Discussion Locked

If we all came from Monkeys, then???

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by jck

you're no midget :p

The girl I have been talking to...is 5' tall. She's got a degree in engineering.

The Irish gals might lose out. Might have found an American girl to my liking...

If you're Irish and want me across the pond, you better send Andrea Corr right away with the dress...hahahaha

by jdclyde

If you had been reading along, you would see that we have been saying we DON'T want the 7 foot tall skeleton woman!

Come to jd. Will kiss that and that and [b]THAT[/b] to make everything better! ]:)
:x

by maecuff

I'm sure that if I were so inclined, that I would find you wildly attractive. :)

by jdclyde

after 10 years of marriage, the best part of a BJ is the ten minutes of silence! :p

by jck

I like a girl that makes noise...

talk dirty to me, baby!!! :D (not you, JD!! :p)

by jdclyde

got to have a nice joint shot of their shoulder sockets! All part of that skeleton look. A nice sexy collar bone is right there for ya too! ;\

no thanks. NEXT!

by jck

that's table manners...thought you would have realized the rules of the bedroom are different by now... :p

or the rules of the shower...or the floor...or the neighbor's hammock :D

by jck

Several have...think Naomi Campbell did.

A while back, she was sued by a former assistant for something...then, by a member of her house staff.

The girl is a nutter. Should be in prison, no matter how famous or pretty the world thinks she is.

I think she's ugly...just like Claudia Schiffer...and Kate Moss.

by onbliss

The study related to just the physical attractiveness. The link that I gave, compared the infants' judgement against the adults'. Maybe we have to examine with some of what Neil said about the symmetry of faces.

I guess, we carry the definitions of attrativeness/unattrativeness from our ancestoral groups, way back when humans started to evolve.

by gadgetgirl

Right.

jd - whose silence? Hers or yours?!
speaking with mouth full - no, just hum .... (honestly)

jck - noise - only if the room is soundproofed, or the neighbours are away
Hammocks are bloody dodgy things. Believe me.

;)

GG

by x-marcap

When I was a young and callow youth, I dated models from Ford (agency). I dated a few of them. Their obsession about weight was insane.

I later Married (23 years ago) a girl who wasn't hefty, but looked good in person. 5'8" 135. I know why models eat ice cream. it is smooth coming back up. I still think she looked better in person than any model I ever saw...

Yuck!!!

by x-marcap

Know the body...

That wasn't JLO in those shots...

I can only guess that the real body double must either sound like a harpy, or be too dumb to read lines...

by jdclyde

J'lo got a name that she never deserved and is given more credit than due. that is why she got the part instead of the person with the better body.

by jck

Hammocks are nothing...

try the hood of a freshly waxed 77 Lincoln Town Car in a summertime rain storm.

THAT is dodgy. ;)

by jck

for the Scotsmen: a MacCallan Bottle?
for the Englishmen: a Bass bottle?
for the American: themselves?

hahaha...sorry... ]:)

by oz_media

I commented on the simple minded theory you opened your comments with, which were also an open question.

If you don't like the answer I offered to your question, dont place you question in a public forum.

I don't see how you can't get such a simple concept as Q&A. It's got nothing to do with your spew about 'the great man speaking' at all. YOU spoke out against my comments, don't like it when you get a reply? Too f'in bad.

by jdclyde

[i]"Your opening lacks integrity"
"It's pretty simple minded really."[/i]
[b]
Yeah, those sound like a basis to start a discussion on.
[/b][i]
a higher intelligence nobody has even seen nor proven,[/i][b]
NOR DISPROVEN.

Now sod off.

by jck

I wouldn't wanna make him jealous of my lovely legs. :D I'll stick to slacks and shorts

by techexec2

The same logical mind that makes me disbelieve things I cannot touch and feel also makes me not rule such things out. There are plenty of things we all can see that we still cannot explain.

If that happened to me, I would largely keep it to myself as you have done. And, I would file it away for future use.

I believe you.

by techexec2

I think you are a man of sound mind. But, please understand if I would prefer to not ride with you driving.

:-) :-) :-)

by x-marcap

Golden Eagles mate for life, The Female will find another mate if she is still fertile.

Most Peregrines mate for life... but!

On rare occasion an older male Peregrine will leave an older infertile mate for a younger fertile mate...

But then he still "visits" the old mate frequently... In Cleveland, OH Peregrines have made homes on some of the tall buildings.

by x-marcap

JLO can also speak English...

Pagan is actually Puerto Rican and American...

Her reading ability was an issue...

by oz_media

If you're capable.

First of all, your opening DOES lack integrity. As explained in my post. I didn't say YOU lacked integrity but your opening question is not logical since there has never been any question as to why a breed of apes still exists if WE evolved from apes.

As for the simplistic part, the comment you offered was far to simple for the complexity of the issue.

It's no different than the old Monty Pythons lark where they are pinpointing simple theories. IE; If all fish live in water, then everything that swims is a fish.

Now as always any comment directed at one of your own must either be anti-american slander, worthy of reporting to Homeland Insecurity, or is a direct slam at your charactyer. As always you just take everything as a personal shot. You are either very insecure, unable to comprehend teh differences or are just flattering yourself by thinking everyone wants to talk about you.

As for NOR disproven, your point is moot. As there is no proof of existence then OBVIOUSLY there's no proof of inexistence. That one's a no brainer.

But for the sake of argument, or a personal pot shot at your character if you want to read it that way and feel good.

All we can do is compare reality, fact and logic, it's the way our brains work. Our fantasies and dreams help ease the wonderment around the unknown. (If you want to discuss human nature and psychology, let me know I can post endless facts to support those findings).

So what we are left with is comparing what we know to what religion dictates.

What we know, the structure of the human body is created from cell structuring. Every other thing on Earth also has a form created from cell structure. These cells are PROVEN beyond any doubt to mutate, transform and allow adaptation to surroundings. It is a fact that some animals have changed to suit their environment over time, even different races of humans generate different cell structures in order to adapt to the habitat we live in. Look at the Bhuddist monks that live and sleep at incredible alititude and below freezing temperatures. Somone from New York, even a seasoned mountaineer cannot survive in the same climate. It's not some act of God, their bodies and cell structures are proven to be different from other humans. They have 'adapted' to their environment.

Fish that live in the dark depths of the ocean grow giant white eyes, these same fish have been said to live in much shallower waters at one time but have since needed to live deeper for food. They have adapted.

Dogs have many different breeds, some smarter than others, some wollier than others, some able to act in very human ways, some simple and needy like good ole Yeller.

All in all, there is 100% uncontstable proof that genetic cell structures will adapt as needed over time to create a cell structure able to exsist in a specific environment.

So how is it so far fetched to see this happening in our own ancestry? This is a conclusion based on real, known scientific fact.

To suggest God exsists or suggest that Jesus walked the Earth as the son of God, there is no realistic, substantial, scientific proof available. We have ancient scriptures written by far less educated or scientifically aware people. These scripture have been translated into hundreds of different languages. In every translation the end result is interpreted differently. Example: One translation shows that Jesus walked on water. Another translation of the same says thet he walked BESIDE water. Small but VERY important difference. So how many other translations are misinterpreted? When we read the bible it is not written in today's common English, instead we get a general idea and conclude what was meant from the passages.

So while we can say that facts lead us to believe otherwise, we cannot say the religion proves otherwise.

As science has replaced religious faith over time, religion has lost credibility. While at one time both concepts were just speculation, science is startng to prove possibility of the evolution theory while nothing has started to prove religios theory, other than faith and personal belief, whether the Christian God, Allah, Buddha or Britney Spears.

Your comment in bold, NOR DISPROVEN, doesn't mean it exists. There is more proof of nonexistence than there is of existence if you realy want to split hairs and prove your pointless point.

There is far more fact surrounding evolution that there is religion, in fact religion is uncovered as more and more sketchy, contradictory and variable every year. Losing consistency, losing credibility, losing support. Much as you have done here.

by jck

Question:

[b][i]"If we all started from the same mold, how can we have become so different?[/i][/b]

Answer:

Evolution.

(I can hear the sigh all the way from Michigan.)

Essentially, all life:

Adapts (either through migration or mutation or invention)

or

Dies (do to the lack of ability and/or willingness to adapt)

You question why changes occur? Propagation of the species is strongest in those which breed the most able to adapt AND those most suited to the environment in which they exist. Eventually, the characteristics in a breed that are most suited to its environment will be most prevalent after many many generations. It's what Darwin called Natural Selection.

It's why you don't naturally see polar bears in Panama.

It's why you won't see an alligator in the arctic.

They have adapted over many many millenia to their environment.

Now when it comes to humans, we are able to overcome through innovation which makes us unique. However, certain traits of people before the modern era helped shape how humans adapted as well.

There are tribes in the African desert lands where the peoples' body stores more water on average compared to other tribes. It is most prevalent in the females where they have a noticeably distended hump above their buttocks which is a part of their body which stores water in the tissue.

This is an example of adaptation over millenia. These people are a result of their environment weeding out those people who could not survive their conditions, just like the Inuit people (eskimoes) adapted to survival in the cold conditions of the Arctic.

As to disease and what not, I'm not sure. I do know that when I worked for an indian tribe, I was told by the Lieutenant Governor (a friend of my parents) that a study had been done and that it was proven that indians and blacks have a higher propensity to contracting diabetes. They think part of this has to do with generations of people in their original tribes and which members were able to survive best on the diet available to consume where they lived. But, there's no conclusive proof.

As for so much smaller Japanese, that probably has to do with their environment, i.e. the fact that they live on islands.

If you look at the Mongols and Chinese (both descended from the same base race as the Japanese, called Mongoloid...not the same as the mental retardation of modern medical taxonomy). However, the Chinese and Mongolian people live on the main continent and tend to be much larger on average.

One theory of this is in line with what paleontologists have found with mammoths around the world. Mammoths that existed on large land masses tended to grow to large sizes. However the pygmy mammoths that grew on an island off the coast of Siberia were disproportionately smaller than Columbia mammoths in North America and those on the Asian continent as well.

Scientists believe this is caused by the fact that the animals who are larger require more nutrition and without it, they tend to perish faster than those who are smaller and require less. Hence, the environment tends to perpetuate survival of the species which are most suited to it again, i.e.- smaller animals would better survive on a limited land mass.

As for how long it takes to re-adapt? Don't know if that can ever be answered...would take 10,000s of years I imagine.

Anyways...enough evolutionary education. I suggest...watching The Science Channel. :)

by jdclyde

as there were so many supporters of Evolution, that some would know the basic theories that would have to go with that theory. I admit to not doing much study of evolution.

As for size, maybe that goes back to what they say about fish. The fish will get as big as the aquarium that you put them in? The more room it has, the more room it will take?

If nothing else, this has been an interesting conversation instead of a heated debate. A nice change of pace.

by jck

who was better: Nat King Cole or Oscar Peterson? :D

or maybe we can go with the Tyson argument...is Pluto really a planet? hahaha :D

I can argue them all. ;)

Thank God I don't watch all that network TV...I watch Cosmos re-runs and old Channel 4 re-broadcasts of "Whose Line Is It Anyways?"... :D

by jck

not tryin to piss you off, but I have to point out something...

The cell structures do NOT adapt.

The mutation of genetic material happens on a chaotic basis through breeding.

If a mutation causes a new trait which is beneficial to the life surviving in its habitat, its lineage has a higher chance of persistence.

If a mutation causes a new trait which is detrimental to the life surviving in its habitat, its lineage has a higher chance of extinction.

The same for a trait which the species has already for both cases as well.

It doesn't have to do with cellular adaptation. Your cells don't change because your genetic makeup does not change, without some undue, unnatural influence such as abnormal radiation exposure which really would not be a natural phenomena on Earth.

Just wanted to point that out.

by maecuff

It's interesting, though. Ultimately, did the experience have a negative or positive impact on you?

As far as worrying about what people here think? Who cares? We're all imaginary anyway..

by oz_media

I am not a geneticist nor claim to be one. I suppose mutation of cells was incorrect, adaptation was more inline. What I mean, and I'm sure you figured it out, was that we adapt to our environment. People that live in different parts of the world have a different structure that others. This proves that just as all apes arent the same, that all humans are different too.

My focus was that it's easy to see how we coul dbe derived from apes at one time, and yet many breeds of ape still exist. The point I was countering was just ludicrous. If we came from apes, whey are there still apes? That's just a retarded thought process. How simplistic and rashly conclusive can one person get? I think some people must actually believe that is a valid theory that discounts evolution, that's the scary part!

by techexec2

"...I exist..it's the rest of these yahoos..."

How do I know that you don't only exist in my mind and I had you write that?

P.S. I haven't been the same since "The Matrix". :-)

by techexec2

I think your experience is just another aspect of nature that we cannot explain. Unfortunately, we live in a world where some people will judge us harshly for conveying an odd experience.

Let's find a way to HARNESS that fog and put all of those people in there PERMANENTLY until they knock it off. :-)

by jdclyde

Let me make this as simple as possible so you don't have a problem understanding.

I was not putting out the hows and whys, thus I have nothing that I need to explain.

I put out a question only to the understanding of a part of the evolution theory, clearly stating that religion had no part of this discussion.

It is obvious that things addapt to their environment.

The question was aimed at WHAT about the environment would make some people tall, some short. Why would some people be genetically more prone to medical conditions than others, and so on.

How long would people have to be in a region for the environment to have a change on their bodies?

What kind of affect does globalization have, with people now moving to completely different parts of the world?

This may not be as argumenative of an idea for you, but oh well. I put out an idea to discuss, without the challenge that you have risen to and taken great care to break down. I have stated several times that I was joking when I threw in the "why are their still apes" part, but that seems to have been wasted on you.

As just about everyone (besides you) joined in on a discussion instead of an arguement, I would venture that it wasn't me that was losing credibility here. You can call this anyway you wish.

by x-marcap

Not the other type.

That is why I said mildly ;-)

If my wife prefers me to a Matthew McConaughey, I think she is blind, but she says she might not survive training a man for another 23 years ;-) I'd worry about him!!!

by oz_media

And was answering JCK instead, I find it hard thatyou think I am the one looging for argument when you reply to a comment not aimed at yourself, specifically to have your little poke at my comments, which you still haven't taken in context and feel it was a personal shot at you, that's either sad or arrogant, I havent figured out which yet.

What I find really amusing is that after all this tim ehaunting TR, you STILL haven't figred out that discussions do NOT always go where you want, you DON'T always get the replies you want, you HAVEN'T got any control over what is said.

But for some bizarre reason, you seem to find it your duty to monitor your discussion as if you had some control or say over what the replies are. Again that is either sad or arrogant also, just not sure which yet.

Get over yourself, yuo made a comment I feel deemed your entire post unworthy of logical reply.

Have an issue with that? Go tell someone who cares. There's no need to interject with my comments to someone else and then sugest I am looking for argument. YOU came looking for argument, I simply dismissed the topic itself based on your opening statements.

You'll never be good at selling your ideas unless you learn to carefully phrase your opening statements.

by maecuff

consider myself close-minded, but I am definitely a skeptic. I would love (I think) to have something paranormal, otherworldly, etc. happen to me so that I could get off the fence.

It's not that haven't had some extremely wierd experiences, but nothing that I can't explain away later, or convince myself that what happened, wasn't really what happened. I've had two different experiences that were odd. The first isn't so much paranormal as interesting. My older son (19 now) on 4 different occasions, picked my EXACT thought from my head and repeated it. This happened between ages 3 - 4. And they weren't coincidental, these were specific, exact thoughts. It was a bit freaky, but all that tells me is that our brain is truly capable of more than we think it is. Either that, or my son was some sort of toddler physic freak. :) The other, well, I've convinced myself that it was a trick my head played on me. Just after my son's first communion, as we were leaving the church parking lot, I saw a man standing in the middle of the street about a block away, wearing an old-fashioned black suit, skinny tie and wide brimmed hat. I turned to my mother and asked her if there was some sort of re-enactment going on, and in the 2 seconds I looked away, he was gone. No where to go, really, unless he flew. The street was empty, no cars, no bushes, nothing to step behind. He was just plain old gone. I've since convinced myself that I didn't see a damned thing, because I just can't explain otherwise.

Nothing compared to what you experienced. That HAD to freak you out. I'm going to have to look up 'time slips'.

by jdclyde

and you will see I WAS replying to you. You would think that by now, you knew how the max level worked?

you said [i]"yuo made a comment I feel deemed your entire post unworthy of logical reply."[/i]

it was unworthy, but you did anyways. Makes sense to me. But again, that reply was a reply to my original post, thus warrented a direct reply in return. Don't you remember how that part works either?

And after all that, I attempt to directly answer your last few posts, and instead you act like your surprised to have a response?

Quit drinking so early. You have completely lost it.

by maecuff

5'8" 135 lbs. isn't anywhere NEAR hefty. It's not the same ballpark it ain't even the same f*cking sport.

There you go, Neil..another Pulp Fiction quote..isn't it odd how many situations call for a line from Pulp Fiction? It's a running joke between me and one of my employees to say "I don't know if it's worth 5 dollars, but it's pretty f*cking good" any time we eat or drink something we like..

by x-marcap

We were both young and beautiful. I may even prove she was... I may not have been beautiful, but I was in great shape.

We used to ballroom dance 3 nights a week, and looked it.

Ah! My vanished youth...

by x-marcap

The sharp points of elbows and knees were less comfortable than a more rounded person...

My wife is a more comfortable size. She was 155 at that height and proportional when 3rd of 4th kids.

She is going to get back there as we ride 5-10 miles on bikes together. She hasn't lost much weight, but is now solid again... She is padded and 80% of my wife.

by techexec2

Just in case, you know I was totally joking with you about being a rider. But, it's no joke about your wife. I'm sorry to hear that. This answers mae's question. It's no joke when the unworldly experience produces a real world hurt.

I don't think much about unexplainable legends or superstitions. But, I don't "whistle past the graveyard" if there is logical evidence of a threat. Your experience is illogical, but if it were to repeat for you or others, that WOULD be logical and warrant action/avoidance. If it never happened before or since, I would largely ignore it as you have.

by onbliss

...movies that I had to watch more than once to like it - The Matrix. I have watched parts of the sequels on TV.

by Member 25348569

That is already nearly with us with pre-implantation genetic diagnosis (PGD), which is done in addition to traditional in vitro fertilization (IVF). Normally, doctors would select several healthy-looking fertilized eggs from a couple to be implanted into the uterus.

In PGD, technicians remove a cell from all of the embryos at the 3-day stage and then screen its DNA specific genetic defects like cystic fibrosis or for chromosomal abnormalities like the one that causes Down syndrome.

Don't see a lot of difference between that and abortion of an "unfit" offspring according to the "pro-life" moral code.

At the moment, PGD is only used to look for one or two specific diseases that a family has reason to be worried about. For example, a couple undergoing IVF who has a family history of Huntington?s Disease, may have PGD performed to remove any embryos that have the genetic signs of the disease.

If that were the case for me then I would certainly opt for PGD as I'd not wish Huntingdon's on any child of mine. But then I would also be in favour of having an early genetic test on a developing foetus conceived by normal means...

by jck

To be honest if you think about it, a lot of the supposition and skepticism has been wrong in the past.

Pteradons and pteradactyls were cast in art (when I was a boy) as being scale or skin covered like a reptile...not with feathered wings.

In recent years, there was more supposition that birds derived from dinosaurs. But, the detractors said "Dinosaurs didn't have feathers! We have no proof or evidence of that!"

Then in the past few years, paleontologists found the missing link in China. Dinosaurs (particularly raptor species) who had 4 feathered limbs and dated from the cretaceous period (124-128 million years ago).

So no one may be able to say discernably when or why the change happened in dinosaurs...but, it did.

Hence, I can't definitively say that humans did or didn't derive from the same genetic chain that apes did.

But if I had to make an educated guess after seeing scientific evidence of various research...I would be leaning toward saying that we did.

The changes in genetics...propagation due to better survivability in our evolutionary chain...etc...makes me think that we did evolve from something less...and hopefully...will continue to develop into something better.

by jdclyde

When the boys are watching TV I will sometimes sit with them for a bit. Thing one is a horrible channel surfer though, so I can only stand it for short periods. Last show of importance I watched was the "Fairly odd parents". :D

I have not turned a TV on since I was home sick.

We DO watch the DVD's from Neil though. Good fun. Will be into the final DVD this coming week!

If wasn't for the boys, I wouldn't even HAVE cable. or a home phone.

by oz_media

There is a lot mroe scientific evidence now and research uncovering new findings all the time to point towards our evolution.

though no true and confirme dorigin ahas been found, all info seems to lead toward an evolved and not created species.

The more science that is uncovered, the more 'holy' nyths are put to rest. Whie at one time, nothing was explained and such stories of splitting the red sea or walking on water, making an ark with two of every animal etc. seemed almost plausible, nowadays such tales have been reduced to just that 'tales'.

Sure, some peopl esay they found Noah's ark.. But was it really the Noah's ark described in the bible or just a big boat to survive a floods period or even move across bodies of water?

Remeber giants of ancient mythologu? Well it has since been proven that there weren't actually giants walking the Earth but more likely larger races of people, such as the Tongans. These men would be seen as absuolute giants to the men and women of Europe at the time or Pygmies for example. When the average height for a grown man, and warrior was only abnout 5'5", then anyone weighing 250lbs at 6'2" would appear to be a giant. Find that guy while exp[loring the waters and landing on the island of Tonga and you woul dnow have found giants walking in foreign lands.

Interpretations over time change the world and the way we look at it, including evolution vs religion.

by oz_media

As you have proven you have nothing relevant or logical to say to me, please just refrain from continuing your little hissy fit.

You said I was attacking you and yet you continue to stick your little two bit pot shots into every post you make, even when I am not addressing you in my comments.

Readng your posts here I have found them to neither be intelligent, thoughtful or creative. I have nothing more to say to you.

If you are looking to feel clever, you even have a little minion running around with you now, then feel clever. You are oh so bright and I am oh so lost. Probably why I make the money and you simply work in your dead end trade for a living.

Have fun with it, enjoy your little spurts of ,what you consider, wit. Think you are clever, have a laugh and look silly. half of what you have offered here is bull and the other half is all $hit.

Yuo say it's not about religion, now even after rereading your initial post, there is no way to discuss your post without discounting or comparing to religion.

It' slike trying to debate gay marriae without debating whether or not it's okay to be gay. Impossible unless you want a one sided and nonconstructive discussion.

But you knew that, your clever comments have proven it, to you anyway.

by oz_media

If you are going to run around the forums and offer your 'me too' comments, try offering a logical thought as well.
'Me too's' don't gain much credibility here, they usually just pop in and lose track before leaving TR. If you want to remain somewhat credible and have people understand your position in issues, offer your position on issues.

Currently, you just look like one of those American sheep that follows qalong and agrees out of fear of independant thought or being different.

by protiusx

Well my friend you must either have a penchant for pain or are just someone who wants to stir the proverbial hornets nest. I broached this subject around a year and a half ago and it reached thousands of responses. Neil and I went round and round (albeit nicely and without banter) and came to the conclusion that we could not agree with one another. We drank to it and went on with our lives. With that said I will post my views ONE TIME ONLY.

Darwin?s theory of evolution states that over time simple organisms mutated to more complex organisms due to stressors in their environments. In classic terms this is called Macro evolution. If this were true then there would be evidence of this macro evolutionary process in the fossil record. To date there has been no transitionary fossils discovered.

When one looks at the actual biological process of macro evolution the mathematical probability becomes beyond the absurd. The process of Mutation alone where over 99% of all mutations are disadvantageous to the organism (if not outright fatal) indicates that macro evolution would lead to extinction rather than an improved or evolved organism.

This can be contrasted to micro evolution which has been duplicated in a controlled study in almost every high school biology class. However, one can not conclude that this micro-evolutionary process can be used to turn the fruit fly into anything else but a fruit fly. Human beings have been mucking around with husbandry for hundreds of years and have yet to produce anything new. One can say ?look at the variety of dogs and cats? and the answer would be yes but they are still and forever will be dogs can cats.

There have been a great number of studies done and papers published by very reputable scientists detailing that the theory of evolution as postulated by Charles Darwin breaks down at a micro-biologic level. In other words, one need only scrutinize the flagellum of a cell to understand that the sequencing of proteins could not have evolved no matter how much time one cares to contemplate.

Now, in anticipation of the retorts I will receive from the usual suspects I will state that I have said nothing about religion, creationism or any other such thing. This discussion is about Darwin?s theory of evolution and that is all.

by jdclyde

Greetings ProtiusX. Read many of your posts, but you soft of faded out about the time I was coming on.

I wasn't trying to discredit any theories, just get people that are believers of the theories to step up and explain some of the finer points of explaining some of the HOWS and WHYS.

Except for oz, who is after all, oz, everyone else stepped up and put forward some interesting ideas.

More of a round table discussion than a debate, if you will.

I don't see this going anywhere near the tally of EL, although I DO hold second place! B-) It is losing steam fast, or at least it WAS until your post? :D

by oz_media

And yet you still insist I am having pokes at you?

One day you'll make sense, actually I won't put money on that.

Funny how I've managed to reply to someone else's logical and relevant thoughts, never yours though. hmmmmm?! Funny how other people email me and say they appreciate my comments for not being the same run of the mill Bs everyone else shares. Funny how only on egroup of people with alternate political beliefs seem to have a problem, but others don't seem to.

I'd say, just as I would to most Americans, try looking inward for a change, you may need to live in another country to learn how but it will be to your benefit I am sure.

by Member 25348569

Irreducible Complexity is alive, well and sprung forth fully formed from the fertile minds of Christian Fundamentalist Lawyers (blech! Now there's a group of people that I wouldn't like to meet on a dark night!).

If you would like me to repost my destruction of "The Flagellum as Proof of Intelligent Design" then I will happily do so. You forget, Protius old chum, that ippirate took on your mantle when you pushed off to the Land of the Exploding Camel and I continued to sharpen my claws and teeth. I learned an awful lot fighting against his stubborn trawl and cut-and-paste from every creationist website.

:D

You said nothing. You implied MUCH! :p

Seriously, do you want to know about the flagellum? It's really very interesting. :)

by oz_media

When you say "One can say ?look at the variety of dogs and cats? and the answer would be yes but they are still and forever will be dogs can cats." this is very true, and if you compare the similarities between humans and apes we are very similar, I think I've heard we are akin to dolphins too, but don't know where that goes.

Now cats and dogs, to ua all seem preetty much the same. But there are MASSIVE differences betwen them, whil eone may be very long haired, another may be almost completely hairless (had a friend hwo raised hairless show cats,eeeewwww,it takes a mother to love one but they all have interesting personalities that grow on you if you give them a chance).

Anyway, some dogs are dumb as hell it seems, others sharp as a tack. Now we must debate just HOW much more advance we are compared to apes. If we lived in the jungle, we would probably be at quite a disadvantage to the apes, they are appropriate for thier environment, in our environment they show extreme inteeligence and learnin abilities, yet still have quite an issue with vocal chords unable to permit human language.

Between other apes, are there really smart ones and really dumb ones though?

WE see dogs and cats as 'all dogs and cats', yet they are all etremely different by breed. Some are more disease prone, some can fend for themselves while others would starve etc. IN the land of dogs and cats, there must be a similar thing where one breed is seen as completely incapable and unevevolved compared other dogs and cats.

So the reference is not all that far off at all. the only tim esuch a reference would seem as you intended it, would be if peopl eall saw all dogs and cats as just dogs and cats. Not one breed being more advanced than another, or adapted to its environment.

Do dogs and cats see humans and apes as one and the same, just as we view them because we can't differentiate between them?

by protiusx

I can not believe what I am reading!! This is awesome. I could not have put it more succinctly myself.

by protiusx

You?re all still talking about micro-evolution where there are trait changes in the organism that can be attributed to environmental stressors. This does not equate to macro-evolution which is what Darwin was referring to when he suggested that we all descended from a common ancestry. Remember that DNA wasn't known about during Darwin's time let alone the complexities or the living cell.

by Member 25348569

Then he did a pretty damn good job considering what he [b]didn't[/b] know. All this time and you religious sorts [b]still[/b] can't put the old boy away! And it's not for want of trying, is it?

:D

Do you [b]really[/b] want to go here again? I've only got to cut and paste from EL.

by x-marcap

It was JD who posted your ancestry. I should have known...

I still can't believe you have enough medula oblongata activity to go on breathing since you have proven you have a micron thick brain stem. with a peferctly smooth cortex.

I had been looking up the wrong family tree.

Fortunately JD directed me to the evolutionary tree that you fell from...

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=199753&messageID=2082334

I suspect Baalams steed is embarassed that you were discovered to be related.

by oz_media

Your replies again illustrate just how slow you really are. You even TRY to sound somewhat educated, but really you just prove the opposite. Once again, you have failed to offer a post with ANY substance, ANY intelligent thought, ANY relevant content and from what I have seen you simply hang onto JDClyde like his little 'yes man' hoping to gain Brownie points...from JDClyde?
LOL Now there's a goal to achieve!

But hey, since you have proven your sense of humour and ability to rebut a comment is about that of a grade 3 or 4 student (I am being nice about that one too), you will instead simply resort to the same grade school attempts at flames as you have before.

There's a place for people such as yourself, actually many of them. Check out the gamer sites, they are full of kiddies trying to flame each other in childish ways, or else Sesame Street may have a forum where you will find like minded individuals, if not, try here for an instant IQ analysis: http://tinyurl.com/2oovs

I don't know whether to credit Max or not on that one, I dragged it from the TR archives. I know he didnt create it but he may have been the first to post it here.

by jdclyde

Who seems to be the one following me around looking for an arguement? Funny I don't see anyone else jumping on my posts to inform me on how to post or when. What is the common factor here? You maybe?

Fine, if it makes you feel better, you are loved and admired by all that have the great pleasure to read the great writings you place here on TR. People around the world hang on your every word and eagerly await your next post.

I hope you are printing off all of those emails you get and hang them on your wall. Something to help remind you just how grand you really are.

I am off to look inward, and humbly beg your forgiveness for not having the ability to post as grandly as you . . . . .

by maxwell edison

Cut from that article:

[i]Religious fundamentalism, bitter partisan politics and poor science education have all contributed to this denial of evolution in the US, says Jon Miller of Michigan State University in East Lansing, who conducted the survey with his colleagues. 'The US is the only country in which [the teaching of evolution] has been politicized,' he says. 'Republicans have clearly adopted this as one of their wedge issues. In most of the world, this is a non-issue."[/i]

It seems to me that it is Jon Miller who is politicizing this and is creating a wedge issue from it. If not, why would he say such a thing?

by jdclyde

and it still amazes me the ignorance of the constitution by many.

[i]"Ironically, the separation of church and state laid down in the US constitution contributes to the tension."[/i]

You would think that educated people would know better than to make such a stupid statement?

by maxwell edison

Cut from that article:

[i]Religious fundamentalism, bitter partisan politics and poor science education have all contributed to this denial of evolution in the US, says Jon Miller of Michigan State University in East Lansing, who conducted the survey with his colleagues. 'The US is the only country in which [the teaching of evolution] has been politicized,' he says. 'Republicans have clearly adopted this as one of their wedge issues. In most of the world, this is a non-issue."[/i]

It seems to me that it is Jon Miller who is politicizing this and is creating a wedge issue from it. If not, why would he say such a thing?

by jdclyde

was on the part where he blamed the contention on something that isn't even in the constitution. The ever famous myth of "separation of church and state". There is no such statement in the constitution, and the only thing it DOES say is that there will not be a state mandated religion. Neither recognize NOR hinder religion.

If there is a lack of adults that accept a theory as fact, maybe it is because of a failed school system that was pushing people though regardless of if they could even read or not. If they failed in even the basics, is it really a wonder that they would fail on the more advanced topics?

as for percentages thrown out of who believes what, I have never trusted them before and am not going to start now.

I do not know what percentage we share with apes, or any other animal. If we share a majority number with anything but apes/chimpanzees, does that mean we are evolved from them as well?