Discussion Locked

President Bush - A Profile in Courage

0 helpful
281 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

281 replies

by oz_media

I wont ad to your comments in fear that it may detract from your honesty.

Well done.

by maxwell edison

.
On declaring war:

We've never declared war, nor could we, on individuals, only nations, and no nation since WWII. And the formal "declaration of war" can only be sought against a nation, not individuals. That's one of the difficult aspects of this whole thing.

Contrary to what many people think, although there's no denying that the USA was indeed attacked, Afghanistan, as a "nation" did not attack the USA on 9-11 . The perpetrators of that act did indeed seek safe haven in Afghanistan, at least some of them did. But not all of them. Should we have "declared war" on Afghanistan AND all those other nations who provided safe haven for anyone involved in 9-11? If we did, we would have "declared war" on a dozen or more nations, including ourselves. We didn't "declare war" on any nation because not any particular nation was behind it. If that was the case, it would have been a pretty clear-cut decision. What we basically did was to say, okay terrorists, enough is enough, and we're going to come and get you, no matter where you go, no matter how long it takes, no matter what anyone thinks about it, and no matter who supports us or opposes us. World-wide terrorism has to stop - PERIOD. To many nations, and too many "United Nations" have stood by and done nothing. How long should we stand by and do nothing?

Ask yourself this question. Did Saddam Hussein's Iraqi regime, either specifically or in general, support world wide terrorism? The answer is yes. Did Saddam Hussein's Iraqi regime, either specifically or in general, support world wide terrorism targeted at America or Americans? Again, the answer is yes. (Don't forget the $25,000 reward he offered to anyone, or at least their families, who killed Americans in terrorist attacks.)

In my opinion, every nation on the face of the Earth should support this war on terrorism, because every nation has been hurt by it. Why did Russia, France and Germany oppose the Iraq phase of the war on terrorism? Because their leaders and/or representatives were financially benefiting from "under-the-table" deals with Saddam Hussein. Do you think they were supporting the World's best interest? Do you think they were supporting Iraq's best interest? Do you think they were supporting America's best interest? The answer to those questions is no. They were supporting their own best interests, and to think otherwise is being naive'.

On the United Nations:

Please read and study all of the United Nations Charters that you are attempting to cite. We violated NO United Nations charters. In fact, the United Nations has violated its very own charters and resolutions. (As they have for years.) The United Nations is a corrupt and inept organization, and they certainly don't look out for the best interests of the United States. And the United States can't set aside its own best interests to simply pacify some foreign criminal posing as a leader. Read United States resolution 1441. We had all the authority necessary to do just what we did.

On Having no real plan for reconstruction:

Again, you are mistaken. There are more schools, more hospitals, more electricity, more clean water, more local elections, and on and on, than there was before Saddam's fall. And you are also mistaken in thinking the whole country is in chaos or engaged in battles. To the contrary, most of the country is indeed rebuilding for a more hopeful future.

As an illustration, I'll point out that Iraq is about the size of the state of California. And all of "California" is not in a perpetual state of disorder and bedlam. The "insurgents", as they are affectionately called by the media, but are really no more than a very well armed gang of thugs who are determined to prevent democracy from taking hold in Iraq, are holed up in a few locations. The hotbeds of violence, for example, are limited to Bakersfield and a couple of other cities. The rest of California, I mean Iraq, is trying to lift itself up and finally join the community of nations.

Why not invade the other countries:

Because it's not practical for us to do so, that's why. But consider this. If those countries deserve to be considered as similar to Iraq and Saddam as it pertains to various atrocities inflicted on its own people, where is the United Nations that you claim we should "rely" on to handle such things? That only proves the UN is inept. And that only illustrates that we can't - and shouldn't rely on them.

by mlayton

...I did not mean we don't have a plan for reconstruction now. What I meant by was at the time of the invasion there was not a plan for reconstruction that other countries could back. Had there been - or had it been properly presented as such - there would have been more support.

And while "declaring war on individuals" was a poor choice of words, it is in fact what we did - and if that is just my layman's view, then probably is the same view held by supporters of those individuals... and thus the folk hero and martyr roles will follow - and put more lives in danger. It is not questioned that in a conflict such as this, overzealousness can be found in all aspects - on the part of the insurgents out to harm the US, and on the part of our own US military, abusing their power over prisoners, according to the latest news. The good leader will seek the peaceful resolutions that cause the least amount of danger to all people, not just his own. The good leader would also be able to put the spin on to say that they sought those peaceful resolutions first, even if the ultimate result is the same.

And if I also am doubtful the US exhausted all peaceful means before subjecting the people of Iraq to the war on terrorism, so are others. Including some of the people in those countries.

A large part of leading a country is being diplomatic and playing the politics. While the UN may have issues (not denying that!) you need to first try to change the system, or at least rally others to your cause before bypassing the system, or you will be out leading a charge with nobody following, leading to the overwhelmingly global opinion that Americans are in it for themselves, and don't have any sense of global awareness. Unfortunately, the world sees us in generalities, just as we see tend to generalize other countries. So our leader needs to project global awareness/sensitivity on our behalf. I don't think that mission has been accomplished.

by maxwell edison

.
The "context" was there for all to see.

I was insulted by them.

You admit to lobbing your own insults.

Why am I "called to task" for my one, but you are given a free pass on your hundreds?

And your insults continue......

by oz_media

Well Max, I don't seem to have much of an issue with other American peers here. Certainly there are disagreements but not the constant misquoting abuse that I and many others see from you when you don't like what they have to say.

I have had several people tell me they had NO idea until coming to TR whay Americans were said to be ignorant and arrogant. The racism begins here, the 'we are superior' mentality begins with you, the 'you are all passive and don't do anything to help the world' begins with you, the constant denial of ANYONE's posts (American or foreign) that don't compliment yours begins with YOU. Others have a say, perhaps reiterate a point or two and generally can see both sides of a discussion.

You twist and twirl words so that you can complain and discount their origin. You then provide your own sources and support as if it is a correction and not just another perspective on events. YOUR sources are the right sources and everything that doesn't compliment it is Anti-American, Anti-Bush or just plain wrong. What I can't get over is that with all your nit-picking, comprehensiion difficulties and slander that you don't see this as coming from yourself. But then again, you have made it VERY clear that you stand firm in yuor convistions and beliefs while expecting everyone else to change or conform to YOUR idea of what's going on.

Yuo constantly post what Bush said in order to discount others reports, when those same people don't buy a word Bush says anyway! So why would I even begin to entertain your ideas and theories if you refuse to accept someone else's opinion, I think it's called hypocrisy and bigotry.

At one time, I thought you were a somewhat educated and well spoken person, the more I hear from you, the more I realize how wrong I was. You simply want everyone to agree with you yet refuse to accept anothers opinion.

You see ONLY what others say to YOU, not what YOU say to others.

You see only what Bush says and never look at the other side with an open mind or without even expecting SOME allegations against Bush to be correct. As Julain said before, if Bush was to meet you he would probably be incredibly embarrassed at the conviction with which you stand behind him. I have never met someone dumb enough to believe every word a politician says in my life.

Why is it that you insist you are correct and anyone that contests your points is anti-american, or slamming your country and offending you?

My suggestion is that if such innocent comments that when taken into a completely different context upset you, why are you here and not living in a protective bubble?

Have others told me I offend them by saying that people outside of the USA often see Americans as arrogant? Not that I've seen, except from yourself.

Have others told me I am anti-American and I am slandering their good name? Not that I've seen, except from yourself.

So again Max, why is it that you insist you are correct and anyone that contests your points is anti-american, or slamming your country and offending you?

Perhaps we need to have a bit of a sit down and rethink who we really are. I'll help by saying you are NOT lady liberty, you are not GWB, you are not the White House administration.

You are a mere man, a mortal. No different than myself, Julian, Colin, Mike or Joseph.

You have an opinion, like myself, like Julian, Colin, Mike, like Joseph.

You voice your opinion, like myself, like Julian, like Colin, like Mike, like Joseph.

You defend your point like me, like Julian, like Mike, like Joseph.

So how is it that you are being so offended or repressed, unlike myself, unike Julian, unlike Colin, unlike Mike, unlike Joseph?

Here's an idea, complain to GWB. He should offer you the same level of support that you offer him. Why he is you 'employer' isn't he? You chose him yourself didn't you? If he showed you even small portion of the respect you show him, he would be happy to speak with you, and probably explain your devotion is just a tad overkill. He would probably also ask you to listen to both sies and actually understand why people say what they do and possibly how to read and understand a little better.

YOU start these little rants, YOU don't let them die, YOU fuel the hatred toward yourself, YOU ARE YOUR WORST ENEMY.

by maxwell edison

.
During an address to the World Economic Forum, Secretary of State Colin Powell was asked a somewhat long and involved question by the former Archbishop of Canterbury, George Carey, which ended with the following interrogative:

"And would you not agree, as a very significant political figure in the United States, Colin, that America, at the present time, is in danger of relying too much upon the hard power and not enough upon building the trust from which the soft values, which of course all of our family life that actually at the bottom, when the bottom line is reached, is what makes human life valuable?"

Secretary Powell delivered a lengthy response to the former Archbishop's question:

The United States believes strongly in what you call soft power, the value of democracy, the value of the free economic system, the value of making sure that each citizen is free and free to pursue their own God-given ambitions and to use the talents that they were given by God. And that is what we say to the rest of the world. That is why we participated in establishing a community of democracy within the Western Hemisphere. It's why we participate in all of these great international organizations.

There is nothing in American experience or in American political life or in our culture that suggests we want to use hard power. But what we have found over the decades is that unless you do have hard power ? and here I think you're referring to military power ? then sometimes you are faced with situations that you can't deal with.

I mean, it was not soft power that freed Europe. It was hard power. And what followed immediately after hard power? Did the United States ask for dominion over a single nation in Europe? No. Soft power came in the Marshall Plan. Soft power came with American GIs who put their weapons down once the war was over and helped all those nations rebuild. We did the same thing in Japan.

So our record of living our values and letting our values be an inspiration to others I think is clear. And I don't think I have anything to be ashamed of or apologize for with respect to what America has done for the world.

(Applause.)

We have gone forth from our shores repeatedly over the last hundred years and we?ve done this as recently as the last year in Afghanistan and put wonderful young men and women at risk, many of whom have lost their lives, and we have asked for nothing except enough ground to bury them in, and otherwise we have returned home to seek our own, you know, to seek our own lives in peace, to live our own lives in peace. But there comes a time when soft power or talking with evil will not work where, unfortunately, hard power is the only thing that works."

by lwoldt

You are a fool and an idiot. The hostages were released from Iran by Carter - he chose to let Reagan be sworn in and the hostages released because he was decent enough to know he was leaving anyway and credit was not what Carter wanted - he wanted the hostages freed.

As for Beruit, Reagan did nothing and neither did Bush the elder even though we knew who did it and we knew where they were. It wasn't the Democrats who got Reagan to flinch it was the Republicans who didn't want to offend the Arab oil, I mean, Arab world.

Just like 9-11, 19 Arabs, the majority of which were Saudis - seen George do anything to the Saudis? No and you won't because the Saudis are good friends of the Bush family and have been for decades going back to George Herbert Walker Bush's father.

Try reading recent history before you tell an ex Marine who let us down in Beruit. Reagan swore he'd never rest until he brought the perpatrators to justice. Well, he can't remember who he is and I'm still waiting for justice for over 240 of my fellow Marines. By the way, your precious Ronnie didn't even allow the Marines ammunition in Beruit because we were 'peacekeepers'.

By the way, what branch of the service were you in and when? Just curious since most right wingers don't bother to serve they just send somebody else to die for them. That includes Dick Cheney, Newt Gingrich, Phil Gramm and Tom Delay (those last two are shining examples of Texas Republicans).

by sullyman

It's funny how search upon search on the web regarding the Iranian Hostage crisis, only makes mention of Carter and Regan. Over 10% of the hostages were freed with the help of Ambassador Ken Taylor ( of Canada ). For some reason US hstory chooses to forget about those individuals. Another shining example on how might in some instances should take a back seat to creatve problem solving......

by mlayton

...on how might in some instances should take a back seat to creative problem solving

Well put.

by maxwell edison

.
You should really be careful about making such charges.

Before you presume to suggest that I don't know what happened in 1980 with the Iran hostages, or twist it to suit your own predetermined outcome, you should read President Carter's very own biography. (Yes, I have read it. In fact, I have an autographed first edition that President Carter signed for me in person.)

President Carter didn't, as you suggest, choose anything. In his very own words (I'm paraphrasing, of course) he admits that the fact the hostages weren't released on his watch was a huge disappointment. Of course the Carter administration was in negotiations with Khomeini; in fact, they had been negotiating for the previous 444 days. And it was Khomeini who intentionally waited for the transfer of power; it was his choice, not Carter's. But my initial message only suggests they were released on the day of Reagan's inauguration, not that Reagan brokered the deal. Just like the debacle in the desert (the failed rescue attempt) was a huge embarrassment for Carter and the USA, so was the inauguration day release. It was a slap in the face of Jimmy Carter for Khomeini to intentionally wait until he was formally out of office. Even President Carter thinks so.

Did you know, by the way, that President Reagan actually sympathized with that "slap" to Carter? And as a way of showing President Carter how he really felt about it, President Reagan, on the day he took office, right after he was told that the hostages had been freed, called President Carter and told him that he was the one who did the work and credited him for doing so much to free those hostages - and should get the credit. He then gave the former president Air Force One and asked him to go to Germany to welcome the hostages, many of whom even returned to the USA on Air Force One with former President Carter. A very nice gesture indeed.

On Reagan and Beirut, I agree, he did nothing. In fact, I've suggested that no former American administration, of either political party, did anything significant to fight world-wide terrorism. Where in my original message, or anywhere else, do you read that I suggest Reagan did much about it. To the contrary, it suggests he did nothing. Man, you should go back and S-L-O-W-L-Y read it so you can correctly comprehend it.

By the way, I served in the Air Force from 1972 through 1978. And in case you're wondering, in 1972 the draft "lottery" system was in place. My number was close to 300, so I would not have been drafted, but I joined anyway. And one more thing, thank you very much for your service to your country. My brother was a Marine in Vietnam in 1969 (returned wounded), and while I have the utmost respect for all who served, the Marines hold a special place in my heart for their courage and commitment. Thank you very much.

by mlayton

...for titling your reply so strongly and then waiting until the end to recognize the courage and commitment of this Marine. Your ending statement was lost in the title, which I assume was meant to incite a strong response.

To the marine: thanks from a grateful nation - no matter your political views, it takes courage, commitment, and honor to serve in the armed forces. I think I speak for many in our nation when I say your commitment to serve means you are anything but a fool or an idiot.

by maxwell edison

.
The actual plane, serving as Air Force One, that former President Carter took to Germeny to meet the hostages - hostages that were in captivity for 444 days - flew 444 total missions from the time it was put into service to the time it was retired.

by maxwell edison

.
To understand the true intent behind most of these messages takes more than what's probably possible within the confines of this forum. We've all been misunderstood and mischaracterized at one time or another, and believe me, as one of the most misunderstood and mischaracterized participants, at least in my estimation, I know all too well. (Let's see, I've been accused of being closed-minded, biased, hypocritical, arrogant, one-sided, heavy-handed, intolerant, ........) Interesting, my Boy Scout Troop wouldn't describe me that way at all.

On declaring war on an individual, or in this case individuals (plural), you're absolutely right, that in a sense, it is indeed what we did. After almost 40 years of world-wide terrorism, almost exclusively at the hands of Islamic extremists, many people believe that enough is enough. It's too bad that it took three thousand American deaths and a trillion dollar hit to our economy to open our eyes to it. This is bigger than just Afghanistan. It's bigger than just Osama bin Laden. It's bigger than just Iraq. It's bigger than just Saddam Hussein.

I won't bother to post the numbers, but do an Internet search for subjects related to acts of terrorism and deaths caused by such acts. The numbers will astound you. Literally thousands upon thousands of acts, resulting in tens of thousands of deaths, and I don't think any continent on the face of the Earth, except Antarctica, has been spared. The United Nations has been either ineffective or has been turning a blind eye. The numbers over the past 40 years bear that out.

All of the things you think should have been tried first, have indeed been tried first - all of them. They have been tried and tried again, and then tried again. In the case of the Iraq, those "peaceful" means have been tried for more than a dozen years. In the case of containing overall terrorism, those "peaceful" means have been tried for almost four decades. How much longer should we have waited and tried? And how more many innocent people should have died? And it's not realistic to think that Iraq and the bigger war on terrorism are not related. (Like I mentioned earlier, Saddam's $25,000 bounty on all Americans - dead Americans - bears that out.)

It's difficult to sift through all the political rhetoric that's being thrown around and reported. Especially this year, an election year, a person has to realize that political opponents will do whatever necessary to discredit their opponent, especially if that opponent is an incumbent. It might sound nice, for example, to attack President Bush with the charge that he should have waited for the UN. But people all over the world have been waiting for the UN to be effective against terrorism for over 40 years, and the people of Iraq have been waiting 12 years for the UN to enforce the resolutions that they, themselves, passed. How much longer should people have waited? All of the "waiting" and doing nothing is what convinced Osama bin Laden to call the American military a "paper tiger".

And here's an ironic thing about the attacks on President Bush. On one hand, he is being attacked and criticized for acting to quickly, too carelessly, to unilaterally, too whatever against our enemies who sponsor and support world-wide terrorism. But on the other hand, they're attacking and criticizing him for not acting effectively enough in the days before 9-11, and in a way that might have prevented it. Consider this. Do you think it was politically expedient of President Bush to circumvent the UN? Of course not. Here we have a politician who has put his political life on the line. Why would he do that if it wasn't the right thing to do? (And please, don't suggest it was to pacify his big oil buddies. That's just nonsense.) And consider another thing. Perhaps his decisions and actions over the past 30 months have indeed prevented another 9-11. It's not possible to know for sure, but another one hasn't happened, and overall acts of world-wide terrorism is at a 40 year low. Personally, I think President Bush deserves a lot of the credit. And the only ones who won't give him any credit are his political opponents or those who are swayed by them.

by mlayton

do an Internet search for subjects related to acts of terrorism and deaths caused by such acts.

Now surely you are not suggesting I take the information I find on the Internet as truth? :-)

by maxwell edison

.
Are you suggesting that none of the Information on the Internet is reliable?

I realize that the Internet can be a source of misinformation. But if you use a little bit of good judgement, you'll know which sites are reliable.

Use the Internet, go to the library, read some books, or use any other source you deem reliable, and get the facts as I suggested in my previous message. That's what I meant.

Of course, some people operate where if any given "source" doesn't support that person's desired conclusion, it's considered unreliable, so you may or may not believe anything. Are you working backwards from a predetermined outcome, believing whatever supports that desired outcome, or are you first establishing a basis of facts on which to form that outcome (opinion)?

by oz_media

You seem to feel that the requests for an Iraq invasion were blindly ignored and turned down, wheras what I think happened was there was a lot of hesitation regarding a quick invasion. This does not mean that others are planning on sitting idly by and lettnig these events continue, in fact it is quite difefrent than it used to be.

There is a GLOBAL war on terrorism now that is understood and supported by the free countries of the world. The issue before was that terrorism was simply not recognized as a global threat. Now it is and people are willing to put and end to it. Nobody was planning on letting this type of terror continue and everyone was willing to see it put to an end, by an ALLILED and global war on terrorism, not "America want to attack these guys next so lets get to it so England can invade their targets too."
The issue was being addressed as it hasn't been over many years, so to imply that this ignorance towards teerorism would just continue as it always HAS been in the past is completely absurd.

There IS a recognized worldwide threat now AND a GLOBAL war on terrorism, they MAY have taken another 6 months, perhaps 1 month perhaps a year, but it would be done, probably MUCH more effectively than it has been so far and less US, UK, and other coalition members lives would have been lost.

Well done America and thank you for saving us all from certain doom.

by mlayton

...coming from an industry where I constantly have to convince people that just because it's on the Internet doesn't mean it's true (i.e. no, Bill Gates is not going to send you a check just for forwarding this e-mail! or no, there's a good chance that "Juanita" the hot babe you've been communicating with perhaps is not quite a hot babe!) I knew what you meant, it just made me giggle was all!

by maxwell edison

.
the names I was called by the person posting the message to which I replied.

(I was called the fool and the idiot.)

by mlayton

... I thought he was calling Ann Coulter the fool and the idiot, since your post was a quote from her, and he was responding to points in the post. Maybe I read it wrong!

by maxwell edison

.
Please wait.........reading it again..........

Still reading.......continue to wait..........

Okay, he said, "You are a fool and an idiot".

Then he asked, "....what branch of the service were you in and when"?

I think I can only surmise that I am the "you" to which he was referring, not Ann Coulter.

But let me look at it one more time.

Please wait.........reading it yet again..........

Still reading.......continue to wait..........

Yep, definitely. I'm the fool and the idiot to which he was referring.

Thanks for helping clear that up.

By the way, I'm not necessarily agreeing with his "fool and idiot" assessment.

But wait, on second thought........I am, after all, wasting my time in these stupid discussions.......At least I'm in similar company.

by oz_media

I think it was Old School where Will Farell is streaking down the middle of the road as his wife and her friends drive up.
When asked what he wa doing he said, "We're streaking!" after looking behind him he realized he's alone.

So I guess the same would apply, "We're invading!"
"Who's WE?"
"uhhhhhhhh"
LOl

by mlayton

...How the same text can be read by two parties and be taken to mean two completely different things, or at least two separate contexts.

by jardinier

It is amazing how the facts are unimportant to so many, and how soon they forget! (Read through to the bottom!)
"One way or the other, we are determined to deny Iraq the capacity to develop weapons of mass destruction and the missiles to deliver them. That is our bottom line." - President Clinton, Feb. 4, 1998

"If Saddam rejects peace and we have to use force, our purpose is clear. We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq's weapons of mass destruction program." - President Clinton, Feb. 17, 1998

Iraq is a long way from [here], but what happens there matters a great deal here. For the risks that the leaders of a rogue state will use nuclear, chemical or biological weapons against us or our allies is the greatest security threat we face." - Madeline Albright, Feb 18, 1998

"He will use those weapons of mass destruction again, as he has ten time since 1983." - Sandy Berger, Clinton National Security Adviser, Feb 18,1998

"[W]e urge you, after consulting with Congress, and consistent with the US Constitution and laws, to take necessary actions (including, if appropriate, air and missile strikes on suspect Iraqi sites) to respond effectively to the threat posed by Iraq's refusal to end its weapons of mass destruction programs." - Letter to President Clinton, signed by Sens. Carl Levin (D-MI), Tom Daschle (D-SD), John Kerry (D - MA), and others Oct. 9,1998

"Saddam Hussein has been engaged in the development of weapons of mass destruction technology which is a threat to countries in the region and he has made a mockery of the weapons inspection process." - Rep. Nancy Pelosi (D, CA), Dec. 16, 1998

"Hussein has chosen to spend his money on building weapons of mass destruction and palaces for his cronies." > - Madeline Albright, Clinton Secretary of State, Nov. 10, 1999

"There is no doubt that ... Saddam Hussein has invigorated his weapons programs. Reports indicate that biological, chemical and nuclear programs continue apace and may be back to pre-Gulf War status. In addition, Saddam continues to redefine delivery systems and is doubtless using the cover of a licit missile program to develop longer-range missiles that will threaten the United States and our allies." - Letter to President Bush, Signed by Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL,) and others, December 5, 2001

"We begin with the common belief that Saddam Hussein is a tyrant and threat to the peace and stability of the region. He has ignored the mandated of the United Nations and is building weapons of mass destruction and the means of delivering them." - Sen. Carl Levin (D, MI), Sept. 19, 2002

"We know that he has stored secret supplies of biological and chemical weapons throughout his country." - Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

"Iraq's search for weapons of mass destruction has proven impossible to deter and we should assume that it will continue for as long as Saddam is in power." - Al Gore, Sept. 23, 2002

"We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and developing weapons of mass destruction." - Sen. Ted Kennedy (D, MA), Sept. 27, 2002

"The last UN weapons inspectors left Iraq in October of 1998. We are confident that Saddam Hussein retains some stockpiles of chemical and biological weapons, and that he has since embarked on a crash course to build up his chemical and biological warfare capabilities. Intelligence reports indicate that he is seeking nuclear weapons..." - Sen. Robert Byrd (D, WV), Oct. 3, 2002

"I will be voting to give the President of the United States the authority to use force-- if necessary-- to disarm Saddam Hussein because I believe that a deadly arsenal of weapons of mass destruction in his hands is a real and grave threat to our security." - Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Oct. 9,2002

"There is unmistakable evidence that Saddam Hussein is working aggressively to develop nuclear weapons and will likely have nuclear weapons within the next five years .. We also should remember we have always underestimated the progress Saddam has made in development of weapons of mass destruction."- Sen. Jay Rockefeller (D, WV), Oct 10, 2002

"He has systematically violated, over the course of the past 11 years, every significant UN resolution that has demanded that he disarm and destroy his chemical and biological weapons, and any nuclear capacity. This he has refused to do" - Rep. Henry Waxman (D, CA), Oct. 10, 2002

"In the four years since the inspectors left, intelligence reports show that Saddam Hussein has worked to rebuild his chemical and biological weapons stock, his missile delivery capability, and his nuclear program. He has also given aid, comfort, and sanctuary to terrorists, including Al Qaeda members.. It is clear, however, that if left unchecked, Saddam Hussein will continue to increase his capacity to wage biological and chemical warfare, and will keep trying to develop nuclear weapons." - Sen. Hillary Clinton (D, NY), Oct 10, 2002

"We are in possession of what I think to be compelling evidence that Saddam Hussein has, and has had for a number of years, a developing capacity for the production and storage of weapons of mass destruction." - Sen. Bob Graham (D, FL), Dec. 8, 2002

"Without question, we need to disarm Saddam Hussein. He is a brutal, murderous dictator, leading an oppressive regime ... He presents a particularly grievous threat because he is so consistently prone to miscalculation ... And now he is miscalculating America's response to his continued deceit and his consistent grasp for weapons of mass destruction .. So the threat of Saddam Hussein with weapons of mass destruction is real" - Sen. John F. Kerry (D, MA), Jan. 23. 2003

SO NOW EVERY ONE OF THESE SAME DEMOCRATS SAY PRESIDENT BUSH LIED--THAT THERE NEVER WERE ANY WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION AND HE TOOK US TO WAR UNNECESSARILY!

by maxwell edison

.
My goodness, are you trying to warm up to me, or what? Nonetheless, I'll buy the beers.

I've posted those quotes on quite a few occasions, but people "conveniently" forget them, and, as you say, claim that GWB "lied". The real truth, at least in my estimation, is that everybody was fooled and Saddam played the biggest gotcha' in history, or we have to ask ourselves a very troubling question. Where are they?

by jardinier

Sorry Max, don't take it to heart but my postings are not in any way intended to express agreement with you personally.

I just feel for the Americans who don't want to vote for Bush, because the alternative is so appalling.

Once again I will say that the Australian "left" party, The Australian Labor Party, doesn't seem at all like the American Democrats.

We, however, do have a choice between two viable candidates to fill the role of Prime Miniser. We all know Howard pretty well, and we know what to expect from him.

Mark Latham is a highly intelligent and principled man. Despite Howard's stringent efforts, he has been unable to find any skeletons in Latham's closet. Latham has promised a lot of lateral-thinking policies which will not favour any section of the populace over any other.

by oz_media

Here's some quotes from various speeches recorded by The White House:

November 7th 2002
"...the resolution is a disarmament resolution; that's what it is. It's a statement of intent to, once and for all, disarm Saddam Hussein. He's a threat. He's a threat to the country, he's a threat to people in his neighborhood. He's a real threat."

Jan. 2nd 2003
"You know, Saddam Hussein -- hopefully he realizes we're serious, and hopefully he disarms peacefully. He's a danger to the American people, he's a danger to our friends and allies."

Jan. 31st 2003

"I've told you the strategic vision of our country shifted dramatically, and it shifted dramatically because we now recognize that oceans no longer protect us, that we're vulnerable to attack. And the worst form of attack could come from somebody acquiring weapons of mass destruction and using them on the American people, or the worst attack could come when somebody uses weapons of mass destruction on our friends in Great Britain."

Feb. 7th 2003
"I have said that if Saddam Hussein does not disarm, we will lead a coalition to disarm him. And I mean it. "

March 16th 2003
"The dictator of Iraq and his weapons of mass destruction are a threat to the security of free nations."

It just goes on and on and on, EVERY single speech or collection of press coments mentions Saddam's WMD and how he is a threat to America that will be stopped. It isn't ntil mid to late 2003 that his speeches STARTED to mention Liberation, I think it was mentioned OCNE in one speech that also mentioned WMD in EVERY paragraph.

Prior to this turn of the tides, EVERY paragraph of every speech mentioned , WMD and Saddam had to be stopped by force if neccessary to protect America and her friends.

I can not see how so many people actually came up with the bizarre idea that this invasion was to rid Saddam of WMD and protect America? GWB NEVER implied such hogwash and wouldn't deceive America. I think The White House is just lying and the great and righteous G.W.Bush is just a nice guy with a bad rap when all he wanted was to help these people in Iraq.

Even though in another comment he says that until now, the issues in Iraq have not been a great concern for America, since 911 it has become imperative to rid Iraq of Saddam Hussein and remove the threat. So I guess all along he has actually wanted to help Iraqi people from harm, no it couldn't be, he said that Iraq has not been a concern of America until 911. Well whatever, we'll just believe him anyway, you can't make heads or tails of most of his comments anyhow.

by nd_it

I don't think Bush necessarily lied about the WMD, I believe he was fed minimal evidence by the CIA and CHOOSE to believe it, another reason for him to go into Iraq. If this wasn't an election year, you wouldn't be hearing some many Deomocrats going back on what they said over a year ago about Saddam and WMD. Isn't there anyone else running for President? I mean someone that we all know, not "Jerry Smith" who somehow got on the ballot because he got so many of his friends to sign a petition? No...Oh boy.

by maxwell edison

.
But no one wanted me to continue my story?

Although the story isn't a verbatim tale of a particular incident, it is based on events that were more common than you might realize, and the details are portrayed fairly accurately - all the way down to airmen playing pinochle in a weapons crew shack.

I guess no one was curious enough to ask.

Tom Clancey, you have nothing to worry about.

by thechas

Max,

I read and enjoyed the first installment of your story.

I did not respond so as to not disturb the thread.

I suspect that most of the others were just waiting for the next installment.

Chas

by mlayton

...with all of the politics here, you are seldom voting FOR someone as you are AGAINST another person. And quotes and actions can be spun to suit any argument for or against anything unless they are looked at in the exact time and context they are given - because even what the politician had for breakfast can affect what comes out of their mouth that day.

Ten years from now,(if we are still around) all these quotes will be brought up again for or against something else - in order to say see, this is what you said.

Many moons ago I worked for a candidate and I was responsible for building a database of everything their opponent had ever said that was documented - every article written, every speech taped, and reference it by keywords so that if any subject came up, my candidate could pull words from his opposition's own mouth to contradict what he said. At the time, I thought it was a brilliant strategy. (I was much younger!)

But now, I have realized that this can be done for every candidate, on almost every subject. It's actually kind of disheartening. I don't know how some of them even look themselves in the mirror - so I have decided that I vote the way my conscience tells me, the way I can vote and still sleep at night. If then the politics of the country go a different way, I work to change them in my own quiet way.

At least, if I take action/responsibility for my own beliefs, then I can feel like I am supporting myself. Its the people who don't vote, and then also don't take action, and yet complain bitterly or try to influence those who do vote, who should be ashamed of themselves. If you actually care, do something. Anything.

by maxwell edison

.
To say "they all do it" is no justification. Moreover, the quotes listed by Julian, and the way those very people showed their hypocrisy, is uniquely Democrat. As an illustration, you could certainly find similar quotes by just about every Republican in Congress or in Cabinet positions. The difference, however, is that these very same Republicans aren't criticizing anyone for it. What a golden opportunity, for example, for John McCain, who isn't exactly the greatest fan of GWB. Why isn't he using the same tactics as the Democrats as a way to win the Presidency? We know he wants it, as he ran against GWB in the 2000 primaries. The reason he doesn't do it is that he knows that everyone thought (or still thinks) the WMDs were in Iraq, and to pretend he didn't think so would be obviously disingenuous. But the Democrats have no problem with being obviously disingenuous.

About the only thing I can think of where Republicans did a 180 on an issue was the term-limits cry of the early 90s. Many of them spoke out in favor of term limits as a way of unseating incumbent Democrats. But after they won on the issue, and were reelected a few times, and were facing term-limits themselves, they suddenly had a change of heart. My state has two such Republican representatives. One of them, as I said, did a 180, and violated his "term-limit pledge". The other one, to his credit, decided to honor his pledge and not run for re-election. (Personally, I was always against term-limits. We can always vote the person out.)

Here's another disingenuous Democrats' issue. The Democrats were all in favor of campaign finance reform. But they are now the ones abusing the spirit of the thing by taking advantage of all the loopholes that they, themselves, wrote into the bill.

I could be blinded by own biases, but if anyone can show where Republicans, in general, and in lock-step, are so obviously hypocritical, I'd sure like to see it.

And on this particular WMD issue, there really is NO justification for it. Absolutely NONE.

by maxwell edison

.
Yes, I do realize that you are not in any way intending to agree with me. This just happens to be one of those rare times when you do. Actually you would probably prefer that I say that your observation and I are in agreement. Okay, I'll buy your observation a beer.

I should become more familiar with the party politics of other nations, especially Canada, Britain and Australia. I will admit that it receives little, if any, mention in most of the US press.

by jardinier

My "observation" is in agreement with your
"opinion."

So let your opinion buy a drink for my
observation, only because my observation is a
teetolaller you had better make that a Coke or
a lemon squash.

by tellangon

Basic Accounting 101 - You cannot spend more than you make without eventually driving the enterprise into the ground.

Bush enters office and declares a tax break. Reduces income to the enterprise. Bush comments that the economy, which has been moving at great pace for 8 years, is in bad shape. In predictable reaction, the stock market tanks. Businesses cease to exist; therefore less taxes coming in.

Less businesses = less taxes paid = less revenue for the government.

9-11 occurs - Bush enters war on terrorism - increases spending. (Expenses go up). Takes control of Afghanistan - misses designated target Osama Bin Ladin. Bush declares victory. (Victory?)

Bush announces that Iraq has weapons of mass destruction. After failing to gain a coalition of forces through the channels established by this country, declares war on Iraq.

Massive troop and equipment movements = increased expenses.

Misses main target Saddam Hussein. Misses again. Misses again. Bush declares Victory. Bush announces war is over. Chaos breaks out due to lack of planning for management after victory.

Increased weapon usage + bereavement benefits = increased expenses.

Troops capture Saddam; Bin Laden still at large. Chaos in Iraq increases.

More troops + longer stays + increased weapon usage + bereavement benefits = increased expenses.

Side issue -- Am I the only on that also thinks that our President apparently launched a war against a country that may have had a vicious leader, but also apparently was not doing anything that actually threatened the United States? Now, is forcibly taking over another country under false pretences be considered a "high crime" or is it more of a "misdemeanor"? I am never sure. Oh well, at least he did not have an affair with an intern, so I guess we can save the expense of an impeachment proceeding.

Meanwhile on the home front, Bush supports reform that rewards businesses for sending jobs offshore. Jobs are lost. Taxpayers go bankrupt. Losses increase at financial institutions as they write off debt and lose interest income.

Bankruptcies = lost business revenue = less taxes paid = less revenue.
Jobs lost = less taxes paid = less revenue (potentially forever).
Unemployment benefits paid out = increased expenses.

So let's recap -- Expenses are WAY up / Revenue base is WAY down & deteriorating. Is this a profile in courage or a profile in failure? I guess we all get to decide in November.

by maxwell edison

.
The premise of your whole tax-revenue argument was that a "tax break", as you called it, "reduced income to the enterprise".

First of all, there were no "tax breaks", but rather reductions in the rate of taxation.

Moreover, I would be willing to wager that even though tax rates were reduced, that the total dollars collected by the government INCREASED. I would wager that the government collected more money in FY 2003 than it did in FY 2002, and that it collected more money in FY 2002 than it did in FY 2001, the year of the Bush tax RATE cuts.

Therefore what?

Therefore, tax rate reductions do not cause deficits. Increased spending is what causes deficits. Now if you want to argue that the war on terrorism caused an increase in spending, you might have a point. But even then, it's insignificant in the grand scheme of things. Did you know, for example, that out of the almost TWO TRILLION dollars the government spends every year, than only about 15 percent is spent on the military? Did you know that more that 50 percent of that - over ONE TRILLION dollars is spent on money transfer programs every year, while only about 300 billion is spent on the military?

So let's recap.

Contrary to what you suggest, revenues are UP, not down, and revenues are projected to increase even more, not decrease, as you also suggested. Spending is also up, but spending on social money-transfer programs has increased by not only a higher dollar amount, but at a higher rate than the increase in military spending.

And here's a scary thought. We're spending (or will spend) more money on the new prescription drug give-away program than we're spending (or will spend) fighting the war on terrorism.

So we disagree, right? Who's right and who's mistaken? The proof in the budget.

Budget of the United States for FY 2003:

http://www.whitehouse.gov/omb/budget/fy2003/pdf/bis.pdf

Budget of the United States 2002 (and previous years):

http://www.gpoaccess.gov/usbudget/index.html

There ya' go.

by oz_media

As I was reading your post I was shocked to see just how different the numbers you provided were with the numbers I heard reported here. I heard that you country is the ONLY country on Earth that spend MORE than 30% of it taxes on the Military funding, either directly or indirectly.

I heard another source report that you spend 40% on military.

Then I read all your information and realized how differebt the figures were. How could such figures be logical with the amount of military might you develop each year and the pay to the MASSES of soldiers who fight for the USA.

Now i am ny no means saying my figuers are correct, in fact as with ANY corporation in history, the nubers always look good by the time they are publically reported, again my brother has spent COUNTLESS nights sitting with accountants trying to make a company's books look as good as legally possible with a nip here, a tuck there a realocation here, an expenditure there etc.

If you ask a guy in a bar how much he earns, do tyou REALLY think you ever hear the truth? No.

SO declared income/expenses are ALWAYS inflated, I don't care who you are or how great your integrity is, numbers are made to be manipulated.

Now I looked at the source of the information itself, The White House, sigh.
Well those numbers are pretty impressive I know, now again, I am not saying what I heard is any more OR any less accurate.

Numbers LIE, there is NO truth in such statements by ANY government or corporation on Earth. People are paid immense amounts of money and even bigger bonuses when the numbers look good, there is no way in hell you can deny this, it is fact and for MOST it is common knowledge.

Then again, some people believe a lot of things don't they.

by mlayton

Let's see, in fiscal year - I think it was 2001, the whole fiscal year vs. calendar thing always confuses me - we had a surplus of $127 billion. The following year, we had a deficit of around $159 billion, which some economists attributed to the smallest tax receipts in decades. The year after that, it was projected to be over $400 billion. Certainly, if I am launching military responses to a country, I might have thought about not granting all those tax breaks (I think you are talking about the refunds?) I might have said instead of giving my people this money, I will put it in a fund for the rebuilding of the nation I am about to launch military responses in - and I will establish a plan that projects costs at this much. These tax checks will cover x amount of that, and so where can I find the rest of the money? Then I might go over my budget with a fine tooth comb and try to find a way to get my well-thought out plan implemented without putting the nation in billions of follars of deficit. But that's just how I would do it.

by maxwell edison

.
To think that President "chose" to believe only what he wanted to, is to suggest that everyone else, including the previous administration, congress, and the United Nations, also "chose" to believe the very same thing. No one - literally NO ONE - denied the presence of WMDs, not ever.

If anyone deserves "blame" - make that "BLAME" - for this WMD issue, you're right in focusing in on the CIA. They either screwed up by providing false intelligence or they screwed up and lost track of them. (The second option is certainly reason for concern.)

by oz_media

I don't remember tha CIA telling us that we were under threat of WMD. It is their job to pass whatever intelligence they gather on to the President. It is the President's job to ensure such information is confirmed beond a shadow a a doubt before informing the peope of America, especially in such a case as a threat upon the country from WMD.

Now I know GWB doesn't have the time to 'double check' these allegations, that is SUPPOSED to be the VIA's job. I have heard allegations that SOME people (Iraqi informants to the CIA) were admittedly offering false information for the sheer purpose of creating this action from the USA, but again from what I know these are just allegations. What I found amusing was how soon after the initial invasion that it was found these people were full of it and had mislead the CIA. Was this due to a knee jerk reaction by the CIA and the President or was it just that after the invasion such stories began to leak.

I belive Tony Blair had actually said something about bringing this person/people to justice over the isinformation. GWB hasn't even recognized the issue and has simply pulled the general public's focus in a different direction of a more humanitarian effort. Well I have no problem with such a basis for the invasion, if a humanitarian effort it is then lets all stay on the same page.

CHANGING the focus was just sidestepping or backpeddling, not admitting or openly explaining the confusion (other than a couple of breif mentions that the allegations in the UK were being investigated)and allowing the people of America to believe one thing then another.

>Was this to save face during election year?

>Will the truth surface if he doesn't get elected?

>Will BUSH deny such 'truth' as it surfaces and claim it is Democratic propaganda to strengthen their 'new' position?

Bush may have been mislead, he inturn mislead ALL of the American citizens and other country's citizens around the globe.

Bush has never corrected his original allegations or apologized to the people for the misleading information (that would most likely have lead to MUCH less support for the invasion by the Americans who were sending their sons and daughters overseas.) so therefore must still stand by his convictions.

GWB is a corporate man, he has grown in an industry that has successfully deceived and mislead millions over the years and continues to do so every day, that's just big business.

How can we say that now he is in a position of even higher power that he would not automatically do the same thing? It's in your blood.
I was once a bloodthirsty and evil corporate drone. I would crocodile smile all the way to the bank, it took several years and a near death exoperience for me to see what I had become and start to find who I really was again. My brother runs a successful corporate law firm, I see such bottom feeder tactics used all the time by the ost 'respectable' corporations.

We rarely hear how these guys get sued several times per week/month for unethical business practices.

WalMart, Esso, TExaco, Chevron, K-Mart, Save-on-Foods, AT&T, Sprint etc. they ALL get sued so many times per month it is unbelievable. My brother has left one courtroom, walked down the hall and enetered another hearing against the SAME company, while another discovery is taking place for the same company AGAIN in another courtroom, it's a fulltime job representing these guys., Yet we only hear of the biggest cases that provide god media fodder based on the political topic of the week.

I just see so many people placing trust and faith in the most unethical and unfathful corporations each day and then being stung or simply not hearing what they really do behind the scenes.

So coming from THAT background, it is no wonder BUSH is a master of deception and steering opinion, it is a learned art, a natural instinct that is focused on and strengthened over time purposely to create the desired outcome, not a personal trait as much as a learned trait.

Bush must wear contacts, I'm sure his eyes are blue in press photos.

by jardinier

We have the same problem in Australia, of intelligence collecting agencies not passing on information to the Government.

In fact there's quite a hoo-ha going on right now, as a couple of former intelligence agents have openly spoken out -- the gist of their revelation being that the agencies only supply information which the Government (or Prime Minster) would like to hear.

Sounds familiar, doesn't it?

by maxwell edison

.
.....and if you ever tried to read through one of those federal budgets, your eyes would glaze over, or glaze over some more, whichever the case may be.

Depending on how the report is worded, the numbers could go all over the place. For example, The Bush Administration submitted a budget for FY2002 requesting $343.2 billion for defense, an increase of $32.6 billion over the previous year. This new budget will mean that military spending will consume more than half of all the discretionary spending by the federal government.

You might say - WOW HALF the spending in on the military?

However, "discretionary" spending amounts to about one-third of the total federal budget with the remainder going for mandatory spending on entitlement programs such as Medicare, Social Security, federal pensions, etc. The next largest item of discretionary spending is about $50 billion for education.

So one-half of one-third equals one-sixth of the total. And one-sixth equals 16.5 percent (I think I said 15%).

By the way, that's a great example of how a "report" may be extremely misleading. Whether or not the report is intentionally misrepresented is another question entirely.

(Link to source and more....)

http://staff.jccc.net/gbelzer/135milspend02.htm

But for the most part, the general breakdown of where it comes from and where it goes can be illustrated by the pie charts at this site.

http://w3.access.gpo.gov/usbudget/fy2001/guide02.html

(Don't forget those pesky SPACES in the pasted URL.)

There are certainly other sources that may be a little different. But within a few percentage points, these numbers are pretty close.

by tellangon

I guess that answer is admittedly evasive as well. Maybe we shuld submit that question to the President so perhaps the answer can pop into his head?

by maxwell edison

.
The answer is really quite simple if you think about the federal budget in the same way as your personal budget.

The money you take in minus the money you spend equals either a surplus or a deficit. If we spend more money than we earn, it's usually reflected in the outstanding debt we carry such as a home mortgage, automobile loan, or credit card debt. If we spend less money than we earn, we see our personal savings account (or investment account, etc.) grow.

When the government spends more money than they take in, it creates a spending deficit, and they, in essence, put it on their "credit card". Their credit, however, is in the form of Treasury Bills, Savings Bonds, and so on. (The total of each years' deficits equally the national debt.) When the government spends less money than they take in, they have a surplus of funds just sitting there. And just like yourself, when you suddenly have a little windfall that you weren't expecting, a choice has to be made as to what to do with it.

Some legislators would want to spend it, since they think spending almost two trillion dollars a year isn't enough. Some legislators would want to use it to pay off the current debt load being carried, just like you might pay off your automobile loan. Some legislators would want to return it to the people - the tax payers - who paid too much in the first place. And I say they paid too much in the first place because, in theory, the government shouldn't take more than they need. And since their spending is predetermined by the previously approved budget, there's nowhere for that money to go.

I could be wrong on this, but I believe that, by law, the government can't keep a surplus. It doesn't have a national "savings account", so to speak. So if they take in more than they are allowed to spend, they must either create new legislation (pass an addendum to the budget) to spend it or they must give it back to the taxpayers. What happened to the past surplus, you ask? Well, I suppose it's a combination of those two things - they spent some of it, and they gave some of it back. Didn't you get your $400 check not too long ago?

By the way, the President doesn't control the national purse-strings. That function, by law and in practice, is the responsibility of Congress. The President can only request that they spend it a certain way, and whenever he wants extra money that's not already allocated for a specific thing, he must ask Congress to approve it. For example, he recently asked Congress to approve an additional 86 billion for fighting the war on terrorism in Iraq. So if you have a question about where it goes, you should ask your Representative or Senator, not the President.

by oz_media

I dunno, perhaps I'm failing to see your point or this was provided as a response to another post i may have missed.

Has anyone said this man was not human or something?

Perhaps it is to show that GWB has some compassion, I'm not sure quite what the intent behind providing these links was?!

by bobhog

A poor and narrow-minded recounting of history. You failed to mention the ties these brave republicans have to some of the people we are attempting to eliminate now. I'm sure Reagan has forgotten, Nixon will never tell, Bush sr. has too much at stake, and Bush jr. is in just as deep.

Sure, democrats have to own up to responsibilities, too, but when Clinton was acting to snuf out genocide in Serbia, the same republicans railing for war against Iraq were railing for Clinton to move troops out of Serbia. Great defenders of freedom? I think not. Those Serbians being killed were Muslim.

Why did dubya stay in that school in Florida so long after learing of the attacks on 9/11? Why did he pose for photos afterwards at that school? Why did he not speak on the attacks for two days?

Courage, indeed!

And now we know in hindsight that Iraq did not harbor terrorists or WMD. So why did we go in the first place?

by maxwell edison

.
Throughout this thread, I've suggested that every administration prior to the current one has been either ineffective or unresponsive to world-wide terrorism. Those administrations include Reagan's and the elder Bush's. Nixon is going back a ways, but I suppose he was busy ending LBJ's war in Vietnam, mending relations with China, and, unfortunately, destroying his own reputation by shifting the focus from his achievements to a cover-up of an unnecessary petty crime.

Your attack on President Bush on 9-11 only shows your blind ignorance.

And you are mistaken when you say that, "we know in hindsight that Iraq did not harbor terrorists or WMD".

On the WMD - old story. Will you never give up? Please read the previous messages and that question is answered in full.

On Iraq and terrorism - again, old story.

Saddam's Iraq ties to terrorism:

1. Saddam Hussein offered a $25,000 bounty to anyone who would kill Americans in a terrorist attack.

2. Abdul Rahman Yasin was a member of the al Qaeda cell that was involved in the 1993 World Trade Center bombing that was intended to collapse the two towers amid a cloud of cyanide gas, planning to kill upwards of 20,000 people. He carried an Iraqi passport, and he fled to Iraq. U.S. forces recently discovered a cache of documents in Tikrit, Saddam's hometown, that show that Iraq gave Mr. Yasin both a house and a monthly salary.

3. Osama bin Laden met at least eight times with officers of Iraq's Special Security Organization, a secret police agency run by Saddam's son Qusay, and met with officials from Saddam's mukhabarat, its external intelligence service, according to intelligence made public by Secretary of State Colin Powell, who was speaking before the United Nations Security Council on February 6, 2003.

4. Osama bin Laden met the director of the Iraqi mukhabarat in 1996 in Khartoum, according to Mr. Powell.

5. An al Qaeda operative now held by the U.S. confessed that in the mid-1990s, Osama bin Laden had forged an agreement with Saddam's men to cease all terrorist activities against the Iraqi dictator, Mr. Powell told the United Nations.

6. In 1999 the Guardian, a British newspaper, reported that Farouk Hijazi, a senior officer in Iraq's mukhabarat, had journeyed deep into the icy mountains near Kandahar, Afghanistan, in December 1998 to meet with al Qaeda men. Mr. Hijazi is "thought to have offered bin Laden asylum in Iraq," the Guardian reported.

7. In October 2000, another Iraqi intelligence operative, Salah Suleiman, was arrested near the Afghan border by Pakistani authorities, according to Jane's Foreign Report, a respected international newsletter. Jane's reported that Suleiman was shuttling between Iraqi intelligence and Ayman al Zawahiri, al Qaeda's No. 2 man.

8. As recently as 2001, Iraq's embassy in Pakistan was used as a "liaison" between Saddam Hussein and al Qaeda.

9. London's Independent reports that Spanish investigators have uncovered documents seized from Yusuf Galan -- who is charged by a Spanish court with being "directly involved with the preparation and planning" of the Sept. 11 attacks -- that show the terrorist was invited to a party at the Iraqi embassy in Madrid. The invitation used his "al Qaeda" name.

10. An Iraqi defector to Turkey, known by his cover name as "Abu Mohammed," told Gwynne Roberts of the Sunday Times of London that he saw bin Laden's fighters in camps in Iraq in 1997. At the time, Mohammed was a colonel in Saddam's Fedayeen. He described an encounter at Salman Pak, the training facility southeast of Baghdad. At that vast compound run by Iraqi intelligence, Muslim militants trained to hijack planes with knives -- on a full-size Boeing 707. Col. Mohammed recalls his first visit to Salman Pak this way: "We were met by Colonel Jamil Kamil, the camp manager, and Major Ali Hawas. I noticed that a lot of people were queuing for food. (The major) said to me: 'You'll have nothing to do with these people. They are Osama bin Laden's group and the PKK and Mojahedin-e Khalq.'"

11. In 1998, Abbas al-Janabi, a longtime aide to Saddam's son Uday, defected to the West. At the time, he repeatedly told reporters that there was a direct connection between Iraq and al Qaeda.

12. The Sunday Times found a Saddam loyalist in a Kurdish prison who claims to have been Dr. Zawahiri's bodyguard during his 1992 visit with Saddam in Baghdad. Dr. Zawahiri was a close associate of bin Laden at the time and was present at the founding of al Qaeda in 1989.

13. Following the defeat of the Taliban, almost two dozen bin Laden associates "converged on Baghdad and established a base of operations there. From their Baghdad base, according to Secretary of State Powell, they supervised the movement of men, materiel and money for al Qaeda's global network.

14. In 2001, Saudi Arabian border guards arrested two al Qaeda members entering from Iraq.

15. Abu Musaab al-Zarqawi oversaw an al Qaeda training camp in Afghanistan. His specialty was poisons. Wounded in fighting with U.S. forces in Afghanistan, he sought medical treatment in Baghdad in May 2002. When Zarqawi recovered, he restarted a training camp in northern Iraq.

16. Zarqawi's Iraq cell was later tied to the October 2002 murder of Lawrence Foley, an official of the U.S. Agency for International Development, in Amman, Jordan. The captured assassin confessed that he received orders and funds from Zarqawi's cell in Iraq. His accomplice escaped to Iraq.

17. Zarqawi met with military chief of al Qaeda, Mohammed Ibrahim Makwai (aka Saif al-Adel) in Iran in February 2003, according to intelligence sources cited by the Washington Post.

18. Mohammed Atef, the head of al Qaeda's military wing until the U.S. killed him in Afghanistan in November 2001, told a senior al Qaeda member now in U.S. custody that the terror network needed labs outside of Afghanistan to manufacture chemical weapons. Where did they go? They went to Iraq.

19. Abu Abdullah al-Iraqi was sent to Iraq by Osama bin Laden to purchase poison gases several times between 1997 and 2000. He considered his relationship with Saddam's regime successful.

20. Mohamed Mansour Shahab, a smuggler hired by Iraq to transport weapons to bin Laden in Afghanistan, was arrested by anti-Hussein Kurdish forces in May, 2000. He later told his story to American intelligence and a reporter for the New Yorker magazine.

21. Documents found among the debris of the Iraqi Intelligence Center show that Baghdad funded the Allied Democratic Forces, a Ugandan terror group led by an Islamist cleric linked to Osama bin Laden. According to a London's Daily Telegraph, the organization offered to recruit "youth to train for the jihad" at a "headquarters for international holy warrior network" to be established in Baghdad.

22. Mullah Melan Krekar, ran a terror group (the Ansar al-Islam) linked to both Osama bin Laden and Saddam Hussein. Mr. Krekar admitted to a Kurdish newspaper that he met bin Laden in Afghanistan and other senior al Qaeda officials. His acknowledged meetings with bin Laden go back to 1988. When he organized Ansar al Islam in 2001 to conduct suicide attacks on Americans, three bin Laden operatives showed up with a gift of $300,000 to undertake jihad, Newsday reported. Mr. Krekar is now in custody in the Netherlands. His group operated in portion of northern Iraq loyal to Saddam Hussein -- and attacked independent Kurdish groups hostile to Saddam. A spokesman for the Patriotic Union of Kurdistan told a United Press International correspondent that Mr. Krekar's group was funded by "Saddam Hussein's regime in Baghdad."

23. After October 2001, hundreds of al Qaeda fighters are believed to have holed up in the Ansar al-Islam's strongholds inside northern Iraq.

.
.
.
.
If you want to believe that Iraq is not about the war on terrorism, well, knock yourself out. The smart money, however, would be betting otherwise.

by jamesrl

The Clinton/American position in Bosnia was not as noble as you suggest. In the wake of Somalia, the Clinton administration was a little gun shy. The UN went in first - Britain, Canada and France, and other NATO allies. There were several battles between "peacekeepers" and various groups. In one Canadian action four days of fighting has escalated to the point where Croat tanks faced Canadian troops, and Canada moved up their TOW II equipped APCs. The incident ended when the Canadian commander brought up international journalists to expose what had been going on(Croat army invading safe haven).

The Clinton admin didn't want to get involved until a formal peace plan was in place. Many people on all sides died before then. There were no US troops in Bosnia until the Dayton accords were signed.

James

by oz_media

Perhaps this is their way of being late to the draw when it coems to war. They are making up for it by jumping the gun (or WMD if you prefer).

Haste makes waste in most cases, in this case it is only lives though, call them brave defenders pf the peace and have a nice military service and it is not seen as waste anymore, it's patriotism.

by jimhm

Wasn't the whole bosnia thing to get the press away from Jefferson Clinton and the BJ's (oh thats right that isn't sex) with Monka in the Blew - I mean blue room...

And don't even talk about Clintons position (bent over) in Samala(sp) ... that was another Wage the Dog - story.

by vahidp

well maxwell, i just don't know where you get your chronological drivel from. but for your own sake, rather than filling your mind with this utter nonsensical narration/ode for bush's courage(!!), try seeking the truth by asking the people who have been directly affected by the series of so called american actions or inactions. i wish you well!!!

by maxwell edison

.
....read all of these messages and/or don't know what was meant by my use of the term "Profile in Courage".

It's the title of a book, written by the late President John F. Kennedy, that describes how some people risk their own political future by doing, what they believe to be, the right thing.

And whether or not you believe what President Bush has done is "the right thing", I don't think there's much doubt that most people think that he believes it to be.

Moreover, I don't think that question will be answered for several decades. Perhaps some of us will be around long enough to look back in history and know the answer.

by gblau

This site is for the exchange of technical information. To indicate a leader or leaders are good or bad, lets be succinct - it's easier to manage foreign policy than domestic policy. Wars will now be fought over greed not ideology. The terrorists had to go, but stupid secular despots in the same way. Our President is not courageous - just like most poloticians to leverage the easier way to sway support. As I learned from being in the military, our leaders consider us as expendable - please tell that to your loved ones. Keep politics of this site and lets us deal with the business at hand.

by oz_media

Well as much as I completely agree with your comments, the "technical Site" comment is not so.

Yes, TR is a technical resource. The Discussion groups are split into MANY depending on what you wish to filter.

You can seek ONLY Win2K or Security, Linux, Novell, etc. There are MANY MANY different forums depending on what you wish to view.

Many people just choose the quick links at teh bottom of the discussion forum, Hot Discussions or Newest Discussions > these are a collection from ALL the TR discussion forums (which you can choose from on the MAIN Discussions page).

There is also a section in the discussions forum named "Miscellaneous", which is where THIS discussion has come from. the miscellaneous section covers ANYTHING that isn't covered by the OTHER IT related forums, therefore MUCH of what is said here is simply topics in the news, politics, relgion, sexuality, etc. YOU name it, you'll find it here.

So if you don't appreciate NON IT discussions, perhaps due to a lack or work or just and undying interest in IT 24/7, then you would be better off finding the MAIN discussion page and selecting which topics you want to read from the many available.

Should you choose to select most popular discussions, you will end up with these "non-IT" discussions, as they realy are the nost popular.

Most people come here to get a break from the grind and share some other interests with peers, as opposed to the IT stuff all day and night.

The choice is completely yours as to what you see here, like magic TR can customize your forums so that you only see what is relevant to YOU.

Don't worry though, you're not the first person to have such an observation and you DID offer our input on the discussion as well, most just bitch and complain then leave.

by cactus pete

Anyone who wants to split political discussions from this forum can go buy techpolitic.com and give everyone a new playground...

Yes, it IS available.

by hi_aftab

this is an IT site for professionals...if you want to lobby for conservatives, then use some other site...

by sbi-limited

Good Lord! Qouting from Ann Coulter? You'd have to go politically LEFT to qoute from "Mein Kampf"
compared to her. You've GOT to be kidding. Please say you're kidding....

by sbi-limited

I served in Vietnam and was there during the Tet Offensive. Lost a lot friends that year. But it was NOT Vietnam that ripped my heart out. It was the VFW (Veterens of Foreign Wars) in Denver that did that. I was refused admission and denied my request to join because I served in Vietnam. I took my heart and my pride an have yet to this day joined a veterns' organization.
I have gotten over the war, the killing, the stench, the horror (some therapy was used). But I have never found a way to get over having my military honor raped by the VFW back in '68.
I just live with it as old history. WE ALL HAVE SCARS!!! and not all of them came from the traditional "enemy".

by maxwell edison

...did President Bush suggest that might take? Did he claim it would happen in one year? Two years? Three, four or five years? Just how long did he say it would take? (And yes, there IS a very specific and correct answer to this question.)

If you're going to make such a comment, perhaps you should enlighten us as to the predicted time-table that President Bush laid out in establishing that "functioning democracy in the Middle East". And I really do hope you look it up, Neil. For it you do, you'll discover that this is yet another example of how President Bush has been misinterpreted and misrepresented. Go ahead, find that answer as uttered by President Bush himself.

And Ms. Coulter said, ".....and begun to create the only functioning democracy in the Middle East."

Context and accuracy is everything, you know.

As a somewhat related side-note: The instant gratification mind-set has destroyed so many people in so many ways.

by Member 25348569

President Bush hasn't - at least as far as I have seen - laid down a timetable. In this, he and I are in agreement. Maybe you have seen a timetable - "specific and correct answer" - but I have not. However, the implication in the various SOU speeches is that this is something that you will achieve. On this we differ and I worry that, again, you (and we) have bitten off more than you will be willing to chew.

Ms Coulter surely meant the word "try" when she used the word "begun" in the sentence that you quoted above.

You know my beliefs. We shouldn't be there and not just simply that we had no right to invade. Any link between 911 and Iraq was tenuous at best. Anyway, what the hell, we then destabilise the one significant country in the Middle East that was not truly anti-American and then trash what was left of their infrastructure after a decade of sanctions.

Trust me. The chances of achieving a democracy in our own image or even slightly close is so far from what is likely that I really have trouble in accepting that there are people who can't see it. Iraq was a Kingdom until the 1950s and, since then, has been a "republic" ruled by a military dictators - culminating in our erstwhile friend Saddam Hussein. They have [b]never[/b] been anything approaching a democracy. Another Shi'ite Islamic Theocracy is what will happen unless we stay there for ever.

Vietnam.

by maxwell edison

Any reference to a time table has been answered by the president in the terms of future administrations. In fact, if I recall correctly, in an early 2002 or 2003 speech given by the president, maybe a State of the Union speech, he did indeed emphasize that what is being started by his administration will undoubtedly have to be finished by future administrations. He knew from the outset that this would be a long and difficult endeavor.

How long did the allies remain in Germany and Japan after 1945? Was it worth it? Iraq is really no different, and it will take just as long (or maybe longer).

by Member 25348569

I may not live long enough.

Iraq is [b]nothing[/b] like Germany or Japan post WWII.

Germany had a history of some form of democracy and the US were - to the most part - welcomed as someone who stopped the war [b]and[/b] saved them from the Russians. The West German people were able to return to democracy and regain their involvement in a market oriented economic system despite many years of central control. In fact, they did it surprisingly quickly.

Japan, also, was unique and in no way resembled Iraq. The US and allies were able to insist on - and got - a balanced budget with money, price and wage stabilization. A viable yen/dollar exchange rate was quickly achieved and the Japanes quickly adapted with a push to maximum production for export. Japan could have been left alone before the end of 1949.

Above all, neither country had a functioning resistance to American-led and financed change. There were no equivalents of the Iraqi insurgents wrecking any economic and social gains and, above all, there were no serious religious matters to be dealt with.

Longer? Much, much longer. Possibly longer than you can take.

Sorry, Max. I still don't get it. If your other thread with Bush's "Energy Miracle" comes to fruition, you'll be out of the Middle East faster than you can say "stuff your oil".

Neil

A cynic: someone who smells flowers and looks around for the funeral.

by oz_media

Max, to compare the defeat of the Nazi's in 1945 to what is happening in Iraq is not too clever at all. Do you really think we will have a VI (Victory in Iraq)day anytime soon? (well I guess Bush can claim that whenever he wants and Americans would buy into it)

WWII ended with the fall of the Nazi furor, they (the Nazi's) accepted defeat and the war was over. Forces were kept in the region for decades to ensure peace was retained and that the rebuilding of Eastern Europe was seen to. But the Nazi's accepted defeat.

With Iraq, the loss of their leader has fuelled mass insurgent retalliation. I highly doubt that the insurgents will just walk out with their hands up and call it a day the way the Nazi's did.

Do you really think that they are just going to be told, "hey, the war is over, we lost" and then all just lay down arms and look toward a new Iraq. LOL!

"Iraq is really no different, and it will take just as long (or maybe longer)."

"...(or maybe longer)" is about the only accurate part of that sentence; as far as Iraq being no different than WWII, get real, the only similarity is that people die and it's a war...except in this case it's a war the US started by invading another country.

How simple and blind it is to even try and compare the two.

by oz_media

There is a show on tonight called 'The Insurgency' (PBS Frontline)a Brit (Matt Haan) and his crew filmed life with the insurgents in Iraq during the conflict. It is estimated that during the onset of the war, there were approximately 3,000 to 5,000 insurgents fighting against Americans. At this time, thise numbers have grown in size to an estimated 10,000 to 15,000.

So as suggested earlier, it is obvious that this growth in anti-American forces and rebellion is a lot like when the Nazi's laid down their arms in 1945. Sure, whatever you choose to believe I suppose.

Do yourself a favour and watch it, whether you buy into it or not, which I can predict you obviously won't (as it doesn't favour your opinion it must be BS).

MORE: http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/pages/frontline/insurgency/

"...FRONTLINE peels back the layers and gets beyond the propaganda to take a complex look inside the multi-faceted insurgency in Iraq. The investigation includes special access to insurgent leaders, as well as commanders of Iraqi and U.S. military units battling for control of the country"

by maxwell edison

.
However, this will only lead to the rest of the discussion, which is ALL the other reasons for the war. And yes, not only is Iraq a part of the war on terrorism, but a BIG part of it.

And here's a gift for you.

http://tinyurl.com/nlrvq

by Member 25348569

is - for me - to discover a way to deal with the 1.6 million Muslims that we have in Britain. It is believed that 0.1% of them feel alienated enough to join a radical grouping. That's 1,600 potential bombers. These are the people who blew up my fellow Londoners on July 7th. The bombers were home grown Leeds boys and recruited - I believe - in Pakistan.

Iraq is a hugely costly political show. I will do [b]nothing[/b] to make relations between me and the majority of those potential suicide bombers any better. Quite the reverse!

I am absolutely certain both that more British innocents will die and democracy in Iraq - which will not happen in my lifetime - would lessen the chances not one jot.

by maxwell edison

I didn't suggest that the circumstances in Iraq are the same, or even similar, to the ones in Japan or Germany. If you follow the flow of Neil's and my comments, you'll notice that it started with a reference to time, how long will he have to wait. My point was that it will take a long-term presence, not a transformation that will take place over night, which is something President Bush has been maintaining from the very beginning.

by thechas

I still see NOTHING that GWB has done of any significant value for our nation or the world in general.

History WILL judge the Presidency of GWB as one of the 10 worst.

Specifically, I predict that future historians will point to the Presidency of GWB as the starting point of the United States falling from the world power, very rapidly to fourth place behind China, India and the European Union.

GWB is FULL of bold pronouncements. Yet for every proposal, the bill comes due after GWB will be safely out of office.

Aside from raising government spending and the national debt faster than any previous administration, GWB has done nothing to benefit the average working person in this country.

As I see it, GWB has no courage or conviction. Except to help the rich get richer!

His term in office cannot end to soon for the benefit of ALL mankind.

Chas

by maxwell edison

...those things. You've proven to be blinded and guided by your hate. You've always hated him, even though, originally, you never had a reason.

by oz_media

YOu have also become so blinded by your faith in Bush that yoru own feelings are very misguided as you choose not to believe any negativity toward Bush at all, he is now God and can do and never has done any wrong.

Unfortunately I fear he feels the same way.

What man/woman would possibly want to take over where Bush leaves off? Talk about putting out fires for 4-8 years. It will take several presidencies after Bush before the damage can begin to be repaired.

Your initial post in this thread demonstrates just how faithfully you support your leader regardless of the questions surrounding what you deem great accomplishments. You simply have no ability to question what you deem your own kind.

by jamesrl

I would not be so bold as to blame him for the yet to happen fall of America from the top position in the world pecking order.

Would you blame the fall of the British Empire on one Prime Minister?

Presidents don't drive the US economy and its the US economy that give the US power and influence in the world. I honestly believe that despite what they may claim, politicians and governments don't significantly impact the economy of a market driven democracy.

I don't advocate massive government spending or raising the national debt, but the debt did not start with this president, nor will they end with the next one.

James

by thechas

While the US government still was in debt when GWB took office, we did have a balanced budget and were beginning to pay down the debt.

GWB ballooned the national debt faster and larger than any previous administration.

Other than GWB, NO ONE was calling for tax cuts in 2000 or early 2001.

While excessive tax rates can be a drain on a countries economy, gross government debt and borrowing is an even worse drain as it directly pulls funds from business investment.

The policies and actions of top government officials can either boost or weaken a nations economic and political clout.

The US is rapidly loosing ground on both fronts.

EVERY initiative that GWB has championed has been aimed at helping the rich at the expense of the middle class and the working poor. It is the working poor and middle class that drive the economic engine.

On the global political stage, the only clout we have left is our over-extended military.
Both Iran and North Korea know that there is very little the US can do to even interfere with their nuclear ambitions.

I believe we are past the precipice. Even if our next President has the strength and wisdom of Abe Lincoln, John Kennedy, or Ronald Reagan, they will not be able to reverse the fall of the US to a 3rd rate power.

Chas

by oz_media

When it comes to specific conflicts, Bush has made some grossly incorrect assumptions.

In 2003 he (Bush as well as others) assumed it would take less than three days to free Falujah of the insurgency. They estimated small pockets of poorly prepared and willing resistance (as stated in reports shown on "The Insurgency" ). It took well over a year with two US withdrawls from the area and many lost lives before they had a foothold even then they were being laughed at by some claiming to be al-Qaeda fighting in Fallujah.

If you didn't see the video footage of the insurgents, they were watching US tanks on the outskirts of the city while taunting them for being so big and mighty but unable to enter the streets of Fallujah.

It was also shown that the US had clearly expected the insurgency to pretty much fizzle out as soon as Saddam was captured, they figured that as soon as the leader was removed, support would be from sparse groups of fundamentalists, some religious and some nationalist and they would be easily overcome.

Instead, what was estimated as a bunch of scattered, unorganized, fundamentalist groups actually grew to numbers of 15,000-20,000 as soon as Saddam was captured. If they kill 1000, there seems to be 1000 more the next day, this force is not being reduced, in fact it is growing due to the US occupation. The US has caused more problems in Iraq than they would ever have seen without the occupation, what was a small group of fundamentalists has grown into a very large and more and mroe organized force of people who would never have become insurgents without the US there to begin with.

In short, the US bit off a lot more than they can chew, and they have learned as much by losing thousands of lives.

So given the situation today, can you still honestly say that a properly coordinated allied coalition of many nations would not have been a better idea? As suggested long before cowboy bill went to war.

oh and I did read your posts, and I also noticed that neil also got the exact same impression from your posts. How can you suggest that reading your dialogue would have resulted in a different conclusion? you just aren't making sense anymore.

by maxwell edison

I can live with that.

I know what the intent of my comment was. And if I failed to articulate my intent in such a way to make it obvious, then okee-dokee. I failed. But I now move on.

If you (or Neil) want to extrapolate from my comment anything other than a time comparison, knock yourself out. And if you want to take it any further than that, go ahead. But it'll be a game called Solitaire, because I won't play.

Welcome back, Oz. I see the absence hasn't changed you.

by maxwell edison

I'm against the death penalty, something President Bush supports. I've been highly critical of President Bush concerning his recent support of adding prescription drug benefits to Medicare, not to mention his support of increasing Medicare spending in all other areas as well. He failed to fully articulate the looming Social Security crisis, something I believe should be phased out entirely, and he's pretty much dropped the ball on that issue; and even when he was espousing a change, it wasn't nearly enough, barely more than lip-service. He's allowed Congress to continue its spend-thrift ways by not exercising his veto power on massive pork-barrel projects and unnecessary spending bills. He caved into Senator Kennedy on an education bill, and he's actually growing the Department of Education instead of taking steps to shift education responsibility back to the states. The immigration issues, especially concerning the border issues with Mexico, continue to be ignored, not to mention we STILL are paying for services for illegal Mexican immigrants, things President Bush is failing to address. I've been calling on him to advance development of alternative energy sources ever since he took office, something he's only recently been doing. And I just opened a discussion wondering on which side of recent issue I should fall, as I'm still undecided; but I certainly didn't fall into the Bush camp just because he supports it.

But you insist that I agree with everything he does and says, and that I consider him God. Those drugs have really affected your brain, dude.

And you have no idea what the meaning of "Profiles in Courage" really is. You really are an idiot, Oz.

by oz_media

Your replies would be so much easier if you could just create a macro for your constant repetition of the same BS. Then you could offer the same comments and defenses in an ALT+? fashion, similar to the old rubber stamp method of unthoughtful reply.

I know you don't like many of Bush's policies, you have used that to try and prove you are not a sheep for years now, you try and show that you are different than other republicans. YOU see through most of his flaws and mistakesm but you still support him anyway...I don't really know what's better in that case, sheep or 'follower because he's not a democrat'?

You know, you use the term 'Typical OZ BS' like a catch phrase, and yet you have never proven what I said to be BS at all. I said you deem him a god, your entire purpose behind this thread [b]"President Bush - A Profile in Courage"[/b] doesn't indicate that you have undying faith for your furor at all...nooooooooo. So you don't support some of his policies, but you sure as hell place him on a podium well above any other nation's leader so obviously he is unbeatable in your books.

This discussion is closed to new replies.