Iraq is out of control
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
Yeah I know Colin.
I think what people don't understand is that there are several 'groups' of people with various reasons for opposing the war.
I see the leftist loonies thta think everything should be peacefully resolved no matter what, I see the leftist loonies that simply bury thier head in the sand, but here I see people who oppose the planing and strategy of the war, the haste and disregard in which it began. Yet this last group of people don't the=ink the WAR is wrong or that the objective is wrong, just the way it was conducted and started.
I would say I fit into this thord group as do quite a few others here, GWB had the right idea in the "wrong place and at the wrong time" :p
This war was probably inevitable, yet it wasn't urgent. I think it WILL pan out in the long run, I mean how CAN'T it? There's no way these select fundamentalists in Iraq are going to be able to oppose the US war machine forever.
It ISN'T going to stop terrorism in any way shape or form though, perhaps internal terrorism in Iraq, but not the growing threat of al-Qaeda's ranks.
When al is said and done, it may be VERY easy for GWB to say "see! I told you so!" (he does that now even) so even if hedoesn't pick up a NPP, he will always be favoured in th ehearts and minds of Republicans. Should the war be completed successfully with Kerry in office, then they will just rush off Kerry's actions (while saying how he was opoosed to the war) and they never would have been liberated/freed without Bush's preemptive actions.
They'll ALWAYS see a way to pin it as a Republican victory, that's the sad part.
by hal 9000
Today at a post erection speech our reelected Prime Minister described himself as the Leftest of the Left Wing. He constantly talks about reducing Government but continually increases the size and amount that the Government hands out. He accepts that he is fostering a "Welfare State" by giving out large "Baby Bonuses" rebates for private health insurance and the like. What I really do find funny is that a lot of people over here tell me what a great guy he actually is and how much he is giving them. But none of them even comes close to understanding that before he can give anything away he first has to take it off you!
I suppose that the Leftest Loonies in the US are different to the leftest Loonies here in AU.
Actually I'm with you as a member of the third group as you describe and while I really think that Iraq needed to have Saddam removed I really think we rushed in without thinking of the consequences but then again we had had elections coming up on both sides of the pond and a fast and apparently easy end of hostilities always looks good for the incumbent Prime Minister/President. That is what really gets under my skin GWB has said that Major Hostilities in Iraq have ended and as a result our troops are not getting full combat pay but at the very same time are in far greater danger than they where previously. Maybe I'm just cynical in my old age but to me it appears that our troops are getting screwed again!
Col
by oz_media
WHile Pearl Harbour may have been a preemptive strike by Japanese, it can't really be seen as an act of terrorism. It was a planend attack by one country's military against another. THe intent wasn't to wipe out as many citizens as possible .
It was a military VS military attack.
It was during a World War even though war on America had not been officially declared
One thing that DOES make it a clittle closer to 9/11 though is that the attacs had been predicted AND detected on that mornig yet ignored for over 38 minutes according to many timeline's and a documentary I saw a while back. But as it was right in the middle of a world war, and wasn't just aimed at destroying citizens, then it hardly falls under the terrorism umbrella.
If so, then I suppose the London Blitz could be even more suitable as terrorist action as it targeted a city and citizens, not military installations.
Churches, schools, homes, hospitals etc. Now as for numbers, let's compare the two and see if Pearl Harbour stacks up to even close to the same.
Pearl Harbour: Attacked on one morning
20 naval ships damaged or destroyed
2,395 Deaths (54 civillian)
NOTE: These warships and aircraft carriers, 30 of them, traveled 4000 miles over a period of 11 days to be within reach of an air attack, in the middle of a word war COMPLETELY unnoticed. Oddly enough, American seaplane patrols that had taken place each day up to December 6th were stopped the day of the attack.
In all, the attack lasted about 2 hours.
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
London Blitz: Was aimed at destroying the entire city of London and killing everyone within it.
348 Bombers and 617 fighters bombed and shot London's public streets, buildings and homes from 4:00PM until 6:00PM.
By 8PM, a sedond wave of planes hit and continued to bomb and destroy a heavily populated city until 4:30 in the morning.
This continued from September 1940 until MAY/June 1941. Remember Pearl Harbour lasted about 2 hours not 9 or 10 MONTHS!
Hitler was pissed that he had lost the battle of britain and his Luftwaffe had been thwardted, so he diceded to bomb the hell out of it instead.
Causalties: 40,000 civilians were killed, 46,000 injured, and more than a million homes destroyed and damaged
That's ROUGHLY 86,000 CIVILLIANS injured or killed and 1,000,000,000 HOMES! A rough count of course, many were just never accounted for.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
SO you can't really consider PH an act of terrorism in as much as it was a military target, not citizens during a world war, even though not formally declared on the US (kinda like the US invading Iraq I suppose).
But as usual, people only see what has happened to themselves and not others.
by hal 9000
As a perfect example of a "Preemptive Strike" which today seem so popular with our current Politicians or as my spell checker wants to insist "Pollutions."
All I was attempting to show was that this form of attack tends to PISS PEOPLE OFF in the attacked country in a fairly big way. They then all gather together and take up arms to defeat those who attacked.
This has always been the way in the past and I think that our current crop of Politician's are deluding themselves if they think for a nanosecond that anything is different today! But at the very least the British, Australian and US Governments seem to think this way that is probably why they are having so many problems in Iraq! They managed to upset some young and impressionable people who think that they are doing the right thing in acting the way that they are.
As I understand the position a German bomber lost and in desperate need to return to their base dumped their load of bombs and they where at the time over London. It all started out as a tragic accident and they where immediately taken to Berlin to be reprimanded by Hitler himself when the Allied forces returned the favor and bombed Berlin in force. The airmen who started this all off instead of being disciplined where promoted to HERO'S and given the Iron Cross. So what started out as nothing more than a tragic accident escalated into a full scale war crime by both sides as they gave up directing their attacks at military targets and just settled for anything of importance.
Incidental you did forget the V2 rockets. While they where inaccurate as hell they where the best weapon of terror that Hitler had and they where quite effective in terrorizing the public at large.
Also tonight I learned that in the Pearl Harbor attack there where also 5 midget submarines from the Japanese Navy involved just like the 3 that where used on the Attack on Sydney in an attempt to damage or sink the Chicago which at the time was moored in Sydney Harbor. None of the 5 midget subs ever returned from the Pearl Harbor Attack and the same can be said about the 3 that where used in the Sydney Harbor attack. Although the wreckage of 2 where found the one that actually did all the damage has never been found and there remain no records from Japan if that sub ever returned to the fleet of Subs that where escorting them along with the sea plane which was used to fly over every major city in Australia. The last bit is directly from the pilot involved who still is living in retirement in Japan. While it was interesting it really is nothing more than a side note in history now days.
Col
by oz_media
Actually that response was more for rickellog as he ahd said : [i]Not to diminish the acts of terrorism that have taken place in Europe but none of them compare to 9-11 or Pearl Harbor. [/i]
I just wanted to point ou tthat if PH was to be considered an act of terorrism (even though targeted as a military attack)then so was the London BLitz because even though ti was a state of war, it was an attempt to simply bomb the crap out of a city and force it into sbmission, but it failed.
I am getting really tired of these bleeding heart Americans who say nobody can understand what they are oing through when Europe has been suffering from terrorists and loss immensly greater than any attack on the US. THey think they are the only ones who can stand up and fight back or something and that everyone else is just sticking thier heads in the sand.
Most other coutries defend thier land, they don't take preemptive strikes against others for just such reasons.
Have a good one,
OM
by hal 9000
Didn't result in suck a large loss of life it did at the very least attack the very heart of the British Government.
Actually I thing if that had of been a successful attack by the IRA it would have rated as bigger than 9-11 as it was directed at the British Parliament and very nearly killed the then British Prime Minister. From memory I think that did manage to kill a few of the Cabinet and injure the British Prime Minister. Now if they had of succeeded they would have virtually wiped out the then British Government surely that has to count for something as it was a direct attack on the Government.
I think there where reports that Maggi Thatcher had to have her hair panel beaten after that attack.
Col
by hal 9000
We are in the same boat! We just do not hear what most of their activities actually where although we where told that a group of SAS actually captured what was believed to remain of the Iraq air-force all fueled and armed on the ground. Apparently as the story goes when the SAS approached the airfield the defenders ran away, but how true that is I really do not know.. The navy also has some ships in the area stopping shipping that they consider as suspect and are supposed to be defending some of the major installations like the ports and off shore oil wells. Also some specialist navy personal where given the job of removing mines in the harbor, they had to find and disarm them in water where you couldn't see your hand in front of your face plate. I also believe that we have a some aircraft {FA18's I think} in the area as well as some AWACS and have some air traffic controllers currently serving. Naturally there are defense forces for the embassy ands other places of importance,but because the majority are SAS we are not told for security reasons and I suppose to keep these people safe as well.
But the official story that so far we have suffered no casualties as a direct result of any action in Iraq but there are in excess of 1,200 injured. At a recent home coming for some air-force people a female officer was in a wheel chair and was quite willing to say she was unable to tell the media what had injured her or how she had been injured. That little gem was on national TV during part of the election coverage. But for the most part we are lead to believe that the injuries are minor in nature like going deaf from using rifles without ear protection and various minor other injuries like broken and strained legs arms and the like.
Over this side of the pond we are the proverbial mushrooms kept in the dark and feed BS from our political masters and as a population we seem to like it as we have just returned the previous Prime Minister to Office and now by the looks of things he will have a free hand as for the first time in well over 30 odd years he will have control of both houses of Parliament so he will be able to do as he likes without needing to agree with a minor party to get his major legislation through the Senate. But that may not be totally correct as it will take a little time to count all the Senate votes currently we only have computer predictions so they may be a little vague particularly as with things like postal votes it depends on when they where made as to which way the people voted. AS all the politician's say the only poll that counts is the one on the day but unfortunately with our system of voting about a week after an election is called postal and absentee votes are available to be used by people and these have grown in number as the political parties make the best use of these for their own ends. OH just as a side issue there are currently 1,800 Postal votes that will be sent out next week to be filled in apparently some one stuffed up and the Australian Electoral Commission has given these ballots an extra week to be filled in and posted so in all likely hood while not affecting anything dramatical they may change the result slightly and will not be expected to be returned for about 2 weeks.
We could be in for a bit of a wait for the final Senate numbers but otherwise I really don't think that they will make a great deal of difference.
About the only good thing to come out of yesterdays erection was that our very good fiend Pauline Hanson appears not to have been reelected to the Senate and has just missed the quota for a seat. What was decided yesterday was who gets to hold the Australian box of Viagra for the next 3 years an old foggy who has forgotten what it is used for or a relatively young guy who isn't old enough to understand what Viagra actually is.
Sorry I'm being SARCASTIC AGAIN but with our Politicians it's hard not to be.
Col
.
....I predict you will either choose not to believe it or will otherwise, somehow, try to discredit it - because you don't want to believe it.
How Saddam supported terrorism:
.
".....as an enticement for others to volunteer for martyrdom in the name of the Palestinian people."
".....But the timing of this clear signal that Saddam is stoking the Middle East conflict with his new $US15,000 bonus to encourage more suicide bombers - and exclusive pictures from the distribution ceremony, which was attended by the Herald - could make it more difficult for the Palestinian leader, Yasser Arafat, to manage his already strained relationship with the United States."
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/03/25/1017004766310.html?oneclick=true
http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/Printable.asp?ID=1309
He supported terrorism; and he did it to encourage the killing of innocent civilians.
More evidence that Saddam Hussein supported world-wide terrorism:
All quotes (except the Ramzi Yousef article) are from the following NRO article:
http://www.nationalreview.com/robbins/robbins091903.asp
"As I have noted before, Saddam Hussein had means, motive, and opportunity to be involved with global terrorism, and al Qaeda in particular."
".....it is becoming increasingly clear that Iraq provided terror groups with some forms of logistical, intelligence, transportation, training, weapons, and other support. The emerging evidence points to the conclusion that al Qaeda had a cooperative relationship ? that is, a strategic alliance ? with Iraq."
"The fact that he gave money to the families of Palestinian suicide terrorists and had a close working relationship with the PLO was well known, and something he admitted. The Iraqi regime maintained a terrorist training camp at Salman Pak near Baghdad where foreign terrorists were instructed in methods of taking over commercial aircraft using weapons no more sophisticated than knives (interesting thought that). Saddam also harbored Abu Nidal and other members of his international terror organization (ANO) in Baghdad. Abu Nidal died under suspicious circumstances in Baghdad in August 2002, an apparent multiple gunshot suicide. Abd-al-Rahman Isa, ANO's second in command based in Amman, Jordan, was kidnapped September 11, 2002, and has not been heard from since. Coalition forces did recently apprehend ANO member Khala Khadr al-Salahat, the man who reputedly made the bomb for the Libyans that brought down Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland. He was hiding out in Baghdad. Another bomb maker, Abdul Rahman Yasin, was also a Baghdad resident. He was one of the conspirators in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing who had fled there after being detained briefly by the FBI. Recent document finds in Tikrit show that Iraq supplied Yasin with both money and sanctuary. The 1993 WTC attack was masterminded by Yasin's associate Ramzi Yousef, who received financial support from al Qaeda through Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, a key 9/11 planner."
Who was Ramzi Yousef?
"ACCORDING TO THE presiding judge in last year's trial, the bombing of New York's World Trade Center on February 26, 1993 was meant to topple the city's tallest tower onto its twin, amid a cloud of cyanide gas. Had the attack gone as planned, tens of thousands of Americans would have died. Instead, as we know, one tower did not fall on the other, and, rather than vaporizing, the cyanide gas burnt up in the heat of the explosion. "Only" six people died."
http://www.fas.org/irp/world/iraq/956-tni.htm
"There is also the case of Abu Zubayr, an officer in Saddam's secret police who was also the ringleader of an al Qaeda cell in Morocco. He attended the September 5, 2001 meeting in Spain with other al Qaeda operatives, including Ramzi Bin-al-Shibh, the 9/11 financial chief. Abu Zubayr was apprehended in May, 2002, while putting together a plot to mount suicide attacks on U.S. ships passing through the straits of Gibraltar. He has allegedly since stated that Iraq trained and supplied chemical weapons to al Qaeda. In the fall of 2001 al Qaeda refugees from Afghanistan took refuge in northern Iraq until they were driven out by Coalition forces, and Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi, an al Qaeda terrorist active in Europe and North Africa, fled from Baghdad during Operation Iraqi Freedom. He has reportedly been sent back to Iraq to coordinate al Qaeda activities there."
"Iraq made direct payments to the Philippine-based al Qaeda-affiliated Abu Sayyaf group. Hamsiraji Sali, an Abu Sayyaf leader on the U.S. most-wanted terrorist list, stated that his gang received about one million pesos (around $20,000) each year from Iraq, for chemicals to make bombs. The link was substantiated immediately after a bombing in Zamboanga City in October 2002 (in which three people were killed including an American Green Beret), when Abu Sayyaf leaders called up the deputy secretary of the Iraqi embassy in Manila, Husham Hussain. Six days later, the cell phone used to call Hussain was employed as the timer on a bomb set to go off near the Philippine military's Southern Command headquarters. Fortunately, the bomb failed to detonate, and the phone yielded various contact numbers, including Hussain's and Sali's. This evidence, coupled with other intelligence the Philippine government would not release, led to Hussain's expulsion in February 2003. In March, ten Iraqi nationals, some with direct links to al Qaeda, were rounded up in the Philippines and deported as undesirable aliens. In addition, two more consulate officials were expelled for spying."
"The most intriguing potential link is reflected in documents found by Toronto Star reporter Mitch Potter in Baghdad in April, 2003. The documents detail direct links between al Qaeda and Saddam's regime dating back at least to 1998, and mention Osama bin Laden by name. The find supports an October 2001 report by William Safire that noted, among other things, a 1998 meeting in Baghdad between al Qaeda #2 Ayman al Zawahiri and Saddam's vice president, Taha Yasin Ramadan. Other reports have alleged bin Laden himself traveled to Iraq around that time, or at least planned to. Former Iraqi ambassador to Turkey, Farouk Hijazi, now in custody, allegedly met with bin Laden before the 9/11 attacks."
My opinion:
Getting rid of Saddam Hussein and attempting to plant the seeds of democracy in Iraq was the right thing to do; the time to do it was not only correct, but a dozen years too late; and if the United Nations didn't want to be a party to it, the United States was right-on about doing it without their support. And to believe otherwise is, in my opinion, to be blind to the reality and severity of the real problem.
----------
There ya' go, Colin.
.
....I predict you will either choose not to believe it or will otherwise, somehow, try to discredit it - because you don't want to believe it.
How Saddam supported terrorism:
.
".....as an enticement for others to volunteer for martyrdom in the name of the Palestinian people."
".....But the timing of this clear signal that Saddam is stoking the Middle East conflict with his new $US15,000 bonus to encourage more suicide bombers - and exclusive pictures from the distribution ceremony, which was attended by the Herald - could make it more difficult for the Palestinian leader, Yasser Arafat, to manage his already strained relationship with the United States."
http://www.smh.com.au/articles/2002/03/25/1017004766310.html?oneclick=true
http://www.frontpagemag.com/Articles/Printable.asp?ID=1309
He supported terrorism; and he did it to encourage the killing of innocent civilians.
More evidence that Saddam Hussein supported world-wide terrorism:
All quotes (except the Ramzi Yousef article) are from the following NRO article:
http://www.nationalreview.com/robbins/robbins091903.asp
"As I have noted before, Saddam Hussein had means, motive, and opportunity to be involved with global terrorism, and al Qaeda in particular."
".....it is becoming increasingly clear that Iraq provided terror groups with some forms of logistical, intelligence, transportation, training, weapons, and other support. The emerging evidence points to the conclusion that al Qaeda had a cooperative relationship ? that is, a strategic alliance ? with Iraq."
"The fact that he gave money to the families of Palestinian suicide terrorists and had a close working relationship with the PLO was well known, and something he admitted. The Iraqi regime maintained a terrorist training camp at Salman Pak near Baghdad where foreign terrorists were instructed in methods of taking over commercial aircraft using weapons no more sophisticated than knives (interesting thought that). Saddam also harbored Abu Nidal and other members of his international terror organization (ANO) in Baghdad. Abu Nidal died under suspicious circumstances in Baghdad in August 2002, an apparent multiple gunshot suicide. Abd-al-Rahman Isa, ANO's second in command based in Amman, Jordan, was kidnapped September 11, 2002, and has not been heard from since. Coalition forces did recently apprehend ANO member Khala Khadr al-Salahat, the man who reputedly made the bomb for the Libyans that brought down Pan Am Flight 103 over Lockerbie, Scotland. He was hiding out in Baghdad. Another bomb maker, Abdul Rahman Yasin, was also a Baghdad resident. He was one of the conspirators in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing who had fled there after being detained briefly by the FBI. Recent document finds in Tikrit show that Iraq supplied Yasin with both money and sanctuary. The 1993 WTC attack was masterminded by Yasin's associate Ramzi Yousef, who received financial support from al Qaeda through Khalid Shaikh Mohammed, a key 9/11 planner."
Who was Ramzi Yousef?
"ACCORDING TO THE presiding judge in last year's trial, the bombing of New York's World Trade Center on February 26, 1993 was meant to topple the city's tallest tower onto its twin, amid a cloud of cyanide gas. Had the attack gone as planned, tens of thousands of Americans would have died. Instead, as we know, one tower did not fall on the other, and, rather than vaporizing, the cyanide gas burnt up in the heat of the explosion. "Only" six people died."
http://www.fas.org/irp/world/iraq/956-tni.htm
"There is also the case of Abu Zubayr, an officer in Saddam's secret police who was also the ringleader of an al Qaeda cell in Morocco. He attended the September 5, 2001 meeting in Spain with other al Qaeda operatives, including Ramzi Bin-al-Shibh, the 9/11 financial chief. Abu Zubayr was apprehended in May, 2002, while putting together a plot to mount suicide attacks on U.S. ships passing through the straits of Gibraltar. He has allegedly since stated that Iraq trained and supplied chemical weapons to al Qaeda. In the fall of 2001 al Qaeda refugees from Afghanistan took refuge in northern Iraq until they were driven out by Coalition forces, and Abu Musab Al-Zarqawi, an al Qaeda terrorist active in Europe and North Africa, fled from Baghdad during Operation Iraqi Freedom. He has reportedly been sent back to Iraq to coordinate al Qaeda activities there."
"Iraq made direct payments to the Philippine-based al Qaeda-affiliated Abu Sayyaf group. Hamsiraji Sali, an Abu Sayyaf leader on the U.S. most-wanted terrorist list, stated that his gang received about one million pesos (around $20,000) each year from Iraq, for chemicals to make bombs. The link was substantiated immediately after a bombing in Zamboanga City in October 2002 (in which three people were killed including an American Green Beret), when Abu Sayyaf leaders called up the deputy secretary of the Iraqi embassy in Manila, Husham Hussain. Six days later, the cell phone used to call Hussain was employed as the timer on a bomb set to go off near the Philippine military's Southern Command headquarters. Fortunately, the bomb failed to detonate, and the phone yielded various contact numbers, including Hussain's and Sali's. This evidence, coupled with other intelligence the Philippine government would not release, led to Hussain's expulsion in February 2003. In March, ten Iraqi nationals, some with direct links to al Qaeda, were rounded up in the Philippines and deported as undesirable aliens. In addition, two more consulate officials were expelled for spying."
"The most intriguing potential link is reflected in documents found by Toronto Star reporter Mitch Potter in Baghdad in April, 2003. The documents detail direct links between al Qaeda and Saddam's regime dating back at least to 1998, and mention Osama bin Laden by name. The find supports an October 2001 report by William Safire that noted, among other things, a 1998 meeting in Baghdad between al Qaeda #2 Ayman al Zawahiri and Saddam's vice president, Taha Yasin Ramadan. Other reports have alleged bin Laden himself traveled to Iraq around that time, or at least planned to. Former Iraqi ambassador to Turkey, Farouk Hijazi, now in custody, allegedly met with bin Laden before the 9/11 attacks."
My opinion:
Getting rid of Saddam Hussein and attempting to plant the seeds of democracy in Iraq was the right thing to do; the time to do it was not only correct, but a dozen years too late; and if the United Nations didn't want to be a party to it, the United States was right-on about doing it without their support. And to believe otherwise is, in my opinion, to be blind to the reality and severity of the real problem.
----------
There ya' go, Colin.
by hal 9000
Yes the links and info where very interesting and besides the obvious I'll not even try to discredit them in the least.
But I will ask why ignore Libya? The leader there is nearly as bad if not in some ways worse.
What I can not understand is why the US Senate Committee investigations failed to find these links.
Maxwell my only real problem with the invasion of Iraq is that the COW seemed to be unprepared for what to do after they had succeeded in overthrowing Saddam.
AND AS USUAL IT IS OUR TROOPS WHO SEEM TO BE GETTING THE ROUGH END OF THE PINEAPPLE AGAIN!
They are the ones that I really feel sorry for as since "Major Hostilities Have Finished" their battle pay has been cut back but they are now at greater risk than during the campaign to overthrow Saddam and his Government.
I think they all deserve far better than what they are currently getting.
If that makes me anti - anything I can live with it but I've seen far too many AU troops who willingly serve their country only to be treated like SHIT after the event. From what I've heard from these people I believe it to be the same in most of the other countries involved as well. You do not know how happy I would be if I'm wrong but to me this just looks like more of the same old stuff again. Incidental do not believe too much from Fairfax as they have been heavily discredited for a very long time now with a lot of their reports. While they are no where near as bad as the News Corp Group they are not much better either.
Colin
.
On Libya: They have indeed capitulated to the most likely outcome, and they have voluntarily agreed to cease and desist in both their sponsorship and support of terrorism, and their quest to acquire (more) WMDs - and they're destroying, under supervision, the ones they've already developed. Libya has admitted culpability in the destruction Pan Am flight 103 over Scotland, and has both compensated and apologized to the families of the victims (or are in that process). In short, they "gave-in" to avoid the same fate caused by Saddam's reluctance to do the same. So Libya is not being ignored. To the contrary, they are being "brought around" - and without a shot being fired. Will it last? Well, time will tell. But make no mistake about it; they are not being ignored.
On the US Senate Committee investigations: Read the whole things, read everything presented, not just the out-of-context sound bites you see reported by the media. And read what everyone has reported, not just the ones being critical. There's good and bad, to be sure, but taken on balance, things are going as well as can be expected; in fact, they're going very well. And after all, name one war in all of history when everything went exactly according to plan. And don't say that there was no exit strategy, because there was an exit strategy, and one that's being implemented according to plan.
Colin, I know you're a smart guy, but I'm not sure how well informed you are. My guess is that you know only what you see on the news, but don't do a lot of digging yourself.
If you have a little bit of time and want to do an interesting exercise, try to support the opposing argument - a tactic used in preparing for a debate. For example, if you are a participant in a debate, and you want to take the argument that the action in Iraq is not related to the over-all war on terrorism, then to best prepare yourself, you study the opponent's position and try to prove that point of view. That way, you'll be best prepared to counter any debate points your opponent might have. However, in this case, if you spend only an hour or so researching "your opponent's position", you just might have a change of mind and see that the action in Iraq is a part - indeed a vital part - in the overall war on terrorism.
Debate question: Is the war in Iraq a factor in the over-all war on world-wide terrorism?
Go ahead, prove that it IS, and you'll be better prepared to show that it's not. However, in this case, you might just bring yourself around to my way of thinking.
Yes, I have done the same exercise. And in my efforts to "prove" that it's not, all I really have is a bunch of nonsensical conspiracy-type arguments and/or shell-game type arguments.
To me, it's as plain as day that the war in Iraq IS vital to the overall war on world-wide terrorism - and there's absolutely no doubt about it.
by hal 9000
But I'm the first to admit that I don't have all that much time to play with. My boss is a real B*****d who makes me work when I'm sick and I never get any holidays either. But enough bitching about myself.
The whole report is a bit long and is really heavy reading but I'm working my way through it slowly, and I'm the first to admit that what I see presented as "Sound Bites" on news reports are not worth the time or power to transmit them.
Libya has only recently come clean so to speak and it was within the last few months that they admitted that that had a nuclear program which sought of caught everyone off guard as from what I've been able to find they just where not high on the list of priories at the time. I think Gaddafi saw what was happening in Iraq and came clean to keep his position but the reality of the position is that while he was the Bad Boy a while ago he has since slipped into relative obscurity as a lot the resources have been placed on Saddam at the expense of other countries in the area.
Anyway back to the original comments that you made I still think that it is our troops who are getting the rough end of the stick as obviously they are in a war zone but are not receiving full combat pay well the AU troops at least as I have not had any direct contact with current serving US troops in Iraq. And while I do not put too much credence on things like this at an election rally here in AU a couple of weeks ago we had the Defense Minister and Prime Minister welcoming returned troops back from Iraq. Now there was a young woman in a wheel chair in Air force uniform who obviously had been injured some how returning from Iraq and when she was asked how she was injured her response was "I can not tell you!" Now maybe she was getting a bit an fell off her commanders table or something similar or maybe she was somehow injured in Iraq but we over here have constantly been told that none of our troops have suffered any injury directly related to combat. There have been something like 1,200 injuries reported {This comes from the Defense Minister} but none where a direct result of combat. Now he went on to list some of the injuries like partial deafness from firing rifles without ear protection broken limbs and the like but he was insistent that none of them where directly related to combat. So I'm guessing that our troops who suffered hearing loss where just shooting bottles or beer cans when they had their hearing damaged as the Minister insists that none of the injuries are combat related.
Sorry mate but I've seen this BS so many times that I no longer believe the people who are spreading it around maybe I've just got cynical over the years but on every occasion that I've heard things like this subsequent inquiries have shown that there is in fact damage caused by whatever which the authorities are unwilling to admit to until it is far too late.
Col
by delbertpgh
I do find problems with the sources for your material. FrontPageMag.Com is a strongly partisan conservative-oriented website in the Gingrich mold. National Review is likewise very partisan. Both of these organizations believe admantly that no harm should be done to the Republican cause, especially during an election. Nothing wrong with that, except that if you are looking for impartial facts about the critical issue in GWB's presidency, you will find only foot-stomping support.
Laurie Mylroie is a more interesting problem. She is a scholar with a substantial academic record. At the time of the 1991 gulf war, she became a fully convinced Saddam opponent, which is okay, but following the first World Trade Center bombing she kept sliding deeper and deeper into weird conspiracy theories that tied Ramzi Youssef to Saddam, and from there, linking Saddam to numerous major terrorist acts against the U.S., including the Oklahoma City bombing. She has been listened to by some members of the Bush administration, who seem to want to look away from the neon sign that lights her up as a cracked pot, and find justification for the invasion. See the editorial in Manchester Guardian, http://www.guardian.co.uk/Iraq/Story/0,2763,1254072,00.html
Very definitely Saddam did pay families of suicide bombers in Palestine and Israel a death benefit. He may not have organized the bombings or subsidized the groups, but he certainly paid the life insurance. No argument there. And he did have stronger connections to terrorist groups in the past, but he seems to have been interested in them only so far as they helped his personal cause to be president of all Araby. Once they lost usefulness, he dumped them. (Abu Nidal is reported to have committed suicide in Baghdad by multiple gunshot wounds to the back.) He has kept a group alive in the northeast, an Iran-hating group, that he allows to live so long as they harass his next-door enemy. I heard he kept anti-Kurd groups alive, too.
He had limited current connection to terror, but it hasn't been shown to be outside of his own back yard (unless you count the Palestinian life insurance policies.)
.
I know that neither of you guys (or others) will ever come around and agree that the war in Iraq is one factor in the overall war against world-wide terrorism. But in contrast, and in all fairness, I'll never come around and agree that it isn't.
Consider this. In the U.S. public school system, a common buzz-phrase is "zero-tolerance". They will show zero-tolerance for this and that, and with just one little infraction, the kid's outta' there. I don't necessarily agree with such policies as it relates to kids in school, but I certainly do think that a "zero-tolerance" policy in regards to world-wide terrorism is the only way to approach it - especially considering the fact that we (the world collectively) have shown an enormous amount of tolerance - or turning a blind-eye or attempting to negotiate or whatever - for the past thirty years.
While you fault the United States' policies and actions against world-wide terrorism, I fault the rest of the world - and especially the United Nations - for tolerating it. And as a disclaimer, I also fault every American administration, of both parties, over the past thirty years. After 9-11, as far as I'm concerned, the time of "zero-tolerance" has come.
Combating world-wide terrorism is bigger than just going after the perpetrators of 9-11. It's bigger than just going after al Queda. It's bigger than just Libya. It's bigger than Iraq, Iran and Syria. And it will take many generations of leaders, diplomats and soldiers to finally defeat it.
As far as I'm concerned, President Bush has been more proactive in combating world-wide terrorism than any other leader, either inside or outside the United States. And do you know what? You may or may not believe this, but if it was a Democrat president in the White House taking the same approach as President Bush, I'd be just as adamant in my convictions. This problem transcends politics and party. Give me a Democrat Franklin Roosevelt or a Republican George Bush, and I'd throw my support behind either of them - as long as they have a zero-tolerance policy towards world-wide terrorism.
I keep two pictures in my office: one of the World Trade Center towers gleaming brightly in the sunlight; and next to that one, is a picture of those two towers in flames. I'll never forget. And I'll never approach it with anything other than zero-tolerance. I hear this nonsense about not sending our sons and daughters into harm's way. But that danger pales in comparison to those who want to bring harm's way to our sons and daughters. And I just can't understand anyone who accepts anything less than zero-tolerance.
by oz_media
"Iraq is one factor in the overall war against world-wide terrorism."
I agree, fully.
But uhhhhhhhhh, WHY did you invade Iraq?
Because Bush came forward with a speach that said "Saddam was not a direct and imminent threat to America but he has a past of promoting and supporting terrorists. While we have determined that BinLaden is not the most imperative target to capture at this time nor do we have the foggiest idea where he went when he escaped us,we still feel it neccessary to invade Iraq and capture Saddam."
I certainly think that given the CURRENT lack of support for the war, he would have failed MISERABLY at gaining support on such a premise.
But that's NOT what happened and that's NOT why people are pissed off. Saddam was/is a terrorist, nobody has ever denied this.
Was he a terroist that threatened America? Did he have the ability to cause harm to Americans?
THIS was what Bush had lied about, Saddam was a threat to America that had failed to stop his development of WMD. BULLSH*T! Admit it and move on. The rest of the world doubted the reports, why wouldn't Bush or Blair? The rest of the world didn't feel justified in helping spend hundreds of billions to work in Iraq when there was a real threat building elsewhere, al-QAEDA, the guys who claimed responsibility for organizing 9/11.
WERE ANY of the terrorists that caused 9/11 even FROM Iraq? 15 of them were Saudi's, who you have neither invaded or attacked in ayway.
Yes, Iraq was/is a terrorists haven, but the threat to the world is FAR greater than Iraq, al-Qaeda is the BIG problem, al-Qaeda hasn't been slowed, paused, hindered, interrupted or even mentioned recently. al-Qaeda, who laughed at America over the whole Afghanistan/Taliban issue is now said to be bigger and stronger than pre 9/11.
Perhaps it's time for someone to admit his mistakes and start to focus on stopping terrorist threats instead of trying to prove he is reducing a terrorist country.
al-Qaeda HAVE threatened England, they DO rally in FREE countries and build thier masses.
Perhaps THAT is why people have walked away from the CowBush agenda and focused thier efforts on building alliances with neighbours in an attempt to gain further intelligence on the REAL threats to the world.
Iraq IS neccessary, it was NOT imperative or time sensitive nor should be seen or reported as much when much greater, REAL threats, to countries have been made and need to be addressed.
But as always you will see that Europeans walk softly and carry a big stick, they don't chant "voceiferously' and fight the wrong targets.
by delbertpgh
I think the problem is so big, so urgent, and so long-lasting, that we can't afford to ignore it, we can't afford ill-timed moves, and we can't afford the wrong moves. So perhaps we agree in spirit, but I believe GWB is making wrong moves that embolden the enemies, dissipate our strength, and waste valuable time, so I'm sure we disagree about him. Find the bums and shoot them dead, right, but kill the most important ones soonest. Have a winning strategy.
The idea of zero tolerance is more an attractive slogan than a useful strategy. What can the U.S. do about the Chechens, for example? The Russians tried to hold on to their influence in the Caucasus region by coming down hard on Chechnya, long before their rebellion had any air of religious fanaticism. Now the Chechen war belongs to the Islamic extremists, and is a training ground for international terrorists. Chechens move out to serve with Al Qaida cells, and Arabs come to Chechnya for experience and to bond with their Muslim brethern. How are we going to influence this crew? Conversations over golf with Vladimir Putin? The Russians made this the mess it is now, and they show no sign of easing off with the heavy hand. Not that easing off will fix anything, at this point. The Russians have left a wound that will vex the world until the Chechens get bored with being martyrs, at which point we can celebrate the victory of zero tolerance.
Most of the terror that goes on has its roots in local political situations that, for one reason or another, we can't influence. About all we can do is pick a side, pump in a little money, and hope that some day we get useful intelligence or overflight rights from the regimes we back. In cases like the Phillipines and Indonesia, GWB is doing about as much as anybody could do. Like the Chechen situation, we'll wind up tolerating whatever happens, until the terrorism falls to zero.
GWB's interesting idea was that by turning Iraq into a prospering, libertarian, free-market democracy, he could shock the whole Middle East into reevaluating itself. One of his favorite concepts is the "game changer", and this, if it worked, would change the game. (After telling us about direct links to terror, WMDs for terrorists, and WMDs against its neighbors, his real reason is finally on the table.) Now, I actually don't oppose the idea of a game-changer; I actually think that our old paradigm was slowly losing us the world, and that a radical, activist shift was necessary. But this one move is so expensive that we can't afford to do much else, is so susceptible to failure, pisses off so much of the world, and has so many elements out of our control, that it just should not have been done. Plus, the way it was done was marked by further carelessness and bad judgement. Bad plan, bad execution.
There's globalism, and there's dumb-sh*t globalism. You can tell where I come down.
by hal 9000
With your sediments what I would ask is exactly where do we draw the line?
Over night Tony Blair has withdrawn now his third reason to invade Iraq. While I do not like Saddam one little bit even the British Prime Minister has had to admit that three of the main reasons used to invade Iraq where based on faulty intelligence.
What I see as unsatisfactory is that post 9-11 we had a world wide momentum to fight TERROR on all fronts and this now seems to have been squandered with "The War on Terrorism" being side tracked in Iraq and so many countries now dropping out of the equation.
If the other side can divide they can conqueror and after all we did start this mess off by supporting the insurgents in Afghanistan to throw out the Russians who had been asked to help stop what was to latter become known as the Talaban. Bin Laden gave a air of credence to Al Quedia as he comes from a rich Saudi family so a lot of the Muslin world believed that if someone like him supported Al Quedia there must be something in it. He is or was a figure head nothing more and while if he is still alive I would like to see him captured it is now really a side issue as what he was allegedly in charge of but apparently never actually planed any activities has now grown far bigger than he could ever hopped for.
Maxwell with "Zero Tolerance" exactly where do we draw the line? You have to remember that there are several different forms of terrorism! The terrorist organizations who do not have to defend any ground but can launch attacks from anywhere in the world to suit their own ends, then there is Political Terrorism like what is happening in Sudan and finally State Sponsored Terrorism like Hitler attempting to destroy the Jewish population or something as simple as a country providing support of a insurgent group against a Sovereign Government which they do not approve of.
Now I was under the impression that the "COW" was fighting the first kind of Terrorism but that has been hijacked into something else now that I'm not quite sure why or where it will lead to.
But I do remember a prophecy from Nostradamus that the Third World War will start in what is now known as the Middle East so in that case I would personally tread very carefully.
Of course if GWB is really serious in his attempts to totally destroy all forms of terrorism he could start legal proceedings against previous administrations who supported this. An easy target would be those who where responsible for the "Contras" which are well known and easily tracked down particularly as some of those involved have openly admitted to their actions and firmly believe that they where justified in them because they where fighting a war which was authorized by their Government!
Col
by aldanatech
According to Pentagon records, U.S. deaths in Iraq this month are approaching 100, making it the second-deadliest month since American forces invaded the country in March 2003.
The worst month was last April, with 135 deaths, when the insurgency intensified and U.S. Marines fought fierce battles in Fallujah, only to be withdrawn from the city. That was part of a failed attempt to put the now-defunct Fallujah Brigade of U.S. and allied Iraqi forces in charge.
Until now the second-deadliest month was November 2003 with 82 deaths, and 80 Americans died in May and September this year.
The rising death toll coincides with U.S. military commanders' efforts to pacify areas of Iraq that need to be brought under Iraqi government control before elections scheduled for late January. It also reflects an escalation of attacks by the insurgents, although some U.S. commanders say they believe this may be a last-gasp effort by rebel forces outmatched by U.S. firepower.
House Changes Rules to Protect DeLay
The Note: His Legacy and Her Future
Democrats Vie for Party Chair
It is difficult to gauge the effect of the growing death toll on U.S. troop morale. Commanders say their men and women are holding up well, although they caution that more hard fighting lies ahead.
Most of the deaths this month have been in the Fallujah offensive that began Nov. 7. Many Marines and soldiers also have been killed in Ramadi and other cities in Anbar province west of Baghdad, as well as in Mosul in the north, Babil province south of Baghdad and in and around the Iraqi capital.
Support troops also have been killed along supply routes. On Tuesday, for example, a soldier assigned to the Army's 13th Corps Support Command was killed and another was wounded when a roadside bomb struck their supply convoy near Qayarrah West Airfield in northern Iraq.
A Marine officer said Monday that 37 Marines and soldiers had been killed in the Fallujah offensive, plus one nonbattle death. He said 320 had been wounded. American estimates of the number of insurgents killed in the offensive range from about 1,000 to about 1,200.
An exact and fully current count of U.S. deaths is difficult to obtain because of time lags between the military's initial reporting of attacks and the subsequent identification of the individual casualties.
Brig. Gen. Mark Kimmitt, the deputy director of plans for U.S. Central Command, said Tuesday that enough of the insurgency's leaders probably got out of Fallujah to keep the violence flaring elsewhere.
"What we primarily captured, we suspect, are not the high-level leadership nor the facilitators but really the common foot soldiers, and we would expect that the foreign fighters that didn't fight to the death are probably moving out to start the fight somewhere else (in Iraq)," Kimmitt said in an interview with AP Radio from Central Command offices in Tampa, Fla.
As of Tuesday the Pentagon said 1,210 U.S. service members have died in Iraq since the conflict began 20 months ago. At the beginning of November the Pentagon count stood at 1,119, and it rose rapidly as the Fallujah fighting intensified and insurgents struck back in other cities and towns.
Because of the heavy fighting in Fallujah and the insurgents' apparent attempts to respond with stepped-up attacks elsewhere, this month also is seeing one of the highest wounded totals. The number of wounded jumped by nearly 500 this week, according to Pentagon figures released Tuesday.
Since the start of the war, 8,956 U.S. service members have been wounded, of which nearly 5,000 were serious enough to prevent them from returning to duty. At the start of the month the total was 8,287.
Of the 91 or more U.S. deaths so far this month, it appears most were Marines. The 1st Marine Expeditionary Force led the charge into Fallujah and did much of the house-to-house fighting. Elements of the Army's 1st Cavalry Division and 1st Infantry Division also participated, along with Air Force attack jets and gunships and several battalions of U.S.-trained Iraqi troops.
The Pentagon has not yet released names and service affiliation for all the casualties reported this month, so it is impossible to tally the exact number of Marines who've been killed. Of the first 71 deaths for which identifications were announced, 48 were Marines. Twenty-one were with the Army, and the Navy and Air Force each had one fatality.
The 48 Marine deaths, halfway through November, are the most for any full month during the war except for last April when the corps lost 52 Marines. None of the 48 Marines was older than 29, and most were in their early 20s. Six of the Marines were 19 years old.
Source:
http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory?id=259764&CMP=OTC-RSSFeeds0312
by protiusx
by aldanatech
by protiusx
by aldanatech
by aldanatech
According to the BBC yesterday, the attacks by Sunni insurgents in Mosul, Baquba and elsewhere in Iraq suggest that the insurgency is likely to continue despite the victory of US and Iraqi Government forces in Falluja.
Lightly-armed insurgent forces are like grains of sand.
As combat power is deployed against them they tend to drift away, either going to ground or seeking another battlefield on which to fight.
This is exactly what has happened in Falluja.
While US troops are largely in control of the town they are still meeting sporadic pockets of quite fierce resistance.
Elsewhere it is clear that some insurgents left Falluja before the US-led assault and have embarked upon a co-ordinated series of attacks in Baquba, Suweira and Mosul.
This implies a reasonably sophisticated level of centralised command.
But in military terms it is far from clear what these various attacks amount to.
The insurgents appear to have suffered serious losses in Falluja, but not necessarily a knockout blow.
Sporadic violence
Yet again it is clear that the US simply doesn't have sufficient troops on the ground to maintain order in several key cities at once while launching a major offensive against another.
Now a light armoured brigade has been moved on from Falluja towards Mosul.
This is a strategically important city - close to the northern oilfields and astride routes into Turkey.
It is also ethnically very mixed. Saddam Hussein's efforts to Arabise the city by moving in his Sunni supporters inevitably created tensions.
And these tensions give the violence in Mosul an added inter-ethnic dimension.
Once Falluja is secure the US may have more troops available to put down the sporadic violence elsewhere.
But it is still far from clear what message Sunni leaders have taken from the Falluja operation.
Will they now be willing to join the political process in Iraq or will their bitterness towards the Americans and the interim Iraqi government be even greater?
Source:
Forget about what the liberal traitors in the United States say. These are the same people who allowed Iran to be delivered into the hands of the Ayatollahs (thanks Carter) and who allowed Bin Laden to roam the globe unchallenged killing thousands of American (thanks Clinton). And forget the President. George W. Bush is never going to come out and tell you why we are really in Iraq, politics and his position in the world arena prohibit him from doing so.
The reason we have to stay in Iraq, forever if needs be, is due to the fact that Islam will come to fight us regardless of whether we are in the Middle East or not. Muslims have a hatred for the West that goes back hundreds of years. According to Islamic thinking the West stole their civilization. Stole their inheritance and their right to be the greatest nation and the best of nations as their wicked book, the Quran, teaches them. Muslims are taught, and they believe that their manifest destiny is to convert the world to Islam, so that the whole world becomes Dar Al Islam (house of Islam) again rather than its current status as Dar El Harb (house of War) where pure Islam is not taught. We saw what happened with the last Wahabi, fundamentalist Islamic experiment (Afghanistan) and how it ended. These are teachings that Muslims cannot deny in their hearts, and if they otherwise to you then they are practicing Taqiyya (lying to promote the cause of Islam). In Europe and America Muslims are trying to convert weak-minded Europeans and Americans to their wicked religion and they are succeeding (thanks to Liberalism). Here in America we still have hope and I believe that we are smarter than liberal Europeans.
With these realizations the administration realized after September 11th that Islamic terrorism, supported by rogue regimes, must be fought and that if we didn't take the fight to them then they will be directing all of their recruiting and resources to sending homicide bombers to busses in American cities like LA, San Francisco, New York and other places, spreading horror in this country and shaking the foundations of our economic and political systems. Such a price is too high to pay and risks cannot be taken. By going to Afghanistan, Iraq, and hopefully Iran (soon) we will be dragging Jihadists, who will fight America regardless, to the places that we choose. We will determine the killing field and they will come like bees are attracted to the honey. These are not people you can reason with or say that they will be better if you give them what they want; They will always come after infidel (kafer) Christians and Westerners regardless. The strategy is paying off, and a quick reading on Jihadist websites reveals that Al Qaeda, despite Zarqawi's allegiance, is fed up with Al Qaeda in Iraq, which is distracting their treasure, donations, people, recruiting and all other logistics towards Iraq. Al Qaeda in Saudi has been almost eliminated (when was the last time you heard of a serious bombing in Saudi), Al Qaeda in America cannot do a thing because all resources are tied to Iraq. So Al Qaeda strategists and publicists, despite public support for Zarqawi, is very uneasy about him and is paralyzed elsewhere. By going to Iraq we have accomplished that. In terms of costs in men and treasure on our side it is unfortunate in the short run but if compared to long-term scenarios we come out as the winners.
By continuing to take battle to the enemy, and keeping a close eye on the sources of oil in the Persian Gulf, preventing its fall in the wrong hands, we maintain influence and control over Chinese fortunes. China is another discussion but it is sufficient to say that there is evidence that in the past few years they have allied themselves with terrorist organizations in Iran and other places in order to have access to cheap oil. By being in the region we have really made sure that China cannot control sources of oil or have any significant influence to rival us in the region.
It is important to continue the fight and not lose courage or heart. Things will be like this for a long time to come. This is a long war and for the sake of our country and children we have to continue it and sacrifice to guarantee that when it is over the evil of Islamic terrorism will be over and that vile religion and its followers will have no leg to stand on.
by jck
No American...not one...had anything to do with allowing the Ayatollahs to stay in power there. The people of Iran did not stand up and overthrow them. Just like the people of Iraq didn't stand up and overthrow Hussein.
You'd think that 15M people could overrun Saddam and take him down.
And don't say it couldn't be done...it's been done before in all sorts of cultures...Anglican, French, German, Arab, etc.
At least Clinton didn't leave troops over in Baghdad for over 2 years to get picked off (by terrorists) by fighting a conventional battle against an enemy (terrorist insurgents) who fight with no rules.
And also, the number of Iraqis (Muslims) killed by extremist Muslim terrorists is almost 2 to 1 compared to the number of Americans being killed in Iraq.
The Muslim community needs to come out and unconditionally condemn terrorism, whether it is by their Muslim "brother" or not. When this happens, the terrorists will be exposed for what they are...defilers of their own faith...and be cast out from the Muslim faith and become no more than hooligans.
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending