Discussion Locked

If we all came from Monkeys, then???

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

For the sake of this discussion, we will ASSUME that evolution is more than the "Theory of".

If we are to accept that Man came from Apes (barring the question of why are there still apes then) why are there so many "races" that are so different from one another?

I understand the idea of life addapting to their environment, but how long does that take, and can it explain the vast differences between the differnt races?

Why would Japanese be so much smaller, while black and white races average so much taller? Different diet maybe?

I understand the eskimo body to concerve heat, but most others I just don't follow.

And how does this relate to certain races having less of a resistance to certain disease or lower/higher tolerance to booze?

And with more people moving to different climates, how long does it take to re-adapt to a new climate, even if breeding among other races did not happen?

And of course if we are all the human race, how can there be so many differenses in our DNA, from race to race?

If we all started from the same mold, how can we have become so different?

324 replies

by jmgarvin

I have a biologist wife so I've been forced to at least have an understanding:

a) Why are there still apes?

It doesn't work that way. That's like asking why is there still strawberry ice cream if I ate all the vanilla.

b) Races on the planet aren't different genetically. We're all homosapiens. We look a little different on the outside, but genetically we are all the same species.

c) Adaptation can take a short time (the moth example) or a very long time (humans)

d) Why are humans different on the outside then? Some of the environment plays into it. Other things as well. Humans are VERY adaptable. We can (and do) live anywhere on the planet. We're cool like that.

e) Booze, etc?? Well, this boils down to tolerance. I'm mostly irish, so I can hold my drink ;-) However, native americans didn't drink until the europeans showed up. Their bodies don't metabolize it as well. An example would be:
Go eat a mean you don't usually eat. Eg: If you eat mostly veggies, go eat a REALLY greasy meal at a BBQ joint. Tell me what happens...

f) Climatic adapation...I'm not sure I follow...

We're all genetically the same species, just different people. I suggest you check out Richard Leaky's book The Origin of Humankind (http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0465053130/sr=8-1/qid=1156133525/ref=pd_bbs_1/104-6815651-3999949?ie=UTF8)

Keep in mind a lot of people (mostly rasist) want you to believe that humans have slightly different DNA...this isn't true. If it were we'd be different species (and we aren't).

Why are we so different? It boils down to a few things, but honestly genetic diversity is GOOD for the species as you breed out the "bad" things...

Inbreeding is bad, right? Why? You get kids with flippers and 12 arms...if you don't inbreed you don't get that...so it is better NOT to do it...

by tonythetiger

simply makes recessive genes more likely to come out. That recessive trait could be a good one or a bad one. Unrelated people can also have good or bad recessive traits come out. The six fingers thing is just what people say to reinforce a social taboo.

by jdclyde

Is that just "what people say"?

We always see "in the movies" that the inbreeders (generations after generation) have more defects mentally and physically.

I have never seen or heard anything to say otherwise to make me question that. Are you saying it isn't so?

by jdclyde

I just threw that in because it makes me laugh, and wasn't really a part of the question. :D

We hear of studies recently that show different "races" living in the US are more prone to heart failure than others.

Note: I use the term "race" because that is the accepted term on all government forms, while acknowledging we are all the human race.

Not trying to say differnt is bad or play joe racist. Just was sitting around the other day and wondered why people physically from subrace to subrace are so different. Hight and shape is what I am looking at, not color. On the road right now, but will check your link later. Thanks.

by jmgarvin

So it boils down to certain races have DNA traits that show up more often than others.

It seems like this is due to:
A) proximity - breeding in the same proximity means you'll contain the same traits...that's why certain traits are being "breed out" now.
B) evolution to the environment - eg Sickle Cell keeps malaria at bay, but is dangerous to the person.

I'm no biologist, but it seems like it is simply a matter of evolution and breeding that keeps some things around (good and bad)

by tonythetiger

There are more things than just DNA that affect heart disease. Diet, amount of exercise, etc.

There is also a lot at stake. If they found a gene that predisposes one toward an expansive to get illness, it wouldn't be long until insurance companies started charging more, or refusing to provide coverage for people who had these genes.

by deadly ernest

1. Differences in DNA

Think of races and DNA as being different lanes in the same olympic swimming pool. Each is slightly different to the ones on each side, but all part of the same pool. Some are in the shade, and look whiter, some are in the direct sun, and look darker (due to the reflections stopping you looking into the water).

2. The differences in skin colour are due to thousands of years of living in environments with different heat, humidity, and sun levels. The darker skinned people were originally in hot dry tundra type climates. The white skinned people were in the cooler winter type climates, with snow. The Japanese were in a tropical type climate with a lot more heat, and humidity, and shade - thus they didn't need the extra dark colouring. This took place over many thousands of years.

NB: Some anthropologists now believe that the current race of man is a result of several groups branching off, and then blending back together, and the physiological variations are hang overs form those branchings.

3. Adaption changes re lightneing of skin due to evolution and the like - most estimate a couple of hundred thousand years.

4. DNA is so huge, and any one small change makes a change, that a 1% variation gives billions of options.

5. Many, so called humans, are not that far away from their monkey ancestors - just watch the Australian PArliament question time or the USA Congress and the way any politician behaviour - what a silly bunch of baboons.

6. The evolution experts recon we all, eveyr living thing on the planet, came from one original single celled bacteria or the like. Aren't you glad that cell bred a bit. Try typing as a single celled thingy.

by nicknielsen

There's no need for gratuitous insults by comparing baboons to politicians. My neighbor is a baboon and he does NOT appreciate it at all. :p

by jdclyde

Skin colo(u)r was the least of my wonders. The actual physical characteristics were more of a wonder to me as that would be less easily explained by the sun.

by deadly ernest

and the culture - in the long term.

Some 'racial' groups have wider noses, due to high humidity rates in the climate they had lived in for hundreds of thousands of years. Most orientals have a slightly different intestinal system to caucasian as they are used to eating lots of rice while the caucasians are used to lots of red meat - they process at differernt speeds. Live in jungle over enough generations and your average height shortens - survival factor for getting through the jungle. Live in a tundra and height goes up, need height to see further. Sunnier climate and you need deeper eyebrow ridges and eye sockets.

All the variations, which are less than about 0.000000001% of the DNA, are due to improved survivability in a particular sub-climate ove a looooong period.

by tonythetiger

or in this case, mutation. Mutations are always occurring, in a way you could say they are "natural". The successful ones thrive and become entrenched in their environment. The unsuccessful ones usually don't survive long enough to breed, and without intervention would eventually be weeded out.

by Member 27734917

Hi JD,

First I must appreciate your questions. Some of them are thought provoking but almost all of them do not account the various milestones in the evolution of Earth (not just humans). You talk about evolution of man from apes etc but where do you think the chickens came from ? (this, considering the fact (?) that chicken came first than the eggs :) ).

Next, the heat, skin, races etc - as the other two people replied aptly, it is all to do with where u live what u eat and HOW you live (lifestyles).

Some of your words do not have the proper fact - for example, "if we all started from the same mo(u)ld, how can ... so different ?". Who told you that we all started from the same mould ? You seem to talk like there was a moulding machine in Amazon forest and people were generated and pumped up in the air in to the world. Then what about Chickens, pigs, goats, buffalos, horses etc etc ? They are all living beings too.

Like the other person rightly said, every single life started from a single cell organism. I would like to add the term mutation in addition to the adaptation that happened over millions of years after the big meteor strike that wiped off the giants from the face of the Earth.

So tell me one thing - did you actually write this after a good booze ?

by aliv4279

Hi, your observations are correct - all you need to figure in is that 'some-one' did some genetic modification (very good at it, too!). If you take your thought a little further, I'm sitting here looking at my two puppies - and thinking - how come we both have eyes, nose, mouths etc. Different species, but clearly someone was working with systems that they knew and understood!

regards

Andrew L

by mjd420nova

Humans didn't evolve from the apes, they are just a similar branch of the complex construction of DNA that makes up all things. We are what we are from the beginning, maybe adding a few mutations along the way, but are not evolved from the apes. Don't mean to rattle anyones cage but that's the path that has been taken. We were human to start and will be to the end. We have just learned to use what we have better than any other bi-pedal species. The creatures in the sea are just as complex and have learned how to master their envirionment just like we have.

by deadly ernest

can get boozed out of his mind and reach an alcohol content of 0.70 in his blood, while still seated. Now go learn some manner and and teach your son the same. Stop hiding under the table to drink - bloody closet drinkers.

NB legal limit around here is 0.06 and anything above 0.5 is supposed to be potentially lethal.

by gadgetgirl

some of us are still working on it.....

Only given half a chance, of course!!

:D

GG

(Pass the gin, please.... :p )

by jck

What doesn't kill us only makes us stronger...

or develop cirrohsis :D

by mark.barker

The theory of evolution does not claim that man evolved from monkeys, only that at some point in the distant past the great apes and humans shared a common ancestor. THAT is why we "still have monkeys"

by jdclyde

goes for the easy out. I was friggen JOKING with that part!

Got any import on the rest? And NO, not skin color!

:D

by tony hopkinson

All the guys with a serious tan who came North were a bit too visible in the snow and invisible in the caves. So if they managed not to get eaten on the way home, they starved to death when they got there.

Richard Prior claimed that we turned white because we was hiding in the caves from bears and stuff, so it's a sort of prison pallor.

As for the major characteristics like say the epicanthic fold which is apparently an adaption during the ice age, after that you can only imagine they finished up in china and then their population exploded. So they ended up with no one without an epicanthic fold in their starting gene pool.

That's the theory anyway. There's a lot of ifs may bes ,could be's and shrugs in it though.

by tonythetiger

Environment does have an effect, which gets reinforced and/or amplified with repeated breeding within that environment. In the dog world they do this on purpose to either breed out undesirable traits and breed in desirable ones.

Humans unconsciously try to do the same thing when they select a mate. The reason you are attracted to a certain "type" is that you subconsciously think that mating with that type will produce offspring with a better chance of surviving/thriving in this environment. The higher brain function of humans often gets in the way of that, though, when you start looking at things like did they come from the wrong side of the tracks, or what other people would think of your selection, etc.

by jamesrl

Take a look at Africa.

In eastern Africa, where there are grasslands and people were herders, people grew up to be tall and thin. Think of all those great runners from Kenya and Ethiopia. In Western Africa, where there is jungle and people were hunters, they grew up stocky and strong.

Similarly in China, people in the North are taller and thinner, in the south shorter and stockier.

I cannot help but to think that over the course of many hundreds and thousands of years, geography played a role in shaping this differences.

I do not believe in race. One biologist once said that the skin colour differences we have are less than the difference between a golden labrador and a black lab. If the old saying about humans and chimpanzees sharing 99% of DNA is true, than how small is the difference between those of different skin colour. Behavioural differnces that are often attributed to race to me are cultural rather than racial.

James

by jdclyde

to answering the question out of them all.

I figured Neil would have a good answer for me...

Please see further up for my disclaimer on the use of the word "race". This was not meant as a devide discussion or politics or any of that other rubbish. Just a "why is he so tall while this other guy is so small"?

by x-marcap

The Quoted phrase is Chemistry.

We share 99% of the same chemistry with slugs too.

The differences come from the bonding and the sequencing of the acids.

A Pig is a Pig. A man is a man. We can take a valve from a Pig heart and put it in a man. that doesn't make the man a Pig. For that manner we can use a whole Pig heart. That doesn't change the replicating RNA/DNA.

By the way, the unnamed biologist was full of it. A Yellow Lab and a Black Lab and Chocolate Labs are far mor closely related than mere humans are. (repeated inbreeding to get the desired dog body,shape,nose,type,color.)

by Member 25348569

It's the other way round. Most equatorial races should have a shorter torso and longer arms and legs so that they have more surface area to remove heat. This is the body shape of a lot of black races (win all of the sprints, provide your basketball players). The cooler climes tend to favour people with shorter limbs and stockier bodies (Russian weightlifters and shot-putters) and the middle latitudes win all of the swimming. This is Allen's Rule in action.

Skin colour is down to vitamin D and melanoma. Too much sun gives you skin cancer while too little gives you vitamin D deficiancy. Optimum survival is to balance it out. Population mobility is screwing it all up! Without atificially enhanced milk, rickets and osteoporosis would happen a lot more in African-Americans than it does - it's already higher than whites. Interestingly, the incidence of rickets in African-Americans can be increased by feeding kiddies on "healthy" breast milk - which obviously isn't fortified!

Without eating whale blubber, which contains a lot of vitamin D, the Inuits wouldn't survive as they are quite dark skinned - probably because they haven't been in the North long enough to select.

Other climate adaptations to cold are fat distribution to protect vital organs and different blood flow patterns.

Or maybe God done it?

Neil :D

by tonythetiger

My sister had to have her gall bladder removed. So did her twin daughters. Some then thought that gall bladder disease must be hereditary, but in fact it was merely because all three shared the same diet!

by nicknielsen

from the genetics work we did in biology class, regressive traits become more common in a limited gene pool. This is given as the reason for the high incidence of hip dysplasia in many purebred dog breeds.

What's truly funny is that I went through basic training with a guy from Tennessee. He was from "up'ar bah three staetes, a coupla hollers aht from Bristol." As we all did when we were young, he once performed a most egregiously stupid act. When asked "Were your parents cousins?" his response was "Yeah. Why?"

On further quetioning, we determined that his parents were NOT first cousins nor even second cousins; it was just that family meant a lot up there, so people kept track.

by tonythetiger

also are more common when both parents have the recessive gene. The difference is, in a limited gene pool, there's a better chance of getting a mate with the same recessive gene. And again, not all recessive genes are bad. Some people have a "defective" t-cell construction that the HIV virus cannot attach to, for example. Meaning they get it, but it doesn't hurt them.

by jdclyde

I put that disclaimer at the top to ASSUME that this was the only explaination. Wasn't looking for anything but the evolutionist answer.

by x-marcap

My textbook was wrong 30+ years ago.

Adenine was described as a Nitrous based acid...
but is always a weak base.

Thymine bonds to a phophorous for a weak phosphoric acid in the structure of the link

Uracil is a very weak acid. that bonds to the sugar.

Guanine is a very weak acid, it
Depending upon where they bond with the sugars, they can actually be acidic or basic...

That is corrected in newer releases of PDR,and after the 1973 release of
G. D. Fasman, Handbook of Biochemistry and Molecular Biology. 1975 release has it corrected. Can you guess which one I have and have studied???

Thanks Neil, Now something make sense, Why a particular compound causes cancer (for example).

Amazing how incorrect memorized information can haunt you...

I stand corrected.

by onbliss

...remember what I memorized 30 seconds ago. And here you are remembering something you read/memorized 30+ years ago. Hats off to you (or to your brain power).

by Member 25348569

No big deal as I was just having a small dig. No offense (well, a very little) meant. :)

One thing, though. As I said to ProtiusX in the Evolution Lie thread, mentioning Uracil is posing. :) Missing out Cytosine...oops! :(

I can't really post anything wonderful on the mechanisms of carcinogens as the real hows and whys of cancers are still incompletely understood. I could post theories that I've read but that's all that they would be. Mutagen mechanisms is a less complex subject. In the scope of this thread, mutagenicity seems the most likely on-topic. You might want to track down the Evolution Lie thread (DO NOT POST TO IT!) and read all 2500 posts where we covered a lot of this.

Neil :)

by onbliss

Wow, I keep hearing amazing nutritional facts about breast milk. Are'nt humans the only animals that find it necessary to drink the milk of other animals? Is'nt calcium available anywhere else?

by Member 25348569

it's because human breast milk is nutritionally designed for baby humans and for the more simple sorts, that obviously equates to "always best". Most of the time, it is. There are various reasons why women don't breast feed but what was interesting about the research on breast-feeding African Americans in the USA was that they [b]shouldn't[/b]!

One study suggests that the dramatic increase in rickets frequency in Georgia is mainly due to three things: drinking milk substitutes that do not contain vitamin D, the failure to supplement breast milk, and insufficient exposure to sunlight.

by onbliss

...when you get the chance, can you post a link to the research work. There must have been ample evidence to not recommend break milk.

Our son's paediatrician, in India, had recommended early morning exposure to sunlight (funny in India) for 5-10 mintues, for controlling any infant-jaundice that would develop in the first few days/weeks.

by jdclyde

to breast feed. The midnight feedings! ;\ No no, pumps are not natural, and only straight from the tap is good enough for my boys! :D

Unfortunately, after a month, the cow dried up.... :0

by onbliss

JD, allow me to nitpick little bit :-)

Your title says "If we all came from Monkeys, then???" and in the content you say "If we are to accept that Man came from Apes".

I think we can not just interchange the words monkeys and apes, as they are different from each other.

And, also apes and hominids (early human ancestors) just shared a common ancestor way back :-) It was not that some apes evolved into hominids.

by onbliss

Here is a very interesting essary that I read sometime back on the subjects of Primates and humans. Though it is not directly connected to any of your questions, I thought some one might enjoy this lengthy essay.

Enjoy... http://www.foreignaffairs.org/20060101faessay85110/robert-m-sapolsky/a-natural-history-of-peace.html

[b]Summary:[/b] Humans like to think that they are unique, but the study of other primates has called into question the exceptionalism of our species. So what does primatology have to say about war and peace? Contrary to what was believed just a few decades ago, humans are not "killer apes" destined for violent conflict, but can make their own history

by onbliss

I think it is Arabic.

Don't the elephants kind of "guard" their injuired for sometime too?

Oh well, as long as we keep talking about animals we should be on-topic :-)

by jellimonsta

Doves
The most famous bird of love is the dove. Doves have been associated with love and marriage for thousands of years. Their loyalty to each other and their joint care for their family is legendary.

Canadian Geese
It wasn't that long ago that the Canadian Goose was an endangered bird. Now it's extremely populous and can be found just about anywhere in the eastern US and Canada. Canadian Geese are extremely loyal and if one of a pair is injured, the other will stay with the injured bird and guard it until it's better. Both will actively protect and care for their young.

American Bald Eagle
Bald Eagles have come back from an endangered status and have rebuilt a stable population. Eagle pairs mate for life and build a large nest together high in a safe location. There they tend to and raise the few chicks they hatch each year, training the young eagle in the difficult task of carving a living out of their harsh environment.

Swans
Swans are large birds with long lives, and they are aggressively loyal. They defend each other and their young chicks fiercely, taking over a pond or lake and making it theirs. One of the more famous swans in the US is the Mute Swan, which was introduced in New York in the 1800s.

Source http://www.bellaonline.com/articles/art10089.asp

by tonythetiger

In some states it's legal for first cousins to marry, others it's not. I've not seen any data to suggest that the states that allow it have a higher incidencd of "abnormal children", though if it were, do you think they would include as "abnormal" any heightened abilities, super-genius, etc.?

It's all part of human nature, that's all... if the abnormality is bad, somebody must have done something wrong to cause it. If the abnormality is good, it's considered a gift.

by rain.longson

We are decendant's of monkey's but note that we are not exactly developed to survive on this planet without tools and clothing. The environment is to too much one way or another. We can do a lot of things that most other creatures can do here on earth swimm - not for long. Run/sprint some people better than others but no where near as well as some animales etc.

My theory goes back, way back to pint in time tousands of years ago. Aliens crash landed on this planet, being stuck here they decided to use the apes they found locally as slave labour (the way we do horses etc). Being lonely out here waiting probably for a very long time for help to come along they probably and most likely did what some shepards have been accused of doing with some of their flock. But in the case of the aliens, they created a 'hybrid' species - us after diidling the local help. And that is my theory as to how we came about. When help came they left the planet and all of the mutants which continued to develop into us.

by deadly ernest

The only reason he would be standing on the street, would be that the bar he was in had shut and he's looking for another - normally he'd be sitting in a bar or pub drinking.

by deadly ernest

quite enough alcohol content for that to be good enough for a spelling mistake. For a bery goos dpellinf midtake you nees a hood (hiuuc).

by oz_media

You nearly contradict yourself.

Why are there still apeas then? There are MANY species of Ape. Just as there are still fish in teh ocean and yet we entertain the Darwin theory of evolution. If fish grew legs why are there still fish? It's pretty simple minded really.

Why are there so many races? There are many breeds of Dog, many breeds of Ape, Fish, Birds etc. Why wouldn't there be many breeds of another evolved being?

Now to really cast light on realitic thought here, the alternative is that some invisible being, a higher intelligence nobody has even seen nor proven, created the entire universe and created all planets and all life upon them, like some magician with a new wand.

We have watched species adapt and evolve, we haven't watch anyone make a species yet though.

by oz_media

That's why the topic will always raise question, there si no proof of anything. We can speculate, we can debate, we can build LOGICAL arguments but nobody will be proven wrong until we prove otherwise.

On life and death, as someone who has been declared clinically dead and then actually awokenfrom a deep coma to live another (18 years so far) I have a pretty different outlook. I have feelings based on spirituality, I have feelings based onscientific knowledge too.

When I woke, I noticed how the trees ouside looked superimposed, how air seemed cool and frech, how water actuaally had a thousand flavours, quite honestly it was like a teenage acid trip. Everything wasn't surreal, it was just REAL.

No white tunnels, no light to follow, no relatives in white or anything like that, but just a 'feeling' that I had seen or realized something I couldn't see or realize in a/my concious world.

I am not religious nor do I claim to have had a religious experience, quite the opposite actually.

FACT: Energy can neither be created or destroyed.
FACT: Energy always exists but can and does change its form accordingly.

So based on these simple realities, I feel that it only logical that our bodies do harness an energy that is laterreleased when our bodies die. NOw whether that energy is simply turned into heat (in th ecaseof cremation) or some formof soil nutrient in teh caseof burial, I am not going to imply. But we are simply a walking power plant. Liquids, fat, electicity. We are living batteries, when we die, I feel that energy can take on many different forms. This would also explain dancing lights in the air, energy FELT by a paranormal, hot and cold rooms, closing doors etc. Energy is force, our energy will remain long after our body dies. Sometime that energy is harnessed and won't leave a specific area, thus we find paranormal activity where people have passed.

Hey it's a theory, I didn't sit down and think it out it was just a realization after being dead myself.

I have a unique and rather calming view of life, death and human energy.

I don't expect anyone to buy into my theory. Why would you if you hadn't experienced the same things I have? In fact it's not even a theory really, just a feeling and sudden calmness I found after gaining a new life.

It is MY faith, and just like everyone else in th eworld, we all have some form of faith, in my caseit's faith that if I do what I feel is right, I am on the right path to a happy life.

by jdclyde

I am not surprised at all that you would spin off in that direction rather than approach the real questions put forward. Questions that have gotten some decent answers, just not from you.

Not here to discuss my religion, or your lack of. Maybe next time.

by oz_media

Why even post such a waste of a comment?

I was responding to your most predictable post. Just your opening comments raised questions yet alone the whole post. My comment was a direct answer to the opening questions you raised. If you weren't expecting someone to comment on your words, why type them?
Or is this one of those US conformity posts where everyone just pertends to have the same view and just agree out of fear of being different?

What's with YOUR last post anyway? You offered nothing to rebut my comments at all, yet still complained i hadn't answered "p[roperly"?

FO, all you did was whine like some little bitch.

Why evern start a thread if you can take the reply's unless they fit your predetermined conclusions? What a tool!

Sometimes you can be such a f****n' joke, you pretend to be articulate and eloquent then ask idiotic, unanswerable questions and complain about replies? Get a life.

by jmgarvin

We have things like Ligers and Donkeys. We've also created (from "nothing") viruses in a lab environment. Cloning has also come a very long way in a short time...We've seen "mixing" of species (although is it a new species??)

So it is possible, just hasn't been done yet (on a large scale and introduced to the wild...)

by Member 25348569

New species of virus tends not to impress the God-botherers so we need to demonstrate in something BIG.

Darwin charted the finches in the Galapagos and the way that isolated populations were developing different traits but these were still not really separate species as they could all breed back.

The key requirement for something to be a new species is that they cannot mate successfully with the origin species.

We could do it with, say, dogs (if there was any point) by breeding to change the mating triggers until we got to the point where "dog" wouldn't know that "nudog" was a potential mate and vice versa. At that point we'd be well on the way.

New species tend to arise in separated populations of a few individuals where the "no mating with the main gene pool" is enforced initially by geography. When the two populations eventually get together they remain separate because they can't or won't mate.

Unfortunately this only happens in any large scale following some form of major catastrophe that thins out the population to the point that mutations matter.

Let's not bother.

:D

by Member 27734917

I suppose the inbreeding that you are referring to with problems is the ones where blood relations are involved (i.e., a very close relative). When the relationships are not that close, it is ok and not a problem.

by jdclyde

breeding within the same small group? How far out on a limb of the family tree does it have to be?

As long as "new blood" gets mixed in along the way, how much of a difference does that make?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inbreeding
[i]"Inbreeding is breeding between close relatives, whether plant or animal. If practiced repeatedly, it often leads to a reduction in genetic diversity, and the increased expression of negative recessive traits, resulting in inbreeding depression. This may result in inbred individuals exibiting reduced health and fitness and lower levels of fertility.

Livestock breeders often practice inbreeding to "fix" desirable characteristics within a population. However, they must then cull unfit offspring, especially when trying to establish the new and desirable trait in their stock."[i]

by Member 25348569

As I'm sitting at home and have nothing better to do, I'll feed you a few things to chew on. Concentrate, now. It's not difficult but you will need to think about it.

The general differences between races of humans comes from the fact that groups seem to have spread out from the original "source" of "modern human" in Africa in different directions at different times in the last 100,000 years or so. There are some indications that there was, around this time, some form of "population bottleneck" where the number of humanity was severely reduced and the subsequent expansion from this small base led to what we see today.

As the migrating groups were quite small they tended not to carry a full set of all of the racial characteristics and associated genes that were in the origin population. This is called the "founder effect". In addition, as the migrating founder groups move further apart from other migrating groups and the ancestral population, the probability that mating outside of the founder population becomes much smaller. This then reduces the gene flow between founder groups and ancestral groups and other founder groups and increases the genetic differences between groups.

Then, other factors also come into play. Genetic drift is the random change in genes over time and is much greater in small populations. The expansion of humans from Africa in small, founder populations meant that these small groups experienced greater genetic drift than the larger original population resulting in new polymorphisms. Polymorphisms are forms of a gene that are too prevalent in the population to be called mutations or even, sometimes, to be regarded as abnormal. Often they confer an advantage in some special circumstance. The polymorphisms resulting from genetic drift that arose in one group were less likely to be transmitted to other groups as gene flow was restricted for the reasons that I outlined above.

The differences aren't that big simply because it didn't happen that long ago in paeleobiological terms. We've also tended to stir the mix with war, more migrations and so on. Depending on which theory you belive, different races fanned out from Africa at different times and some are more closely related than others.

As I said in an earlier post, the selection of populations for pigmented skin was a simple necessity and would have happened pretty quickly. It doesn't necessarily all come from the original African ancestors, either, as groups that moved north and then back towards the equator would necessarily have selected for dark skin. Selection for light skin, well, there's a choice. You can either believe those who say that light skin was selected to cut down the incidence of rickets as vitamin D is activated by sunlight or follow the other claim that light skin is just because there was no reason to select for dark skin. Could be both.

The reasons for different facial features is likely just chance - people mate with people that they like the look of - or genetic drift in a small population "fixed" certain features such as the epicanthic fold of some Asian eyes into a polymorphism.

what else do you want to know?

:D

by jdclyde

What we feel atracted to. You did touch on this earlier, on being attracted to mates with trates for various reasons.

Kind of odd how different cultures find different traits attractive? Also, how even in a same culture, how the desired trait changes with the times.

Of course, it is hard NOW to distinguish what we would be attracted to after being told what to be attracted to by TV and the movies. Is anyone really attracted to walking skeletons? :0 pass on the "super" models.

by maecuff

I don't understand the attraction to emaciated women. My boss and I had this discussion. He said something about JLo having a big a$$. Now, I don't think she's a particularly talented individual, but physically, I think she's fine. I couldn't understand why he found her unattractive because of her 'size'.

by jck

I know what I desire right now...this piece of cake on my desk!! :D

I don't like sickly looking girls like Kate Moss.

Someone get that girl a sammich! :D

by Member 25348569

and it may take some time. I've been wandering the Internet for a while and this is what I've found so far!

I first got into pheromones - whether smells are really an attractant (underarms a la Francais, anyone?) but I don't think that they are for most people. One very strange study though, has women sniff the t-shirts of symmetrical men (see below!) and it seemed to show something. It may be that pheromones have a subconscious effect and these would probably be a racial thing - women would go for someone who had a similar smell to her father?

Other researchers reckon that a gene mutated 23 million years ago among primates in Africa that are considered to be human ancestors, allowing them to see color. This let the males notice that a female's bottom turned bright red when she was ready to mate and this decreased the necessity for pheromones.

It would seem that we all find symmetry attractive in both face and body. Generally, models have symmetrical faces. This applies to all races so it doesn't answer your question. Some other things that seem to apply to all races and both sexes is a waist to hip ratio between quite narrow limits. This seems to indicate that the potential mate is healthy and not suffering from any diseases.

I ran across a scientific explanation for one of the oldest theories about attraction. Like attracts like. I do know some married couples who have such a lot in common and - to a certain extent - look the same.

There have been some studies on married couples genes and their relationship. The study found that, based on a set of inheritable personality traits, having similar genetics plays 34 percent of the role in friendship and mate selection. That would be pretty race-specific and tend to lock the majority of people into searching for a mate within their own racial grouping.

The main theory that resulted from the study is that some genes evolved to work well in combination with other genes and so you don't want to break that up too much for your offspring. Finding a mate with similar genes will help you ensure this.

I don't know how true this is but the paper went on to say that "If your spouse is genetically similar, you're more likely to have a happy marriage. Child abuse rates are lower when similarity is high, and you'll also be more altruistic and willing to sacrifice more for someone who is more genetically like you".

by onbliss

Sometime back I read/heard about a research carried out by a British team that concluded that infants could distinguish between an unattractive and attractive face. I just can not get any link pointing towards that material.

But looks like there are other studies, that touch this subject - infants' judgement on attractiveness match the adults' judgement on attractiveness.

To my lay mind, it points to some kind of hard-wiring in the brain about universal attractiveness that is not necessarily related to social or cultural factors.

But here is one link:
http://www.utexas.edu/opa/pubs/discovery/disc1996v14n3/disc-beauty.html

by tonythetiger

Nothing turns me off more than a visible ribcage. Nor would that type of body seem to me to be a healthy trait for "survivablilty of the species" purposes.

I did notice on my HDTV that the setting to make regular 4x3 picture fill the screen does make them more attractive... as long as they are standing up and fully clothed :)

by x-marcap

When I crack the code to cure Lupus, and arthritis, I'll let you know after I get the ribase sugar block quantified.

(would you believe in mobility for old guys like me!!!)

Tim

by Member 25348569

Gimme six!

Sickle cell anaemia is one of the "fuzzy" genetic issues. In areas where Malaria is prevalent, to be a carrier of [b]one[/b] copy of the sickle cell gene will prevent you catching the disease. You have no sickle cell symptoms so it is a pro-survival mutation. Sickle cell anaemia is only seen to be detrimental when both copies of the gene have the mutation.

Haemophilia continues to be expressed because only males get it and their carrier mothers are asymptomatic.

by jck

Where's the asteroid!!! :D

I know where you are coming from about breeding. However, you can technically breed different species. Dogs and wolves can interbreed and they are totally different species, but same family and genus.

Got me a cave scoped out. Let the asteroid splash, baby!! :D

by jellimonsta

The NZ and sheep would be more pertinent to Col.

For Neil, you need to suggest the Welsh and sheep! :p

by gadgetgirl

indeed to goodness, yes, look you!!

:D

GG

Sorry, Neil, couldn't resist. Now, stop trying to answer the phone with the iron again, and get on with some work.....

by Member 25348569

do not belong in this serios discussion. Here I am researching on founder groups and polymorphisms and you're coming at me with SHEEP JOKES.

Be ashamed!

You guys are baaaarmy. Why won't ewe take this seriously. Look, I could pull the wool over your eyes easy as pie and fleece ewe just by spinning a yarn and ewe'd never know it. So don't go bleating to anyone if I do!

:D

Ah, burger it. If you can't bleat 'em...

There was this really smart sheep down in Mexico who knew how to make butter and buttermilk.

One night she sneaked across the border and got a job working for a farmer, who set up a roadside stand and told her to try to sell the stuff. Unfortunately traffic was very heavy and the sight of this sheep making butter and buttermilk was so distracting that naturally there was an accident.

The police investigated and issued the farmer a citation for attempting to make an illegal ewe churn on a busy highway.

by jdclyde

when they have a disproportionate amount of padding to the rest of their body...... She looks good EXCEPT for that.

BUT J'lo doesn't do anything for me, maybe that has a lot to do with her lifestyle and crowd she runs with. It is like everytime someone does or says something stupid, another mental scar appears and after a while, that is all you see. (yes, the EX is very scarred up)

Jolie, now THERE is a great a$$ ! ]:)

by jdclyde

she needs that cake more than you do. I agree entirely.

Naomi Cambel is another one. Pretty, but something about her just creaps me out.

The bad thing is, I don't understand how they are able to sell clothing for the REAL women of the world that do that "digest" thing with their food.

by jck

What's wrong with her? SHE IS A PSYCHO!

She not only hit (reportedly) several of her hirelings, but she has twice thrown her blackberry at people (and has been sued).

by jdclyde

So if an offspring is not a close match to the donors, they are more "at risk" of child abuse and neglect? I have NEVER heard that one before. I suppose it could happen.

I wonder how looks play into that? Everyone loves the pretty people. If you have two children, one is pretty and one isn't, does the pretty one fair better with the parents? Man, that is just sad to think about.

by jck

First...I gotta address the "J. Lo's butt" thing:

J. Lo's butt looks big on camera when she's in some really tight pants cause she's got a really small waist.

If you are a real man and ever saw her backside in the movie "The Cell" in front of that refrigerator bent over and didn't like it...you're just gay. That girl has a nice butt. It's not boney...it's not fat...it's just right :D

And I agree...J. Lo is not talented other than as a dancer. She was a dancer on "In Living Color" (Wayans brothers' show)...and her choreographer was Rosie Perez...another gal with a nice bod that isn't thin as a rail.

As for attractiveness, well...everyone has different tastes.

I've never found that I particularly thought any single body type was repulsive other than women who were obviously medically at risk (emaciated or extremely obese). I've gone out with girls from the 5'3 97 lb chick, to a girl I got to know for a while who was 6'1 and about 170 (she wasn't thin, but she wasn't morbidly obese).

I tend not to look so much at a woman's body type, unless it's obviously WAY out of the norm. I'm more into...well...things like personality, eyes, intelligence...in addition to needing a woman who's not materialistic or sadistic or narcissistic...as well as it being a bonus having some talent or ability at something...whether it's knitting or music or art or something.

Oh...and...well...hehe...I have a girl who I have been talking to recently. I wonder if she'd move to Ireland?????? And no, she's not thin as a rail before you ask, Mae :D

by jck

several women I have met would have been marriage material...if they'd been mute. :D

by jdclyde

but it goes back for his study, how do you determine what is atractive and unatractive, to base the study on?

I have known many stunningly attractive people with all the personality of a spoon.

by jdclyde

Between people pushing abortion as acceptable birth control AND looking at DNA before a child is born, it won't be too far off that we "scrap that one and try again" because of the wrong mix of DNA.

The cull isn't too far off.