Discussion Locked

President Bush - A Profile in Courage

0 helpful
281 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

.
This President put his political life on the line to do what four of his predecessors didn't do, but should have done. Add a chapter to Profiles In Courage for President George W. Bush.

How 9-11 Happened
by Ann Coulter

We don't need a "commission" to find out how 9-11 happened. The truth is in the timeline:

President Carter, Democrat:

In 1979, President Jimmy Carter allowed the Shah of Iran to be deposed by a mob of Islamic fanatics. A few months later, Muslims stormed the U.S. Embassy in Iran and took American Embassy staff hostage.

Carter retaliated by canceling Iranian visas. He eventually ordered a disastrous and humiliating rescue attempt, crashing helicopters in the desert.

President Reagan, Republican:

The day of Reagan's inauguration, the hostages were released.

In 1982, the U.S. Embassy in Beirut was bombed by Muslim extremists.

President Reagan sent U.S. Marines to Beirut.

In 1983, the U.S. Marine barracks in Beirut were blown up by Muslim extremists.

Reagan said the U.S. would not surrender, but Democrats threw a hissy fit, introducing a resolution demanding that our troops be withdrawn. Reagan caved in to Democrat caterwauling in an election year and withdrew our troops -- bombing Syrian-controlled areas on the way out. Democrats complained about that, too.

In 1985 an Italian cruise ship, the Achille Lauro, was seized and a 69-year-old American was shot and thrown overboard by Muslim extremists.

Reagan ordered a heart-stopping mission to capture the hijackers after "the allies" promised them safe passage. In a daring operation, American fighter pilots captured the hijackers and turned them over to the Italians -- who then released them to safe harbor in Iraq.

On April 5, 1986, a West Berlin discotheque frequented by U.S. servicemen was bombed by Muslim extremists from the Libyan Embassy in East Berlin, killing an American.

Ten days later, Reagan bombed Libya, despite our dear ally France's refusing the use of their airspace. Americans bombed Qaddafi's residence, killing his daughter, and dropped a bomb on the French Embassy "by mistake."

Reagan also stoked a long, bloody war between heinous regimes in Iran and Iraq. All this was while winning a final victory over Soviet totalitarianism.

President Bush I, Moderate Republican:

In December 1988, a passenger jet, Pan Am Flight 103, was bombed over Lockerbie, Scotland, by Muslim extremists.

President-elect George Bush claimed he would continue Reagan's policy of retaliating against terrorism, but did not. Without Reagan to gin her up, even Prime Minister Margaret Thatcher went wobbly, saying there would be no revenge for the bombing.

In 1990, Saddam Hussein invaded Kuwait.

In early 1991, Bush went to war with Iraq. A majority of Democrats opposed the war, and later complained that Bush didn't "finish off the job" with Saddam.

President Bill Clinton, Democrat

In February 1993, the World Trade Center was bombed by Muslim fanatics, killing five people and injuring hundreds.

Clinton did nothing.

In October 1993, 18 American troops were killed in a savage firefight in Somalia. The body of one American was dragged through the streets of Mogadishu as the Somalian hordes cheered.

Clinton responded by calling off the hunt for Mohammed Farrah Aidid and ordering our troops home. Osama bin Laden later told ABC News: "The youth ... realized more than before that the American soldier was a paper tiger and after a few blows ran in defeat."

In November 1995, five Americans were killed and 30 wounded by a car bomb in Saudi Arabia set by Muslim extremists.

Clinton did nothing.

In June 1996, a U.S. Air Force housing complex in Saudi Arabia was bombed by Muslim extremists.

Clinton did nothing.

Months later, Saddam attacked the Kurdish-controlled city of Erbil.

Clinton lobbed some bombs into Iraq hundreds of miles from Saddam's forces.

In November 1997, Iraq refused to allow U.N. weapons inspectors to do their jobs and threatened to shoot down a U.S. U-2 spy plane.

Clinton did nothing.

In February 1998, Clinton threatened to bomb Iraq, but called it off when the United Nations said no.

On Aug. 7, 1998, U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania were bombed by Muslim extremists.

Clinton did nothing.

On August 20, Monica Lewinsky appeared for the second time to testify before the grand jury.

Clinton responded by bombing Afghanistan and Sudan, severely damaging a camel and an aspirin factory.

On December 16, the House of Representatives prepared to impeach Clinton the next day.

Clinton retaliated by ordering major air strikes against Iraq, described by The New York Times as "by far the largest military action in Iraq since the end of the Gulf War in 1991."

The only time Clinton decided to go to war with anyone in the vicinity of Muslim fanatics was in 1999 -- when Clinton attacked Serbians who were fighting Islamic fanatics.

In October 2000, our warship, the USS Cole, was attacked by Muslim extremists.

Clinton did nothing.

President George Bush, Republican:

Bush came into office telling his national security adviser, Condoleezza Rice, he was "tired of swatting flies" -- he wanted to eliminate al Qaeda.

On Sept. 11, 2001, when Bush had been in office for barely seven months, 3,000 Americans were murdered in a savage terrorist attack on U.S. soil by Muslim extremists.

Since then, Bush has won two wars against countries that harbored Muslim fanatics, captured Saddam Hussein, immobilized Osama bin Laden, destroyed al Qaeda's base, and begun to create the only functioning democracy in the Middle East other than Israel. Democrats opposed it all -- except their phony support for war with Afghanistan, which they immediately complained about and said would be a Vietnam quagmire. And now Democrats claim to be outraged that in the months before 9-11, Bush did not do the very things the Democrats opposed doing after 9-11.

What a surprise.

281 replies

by maxwell edison

.
(Confirmed to be authentic - I blocked out his name)

This is a letter from *** ********, a medic in the Iowa Army National Guard, serving in Iraq:

As I head off to Baghdad for the final weeks of my stay in Iraq, I wanted to say thanks to all of you who did not believe the media. They have done a very poor job of covering everything that has happened. I am sorry that I have not been able to visit all of you during my two week leave back home. And just so you can rest at night knowing something is happening in Iraq that is noteworthy, I thought I would pass this on to you. This is the list of things that has happened in Iraq recently:

(Please share it with your friends and compare it to the version that your paper is producing.)

* Over 400,000 kids have up-to-date immunizations.
* School attendance is up 80% from levels before the war.
* Over 1,500 schools have been renovated and rid of the weapons stored there so education can occur.
* The port of Uhm Qasar was renovated so grain can be off-loaded from ships faster.
* The country had its first 2 billion barrel export of oil in August.
* Over 4.5 million people have clean drinking water for the first time ever in Iraq.
* The country now receives 2 times the electrical power it did before the war.
* 100% of the hospitals are open and fully staffed, compared to 35% before the war.
* Elections are taking place in every major city, and city councils are in place.
* Sewer and water lines are installed in every major city.
* Over 60,000 police are patrolling the streets.
* Over 100,000 Iraqi civil defense police are securing the country.
* Over 80,000 Iraqi soldiers are patrolling the streets side by side with US soldiers.
* Over 400,000 people have telephones for the first time ever.
* Students are taught field sanitation and hand washing techniques to prevent the spread of germs.
* An interim constitution has been signed.
* Girls are allowed to attend school.
* Textbooks that don't mention Saddam are in the schools for the first time in 30 years.

Don't believe for one second that these people do not want us there. I have met many, many people from Iraq that want us there, and in a bad way. They say they will never see the freedoms we talk about but they hope their children will. We are doing a good job in Iraq and I challenge anyone, anywhere to dispute me on these facts. So If you happen to run into John Kerry, be sure to give him my email address and send him to Denison, Iowa. This soldier will set him straight. If you are like me and very disgusted with how this period of rebuilding has been portrayed, e-mail this to a friend and let them know there are good things happening.

*** ********, SFC
Iowa Army National Guard
234th Signal Battalion"

by nd_it

This is exactly what my brother told us when we talked with him on the phone or he wrote in e-mails. He just recently returned home from Iraq and said that the people were very grateful for the things that they did. These insurgents are just a few "bad apples" that are spoiling it for the rest of the millions of Iraqi people who have an improved life now that Saddam is gone. I agree that we have many problems here at home we need to solve, but we can't ignore the rest of the world either. "Love thy neighbor as yourself". How many more Iraqi's would have died because of improper medical facilities, no immunizations, contaminated drinking water. These are things that we take for granted everyday, but these people are starting to experience this for the first time and are very gratefull for it. These type of stories are boring for the media to put on the front page, but when we drop bombs or start shooting, nothing ever good comes out of it from the media standpoint.

by oz_media

I don't think anyone has ever said that the US was not rebuilding a downtrodden country.
That was also never the issue though, nor the reason for conflict,nor the reason so many are against the war. IN fact, I think that's the only part of this invasion people DO agree on and feel positive about.

Lets just not forget WHY they were sent there in the first place. To protect America from Saddam, NOT to protect Iraqi's from Saddam, America. Just because you manage to lick your wounds well
and try to save face by ignoring the initial issues and reasons for the invasion, doesn'y mean it goes away. We were all here watching everyone saying how we would let our children die and how you are saving your families lives, and the ever popular Texas based Marine saying that we don't care about or families and would let them burn. Remember ? "help it burns it burns!".

These strongly supported comments and the people who made them have been not-surprisingly absent from TR for the last 6 to 8 months for wome reason.

Do they represent mainstream or 'common' America or do you? Somehoe I would say that you are far more politically educated than the majority of US citizens, you take a great pride in your research and facts, even though I often call them slanted, even if one sided you seem to have a firm conviction and knowledge of your stand that would surpass most, including some of your soldiers opinions.

So all in all, great job at helping Iraq rebuild. Thank you for helping and educating children. You did a fine job at capturing Saddam. Kudos to America, you guys really rock.

It's just too bad that your president didn't sell his objectives that way, it would have probably been supported by ALL, except US ctizens. Why should we die for them?

Well, you died for your own families instead, although not threatened. But you did do some good too. If I was you, I would oust the misguided president and find someone who wants to help America help others, not kill them out of fear.

by nd_it

The topic of the rebuiling process has never been debated because I think most will agree that there is improvement in the Iraqi's way of life. You are right that the reason the US did you into Iraq was because they felt Saddam proposed a threat to the US. I do think he was a threat to his own people though. He has killed thousands of Kurds with chemical weapons and I believe he only did things to benefit himself, not his people, thus resulting in the poor quality of life of the Iraqi's. Do I think that he had WMD? Honestly I don't know, and there is a lot of speculation on whether the information was correct or incorrect on WMD. I don't know what to believe, since what I see from the media is Repulicans and Democrats at each other's throats over who is too blame for 9/11 and throw a presidential campaign in, and you have political chaos. I am neither a Democrat or Republican, so I couldn't tell you as of this moment who I would vote for come November. All I know is regardless of the reasons of why we went to Iraq, whether they are wrong or right, we are there now, and our troops need to see the support from us, not the bickering of the goverment. I believe that brings down troop morale. Vietnam was run by politicians, not by the generals, thus the reason for us pulling out. I don't want to see that happen now. We do need to finish the job whether we were right or wrong for going there in the first place. Who is the best for this, good question. Max did display some good points, nothing was done for fighting terrism for many years, however I do believe Bush was just a little too trigger happy after we kicked the Taliban out of power. But on the other hand John Kerry hasn't appealed to me as a good leader during a time of war.

by jimhm

Well - here in america we have Bush and Kerry - Kerry who servered in Vietnam (maybe) won 11 ribbons - 4 purple hearts in 6 months of service. Now thats pretty dam good healing power he has.

Then he said he returned his ribbons - then he didn't they were someone elses - then he did - but the were the ribbons not the medals (medals are attached to ribbons) - then he didn't return any of them an kept them ...

Voted to go to war - then vote against funding it -

Kerry is no leader - has poor values and little if any integraty.
Now theres a leader that stands his ground - not - be thankful your a canadian - I vote for BUSH -

by jimhm

Well - here in america we have Bush and Kerry - Kerry who servered in Vietnam (maybe) won 11 ribbons - 4 purple hearts in 6 months of service. Now thats pretty dam good healing power he has.

Then he said he returned his ribbons - then he didn't they were someone elses - then he did - but the were the ribbons not the medals (medals are attached to ribbons) - then he didn't return any of them an kept them ...

Voted to go to war - then vote against funding it -

Kerry is no leader - has poor values and little if any integraty.
Now theres a leader that stands his ground - not - be thankful your a canadian - I vote for BUSH -

by maxwell edison

.
(To keep my previous comments in proper perspective)

For those of you who may not know, Profiles In Courage is a book written by the late John F. Kennedy (written before he was President) about people who set aside political considerations, possibly putting their own political future at risk, to do, what they considered, the right thing. (Some suggest that it was more accurately edited by JFK, as many people contributed to the book.)

As one book reviewer put it:

The United States government has been plagued throughout its history with corrupt leaders, cowards, and politicians who would do anything for re-election. Some, however, did what they believed was right for the nation they proudly represented.

John F. Kennedy's Pulitzer Prize-winning Profiles In Courage tells the stories of some of the courageous, self-sacrificing people who have made our nation the great place it is today.

Each man depicted confronts a serious issue where his conscience dominates his opinion, usually in spite of the views of his own party or of his constituency. Often, the decision made for the good of the country led to his political death.

First, the reader hears of the unconventional, pessimistic John Quincy Adams and his many struggles on countless issues. Adams spent much of his political life with little support, yet still made a name for himself by voting his conscience rather than with popular opinion.......

----------

A very interesting and inspiring book indeed, for any student or enthusiast of politics or history (or both).

by oz_media

Absolutely no interest in the thread itself as I've seen a thousand contradictory timelines going in both directions and nobody seems to have the same opinions. It's an undebatable issue.

You did say "...made our nation the great place it is today." , which I somewhat admire and can accept ass your pride in your country.

I have just never heard ANYONE ever describe their country as "the great nation it is today." outside of America.

Does this mean other people aren't proud of their country's history?

Perhaps they don't think they live in a great nation.(why live there then?)

I know Rule Brittania was big during and after WWII but nobody says "our great nation..."

Is it simple pride? Is it arrogance that you surpass others in how great you are? Is it overpatriotic (to outsiders) yet just simple patriotism for a US citizes?

I think the last point may be close,what you see as patriotic support for your country, others see as blatant flag waving. We are all proud of our countries and where we live, we just don't feel the need to reinforce it everytime we refer to our country perhaps.

Seeing as that is a common way of life for US citizens, heavy patriotism (just look at July 4th!)it is baffling to US citizens that others don't feel/show so much pride toward their own countries and therefore MUST be jealous for not living in the USA?

If so, all I can say is that we DO have pride in our country, we just don't see the need to express it as trumphantly as you do.

There's a good one for you, MANY Canadians don't know when Canada day is. They know it's the 1st but ..."is it June or July? NO, July is the US holiday, when's ours, is it June?" comes up all too often. I guess that July 4th is in the media so much that we forget our own Birthday.

Maybe we need a movie like you guys had with Tom Cruise to help us remember. We could have the monosyllabic Keanu Reeves and Anne Murray as stars in it. Perhaps Michael J. Fox could co-star and Celine Dion, actually make that Brian Adams, write the soundtrack. (Celine's still not sure if she's Frankophone, French, Canadian or American).

by thechas

Max, 1 point about the first Gulf war and President George H.W. Bush.

General Schwartzkopf and our troops were over halfway across Iraq. Kicking the Republican Guard's butt all the way.

They stopped and withdrew not because of any lack of desire or conviction, but because our Middle East coalition partners demanded an end to the battle.

President Bush, with his knowledge of both intelligence and diplomacy knew that it would be a fools mission to violate the trust of the coalition partners.

Personally, I feel that the US is at a greater risk of another terrorist attack because we invaded Iraq.

While we "may" have removed a funding source for terrorist activities, we have doubled or tripled the number of religious fundamentalists that are willing to sacrifice their lives to exact revenge against the US.

As a history scholar, you know well that very seldom does a regime change caused by outside forces result in a lasting positive change.

Chas

by pgm554

So the forced regime changes in Germany and Japan after WWII didn't result in lasting positive change?

by thechas

Note, I did say "seldom", not never.

In the grand scope of human history, the changes of / after World War II are far outside of historical precedence.

All of the worlds major powers took part in assuring that Germany and Japan would not become aggressor nations in the foreseeable future.

Unlike the punitive measures taken against Germany after WWI, Western Germany was rebuilt as a vibrant productive country.
The billions that the US sent to Germany via the Marshall Plan played a major role in that transformation.

Keep in mind, that to make that regime change take hold, the US and Britain occupied Germany for decades after the war.
The US still maintains bases in Germany and Japan. In part because both countries do not have significant military forces, or weapons.

NATO along with the cooperation of our allies has played no small part in keeping Germany from reverting back to an aggressor nation.

In Iraq, we do not have the support of Iraq's neighbors to assure that the new government will be able to take hold and mature.
Nor, do I believe that the US and Iraqi people will stand for a 20 year or longer occupation.

Couple that with the strong anti-tax and anti-foreign aid sentiment in the US, and how do you fund a Marshall Plan style reconstruction of Iraq?

Chas

by nd_it

Is that you have radical religous extremists in Iraq that are willing to die because they think God. In Germany and Japan you had radical political extremists who believed in domination of other countries. Is is possible to install democracy in Iraq, maybe, but at what cost?

by maxwell edison

.
....only ask it in a different way.

You suggested that, "very seldom does a regime change caused by outside forces result in a lasting positive change."

How about putting it this way, in the form of my question to you. When, in all of history, did a country's change from a dictatorship to a democracy not result in lasting positive change? I can't think of a single instance when it didn't result in lasting positive change.

by jamesrl

If you look at Britain's attempts to create democracies from its colonial possessions, it has proved difficult.

India went through quite a lot of bloodshed before things became stable.

Kenya, Zimbabwe, South Africa, do I have to go into all of that?

Take a look at the challenges in the former Yugoslavia.

And though this might be controversial, I'd say in hindsight, Vietnam was much better off after the war, but gave up some level democracy(in the south) to do so.

Creating a democracy in a political vacuum isn't easy. In the case of Canada, we had political reform in the 1840s, leading to a democratic country in 1867. It stuck because it was slow and deliberate. South Africa had a flawed democracy, but at least had a model to work with that could be reformed through the end of aparteid.

Iraq has no history of democracy, simmering religious tensions between Shia, Sunni and Kurd. Its a tough slog.

The previously mentioned regime changes - Japan and Germany - were situations where both countries had soem sort of frgaile democracy, had a shift to an oligarchy. And frankly the justification for regime change in both countries was the end of external aggression. After the first gulf war, Saddam lost his power for overt exetrnal aggression - his army was devastated and he had no money to rebuild. Most people don't connect the fact that the only uses of gas(which is a hideous crime) were BEFORE the first gulf war, when by the way the US, Iraq's ally, said nothing.

Saddam was no threat to anyone(unless you believe he had WMD). I am not saying he was a nice guy. But he lost the ability to even control his own areas - the kurdish areas in the north were running things on their own. That is the area, by the way, where the Al Queda cell was. Saddam, who by the way was NOT a devout muslim until it suited his interests, was not a friend of Al Queda(sp?) - they were in fact in many ways enemies. Al Queda would have liked nothing more than to overthrow Saddam and install something like the Taliban in Iraq. If the US is not successful in installing democracy this may indeed may be what happens - or more likely a bloody civil war.

James Linn

by maxwell edison

.
From The Weekly Standard:

OSAMA BIN LADEN and Saddam Hussein had an operational relationship from the early 1990s to 2003 that involved training in explosives and weapons of mass destruction, logistical support for terrorist attacks, al Qaeda training camps and safe haven in Iraq, and Iraqi financial support for al Qaeda--perhaps even for Mohamed Atta--according to a top secret U.S. government memorandum obtained by THE WEEKLY STANDARD.

The memo, dated October 27, 2003, was sent from Undersecretary of Defense for Policy Douglas J. Feith to Senators Pat Roberts and Jay Rockefeller, the chairman and vice chairman of the Senate Intelligence Committee. It was written in response to a request from the committee as part of its investigation into prewar intelligence claims made by the administration. Intelligence reporting included in the 16-page memo comes from a variety of domestic and foreign agencies, including the FBI, the Defense Intelligence Agency, the Central Intelligence Agency, and the National Security Agency. Much of the evidence is detailed, conclusive, and corroborated by multiple sources. Some of it is new information obtained in custodial interviews with high-level al Qaeda terrorists and Iraqi officials, and some of it is more than a decade old. The picture that emerges is one of a history of collaboration between two of America's most determined and dangerous enemies.

According to the memo--which lays out the intelligence in 50 numbered points--Iraq-al Qaeda contacts began in 1990 and continued through mid-March 2003, days before the Iraq War began. Most of the numbered passages contain straight, fact-based intelligence reporting, which some cases includes an evaluation of the credibility of the source. This reporting is often followed by commentary and analysis.

The relationship began shortly before the first Gulf War. According to reporting in the memo, bin Laden sent "emissaries to Jordan in 1990 to meet with Iraqi government officials." At some unspecified point in 1991, according to a CIA analysis, "Iraq sought Sudan's assistance to establish links to al Qaeda." The outreach went in both directions. According to 1993 CIA reporting cited in the memo, "bin Laden wanted to expand his organization's capabilities through ties with Iraq."

The primary go-between throughout these early stages was Sudanese strongman Hassan al-Turabi, a leader of the al Qaeda-affiliated National Islamic Front. Numerous sources have confirmed this. One defector reported that "al-Turabi was instrumental in arranging the Iraqi-al Qaeda relationship. The defector said Iraq sought al Qaeda influence through its connections with Afghanistan, to facilitate the transshipment of proscribed weapons and equipment to Iraq. In return, Iraq provided al Qaeda with training and instructors."

One such confirmation came in a postwar interview with one of Saddam Hussein's henchmen. As the memo details:

4. According to a May 2003 debriefing of a senior Iraqi intelligence officer, Iraqi intelligence established a highly secretive relationship with Egyptian Islamic Jihad, and later with al Qaeda. The first meeting in 1992 between the Iraqi Intelligence Service (IIS) and al Qaeda was brokered by al-Turabi. Former IIS deputy director Faruq Hijazi and senior al Qaeda leader [Ayman al] Zawahiri were at the meeting--the first of several between 1992 and 1995 in Sudan. Additional meetings between Iraqi intelligence and al Qaeda were held in Pakistan. Members of al Qaeda would sometimes visit Baghdad where they would meet the Iraqi intelligence chief in a safe house. The report claimed that Saddam insisted the relationship with al Qaeda be kept secret. After 9-11, the source said Saddam made a personnel change in the IIS for fear the relationship would come under scrutiny from foreign probes.

A decisive moment in the budding relationship came in 1993, when bin Laden faced internal resistance to his cooperation with Saddam.

5. A CIA report from a contact with good access, some of whose reporting has been corroborated, said that certain elements in the "Islamic Army" of bin Laden were against the secular regime of Saddam. Overriding the internal factional strife that was developing, bin Laden came to an "understanding" with Saddam that the Islamic Army would no longer support anti-Saddam activities. According to sensitive reporting released in U.S. court documents during the African Embassy trial, in 1993 bin Laden reached an "understanding" with Saddam under which he (bin Laden) forbade al Qaeda operations to be mounted against the Iraqi leader.
Another facilitator of the relationship during the mid-1990s was Mahmdouh Mahmud Salim (a.k.a. Abu Hajer al-Iraqi). Abu Hajer, now in a New York prison, was described in court proceedings related to the August 1998 bombings of U.S. embassies in Kenya and Tanzania as bin Laden's "best friend." According to CIA reporting dating back to the Clinton administration, bin Laden trusted him to serve as a liaison with Saddam's regime and tasked him with procurement of weapons of mass destruction for al Qaeda. FBI reporting in the memo reveals that Abu Hajer "visited Iraq in early 1995" and "had a good relationship with Iraqi intelligence. Sometime before mid-1995 he went on an al Qaeda mission to discuss unspecified cooperation with the Iraqi government."

Some of the reporting about the relationship throughout the mid-1990s comes from
a source who had intimate knowledge of bin Laden and his dealings. This source, according to CIA analysis, offered "the most credible information" on cooperation between bin Laden and Iraq.

This source's reports read almost like a diary. Specific dates of when bin Laden flew to various cities are included, as well as names of individuals he met. The source did not offer information on the substantive talks during the meetings. . . . There are not a great many reports in general on the relationship between bin Laden and Iraq because of the secrecy surrounding it. But when this source with close access provided a "window" into bin Laden's activities, bin Laden is seen as heavily involved with Iraq (and Iran).
Reporting from the early 1990s remains somewhat sketchy, though multiple sources place Hassan al-Turabi and Ayman al Zawahiri, bin Laden's current No. 2, at the center of the relationship. The reporting gets much more specific in the mid-1990s:

8. Reporting from a well placed source disclosed that bin Laden was receiving training on bomb making from the IIS's [Iraqi Intelligence Service] principal technical expert on making sophisticated explosives, Brigadier Salim al-Ahmed. Brigadier Salim was observed at bin Laden's farm in Khartoum in Sept.-Oct. 1995 and again in July 1996, in the company of the Director of Iraqi Intelligence, Mani abd-al-Rashid al-Tikriti.
9 . . . Bin Laden visited Doha, Qatar (17-19 Jan. 1996), staying at the residence of a member of the Qatari ruling family. He discussed the successful movement of explosives into Saudi Arabia, and operations targeted against U.S. and U.K. interests in Dammam, Dharan, and Khobar, using clandestine al Qaeda cells in Saudi Arabia. Upon his return, bin Laden met with Hijazi and Turabi, among others.

And later more reporting, from the same "well placed" source:

10. The Director of Iraqi Intelligence, Mani abd-al-Rashid al-Tikriti, met privately with bin Laden at his farm in Sudan in July 1996. Tikriti used an Iraqi delegation traveling to Khartoum to discuss bilateral cooperation as his "cover" for his own entry into Sudan to meet with bin Laden and Hassan al-Turabi. The Iraqi intelligence chief and two other IIS officers met at bin Laden's farm and discussed bin Laden's request for IIS technical assistance in: a) making letter and parcel bombs; b) making bombs which could be placed on aircraft and detonated by changes in barometric pressure; and c) making false passport [sic]. Bin Laden specifically requested that [Brigadier Salim al-Ahmed], Iraqi intelligence's premier explosives maker--especially skilled in making car bombs--remain with him in Sudan. The Iraqi intelligence chief instructed Salim to remain in Sudan with bin Laden as long as required.
The analysis of those events follows:

The time of the visit from the IIS director was a few weeks after the Khobar Towers bombing. The bombing came on the third anniversary of a U.S. [Tomahawk missile] strike on IIS HQ (retaliation for the attempted assassination of former President Bush in Kuwait) for which Iraqi officials explicitly threatened retaliation.

IN ADDITION TO THE CONTACTS CLUSTERED in the mid-1990s, intelligence reports detail a flurry of activities in early 1998 and again in December 1998. A "former senior Iraqi intelligence officer" reported that "the Iraqi intelligence service station in Pakistan was Baghdad's point of contact with al Qaeda. He also said bin Laden visited Baghdad in Jan. 1998 and met with Tariq Aziz."

11. According to sensitive reporting, Saddam personally sent Faruq Hijazi, IIS deputy director and later Iraqi ambassador to Turkey, to meet with bin Laden at least twice, first in Sudan and later in Afghanistan in 1999. . . .

14. According to a sensitive reporting [from] a "regular and reliable source," [Ayman al] Zawahiri, a senior al Qaeda operative, visited Baghdad and met with the Iraqi Vice President on 3 February 1998. The goal of the visit was to arrange for coordination between Iraq and bin Laden and establish camps in an-Nasiriyah and Iraqi Kurdistan under the leadership of Abdul Aziz.

That visit came as the Iraqis intensified their defiance of the U.N. inspection regime, known as UNSCOM, created by the cease-fire agreement following the Gulf War. UNSCOM demanded access to Saddam's presidential palaces that he refused to provide. As the tensions mounted, President Bill Clinton went to the Pentagon on February 18, 1998, and prepared the nation for war. He warned of "an unholy axis of terrorists, drug traffickers, and organized international criminals" and said "there is no more clear example of this threat than Saddam Hussein."

The day after this speech, according to documents unearthed in April 2003 in the Iraqi Intelligence headquarters by journalists Mitch Potter and Inigo Gilmore, Hussein's intelligence service wrote a memo detailing coming meetings with a bin Laden representative traveling to Baghdad. Each reference to bin Laden had been covered by liquid paper that, when revealed, exposed a plan to increase cooperation between Iraq and al Qaeda. According to that memo, the IIS agreed to pay for "all the travel and hotel costs inside Iraq to gain the knowledge of the message from bin Laden and to convey to his envoy an oral message from us to bin Laden." The document set as the goal for the meeting a discussion of "the future of our relationship with him, bin Laden, and to achieve a direct meeting with him." The al Qaeda representative, the document went on to suggest, might provide "a way to maintain contacts with bin Laden."

Four days later, on February 23, 1998, bin Laden issued his now-famous fatwa on the plight of Iraq, published in the Arabic-language daily, al Quds al-Arabi: "For over seven years the United States has been occupying the lands of Islam in the holiest of places, the Arabian Peninsula, plundering its riches, dictating to its rulers, humiliating its people, terrorizing its neighbors, and turning its bases in the Peninsula into a spearhead through which to fight the neighboring Muslim peoples." Bin Laden urged his followers to act: "The ruling to kill all Americans and their allies--civilians and military--is an individual duty for every Muslim who can do it in any country in which it is possible to do it."

Although war was temporarily averted by a last-minute deal brokered by U.N. Secretary General Kofi Annan, tensions soon rose again. The standoff with Iraq came to a head in December 1998, when President Clinton launched Operation Desert Fox, a 70-hour bombing campaign that began on December 16 and ended three days later, on December 19, 1998.

According to press reports at the time, Faruq Hijazi, deputy director of Iraqi Intelligence, met with bin Laden in Afghanistan on December 21, 1998, to offer bin Laden safe haven in Iraq. CIA reporting in the memo to the Senate Intelligence Committee seems to confirm this meeting and relates two others.

15. A foreign government service reported that an Iraqi delegation, including at least two Iraqi intelligence officers formerly assigned to the Iraqi Embassy in Pakistan, met in late 1998 with bin Laden in Afghanistan.

16. According to CIA reporting, bin Laden and Zawahiri met with two Iraqi intelligence officers in Afghanistan in Dec. 1998.

17. . . . Iraq sent an intelligence officer to Afghanistan to seek closer ties to bin Laden and the Taliban in late 1998. The source reported that the Iraqi regime was trying to broaden its cooperation with al Qaeda. Iraq was looking to recruit Muslim "elements" to sabotage U.S. and U.K. interests. After a senior Iraqi intelligence officer met with Taliban leader [Mullah] Omar, arrangements were made for a series of meetings between the Iraqi intelligence officer and bin Laden in Pakistan. The source noted Faruq Hijazi was in Afghanistan in late 1998.

18. . . . Faruq Hijazi went to Afghanistan in 1999 along with several other Iraqi officials to meet with bin Laden. The source claimed that Hijazi would have met bin Laden only at Saddam's explicit direction.

An analysis that follows No. 18 provides additional context and an explanation of these reports:

Reporting entries #4, #11, #15, #16, #17, and #18, from different sources, corroborate each other and provide confirmation of meetings between al Qaeda operatives and Iraqi intelligence in Afghanistan and Pakistan. None of the reports have information on operational details or the purpose of such meetings. The covert nature of the relationship would indicate strict compartmentation [sic] of operations.
Information about connections between al Qaeda and Iraq was so widespread by early 1999 that it made its way into the mainstream press. A January 11, 1999, Newsweek story ran under this headline: "Saddam + Bin Laden?" The story cited an "Arab intelligence source" with knowledge of contacts between Iraq and al Qaeda. "According to this source, Saddam expected last month's American and British bombing campaign to go on much longer than it did. The dictator believed that as the attacks continued, indignation would grow in the Muslim world, making his terrorism offensive both harder to trace and more effective. With acts of terror contributing to chaos in the region, Turkey, Jordan, Saudi Arabia, and Kuwait might feel less inclined to support Washington. Saddam's long-term strategy, according to several sources, is to bully or cajole Muslim countries into breaking the embargo against Iraq, without waiting for the United Nations to lift if formally."

INTELLIGENCE REPORTS about the nature of the relationship between Iraq and al Qaeda from mid-1999 through 2003 are conflicting. One senior Iraqi intelligence officer in U.S. custody, Khalil Ibrahim Abdallah, "said that the last contact between the IIS and al Qaeda was in July 1999. Bin Laden wanted to meet with Saddam, he said. The guidance sent back from Saddam's office reportedly ordered Iraqi intelligence to refrain from any further contact with bin Laden and al Qaeda. The source opined that Saddam wanted to distance himself from al Qaeda."

The bulk of reporting on the relationship contradicts this claim. One report states that "in late 1999" al Qaeda set up a training camp in northern Iraq that "was operational as of 1999." Other reports suggest that the Iraqi regime contemplated several offers of safe haven to bin Laden throughout 1999.

23. . . . Iraqi officials were carefully considering offering safe haven to bin Laden and his closest collaborators in Nov. 1999. The source indicated the idea was put forward by the presumed head of Iraqi intelligence in Islamabad (Khalid Janaby) who in turn was in frequent contact and had good relations with bin Laden.
Some of the most intriguing intelligence concerns an Iraqi named Ahmed Hikmat Shakir:

24. According to sensitive reporting, a Malaysia-based Iraqi national (Shakir) facilitated the arrival of one of the Sept 11 hijackers for an operational meeting in Kuala Lumpur (Jan 2000). Sensitive reporting indicates Shakir's travel and contacts link him to a worldwide network of terrorists, including al Qaeda. Shakir worked at the Kuala Lumpur airport--a job he claimed to have obtained through an Iraqi embassy employee.
One of the men at that al Qaeda operational meeting in the Kuala Lumpur Hotel was Tawfiz al Atash, a top bin Laden lieutenant later identified as the mastermind of the October 12, 2000, attack on the USS Cole.

25. Investigation into the bombing of the USS Cole in October 2000 by al Qaeda revealed no specific Iraqi connections but according to the CIA, "fragmentary evidence points to possible Iraqi involvement."

26. During a custodial interview, Ibn al-Shaykh al-Libi [a senior al Qaeda operative] said he was told by an al Qaeda associate that he was tasked to travel to Iraq (1998) to establish a relationship with Iraqi intelligence to obtain poisons and gases training. After the USS Cole bombing in 2000, two al Qaeda operatives were sent to Iraq for CBW-related [Chemical and Biological Weapons] training beginning in Dec 2000. Iraqi intelligence was "encouraged" after the embassy and USS Cole bombings to provide this training.

The analysis of this report follows.

CIA maintains that Ibn al-Shaykh's timeline is consistent with other sensitive reporting indicating that bin Laden asked Iraq in 1998 for advanced weapons, including CBW and "poisons."
Additional reporting also calls into question the claim that relations between Iraq and al Qaeda cooled after mid-1999:

27. According to sensitive CIA reporting, . . . the Saudi National Guard went on a kingdom-wide state of alert in late Dec 2000 after learning Saddam agreed to assist al Qaeda in attacking U.S./U.K. interests in Saudi Arabia.

And then there is the alleged contact between lead 9/11 hijacker Mohamed Atta and an Iraqi intelligence officer in Prague. The reporting on those links suggests not one meeting, but as many as four. What's more, the memo reveals potential financing of Atta's activities by Iraqi intelligence.

The Czech counterintelligence service reported that the Sept. 11 hijacker [Mohamed] Atta met with the former Iraqi intelligence chief in Prague, [Ahmed Khalil Ibrahim Samir] al Ani, on several occasions. During one of these meetings, al Ani ordered the IIS finance officer to issue Atta funds from IIS financial holdings in the Prague office.

And the commentary:

CIA can confirm two Atta visits to Prague--in Dec. 1994 and in June 2000; data surrounding the other two--on 26 Oct 1999 and 9 April 2001--is complicated and sometimes contradictory and CIA and FBI cannot confirm Atta met with the IIS. Czech Interior Minister Stanislav Gross continues to stand by his information.
It's not just Gross who stands by the information. Five high-ranking members of the Czech government have publicly confirmed meetings between Atta and al Ani. The meeting that has gotten the most press attention--April 9, 2001--is also the most widely disputed. Even some of the most hawkish Bush administration officials are privately skeptical that Atta met al Ani on that occasion. They believe that reports of the alleged meeting, said to have taken place in public, outside the headquarters of the U.S.-financed Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, suggest a level of sloppiness that doesn't fit the pattern of previous high-level Iraq-al Qaeda contacts.

Whether or not that specific meeting occurred, the report by Czech counterintelligence that al Ani ordered the Iraqi Intelligence Service officer to provide IIS funds to Atta might help explain the lead hijacker's determination to reach Prague, despite significant obstacles, in the spring 2000. (Note that the report stops short of confirming that the funds were transferred. It claims only that the IIS officer requested the transfer.) Recall that Atta flew to Prague from Germany on May 30, 2000, but was denied entry because he did not have a valid visa. Rather than simply return to Germany and fly directly to the United States, his ultimate destination, Atta took pains to get to Prague. After he was refused entry the first time, he traveled back to Germany, obtained the proper paperwork, and caught a bus back to Prague. He left for the United States the day after arriving in Prague for the second time.

Several reports indicate that the relationship between Saddam and bin Laden continued, even after the September 11 attacks:

31. An Oct. 2002 . . . report said al Qaeda and Iraq reached a secret agreement whereby Iraq would provide safe haven to al Qaeda members and provide them with money and weapons. The agreement reportedly prompted a large number of al Qaeda members to head to Iraq. The report also said that al Qaeda members involved in a fraudulent passport network for al Qaeda had been directed to procure 90 Iraqi and Syrian passports for al Qaeda personnel.

The analysis that accompanies that report indicates that the report fits the pattern of Iraq-al Qaeda collaboration:

References to procurement of false passports from Iraq and offers of safe haven previously have surfaced in CIA source reporting considered reliable. Intelligence reports to date have maintained A that Iraqi support for al Qaeda usually involved providing training, obtaining passports, and offers of refuge. This report adds to that list by including weapons and money. This assistance would make sense in the aftermath of 9-11.

Colin Powell, in his February 5, 2003, presentation to the U.N. Security Council, revealed the activities of Abu Musab al Zarqawi. Reporting in the memo expands on Powell's case and might help explain some of the resistance the U.S. military is currently facing in Iraq.

37. Sensitive reporting indicates senior terrorist planner and close al Qaeda associate al Zarqawi has had an operational alliance with Iraqi officials. As of Oct. 2002, al Zarqawi maintained contacts with the IIS to procure weapons and explosives, including surface-to-air missiles from an IIS officer in Baghdad. According to sensitive reporting, al Zarqawi was setting up sleeper cells in Baghdad to be activated in case of a U.S. occupation of the city, suggesting his operational cooperation with the Iraqis may have deepened in recent months. Such cooperation could include IIS provision of a secure operating bases [sic] and steady access to arms and explosives in preparation for a possible U.S. invasion. Al Zarqawi's procurements from the Iraqis also could support al Qaeda operations against the U.S. or its allies elsewhere.

38. According to sensitive reporting, a contact with good access who does not have an established reporting record: An Iraqi intelligence service officer said that as of mid-March the IIS was providing weapons to al Qaeda members located in northern Iraq, including rocket propelled grenade (RPG)-18 launchers. According to IIS information, northern Iraq-based al Qaeda members believed that the U.S. intended to strike al Qaeda targets during an anticipated assault against Ansar al-Islam positions.

The memo further reported pre-war intelligence which "claimed that an Iraqi intelligence official, praising Ansar al-Islam, provided it with $100,000 and agreed to continue to give assistance."

CRITICS OF THE BUSH ADMINISTRATION have complained that Iraq-al Qaeda connections are a fantasy, trumped up by the warmongers at the White House to fit their preconceived notions about international terror; that links between Saddam Hussein and Osama bin Laden have been routinely "exaggerated" for political purposes; that hawks "cherry-picked" bits of intelligence and tendentiously presented these to the American public.

Carl Levin, a senior member of the Senate Intelligence Committee, made those points as recently as November 9, in an appearance on "Fox News Sunday." Republicans on the committee, he complained, refuse to look at the administration's "exaggeration of intelligence."

Said Levin: "The question is whether or not they exaggerated intelligence in order to carry out their purpose, which was to make the case for going to war. Did we know, for instance, with certainty that there was any relationship between the Iraqis and the terrorists that were in Afghanistan, bin Laden? The administration said that there's a connection between those terrorist groups in Afghanistan and Iraq. Was there a basis for that?"

There was, as shown in the memo to the committee on which Levin serves. And much of the reporting comes from Clinton-era intelligence. Not that you would know this from Al Gore's recent public statements. Indeed, the former vice president claims to be privy to new "evidence" that the administration lied. In an August speech at New York University, Gore claimed: "The evidence now shows clearly that Saddam did not want to work with Osama bin Laden at all, much less give him weapons of mass destruction." Really?

One of the most interesting things to note about the 16-page memo is that it covers only a fraction of the evidence that will eventually be available to document the relationship between Iraq and al Qaeda. For one thing, both Saddam and bin Laden were desperate to keep their cooperation secret. (Remember, Iraqi intelligence used liquid paper on an internal intelligence document to conceal bin Laden's name.) For another, few people in the U.S. government are expressly looking for such links. There is no Iraq-al Qaeda equivalent of the CIA's 1,400-person Iraq Survey Group currently searching Iraq for weapons of mass destruction.

Instead, CIA and FBI officials are methodically reviewing Iraqi intelligence files that survived the three-week war last spring. These documents would cover several miles if laid end-to-end. And they are in Arabic. They include not only connections between bin Laden and Saddam, but also revolting details of the regime's long history of brutality. It will be a slow process.

So Feith's memo to the Senate Intelligence Committee is best viewed as sort of a "Cliff's Notes" version of the relationship. It contains the highlights, but it is far from exhaustive.

One example. The memo contains only one paragraph on Ahmed Hikmat Shakir, the Iraqi facilitator who escorted two September 11 hijackers through customs in Kuala Lumpur. U.S. intelligence agencies have extensive reporting on his activities before and after the September 11 hijacking. That they would include only this brief overview suggests the 16-page memo, extensive as it is, just skims the surface of the reporting on Iraq-al Qaeda connections.

Other intelligence reports indicate that Shakir whisked not one but two September 11 hijackers--Khalid al Midhar and Nawaq al Hamzi--through the passport and customs process upon their arrival in Kuala Lumpur on January 5, 2000. Shakir then traveled with the hijackers to the Kuala Lumpur Hotel where they met with Ramzi bin al Shibh, one of the masterminds of the September 11 plot. The meeting lasted three days. Shakir returned to work on January 9 and January 10, and never again.

Shakir got his airport job through a contact at the Iraqi Embassy. (Iraq routinely used its embassies as staging grounds for its intelligence operations; in some cases, more than half of the alleged "diplomats" were intelligence operatives.) The Iraqi embassy, not his employer, controlled Shakir's schedule. He was detained in Qatar on September 17, 2001. Authorities found in his possession contact information for terrorists involved in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, the 1998 embassy bombings, the 2000 attack on the USS Cole, and the September 11 hijackings. The CIA had previous reporting that Shakir had received a phone call from the safe house where the 1993 World Trade Center attacks had been plotted.

The Qataris released Shakir shortly after his arrest. On October 21, 2001, he flew to Amman, Jordan, where he was to change planes to a flight to Baghdad. He didn't make that flight. Shakir was detained in Jordan for three months, where the CIA interrogated him. His interrogators concluded that Shakir had received extensive training in counter-interrogation techniques. Not long after he was detained, according to an official familiar with the intelligence, the Iraqi regime began to "pressure" Jordanian intelligence to release him. At the same time, Amnesty International complained that Shakir was being held without charge. The Jordanians released him on January 28, 2002, at which point he is believed to have fled back to Iraq.

Was Shakir an Iraqi agent? Does he provide a connection between Saddam Hussein and September 11? We don't know. We may someday find out.

But there can no longer be any serious argument about whether Saddam Hussein's Iraq worked with Osama bin Laden and al Qaeda to plot against Americans.

- Stephen F. Hayes, staff writer at The Weekly Standard.

by jackofalltech

This is worth a few minutes of thought no matter which "side" you are
on.

You know, it is easy to forget the 'promises' that Bill and Hillary made
while in office. It strikes home when it is listed like this.

After the 1993 World Trade Center bombing, which killed six and injured
1,000; President Clinton promised that those responsible would be hunted
down and punished. BUSH COVERED IT!

After the 1995 bombing in Saudi Arabia, which killed five U.S. military
personnel; Clinton promised that those responsible would be hunted down
and punished. BUSH COVERED IT!

After the 1996 Khobar Towers bombing in Saudi Arabia, which killed 19
and injured 200 U.S. military personnel; Clinton promised that those
responsible would be hunted down and punished. BUSH COVERED IT!

After the 1998 bombing of U.S. embassies in Africa, which killed 224 and
injured 5,000; Clinton promised that those responsible would be hunted
down and punished. BUSH COVERED IT!

After the 2000 bombing of the USS Cole, which killed 17 and injured 39
U.S. sailors; Clinton promised that those responsible would be hunted
down and punished. BUSH COVERED IT!

Maybe if Clinton had kept his promise, an estimated 3,000 people in New
York and Washington, D.C. that are now dead would be alive today BUSH
TOLD THOSE FIREMAN -- THEY WOULD HEAR US TOO!

And, now that Bush is taking action to bring these people to justice, we
have opponents charging him with being a war monger...

AN INTERESTING QUESTION: This question was raised on a Philly radio
call-in show. Without casting stones, it is a legitimate question.

There are two men, both extremely wealthy. One develops software and
gives billions of dollars to charity. The other sponsors terrorism. That
being the case, why was it that the Clinton Administration spent more
money chasing down Bill Gates over the past eight years than Osama bin
Laden?

Think about it.. It is a strange turn of events. Hillary gets $8 Million
for her memoir. Bill gets about $12 Million for his memoir yet to be
written. This from two people who have spent the past 8 years being
unable to recall anything about past events while under oath!

Sincerely, Cmdr Hamilton McWhorter USN (ret)

by jimhm

I like the way you put those together sir - nice job ...

When you have a wimp in the white house the country will be attacked! They didn't learn from WWII - Isolationizm just doesn't work - Spain is gong to learn that the hard way as well - They caved once - now theres a track record -

by cactus pete

Were there any clarifications of what Clinton did or did not do? I mean Specifically. And just how did Bush cover each of these items? I don't see a conclusion to any of those above.

by jackofalltech

Although I promised myself I wouldn't log on here anymore, I do occasionally browse thru the discussions. I couldn't resist responding to this one. Thanks Max!

Along the same lines as this is my other post, Think About It.

Take care everyone.

Ralph

by maxwell edison

Taking the obvious examples of Germany and Japan off the table, since the circumstances were unique, and there's probably no argument in those cases anyway, we're left with your other examples. All of those examples were countries that broke away from British colonialism, not unlike America's breaking away a couple of hundred years earlier. Perhaps not as "bloody", but similar nonetheless. The difference between the United States' attempts at instilling a democratic government and the British examples you cited is one of willingness. Britain gave up those colonies kicking and screaming, so to speak, and the establishment of an independent democratic government wasn't their initial intention. Whereas America's attempts have been an answer to another's cry for independence from a more dominant and oppressive regime. Vietnam was, of course, a failed attempt (and that's a unique example as well). But Poland, as well as numerous other Eastern European countries, was a successful attempt, as are some Central American countries. I would still suggest that where the installation of an independent and democratic government was the intention from the outset, there are very few, if any, that didn't benefit in the long run.

You said that, "Saddam was no threat to anyone (unless you believe he had WMD)". Well, I believe he did, as did President Bush, as did President Clinton, as did the UN Inspectors, as did the U.S. inspectors, as did Al Gore, as did Sectary of State Colin Powell, as did former Secretary of State Madeline Albright, as did many Iraqi informants, as did John Kerry, as did........the rest of the world. And besides, it's still not been shown that he didn't, which was a condition of United Nations resolution 1441. Moreover, with the revelation of the recent thwarted chemical weapons attack in Jordan, one that could have killed up to 80,000 people, we now have mounting evidence that the WMDs were indeed there, but taken out of the country just before the invasion, something U.S. inspector David Kay had earlier suggested as a strong possibility.

How else was Saddam "not a threat", you might ask? Well, people conveniently forget that Saddam offered $25,000 cash (U.S. cash, by the way) to the families of any terrorist who killed any "infidels", Americans in particular.

Or how about this. According to the presiding judge in the 1996 trial, the bombing of New York's World Trade Center on February 26, 1993 was meant to topple the city's tallest tower onto its twin, amid a cloud of cyanide gas. Had the attack gone as planned, tens of thousands of Americans would have died. Instead, as we know, one tower did not fall on the other, and, rather than vaporizing, the cyanide gas burnt up in the heat of the explosion. "Only" six people died. Few Americans are aware of the true scale of the destructive ambition behind that bomb, this despite the fact that two years later, the key figure responsible for building it, a man who had entered the United Stares on an Iraqi passport under the name of Ramzi Yousef, was involved in another stupendous bombing conspiracy. In January 1995, Yousef and his associates plotted to blow up eleven U.S. commercial aircraft in one spectacular day of terrorist rage. The bombs were to be made of a liquid explosive designed to pass through airport metal detectors.

And for those who think that Saddam didn't have ties with Al-Qaida, look into a civil case decided about a year ago in a U.S. Federal court. Judge Harold Baer ruled the plaintiffs had shown that Iraq provided material support to bin Laden and his al-Qaida terror network. Baer granted a judgment to the plaintiffs against the Taliban, the Islamic Emirate of Afghanistan, al-Qaida, Osama bin Laden, Saddam Hussein and the Republic of Iraq. I could cite much more, but it's there if you care to find it and consider it.

I won't even mention the hundreds of thousands of bodies recovered from mass graves.

Saddam was not a threat? Well, If that's what you choose to believe......

by jamesrl

In all of those cases, Britain did willingly try to transition them to democracies.

In the case of India there had been some rebellion, but there were also plans to hand them over. WWII interrupted the process, but the British, consumed with post WWII economic issues, accelerated it into a 4 year process. As a result, the Hindu Majority and Muslim minority, which had been united in calling for independance, fell on each other - and as a result Independance day saw riots and killing between the two.

Similarly in the 50s and 60s Britain tried to peacefully transition the African colonies. With not too successful results.

Using David Kay as a source is a two edged sword, he has also said that the weapons didn't exist. As did many others of the inspections team. As for Colin Powell -doesn't Woodward suggest a lot of doubt.

I am well aware of Saddam's bounty in respect to Isreal. I have never seen it in any other context.

1993 was Al Qaida plain and simple. The fact that he had an Iraqi passport suggests nothing - he could have easily had a Saudi passport, as Osama does. Are you suggesting we take out Saudi Arabia?

I'm not suggesting Saddam is a nice guy. I would have been happy to have seen the US support the Shia, as they had promised in 1991 just after the first gulf war. The US allowed Iraqi military helicopters to fly over restricted airspace and attack they Shia who they had promised to support.

But it is one thing to respond to a clear and present danger, as in Afghanistan - they were clearly linked to Al Queda. I wouldn't put Saddam in that catagory. North Korea would seem to pose a stronger threat.

James Linn

by maxwell edison

.
"Are you suggesting we take out Saudi Arabia?"

Well, if I had my "druthers".................POW! (just kidding - kind of)

Seriously, I think we need to find a way to stabilize the entire middle-east, not only in regards to the humanitarian issues, protecting human rights, and all that stuff, and, of course, world-wide terrorism has its roots in the middle-east, and that has to be stopped, but also in regards to how the middle-east oil has direct ties to the world economy. Like it or not, the world (note I said world, not just U.S.) economy is directly affected by all of them. And personally, I'd rather control them than the other way around. Instead of "taking out Saudi Arabia", I'd like to "take out" OPEC, by peaceful means, of course.

It's a real tight-rope over there if you take everything into consideration. The United Nations has failed miserably; previous American administrations (of both parties) have failed miserably; left to their own devices, they've failed miserably; France and England have failed; every attempt has failed. Do we isolate them and sever all ties with them or intervene in some way? It seems like a lose-lose situation. About the only thing that hasn't been tried is installing a true democracy with individual freedom and liberty, and free markets. I truly do think that's the goal, one of the goals, of the Bush administration. And if it catches hold in Iraq, look out Iran and Saudi Arabia and Syria and........

On the rest of your message, no point in beating a dead horse. You see things one way, I see them another.

by nd_it

"radical extremists in Iraq are willing to die and become martys because they think it is God's will"

by oz_media

Well I am very furtunate to live in Canada. THese topics of discussion RARELY come up regarding Canadian politics, nobody like Canadian politics, it's oring droll and mostly crap anyway. What do we have to talk about, we aren't under attack or imminent threat from anyone, which is surprising as we border the USA, we don't invade,we don't tell the rest of the world how to conduct thier business. We don't expect other countries to be like us or see eye to eye with us, infact most countries would be wiping out a HUGE portion of thier own race if attacking Canada. We don't push religion on each other, we don't use religion to justify our every move.

We don't care, bottom line and are simply left to live and enjoy it.

If I had these same issues that you guys do occuring in Canada each day, I'd be moving home. I won't support my government on such actions unless properly justified and imperative.

Now this goes back to the origins of our coutries.

I saw a comedian who was talking about our origins ad how our countries were established. IN short,

America: the established USA was WON as a result of a nasty and very bloody battle between the North and the South.

Canada:
Delegates from Upper and Lower Canada requested an invitation to speak about the possibilities of a union of the British North American Colonies. They had soon won the attention of the entire conference and had proposed the Federal Union of Canada and the Atlantic Provinces.

So while you have established yourselves as a nation by fighting for it's freedom, we just signed a few papers and went for a cold beer and a lobster dinner.

Just like many countries in the world, America will ALWAYS be at war and never existing in true peace.

Canada will probably NEVER be at war again and we live daily in true peace.

I guess your'e right, I AM jealous of America. I guess I'll have to get that citizenship afterall.

by jamesrl

Its not as simple as that comedian claimed.

If you go back to the French and Indian wars, there was bitter fighting between the French and the English and their colonial armies(which included George Washington and Benedict Arnold).

Upon winning, the crown granted Quebec extraordinary rights (google the Quebec Act of 1760) - the right to keep their own religion, education system(Roman Catholic) and Civil code (versus common law found in rest of colonies). This by the way became a bone of contention and drove a wedge between the thirteen colonies of America and Britain - many of the colonist who fought for the British were anti-french.

We did have a minor rebellion in 1839, which resulted in democratic reforms.

The reason for the timing of our "confederation", the joining of the colonies into a country called Canada, was largely to do with the states. The US Civil war made us nervous, and even after the war was over there was some fear of invasion. In fact many who served in Irish regiments joined the fenian movement, and there were a few border crossing and battles with Canadian Militia.

Canada would have come together anyway, but the US Civil War helped speed the process. And it wasn't entirely smooth - one of the colonies did not join at the time of Confederation, but did join a few years later.

James

by oz_media

Now normally I wouldn't bother arguing with a fellow Canadian. You seem to feel that your historical knowledge has some bearing though.

When the said American comedian told this "JOKE" it was not intended to be an indepth history lesson. Nor was it supposed to be a description of Canada's history or Britain's colonization.

The difference is just that war resolves everything in the US whereas things are more passive in Canada.

Now I'm sure it will be hard for you to accept such a simple blanket statement without showing your historical prowess but please try to just take things for what they are.

It seems like we have a Canadian Maxwell too!

by oz_media

As this discussion has turned into another justification of what Bush may or may not have said, I think it should be remnamed accordingly.

President Bush - A profile instilling fear

by jamesrl

You were trying to show how superior Canada was by using a joke.

I tried to tell you it wasn't that simple.

If you didn't want to use it in an argument, then don't use it in an argument. Tell it as a joke and then we will all have a laugh.

But you can't try it one way - use it to show some sort of moral superiority over americans and then when someone calls you on it, back away and say we take it too seriously.

Guess if I make both you and Maxwell mad in one day I must be doing something right.

James

by oz_media

I was not using the joke to demonstate superiority.

Most here know that I am proud to be Canadian in that we don't get lumbered with leaders who make decisions of war. I live in Port Hardy now, after years in Vancouver and a few in the Maritimes.

West coast living is like a permanent holiday, life is very laid back (as is the Maritimes) and in general we don't take the government seriously with the exception of a few political protestors and hippies who want to free the weed, hell the government's way over there! Sure we have parliment in Victoria but that's just a nice building and tourist attraction to us, it isn't like capitol hill or something.

My point isn't that we are superior to anyone, quite the opposite actually as we don't feel the need to BE superior to anyone, nor should we.

We don't need to fight for our land, we don't need to fight for 'their' land. We do help other countries as needed but we don't invade them unless at war, which isn't really a Canadian reality anymore.

america on the other hand has ALWAYS fought for land, government, rights, policies and pretty much anytging else. It is a mentality and way of life, you fight for your freedoms.

We don't fight for our freedoms everyday, we aren't constantly under threat by anti-Canadian terrorists. It is a completely different lifestyle.

I have worked in America, I have spent countles hours in America on tour with acts I manage, on scouting ventures for the labels etc. I am quite familiar with Americans as a people, and no I don't think they are bad people. Just a society I do not wiish to be a part of. Why you may ask?

Because I don't think everything has to be WON by a FIGHT.

Please don't see this as me saying we could have taken Iraq without a fight, that's not even part of the topic here.

by maxwell edison

.
There were 44% fewer international terrorist attacks in 2002 than there were in 2001.

AND

There were fewer international terrorist attacks in 2003 than AT ANY TIME SINCE 1969.

The war on terrorism is indeed, thus far, an astounding success. Stay the course....stay the course.....this CAN BE defeated.

It's about time America has a leader - no, make that a world leader - who FINALLY has the political onions to do something about it. And that's not to take away from the soldiers on the line fighting it, without whom it would not be possible. They deserve the utmost respect and admiration.

The results don't lie.

Yes indeed, a Profile In Courage.

(Damn, just imagine the impact we could make if the other world leaders grew some onions.)

P.S. The next time you see a G.I. in a restaurant, perhaps with his family, call the restaurant manager over and give him/her some $$ to pick up their bill.

by maxwell edison

.
As mentioned, There were 44% fewer international terrorist attacks in 2002 than there were in 2001. And there were fewer international terrorist attacks in 2003 than AT ANY TIME SINCE 1969.

Why did this happen?

Another question:

This is HUGE news. Why is this not the front page headline of my local paper, or the New York Times, or the SYdney Morning Herald, or......?

by lostandfound3

Allow me to elucidate the facts to some of the ignorant and arogant. The reason for the decline in terrorist activities (hijackings and homocide-bombings) is because political leaders in Israel and MY president (and hopefully yours) George Bush stood up to the group of thugs, murderers, rapists, meglomainiacs, and just flat out psychopathological monsters and said that enough is enough. They brought the battle to these wicked demons. I don't consider these individuals human beings anymore because of their actions.

Through military action and assasination of key terrorist leaders, there is no one to plan and coordinate attacks--at least not the kind that we have seen in previous years. We summarily cutting the head off the snake. With out the head the snake cannot live. Others that attempt to take their place are so uneducated, senseless, and just flat out too stupid to execute any coherent, coordinated attack of the likes of previous years.

While these vile perpatrators against mankind sit in relative comfort, they send out the young and easily brainwashed youth to do their dirty deeds, and of course, all in the name of merciful Allah. These men are cowards, not worthy to be leaders of their own people. They are not willing to put their own life on the line to advance thier cause. Instead, they send out the gullable, uneducated, and poor to do their dirty work.

I hope they all rot in Hell.

by thechas

Max,

I suspect that the primary reason that terrorist attacks dropped in 2002 was that the September 11 and Bali attacks provided a wake-up call to all nations.

Prior to these major attacks, the potential for a terrorist attack was not given the focus needed to prevent an attack. The US in particular had a belief that "it could not happen here".

Suddenly, the whole world felt VERY vulnerable.

The intelligence organizations were kicked in the butt to find ways to intercept potential terrorists and prevent attacks from happening.

Nations that previously ignored the terrorists within their borders suddenly cooperated with the US and our allies. Allowing access to terrorist strongholds, if not capturing the terrorists themselves.

Individuals became willing to notice and report suspicious activities.

Governments and security organizations became much more interested in investigating suspicious activities.

The "true" war against terror in Afghanistan disrupted all aspects of major international terrorist operations.

For 2003 and 2004, the war in Iraq has drawn Muslim extremists into Iraq to battle the infidel invaders, and attempt to prevent an open democracy from forming.

We can also thank the fact that the terrorists misjudged the impact that their 2001 attacks would have on the world, and the US in particular.
The fact that we did not cower and hide, or buckle under to their demands must have had a demoralizing impact on many terrorist sympathizers.

As to media coverage.
We have discussed before that the media has a greater interest in bad news than in good.
Bad news sells papers and raises ratings.
Good news just takes up time and space.

I would argue that it would be a bad thing for the media to proclaim the news of reduced terrorist attacks.
The US public is VERY fickle when it comes to matters that don't have an immediate impact on their individual lives.
Letting it be known that terrorist attacks are on the decline would make far to many US citizens believe that terrorism had been "handled". They would become complacent and again ignore suspicious activity.

We need to maintain a little fear if we wish to prevent another major terrorist attack.

Chas

by oz_media

We all know that the terrorists are being slowed and that the war in Iraq is looking better each day, so what, there is still no jusitification for the president's actions leading up to it and it could have been quicker, and more effective.

Hanging on by the seat of your pants and hoping for the best is OK when you succeed, but what if you didn't?

Secondly, there are 30 countries that have become part of the liberation effort not just the USA. So I suposed you will be buying lunch for Polish, Danish, Spanish, Italian, Ukranian, Bulgarian, Tai, Estonian, Slavadoran soldiers and all the other too. Dig deep, we know you despise hand-outs.

Profile in courage is correct but you seem to feel (just like WWII) that you are doing this by yourselves and winning without anyone else's help AGAIN. This is the exact attitude that has people saying you are an arrogant and stuck up bunch while at the same time you thumb your nose at the rest of the world for not aiding your efforts. Sure America jumped in with both feet against everyone else's wishes, but they STILL came and helped when you were in deep and needed support. Whatever you say, don't say you didn't need supoprt, there's no way you could have done this alone, just lok at how thousands of Iraqi's are helping for a start. Policing that your troops had no hope of doing themselves.

I am not trying to defame your troops, nor am I saying that they are weak or ineffective. I think ANY soldier who goes to war when he is told to is a great citizens and brave defender of his country, just don't forget the rest like you have done before.

As for defeating 'Terrorism', well that';s a chuckle in itself, it may be quiet and it may be somewhat peaceful now, but who's going to stay behind for the next millenium to ensure it stays that way. There are many more terrorist organizations than those we have faced in the middle east, are they next? If so, how many more years do you expect to be at war? 50, 70, more?

I will always respect a soldier, but it's not JUST America as you always seem to credit yourselves and forget the rest.

by lostandfound3

True, it is a bit overboard calling for a complete elimination of terrorism throughout the world (rhetoric for presidential campaign-perhaps). Likewise, it is a chuckle for me as well.

The best we can hope to do is stem the problem as best as we can. Of course, also realizing that overzelous individuals, still have a possiblity of succeeding regardless of how good the intel is.

I know what you are thinking, am I one of those overzelous morons. No. Overzelous, yes. Goofy and lovable yes. See, I can agree with you on something!

by maxwell edison

.
Disingenuous comes to mind to describe you, Oz, because you know as well as I do that I don't, as you suggested, "despise hand-outs". I despise a government seizing the personal property of one citizen who chooses to be responsible, for the purpose of redistributing that property to another citizen who chooses to be irresponsible.

I love voluntary charity, and I love kind gestures, and I love the idea of buying a G.I. a meal. I live close to several military installations, both Army and Air Force (about 50 miles), and I've done it several times over the past month. The thought first came to me one night when we were having dinner at a Mexican restaurant with friends we were visiting. We spotted a young G.I. (two stripes) and his family (a wife and one little boy) in a booth across the aisle and a couple of spots down. Throughout dinner I kept noticing his little boy just crawling all over him, and I surmised that he was one of the soldiers who recently returned from Iraq. His bill was probably in the $30 - $35 range, so when I paid my bill, I gave the waiter an extra $50 with instructions to tell the G.I. that someone else picked up his tab, and for the waiter to keep the change. A nice tip for the waiter, a nice thing to do for a G.I., and a nice feeling for me. Well worth the $50 bucks.

And how convenient of you for finally remembering that the USA isn't doing this alone. After months of suggesting that we were indeed acting alone, you finally are admitting that you were mistaken (or lying or being disingenuous). The Germans, French and Russians were against the Iraq action because they were accepting bribes from Saddam (yes, it has been verified). But I suppose the Canadians are either cowards or are simply willing to sit by and do nothing but watch thousands of people die by the hands of world-wide terrorists. Keep sitting on your hands, Oz (and Canada). Others will take care of the terrorism problem for you.

You acknowledged that, on one hand, the terrorists were being slowed, but on the other hand there was no justification leading up to it. Are you suggesting that the intention of slowing terrorism and ultimately stopping terrorism, i.e. the war on terrorism, isn't justification? Oh yea, you think Iraq is all about oil, not about the war on terrorism. Well, believe what you want, Oz, but Iraq is stage two against the war on terrorism. And you suggest that it might take 50 to 70 years to defeat it? Well, you're right in the sense that it will be a long time. President Bush, himself, suggested it might take 20 to 30 years, and indeed it might. Every country in the world and every American administration prior to this one has let international terrorism grow and fester, doing nothing about it, for at least that long, maybe longer. And it just shows that this is not something that just one US administration can do, or has to do, but will take the resolve of many yet to come.

You may say that you are not "trying to defame our troops, or saying that they are weak or ineffective." Well, I can certainly believe that. You do it on a regular enough basis without even trying, so it must come natural to you.

By the way, Oz, buy a meal for a Polish, Danish, Spanish (even though they bailed out), Italian, Ukrainian, Bulgarian, Tai, Estonian, or Salvadoran soldier, or a British soldier the next time you're in the UK. Unlike Canadians, they, too, are contributing to the international war on terrorism. I'm sure any one of them would appreciate the kind gesture. (By the way, when I suggested buying a meal for a G.I., I didn't single out the American G.I, did I?)

by pgm554

The Germans and the Japanese certainly felt that God was on their side when they went to war.And so does everybody else wo goes to war.

There is a saying that there are no atheists in fox holes.

Religion, for better or worse, is an instrument of social control used by political leaders since the dawn of civilization.

The religous folks willing to die in Iraq are no different than the zealots in Christ's time to rid themselves of the Romans.

Saddam used every pragmatic social tool at his disposal to rule Iraq(religious, historical, structural-functional,economic,and political).

Good politicians know how to use these tools.
Saddam might have been an a**hole,but you don't get to where he was by not being adept at using these tools.

The new religous leaders are just using one of these social tools to gain power.They are just being pragmatic,plain and simple.

by nd_it

Religion does play on both sides of the campaign, but my point being that these insurgents in Iraq are a small (a couple thousand maybe) number trying to inflict as much damage as possible in the name of of "jihad".

The Germans and Japanese used massive armies to conquer smaller and weaker nations. Their motives were more political and true they did use religion as a tool to justify their cause. The Nazi's murdered millions because they believed they were the master race and the Japanese Kamakazi pilots did inflict damage to our Navy

The Germans and the Japenese tried to use their massive military to conquer victory, however these Iraqi isurgents know they can't defeat the US military, they are going to try to use the same tatic the North Vietnamese used, that is to use the media against, have every American so against the war, that Washington will have no choice but to pull the troops out.

by jamesrl

With regards to current conflicts, both Christianity and Islam have "golden" rules which say "do unto others, as you would have done unto you" and in both cases it isn't restricted to those of your own faith.

Germany and Japan in WWII didn't particulary try and use religion per se. Germany revived aryan mythology to try and create a "master race" myth, but it was hardly an organized religion - no churches, holy books, deities etc. Japan's major religion was Shinto - something the emporer followed faithfully, but the war was really run by the military elite. Shinto may have been used as a tool to recruit kamakaze but religion has been used that way forever.

Religion is often used as an excuse for war. Saddam Hussein was not religious, and tried hard to keep the various religious leaders in line and powerless. He only used religion when he was desparate - desparate to try and get other Muslim nations onside or neutral, and desparate to motivate his own people when he lacked other means. He added the religious script to the Iraqi flag only recently.

In Iraq, as in Yugoslavia, the dictator in place was the only thing keeping the rival religious factions from fighting. The dangerous thing to observe in Iraq is that some of the rivals have worked together in attacking a common enemy - the US. This isn't to say that the partnership will hold of the US pulls out - it could end up in a bloodier situation than now.

The main point is that religion is often used as a tool to manipulate people and opinions, but isn't the thing that instigates wars.

James

by jackofalltech

The Zealots fought against the Roman SOLDIERS, they didn't go around killing innocent civilians. The Chechnian (spelling?) rebels fought against Russian SOLDIERS - they didn't try to crash a plane into the Kremlin.

Don't you dare compare ANYONE else in history fighting for their freedom to these Islamic bastard cowards!

Ralph

by nd_it

I think you are missing what I am saying. I am saying we fought military armies during WWII. The difference being both the Japenese and the Germans surrendered. That being the key word here. These Islamic bastards, I do agree with you there, don't know the meaning of the word, they will keep on fighting because they would rather die. I am not comparing anyone that has fought for their freedom, the Japenese and Germans weren't fighting for their freedom, but for world domination. I don't know where you are getting that at, besides the topic was religion, and I am saying that these Islamic extremists are going to make it more difficult for us to have the Iraqi's govern themselves then it was for Germany and Japan post WWII.

by pgm554

Which end of the rope you?re on.

War is by definition a controlled madness. So how far one side takes it throughout history can be described as cowardly and treacherous by the other side.

In the US revolution, the British, tried to fight a war by European standards, while the US used guerrilla tactics. They were called cowards by the British.

If you have no legitimate means of redressing grievences, then violence becomes a way to get your point across.

Although nations have tried create a civilized war by setting up rules,the words "civilized" and "war" are the antithesis of each other.

by worker bee

Well Hurrah, Hurrah. Bring it on. Mission accomplished. We will fight to the last man. We will choke their rivers with our dead, that'll show em. After all those marines are just a bunch of expendable green plastic army men to our profile in courage president.

Bush will have no more success in bringing democracy to Iraq than Clinton did in bringing democracy to Haiti. We should just pull out and let those savages have their dammned civil war, and since they don't have any weapons of mass destruction we should give them some so they can kill as many of each other as possible.

by nd_it

These are the types of comments that hurts our military men and women, not Iraqi isurgents or other terrorists. These men and women are in harm's way and do their duty no matter whether they agree with the politicians in Washington. As a brother of a Army Ranger, I am VERY proud or our military and resent the comment that they are just expendable green men. They need our support, DUTY, HONOR, COUNTRY. Thank you US military!

by worker bee

Ok, so continuing to shove our soldiers into that meat grinder is "supporting" them while pulling them out of that hellhole would be "not supporting" them. If you feel so grateful to the U.S. military perhaps you would consider allowing them to live? I personally believe that the "Iraqi people" are not worth one drop of American blood. How about you?

This week I spent some time supporting a network in a rural area. Listening to the users talk about family friends and relatives serving in Iraq and comparing notes as to when they last heard from them really brought home to me that real people's lives are at stake. It is too bad our president can't seem to make the same connection.

by lostandfound3

What is amazing to me is the amount people in the world that is apathic to the inherent evil that has spawned through out the world.

I do not normally make any comments, rather I sit back and read. What I find is the incredible amount of ingnorance, arogance, and thoughtlessness that some of the individuals that are posting.

I say kudos for those that are supporting Bush. I say kudos for those that are in the military that is over there fighting to keep to ensure that MY freedoms our secured.

The only reason individuals outside of the US are against us is because they are jealous of our progress. They are jealous of our wealth. They are jealous of the abilities of a simple American citizen being able to work to achieve successes, when this individual can be anyone. This includes those that are the most berift of the luxuries that others have. They our jealous of our productivity. Most of all, they are jealous because we are the only reigning super power in the world that takes its responsibilities seriously.

The reason why they are against us is because they want to see us fail. We have not failed. They want to see us become a poor third world nation. Our economy is in a recovery and we are stronger than ever.

If everybody sees the United States as a country of decadence and debauchary, then why is it that millions of individuals seek to become citizens? Answer me that. This country has more opportunities to provide individuals with the basic freedoms that have been endowed by our creator to seek the necessities to establish a stable family that will prosper and continue in perpetuity without worry of any other country or even our own government envenerating the strength and courage of the American spirit.

For those whose nations that were built on peaceful terms, I say that is fabulous that you and your countrymen were able to do this. However, we have had to continue fighting to earn our place in the world.

When the day comes when your country faces the crisis that occured on 9/11, will fight to make sure that an incident like this again, or will you turn tail and run like cowards like the current Prime Minister of Spain. I am not saying that the Spanish people are not couragous in their own right, but their government is building a policy of appeasement that has never worked. This can be proved throughout history. Take more recent events: World War II. It was through appeasement by Chamberlin that Hitler became the menace to the whole of Europe and the world. Threating to wipe out entire populations of Gypsies, homosexuals, and, most of all, Jews. Do you honestly think that a radicall Islamist is going to be sane enough to negotiate peace with? Personally I think if they want to die for Allah, I say we help them along by taking the battle to them; rather than sitting our our hands, fearing the next attack.

It is absolutely deplorable how even certain members of my own government don't get it. Take Senator Ted "where's my pants" Kenedy, House Rep Jim McDermmot, House Rep Nacy Pelosi, Senator Tom "little general" Daschel, Senator Robert "KKK" Byrd, and presidentail nominee Senator John "Mr. Heinz" Kerry (gigalo extrodinare). These people are doing more harm to our troops than ever by the statements they make that what is even realize. They are giving aid and comfort to our enemies, for whom swore to fight us to the bitter end. They lift the morale of our enemies by showing that there are those in our country who do not support the effort. This makes them more hardened and more determined to not surrender or negotiate. Kennedy said that this ware is, "George Bush's Vietnam." Well if that is the case I say to him that is because YOU are responsibile for turning the coflict that way by not shutting you fat, bloated, drunk mouth you hypocrite. These individual exemplify treason at its finest.

I am I calling these fine (snicker) individuals treasonists. Yes I am. As long as they continue to give aid and comfort to our enemies, thereby putting our men and women in uniform in greater harms way, they are treasonists. And I am willing to expand this conjecture further by saying, that those that support these representatives are treasonists as well and should be ashamed of themselves.

We fought for our freedoms. MY country has the tendancy to not realize how wonder full we have it here and are apathetic to the world around us. It is time we wake up and realize that in order for us to survive as a nation, we must fight for what is right, and support those who are oppressed, tortured, maimed, and killed because of the whims of a mad man.

by nd_it

So we should have pulled out of Europe and the Pacific during WWII then? Because that was a hellhole too. No matter where war is waged, big or small, it is hell, and our troops need our support whether we agree with why we are there our not, they need to know we are behind them all the way.

by jacko4

thanks for the history of poor downtrodden america,of course we wont mention the atrocities and carpet bombing carried out by the US in Vietnam,Cambodia,most of central and latin america and of course the invasion of a little place called Grenada.

by maxwell edison

.
When did the U.S. "carpet bomb" anything in Central America? And will you please describe what you feel were the "atrocities" connected to, or lack of justification connected with the Grenada conflict? And please include a history of, and circumstances associated with Grenada at that time.

(By the way, Grenada - if you blinked, you missed it.)

by jacko4

I did not say specifically that central america was carpet bombed,though we all know about vietnam and cambodia.Grenada was "invaded" because of bad intelligence reports and they were frightened a leader would get in that they didnt approve of,by the way,it doesnt matter how small grenada is the us shouldnt have been there,the same as the us shouldnt be poking its nose into lots of other countries business. About WMD,not only did us invent most of these weapons it actively sold the technology to anyone,there is only one country in the world that has used weapons of mass destruction on a large scale,yes you are right,usa,there is also only one country in the world that does not have to conform to any inpections for any of these capabilities and that is israel,why?
oh but thats another topic us/israel v arabs

by jacko4

I forgot, my information is from us websites,if I can post links on here you will be able too see for yourself

by maecuff

If an American does not agree with your views, they are a fat bloated drunk mouth hypocritical treasonist? So much for the freedom you speak of..

by lostandfound3

Just as you are entitled to your opinion, I am entitled to mine. Mr. Kenedy is entitled to his, but because he is a public figure he should be more responsilbe for the words he uses.

With freedoms comes responsiblities use those freedoms wisely. Exercising your rights to free speech is very important, whether or not you agree with my statements. The likewise is true, and I am willing to presume that individuals, such as yourself are careless about what you say.

As human beings, we stand above all creatures on the planet because we have the abilities the think, show emotion creatively, logically reason (for most of us--in case you are to simple minded to understand the comment, this is an opinion), and the ability to manipulate the environment around us (for good or bad).

As responsible individuals in a civilized society it is our duty AND responsiblity to act in a manner that overturns the barbarism that is pervasive through out the globe.

If you refuse to acknowlege this simple fact, then I pray that one day that you will eventually get it.

I do not force my opinions on others. I call it like it is. If you don't like it tough. The same can be said to me, as well.

I do not need government to how to run my life, and I rather not. If you have not guess, I am a contractor for the government, and I personally thank God on a daily basis for the inefficiencies inherent in the system. It is some members in our own goverenment, people apathetic as yourself, and other individuals through out the world that threatens this. To them, I rather see them defeated than to be in an area of influence. It is them that got us into this mess to begin with, like it or not.

Take some responsiblity for the freedoms you exercise, or else one day freedoms that you are so condesending about, and freely exercise, will exist no more.

by maecuff

Okay, I am careless about my words, I am condescending about my freedom, yet you are the one who resorts to school yard name calling. Fat bloated drunk mouth..I'm not sure I know what a drunk mouth is? Wouldn't the WHOLE person be drunk, not just the mouth? And another thing, you are a frightening person, you realize this, right? I sincerely hope you don't own any weapons. (Although, I am willing to bet that you are a gun owner).

by maecuff

And here I've always thought that I was an open minded, reasonably intelligent, kind person..when all along, I've been the corruptor of an entire nation, just because I may not (or may, I didn't really say) agree with your particular point of view. As far as your suggestion that I leave the country, thanks..but I think I'll stay. And vote and retain my opinions about the way I would like to see MY country progress.

by maxwell edison

.
By the way, if you don't mind a suggestion, you should consider changing your TechRepublic alias to something other than your email address.

by jamesrl

I am of course referring to the excellent book and ok movie, but its amazing how it applies to this post.

If you don't agree with the last poster's opinion you are either an apathetic ignorant foreigner who is jealous of the US or if you are an american you are a traitor.

In a democracy, we have to have a certain level of respect for the opinions of others, else we end up with the "Tyranny of the majority". Its a fool and a tyrant who believe that only they know the truth.

I for one am happy to be where I am(Canada). I have had the chance to move to the states, and turned it down, despite the fact I would have been economically better off. This isn't to say that I hate America or Americans. But I am glad they aren't all of the same mindset as Aggie.

Wake up and smell the coffee as Ann Landers would say. There are happy, economically prosperous people all over the world living in democracies. They have the right to have their own opinions. They may not share you point of view, but that doesn't make them ignorant. The same for the democrats you and Anne Coulter call traitor. If you don't have opposition you don't have democracy.

James

by lostandfound3

With all due respect, forgive me if I insinuated that you were ignorant in any way shape or form. If you are responding obviously you have a clue as to what is going on.

Respectfully, I agree, there must be a balance. Just because I hold the beliefs that I have, does not mean I do not want to hear the other side. It is good to have a check on the majority to ensure smaller groups are not simply railroaded.

In previous posts, I have been seethingly angry and have let my emotions get the better part of me. After all I too am fallable. It is for that reason a check is good to make sure raving lunatics, such as myself (you can go ahead and laugh at this--I got a sense of humor too), in balance with the rest of society.

I express deep concern that the majority is being squelched with the likes of the minority. There is no compromising going on to better things. Its frustrating as Hell when you believe you are doing the right thing and your next door neighbor kicks you in the teeth. Any further posts I make I will tone it down. I know it has gotten out of hand and I have cooled down a bit, please forgive me.

When you sit and pay attention to all that is going around you. In your heart you believe you are doing right, when some body decides, instead of talking rationallay, goes on a series of diatribes against you (I am at fault for this). However, remember that the form of government that the United States has is not a PURE DEMOCRACY. We are a Representative Governement with a federalist system in place.

With that said, I want to hear and I want to learn. Remember it goes both ways. The majority interest is the rule day, but that does not mean the minority, and at times, dissenting opinion will not be heard.

Before I submit, I humbly (spelling?) appologize for words spoken in anger. But would you be angry too if some consistently described every effort, every action, and every move as being acts of evil? I think you would...

by jamesrl

I understand where you are coming from. I am not perfect either, though often when I get angry, I find it helpful to comppose a scathing reply and then delete until I've calmed down.

The challenge you raise is that you feel that you are right and the people who are wrong are wrong to challenge you. But this is the essense of democracy. Of course its bad when it degenrates into name calling and away from constructive discourse. Of course there are many issues where this happens - its not Iraq, its every war, and things like capital punishment, abortion, and other issues which tend to vear away from dialogue and move into rhetoric, and then into charecter assasination(and in the case of abortion, people assasination).

There does come a time when you have to accept what is, and move on - especially if you are on the "losing" side. You can't win every time, and you should try and pick your battles. Myself, I find sometimes I would rather abandon an argument where I am never going to change a mind than to frustrate myself battering my head against a wall.

James Linn

by maecuff

is.. I HAVE a sense of humor. You'll sound less like an ignorant psychopath if you improve your grammar.

(you can go ahead and laugh at this--I got a sense of humor too)

by lostandfound3

Any way we can change that to:

The Image-Sending Impaired American

or

The Not-so-beautiful/handsome American

???? lol!

by jamesrl

I highly recommend it. Despite the non-PC title.

The movie gets the point across , but less subtly.

James

by lostandfound3

As a matter of fact, I do not own a gun. I do not really like the things myself. However, people are entitled to defend themselves in the face of an attack, especially when they have not been provoked.

We did not start this. But we sure are going to finish it. It is a terrible shame that the manner of resolution could not be accomplished by peaceful terms, but when you are dealing with psychopaths there is no negotiating. These monsters understand only one thing, brute force. If they will not negotiate, and I quote from a European general for who I cannot recall is name right now, "Kill them all, God will know his own."

Again, if you don't like what I am saying tough.

If you think I am going to sit idle and let like minded individuals destroy what we, as a nation, built for the last two hundred and twenty-eight (228) years, then you have another thing coming. You have hijacked this nation long enough and it is time the good people around the country stand up for the values that we all believe in. If you don't like the country I live in, stay out I don't want you here corrupting our way of life; or if you are current citizen, find a country that will you can better identify with your political beliefs and become a citizen there (good riddence).

And with people like you in the world, I may just take you up on your suggestion of getting a gun. Simply to protect myself and my family and other people I care about from the likes of YOU.

If I scare the Hell out of you, good. Be frightened. For the kingdom of God is at hand. Those who support wickedness will swept away with the rest of the chaffe in to the fire, while the grains will be collected and stored in His silo.

by oz_media

Well your patriotism is strong, your hate for others is strong, I'd say you were American!

You seem to be vastly underestimating your enemy though. UNlike a snake, terrorist are more of a wrom, you cut it in half and you have two terrorist regimes, don't fool yourself by thinking they are below you or undereducated. Only an idiot can kill senselessly, it doesn't take a friggin brain surgeon.

Any moron can kill a few US soldier, and the a few more etc. etc. They aren't exactly playing tactical warfare here, you're not up against Hitler, you are up against people who die to kill.

Make some sense and perhaps try again.

by lostandfound3

If people were more supportive of the goals of reducing conflict, maybe there can be better progress. What suggestion do you have, that will actually work? I am open minded, and as far as hatred of other outside my country.

Your words remind me of saying we have down here in red neck, white trash country: "It's like the pot calling the kettle black." I know this is what you think of us and do not deny it. It is a fact that I do not worry myself with, because it is not worth it. Before you accuse me, have a look at yourself.

by oz_media

I didn't realize that old phrase was from Texas!
Well I guess I owe, y'all an poligy.

I didn't accuse you of anything except underestimating your enemy which is a major mistake of any war or fight.

You seem so happy to jump up and down for lady liberty and think you are up against a retarded opponent. If they are so pathetic, how do so many soldiers keep dying? According to your analogy of these terrorists, you seem to be inimizing the effectiveness of your own military. If they were that sad, you'd be done with it already and not a single life lost.

by lostandfound3

Those who provide no solution to a problem, but criticize those who make an attempt at a solution and when they don't get their way EXACTLY (i.e. they do not compromise at all or bring to the table a set of comparable solution), and rather scare people into voting for them: are they Democrates and Canadian counterparts?

by oz_media

I think you're digging in pretty deep now, but there's got to be some point you are trying to make.

You'll shoot somebody, why don't you just spit it out and say what you are implying?

It's obvious that you are a typical Republican and wish to bully the rest of the world's population into submission that you are the high and mighty leaders of the world. You do realize your country has also been trying to do this without success since it's fouding though right?

Now you are either suggesting that Canadians are like Democrats or that Canadian ARE Democrats, in which case which neither could be farther from the truth. Now as for politics, canada does not play politics, we don't look at one another or judge one another based on political preference. I couldn't tell you what political patry ANY of my friends, family or associates support, it simply isn't a topic of discussion as we don't play political games all day. So while they may well be Democrats, Liberals, socialists etc. we don't tag each other nor do we need to as nobody is welcome to discuss politics here, it just doesnt matter to us what or who you support. We just live instead of figuring out HOW to survive, we aren't at threat and haven't been raisied to fear others or their religious/political views.

That said, prehaps you could elaborate on just which Canadians don't support your war efforts? Is it the ones who fight beside you guys all the time or is it the parents who are sick of their kids being sent to war because YOU have gone to war again? Would it be the Canadians who went to battle in WWII several years before you were attacked and pushed to help out too? Do you think you'd have even turned up for WWII if you hadn't been attacked yourselves? Now don't get me wrong, the US provided many brave men who were willing to fight and help repress Hitler, including almost every country in the world.
What really bugs me though is some people, usually with the 'You are jealous of us" mentality as you have expressed feel that america won WWII. Failing to realize that Hitler had run up against a brick wall (The RAF), he was spread too thin and after the 'Allied' invasion of Normandy was pushed back until he finally had the Russians kicking his ass as he tried to backpeddle.

You efforts were welcomed and appreciated, they were about four or five years later than needed and the whole mentailty that the US won the war must stop, but you did send a large number of troops to invade Normandy after you were attacked yourselves.

by oz_media

I don't think you could or should pull out now. THat would be the most detrimental move made by the US to date.

I DO feel tht these people who bravely support the clown with the biggest shoes were being sent to die a little prematurely though, MANY less would have dies if this truly was an allied effort from the start and not just some hasty grudge the president boiled up. Can you imagine how successful this would have been with full Allied military at the door? It's inevitable that less lives would have been lost, you were pretty much trading 1 for 1 for a while?

I agree though that the pres need some help of institutional kind. How many Germans supported Hitler thinking he was the righteous one and was saving them from certain doom?

A hitler refernece in the same paragraph with GWB always riles the masses, don't miss that one next time.

by nd_it

I also feel that pulling out now would by disasterous for the Iraqi people. I don't think we could win either way. We are viewed as occupiers now by many, but if we just pack up and leave, they think we have abondoned them. Some people think it is okay for us to leave and let them fight themselves, how many more innocent Iraqi's will die as a result? We need to stay the course no matter what kind of person is in the White House. I just wish one of one them would give me a clear cut plan for what they are going to do. Kerry has spent too much time debating something that happened 30 years ago, tell me how you are going to improve the economy. I wasn't alive 30 years ago, could have cared less what Kerry did (unless it was some henious thing) I want to know what he is going to do for the next four years.

I agree that an allied campaign would have been a better approach. I think Bush was looking for a fight after 9/11 and took his posse to the OK Corrall and beging to start shooting the bad guys. I am disappointed however with the UN. Not against it, just disappointed. I think they passed resoltution after resolution without anything getting accomplished, we had to act. I just wish we did have more friends, more of which are becoming our enemies, for which I am sorry for as well, to assist us.

by jamesrl

In terms of a warfighting campaign, the American forces are the best equipped and best trained. I'm not sure what contributions other countries could have made. And as in Aghanistan, there are often problems when you have too many players involved, in terms of the efforts in co-ordination.

Where more participation would have been helpful is in peacemaking/peacekeeping. Canada, for example, has been involved in every major UN peacekeeping initiative. Our troops have extensive experience in it, are well trained, and can and do train other forces in it as well. But right now, we are stretched with our deployment in Aghanistan.

But its hard to go to the UN and ask for help when many in the Bush admin called the UN, and major players on the security council irrelevant. Hard to undo some of the things said and done.

I don't see a good way out here. If a rapid pullout happens, civil war may happen too, and we know from experience civil war is the bloodiest type of conflict. You have a Shia majority who have been out of power for decades, a Sunni minority who are used to controlling the country, and the Kurds who have been relatively independant since the first gulf war, and who would resist any attempts to impose a "Baghdad" government over them.

James

by nd_it

Now Bush is trying to lobby the UN into a peacekeeping role. I don't know if the damage can be undone. Some US forces in Iraq are trained for warfare and combat, not so much peacekeeping missions, that is where the UN needs to be involved, and I think Bush said the hell with you, we are going it alone. We can obviously wage war by ourselves, but conducting peace is a whole another thing, more have to be involved.

by oz_media

Well firstly, the US Army relies heavily on Canada's Coyote recon vehicles. They are faster, lighter and better equipped for recon than what the US offers.

The British have extremely talented and dedicated Special Missions teams that were carrying out covert operations as the US kicked in the front door to Iraq. Remember the UK forces uncovered the mass graves, not the US.

Every army has it's strenghts and weaknesses. The US has strength in numbers more than anything else as we have seen in almost every battle they have fought, not to say the Armour and Weaponry is substandard, but numbers have helped immensely over the years beginning with WWII. Other countries fear fighting the US because the US can replenish it's soldiers in a rotation so that they aren't all wasted and too tired to fight after a few months.

by lostandfound3

I see us engaged for at least 2 years after an elected government is put in place. The big problem is that Iraq has no way of adequately defending itself.

If we are going to ensure peace there, their military needs rebuilding and support from everyone. I am skepitcal that the U.N. is competent in doing this (what a suprise there), but what is needed is a way for international involvement to take place with visibility into the operations of what ever conceived operations. Even if the U.S. is in the lead, I believe there should be no exception to us. Even when we demand it from others.

by lostandfound3

Let me make amends on this one point. I have people believing I am a gun totting luntatic from Texas. I really do not fit this profile at all. In fact, this has to be the first time I have let people know how I am feeling and thinking.

You can't win them all, but you sure as Hell can try!

by oz_media

explain this comment please in detail.

"...over there fighting to keep to ensure that MY freedoms our secured."

Look at this one Max, I told you these people wer here.
"The only reason individuals outside of the US are against us is because they are jealous of our progress. They are jealous of our wealth. They are jealous of the abilities of a simple American citizen being able to work to achieve successes, when this individual can be anyone."

Perhaps you can explani to me exactly WHO is over there fighting YOUR war, don't forget all the others.

As for everyone wanting to become American citizens, you are speaking not of MOST of the world but most of the repressed world or thiose that have lived in poverty. I have never met a single Canadian that would rather live in America, most cringe at the thought.
I COULD be an American citizen VERY easily, in fact easier than most but have no desire to.

"rather than sitting our our hands, fearing the next attack."
Yes you ahve been listening to BUsh haven't you, where did you get that sense of fear of attack from? Do you feel you were in line to be attacked? By what and whom? (you are simply digging a hole here you know)

"or will you turn tail and run like cowards like the current Prime Minister of Spain."

SPAIN??
"apatero vowed that fighting terrorism would be his first priority as he sets about creating an administration "that will work for peace."

"I am going to fight the violence that also is attacking other nations in this world," he told reporters.

For that he was asking for the support of the Spanish people, he said.

"I want to create an alliance against violence and all kinds of terrorism," he said. "I don't want to create my own war."

So what for decideing that this should be a unified or alied effort and not a singular effort, Spain is now a bunch of "cowards"?
What about the spanish military that is fighting alongside your own troops in Iraq?

Conclusion, you have a very narrow and blind understanding that you are doing this alone and protecting yourself from ????? (you can fill in the blank) and yet blame those who ARE helping you in Iraq (30+ countries) for not showing up? Where were you in 1939 when the world went to war, without US support?

Curled up in bed, hoping it never came your way.

You are the exact type of typical Yank who gives the rest of Americans a bad name, you should not speak for your country if you are going to drag them in the mud as you do so.

As for your "wonder full" country, it is a wonder how being constantly in harms way or going to war is considered freedom or wonder full.

by lostandfound3

Don't know, I am a Texans fan. Though we do kind of stink right now.

Sounds like you are in New York. Don't mean to light a fire over you (couldn't help the pun), but with Roger Clemens and the rest of the pitching line up, I think the Astros may win something.

Like we say here in Houston: If it get dreadfully cold and we see a blizzard the likes of the northeast, then Hell has frozen over and the Astros won the World Series!

by lostandfound3

Well you know my types: I like my 4 rods to a hogs head, and that is the way I likes them!

I have stated in my other posts, I am a victim of letting emotion get the better of me, and I would like to apologize. Whether you accept this or not, thats up to you. Besides, instead of ridiculing each other ( I admitt I started it this time), we should both hope to that our country progresses.

We both share a common ideal, we both have a love for our country (I tend to show mine bit more than others). So, I propose we start acting like a single people keeping the intrest of allowing progress to occur, and work together in providing solutions. Lets get rid of the scare tactics and develop an honest solution, with no regards to party affiliation. We should both share an interest of securing ourselves so that we both prosper and the world prospers. We cannot achieve this without some consideration for both our point of views.

I started it and I'll close it. I repeat my humble appologies. Since this gets read by everyone in this discussion, I cannot hide from it.

I think many of the readers agree that our leaders, Democrat and Republican, should work to solving problems together. Those individuals should not shove things down another throat, while others should not breed fear and dissent that provides hope for those we are trying to we are trying to overcome.

Working together good... (Your friendly neighborhood barbarian).

by oz_media

It would really be helpful if you didn't come across as a patriotic American and a sick individual at the same time. You raise some interesting concerns (nothing new but interesting all the same) and then screw it up by elaborating on your comments. If your post was shorter you might have some credibility left.

You said "...defend themselves in the face of an attack."

Now which 'attack' are you referring to?

by lostandfound3

You're right. I generally read through the first time before I send things. I been, lets say, trigger happy?

by oz_media

C'mon maecuff! You are a free person who is allowed to express herlsef however she feels, that's your freedom. Just make sure it coincides with everyone else's opinion though or you will be a traitor.
;-)

by maecuff

Apology accepted. Hopefully, you still don't want to shoot me. I promise that I will never endanger your family.

by nd_it

I agree with you on this point. I thought that my posts indicated that, I am sorry if it didn't. Religion is a tool, not usually a justification in war. More times than none it is political.

by oz_media

If you showed proof in any form to support your beliefs, you will find th erepondent will either:
A) Discount your sources
B) Play on words
C) Flame your own integrity if nothing can be contested

You are being baited and there's no end to it.

by jacko4

there is plenty of proof out there,Im afraid I just see the usual we are better than everyone else mentality,I think bush will go down in history as one of the worst leaders of all time,unfortunately for me mr blair seems to think the sun shines out of his a,@#e and he will take us down the same road,never mind im sure there will be some more flag waving when i come back on tomorrow !

by nd_it

I live up here in the Great White North, and it has been cold enough for hell to freeze, but the Vikings still haven't won the Super Bowl :)

by maecuff

I'm not from New York and I don't follow sports. I also enjoy Michael Moore. I am a democrat (although, I think we could have done MUCH better than John Kerry) and I would like nothing more than to see this war end. I have many opinions on many of these posts, however, taking the time to write them down wouldn't change anyone's views from theirs to mine and quite frankly, I wouldn't want to. We're different, we see things in a different way. That's what makes us human.

by oz_media

What about Vic Peters who's Manitoba rink lost to Alberta in the Brier?

Or those BC Lions (better still the BC Felions)?

I can't handle NFL my alarm keeps going off and waking me up, the hard part is when you have slept for an hour and they are still on the same down they were before, but the ball has changed hands 17 times in the process.

Oh well, I won't slag football I guess, you guys are pretty hooked on NFL there as well as the 'Pumpkin slapping' league.

I don't watch durling and lacross as many people would think but Lions games are fun and the babes are worth the price of beer (I wonder if they are or if it's the price of beer that is justifies the women)? Nah, all the hotties are here that's our one claim to fame.

I guess nobody wants to talk kayaking or sailing. Golf is too personal. Baseball is too corrupt nowdays. I guess it's the great GWB then, sigh. Oh well with any luck it won't be for long. Then we can bitch about whoever the next moron is.:-)

by maecuff

Those topics are all boring too. Think of another one. Preferably one that won't get me shot, deported or sent to the fiery silo.

by oz_media

It has been rasied many times here that people in the US have different understandings of WHY the war began, why GWB refused to abide by his former allies wishes etc.

What was it that you feel made this neccessary?

You mentioned several times that you want to protect your family and not wait for an attack. Where did you get the idea you would be attacked? What were you protecting yourself from?

by lostandfound3

Let me establish what made my mind up. First, I will agree the WMD stuff was over board. Realistically, speaking the capability of WMD development is one point, but it was not the total selling point. Given Saddam Hussein's (spelling?) past record on the international scene, it was evident to me that eventhough WMD was not found it is the knowledge of how to build such weaponry. Furthermore, his past track record has proven him unreliable in maintaining agreements to dismantle his programs fully. I can go into sources information, but we don't have the time, nor it is not the point you asked me to make. This posses a serious security concern especailly when U.S. troops uncovered terrorist bases north of Baghdad and substantial evidence that the former Iraqi government had relations with this group and other Al'Qada (sp?-correct me please) connected organizations. This includes members of the cell that executed the 9/11 attacks.

The point that convinced me was the inhumane treatment that members of the Baathist party was performing. You may call me a Republican bully, but I do not condone or come anywhere close to the thuggary and intentional brutality that he was responsible to protect. Furthermore this is the same regeime that its neighbors, other Arab states loathed and feared because of what I pointed out. Hussein's and the Baathist Party's crimes against humanity rank up there with Hitler and the Nazi's. From some of the reading I have done, I would almost say that it surpassed it. This man had no moral or ethical standards, except for ones that provdied the greatest luxury for himself and his cronies. As someone of spiritual faith, I was taught to forgive others for their sins. Its difficult to do this with him because of the enormity of the atrocities that have taken place during the last 30 years he ruled the country.

Lastly, the in action of the United Nations to enforce the very resolutions that it imposed on him and Hussein denied for the past 13 years prior to the war. What good is U.N. resolutions if ,the very body that is responsible to keeping all countries in check, does not back up what they say with extreme penalties (military conflict included) when resoultions are not followed through by ALL parties. What I found disgusting is reports coming from the Food for Oil scandal, in which the likes of France, Germany, and Russia (our very allies) were simply bought off by Hussein through exclusive and very lucrative oil exports. The very program established to make sure money to be used on medical supplies, food, and water never managed to make it to those who were in desperate need of it: Iraqi citizens. Saddam pocketed the money and used it to advance his weapons programs, leaving the country in serious state of depravity and poverty. Let's not forget the suppression of the Shittes that are in southern Iraq and the Kurds in the north. Do the same humanitarian rights apply to them as well? Do we sit by when acts of atrocity take place on people by the very government that is supposed to protect them? You sound like a sensible person, can you deny the fact of these atrocities taking place? Knowing this would you allow this to happen? Can you accept the decision of in action by the very world body that is supposed to ensure such attrocities are averted or mitigated?

Bottom line, I believe in and support my president because of these points. Declaring Saddam had WMD was a mistake and not put into proper context to begin with. Frankly, I do not think it was needed to press the point for going to war. Bush had enough rationale for going forward with this effort. Regrettably, I now believe he used a poor choice in a point to expand upon. There was enough evidence to support this conflict without it.

What's said is said, and what is done is done. It may be my feeble attempt at optimisim, but I really believe that the world is a better place since that monster was deposed.

You have my rationale, you've seen my passion (and foot inserted in mouth on numerous occasions today), and you have seen my belief. If I have not adequately provided the answer to your question, please post and clarify.

It would seem the goals of the world community are clear: a peacful and stable Middle East. Without this, there is a lot of hurt everyone feels (economically as well as personal). Bashing and individual who is taking action to achieve these goals are productive, just as previous remarks made by myself.

As far as a narrow view of the world, I fully understand there are other countries involved as well, your country I believe has made some sort of contribution. That all is greatly appreciated. The one thing that I cannot help looking from my position, as small as it may be, and trying to understand the events that surround me. What may appear to be common sense to me may not be necessarily so to others. If it sounds as if I am backing down a bit, I am. Time to cool down and time for rational thought to occur has helped. But, continued insult after insult has caused my reaction. If I am respectful to you and others, I would expect a same level of respect in all our discourse. We can agree to disagree, but there is no reason to be insulting and disrespectful to others in the process.

One last thing, it is Friday, lighten up some.

by oz_media

A major reason others didn't join the initial invasion was because they feared it would be a long resolve if not conducted properly.

They KNOW they are going to be policing and occupying Iraq for a long time and simply wanted a more tactical aproach to the situation. GWB ignored the request and basically said 'F all of you and the UN' so he went in alone, with your family in front of him of course. THIS is the ONLY issue I've ever contestd regarding this war, the reason for the knee jerk reaction and the haste of the decision to invade unsupported. Well luckily everyone else has joined in now and things are getting better, from the mixed opinions that we hear anyway.

by lostandfound3

If you haven't guessed (been sleepin' or something :)) I am a Republican. And yes, you guys could have done better with your nominee, what does he stand for again? He changes his mind too much for my simple Angry White Male mind to follow. I guess I like my president like I like a lot of things in life: simple (lol). I too desire and end to this, but I would hope we can make the world a better place in the process. The very democracy that all of us here that gives us the right to ridicule each other, political figures, and other hair-brained morons (such as myself) should not be soley a right of the United States and most modern countries. Democracy, freedom, and liberty should be a right to everyone in the world regardless of ethnicity, nationality, or other reasons. Can we agree on that?

What do you guys think about a homeland security plan that does not include effective controls on immigration? This is a big issue that I have against Bush, and I don't mind B***hing about myself.

I take the stance that illegal aliens, or as you guys call it now-- undocumented workers, should be expelled and tighter security along our borders should be implemented. Furthermore, I would like to see a promotion for legal immigration and assisting and supporting those who want to follow the law. I am not an isolationist, beyond your belief. The world economy is far too in-grained with ours and it would be impossible to sever its ties without causing a world depression (then we become the real oppressors of everyone around the world). It would make sense to enforce and improve the laws we have, strengthen our border security taking sensible measures, and promoting the legal route to becoming a citizen.

Let's face the facts, the United States looses a lot of money each year to illegal immigration. Money that would be used for legal residents and U.S. citizens gets funneled into supporting programs that give the impression of supporting what should be an illegal activity.

Thoughts?

by thechas

Now that we have invaded Iraq and deposed of Saddam Husein, we need to stay and finish what we started.

I was opposed to this war before it started. But, if we leave now, all the lives that have been lost will have been lost in vain. We need to support our troops, and stay until the people of Iraq are capable and ready to govern and protect themselves.

The US has created many of our enemies because we left other conflicts without finishing the job. Or, because we supported a "cooperative" dictator rather than take a chance with a group of freedom fighters.

If we leave Iraq too soon, Iraq will become another Iran. Ruled by religious extremists bent on teaching their followers to hate the United States and ALL non-believers.

We would then have a worse situation than we had before. A situation that we would never be able to recover from. As the people of Iraq (and the rest of the world) would never trust the US to help them get rid of a ruthless dictator.

Chas