Iraq is out of control
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by hal 9000
But I do wish to attempt to give you my take on what some people here appear to do. Granted we all work IT and some seem to think that because they can point to a URL it must be true! But for some unknown reason the very same people would treat with suspicion the very same things in conventional media like TV or Newspapers which they see as biased but for some reason which totally escapes me they are willing to believe totally anything that they find on the Web.
Perhaps because they find it in "Cyber Space" and they work IT they tend to believe it more, I really do not know why but just that it happens.
Col
by thelastword
by ippirate
Mental handicap that I should be aware of when discussing things with you so that I know the reason for your ignorance, lack of reason, etc. or are you just plain stupid?
From this comment of yours:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=159741&messageID=1656745
You live in Canada right? You do realize that BC, Alberta, Ontario, PEI, etc. are all "provinces" in that same nation right? You also understand that this means that BC can be fiscally even and Canada can still be in debt overall right? Those facts make your prefious comment ludicrous and in fact outright false. BC may be very much out of debt but as a nation, Canada is without doubt, in debt. I hope that this clarifies for you why I find your statement of "At least Canada is debt free" so drastically funny.
In response to this comment:
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=159741&messageID=1656824
To answer your question, I didn't find it offensive as much as I found it overwhelmingly juvenile and ridiculously hilarious.
And then of course there is this one
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=159741&messageID=1656846
I am peeing my pants again. You are so terribly thick as to no longer be funny.
1. You have got to stop this whole debt thing, you are making yourself look like an idiot.
2. Healthcare? What a load of BS. If your healthcare is so grand then why is it that just last year there were so many hospitals shut down nationwide? Why is it that Canadian citizens are seeking treatment in US facilities? Why is it that the hospital our youngest was born in left the impression of a cross between a 1920's asylum and a set from a Steven King horror flick?
Why is it that everyone seems to be screaming for modernization funding? Why is it that your physicians are so drastically over worked and people are going onto waiting lists to see a General Practictioner or Family Physician, the most fundamental of the medical profession? Why is it that your ER visits are going through the roof because folks can't get care for non-emergent problems that need to be treated but would be suffered through, done and the consequences of will be long felt by the time that person sees the correct physician? Why is it your nurses and you doctors are swarming to the boarders to work in US hospitals?
These are all facts. And they are all very key indicators to your "low cost, subsidized, state funded" medical system. Here's another winner for you, the rate of foreign body presence(this means implements left IN the patient)in your surgical wards is exponentially higher for a population that is exponentially lower. Another? Sure, recently there has been a massive scare in Canada at the dramatic increase of hospitals that have experienced post surgical death due to a common bacteria that, under normal circumstances is harmless but in the recovery wards is lethal. The root cause? Sanitation and general housekeeping.
Yeah, you've got it made and your healthcare is par excellence and second to none.
As to your comments about the lawsuits? Yep, sure is. And that is being proliferated by the Democrats because they don't want to cap what you can sue for. Folks are suing for BILLIONS, more than anyone on a middle class level can even imagine much less earn in a lifetime. That is way out of hand, Bush tried to introduce settlement caps, the democrats(including Kerry) shut it down. Furthermore, you don't have the issue near is big in Canada, not because there are no problems as we have already determined but because it is exponentially more difficult to sue the government!
To your last comment.
The current national debt is 7 trillion dollars.
I am well aware of this.
My statement was and is still how Kerry is going to fix that? Who is going to pay? It won't be him and it won't be corporate America and it will not be the poor and welfare class. Who pays and why should I support him over Bush? At least Bush is open with the fiscal policies, Kerry won't say more than "I am going to lower the national debt". Talk is cheap and words empty without explanation.
Furthermore, that figure did not begin on Bush's watch and I find it utterly amazing that everyone, including a flaming twit, seething with anti-American sentiment, would think it reasonable to place the entirety of the blame on his shoulders. It's asinine and ignorant.
CAN YOU HEAR ME NOW?????
by ippirate
I understand that issue entirely. The convention of the current thread came from my posting the link to an article concerning Kerry's whining about the lights and also somewhat I think the interaction between lastword and I and Oz's subsequent involvement(Oz if you are reading, not a jab, actually trying to give you the BOTD) without being fully aware of the pre-existing issue between last and myself. Oz and I have had words in the past, and quite nasty ones at that (I think because he doesn't realize that I AM RIGHT :) )and I was just trying to run back to a more diplomatic position, as I think he is as well, so that we can actually exchange information, call each other lefty/righty, Yank/Canulimey, whatever and move on.
I think that this is what prompted your comment and I hope that I have communicated my thoughts effectively. Either way, thanks for the input and if I am missing where you were going with your statement, please, correct me. I admit readily that it is important to me that I be understood in my opinion and that can quite easily come across as pushing it on, I don't mean it to be and I honestly do value understanding what someone else is trying to say, if for no other reason than I want to hate someone for the right reason not for a misconception j/k.
Again, thanks and let me know.
by oz_media
And yes ou are right, Canada does sit about 530 billion in debt, mainly due to bonds and other public investments in the country.
Canada as balanced the budget a few times, cretien was pretty good for Canada financially, despite the Liberal scandal that is now coming to the surface with Conservatives working to establish how much and where. The people have held Liberals responsible fo their mistakes and now they are being understood and blame will follow.
Alberta was actually Canada's first deb free province, then BC, now several others are also.
But when you consider that our NATIONAL debt (which is mainly composed of interest) is generally owed to the people of Canada for investments in the country (should they all wish to cash in at the same time it may be an issue)only about 23% of the debt is owed to other sources and while this is a large number and no debt is good debt, it really isn't that bad seeing as it is just over double what Bush has invested into the Iraq war.
As for the last fellow, I dont know if he's from BC or not, but it is irrlevant.
When yuor kids say "Elephants have trunks so that they can balance better!"
Do you reply with "What are you mentally deficient? Had a lobotomy or suffering from some....
Mental handicap that I should be aware of when discussing things with you so that I know the reason for your ignorance, lack of reason, etc. or are you just plain stupid?"
Why is it when someone doesn't know somehing that they are considered mentally deficient? Just plain stupid?
Just look at your analogy of the Canadian medical system?
Your entire conclusion is based on isolated incidents not a generalization of a fairly decent system.
Why do Canadians go to the US for nonemergent surgeries? Well they have the money and simply don't want to wait as they are generally not in a life or deth situation. We treat our sick based on neccessity not money.
A friend of mine had emergecy hip surgery (his 7th)within three days of falling. (it is a genetic issue) His daughter has had over 12 hip surgeries as she is in excrutiating pain and cannot walk or lead a normal life.
Last week there was a retired couple complaining on TV about the medical asystem and said they have MORE than enough money to pay for the surgery, yet it was deemed his wife's surgery was NOT imperative or even neccessary at his time, she was not in pain and simply had a dry socket which the hospital had agreed to repair but she had demanded a new hip. So unless we let our citizens decide what surgery they need, YES, they will have to go to the US for non-emergency surgery.
They don't want to wait, they don't NEED the surgery but I am positive there is a US doctor somewhere who would be happy to take their money and perform an unneccessary operation.
Now, in that same respect. WHY are Americans coming to Canada in droves to TRY and fill prescriptions? You can help people immediately, at a cost it seems. How humanitarian.
People aren't dying from lack of treatment, there have been a FEW cases but they also occur anywhere else in the world including the USA when people are simply misdiagnosed.
I have NEVER waited for care, and yes I have had lots. I have NEVER waited for an MRI, yet I read 'stories' about people waiting years.
I have a LOT of friends that work at VGH and UBC hospitals. Sure when they were TOLD to strike they looked at the southern opportunities, but when they found out that the union had scammed them into it, most stayed.
So it's not all garbage as you suggest just because a few feel they got shafted, I am sure that just as many and rationally MANY more are suffering the same issues in the US by not being able to AFFORD the surgery that is available today at 3 PM.
You had a point, but it was just degraded by your flaming of someone who simply hasn't taken as much interest as you. Like I said, in Canada we just live and don't NEED to concern ourselves with this crap all the time. It's a great FREE way of life that doesn't have our heads cluttered with political propaganda and irreversible BS.
Is it really stupidity as you say or perhaps it is just that we don't need to be concerned?
by oz_media
You are right, it is about time we all started to look at things with a little more diplomacy and I agree that in recent conversations I have noticed and shared the same level of respect with you as you have toward me, now if only our leaders could follow suit! :p
As for callig you a liar, I supose if you have a lot of public speaking experience then yes I did call you a liar, as that was the implication, "IF YOU..."
As a public speaker, I am assuming you have some experience in front of large groups (several hundreds or thousands not just boardooms and meetings) then you SHOULD know how distracting ANY lights, flashes, bright clothing even can be.
That's why, at most professional debates, it is required that audience members follow a closely monitored dress code.
I have issued MANY press conferrences and press releases, the flash photography is the absolute worst but even someone's watch lighting up as they check the time is extremely distracting when responding to someone else's question when you have to carefuly word your response.
That's all my point was, that I know first hand just how distracting it can be and can understand Kerry's concern with podium lights, as it turned out they were very discreet ad didn't seem to hinder Kerry's ability to make GWB look unprepared byuy forcig him to repeat himself over and over again even when corected.
Overall, Bush looked pretty sad, and I definitely took a serious and very nonbiased aproach when reading the transcripts. I gave then equal interest and refused to hold any personal grudges when reviewing what was said. Bush just looked as unprepared and unable to answer logically as ever. He dwelled on unimportant issues that had already been cleared up and adressed, he wasted several responses, by repeating the same old crap that had already been cleared up, all over again.
So, what about them Bears? :D
by thelastword
good god, get a grip on yourself, youre in a state of panic over anyone having any single possible edge in ANY WAY over your country, could you admit to anything being better in any other place than your country. Dont compare this medical system to any state run crap either, we all know what state run is about, it doesnt really compare because nothing in this country is as low and cheap as that service, nothing. As far as paying for medical care, yes then you woudl go down there ok? Can YOU AFFORD IT yourself?
The bottom line is you are terribly insecure and feel you own this forum. Your system is bogged down with suits and forgeries and if you dont have the money or work for MERCK forget it. There are issues with both, Id say they run about equal in the overall, Ive lived and worked down there lots and have had plenty of US doctors. The clinics were cool and all that, a couple of the doctors were absolute shams, thanks for taking on our well educated medical professionals I guess, the population of your country is some kind of billions so I would hope there would be a few JOBS there. We have americans living here who are totally happy and content and love this lifestyle, free of racism, without the blood of salvery on our hands and without the oppression of politics and extreme capitalism. There is a lot to compare if you want to go there, most people wouldnt. Most people from other countries just respect the differences
by ippirate
Dear lastword
What's in a name? I think that is a good place to begin. Could it simply be that you are finding it difficult to live up to your pseudonym and feeling a little frustrated? Generally used to being able to wittle away with your comments and get just what your name implies you want?
Moving on. You assault me with words in defense of your own erroneous comments which I am apparently wrong for pointing out. If that is how you feel then so be it. As it stands I would more readily draw the conclusion that you are drasticaly ignorant of the facts in a great deal of what you propose and a willing twit to attempt to act an expert on them.
Let us review.
1. Canada is in debt and no, British Columbia is not a country, it is a province of the country Canada.
2. Your health care system does have very serious issues and so does ours, that does not make Canada superior and I feel for you in the regard that your justification as a Canadian apparently comes from a desire to be better than America.
3. Your comments concerning other issues of past history is really not something that you want to go into. I promise you, if you are wise you will back off from that line of thought because Canada definately has no position of superiority in those areas either. Maybe you can show even greater wisdom and go read a few history books and current public policy/issue books before you open your mouth in response to this or any other post.
Your near hysterical and thoroughly injured state would be much easier to be compassionate of if you weren't quite so lopsided in your stance. You find it quite worthwhile to lambast me but when you get it jammed back into your face it upsets you? Go weep to someone who will actually care. I am not of the mind to sit here and gorge myself on your half-truths, slander and ignorance. When you grow up a little and can offer more than your hyped-up and overtly emotional brand of "I believe it, you have to as well" BS then, by all means, feel free to engage me, until then and whilst you have nothing more to offer than that, run away and find someone that is willing to play tinker toys or whatever sport would be safer and more to your skill level.
Oz,
In response to yours, your right, it may definately not be the best way to engender fellowship with this twit and I apologize for your having found yourself in the middle of this crossfire but I will not apologize to it for giving it what was given me. This jerk has yet to extend even the simplest of courtesies to me in his response to any originating post but it believes I should "be nice" to it's ignorant and false statements? Oz, that's BS and you know it as well as I.
Having said that, two responses more.
1. I was not attempting to belittle the mentally challenged, ill or incompetent and your right I should not have gone that tack. I apologize.
2. No, I would not react to my children on that scale and in all fairness, I was not with lastword. I have endured his ignorant diatribe from the moment he has first given voice to anything I have said and at this point, I've had enough. His lack of education, knowledge or intellect may be a mitigating factor but even a fool knows when to shut up occasionally Oz.
Thank you for the time to say the above. In response to your post to health care. Oz, I listed a great many issues that are arisen in the Canadian healthcare system. I never said that people are expiring in the waiting rooms or that the whole of it is bunk. My point is that these are all very real problems in the Canadian system (some of them are very serious) and therefore it is quite foolish to say that American healthcare is any worse OR better. Both has it's merits and biased as it is I choose US at every possible turn. My son was born where he was because my wife and I felt it more prudent to arrange the relationships on the Canadian side and have that in place for delivery rather than risk going to strangers if we were unable to get across the bridge to the US safely. Does that make sense? Honestly asking, let me know, tried to be as short as possible but not sure it communicates.
I hope that clears things a little. Thanks again.
by oz_media
Yes, I will accept your explanation, and I wasn't trying to have a poke either just that it seemed you were being a little overly 'vociferious' about it LOL! :D
ok, ok, I gotta stop laughing!
After reading the latest post from our new friend, I can almost side with what your thoughts are, but I can find five people in fie minutes that would say similar. As I am SURE you could also right there.
Oh well, patience is a virtue right? We haven't exercised much of it lately and perhaps it's time we did.
I have ALWAYS said I do not dislike Americans OR America but just the current president. I think the world has enough enemies already and we don't need to add to it.
I am not saying I am not guilty of the exact same heated responses and flames, but you seem to be wise enough to realize your own issues and accept them so I will also out of respect for you awareness.
It brig back mmories of 'Hands Across the Border', Max may remember that as a scout leader.
by ippirate
Thank you Oz for the candid and direct apology. I appreciate it.
Moving on then.
Yes, I agree, many elements can be distracting, even the sudden movement of someone in the crowd can be. Podium lights? My point was this, it is standard fare in debates to have a time signal and lights on the podium have been used for years. In my experience a light on the podium, fully expected to come on in the next 90 seconds is a dramatic difference from flashing jewelry and bulbs. In regard to this I thought it overwhelmingly funny that the Kerry camp would find this as something to complain about, especially for a veteran debate champion.
Anyway, I agree, Kerry did do a better job debate-wise. My take was that Bush allowed himself to show his emotions when it would have been more appropriate not to. He allowed Kerry to insight him to anger among other things. I do not think though that Kerry made any serious inroads on his statements, he seemed to have(at least in the short amount that I heard on the radio) a hard time reconsiling what he says he will do with what he did do. The most impacting statement that I am currently aware of that Bush made was that Kerry made the exact same choice from the exact same data that Bush had himself. Kerry did not have a strong response to that statement and I am wondering how that will haunt him.
As I said, I only heard parts of it as we didn't expect it to be available in Canada but as it turns out, our favorite radio station carried the first hour and I caught parts of that. A friend here at work taped it for me and my wife and I intend to watch it over the weekend. I'll post more of what I see and hear then.
Thanks
by ippirate
I appreciate the sentiment and the recognition that I do show some restraint when it comes to my flamethrower. Don't go getting randy though, I can still light 'er up and give it the go. :)
Seriously though, thanks for the objectivity.
by aldanatech
by ippirate
Delbert,
That is the crux of the argument I present. It was okay for folks to die, be injured or incur any number of other hardship for the past twelve years.
I understand the target of peacekeeping, policing and other "dirty policies" and at the end of the day, any military strategist will tell you that it is an incorrect use of a military weapon. Military personnel have to primary purposes-
1. Indirect defense and policy projection through deterrence.
2. Direct defense and policy projection by active engagement.
To attempt to use them in any other fashion is useless and undermines the moral of the organization, the single greatest factor of any military machine. Every military scientist in history agrees. You can place a grunt into almost any situation and he will serve willingly, valiantly and couragiously, consistantly, as long as moral is high. Remove moral and you have a chunk of flesh on your hands.
I diverge from my point though.
We have been in conflict in the Middle East and I think it pretty ridiculous that there are so many saying that to be in an aggressive stance or to be engaged in military action in the area but we have it seems to blow right past that we have been there for years. Furthermore, I hear continually about the GI's dying in the region. I am looking for the answer of what makes the lives and contributions of those who have given over the past 12 years less significant to now? Why is it now an issue that deserves national outcry and previously none? It's gotten ugly now and there are more deaths at higher rates. I understand this and do not make small of it. My question is why does it take this extreme for the American people to want it done and over with and the US out of the region but not before?
Thanks
by oz_media
Bush said Kerry looked at the exact same documents from the same sources and reached the same conclusions.
I find it VEY hard to believe, even IMPOSSIBLE to believe that the president had NO information that he kept to himself and did not share openly.
I think Kerry was given information and shown information that GWB had ALSO seen, yet I don't think he got to see aything that GWB didn't want him to see. GWB or any president for that matter would only share what they consider pertinent infomation or the information needed to reach a similar conclusion or agreement.
I think Bush LIED in that respect, I don't think he showed ALL his intelligence to Kerry, why would he, why would ANY president that's not an obligation of the president?
I think he dealt with it on a need to know basis and while technically Bush and Kerry did see the EXACT SAME documents, they didn't actually BOTH see ALL the documents, but the ones he was shown were the exact same documents Bush read.
Get my point?
by ippirate
First question, what is Kerry's Senatorial position? That's right, the SIC (Senate Intelligence Committee).
Second question, what is the job of the SIC?
To review intelligence provided, by any number of sources, for presidential and senatorial brief and forward findings to the Senate as whole.
Third question, why? To limit the actual number of people that come in contact with potential live and traceable intelligence data. Minimizes contact and maximizes exposure and apprehension of leaks/moles.
Fourth question, is it the same data? Yes, at that point in the game it was the exact same data and intelligence, every bit of it. Anything that Bush would have seen, Kerry would have to, it's the law and it isn't something that Bush would have been able to can or manipulate.
At this point in the game, the data is going to be drastically different because it is now at an operational level, before just analysis. The Senate has given authorization to act and now, barring a something big popping up and regular "briefings", Kerry wouldn't have contact with it.
Oz, Bush didn't lie, if he had then Kerry would have called it. The chances are slim and none and I think slim just walked out the door. Still, consider this, Kerry has made accusation after accusation of Bush "not being completely candid", doesn't it stand to reason that if Bush was going to tell such a dangerous lie and Kerry had the chance to catch him in it on national television that he would? He didn't, not because he didn't want to but because there wasn't one there to catch Bush in.
Food for thought, enjoy.
by oz_media
That does sound like a pretty good explanation and not knowing better, I will agree.
Even then though, I don't see the original findings as that important though, we all make mistakes and intelligence can be sketchy at its best.
Blair recognized and admitted as much with an outright apology to Britain. GWB had his chance and once again failed miserably.
Bush just ignores it and pretends he was right all along, I think that's one of the issues that gets me going the most, his inability to accept fault when he is proven without any question to be incorrect.
Yet he just says, well we didn't find the STOCKPILES of WMD we had expected but we have disarmed Saddam.
Who cares, that was NOT the justification for war.
If he had just said, our inteeligence may have failed us, the onformation was perhaps incorrect or misleading and we acted on a false pretense, it would be more acceptable.
Even admitting the war was wrong would be acceptable because everyone in the world knows it was an error. Yet the on eresponsible is still refusin to see or admit to his error (it wouldn't be good for the troops) BS it would be honesty, and that's all anyone can expect in these times, a little truth.
Thanks for the lesson!
by thelastword
by delbertpgh
Yeah, morale counts, but mission trumps morale. You can't use your military for objectives that don't serve the needs of the state. Otherwise, you become like Sparta... the martial spirit of the military arm has an effective veto over the politicians. Not what you want for your modern world.
The war in Iraq is bad only because it presents endless entanglements that will keep us tied up for years, and may never have a good outcome. It is bad also because it may make the whole Middle Eastern situation into an even bigger critical mess.
Winston Churchill was quoted, "To jaw-jaw is better than to war-war." With his accent, it sounded funnier. But it is generally true.
by oz_media
Hey, I know what you're saying and why. These "discussions' are generally heated debates but recently have been turned into swearing and flaming just for the sake of ruffling feathers. You should SEE what has been going on before you got here, TR has gone to the dumps with politics now.
IPIRATE would NEVER be stupid enough to try and form alliances with me, this isn't Survivor and I'm not in the Bango tribe. It's just people talking about the most venemous issues in our life (excluding our Vietnam vets who often "report for duty":p here).
We have had some decent discussions/debates go to crap due to the BS sessions and two way flaming, I am 100% as guilty as others in that respect.
It needs to stop and we need to get TR back to a cool and respectable forum that doesn't get reduced to a childish mud-slinging match. The threads get too long and hard to navigate, people start getting misunderstood because posts aren't flowing right and all hell breaks lose.
So have you're say, let others have thier say. Accept and reject, don't just flame. Ippirate and I are VERY different people with VERY different views, we also have found on several occasions that we agree on some key issues. So we let it drop now when it gets unmanagable and respectfully agree to disagree. Not Bango vs Kanjo tribe nobody gets a million dolars here for fooling each other or winning the head game. :D
by hal 9000
"1. Indirect defense and policy projection through deterrence.
2. Direct defense and policy projection by active engagement.
To attempt to use them in any other fashion is useless and undermines the moral of the organization, the single greatest factor of any military machine. Every military scientist in history agrees. You can place a grunt into almost any situation and he will serve willingly, valiantly and courageously, consistently, as long as moral is high. Remove moral and you have a chunk of flesh on your hands."
What exactly are we asking our troops in Iraq to do now?
Currently their job has been moved from the role of military personal to Police Men/Women and that is a role that our military are not trained to fill.
Currently I believe that we are asking far too much of our military personal when we asked them to invade Iraq they did an excellent job with very few casualties but now that major military activities have ceased we are seeing just how hard it is for them to function in a role of Keeping the peace. This is something that they where never trained for.
Col
by delbertpgh
Hal sez, "When we asked them to invade Iraq they did an excellent job with very few casualties but now that major military activities have ceased we are seeing just how hard it is for them to function in a role of Keeping the peace. This is something that they where never trained for."
And Pirate thinks that sitting around being shot at on a peacekeeping mission, where you can't just squash your opposition, is demoralizing. Well, damn straight, that's true.
We invaded Iraq, and now we're no longer peacekeeping while being shot at in Saudi Arabia. We're right in Saddam's home, being shot at, trying to keep the peace. Sounds familiar, don't it? But now, the stakes are higher.
I'm not saying we should pull out. I'm just saying that invading Iraq solved none of our problems. It just created new ones. Dumb move.
by hal 9000
And what made it even worse was the haste that was involved to get in there in the first place. I understood the reasons something about starting prior to their wet season or something like that but to me there appears to have been no thought of what would happen after the event.
At first everyone seemed to think quite rightly that things would be over very quickly. And I can remember an Iraqi Minister saying that the news reports where all USA Propaganda while the US tanks where rolling down the other side of the road. I think we all remember that one and our troops did an excellent job of it I might add, but their problems really started after they had won the war and are continuing till today and beyond. From the news reports that I see here it appears to me that the troops while being valid targets for the insurgents are pretty much safe {so to speak} where as the aid workers and others who where brought in to rebuild the country and deliver necessary supplies are easy pickings for these people who find it useful to their ends to kidnap and kill at will. Now while I'm sure that our troops are attempting to make these people safe as possible because of the amount of area that they have to cover it is an impossible position for them to be in and something that they are incapable of doing. This is not because of poor training but more likely poor planning as the people in the know do not appear to have setup safe routs into the country or safe areas for those in the country to stay and work. Now I understand that by the very nature of aid work it means that you have to go to the trouble spots to offer assistance but even in the most radical Muslim country Iran when they had the earthquake there was not one single foreigner taken hostage. Even though they are apposed to the USA the people from that country where welcome with open arms for at the very least as long as they could be of assistance to the Iranian Government who where hopelessly under prepared for that event.
Col
by ippirate
Again, as trivial as it may seem Del, nothing changed but geography when you get right down to it. Is that what has made it now wrong or less acceptable for our troops to be there? New problems? I don't believe they are. More severe and obtrusive? Yes, that they are but they are none new.
Dumb move? I don't know which way to go on that one. Yes/No. Both answers are decided on a roll of the dice. Stay the course in Afghan only and hopefully the UN can actually be effective in Iraq this time (you have got to admit that they haven't been over the last 12) and that they can hold it together? Take Iraq to the mat and hope that you can hold it together in both?
I don't think that either of them is any better than the other, I sure wouldn't want to make the call. You have to remember that it wasn't but what, 2 months before we invaded that even Hans Blix was screaming that there was no doubt that Saddam at least had capability. Then the intel? Geez, that would be hard to call. I'll tell you what I see, just looking at it cursory.
Two paths, four outcomes to oversimplify
1. Stay in Afghan after looking at the data and passing it as cooked (It's intel after all, proven value but not always stable, remember what led up to Pearl Harbor?)
- Nothing develops, we get bin Laden and move on to next target
- Saddam delivers weapons to anti-American agencies. Sept. 11 again except this time it isn't just a bomb.
2. Trust the intel and go to Iraq
- We find huge stockpiles and divert the ability to deliver a new attack
- We find nothing but a single exploded Sarin bomb and a cache of WWII weapons, no new attacks
- We find nothing, they are either already on the way and due for delivery or they are non-existant.
I know there are a great many variables to subject here but given the rough I can already begin to define which way I would have gone, how about you? Dumb move, maybe but I don't think it was the dumbest and I have to wonder if it wasn't the least in ignorance.
by oz_media
I thought one of the main issues that everyone agreed on with the Gulf War was that military troops are not peace keepers. They are not police and this was proven before.
Unfortunately in the case of Afghanistan, they were left to turn over such actions to those who which they initially opposed to begin with. Instead of police, they were left with thugs.
THIS is exactly why I feel a much stronger global presence is needed. Take Canada as one example, the troops have been more focused on peace keeping and policing missions as opposed to heavy handed presence (compared to previous Canadian forces who have been a formidable offense), this is also why I have often referred to US soldiers dying as a result of poor recon that they generally receive from Canadian troops.
The force has been built on an allied/global perspective. THe US military is known for it's size and strength, the British for it's experience and tactical forces, Canadian for humantiarian and peace keeping/support etc.
THIS is the force that won WWII, a collective of the world's best and most feared strengths.
You would think that such issues would cause some to raise an eyebrow and actually realize that no force is the ULTIMATE power and that multiple forces have been developed and carefully designed to compliment each other, not act alone.
This is why I know see Kerry's resolution as a plan that WILL work and WILL be effective in the shortest amount of time, no not quickly but in less time than the current plan is doing.
From watching some of and reading all of the debate issues several times I have become more certain that Kerry is more composed, more able to think clearly without predjudice or personal/religious 'core values' impeding his judgement.
I feel Kerry does have a better relationship with allies and his ideas will be well receved and acted upon as he come across as someone willing to work with th eallies, not dictate how they should behave or where they should help, which I feel that GWB with all his sincerity just hasn't done.
by delbertpgh
After WWII the US and other allies had to police Germany, Austria, Japan, and other defeated countries. After WWI we sent troops into Russia, to hold open a port for the White Russian army, again a police or garrison mission. The entire business of subduing the Indians of the American West was a police mission. The recent actions in Haiti and Bosnia are police actions.
Every army in the world is stuck with policing as a military mission. Policing is peacekeeping that does not rise to the level of war. The military objective is to maintain the quiet, calm state of things, not to achieve a victory.
Policing becomes a military issue when cops with their billy clubs and sidearms cannot counter the threat to the peace. In some countries, you can't trust the cops to do all the peacekeeping missions, because they are partisan.
Winning a war does not serve national objectives unless the subsequent peace is satisfactory. Armies cannot get away in the modern world without doing police duty. Usually different talents are called for, and probably a separate corps should be organized within the army of police/peacekeepers, but it remains an army-sized mission.
by ippirate
I am not saying I agree with now as oppossed to previous or vise-versa. I am asking what's the difference. I am trying to understand why the citizenship of my nation has issue with the sacrifices of the military in the region now versus the sacrifices of the military in the region for the past 12 years. Why has it all of sudden become and issue? Logic/rational dictate the constant. If military sacrifice is now wrong in the region then it has always been wrong. What does this in turn say about the populace in whole? A shift in ethic can only be deemed correct with a shift in data/status/situation. There really hasn't been besides the direct interdiction and engagement of troops versus the indirect suppression. The use of troops hasn't changed, just the methodology.
Is this making sense?
I am really not trying to pose an argument or be the "devils advocate" or to come of as thick. I understand gentlemen the philosophies of warfare, policy projections, international affairs, etc. My issue is the underlying logic to the entire anti-war movement. Does it sicken me that folks are dying over there? That GIs are coming back sick/changed? You bet it does. That side of it is very personal for me. I have 3 friends that have come back and are now exhibiting signs of Gulf Syndrome. I am waiting to see what happens with the other dozen or so folks that have/are come/ing back. The numerous others I know that are getting ready to go. I have a nephew who will deploy within 2 months.
Guys, the stakes for me personally are very high is all I am trying to say in this. Still, I have a very hard time saying that it is different (as in wrong) now versus 24months ago. The situation has not changed as best I can tell, only the extreme of condition and the method by which we are interdicting. Rather than taking a drawn out, passive-aggressive stance, leading to the destabilization of a regime and overthrow of leadership we have entered into a much more direct and overtly aggressive tactic to the same.
I know that each of you are attempting to address the question and please do not take it that I am calling either of you thick, just that, communication is failing I think, due mostly to my inability to transfer my reasoning cohesively to you each. Thanks for the patience as I try.
by delbertpgh
I've got draft-age kids of my own, and an 11-year-old son who may be drafted in eight years because we'll still be in Iraq, maybe.
We took upon ourselves to overthrow the government of Iraq, a socialist country where the state was everything, and one man was the state. Iraq is not some rinky-dink place like Bolivia that we could smash and ignore, but something the whole world has to care about: it's got maybe the world's fourth largest oil reserves, and it's an ethnic partner to the folks who own half the world's oil. So, now that we've reduced the Iraqi state to nothing, we've got to fix it, in some way that shows we care about the Arab self respect and that we have ideals worth exporting. Hard enought by itself. The Arabs in Iraq don't seem to want to make it easy for us, either.
I think this is a big stinking leap backward for us. The commitment for us is so huge, once we moved from police-type combat to full out war.
by delbertpgh
There is a basic problem with the Iraqis: they don't want to be our buddies. In fact, a lot of the time, they don't seem to have any perspective at all on what needs to be done for their country. They figure that government will always be run by crooks, and judging from what's happening now, they may be right again. I heard this morning about a bunch of U.S. officers around Mosul complaining that the Iraqi cops had not been paid in two months. I hear the news about the crooked way you can bribe absolutely anything through the Jordanian border... the only way to keep somebody out, it seems, is if he won't offer a bribe. The army is popular because they offer a paycheck... soldiers desert like seeds on the wind, sometimes run away from combat, or even sell us out. Sorry to say this, but it is a lot like the South Viet Nam army.
I don't want to seem prejudiced about Arabs, but it seems like they don't do so great at organizing modern societies. Whenever a democratic opportunity comes upon them, instead of launching a dialogue based on national self interest, it turns instead to a bunch of missionary crap about Pan-Arabism or the poor Palestinians or how society has turned its back on the true path of Islam. If a people refuses to think in terms of profit and loss, and liberty and happiness, and a tomorrow better than yesterday, how are you going to help them solve their problems?
Plus, this is not a free enterprise culture. These guys believe in socialism at every level above the retail shop. They also believe government should solve everything, at the same time as they distrust it.
The Brits occupied Iraq for 30 years and had to send the army in five times. When they left, after WWII, Iraq went through two or three brutal changes of government before they settled on fascism, in the face of Saddam. We're on the hook for their issues, now.
Call me a pessimist, if you want, but I see a very strong chance of complete failure, just as I see a strong need for us to do right by the place and leave it in good shape.
by delbertpgh
Yeah, it makes a certain amount of sense: you are out there fighting to enforce a peace treaty, although it is not called war, it carries the strain of war. It doesn't look like it will ever end, because the guy you fight does not negotiate in good faith. So why not go to the next level, open war, and fix it and get it over?
Is anything fixed yet? Is the fighting over? No. Saddam is over, but our problems are not. I think that our problems now are bigger. Building a new Iraq is tougher than containing Saddam. More U.S. soldiers are now at more risk and under more stress than before, including the National Guard. And now we're in a box. We can't build a country because of the insecurity in Iraq, and we can't leave, and staying there creates new insurgency.
A lot of these problems could have been foreseen. They weren't. We're stuck.
by oz_media
I really do wish there was a simple or logical explanation for this but here is a guess anyway.
The current war, Bush's missteps, casualties etc. are all brough into the public spotlight now that the media has focused on it.
12 years ago some people knew you were there but the issues were not deemed as vital because people weren't being killed in the numbers thay are today, the media did nothing other than the odd mention or update, no official call to arms had been made, and again it wasn't in the media and thus becoming common knowledge.
We have no idea what is going on in other parts of the world unless news is reported. If the news isn't interested, sadly enough, the people won't be either. Over the last 12 years there have been SO many top focuse news stories that Iraq was not even mentioned and was just a place in the sand. The media filled our lives with OTHER 'more important' information to be focused on (more important meaning the implication of being more important of course).
SEGUE: The emovie Hidalgo spoke of a race through Iraq. Iraq didn't even exist in that time as it was called Persia back then. In order to make the movie more compelling and understandable to US audiences, they used the term Iraq to describe the destination as it would be more recognized. Iraq is in the media, Persia was/is not. When I was in automotive school I had a shop partner who was PERSIAN, he would never say where he was from other than Persia. He was so embarrassed by what had happened to his former home that he couldn't even refer to it by name.
ANYWAY
Canada has troops all over the world as does Germany, France, UK and most others have done since WWII. PEace keeping missions in foreign countries have become a standard for all armies.
These 'watchmen' rarely make the news though, unless somehing goes wrong.
SO I would say media coverage and the urgency behind this questionable attack is why everyone cares all of a sudden.
People's sons and daughters are no longer being sent to retain peace or watch for resistance, they are being killed in great number while engaged in a full scale war.
So 2 answers for you,
1) Media involment
2) Full scale war has been declared
There wll be some who oppose ANY war ANY time, there are those who oppose any war where they see thier own are being killed and there are some who just don't feel the invasion is warranted.
NONE of this is possible though without media coverage there's no war, no death and no unwarranted invasion.
I hope this helps you understand where the appreciation stems from and how it is forgotten at other times. :)
OM
by hal 9000
While it might not be all that eloquent it at least comes from the heart and may lack some to the niceties that others have expressed.
For 12 years since the Gulf War there have been United Nations Sanctions and agreements to contain Saddam Hussein and prevent him from invading other countries. These Sanctions and agreements where supported by most of the Arabic countries in the Middle East and while they sure as hell didn't want our troops in there mostly they where more afraid of what Saddam would do if we where no there so our troops where tolerated if not overly welcome.
Now since the invasion of Iraq without UN Approval all that has changed. We no longer have a loosely agreeing group of countries willing to at the very least put up with our troops being there our navies stopping and boarding shipping and so forth.
To many of these countries we have become what Saddam was 12 years ago a unknown quantity that there is no way of knowing how we will act. It is under these conditions that we are seeing the current crop of insurgents and other actions. Currently the Middle East is a POWDER KEG waiting to explode. Unfortunately once we decided to invade Iraq for whatever reason without the approval of the UN and other Arab Countries they started looking at us in a different light. Sure they where unhappy with Saddam but really he was small potatoes compared to the strength of the COW who where responsible for whatever reason for invading Iraq. Currently there is a potential for a force in that area that has not been seen there since WW11 and the worry is that we just might decide to continue onto bigger and better things once we took Iraq. There are quite a lot of other countries in the region who we do not look upon favorably.
If you look at it from a Arabic perspective the main reasons that we used to invade Iraq where WMD's Iraq's missiles that broke the treaties by a minor amount from memory something like 30 KMS in range but they lacked any modern guidance system so they where not all that effective in a war situation. Sure they could be fired but there was no guarantee where they would hit the ground just somewhere that way {that is the way that they where pointed at the time.}
Now every Arabic State sees a large war machine which seems hell bent on doing as they please without discussions or agreement with the Arabic States. SO they quite rightly see us as a far bigger threat than Saddam ever was. They know that if our troops where wiped out tomorrow that we could launch attacks from a long way away that they could never hope to stop with weapons far more technically advanced that has ever been seen in the area and worst of all no way of stopping them!
However if we had of invaded Iraq with UN approval and Arabic Support it would have been a totally different story as we would have had the support of most of the countries in that area of the world even if they where less than happy they would have understood, but instead they see a force that they would not have a hope of stopping or even defending themselves against with far better weapons sitting right on their door step and currently they appear to do what they want without regard for the UN or any one else other than self interest of the countries who's troops are currently there.
Now if you where in their position and had a couple of hundred thousand troops sitting just a few miles away wouldn't you be a bit concerned? Particularly if they appeared to be doing as they wished rather than under the instruction and sanction of the UN. The agenda of these countries is unknown to the Arabs but a large part of it from their way of thinking is about oil and if they we are willing to invade Iraq for their oil what would be stopping us from doing the same thing to another country in the area if it was in our interests?
I actually put this to Maxwell a little while ago and it went something like this. A country who is openly claiming to prefer the first strike option is a maverick and need to be reined in. I used as an example Japan and the attack on Pearl Harbor. I asked Maxwell did he approve of Japans actions there as it was obviously in Japans best interests to cripple or destroy the Pacific Fleet. If they did not follow this attack they would have run the risk of being halted in their required expansion so that they had the raw materials to maintain their industry. At the time the Western World had sanctions on Japan and where starving them of oil and other necessary materials and then to add insult to injury we would only buy what we wanted from Japan and refuse to allow any of their other products to be sold on our shores. Under those conditions it is understandable why Japan chose to act the way that they did all those years ago. While I do not agree I do not see any difference here either as it was us who where responsible for attacking instead of enforcing the peace.
Now there are quite a few reasons for this action but very few where made public but what was obvious was that the 12 years of UN sanctions where not having the desired effect and if anything where making Saddam more popular with the population of Iraq not the opposite. For that reason alone I think that the invasion of Iraq was ordered nothing else and anything else that was derived from the invasion was just icing on the cake so to speak. Granted the Politicians made a lot of noise about several things but as usual these have all come to nothing at present and I personally think that the Iraq situation had become a thorn in the side of the bigger Western Powers so they chose to invade without fully appreciating the consequences. They thought that they could remove one major problem in something like a surgical operation but unfortunately because of the age group of the Arab Countries that plan has back fired on us as we are now seen as the problem rather than the solution and these young men who are taught about the evils of the Western World are seeing this for themselves and they are acting as they think best for their own ends which if anything is destabilizing the area even further.
Now if we where to be brutally honest with ourselves Saddam was a nasty piece of work but as Dictators go he wasn't so bad and if the only excuse was to remove him because he was a Dictator then we would have to do the same thing in almost all the Arab countries and Pakistan as well.
What we in the west fail to understand is that these people have only lived this way and know no other way to live so all that they are doing is reverting to type to defend themselves against the enemy who next operation is unknown.
I hope that makes some sought of sense.
Col
by hal 9000
That was just my take on the situation currently in the Middle East. While I don't personally agree with the analogy with Japan and Pearl Harbor either it at the very least is a way of showing just how an affected sovereign country may perceive the "First Strike" mentality that is currently about in a lot of the Western Governments.
Over here in AU we have a Federal Election next Saturday where we get to vote on who the political parties think will be the better candidates for them to run our country for the next 3 years or so. Currently because I hate politics I'm feed up with the whole thing and the current erection has only been going on for 6 weeks I really do not know how most Americans can put up with your long protracted elections personally I would go nuts with the constant barrage of TV commercials. It's probably a good idea that you do not have compulsory voting as if you did I could see a lot more Politicians been shot out of shear frustration.
But last night I did see an interesting statistic in Pakistan the average of the population is about 19.5 years old. Now can you imagine what the reaction of a bunch of hormone enriched teenagers would be? I think that the statistics is something similar in the Middle East as well so that may explain quite a lot.
Col
by garion11
by oz_media
I think you took me a little too literally but there is no question that the US military is best suited for combat and not peace keeping.
Especially when there are soldiers talking to cameras that say, they weren't taught how to babysit these people, they are trained to fight.
You may remember those comments to the cameras investigating police actions in Afghanistan.
Yes 'keeping the peace' is a military action when local police forces fail, the old "time to call in the army" comes to mind in fact.
They are extensively trained in armed combat though, not psychology or legality. Other forces have MUCH greater hands on experience in these roles than the general US military does though. This isn't good nor bad, I am not trying to deflate the US military in any way, I am merely saying there are other forces who are better suited for such issues as they have more hands on experience in those situations.
AI still feel that a full global force offers much greater flexibility in how troops are used, where and for what. This was shown in the beginning of the Iraq invasion where UK special forces were used for more covert/specific missions, as this is really what their speciality/strength is due to fewer numbers.
Face it, the US relies on other armies as much as others rely on the US, this whole "with us or against us" stuff is pure crap. It really implies help is not needed or wanted, just expected.
by jbp_pipes
Do you know what them people died for? The freedom your doing right know. Think about it! live'n breathing in the United States and still disapprove.
well.....................
by hal 9000
You can not force your system of Government on anyone if they do not want it in the first place.
The main reason for the current conflict in Iraq was the supposed WMD which we where told where a threat to all western countries but most people in the USA thought that only applied to them. At the beginning of the Iraq war there was a coalition of forces involved all of which participated in their own specialized area of expertise. This is something that appears to be overlooked now and the old ways seem to be returning that the USA did it all. Well if the main reason was to get rid of Saddam why stop there?
There are numerous other countries not only in that area of the world who have less than perfect leaders. Sudan has a very large problem right now that needs cleaning up but I suppose it doesn't because there are no supposed links to terrorists from that Government. However Libya which has already been found to support Terrorism hardly rates a mention now days but a few years ago their leader was the worst man under the sun and Saddam was if not one of the good guys at least tolerable.
Now I'm all for defeating terrorism at the grass roots buy I really fail to see that the invasion of Iraq did anything to further this end. If anything it has proved a rallying point for these people to use to gain more recruits and continue their actions.
Col
by jbp_pipes
by ippirate
I prefer to think of it point by point.
Thanks though. :)
by jbp_pipes
by ippirate
Del,
Policing yes but the one key issue that was never stated was a clear, definable out in the Gulf either. We went and we stayed and we we're scheduled to stay indefinately.
by ippirate
Del,
I agree, we broke it, we fix it and rightfully so. Problem is that we have been breaking it for 12 years and the committment has been getting bigger all along, never smaller.
I'll give you SOSDD but I can't give you "It's different". It's the same, just got bigger alot quicker than it would have if left to run the course. Either way we would have been met with this mess in the end. Why not meet it and try to start fixing it in this generation rather than leaving it to our kids? Don't we get after them for trying to leave a mess for someone else to clean up or trying to avoid the inevitable? Why should we be different?
by ippirate
You know, I sure am glad that the Indians, the Pakistanis, the Africans and the Americans didn't view themselves in the same way as you propose the Iraqis should/do.
The biggest problem that I see with your rant is that it is prejudicial and belittling to the Iraqis. What you are basically saying is that they don't have the same spirit, will or heart as many other nations who have gone before them down that same path. I my ignorant opinion I believe that you should be completely ashamed of yourself for more or less saying that they don't have what it takes because I think it a foregone conclusion that you can't justifiably say others have not done it before.
by ippirate
1. Oz and I are generally more at odds with each other than in agreement. I addressed him in a courtesy to afford him the chance of not jumping on a wagon with you and getting up with the fleas. He came into that conversation without knowledge of all our other comments and I didn't feel it fair to have a go at him before that was all verified.
2. As to you and your arguments. I think that my arguments are more than clear and my position solid enough to debate you, if that is what you call debate. You obviously don't like it when the heat comes up so I would suggest you not striking the match.
3. I disagree with you and funny thing is, the positions you preach from are some of the self same that others here do and we have a grand time of it. You can interpret that however you wish but suffice it to say that there is one flame war that I am engaged in on this string and that is with you and that doesn't bode well for one or the other. After looking at the way you attack and ridicule others here I am fairly secure in the assumption that your insecurities and tantrums are not unduly brought on by my actions.
4. Your trite little assumptive catagorization of intellectual prowess is very humorous to say the least. Still, if being more intelligent than I is what you need to help your superiority along then by all means, Iza bae a fool fo ya.
Now that you have all your questions answered and your ego stroked, will you please go find someone else to prattle of to and about? Like the ignorant ape that I am, I find the possibility of another round of "discussions" with you droll and, quite frankly, fearsome as you unequivocally demostrate a superior mental prowess with your deft use of logic and reasoning. Such a powerful weapon is critical thought in your hands and the level of insight which you display is unbelievable. Please, allow me to remain my ignorant, ancient, unenlightened and uninitiated self. You know, cause it's easier.
by ippirate
On a technical level Kerry won it. On the content level, neither. From Kerry I got the feeling he was playing dirty pool and with Bush I got the feeling he was witholding because of it. He seemed like he got in a couple of retorts but for the most part seemed his hands were tied. The whole "Come on, what are you not saying? What is it that is wrong in his statements that you aren't cutting back at? Why?"
Oh well, just my take.
by thelastword
by thelastword
by delbertpgh
The U.S. and Europe cannot function without the oil of the Persian Gulf. The U.S. made a commitment to the Saudis during World War II, and we've stuck by it, and now more than half the world's reserves and a third of its production is centered in the unstable countries around that shallow sea.
The policy question is, now that we have to be there, how do we conduct ourselves? There are three major countries, two minor countries, and a bunch of little princedoms, all with important oil assets. Saudi Arabia has got as much oil as the whole rest of the region combined, and it is teetering on the brink of civil and religious war.
We can't make decisions about Iraq or any other single country without thinking about the whole region. One problem is tied to a half dozen other problems, and if the cloth comes unwoven, the developed war plunges into economic collapse. At which point we really would have to invade, seize oil for ourselves, occupy with one million soldiers, deport populations to resettlement areas, and threaten with and probably use nukes. And get nuked in return.
We gotta get off oil. But until we do, we got to not screw up.
by oz_media
I agree that it was fairly even, Bush seemed VERY firm in his convictions as always, I think that's all he's got to go on these days, "we will win" repeat it 300 times and you may believe it.
I think Kerry offered great deal more in his responses, he offered what HE would do diferently, Bush just pretended all was going well, any idiot can see that it isn't though.
I think that while bush remains credible in that he's not a liar and he actually does believe what he says, Kerry offered NEW ideas, NEW resolutions and that what this war needs I think.
Someone needs to take a good look and figure out what is wrong, Kerry touched on many key issues, reinforcing support (that will go miles with soldiers AND thier families at home)and more.
Bush screwed up BIG time twice that I could see.
1) Implying that Saddam atacked on 9/11. Big slip up, but when he was caught on it, his quick thinking response "I KNOW THAT!", damn how do you get around a genius mind like that? When my son was young and he used to do the "I know you are but what am I" I would cringe, hoping that he'd grow out of it.
2)He took Kerry's styatement out of context when Kerry said Wrong war, wrong place and wrong time.
Well NOOOOO KIDDING! But Bush then started to twist and warp it to imply Kerry was sending the wrong message to troops in Iraq. Do you NOT think they know this already? Kerry fought in Vietnam, he also thought it was the wrong war and the wrong time. He rightfully said so AFTER completing his duty.
Kerry wasn't saying anything to bring the troops morale down, they know better, I know better, you know better, but BUSH instisted on continually saying "Here's a man who said wrong war, wrong ..." A question later, Kerry offers a clear explanation of his intent, Bush's turn "Here's a man who said wrong war, wrong ..."
Seriously man, if that's the best you can do out of 300 million people, well......phew, what more can I say?
But all in all, both were somwhat sincere, yet I feel Kerry was clearer in his comments, he addressed each issue with the appropriate response, he was VERY composed (expected as this is his specialty)and very convincing.
Bush was sincere and convicing, but had less to offer, no answers, no fresh ideas just the same old thing we've heard for two years, everything is going great and we are going to win by keeping it up, but he muddled, fumbled, tripped and scoffed like a teenager at a spelling bee.
My call, Kerry 1 Bush 0
by oz_media
by ippirate
I understand and appreciate your viewpoint, however, allow me to go back to your statement about Pearl Harbor for a moment.
For reference, here it is:
"A country who is openly claiming to prefer the first strike option is a maverick and need to be reined in. I used as an example Japan and the attack on Pearl Harbor. I asked Maxwell did he approve of Japans actions there as it was obviously in Japans best interests to cripple or destroy the Pacific Fleet. If they did not follow this attack they would have run the risk of being halted in their required expansion so that they had the raw materials to maintain their industry. At the time the Western World had sanctions on Japan and where starving them of oil and other necessary materials and then to add insult to injury we would only buy what we wanted from Japan and refuse to allow any of their other products to be sold on our shores. Under those conditions it is understandable why Japan chose to act the way that they did all those years ago. While I do not agree I do not see any difference here either as it was us who where responsible for attacking instead of enforcing the peace."
You mention that you see no difference. I think that there is a division between the two. At Pearl Harbor, the Japanese used first strike to cripple a nation they perceived as a possible threat to their expansion into the Pacific rim. In Iraq, we attacked a nation that we perceived as a threat to national security with regards to the ability to develop, build and distribute WMDs. I know the tangents that come with that last statement and they can go on forever because sadly, we as the populace are left with theory, supposition and hearsay to make a determination of why we "really" went into Iraq, oil, silence, weapons testing, etc. The theories fly but the difference between the two are clear, at least on the surface.
In regards to the rest. I would put it to you that maybe, as a nation, it was the right thing to do on the basis of peace keeping. In reality the Arab states were taking no initiatives to secure their region and the US, among other nations, were dumping resources into the region to do what they rightfully should have been doing. As pig headed and obtuse as it may be, there is at least this logic in it: If I have to be there, I may as well start working on cutting out the cancer that is keeping me there. Otherwise I am there indefinately.
To really be the devils advocate, maybe we (the US) should have pulled out of the region completely with the final communication of, get him under ropes or you can deal with his activities. If he attacks we will not come to aid without carte blanche in the effort and in the event that he attacks us or supports an attack against us, we will launch long range attacks against and targeting specifically, him. Cut off the head, so to speak.
I know that it sounds obtuse and leads inevitably to larger problems but to not do anything leads me back to this - everything was fine as long as our troops were there, quietly and meekly putting up with the BS, and they could have stayed there indefinately, that was fine. To elevate the presence and do what no nation in the region had the desire to do, take Saddam from power and actually move toward the possibility of bringing the boys home is wrong. In other words, the US should make itself subject to those who have no desire to make the issues better themselves.
This much is clear, leaving things as they were would have only led to more of the same. Stepping out has caused a lot of chaos but at least there is a chance for change.
Col, thanks for the response. I hope mine doesn't come across harsh and that you can appreciate my playing the advocate in this.
Thanks again
by ippirate
Del, WWII lasted from 1938 to 45 correct? Honestly asking, not sure. I guess that it is besides the point as the span of time is what I am seeking. Seven years there, I suppose more importantly 4 years for the US leading into the Cold War, Korea, Vietnam, etc. None of these being over in a couple of months.
My point is this. Is it really realistic/fair to expect this to all be over on the short. When we consider everything surrounding all of this and the conditions of the area, it would in fact be very foolish to expect it as so.
The military campaign, the actually engagement was the easy part, everyone knew that. Fixing it, that was, is and always will be the challenge, it's been 200+ years and we are still working on it here in the US, not fair to expect it to happen in a few months in Iraq.
The box? I agree, we are right deep inside one. I don't think it is a new one though, I think it's the same one, just new location. Like I said in the response to Col, the policy previously in place meant we were going nowhere soon, as in decades, in this policy there is at least a chance. Granted, it depends heavily on decisions from here out but there is still that chance.
That make any sense? Optimistic, maybe extreme but without hope then we should have just pulled out all together and let the region deal with it.
Thanks
by ippirate
On your second point I will give. Not that I agree mind you but I think that it is something that could be argued for hours and will continually come down to position/perception/opinion etc., because of the individual making the statement and the personalities of those who are left with interpreting it. I have listened to Kerry's comments and I have payed heavy attention to how much time Kerry has spent trying to talk with troops(This incidently works out to just barely over 0% and that in towns and at conferences, not yet seen him on a base) and it all adds up to just plain make me suspicious and nervous.
On the first point though, something to think about. I understand you analogy of your son but think about this. Ever get so frustrated that you start to stumble on your words, jammering, slobbering yada? You had better say yes to this Oz, I would hate to go get posts from TR and that is getting upset with myself and max and others, I can't imagine how it would be with your son. LOL.
Anyway, Bush's biggest failing was getting emotional, you know that as well as I do. Debate? Get emotional? You gotta be really careful with that combination.
As far as new ideas? I think that Bush does have and has presented new ideas and strategies as he has gone but Kerry's stand out because they are completely different and completely new, where as Bush's are developing from the overall policies and situations of his administration. It's really hard to stand out from the crowd when your policies have to play by the rules of what is already in force. A lot easier to make it sound better when you seperate what you propose from the current situation. Sure, Kerry made a lot of bold statements. One caveat to that though, those same bold statements were made on the pre-supposition that other mitigating factors either change drastically or become non-existent/determinate, i.e. the ally issue. Both Germany and France have already issued statements of non-involvement, regardless of policy or politician. Interestingly enough the UN has hinted at similar philosophy.
As Kerry goes, I am by my very nature repelled by the, "I'll make everything better" presentation he made. I have to ask myself how, how, how, how, and finally how? He hasn't answered that fundamental question of how he plans to fund it and that makes me very nervous, especially when he said very early in his campaign that he would raise taxes and hasn't said one word since. That gives me the impression that the single greatest truth he has stated to date has been about taxation. Look at Mass. for crying out loud.
by oz_media
Who is teling the truth, who can put it in to action.
I agree, Bush tells the truth in what he is saying. He feels he has some allied suport and that it is sufficient, he also feels he has a close enough relationship with allies that he has done his best, and he probably has but is it enough?
Not from what I am seeing from Iraq. Now another post on another forum said that the reason everyone outside America is against the war is because they see only negative news, duh yeah! We see the happy stuff too, but they don't seem to show as much negative reality in the US news. So YES, we get a different picture, the question is, WHY AREN'T YOU GUYS ? Yes it is all fine if we disregard the negative, but reality commands that we need to see both.
So whilst GWB is very firm in his convictions and I believe SOMEWHAT honest at least to the point of stating his plans, I do not see it as being effective, it has gone from bad to worse, with not even a glimmer of hope as of yet.
I feel Kerry DOES have a better relationship with allied countries than Bush does, he is also a professional at debatig and presenting his case as this is what he does, his ability to coerce allies would be FAR better than Bush, in my eyes. The world DOESN'T LIKE Bush, his Allies think he's a dolt half his own countrymen think he's a dolt, so where does one expect him to gain credibility and support? Sorry, Republicans just ain't gonna be enough.
Kerry is welcomed, his ideas are welcomed and his goals are fresh, I am confident that he will succeed FAR better than Bush could ever hope to with gaining alied suport. Perhaps not Germany, perhaps not France but there are tens of coutries he could approach. Even existing allies may be coerced to lending more troops, arms and monetary suport, thus reducing the US burden. His aim is to share the burden, I think he will succeed, Bush DEFINITELY won't (succeed at getting the burden solely off of America's shoulders) nor will he attempt to, he thinks he's doing just fine and doesn't need anyone else to help out.
I think one day he may wake up, and like a blast of cold air it will hit him, 'what have I got myself into?' Where did I go wrong? What happened to my nonexistent plans? He tried, he tried REALLY hard, but from what I see, he has also failed at this point. Perhaps several hundred billion more, perhaps a few thousand more US lives, perhaps ....he MAY win by just sticking it out, you do have a larger population after all, they cannot kill one for one ad hope to win in the end. But why SHOULD you need to go to all that in order to succeed, when someone else may share the loss, burden and responsibility moreso than they do now?
by hal 9000
Offer any comments on the "Debate" other than the "TRUTH" is relative depending on how you as a person wish to view it.
This was brought home to me a very long time ago when I saw a death in a car collision. At the Coroners Court there where at least 6 direct wittinesses to the collision and they all saw a different thing. Now while none of them where directly lying they had all put their own emotions and beliefs into what they described. The same applies to Political Debates.
Currently the UN appears to be in a neutral position and do not appear willing to come in as they seem to have the idea that you created this mess without our support and if anything in direct violation of our agreements so we'll leave it to you to clean up. Here I don't just mean the USA but the COW.
So unless something drastic happens I think they will stay that way. Incidental I did see an interesting statistic last night about Pakistan the average of the population there is about 19.5 years old so if the same applies to the Middle East countries we could have a very large problem as teenagers think that they are indestructible and the "Old Farts" like me want to be a lot more conservative with our lives.
Col
by delbertpgh
WWII started at different times for different countries. For the U.S. it was Dec 41 thru Sep 45. For Europe it was Sep 39 thru May 45. For the Chinese, it started in 1937. The whole war cost 55 million lives, the great bulk of them Chinese and Russian. The US had a population of 130 million, put 16 million into uniform, and saw 400,000 die. Germany, a smaller country, had 7 million deaths, half of them civilian. It was a level of commitment that we can scarcely imagine today.
Iraq is far smaller, but I think it was a task we should have avoided. The place is filled with problems that cannot be fixed by pointing a gun at them, and the Iraqis don't want to fix them on their own. One of GWB's war objectives, which I infer, was to shock all Arab states into modernity by turning Iraq into a rich and successful country, founded on the rule of law, democracy, and free enterprise. We could utterly fail in all of those objectives.
Saddam was a source of instability in the Middle East, but for as long as we are occupying a country and stirring up the faithful, the United States will be a source of instability.
A lot of guys like Victor Davis Hansen and the neocons at Commentary and the Weekly Standard feel that when we defeat a country at war, like Germany and Japan in WWII, a much better country results from it. Our success in reforming those two was due to our national unity, lots of money, lots of luck, the cold war, and unique local conditions.
We may not be successful in reforming Iraq, and we may create more regional trouble than we solve. That's two big reasons I think we should have held back.
by rickkellogg
Imagine for a moment its Fall 2007, Iraq has had a Democratic Government in place for over 2 years and the economy there is thriving. The fighting has been over for more than a year and all but a small contingent of US Forces have been re deployed to other parts of the world.
An awful lot of folks thought President Regan was crazy back in the 80's spending money like a drunken sailor on defense. He knew what he was doing just as George W knows what he is doing. The Evil Empire simply gave up as they could no longer keep up with the US in defense spending. (The Golden Rule) Whom ever has the Gold Rules!
Whether or not the first paragraph of this note becomes reality will be determined in about 27 Days on November 2nd. I for one believe the picture to be closer to this then many of the Whining Liberal Left would lead you to believe with the Doom and Gloom scenarios they keep spewing out. Do I like the fact that over 1000 Americans have lost their lives in this battle half way around the world? Certainly not. However, better that we take the fight to them on their own ground and keep them and their considerable resources struggling for survival, than simply closing our eyes and hoping the problem will go away.
Like I said 27 days from now when George W is re elected perhaps we will have a fresh perspective and mandate on this issue and about 3 years to get it resolved.
by oz_media
So in a dream of prfection, this will all be roses and lollipops in three years. I know that is truly positive speculation. VERY positive, I am sure the world would LOVE to see it. Then we could focus on the next enemy, then the next and so on until the world is one.
"Better we take the fight to them on thier own ground."
This implies you were attacked or WOULD be attacked by Saddam. As you say hindsight is 20/20, so you should know and agree by now that Saddam had neither the means or the ability to do so at this time, just as those who didn't support the invasion had suggested and said that you should focus on more imprative issues other than Saddam not liking GWB or tying to assassinate his father. Saddam was not a direct or imminent threat to the USA, he barely had the technology to lob missiles at his neighbours with complete inaccuracy, yet alone launch a trans-Atlantic chemical attack on key US targets. It was all hype, not reality.
Doom and gloom scenarios, you mean live news I suppose. Well I hate to break it to you like this but even with all the victory and comradery surrounding a war, there is a lot of "doom and gloom" except others treat this as REALITY instead of dismissing it as propaganda. A picture's worth a thousand words right?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Why is it that the Right wing is offended with words like gun toting or war monger, and yet they in turn see it fit to refer to every non-republican as "Whining Liberal Left"?
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Why is it that everything Non-Republican is lies, deception and BS. Yet the ONE person who HAS been proven as deceptive, misleading, acting on false pretenses etc., is actually a Republican?
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
Lets just hope there are enough level headed citizens in the USA that understand how they were deceived and led astray for FOUR years, to make sure this detriment to the safety of mankind is removed from his office, or is that his orifice.
by rickkellogg
Time and current events has a way of erroding the memory of the past. Fortunately you are in Canada where I believe you have your own social issues to contend with. Like timely health care, and holding the country together (Quebec).
As Canada posses no threat to anyone except perhaps themselves hey...Pass the Molson..
You actually have no say in anything we do on this side of the border. So I for one would appreciate it if you would confine your thoughts on Global issues to Hockey, Brewskies, and controlling the French Rebels in Quebec. While your at it perhaps you could find a way to provide medical care to your socialist population and free up the border crossings with the daily exodus of your citizens coming here to see our Physicians.
by oz_media
Well you tried the same old same old that every American thinks he is right about Canada.
So here's a fair reponse.
First of all let me explain the difference between internal and Global issues that you seem to confuse.
Firstly, the war in Iraq is a GLOBAL issue. Your actions or inactions effect the entire free world, therefore your invasion of Iraq is EVERYONE'S business, not just your own.
Canadian economics, you suggest is a GLOBAL issue, this is actually an internal issue and none of YOUR business. Should your doctors CHOOSE to MAKE MONEY from Canadians who go south for non-emergency surgery let them cash in, I believe that IS the American capitalistic way, your doctors are fee to make money off of whomever they choose whether they need an operation or not. Neither myself nor anyone I have EVER met has been refused surgery or told to wait indefinitely for an operation. In fact while in a waiting room for an MRI scan on my kneck (three days after seeing my GP, due to MY schedule not making me available sooner)I was reading a magazine article about an Eastern Canadian lady who was complaining about a long wait for an MRI.
In Canada, we treat our sick on an urgncy basis, those that NEED surgery GET surgery, those that CAN wait, wait. A lady a few months ago was in the paper saying she couldn't get a hip replacement surgery. As it turns out, they HAD offered reconstructive surgery, she had seen a magazine article on some NEW type of hip socket and demanded the operation. She was told it wasn't needed and that the existing (man made) socket is fine but needed adjustment. Her respose was to bitch to the press and say she would go south for the operation, which isn't even approved in Canada yet as we have closely regulated medical procedures and drugs, no experimental human 'lab rats' here.
In contrast with US systems, those that need or don't need surgery is irrelevant. It is WHO has insurance or WHO can pay for it, yes MUCH better, if you are able to pay for insurance keep up with your remiums or pay big bucks for a doctor when you haven't been able to ay premiums!
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
"As Canada posses no threat to anyone except perhaps themselves"
We also haven't brought on our own enemies, the ONLY threats upon Canada are a result of US actions. Don't be upset if I don't say thanks.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
The French? I think they live a few thousand Km's in the other direction, they were having issues about becoming a separate country, let em.
Done deal, Canada's troubles resolved.
Now, let's look at the GLOBAL issues that surround Canada's safety and pose a threat for Canada's soldiers.
Well they are doing just fine at your side in Afghanistan. They were fine when they fought at your side in WWII (even long before you got there)in fact they were the most successful force to land on d-day! The Us relies HEAVILIY on Canadian forces for recon missions and humanitarian/peacekeeping efforts. Canadian forces are very well trained and very welcome at your side in times of war, even if the numbers are fewer now.
So I guess we can discount the insinuations that Canada's military is of no use to you, either. I know there as been at least on tank commander who said he would not have lost friends if Canada had Coyote's in Iraq.
So you made a few claims, but maybe understanding that your isues ARE global and ours ARE internal will help you understand why this is just as much my business and ANYONE's business as it is your own and our business is none of yous.
Now perhaps you can tell YOUR medical patients to STOP coming to Canada to get prescriptions filled at an affordable cost. You know, the senior citizens and people that don't matter down there.
P.S. In all your rating about my post and about canada's internal affairs, you conveniently neglected to respond in defence of the inaccuracies I pointed out in your previous post regarding Iraq. You afiled to answer questions and you discounted nothing I had said. Seeing as this is VERY common from Republicans when they have no leg to stand on, can I assume that you admit your post was completely wrong as pointed out?
What memories of the past do you speak of?
The battle of Britain?
Vietnam?
The rise and fall of the roman empire?
9/11?
How many Canadians and thier families were directly efected by 9/11?
How many Canadians DIED on that trrible day in WORLD history?
Or again, is it just an American thing and nobody else's business?
by rickkellogg
Looking back 2-3 or even 10 years from now on these issues you seem to be so concerned about I am 100% certain that you and your liberal minority friends will find a way to discount the job that was done in Iraq. Christ if Iraq became the 51st State you would probably find fault with that. You and your type seem to argue for the sake of arguing.
While the loss of life is deplorable now and back on 9-11 the fact is it was America that was attacked. Now argue as you will that it was not Iraq that attacked us. The point is we have chosen the battlefield, thousands of miles from our shores. We are essentially creating a vacuum within Iraq for terrorist to concentrate their efforts trying to demoralize us. Its not working, and they are dying at a rate expotentially higher than our losses.
Had we stuck our Heads in the Sand utilizing the Hope they don't come back methodology you seem to endorse I am fairly confident that we would have been attacked again and possibly much worse than the attack of 9-11. I am very content to keep them on the other side of the globe dying as martyrs in search of the 100 Virgins.
The period in time I was referring to was under President Reagan. When the left was complaining about the billions we were spending on defense. Remember Star Wars? Where is the Evil Empire today?
Am I a Hawk you bet. Will Iraq be the last Battlefield on Terrorism, not likely. Will the US attack another county known to harbor terrorist, or trying to develop nucelear weapons? I hope so. As long as we continue to take the fight to them they are too pre-occupied to stratigize another major attack on America.
by hal 9000
That Terrorists don't belong to countries and if you where to logically follow your own argument it would have been Saudi Arabia which was invaded as most of the 9-11 people came from that country.
As far ass looking back in 10 - 15 years time I would very much hate to be looking back on our troops being tried for "War Crimes" when we lost this war. What you have to remember here is that it is the winners who dictate the outcomes of conflicts and as much as you seem unable to believe that the USA could loose this conflict you do not have a very good record in recent times. Korea is currently in a state of Cease Fire and that "Police Action" has never ended yet. Vietnam was lost and horribly as well.
Now with that in mind do you seriously believe that what remains of the COW is capable of withstanding a combined assault by a United Muslim Nations? Currently the Radicals are painting the current conflict not as a "War on Terror" but a "War on Islam" and while we continue to involve countries that had no part in 9-11 or any of the subsequent bombings no matter how much we dislike the leader we are playing right into their hands as it very much looks like we are not just attacking Terrorists but Islamic Nations at random and without good cause. That is what is being portrayed by the very people we should be attempting to stop and not getting sidetracked on a tangent to the actual problem.
Sure we might have a battle field half way around the world from the USA but unfortunately the very groups that we should be attempting to discredit are growing at an alarming rate and while some of their new recruits do end up in Iraq sure as God made little green apples that vast majority will not end up there but on your soil doing more damage than they previously had.
The very idea of terror is to terrorize and this doesn't happen half way around the world but on your own door step. Personally I would be upgrading home defenses and tightening your belts waiting for the next attack which will be coming. The only good thing about 9-11 was that the person responsible for arranging that attack had a one tracked mind when it came to the WTC and really made a very poor choice. That attack should have been far worse that it was.
So treat it as the "WAKE UP CALL" that it was and don't bury your heads in the sand thinking that you have a war a long way away so you will not be directly affected by whatever happens.
One other thing what is currently happening in Iraq is no longer a war as the troops are not getting "Battle Pay" and it is in that area where they have suffered the majority of their casualties while inflicting very little harm to those who are apposing them. You have to get the idea out of your head that this war is about controlling land as it isn't it is about controlling the youth of the Islamic world with an IDEA that you can not hope to fight and destroy!
Col
by oz_media
Firstly, you are wrong in thinking I am a Liberal, I didn't and don't vote Liberal. In a business erspective I am FAR closer to a US Republican than a Canadian Liberal, on issues of war and retaliation, I am not a Republican thinker at all, nor am I a Liberal or Democratic thinker.
That aside, you kep saying you hae prevented a further attack on the USA, do you REALLY think Saddam was able to or planing on attacking the US in the near future (say 3-5 years?) he didn't hae the capability and it has been shown since that his plans to develop weapons of mass destruction were actually reduced since the sanctions were placed on him 12 years ago, labs hadn't been used in years etc.
So anyway, all that aside. You DO realize that North America is not said to be nor ever was planned to be the next terrorist target. al-Qaeda has been rebuildig far stronnger than before in MANY countries, they have been able to do so with little resistance and even support in many. The next tarrorist target is said to be London England's Tube, they have been preparing and planning a recovery strategy ever sice the news broke, they didn't simply discount it as just another threat and people are ready for what may happen.
I never at ANY point in ANY of my posts said that this war wasn't neccessary, nor have I EVER said that Saddam wasn't a dictator to be removed, neither had any of your allies, the UN etc. Th justification was wrong and is a crime, Bush lied abotu waiting until it was a last resort, he lid abaout waiting for UN inspectors to finish. He didn't like the fact they found nothing, he was CERTAIN there were stockpiles of WMD even though he had been told otherwsie by his advisors and inside sources.
The rest of the world is gung-ho on the war on terror, the rest of the world is actively investigating, watching and looking to stop the gowth of al-Qaeda (the terrorists who attacked YOU) while you stil Iraq.
The war in Iraq shouldn't be stopped, you're in to deep now. The war in Iraq should have never started to begin with, BUT you did and now the free democratic world will suffer as a result of your actions.
Bush, in my mind, dos NOT have what it takes, he is underqualified and as his actions prove incapable.
I do not know if Kerry is any better, but in no way could he trump what Rumsfield and Bush have done in four years as far as tearing apart Americans and thier global alliances/respect.
Can you imagine the amount of global resentment towards America if these two are allowed to continue?
by hal 9000
And to my knowledge we still have troops in Iraq and have done since the inception of this silly event so I guess I can say something here. On this mournings news it was reported that Donald Rumsfield {at least I think that is how he spells his name} has openly said that Iraq posed no threat to the USA had no WMD's {this was supported by a CIA report as well I understand} and had no connection with Al Quedia. Now other than being a Muslim that was the only connection with the attacks on 9-11 so if the invasion of Iraq was necessary to protect mainland USA it must there fore be necessary to invade all Muslim countries to stop any further attacks by terrorists.
But seriously instead of being side tracked by unnecessary invasions would not it be better to get on with the War on Terror which had world wide support until the USA decided it could misuse this War to justify they long held ambition to over throw Saddam.
The moment that the USA embarked on this silly tangent of the WOT it quite rightly started to loose the support of most countries of the world. What worries me greatly is the fact that now these organizations are using US actions to justify their belief that you are not the world policeman but in fact the worlds enemy and they are currently gathering their forces to attack you and your allies at every opportunity. Now that the USA has shown its true colors I very much doubt that you'll see the same level of support ever again from the rest of the world and without that support you are doomed to loose eventually but only after a long and protracted conflict that at each stage inflicts greater damage on your and your allies countries.
************************************************
Incidental I think your right about the Canadian Border Issue. Things need to be speeded up there that way all the old people from the USA will then have easy access to what is to them at least cheap medicines but more to the point what are cost effective medicines. Currently the FTA between the USA and AU seems to be only put in place to destroy AU PBS which has been a thorn in the side of the major Drug companies for a very long time now and something that they have wanted to see removed particularly since some USA States have started looking into adopting the AU system. While it was confined to AU it was at least acceptable and even though it was held up as the way to go by every Government around the world it only really started to become a threat to the Drug Companies when some USA States started looking at incorporating it themselves. If this was allowed to happen it would break the control of the Drug Companies who at the moment can charge exorbitant amounts for unnecessary drugs which they market more as recreational drugs rather than necessary drugs for the treatment of medical conditions. A very good example is the way Viagra is being advertised in the USA it was originally intended for erectile dysfunction but now is considered necessary by the yuppies after the makers have heavily advertised it.
Col
by rickkellogg
Read some of the other posts. Iraq is the Battlefield we have choosen to prosecute this war on. It has become a magnet for every self respecting terrorist on the planet looking to make a name for themselves. All we are trying to do is help them to acheive maryter status and find the elusive 100 Virgins. As long as nobody tells them there ain't no 100 Virgins waitng for them and all they are is DEAD I will be very happy. Like I said previously, better to keep the battle on the other side of the globe than in our own back yard.
Whether or not Sadam had WMD or not is not really important. He did at one time and used them. He was a bad guy and had to go. His country will in time be much better off without him.
You are correct in your opening statement. As an Aussie you do have the right to your opinion as your country, unlike our Beer Swilling neighbors to the North, have stood up with the US in this Battle.
I guess only time will tell for certain who was right.
by oz_media
In Canada we get a lot of 1-hour special reports from foreign lands. Recently they aired a special on al-Qaeda since the Gulf War.
Bush says he as captured 75% of the al-Qaeda leaders and brags as much. What he fails to mention is that EVERY inteligence agancy in the world (including his own) knows just what a miniscule impact this had on al-Qaeda. There are KNOWN al-Qaeda recruiting circles in England, Canada AND THE USA. So if al-Qaeda terrorists are rebuilding in the USA, why are you in Iraq fighting a war on terrorism? The terrorists are rebuilding in your own country too, not just in Iraq? They are rebuilding in HUGE numers in Bosnia, Pakistan is even allowing al-Qadea propaganda to be distributed and have turned a blind eye on them because the chief of police even says he doesn't expect Muslim police to arrest Muslims (even if they ar radicals o terrorists).
So what about all the countries that DO have nuclear weapons, FAR more of a threat to the USA than Saddam EVER was? Yet they rest and build thier weapons without problems.
What about Africa, where poor Muims are PAID to join the ranks of al-Qaeda?
Instead you feel that you have centered terrorist activity in Iraq, well yes many small insurgent groups and terror groups have united to bring death upon Americans, no passports or airline tickets to buy either, you went to them this time, how ocnvenient for them!
Meanwhile the REAL terrorists who killed 3000 Americans are rebuilding with a vengeance, the sons and relatives of th captured leaders have started to build MUCH bigger and stronger terror groups than the al-Qaeda you once feared.
It's just like waiting for the other shoe to drop. When you are in a fight and say 'hey look over there' will the person ignore you and go beat up someone else? NO they wouldn't be that easily distracted from thier cause, America did though. 'Hey look over there!'
Bush, f'd up, everyone knows it, the world knows it but a handful of Americas still think he's the righteous one and the rest of the world simply doesn't understandhow to fight for freedom, what's wrong with THAT picture? The free nations and several billion people see what one half assed leader and his minions don't. I think its time to look at the BIG picture and stop thinking of only yourself for once.
by hal 9000
What about the bombings in the Indonesia?
Currently they are averaging about 1 a year and while JI is connected with the Al Quedia network in some form they are using places like Bali and other holiday resorts to inflict their terror upon. At the same time they are unconcerned about the collateral damage done to their fellow countrymen.
While Iraq is a magnet for some Terrorists {the poorly funded ones I might add as well} it is only a small proportion that are going there the rest of the new recruits currently seem to be getting trained for bigger and better things from their Organizations point of view.
It is at best silly to assume that the better funded Terror Organizations do not have plans to inflict bigger and better attacks on the mainland USA or for that matter AU, Britain & Europe in general as they see all of these countries in League with the United States. Where we are going wrong is not attempting to cut the funding for these Organizations to prevent them from being able to carry out these attacks. This is the hard part particularly since these organizations are not really interested in controlling land as every previous conflict in recorded history has been. They want to sell an idea and then they hope that the idea will lead to Fundamentalists Islamic States being born but while they do want these state to come into existence they are not personally interesting in running them as they want to stand back and criticize as to how things should be run.
These groups are the ultimate fundamentalists who are only concerned by spreading the word and attacks like 9-11 are their highlights to their fellow Muslims. Particularly those in Dictatorial countries where the education standards are not all that great. After the collapse of the Twin Towers there where scenes in Iraq of people celebrating in the streets but the very same scenes could be seen in most of the Muslim world. The only good thing that could be said about Saddam was he did control these religious zealots by curbing their activities in a very heavy handed manner. Now that has been removed we are seeing the consequences.
There is a very big trap here as these people hide in the general community and use the population for cover so any strikes against them hurt and kill many uninvolved people which only goes to wards increasing the dislike, or they hide out in Religious Sacred Sites which would mean a universal Muslim uprising if we where to destroy them. A perfect example would be the destruction of Mecca the Muslim holiest of holies if we where to drop a nuke onto that place it would guarantee to unite all of the Muslim nations to destroy us. The same could be said for many other religions as well.
What we have to do here is to tread a fine line and NEVER step over it in the slightest.
Col
by rickkellogg
He who has the Gold Rules. It doesn't hurt to carry a big stick either.
I like most of your thoughts on this subject. Just don't agree with the conclusions you draw. The Muslim People as a whole are great people. Just as most Christians, and Jewish people are. However, as with any organization they do have splinter factions. That do get a lot of attention. "Bad News Sells Papers" I do not share in your opinion that the entire Muslim World is about to organize a Crusade against the United States and the COW. No offense meant but frankly they do not have a means of anything of this nature other than the random acts of terrorism. If like you imply it were so easy Israel would have been erased in 1967 6 Day War and certainly in the 37 years since.
Sadam could not keep his house in order and he did pose a threat to the US whether direct or just by allowing things to happen within his borders. He had to go. Iraq is also an ideal place to stage this Battle and keep these terrorist on the move on the other side of the planet. Granted Saudi Arabia does have a significant radical population, and hopefully the Royal Family will take a more pro active role in getting rid of these terrorists. Don't think for a minute that they are somehow a sacred cow and safe from the same fate that Iraq and Afganastan went through though. That being said though, the Saudi Royal Family and the population in general enjoy a very prosporus lifestyle, and are extremely well educated and do understand that 9-11 changed the way we do business with the rest of the world. They do understand the Golden Rule and do want to continue the lifestyle they have grown accustomed to.
by rickkellogg
If not you should. I hear Prescription Drugs are cheap in Canada if you can get into a Doctor.
No Nation on the Planet has anything to worry about from the United States as long as they conduct themselves in a civilized manner.
By the way there is no fear here. We are capable of taking care of ourselves but thanks for the concern.
Seriously though you do need help. I would recommend you back off a little on the world news & current events. Perhaps move to a small island with no radios or television for a while.
Check back in 26 days and lets see how small that handfull of Americans are. W 2004
by rickkellogg
by oz_media
You simply countered ALL of my arguments with undeniable proof!
Your research and conclusions are astounding!
Your facts are simply undeniable!
Oh no....wrong post, you didn't do anything other than shoot the messenger in true republican form. It's so clever, funny how nobody's on to that game yet isn't it?
Anyhow, you went to war out of FEAR. Thee is absolutely no question in ANYONE's mind at all regarding that issue, you went to war to save ou families and your country from the evil madman's nonexistent weapons of mass destruction.
To say anything else is an outright lie without any recourse whatsoever. Your president spent a great deal of time planning just how to instill fear into his people, to say otherwise is simply not giving him credit for his hard work!
Before you crawled in, people were all oer this board sayig how unatriotic people wer for not syupporting a war to save thier babies, VERY EXTREME examples were given here. People would NEVER have stood behind Bush saying, [i]"we are going to start a campaign with no end in sight in order to liberate the poor repressed people of Iraq. It wil cost 200 NILLION taxpayers dollars ad many of our sons and daughters lives, but we WILL succeed at any cost and we will not give up."[/i]
Get real and give your head a shake.
Turn that into the 'save yourselves' syndrome and Americans jumped at the oportunity, spit in the faces of anyoe oosed to immediate action and started the flag waving and patriotic song all over again.
YOU WERE SOLD FEAR TO JUSTIFY AN UNWARANTED WAR
SADAM HAD NEITHER THE WEAPONS NOR TH EABILITY O PRODUCE SUCH WEAPONS THAT HE WAS SAID TO HAVE STOCKPILED!
Certainly I agre an evil dictator who was fully intent on bilding such weapons ad developing such technology was a threat to ANYONE, not an immediate threat though, and not one that the rest of the world wasn't also aware of.
nobody said saddam should be left in power, nobody said he is not a man to be feared.
They said it wasn't imprative that Iraq be atackd at this time as there were more important issue to b addressed first, such as al-Qaeda rebuilding, women in Afghanistan losing new found freedoms etc.
GWB said F-THIS!! I'll scare the people into suporting me! In light of 9/11 and what was said on this forum in the days preceding th war in Iraq, it is clear that you were saving your souls (FEAR).
Are you suggesting you are one of those wanabe BIG men who say they aren't scared of anything, until they are left crying for mommy.
by oz_media
If Saddam was using what we consider horrible techniques to control his population, is it still not yet understood that this was the most effectve way of dealing with them considering HIS military's strength and size?
Perhaps as this was the world he was raised in, he saw it as the best way to keep rule in Iraq.
While it is demed terrorism to us, what he was up against truly WAS terrorism.
If he had democratically accepted these people, you would have been just as hell bent to remove him. If he went to war with these people and fought under thier own terms of dirty warfare and car bombs, you would have seen it fit to remove him.
Either way, middle Eastern ideals didn't coincide with what OUR ideals were and that was enough to begin a war. Democract or terrorism, we would have reached the same conclusion, this must be stopped.
So why the sudden urgency, so urgent in fact that allies and the UN were ignored after the great president of the world decided that he would not stand by his word and would attack prematurely?
F.E.A.R.
by hal 9000
The definition of a Political Joke is that one of them gets elected!
Well at least over here it's Friday so I thought I start off with something light.
Tomorrow we have our own Federal Erection where we all have to vote and the latest poles show 79% of people don't give a DAM! Of the remaining the split is about 50 50 so it will be a close one unless of course most of the 79% who don't give a dam decide to not vote for anyone and just write on their ballot papers that they are all worthless. In which case we would have to have another erection with different candidates but of course the media which is mostly pushing the incumbent will not mention this fact.
What do find funny in this so called Democracy is that we are really only as Democratic as the Political Parties want us to be if there is anything that directly opposes their power it gets quashed.
But on the up side we have a independent running in our Prime Ministers Seat under the Logo "Not Happy John" and he is getting a lot of attention so with a bit of luck Little Johny Rotten will not get reelected he could be the first sitting Prime Minister in AU history not to retain his seat. That alone will almost make watching the erection results worth watching.
Apparently a Liberal Prime Minister is only allowed one Viagra tablet once every 3 years under our PBS or they have to pay full price for any further tablets that they want. Naturally our current Prime Minister who has private health insurance is far too tight to spring for any more Viagra than what is allowed under the PBS so he tends to only go for an erection every 3 years or as soon as he can get another tablet for the $3.80 AU that the PBS allows. For those non AU people out there the PBS stands for "Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme" which is acknowledged as a world leader in the control and pricing of all legal pharmaceuticals.
Col
by rickkellogg
While we already had a sizable force in Afganastan and 2 or 3 Aircraft Carrier Battle Groups in the area. Iraq to my way of thinking would have been the next logical step in the global was on terror. It is accomplishing a number of thing that in time 2-3 years should begin to make sense. 1. Saddam is gone. 2. Iraq will have a Democratic Government next year. 3 while there are still plenty of terror cells spread out around the globe we are doing a good job of thinning the heard in this part of the world. 4. These people especially the uneducated ones respond to only one thing and that is overwhelming power. Don't think for a minute that they enjoy sleeping in a different bed every night and watching their associates go to the promised land. 5. While some of them are pretty well funded their petty cash funds world wide are under very close scrutiny and one by one we are finding their cash stashes and freezing them. Sooner or later the well does dry up.
I am not under any illusion that Iraq will be the final Battlefield. However, once we shore up that government and the Afgan government some people believe the prosperity in these countries especially Iraq will set an example for other Mid East Countries.
I have no idea as to what or who will be the next target for the US. I do know that this battle will go on until the world is free of these cowardly thugs. Maybe Iran, the Phillipenes, Africa, North Korea, only time will tell.
The one point I do conceed is that we do need a solution for Pallestine and Israel before there will be a complete peace in the Middle East. Not sure how that will take place. I do know our government has to swing the pendelum more towards the Pallestinians as we are rightly viewed by the world as complete supporters of Israel. It seems though every time we get close to talking some event sets the process back again.
by oz_media
I understand and age with most of your reasoning and hopes for the war, I don't think ANYONE democrat, socialist or republican thinks that liberating people and killing insurgents is a grand feat. Saddam was a horrible dictator and should have been removed, the people SHOULD be able to have a democratic government (if that's what they want of course).
In 2001, the Taliban headed by the al-Qaeda terrorist regime set out to destroy what they felt America stood for. Retaliation was GLOBAL, everyone stood at your side and fought for lady liberty, and rightly so I may add. These bastards entered YOUR country and killed YOU people, fair enough I stand by this 100%.
A few years later, womeon's freedoms and liberation (the main focus of STAYING in Afghanistan other than capturing Bin Laden) has started to fal apart. Womeon were oce again stoned in the streets, beaten while lining up for schools etc. by the very same 'security' we had handed over such tasks to.
This needed to be addressed and we should have ALL as world allies been workig to secure or fud security in order for these women AND men to continue thier pursuit of democracy and freedom. We didn't though.
Troops remained, funding and security ceased.
The focus was quickly turned to yet another middle eastern enemy, except this one had failed to comply with 12 years of resolutions and was said to hae used that noncompliance to build an huge arsenal or WMD! Now that's some heavy duty stuff! THen it was second guessed, DID they have WM after all. Inspectors said they were finally being allowed to work ad found some irrelevant and useless (antiquated) arms but not the stockpile of WMD.
GWB had promised the rest of the world ad the UN h would wait until inspections had failed completely and would use force to continue inspections, war being an absolute last resort. the UN and allid nations agreed at this point, and YES JOHN KERRY DID TOO.
Then befo you could say 'Saddam', weapons inspectors were removed and the US was entering Iraq for a full scale invasion. Errr, did I miss something? Did something turn up? Did wepaons inspectors get kicked out again, and after forcing thier return a war was inevitable (that WAS tha plabn afterall)?
Nope, none of the above. GWB just invaded ad declared war on Iraq.
Meanwhile, women's freedoms further slip away in Afghanistan, al-Qaeda BARELY took a bump on th head and was shown to e rebuilding a MUCH bigger and stronger force than we had EVER imagined, they had more money and wre BUIYING recruits, they were said to be building on some 60 diferent countries , 1200 mosques were built in Bosnia ad Bosnian citizens were being recruited left right and ceneter by al0Qaeda, propaganda brochures promised more construction and rebuildig of the cities if they joined the ranks of al-Qaeda, BBC news was showing al-Qaeda terrorists IN ENGLAND, parading and rallying, they wre then rebuilding in Canada AND the USA as well. Meanwhile, Saddam is found, war is absolutely horendous, lives are being lost daily, the prior support had all backed out due to th breach of terms (or lie) that Bush gave them about war as a last resort and all hell broke loose? How?
O minute the world was fighting a successful war on the KNOWN ad capable enemy of the free world, the next minute it is every man for himself as the US attacked ad continues to atack in Iraq. The death toll from Insurgents upon the US is nearig the levels of 9/11 and beginnig to justify itself, but IS IT?
It was started on false pretenses, Bush lied to ME, he lied to YOU, he lied to his allies, he lid to teh United Nations, he LIED AND LIED SOME MORE THEN LIED SOME MORE.
Meanwhile, Afghsnistan (even though Taliban has been forced into Kandahar where they now thrive without resistance) has reverted back to repression and islamic fundamentalist ways, by it's OWN free citizens, not terrorists.
So HOW and WHY is ANYONE supposed to support the invasion of Iraq, regardless of the cause, it was wrong. The people who attacked you are NOT being stopped, they HAVEN'T been slowed and grow in bigger proportions than before 9/11.
Yeah, I'd vote for Bush if I was American (and followed the word of my great leader blindly and verbatim).
I'll agree to disagree here as I know you feel strongly about your convictions and that deserves some level of respect. I just don't see that you are considering the WHOLE picture more than you are visualizing a Muslim democracy in the Middle East. It can be quite blinding to have such a staunch focus though.
by hal 9000
I feel it necessary to point out some very important facts.
1 The majority of the population of Iraq and most of the Middle East is in their late teens and are poorly educated into the bargain. These kids are easily swayed and with being young believe that they are indestructible and even if the worst does happen they will find themselves with Allah and their 100 virgins each. Although I don't really know what the women who are involved in Palestine think they will get when they kill themselves as suicide bombers in Israel.
2 The population in most of the countries of the Middle East has increased dramatically with the advent of the oil fields but the wealth has not been distributed evenly. Currently we have a situation where the living standards of most of the people in these oil producing countries has actually dropped and now instead of being the aging population that we are they are all young and continuing to grow younger with each passing year.
3 Saddam was only one of the Dictators who should have been removed Libya comes to mind but currently that country appears to be flavor of the month even though they have admitted that they had a nuclear program. The whole of the Middle East is like this and those countries which currently do not have Dictators in power have Royalty. The remaining countries like Iran have a popularly elected Government in place which is anything but friendly the the West. Iran actually is a very good example of a Democratic State in the Middle East and it sure as hell is not what we need in that area. Saddam was only accepted for so long because he had an ongoing war with Iran which was considered as a larger threat to our way of life that Saddam ever was. I do not know what changed that one either, but if any country was willing to support al-QAEDA it would have been Iran.
4 With the Palestine thing you are totally correct and I really do not know what the answer there will be or even if there is one as the last time that an Israeli Prime Minister made any attempt to create a peace between the two civilizations he was assassinated by his own people. He needed protection from his fellow country men rather than Hamas. But as I've been there I can honestly say that there is wrong on both sides and that neither side appears willing to give an inch. They all want peace but only at the total collapse of the other side and this just is not going to happen.
5 The Koran never states to use the current measures that are being invoked by some radical clerics but because these people are considered in the area to be the "Learned Ones" they are followed by the masses blindly.
I'll give you a very good example of what these people are like here in Australia. A well known cleric with questionable values was stopped by the Police for driving an unregistered car on the road. The next thing that happened was that at first a hand full of his supporters came running out from their homes and attacked the Police for daring to stop their religious leader. Unfortunately it didn't end there as the people that came to the clerics aid got their women to ring for other supporters to come help. Eventually it ended up in a full scale riot that involved at least 200 Muslims and quite a few Police a lot of which where injured. That night after being bailed the cleric got on National TV and complained that he was being harassed by the Police who where out to get him, when he was asked why he was driving an unregistered car he brushed this off as unimportant and appeared to say he should be able to do as he wished without ever coming to the Police attention for what after all was nothing more than a minor traffic offense. Now if it was up to me I'd have him thrown out of the country but by saying that I become a racist but in actual fact I believe that anyone who migrates to this country should be willing to follow the rules and not consider that because of their position they do not need to comply and even worse start saying that they are being harassed because they willingly break the law of the land. Now the people involved where not newly arrived Muslims but most of them had been born here in AU so they should have known better but none the less they where only too happy to rush into a riot to protect their religious leader no matter what he had done wrong, from what they seemed to be saying because of who he was he could do no wrong. Now there are educated people who think this way just how much worse do you think it would be if the lads involved lacked any formal education and only had their cleric to learn from?
6 Today we say a very good example of just how bad things are in Egypt with the bombing of the Hilton hotel and two back packer resorts. That very same country had its leader shot to death because he was willing to sit down and talk to the Israeli's quite a few years ago now. They also have had numerous terror attacks that have been solely aimed at tourists. Now I do accept that the Egyptian Government does try to stop these attacks but so far have failed miserably because of the very nature of the cells that these terror organizations work under. You can take out an entire cell but they can not lead you to anyone else so you effectively come to a dead end when investigating these attacks.
Col
.
These people will never recognize the real scope of the "war on terrorism". They all look at it through the narrow view of only the events surrounding 9-11, and they refuse to acknowledge the bigger picture. Not one of them has ever said, for example, that Iraq is one factor - indeed a major factor - in the bigger war against world-wide terrorism. Or if you are able to corner them into conceding that it is or might be, then they'll question the methods and/or fall back on preferring the United Nations' approach (which is really more of the same "nothing" that they've been doing for the past 30 years).
It's politics, pure and simple, either domestic or international, that's driving their opinions. And I'm absolutely disgusted at the people who put politics above principle. And the ones who aren't playing their political cards (or don't really have any political cards to play), are blinded by the (mostly) one-sided media coverage.
I have never gotten any of these people to answer the real question, and I've asked it dozens of times. Where are the stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons that the entire world knew, without a doubt, existed in Iraq, and for which Saddam Hussein failed to account for their destruction (per various United Nations resolutions); or if they never existed in the first place, how was the whole world fooled in such a way? (By the way, "stockpiles", in this case, is equal to biological agents that could fit into a suitcase, and chemical agents that could be separated into benign components and/or fit into a space the size of a large van.) Instead, they simply "choose" to retort that President Bush "lied" or misled.
Nonetheless, you'll never change their minds or get them to concede that your point of view may be right. You're saying the same things I've been saying for months, and the more we might say it, the more they dig in their heels and argue against it.
by garion11
Disk With U.S. Schools Info Found in Iraq
Friday, October 08, 2004
WASHINGTON ? Federal law enforcement authorities notified school districts in six states last month that a computer disk found in Iraq (search) contained photos, floor plans and other information about their schools, two U.S. officials said Thursday.
The downloaded data found by the U.S. military in July ? all publicly available on the Internet ? included an Education Department (search) report guiding schools on how to prepare and respond to a crisis, said one official, speaking on condition of anonymity.
The officials said it was unclear who downloaded the information and stressed there is no evidence of any specific threats involving the schools.
The districts mentioned are in Georgia, Florida, Michigan, New Jersey, Oregon and California. The officials said last month FBI (search) agents in charge of those areas alerted local education and law enforcement officials about the finding.
The officials did not provide the names of the districts. But Salem, Ore., Superintendent Kay Baker confirmed her district was among them.
"Local law enforcement has no knowledge of a specific threat to any of our school buildings," she said. "We will work collaboratively with law enforcement on any further developments."
San Diego schools also were included, according to The San Diego Union-Tribune, and ABC News said there was a second California district. The Salem Statesman Journal reported the other districts were Fort Myers, Fla.; Jones County, Ga.; Birch Run, Mich.; and Franklinville and Rumson, both in New Jersey.
The disk contained an Education Department report called "Practical Information on Crisis Planning: A Guide for Schools and Communities," published in May 2003, as well as photos and floor plans.
In a separate but more widespread warning put out this week, the Education Department advised school leaders nationwide to watch for people spying on their buildings or buses to help detect any possibility of terrorism like the deadly school siege last month in Russia.
The warning follows an analysis by the FBI and the Homeland Security Department of the siege that killed nearly 340 people, many of them students, in the city of Beslan.
"The horror of this attack may have created significant anxiety in our own country among parents, students, faculty staff and other community members," Deputy Education Secretary Eugene Hickok said in a letter sent Wednesday to schools and education groups.
The Education Department's advice is based on lessons learned from the Russia siege. But there is no specific information indicating a terrorist threat to any schools or universities in the United States, Hickok said.
Federal law enforcement officials also have urged local police to stay in contact with school officials and have encouraged reporting of suspicious activities, the letter says.
In particular, schools were told to watch for activities that may be legitimate on their own ? but may suggest a threat if many of them occur.
Among those activities:
? Interest in obtaining site plans for schools, bus routes and attendance lists.
? Prolonged "static surveillance" by people disguised as panhandlers, shoe shiners, newspaper or flower vendors or street sweepers not previously seen in the area.
? Observations of security drills.
? People staring at or quickly looking away from employees or vehicles as they enter or leave parking areas.
? Foot surveillance of campuses involving individuals working together.
The effort is the latest by the Education Department and other federal agencies to encourage school officials to maintain and practice a plan for responding to emergencies.
"It's a positive sign that they're finally discussing this after years of downplaying or denying even the possibility of a terrorist strike on schools," said Kenneth Trump, a Cleveland-based school safety consultant who has worked with officials in more than 40 states. "Public officials are in fear of creating fear, but we have to put the cards on the table, educate people in the school community and make sure they are well prepared."
After the terrorist takeover of the Russian school, President Bush asked his top advisers to review their strategies for dealing with hostage situations, Homeland Security Secretary Tom Ridge has said.
The federal government is advising schools to take many steps to improve the security of their buildings. Those include installing locks for all doors and windows, having a single entry point into buildings and ensuring they can reach school bus drivers in an emergency.
The Education Department sent its letter by e-mail Wednesday to school police, state school officers, school boards, groups representing principals and many other organizations.
The Homeland Security Department also sent a bulletin to federal, state and local emergency officials to provide fresh guidance based on the review of the school siege in Russia
Imagine that, if we never went into Iraq, this would have never been found. If its your kid that was saved BECAUSE we found this, what do you have to say about the Iraq war after this you stupid thoughtless lefty loonies?
.
....Iraq had no ties to terrorism, remember? At least that's what John Kerry and his merry band of followers want to claim. (But they're very wrong.)
If you (or anyone) wants a real eye-opener about all this, read the new book, "Inside CentCom" by Lt. General Michael DeLong, former Deputy Commander of the Central Command, about both Iraq and Afganastan.
Or do a Web search to read some of the various interviews.
by rickkellogg
by ippirate
You guys, you should know by now that this will be dismissed as well. Here, I'll give you the arguments before they start to pop up.
1. The disk was made after Sept. 11th, Bush deceived
2. It wouldn't be there if we hadn't gone into Iraq, Bush's fault
3. We went to Iraq only to find WMDs, anything else is inconsequential and should be ignored, Bush lied.
4. The sky is blue the grass is green, get Bush out of office
5. Your post shows a hint of supporting Bush, war-monger, hater, baby-killer
6. Your post does not sound like it is pro-Kerry, flame, flame, flame.
7. Logic? Reason? Who cares about those. Get Bush out because anyone is better than him, even Stalin, Hitler, etc.
Garion, you know, I have to admire your spunk but posting this is just something that Libs/Dems are going to ignore, gloss over, explain away or outright attack. Not because it is logical but because it is a voice of opposition to the golden child.
by hal 9000
WHAT THE HELL DO YOU EXPECT IF YOU MAKE INFORMATION LIKE THIS AVAILABLE VIA THE NET?
You could also say that there have been downloaded text found that tell how to make a fission weapon which any high school student who studied Physics 101 could and should know.
There is however something good that is coming out of this whole thing and that is that the American Public are beginning to take the threat of attack seriously by these people as previously there have only been a few attacks on mainland USA. So any improvement in security is to be admired.
Incidental Garion it has just come on the local news John Howard has come out and admitted that he and his political party have won the AU Federal Election that was held today. So for all of those who where looking at the AU election and drawing comparisons to the US elections in November things are looking good for GWB.
Now if only he can start to get the average citizen to start taking security seriously everything would have a great outlook for your own protection. The only thing that I did not see listed in your posting was an instruction not to train pilots in flying commercial aircraft and only be interested in being able to fly them and not worry about take offs and landings!
Col
by garion11
Nine hurt in Paris bomb blast
Associated Press
Friday October 8, 2004
A bomb explosion outside the Indonesian embassy in Paris slightly injured nine people today, authorities said, in the first terror attack to strike the French capital in years.
France's interior minister, Dominique de Villepin, said a rigged package exploded beneath a balcony at the embassy in Paris' exclusive 16th district, not far from the Eiffel Tower.
Mr Villepin described the explosive device as "a bomb of medium strength".
The blast also damaged cars and created a small crater in front of the building, which was sealed off by police shortly after the 0500 BST explosion.
Most of the injured were hurt by flying glass, the interior minister said. Three were embassy staff members and lived in the basement of the building. They were treated and released from local hospitals, according to Indonesian foreign ministry spokesman Marty Natalegawa in Jakarta.
Shattered glass carpeted the street for at least 30 metres. Windows as high as the top fourth floor of the embassy were blown out, and chunks of stone were blown from the embassy wall where the package was placed.
French authorities were at a loss to explain why the embassy was targeted. There was no immediate claim of responsibility.
"To our knowledge, there were no specific threats," Mr Villepin said. "But the investigation will allow us to verify this."
Mr Villepin also noted the overnight attacks in Egypt, which killed at least 19 people, but he was careful not to draw any links between the two attacks.
Advertiser links
Save Now - 21st Century Insurance
Save $300 on auto insurance and get more coverage and more...
21st.com
Motor Vehicle Insurance
Are you a driver over 50? You could save up to $300 in...
aarp.thehartford.com
Drive Away with Savings
Auto insurance from the American Express Property Casualty...
americanexpress.com
Europe-1 radio said security was being reinforced throughout the French capital.
The anti-terrorism unit of the Paris prosecutor's office and the police department's anti-terrorist brigade are conducting an investigation.
Authorities in Jakarta said they were prepared to send investigators to Paris. Police Major General Dadang Garnida said officers "were coordinating with Interpol and are prepared to send a team if needed" to help with the investigation.
The French president, Jacques Chirac, said his government would use every available means to track down those responsible for the attack. He spoke from Hanoi, Vietnam, where he is attending an Asia-Europe summit.
The last major terrorist attacks in the French capital occurred when Paris was hit by a wave of deadly underground train bombings in 1995 and 1996, a campaign orchestrated by Algerian Islamic militants.
Algerian extremists were also allegedly behind a plot to attack a Christmas market at the Strasbourg Cathedral on new year's eve 2000.
British "shoe bomber" Richard Reid is serving a life sentence in the United States for trying to blow up a Paris-Miami flight with explosive-stuffed shoes in December 2001.
France's foreign minister, Michel Barnier, went to the embassy to survey the damage. "This reinforces our determination to fight terrorism in all its forms," he said, adding that "no person and no city is safe" from this kind of attack.
Indonesia is home to two separatist rebel groups, one of which - the Free Aceh Movement - has been blamed by authorities for several small bombings in the country in recent years.
The group, which is fighting for independence for the western province of Aceh, maintains a government in exile in Sweden. Scores of its members have fled Indonesia since 1976.
The blast in Paris comes four days before the second anniversary of the terror bombing at nightclubs in Bali, Indonesia, blamed on the al-Qaida-linked Jemaah Islamiyah group. The attack killed 202 people, mostly foreign tourists.
On September 9 this year, Jemaah Islamiyah suicide bombers detonated a car bomb outside Australia's embassy in Indonesia, killing nine people.
by rickkellogg
Maybe a little callous but I have no use for the French right now. They have shown their colors "Yellow" on several occasions and frankly they deserve whatever they get. Remember when they refused the Air Force flyover rights when we went after Lybia?
Sooner or later this pendelum of terror will strike them squarly in thier A-- in a much more spectaculor event than this.
Who do you imagine will be the first country ready to stand up and protect these French Cowards when 9-11 does come home to them? America will of course without question or condition because it is the right thing to do.
The fact is when times are tough the entire world looks to America for help and we never refuse a just cause we simply ask "What can we do"
How quickly they forget!
by oz_media
I believe it was your mentor/god GW Bush who actually said on live TV that he was disappointed with the way Americans have reacted regading the French.
He sees them as a VALUABLE ally who has ALWAYS fought beside the US in times of war.
The French have an embassy in Afghanistan to assist in issues there, remember the Gulf War?
They also have troops supporting the war in Haiti alongside CANADIAN and US troops.
So they didn't buy into GWB's war in Iraq, so what? MUST they ? WHY?
by murphmm
by oz_media
Is because you're not American. Apparently, from what I have learned from our American peers here, they were attacked! Other countries couldn't possibly understand what it is like to be attacked on your own soil, especially European countries who have never been at war on thier own soil, we just don't understand them and that is what OUR problem is.
They are RIGHT, get that straight first. You are wrong, you will always BE wrong as long as you have a different/independant view of things.
Again, you just don't get it as it is America's problem and we lowly outsiders simply do not understand what is really going on, whereas they do.
all the stuff about WMD and Saddam's ties to al-Qaeda and that 43% of Americans were lead to believe saddam was responsible for 9/11 is just smoke screen, if we were American, we'd see the full story and wouldn't be mislead by global news reports. The news is not reliable, Americans have a secret decoder ring that they receive secret messages from late at night.
That's how they all get the truth and all the rest of the world sees is common news, not the REAL story, so we are left delusional.
Don't let it bother you though, we still haven't admitted that America resolved WWII single handedly and saved us all from Hitler. One day I will get to be American, and boy what a day it will be!
As for the 43% that were mislead, they ae not americans REALLY, they are what americans call leftist loonies, just wanabes who don't hav any idea what they are talking about, there's only ONE true American and that's a Republican because Republicans support Bush and Bush is right. Getting any of this yet? Stick around TR and you will.
First you will think they are lost, then you will think they are bitter, then you will think they are stupid and finally you will realize that they were simply misundersstood, your entire life and country's morals ad actions are wrong and unless it is American, it is also wrong.
Thankfully they have SOME patience for us simpletons, they will laugh ad giggle amongst themselves, then they will call you names, then they will tell you all about what YOUR country does wrong, then they will say it's none of yur business what thier coury does and finally, you aren't American so you just don't get it.
But oh well, there's not too many of them (REAL Americans that is) so they need to work extra hard in order to educate the world about what is REALLY happening.
by ippirate
by rickkellogg
That's the problem with many European Countries. You hide behind the term Neutral until it is in your best interset to take a stand. Many American's have a different term for your Neutrality which I shall not get into in this venue.
Put this in your Time Capsule though. Sooner or later your neutral country, or perhaps one of your neutral neighbors will face a Terrorist Attack on the scale of our 9-11. What exactly does it take to convert a neutral country into a country willing to fight for their survival? Are there any conditions?
Being Neutral is quite like being an Athiest. That is until your dying breath and final spoken words lying in your sick bed when your finally ask your creator for forgiveness.
by oz_media
Not like being an athiest.
Neutral does not mean that there is no defense, it means there is LITTLE offense unless required for protection of ones self or country.
Europe IS said to be the next target of al-Qaeda (the enemy you used to be after that GWB claims he's captured 75% of, well he used to say 75% of leaders but tonight's debate he said he'd caught 75% of al-Qaeda[ooops!])in fact LONDON specifically is rpeparing for an attack on the Tube. Citizens are VERY aware of the threat al-Qaeda have been recruiting and demonstrating in England. This doesn't mean they need to invade Equador though.
by hal 9000
"Most European Countries are Neutral." Please advise me of just which countries where invaded by Hitler in WW11 and which countries where invaded by the Kaiser in WW1?
From my very limited and poor memory I was led to believe that only Switzerland was considered as "Neutral" and in every conflict that has happened in modern times that Neutrality has been respected by all parties. Perhaps it is because that country is effectively the "WORLD BANK" and any attack would lead to the instant disappearance of the attacking countries money and assists held in the Swiss Banks!
As far as terror attacks go most of them have happened in Europe but then again I suppose that the attack on the Olympic Games in Munich and the like do not count as they do not involve Americans RIGHT?
Rick what you have to understand is that Terrorism did not start on September 11 2001 what we currently call "Modern Terrorism" actually started in 1947 and was first used by a bunch of Jews to throw out the Palestinians that where near by. That comes from a Documentary called "The Age of Terror" and that was made by
Louise Rosen Ltd
100 Winchester Street
Brookline, MA 02446
and was very well researched and put together. But I suppose you would consider this company "Leftest Loonies." Unfortunately they are unable to sell me a copy of the complete series or even a single episode but I was informed by e-mail that they would not be offended if I recorded the entire series next time it was broadcast on TV. If you ever get the chance it is a "MUST SEE" series that will be a real eye opener to almost everyone who is willing to accept the truth.
Col
by ippirate
Does that then mean that the US should have continued to pour money into Operations Northern/Southern Watch? Am I to take from your post that it was;
Good for the US to spend money for everyone's benefit indefinately but;
Bad to do anything other than that?
Maybe we should have just pulled out and let the UN take care of it. Ohhhh, that's right the UN didn't have the resources. Maybe we could have let the coalition forces take care of business, Ohhhhh, that's right, they were already taxed to the limit, none able to increase spending and many getting ready to cut spending/presence.
Has invading gone over like gangbusters? Nope but you know what, it has gotten exactly what Democrats are calling for, change. If Bush hadn't then we would have what Clinton gave us and what Kerry is so hard against, "More of the Same".
It's really kind of ironic, everyone is against the one man who has given exactly what his opponent is claiming he will give.
Of course, don't take my word for it, I'm just another arrogant, un-enlightened, asinine, loud, simple, American. I really should learn to not have an opinion that isn't based from a European standpoint or isn't "globally" centered. Maybe, one day, if I'm lucky I can move to one of the more tolerant and humble nations of the world.
by oz_media
By claiming that Kerry is proposing to increase force and finish the job in Iraq you are TRYING to imply it is IRONIC?!?
If Kerry pulled OUT troops at this point in time it would be wrong, you are in too deep, not due to Kerry, not due to Saddam but due to Bush.
People oppose the war, the damage has been done though and now the people want someone capable to see this cause through to the end andnoody has any faith that the person who started the mess can finish it properly.
So for Kerry to oppose the war and then once war IS started by his opponent, what choice would he have when enetering office other than to finish it?
That's not irony, it is living up to your responsibilities.
by hal 9000
GWB is awarded the Nobel Prise for Peace?
I can just see the day coming can't you?
Col
by rickkellogg
Truth is GWB is extremely P----d off with the French and some other European Countries and he was simply saying the politically correct comment for the venue he was speaking in at the time.
The only reason the French would have a Embassy in Afganastan would be to try to suck up some contracts for rebuilding the country. How many French Troops fought along side the Americans during the ousting of the TBan?
Sending a few troops to Hatti is another very safe thing for France. Certainly Hatti one of the poorest countries in the world could never pose a threat to France. I would not pound my chest too hard about the French or Canadian Hatti commitment.
by oz_media
While I see what you're getting at I think your reasoning is a little unqualified.
Firstly, the VENUE that Bush was supposedly being PC was on a US network interview. I forget which it was now, but it was similar to a Larry king, Barbara Walters type of 1 hour interiew with him and Laura Bush. His responses throughout the entire interview was VERY conservative as it was during his subtle shift back to left center as the election nears (about a month ago).
The French have had an Embassy in Afghanistan as well as the British, in fact the French have nearly 200 embassy's in various countries around the globe, including Iraq. Suppose they are sucking up for contracts just about everywhere you can think of. Not too much of a point made there is that's your reasoning.
[i]"How many French Troops fought along side the Americans during the ousting of the TBan?"[/i]
[b]Number of French troops in the Gulf theatre:[/b] 18,000 troops, 60 combat aircraft, 120 helicopters, 40 tanks, 100 armored vehicles, 1 missile cruiser, 3 destroyers, 4 frigates
- in Afghanistan 1,500 including the contributions to the training of the new Afghan army, and those to Enduring Freedom on the ground (special forces), at sea (3 frigates, 1 tanker and 1 Maritime Patrol Aircraft) or in the air (2 transport aircraft)
France provided 2,000 French soldiers and several Mirage IV fighters in the United Arab Emirates, which were conducting ?intelligence and secret service operations?, plus a contingent of 58 soldiers that were sent from the French base at Istres that secured the airport at Mazar-e-Sharif in northern Afghanistan.
Haiti, well maybe you should do a little research there, you obviously aren't too aware of the situation in Haiti.
Haiti is yet another country suffering from terrorist actions against its government members and is/was facing anarchy. Haiti is an IMPERATIVE part of the war on terror, in case you forgot, it goes a LOT farther than Iraq. During this uprising they were hit with a MASSIVE hurricane and humanitarian efforts by allies and the UN were stepped up. SO if stopping terrorism and helping the people of Haiti is something that you "wouldn't pound your chest too hard over" it tells us ALL c aouple of things.
a) Your efforts in Iraq are not worth anyone pounding thier chests over, including yourself.
b) You don't think that terrosim is an issue worth fighting unless it is by YOUR government and military
c) You don't think that helping several hundred thousand homeless people in a country suffering from thug uprisings is a valiant duty (therefore see 'A' again).
THis is why people say you are arrogant or that you only see what you do while dismissing the actions of others. America is the only country doing any good...if you keep your head in the sand.
by hal 9000
But firstly I have no political affiliations whatsoever in any form so no one can say that I'm playing a political card.
The so called bio & Chem weapons I think where used in containing the Kurds when they attempted to follow the US Propaganda to succeed from Iraq and Saddam Husein. The Kurds have for a very long time wanted a land of their own and this is not confined just to Iraq but most of the surrounding countries as well particularly Turkey. I do not think that Saddam had the ability to reproduce the bio or chem weapons that he had acquired from "friendly" sources. So when they where used they where gone and not replaceable.
If you could please explain just how invading Iraq has anything whatsoever to do with the War on Terror I would greatly appreciate it as from what I have seen reported there was no connection between Iraq, Saddam and al Quedia other than both being Muslim.
There was no link to Weapons of Mass Destruction capacity after the Iraq Government supplied all the information that the UN demanded but the US edited it prior to the UN receiving it.
Now it was accepted that he had these type of Weapons but only because we knew that we had given him these weapons meaning the Bio and Chem ones and it was a nice thought that he wanted to acquire Nuclear technology which is hardly surprising considering just how close he was to a nuclear power in Israel. Now it is one thing to wanting to acquire this type of technology and a totally different thing to getting it.
Right at this point in time the average High School Student who does Physics could tell you the basic principals of building a Atom Bomb or Hydrogen Bomb but that by no means implies that they have the capacity to make one. If you would like to scroll up a bit to the post that I put in about not wanting to start off anything along these lines because of the closeness to 9-11 anniversary which I see no one particularly yourself has responded to in any form whatsoever. There are some very well laid out forms of terror and the way it has been used over the years. Even the term "Preemptive Strike" itself implies a terror like action. Now I'm the first to disagree with the posting that I put to you about Japan being right to launch a Preemptive Strike against the USA by attempting to destroy Pearl Harbor but I was trying to show what to one country is outrageous to another is justified. We can agree to disagree till the cows come home but the fact remains in that case Japan thought they where doing the only thing available to them at the time. That single act was what brought about their downfall because if they had never have done it the USA would have remained neutral in WW11 until it was far too late to respond and they would have literally been an island surrounded by hostile forces and eventually they would have been forced to surrender. They certainly would never have had the help of the British in acquiring both the manpower and materials to create the first A Bomb. The Germans would have beat you to that by years and without the help of the Norwegian and British forces the Germans would have had control of the only heavy water on the face of the planet. The single attempt by the USA to destroy that factory was a dismal failure. That is undisputed by any one!
Col
by oz_media
I have heard all of those generalizations myself on this forum from Americans in defense of thier political views.
You see, it is far too common for the quickest response to be, puting down someone else's country in order to justify your own shortcomings. As soon as someone questions the actions of the leader of the free world, the minions seem to rise from the woodwork and when no easy answer is readily available, they just talk about how nobody understands Americans, that they have VALUES that others don't and so on and so on, EXACTLY as GWB did during tonight's debate regarding allied support.
Just to let you in on a little known secret, you guys are exactly the same flesh and blood as every other living human on Earth. Your actions, thoughts and opinions are differnt, but when it comes down to it, the natural instinct of man to protect his home or self is pretty much universal. Everyone would defend thier country if needed, that's why there was OVERWHELMING support in the Gulf Wars until the invasion of Iraq.
I was just repeating what I have learned and been told from American peers on this website.
by hal 9000
It would give them a very good reason to invade Egypt to claim that they are protecting their country right.
OH I should have started this off with "SARCASM ALERT" shouldn't I?
But now back to somewhat normal perhaps we'll see that movie that was canned after the 9-11 attach where a container of Anthrax was placed in an underground railway station and struck by a train spreading the Bio weapon around. What I found interesting about that movie was that the people responsible for researching the whole thing found out that they where in fact the experts as no one that they asked for advice had any idea of what would happen or how to prevent the spread of the weapon. Unfortunately after the 9-11 incident the makers canned the movie as it was too close to the truth for public consumption.
Col
by rickkellogg
by delbertpgh
According to a post I saw, the Australians sent 2000 SAS commandos and some surface ships to take part in the combat. I know from the news about the Australian elections that there is still some active engagement in Iraq.
What do the Australians in the gulf do there today? How many, how many on the ground, where, what mission and what combat exposure, and how many casualties have they experienced? I think the Australians are the third largest component in the war, but I never hear anything here in the U.S. about what they do or have done.
Sort by Trending