Has this group of FireFox supporters gone too far?
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by mjwx
by apotheon
by smorty71
Wow, as a joke, I thought it was sort of funny. As a real "campaign," it is just plain dumb.
When are activists/extremists like this going to learn that their actions usually do more to push their "cause" further to the fringe rather than get it into the mainstream.
by jaqui
I personally just code my sites to the current standards. if a browser doesn't handle it, that is the browser supplier's problem.
Generally, it's IE that fails, but there are others that fail as badly as ie with current W3C site standards.
the other browsers make one change that ie < 7 should do, when they can't use the code, they get rid of parsing it.
lynx can't use the css, same as Dillo, yet both give a usable site, whereas ie the code needs to be tweaked for it to work, because ie refuses to just ignore code it can't render correctly.
editing to add:
There is a single line tweak that does get ie to work very well with css:
[pre]
[/pre]
that one line does the trick. by adding it to my own site it fixed all the rendering bugs that ie was hit with.
by mustangj369
that have chosen, for whatever reason, to hate Microsoft specifically, and big business in general. They are Linux users usually, but Apple people are represented too and that's really funny because Apple is one of the most closed and proprietary companies on Earth, more monopolistic by true definition than even MS. They are few in number but they are loud and persistent, pervading forums all over the 'net that have little or nothing to do with Linux or Macs, spewing their obvious hatred of everything MS in order to turn more people away from the "evil empire". It doesn't work, of course, as market share for alternate OS's doesn't seem to be going anywhere, but zealots have a deaf ear for anything that doesn't support their cause.
Google will find themselves in this company soon if they continue as they are, buying everything in sight and looking to challenge MS. It may take longer as they are hardly necessary and easily avoidable, but their PR people are working overtime to plant stories about Google everywhere except restrooms these days, and it'll get to the point where many will gag at yet another mention of the word. I think I may already be there.
BTW, saw a story somewhere that said those looking to cash in on these referrals of FF with the Google toolbar will have to get to at least 100 downloads before Google will cut a check. They do aim high. Most who fall for this will never see a dime.
by ali40961
Then I must be too because I took IE COMPLETELY off every user's pc i support and gave them a choice!
The funny thing is I am a relatively conservative person, and still use MS prods.
On what authority did u get ur info? Do you know them all personally?
by ali40961
I was gonna reply to the original and say "How is that any different from what MS has done?" And I won't get started on the degree MS has gone to to force things down our (my) throat. Ok so I lied.
Let's see....I'm not safe unless i keep my system patched......Ok so autoupdate keeps me updated. Then I find out MS Office won't work correctly once patch was applied. And I don't mean just a lil glitch. I mean tasks that took a sec now take 5 mins or more and lucky for me I found a workaround. (And it WASN'T FROM THE KB)
Running a small business, using office products, requires that said product works 100%, 100% of the time. Lost productivity the coupla weeks while we waited for a fix? Sounds kinda like prison to me... And yes Virginia, i could migrate to Linux. With what time? And at what learning curve? No time as it is to do what I need to with products I know well. One day, i will! MS will piss me off bad enough I'll say to hell with it and FORCE MYSELF.
PS i already gave up IE. And Yes i use Firefox and mozilla. And sometimes even netscape and opera)
by ali40961
by deepsand
That's a game you'll need to play by yourself.
Kadeetya vadoo, pyetik.
by deepsand
by deepsand
To quote you, "[i]It sounds like Microsoft is intentionally sabotaging the ability of users to access the competition.[i/]"
Or, did you think you could simply disclaim this post and we'd be none the wiser?
It's time to grow up & face the real world.
by deepsand
You're obviously looking in the mirror yet again.
When will you learn?
by deepsand
How does this act comport with Google's mantra?
It seems, to me, not well at all.
by absolutely
by deepsand
If Google is giving affiliates who carry this AdSense ad a buck for each download, how much is Google receiving from the sponsor of the ad?
Or, is Google in fact underwiting the campaign by giving the sponsor a free ride?
by apotheon
The referral payments are only for Firefox downloads that include a Google toolbar. It's all basically just advertising for Google. Firefox is getting a "free ride" in that the Google toolbar that is being advertised is advertised by way of the Firefox browser.
Google didn't create this campaign. The Firefox (with Google toolbar) referral program existed before this Explorer Destroyer thing, and from what I can see, Google hasn't reacted to it in any way at all.
by apotheon
Does that look like an absolute claim of fact to you? Perhaps you didn't notice the equivocating terms. Perhaps you're too dumb to realize [b]that was speculation[/b], and I never intended it to be read as anything but.
What exactly are you trying to prove with that quote?
by apotheon
by apotheon
Google isn't doing this. Google has a referral program. Someone unconnected decided to leverage it for what amounts to net politics.
I'm still not seeing it as "evil", anyway. Some of the more extreme applications of this are a bit inadvisable, generally, but that doesn't make any of it "evil".
by mjwx
Why are you closing your account with us? any more.
I closed my account because of outrageous fees, I didn?t use net banking back then. My credit union just implemented a few new security features including "virtual keyboard" which you have to use with the mouse (moves every time you click on it as well) to defeat key loggers. It does take 6 times as long to put in your password but hey, it?s my money in there and I like the extra security. Works fine in firefox from Winblows, Linux and even a Mac (shudder). Havent tested it in IE, seems I dont use it any more :)
by itjunkie
by apotheon
by apotheon
Now, for an explanation of my previous post:
A post that involves nothing but an inflammatory comment without any supporting discussion or explanation is, by definition, trolling. I recommend not feeding this troll. Thanks for your time and forebearance, folks.
by deepsand
by kniht
Inflammatory comments without supporting discussion to me, at least, makes no sense.
At the top end, FF is a decent browser. I have used FF on occasion, but have quit using it. If this group wants everybody to use FF then FF developers need to find a way for it to use less system resources.
I have 768MB RAM and when I see FF using over 500MB, it's time to put it away
by rgeiken9
by kniht
When I leave ff on for extended periods of time, say overnight, go to my PC the next morning and my memory monitor tells me I am down to 32MB free memory (my PC normally uses around 260MB for all processes, etc. out of 768), I turn off ff and my free memory jumps to 524MB, I figure ff was using around 500MB memory.
Discussions on this topic can be found here:
http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/ben/archives/009749.html
pages open to use that much. I currently have 4 TR pages open as tabs and FF is using 36.9 MB. When I was looking at switching to it I open 5 pages in FF and the same 5 pages in IE.
IE used 20 MB for each instance and opened a new instance of IE for each page; FF opened I instance with 5 tabs for 28 MB. Total for IE was 100 MB - so I switched.
I have notices that FF uses more RAM and VM as required by each page - but that would happen with any browser as you open pages.
by kniht
Could be I did have a lot of Hellashish pages open. Possibly with a lot of flash, who knows, too late now to look back.
I'm no IT Pro nor do I consider myself an "expert" in the workings of a computer. I am a commoner and all I know is I've never had as high a memory usage with Maxthon, Opera, K-Meleon, Avant, or even IE as I have with FF.
Maybe my PC is allergic to FF (I use very few extensions). Like I stated previously, FF all in all is a good browser, but in it's present state it doesn't seem to agree with my lowly HP equipment.
Again I reiterate:
http://weblogs.mozillazine.org/ben/archives/009749.html
by absolutely
The MSN Search Toolbar allows tabbed browsing in IE. I use it at work, and Firefox at home in Linux. My own desktop is -- DUH -- faster than my company laptop. I haven't noticed practical performance differences that manifested in page load times or times to load other applications with either, so the free OS and more secure, utilitarian browser wins.
by deepsand
I presently have 4 FF windows open, totaling 10 tabs, and FF's total memory consumption is 184 Meg.
Opening another tab for this discussion alone uses 28 Meg.
by rgeiken9
I have been using Firefox for over a year now, and wouldn't consider going back to Internet Explorer except for when it is actually necessary to view a particular site. I would imagine all of the power users of browsers are using Firefox since it is so far superior to IE. The main users of IE are people who can barely use their computer. I have an older neighbor woman who is using the copy of Firefox that I installed on her computer, and she likes it just fine.
For an awful lot of people it is too much trouble to install a new Browser, and the are content to use IE even though a lot of us consider that to be an inferior product.
by vlape
by deepsand
And, consistent with like claims that you've made in other discussions.
They're your words; now you must live with them.
by deepsand
by apotheon
Do you refer to the one that you quoted at me? Perhaps you didn't notice that it starts out "It sounds like".
Do you even know what "equivocal" means?
by apotheon
by deepsand
Both Google and Yahoo/Overture show signs of inconsistency with regards to approving/rejecting PPC listings and ads.
Much obviously depends on the particular "editor" responsible for a given submission.
When rejected, just keep re-submitting until you get the result desired.
by apotheon
Do you mean when someone first signs up, or when someone puts ads on a page? When someone first signs up, Google treats it as an application for membership or something to that effect. This is before there's any advertising added to the site. As a result, there's no way for anyone at Google, at that time, to deny an Adsense account based on use of the Explorer Destroyer banner or splash screen, since it doesn't exist on the site yet. Once you have your account, you add the code to the site for whatever ads you want to use, and if someone at Google happens to notice something that violates Google's terms, it's gone.
None of that indicates any reasonable likelihood of an Explorer Destroyer ad getting disapproved by Google personnel, and in no way makes Google complicit in what you characterize as "evil", as far as I can tell.
by deepsand
cache pages the only difference being the number they cache and that is adjustable in FF the only adjustment I ever found in IE for that was to turn it on or off. I have noticed that whilst I am on the Internet with Windows open there are a couple of system services that keep growing and only shrink when I reboot. They grow whilst on-line but do not shrink when the connection is broken. They are listed in Windows Task Manager as simpy svhost.exe. They clear on a reboot.
A side point of this discussion you might find interesting is that I have a few machines on a LAN. My main machine is a 64 bit system and currently running Win XP 64 bit - I opened FF, IE and Avant and had each load the same set of pages. Then I went to another machine with Fedora Core 4 and opened the same pages again in FF. RAM usage was
FD4 + FF 25MB
XP + FF 34MB
XP + Avant 42MB
XP + IE 105MB
And the svhost file blew out as each extra browser was opened and really jumped as each extra IE instance was opened. I have no clue as to why it happens as I don't know enough about this end of things - but interesting results. I wonder if they ware the same order of results for others.
same functionality - I did that to IE with Avant and found it much better than plain IE. But FF does it as part of the basic set up. All that is really important is that you are happy with what you are using and they way you use it.
I do not use anyone's add in toolbars as I find most of them add a lot of extra 'features' that I do not want. I have a client who constantly adds in the Yahoo toolbar and her husband adds in the MSN toolbar - the browser looks crowded and every so often something happens between the two to crash the system. Remove the browser and reload without the toolbars and the problem goes away - until about 6 weeks after they have reloaded the suckers.
by deepsand
You have forfeited this debate, owing to your continued manipulation of any and all statements, both mine and your's, so as to suit your pleasure of the moment.
Game over.
by deepsand
figuring out the the correct settings re. parity, no. of stop bits, etal., and succeeding in making contact with another machine, all at the whooping speed of 300 baud!
Bring back FIDO!
by nicknielsen
FIDO has unfortunately been put down.
But 7,1,even is engraved on my brain...
by deepsand
by apotheon
by deepsand
by absolutely
1. Have you compared IE with tabbed browsing capability added to opening the same number of different pages in separate browser windows?
2. Have you tried Ctrl+Alt+Del to shut down the service, then re-Start it?
PS I don't care enough to try these tests myself, and won't think less of you if you don't, either.
by absolutely
1. The last version if MSIE that I used is IE 6.0.3 something and it does not have tabs. IE 7 may have tabs I don't know and don't care I have given up on IE. Anyway IE 7 is Beta only and will probably end up different in the final version. Also I am testing various Linux flavours for what suits me best and will shortly be leaving Windows completely as I am fed up with security upgrades that crash applications.
2. Oh yes I have tried closing the service concerned and when I do it closes off my network access and a reboot is needed to restart it and get access again. One of the reasons why I know it is related to the network and Internet access.
3. I am happy for you that you are happy with IE, however I am not. Reasons for not hiring the FF designers could be that MS think anyone who works for Mozilla may not be compatible with the MS ethos, or the designers may have refused to work for MS when asked. Maybe MS just wanted to leave it with their in house people - who knows, who cares. It is interesting to not that several IE overlays, like Avant, got a lot of mileage out of selling the 'We have tabbed functions' bit for many years before MS even took notice of it as a function that people liked. This points to major problems in the MS hierachy as far as client usage and concern is.
by rgeiken9
After my third attempt to install IE7, and you guessed it another failure, it doesn't seem so. I don't hate Microsoft, but IE7 beta seems to be a real piece of work. They have several other software programs that you have to install to help with the IE7 beta, but so far no soap. They want users to make adjustments to the registry!!!! With Mozilla Firefox and Thunderbird, I have never had to do anything like that. Also Firefox 1.5.0.3 automatically installed itself when it was released.
I'm not sure what Microsoft is trying to do, but they are sure making it hard to use IE7. I have never had any other piece of software that was so impossible to install. Right now since I have installed several other Microsoft programs that are supposed to help with IE7 beta installation, the install should be possible, but with all the aggravation that I have had trying to install it, I'm not sure that it is worth the problems since I enjoy using Firefox so much.
by apotheon
IE7 is a beta, of course. That means that one is supposed to expect some issues with it. Betas are for early adopters, not people who want ease of use and installation, with no problems. That, of course, is the reasonable answer to your problems with it. I'm sure that stuff will be pretty much cleared up for the actual release version.
Of course, that's a problem in itself. The general public has already waited such a long time for IE to incorporate advanced browser features that they've finally given up and started migrating to other browsers such as Firefox. These other browsers have integrated advanced browser features for years now. Consumers have finally started noticing. What's Microsoft's response?
Wait. Wait for IE7. Wait for it to become production-ready. Wait wait wait. You've already waited: you'll wait some more, just because they're Microsoft.
Of course, if you wait for IE7, you'll eventually get your advanced features, and it will probably be on par, technology-wise, with its main competitor. Then, it will start to fall behind again.
There are some definite benefits to the open source development credo of "release early, release often". You get a faster effective development cycle, where things get done more quickly and with greater attention to detail. One such benefit is, of course, that it doesn't shoot itself in the foot the way corporate closed source development has with IE.
by rgeiken9
I was a beta tester on Windows 95, and there were a ton of problems, but eventually it did work OK, and I was able to take a trip to Seattle for the roll out in 1995. At that time the jump was from Windows 3.1 to Windows 95 which turned out to be a quantum jump. I have also beta tested other products, but nothing has ever presented the problems of IE7. When the program refuses to install, they mention that some registry settings were unable to be changed that were required to install IE7. I have been using the Administrator Account, so the software should have been able to be installed. My computer is upgraded to the latest Windows XP upgrades, and has had any spyware removed, and also checks clean for viruses. I am using Zone Alarm Free and also AVG free edition. I have never found any problems in any computer that I have ever had, and have had one since 1985.
The information presented by Microsoft that says why the software won't install is very cryptic. Most Betas might present problems in operation, but hopefully they will install properly. I have IE6 installed now, and it works fine, and have also used Netscape and Maxthon successfully. I have had problems installing Netscape 8.0, so just gave up on that. With the Firefox operation so clean, it doesn't make sense to screw around with IE7.
I wasn't actually planning on using IE7 as my default browser anyhow, I just wanted to see what Microsoft had come up with. I guess I will just wait until I buy a new computer with Vista which will likely have IE7 preinstalled.
by deepsand
When I was working on big iron, at an IBM beta user site, it was my experience that their betas were damned close to being ready for prime time.
Today's "betas," not those from MS alone, really don't qualify as such. That some people actually pay for the "privilege" of debugging an alpha release never cease to amaze me.
By the way, on what OS & SP are you try to install IE7?
by rgeiken9
by apotheon
The reason IE never incorporated those extra features is pretty simple:
MS is a huge corporation. The dynamics of corporate economics encourage thinking in terms of market dominance rather than product quality or even actual dollars and sense pofitability. Once IE had killed Netscape and captured more than 97% of the browser market, Microsoft figured its job was done. Thus, it stopped. It rested on its laurels. It ignored the "bit players".
Then . . . Firefox came out of nowhere, captured more than ten percent of the market, and made MS executives take notice of the browser market again. Suddenly, Microsoft said "What's up with all this tabbed browsing stuff?" and so on. Now we've got IE7 on the way.
Ain't competition from the noncorporate little guy grand?
by deepsand
by deepsand
While I do like FF's tabs, because such uses up less real estate on the Task Bar, I do find it a bit "primitive" compared to IE, particularly with respect to it's handling of cookies & pop-ups/unders. Overall, FF lacks a sufficiently fine level of granularity with respect to user control of the granting of permissions relative to that offered by IE.
I would advise against judging IE 7 by the experience that you've had re. installation porblems with the beta version; but, that you reserve judgement until it's past the .0.0 version.
I also find it to be quite a memory hog, though not in manner that is wholly predictable.
As a result, I find myself switching between IE & FF, depending on the site(s) involved.
With regards to computer "literacy," it is my experienced observation that IE in fact requires [b]more[/b] of such than does FF, per the subject of control addressed in my 1st paragraph.
by nicknielsen
Yes, IE does require greater ability to set up properly. The problem is Microsoft has emphasized the "ready-to-go-out-of-the-box" capability of their software for years. The average user sees this and thinks "Good! I don't have to do anything to use this except start it up."
Thus, the less computer literate use IE.
by deepsand
In view of the fact that we have already established that most use what they have at hand, as opposed to that which they have deliberately selected for use, this statement seems unfounded.
Those who use AOL as their portal tend to use Navigator as their browser, rather than IE; those using MSN as their portal, MSN Explorer, which is [b]not[/b] IE.
Furthermore, it appears to be tautological, in that it infers a quality of the users from a quality of the tool used, which itself was inferred from a quality of the users. And, it seems to be based on the assumption that "ease of use" and "computer literacy" have a positive correlation factor.
In fact, "ease of use" and "computer literacy" are in [b]no[/b] way correlated. "Ease of use" is in the eye of the beholder, i.e. subjective, whereas "computer literacy" can be objectively defined and measured.
I, for example, am highly computer literate, but find IE to be more easily used for control of cookies than is FF.
by nicknielsen
I see your point.
Reiterate reasoning, strike conclusion.
by dogx
And I'm a one woman show, disabled and only able to work (security and Net) VERY part time... I'd give a client a $5 spot per workstation for every one they converted to using Mozilla Suite or FF/T-bird... my job would be that much easier. It would bring me a better reputation, and a few more referrals would be a nice thing
I could be that much more certain my Client's were SECURE and that I'd provided them with the best available apps for their needs. I would adamantly DITTO and toss in another Finn if I could get them using Open Office. For the same reasons. Using an Open OS is out of the question. I'd have a stroke out of disbelief.
My small and select clientele is in Criminal Defense and Civil rights law offices -- and the legal imbroglio's surrounding "Meta-data" and the non-securable BLOAT of most Micro-Sausage OS and applications are a nightmare, like Abott and Costello doing Catch 22...
If my clients used Open source, secure applications, they could avoid 90% of these issues... If they used LINUX and a rigorous "Security Hygene" routine, they could avoid ALL of them.
I have nothing against Micro-Sausage. There are brilliant people working there, and surely some decent, kind and ethical folk -- why have ill thoughts toward people I don't even know?
If MicroSoft truly did provide the Overall Best applications for my client's needs, I would be saying drop the Mozilla before you get burned!
For my clients, the MS "suite" is THE PROBLEM. I had to get over some Ethical Hiccups of my own, charging them to patch and band-aid something that was "broken" from jump street.
In economic sectors where ethics and privacy are not a "Gold Standard" (such as Government Offices, Pawn Shops, "As Seen on TV" Outlets, and Used Auto Parts) MS apps are ideal. They BELONG there ;-)
Meanwhile, I'll turn the screws, change the parts and feel like a little dutch boy stopping up holes in a firewall that was built backwards to begin with....
God Bless
Dogx
by deepsand
by crabbyabby86
so... that pcworld link, this one, and this whole conversation... are probably the only debates between IE and FF that I have had the patience to sit through and read... most of. sort of.
i find it amusing that some people want to both defend the 'destroyers' and dissociate themselves from them at the same time.
i also find it amusing that people whine about choice, when they do have a choice: get ff or don't patronize those douchers' sites. it works the other way too: get IE or don't visit the other extremist (or lazy) douchers' sites.
personally, i wish i had thought of it. with my more popular website being visited mostly by people who would be willing to throw the chains of microsoft, i might yet. however, i would probably not take any money and just toss up a page that asks them to try it, and then let them in anyway. i dont TRY to be a doucher. while im at it, maybe ill throw up a form for the FF users asking them why they switched. could be interesting.
now my question is, would you all have a long, boring debate about my idea? would you give me too much credit, like you've done for these guys? it's like you think they might start a revolution. i have news: the revolution has already begun, and you just have to accept that every revolution has its extremists.
i will admit though, that you guys in this discussion are having a far more sensible time of it than these linked ones. bravo.
by deepsand
What I take strong issue with is the notion that it's okay to [i]restrict[/i] choice by intentionally blocking one's site to those who are, at the moment, using a browser other than that esposed by the site's owner or operator.
Legal? In my opinion, yes. Ethical? Hardly; particularly in light of the fact that not everyone has a choice in all things and at all times.
I've yet to find any tool that is truly best for all occasions. That's why, for example, my mechanic's tool box includes, for working with nuts & bolts, box wrenches, open-end wrenches, sockets and adjustable wrenches. Browsers are no different in this regard; I use several, as best suits the needs of the moment.
by apotheon
by deepsand
In so doing, they are wasting the resources of [b]others[/b].
If you're going solicit my visiting your site, but going to knowingly and with intent block my access under certain conditions, then you damn well better tell me that up front; to do otherwise is fraudulent.
by apotheon
by deepsand
This argument has been used to justify a great number of evils, not he least of which was racial segregation.
That a particular form of discrimination has not been declared unlawful does [b]not[/b] mean that it is ethical.
The action here in question is not a boycott; it is an unethical denial of service.
by apotheon
That's a new low.
Unlike race, you can choose your browser.
by lunekeltkar
If "no real website requires anything but basic text," then why the hokey picture by your name?
Lune
by deepsand
by lunekeltkar
...for me. Dang, I haven't been this nostalgic since, oh I don't know, yesterday. Where in tarnation did I put those Commodores (Lionel and 64)? v, deep, nick, stop by sometime and I'll buy you a beer, just for the pastime of it.
Lune
by deepsand
Based on countless posts here, it's obvious that a lot of us go way back to the yesteryears of computing, when IT was known as DP. We may very well collectively have the makings of a first class museum of old computers, etal..
Enjoy that beer.
by nicknielsen
by lunekeltkar
Deep,
I would be in willing to participate in such a project. Over the years I've collected DP/IT stuff that I haven't been able to make myself throw away. As I recall, a (now retired) IT guy from our college has a pretty substantial storage building filled with wonderful relics. I wonder if any quality tech museums already exist. I feel that there must be, but I haven't heard of any. I'll poke around.
Lune
by ken coe
by deepsand
1) This thread is [b]not[/b] about bashing any particular product, OS, etc.. It [b]is[/b] about the particular tactics employed by a specific group.
2) As for open source & Linux bashing, I submit that there's plenty to be had by all; in fact, if you look around here, you'll finding the [b]overwhelming majority of "bashing"[/b] to be directed at [b]MS and Windows.[/b]
3) With regards to proselytizing, the FF fans are here exceedingly well represented, as witnessed by the numerous posts seeking aid receiving replies that simply say "You're a fool for using IE; switch to FF."
In summation, I submit that you are either ill informed re. the totality of posts here, or you are selectively choosing those to be acknowledged.
by ken coe
Google is not in some big browser conspiracy, and neither is Mozilla. Google pays for someone downloading the google search bar for ANY browser. It just so happens that Firefox took it one step further and included it in their browser by defualt. Google makes money off searchers. The searchbar makes it easier to make that money. Google pays for the toolbar, and the toolbar is in that version of the browser. It is THAT simple. You can also get paid if they download the toolbar for IE (it IS available for IE).
I have made money off adsense on a couple of sites (although not much) by linking to things my reader might like, such as a link to amazon for the book I discuss. This is used all over the place, including on the right side of the page you are LOOKING AT NOW. See where it says from our sponsors? Read the url for the link. Viola! A new conspiracy to discuss!
Yes, adsense DOES pay people for advertising. Do you think all those neat commercials on TV are free? Adsense takes the step in a slightly different direction by basing it's advertising dollars on productivity. Kind of like paying truck drivers by the mile.
The problem with this is that some people get greedy and try to trick, or force, you into clicking with their website. It's called SPAM. It's been around a while. They just have a new angle. If you report them to Google, they will sever the account with that site, as it is in violation of the ad-sense contract.
Go to ad-sense and check it out yourself.
by deepsand
by apotheon
by deepsand
by deepsand
The unfounded charge of "race Baiting" is the [i]non sequitur[/i].
And, it was evasive in that it fails to address my point that "freedom of association" does not justify any and all actions.
Furthermore, you've yet to address my immediately prior post re. fraud.
by deepsand
The unfounded charge of "race Baiting" is the [i]non sequitur[/i].
And, it was evasive in that it fails to address my point that "freedom of association" does not justify any and all actions.
Furthermore, you've yet to address my immediately prior post re. fraud.
by deepsand
But, I don't recall either its name or location.
There's as good chance that such was mentioned here in one of the regular contributors' columns, but, given the primitive naure of the Search function here, locating such may be damned near impossible.
If I come anything, I'll try to remember to let you know.
It the meanwhile, enjoy your old "stuff."
PS - I've a copy, somewhere, of 2-tape Autocoder on cards; now, if I could just find an IBM 1401, with card reader, printer and tape drives, in working order, I'd get back to assembly language programming in ernest. Hell, I'd even settle for a 1620!
by apotheon
"[i]This argument has been used to justify a great number of evils, not he least of which was racial segregation.[/i]"
Race-baiting. Don't bother trying to deny it. You're intentionally and blatantly associating racism with the issue at hand, which has zero to do with racism. Ooh, since someone used "freedom of association" to justify racism, I must be an eeeeeevil racist for uttering the phrase. No, it's not what you said, but without being much stupider than I know you to be you couldn't possibly have been unaware that impression might be made by your statements.
"[i]That a particular form of discrimination has not been declared unlawful does not mean that it is ethical.[/i]"
That something is not ruled out doesn't prove it. Please try to avoid absurd logical fallacies. They make us both look stupid without providing a solid argument for anything: you look stupid to people who recognize logical fallacies, and I look stupid to people who don't. Nobody wins.
"[i]The action here in question is not a boycott; it is an unethical denial of service.[/i]"
How is it not a boycott? People who take part in this anti-IE campaign are attempting to remove themselves from economic circles that support the software of a given vendor. That sure sounds like a boycott to me. It's like refusing to watch a TV show when advertisements for an offensive (to the boycotter) product are aired during the commercial breaks for that show, thus reducing the show's ratings, until such time as the network drops that advertiser. Perhaps you're not aware that's how boycotts often work.
"[i]The unfounded charge of "race Baiting" is the non sequitur.[/i]"
No, a non sequitur is something that doesn't have a point of relevance, like your absurdly inappropriate reference to racist segregation politics, implying some kind of ethical similarity between A) not wanting your business because of skin color and B) not wanting your business because your other business dealings support a particular monopolist (by intent, if not in practice).
"[i]And, it was evasive in that it fails to address my point that "freedom of association" does not justify any and all actions.[/i]"
That wasn't evasion of a relevant point: it was ignoring a non sequitur. I didn't try to justify "any and all actions" and you damned well know it.
I've addressed your silly "point" about fraud. Get a dictionary.
by ken coe
I would agree that the article talks about a single group of people who are going the wrong way, but the bulk of the threads switched to "the Google/FF conspiracy" (OK, not THAT extreme) pretty quickly. I was responding to one of those threads.
As far as the bias of the site, I was refering to the news distributed by the site, not the discussion threads. I said that specifically in the message. I do see a lot of people standing up in support of free/open-source software in the discussion threads. I also see reference to them as fanatics for doing it. My reference was to what is distributed by the site.
A good refernce point for that is what is selected to be sent in the newsletters. If you receive them, go back a few weeks, and count how many articles are pro and con. It is not exactly pro-gpl.
Two examples- The issue that covers Novell announcing its new OSS Offerings, and the issue which announces Sun will ship some servers with Ubuntu. Both of these (and many more), where followed by a link to at least two blatantly anti-OSS blogs. Show me where they did that with a MS announcement. How about the article about MS declaring that Linux is not mature enough to be stable or reliable. No answer to THAT? That's an outright lie, but no counter to it.
I would hardly say that I am trying to tune out the MS crowd. I am here for the MS news, as I stated in the original post. Techrepublic covers what most IT people see in the field, and that is MS. I don't see that as a problem. Every site leans one way or another. I certainly would not go to Slashdot for MS news or info.
by deepsand
articles in general, or specific columnists.
If the latter, which one's
by ken coe
I appreciate the chance to clarify that.
Overall, I think the columnists do a pretty good job. It is the selection of the stories that I see. Call it the editors.
I don't think that they are deliberately trying to slam OSS. I think they tend to lean toward commercial software. A good part of that is the number of whitepapers and publicized announcements being financed by commercial suppliers. Tech Republic is doing nothing like the fools that this post was about.
As I said, any communication outlet will lean one way or another. This one tends to fall toward Microsoft. Not surprising considering its installed base, and not a bad thing at all. I was just pointing out that we need to consider our sources for news.
by deepsand
See
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fraud
I contend that the actions in question do constitute fraud, at least in the broad sense, in that those involved are engaged in "deception made for personal gain."
by deepsand
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Non_sequitur
Your accusation of "race baiting" is a [i]logical fallacy[/i], unsupported by other than your own opinion.
Hence, your reply is nonsubstantive, and serves only to evade the issue re. "freedom of association."
by deepsand
boy?cott
To abstain from or act together in abstaining from using, buying, or dealing with as an expression of protest or disfavor or as a means of coercion. See synonyms at blackball.
n.
The act or an instance of boycotting.
--------------------------------------------------
As the actions of those here in question [b]deliberately seek to deal with[/b] IE users, thay cannot be said to be boycotting them.
Only [b]their own abstainance[/b] from using IE constitutes a boycoot.
by apotheon
by apotheon
It's really difficult to believe you actually want me to buy that asinine song and dance. The logical fallacy here is your attempt to associate my reference to a Constitutional protection of individual rights with racism on some kind of moral-judgment level. That, m'friend, fits the very definition of race-baiting. It matches the formula for Godwin's Law exactly, except that in place of Hitler or Nazis you're comparing me to the KKK. Go suck.
"[i]To abstain from or act together in abstaining from using, buying, or dealing with as an expression of protest or disfavor or as a means of coercion. See synonyms at blackball.[/i]"
Yes, exactly. See those banners and splash pages? They say you [b]don't get to deal with these websites as long as you use IE[/b]. That's the [b]opposite[/b] of specifically trying to "deal" with IE users. Get a friggin' clue.
I'm done with this crap. Once someone consistently and persistently tries to skate by on blatant BS like this, it's obvious that the person in question is more interested in some kind of back-patting sense of righteous indignation than having a reasoned discussion. Again, go suck.
by deepsand
by deepsand
What I did say is that for one to invite another to his site, for the supposed purpose of providing a service, but with the intent of requiring the visitor to down a specific browser if not already present, is deceptive.
And, said deception is accomplished through [b]material misrepresentation[b]; that it is one of omission is irrelevant. A material misrepresentation is one which, had it not occurred, may have resulted in the respondent choosing a different course of action.
And, as the result of such deception is gainful to the operator of such site, such constitutes fraud.
The only thing that keeps it from being [i]criminal[/i] fraud is that the material misrepresentation was not made with the intent to cause loss to the visitor.
by deepsand
Their goal is [b]not[/b] merely to avoid IE users, but to coerce IE users into switching to FF. Such is [b]not[/b] a boycott.
As for the "race baiting" charge, such is pure bullshit. You're simply ignoring the fact that "freedom of association" is [b]not sufficient[/b] to justify and and all acts.
Yes, my eyes are brown; that's another thing that's not by my own choice, just like my "race."
BTW, there's genetically [b]no such thing as "race."[/b]
by apotheon
Sort by Trending