Right off the top, this judge claims that 2 thirds of the states did not ratify this amendment. At the time the amendment was ratified, Feb 3, 1913 there were 48 states in the union. Two thirds of the states are required to ratify any amendment, please see my previous post. Two thirds of 48 is 32. 16 + 16 =32 + 16 = 48.
Following is a list of all 50 states sorted in the order they joined the union. The order of the column are as follows: date state joined union, name of state, ratification date, and notation if ratification was on or before 02/13/1913.
Dec. 7, 1787 Delaware Delaware,February 3, 1913; ratified in time
Dec. 12, 1787 Pennsylvania
Dec. 18, 1787 New Jersey
Jan. 2, 1788 Georgia Georgia, August 3, 1910; ratified in time
Jan. 9, 1788 Connecticut
Feb. 6, 1788 Massachusetts Massachusetts, March 4, 1913;
April 28, 1788 Maryland Maryland, April 8,1910; ratified in time
May 23, 1788 South Carolina Kentucky, February 8,1910; ratified in time
June 21, 1788 New Hampshire New Hampshire, March 7, 1913
June 25, 1788 Virginia
July 26, 1788 New York New York, July 12, 1911; ratified in time
Nov. 21, 1789 North Carolina North Carolina, February11, 1911; ratified in time
May 29, 1790 Rhode Island
March 4, 1791 Vermont Vermont, February 19, 1913;
June 1, 1792 Kentucky Kentucky, February 8,1910; ratified in time
June 1, 1796 Tennessee Tennessee, April7, 1911; ratified in time
March 1, 1803 Ohio Ohio, January 19,1911; ratified in time
April 30, 1812 Louisiana Louisiana, June 28, 1912; ratified in time
Dec. 11, 1816 Indiana Indiana, January 30, 1911; ratified in time
Dec. 10, 1817 Mississippi Mississippi, March 7, 1910 ratified in time
Dec. 3, 1818 Illinois Illinois, March 1, 1910; ratified in time
Dec. 14, 1819 Alabama Alabama, August 10, 1909 ratified in time
March 15, 1820 Maine Maine, March 31, 1911; ratified in time
Aug. 10, 1821 Missouri Kansas, March 2,1911; ratified in time
June 15, 1836 Arkansas Arkansas, April 22, 1911 ratified in time
Jan. 26, 1837 Michigan Michigan, February 23, 1911; ratified in time
March 3, 1845 Florida
Dec. 29, 1845 Texas Texas, August 16, 1910; ratified in time
Dec. 28, 1846 Iowa Iowa, February 24, 1911; ratified in time
May 29, 1848 Wisconsin Wisconsin, May 16, 1911; ratified in time
Sept. 9, 1850 California California, January 31, 1911; ratified in time
May 11, 1858 Minnesota Minnesota, June 11, 1912; ratified in time
Feb. 14, 1859 Oregon Oregon, January 23, 1911; ratified in time
Jan. 29, 1861 Kansas Kansas, March 2,1911; ratified in time
June 20, 1863 West Virginia West Virginia, January 31, 1913; ratified in time
Oct. 31, 1864 Nevada Nevada, January 31, 1911; ratified in time
March 1, 1867 Nebraska Nebraska, February 9, 1911; ratified in time
Aug. 1, 1876 Colorado Colorado, February 15, 1911; ratified in time
Nov. 2, 1889 North Dakota North Dakota, February 17, 1911; ratified in time
Nov. 2, 1889 South Dakota South Dakota,February 1, 1911; ratified in time
Nov. 8, 1889 Montana Montana, January 27, 1911; ratified in time
Nov. 11, 1889 Washington Washington,January 26, 1911; ratified in time
July 3, 1890 Idaho Idaho, January 20, 1911; ratified in time
July 10, 1890 Wyoming Wyoming, February 3, 1913; ratified in time
Jan. 4, 1896 Utah
Nov. 16, 1907 Oklahoma Mississippi, March 7, 1910 ratified in time
Jan. 6, 1912 New Mexico New Mexico, February 3,1913; ratified in time
Feb. 14, 1912 Arizona Arizona, April 3, 1912;
Jan. 3, 1959 Alaska
Aug. 21, 1959 Hawaii
37 states ratified in time
By my math, neither the judge mentioned in the movie nor the person that created that document on the federal web site know how to add. http://www.gpoaccess.gov/constitution/html/conamt.html
The above web site is where I acquired the ratification dates for each state.
My reference for when the states joined the union is here:
http://www.50states.com/statehood.htm
Sorry, that amendment was ratified by the required amount of states.
If anyone would like to review my math, I used an excel spreadsheet that didn't copy wort crap for this. I will be more then happy to forward it to you for your review.
Dan
[i]Edited the crap out of this:[/i] I have bloody bad eye site, so if you see errors in this document. Trust me, I won't take offense. So please, point out the error.
Chuckle, by the way. 2 states joined the union the year I was born. Have always know this, but it's nice to see it in print. ;o)~ ~ ~
Let me add to this. There is a 7 year time period allowed for ratification of an amendment. I believe that was mentioned in my previous post also. This amendment was proposed on July 12,1909. 7 years had not passed.