Discussion Locked

Media Bias - Hollywood Bias - YES it's real

0 helpful
72 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I'll never be convinced it doesn't exist. But go ahead and make your case that it doesn't.

I could list case after case after case of such bias. (And I might.)

Republicans and the Republican agenda, in general, are unjustly demonized and discredited by both Hollywood and the main-stream media, i.e. journalists, reporters, and news anchors.

Moreover, much of the general American population - AND MOST of the world population - is led into believing things that did not happen, things taken out of context, and things that are just downright false. They are given a false impression of reality, and are duped - YES, DUPED - into believing things that simply are not true. I've seen it time and time again.

In the very least, it is common for them to take an ounce of truth and extract a ton of lies, lies, and more lies.

The following is from a Drudge Report Story:

CONTROVERSY SWIRLS AROUND CBS REAGAN FILM; SCRIPT REVEALED

In the upcoming CBS telefilm on President Ronald Reagan producer fail to mention the economic recovery or the creation of wealth during his administration, nor does it show him delivering the nation from the malaise of the Jimmy Carter years.

The film depicts Nancy Reagan as a pill-popping control addict, who set the president's schedule based on her astrologer's advice and who had significant influence over White House personnel and policy decisions.

MORE

The NEW YORK TIMES has obtained a final script for THE REAGANS, according to newsroom sources.

TIMES reporter Jim Rutenberg does it again, and is planning a Tuesday splash.

"This was very important for me, to document everything and give a very fair point of view," says Leslie Moonves, the CBS chairman and a top Democrat supporter [he sat next to Hillary Clinton during her husband's re-nominating convention].

MORE

The film is set to air during next month's Sweeps. It stresses Reagan's moments of forgetfulness, his supposed opinions on AIDS and gays, his laissez-faire handling of his staff members. The scenes often carry a disapproving tone.

During a scene in which his wife pleads with him to help people battling AIDS, Reagan says resolutely, "They that live in sin shall die in sin" and refuses to discuss the issue further.

The film's producers, Zadan and Meron, acknowledge their liberal politics, as do the stars of the television movie, James Brolin and Judy Davis. But Meron tells the TIMES: "This is not a vendetta, this is not revenge. It is about telling a good story in our honest sort of way. We all believe it's a story that should be told."

----------

This is becoming more and more shameful every day.

It's time people start discovering for themselves what the truth really is, and STOP relying on Hollywood and the main-stream media for information.

Or are there better options?

72 replies

by thechas

Max,

Every individual has their own personally biased point of view.

I know that you and I will take away very different interpretations of the exact same speech from George W. Bush.
The main difference here is that you have a higher level of trust in our President than I have.

As to CBS's planned drama on the Reagan years, what did you expect?
CBS and the majority of "entertainment" companies have little interest in the "truth" and being factual.
The key word here is "entertainment"! The goal of ALL entertainment programs is to maximize the ratings. Sensationalism is the fast and cheap way to raise the ratings.

It was a sad day for "truth" in the US when the news divisions at the big 3 networks lost their autonomy.

The national news from the big 3 (4 with FOX) is little more than a joke to anyone looking for detailed factual information.

What's the answer? I do not know.

Perhaps if we can get enough people to watch something other than trashy dramas on TV we may have a chance.

The only other option is to launch an advertiser boycott campaign.

Chas

by maxwell edison

I've been pretty clear in past discussions as to my particular biases. But a person having a bias is quite different than a media source having a bias.

For example, my bias, politically speaking, always falls in line with a couple of basic core beliefs - personal values, if you will. First, a person should take personal responsibility for themselves - period. (Disclaimer and exception: If a person truly can't be responsible for him/her self, then our compassionate society should care for that person in a reasonable and dignified manner.) Second, it's inherently wrong for a government to take a dollar from a person who earned it and give it to a person who didn't earn it. Almost ALL of my political (and personal) views have a basis in one of those two values. That's my bias. I admit it.

But for a newspaper or news anchor to let his or her bias influence the way a story is reported is deplorable. News stories all too often don't just report the news, but attempt to influence how a person thinks about it, and that's wrong.

by cactus pete

OK, I haven't thought this one all the way out yet, but here's my initial take:

The news station is a business, and has the right of free speech. If they report something, the have the right to put their spin on it.

Now, the average citizen might not be smart enough to realize this, but most of them probably don't watch the news, anyway...

As to your personal views, your own disclaimer and exception of view #1 seems to fly in the face of the second view. I'm sure you recognize this.

Now what you seem to have a problem with is the interpretation of what defines the word "truly" when deciding who truly cannot take care of him/herself.

Am I right?

by hal 9000

But the truth is subjective as no two people who see the same thing will tell the same story. They will in all honestly tell what they believe thay saw and while they aren't telling any mistruths they aren't necessarly telling exactly what happened in an unbiased fassion either.

Just one example here Max on the 14 of thsi month I was rear ended by a young Social Worker on her way to work while I was going to a product conference. She saw a sligh gap in the traffic and accelerated in an attempt to get in but unfortantly forgot theat I was in front of her on the Ducati. Now when she hit me she panicked and accelerated harder which caused me no end of concern particuarly as I was being pushed into oncomming traffic namly a bloody great big bus so I elected to throw the bike dow in the hope that she would stop or at the very least there would be far more friction offered so she would stop pushing me forward. It made absolutely no difference to this young girl who was by now in a state of total panic and I was pushed another 6 feet or so along the road until her car actually ran up on the Ducati and lifted it's front wheels far enough off the roadway so they just spun and smoked up but at least I was no longer moving forward. Luckely it was a front wheel drive or I would be dead now.

She was a mess to say the least and she actually got out of her car eventually after her passanger turned of the iginition and asked me how I was at the time I was lying on the ground with the Ducati on top of me and her car on top of that so I was somewhat less than happy and firmly suggested that she get that bloody thing off me.

Anyway enough of that when th4e Police arrived several hours latter they took statments from everyone who saw what happened one person walking down the road insisted that this young girl attempted to murder me and while I'm not a firm believer in paronid beliefs it was a fair comment from her actions. But on the other side it could be said that she just panicked when she hit me and froze and couldn't do anything. Those are the two extremes and the truth is probably somewhere in between I don't know but I tend to give her the benifit of the doubt. However what really pisses me off about this is currently the Police force over here is having a Blitz on bad driving so they are handing out traffic tickets as fas as they can print the books but in this case thay where unwilling to give her a ticket for anything even though she admitted that she was stationary behind me for well over 1 minute and just forgot I was there.

If I was to ride down the road at 5 KM's over the speed limit I would get a $150.00 AU fine but apparently it is OK to run someone down as this is not considered as any form of traffic violation even it it leads to a death.

I will admit to being totally biased in this case and I think it is wrong but then again that is just the way it is.

by jackofalltech

Many people on the right believe that there is an organized conspiracy by those on the left, especially the media, to portray us in the worst possible light. Although that is, in fact, begin done, it is not due to any organized plan. Randy Alcorn, in his excellent book Deadline, explains it very well. I believe he calls it a conspiracy of culture. A vast majority of the media are liberals and only associate with other liberals - hence there is a synergistic re-inforcement of ideologies. Since they have little or no contact with normal people, what they know about us is almost all hearsay or worse. They believe we are bucolic sheep and have no real interest in what we think and therefore rarely pay attention when we try to explain our positions. If you listen closely during a debate between a liberal and a conservative, you will notice that liberals can almost never justify their position with facts but resort to attacking the conservative on irrelevent side-issues.

Please understand that what I just said is a generalization and not always the case - just almost always.

I know I'll get flamed for this, but you watch! Those who attack me won't have any facts or statistics to contradict me, they will resort to name-calling.

Ralph

by oldefar

Mr. Alcorn nailed it, but it isn't just the press or just liberals. Most people associate with those who share a common perspective, and so get continual reinforcement of their views, right or wrong, factual or fantasy.

In my opinion, the Web serves as a doorway to expanding every user's perspective beyond that of themselves and their social groups. I believe history will talk of this expanded exposure to positions and ideas as perhaps the most important social change to ever impact humanity.

by maxwell edison

I agree that it's not an organized "conspiracy", but rather, as you so eloquently stated, a result of the liberal culture that permeates the journalist ranks. (Just as it is in the teaching profession as well.) But just because it's not a concerted effort, per se, it's there nonetheless. And more alarming is the fact that it's influencing the way people think about us - especially in other parts of the world, as they have no (or very limited) alternative conservative view for balance. Balance is the key, and all too many people don't get that balance.

The New York Times is a prime example - and a major offender. Most news agencies around the world site the New York Times as their source for news stories, especially ones about the United States, its politics, and its policies. All a person has to do is compare the extreme liberal slant of the New York Times to the more conservative slant of the Washington Times. But how often is the Washington Times used as a source for stories around the world? I can honestly say that I've never seen it, and I have read a lot of news stories from newspapers around the globe. The source is almost always the New York Times.

It's no wonder the rest of the world has such a skewed view of us, instead of a more realistic or balanced view.

Now as for Hollywood, that's another story entirely.

by hal 9000

That the New York Times doesn't charge for its stories to be reproduced in other places where as the Washington Post does.

Big business being the way it is, is always looking for the cheapest alternative.

Could the answer be as simple as this?

After several years of this kind of "fact" being passed around the world it would only go to increase the "Bleeding Heart Liberals" views to more of the Media and make them become as accepted "fact."

by hal 9000

Ralph you are totally right in your posting I can't agree more with what you have posted here as it is all correct and this problem isn't limited to the US but most of the so called Westeren World.

Sorry for the heading but I couldn't resist. I needed a good laugh.

Colin

by maxwell edison

Howard Dean on 60 Minutes II with Dan Rather on Wednesday night, October 22nd.

Dan Rather should be ashamed of himself. I've never seen a more "love-fest" interview. You would think it was Barbra Walters interviewing Barbra Straisand. The only thing Rather didn't kiss was Dean's ring.

Dan Rather HATES the Bush family.

Dan Rather has always been sure there was "more than meets the eye" on Iran-contra. Rather had CBS investigate extensively into the scandal in hopes that possibly Ronald Reagan or George Bush were involved. On January 25, 1988, Dan Rather interviewed Bush in a now-infamous interrogation. The interview is now considered so much a part of history by C-SPAN that it sells video tapes of the confrontation on its Web site.

In the interview, Dan Rather kept trying to implicate George Bush, trying to get Bush to say that he was involved in Iran-contra. Over and over again, Rather would ask Bush a question about his knowledge of the imbroglio. When Bush wouldn't concede that he had prior knowledge, Rather would interrupt him and ask him another question about whether he knew. This went on until Rather interrupted Bush for the last time and ended the interview. The interview caused a stir. A number of CBS affiliates called the Bush campaign to apologize for the anchor's behavior. Sam Donaldson, known for his own confrontational interviews, said, "Rather went too far." Mike Wallace, a fellow CBS reporter, said, "The style was wrong. Dan lost his cool."

"I was doing the Rather live program from my office right in the Capitol.... There were four minutes of clips -- all questioning my word. It was a mean, tough interview. Dan came on, and he and I got right with it. I tried to keep cool.... But I'd be damned if I was going to let this guy walk all over me..."

--George H. W. Bush in his diary, January 25, 1988, included in All the Best, George Bush.

"I won the battle with Dan Rather that night, but he won the war. His coverage of my campaign and presidency was consistently negative."

--George H. W. Bush in his 1999 book, All the Best, George Bush.

"...he was at the very least skirting the truth about his involvement in sending some of America's best technology to the Ayatollah Khomeini."

--Dan Rather to Chris Mathews CNBC's Hardball, June 28, 1999.

In 1988, Dan Rather repeatedly hammered then-Vice President George Bush about his role in the Iran-Contra affair. How did Rather treat Clinton in his first interview with him as President? During the special March 24 White House tour and interview on 48 Hours, Rather never questioned Clinton about false statements he has made: claiming that Republicans, not he, made gays in the military an issue during his first week in office; that he never asked Kimba Wood to be Attorney General; and that his stimulus package did not contain any pork-barrel projects.

Instead, Rather asked: "Mr. President, it's my unfortunate duty now to ask the tough questions you don't want to hear. Number one: do you have a favorite in the Oscar race for the Academy Awards?"

A review of Rather's opinions both on and off the air over the past few years suggests a reason for the disparity - He agrees with Clinton: the 1980s were a decade of greed, Reagan's tax cuts were unfair, Soviet citizens weren't opposed to communism. He's been on the liberal frequency for a long time.

On June 17, 1987 on the CBS Evening News, Dan Rather said, "Despite what many Americans think, most Soviets do not yearn for capitalism or Western-style democracy."

On November 29. 1989 Rather reported, "This week's meeting of Pope John Paul and Mikhail Gorbachev brings together two traditional enemies, both of whom have shown, time and again, that they can rise above the hatreds of history. The meeting, said one priest in Rome, is like the lion lying down with the lamb, but in this case, he said, it's hard to tell who's the lion and who's the lamb."

On July 13, 1989, Dan Rather joined the Jesse Jackson fan club. "Jesse Jackson is one American politician who consistently speaks for the poor and downtrodden. One of the few national leaders openly advocating aid to the cities."

Whenever a liberal "study" was released that made the Reagan years look bad, it made Dan Rather's broadcasts. On March 1, 1989, Rather introduced a Susan Spencer story on health threats posed to poor kids by asserting "children are already suffering from cutbacks during the Reagan Administration." Liberal reports were spun to make the facts look worse even than the activist group claimed. When the little-known left-wing Food Research and Action Center (FRAC) released a "study" on child hunger CBS made the FRAC study the number one story on the March 26, 1991 Evening News. Rather began: "A startling number of American children are in danger of starving...Good evening. One out of eight American children is going hungry tonight." Starving? Not only did FRAC not claim their "hungry" children were hungry every night -- just at least once a year -- the study didn't even focus on starvation or clinical malnutrition. Rather exaggerated.

Dan Rather - SHAME on you.

by maxwell edison

"Bush: How I'll rule the world"

President George W. Bush NEVER said that. He NEVER implied that.

But the New York Times spun a story to imply he said it. The story and headline was picked up by many newspapers around the glode including the Sydney (Australia) Morning Herald.

The Sydney Morning Herald story started by reporting (falsly reporting), "The Bush Administration has spelt out its determination to enforce America's global domination, insisting it will allow no other power to challenge its military and economic supremacy."

Lies, lies and more lies.

Shame on you New York Times and Sydney Morning Herald.

by maxwell edison

It is going VERY VERY well in Iraq - right according to plan. Do we hear about it?

Media's dark cloud a danger
Falsely bleak reports reduce our chances of success in Iraq

By JIM MARSHALL (D), U.S. Congressman, Georiga

On Sept. 14, I flew from Baghdad to Kuwait with Sgt. Trevor A. Blumberg from Dearborn, Mich. He was in a body bag. He'd been ambushed and killed that afternoon. Sitting in the cargo bay of a C 130E, I found myself wondering whether the news media were somehow complicit in his death.

News media reports about our progress in Iraq have been bleak since shortly after the president's premature declaration of victory. These reports contrast sharply with reports of hope and progress presented to Congress by Department of Defense representatives -- a real disconnect, Vietnam d?ja vu. So I went to Iraq with six other members of Congress to see for myself.

The Iraq war has predictably evolved into a guerrilla conflict similar to Vietnam. Our currently stated objectives are to establish reasonable security and foster the creation of a secular, representative government with a stable market economy that provides broad opportunity throughout Iraqi society. Attaining these objectives in Iraq would inevitably transform the Arab world and immeasurably increase our future national security.

These are goals worthy of a fight, of sacrifice, of more lives lost now to save thousands, perhaps tens or hundreds of thousands in the future. In Mosul last Monday, a colonel in the 101st Airborne put it to me quite simply: "Sir, this is worth doing." No one I spoke with said anything different. And I spoke with all ranks.

But there will be more Blumbergs killed in action, many more. So it is worth doing only if we have a reasonable chance of success. And we do, but I'm afraid the news media are hurting our chances. They are dwelling upon the mistakes, the ambushes, the soldiers killed, the wounded, the Blumbergs. Fair enough. But it is not balancing this bad news with "the rest of the story," the progress made daily, the good news. The falsely bleak picture weakens our national resolve, discourages Iraqi cooperation and emboldens our enemy.

During the conventional part of this conflict, embedded journalists reported the good, the bad and the ugly. Where are the embeds now that we are in the difficult part of the war, now that fair and balanced reporting is critically important to our chances of success? At the height of the conventional conflict, Fox News alone had 27 journalists embedded with U.S. troops (out of a total of 774 from all Western media). Today there are only 27 embedded journalists from all media combined.

Throughout Iraq, American soldiers with their typical "can do" attitude and ingenuity are engaging in thousands upon thousands of small reconstruction projects, working with Iraqi contractors and citizens. Through decentralized decision-making by unit commanders, the 101st Airborne Division alone has spent nearly $23 million in just the past few months. This sum goes a very long way in Iraq. Hundreds upon hundreds of schools are being renovated, repainted, replumbed and reroofed. Imagine the effect that has on children and their parents.

Zogby International recently released the results of an August poll showing hope and progress. My own unscientific surveys told me the same thing. With virtually no exceptions, hundreds of Iraqis enthusiastically waved back at me as I sat in the open door of a helicopter traveling between Babylon and Baghdad. And I received a similar reception as I worked my way alone, shaking hands through a large crowd of refinery workers just to see their reaction.

We may need a few credible Baghdad Bobs to undo the harm done by our media. I'm afraid it is killing our troops.

-- U.S. Rep. Jim Marshall (D-Ga.) of Macon, a Vietnam combat veteran, is a member of the House Armed Services Committee.

by jardinier

As you are not personally in Iraq, you wouldn't have a clue what the situation is, and obviously
choose to believe those reports which are in harmony with your own point of view.

In his address to the combined Parliament of Australia today (televised live, so there is no media bias involved in the equation) President Bush (or the White House speech writers)conveniently evaded reference to any negative aspects of the issue of Iraq by including, among other comments, the unarguable statements: "Who can possibly think that the world would be better off with Saddam Hussein still in power" and: "Today, Saddam's regime is gone, and none should mourn its passing." He also spoke only of the positive aspects of the current situation in Iraq.

And please don't accuse me of personal bias by selecting these particular portions of his speech, which is obviously too long to fit in a posting.

Doubtless the full text of President Bush's speech will be published in the American media. Perhaps you also received a live telecast of his speech.

So why don't you catch the next plane to Iraq and make your own observations, instead of relying on carefully selected reports?

by maxwell edison

Peter Jennings Accused of Liberal Bias by Another Former Reporter

By Marc Morano
CNSNews.com Senior Staff Writer
May 12, 2003

A former ABC News reporter has confirmed fellow former ABC News correspondent Peter Collins' contention that anchor Peter Jennings routinely attempted to insert his left of center editorial slant into correspondents? news copy.

The charges leveled by Bob Zelnick, who spent 21 years at ABC News, follow revelations from former network correspondent Peter Collins that Jennings manipulated news scripts during the 1980s in order to praise the Marxist-backed Sandinista government in Nicaragua.

Zelnick, now the chairman of the journalism department at Boston University, left ABC News in 1998 after executives refused to renew his contract because they feared Zelnick's work on a political biography critical of then-Vice President Al Gore might compromise his objectivity.

Zelnick could not corroborate Collins' assertions, the focus of an earlier CNSNews.com article, but did recount his own experiences with Jennings' editorial influence at ABC News.

"It was very common for correspondents, both domestic and foreign to run into a World News Tonight [staff] that was influenced by Peter [Jennings] who had a different interpretation of a story," Zelnick told CNSNews.com.

"The correspondent who knows that he is going to be doing a piece on World News Tonight girds himself for battle when the phone rings and the editors or sometimes Peter [Jennings] gets on the phone," Zelnick explained.

And there was usually no doubt about which ideological direction Jennings would attempt to lead correspondents.

"In terms of the direction that Peter Collins recalls Peter Jennings pushing in - and that was to the left of where the correspondent is - that's consistent with my experiences and I think most [ABC News correspondents'] experience," Zelnick explained.

Zelnick referred to what he called the "Peter [Jennings] Factor."

"I have never condemned Peter Jennings for trying to bring others around to his point of view ... but there was the Peter Factor," Zelnick said.

World News Tonight, unlike some organizations, has a tradition of changing the scripts of correspondents, often for stylistic reasons, often for editorial reasons," Zelnick added.

'Comical'

In an earlier, exclusive interview with CNSNews.com, Collins alleged that Jennings personally dictated changes in a Collins television script in order to praise the Sandinista government for its "new, unselfish society," for successfully reducing illiteracy and "launch[ing] the biggest land reform in Central America."

Collins covered Central America for ABC's World News Tonight and Nightline from 1982 until 1991. Collins is now retired from journalism.

When asked Friday whether he still believes ABC was wrong to let him go, Zelnick responded with another question.

"Has Stephanopoulos been barred from reporting?" Zelnick asked, referring to George Stephanopoulos, the former aide to President Bill Clinton and current anchor of ABC's This Week.

Referring to his own experience with the network, Zelnick said, "It's the only time I have ever heard of a reporter being prevented from writing a book. Usually, they are encouraged to write books."

by generalist

Hollywierd has the problem of trying to sell entertainment, even when it is in the guise of a documentary. They need to make their products entertaining, which often means that things are left out or over emphasized. That is one strike against them when it comes to believable information.

Strike two comes when various resource constraints hit the production of the Hollywood product. Accuracy often suffers in the effort to produce things on time and within budget.

Then you have the strike three of the bias that EVERYBODY has when it comes to things like politics. If this bias is strong, it can slant things unless you're making a special effort at avoiding the slant.

And when you get down to it, mainstream media AND alternative media suffer from the same problems.

In some cases it is probably due to an informal 'conspiracy', the type that occurs when groups of people in a given field associate with like minded people. But I suspect that much of the problem is a matter of people just being people, reacting to things without really taking a deep look at where they are coming from.

by hal 9000

We can all see exactly the same thing and get different stories from it.

So it is true to say that no matter what the media actually presents we only see what we want to.

Boy this woter cooler is getting croweded isn't it?

by jimhm

It is also in Print Media, Radio Media, TV - every form. There will always be Bias - when it's the libral bias - nothing is said. But god forbid a conservative view - then it is a Right Wing - Liberal Bashing media blitz.

The Media needs to report the news - the truth - no personal views - no editorizing - Just report it ... What I hate the most about the Media is when these "Holier than thou" reports, tell you what the President ment after a televised speach that you just watched....

Like I am not smart enough to understand the english language that he used. The Words were to big... No I have to hear a translation from Dan Rather or Walter about what President Bush said and what it trutly means - then you have to hear from some Democrate that tells you something else.

Report the news, no personal bias, no interruption, no slants - but it will never happen...

by maxwell edison

Almost all of the main-stream media has an extremely liberal bias - CBS, NBC, ABC, NPR, New York Times, Washington Post, Time Magazine, Newsweek Magazine, USA Today, LA Times. I don't think anyone could provide a compelling argument to the contrary. And to be sure, there is an element (a small element) of Conservative bias in the media - Washington Times, FOX News. (And I suppose that some media do try for the unbiased.) But the balance is 10-1, at least, tilted towards the liberal perspective. Most of the Conservative alternative (Rush Limbaugh and others) are admittedly commentary, not reporters or news anchors. Commentary is different than reporting.

Let's get balance in reporting. And if the liberals feel so inclined, get some balance in the commentary. I love debating issues in the arena of ideas. The reason there's not as much liberal commentary is that the ideas won't hold up under the scrutiny of debate and analysis, while the conservative ideas do.

by jardinier

who owns Fox? Yes, good old media mogul Rupert Murdoch, who paid my salary for the four years that I worked on the now defunct (Sydney) Daily Mirror.

Now this same man founded our first national newspaper, the Australian. It ran at a loss for 10 years, being subsidised largely by the Daily Mirror. It is now one of the most respected newspapers in Australia.

Not that he's an altruist of course -- he just wants more political influence.

He helped to get Gough Whitlam into power in 1972, and helped to remove him in 1975 when there was too much controversy surrounding the Whitlam Government.

by jimhm

What was that about the Green Party - that happened during Bush's address to the Austie parliment? Hum - freedom of speach is fine for the Greenies but not for anyone else? Ingnorant action and childish beheavor is bad for everyone except the greenies? If I were an Aussie I would be ashamed of the way my representatives acted and displayed to the world - the ingronance of my country...

Aren't the Green's the liberal party downunder... The people of Austrila should be ashamed of their beheavor... it was an imbarassment to them and their government.

One American's Op Ed

by hal 9000

While the Greens Party hold some very strong views on things it was the beatup within the media that prevented any Australian Citizens from attanding the Parliment to actually see the US President in person.

I some how feel that thi swas the intended wish of the current Australian Government who are of the firm opinion "We are here to serve you just don't come near us as we do this"

Then there was all the problems that where introduced by Airforce fighters constantly flying across Cantberra all nigh and keeping everyone including GWB awake. This was one of the best media circusis I've ever seen and they kept refering to these measures being necessary because of "Security Matters."

Now just why is it that the US president is offered better security when he is here in AU for 21 hours than what he gets when he is in his homeland? I am the first to reconise the "Public Statment" that could be made from an attempt on his life while away from home but this was just over kill particuarly when they insisted that AIrforce 1 land in Cantberra that was not only dangerious but completely unnecessary as that airport was never intended for aircraft of that size to arrive there. They are just very lucky that it could land and take off again without incident and if anything had of happened at particuarly take off this would have been far more serrious than the other alternatives and we would see all these splinter groups jumping up and claiming responsibilty for this incident when the reality of the sisutation is that they would have had nothing to do with it and would claim a media victory from any incident that did occure.

Of course the Media would run with the story as it would only serve to increase their revenue, this would be a perfect example of where the truth matters not but the better story we can make up the better off we are.

by jardinier

of Australian politics, you are only confirming what most of the rest of the world asserts, i.e. that many/most Americans believe that the USA is the only country on the planet.

The "liberal" party in Australia is the Australian Labor Party, which was established even before Australia was given a constitution in 1900. Many of our best Prime Ministers have come from the Labor Party.

The conservative party which is named The Liberal Party, was formed in 1949.

Bob Brown, from Tasmania, where conservation is a big issue because of the large amount of unspoiled forest, was the first Greens candidate to be elected to the Senate. At the time, the third largest political party in Australia was the Democrats, which was started by a breakaway member of the Liberal Party, Don Chipp, in order to "keep the bastards honest." Currently the Democrats hold seven seats in the Senate, and the Greens only two.

As for trying to disrupt Bush's speech, the two Greens senators actually did your president a favour by giving him the opportunity to say: "I love free speech," which comment was greeted with applause by the whole parliament.

I wouldn't know if the footage was shown in the US of Senator Bob Brown shaking George Bush's hand outside the House shortly afterwards.

The Labor Party also handed Bush a statement signed by 41 Labor MPs giving the reasons why the Labor Party was not in favour of the war in Iraq.

by road-dog

doesn't know something about the American political system, it's due to whatever reason.

When an American doesn't understand something about Australia's political system, it's due to some belief that our system is the only system, some Americacentrism...

More and more often you let your anti-American viewpoint color your comments to the point where your opinions relating to anything American must be taken with not just a grain of salt, but a metric ton.

I get the impression that if you are stuck in traffic, the delay is America's fault somehow. It must be nice to have an entire nation to blame for all that's wrong in the world. That simplifies matters greatly, doesn't it? It saves you all that tedious consideration....

by maxwell edison

... when you said, "As you are not personally in Iraq, you wouldn't have a clue what the situation is". Julian, you'll get no argument from me on that point. You are absolutely correct.

(I will say this, however. I have a number of military friends, I've served in the military myself for 6 years, so I know the culture, and I live in an area with a very high concentration of military installations; and, for the most part, soldiers are not complaining about how poorly things are going. To the contrary, most of them feel proud to have helped liberate an oppressed nation, they understand that another 9-11 is very possible, and they're proud to do their part - their duty - to help prevent it. This is the exact opposite of what I experienced during the dark days of Vietnam. Sure, there are those who complain, those who say things like, "I didn't join the guard for this", and so on, but in the context of the full history of the military of any nation, some soldiers will always complain. What else is new? But I digress.)

However, to get back on track, you also are not personally in Iraq, and therefore you wouldn't have a clue what the real situation is either. Is that a fair conclusion? So who do you and I believe - and why? Do we believe that things are going well - as well as can be expected - or that they're not? Do we believe that this conflict was right and just or not - and why? You and I are both at the mercy of others, whether they be reporters, soldiers, or whomever, who "report" what's going on. And we hear a wide range of stories. You and I are not unlike the majority of the world's population in that regard.

But I will say this, just as in ANY aspect of life, if a person "looks" for something - good or bad - he'll most likely find it. And if reporters look for bad things to report about the events surrounding Iraq (or anything else, for that matter), they'll undoubtedly find them. But where's the balance? (Reminds me of that old Wendy's commercial - Where's the beef?) Sure, I know that some bad things are happening. But I also know that a lot of good things are happening. Why aren't the good and the bad things BOTH reported? Moreover, why aren't they reported in a proportional way? (One bad thing for every ten good things - or whatever the real proportion is.)

I've always held the position that when it comes to foreign policy, none of us really has a clue. We are not privy to the intelligence data. Even if we were, we're not savvy enough to properly interpret it. (Even some of the "experts" aren't.) We don't sit in on the security briefings. We don't sit in on private meetings with foreign leaders. We are not foreign policy experts. When it comes right down to it, you're right, none of us has a clue.

Therefore what?

Personally speaking, knowing that there are forces in the world who really HATE the United States and its people (including me), and knowing that these forces (people of evil) wish to do us harm (evidence 9-11), and knowing that we are quite vulnerable to future attacks, and knowing that President Bush is an honest and honorable person (there's no evidence to the contrary), and knowing that he's assembled a high-powered, experienced, and balanced foreign policy team (I say balanced because it's generally known that Secretary of State General Colin Powell and Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld are considered to be, shall I say, often at odds with their opinions.), I feel very comfortable with the trust I've placed in this administration. I "hired" this President to act on my behalf and to do what he thinks is best when it comes to matters on which I'm "clueless". Yes, I trust George W. Bush to do the right thing on my behalf and that of my country. But that trust is not blind. I believe that I'm just as informed as most people (maybe more informed), and that my thoughts and actions are well thought-out and based on reason.

You know, I will make an admission here. In the days following September 11th, 2001, I thanked God that George W. Bush was in the White House, and not Al Gore or Bill Clinton. I truly did. Moreover, I've come to believe that "Divine Intervention" had some influence on the closest election in U.S. History.

On a couple of your other points.

The first, I applaud you for listening to President Bush's speech live and in its entirety instead of listening to some analyst tell you what he said and what to think about it. Sure, there will be both those who agree and disagree with him. Sure, there will be both those who have a lot of faith in what he says and those who have little. But for Pete's sake, people should just listen and decide for themselves - like you and I do - and not rely on some analyst to interpret it for them. Or at least get the "beef" - the balance. Hopefully, the worst that will happen is that normal folks like us can respectfully agree to disagree.

The second thing, if I do catch the next plane to Iraq so I can "see for myself", would you be interested in joining me? (So you can see for yourself as well.)

by hal 9000

Only the bad things are reported because no one wants to hear "Good News" the more blood and guts the better.

It is a refelction on our society that this is the case but unfortantly this is the way things are and any attempt to only brodcast "Good News" has always failed.

It appears that there is a culture of only wanting "Bad News" so perhaps this says far more about the society we live in general rather than the Media in particualar.

Otherwise I'm in full agreement with the above statment and my only disapointment is that I couldn't go personally to Cantberra and actually see the guy in the flesh so to speak because once again Parliment House was out of bounds to the General Public and no doubt any of the other places that GWB went on the day.

by road-dog

In any interview there are two agendas.

The interviewee is there to make his point on the issues that he is prepared to speak upon.

The interviewer seeks to make the contact interesting (marketable). Interviewers do this in several ways, by interviewing people who viewers are interested in, by creating or exploiting conflict, or by getting the interviewee to reveal interesting and fresh information.

These two differing objectives place the interviewer in a position where he can prevent the interviewee from accomplishing his objective by taking up all of the allotted time with questions.

Why should the President spend the air time answering hostile and biased questions that in all likelihood will be taken out of context when reported anyway?

Why should the President's speech include what anyone else thinks he should say? He is there to speak his piece, if the press wants to cover the opposing view, why should he help them?

As for traveling to Iraq to get the news first hand, isn't that what the press is for? If reported information is valid enough to damn this President, then it should be valid enough to support him as well. If positive news must be verified with one's own eyes, then doesn't the same apply for the negative?

In other words, take a trip to Iraq or retract your statement. Otherwise, your own arguments are invalidated by your own demand for first hand knowledge.

by hal 9000

If the US President doesn't want to be misquoted by the press which he has a right to believe in just why was it only the press who where allowed to actually be in Parliment house at the time?

Every Australian citizen was barred.

Sure there where some who wanted to cause some trouble but then again there where a lot more who would have liked to see the man in the flesh and where prevented.

After all the main purpose of his trip here was to thank the Australian People for their help in Iraq and he only got to be seen live by the very people who wern't interested in the speach but for political benifit. Sorry mate but I see something wrong here. I for one certianly would have liked to be in the audience that there is room for there but we where all kept away.

So I settled for the only possible alternetive and watched the broadcast but I'm certian that there would have been a far better feeling by being live in the audience rather than sitting at home watching TV.

As far as the going to Iraq stuff I think that I covered that earlier by saying that our society doesn't want to see "Good News" only bad so there was very little coverage when the British forces played soccer with the locals at the height of the conflict and a hell of a lot of "Bad Press" coverage devoted to everything negitive that has been hapening since.

After all a truck carring muninitions blowing up makes far better news fottage than a Soccer game that takes hours we only get at best a 30 second film clip so the media always wants the most impressive shots to fill their valuable time between adverts. Or maybe I'm just to sinical in my old age.

by jimhm

So with all due respect - were has your knowledge of Iraq come from. You are telling people to go there and see for themselfs - How long were you there ... what branch did you serve with - what thearters where you engaged in...

All because someone doesn't believe the Liberal Maxist American press - and does research - talks with those that servered over there - gather information from the internet - and other sources... You condem and demand they go over themselfs ...

So what is your knowledge base from - Live Experence? Liberal press releases? And when someone challenges you to the same - you cry and boohoo - and don't answer where your knowledge of what is going on over there ...

So answer the question ... don't attack the question - answer it - Unless you don't have a knowledge base except for the liberal maxists media...

by jardinier

the American media feeds to you, but in Australia
it is quite easy to get both sides of any situation through the mainstream media. As I run a website, I make it my business to search for different viewpoints. They are not difficult to find. What I choose to publish on the website naturally is inclined to reflect my personal bias, although I try and be as non-partisan as possible. I happen to hate the Howard government for reasons which I will not go into here.

However I am on friendly terms with my local Federal MP, Dr Brendan Nelson (Minister for Education) and my local State MP, Barry O'Farrell (Deputy Leader of the Liberal Opposition). Both know me personally, and are happy to answer any questions which I may address to them via email.

It is a marvelously liberating experience to be my own publisher, and not have to fall in line with the personal agendas of management, ownership and advertisers.

by maxwell edison

President Bush's speech to the Australian Parliament, unedited and in its entirety:

http://tinyurl.com/s1kh

New York Times bias:

Headline: Bush Is Heckled in Australian Parliament

Why not, "Bush is cheered in Australian Parliament"? From reading the actual text of the speech, it sounds as though he was applauded and cheered (Hear Hear) more than he was heckled.

Or, in the very least, "Bush is met with mixed reaction in Australian Parliament" ?

First lines of New York Times' "coverage":

"CANBERRA, Australia (AP) -- Heckled inside and outside Australia's Parliament, President Bush offered a pointed answer to those who say the war with Iraq wasn't worth fighting.``Who can possibly think that the world would be better off with Saddam Hussein still in power?''

(Interesting that Julian cited the same sentence.)

The New York Times was editorializing a news story when they interjected, "a pointed answer to...". Who asked? What was the question? Why the commentary in the middle of a news story? Just give me the facts, and let me decide for myself.

The New York Times made several references early in the story to the "thousands of protestors" who "banged drums and shouted" and "jostled with security officials".

However, it made no reference at all to the fact the many of them (the protestors) were arrested, that they breached the fencing outside the US embassy, that violent elements in the crowd threw metal poles at Australian officers, that an Australian Service officer required medical treatment, that scuffles erupted as protesters tried to break through a police line, or that elements of the crowd were consistently violent towards police.

Gee, it sounds as though the "protestors" were close to creating riot conditions, while the New York Times portrayed them in a much more, shall I say, generous and "peace loving" light.

And the papers around the world pick up on - and stretch even more - the New York Times.

Where's the beef? Where's the balance?

If there's any balance in the Times' story at all, it comes late in the article. Even then, the editorializing is rampant. For example, "Bush failed in his efforts to persuade leaders of both Japan and China to stop artificially valuing their currencies against the dollar." He did? Why, where, what, who? Why did he fail? Who said that he failed? More editorializing when the Times said, "Bush came here from Indonesia where he tried to convince skeptical Islamic leaders that America is not biased against Muslim countries." Which Islamic leader is "skeptical"? Give me just the he said - he said, please.

Yes, there was eventually an attempt on the Times' part to be impartial when they reported (late in the story), "For the most part, Bush was warmly received. Opposition Labor Party leader Simon Crean, in opening remarks, said that differences over Iraq ``strengthen rather than weaken the relationship.''

Well then why didn't the Times make THAT their headline? "Bush was warmly received"?

Because most people read ONLY the headlines and the first few sentences of a story, that's why.

by jardinier

The first link which you posted merely led to a verbatim report of the address (which no doubt was why you said "forget the link" and posted another.) However I found that I had to register to read this item, which I don't feel the need to do. I receive the NYT headlines, with links, in my mailbox each morning. So I will just address your remarks.

Apart from the interjections by the two Greens senators, I considered the whole parliamentary session a masterpiece of diplomacy on all sides. I would agree with Simon Crean's comment: "Simon Crean, in opening remarks, said that differences over Iraq `strengthen rather than weaken the relationship.'"

Now if I were to write an article for publication, of course I would include reference to the protests and interjections, but for the heading I would choose: "President Bush Warmly Welcomed by Australian Parliament."

My leading paragraph would read: "When the president addressed a joint sitting of both houses of the Australian Parliament, introductory speeches by both the Prime Minister, John Howard, and Opposition Leader, Simon Crean, applauded the importance and mutual benefit of the long standing allegiance between the two nations."

And so forth and so forth. Reference to the protests and hecking would be introduced about half-way into the article, to be followed by excerpts from the speeches by Bush, Howard and Crean.

As I'm sure you are all tired of hearing me say, I trained as a journalist on the Sydney Morning Herald in the early 60's when it was a serious and highly respected newspaper. Everyone to whom I speak is appalled by the poor quality of reporting in this newspaper today.

by maxwell edison

...much better than the New York Times' version. (Especially your headline)

As for the links, I intended to post both a verbatim of the speech as posted by the White House AND a link to the New York Times article.

I think it was Colin who said that it's interesting to read - or hear - a live version for yourself, and then read the variations of accounts as reported by others. (I agree.) One might ask, were we all at the same event?

by maxwell edison

Event: The World Will End Tomorrow

---------- Headlines ----------

Wall Street Journal:

The World Will End Tomorrow: Market Reaction Uncertain.

USA Today:

The World Will End Tomorrow: The Poor Hardest Hit.

New York Times:

The World Will End Tomorrow: House Democrats Demand Independent Investigation

Washington Post:

The World Will End Tomorrow: Bush Administration Accused Of Cover-Up

by hal 9000

I was once told by a person in the media that there is no legal responsibility to report the truth in NEWS bullitens they are only required to report along their company lines and this generally comes down from the top and is filtered through the whole chain of comand within that particualar news/media company.

Now understanding thsi I just can't understand why recently in the US the Media Owernship Laws where relaxed as the only way to get some form of fair and unbiased media coverage is to have as many media owners as possible with different political leanings. That way while indivual companies have their own views we would at least get a more orless fair cross section of reporting.

By allowing these media outlets to be owned by only a few indivuals is allowing a vested interest group to run almost all the media coverage within a country.

If they are supporting the existing Government its good for that Government but if they are against the policies of the Government or it could be something as simple as the owners not liking the guy in charge then this is not a good thing for the existing Government.

While I wouldn't go as far as claiming bias by the media I think it is more and example of free enterprise allowed to get out of control and do what is best for them no matter the cost to others.

Incidently this is not something confined to the US but to most of the Westeren World.

by maxwell edison

As far as the implementation, and whose definition of "truly needy" is used, I should say that my principles are more of a wishful mindset rather than the basis on which current policy could be changed. I'm not suggesting a radical change, at least not at this point, as we've come to this apparent social quagmire over the last seventy years. It would probably take another seventy - or more - to reverse the trend, and I don't think I'll see it in my lifetime, but I'm hopeful that my grandchildren (or great-grandchildren) might. But the language has to change and the expectations from government has to change. The view of the government as the sole provider of all one's needs from womb to tomb has to change. To illustrate my point, I'd take you back to 1925. (No, I wasn't alive then.) How different would thing be today if the following mindset was prevalent throughout the last seventy years?

The "chain of command" in taking responsibility:

A person is responsible for him or her self - period. The government (federal, state and local) should indeed be structured to create an environment for equality of opportunity, but equality of outcome can't be considered, as each individual is responsible to take advantage of whatever opportunities are available, and whatever opportunities he or she chooses, so as to determine his or her own outcome. In the event this person, for whatever reason, cannot be responsible for his or her own life, the next in line is:

The family. My mother's grandmother lived with them (in the 1920s and into the 1930s) until the day she died. (Kinda' like the Waltons.) The government wasn't expected to care for her, the family was - just as she cared for her family 40 years prior. If there is no family to care for this person, the next in line is:

Private charities and churches used to provide care for the needy. They were supported by generous people - local people - through voluntary contributions. Care could be provided at a smaller and local scale, more individualized, cheaper, etc. If the churches and charities become overburdened, the next in line is:

The local government. It's silly to assume that the social needs of New York City can be grouped together with the social needs of Salt Lake City and the social needs of Springfield. Sure, some cities might be better at it than others, and the smaller cities would most likely fare much better, but why bring the successful down to the level of the unsuccessful? Trying to find local solutions to local problems make more sense than solving local problems by way of federal legislation a thousand miles away and light years removed. If the locality is overburdened, the next in line is:

The state government. The same theory applies.

By the time it gets to be the problem of the federal government, well, it probably won't - at least it shouldn't. And if it does, the federal government should try to find ways to fix the problems, whatever they may be, and not just treat the symptoms.

The social programs of the 30s started this mess. Even social security wasn't intended as a retirement guarantee, but rather a safety net. (And besides, the life expectancy was not even 65 yrs. in the 30s, but that's when social security kicked in.) From the 30s until today, control of the school systems gradually shifted from full local control to less local control to more federal control. Gee, our school results have been going down respectively. Before the federal government started their "war on poverty", the percentage of people living in poverty had been in a steady decline for six straight decades. Once the feds got involved, it started to increase again. I could go on, but I'm sure you get the idea.

I'm not suggesting that a stop sign be put up on all social programs, but rather a gradual reduction in the speed limit, a reduction that may last another seventy years until responsibility is assumed to fall on the shoulders of the individual, not the federal government. People like you and me are having a harder time taking responsibility for ourselves because of the added responsibility of eing forced to take care of others - others who are perfectly capable of caring for themselves. (I could be retired right now, quite comfortably, if I had invested that $100,000 I've paid into social security up to now - much more than the $2,000 a month it "might" pay me over 15 years from now.)

I know, there are plenty of ways to find holes in this, but is there any doubt that we wouldn't have been better off if we never got on this road to begin with? There has to be a way to turn it around. And one way is to stop adding to it. Stop expecting more from the government and start expecting more from ourselves.

by cactus pete

Please don't think I'm being flippant by responding with so fewer lines. You were well said.

I would like to add one point at this time: The government should not take my money and give it to someone else, even if that 'someone' is a coporation.

by maxwell edison

...what you said?

You said, "The government should not take my money and give it to someone else, even if that 'someone' is a coporation." I agree 100%

But don't confuse taking less money from corporations (lower taxes) with giving them money. Taking less in taxes does not equal "giving" them anything.

Moreover, on the same "corporate" subject, corporations NEVER pay taxes. People pay taxes - in the form of higher prices passed on by corporations who are taxed.

by hal 9000

Forgot about the children. Back in the 30's it was considered that the parents knew what was best for their children and that has gradually shifted to the point where the State or in your case over that side of the pond the Federal Government thinks it knows best and a whole industry has sprung up to support this idea actually a whole lot of GAOvenment Departments rely on this belief and will not easily give up any authority that they have fought had to gain.

Now days however the parent is considered as the last person to know what is best for their child/children and there has been a whole mass of legislation introduced so that the parents now days have no control over their childern but all the responsibility.

Yes we know you can't make your son/daughter attend school but it is your fault that they aren't there so we are going to jail you for this.

Unfortantly this is the current thinking and most parents now days live in fear of what their children might say when they are out of the house at school where they are constantly told their rights but never their responsibilities.

The next logical step is to remove every child once it is born and place them into Government run facalities where no one has any control but at least the parents are no longer held responsible for actions that they have no control over.

While this won't happen in my lifetime if things continue the way they are going this will eventually happen and then we will be placed in the position of not only having to support our aging members of the comunity but also the young members of the comunity making the tax burden even heaver than what it currently is. Not to mention the fact that we currently have an aging community so eventually these few children will be responsible for the care of all the aged people this is when the whole system will collaspe under the weight of numbers that it has created for itself.

But luckely you and I won't be around to see this happen.

by cactus pete

That's a pretty easy dot to connect, of course. But I was leaning more towards subsidies and tariffs.

by mrbill-

"That's a pretty easy dot to connect, of course. But I was leaning more towards subsidies and tariffs."

So who would pay for those subsidies and tariffs?

Would the subsidies come from tax revenues? The Tariffs would be covered by higher consumer prices.

by cactus pete

Ultimately, yes, all money comes from my wallet. (tm)

Tariffs are like subsidies in that they artificially increase the price of a domestic item. The subsidy takes money from me directly, and gives it to a company. The tariff takes money from me indirectly and gives it to an industry.

by oz_media

I feel that most if not all media is biased in one way or another. Even the most straight up news stories often exclude pertinent facts due to time or interest restrictions.

I don't feel that this stops with merely Hollywood's depictions and the reporters. If we are RAISED in a world full of one sided stories and half truths, it takes an extremely strong and individualistic person to learn to do otherwise.
I feel this form of 'constructed reporting of facts' is seen in all aspects of life and in all people, obviously not to the "Enquirer" extreme.

I see this in the News, the newspapers, political debate and YES even the government.

We are told what's best for us to hear, we are told what conforts us in our homes, we are told what we WANT to hear. they say bad news sells, perhaps that's because we WANT bad news, we WANT to see others suffer under our pressures out of a human need for self assurance and security.

Once we are happy as humans, we no longer need this form of 'entertainment' as it is no longer amusing or entertaining to see loss and hardships.

I feel that ideally the world's citizens should learn to respect themselves so we can learn to respect one another and eventually live in peace.

It is the unsure and self concious that fuel the need for hatred and give it a home to dwell in.

After all, isn't that why the school bully picks on the happy kids?

by hal 9000

That position right now and with the aid of the media driven poltics I think we are getting further away every day.

I think it interesting the positive reporting that occurs when the press portray someone "As a Man of Action" who gets things done. But at the same time will discredit anyone who works slowely behind the scenes and gets results that benifit all man kind.

Actually before anyone here jumps on me I am in no way talking of any particular people here or for than matter anyone connected with any political party but only in general terms and even then across the board.

by oz_media

Don't worry, someone will FIND a way to take your comments out of context. It's human nature, and bad reporting. :-P

by jardinier

from a bigot, I regard as a compliment. As for my being anti-American, that is simply not true. I may not like your current administration, but then I guess a significant proportion of the citizens of the USA don't like it either. Democracy was not invented by Americans, in case you were unaware.

I go into some detail explaining how the political system in Australia functions, usually because I am asked to by some American who posts to this website. I don't recall ever saying that I consider it better than the American system. It is, however, a different system and one which, in my experience, works rather well.

If you read anti-Americanism into my postings, as far as I am concerned it only reveals your paranoia.

by road-dog

I have never asserted that the US invented democracy, nor that it was in any way superior to Australia's version. Where did that one come from?

I really suspect that you attribute a lot of prejudices and ignorances to Americans that are unjustified. Further, you often paint the US with a pretty wide brush.

I propose a little academic exercise. When throwing out terms like "a lot", "most", and "many", try to pin down an estimate in percentages. I will do so also. This will prompt an informal "poll" of that country's members here. We may find that some of our observations are really generalizations.

Bush is a polarizing figure here, as was Clinton. There is a HUGE clash of ideas tied up in our national elections. The division is tight, with both sides being separated by a single percentage point in 2000. This being the case, it's hardly justifiable for you to use descriptions like "most" in describing us (US).

by jardinier

When your President's speech to the combined parliament was interrupted by the two Greens senators, he remarked with a smile: "I love free speech."

So if your president can accept criticism by at least two Australians, (actually of course there were many more involved in protests at a safe distance from Parliament House) then perhaps you might consider following his example.

As for generalisations, of course it is impossible for me, or anyone else, to calculate in percentage terms how many people hold a certain view. I couldn't possibly tell you what percentage of Australians like or dislike Bush. So I am learning to use phrases like some/many/most to cover all possibilities.

Anyhow as you seemed determined to prove that I make false or inaccurate generalisations, I can't see any point in taking this discussion any further.

I will continue to post to the discussions on this website, so I suggest that you don't read any postings by jul646@aol.com if you find my views offensive/inaccurate/biased or whatever.

by jimhm

The Mini-Series about Ronald Reagan's presidency and AID's support is so Bias against what was the truth - The US should boycott CBS for 2 months. No Sit-com's - No New's - Nothing. Let that hit the Nelson's rating and see what that company does...

BOYCOTT CBS - THERE HAS TO BE TRUTH IN THE MEDIA NOT BIAS - IN EITHER DIRECTION.

by maxwell edison

I have a mixed feeling about CBS in general. On one hand, they broadcast the likes of Dan Rather - one of the liberal poster boys, and they (plan to) show a movie that falsely characterizes and defames Ronald Reagan.

But on the other hand, CBS has been the network that airs the most "family-friendly" and "morally straight" shows. (Not a lot of them, but at least more than the other 3 major networks.)

I remember several years back when CBS was first planning to cancel "Touched By An Angel", and the viewers wrote CBS in hoards asking them to reconsider. CBS did indeed reconsider, and the series was aired for a couple of more years. (It's since been canceled, however.) So letter writing can make a difference. But in the case of this Reagan movie, as much as it rubs me the wrong way, it's probably a done deal.

Maybe some Hollywood producer will make a movie showing how Franklin Roosevelt and/or Lyndon Johnson ruined this country with their socialist ideas. Maybe pigs will learn to fly.

by hal 9000

Sentance is a Oxymoron. We all know the only reason why anything is made for any reason no matter what it is aimed at it is to sell advertising slots for as much money as you can get. {Well in this case "You" means the TV networks.}

There has never been any obligation to present the truth or any sembelence of it only something that will sell adverts. If you really want to look back at just how bad things where look at the depction of Bonny & Clyde the TV movie bore very lttle resemblance to the real people did it?

Just why do you think things would be different now days? Personally I wouldn't be at all surprised to see some one that looks like Tom Cruse playing Ronald and some young preety Starlett playing his wife and that is when he was the US President. We just will not them protrayed as "Old" people.

by road-dog

That Fox news is shaped by Mr. Murdoch? Is the "conservative" "slant" of Fox news an extension of the overall culture of the Australian?

Would you say that the creation of Fox News is an attempt to play politics in another arena, or a marketing decision to fill a void? If this is the case, he did it very well.

How big a role does his personal views and ambitions play in the shaping of the network's coverage? I really cannot make a determination, as with most companies, the bigger they get, the less of a hand the owner had in shaping the culture, through dilution at middle management levels. His personality would probably be more pronounced at the Australian....

Is there a disconnect between the company and the man?

by hal 9000

He has been known to fire people for writing what he doesn't like so he has a fairly firm hand on the tiller of any business that he owns despite what he said to the {was it Congressional} Hearing on Media Ownership.

He is like a mini "Hitler" wants to run the world but without the adverse side effects.

I do believe that one time in one of the news papers that he owns he demanded that the whole print run be recycled and the typesetting redone just to get rid of a minor story towards the back of the newspaper.

While he certianly wouldn't have that kind of "Hands On" ability now he sure as hell would get rid of anyone who published something that he didn't like or where against his personal ideals.

Actually Robert has never made any secret of the fact that he wants to dominate the world media and with FOx he has made a fairly good start particuarly when it is considered what he still controls over here as well.

by john_wills

During the 1960s a story appeared on the front pages of many newspapers about Portuguese soldiers massacring a village in Mozambique. There was follow-up for quite a while, and there can be no doubt that the story was important in ensuring that Mozambique came to "independence" under a dictatorship, which, I understand, erected a monument on the site of the massacre. Then the story turned out to have been a lie, invented by lefties in London. But that just made a small paragraph on the inside pages.

Shortly after the Iranian revolution a synagogue got bombed. The Zionists used this to encourage aliyah and generally to get sympathy. Eventually it turned out that the bombs had been planted by Zionist agents. Again, the let-down got a small notice on the inside pages.

At his trial in Jerusalem, Adolf Eichmann stated that a main reason for his 1937 Palestine trip had been to meet the Mufti of Jerusalem. This is still quite often repeated. The trip report was captured by U.S. forces in Berlin after WW II, and copies are available for about $20 from US National Archives. Not only is there no mention of the Mufti, there is a description of a friendly meeting with a Zionist agent named Polkehns, who imparted useful information abut the German resistance. Somehow the press when quoting Eichmann at his trial always omits to refer to the trip report. Indeed, it was only in reading an academic journal and then obtaining the trip report that I found out: it just doesn't get into the ordinary media.

In all these cases the media were fooled, not initially dishonest. But they have been dishonest in giving the let-downs less space than the original stories. This has nothing to do with pseudoliberal or quasiconservative bias, it is more to do with failure to admit a mistake and investigate the origins of the mistake.

by hal 9000

Thow Shall not get caught!

And even if you do get get caught and are forced to print a retraction then it is made in the most obscure place possible and hopefully the opposing media will not get hold of the story that you had exclusive rights to and hound you down.

I think the same thing happened with the so called "Hitler Diaries" in the UK a few years ago didn't it?

by maxwell edison

From The Drudge Report:

Former first lady Nancy Reagan has reached out to Hollywood heavyweights, including Merv Griffin, to somehow stop an upcoming CBS-TV movie about her life and times with Ronald Reagan.

A concerned legal department at CBS repeatedly called producers of the upcoming miniseries THE REAGANS, during filming, looking for assurances that shocking claims made in the telefilm could be backed up, productions sources tell the DRUDGE REPORT. Irritated producers reminded the network they had already cleared the script, with few notes!

THE REAGANS is now at the center of a media and political firestorm.

Insinuations that Nancy pill-popped are scattered throughout the story, as are repeated allegations that Ronald Reagan was homophobic, and was suffering from Alzheimer's disease as early as 1984. [Nancy rushes to a doctor to warn that her husband is forgetting things.]

Actress Judy Davis's portrayal of Nancy Reagan appears to be inspired by the Joan Crawford camp biopic MOMMIE DEAREST; wild mood swings, dramatic lighting, and tart-mouth insults are hysterically delivered by Davis.

[The showcase line "Ketchup is a vegetable! It is not a meat, right? So IT IS a vegetable" is likely to become the "No wire hangers ever!" camp highlight of the season.]

One camp scene shows Nancy and Ron both standing nude [wrapped in towels] when they first learn from NBC's John Chancellor they have won the election.

Pages 32, 33 of script:

INT. REAGANS' HOUSE -- PACIFIC PALISADES -- DAY

A FILM CREW is swarming all over the living room, setting up lights, cameras, etc. Reagan sits in the middle, putting on his own make-up.

INT. UPSTAIRS -- PATTI'S BEDROOM

Nancy arguing with Patti, (age 5), who won't come down.

NANCY: Come on, Patti. They're all set to go.

PATTI: No. I won't. I want to stay up here and play.

Nancy grits her teeth, and takes Patti by the wrist.

NANCY: No arguing. We're going down, right now.

PATTI: No! No! No! No! NO! NO!

Nancy reaches out, and slaps Patti. Patti reels, holding her cheek. Nancy

freezes.

*** Nancy is shown talking with her own mother in one flashback.

Page 16 of script:

NANCY'S STEP-FATHER: Nancy, I don't know what you see in Hollywood. As far as I can tell, it's nothing but Communists and drug addicts.

NANCY: It didn't used to be this bad -- did it, Mother?

NANCY'S MOTHER, EDITH: Hell, no. When I was here, it was just wall-to-wall Jews and queers.

****

President Reagan, played by James Brolin, is shown cursing his staff during one Oval Office meeting.

Pages. 152 of script:

REAGAN: "Rank amateur"! Who does that sonofabitch think he is? I'm the goddam President of the United States, I'm his boss!

****

Lawyers for CBS have growing concern that few of the most-intimate scenes created for THE REAGANS have much historical documentation or on-the-record witness corroboration.

Complicating matters is the film's charge that Reagan believed AIDS was biblical revenge -- as actor James Brolin finds his family in a real-life fight with the disease!

An immediate member of the Brolin/Streisand family is currently suffering from HIV, according to press reports.

During a scene in the film which his wife pleads with him to help people battling AIDS, Reagan says resolutely, "They that live in sin shall die in sin" and refuses to discuss the issue further.

Actor Brolin delivers the uncorroborated words with extra confidence.

In 1992, Streisand wrote an essay condemning Reagan over AIDS:

"I will never forgive my fellow actor Ronald Reagan for his refusal to even utter the word AIDS for seven years, and for blocking adequate funding for research and education, which could have saved hundreds of thousands of lives. Then came George Bush, once the moderate, who, in a Faustian bargain, allied himself with the same primitive, gay-bashing, immoral minority."

Streisand, who spent weeks on the set of THE REAGANS, did not return calls seeking comment.

Developing...

by jimhm

Maybe the answer to this media BS - is to let CBS air the Reagan's - then Ronnie and Nancy suite CBS for every penny it has. Then have CBS air 24 stright hours of retractions - no other programming -

Yea - maybe hitting in the bottomline and bonus's will change their bias views..

by hal 9000

It sounds like the normal crock of Sh1t that is usuall from this kind of place particuarly when it is susposed to be about real people.

The truth of the matter is that the true story wouldn't get any attention so to spice it up a bit and sell more adds they use "Potetic Licence" to make the characters more "REAL" that actually means more controversial so we get better press and if we can manage to get the real people off side well so much the better as this will give us millions of dollars of free publicity.

Sorry guys but this is only the usual crap that spews out of this industry by the boat load.

by maxwell edison

I certainly understand when films take some, shall I say, "artistic liberties" to make a story exciting or, as you say, "spice it up a bit". For example, when I was a kid we thought that John Wayne not only tamed the American Wild West all by himself, but he also single-handedly won WWII in the cockpit of his Flying Tiger.

But this film takes artistic liberty to a new low. In fact, it threw artistic liberty out the window in favor of artistic fantasy - artistic slander.

This is an attempt to smear the memory of an American President and turn the public against him and the things he believed. This is worse than a political smear campaign. This is probably the most shameful thing I've ever seen come out of Hollywood. Moreover, CBS has shrunk to a new low by contracting to broadcast it.

I really am at a loss for words to describe how deplorable this really is.

by hal 9000

The next time I'm stuck in traffic I'll just blame it all on the "Yanks" after all wasn't it one of them that started the production line?

So evert traffic jam must follow directly from Henery Ford's decision to build cars differently to all previous ways where one group of people built the car from the ground up from parts, now of course they only fit a few bolts or what ever where a robot can't do the job So I'll take great pleasure in blaming the "Yanks" from now on for every problem that I ever have.

"If only I could!"

Actually however Bob Brown got quite a bit of stick in the press the following day and on things like talkback radio and TV he was given hell for his "bad manners" and as punishment they locked him and his cohort out of Parliment when the Chinese Premier took the same place as the US President only this time Australians where allowed in to see what went on.

I really don't want to start a fight here over someone's particuarly bad manners but honestly this was the best behaved sitting of Parliment that I've ever seen as just about everyone behaved themselves normally it is like a group of children in preschool fighting over who has the bucket and spade in the sand pit.

I don't know what its like in your neck of the woods but from the very little that I've seen on this I thought Bob Browns actions only made GWB look far better than if he had been left alone to finish his speach uninterupted. In my eyes he certianly came out looking far the better for this action as he remained unflusted and hardly broke stride.

However the media beat up after the event was a perfect example of what Maxwell was originally complaining about. In this case the Media took something positive for the US President and turned it into a negative event.

But that is what sells adds and they had to find something to fill the holes that are left when they can't run their precious adds. Most people are under the mistaked belief that this is susposed to be a news time when in actual fact it is prime advertisment time.

by hal 9000

But Max you forgot one of the IT publications

The World Will End Tomorrow: Microst to stop making software and cripple all of their existing products.

You can chose the publication.

by road-dog

and this results in apathy and mistrust on the part of citizens and voters; but not for lack of entertainment value.

In our government, people who you KNOW can't stand eachother, who trash eachother personally when in public appearances separately will grip and grin when seen together. There's an inherent dishonesty in that.

When politician B lies about an agenda or quote of politician A, the press inevitably asks "how do you react to that? I'd love to hear a politician A reply; "I don't react at all, he's a lying scumbag and if this were 1790, I'd challenge his dishonorable ass to a duel, and let my pistol reply for me".

False gentility is still a lie. It's a basic two facedness that most folks cannot stand.

Personally, the rancor of British and Australian politics is refreshing to me. If it's worth saying, it's worth saying directly....with insult if the situation dictates.

by maxwell edison

"Everything I have read and heard about "The Reagan's" is that it is a madeup character assasination piece meant to discredit one of the greatest president's this nation has ever had.

I will boycott CBS, it's affiliates, and any companies that advertise during the broadcast should they choose to air this vile piece of crap."

----------

"I will boycott any advertiser that would pay CBS to play this movie! This man is on his death bed! I am a Democrat that voted both times for Reagan. If this movie goes through...CBS WILL HURT in ratings! CBS must think that they are too big to be hurt. It is up to the American people to show them different. I promise if this movie plays...I will block CBS from my TV and boycott the advertisers! The advertisers need to be warned..they will be boycotted!! What has happened to simple niceness. Who would make-up lies on a man who is on his death bed?! Who would make Mrs. Reagan act like Joan Crawford?! This is so disgraceful!"

----------

"Count my family in on the boycott. I am so sick of Hollywood trying to bully people into sharing their warped opinion of the world. Just because Hollywood declares something to be so, that doesn't make it so. The Reagan family, not just Ronald, deserves better than to have their lives distorted for the sick pleasure of people who can't find anything valuable to say about their own lives so they trash the lives of good people.

It is time for the silent majority to speak up and take a stand against Hollywood propaganda. It has gone on for years now and has caused significant harm to our country and to our families.

If you haven't read the scripts, go search the net for them. They are out there and the lies are blatant.

Even James Brolin expressed gleefully in an interview how he at first didn't want to take the role of Reagan but his wife, Barbara Streisand encouraged him to just read the script before he decided. When he read the script he started to laugh and realized it would be fun to portray Reagan in this manner.

Really funny isn't it? To smear someone's life deliberately and maliciously and then publicly laugh about it. What arrogance."

----------

"Isn't it remarkable that every November Hollyweird, major networks and PBS seem to air negative Replublican/conservative political shows? Gee, do you think they might have an agenda?"

----------

"Count me in on the boycott of the network as well as the advertisersers. Hollywood has gone too far, CBS has gone too far.The Reagan family has suffered enough with his illness; Americans have suffered enough with all the propaganda that comes from Hollywood. I am sick of hearing about Freedom of Speach and turning the channel when smut and lies are constantly shoved down my throat. I pay the same price for cable tv and to see a movie as anyone else; darn shame I can't find anything to watch."

----------

"CBS, Moonves and any sponsors of this re-write of history are doomed. I think the people will see thru this tripe. They should wake up and stop cramming their view of the world down the public's eyeballs."

----------

"Many people who watch a mini series like this for what ever reason will accept the information portrayed as fact. This is just more of the Hollywood liberals wanting to rewrite history. They have to attack a great president like this, and all the things he did for this country.
I will be amoung the many who will boycott CBS."

----------

"How can we find out the advvertisers ahead of time so that we can start a boycott campaign and hopefully stop this piece of crap before it is aired?"

----------

"Go to the CBS website and look for their advertisers. Then go to the advertisers website and use their feedback options to them them know you will boycott them. American Express is one of the big sponsers."

----------

" will not waste my time watching CBS try to rewrite history in order to try to draw an audience for sweeps and to help democrats. President Reagan is still alive and his illness should be respected.

As a matter of fact, I will not watch CBS again. Fox is the place for me."

by oz_media

From what I understand, this movie will be tasteless. If so, I don't think it will justify Reagan's work.

One thing I do find amusing, people (nobody's) actually saying that they will Boycott CBS.
There seem to ba a few who have stated this and also feel it will hurt CBS.

I find that usually people like this have NO IDEA how big of a corporation CBS really is. Even if 1000 people decided NOT to watch the movie, do you really think that CBS will even notice?

Normal changes throughout an hour TV show will be in the tens of thousand to millions as people tune in, change channels, surf etc.

I'm afraid it's gonna take a little more than a few people not watching to effect CBS.

by hal 9000

That with our current society junk like this is believed because no-one wants to actualy read the true story or research the person/people in question after its easier to view a movie and believe everything in it.

Just think haw damaging thi swill become after CBS has finished with it and realeased it on vedio it will get wide spread attention and viewing and worse still be believed.

The problem won't come with the current generations of people around the world who remember the Person when he was head of the US but will come latter on when students study their history instead of reading the facts and making their own conclusions they will just rent the vedio and view that and work from it as "fact." Now while I'm not the slighest bit political I do really object to things like this where the truth is taken and thrown out the window and in place something that will hopefully improve rattings is inserted parhaps it is things like thsi that go to show just where the failings with a "Free Market" actually are because with all our susposed enlightment we are still capable of producing junk like this.

All I can say is come on the Osbornes at least that is entermainment and not intended to be serrious.

by jardinier

As the population of the USA is close to 300,000,000 I think I can safely say that I am not particularly enamored of a at least 0.000,000,003 per cent of the population.

by hal 9000

A book of quotes and I saw this one which I think says it all about theis whole discussion.

An oligarchy of private capital... cannot be effectively checked even by a democratically organized political society (because) under existing conditions, private capitalists inevitably control, directly or indirectly, the main sources of information.

Albert Einstein

Now call me crazy but hasn't god old Uncle ALbert said here a very long time ago what everyone is complaining about today?

by john_wills

If Einstein was right on this matter, we do not have an oligarchy of private capital in the world today. I get quite different ideas from the SF Chronicle and the Economist. Among the free newspapers available in SF are those of several communist parties (they all seem to hate each other). For a dollar a month I get the Street Sheet, which is certainly not kind to the private capitalists who own a lot of rental accomodation in SF. Those with time to read an extra magazine have a wide variety of choice: Ms, Mother Jones, Utne Reader, I think a revived Saturday Evening Post is still around. The Economist is a liberal newsmagazine, but I occasionally look at Der Spiegel, which is socialist, and there are lots of other newsmagazines. If I have time to read an academic magazine I may find new insights on the things I read. Now, can anyone tell me what I should read insted of Scientific American, which in the last couple of decades has gone lite on science while evolving from Nineteenth-Century Village Atheist to Secular Inhumanist in its editorial policy, so that I no longer trust it?

This discussion is closed to new replies.