Discussion Locked

If we all came from Monkeys, then???

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by Member 25348569

Um, perhaps because there's a significant element of truth in what he's saying. It's probably not completely true but certainly forms a basis for discussion on how much of it is.

by maxwell edison

It's just like all the people who go around, criticizing President Bush, spewing their vitriol and anger, flinging accusation after accusation, and so on, and then they call him divisive. Geesh, look in the mirror! Just because a person disagrees with someone else, it doesn't mean that the other guy is the one politicizing the issue, or that it is he who's being divisive.

I've observed that the left in America is capable of "bipartisanship" only when you agree with them. Otherwise, it's always the other guy who's being partisan or divisive. Just as it takes two to tango, it also takes two to argue. Where is Jon Miller, for example, willing to compromise on this political issue where no middle-ground is apparent? And don't suggest that it should be a scientific issue, not a political one, as a reason to avoid the question. As long as our government is dictating how the government schools are run, it's political.

Jon Miller says. "[i]'Republicans have clearly adopted this as one of their wedge issues."[/i] Clearly adopted this as a wedge issue? Please support that with solid examples. And as Jon Miller probably won't read this, and since you, Neil, are arguing on his behalf, perhaps you will step up and support that comment with solid examples. What is it "Republicans" are doing, how is it so clear, and why is it their wedge issue, not yours?

And on the "denial of evolution" comment. It seems to me that it's the denial of the possibility of creationism, or intelligent design, or any variation of anything similar that's equally contributing to the divide, if not causing it entirely. It's Jon Miller's way, or no way. Does that about sum it up? And who's being "divisive"?

by Member 25348569

that there was "some" truth in it. Whilst I know that you are more interested in the "political" implications of the piece, I, who know little about who decides what will be taught and not taught in US schools, am obviously more interested in the scientific. If I fail to satifactorily address the politics, well, I'm British and we [b]never, ever[/b] interfere in other countries' politics.

Let's deal with your last paragraph first as it's an easy one and then work back. To the best of my knowledge, we "Evolutionists" do not wish to deny the teaching of [b]any[/b] of the [b]many[/b] creation myths but merely wish - rightly insist - that they are taught in classes of comparative religion and not as scientific theories in science classes for the hugely simple reason that they are not science in an way, shape or form. When Creationism and Intelligent Design and any other creation myth are investigated and tested with the same rigour that is used on any scientific theory and when the same criteria of validity is placed on them, at that point they rightfully belong alongside the theory of evolution in science classes. As a side issue, I would guarentee that those who wish the teaching of "Creation" and "Intelligent Design" would pour infinite scorn upon the creation myths of, say, the Hindu religion. That, I feel, displays their agenda.

You suggest that Miller is at fault for his lack of "compromise (...) where no middle-ground is apparent". I'm interested as a scientist in what you feel that "middle-ground" could lie in the Creation-Evolution debate. Taking the middle-ground where none could possibly exist was precisely the reason that Intelligent Design was created by a cabal of Christian fundamentalist lawyers. A little bit of diggings displays their intention that ID is the "wedge" to remove Darwinism, Humanism and any other form of non-Christian teaching from US schools. I can't be bothered to post references, Google "Discovery Institute" - hell, read their Wiki - and proceed from there. Whether these guys are Republicans, have Republican support or whatever, I don't know and don't really care enough to find out. You know more than me about the country in which they operate, you tell me.

Of course I cannot answer for Miller as to Republicans particularly favouring ID as I've little knowledge about US though processes that gives rise to crap like ID, anyway. I suppose that the logic is that the creationists are - to a man - Christian fundamentalists and that Christian fundamentalists seem to favour Bush. If that's not the case then you have more misguided people than I ever dreamed.

Neil :D

by x-marcap

Where is the missing link. (My brother even with a tail would be a homo sapien, I think)

Without a complete chain of evidence the theory of evolution is as much an "accept these facts" on faith as ID. Where is the breakage in the chain of evidence?

Even if we found the "Missing Link" could we trust the archaeology field. It has been rife with mistakes and fraud... especially around the turn of the century.

Can we throw out all the old research and build that bridge to the past? I don't know...

by maxwell edison

Who gets to decide what to teach whom? Or does it depend on what's being taught?

Of course, if schools are teaching hate, and espouse killing those they hate, that shouldn't be tolerated. And if a school is teaching that two plus two equals five, then that, too, should be corrected, since we want our population to be able to balance a checkbook and make proper change in a transaction. Teaching people how to function in a society, however, is not really on the same level as teaching the more "enlightened" kind of things. Whether a person believes in evolution or creationism, or possibly a combination of both, will not matter in how that person functions as a responsible member of society. (And before you extrapolate anything from that, please be genuine enough to take it as it was intended.)

I'm not exactly a dumb-ass, and neither are you. We're both reasonably intelligent, and probably both have developed a bit of wisdom over the years we've been around. We can both function equally well in society, although we disagree on many matters. One of our disagreements is that we see "the beginning" in totally different lights. You have your version of how life, as we know it, and as it all started, and I have mine. (And others have theirs) Neither can be conclusively proven or disproved. And do you know what? It doesn't matter.

So here's my compromise. You teach your kids whatever you want in that regard, and I will neither try to influence them or try to force you to do otherwise, and you make the same deal with me. ("You" and "me" are to be interchangeable with, and apply equally to all others.) And let the public school system accommodate both (or more than both), since the school system is both paid for by, and in place to serve the public. (The American government serves the people, not the other way around. Remember?)

But Jon Miller is (apparently) not willing to do that. He wants to force the teaching of one theory, and totally disregard the other. That's fine for him and his kids, but perhaps it's not fine for someone else. For him to be astounded that so many people have not bought into the theory of evolution, lock, stock, and barrel, is, by definition, an indicator of his total disregard and dismissal of anything else, to any degree, and by any name. Who's really driving the wedge in this issue, people who totally disregard one side of the discussion, or those who are open to discussing both?

I rarely enter into these kinds of discussions, and for good reason, but I have entered into the fray on occasion. Even publicly, I don't personally enter into the argument, and have elected to simply opt out of the public school system, even though I pay to support it. The mere fact that these kinds of discussions not only exist, but are prevalent in the public school system, is very distasteful to me. It compromises the basic rights all parents have to teach their kids in a manner they deem appropriate, and it actually distracts from providing a well-grounded education. One only has to look at the continuous reduction in test scores over the last few decades to surmise that the politicization of the schools (and irresponsibility of many parents) is squarely to blame. Heaven forbid that some student fails a grade, for fear his "self-esteem" will be hurt, but try to mention the possibility of "creationism" (in any form or by any name, either within or without the realm of "religion"), and all hell breaks loose!

However, I now dare to tread (very lightly) into the arena, nonetheless. In my estimation, the strict theory of evolution totally discounts the possibility that there is a bigger meaning and/or reason to life and the universe, as we know it to be. The theory of evolution (and the big bang theory) presume and teach that we start from nothing, we live a meaningless life, and then we die and simply cease to be in any form, whatsoever; it all started from nothing, and it will all end in nothing. Quite frankly, I simply don't buy that. I believe that there's more to "all this" than we are even capable of imagining, not to mention understanding. I believe there's more that we don't know than what we do know. And I believe I owe it to my kids to plant the seeds of such possibilities into their minds. And one thing don't want is for some public school teacher, or worse yet, administrator, dig up those seeds and dismiss them as nonsense.

In the final analysis, for any movement, scientific or otherwise, to try to deny teaching such a thing as "there's more than just evolution", is just wrong -- at least it's wrong to me and to millions (or even billions) of others. Why do you, or Jon Miller, or any of your ilk presume to force your view onto others? And make no mistake about it, to deny what they do want or do believe, in favor of what you believe, is tantamount to forcing them into your belief system.

In the United States, we have some rules around here. You may or may not agree with them, but they're rules, nonetheless. One of them says that [i]Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.[/i] And by extension, the "rules" that apply in a government school (public school), have their beginnings in the halls of Congress. It seems to be that by prohibiting the teaching of anything in a school, public or otherwise, that might be construed as religious, actually violates the part of the "rule" about [i]prohibiting the free exercise thereof[/i]. I've seen no "rule" [i]respecting an establishment of religion[/i] (in public schools), but I've sure seen ones that are [i]prohibiting the free exercise thereof[/i].

I find it very sad that there are those less willing to even mention "creationism" (in any form) in American schools than to allow the unbridled hate being taught in schools of other countries. Priorities are very skewed. And if this is what we've evolved into, God help us.

by jdclyde

there are three sides to every story. My side, your side, and what really happened.

We may never find out what really happened.

An idea about the numbers of people that accept vs don't accept the Theory of Evolution. As many that say they believe the theory of evolution really don't know jacksh!t about the theory, they are taking the same blind faith acceptance that people of religion take, only it is in the faith of science instead of God.

The amusing thing is the way the Evolutionists want to shove this on everyone, much in the same way they complain people of faith try to shove their religion on others. As you saw in EL, people got very worked up on both sides of the issue.

Why?

Does it really put you out if someone doesn't accept a scientific theory as the answer to all?

Does it really put you out if someone doesn't accept your version of a god as the answer to all?

Why the need to go beyond personal belief as to have to tear down the other persons beliefs in order to justify your own?

And what is also amusing, a sharing of DNA or the ability for adaptation does not in anyway prove there is no god behind it all. Maybe that god just did a good job?

Believe what you want, that wasn't my intention as no one is going to get their beliefs changed by a board on TR unless you really had no beliefs in either camp before.

I was just looking for ideas to explain what some of the factors are that make people so differnt.

by jdclyde

Isn't that the time to watch out the most? The best lies always have that element of truth in them.....

A general rule, not specific to this case. B-)

by jdclyde

but that is where careful documentation come into play! :D

And yes, I do have SEVERAL copies, stored in several LOCKED locations, as well as in digital format in two different physical locations.

I made her a deal. She walk out of my life, I will not take everything to loverboys WIFE, and/or each and every boytoy she ever brings into the picture to show what she is like and capable of.

I almost feel like a Ferengi.

#7) Keep your ears open.
#40) She can touch your lobes but never your latinum.
#60) Keep your lies consistent. (she should have listened to that one)
#76) Every once in a while, declare peace. It confuses the hell out of your enemies.
#85) Never let the competition know what you're thinking.
#94) Females and finances don't mix.
#99) Trust is the biggest liability of all.
#111) # Treat people in your debt like family ... exploit them.
#229) Latinum lasts longer than lust.
#255) A wife is a luxury ... a smart accountant is a necessity.
#285) No good deed ever goes unpunished.

I thought for sure there was something about leverage? Oh wait! Cross-threading from the movie discussion where Battlefield Earth came up. :D

Anyways, the winner always writes history! B-)

by jdclyde

Funny Oz, how you are doing exactly what you were crying that I did? Telling people how to post.

I know you think your a big shot around here, but your just another poster with a huge ego.

I HAVE noticed that the only time your typing is readable is when your attempting to chastise me. Do I rate more of your attention than your fan club? I am honored that I am worth taking the time to think out your post, and clearly type it in, while your fan club rates only the now famous "Oz type". I wonder why?

You have nothing further to say to me, but you do anyways. Sad.

Just like the mighty OZ in the movie, you make a lot of noise trying to scare people, but in the end it turns out your just a pathetic little man cowering in the corner, no real power, and a total fraud.

"dead end trade for a living"? If you say so dude.

by gsaravin9

Man was created in god's image & not a monkeys image.God is reproducing himself in man by giving him holy & righeous character through his son Jesus
& through him whosoever believes on him about the kingdom of god on this earth forever & ever.They will beget righous character & live forever.This is the hope of mankind not evolution.
ta mick

by jdclyde

because I already KNOW that side.

Specifically gave evolutionists the benifit of the doubt for this conversation, to ask about environmental impacts and such without having to argue if it was God or luck that made humans adaptable to their envrionment.

Thanks for stopping by anyways....

by onbliss

...Palestinians?

Heee heee.. could'nt help myself from sneaking that in here. So out-off topic. Sorry for the digression.

by protiusx

Your assertions are made from a faith of which those who disagree with you do not share. Their faith lies elsewhere.
There is a time and place for everything my friend. The author was right not to bring God into the discussion as this would have alienated those who do not believe as you and I do. This is a discussion about a scientific theory put forth by a man who lived in the nineteenth century and if one wishes to stay on topic and not muddy the waters one must not bring religion into the discussion.

by jdclyde

At one time, the rest of the world believe that the earth was flat.

The rest of the world was wrong?

hmmmmm

by Member 25348569

No one ever thought that the World was flat. The ancient Chinese knew it was round, the Greeks knew it was round and had a pretty good stab at the diameter! The Egyptians knew it was round and how big it was. the Europeans at the time of Columbus knew it was round and he knew he was sailing "the wrong way" to find the "Indies" but he just didn't know how big it was and that you lot and the Pacific Ocean were in the way.

Galileo got his backside warmed by the church for promoting the idea that the Sun was the centre and that the Earth revolved around it and not the simple idea that the Earth was round.

Information provided by NITS (tm) because I'm as pedantic git.

by jdclyde

Was that one "S" too many or not enough? :0

[i]"because I'm a[b]S[/b] pedantic git."[/i]

by Member 25348569

My one typo of the week and you're on it like a ratting terrier. And, yes, it was one 'S' too many. I'm British, remember, and we spell it 'arse'.

You will pay for this! Oh yes indeedy, Mr "I type with my forehead"!

:p

by Member 25348569

Before we go anywhere, let's correct one thing in your post. If you go back and [b]look[/b] at the EL thread, what you will see is all of the subthreads headed by ProtiusX, ippirate or MrMiami - opponents of Evolutionary Theory to a man - with those of us defending our position only when attacked. Hardly "shove this on everyone" tactics on our part.

Now, scientists have established the consistency of the theory of evolution with thousands of lines of evidence and the work of hundreds of thousands of researchers. This idea is based on material evidence and repeated experiment, extensively documented in the scientific literature.

Because this evidence flatly contradicts all literal religious accounts, religious conservatives have mounted a long running social and political campaign to get their dogma treated as the truth, despite the absence of any material or logical support for their position. What we have with Creationism and ID is a PR campaign and Microsoft have shown what you can do with one of those.

This debate is not about assessing the evidence, but about getting faith-based bullsh:t taught as science.

Put quite simply, any attempt to incorporate faith and the supernatural into science is as destructive to the enterprise as would be requiring religion to provide concrete, repeatable tests of their beliefs. And we're not going to see [b]that[/b] are we?

by onbliss

Jd: Look at the depth of googling I (we) have to do :-) . So far it has been an interesting read this thread, except for a few sub-threads.

http://anthro.palomar.edu/adapt/adapt_2.htm

The above link addresses several of the questions you had raised earlier, regarding climatic adaptations. To my lay mind it feels that wen species were adapting they had to take into account more than just climatic adapations, and thus things get little more complex.

Neil: If you are reading this post, can you help me understand one thing? I read that Polar Bear has a black skin (I just knew it today) to absorb the Sun's heat, and that the white fur allows the heat to reach the skin, and provide a camouflage. So why did'nt the people in the colder climates develop darker skins as well to absorb the Sun's heat? Maybe the human ancestors and the bear's ancestors had different factors to consider during the evolution.

by Member 25348569

Definitely, Equatorial races have black skin because they need it to protect from skin cancer, uv damage generally, pore damage, etc. That's a given.

As for white skin, two theories. One may be right, both may be right or neither may be right.

Theory one says northern races have white skin because they have no reason to have black skin so there's not any reason for selection although that doesn't work if you factor in the "heat absorption" issue except for the fact that northern humans wear clothes and cover the skin. Hmmmmm. Puts us back where we started, northern humans have white skin because they have no reason to have black skin.

Theory two says that northern humans have white skin because they keep it covered more of the time so they wouldn't get enough sunlight-activated vitamin D so what bits they do expose they want to absorb as much sunlight as possible as quiclky as possible. If you don't get vitamin D, you get rickets and end up with twisted limbs. Not particularly good for a potential hunter-gatherer mate.

Polar bears (and Inuits, who are relatively dark skinned) eat lots of seal and stuff that has a lot of vitamin D so they don't have a problem. And, I guess, polar bears probably have different metabolic requirements.

I haven't found any other explanations yet but I'll carry on looking.

Neil :D

by onbliss

for looking and answering.

Theory one, let us call it as NRT (No Reason Theory) for our discussion. If the ancestors of humans came from the equatorial region of Africa, they would have had black skin to begin with. If that is a safe assumption, then there must have been a reason for the skin color to change, right?

But I doubt if the ancestors of hominids covered themselves much with any kind of material.

by jdclyde

Why in the colder climates people are fairer skin, but then I figured it was because,

1) they are bundled up more, so not exposed to as much direct sun

2) the sun is not as intense in the colder regions, so again, less likely to darken pigment.

You would THINK that people in the more arid regions that are also covered most of the time would be of lighter skin than they are?

by Member 25348569

I think the issue is that skin damage occurs however much they show. If you only get skin cancer on your face, you still get skin cancer.

by onbliss

I have noticed that I become quite uncomfortable, when the Sun really shines brightly in the summer. Sometimes, I think the summers in India were far better and I could withstand the heat better than now. There seems to be an aggression in the Sun's rays :-) Maybe 1) I am getting used to the colder weather, especially when I have to wear some kind of jacket 6 months each year. 2)Or I am getting older. 3) Or maybe there is something more than that meets the eye.

by jdclyde

I will also confess that I didn't read even a tenth of the posts in EL. I mostly just read headings and went on with my life.

Science and Religion. Not a good mix, is it?

I think the way to approach it would be to just simply say "here are some of the many ways people THINK the world began". Make it Earth history class instead of labeling it "science" and banning all non-scientific ideas because they don't fit into the labels that science has put in place.

Yes, I have no problem with Hindu origins being put forward at this time, as none of them are provable, including Evolution.

Once THAT is out of the way about the very start, the DNA studies and the addapting to environments fits in will all of the beginnings as it is just as acceptable that a god made beings adaptable as if they were just accidentilly adaptable. No longer a religious discussion one way or the other as far as I am concerned, which is why I TRIED to not bring religion into the discussion.

Of course, people from each side of this issue are apposed to having any alternative view being taught, as indeed, it does challenge what they are inside.

Because of anti-religion people, yes, people are trying to get the creationism in as well. I think MY approach better serves everyone than the separationists idea of banning anything that doesn't fit into your neat little world.

"How the world MIGHT have begun....." There are no facts here, only theories and beliefs.

by Member 25348569

One of the things that really ticked me off in the EL thread was that "Evolution" was taken to mean the Theory of Everything, first cause, big bang, first life. These aren't evolution.

The origins of the Universe and the origins of life are still undetermined. We haven't been looking very long, anyway, so I'm not expecting an answer for a while so if you want to lump together the Big Bang with "let there be light" and "Vishnu spoke to his servant, Brahma: 'Create the world.'" then I wouldn't like it but I don't really have a valid objection.

Evolution as a biological mechanism to explain the diversity of life - as proposed by Darwin and modified by thousands of researchers since - that's another matter entirely. That's been codified, demonstrated, explained, honed, tested and - most significantly - used as a predictive tool. You can keep your God-bothering hands off [b]that[/b] bit.

But you don't. The difficulty, it seems, is that "Origin of Species" is also contrary to the word of the bible so out goes baby, bathwater, plumbing and sewage systems. The adoption of creationism to describe the origins of first life is painful but within the realms of logic as Abiogenesis is such a young science that it is still gaining credibility. The unthinking adoption of creationism and the negation of Darwinian natural selection would be to destroy the lifes' works of myriad scientists and researchers over the last 150 years. If you want to do that, then you'd better have something much, much better than "God done it" to justify yourself.

Neil :)

by Member 25348569

Once Humanity - the naked ape - got away from the Equator they would have to cover up or else die from hypothermia. It would seem likely that the diaspora out of Africa which spread humanity happened in the last 100,000 years which is time for some adaptation but not a huge amount. Humanity by this time was reaonably intelligent - probably pretty close or equal to our level - so clothes is a fairly simple invention.

Anthropologists have given values of between 500,00 and 100,000 years ago for the first clothes. The oldest needle found is 30,000 years old.

by onbliss

Kind of makes sense.

One thing that unsettles me is your point about the humanity (whatever form) that existed 100,000 years being pretty close or equal to our level of intelligence. Based on anthropological evidences, I can see that humans 3000-4000 years ago were pretty much just like us. But 100,000 years?

edited: clarity

by Member 25348569

Obviously, I have no first-hand knowledge...

I've seen some reports that say that the human intellect reached modern proportions in some sort of European creative big bang around 40,000 years ago. I do remember, though, reading that some very sophisticated bone tools - detachable projectile points, etc - had been dated to 80,000 BPE or earlier in Africa. The tools would have required considerable investment in effort (thinking ahead) and would have been the product of complex thought processes. The archaeologists also found some several thousand pieces of red ochre - used in all later cultures for decoration - which would seem to indicate symbolic thought processes akin to our own.

by tonythetiger

lots of things were at one time unexplained. That doesn't mean that they didn't exist before they were explained. It means that all that the people of the time knew was not all there was to know. The same thing is true today. A truly open mind would realize that... that until something is disproven absolutely, its existence is a possibility.

Thank God for all of these puzzles he created for us :)

by x-marcap

Was the Mom an Idiot, or was Dad. Was it only one positive mutation?

I just want the same level of proof that is demanded from ID people to be leveled at the evolutionists.

They are working from speculation to speculation. They demand proof of the unprovable, and not from their own sources.

Archaeology and antrhopology are creative fictions. I haven't seen significant differences in their attitude andf the nuttier religious types. The attitude is the same.

We don't have the evidence per se. But we have some records that indicate the existance of ______
you fill in the blank.

Since Hebrew is not a dead language, the Dead Sea Scrolls and the Jewish histories are becoming recognized as more accurate as time goes on... For years Pontius Pilate's existance was discounted. Now, it has been proven that he lived and was the military governor of the right area...

Evolution is a theory, not a natural law. I have a theory that has never been proven or disproven. OZ is either insane, or just revealing his genetic inheritance. OZ is decended from Equus Asinus.

Thanks JD for the point in the right direction.

Sorry I can't help but Zing OZ. My favorite target.

by Member 25348569

to be drawn down in this discussion to the level of total bollocks.

Evolution is a scientific theory. You [b]know[/b] what one of those is - or at least a person or your claimed medical and scientific training damn well should know - and you know what is involved in the acceptance of such a theory: A self-consistent, internally logical model for describing the behavior of a related set of phenomena, originating and supported by experimental evidence.

The scientific theory that describes the mechanism of evolution is both systematic and formalised and was proposed by Darwins on the basis of his original observations and modified by all subsequent observations. It is both logical and testable. Above all, and so different from that contrived nonsense of ID, it is predictive.

by tonythetiger

No, especially when you use the rules of one to try to assess the other. Kinda like trying to prove that art is art.

by x-marcap

If I wrote using concise polysylablic nomenclature, you would never get the joke. You would be looking up every other word.

It must not be too subtle, or you will not catch it. If I were subtle, it flies so far over your head you don't hear it's wings flap. If it has more than two three sylables, you need to look up the words. You are hovever a quadruped of extreme unction.

Do you get the picture? I really hate fighting 1/2 armed opponents in battles of wits. Call me when you have graduated Med School, BFT,AFT,and boot camp. Then, you may have 1/2 the vocabulary to understand creative insults.

You are a flying wing with a mid-body propeller.

by protiusx

My interest is peaked. I would very much like to hear (or in this case read) about the Flagellum. Perhaps I would have made an moderately good scientist. I am fascinated by it.

One thing I must tell you though - My two boys and I were watching the science channel the other day (something we do a lot - I think they've developed my interest) and the show was about the wooly mammoths and how they lived and eventually became extinct. My oldest son turns to me and says "How do they know Dad?" Now forget about the answer being deductive science for the moment and ponder the question coming from a seven year old. Young minds aren't bound by learned prejudices and yet he was able to work out that if the mammoths died off thousands of years ago how can we truly know anything about them. Pretty good huh?

by onbliss

My pet thoery is that language could be used as a measuring technique to judge the advancements. Ofcourse, I conceived this theory without reading any material.
I started thinking along these lines, when I perceived a relationship between Language and Thoughts. To express complex thoughts, it requires a developed language. Simply put - larger number of sounds and vocabulary in the language.

So how advanced were the languages 100,000 years ago - would be an interesting question for me to answer :-)

by x-marcap

I want that missing link...

Before you tell me look at either OZ, JD, Max, or a mirror, I have a problem with the chain of evidence. There should be one heck of a lot of evidence that I just can't find.

I want to test for the genetic relationship. I want to find the bridge. Where is the "Monkey in the Middle?"

I am only asking since anthropolgy is a very inexact science, and it is very speculative reconstruction...

by onbliss

....to give a heady concoction :-) Don't you think many of the Sci-fi movies and articles freely take things from religion? Matrix series movies are just one example.

[i]I think the way to approach it would be to just simply say "here are some of the many ways people THINK the world began". Make it Earth history class instead of labeling it "science" and banning all non-scientific ideas because they don't fit into the labels that science has put in place.[/i]

It is akin to changing the definition of Planet to include Pluto into the Solar System :-)

I think in the science classes, scientific theories should be the focus. Different religious points of view could be taught under appropriate classes.

by protiusx

I am more than willing to go there with you my friend. You argue well, are well written and articulate. More importantly you try very very hard not to succumb to childish jibes thrown your way.

One thing before we begin though. I promise to stay on topic, which is the discussion of the scientific merits of Darwin's theory of evolution and I would ask you to stay there with me. I am not going to bring up creationism as we have no common ground there. I am not nor will not attempt to refute Darwin's theory using creationist ideology. I will merely speak to the logic and reason of what is postulated. What say you my friend? Care for some friendly banter?

by Member 25348569

Of course I'll admit that there are gaps in the fossil record but considering what the fossil records actuually IS, it's doing OK. You're throwing baby out with bathwater again. Just because the fossil record DOES have gaps there is neither reason nor logic enough to discount the ENTIRE theory and the ENTIRE fossil record to date and replace it with mumbo jumbo. YES! MUMBO JUMBO!

The theory of evolution can predict what some of these missing records will be. It can also explain what some of the anomalies are. Can any of the god-botherer MUMBO JUMBO mechanisms do either? I don't THINK so.

Please feel free to investigate the "missing link" on our behalf and report back with a term paper of at least 15,000 words. I don't give a bugger if they NEVER find it as it only means something to those who don't know its significance (not a lot).

Neil :D

Have any of you bods realised that I have the whole of the Evolution Lie thread copied off into WP and I can cut and paste you - with the emphasis on CUT - to PIECES!

BWAHAHAHAHAHAHA!

by oz_media

Boudary Bay is just a stone's throw from where I walk my dog. I am in Seattle every month or so, racing at Em Downs and golf at Tapps Lake. I see far mroe of America than most of these guys do of Canada, as you probably know we are back and forth all the time, business, shipping etc. You go to a mall in the the northwest on a weekend and it's full of BC plates getting cheap gas and smokes. It used to be so much cheaper there, but even with a low exchange rate and strong Canadian dollar, your prices just aren't as exciting anymore. A little cheaper on some stuff but pretty much par for most of it. Sorry, segue that went nowhere.

Have several friends there, Seattle is a lot like Vancouver; same recreational/laid back mindset, similar weather (though it always seems grey in Seattle due to the grey stone skyline). Lanuage is very similar, very little differece in accent etc.

I was a bit shocked to see the look on a girls face at Subway in Auburn, she had never seen Canadian money and couldn't take it???? Two hours from the border? :D

Oh well, I guess some of us don't get outside that much.

by protiusx

My wife and I see a ton of Canadians when we go to Costco in Burlington which is about 30 miles south of the border.

by protiusx

The title asks whether we "believe" that man has evolved from animals. Are we asked by any other scientific theory to "believe"? I refuse to apply faith to science. Science should be the one area where things either are or are not. Either we know empirically or we do not know. It is okay to say "I don't know".

by jdclyde

but where is your faith? :D

This is a point that is NOT suppose to be brought up about the new religion called science. Refuse to bow down at the alter, will you?

by Member 25348569

scratching at semantics to make your point is not allowed.

The question was "Human beings, as we know them, developed from earlier species of animals: true or false?"

Strange word, believe: to have confidence in the truth, the existence, or the reliability of something, although without absolute proof that one is right in doing so. I "believe" that Canada exists but, because I've never been there, you would say that I cannot "know" that there is a Canada?

Come, on. Try a little harder! :D

by onbliss

...the EL thread was active during my inactive days. So recently, I opened it and saved the "print" version to my PC. I read at my leisure some of the posts, obviously not all yet.

I can peer email the html if soembody wants it.

by jdclyde

You mean people got skin cancer before man weakened the ozone layer? Or did that just increase the occurance?

How far back can we document skin cancer?

by Member 25348569

Not very far at all, I guess. We do have to make some assumptions that Man way back then wasn't THAT different to what Man is today. Given that, selection of something like dark skin is all statistical probabilities. We have, say, a thousand men and women of all skin shades in the tropics over a couple of thousand years without much clothing then those who don't burn, don't get melanoma, etc would statistically be favoured against those who do. The population would get darker - and not by tanning - by the darker skinned living longer and being less affected by the Sun and so passing on their more favourable genes.

Simple. If you believe in evolution. :D

Oh, and yes they certainly got cancer! The current ozone layer issue mainly affects the Poles but does stray over NZ, Oz and tierra del fuego.

by tonythetiger

increases in skin cancer aren't partly due simply to people being where they're poorly adapted to the climate (genetically).

by jdclyde

Wasn't there just talk about the Sun being hotter now than it was 1000 years ago?

That would make a difference as well?

by tonythetiger

... you haven't been able to explain it, so it didn't happen.

... you can't prove it, so it didn't happen.

... you're making it up, so it didn't happen.

... it's never happenned to them, so it didn't happen.

But I'm not one of those... :)

by oz_media

Still not impressed in the least, While you attempt once again to appear to be so highly educated you are coming off like a dork still.

Battle of wits? You are referring to a battle of vocabulary, not wits. If you feel that having a vocabulary full of antiqauted English (polysylablic [i](sic)[/i] nomenclature)makes you witty, you need to read yet another comic book. When you finish reading Archie, try and place 'nomenclature' into a sentence where the context fits. Though someitmes used in American English, it is only a person who wishes to sound pompous that would place those two words together. Nomenclature refers correctly to science diagrams, exploded diagrams etc. It refers to the intricate diagram or sequence of build found in science, engineering and mechanics. Though it has been bastardized by some who feel it should also define the build of English words or statements, it is simply misused by snot nosed pukes like yourself who are trying to appear to be more than they really are. I have studied many nomenclatures in my line of work and no I didn't need to look it up, or spell it.

If you need a thesaurus at least learn how to put words together and not just find big words and chain them in some sort of unique sentence structure, give up.

Now while I honestly admit to tying too fast and having poor keyboarding skills, your only excuse for mispelling YOUR big words must be due to your simple misunderstanding of them, or the fact that Americans can't spell English words anyway.

Secondly,

To spout off what you consider great personal accomplishments in an attempt to once again imply you are educated and witty is once again idiotic and immature. You are one of those wannabe's who insist on having his cert acronyms on his business card (You must have missed that discussion), unless of course your company just gives you blanks to write your name on. Generally these people have been losers all their life, have no social skills to get ahead and when they finally get a cert they are so happy to be sdomebody that they add acronums ot their business cards like complete losers. I don't know how many clients I've had laugh these knobs but it really isn't taken seriously by anyone who actually IS important. It's typical crap from the insecure as always. Your posts just echo your psychological issues so deeply, you weren't even included in this part of the thread and yet you have stuck your nose in and now are just trying to have a pissing contest with vocabulary you learned yesterday? Give it a rest and go back to school.

You're as sad as that jd loser who feels that IT is actually a career with great future. When I said it was a dead end career he scoffed, proving what little he actually knows about the market he is stuck in compared to the opportunities around him everyone else is persuing. Hey you guys go read a few books, spew your monosyllabic BS here all you like, you are only fooling yourselves or making yourselves feel clever.

Lastly, while you may think that words make you intelligent, the proof is you couldn't be more wrong. The most successful, intelligent and highly regarded people in our history have been illiterate, on extremely powerful drugs, dyslexic and mainly uneducated as they don't have the patoence to sit in school for 12 years while they could be gettign ahead in life.

The whole premise of your argument is flawed.

Nobody with any intelligence is going to buy into that immature BS anyway.

by Member 25348569

Bacterial flagellum first, I suggest, and then the Bombardier Beetle as dessert. These are the two Holy Evolution Killers and should put me away with nowt but a whimper.

Set out your stall...

:D

p.s. I can do jibes but i'll try and resist.

by oz_media

Well done, you just get dumber and dumber, your replies more and mroe sensless and without context at all.

And you REALLY think you are being clever? You aren't even somewhat good with sarcasm!
'mercun's, who'da thunk it?!? Yeeehaw!

by jdclyde

It just doesn't matter what you think, as I am not here to impress you.

You are dismissed.

by Member 25348569

it's an "either/or".

The majority of Christians read Genesis as a metaphor - the last Pope said that it's not to be taken literally and that "evolution is OK".

For the (mostly American) Christian fundamentalist conservatives, however, the Bible is to be taken literally therefore Darwin cannot be allowed as it is contrary to the "Word of God". By the way, they're in the company of Muslim fundamentalists who are the other body that won't have anything to do with Darwin.

Intelligent Design, although not outwardly "Christian" is an attempt to take the non-existent "middle ground" to weaken Darwinism as a prelude to moving over to "pure" Biblical Creationism. I can produce the evidence that convinces me of the perfidy of the ID proponents but I'll save it until requested.

So, you see, we (people like me or the fundys) can't have both so "absence of proof..." doesn't hold. So long as Darwinism is an accepted scientific theory then Biblical creation [b]cannot[/b] be a viable explanation.

by jdclyde

that I only point them out when they are funny, right? :D

And it was so perfectly timed too..... :p

by tonythetiger

to "fundies", but only in the accusatory. I've never actually met one, nor do I know anybody who has.

by tonythetiger

but I do have a problem teaching it "as science", because it's not. I would have the same problem if they wanted to teach Art or Literature in science class.

by Member 25348569

We may be talking completely at right-angles.

This is not aimed at you, personally, Max. The "you" that I'm addressing are the people who just don't take the time to find out what they are talking about.

I have absolutely no objection to you teaching your children whatever you want. You want to teach them half truths, untruths and downright lies than that's very sad but yours to do as you see fit.

But please, please don't try to justify it.

If it fits your religion or your personal feelings to want to believe in "something more" or you feel that your faith is somehow at risk then simply say so and have done with it. But do not attempt to dress up the desire to find a "meaning" that you cannot find in the pragmatism of Darwinian evolution in the pseudo-scientific mumbo jumbo claptrap of ID or creationism. Don't join the band of people weaseling away at the edges of established science trying to poke and prod and nibble their way like maggots into the current theory because it doesn't fit their beliefs.

Creationism and ID are religious beliefs. Period.

by Member 25348569

If you compare the colour of the indigenous population of Australia with the immigrant population they're about as different as you can get.

Australia, South Africa and the Southern American states all have a very high incidence of skin cancer in their white populations. It's decreasing in Oz, now, because they have a very aggressive "cover-up" campaign.

by maxwell edison

Sorry, Neil, but not all people who believe in such a "bigger purpose" can be pigeon-holed into something "religious". In my opinion, where science simply cannot answer the next question (or the "previous" question, in this case), the "what-ifs" prevail. I am not what I would call a religious person, but since I'm not an Atheist, perhaps you would. Is everything so black and white to you, or just this? Is a person either an Atheist or religious? Is there no other possibility? Maybe it's all relative. In any case, I'm obviously not as closed-minded as you, at least not in this case.

I also contend that a creator (lower case) doesn't necessarily have to be The Creator (upper case). But then again, I don't discount the possibility of The Creator. What does all this make me? It makes me someone who deems such discussions worthy of attention in schools, whether that be in the scientific realm or otherwise. Unfortunately, for people like Jon Miller, they don't want it anyplace in the public school system, and that's what I disagree with.

My dog in this hunt wants parents who pay for public school education for their kids, and are the customers of the public school system, to have the ability to decide what may or may not be taught to their kids -- AND on the dime their taxes provide. If a parent wants absolutely no mention of such things, so be it. If a parent does want it, then again, so be it.

The solution -- and the compromise -- is school choice for parents within the public school system. And the ones who fight against it are the ones who are using it as a wedge issue -- and that's what started the dialogue between you and me in the first place, the "who" who is REALLY causing the "wedge"! I say it's Jon Miller and his ilk; you apparently disagree.

By the way, define "religious". And what do you call a pure scientist who believes in God? About two-thirds of them do, you know.

by protiusx

The question was "Human beings, as we know them, developed from earlier species of animals: true or false?"
The answer is: Inconclusive. We don't "know" that they did or did not. We might postulate but we may not "know" something unless it is empirically proven to be so. There is a difference between "knowing a thing" and "believing" a thing. The difference is empirical. I can "know" that Canada is there without ever actually having been there because it has been demonstrated to me in fact that Canada exists. Conversely, let us say that there exists a place on Earth that I have never heard of, been to or have had previous knowledge of. If someone tells me of this place I must qualify the information and at that time given that I have no preponderance of data that empirically or emphatically proves the place exists I must "believe" what the person is telling me is truth or not.
To "know" is to perceive directly or have direct cognition of a thing.
I "know" Canada exists because of the preponderance of evidence that tells me it is true. I need not "believe" because of the preponderance of evidence. Now if only one can see the evidence of Macro-evolution which is what Darwin's Theory puts forth. There have been no intermediary creatures found in the fossil record (not one) and the idea that random mutation over time provides beneficial mutation has been proven to be false.

by Member 25348569

"random mutation over time provides beneficial mutation"

If we are to have a sensible discussion then I think it necessary for both of us to quote the sources of any sweeping statements so that we can check for bias and provenance.

Oh, and I [b]still[/b] don't know that Canada exists. You're simply not authoritative enough in matters of geography! Belief is a spectrum and total certainty has no real place in science, you know. Real certainty, I find, is only associated with faith.

:D

by maxwell edison

But that's not what "that side" is proposing. Generally speaking, anything and everything that has any semblance of "religion" or "God" attached to it is literally under attack in our public school systems. And that's grossly unfair to parents who want it part of their kid's education.

by protiusx

What? Science Fiction? I have to admit is more plausible than random mutation over time which caused beneficial mutations in creatures who were able to adapt and change into other totally different creatures all without leaving a trace of the transition from one species to another.

by Member 25348569

you either accept what I say or you don't. You would be on shaky ground if you attempt to argue against the science.

The original thread was a request by jd for some information on the mechanisms of human differences. How we got how we were where we were. and I was quite happy to answer those on the basis of current scientific thinking.

Someone the raised the subject of ID - I don't think it was me - and that just happens to be something that really sets my teeth on edge. Not because of my "closed mind", as I don't really think that I have one, but because the way that the proponents of the theory operate.

As I said to jd elsewhere in this thread, the US idea of "Greater Evolution" seems to encompass first cause, big bang, first life and everything between - including the "something more" that you belive there must be. I am simply attempting to discuss the current evolutionary mechanisms to explain to jd how the epicanthic fold appeared and why the Japanese are shorter than him.

The current scientific theories on "big bang", "first life" and the other less obvious aspects of "Greater Evolution" are tentative and unformed - the science is brand new - and have room for everyone to believe what they want and teach what they want. Let's both play there. I can sit and boggle quietly at just how damn big, complicated and wonderful it is and wait for the amazing revelations and insights that I believe that science will eventually bring and you can teach your children just how damn big, complicated and wonderful it all is and how little we know and that ANYTHING goes. Perhaps we might both agree that those who wish the centre of the Universe to be our tiny little planet are the ones with the closed minds.

"Darwinian Evolution" is something for which there is more evidence and therefore much less of a justification for anyone to label me closed minded for insisting that it is a true depiction of what happened. Unfortunately, however, it is absolutely threatening to a literal interpretation of Biblical Genesis and therefore lumped into the threat that Greater Evolution is to their narrow faith.

by protiusx

Here again all your examples of "evolution" speak to micro-evolution which is where change occurs in a species through adaptation primarily do to environmental stressors. I don?t think anyone is thick enough to argue that this kind of adaptation doesn?t occur. It has been evidenced in every high school biology class for years. I would ask though if you could please provide an example of Darwin's theory of evolution by presenting evidence of the mutation from one species to another.

by Member 25348569

I spend most of my time searching out rebuttals for your anti-evolution posts. It's my bedtime so no more tonight and, by tomorrow, I expect an answer to this:

You accept microevolution is demonstrable and, at the same time, argue that there has been no proof of macroevolution. No mechanism has been described for preventing microevolution causing macroevolution. Since every step of the process has been demonstrated in genetics and the rest of biology, the argument against macroevolution is, in fact, the downfall of the anti-evolution platform. Discuss.

by maxwell edison

Mae informed us that it was her. (No, I did not disagree.)

Okay, I'm outta' here. Neil, we agree and/or disagree however necessary to facilitate my graceful exit from this monkey discussion. Thanks a lot, jd, for getting me to swing into this!

by oz_media

You really seem to be the mature adult now. LOL.

Next time, don't bother attacking a comment that you don't agree with. I didn't post what you had wanted posted....to bad, grow up and get a life.

by jdclyde

I was all along, you were just too busy beating your chest to notice.

Is that what this was all about? I "attacked" you and hurt your feelings?

Seems some of your own advice would suit you well.

by oz_media

I've never done a US Costco, that's probably a good idea.

I wonder if a Canadian membership card works down there, otherwise how would you get one? Don't you have to be working for a US wholesale type business?

by Member 25348569

It's a matter of perspective and, given that I'm pretty damn secular even in a secular country, a "fundy" to me is someone who takes their Holy Book too much as the literal Word of God. there's lots of other things that they can do as well, but that definition is the most germane for this discussion.

Trust me, from my perspective, you've got LOADS!

:D

by tonythetiger

As I understand the theory, Mae [b]is[/b] the the center of the universe (but then so am I, so are you, so is Neil, etc.)

by oz_media

But you are complaining that I started an argument that you actually started and persued. Even now, you continue to persue it but then complain that I am arguing with you?

I am teh holy one who must be right? Yet your only resolution is for me to simply lay down and accept what you have said and stop posting to you?
Thus making yourself the one who has to be right?

That's why i dont buy into your BS, you are too much of a hyprcrite while you accuse me of hypicrisy.

Get a life, go learn something.

by maecuff

Y'all can be slightly OFF center of the universe. That's fine with me, however, I really don't want the share the center of the universe spot..