Discussion Locked

Palm OS Treo or Windows Mobile Treo for corporate users?

0 helpful
3 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

At a September 2005 news conference, Palm, Microsoft, and Verizon announced the January 2006 launch of a new Palm Treo running Windows Mobile 5.0. While Palm stated their continued development of new Palm OS devices, this pairing of one-time rivals could signal the demise of the Palm OS.

TechRepublic news article: https://www.techrepublic.com.com/2100-1035_11-5879443.html

The TechRepublic poll question for the week of 10/3/2005 is "If given a choice between a Palm Treo smart phone running Palm OS and the same Treo running Windows Mobile, which would you give your corporate users?"

Let us know which Treo OS you chose and why. Or, if there's a different smart phone option that you would choose, name that device and explain why it's better for corporate users.

3 replies

by firstpeter

Personally, and I'll extend this to corporate in a minute, I'd pick the Palm version. It's simple, it's sleek, and it's significantly less of a battery-hog than WM 5.0.

The latter one is my biggest issue. I can get a good two days of normal activities on my Treo before I have to recharge. If the battery life of a WM version mimics the comparison between current Palm & Pocket PC phones then that would indicate I'd get about 3 hours (okay, I jest, but certainly not much more than a day) of life with a WM version of the phone. Not going to happen.

On to corporate. That's a tough one. My experience is that it's a lot easier to program for WM because we have a background in PPC development. Because of that it would be, theoretically, easier to extend some of our applications to the new environment instead of porting them to Palm. WM is also more robust (or so I hear, anyway) than Palm is, so that helps.

Assuming comparable pricing, I would have to consider the WM one at the moment for a corporate rollout. Maybe with the added cost of some car chargers for folks to make sure I don't get death threats from the road warriors.

by apotheon

Define "more robust" for me so that it applies to Windows Mobility over PalmOS. My experience is that it's more bloated, perhaps, and a little crashy. That's sorta the opposite of "robust", in my book.

You could always just change hardware platforms altogether, and go with the Sharp Zaurus. It uses embedded Linux with a Java environment, so that very little (comparatively) is involved in porting software from other unices, particular other Linuxen.

by drafferty

As a company that provides technical support and troubleshooting for both Palm and PPC and a Treo 650 user this is a no brainer. I would stick with the Palm OS. Things that you take for granted in Palm need regedits to make them available in WM. OOOH that's scary The next issues has already been stated and that is overhead. WM is a hog. The current 650 already has limited memory so would probably need significantly more to run WM. Many IT departments make WM decisions because they are familiar with Windows. Sounds logical. By comparison WM is more like Windows 98 then newer versions. That said, there are apps that only run on WM and therefore justifies that decision. Regardless of OS the device is outstanding as a converged device. Add the Enfora WiFi sled and it is the best of all worlds in corporate America.Using options like Good email, it should be considered before products like RIM.

This discussion is closed to new replies.