Heads you win, tails I lose - all based on a false premise
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Windows Forum
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
major concerns on all these issues. The politics and money are behind most of what's happening in this arena.
Look at the countries pushing the Kyoto Protocol, and look at their economies and their level of development.
All the European countries just love Kyoto, but they're 98% fully developed and very high population densities. They have no land on which they can create what they call greenhouse sinks by planting acres of trees. The items they wish to measure are at very stable levels in those countries.
Then look at Canada, the USA, and Australia - we have much more land, much lower populations and are still developing much of the country. We also have huge areas that are still forested and many more we can plant forest on. Thus, we'd get an advantage if greenhouse sinks were allowed. Our greenhouse gas emissions are still rising as we take in migrants and develop the infrastructure required to support them, also just moving things like food about the country takes more than it does in Europe.
The Europeans want countries to pay a cash penalty based solely on gas emissions of the country divided by the number of people. They absolutely refuse to make allowance for the size of the country or the amount of forestation the country has. Based on the figures the Europeans want, and got in Kyoto, they would have to pay damn little while doing next to nothing to combat the greenhouse gases they create; while they force heavy payments on the USA, Australia, and Canada. If they allow adjustments for forestation then Canada, the USA, and Australia would be able to offset quite a large amount of their emission due to the large swathes of forest and brush, and pay a lot less; they could also make money by selling land for afforestation to the Europeans. If the per population and per square kilometre aspect were added, then the Europeans would be paying about five times what they should under Kyoto.
The other side is the majority of the people screaming about how extremely harmful the humans are are not those that have been heavily involved in world wide climate research for decades, and nearly all are currently in positions where they get paid good money to promote the concept. Take away the problem and they lose a lot of their salaries and power.
I agree much more research is needed, and we should work at decreasing our impact, but we should not be panicing the way these people are pushing things.
Here's an interesting web site:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Countries_by_population_density
Have a look at the figures for the countries really pushing for the Kyoto reasoning and process, and have a look at those who've stood against it.
three against Kyoto
Australia -- 2,966,200 sq miles -- pop density 7.472 per sq mile
Canada -- 3,855,100 sq miles -- pop density 8.819 per sq mile
USA -- 3,717,813 sq miles -- pop density 83.019 per sq mile
four for Kyoto
Germany -- 137,847 sq miles -- pop density 594.009 per sq mile
Netherlands -- 16.033 sq miles -- pop density 1,034.672 per sq mile
UK -- 94,060 sq miles -- pop density 659.608 per sq mile
Belgium -- 11,787 sq miles -- pop density 918.614 per sq mile
............
The World -- 148,940,000 sq miles -- pop density per 118.280 sq mile
European union -- 1,707,670 sq miles -- pop density est114.000 per sq mile
........
Canada, the USA, and Australia represent about 18.326% of the total world land area, but have only 5.363% of the world population, while the EU has 7.264 of the world's population in 2.969% of the world's land. Yet the EU is pushing the rest of the world to accept there ideas on what constitutes climate change and how to manage it. The way they're going will give them a huge economic advantage over Canada, the USA, and Australia by burdening those three countries with the bulk of the charges for they wish to impose for climate change as they'll give exemptions to many others as being developing countries while claiming these three are developed - when the only fully developed countries today exist in Europe. On a percentage basis, the EU has about 1.4 times the population on about one six of the land of the three anti-Kyoto countries.
............
Under Kyoto, countries in Asia and South America are allowed to keep ripping up forests and shoving emission out at levels not permitted countries like Canada, USA, and Australia, nor will they be charged for doing so. Hell, the way China is going, it will soon be more developed than the USA, Canada or Australia.
We need to get the politicians out of the loop, all these BS programs like Kyoto need to be scrapped and one set of behaviour rules applied to all - end of story. Kyoto is simply about making the EU countries more economically viable at the expense of what they call 2nd world countries.
Is there anything else that we may not post less we trample on your sensibilities?
With the rise and rise of political correctness, society has become obsessed with not offending people who have religious beliefs of one sort or another. I'm afraid that I do not subscribe to that philosophy.
As I get older, I am finding it harder and harder to politely listen to people spout off about God and Allah and being forced - by law! - to remain quiet.
Groups bomb my city in the name of religion. The previous leaders of both our countries think it's OK to cause bombs to be dropped on both guilty and innocent people when they 'passionately believe' something is right.
Not in MY name.
I'm not getting militant about it and I'm not trying to make enemies or insult people. But I have, these past few years, decided not to be quiet about it any more.
:)
Times and industries may change, but human nature will not; and the principles of individual liberty are based on the latter. There will always be people who are more ambitious than others; there will always be people envious of others; there will always be people who want to do the least and get more; etc.
People will always have a desire to live free.
The concept of individual liberty is anything but outdated dogma.
Edited for the following addition:
I can't recall a single instance in all of history in which people rose up and took to arms for the case of larger and more intrusive government, for more government control over the population, and for less liberty for the individual citizen.
It's always been the opposite.
Outdated dogma? I don't think so.
.... the first global warming / climate change billionaire.
If there is one person most responsible for politicizing the issue in the United States - and possibly around the globe - it's Al Gore.
Al Gore won an Oscar and a Nobel Peace Prize for spreading lies and mistruths in what is no more than a quest for power and money.
Al Gore is the horse pulling the bandwagon, although many horses have been added since the early days of global warming hysteria.
If you truly believe that which you say about man's contribution to changes in climate patterns - and I have no doubt that you do - then you and your side, so to speak, needs to lead the charge in discrediting the likes of Al Gore; and instead of wanting to hold [i]global warming deniers[/i] accountable for [i]crimes against humanity[/i], you need to hold Al Gore - and his ilk - accountable for his (their) REAL crimes.
Until that happens, like it or not, you're not only in bed with the guy, but you're smooching up to him and adding fuel to his cause (and dollars to his bank account).
If you truly believe that which you say about man's contribution to changes in climate patterns - and I have no doubt that you do - then you and your side, so to speak, needs to lead the charge in implementing change or making plans to adapt WITHOUT infringing on the basic human rights of people to live free, without the intrusion of government, and without the solutions ALWAYS being socialist in nature.
Until that happens, your cause will always be a political agenda - a socialist political agenda - in search of justification.
Here's a link to his Web site where he's posted many articles on the issue. I'd be interested to see exactly what you disagree with - scientifically speaking, of course.
Here's another link to a paper Dr. Spencer wrote which, I presume, branded him an Intelligent Design whacko - thereby discrediting ANYTHING he's said. Again, I'd be interested to see how you feel about the paper in its entirety and full context, and how you can reconcile the apparent contradiction in what you said: [i]"I wouldn't discount any scientist who was a believer. I would, however, tend to look skeptically at a cooking recipe from a scientist who was a proponent of Intelligent Design."[/i]
http://www.tcsdaily.com/article.aspx?id=080805I
Someone who is a believer IS a proponent of Intelligent Design. After all (if I'm not mistaken), the whole [i]Intelligent Design[/i] notion was started in what was not much more than an end-around attempt to teach something other than pure evolution in schools. It's not some radical spin-off group who believes some intelligent designer suddenly snapped his/her/its fingers (or whatever digits he/she/it might have) and bingo-bango-presto the earth was created.
Not to digress into an Intelligent Design discussion, but to not [i]discount any scientist who was a believer[/i] and to [i] look skeptically at a cooking recipe from a scientist who was a proponent of Intelligent Design[/i] seems like a contradiction, at least of sorts.
P.S. I didn't see any cooking recipes on Dr. Spencer's Web site. I'm always interested in new ones, so if you have any of Dr. Spencer's cooking recipes, could you share one of them with me?
Edited because: oops, I forgot to post the links.
by geek3001
I like your use of the population density figures. It contributes to a well reasoned argument for rejecting Kyoto.
To be fair for all involved, it would be worthwhile to add in factors that consider the size of the country, the total environmental footprint, the potential for self mitigation of the environmental footprint, the level of development, the income range of the residents, the cost of living of the residents, and the efficiency of the infrastructure.
Some sort of rating system based on population density, plus all of the above factors, could then be created. It should be a rating system with multiple 'grades' that can show the good, the bad and the indifferent. First world countries might rate high in things like population density, infrastructure efficiency and income ranges, but they would need to show improvement in their environmental footprint and their cost of living. Second and third world countries would have a different mix of pluses and minuses.
This 'dashboard' would need to be something that reflects the impact of man on the life support systems of the planet. It would also need to be something that could be verified using hard data that is available for all to see.
The designers of the 'dashboard' would need to be scientists, not politicians and pundits. The spectrum of opinions that go into the construction of the 'dashboard' would need to be part of the backup data that supports the 'dashboard'. If there are several distinct and opposing 'camps', a 'dashboard' element may have several readings, all of which would have supporting data behind them. (The supporting data might have 'peer review percentage acceptance' ratings to show which views dominate.)
The 'dashboard' results could then be used in the political and economic arena. Perhaps countries could have mutual assistance agreements where they work at improving each other's 'dashboard' scores via trade and tech transfers. Countries would also have the right to limit their trade with other countries that have undesirable 'dashboard' scores, though that could backfire.
I suspect that an accurate 'dashboard' would be rather complex. But if it is well designed, it could evolve as we learn more and it could accurately reflect the state of both humankind AND the life support systems of the planet.
so it may take a little time. I've skimmed through the first couple of screen-feet and it's an explanation as to why it's so damn cold this January gone in this age of GW. We had our weather forecasters answer it in much the same way "it's warmer somewhere else".
It's not a question I bothered to ask as the answer is so simple - the difference between weather and climate.
Hopefully there will be something I can agree with or disagree with. :)
My problem with Spencer does indeed come from his ID. "I came to the realization that intelligent design, as a theory of origins, is no more religious, and no less scientific, than evolutionism." Sorry, I disagree SO strongly that I HAVE to view his writing on other subjects coloured by his views on ID.
I will now examine Spencer's writings on climate at your request. His writings on evolution are so far off the mark and just so lacking in logic that I've been inhibited from bothering to date. In this I speak as a biological scientist where I've reason to believe I might know enough to make a definitive judgement.
Like all those opposed to any form of Darwinian evolution, he misses his target. While he trumpets on about "evolution has not been observed", referring to the generation of new species, he misses the real point that must be answered and that is "given what HAS been observed, how could speciation NOT happen?".
Because I can't resist a chance to rubbish ID...
Neil :)
As I said, I wouldn't follow a recipe from Spencer's site because, surely, I'd need to take it with a pinch of salt.
by geek3001
I had already visited the Roy Spencer site and am impressed with his knowledge and presentation of the climate/weather data. It would be a much better site if he had a blog for political opinions that was separate from the hard science part of the blog. It demeans the science when you mix the two.
Note that this should apply to science/opinion blogs on the left, right AND the spectrum in the middle.
The link to the Intelligent Design article is a VERY good one. It needs to be quoted by all parties when they mention ID as a possible weakness. For that matter, Spencer should include it on his website as a way of diffusing criticism. It would show that he appears to be a conservative in the ID field.
When you get down to it, ALL science is 'faith' based in a sense. Newton's Theory of Gravity is still a 'faith' based theory, but one with a lot of empirical data supporting it. It ended up being tweaked by some of Einstein's theories, but that's science.
Still, Spencer's arguments against what he calls 'true evolution' have some weak points. I commend him for having spent two years studying evolution versus ID as a PhD scientist, but that was, back calculating from the article, almost twenty five years ago. Since that time, there has been a lot of research in genetics and archaeology that weakens his case. Has he been keeping up with all sides of the ID discussion?
One of the sticking points for me is the following quote from the article:
"While natural selection can indeed preserve the stronger and more resilient members of a gene pool, intelligent design maintains that it cannot explain entirely new kinds of life -- and that is what evolution is." (Spencer, "Faith-Based Evolution", TCS Daily, 08 Aug, 2005.)
That strikes me as redefining 'evolution' so that Intelligent Design becomes a core part of it. It also ignores the possibility that small changes caused by natural selection, combined with the separation of populations and the occasional mutation, can create different species. Over a long period of time these species become other species until they have differentiated enough to become 'new' life forms.
This process can happen a lot faster when life is under stress and slight differences can mean the difference between survival and extinction.
Are there any other articles on Spencer's ID beliefs?
comes from the following snip from your post:
"It also ignores the possibility that small changes caused by natural selection, combined with the separation of populations and the occasional mutation, can create different species. Over a long period of time these species become other species until they have differentiated enough to become 'new' life forms."
What is really difficult is to devise a theory where that DOESN'T happen. Microevolution - which the ID'ers accept happens - and Macroevolotion - which they don't - are really no different.
:)
And, how you will, Neil.
I will squelch you only as to epistemological merits of what you say, as in, "irrationality of religious belief" (below in the thread).
Religious belief [i]is[/i] rationality. The construct of God is deep foundation and font of rationality; that without which there is no rationality.
Furthermore, we don't get to recursively apply "rational" to the components that constitute rationality. If we could, you could -- as you do -- apply the word to the components of your own construction, the selfsame construction that amounts to your rationality. It is, in short, because you say so.
Were you God, for example, fashioning [i]Logic[/i] to unleash upon us for the first time, would you knowingly pronounce each of the parts of Logic, "logical", before being brought together and comprising that very Logic?
Same with, "knowingly". Where did knowing -- aka, [i]scientia[/i] -- come from? Was science present before being, according to Neil?
That touches on three of the biggies: rationality, logic, and knowing. There are more.
Your sensibilities, [b]JackOfAllTech[/b], betray you. You have yet to do the hard work of God as betrayed by your delicate preoccupation with polity. You may "know" that what you are onto is of mind-boggling importance; that it literally is how you are -- "is" being another biggie. But, neither you nor Neil evidence a prayer of getting out of your own respective ways, and into the construction of self.
I can get myself out of it. Should I so choose. But it's taken me a while to get here so I may stay for a while.
Oh, and science didn't exist. Stuff still did stuff, though. And did stuff properly.
by oz_media
Yuo simply dismiss mankind's impact as irrelevant and worthless.
It seems that you now finding that your comments were rash, again, and you are sidling into more common ground, as usual.
You often come up with absolutely ridiculous comments, and then after seeing mass dissention and corrections to your false claims, you realize your mistake and work to neutralize your initial comments as if people were mistaken all along.
Old hat, not into watching you wriggle again.
by oz_media
You can try and twist my words, and then try to imply my core values incorrectly, however we both know you fail at convincing me of what you THINK I stand for.
I don't stand for more government simply because you take the personal liberties issue as a defense for anything you don't personally understand or agree with.
Such concept offers the simplicity of a child's comprehansion and irrational thought pattern.
If I support something that you feel is a waste of American tax dollars or your personal liberties, you then instantly raise the argument that I don't understand freedom and support big govrenment control of everyone's lives and income.
Get a real life.
You are so black and white it is outdated and boring, you just drone on an on with no concept of mankind's ever growing understanding of the world and need for global unification.
Even since you were a child, the world and the mindset, that people of any nation have to accept, has changed so much.
Without minds that understand that you must give a little in order to move ahead, we would still be living the blind life of the 50's. Where women wore heels and pearls do make dinner and serve the family.
Because some people know that a false reality is not reality, we have progressed as a species.
You have to understand that shades of grey have and always will exist, behind any so callec reo values and you don't have to give up such core values in order to accept the need for an ever changing society. Expecting people to be mroe resourceful is not removing people's liberties. Expecting business to do the same is also not removing anyone's personal liberties.
Your government will always rip you off, fact of life. Taking people's tax dollars and FORCING them to support a war they don't actually support is not removing personal liberties in your narrow mind. It is something you value and support so YOUR liberties are not infringed on, which is just fine by you.
Your government, while you feel is working in your favour, is in turn removing other people's liberties, which you gladly accept when it is in your favour. You don't actually have these core values you soeak of so often, you have personal, and rather selfish values despite your naturally giving personality.
A personality which gives in order to feel personally jutified; self gratification without a real care for anyone else or what others think as long as you look and feel good.
In your steadfast ways, you are in turn infringing on other people's rights.
You simply don't see it because it is not black and white, as you feel your life should be.
by oz_media
Nope, not gonna work, but nice try.
Warmer climates also kill more animals, thus your thinly velied BS/theory doesn't hold water.
First, try to gain a basic understanding of what you are talking about.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ice_core
Then a more comprehesive understanding:
http://www.esf.org/activities/research-networking-programmes/life-earth-and-environmental-sciences-lesc/completed-esf-research-networking-programmes-in-life-earth-and-environmental-sciences/european-project-for-ice-coring-in-antarctica-epica-page-1.html
Sorry, you'll have to read about European Science as it simply doesn't exist or recieve sufficient funding in the US.
Then perhaps you'll begin to understand the big picture, though not bloody likely.
You also accept that CO2 levels and climate change are related. So whether the ocean creates more CO2, volcanoes (had to include Ernest here too), or plants and animals. CO2 levels are directly re;ated to climate change, fact.
This increasing CO2 levels, as just one part of many other contributing factors from hyman emissions, we are in turn reducing out contribution in speeding up a nartural process.
I am pretty sure my friend's 7 year old daughter can grasp it, hopefully you can get a bit of help and grasp it also, however that is doubtful.
The egg came first.
Just like a horse plus a donkey produces a mule, [i]something[/i] plus [i]something else[/i] produced the first chicken egg.
It had to happen twice (or more), however, so that the male rooster and female hen were both produced.
What happened next was probably something like this: the two [i]somethings[/i] that produced both the chicken rooster and chicken hen set them up on a blind date so they could make beautiful chicks together.
What happened after that was the establishment of both the standard breakfast, bacon and eggs, and the standard dinner, fried chicken and mashed potatoes.
The side dishes are different stories entirely. I would go into it, but I don't want to detract from the main thread.
Is it right or wrong to enslave people? Is it black and white, as I suggest, or are there shades of gray?
Is it right or wrong to rape people? Is it black and white, as I suggest, or are there shades of gray?
Is it right or wrong to rob people of their personal property?
Physically or financially? Is there a difference? People are being financially raped and enslaved.
Some things ARE black and white, Oz. The only question is this: do you have the courage to take a stand, one way or the other, or do you waver in some lame attempt to appease both sides?
Your shades of gray are obscuring your sense of right and wrong. And in some cases, there is no shade of gray in-between.
by oz_media
I don't have someone chained up in my basement, however I don't feel paying taxes enslaves me. I can leave any time I want.
Nobody steals my money, I pay taxes are part of accepting Canada's government and laws, again that is by choice, I can always leave.
You seem to have this simplistic view on life that cannot determine between a fender bender and a fatal accident, or at leat your analogies constantly lean that way.
You voted for a government, by definition a government is entrusted with the citizens tax dollars to spend that collective money as the majority of their voters deemed most suitable. The only enslavement and robbery is due to your being let down by fellow citizens who didn't elect your choice of government, thus you feel enslaved and robbed by the same democracy that you feel makes the USA the best nation on Earth.
Nobody went to the UK and put my family on a ship, brought me here and forced me to work.
Nobody dug into my wallet and helped themselves, I made a choice to be here and accept the bill of rights and government of this free nation.
If you feel that is accepting being enslaved, raped and robbed, then you really need to start learning how to differentiate between such crimes on humanity and reality.
by oz_media
So life didn't evolve from single celled organisms eventually adapting to the changing surrounings and a need to protect its young.
God simply made two animals that fornicated and created a chicken egg.
Why didn't he just make a chicken then?
Birds have been proven some of the earliest evolved life forms on Earth as sea born creatures evolved into mammals and then continued to evolve in order to feed and protect their young by nesting off the ground and developing a hard shell for their offspring to begin life in.
Yet a badger and a pterodactyl get together after a night at the bar and viola, chicken man! Much mroe realistic.
I often wonder where you come up with such utter rubbish.
[i][b]Climategate U-turn as scientist at centre of row admits: There has been no global warming since 1995[/b]
The academic at the centre of the "Climategate" affair, whose raw data is crucial to the theory of climate change, has admitted that he has trouble "keeping track" of the information.
Colleagues say that the reason Professor Phil Jones has refused Freedom of Information requests is that he may have actually lost the relevant papers. [/i] (Lost the relevant papers? Yea, right! Nice excuse for never had in the first place.)[i]
Professor Jones told the BBC yesterday there was truth in the observations of colleagues that he lacked organisational skills, that his office was swamped with piles of paper and that his record keeping is "not as good as it should be".
The data is crucial to the famous "hockey stick graph" used by climate change advocates to support the theory.[/i] (Which was discredited years ago.)[i]
Professor Jones also conceded the possibility that the world was warmer in medieval times than now - [b]suggesting global warming may not be a man-made phenomenon[/b]...........[/i]
I've never had to make such a u-turn. For years, I've been leading the charge claiming that the whole thing was bad science, bogus claims, lies and misrepresentations, a political agenda in search of justification, etc.
I've always said that the truth will eventually come out. And now it's starting to.
The numbers of people riding on the respective bandwagons will be changing rapidly. But I maintain my position in the driver's seat of mine.
The die-hards will continue to cling, but they're sure to fall.
by oz_media
[i][b]Colleagues say[/b] that the reason Professor Phil Jones has refused Freedom of Information requests is that [b]he may[/b] have actually lost the relevant papers.[/i]
So when hounded by the media as to why he didn't readily provide the papers, people who know him guessed that he may have misplaced them. It admits or proves nothing of fact, just that the media creates what it wants to portray.
Ex.
Joe truth spinner: "So why hasn't he provided them? He said he's lost them."
Coworker: "Yeah, he's pretty disorganized, he may have misplaced them, I suppose"
[i]Professor Jones told the BBC yesterday there was truth in the observations of colleagues that he lacked organisational skills, that his office was swamped with piles of paper and that his record keeping is "not as good as it should be".[/i]
This illustrates that those were the actual words of his colleagues, repeated to him as a question, just as I quoted in example above.
Certainly you understand reporting better than that.
[i]"Professor Jones also conceded the [b]possibility[/b]"[/i]
He's a scientist, scientist by core nature are always open to possibility, he didn't say he agreed or disagreed.
[i]"suggesting global warming may not be a man-made phenomenon."[/i]
It most certainly isn't, and pretty much anyone will agree with that, so far nothing is proven or disproven in any way, shape or form.
Just nice little bits and bytes manipulated to create a sensational news article as always; great fodder for people, such as yourself, who gobble up anything that supports their preconceived notions.
[i]"that for the past 15 years there has been no "statistically significant" warming."[/i] But he does agree the Earth is warming and that a 15 year sample is irrelevant. (later on anyway, after the reporter corrects himself)
'Statistically significant', were his words. Which would mean we not going to die tomorrow. The inevitability of "statistically significant" change is exactly what reduction of emissions is hoped to prolong.
Though warming has occurred, as proven in the loss of polar ice caps and reduction in ice floes in North Eastern Canada, endangering the polar bear. No hockey stick graph needed for that, its visual and easily measured and accurately recorded.
Ice doesn't melt and reduce it's presence unless it is warmed. Perhaps, you can research [b]'hot vs cold'[/b] to better understand such an intricate concept.
[i]"The admissions will be seized on by sceptics[/i] Yup they at least got that right, funny how they knew what they were creating before even printing it, sounds like a pretty clear objective to me. You bit that hook pretty quickly!
The accusations about his reasons for stepping down were due to skeptics CLAIMS that show SOME scientists were manipulating data.
Therefore, in your wee mind, ALL scientists manipulated data in their favour, ignoring that scientists SEEK to be proven wrong in their conclusions, that's the basis for scientific discovery.
Your astute sense also assumes that nobody from the anti-global-warming camp has manipulated data to support their argument...ahem, as we see over and over again in this joke of an article.
[i][b]accused[/b] of scientific fraud for [b]allegedly deliberately[/b](LOL) suppressing information and refusing to [b]share vital data with critics.[/b][/i]
Allegedly, deliberatley suppressing. "We [i]think[/i] you did something on purpose!"
Vital DATA, is not proven fact until it is analyzed. I wouldn't share such data with skeptics either, if that data is found to be flawed, even by Jones himself, it will be paraded in a report such as we see here, whether he himself would have supported it or not. Scientists don't automatically accept all data they are given as being factual. They are usually the first ones to dissect it and find flaws, as is their ultimate goal, finding the facts and analyzing them.
And under what law is he obligated to do so anyway?
[i]"colleagues of Professor Jones who had told him that his strengths included integrity and doggedness but not record-keeping and office tidying."[/i]
Which proves....? Yeah, nothing negative against him at all, it's just column filler, they already said that and took it out of context to sensationalize their story. (seriously, how you don't see such things amazes me. It jumps off the page like 3D print to me.) No wonder you buy into the political BS you are fed daily. You simply don't know how to take in what you read.
[i]"said he still believed recent temperature rises were predominantly man-made."[/i]
So they lied so blatantly early in the article, knowing people wouldn't actually read past bold type and see that they later corrected their initially misleading statement themselves.
I see you omitted it in your race to say man didn't 'cause' global warming too. Clever! :D Ever thought about writing for the Enquirer or maybe scripting a few Jerry Springer episodes?
[i]but said these could be explained by natural phenomena whereas more recent warming could not.[/i]
So he says there HAS been recent global warming, and details that the last 15 years are but a blip, in a cycle shown to have taken centuries or millenia over the Earth's history. Again this was taken out of context early on and used to sensationalize the story and mislead the reader.
Your joy is based on some rubbish news piece that proves absolutely nothing at all in even the tiniest way. It's very clever but very false in almost every paragraph.
He said the debate over warmer periods in Medievil times was also far from settled. However earlier in the article, they state that he agrees it was warmer in medievil times. Again they twisted his words to intone that without actually saying it, hell, you bought it. Even though they also rephrased it later on.
[i]Sceptics believe there is strong evidence that the world was warmer between about 800 and 1300 AD[/i]
[b]Sceptics believe[/b], but have no factual basis for such a theory or did they misplace their paperwork and that's just fine?
I'm not even going to bother showing the gaping holes in the rest of their fabrications, this post is long enough already. Just the conflicts in their own story show it to be complete and utter rubbish.
Why would you bother to read, buy into and post such crap as facts or proof of ANYTHING, other than how the media spins a story out of nothing?
It sure speaks volumes about how well you research and understand the points of view you offer around here.
Warning to peers: take it all of Max's posts with a grain of salt, this guy will believe anything he reads. LOL :D
What a joker, you don't REALLY take that BS seriously do you? Certainly your years have shown you how the media works.
It's about as proven and factual as Jaws or E.T. Yes there are sharks in the ocean, yes it is most possible that we are not the only life form in the universe, beyond that they are just Hollywood movies, to sell tickets.
I can see how Joe Public would buy into such tripe, but I thought most people around here were a little beyond that level of incomprehension.
by tonythetiger
[i]Colleagues say that the reason Professor Phil Jones has refused Freedom of Information requests is that he may have actually lost the relevant papers. [/i]
"The dog ate my homework."
by tonythetiger
[i]Warning to peers: take it all of Max's posts with a grain of salt, this guy will believe anything he reads. LOL grin
What a joker, you don't REALLY take that BS seriously do you? Certainly your years have shown you how the media works.
[/i]
is what most of the media [b]aren't[/b] saying.
by jdclyde
will admit for ANY science to have ANY validity, the data has to be available and repeatable.
Watch for Profits making a profit and you will quickly see the truth.
by jck
Valero, BP, Halliburton, Exxon-Mobil and other international petroleum conglomerates have been making sky rocketing profits off the policy standards set by the previous administration in not requiring them to conform to the environmental standards that other modern, industrialized nations are pursuing under the Kyoto Accord and other adopted policies.
All this, despite the previous administration and private industry having [b][u]no proof to back their claim that increased use of fossil fuels by people does not cause increased average global temperatures[/u][/b].
So:
A) You criticize scientists who are proponents of global warming due to the [b]fact[/b] that CO2 traps heat in the atmosphere and that concentrations are at all-time records since the industrial age began.
B) You support the statements of scientists who are against global warming as a [b]belief[/b].
Where are your [b]facts[/b] from the antagonists that [b]validate[/b] your stance with [b]data[/b]?
Thanks. :)
..... TOTAL taxation in the United Stated versus Canada. I'd bet a dollar to dirt that the TOTAL taxation in the USA is higher - much higher - than that in Canada. And not just the percentage of income taxed, but everything, regardless of what it's called or how it's collected.
You try to paint me as a radical anti-tax zealot, but nothing could be farther from the truth. I know that taxes are necessary to support the role and functions of government; but where we disagree is in defining the extent of that role and those functions.
P.S. And at what threshold, do you think, is too much?
[i]......fornicated and created a chicken egg.[/i]
We could have fun with that one, couldn't we?
Maybe a turkey and a pheasant.
But what laid the first turkey egg? And pheasant egg?
And all those migrating Canadian Geese who keep pooping all over the place in the park across from my house have to be in the equation somewhere. (They seem to be appearing in unusually high numbers this winter. It must be that blasted global warming!)
P.S. There are times when that park is occupied by hundreds (yes, hundreds) of those geese, and I get a kick out of seeing them all take-off and fly away after I let my dog chase them away. And he has fun chasing them. They do, however, fertilize the golf courses around here.)
P.P.S. Did you know that ALL dog breeds are direct descendants of the wolf? (Even those little fuzzy and cuddly ones!)
by oz_media
Well considering the "animal" could have at one time been a single celled organism, that became ameoba, that became...yuo get teh picture. So then fish adapted to land, then grow wings to reach food, then TWO winged creatures EVOLVED and becamse what we know as chickens today.
Each time, their eggs also changed as they did, at one time it was primitave chicken a, then it evolved to primative chicken B, then C etc. Each time, it is a chicken, laying a chicken.
It's just like how Chinese people have Chinese babies, African American people have African American Babies etc.
They are all humans, they have simply evolved differently to adapt to their environment.
It's certainly not a result of a really black person having sex with a white person and creating a brown person.
Man, you guys REALLY need some science in your educational system!
The whole chicken and egg 'brain teaser' only stands up if you believe in creationism.
[i]....." Man, you guys REALLY need some science in your educational system! The whole chicken and egg 'brain teaser' only stands up if you believe in creationism. [/i]"
I'm shaking my head in disbelief that you could segue to what you said from what I said.
by oz_media
I get two different possible tones from your vague reply, 1) you are agreeing with the article or 2) you are agreeing that he got caught spewing a load of crap.
If #1)
It's in black and white, truth spinning BS that even contradicts itself in the same page.
First he is said to deny global warming, then when the full comment is quoted, he is not denying it at all. He is said to agree that the Eath hasn't been warming for the last 15 years. Later he is shown to suggest that 15 years is insignifiant in the GW scale. First they state that he wouldn't release data as proof to skeptics, then they say how skeptics "suggest" but have no proof, that he is wrong. Just a tad two faced.
His coworkers STATE one thing, then later on and in full context they are merely GUESSING at it.
It's full of gargantuan holes and hypocrisy, without a shred of fact to support it as it falls apart under its own words.
It does demonstrate why Americans are such an easily lead and fed marketplace though, and why The Enquirer is so popular there.
by oz_media
Your grasp of a news piece as taken out of context is abysmal. You simply can't read words and use them to understand teh context of teh statement, that's why press misleads people so easily. People just don't know how to decipher what they read,
Even THE artcle contradicts the opening comments later by reiterating what was really said.
YOu can laugh all yuo like, but your are clearly the fool here. They use ACCUSE, and ASSUME, and POSSIBLE, and COULD BE so often it clearly shows the piece to be nothing more than a work of fiction based on nothing but bits of comment taken out of context.
When they later explain in detail, it casts a completely different picture.
If you can't follow it, you are lost and it certainly explains where you get yoru radical conclusions from, either a complete lack of reading comprehension or a simple misunderstanding of the English language.
The article supported NOTHING that your post says it supports, nothing at all.
by tonythetiger
by jck
Walking chewing gum is hard for us liberal leftist wingnut Democratic-speeling people.
Just ask the Rushheads. :^0
by puppybreath
I here I thought you'd be promoting headgear usage because the sky is falling!
:-)
by oz_media
You feel your taxes should be spent on those issues of which you approve. The fact that others approve of spending on climate issues, and you don't is where you are disconnected. YOu feel it is unjust, as you don't support such finding, yet you support military funding in an unjustified, foreign war. Other Americans feel the opposite, spending on climate control is okay, spending on war is not.
THe difference is only due to political preference. The government is elected and entrusted with tax dollars, those who are the majority vote, usually support that government's spending choices, while those who voted for the losing party will not.
So when bush spent your money on Iraq you were behind that, you entrusted that gopvernment to spend as you deemed suitable and acceptable. Others just had to deal with it and live on.
Now the tables have turned, you had a vote and it didn't win. Thus OTHERS, the majority voters, are happy and YOU are now all upset that the government is spending how YOU feel they should.
Democracy, freedom, it either works for you or against you. Either way it goes, someone is left feeling shorted. This time around, it's you.
by jck
None of those sources you quoted has read this site:
http://www.ucar.edu/learn/1_3_1.htm
A nice little tutorial for you all to learn how the greenhouse effect works.
You and all those folks could learn about what is called "The Greenhouse Effect", which is the basis of what traps heat within the atmosphere and how it works.
And btw, "The Greenhouse Effect" is accepted, standard, proven basic science. Not hypothesis or theory.
You and John Coleman and Bill Gray should all go learn that first so you can get up to speed how it works and what is fact.
Now, let's go to your quotes:
[b]"Yet I am totally convinced there is no scientific basis for any of it.... Global Warming: It is a hoax. It is bad science. It is high-jacking public policy. It is the greatest scam in history."
-John Coleman, founder of the weather channel.[/b]
John Coleman is a celebrated meteorologist, and not an expert on global warming or its causes.
I like him as a weatherman, and I watch the Weather Channel a lot. But, I would not use him as a knowledgeable source of what is a "hoax" in regards to global warming.
[b]
"Global warming is a hoax."
- Bill Gray, Emeritus Professor of Atmospheric Science at Colorado State University; M.S. in meteorology from the University of Chicago, Ph.D. in geophysical sciences.[/b]
Bill Gray is another fine meteorologist. His specialty is tropical forecast modelling and hypothesis. Not global warming.
A well respected man in his field, but his knowledge and study are in a field that is only a small subset of the indicators of global warming...not what causes them.
Now why would I refute those two?
Every study of global climate differentiation in the past 10,000s of years since the last 7 major ice age shows 3 things:
- CO2 levels are an abnormal deviation above (450 ppm) within the past 100-150 years than anything previously recorded in the last 650k years (380 ppm) and with no abnormal natural incidences to account for their abnormal deviation (vulcanism, etc).
- In that past 100-150 years, the normal deviation of temperature change has exceeded the known deviation for global average temperature within the past 650k year record of isotopic temperature extraction for any other 100-150 year period.
- The deviation of other greenhouse gases has not been far outside of the normal deviation to the extent CO2 has.
Besides that, neither John Coleman nor Bill Gray have shown anyt contrary proof or data to the scientific proof that CO2 is a heat trapping greenhouse gas.
Or have they? Where is their proof to contradict the rest of the scientific community?
Now as for schools showing [i]An Inconvenient Truth[/i]:
I have no say-so in what any school shows. I'm not a school administrator, school-age child's parent, etc.
As well, I might homeschool my children when I have a family. Simply because I get sick of the rhetoric from both sides that teaches children to accept what is mostly accepted within regional ethic rather than presenting fact and letting them learn to derive the facts from true information and dismiss what is unrepresented or untrue.
I am sick of both sides bickering. And, I'm certainly sick of people saying increased CO2 levels in the atmosphere don't cause increased trapped heat.
That is just stupidity.
You talk a lot of smack about the untruth of Global Warming, Max.
However, your quotes from Coleman and Gray might have well as come from Al Roker and Jim Cantore.
In regards to your quote from Dr. Spencer:
You should go read his entire discussion. He never says he can refute the claims. Only that he has a hypothesis, and that there is no conclusive proof that cloud cover does or does not increase artificially global warming averages.
i.e.- he's in the process of studying it just like everyone else.
Hence, he has [b]no contradictory proof[/b].
BTW, Dr. Roy W. Spencer also is a proponent of intelligent design, and rejects evolution as the mechanism for the origin of species.
Even though we have carbon-dated fossil records to show that species evolved.
Realistic, is he?
I think not.
As for Richard Lindzen:
The one fully qualified person you quoted to discuss global warming.
Lindzen worked on that IPCC panel that reported on Global Warming. He states that the facts of the document were true (the ones that you don't believe?), but that the summaries were amended due to political/policymaker influences.
Lindzen also has stated that the global average temperature has increased 0.6C in the last century. He admits it is occurring. He just doesn't think it's because of CO2.
However, another global warming expert:
[i] James E. Hansen, a climate scientist at the Goddard Institute for Space Studies estimated a climate sensitivity of 3?4 degrees Celsius. Hansen based this estimate on evidence from ice cores. According to Hansen: "Dick's idea that climate sensitivity is low is simply wrong, [...] The history of the earth proves him wrong."[/i]
Hansen quotes scientific study of the evidence from the study of known data, not subjective opinion as Lindzen proposes.
Anyways, enough diatribe.
You keep believing in the hypothetical information given you.
I'll keep attuned to what international panels of experts (most with 20-40 years of study in the field) say on the topic in relation to scientific research and analysis.
Anyways...blah blah blah on.
by oz_media
by jck
Just like most of the people who try to discredit Global Warming with conjecture and estimation, they also try to blame Obama for legislation he has no part in writing.
Obama can tell his party all he wants to take a direction, but they are like a bunch of unruly, rebellious kids. They will only do, in the end, what he wants.
Same for the politics involved in climate change and global warming. The reports have facts. If all you are gonna do is base your conventions on a summary rather than the data, you might as well have never even considered it and just based it on the temperature outside your house on an arbitrary day.
by jck
the first rooster and hen came from an "egg".
Perhaps they were not ovoviviparous?
by sampetrova
The above thought is smart and doesn?t require any further addition. It?s perfect thought from my side.
****
sam
caravans for sale
by oz_media
Sell your caravan at "cravanmarket" :D
Obviously whoever made that site has no idea of who AdPerfect is.
by oz_media
by oz_media
by oz_media
by oz_media
I am referring to one piece, which represents exactly how someone can create a full blown, BS story in a pathetic attempt to gain some popularity amongst the public.
The fact that it's just one piece that supports such a radical claim, which Max dug out like finding buried treasure, is the sad part.
by jck
even admits the global temperature average has warmed.
He just says it's not mostly contributable to CO2 from anthropogenic sources.
He never denies it. :)
by oz_media
It's just soem absolutely ridiculous junk that Max dug up to support his desires. nothing in it states anything that supports either the title, opening paragraphs or max's post.
It's just a bunch of headline text used to sensationalis a rather mundane article, proving nothing but a scientist with a messy office.
I've been in a few such offices at UBC and it makes me feel neat and tidy. In a stack like that, a 20 year old collection of data plus all other previous paperwork that has crossed his desk, it doesn't phase me at all that such documents aren't close at hand for quick reference when some whiner holds out his hand.
I'm sure he's actually worked on other things in the last 20 years.
This article was just a waste of space with hardly a shred of fact to support it, besides a cluttered office.
by tonythetiger
misses the bigger picture. Look at all the things that are "falling apart". They ARE related!
The kings of the world are in a game of strip poker, and they're all losing!
by oz_media
Glad to hear that you think you are more astute and in the know than all the world's politicians and science community.
You and your political fear, LOL.
What the hell are you doing in iT?
is why anyone would believe what the media says.
Either way.
by oz_media
It takes time to research something and make up your own mind, people think they are too busy so they just pick their news flavour of choice and go with it.
It happens all the time here (TR), as I am sure you see also, people post such rubbish that is so easily dismissed and proven false, because they can't be bothered to read through it to research it, whether climate change, politics, health care, education, new technology etc., we've seen it all.
To some people, having a single source for all life's news seems sufficient to them.
by boxfiddler Hot topic
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
Both sides of the issue, don't know. They believe.
It's only percieved as a deception by those who believe the opposite.
You'd have as much luck getting 'proof' from Stumpy and Max on this issue, as you would from me and the pope on the existence of God.
Which one you believe is down to which belief you hold....
Don't tell me it's a scientific question, I'll laugh my arse off. An outcome from an eco-political value systems quite possibly,
But's that's like justifiying the existance of Jesus, because he was God's son....
Examine your assumptions and your motives. Choose who to support, review regularly, is all an objective person can do.
by jdclyde
Neil, I would like to point out some differences if you'll spare me a minute.
I wasn't offended, I just don't like to hear/see His name used that way. True christians don't EVER start fights about this, you're correct, that's up to God.
If I were in a crowd of strangers, I would not presume to try to censor what anyone was saying - I'm a big proponent of free speech.
This is not, however, a crowd of strangers, and I believe I have the right to ask an almost friend to do me a favor just as he has the right to say no.
I'll say it again, this has nothing to do with who's right or wrong, I just made a polite request.
It depends on the circumstances and on my mood. In this particular case I didn't post to insult, just to say "Hey, don't get so uptight.". Santee posted as you can see above and I just felt the need to ask Jack why he thought his particular beliefs were so important.
Santee is nicer than me - although he hasn't edit the post, I notice.
Neil :)
Everything that we say that is anything other than totally bland is going to upset someone, somewhere. This country is full of laws against "hate crime" which is interpreted by some as the need to prevent anything that might ruffle the sensibilities of one group or another. Well, I say "Hey, I don't hate you but you do and say an awful lot of things that I don't like! And I'm not allowed to tell you so."
Mostly it's religions that that "need" such protection and I fail to see why they think they need it and why we feel obliged to supply it. Stop treating your women badly, making them wear such ridiculous clothes. WHY can't women be priests? You believe WHAT?
(That last one's aimed at Scientology).
(Among others)
(Many others)
(OK, most)
(But DEFINITELY Scientology)
by oz_media
"They will only do, in the end, what he wants."
I think you meant to say,
"They will only do, in the end, what THEY want."
Your point is still clear though.
by jck
Hard to write things when you're also thinking about how to patch a dataset because an end-user ran a process before they were supposed to.
Ugh. Okay. I gotta go again. More SQL scripts to write. Yay? lol
by oz_media
?
Edit:
Or you confuse me for someone who cares.
Like I've said in previous messages, the politics of personal destruction is alive and well at the TR water cooler. When one can't debate the issue, then the standard tactic it to attack the person.
Edit 2:
Gee, I just did it again, didn't I?
by ic-it
Even then the main thrust is that a few loose cannons made headlines and now
quote- But there's no doubt that climategate has spurred at least some reporters to scrutinize the IPCC's headline-grabbing claims in a way they had rarely done previously. -end quote
Ok major revelation - not.
by oz_media
"Has spurred some reporters to scrutinize..."
Uh, yeah, they get paid to do just that. So reporters are now deemed fact finding scientists and the word of truth?
Man, what a waste.
by tig2
And Max posts it, Oz isn't far behind.
Some things never change. I find this oddly comforting.
by tonythetiger
by oz_media
I have supported Max many times when he offers actual facts on a subject.
However in his quest to be a hack journalist/troll, posting spew from the most ridiculous sources and hoping nobody actually investigates his claims, I can't help but laugh and post reality to balance the scales.
Now there's a long sentence!
by tig2
That I love you for that?
My God is not so fragile that He can't stand to hear what people say about Him. Frankly, I get a mental image of Him rocked back on His heels and laughing at so many of us. But then, the God of my faith is also capable of taking to the pub, buying you a pint, and engaging in conversation.
Of course, your mileage may vary.
..... that Al Gore is a liar and a fraud - the equivalent of an environmental comb-over; he tries to make something look like it's there, but it's not really there.
http://www.nypost.com/p/pagesix/global_cooling_7njz5ZtpFblMuF5Vf7LJmN
by ic-it
Unusual weather is a part of climate change.
The nations listed are exploring ways to minimize.
This was just Donald (in his ignorance) drawing a laugh (from his gof club cronies, no less). Here is the whole article.
Donald Trump is not a big believer in global warming. "With the coldest winter ever recorded, with snow setting record levels up and down the coast, the Nobel committee should take the Nobel Prize back from Al Gore," the tycoon told members of his Trump National Golf Club in Westchester in a recent speech. "Gore wants us to clean up our factories and plants in order to protect us from global warming, when China and other countries couldn't care less. It would make us totally noncompetitive in the manufacturing world, and China, Japan and India are laughing at America's stupidity." The crowd of 500 stood up and cheered.
by jck
who lets investors take the financial brunt of his bad deals, while he protects his personal wealth behind bankruptcy law and avoids paying his debts in a timely manner and under terms of the loan agreement.
e.g.-
Trump Taj Mahal
Trump Towers - Chicago
Trump Towers - Tampa
Talk about a liar and a fraud. Promises the world to everyone who'll put faith in him, and then half the time loses money for them.
There's a guy I'd trust to be fair and honest.
He's also the guy that said:
[b]"Show me someone without an ego, and I'll show you a loser."[/b]
Donald Trump, [i]How to Get Rich[/i]
Okay, Donald...how about:
Jesus Christ
What a loser, huh?
by oz_media
Fortunately for him, one success makes him millions.
He's the first one to admit the billions he's lost and how many times he's had to rely on others to help him stay afloat.
"Okay, but give me another chance anyway"
Should be his corporate slogan.
by oz_media
Who teh hell cares what Donald says, he's not a scientist in any way shape or form. You may as well say, even Donald Duck thinks so.
And why are you still arguing what some extremist tool, Gore, known by the global population to be a complete fool, had to say?
Real GW scientists don't support Gore or Trump, h=one's a politician the other an entrepreneur, neither isn a scientist, who gives a rat's arse what they say or think.
Their rantings are about as qualified and credible as your own.
Your arguments are so out of date on this suhject, I often wonder why you bother to regurgitate such rubbish and refuse to ignore proven science for the sake of political posturing.
You may as well be arguing that the world isn't flat.
by jck
At least he quoted research by scientists.
Donald just quotes himself.
buggered!
The only truth in either for or against human caused climate change belief, is some people see a way to gain power, others see their power being eroded.
Whether we cook or freeze is irrelevant to you people.
Meanwhile, I'll buy goods that last, and keep them until they don't work. Use public transport, grow plants, only eat things in season, recycle anything I can, and point out to people yourself and Tarquin the tree hugger, that I see no difference between you.
You're denying that the sky could ever fall, Tarquin is flying around saying it is...
Neither one of you makes sense to me.
[b]Fact One:[/b]
There never were any real [i]facts[/i] to conclusively [/i]prove[/i] the notion of mm gw/cc, only assertions to suggest a theory (none of which have been fully provided for peer review), all based on incomplete and/or flawed computer models, and all to support twenty-plus years of predictions - none of which have come true.
[b]Fact Two:[/b]
And today, we see the global warming house of cards falling down all around us. None of it has - or ever will - stand up under even the slightest bit of scrutiny.
[b]Fact Three[/b]
The real [i]deniers[/i] are the ones who continue clinging onto the notion of mm gw/cc.
I've said it for years, and I say it today. The notion of mm gw/cc is arguably the biggest lie in the history of the world.
By the way, Oz, I never thought you were a mm gw/cc extremist/zealot. I always thought you were a [i]just in case[/i] kinda' guy. And now that their arguments are falling apart all around us, you decide to jump on the bandwagon. Interesting. You must get thrills from riding bandwagons off of cliffs.
by oz_media
[b]FACT 1:[/b] There are absolutely NO facts to the contrary of scientific conclusions. Just more theories. I'll accept scientific conclusions until proven false or until FACTS appear to tha contrary, as you say "just in case".
[b]Fact 2:[/b]Is not a fact at all. GW stands up against a lot of scientific scrutiny, if it didn't we wouldn't be havign this debate. You simply deny sciencific theory being a result of fact based conclusions. Climate change is an undeniable fact, as is the increase of CO2 during such climate changes. To deny the Earth's cycle of warming and cooling simply demonstrates a lack of education. Your dismissal that 'man didn't make it happen', results in your disbelief of the entire Earth cycle. Just like the BS articles you keep posting, you need to learn how to determine fact from fictional/sensationalized press.
[b]FACT 3[/b] Is also not a fact at all, it is simply your personal disbelief. Are you now suggestin gthat if you don't believe then it is a fact? YOu believe in religion don't you? Well you play on the side of safe anyway, meaning that you accept faith as much as history and facts anyway.
" The notion of mm gw/cc is arguably the biggest lie in the history of the world."
Your belief as to what is lies vs what is truth is irrelevant to this part of the thread.
You state your beliefs as if they are facts, though with no proof whatsoever. What you consider proof is just some ridiculous news piece that even contradicts it's own false opening comments. Your PROOF had mroe holes than a seive.
[i]"By the way, Oz, I never thought you were a mm gw/cc extremist/zealot."[/i]
You are right, I am not a zealot at all. My dismissal of contradictors bullshlt doesn't make me an extremist or zealot.
My views are not extrame, your support for utter rubbish certainly is though.
I am also neither Jewish nor am I fnatically comitted. Like a scientist, I welcome proof either way.
Unlike yourself, I don't dismiss globally shared and factually supportd scientific conclusions, to support absolute BS that works in my favour.
Nothing at all is fallign apart all around me. GW isw only a real issue of debate in the USA. Most nations, with an acceptable scientific culture and history agree, it's just the handful of others, such as the still faith based USA, who won't wake up and do something about it. You feel it is political. God didn't tell you to believe in politics, so it must be wrong.
I'm not on anyone's bandwagon. I simply recognize that science proves the Earth is warming and cooling, that CO2 is a huge issue behind such patterns and thay we emit CO2 and thousands of other gases into the atmosphere in immense amounts.
Yourself you feel man didn't cause it so it isn't happening, and then post some insanely stupid article, offering proof of NOTHING, as your proof.
You sir are on a bandwagon, not I.
By your own admission (albeit many years past), you were (and still are?) a political novice when you first started to reply to my messages. By you own admission (albeit many years past), your motivation was (and still is?) nothing more than a lame attempt at stirring the pot.
YOU try getting things right, Oz; then - and only then - are you worthy of being taken seriously. Until then ......... you fall somewhere between a joke and a legend in your own mind.
by oz_media
That many years ago I had little or no interest in US politics?
You also failed to recignize that (over the years) I have been urged (by yourself)to learn more about US politics in order to prove your attempts at political mudslinging as BS, which I did. Note, more specifically, the US's view of global politics, I don't give a crap what happens with your internal issues.
As it sits now, when we discuss recent politics, I am as well versed as anyone and in many cases, moreso than a lot of people here. Now that's a scary reality!
While you are more focused on personal attacks than proving your false claims correct:
Regardless of the fact that politics is irrelevant in the debate of scientific facts, you have a constant habit of posting BS articles and online blogs, that are full of holes and can be easily seen through... well, for most people here anyway.
When you post something, it is usually only a headline or opening paragraph that supports your desired conclusion, beyond that it falls flat on its face.
It's either a failure by yourself to understand the material you present or you assume that people are too ignorant to read through it and see the holes themselves.
You can't possibly hope to convince anyone that the reason for this entire thread was not based on a contradictory and unsupported BS news piece that you grabbed and posted just to "stir the pot".
As for stirring the pot, yes, in many cases I do like to play and have fun in the political arena, mainly because Americans are so politically defensive and get personally upset over their political preference being challenged. Note that it is something that merely exists in the US, in other nations people are happy to agree to that fact that their politicians are all clowns and completely screwed in the head.
I don't often defend a Canadian or British politician, if I can think of doing it once at all. I concede, NO politician is worth their time in office, I don't think they are correct, they make horrendous decisions at the cost of the citizens whether for or against their party.
Politicians are a joke, Bush, Obama, Clinton, Regan, Harper, Cretien, Blaire, Howard et al. They are crooks and not worth the time nor effort defending.
I simply don't accept it when someone stands behind a politician and makes excuses their constant f-ups, as you did for 8 years of Bush. And yes they were many concocted lies, not simple misunderstandings due to misinformation.
Now if yuo want to try and show some FACT in the article you posted that started this thread, or even begin to discount the gaping holes i pointed out in it, please do so.
Besides focusing on the BS you started this thread on, which you take great defense to, you have no leg to stand on.
I proved your excitement was due to a news piece that was full of contradicting crap, just in the way it was written. and you are yet to show otherwise.
So get off your high horse and support your statement that this article proves GW is "based on a false premise."
The article PROVES nothing of the sort, that's just your sensastional headline created merely for the sake of "stirring the pot."
Talk about the pot calling the kettle black.
[i]"YOU try getting things right, (Max); then - and only then - are you worthy of being taken seriously. "[/i]
.... you said nothing of substance.
Try again.
by oz_media
The burden is not mine any longer, you have no recourse, you failed and it's proven in your posts over and over again for everyone to see.
[b]FACT IS:[/b] I pointed out the obvious flaws in your "news" and you simply can't offer a single shred of proof to support your joke of a thread. That upsets you as your credibility was trampled on for all your 'peers' to read, no matter what you think of me or what titles you use in your posts, you can't change the simple fact that you were proven wrong.
Your only recourse has been to flame me, to suggest I don't understand politics which, whether right or wrong, is completely irrelevant.
You failed and it's clear, there's nothing you can do to change that.
Now you can/will continue to post your little comments and catchy titles, in hopes nobody has followed your inability to support your comments, but I've had enough of your constant hypocrisy.
If you feel otherwise, I challenge you to prove me wrong and your 'story' correct.
You won't though, as you simply failed again and can't prove otherwise.
Some idiots may buy what you consider "proof", anyone with a second brain cell won't, end of story.
by jck
His father was the real business success story.
"The Donald" is really nothing more than a bad speculative investor.
If he was a financial advisor, he'd have been working at Burger King long ago.
by delbertpgh
Although there are climatologists and geologists, all with PhDs, who would say otherwise (and get a lot of publicity for saying so), the great bulk of scientists in the field agree that (1) it's possible for human activity to affect climate, and (2) it probably already has. There's not a big debate about these two principles.
Although I'm skeptical of a lot of warming assertions, because this is an emerging field with a lot of unsettled doctrine, the scientists are way more likely to know what's going on than the average citizen, be that Sarah Palin, Mitch McConnell, Glenn Beck, or Pat Robertson. My confidence is with the nerds on this one.
by tonythetiger
[i]There are absolutely NO facts to the contrary of scientific conclusions.[/i]
as a scientific conclusion. Just ask Ptolemy.
by tonythetiger
by tonythetiger
[i][u][b]increased use of fossil fuels by people does not cause increased average global temperatures.[/b][/u][/i]
who has made that claim.
by jck
In 2004:
a) the Republican party
b) Bush's own administration/re-election team
c) those tied to petroleum entities such as Exxon-Mobil
Need the press info? here...
Quote:
[i]George W. Bush's campaign workers have hit on an age-old political tactic to deal with the tricky subject of global warming - deny, and deny aggressively.
The Observer has obtained a remarkable email sent to the press secretaries of all Republican congressmen advising them what to say when questioned on the environment in the run-up to November's election. The advice: tell them everything's rosy.
[b]It tells them how global warming has not been proved, air quality is 'getting better', the world's forests are 'spreading, not deadening', oil reserves are 'increasing, not decreasing', and the 'world's water is cleaner and reaching more people'.[/b]
The email - sent on 4 February - warns that Democrats will 'hit us hard' on the environment. 'In an effort to help your members fight back, as well as be aggressive on the issue, we have prepared the following set of talking points on where the environment really stands today,' it states.
The memo - headed 'From medi-scare to air-scare' - goes on: 'From the heated debate on global warming to the hot air on forests; from the muddled talk on our nation's waters to the convolution on air pollution, we are fighting a battle of fact against fiction on the environment - [b]Republicans can't stress enough that extremists are screaming "Doomsday!" when the environment is actually seeing a new and better day.'[/b]
Among the memo's assertions are 'global warming is not a fact', 'links between air quality and asthma in children remain cloudy', and the US Environment Protection Agency is exaggerating when it says that at least 40 per cent of streams, rivers and lakes are too polluted for drinking, fishing or swimming.
[b]It gives a list of alleged facts taken from contentious sources. For instance, to back its claim that air quality is improving it cites a report from Pacific Research Institute - an organisation that has received $130,000 from Exxon Mobil since 1998.[/b]
The memo also lifts details from the controversial book The Skeptical Environmentalist by Bjorn Lomborg. On the Republicans' claims that deforestation is not a problem, it states: 'About a third of the world is still covered with forests, a level not changed much since World War II. The world's demand for paper can be permanently satisfied by the growth of trees in just five per cent of the world's forests.'
[b]The memo's main source for the denial of global warming is Richard Lindzen, a climate-sceptic scientist who has consistently taken money from the fossil fuel industry. His opinion differs substantially from most climate scientists, who say that climate change is happening.[/b]
But probably the most influential voice behind the memo is Frank Luntz, a Republican Party strategist. In a leaked 2002 memo, Luntz said: 'The scientific debate is closing [against us] but not yet closed. There is still a window of opportunity to challenge the science.'
Luntz has been roundly criticised in Europe. Last month Tony Blair's chief scientific adviser, Sir David King, attacked him for being too close to Exxon.
Rob Gueterbock of Greenpeace condemned the messages given in the Republican email. He said: 'Bush's spin doctors have been taking their brief from dodgy scientists with an Alice in Wonderland view of the world's environment. They want us to think the air is getting cleaner and that global warming is a myth. This memo shows it is Exxon Mobil driving US policy, when it should be sound science.'
The memo has met some resistance from Republican moderates.
Republican Mike Castle, who heads a group of 69 moderate House members, senators and governors, says the strategy doesn't address the fact that pollution continues to be a health threat. 'If I tried to follow these talking points at a town hall meeting with my constituents, I'd be booed.'
Vermont Senator Jim Jeffords, who left the Republican Party in 2001 to become an independent partly over its anti-green agenda, called the memo 'outlandish' and an attempt to deceive voters.
'They have a head-in-the-sand approach to it. They're just sloughing off the human health impacts - the premature deaths and asthma attacks caused by power plant pollution,' Jeffords said.
Republican House Conference director Greg Cist, who sent the email, said: 'It's up to our members if they want to use it or not. We're not stuffing it down their throats.'
He said the memo was spurred by concerns that environmental groups were using myths to try to make the Republicans look bad.
'We wanted to show how the environment has been improving,' Cist said. 'We wanted to provide the other side of the story.'[/i]
- Antony Barnett, The Observer, 4 April 2004
Facts are:
- the Republican party and the Bush administration/campaign tried to deceive America on the topic
- the Republican party and the Bush administration/campaign tried to lead people to believing that [b]proven CO2 level increases[/b] have not caused global warming.
- Bush administration/campaign personnel and Republican party personnel backed and forwarded these deceptions as truth.
So, there you go.
Happy now?
P.S. - In case you think the Bush administration had no scientific data to show their/the Republican party's assertion to be wrong:
http://www.esrl.noaa.gov/gmd/aggi/
The NOAA has been showing it for years that CO2 has been building in the atmosphere.
by jck
the fact that people critical of global warming/climate change say that there is no proof that it is occurring (even tho the CO2 levels have been elevating for 100+ years and the average surface/sea temps have risen during that time).
However, they give no definitive proof that the conclusions, research, readings and studies are wrong.
They would ask pro-theory for proof.
They would ask for anti-theory for speculation.
Bias. Pure and simple.
by tonythetiger
Does not make sausage alike of climate and God.
Climate, though widespread, is easily and grammatically separable from existence, the two served on separate plates.
The existence [i]of[/i] God, they may not.
You and the Pope -- now, there's a pairing.
by jck
You can measure temperature, CO2, methane, ocean levels, etc.
You can't measure God.
by jck
by oz_media
You aren't so far off base. Your personal committment to being wiser in the use of resources is really a key personal factor. Unforunately, most people dismiss such efforts as a result of not "buying into" GW.
As if, because they don't feel it is correct for whatever reaons, they then don't have a reason to care about personally contributing to becoming more resourceful.
You would fare well with the one tonne challenge (reducing your carbon footprint by one tonne per year) just by doing the simple things you do. I'm sure it doesn't impede your lifestyle and you eat healthier too, well done!
I don't buy into heavy, government imposed industry regulations either, however they have proven they are not ready to become responsible for their own actions. they just point at China and say "well they aren't changing anything, why should I?"
Brings to mine the old jumping off a cliff scenario.
Sort by Trending