Discussion Locked

Iraq is out of control

0 helpful
525 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Iraq is going from bad to worse. The number of U.S. dead in Iraq already passed the chilling 1,000. More than 20 U.S. servicemen were killed in one week, 11 in one day, hundreds of Iraqi civilians also dead. Several major cities in Iraq are still under the control of insurgents. Where is this grim situation heading? Answer: Civil war. So is the most likely future for Iraq, says a brand-new report from the regarded British Royal Institute of International Affairs.

It is also a view shared by many American analysts. The three-way civil war scenario is as follows: One, the Kurds in the north gained breakaway self-rule in the 1990s and will not give up their autonomy. Kurdish militias are battling now for control of Kirkuk, a city outside of Kurdish-held territory and oil-rich. Two, the Shiite majority that suffered under Saddam Hussein and his Baath Party government, dominated by minority Sunnis, do not want to suffer under Sunnis again. Three, the Sunni minority, in control of Iraq for decades, like it that way. Sunnis now hold much of central and northwestern Iraq and will resist both Kurdish domination in the north and any attempt at Shiite control of Baghdad.

What are your projections for Iraq in the following months or years?

Source: PBS

525 replies

by admin

Even bigger than just Iraq, I predict that there will be unrest in the Middle East for the next ten years.

by highlander718

Now that is to late to repair some of the damages, I think the international community should realize that we cannot let things go out of control in Irak. Obviously as much as I agree with the "invasion" I consider that the US and her allies had a poor post-war plan and should take the lead in "resolving the situation" in whatever way, because it would be worst if things get out of control, as it looks now.

by aldanatech

As of now the President is still adamant with the international community and that can make reaching a solution even harder. Any ideas on how we could overcome this with Bush in office?

by oz_media

You're being nice and positive i think.

If it was a ten year resolution, it would be somewhat acceptable.

Bottom line is that the terror regime to be stopped is the ever faster growing al-Qaeda, and that stems across FAR more places than just the middle east. I saw caucasian Bosnians, signing up for al-Qaeda recruiting seminars on a news profile last week. This isn't being made up, they interviewed the people and showed the pamphlets. Poor African Muslims are being PAID to enroll now, folloing America's lead for the first time. Until now it has always been faih and belief that motivates new recruits to terrorism, now it is money and they have a LOT of it.

10 years to soothe the middle east? How about the rest of the world?

Instead of attacking th eenemy, we need to force our governments to change the focus on understanding the enemy (they know our actions but we can't predict thiers), and THEN maybe we can start to effect change. It isn't going to be resolved by forced invasions though that's for damn sure!

The US is just stirring the beehive while al-Qaeda rebuilds all around them, get a few kills and the people feel better for not capturing BinLaden or stopping the actual force of terror that builds today. It builds a fase sense of security to watch planes bomb and tanks attack unsuspecting targets by utilizing modern weaponry. It displays ability but it doesn't actually get asnything done, other than make a mess and a whole lotta noise. This seems to be an acceptable action for many though, for some reason, however ineffective it may actually be.

Nobody is ANY safer today than they were 4 years ago, they just FEEL safer from watching all the propaganda surrounding success in the middle east. In fact the threat today is MUCH geater than before.

Given that Bosnia now has had 1200 new mosques built SINCE the Bosnian war, and al-Qaeda are actively working to build a regime bigger than any force the US has seen in history, it is quite interesting to look at a map, see WHERE the regimes are building en mass (including WITHIN America) and then look at where Bush sent his troops.

You are practically surrounded by a rapidly growing force and yet are focus on some little country of resistance who didn't like inspectors of sanctions being pushed upon it.

Bosnia to your east, may effectively terrorize western Europe systematically.

Africa to the West is setting up to doing the same in North America.

It is being built on BOTH sides of Western Europe and North America. And yet the focus of the people is in Iraq and supporting the guy responsible for you being there.

Oh well, only time will tell I suppose.

At least the British quickly conducted thier missions in Iraq and were done for the most part, now they have the focus on protecting Western Europe (mostly London as it is a known target). Everyone in England is aware of the theat and is preparing for the worst. They are not so much living in a cloud of fear in as much as they are prepared and aware. Just as the USA would have liked to have have been regarding the Taliban and 9/11, if not that specific attack, then at least aware of a growing threat and prepared LOCALLY to respond to such an issue, instead of runnig off to fight terrorism in another continent or get a little eye for an eye for not finding Bin Laden.

Everyone in America stood wide eyed and mouth open on 9/11 (as most of us outside America did too). The FALSE sense of security and safety of being the MOST POWERFUL NATION ON EARTH wasn't enough on that day and many people have realized it now, yet there are still those that believe a display of power will resovle the issue, we are finding out daily just how icredibly mislead thay have all been.

Look at the countries who regularly paraded thier military might before the people to instill goverment support and faith in the country.

Iraq, Germany and Russia.

Where did it get them?
Humbled a little now by a slap in the face.

So why follow the lead?

by highlander718

What do you mean by "understanding" the enemy ?
You want us to sit and try to "understand" the enemy while he's sending planes into our buildings, beheading civilians and bombing school buses ? What will you do with the "understanding" ? Send them flowers and peace proposals ? What is it to understand ? That they are ruthless terorrists ? That they are criminals ? We already know that.

by aldanatech

Between 10 and 20 years sounds like a realistic time frame to clean up this mess. And yes, I am trying to look at this from a positive point of view -- which obviously can't go very far at this point.

by oz_media

That is an interesting perspective. It also fits in with removing thier assets, which is virtually impossible due to borders and laws.

They are using MONEY to appeal to many.

In Bosnia, Muslims ae seen as great people because they have rebuilt MUCH of Bosnia (even if it is by erecting over 1200 mosques).

These minor things for western culture are seen as utopia for a country that lies in ruin after such devastating war.

To take it a little further;
That 200 billion beig spent in Iaq, MAY (speculation)be better applied to rebuild elxewhere and throw a little cash around to make America's goal seem MUCh moe appealing than al-Qaeda's.

by tomsal

This is beyond frustrating, way passed upsetting, and hell and gone from aggravating.

I don't get it...I swear I really don't...

Why do we (United States) get involved in this crap? Fine if someone is possessing nuclear weapons and they are radicals, with itchy trigger fingers and such --- ok, send in the forces you need and rip them a new one.

*BUT*....

1) Don't start a long drawn out campaign that lasts years and years .... learn from the past, 2000 years of bloodshed and holy wars and all of a sudden we are gonna create peace and they are just gonna go "oh yeah you are right, this is dumb" and just start laying down their arms and hugging one another. Please!

2) I think (for our own safety and economy as well) America needs to stop getting involved in this crap. And for the folks who want to say "What about 9/11?"...yeah um...that wasn't Iraq there buddy...so don't give me the 9/11 excuse for 200 BILLION dollars and counting over 1,000 US soldiers dead.

3) Why don't we conserve the lives of our soldiers, we don't we invest the 200 billion in our OWN COUNTRY, why don't we direct the resources and efforts at battling overseas an unwinnable war (against a country who wasn't even responsible for 9/11) on better security in our country?

Even after 9/11 our security is still largely a joke...there is MUCH room for improvements.

Its just so sickening anymore...such a waste of human life.

by aldanatech

I'm with you. Ever since the war in Iraq began I've been asking myself those same kinds of questions over and over again. Obviously the administration hasn't provided me with clear and satisfactory answers and that just pisses me off.

by oz_media

I think oe of the biggest falacies was saying that the people WANT liberation and will accept democracy once they have a taste.
Certainly there are some if not many who would seize such an opportunity but for the most part all they see is America forcig themselves upon thier country.

Now for a Muslim to see a Christian country do this by force, even though WE don't see it as a religious war, how are they expected to not equate it to a Christian Crusade?

al0Qaeda have not been stopped, removed, captured or thwarted in any way other than placing some hurdles in the way. But while the concentration is on Iraq, al-Qaeda have shown they are building in Eastern Europe and in Africa in a sort of flanking maneuver. Yet all people say is to continue ridding the nasities in Iraq, completely missing the point that the focus needs to be chaged ito KNOWING the enmy.

They know Western warfare ad ideals well, they know what the motivation for the west is. We can't even begin to say the same, other than 'They don't want us to have our freedoms?', a little simplistic I'd say.

At least some of the world has caught on to this and started to make changes to ease the recovery after thier next attack, which is a WHEN not an IF in western Europe anyway.

So when they do the Tube in London, and everyoe in North America stands with eyes wide and mouth agape, at least they were expecting as much in London and were prepared to deal with it.

The media is responsible for much of this segue in the war on terror, but for the presidet to not clear it up and explain that this force is once again growing globally is just asinine. Better not scare too many Americans into thinking you haven't done anything with the lives it's citizens spared, this close to an election at least.

by hereinoz

I hate to say it because there will be plenty out there who will howl me down, but when all this was getting going, I posted in this forum that the likely scenario for Iraq was civil unrest and anarchy until another "Saddam Hussein" seizes power and threatens to shoot anyone who disagrees with him.

That is the way it is heading, and I will stand by that prediction. I campaigned against our Government (Australia) getting involved, not because I figured that Saddam Hussein was a warm cuddly little bloke who should be left alone, but for the reason that it would open a can of worms which would take much bloodshed and time to close again.

Not that it will ever be closed - just the lid tightened. The Iraqi people are too fragmented to ever accept the concept of majority rule. Democracy in Iraq is as likely as a synagogue in Baghdad.

Your government and ours were warned, they just didn't want to listen. Now we pay the price, for now that we are in there, how in hell are we ever going to get out?? No idea - that is why I campaigned to stay out, because we will not be able to leave Iraq, not in the forseeable future, but it will be almost impossible to stay there as well.

A totally dumb action all round, and I am ashamed to be associated, by nationality, with a government that was stupid and arrogant enough to think that we could bowl in there and make a Democracy.

I have no solution - my solution was crippled years ago when we first decided to invade.

Alan

by maxwell edison

.
With all due respect, no one in the Bush administration ever suggested that it would be either quick or easy. To the contrary, they warned that it would be long and difficult. Do you want to debate that question alone? Go ahead, I challenge you - or anyone else - to find a single speech, a statement, or anything that came out of the Bush administration that even hinted at the prospect that it would be anything but a long and difficult endeavor. (And please, don't cite one little thing and twist it and skew it and misrepresent it to mean something it did not mean.) The "instant gratification" mind-set of too many people has created a scenario that never existed in the first place.

Ask yourself this. What will it take to stop this kind of thing in the world? ("This kind of thing means terrorism, tyrants, murderers assuming power, oppression, etc.) Then ask yourself this. Should it be attempted - even though the process will be long and difficult? Will the sacrifices made today be worthy of the noble goal of eradicating the world of such evil and injustice? If you want to say no, it's not worth it, then that's fine - but many will disagree. However, don't change what was just to drive home your opinion.

Bringing peace and stability to the middle-east, something unknown to the region for generations, is a noble and worthy goal. Putting a stop to the proliferation of world-wide terrorism, which was conceived and is nurtured in the middle-east, is a noble and worthy goal. President Bush has been working on doing just those things for a mere three years, and you grow impatient. The United Nations has been "working" on doing it (supposedly) for thirty years - or more - with absolutely nothing to show for it except more of the same - much more of the same - not to mention the corruption that they, themselves, became involved in. And you want to return the solutions to them? I just don't get it.

by av .

We invaded the country, took out Saddam's regime and just bought ourselves the responsibility of years of involvement in rebuilding that country with our blood and money. In the process, we also lost face in the international community. This is our burden and we can't walk away without dire consequences that are probably worse than Saddam. What was it all for? I don't feel safer, I think its even worse now. Our troops are fighting a war that we cannot win. This is just as bad or worse than Vietnam.

GWB could not contain himself when it came to Saddam because he felt that his father did not finish the job. GWB was arrogant, impatient and extreme. Not good qualities for a leader. He couldn't look at the big picture. He misled the American people with the assertion of WMDs and links to Al-Qaida. His biggest mistake was alienating the international community and going to war without their support.

True, Saddam was awful and his sons were even worse and more of a threat than him one day; but there are countries that admittedly have nukes and leaders even worse than Saddam. If that was the criteria, why weren't we attacking them instead?

Our real enemy is Al-Qaida and we should be concentrating our efforts on that. They did attack us and Usama Bin Laden is still out there somewhere maybe. The fact that Usama was not caught and bought to justice, as GWB would put it, just shows Al-Qaida our weakness. If we had put the same effort into finding Usama as we did for Saddam we might actually have him. Instead he grows stronger, dead or alive.

Under GWB's leadership, we made a big mistake. I don't see anyone in Iraq handing out flowers to our soldiers thanking them for freeing them like GWB said they would. It is all a big fat lie. Our soldiers are unfortunately paying the highest price and it is just going to get worse for them. The only ones making out in Iraq are the Dick Cheney's and Halliburtons.

Our only hope in America is regime change. It is time for a new President with a different, more moderate approach. One that will concentrate on a more domestic agenda and on rebuilding the international relations that we lost.

Our economy is fragile at this point. Security is less than comforting. Jobs with a liveable income are almost non-existant and not just in the computer field. Our infrastructure is aging (remember the power outage of August 14, 2003)? Our healthcare system is beyond inadequate and too expensive for many to afford. What about the weather damage from all of the hurricanes that cost billions of dollars to repair. We need a President concerned with the problems of this country, first and foremost.

GWB appeals to those that are military minded. Might makes right. I don't know if John Kerry is up to the tasks at hand but I would take a chance. I'm not overly impressed by Kerry, but he does have a more moderate, domestic agenda. Flip-flop or not, I would vote for him so that we can have change. Who wants war, and more war?

One thing is for sure. Iraq is now free of Saddam, and they are going to have to fight for their freedom just like America did many years ago. Many people will suffer and die in the process. They will probably have a civil war and the outcome will be up to them. I hope they have the strength to hold onto the promise of freedom and democracy. The worst case scenario would be an Islamic fundamentalist government.

That part is not America's battle. Its up to the Iraqi people.

by hal 9000

This conflict is worse than Vietnam because in Nam the North Vietnamese wanted land namely South Vietnam but in this case the current insurgents don't want control of the land only kill as many as possible before being killed and they have far more to throw at us than we have to spare. Right here we are attempting to fight an idea which is exactly the same as attempting to grab a hand full of smoke it isn't possible and that is where the current leaders and their advisor's have gone astray as this is a different kind of war where land isn't an issue and they are unprepared for a conflict like this as it just has never happened in recorded history. They are unable to grapple with the case that controlling land isn't an issue but controlling peoples minds is and that is something that they are unprepared for.

Col

by hal 9000

There where a bunch of nations who where willing to get involved and we where told that Iran was developing Weapons of Mass Destruction. Well even if they where what where they going to do with them FedEx them to us? It is one thing to develop WMD but another thing to be able to deliver them where you want to hurt people Iran just lacked the ability even if they had the ability to make those weapons which it now appears they didn't.

Of course everything that has been said about Saddam Hussein was right but then again he did have a relatively peaceful country compared to what it is now once it has been liberated seems that a lot of people over there where very happy to be rid of Saddam and his political party but no they like us even less than the predecessor and it is something that we must fix {although I'm dammed if I know how} before we withdraw or things will be far worse than they where before we invaded in the first place.

Incidental have you noticed that North Korea who does have these weapons and a delivery system is no longer in the news? What is even worse is that while the Korean conflict has never been brought to an end only a "Cease Fire" we the Western countries are now looking like the weaklings that we actually are with out current inability to control poorly armed people in both Iran and Afghanistan from making anything but the major towns into no go areas for our relief workers and troops.

Currently North Korea is sitting back watching and seeing when it is in their best interests to act and when they do we will have one hell of a mess to try to clean up as they will drag other countries into the fray without them really wanting to be involved but at the same time they will not be in a position to do anything else.

China is a very good example currently the balance is keeping them from reclaiming Taiwan but if it was to appear to them that we where either unable or unwilling to prevent them from retaking that island they would jump at the chance if only for all the hard currency that it would bring into mainland China.

Col

by oz_media

Given the fact that Iran is KNOWN to be developing nuclear weapons, they are KNOWN to have direct ties with al-Qaeda and we KNOW they have WMD, and now we know that Iraq DOESN't have WMD OR ties to al-Qaeda; why is everyone in Iraq?
:)

by oz_media

okay I rephrased the popular KNOW your ENEMY, which has been proven and admitted that you don't.

You seem to be sitting on the surface and not understanding the point at all.
KNOWING your enemy is finding out WHAT motivates and fuels them. At THAT point you can begin to devise ways to thwart the actions. As it sits, you cannot fight an enemy you don't understand. The US war machine is understood by the world, as are most free countries in thier mission to protect thier lands.

When it comes to al-Qaeda, nobody had a clue what they are up against and are starting to slowly realize it.

"Know your Enemy" was taken from a Japanese propaganda film and has been a fact of war for most countires ever since. The strategic challenge is to use that knowledge to force him to fight on your own terms. It's even better if that fight on your terms is a fight he cannot refuse.

I said nothing about sending flowers to Aghanistan (where the Taliban terrorist regime who claimed responsibility for 9/11 originated).

Here's a question for you, if attacking the enemy (remember you don't even really know who you are up against yet)is a good resolution. How are the Taliban in Afghanistan and al-Qaeda
still in existence?

Not enough bombs?

What have you done to thwart thier growth in Eastern Europe? Never mind the middle east.

What have you done to thrwart their recruiting efforts in Africa?

Bin Laden managed to cause the US to start a crusade against Islam.

Al-Qaeda have shown thier ability to think like the enemy by paying for recruits now. Iraq is just the tip of that iceberg. They have responded to America's better intel and military might by adapting to the US pressure and organizing Sleeper Cells and seeking WMD far more agressively. While many of the former operatives were captured, this fuelled even greater interest in al-Qaeda and fighting the fight as they also had followers, and the next generation of al-Qaeda is predicted to be a much more formidable force than the last.

When the conflict in Afghanistan seemed to be nearig an end, nearly 500 al-Qaeda went on the offensive specifically linking the attacks to America's pending war in Baghdad, that's before you even changed focus.

It was said that with Saddam's demise, they would be finding some loose lips that would sing to the tune of al-Qaeda's plans.

Well al-QAEDA is forming a bigger regime than ever before, so I guess that theory's out the window.

Why? Not KNOWING the enemy, that's why. Bush has said many things since the invasion has been questioned, "we EXPECTED to find stockpiles of WMD but didn't", "There have been may adjustments needed to he US strategy in order to keep up with expectations." etc. ALL indicating a failure to KNOW YOUR ENEMY.

But if you want to send a bouquet to Osama's family, feel free to.

by aldanatech

I agree with you. It has been proven for a fact through history that the best way to defeat your enemy is to know you enemy.

by voldar

Know your enemy is first lesson you are learning when you start to study 'Martial Arts'...Sun Tzu was not great for nothing. Going back in history, the Roman Empire was the greatest empire ever, not because the emperors sent the army all over, but also had a very good diplomacy - DIVIDE ET IMPERA was the first rule, not INVADE AND IMPOSE...
- Coming back to what Oz said...I am agreeing with him + :
1. To know something about someone means to be capable to think like him...(not easy for Europeans or Americans)
2. Knowing someone very well, means you can prevent and be capable to react to his reactions in one 'combat situation'... ideally, but almost impossible - read 1.

So...the single things you can do:

- Increase your diplomatic skills and develop a good sense of understanding...things always have 2 faces (example: Kosovo? US was there to preserve the 'kosovo people right for life'...but the eastern Europe countries knew that was a war between Christians and Muslims... and trust me...nobody applauded the US)

- With a great power comes a greater responsibility! How about thinking first and shoot after...rather than shooting first and cleaning the mess after?

Best regards

by highlander718

I always liked guys strong in theory :-). "We should do this, we should do that". HOW should we do it, that's the question. What else should we know about terorrsits other than they are ruthless killers ? Their motives are clear, their ways are clear, what else do you guys want to find out ? Diplomacy ? With terrorists ? Are you kidding me ?

You believe the US did not think first (before shooting) ? I think they did, they just miscalculated the consequences.

by highlander718

OK, I hear this "know you enemy" theory for a long time now. What (else) do you expect to find though ? OK, what if you get to the bottom of it (very unlikely) and find out why the fundamentalists are doing what they're doing ?
Would you act differently ? Would you not fight them ? Would you fight them in a different way ? How ?

by hal 9000

You would never be able to stop the fundamentalists but by knowing your enemy you may just find yourself in a position of stopping people joining these groups so they become far more dangerous than they currently are.

Did you notice that the leaders of al-QAEDA and JI where not involved in the actual attacks they left that dirty work to others who they recruited now if we could stop the recruiting or financing of these people that would be a big step in the right direction.

What we need to do is make these fundamentalists impotent rather than making them stronger by doing exactly what they want us to do so they can increase their numbers and people willing to support them with money.

Col

by oz_media

Nobody has any idea, we don't understand thier mentality and goals.

THey understand US culture very well though.

So what do they do to play the US like pupets, behead soldiers, to them its normal, to us it's horrific. Unlike them, we cae about our soldiers and go to great ends to see them safe.

So how do you get what you want from the US? Harm soldiers.

It's like people jumping of a bridge for attention at rush hour, traic is held up for ages while cops talk people down. They are ONLY lookig for attention ad really have no intention of actually jumping, otherwise, they'd do it at night so as not to be seen.

So once the cops just let a few jump or even give them a push, not too many others will be in line to get thier day on the news.

They already figured this out regarding serial killers, that's why we see VERY little of serial murder on TV, many are motivated by the notoriety. not giving them notoriety takes thier chips away and they no longer dangle bodies for the news to see (well other than Michael Jackson I guess).

by hal 9000

That the Bin Laden Family is along with the Rothschild's {or however they spell their names} so al-QAEDA is given a legitimacy that it otherwise would not have as their claimed founder is allied to one of the richest families in Saudi Arabia so he is respected.

While not the typical free market entrepreneur he does give a legitimacy that otherwise would simply not exist for al-QAEDA to have started. Now that they have established such a reputation for themselves Bin Laden is no longer an issue as al-QAEDA has established itself as a force with the ability to out wit the Americans on their home ground, this fact alone makes it very easy for al-QAEDA to attract new members and the fact that they are now paying new recruits means that we in no way have put a dint on their finances and if anything these finances are now bigger than they previously where prior to 9 11.

Col

by oz_media

I know what you mant, I just didn't want 10 years to be seen as a log time, because from what I see, this will take much longer than MY lifetime to resolve, especially under the current administration.

A funny comment I read yesterday on another website was that a Republican would vote for a retarded mule if it had an R in front if it's name.

Well I guess that's been proven correct hasn't it?

by oz_media

I agree that this is an extreme action in the face of Western culture.

What we are seeing here again is the fact that we don't understand our enemy well enough to defeat it. I am not saying that the US needs to peacefully leave and apologize on the way out, but some form of global solution or realization is in order. Something other than the current resolution which has proven a failure overall in the effort to reduce threats of terrorism on the world.
As everyone knows and even a staunch Republican would agree, GWB is no world affairs guru. He knew VERY little and acted on even less, bad move. Now what can be done to resolve it other than just feeding more money and more bombs into a war with no end to be seen?

I think first and foremost people have to understand, that this is an expected and previously seen action of Iraqi's toward prisoners in order to get what they want.
They know it disgusts everyone, they know that it creates more controversy about the war (some will want it ended, others will want to retaliate with more war). This is to be expected, to say anything else is just ignorant.

America needs to get used ot this form of extreme revenge if the war is to continue, there needs to be some other solution found, on a global alliance scale, not a one on one fight for territorial victory.

SO yes, it IS absolutely ghastly, but it doesn't justify anything that's been done, this is what was to be expacted of them.

by jamesrl

Don't make a right.

No one here is suggesting for a moment that beheading is right or understandable or even comprehendable. It is barbaric and cruel, an act of people who have lost touch with humanity and decency. And by the way, more than just US citizens have been beheaded - are they less worthy of your attention?

That doesn't justify bending and breaking the rules in Guantanamo or in Abu Ghraib. The rules of law has been suspended. Its a slippery slope.

If you expect your citizens to be treated fairly around the world, then you treat others fairly. No doubt there are some evil people in both places, but also without doutb there are people there who are innocent. Without due process to determine which is which, you are saying its ok to detain people for an indeterminant length of time without legal recourse. This is what America criticised the Soviet Union for, this is what America criticises Cuba for.

James

by maxwell edison

.
you said, "No one here is suggesting for a moment that beheading is right or understandable or even comprehendable."

Oz did.

by dwdino

Remember WW2 Japan ...

An enemy who cannot be brought into diplomatic relations, is more willing to die than surrender, believes that compromise is worthless, uses non military entities to wage war, can only be defeated in one manor - absolute, resolute overpowerment.

Now with WW2 Japan, we had a unified entity which made targeting easier; but the same style must be applied.

Muk-Tattar-al-Sadder = Shot on sight
Known Terrorist Camps = Eliminated
Terrorist Backing / Supporters = Stripped of Assets

Like the movie "The Patriot", "I will order the shooting of officers out the outset of every engagement..." If we know that person X is doing job Y in Al-Queda, REMOVE HIM!!

by jamesrl

in WWII, and for good reasons. Once you start assasination of leaders, you put your own leaders at risk. That "Eye for an Eye" reasoning cuts both ways.

You also risk making them martyrs - that doesn't end the fighting sooner, it drags it on.

As for eliminating terror camps, this goes back before 9/11. Clinton targeted camps in Afghanistan and Sudan with cruise missiles, but it didn't result in any real damage. The same can be said with the war in Afghanistan after 9/11 - Al Qaeda melted away. I don't think anyone is suggesting that the camps not be hit - but don't think its a big win.

Stripping Al Qaeda of assets - go for it - but again, not as simple as you might think - its not like western business where a forensic accountant can follow the audit trail.

As for the Patriot, its anti-British sentiment lays it on a bit thick for me. As far as I have ever read, there were no incidents like the church burning with people inside during the American revolution. The incident on Boston common was similar to what happened at Kent State or Bloody Sunday in Belfast - poor military leadership and fear leading to troops firing on civilians. In fact many of the leaders of the American army had fought on the side of the British a few years earlier in the French and Indian wars, and there is some evidence to suggest there were "gentleman's agreements" on how to wage that war.

The way you suggest to wage war in Iraq is somewhat similar to what is happening in Israel with Hamas - has the assasination of the leadership created more or less suicide bombers?

James

by oz_media

1200 mosques in bosnia, destroyed.

Africa, wiped out.
America, bombed.
Canada, invaded.
Germany, attacked.
The UK, elminated.

Just think of a country and be prepared to fight it, including your own.

by highlander718

I'm afraid that bringing Kerry in, will maybe make the international community more cooperative, but in the mean time will set back the war on terrorism by following the international/european "softway". Which I think is not the good way.
Just a thought.

by hal 9000

We are supposed to be fighting a "War on Terrorism" but are clinging to old war ways by grabbing land.

What we are currently fighting is not a nation or group of nations but an idea spread by those with nothing to loose. Sure Saddam wasn't a very nice guy and he should have been deposed but at least he did control that country which we seem unable to do now.

Until some new means can be brought to beer on our current problems with groups like Alqueda and JI which are currently in the mist of galloping enlargements of participants we will lose. We need to find other ways of fighting the terrorists rather than trying to take away land that they are not interested in for any reason but by occupying that land we leave ourself vulnerable and overstretched to react to the real problem.

Col

by highlander718

sorry .... but WHAT OTHER WAYS ? Can we talk practical instead of theoretically nice solutions ? Can we talk on a concrete basis here ?

by hal 9000

Particularly because it is so close to the 9 11 anniversary but here goes.

The Age of Terror

Last week I was privileged to watch a series on the rise of Terror in Modern times. This was a four part series which began with the title of ?In the Name of Liberation? followed by ?In the Name of Revolution? which was followed by ?In the Name of God? and finally ?In the Name of the State..

Now every one of these shows was interesting and very well balanced in their presenting of the facts and how the ?Modern Terrorists? behaved and from that I do mean what they considered as ?Modern Terror? which was first recorded in 1947 with Jewish Settlers in Israeli using terror tactics on the Palestinians to get what they considered as an established State of Israeli and just how numerous Countries justified Terror Tactics in their Domestic and Foreign Policy decisions. Naturally the makers of this show didn?t promote themselves to a great extent and I was left wondering exactly where it was produced but it was fairly new as it covered the World Trade Center Attack ?although I don?t think there was anything newer? amongst other things and had people from all over the world so I was left wondering just where this series was produced. The best part about this entire series was that no convictions where passed on only a balanced reporting of events and their consequences. It charted the rise of what they called ?Modern Terrorism? and all the ill effects that have arisen from these actions.

It did however vividly show just why Israel is suffering its current problems and the new mix that was introduced to Terror Tactics with the advent of Religious Leaders lending support to the causes and how the use of suicide bombers had arisen which incidently was first used by the Jews and not as widely spoken on the current media reports by the Islamic peoples.
Actually according to this series the current crop of Islamic fundamentalist are only the last of the current crop of ?Modern Terrorists? to adopt these tactics.

But what this series do show was how the rise of terror related activities has always come back to hurt the instigators far more than those who where their original targets. Naturally enough the 4 episodes where divided up as their name suggests where the terror tactics where used to liberate people from oppression or like the second episode to overthrow an existing Government in the case shown Iran by ?People Power? under the leadership of a charismatic Religious Leader. The third series showed just how conventional Religions had become involved in these actions and finally how various States or Countries used Terror to gain their desired ends.

The finial episode was very telling as it covered just how a country had trained and supported various rebel leaders illegally without that countries political leaders full knowledge and how that country had in some cases ignored the fact that they where in fact unlawfully attacking foreign countries by limiting shipping into some ports and how this breach of International Law was accepted by those involved and put aside as justified even though the shipping that was attacked was only caring food stuffs and hurting the general population.

Unfortunately I didn?t record these shows but when I receive a response from the maker of this series I?ll place anything that they wish to add here.

Well the response has come through and it is simply that the tape will be far too expensive to place on public sale which came as a real shock since the company involved in in Brooklyn but they seem to only want to make money off these programs from the TV industry. However they are a MUST WATCH SERIES to begin to understand what is exactly going on with the current crop of terrorism.

Col.

by maxwell edison

.
(Note: For a full understanding of this message, FIRST READ, or read again, aldanatech's original message.)

aldanatech is going from bad to worse. The number of dead aldanatech messages is already passed a chilling number. More aldanatech points were killed by his own, silly, redundant, and inaccurate assertions in one day than everyone else's put together. Hundreds of former Kerry supporters are also dead - as they grow more tired of his silly rhetoric. aldanatech's major points, including lies, mistruths, fabrications, and contradictions are all under the control of like-minded insurgent Democrats. Where is this grim situation heading? Answer: An overwhelming George W. Bush victory, and a future "civil war" for the lost heart and soul of the once respectable Democrat Party. So the most likely future for John Kerry is to continue his insignificant time in the Senate, since he's never done anything of significance in the past, says a brand-new report from the regarded Maxwell Edison Institute of Domestic Affairs.

It is also a view shared by many American analysts. The Democrat Party in-fighting "civil war" scenario is as follows: One, the extreme radicals of the left gained breakaway self-righteous hope for rule in the 1990s and will not give up their autonomy easily. Democrat militants are planning to battle for control of the Democrat Party in hopes to acquire respectability in the future. Two, the Democrat minority that suffered humiliating defeat under President Clinton and his Democrat Party government, dominated by minority extremist liberals, do not want to suffer such humiliating defeat again. Three, the extremist liberals minority, in control of the Democrat Party for decades, like it that way. Extremist liberals now hold much of the Democrat Party , but common sense Americans will resist, and control will remain with the Republican majority.

by hal 9000

After all those responsible for 9-11 killed themselves didn't they?

Exactly who where you going to shoot ans "Ruthless Killers" when those responsible where already dead?

It is an unfortunate thing but it is perceived that the US has a tendency to shoot first and ask questions latter in this case it just doesn't work as when you have finished shooting you have created a far bigger mess than what you started with along with thousands of people who think that al-QAEDA and it's likes are a good thing to be involved with.

Since 9-11 there have been 3 major bombings in Indonesia about 1 a year all aimed at western interests the Madrid bombing and several others. Now if you can explain just how invading Iraq has prevented things like this from happening and caused the groups like al-QAEDA and JI to no longer exist I'm al ears. But it is my understanding that the invasion of Afghanistan and Iraq has actually increased the number of members of groups like this and in no way decreased the possibility of direct attacks leveled against us on our home ground.

If anything we now look weaker than we did prior to starting the current "War on Terror" and it is places like North Korea who we really should be scared of or at the very least treat them with caution rather than be in the position of showing them just how we are unable to control what we begin.

Col

by oz_media

They know and understand Western Culture and warfare very well. When our prisoners are captured, we go to immense lengths to seek thier freedom.

We are still shocked when they torture and behead thier captives. This is a display to show us in the west, how little they actually care about POW's.

In the case of the recent request for the women's release it isn't because they don't want women in prison, they couldn't care less. They just want female key weapons developers released from prison. Therefore how do they get at western culture? They behead a prisoner. NO big deal in thier books a massive deal in ours.

So if America and Americans feel so strongly about the need for this conflict and the need to have soldiers there, then be prepared to see this more and more. They know we want our prisoners back, if the USA stopped responding to such displays with shock, they wouldn't have any bargaining chips left.

Our soldiers, while willing to die for thier country, must be left to do so oin these situations, that's what they would do themselves and that's what they expect is happening in our POW prisons. I'm sure they get a MUCH diferent story projected than we do. We cannot play into thier game, the first and most important part of knowing an enemy is to have him play YOUR game on YOUR terms. Well this is EXACTLY what is hapening in Iraq. They have the US in the palm of thier hands and play it like a puppet.

If people want to see an end to the beheading, we mustn't respond to it, We must start by inferring that "these are brave soldiers and they are proud to die for thier country" just as any al-Qaeda terrorist would.

We need to change the action from Western war and adapt to a terrorists war, or else they will continue to play the US puppet theatre with the troops.

I know it sounds AWFUL for western civilization to start NOT caring about POW's, but that's thier game and they are using it against you, it will never end until it is ineffective.

Just ONE example of how we need to change the ideals we are based on in order to win a conflict, if that's still the focus and not just a never ending war in the middle east.

by oz_media

THat would be up to GWB and the other allied nations of the world to address, we as citizes have NO relevant information regarding ANY part of this conflict really.

To make any SOLID concrete solutions on our level is going to be hypothetical theory at best.
Just as most information posted here is.

by hal 9000

that Iran does have WMD or is it only from the same sources that claimed that Iraq had WMD's? What we do think we know is that Iran is developing enriched Uranium commonly known as U235 and they claim it is for power generation.

That is a fact everything else is a superstition which I might add we are partly responsible for by propping up the Shar of Iran for so long and in our our lilly livered way not allowing him to kill of Kemlami which would have prevented the overthrow of the Shar by a fanatical religious leader.

But even if Iraq does have the ability to produce WMD's {although I'm more of the opinion that they are not but could provide materials to produce "Dirty Bombs"} exactly how would they get them to where they want them to go bang? Bear in mind that for a Nuke to have maximum effect they must be detonated at about 4,000 feet of altitude above the existing ground. Granted a nuke denotation on mainland USA would have devastating moral effects but would only produce minor damage in relation to what was possible. However placing a few pounds of U235 around conventional explosives would be a totally different story and while it would have at first limited damage it would have some very serious long term effects that just do not bear thinking about.

Or something that would be even worse was an attack on a Nuke power station that severely damaged the cooling system and allowed the reactor mass to go critical. That would be far more serious than any dirty bomb that any group could provide and something that is not accounted for.

Or even a sustained attack upon the power distribution grid that didn't cause serious reactor damage but disrupted the power for a protracted period of time things like this just don't bear thinking about and from what I've seen of so called Security Measures we are unprepared for.

Col

by oz_media

The point was that we ae fightig a war in the wrong place for the wrong reasons.

YEs Saddam needed to be stoped, but given the face of the world, he was NOT the most important target at THAT time, even though the issue needed to be taken care of sooner or later. There was no need for a rushed effort, weapons inspectors were doing fine. If they were left to continue, they would have found what the US army did, nothing, and then proven that there was NO immediate or imminent threat that needed to be taken care of with several hundred billion dollars and 1000's more lives.

by hal 9000

Officially we are currently supposed to be in a peace keeping mode hence the reduction of "Battle Pay" to our troops.

Col

by hal 9000

Officially we are currently supposed to be in a peace keeping mode hence the reduction of "Battle Pay" to our troops.

Col

by hal 9000

Would be to cut off the funding which to date has proved impossible to perform. The reality of the position is while these fanatical fools have access to vast sums of money they can virtually do as they like and that is something that we must address.

Col

by oz_media

I at NO time suggested or implied that beheading is right or uderstandable.

What we aren't getting the point of is that they KNOW this is how to attack America. They couldn't give a damn about thier own POW's, they are allowed to die and ther families are proud that they have served al-QAEDA.

It's not right and NOT acceptable, as James has implied also, we need to get with the program. They KNOW we will go to any length to rescue a POW, they KNOW how riled westerners all get when they see pictures or video of citizens being beheaded.

NO it's not right, YES it is understandable, if it isn't then you need to begin undertstanding THIS IS HOW THEY FIGHT A WAR. It doesn't make it acceptable, it just IS.

So they are playing the US like puppets by having the US play into THIER game. First rule in knowing your enemy, is learning about him and how to get HIM to play by YOUR terms.

So they find out how America reacts to beheading (a normal punishment to them) and they use it to play you. They use it to get what they want, it is a ransom call.
When we respond as expected, WHY would they possibly change thier focus, they probably jump up and down and think of a new demand they can use beheading a prisoner for, perhaps a case of Budweiser for the next one.

The problem with western warfare intelligence is that we let them play a game. We need to be prepared to fight like terrorists and think like terrorists. We need to accept that thy are going to use POW's this way to get thier demands met, over and over again.

Once we see things on THIER level, we can begin to turn the table and have them play into OUR game, instead of the US playing thiers.

If the choice is to continue this fight and it is justified, then these men and women must be prepared for the type of consequences they may face. Once we stop responding with such shock and horror, the ransom value drops, they have nothing to go on and they will seek new ways to have demands met.

Surely a linear thinker such as yourself can see this as a reality.

NO I don't think it's RIGHT nor JUST, it is disgusting, it is ghastly, but this is the enemy that you have CHOSEN to face and supported faithfully for years, ineffectively.

by maxwell edison

.
In response to the initial "be-heading" message, Oz said:

".....first and foremost people have to understand, that this is an expected and previously seen action of Iraqi's toward prisoners in order to get what they want. They know it disgusts everyone, they know that it creates more controversy about the war....This is to be expected, to say anything else is just ignorant.....SO yes, it IS absolutely ghastly.......but this is what was to be expacted [sic] of them."

He said it just as stated above:

The full context of his message won't detract from what Oz said:

https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=8&threadID=159741&messageID=1652191

Someone else said, "No one here is suggesting for a moment that beheading is right or understandable or even comprehendible."

Oz Media understands it and can comprehend it. And Oz Media said it's ignorant to expect anything else.

Oz Media said, "people have to understand, that this is an expected.....this is what was to be expacted [sic]."

And now, for some weird reason, Oz is trying to reel in his very own words.

(Don't bother with a reply, Oz. I've stopped trying to figure out your twisted logic.)

by oz_media

If you BEGAN to make any sense it just might scare the hell out of me, so go easy.

I said it is understandable (meaning that we know terrorists act this way BECAUSE WE'VE SEEN IT ALREADY!!!!) but in the same breath montioned how it is ghastly.

At no time did I condone this as you are trying so hard to suggest. If that was my intent, you would be first on the block, but as we no longer get away with public beheadings in western culture, I am forced to just listen to your drone on and on whil trying so hard to twist every post or comment I make.
I'm flattered but not enough to find you amusing. Just look at the way Repubs say Kerry keeps flip flopping, whereas MOST of the insinuations are simply misunderstood, partial quotes or out of context.

Is there a qualifer that says ALL Republicans must derive something else from all messages other than the intent of it?

It must be 'accepted' and 'understood' that THIS IS WHAT IS GOING TO HAPPEN. (Noting that ACCEPT does not mean it's OKAY but we need to get over it and expect it, THIS IS WHAT THEY DO.)Were you expecting some other type of enemy or is it terorists that are the target, thus the name TERROR? Now you are imlpying TERROR should NOT be expected?

If you don't think so, just don't do anything about it and wait for the next beheading to happen. Perhaps after about 50 Americans are publicly beheaded you will begin to realize that THIS IS HOW THESE PEOPLE OPERATE AND WE MUST EXPECT AS MUCH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Based on the same conclusions, I can say that you think this is a one-off issue that won't be repeated and we just need to kill more of them to stop such artocities.

There is NOTHING in my post, even in your REPOST and unwaranted analogy of it, that implies that I CONDONE it or feel it is right, NOT A SINGLE WORD.

Understanding is NOT accepting.
Acepting is NOT agreeing with or condoning.

You speak to ME, then on a third party HE, just like that 'other guy' when he tries to get attention and prove himself clever.

What is it Max, you looking to have a discussion with me (ovbviously not by your closing comments)or make everyone believe that I condone beheading US soldiers? I think you are honsestly trying to make everyone think I condone beheading US soldiers and think they should all die, better get to work on that one Max.

You already said you are not interested in a discussion, just to have you opinion heard and not responded to.

EVERYTHING here has been clearly voiced based on some fact mixed in with personal views, conclusions and opinions, if you're looking to prove something, hit the schoolyard.

by highlander718

so you think it's notoriety ? Again the HOW question. How can you take that away from them ? You can't hide 9/11, you can't shut down Al-Jazeera, these are the news, US does not (thanks God) control the media in the whole world. We are not only talking serial killers here (although I seem to remember they are still very media covered (see Malvo), we are talking serial mass killers, bombers, terorrists.

by oz_media

I forgot that they weren't actually at war anymore. And here I am going on about terrorists ad radicles and nasty WMD. I have just been watching reruns of he conflict. When does the new season start?

Silly me!

by highlander718

well Oz, I agree with you on this one (the POW matter). I don't think there is a single soul going in there (Irak) not thinking of the worst could come. And yes I think it's a weakness being ready to pull out hundreds of troops or freeing hundreds of terrorist to free one POW, even civilian. I don't think anyone can force a civilian to go into Irak, am I wrong ?

by oz_media

That if we don't have any information on the war, which we don't other than what the media is allowed to tell us or what is in the best interests of advertising dollars, then we should just continue bombing ad movigowith the same blind focus as we have all along?

Because you can't think of anything better to do?

How about a summit of all the worlds alied countries ad getting this damn issue on the table. Reduce the cost and the burden to the USA, increase troops by masses, take intel to a whole new level of coopration, there are many things that can be done as a unified force.

The thing is, will GWB have the nads to at crow ad look for help at this point in his solo crusade?

As I've said ALL along, nevr iss off and spit on your allies. France and England are working together with Germany and others in order to share intelligence and prepare for an attck on western Europe.

the world is NOT against fighting terror as many would like to think, they are just seeking iother resolutions such as knowing and understanding enemies in order to defeat them, as opposed to thee "knees bent, running around" in Iraq.

by oz_media

As for serial killers, there are MANY diferent types of serial murderer, of the ones who kill for attention a GREAT deal of them are rarely recognized, when they are, the FBI usually blacks out any further reports as they jeopardize investigations. This is my hobby.

As for equating al-Qaeda to serial killers, that's not my intention. The comparisson is to show how we cannot use conventional methods to solve these issues, we are only playing into thier own game, this is the first sign of losing.

So NO I don't have all the answers, I also don't hold the intelligence that the White House supposedly has/should have. Other countris need to converge, this cannot and will not be solved one on one, it will take a global realization and combined effort. This was the original intent of the war on terrorism, before Bush ran off to fight Iraq despite everyone's reluctance to support him or go to war in Iraq.

Now with no end in sight, the scary reality of this mistake is becoming quite clear, the "what hae we got ourselves into" thought aer showing up.

No matter what you may believe, GWB did NOT plan things to go this way, in fact that's probably a large part of the issue, he DIDN'T plan properly.

Just as on D-Day, where the Americans were unprepared for thier assault due to poor planning. Engineers were sent whereas the rest of the forces were using modified tanks (funnies) to clear the road. The failure of the US to also use these methods, cost MAY lives due a great effort needed to try and move to thier objective.

The USA needs to understand, while it is a great and powerful nation, it cannot handle such issues alone. Well I think it MAY be easier for most to understand in the future anyway.

by onbliss

Well the thread originator said "hundreds of Iraqi civilians also dead". I read some of the posts in random and did not see anybody else talking about the dead Iraqis. If anybody did talk about it, my sincere appologies to you.

I read in one of the newspaper articles that the number of Iraqis dead was about 15,000.

I think an Iraqi life is as precious as any other human life. That's my thought.

Considering this, would somebody call the situation out of control if the American damages were far fewer than what it is now?

by oz_media

Nobody sems to care about how many the OTHER side loses when it comes to war.

They only see what has happened to themselves, it's common, it's to be expected.

Some people care, not a LOT of people but some.

It is to be xpected of anyone who has a son o daughter over there to simply see one vision, I don't know if that applies here or not though. :)

OM

by tbragsda

Its not just war. So many deaths seem more important than others in peoples minds. The death of a young beauty pageant keeps people obsessed for years, while other children die horrible deaths.

Its not just the liberal in me. WHY DON'T THESE PEOPLE CARE! Do you see the tears on the faces of the mothers and fathers? Both sides. Im not a Christian, but I seem to get better than they. "DO NOT KILL"

by onbliss

... one of the core reason to wage war was to liberate Iraqis from a cruel regime and seed Democracy and Freedom.

In that context the number of Iraqis dying should be part of the equation.

I do understand in times of war, our emotions get carried away and pride & nationalism come forefront. Nothing wrong. It's but natural.

To the relatives and friends of the deatd, on both sides, each death is horrifying and traumatic.

We should attach importance or price to Iraqis too. Lives of the dead Americans are equally precious, and hope my earlier post did not convey any disrepect to the dead Americans.

by hal 9000

That the insurgents are only too willing to kill citizens of Iraq to get their own way. They consider these deaths as collateral damage and the dead as martyrs to the cause.

What we have to begin to understand is that normal warfare doesn't apply here as our current enemy isn't interested in controlling land, wealth or anything else just kill as many as possible until the whole area explodes into Kaos. They are not interested in stability only driving us out of the area and then setting about causing as much pain as possible by inflicting as much harm as possible on us. If we where to withdraw today they wouldn't stop their actions they would continue. The fact that most of the Iraq population wants to get on with their lives is unimportant to these people that is why they are attacking anyone who is attempting to join the police force in Iraq.

What their eventual aim is to do is disrupt the country so much that it is unworkable and then out of desperation the masses will turn to joining them in an all out attempt to kill off our way of life.

Make no mistake we are the enemy and anyone who supports us falls into the same category. The current spate of kidnappings and killings are only continuing because they have been proven to work {for example Spain and the Philippines.} When it is shown that these actions do not affect us at all they will switch their attack to other areas but will not stop. Currently the main number of people being taken hostage and killed aren't even Westerners but fellow Muslims. What exactly does that tell you about these people and their ways of doing things?

Col

by onbliss

"What exactly does that tell you about these people and their ways of doing things?"

To put it mildly I would say they are terrorists, fanatics, morons...

Though I understand what you are saying, as there is truth in it, I fail to understand your post in terms of my post.

Don't you think that US should own some moral responsibilities for the Iraqis killed by the wretched rogues because US initiated the war? The fact that US started the war is beyond a shadow of doubt.

by highlander718

didn't the US tried that through ONU already ?
Are you suggesting to sit back and relax, then ?
Of course you idea of getting together and put the damn thing on the table is good, but is it viable in the light of the ONU experiment ? Do you think there would be total agreement among different countries with different interests, not to mention pride and stuff ?

I would be the first to applaud a peacefull solution, I just don't see it coming and I don't see another solution at the time being. I would love you or someone else to give me some hope in this direction. But so far just utopian theories.

by highlander718

yes there was poor planning. Yes The US cannot go by itself to solve this. All this said , what if no one wants to help ? What should we do ? Get out of Irak ? Just do nothing ?

by oz_media

the United States of America has formed Alliances with members of the former Allied army and even the Axis armies now. France, germany, Portugal, England, Spain etc. I didn't suggest having tea with al-QAEDA operatives.

Bush went against allied wishes to start this whole mess, they are still involbed elsewhere in the fight to try and stop such trrorist networks.

I believe many of these countries leaders will be together next week, is it not a good idea to start seeking a unified resolution?

by oz_media

You seem to think that the allied nations who decided they didn't want to invade Iraq based on suspicion, when inspectors were still working as demanded, that they would not be interested in seeking a wolrd resolution to such issues?

ON the flip side, these nations ARE the ones who want to sop terrorism as much as you do, they just didn't comply with GWB's threat of an impending attack from Saddam's WMD.

by is girl

I'm not sure we CAN fix the situation in Iraq, and even though Saddam was indeed an "evil doer" in the world, removing him from power may prove to be one of the biggest mistakes a US President ever made.

I don't believe that we can "win" this war because we no longer know what we are fighting for. True Democracy in that country means majority rule, which means Shite Rule. The Kurds won't stand for it and are already planning for civil war. They've already named their new country Kurdistan and already have the borders they will defend defined. The US has armed and backed them for a couple of decades since we abandoned them to Saddams vengance after Bush Sr's Gulf War and - when it comes down to it - the US will back them in civil war. The Kurds will separate from the Arab Shites and the remaining part of Iraq will become part of The Republic of Islam. With Iran Shite rule next door and this new Islamic Nation, a great Muslim power - with nuclear weapons - will emerge.

I have no idea what W was thinking was going to happen and am positive that he did not consult with anyone who is well versed in Middle Eastern politics because the situation he has created will ultimately be a much, much greater threat to the security of the US than Iraq has been to us since the first Gulf War.

I have even less idea why he thought going after Saddam after AlQuida attacked the US was the right thing to do. He's failed to capture BinLaden and fueled the fire of Islamic Extremism.

by oz_media

I am going to apologize in advance for this post as it pertains to your spelling and I am admittedly THE WORST typist on TR by FAR! I have seen non-English speaking people hen peck a comment better than I do as I just have the worst keyboard skills and little patience for proof reading.

But I haven't stopped smiling since you mentioned that they want a SHITE government instead of a democracy. Well in the western world, anything OTHER than a democracy is a SHITE government. LOL :D Yup, they want a SHITE government alright!

I know that you meant Shiite (I believe that's right, TWO I's) and it was a VERY simple typing error but the context it was used in couldn't be better!

So excuse me for pointing it out, it wasn't to laugh at your missed keystroke, but it went together SO well, I had to offer kudos!

Thanks for the smile,
OM :)

by aldanatech

Iraq and national security is a central issue in this campaign. We owe it to the American people to have a real debate about the choices President Bush has made and the choices John Kerry would make to fight and win the war on terror.

That means we must have a great honest national debate on Iraq. The president claims it is the centerpiece of his war on terror. In fact, Iraq was a profound diversion from that war and the battle against our greatest enemy, Osama bin Laden and the terrorists. Invading Iraq has created a crisis of historic proportions and, if we do not change course, there is the prospect of a war with no end in sight.

This month as you know, we passed a cruel milestone: more than 1,000 Americans lost in Iraq. Their sacrifice reminds us that Iraq remains, overwhelmingly, an American burden. Nearly 90% of the troops -- and nearly 90% of the casualties -- are American. Despite the president's claims, this is not a grand coalition.

Our troops have served with extraordinary bravery, skill and resolve. Their service humbles all of us. When Kerry speaks to their families he knows this: we owe them the truth about what we have asked them to do and what is still to be done.

In June, the president declared, "The Iraqi people have their country back." Just last week, he told us: "This country is headed toward democracy. Freedom is on the march."

Nevertheless, the administration's own official intelligence estimate, given to the president last July, tells a very different story.

According to press reports, the intelligence estimate totally contradicts what the president is saying to the American people.

So do the facts on the ground:

1. Security is deteriorating, for us and for the Iraqis.

2. 42 Americans died in Iraq in June -- the month before the handover. But 54 died in July -- 66 in August and already 54 halfway through September.

3. In addition, more than 1,100 Americans were wounded in August -- more than in any other month since the invasion.

4. We are fighting a growing insurgency in an ever-widening war-zone. In March, insurgents attacked our forces 700 times. In August, they attacked 2,700 times -- a 400% increase.

5. Falluja, Ramadi, Samarra, even parts of Baghdad -- are now "no go zones" -- breeding grounds for terrorists who are free to plot and launch attacks against our soldiers. The radical Shiite cleric, Muqtada al-Sadr, who is accused of complicity in the murder of Americans, holds more sway in the suburbs of Baghdad.

6. Violence against Iraqis from bombings to kidnappings to intimidation is on the rise.

7. Basic living conditions are also deteriorating.

8. Residents of Baghdad are suffering electricity blackouts lasting up to 14 hours a day.

9. Raw sewage fills the streets, rising above the hubcaps of our Humvees. Children wade through garbage on their way to school.

10. Unemployment is over 50%. Insurgents are able to find plenty of people willing to take $150 for tossing grenades at passing U.S. convoys.

Yes, there has been some progress, thanks to the extraordinary efforts of our soldiers and civilians in Iraq. Schools, shops and hospitals have been opened. In parts of Iraq, normalcy actually prevails.

However, most Iraqis have lost faith in our ability to deliver meaningful improvements to their lives. Therefore, they are sitting on the fence instead of siding with us against the insurgents.

That is the truth -- the truth that the commander in chief owes to our troops and the American people.

It is never easy to discuss what has gone wrong while our troops are in constant danger. Nevertheless, it is essential if we want to correct our course and do what is right for our troops instead of repeating the same mistakes over and over again.

Kerry knows this dilemma first-hand. After serving in war, he returned home to offer his own personal voice of dissent. He did so because he believed strongly that we owed it those risking their lives to speak truth to power. We still do.

As Kerry put it: "Saddam Hussein was a brutal dictator who deserves his own special place in hell. However, that was not, in itself, a reason to go to war. The satisfaction we take in his downfall does not hide this fact: we have traded a dictator for a chaos that has left America less secure."

The president has said that he "miscalculated" in Iraq and that it was a "catastrophic success." In fact, the president has made a series of catastrophic decisions from the beginning in Iraq. At every fork in the road, he has taken the wrong turn and led us in the wrong direction:

1. The first and most fundamental mistake was the president's failure to tell the truth to the American people.

2. He failed to tell the truth about the rationale for going to war. Moreover, he failed to tell the truth about the burden this war would impose on our soldiers and our citizens.

3. By one count, the president offered 23 different rationales for this war. If his purpose was to confuse and mislead the American people, he succeeded.

4. His two main rationales -- weapons of mass destruction and the Al Qaeda/September 11 connection -- have been proved false by the president's own weapons inspectors and by the 9/11 Commission. Just last week, Secretary of State Powell acknowledged the facts. Only Vice President Cheney still insists that the earth is flat.

The president also failed to level with the American people about what it would take to prevail in Iraq.

He did not tell us that well over 100,000 troops would be needed, for years, not months. He did not tell us that he would not take the time to assemble a broad and strong coalition of allies. He did not tell us that the cost would exceed $200 billion. He did not tell us that even after paying such a heavy price, success was far from assured.

And America will pay an even heavier price for the president's lack of candor.

At home, the American people are less likely to trust this administration if it needs to summon their support to meet real and pressing threats to our security.

Abroad, other countries will be reluctant to follow America when we seek to rally them against a common menace -- as they are today. Our credibility in the world has plummeted.

In the dark days of the Cuban Missile Crisis, President Kennedy sent former Secretary of State Dean Acheson to Europe to build support. Acheson explained the situation to French President de Gaulle. Then he offered to show him highly classified satellite photos, as proof. De Gaulle waved the photos away, saying: "The word of the president of the United States is good enough for me."

How many world leaders have that same trust in America's president, today?

This president's failure to tell the truth to us before the war has been exceeded by fundamental errors of judgment during and after the war.

The president now admits to "miscalculations" in Iraq.

That is one of the greatest understatements in recent American history. His were not the equivalent of accounting errors. They were colossal failures of judgment -- and judgment is what we look for in a president.

This is even more stunning because we are not talking about 20/20 hindsight. Before the war, before he chose to go to war, bi-partisan Congressional hearings... major outside studies... and even some in the administration itself... predicted virtually every problem we now face in Iraq.

This president was in denial. He hitched his wagon to the ideologues that surround him, filtering out those who disagreed, including leaders of his own party and the uniformed military. The result is a long litany of misjudgments with terrible consequences:

1. The administration told us we would be greeted as liberators. They were wrong.

2. They told us not to worry about looting or the sorry state of Iraq's infrastructure. They were wrong.

3. They told us we had enough troops to provide security and stability, defeat the insurgents, guard the borders and secure the arms depots. They were wrong.

4. They told us we could rely on exiles like Ahmed Chalabi to build political legitimacy. They were wrong.

5. They told us we would quickly restore an Iraqi civil service to run the country and a police force and army to secure it. They were wrong.

In Iraq, this administration has consistently over-promised and under-performed. This policy has been plagued by a lack of planning, an absence of candor, arrogance and outright incompetence. Moreover, the president has held no one accountable, including himself.

In fact, the only officials who lost their jobs over Iraq were the ones who told the truth.

General Shinseki said it would take several hundred thousand troops to secure Iraq. He was retired. Economic adviser Larry Lindsey said that Iraq would cost as much as $200 billion. He was fired. After the successful entry into Baghdad, George Bush was offered help from the UN -- and he rejected it. He even prohibited any nation from participating in reconstruction efforts that was not part of the original coalition -- pushing reluctant countries even farther away. As we continue to fight this war almost alone, it is hard to estimate how costly that arrogant decision was. Can anyone seriously say this president has handled Iraq in a way that makes us stronger in the war on terrorism?

By any measure, the answer is no. Nuclear dangers have mounted across the globe. The international terrorist club has expanded. Radicalism in the Middle East is on the rise. We have divided our friends and united our enemies. Moreover, our standing in the world is at an all time low.

Think about it for a minute. Consider where we were... and where we are. After the events of September 11, we had an opportunity to bring our country and the world together in the struggle against the terrorists. On September 12, headlines in newspapers abroad declared, "we are all Americans now." However, through his policy in Iraq, the president squandered that moment and rather than isolating the terrorists, left America isolated from the world.

We now know that Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction and posed no imminent threat to our security. It had not, as the vice president claimed, "reconstituted nuclear weapons."

The president's policy in Iraq took our attention and resources away from other, more serious threats to America.

Threats like North Korea, which actually has weapons of mass destruction, including a nuclear arsenal, and is building more under this president's watch -- the emerging nuclear danger from Iran -- the tons and kilotons of unsecured chemical and nuclear weapons in Russia -- and the increasing instability in Afghanistan.

Today, warlords again control much of that country, the Taliban is regrouping, opium production is at an all time high and the Al Qaeda leadership still plots and plans, not only there but also in 60 other nations. Instead of using U.S. forces, we relied on the warlords to capture Osama bin Laden when he was cornered in the mountains. He slipped away. We then diverted our focus and forces from the hunt for those responsible for September 11 in order invade Iraq.

We know Iraq played no part in September 11 and had no operational ties to Al Qaeda.

The president's policy in Iraq precipitated the very problem he said he was trying to prevent. Secretary of State Powell admits that Iraq was not a magnet for international terrorists before the war. Now it is, and they are operating against our troops. Iraq is becoming a sanctuary for a new generation of terrorists who someday could hit the United States.

We know that while Iraq was a source of friction, it was not previously a source of serious disagreement with our allies in Europe and countries in the Muslim world.

The president's policy in Iraq divided our oldest alliance and sent our standing in the Muslim world into free fall. Three years after 9/11, even in many moderate Muslim countries like Jordan, Morocco, and Turkey, Osama bin Laden is more popular than the United States of America.

Lets put it plainly: The president's policy in Iraq has not strengthened our national security. It has weakened it.

Two years ago, Congress was right to give the president the authority to use force to hold Saddam Hussein accountable. This president, any president would have needed the threat of force to act effectively. This president misused that authority.

The power entrusted to the president gave him a strong hand to play in the international community. The idea was simple. We would get the weapons inspectors back in to verify whether or not Iraq had weapons of mass destruction. In addition, we would convince the world to speak with one voice to Saddam: disarm or be disarmed.

A month before the war, President Bush told the nation: "If we have to act, we will take every precaution that is possible. We will plan carefully. We will act with the full power of the United States military. We will act with allies at our side and we will prevail." He said that military action was not "unavoidable."

Instead, the president rushed to war without letting the weapons inspectors finish their work. He went without a broad and deep coalition of allies. He acted without making sure our troops had enough body armor. Moreover, he plunged ahead without understanding or preparing for the consequences of the post-war. None of which Kerry would have done.

Yet today, President Bush tells us that he would do everything all over again, the same way. How can he possibly be serious? Is he really saying that if we knew there were no imminent threat, no weapons of mass destruction, no ties to Al Qaeda, the United States should have invaded Iraq? My answer is no -- because a commander in chief's first responsibility is to make a wise and responsible decision to keep America safe.

Now the president, in looking for a new reason, tries to hang his hat on the "capability" to acquire weapons. However, that was not the reason given to the nation; it was not the reason Congress voted on; it is not a reason, it is an excuse. Thirty-five to forty countries have greater capability to build a nuclear bomb than Iraq did in 2003. Is Bush saying we should invade them?

Kerry would have concentrated our power and resources on defeating global terrorism and capturing or killing Osama bin Laden. He would have tightened the noose and continued to pressure and isolate Saddam Hussein -- who was weak and getting weaker -- so that he would pose no threat to the region or America.

The president's insistence that he would do the same thing all over again in Iraq is a clear warning for the future. Moreover, it makes the choice in this election clear: more of the same with President Bush or a new direction that makes our troops and America safer. It is time, finally, to ask the questions and insist on the answers from the commander in chief about his serious misjudgments and what they tell us about his administration and the president himself. If George W. Bush is re-elected, he will cling to the same failed policies in Iraq -- and he will repeat, somewhere else, the same reckless mistakes that have made America less secure than we can or should be.

In Iraq, we have a mess on our hands. However, we cannot throw up our hands. We cannot afford to see Iraq become a permanent source of terror that will endanger America's security for years to come.

All across this country people ask what we should do now. Every step of the way, from the time Kerry first spoke about this in the Senate, he has set out specific recommendations about how we should and should not proceed. However, over and over, when this administration has been presented with a reasonable alternative, they have rejected it and gone their own way. This is stubborn incompetence.

Five months ago, in Fulton, Missouri, Kerry said that the president was close to his last chance to get it right. Every day, this president makes it more difficult to deal with Iraq -- harder than it was five months ago, harder than it was a year ago. It is time to recognize what is -- and what is not -- happening in Iraq today. And we must act with urgency.

Just this weekend, a leading Republican, Chuck Hagel, said we are "in deep trouble in Iraq ... it doesn't add up ... to a pretty picture [and] ... we're going to have to look at a recalibration of our policy." Republican leaders like Dick Lugar and John McCain have offered similar assessments.

We need to turn the page and make a fresh start in Iraq:

First, the president has to get the promised international support so our men and women in uniform do not have to go it alone. It is late; the president must respond by moving this week to gain and regain international support.

Last spring, after too many months of resistance and delay, the president finally went back to the U.N., which passed Resolution 1546. It was the right thing to do -- but it was late.

That resolution calls on U.N. members to help in Iraq by providing troops, trainers for Iraq's security forces, a special brigade to protect the U.N. mission, more financial assistance, and real debt relief.

Three months later, not a single country has answered that call. In addition, the president acts as if it does not matter.

Moreover, of the $13 billion previously pledged to Iraq by other countries, only $1.2 billion has been delivered.

The president should convene a summit meeting of the world's major powers and Iraq's neighbors, this week, in New York, where many leaders will attend the U.N. General Assembly. He should insist that they make good on that U.N. resolution. He should offer potential troop contributors specific, but critical roles, in training Iraqi security personnel and securing Iraq's borders. He should give other countries a stake in Iraq's future by encouraging them to help develop Iraq's oil resources and by letting them bid on contracts instead of locking them out of the reconstruction process.

This will be difficult. Kerry and others have repeatedly recommended this from the very beginning. Delay has made only made it harder. After insulting allies and shredding alliances, this president may not have the trust and confidence to bring others to our side in Iraq. However, we cannot hope to succeed unless we rebuild and lead strong alliances so that other nations share the burden with us. That is the only way to succeed.

Second, the president must get "serious" about training Iraqi security forces.

Last February, Secretary Rumsfeld claimed that more than 210,000 Iraqis were in uniform. Two weeks ago, he admitted that claim was exaggerated by more than 50 percent. Iraq, he said, now has 95,000 trained security forces.

But guess what? Neither number bears any relationship to the truth. For example, just 5,000 Iraqi soldiers have been fully trained, by the administration's own minimal standards. And of the 35,000 police now in uniform, not one has completed a 24-week field-training program. Is it any wonder that Iraqi security forces cannot stop the insurgency or provide basic law and order?

The president should urgently expand the security forces training program inside and outside Iraq. He should strengthen the vetting of recruits, double classroom training time, and require follow-on field training. He should recruit thousands of qualified trainers from our allies, especially those who have no troops in Iraq. He should press our NATO allies to open training centers in their countries. Moreover, he should stop misleading the American people with phony, inflated numbers.

Third, the president must carry out a reconstruction plan that finally brings tangible benefits to the Iraqi people.

Last week, the administration admitted that its plan was a failure when it asked Congress for permission to radically revise spending priorities in Iraq. It took 17 months for them to understand that security is a priority, 17 months to figure out that boosting oil production is critical, 17 months to conclude that an Iraqi with a job is less likely to shoot at our soldiers.

One year ago, the administration asked for and received $18 billion to help the Iraqis and relieve the conditions that contribute to the insurgency. Today, less than a $1 billion of those funds have actually been spent. Kerry said at the time that we had to rethink our policies and set standards of accountability. Now we are paying the price.

Now, the president should look at the whole reconstruction package, draw up a list of high visibility, quick impact projects, and cut through the red tape. He should use more Iraqi contractors and workers, instead of big corporations like Halliburton. He should stop paying companies under investigation for fraud or corruption. And he should fire the civilians in the Pentagon responsible for mismanaging the reconstruction effort.

Fourth, the president must take immediate, urgent, essential steps to guarantee the promised elections can be held next year.

Credible elections are key to producing an Iraqi government that enjoys the support of the Iraqi people and an assembly to write a Constitution that yields a viable power sharing arrangement.

Because Iraqis have no experience holding free and fair elections, the president agreed six months ago that the U.N. must play a central role. Yet today, just four months before Iraqis are supposed to go to the polls, the U.N. Secretary General and administration officials themselves say the elections are in grave doubt. Because the security situation is so bad and because not a single country has offered troops to protect the U.N. elections mission, the U.N. has less than 25 percent of the staff it needs in Iraq to get the job done.

The president should recruit troops from our friends and allies for a U.N. protection force. This will not be easy. But even countries that refused to put boots on the ground in Iraq should still help protect the U.N. We should also intensify the training of Iraqis to manage and guard the polling places that need to be opened. Otherwise, U.S forces would end up bearing those burdens alone.

If the president would move in this direction, if he would bring in more help from other countries to provide resources and forces, train the Iraqis to provide their own security, develop a reconstruction plan that brings real benefits to the Iraqi people, and take the steps necessary to hold credible elections next year -- we could begin to withdraw U.S. forces starting next summer and realistically aim to bring all our troops home within the next four years.

This is what has to be done. This is what Kerry would do as president today. But we cannot afford to wait until January. President Bush owes it to the American people to tell the truth and put Iraq on the right track. Even more, he owes it to our troops and their families, whose sacrifice is a testament to the best of America.

The principles that should guide American policy in Iraq now and in the future are clear: We must make Iraq the world's responsibility, because the world has a stake in the outcome and others should share the burden. We must effectively train Iraqis, because they should be responsible for their own security. We must move forward with reconstruction, because that is essential to stop the spread of terror. And we must help Iraqis achieve a viable government, because it is up to them to run their own country. That is the right way to get the job done and bring our troops home.

On May 1 of last year, Bush stood in front of a now infamous banner that read "Mission Accomplished." He declared to the American people: "In the battle of Iraq, the United States and our allies have prevailed." In fact, the worst part of the war was just beginning, with the greatest number of American casualties still to come. The president misled, miscalculated, and mismanaged every aspect of this undertaking and he has made the achievement of our objective -- a stable Iraq, secure within its borders, with a representative government, harder to achieve.

In Iraq, this administration's record is filled with bad predictions, inaccurate cost estimates, deceptive statements and errors of judgment of historic proportions.

At every critical juncture in Iraq, and in the war on terrorism, the president has made the wrong choice. I have a plan to make America stronger.

The president often says that in a post 9/11 world, we cannot hesitate to act. Kerry agrees. Nevertheless, we should not act just for the sake of acting. He believes we have to act wisely and responsibly.

George Bush has no strategy for Iraq. John Kerry does.

Bush has not told the truth to the American people about why we went to war and how the war is going. Kerry has and he will continue to do so.

He believes the invasion of Iraq has made us less secure and weaker in the war against terrorism. Kerry has a plan to fight a smarter, more effective war on terror -- and make us safer.

Today, because of Bush's policy in Iraq, the world is a more dangerous place for America and Americans.

If you share his conviction that we cannot go on as we are that we can make America stronger and safer than it is then November 2 is your chance to speak and to be heard. It is not a question of staying the course, but of changing the course.

Kerry is convinced that with the right leadership, we can create a fresh start and move more effectively to accomplish our goals. Our troops have served with extraordinary courage and commitment. For their sake, and America's sake, we must get this right. We must do everything in our power to complete the mission and make America stronger at home and respected again in the world.

by olprof67

Let me state first of all that this post is not an attack upon Islam itself; but the fact remains, as demonstrated on 9/11/01, as recently demonstrated in Russia, and as repeatedly demonstrated in Israel, Islamic militancy is as great a threat to the continued development of civilization as were Hitler and Marx.

They just don't get it; you can't reason with them, because their core values are at odds with another, far better system which has been slowly developing in a handful of nations for the past two centuries, and which is showing signs of flowering in many more. None of the members within that group has since taken up the sword against another member.

Unfortunately, while the spectre of total, global nuclear conflict has been averted for the near future, the worst of the madmen have gained acces to a rapidly-growing potential for terror.

History may well regard the Iraqi incursion as a mistake. But the second President Bush, like the first, may be villified largely because the more simplistic of his core constituency simply expected too much.

And rogue, criminal nations are still among us; criminals require a strong police action. The list of nations hated by Islamic fundamentalists is long, - The United States, Great Britain, Russia, India, Israel. Taken together, they have far greater power, and not all of them are cabable of as much restraint. A number of third world nations (The Philippines and Nigeria, to cite only two) have suffered similar indignities.

The only hope for defusing this powder keg is a serious attempt at reform within the Islamic community itself. But are we naive enough to believe that a culture which subjugates its own women is cabable of respecting other value systems?

In the twisted logic of fundamentalist Islam, the enemy of my enemy is my friend. Sooner or later, this will likely bring a terrible retribution upon them, and it will be difficult for some of us not to stand up and cheer (just as on 9/11/01, the rabble in East Jerusalem cheered the murder of thousands of the finest from many nations whose only crime was a superior work ethic).

Kerry, if you don't have the guts to tell Arafat he's got it coming just as much as bin Laden, stay in Massachusetts where you belong!

by garion11

Completely agree, as I said before this war in Iraq (part of war on terrorism) is the one of the most important wars in the history of humanity. Its a clash of cultures and civilizations and ultimately it will be up to the culture of Islam to either join the 21st century or die.

by hal 9000

And in no way wish to become involved in them. But to you I have to point this out there once was a terror organization called the IRA {Irish Republican Army} you may have heard of them! They still officially exist though they are no longer active and now have their own political wing with their own Representatives in the British Parliament.

The Irish problem wasn't overcome by firring more bullets and bombing more towns it was finally solved by talking getting down in the mud and the blood and TALKING! Now days the IRA is no longer considered a threat but at one time all of London was under constant fear of being bombed by the IRA. The Irish problem certainly was not overcome by putting tags on people and then deciding that everyone from that religion was responsible. Currently I think we are at a crossroad and we must be very careful in which way we decide to turn.

GWB is an Evangelical Christian and speaks like one which is hardly a good sign to the rest of the world with his constant speeches of having God on his side the others say exactly the same thing.

Now what we have to prevent at all costs is starting a new crusade on Islam after all Rome tried this all those years ago and failed surely we must at the very least have to take some notice of history and not make the same mistakes as where made by others in the past.

Col

by hereinoz

Oz did say that it was comprehendable, and understandable - any one with an understanding of cultures around the world would be able to understand the reasons for beheading, and would be able to comprehend it.

However, understanding an act and comprehending its reason and effects, does not necessarily mean that we agree with it.

Oz never implied or stated that he believed it was right. He may have implied that they (the beheaders) might think it is right, and I understand that they probably do, and being a thinking person, you probably understand that they think it is fine, but that does not mean that you think it is fine too.

Hope this makes it clear for you.

Alan

by maxwell edison

.
Exactly - no more, no less. Except Oz challenged what I said, but I will venture to guess he will not challenge you.

If my logic is twisted, why isn't yours?

Go back and read the whole flow of what was said and by whom. You will indeed see that you and I said exactly the same thing.

by oz_media

Sorry Max you are MAINLY right, I did say it is to be expected or understood.

I did not say it was 'RIGHT'. THat word just threw me for a loop and I just couldn't see where I had said it was right, in fact I knew it was a touchy subject and was VERY clear to say it is ghastly etc. I do not think it is right, I do think it must be expected from such an enemy, this isn't a conventional war in moral terms.

So I do take back my argument, but you should also accept and understand that I in NO way say this is right or acceptable in anyway. Just that this is the weakness they are using to thier benefit, they KNOW you will go to great lengths to free prisoners of war, thus it is a great bargaining chip on thier half. Once the US stops playing into thier hand (as horrific as it sounds to let people die) they will lode the ability to use your POW's against you.

But again, I did NOT say 'I think it is right, expected and understandable'

It NEEDS to be expected, it NEEDS to be understandable.

I don't think that was James' point either, I think he was referring to the same thing I am in that NOBODY thinks it's okay or acceptable, but I think he would agree it must be expected of them.

PLus I am sure your intent was to single me out as a bad guy by implying that I think it's right.

Stirring the pot shall we say.

by voldar

the real question here is how you can stop religious fanatics to stop acting like Kamikatze!!!!...The rest is just simple guerila war...In theory, as one person said...I am good, so...lets go in theory:

- the kamikatze spirit is applying here on a muslim root...and you cant stop someone who think and live with the idea that killing enemies (no matter how, even with the price of his life) will send him directly to heaven (or on the right side of Mohamed)...so..forget about trying to change something here...u cant change thousands of years of religion.
SINGLE way to avoid this is to change ur image (enemie) ...using DIPLOMACY...stupid word for some but...not in my theory.

- just a dream...imagine what will be a world where the oil is no longer the power!!!...Imagine if water (ionic engine, hidrogen engine etc) will be all over, same for all nonconvetional resources...Imagine how will be that world..in which a galon of water cost 10 times than now... and the oil is no longer good. In my dream, who can become nightmare for some...maybe is the answer to this 'how can you fight with something non-understandable from point of view european-american.
But is just a dream!...so...maybe in theory is good but in real life ...

best regards

by voldar

if you are maybe right about my mistake, "You believe the US did not think first (before shooting)?", than, let me tell you that the miscalculation they made is huge. Remember about the 24 hours war, which grew every day up to a month, than again ...

Anyway, I am not here to say and blame that "that one did that, this one did this", but I think it is time to see our mistakes, and start to learn from them, if not, the history is cyclic, we might be forced to learn again the same lesson, to pass the exam.
I agree with the fact that I have "the right" to make mistakes, but I don't understand to make the same mistake more than once. No one is clairvoyant to foretell the future, but, to prevent some erratic behavior, by using common sense, is a must!!

I will also say that when I heard that US had enough of being a target for terrorists, I was pleased and supporting it (at least in my thoughts ;D) ?finally someone stood up and got out of the shell looking after the terrorists?, but when I saw that what was claimed to be quick, is becoming something like "eternity", something, I thought, is wrong with the preparations, and I start to think that maybe this war against terrorism was very "mediated", but less prepared.
I don't know, maybe because of too many movies where the positive character always wins, made me think this is the case with this campaign, but, as life very often proved, it is not the good who wins, but the bad. Hopefully, at the end, the good guy will win!

And now, to settle once for all the good and bad: what is good for ones is bad for others, and vice versa. Arabic people are pride, and they like that no one interfere with their own way of living, unless they have something to gain.
Remember Rambo book? The colonel said to the policeman who was chasing Rambo "if you'd let him go his way, in a month you'd found him in a town, working like anyone else, and you'd be able at that time to arrest him, with no problems. Now, after what you did, ?you brought your war into your city". And I fear that this is exactly what is happening right now. When I said that it is better to know your enemy behavior before going to chase him, I also meant to know its history as well, his habits, and to act in consequence.
I only hope that in a way or other things will have a good turn. I also think that democracy as the West understands to be is not the perfect fit piece in the Arabic puzzle. For God sake, they are living in tribal kind communities, with their fears and enemies, with their pride and their customs, and West democracy just don't fit in. They have the right to choose, let them choose (and I talk about peoples, not terrorists).
Why do you think Al-Queda and any other terrorist groups receive such a support from different type of people? Not because they are better, but because they speculate every failure point that the West has shown, especially US in the last "war", and they hide their own hideous face under this smog-wall that unfortunately we so often tend to gave it reasons to grow in weight and scale. Let?s stop that and show their real face to the world! Let?s act as much responsible as we all are, and we will bit the beast.

And to conclude, there is no war between two religions, as many of Al-Queda often claims, but a war against butchers, terrorists, sick people, but if the butcher is dead, who will take over the role?

by maxwell edison

.
I never said, or suggested, or implied that you said it was right. I said what I said, and that's all that I said - no more no less. (And almost all of my message was just repeating someone else's quote.) As to my intent behind the message, you can speculate all you want. But, as you obviously showed, you jumped to your desired conclusion and twisted my words to suit your own desired outcome - which was to find a reason to attack me.

It just goes to show how you, and other like-minded people, take something and misread it, misinterpret it, stretch and skew it in whichever way necessary to come up with a total lie of your own just for the sake of attacking people.

You and your Australian buddy - and the blind-followers of John Kerry - all do the exact same thing. You come up with a lie so you can justify calling the other guy a liar - the true essence of disingenuous.

by dwdino

This news is actually 2000 years old:

Matthew 24:6-7

"Jesus answered and said to them . . .
'And you will hear of wars and rumors of wars.
See that you are not troubled;
for all these things must come to pass,
but the end is not yet. [Still before the Rapture and the 'Apocalypse']
For nation [ethnic group] will rise against nation [ethnic group],
and kingdom [country] against kingdom [country] . . .
All these are the beginning of sorrows [actual translation is "birth pangs"]
[As with "birth pangs" they will grow closer]

So Israel/Palestine, Iraq, etc. are simply the fulfillment of prophecy.

by hal 9000

Firstly you have to investigate these groups and find out what their demographics are and who they appeal to. You then have to attempt to make them less appealing to this group by either better education or standard of living.

Treat the terrorist groups like a market audience for lets say a TV show and act accordingly but instead of attempting to increase their market appeal what we should be doing is make joining these groups less appealing.

What is certain is that our current actions are not having this effect so where are we going wrong?

Col

by garion11

The ideology that embraces death will never be accepted by me (if you want to by all means be my guest).

But as a Buddhist I know you never would. You are a Buddhist no? The problem isn't us, its them.

They will never accept our ideology (their actions proove otherwise) and yet we tolerated them for this long. What does that tell you who is correct morally?

by hal 9000

I was taught by a monk for many years and still follow their teachings today. And you are wrong the moderate Islamic people aren't the slightest bit interested in fighting with us only getting on with their lives as they are it is the fanatical ones who are the problems as always but then again that isn't limited the the Muslims either is it?

Christians, Hindus and many others have been guilty of this belief from time to time but always it has passed. Currently conditions are right for these pressure groups to expand in Islam but by your reasoning the same could have been said about Catholics in the middle if the "Troubles" in Ireland as well. It is wrong to condemn a whole religion just because a few don't follow their teachings they way they where meant to be followed but chose to twist them to suit their own ends.

Col

by oz_media

And I thought that being forward and honetly admitting a mistake would be res[pectable enough for you to simply stop flaming every post made.

I supose that's WHY people just flame your comments and don't try to offer reason.

No wyou did suggest that you didn't say I said it was right.

YOu quoted another post that said: ""No one here is suggesting for a moment that beheading is right or understandable or even comprehendable."

Your title reads" Oz is indeed suggesting such a thing"

This means in black and white, NOT shades of grey, that I uggested beheading is right or understandable or even comprehendable"

I agree that YES, I do think it MUST be understood and it is expected.

I didn't say it was right OR comprehendable.

So who has taken to TWISTING words?

Let me guess, all non-Republican TR members.

You rebutted a statement by twisting what I had said.

I misread YOUR statement and when you pointed it out I agreed and apologized for my oversight.

You misread my statement and tried to use it to make a point. No apology, no explanation that I only said SOEM of what you imply or anything.

So while YOU go around spouting off about how everyone takes comments out of context, how everyone MUST be rigght and how I'm a know it all, you have done exctly that.

You are a man of faith, practice what you preach.

by oz_media

I was in London when they bombed the queens guard on parade. Seeing men, women and horses die from such a disgusting and cowardly measure will never leave my sight.

There is no excuse. So did Englad invade Ireland? No. After COUNTLESS years of terrorist fears, it was resolved VERY peacefully as you suggested, DIPLOMACY at it's best.

I have been to Ireland a few times as the REAL Oz, was raised there (now lives in England). It is one of the most beautiful places you could ever hope to visit. The people are AMAZINGLY kind and welcoming, they REALLY are a delight to be aroud, to meet, to tip a few with etc. What kind and peacful people. I really can't say enough about them as I am quite indebted to them for extending hospitality well beyond what anyone would expect.

Muslims are also this way by nature, they are not all raised as terrorists.

Bombs haven't stopped terrorism yet, diplomatic resolutions HAVE. It's not brain surgery, it's humanity.

So before everyone goes off on some wild tangent, I think it will take a LOT more than a simple "Ooops, sorry mate, we'll go home now"
but I feel that a diplomatic solution is in order or must at least be tried again.

'We tried diplomacy for 12 years and where did it get us!?'

NO, you were on thier side, against thier side, on thier enemies side, against thier enemies side.

This isn't a diplomatic reolution.

by maxwell edison

.
You qualified it, which wasn't necessary, and you even went on to suggest that I erred in some way, which I didn't. If you would have simply said that you made a mistake and left it at that, I wouldn't have posted a reply at all.

Never ruin an apology with an excuse. It waters it down and makes it meaningless.

by highlander718

First, I think we have a pretty good picture on what their demographics are. Second, it is obviously a good idea to "educate" them, I'm afraid that's exactly what they do not want (I mean educating them in western standards, western values ...etc.) So HOW you go about it ?
Putting terrorists in a bad light ? Well, aren't they doing this with tremendous success already ? Unfortunatelly, I believe the only way you put these terorists in a "bad light" is by catching/killing them.

by highlander718

Well Oz,
I just don't see those countries doing much about fighting terrorism that's all. Meetings and declarations won't help.

by oz_media

Germany: "...on November 16, 2001 mandated deployment of German troops abroad specifically to fight terrorism. Troops were sent to Afghanistan in response to this decision. The mandate would not cover any potential military action aimed against Iraq. "
http://www.aicgs.org/c/pressrelease.shtml

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Well we ALL know the UK went to Iraq, they uncovered the mass graves.
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
FRANCE: Well I had to laugh while digging at this one. Actually even GWB says that France is a valued ally of America. They have been pretty tied up over recent years with the whole Libian affair but are still suporting the US in Haiti as well sa thier participation in Afghanistan, they as many others also said, were not prepaed to invade Iraq given the evidence put forth, or lack thereof.

But here's a little laugh to prove they REALLY are fighting terrorism.

'"Pierre" was fined $615 (I'd guess 600 Euros?) for attempting to run over a pedestrian he thought was Osama bin Laden.' :D Thuis is an actuial news report from France, th epicture shows a guy (jacket over head) being escorted to a polirce car.

"Now I don't care WHO you are, that there is FUNNY!" Larry 'The Cable Guy'
+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
SPAIN:
""The Bush administration's clumsy diplomacy and its critics' hyperbolic charges of 'unilateralism' sometimes obscure the fact that the United States has had true and valuable allies in the war on terrorism. Thursday one of the best of those, Spain, suffered a blow as shocking and as terrible as any the enemy has landed since Sept. 11, 2001. . . . The horror of Madrid only confirms that a broad and determined alliance is the only answer to terrorism. It reminds us that the United States neither fights, nor suffers, alone."

-- editorial, The Washington Post

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
And this is just an interesting article explaining how and why the EU and the USA see trrorism differently and have a different way of dealing with it.
http://www.isn.ethz.ch/dossiers/terrorism/
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
ITALY:
"The US attorney general, who met Italian Justice Minister Roberto Castelli on Thursday, welcomed the latest development.

Mr Ashcroft said the arrests were "tangible evidence that Italy takes terrorism seriously and fights it aggressively".

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

I am sure I can find similar articles for most European Coutries, they have ben facing terrorism on thier own soil MUCH to the tune of 9/11 for decades. They hae been actively coutering it by treating it as a criminal activity.

This may seem to be not enough as the US is engaged in a full blown war that THEY chose to start alone, with temporarily assigned UK special forces for the initial missions.

Yet the war in Iraq is proving just as futile and pointless as not doing anything at all.

the French wre pretty pissed when the USA changed focus from Agfhanistan to Iraq, and allosed a united coalitions eforts to fall to the wayside, allowing al-Qaeda and Taliban terrorists to regroup and rebuild in force around Afghanistan.

Th only terrorist issue that have been resolved is the issue with th Irish REPUBLICAN Army and England. It was fought for MANY years, IRA just didn't feel that England belonged in THIER war with the south and continued to fight endlessly. The fight proved nothing but to fuel more hatred and terrorism.

A peceful resoltion was the only way to deal with thier REPUBLICAN interests.

++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

You may feel the world is not doing enough, as it may not be shown in your news, maybe the problems are but not the actions.

The world has been looking to stop the growth of terrorism for many decades before America really saw and understood it, I grew up understanding terrorism, I've seen it, watched trains bombed on BBC news(one of which my mother had JUST got off of several minutes before a bomb exploded, that memory will never leave my mind nor the single photo shown on BBC news that night. I thought she was dead and I was only about 5 or 6 at the time with a father in Canada) It is a reality I have prety much always seen and I can understand people's primal scream for revenge, I just don't see it as workig that way. It didn't in Afghanistan, terrorism is NOT stopped. It is PROVING fruitless in Iraq also as terrorism still grows in proportions never seen before.

If ANYTHING, the Iraq war has INCREASED the threat of terrorism, it certainly hasn't slowed or revented it. To actually feel and believe otherwise is just being clueless or simply in denial of the reality of what has occurred.

So for the may who hae deensively said, I wouldn't understand unless it happened in my country. I don't know what it's like. America has sufered and nobody cares.

Well I DO understand the repercussions of terrorism. I HAVE seen it and know JUST what it's like to not know if yuor loved on eis alive. I grew up in a country that recovered from the Blitz, IRA bombings for decades and now al-Qaeda. If anything, with ALL due respect, I think it is the US citizens who don't know terrorism, not until now anyway.

This is new to may, it has always been 'the poor people in Europe' hmmmm, glad it's not in MY home town thank God for Democracy and a peaceful nation.!'

Now don't get me wrong, i am not sayig you had it coming or anything, but the initial knee jerk reaction by an unqualified represntative of the people in America was not immediately rsponded to with war. They hve proven over MANY years, wa will NOT be the answer. So many spit upon others for not going to war ad suporting the USA, one day they MAY learn. Did the USA offered to ivade Northern Ieland to help Englad rid itself of this constant terrorism? Not once in a while but all the time. (I really don't know myself, but I am assuming not because it was resolved by an alied conflict).
And what would YOU think if your sons or daughters were sent to combat terrorism in Ireland with america not also beig threatened?
++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++
CANADA:sorry to go on but I can't miss Canada can I?

"OTTAWA ? A new Canadian Forces operation, known as Operation SAFARI , began this month with the deployment of two CF personnel to Sudan. Major James Simiana, a Public Affairs Officer, and Warrant Officer Robert Moug, a Staff Officer, will support the United Nations Mission in Sudan (UNMISUD) as members of the international advance party from the United Nations Stand-By High-Readiness Brigade (SHIRBRIG)."

"SHIRBRIG was established in 1996 as a non-standing multinational high-readiness brigade based on the UN Stand-by Arrangement System. On a case-by-case basis, member countries decide whether to participate in specific missions. Current full participants in SHIRBRIG include Austria, Canada, Denmark, Finland, Italy, Ireland, Netherlands, Norway, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Slovenia, Spain and Sweden. Chile, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Jordan and Senegal are observers."

NO USA? Gee aren't you supposed to be fighting too? Oh yes, you are, just in a different place than some other countries who are also fighting terrorism. Iraq isn't the ONLY place this needs to be fought.

by oz_media

Well we all know where you stand anyway so thre's nothign mroe to say I suppose.

In future I will not apologize to you, even if I don't have a full apology to offer. Which in the case cited was a 50/50 fault of misinterpreteation, misquoting, if you can't accept it niether can I.

by onbliss

which was conceived and is nurtured in the middle-east, is a noble and worthy goal.

Iran & Saudi Arabia ? And did'nt the world powers play a part to conceive and nurture the trouble there? Be it British, France, US or USSR. It looks like making the baby cry and then rocking the cradle.

by maxwell edison

.
....it will be sometime in the future - one way or the other.

"And didn't the world powers......", you ask?

Yes, therefore what?

by onbliss

Why do you think it should'nt have been Iran or SA? They seem to have all the rogue attributes, if not more than Iraq.

You ask 'therefore what?'.
I expected a better answer from a person who earlier asked the question "Do I dare attempt reasonable dialogue".

Anyway, after adding fuel (how topical) to the existing fires raging in the middle-east [warring tribes, clans...] for so long... now if we start talking about 'worthy', 'noble', 'sacrifices', 'eradicating the world of such evil and injustice' has a hollow ring to it. It is akin to the analogy of crying baby and craddle I mentioned.

by hal 9000

That most countries where adversely affected by both WW. In this case we could very well have the Islamic nations unite against the Christian nations and it would be an all out war that could have no clear winners. Sure eventually one side would prevail but the cost in human life would be horrendous and even the winning side would suffer far more than it gained.

The problem here is that a lot of people seem to think that Islam is confined to the Middle East but in fact is covers a wide area and there are many Muslin countries trying to stop the Fanatical Muslim Religious people from getting carried away. What we can not afford to do is alienate these moderate countries and tar then with the same brush as the fanatical members of the Islamic faith.

Unfortunately I'm seeing that appear here. What these fanatical could very well be called is "Evangelical" which then brings into question some of the actions by the Christian groups as well.

Col

by maxwell edison

.
...was intended to continue dialogue, not avoid it. You stated a fact, but drew no conclusion. I was simply wondering where you were going with it.

I agree, for decades, the nations of the world - including the USA - have been propping up and supporting these kinds of people - and ignoring the real threat - in various countries. So do we therefore keep doing the same thing, or do we therefore continue to turn a blind eye, or do we therefore do something different.......what's your "therefore what"? It's an honest question - what do you propose?

Mine is to do something different, and it's beginning in Iraq. Why Iraq? because it was the most viable place to begin the process - the process of planting the seeds of "contagious" democratic reform which has a good chance to result in a change of outlook and perspective in the region. (The "domino theory", but applied to freedom and liberty instead of communism.)

by maxwell edison

.
My "Do I dare attempt reasonable dialogue" comment was a specific question to a specific person who, in a different message, said exactly the same thing I did, but, for some strange reason, slammed me for saying it. It seemed rather "unreasonable" to me.