Discussion Locked

Has this group of FireFox supporters gone too far?

0 helpful
208 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

208 replies

by apotheon

You're psychic now? You can tell me what people are thinking when they stick a banner on a page? You know for a fact that everybody with a Firefox button and a splash page or banner is trying to "coerce" someone into using a specific browser? You know for a fact they're not trying to "coerce" them into [b]going somewhere else[/b] if they're using IE and unwilling to get a different browser, or trying to "coerce" them into having a better browsing experience if IE doesn't work as well with their sites?

You're wrong. I know you're wrong, because I have a couple of Firefox buttons on one of my websites, and in relation to one there's text suggesting that you'd have a better browsing experience if you chose another browser than IE -- and only IE users see it. I actually got the idea from the "Explorer Destroyer" guys. I'm [b]NOT[/b] trying to "coerce" anyone to do anything. You're full of crap. Accept it and move on.

"[i]You're simply ignoring the fact that "freedom of association" is not sufficient to justify and [sic] and all acts.[/i]"

No, I'm not. In fact, I directly addressed that, and pointed out that [b]I never did anything like using it to justify any and all acts[/b], but you persist in trying to pretend that drawing parallels between an appropriate reference to freedom of association and racism is somehow logically supportable. Get off it.

Damn. I was going to stop talking to you about this. Now look what you've provoked.

by deepsand

My statements here re. intent relate [i]only[/i] to those who participate in the IE Destroyer campaign [b]and[/b] elect to use the "dead serious" option.

by apotheon

I mentioned the idea of convincing a lawyer to point out that you'd have a tough time convincing someone that actually knows what "fraud" means, criminal or otherwise.

It's not fraud if it's not deceptive. Get that? Clear yet?

The problem, though, seems to be that you think YOUR LACK OF ACCURATE EXPECTATION constitutes SOMEONE ELSE'S FRAUDULENT INTENT.

Besides, if it was fraud, it WOULD be criminal in nature, since it's worth a dollar per click. Supposedly.

by deepsand

My statements here re. intent relate [i]only[/i] to those who participate in the IE Destroyer campaign [b]and[/b] elect to use the "dead serious" option.

by deepsand

FYI, I have formally studied contract law, which includes the subject of fraud.

The definitions & explanations provided are not my personal views, but those generally accepted.

It is important to make the distinction between general & criminal frauds. While the [b]latter[/b] requires intent to cause [b]loss to another[/b], the [b]former[/b] involves the lesser motive of [b]personal gain[/b].

Furthermore, "deception," as used by you, is not an accurate way of describing a key element of fraud; the proper term is "material misrespresentation," as I've previously noted and described.

by apotheon

1. "Material misrepresentation" is even narrower than "deception".

2. Intent is still necessary to the definition.

3. I thought the whole problem for you was that you're being "coerced" in some way. That's a loss. Get with the program.

4. Whether you've taken classes in contract law or not, you're still full of it.

by deepsand

and given that I've previously adequately addressed all of the points that you here again raise, I'll not revisit them without substantive rebuttal.

This discussion is closed to new replies.