78 replies
by jbaker
While I cannot quote statutes, it does constitute theft of services if you log in to your neighbor's wireless without his or her knowledge or permission.
It is basically the same thing as if you were to run a cable from his cable box to your television.
by smorty71
This is an issue that has been debated on TR in the past; however, I don't think there has ever been consensus on what is or isn't legal.
It's definitely not the same thing as running a cable to your home from the neighbor's home. It is more like your neighbor watching TV with the windows open. If you can see or hear their TV from your yard, is THAT stealing? I don't think so.
But I think it is still pretty gray legally.
sm
by bfilmfan
United States Code
Title 18, Part 1, Chapter 110, Section 2511
(1) Except as otherwise specifically provided in this chapter any person who?
(a) intentionally intercepts, endeavors to intercept, or procures any other person to intercept or endeavor to intercept, any wire, oral, or electronic communication;
shall be punished as provided in subsection (4) or shall be subject to suit as provided in subsection (5).
(4)
(a) Except as provided in paragraph (b) of this subsection or in subsection (5), whoever violates subsection (1) of this section shall be fined under this title or imprisoned not more than five years, or both.
(b) Conduct otherwise an offense under this subsection that consists of or relates to the interception of a satellite transmission that is not encrypted or scrambled and that is transmitted?
(i) to a broadcasting station for purposes of retransmission to the general public; or
(ii) as an audio subcarrier intended for redistribution to facilities open to the public, but not including data transmissions or telephone calls,
is not an offense under this subsection unless the conduct is for the purposes of direct or indirect commercial advantage or private financial gain.
(5)
(a)
(i) If the communication is?
(A) a private satellite video communication that is not scrambled or encrypted and the conduct in violation of this chapter is the private viewing of that communication and is not for a tortious or illegal purpose or for purposes of direct or indirect commercial advantage or private commercial gain; or
(B) a radio communication that is transmitted on frequencies allocated under subpart D of part 74 of the rules of the Federal Communications Commission that is not scrambled or encrypted and the conduct in violation of this chapter is not for a tortious or illegal purpose or for purposes of direct or indirect commercial advantage or private commercial gain,
then the person who engages in such conduct shall be subject to suit by the Federal Government in a court of competent jurisdiction.
(ii) In an action under this subsection?
(A) if the violation of this chapter is a first offense for the person under paragraph (a) of subsection (4) and such person has not been found liable in a civil action under section 2520 of this title, the Federal Government shall be entitled to appropriate injunctive relief; and
(B) if the violation of this chapter is a second or subsequent offense under paragraph (a) of subsection (4) or such person has been found liable in any prior civil action under section 2520, the person shall be subject to a mandatory $500 civil fine.
(b) The court may use any means within its authority to enforce an injunction issued under paragraph (ii)(A), and shall impose a civil fine of not less than $500 for each violation of such an injunction.
by anykey???
since I'm not an attorney. But is is stealing bandwidth.
Craig Herberg
by jmgarvin
It is bandwidth theft and the cable company will see it a service theft.
It is NOT the same as watching your neighbor's TV through their window (perv), it is just like running a cable to your house.
A big problem is that you are using the service and not paying for it. It can also be seen as "hacking" depending on your local laws.
by hal 9000
It could be seen as just plain and simple theft where Civil Action can be brought against the person using the connection without authorization for exceeding the download limit and costing the owner of the unsecured LAN money.
While the ISP will just bill the connections owner and will not be interested in how the service is being used unless some flagged sites are accessed or data is downloaded the owner of the connection will be paying for the other people who use the service free of charge and there could be some quite excessive costs involved if the download limit is exceeded by a large margin.
Col ]:)
by cp7212
First, learn your acronyms before you use them.
Second, using the neighbor's wireless connection without obtaining the consent of the ISP is theft of services.
by smorty71
The original poster asked about logging into someone's wifi signal, not stealing broadband access.
I think those are two different issues.
I don't think it is illegal to log into someone's open wifi network. After all, you have no idea whether or not the neighbor intends for it to be open.
by apotheon
That's sorta splitting hairs. Rooting around in the network could get you in trouble in court as trespassing or similar infractions, and accessing broadband Internet accounts might be theft of services, so if there's nothing illegal about logging in you're then constrained against doing anything beyond that. So you can log in, and you can log back out again.
Of course, if you log in and are caught at it, and it is shown in court that you did so intentionally, then you'll probably be said to have demonstrated intent to do something further, such as go through the network owner's files or access his or her broadband Internet account, and at that point you've been shown to have at least attempted an illegal act.
The short version: Don't try to access a wireless account without explicit permission, ever, unless you're willing to risk fines and/or jail time.
... is about accessing a neighbor's wifi just to browse the neighbor's LAN. (Question mark key is not working today.)
I figured that accessing the neighbor's wifi would only make sense if you wanted to use their ISP service. Maybe I was wrong.
by cp7212
by j.lupo
but the field of IT law is still growing. Unfortunately, the legal system has not been able to keep up with technology. I have several lawyer friends and they all say that this field with in law is very difficult but interesting because they are helping to build or create the laws governing IT/IS in society.
I don't believe it is ethical to use someone's wireless network, mainly because they may not know it is available to others. A lot of people now have plug and play systems that are wireless and don't know anything about security or configuring their systems. There is no requirement that they learn before they purchase (and there shouldn't be, it would just be common sense).
Now, there may be laws getting passed about it, but there may not. I think it is more an ethical question at the moment. But that is just my opinion.
by synthetic
by smorty71
This thing works both ways. If I am sitting at my PC in *my* house and my PC connects to your WiFi signal, then where does the real responsibility fall? Does my neighbor's property line now extend into my home? I don't think so. So that rules out trespassing.
No one is talking about walking in someone's front door. So that analogy isn't a good one. It's more like your neighbor placing their front door in your house.
I'm not advocating accessing someone else's network. I just don't think that it is illegal as others are defining it. I also don't think the issue of broadcaster (i.e. your neighbor) responsibility for how far their signal goes has been defined legally.
What if I don't want my neighbor's wifi network extending to my house (to avoid interference for example)?
First, the analogy of the unlocked front door is a good one because ... well ... it JUST IS!!!
My REAL comment, as stated in the subject line, is that people who rely on the law to define their morality are just trying to place responsibility for their own bad behavior on others. A particular behavior may be legal one day and illegal another. I don't believe that a change in the law changes the morality of an action. Wrong is wrong whether it is legal or not.
And it doesn't matter if the wifi signal reaches into your house. The people who own the wifi equipment might not be technical giants. You can't take advantage of a situation just because the owners are not knowledgeable enough to keep their signal out of your house. What are they supposed to do anyway. If the problem is a question of effective range of the equipment do you expect the wifi equipment owners to build a Faraday cage around their house.
I suppose you'd say that if their windows are open then it is legal and moral to spy on them. Well, in the case of windows it is neither legal nor moral to watch people in their home through open windows. Now THAT'S a good analogy.
(My question mark key still isn't working.)
by smorty71
After revisiting an older thread on this topic, I found a post that discusses the fact that you can't expect a neighbor to "control" the range of their signal as long as the device is operating within spec. So I guess I can't expect my neighbor to keep their signal out of my yard. Bummer.
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=3&threadID=166922&messageID=1708694
by jkaras
You make a good point that circumstances beyond your control creates the issue. However nothing is stopping you from walking over to your neighbor and informing him of his lack of security. You are saying, his fault, not my problem, then knowingly take service that you didnt pay for. You know its wrong, it may not be your fault about his lack of security but it isnt his fault that you choose to not do the right thing but to do the wrong thing, you had a choice, nobody forced you. Now I am taking the stand point that you do not have an internet service and turn on your new pc and you realize that you have an internet signal and your neighbor bragged about his new wireless network and you know that internet service is not free it needs to be turned especially since you work in IT. My point is that it is a premeditated decision to do wrong, that's why its a crime. Bfilm showed the law on pirating another signal, just because wifi wasnt specifically mentioned doesnt absolve the liability.
In your scenario if you had an internet service and hooked up a wireless network and thought that you were tuning your own internet service not his, then that's just a simple mistake, not deliberate, no intent for malice.
by synthetic
by j.lupo
See the article: http://legalaffairs.org/printerfriendly.msp?id=827
Which was written with the law in mind. I don't know how valid it is, but it does address this issue.
Here is another view on it: http://seclists.org/lists/isn/2003/Apr/0129.html
It seems that the law is not on the books yet, but it is coming.
by smorty71
I like that the network owner has some responsibility to close their network.
"Like most state and federal computer crime laws, New Hampshire's
existing statute says it is a crime to knowingly access any computer
network without authorization. By analogy, just because someone leaves
his house unlocked doesn't mean you are authorized to walk inside, sit
on the couch or help yourself to the contents of the fridge.
But HB 495 turns that thinking upside down, experts said. It defines
an operator's failure to secure a wireless network as a form of
negligence. According to the proposed amendment, 'the owner of a
wireless computer network shall be responsible for securing such
computer network.'"
by j.lupo
Is on both sides. People shouldn't take the signal just because they can and people with the network should do all they can to shut the signal and confine it.
I know that I open my signal when I want to enjoy a nice day in my backyard. However, when I go in, I shut the signal down again. There is probably a better way to do this, but I am not that adept in networking - I am just learning that aspect of IT.
Guess this is one of those topics that is going to end up a long drawn out debate in the courts.
by smorty71
First of all, the question was a legal one, not a moral one.
Second, just for the moral record, I didn't advocate accessing anyone's network.
What I pointed out is that there is a responsibility on both sides. The fact that the signal extends onto my property makes it a stickier legal question I think. Has nothing to do with morality or bad analogies (To make the window analogy work, the window to my neighbor's house would have to be in my house since their wifi signal is in my house).
I think the New Hampshire bill sums up my position on it. It's your network, take some responsibility for it. Because you can't always depend on your neighbor to be as responsible.
by oz_media
"if their windows are open then it is legal and moral to spy on them"
Terrible analogy, legal and moral are two entirely different issues and you seem to be lumping them into one and the same too easily.
It IS legal to use the Internet if your wireless laptop picks up a signal because most people wouldn't know if it was THIER wireless connection or the neighboursthat they are picking up.
It is NOT morally acceptable or ethical for most though.
If someone leaves a wallet on the bus seat beside you and you take it, it is not morally correct, it is not ethical but it ISN'T theft.
In the case of a WiFi signal reaching into public areas,you are not opening an unlocked front door or spying through a window at all.
ACCURATE ANALOGY:
If someone started placing thier furniture and television on YOUR front yard or in a public parking lot, you are well within your LEGAL rights to sit down and watch TV.
It is up to the owner to secure thier property in thier own premises.
Costs:
In the case of most residential connections, jumping on an internet connection is no big deal as bandwidth and usage is not very limited.
In the case of a business signal, the business could be billed hundreds if not thousands of dollars in usage fees, thus it is in the company's best interests to lock down thier signal.
But the unlocked front door and open window analgies are old, overused and just plain poor analogies that really don't equate to he situation in any way at all.
They even sell scanners for less than $10 so you can drive through indusrtial parks and pick up wireless signals without booting your notebook. Any admin not addressing this is just a crappy admin.
The Canadian Criminal Code establishes several specific offenses dealing wit the theft of telecommunications service. This encompasses, stealing payTV signals, Wireless phone signals and any other broadcast signal, such as WiFi.
The code has VERY strict rules that state:
"Theft of telecommumication service wil occur when any person, in a fradulent or malicious manner, or without colour of right,
1) uses or consumes, extracts any gas, causes it to be diverted or wasted.
2)Obtains any telecommunication service....
THis now includes computers as they are seen as a telcommunications service, as are most ISP's ADSL services from the Telco.
But if you INADVERTENTLY pick up WiFi in public, it's not a criminal offence but a moral one.
by oz_media
In Canada "The state of mind of the accused is unimportant, but the act must be fraudulent, malicious or without colour or right."
This description allows for someone to 'play dumb' until it is proven that is was purposely done with the intent of obtaining a free signal.
They define Telecommunications as;
"any transmission, emission or reception of signs, signals, writing, images or sounds or inteligence of any nature by wire, radio, visual, or other electromagnetic system, wich encompasses in any manner any form of communication at a distance."
So WiFi would fall into this category of a protected telecommunications broadcast BUT the intent must be shown as malicious.
One such example stated: A man rigged a tunable stub to his TV to improve his reception, in eth process he picked up fre pay TV the payTv company couldn't sue because the customers intent was not found to be "fraudulent, malicious or without colour of right." He was merely trying to improve his own reception, not steal Pay TV (or so he said, I've made PayTV descramblers out of car radios too before the braodcasters kept changing the signal and you'd have to retune every 20 minutes).
by j.lupo
by hal 9000
It is up to the Government to legislate and then the Courts enforce the Legislation. Courts can not write Legislation but only interpret it in whatever way they see fit with what they are presented with.
A State can introduce a piece of Legislation which they feel is in their best interests but it may contravene Federal Legislation and in a case like this the Federal Legislation takes Precedence over the State Legislation so effectively the State Legislation is invalid. Sure the State can keep it on their books and even attempt to prosecute at every opportunity but even if a State Judge accepts the flawed Legislation as workable they know it will be thrown out when it reaches Federal Court so effectively the Legislation becomes invalid.
Col ]:)
by tomsal
..however, and this part is often over looked on these kinds of issues...just because something isn't illegall federally doesn't mean there isn't some state, county, or borough law against it.
I live in a condo development and as you can likely imagine on any given day I use my wireless laptop I can pick up a half dozen signals from my various neighbors (and half of those are unsecured consequently)...I'm sure they pick up my wireless network too -- that's why I have a lot of security features enabled, aside from my firewall, router and encryption my wireless network filters by MAC address.
If I ever found out that a neighbor was riding my signal I honestly don't think I'd be completely upset about it. It would depend on the frequency it happened and the amount of bandwidth they are hogging up.
If the frequency was common or the bandwidth hogging severe, I'd say the hell with the legal channels -- I'm knockng at your door.
by j.lupo
I haven't found any federal laws in the US specifically dealing with WiFi as yet. Of course, companies are actually setting up WiFi cities in my area so it becomes an interesting issue.
The city of Philadelphia has a project along these lines right now. I don't remember all of the information but I think by 2007 they want the city completely wireless accessible.
by cp7212
by dumblogic
by smorty71
This thread is full of armchair lawyers (myself included) declaring things illegal without providing any kind of legal basis (except for BFilmFan).
Just 'cause you think something is morally wrong doesn't make it illegal.
sm
by j.lupo
I don't think I am playing arm chair lawyer. I provided some rebuttle arguments and specifically the issue that is going on in NH right now regarding this.
The law has yet to be determined. The courts in the US are still addressing the issue based on who wants to take it on.
Right now it is a moral one.
by cp7212
by mhambrecht
by jkaras
by smorty71
Do you know for sure that the wifi frequencies are covered under "subpart D of part 74"?
"a radio communication that is transmitted on frequencies allocated under subpart D of part 74 of the rules of the Federal Communications Commission"
by jkaras
by bfilmfan
The Wiretap Act "Trespasser Exception" 18 U.S.C ? 2510(21)
The 2001 Patriot Act created the "Trespasser Exception" to the wiretap act. This exception allows law enforcement to to intercept communications to or from "computer trespassers." A "computer trespasser" is a person who a computer/network "without authorization" and "thus has no reasonable expectation of privacy..." The definition specifically excludes people with "an existing contractual relationship with the owner or operator."
There are several conditions attached in order for law enforcement to obtain these interceptions: the University must authorize the interception, our office must act under the color of law, there must be relevance to an ongoing investigation, and nothing but the communications sent or received by the computer trespasser may be intercepted.
(21) "computer trespasser"--
(A) means a person who accesses a protected computer without authorization and thus has no reasonable expectation of privacy in any communication transmitted to, through, or from the protected computer; and
(B) does not include a person known by the owner or operator of the protected computer to have an existing contractual relationship with the owner or operator of the protected computer for access to all or part of the protected computer.
As can be clearly seen, if the owner of the system can show that you "trespassed" on their system, then you are clearly in violation of federal wiretap acts.
As some of the respondents have pointed out, public wh-fi networks have clearly been established with the concept that "guests" will be allowed access and are not considered trespassers.
by hal 9000
This is all about intercepting transmissions not stealing ISP usage.
This section would certainly apply if the party involved was intercepting any transmission to or from their neighbors computer but not just ISP usage through a unsecured Wireless connection.
While I'm certainly no expert in US Law I do associate with quite a few undesirables in the Legal Profession and they would tell you that any piece of legislation deals in specifics and this specifically addresses interception of communications not Wireless Internet usage.
So I would say that using your neighbors unsecured wireless is morally wrong but as the law is still attempting to catch up with advances in technology it may be legal to do at this particular point in time.
However that doesn't mean that you can proceed to steal with impunity as at some point in the future retrospective legislation could be introduced to make any action like this a Criminal Offense.
Or more importantly the owner of the unsecured Wireless could instigate Civil Action against the person who is using their ISP without authorization to recover costs that have been incurred by exceeding the download limit that is likely to be in place with this service.
Just my .25 cents worth.
Col ]:)
by tcook002
by hal 9000
You are welcome to allow anyone to use it but do you want to be responsible if someone downloads something illegal? AS you being the point that is responsible for the download you will be. :D
Try reading the following:-
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=82&threadID=172666&messageID=1768076
And if you still want to give it away at least you'll be aware of some of the potential consequences. ;)
Col ]:)
by barks25
by j.lupo
The answer lies in the court battles going on. It doesn't cost me more than some research time to see what the rulings were/are. A few internet searches and you can even find them online for the most part.
My only point (of which I addressed the idea of responsibility in another post) is that right now the issue is a debate when it comes to the law. Computer Law is still in its infancy, so all we can do is watch as it grows and laws are passed, rulings made. In the mean time, this is a moral/ethical concern for each individual person.
My opinion, be responsible for your own actions as far as you can. If you make an HONEST mistake be accountable and provide restitution (not revenge, not punishment, not retribution). Just my view and opinion at this point.
If I find any other articles or points of law I will be happy to post the links.
by hal 9000
On the financial loss involved wouldn't it?
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Illegal?
The only reason to do something like this is either to download data off the LAN or take ISP time.
Without the owner being aware of this possibility which by all accounts they are unlikely to be as they would have been sold the Wireless hub as a cheap LAN solution that saved running wires all over the place in all likely hood they are not even aware of the security issues involved.
But I believe that even browsing a LAN is still Hacking and it doesn't matter if you are coping any data just the fact that you are in there is enough to have you a a pile of hurt here at least.
Actually I was thinking that the only reason to log in would be to steal ISP time but as that wasn't specifically asked the only other thing that can be applied here is a form of hacking which most defiantly is illegal. It doesn't make it right that there is an open wireless connection that is no excuse to hack any system and I would personally love to see the original posted jailed for this type of action.
The ISP thing however is much more a "Grey Area!"
Col ]:)
by j.lupo
Here is an excerpt from an article I found about this topic. It cites a federal computer crime statue:
----
The U.S. federal computer crime statute, Title 18 U.S.C. 1030, makes it a crime to knowingly access a computer used in interstate or foreign communication "without authorization" and obtain any information from the computer. A separate provision makes it a crime to access a computer without authorization with "intent to defraud" to obtain "anything of value." Fortunately, this provision also specifies that it doesn't apply if "the object of the fraud and the thing obtained consists only of the use of the computer and the value of such use is not more than $ 5,000 in any 1-year period."
----
Can find article at: http://www.securityfocus.com/columnists/237
Oh and the author's credentials: Mark D. Rasch, J.D., is a former head of the Justice Department's computer crime unit, and now serves as Senior Vice President and Chief Security Counsel at Solutionary Inc.
by barks25
My 2 Cents for What IT's Worth
Again the content, purpose or intent of the law is stated in the article. Words such as, "knowingly access a computer" or "intent to defraud" can be "interpreted" by the courts. Regardless of the amount of articles or laws either pro or con, moral or unethical, lawful or illegal, there is a need to have "reasonable, equitable solutions of responsibility" to situations of this nature. The initial question, "is it legal", can and will be interpreted by the courts. I think the answer to this problem needs to come from the community of Information Technology not a law based on what "could be interpreted legally right or wrong". We are the people with the intelligence and knowledge (I think) to give the "real guidance" when necessary.
by j.lupo
by hal 9000
Fix your keyboard?
I know one in your area but he is a lazy sod who will not work on his own equipment as he doesn't get paid for it. :D
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
You can only get interference if you are already using that frequency with another device not directly related to the Wireless Standard.
Would you like free to air TV and Radio stations to keep their RF out of your house and yard? That would defeat the entire purpose of the RF in the first place.
Now there was a quite bright mathematician called Hadley Lemar who developed a method for several radio devices to share the same frequencies with each other without causing any interference with each other.
In a case like this where two neighbors had Wireless Hubs at the very least each should be more than capable of using their own signal without interference by the other device transmitting RF. Your computer should log onto the strongest signal which would and should be the one that they are closest to namely the one in your house even without any setup done and only an absolute fool who knows better would be considering not locking down their Wireless Hub at least those here at TR. The problems arise when domestic people with little to no computer knowledge buy these things because they are sold them as a cheap alternative to hard wiring the house and are not provided the correct information on how to lock their Wireless Hubs down properly. If everyone took the time to first print out their instruction book and then read it things would be a lot easier for everyone but here in the real world that just doesn't happen these people will at best read the single sheet provided by their ISP to setup their Wireless Hub and then because they know no better think every thing is great and secure.
Now if you accidentally log onto a neighbors wireless connection that is an accident and you at the very least should tell your neighbor but if you make a habit of doing it that is a different story as under the law it shows Intent and you at the very least have access to the LAN so you have effectively "Hacked" the network. Now I do believe that Hacking in the USA is still illegal I do know that in the early to mid 70's big business lobbied the Government to introduce anti Hacking laws and I really can not believe that these have been repealed. So if you constantly log onto any wireless connection that you do not own, is owned by the company that you work for or is a public access point you are showing "Intent" under the Law to commit an offense.
Now every Law that has ever been written depends upon Intention to get a convection as if you where just walking past a place and a kid ran out in front off you and you walked it into the ground and it died you couldn't be charged with any offense. But if you where to constantly walk over the kid in an attempt to stomp it into the ground that is a different story and depending upon the severity of the actions taken could range from Manslaughter to Murder. At least that is how things work over here and I don't think that there would be too many differences in the main Laws like this between our two countries.
Col }:)
by hal 9000
In this particular case the person with the wireless connection has done everything that they know of to secure their network.
The person accessing the network through the wireless connection however is showing intent if they do it on a regular basis as they are effectively either hacking the network or deriving something for nothing namely an Internet access point that they are not paying for.
Now the thing here is the "INTENT" the owner has done everything that they where told to setup the connection and the person who is accessing it repeatedly without authorization is showing intent to breach at the very least network security.
Do you see the difference?
The wireless owner has intended or shown "Intent" to secure as best as they know their wireless hub and the person constantly accessing the wireless hub is showing "Intent" to break into the network.
The fact that wireless hubs are now consumer items that are sold with minimal instructions is the sticking point here as the person who owns it knows no better and the person who is accessing it knows better.
The only real problem here is that the legislation is still to catch up with the advances in technology so while there may not be anything currently on the books that directly addresses this situation the Common Law then takes effect and it all boils down to "Intent" the one that can be shown to have the "Intent" to fraudulently derive something for noting or actively steal data from a network will the the most guilty party and be sentenced accordingly.
Col ]:)
by j.lupo
you also restated my point about responsibility. So long as the wireless owner did EVERYTHING they knew how to do then they have met that obligation of responsibility to secure their network.
Then it becomes an issue of intent as you describe on the part of the person picking up the signal.
See my other post at the very end of the main thread about the law and statutes. I actually found one that "somewhat" applies.
by hal 9000
He is constantly mixing State and Federal Laws to make his case.
Sure the States do have rights but these Rights do not supersede the Federal Rights and responsibilities. Everything should be reduced to Federal Law as that is the one that covers Hacking in the first place.
But I actually can not see any State pursuing their own laws in this case as they would first have to receive a complaint from an ISP who provided the wireless hub in the first place without sufficient security warnings or instruction to their customer. I hardly think it likely that any ISP will make a complaint that will ultimately land themselves in Legal Hell.
He also doesn't address "Public Access Points" but attempts to lump all wireless connections into the one basket which clearly they are not.
For example a State Government will not bring a complaint against one of their departments for providing such a service even if they have it on their books that such a service is illegal. What is being mentioned here is some old legislation that was designed for other purposes and he is attempting to apply it to new technology which it was never intended to address.
God I have to stop this now I'm sounding far too much like a Lawyer aren't I? :(
Col ]:)
by smorty71
by oz_media
"any person who?
(a) intentionally intercepts, endeavors to intercept, or procures any other person to intercept or endeavor to intercept, any wire, oral, or electronic communication;"
In posts below, I have posted similar law from Canada. In the UBC Law Library there is an example given, it explains how one man used a tuner to 'improve a poor television reception' and accidentally picked up pay TV. I remember when everyone was using old analogue car radios to intercept First Choice (The first pay TV movie channel up here).
So if the act did not have the clear requirement of willingness to conduct malicious intent, then he would be guilty of the interception.
As I explained below, I think that you could simply play dumb IF you were pcking it up at home from a neighbour. You could claim you thought it was YOUR signal; in a parking lot of an industrial park, you could claim the same thing.
It would be a hard conviction for the prosecution anyway. I think the law was ammended this way so that apartment owners couldn't offer free services, hotel rooms couldn't use it to increase profits etc. Much like the copyright laws on music, they REALLY care when you profit from it, personal copying isn't really an issue.
by jkaras
by oz_media
Prove it.
THer's your issue.
As for the ISp, they are resllers of a telco's ports in MANY cases (especially ADSL). Very few ISP's have built a telecom infrastructure, or laid several hudred million dollars worth of fibre, copper or maintained the line services.
by alt.wally
The "key" word here is "communication," and the "key" concept here is interception of communication(s).
Using spare bandwidth is not intercepting communication, and FCC regs clearly state that every U.S. citizen has the right to receive any signal aimed at them. An unsecured wireless network is "aimed" at everyone within its radius, and the documentation for such hardware makes this abundantly clear.
Morally wrong, yes. Illegal? Not an open and shut case...
.
No, I don't think it's illegal to access an open wireless connection to go OUT, but to go IN is another issue.
I would challenge anyone to show me even ONE case where someone was arrested, tried, convicted, and paid a fine and/or served a sentence for simply using an open wireless connection to do some harmless Internet browsing. (Or even a civil case, for that matter.)
If you can show me even one case, then I will stand corrected. If you can't show me a case, it tells us that there is no legal authority currently written into the laws to make it illegal.
by bgarvin1
by skidoggeruk
Stupid
Was the one I knew. slightly more polite
by hal 9000
But I was a lowly engineer working with fitters so I most likely wouldn't know any better.
Any Time that I came out with one of the more complicated designs I was asked had I followed the KISS principal all the way. :D
Col ]:)
by smorty71
J.
I didn't mean to offend you with the term "arm chair lawyer." You did provide some great info about the issue and how some states are dealing with it.
I was merely pointing out that this group (myself included) probably isn't going to get to the bottom of the legalities. A small part of that is because that the laws are still being written. I think a larger part is that most of us (especially me) don't really know enough about the law to make a valid argument. Configure a router? Sure, no problem. Answer legal questions? Probably not.
by j.lupo
I wasn't offended, but I wanted to clarify. Lately, I have been accused of not backing up my arguments (opinion?) with solid evidence of my position. :) Guess those generalities we humans somtimes tend to use get us everytime, either that or I have been a programmer for to long. ;)
If (condition) then ... else if (condition) then . . . else . . . endif;
by hal 9000
Well I did the unthinkable yesterday and asked some of the people that I know the disreputable ones practicing Law they ranged from Barristers to QC's and even worse a Judge and the opinion seem to be that while this particular item was not directly covered by current legislation it could be taken under existing legislation to court for loss or damages to any party. The most likely scenario is someone buys a new Wireless Hub and then someone within range downloads some Kiddy porn or other flagged material and the person who is paying for the Internet connection gets the blame. In the case of Kiddy Porn there would be massive damages involved as the person who owns the account would be the first suspect and would at the very least have their computer network impounded and forensically scanned to recover data that may have been over written and then if nothing was found be interviewed about that "Other" computer which they couldn't find with the material on it. The Current Law would hold them responsible for the downloaded material and the owner of that wireless access point would be responsible and charged and convicted for the offense.
It would then be up to the person who was convicted to instigate Civil Action against the person responsible for downloading the data if they could be found and in the case of Kiddy Porn or other obnoxious items could then sue for damages incurred to their reputation and standing in the community. At the same time the proper authorities would become involved and instigate a case against the offender and do exactly the same things that they had done previously to the owner of the Wireless station.
But the main point is that in the event of something like this happening it would be the owner of the access point who would carry the responsibility for the downloaded content even if it was through Ignorance and be charged for the offense.
To the other thing if they where to just access the wireless connection and tell the owner that it was open and unsecured the "Good Samaritan" Clauses would be invoked and no action could be brought against the person for reporting the ability to access but if they where to dig around in the network they would be hacking and guilty of an offense.
Now is that of any help?
Of course they all said that new Legislation was being worked upon and that it would be best to involve the Technical People in its formation so that the loop holes would not be written into the Legislation by people with the right idea but no technical knowledge. :)
Of course because the people involved in answering this question where all highly paid professionals I'll be working for them for free for quite a while to come and what is even worse that BLOODY Judge has put my name forward to the Government to be considered as a resident "Expert" God help me! :(
Now who was it responsible for starting this I'm going to take out a contact on them. I'll at least enjoy that they are dieing a slow and painful death as I work free for God only know who long. :D
Col ]:)
by smorty71
Great info there. I hadn't considered the potential ramifications based on the type of content being accessed.
That should make everyone reading this thread doublecheck their own network.
Have fun with the lawyers!
sm
by jkaras
I responded to shorty's response pointing out that if you dont have an internet service, got a new pc and turned it on realizing that you "magically" can have an internet connection. Your neighbor bragged about his cool wireless network proving karnal knowledge of the signal. You work in IT and know fully well how everything works. You dont have to be in the industry to know if you dont pay for it, then its stealing. It runs on the same principle of cable/satelite signal, they are paid services and the stand point of "cop didnt see, it didnt happen" doesnt justify a crime, a conscious decision to try to get away with something. I dont have to work in the cable/tv industry to know that people have to pay for the service.
ON the flip side I have an internet service, my neighbor bragged about his cool new wireless network and I decide I want to be cool like him. I buy the equipment and set it up unknowingly synching into his signal, not mine because he didnt set the security right. That is a classic mistake, its understandable, no malice. But to defend a point of prove that I didnt intend to steal a paid service and use the Chewbacca defense is wrong both professionally and morally. Nothing stopped you from informing your neighbor on his lack of security, you chose to profit off his stupidity hence Bfilm's response "(1) Except as otherwise specifically provided in this chapter any person who?
(a) intentionally intercepts, endeavors to intercept, or procures any other person to intercept or endeavor to intercept, any wire, oral, or electronic communication;" the key word is intentionally on the premise that you had karnal knowledge of the signal, which he did asking the question if I log onto my neighbor's wifi signal is it stealing? It wasnt he came over and complained or the internet service ran a security check of pirated signal. You knew you chose and try and play stupid when caught.
by smorty71
where I said that I don't advocate accessing anyone else's network. Period.
I was just questioning if it is truly illegal. Everyone seems to want to equate "illegal" with "wrong." They aren't the same thing.
by hal 9000
Perhaps you would like a shortish holiday doing some of their IT work? :)
I'll quite happily put you up for the stay. :D
Col ]:)
by cp7212
Years ago, I had some upstairs neighbors that played boom-boom dance music from a local college station every Saturday morning. I figured their stereo was right above where my refrigerator sat. I put my old Apple ][+ (a whopping 48K of memory in that one) on top of the refrigerator and turned it on.
The station was broadcast at a lower frequency than the Apple operated at....static never sounded better. ;)
by cp7212
by tcook002
by xcaliber
I left the darn thing on for you to connect!
I only kick you off at night when I get home and you're surfing the naughty stuff.
Enjoy!
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Trending Networks posts
Sort by Trending