Question Locked

I have a bizarre remote desktop issue

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I own 2 businesses. I have had RDP setup on both business pc's and home pc for several years. All run xp pro. Suddenly, I can access business #2 from home but not business #1. However, I can log into the business #2 from home then log into business #2 from it. That tells me that there isn't a problem with business #1 accepting connections or home making connections. Anybody know what could be the problem? Thanks in advance.

Update... I went to business #1 and cannot connect to home but can thru business #2, so the communication problem seems to be between home and Business #1 and vice versa. They are the same internet provider but #2 is different.

11 replies

by older mycroft

"[i]I can log into the business #2 from home then log into [u]business #2[/u] from it.[/i]"

Assuming you meant 'business #1' then you have made an error in your assumptions.

"[i]That tells me that there isn't a problem with business #1 accepting connections or home making connections.[/i]"

[b]No it doesn't! Where in a connection between business#2 to business #1, does #1 have a direct connection to your home?[/b]

by balloonatix

I can log into #2 from home, then use rdp on #2 to log into #1 ( a round about way to connect to #1 from home) but I can't connect to #1 directly from home. All scenarios work fine except direct connection from home to #1 and from #1 to home. All other connection atempts work fine. Hope this clears it up.

by older mycroft

Home to #1 doesn't work.

But you were under the impression that it DID because you could connect through #2. ;)

by jmalerbi

Have you tried a simple system restore on number one to a date prior to when the problem started? All too often, we try to trouble shoot the hard way.

by balloonatix

simple brekadown

#1 to #2 works
#1 to homes DOES NOT WORK

#2 to #1 works
#2 to home works

home to #2 works
home to #1 DOES NOT WORK

home to #2 then #2 to #1 works

Everything worked fine until Saturday.

by older mycroft

Seriously. Depending on the geographical locations of #1 and #2, maybe an optic-fibre got compromised over the weekend.

Have you tried to 'start again' as if you never had an RDP between HOME & #1 ?

by balloonatix

Ironically both 1 and home are cable connections thru the same provider and all other internet related activity functions fine. #2 is DSL thru a different provider and everyhting else works fine.

I did delete the saved RDP files and created new ones but I didn't go so far as to uninstall the rdp feature from any pc's

by ranman60

I have seen mystery issues like this that worked fine then suddenly stopped working. Router firmware updates usually solve this.

Sounds like either home or #1 router needs to be checked for a firmware update. What kind of routers are you using?

by capt_skippy

Sounds like it could be a firewall issue. I would check to make sure nothing blocking the home computers ip address on computer #1.

by cnet19

Did you configure port forwarding in the router for business #1? Are you connecting directly to the public IP?

Some routers ask you what IP address to allow incoming connections from. Otherwise, there is nothing that should be preventing you from using RDP at business #1. I would try using another PC (besides the one at business #2) to attempt to connect directly to bus #1.

This discussion is closed to new replies.