downloads without use of ActiveX, while less up-to-date versions of IE and Windows continue to be able to download without problems, I'd hardly blame that on the Mozilla Foundation.

by deepsand

Would a store have the right to refuse your business based on the web browser you use?

What if your referred browser were not the one that you use?

What is you use multiple browsers, one of which is the store's preference?

by absolutely

"This establishment will not discriminate on the basis of race, gender, nationality, religion, military service, mental or physical attribute of any kind, etc., etc., etc."

That's a good question, to which I have a good answer, but I won't waste it on society, which has proven itself unwilling to practice it.

by apotheon

Perhaps you're not familiar with the US Constitution. Find an online version and check the first, ninth, and tenth amendments: they collectively provide the basis for the Constitutionally protected freedom of association. If someone doesn't want your money, there's no justification for forcing them to take it.

by deepsand

And, I am more than amply familiar with the U.S. Constitution.

Did I make any reference to it so as to suggest that issues of constitutionality were here involved? I think not.

by deadly ernest

they sure have the right to be stupid in how the turn away sales by not allowing them to find out about the business.

by apotheon

The terms "liberal" and "conservative" have been so polluted in modern politics that they're almost meaningless. I'd rather just use that definition for just about everyone in either party, and a fair number of the other parties out there, too.

by apotheon

1. I never said that Firefox users were inherently more security conscious. It's true that, in general, Firefox users tend to be more security conscious, but it is in no way axiomatic, and I never suggested it was. My point is that IE users' computers are more likely to be infected -- and that's just a statistical fact.

2. I suspect your statement that "most" people who interact with the Web for business purposes require IE. It's true that "some" do, but "most", if it was ever the case, has ceased to be an accurate statement. The fact that most [b]do[/b] use IE does not translate to most [b]needing to[/b] use IE.

by apotheon

1. It's more deniable in a court of law if you can blame it on a technical limitation or error.

2. I find it ludicrous that, given Microsoft's long and well-documented history of anticompetitive practices, you refuse to entertain the notion this might just be more of the same.

by absolutely

DS, you left out "...or from users' indifference and the ability of the marketing profession to manufacture "demand"," which leaves the remainder of that sentence, the fragment that you quoted, a defenseless straw man. Come on, man, I've seen you do much better! I'm sure you were in a hurry so I won't belabor the point. When I want to start a flame war, I'll start it with somebody who more consistently annoys me.

by absolutely

Would that be [b]better[/b] than a deliberate attempt to block FF, or would it just mean that Microsoft's talent has all retired with $Millions in stock and they're coding strategy is the "Shakespeare monkey"?

by absolutely

Liberal: in favor of freedom

Conservative: in favor of stability, tradition & constancy.

In 1776 a liberal government declared war on Britain, and the main point of contention in the early government was whether the United States should be more like a Greek democracy or a Roman republic. Neither side wanted to use the government to feed all the poor or use taxes to fund churches or legislate religious dogma. I think every last one of the great men who signed the Declaration of Independence would be heartbroken to see what has become of their grand experiment.

by deadly ernest

choice at work and I know of one company that has two staff dedicated to going around their 700 employees and fixing the viruses and other damage done from using MSIE as their corporate web browser and it auto runs so much damaging crap. The USA HQ refuses to let them run anything else as they have some sort of special arrangement with MS. One small section of 50 people was sold off about 12 months ago and they immediately switched to OpenOffice, Firefox and Thunderbird on their Wndows XP - service calls dropped to 5% of the previous 12 months.

Life's little TR mystery - Why does the Maximum message depth have to kick in just when a sub thread discussion gets interesting?

by smorty71

The whole Explorer Destroyer site is a joke (and by "joke," I mean a real joke).

If you didn't pick up the subtle clues at the top of their home page, the last paragraph in the right column is a dead giveaway:

"Set script to Dead Serious mode if you a) feel particularly responsible for your readers' well being b) demand vengeance for all those times a site said "you need Netscape 4.7 to view this page" or c) don't give a fuck."

And then there is this line right before the hilarious "wealth" graph on the home page:

"This graph illustrates the dramatic transfer of wealth from Google to you as you participate in their affiliate program (yes, this is a joke)."

by jaqui

A few news site links where Google's payment is discussed.

http://www.betadot.com/news/2006/211/google-firefox.html

http://www.toptechnews.com/story.xhtml?story_id=122000034FQU

and:
Global:
Google Offering $1 For Firefox Referral
Search giant Google is offering a standard $1 per user referral fee to Web sites that generate new downloads of Firefox with the Google Toolbar. Taking advantage of Google's new AdSense program, a group of self-titled "political activists" in Massachusetts has started an aggressive campaign called "Explorer Destroyer," to get browser users to switch from Microsoft's Internet Explorer to Mozilla's Firefox.

from:
http://www.interbiznet.com/bugler/bugler_06.05.02.html

so while the graph is a joke, a poor one since it's also the truth of the situation, the get paid a buck for every person to download firefox from your website is not a joke.

by deepsand

I did not say that anyone needed a specific browser. Rather, I said that at work, most have no choice in the matter.

See Deadly Ernest's post directly above this one.

by deepsand

No, I deliberately omitted the portion that you reference, as I consider it irrelevant to my point regarding web sites & their developers.

I do not consider web sites to be software applications, but publications. That they may be interactive, and may incorporate the use of true applications, does not alter the fact that they are firs and foremost publications.

As with all publications, it is the sole responsibility of the author to ensure that his work is readable, clear, understandable and unambiguous.

by deepsand

I think that TR has an algorithm for determining the "interest level" in a given thread, based in part on the number of different members posting to it, and [b]reduces[/b] the allowable depth so as to maximize our level of aggrevation.

by deepsand

I simply refuse to resort to the old and tiresome conspiracy theories as the explanations for all things.

by apotheon

I don't let people who are obsessed and unreasonable convince me to follow their path, but I don't let them drive me away from it, either. Try taking a reasonable, rather than reactionary, approach: try Firefox out for yourself, determine its benefits and detriments, do some reasearch, and make an informed decision.

by deepsand

All of us are, to some extent, judged by those with whom we are associated. While such may be neither reasonable nor equitable does not prevent it from occuring; it seems to be a nature trait.

by apotheon

"[i]most people who require the net for executing their job related responsibilities do not have a choice as to which browser they use.[/i]"

That's what you said. The implication, from that context, is that people require use of a given browser based on their job related responsibilities. You mentioned executing job related responsibilities, requiring such functionality, and not having a choice in browser. You did not mention anything about managerial policy, et cetera.

You commented in response to Absolutely about the author of an online publication having the responsibility of clearly communicating his ideas. You might take your own advice.

by apotheon

. . . and it's not a conspiracy, since it's just Microsoft.

Perhaps you haven't been paying attention, but Microsoft has been convicted many times in a number of different countries for anticompetitive and otherwise criminal and civil malfeasance. It's a trend, not a theory.

by nicknielsen

Mother Nature still recognizes the right to be as stupid as you want to be. If you're stupid enough, you earn a Darwin Award.

by deepsand

Your reply leaves me baffled.

By "users" I plainly mean "end users," i.e. those that actually use a browser, [b]not[/b] the organization which decides which browser thay will use.

I stand full square behind my position that most users have no choice in the browser that they use at work.

by deepsand

With regards to the problems downloading FF, where's your proof that such are the results of deliberate actions on the part of MS.

Absent such, your charge remains but mere speculation.

by nicknielsen

They just haven't learned that just because you can use something doesn't mean you should.

Besides, bells & whistles are all the rage. How else do you explain a cell phone/walkie-talkie/camera/web browser/email client/iPod-wannabe almost as thin as a credit card?

And EVERYBODY has broadband, so there's no problem, right?

by nicknielsen

What kind of movement?

Actually, I have long been in favor of taking people like this up in an airplane, then telling them they can step out the door without a parachute. It's one way to drive the lesson home.

by nicknielsen

Most employers specifically forbid the end user from downloading & installing software. Since IE is embedded in the OS, it is the mandatory browser for corporate America by default.

by deepsand

This apotheon knows, but seems to be reluctant to acknowledge. He clings to the ideal that the end users can & should rise up to overthrow the evil empire.

That's an easy position to take when you're the master; not so easy when you are the hireling.

by deepsand

Might that earn us a Darwin Award?

As I understand it, no, because 1) such would [b]not[/b] have been an act of stupidity; and 2) the act would not have been committed by the party who was removed from the gene pool.

by nicknielsen

...such as removing all those common-sense warnings from the front pages of product manuals. You know the ones:

Chainsaw: Do not attempt to stop blade with fingers.

Electric curling iron: Do not use in shower.

by apotheon

I never denied that corporate policy typically allows end users to download and install software willy-nilly.

I never denied that the majority of corporate desktops are pretty much stuck with IE from the end user's perspective.

I never said that anyone should "rise up" in revolt to overthrow any "evil empire".

Either substantively respond to the points that I have made or shut the hell up. Straw men and fallacies of argumentum ad ridiculum prove nothing.

by apotheon

I never claimed it was anything [b]but[/b] speculation. I simply take issue with your absolute refusal to entertain the notion that perhaps, just perhaps, this is more of the same from Microsoft.

by apotheon

1. I said "If your website [b]requires[/b] ActiveX" (emphasis added). Maybe you missed that part. I don't see how you could, though.

2. That's a scary thought. Thanks for letting me know such asinine nonsense exists. I really don't think using a third-party hack to be able to access an ActiveX-based website really justifies the web developer's intent of targeting IE, though -- just as the ability of an IE user to turn off Javascript to circumvent the functionality of the "Explorer Destroyer" code doesn't change the web developer's intent of targeting non-IE browsers.

by apotheon

The obstinate refusal to recognize my actual points in this entire discussion, consistently and (apparently) deliberately trying to use strawmen to distract from the actual discussion, that you've displayed is really getting old.

edit: typo fix

by deadly ernest

every time someone finds a new way to be exceedingly stupid the legislators enact a new law making it necessary for people to do things so that the stupid can not get hurt by this kind of stupidity again.

For example idiots get hurt in cars because they have accidents when drunk, or speeding, or tired, or busy rading the paper instead of watching the road - do the legislators punish them for their stupidity, no - they enact laws making everyone go slower so that they wont get as badly hurt in the accidents as the cars are no going slower. The sensible solution would have been to enforce existing laws better and make licence testing harder and institute retesting more. But no that requires thought instead of a kneejerk reaction - anyway slow speeds means more likelihood of more speeders as the idiots who sped by at the higher sped will continue to speed, so they get more revenue to spend on legislator rorts.