President Bush - A Profile in Courage
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by oz_media
Firstly. you are right in saying that this man needed to be stopped, that's never been a topic od debate here. The INSTANT means in which Bush ignored the Allies after talks and then invaded hastily and without much needed support is the issue. His means for justifying that issue was fear, by telling the people of America they had reason to hate this man, that he had Weapons of Mass Destruction and would not think twice about using them against America (Yes Max, I DID find that info at the White House site if you want a link, but I'm sure you've read all that by now.).
You also mention some recent findings of the US military since the invasion, yet that ws not known prior to the invasion so cannot be used as a means to justify prior action.
As for the Oil For Food program, well that was feulled by America's want for Iraq's oil and Saddam not allowing the export. OFF was a means for other countries to import oil for export and a profit to the USA, although many say that the US never bought Iraq's oil, you were buying it from the same people who you are accusing of exploiting th eOFF program, it is just hypocritical and doesn't hold water.
It's not because you didn't want it it's because you couldn't have it. Now what's the worst thing you can say to someone? "No you can't."
As for food NOT getting to Iraq, well that was a major fault of America's. Saddam was pissed that these "needed" supplies were not being received, whether for his own resale or proper distribution is irrelevant at this point. The US government was in charge of inspecting the imports for 'dual purpose' goods. Supplies, needed supplies, were being held by American officials indeffinately, it started with a few months then a few more and so on.
The US was doing this as they felt Saddam was playing the same game with weapons inspectors, Saddam was playing with the weapons inspectors because the US was holding off needed imports, touche'. This is all neatly detailed in The White House Report to Congress.
If you are generally interested in reading more about the Oil For Food program, I have the 60+ page document that shows it all in detail that I am happy to email to you. (once I dig it out of my own archives of course:-P )
Your points for supporting Bush are unneccessary, you are free to support who you wish without explanation in a democratic nation. The fact that you say he was wrong in talking about WMD and that the war was really needed anyway is not too sensible though.
We ALL know saddam needed to e removed, the WORLD knew and was lookng at making a move. Bush seems to feel that everyone said NO WAY to his idea, the issue was that seeing as recent UN missions HAD been sucessful, they should be allowed to uncover more. If at that time they had found further destruction, which they ineveitably would, the woprld's forces were prepared to remove him and continue the global fight on terrorism, which Bush has dcided is HIS war on terrorism and others will play by HIS rules. I know he's YOUR leader but the rest of the world? Give me a break.
He doubt he'd even know where Canada is, he has very little global knowledge which is no secret, and needs to rely on the experience andknowledge of those that do.
for you to say "Bashing and individual who is taking action to achieve these goals are productive," is a little arrogant itself.
You want your leader to act alone and without support, yet you call others fat & drunk mouthed for not joining you? What is it, America's war on terrorism or the world's, or is that all the same thing to you?
All I am saying, it was wrong for him to act alone and without the proper intelligence and support of his allies as they would respect of him. If the world was ready to go to war and Bush wasn't they would most likely stop and at least hear him out, not slag America and then go at it anyway.
He was wrong to use WMD as an excuse, you've admitted and yet e has done the right thing. Well you voted for him, you trusted him, you supported him, now you're saying he lied to you but that's OK as he is doing the inevitable anyway. If he hadn't said WMD were an issue and simply waited for the next inspections to turn up more evidence in order for the entire Allied force to occupy Iraq and get it straight, would that have been so bad? I think not.
There's a saying we use in Canada, 'haste makes waste.'
I think his haste wasted your lives.
.
I agree with absolutely everything you said. I might add some things (but I won't), and perhaps others might as well. But very well stated indeed.
Another related question. How long will it take, and what will it take, to defeat international terrorism and finally bring it to a hault? Twenty to thirty years, as GWB has suggested? Not that long? Longer than that? Or is it a futile effort? (And yes, I might also suggest that it will take more than just guns.)
by oz_media
I don't know if we can actually speculate how long it will take to halt terrorism as a whole.
I think in essence there wil ALWAYA be terrorists on Earth just as there always has been. In respect to these organized regimes we are currently at war against, who can really tell ?
Nobody REALLY knows what fuels such terror other than the obvious religion and dictatorship issues. So without understanding the enemy we really cannot predict or even begin to flatter ourselves by assuming how long it will take.
As BUSH has said numerous times, we have no idea how long the Iraq situation will last.
With that being only a miniscule part of the overall problem, even if narrowed down to only middle east terrorists, we cannot even begin to entertain the idea of ending terrorism on aglobal scale if at all.
Perhaps in the present day it is futile. We can eliminate leades temporarily before another takes his place. We can push them out of a chosen country but sooner or later it will be like trying to cull together all the foam in a bathtub. Eventually it will run through your fingers and over your hands.....I think I'll leave it there.
Or trying to stop an oil spill, the oil can be trapped into a region but the lasting damage will be there for many more years than ever expected. You know they are STILL cleaning up the shores and wildlife from the Exxon Valdez spill. At the time, some were predicting 5-10 yearsm other said many more. We just don't know without comparisson, it is pure specualtion.
I'd like to say Monday, but I know it won't be that pleasant. Now that you guys have dropped the second shoe, who knows when or even IF terrorism will be stopped and even then how long until it resumes. As long as we have recorded history, we have had people who want to dominate or destroy mandkind. NOw we have Bush vs Terrorism, again domination vs destruction.
.
And the word is "too funny". (Okay, two words.)
Although you and I disagree on an issue or two (but we're probably closer in principle than we might think), I sure do like your sense of humor.
by cactus pete
What was not included in the results were the terrorist bombings, etc in Iraq. They were considered aimed against an army, and therefore do not qualify.
So, if the aim is to concentrate terrorists into non-civilian, non-Amirican areas, then I suppose it's truly down. But you can count it however you wish...
.
To attack a standing Army, in the sense as one exists in Iraq, is contrary to the accepted definition of terrorism.
Some people may believe that the Earth revolves around the Moon, but that doesn't make it so. And if you want to count an opposition in the armed conflict in Iraq as terrorist attacks, well, I suppose we'll have to agree to disagree.
I can't help but think, however, that you're splitting hairs a dozen or more times.
If you really believe what you suggest, why don't you just come right out and say so, instead of playing some word game?
by maecuff
by maecuff
by maecuff
by oz_media
Well although you do export a lot of resources, cutting off your imports would be just as detrimental to the US as your cutting off exports.
Canada ships 10 Billion in softwood to the US. Major US corporations rely on logging our forests and fishing our coastal waters to stay productive and able to employ Americans.
British Columbia :
Canada has one third of the world's fresh water supply, of which 1/4 is located in British Columbia.
This is why we have the majority of North America's energy-intensive industries relocating here.
These same waterways deliver over 9,000 Gigawatts of electricity to California and coastal US cities.
So it may be a little darker on your West coast and hydro costs a little higher without your neighbours.
B.C. Hydro also provides 1500 jobs to Washington resident in Call center and customer services roles.
90% of our oil comes from Alberta, and we are a MAJOR exporter of coal and natural gas to the USA.
Now, we also receive MOST of our imports from other regions in Canada. We have a pretty self sufficient country.
Cutting off your West coast from work, electricity, coal and natural gas may hinder and upset some of your coastal inhabitants.
Perhaps a time to be thankful for your trade alliances and not looking to remove them.
As for Immigration, now you actually touched on a few contradictory points, Immigration BUILT America and Canada, without it you simply would not exist.
Illegal immigration is another story, we get tens of thousands immigrants claiming refugee status in BC each year,the majority Asian, and many often disappear to the US
before facing any immigration boards as it is too hard to immigrate thre.
Perhaps easing the ability for others to become citizens would reduce the number of illegal immigrants working under the table. I'm sure they would rathre be paid and recognized citizens than live iunder a veil of secrecy. Perhaps the tight laws actually promote illegal immigration or workers?
Jst another view to consider, our economy has boomed since the masses of Asians wer allowed to enter Canada for several years, the numbers are being reduced now but for example:I was at a driving range in Richmond a few weeks ago (Richmond is THE chosen place for Asian immigrants to Canada) as walked past 75 stalls on two levels looking for a free tee, I finally found one next to another guy who said "Hey, I'm the token white guy here!" Well he was obviously somewhat racist and a resident of Richmond. THe FACT and I mean without any exageration at all, him and I were the ONLY two caucasians in the driving range. Now at an average of three people per stall, that is about 225 asians to 2 caucasians in the driving range, again I promise you this is NO exaggeration at all.
iIf you stand on a corner ( used to be a field that's now a mall where you can't read a word of English ANYWHERE) there will be a line of say 30 cars at a light (most heavily populated part of BC that was once a few farmers and fishermen only)you would have to walk down the entire line of cars to find a single caucasian, IF you were lucky.
So without souding racists, althouh some may feel I have been already, this mass population increase has also brought millions into our province, if not billions.
The only frustrating part is that no matter how we choose NOT to be racist, the Asian population shows more racism than anyone.
THey will NOT hire you unless you are also Asian. They will not SELL to you if you are not Asian. THey refuse to learn English and when they do, they refuse to use t. So in essence they segregte themselves, just the same as the East Indian community had until recently when they realized that they want to befriend 'white' Vancouver and join forces against the asian community. Its a VERYlong and complicated issue here but I just wanted to iterate how we can allow immigration to benefit ourselves financially, not really socially though.
.
(The other thread was a "tangent" discussing the American Civil War and the suspension of the writ of habeas corpus ordered by Abraham Lincoln.)
----------
That really is a most interesting time in American history, a defining time, and it did indeed change the course of not only the American experience, but world history as well. The "what if" questions are really quite intriguing.
What if the north simply said, "good riddance" to the south, there was no American Civil War, and a new nation was born - again? What if the British or the French, and especially the British, provided full support to the South, which was certainly plausible, as both European nations sympathized strongly with the Confederacy - so strongly, in fact, that with just a little prodding they might have been moved to intervene by lending full military support and bring about Southern independence, not too unlike American independence from England only 75 years prior. (And consider that 75 years was/is only one person's lifetime). The South was, after all, an aristocracy, very similar to France and England (at the time), and the fact that it had a broad democratic base could have been easily overlooked at a distance of three thousand miles. Europe's aristocracies had never been happy about the success of the Yankee democracy, and if America had broken into two halves, proving that democracy did not contain the wherewithal to survive, the monarchs of Europe would have been quite pleased. And after all, the most recent war with England was less than 50 years in the past and on the minds of many Americans - both the northern and southern variety Americans.
Instead, President Lincoln pretty much acted with total disregard to the Constitution. (Why would he do that?) He wanted to stifle States' rights to govern themselves, and he was against slavery, which was pretty much acknowledged as legitimate (as a compromise, by the way) in the original Constitution. The American Civil War was, in many ways, was an extension of the original negotiations between the individual and sovereign states to form a "perfect union". (The Gettysburg Address, by the way, is the most incredible speech, in my opinion, ever delivered in the history of mankind.)
Abraham Lincoln was really an incredible person, loved by many, but hated by just as many. And the notion of "destiny" or "divine intervention" is certainly reinforced by considering the way things could have been, and the way things all worked out in the long run.
And I still suggest that the similarities between Abraham Lincoln and George W. Bush are amazing. Put yourself, if possible, 150 years into the future, look back, and play the "what if" game. Look at what would have been if.........and what actually happened because.......(And then include the time/universe/meaning-of-life considerations, and it's mind boggling.)
It truly is something to consider.
by wrlang
Isn't it amazing how people today can know what was in the mind of people long dead?
Nothing in the constitution legitimizes slavery. The current opinion on the subject says that the framers of the Constitution did not outlaw slavery because of the free labor it provided to farmers - purely economical. Not outlawing slavery is a far cry from legitimizing it.
As well with Lincoln, his foresight saw that America would be seriously harmed and each (Union/Confederacy) would become very vulnerable to the other colonial powers of the day by a split of states. Most people simply pick up on the slavery part because that's what they've been taught. That's the references most ascribed to Lincoln by teachers because kids wont understand sophisticated economic and governing principles.
GWB will most likely be compared to his father and perhaps Reagan. I doubt he will rate the same status as Lincoln.
by nd_it
if GWB is in the status of those of Washington, Lincoln, and Roosevelt. I think it will all play out 50 years down the road and what has happened in Iraq and Afganistan to whether we can compare GWB to such a status.
As to some of the comments about states' rights. I do believe the states' have their rights to govern it's residents for the most part, but I think their needs to be a central core of the federal government to make sure things do run smoothly. We did try this before with the Articles of Confederation, which just gave the federal government no power at all, which we all know according to history did not work out, thus resulting in the creation of the Constitution. That is one of the main reasons why the Confederacy failed as well and there was not European intervention, because the Confederacy couldn't establish itself as a power. It tried hard to copy the US Constitution, without trying to be the US government. The southern states couldn't agree on anything other than "the cause".
by jamesrl
The Canadian perspective is a little different on how both Canada and Britain felt about the US Civil War.
It is true that many parts of the business class in Britain supported the South. Thats because many mill owners made their fortune from southern US cotton supplies. But many others in Britain, did not support the south because of slavery. You must remember that slavery was outlawed in Britain many decades earlier and the Royal Navy was even sent to stop slave ships off the coast of Africa.
Here in Canada, we were a terminus for the Underground railroad and many former slaves were full citizens. While there were some Confederate sympathisers, if you look at the fact that over 50,000 Canadians joined the Union army, and less than 10,000 joined the confederate forces, you can see how the "common" Canadians felt.
There were of course those who felt that the enemy of my enemy is my friend. But the trade ties that bound the Northern US states with the Canadian colonies were deep. By that point there was as much trade with the Northern States as there was with Britain.
As to the War of 1812 - Max I suggest you look for a book http://www.amazon.ca/exec/obidos/ASIN/1896941133/702-3144712-9601660
Great book with the Canadian perspective of 1812 - it was the southern states (jayhawks) who rallied for the war, while the New England states resisted. That also helps explain a few things.
James
.
You said that, "(President) Bush will go down in history as one of the worst leaders of all time."
I, on the other hand, believe that President Bush will go down in history as one of the best leaders of all time.
If possible, remove your biases. If possible, remove what others may have told you. If possible, look at every angle of every consideration. If possible, look at the BIG picture in a historical context. If possible, look at the desired outcome.
(By the way, see my Abraham Lincoln message.)
Why do you and I come to an exact opposite conclusion?
If it's possible for me to remove myself from those things, I would suggest that I may be right, but I may be wrong. I think that if democracy does indeed take hold in the middle east (in Iraq and Afghanistan), and I think that if the war on terrorism does indeed succeed, then I'll be right. If those two things fail, then I'll be wrong.
However, and this is a BIG - A REALLY REALLY BIG however - I don't think it will fail. Why? Because it shouldn't fail. Moreover, I think that those who think that "President Bush will go down in history as one of the worst leaders of all time", by definition, thinks that the effort will fail. Some even WANT it to fail. Why in the world would someone WANT those things to fail? If the desired outcome is preferable, which, presumably, it is, and if failure is not an option, which, presumably is the case, then how could it NOT succeed? Why SHOULD it not succeed?
Keep focused on the desired outcome, and just let the chips fall where they may.
Come on, be real here. What do we really want, and how do we get there. And regardless of who gets the "credit", per se, what difference does it make? What's your desired outcome, and how do YOU propose we get there?
Just some food for thought.
.
I don't own a gun either.
by worker bee
I was originally in favor of the war. There was plenty of evidence that Saddam had a huge stockpile of chemical and biological weapons and it seemed plausible that sooner or later he would give or sell them to terrorists to attack the United States. Now it is time to admit we made a mistake and get out.
As for as what happens to the Iraqi people, I say we just let them to back to torturing and butchering each other. After all that seems to be the normal state of affairs in that part of the world. I think that it is highly unlikely that Iraq would become another Iran. The Sunnis seem to know were all the weapon caches are and seem to know how to use them. Iraq would just go back to being what it was before the war, a backward country run by a bunch of murdering Sunni sociopaths but not a threat to the United States or the world as a whole.
The mistake would be to stay and try to fix Iraq. Every day we stay there we spill more blood and treasure. Every day we stay our forces become more overstretched and fatigued and therefore our overall level of readiness goes down. Every day we stay our nation goes further into debt and therefore has less capacity to deal with future contigencies. Every day we stay we grow weaker. Our enemies all over the world see this and grow bolder. In other words, we are losing. The war on terror will be a long one and we cannot afford to squander our resources trying to bring peace and democracy to a people who don't want it and won't fight for it.
by thechas
A large part of the motivation behind many of the terrorist groups is the fact that the US has a record of getting things started and then leaving.
If the US had stood consistently behind democratic regimes over the past 50 years, many of these terrorist groups would have little ability to incite a following.
Yes, if we pull out now, the initial result will be a civil war in Iraq.
Most likely followed by the neighboring countries coming in and grabbing border areas.
The end result however would be renewed vigor for existing terrorist groups. And, a new group crop of terrorists from Iraq.
Further, pulling out of Iraq would weaken our already fragile standing within the global diplomatic community.
Another thought on the subject.
If we pull out under the pressure of these small insurgent groups. We only serve to embolden the terrorist networks.
I shudder to consider the consequences of having the terrorist groups believe that they forced us to leave Iraq.
Chas
by nd_it
by jardinier
Boy, is it hard to find objective statements in these political discussions. Please overlook my sarcastic posting to you in the "Iraqgate" discussion. I was just sick of the whole stupid thing, and I will refrain from reading all the postings in the current discussion.
I just read yours, to see your views as a new contributor. I wouldn't dignify this discussion by reading all of it.
Once again: welcome and thank you.
.
...then comment on some more things you haven't read.
And on knowing what an objective statement really is, you are so far removed from being objective, that you wouldn't know one if it jumped up and bit you in the derriere. Your definition of "objective", in regards to Bush and the USA, is this. If someone says that Bush is a terrible president, you call that "objective". If someone calls Bush anything close to a good president, you call them slanted.
Go figure.
by jardinier
I can see where you're coming from, but I don't think anyone has suggested that someone who is anti-Bush must then necessarily subscribe to all the Democrat policies.
While the policies of the American Republican Party are closely mirrored in the Australian Liberal/National Coalition, such a comparison can not be made between your Democrat Party and our Labor Party.
Believe me, I empathise with you in not having a viable alternative to vote for. As a centrist with a slight leaning to the left, I would certainly have a problem with choosing between the two major American parties.
by jardinier
Firstly, thank your for your polite and thoughtful comments on my posting.
I will try and list my core set of values:
Ethically, I try to follow the teachings of Jesus, especially as outlined in The Sermon On The mount. This has been my goal for most of my life.
I also borrow from Buddhism and Taoism to get different perspectives.
I am totally open and honest, and will answer any question, no matter how personal, which anyone cares to address to me.
This of course does not exclude me from giving sarcastic responses to anyone who casts unjustified aspersions on my character and integrity. While basically humble, I am certainly no door mat. ?God help anyone who puts s**t on Julian.? I will not accept other peoples? emotional baggage being projected onto myself.
I try not to judge other people and to accept them as they are, and in no way attempt to impose my beliefs on them. One of my personal maxims is: ?nobody is perfect, least of all myself.?
Politically I am not rigidly aligned to any ideology, however as the teachings of Jesus are primarily left-wing -- looking after the poor and needy; sharing whatever I have with others; living one day at a time; not aspiring to accumulate material possessions ? and many other edicts, it would inevitably follow that my political leanings are towards the left.
You would have to read the whole of Matthew chapters 5,6,7 and many other Biblical verses, to learn the extended set of ethics which I do my best to follow.
Without giving a whole Bible lesson, while Jesus in no way condemns individual enterprise and wealth, he suggests strongly that attachment to material things is an impediment to spiritual growth. ?Matthew 6:33 But seek ye first the kingdom of God, and his righteousness; and all these things shall be added unto you.
Matthew 6:34 Take therefore no thought for the morrow: for the morrow shall take thought for the things of itself. Sufficient unto the day [is] the evil thereof.
Politically, the two major parties in Australia cannot be compared directly with the American Republican and Democrat parties. The Australian Labor Party has produced many of Australia?s greatest Prime Ministers. While initially its primary goal was socialism, from the time Bob Hawke became Prime Minister in 1983, the party has moved so far to the centre that many people complain that you can?t tell one party from the other.
Mark Latham is promising many radical changes to Labor policy which will distinguish it clearly from the Liberal Party, but without favouring the poor and disadvantaged over the wealthy. Howard has tried to turn Australia into an elitist society, with a marked division between rich and poor.
So without posting a long essay I can say simply and accurately state that my core values come from the teachings of Jesus, St Paul, Gautama Buddha and Lao Tsu.
While I may not live up to these precepts, these are the values which I try to follow.
by jamesrl
I will admit I've been away from TR for a while.
I am back now because I have a new job leading a technical group, and I want to keep up with new issues.
Maxwell was around back then.
I did log on this morning to find my 5000 points have been reduced to 0.
Not that the points mean anything to me anyway.
Regards,
James
Yes, sometimes, violence is the only answer. BUT not against civilians! And what grievances do these cowards have against the US? That we support Israel? Until they attacked us, neither Israel nor we have EVER initiated agression. This is no different than if a man, because he hates another man, rapes that mans daughter instead of confronting the man himself.
Ralph
by jardinier
Well I wouldn't know John Kerry from Donald Duck, because he rates barely a mention in the Australian media. Besides we have our own election coming up, and we DO have a viable alternative leader.
However, just to get in the spirit of things, the following was sent to me by a Republican friend in America:
AN OPEN LETTER TO JOHN KERRY
From Don Bendell Canon City, Colorado, March 25, 2004
My wife had rotator cuff surgery earlier this year, and the recovery is terribly painful. Then, she developed a staph-epi infection, and they had to cut the same scar open and operate on her again. Just thinking about the pain and anxiety of facing that painful surgery a second time in the same wound, makes me cringe. That experience, however pales in comparison to what I am going through right now, in my heart.
The old hurts are surfacing and the feelings of betrayal by fellow citizens, and their leader stirring them up, are breaking my heart again. I am being cut in the same scar. How did we who served in Vietnam suddenly become cold-blooded killers, torturers, and rapists, of the ilk of the Nazi SS or the Taliban? Most of us were American soldiers who grew up idolizing John Wayne, Roy Rogers, and all the other heroes. That was why I volunteered.
But for political expediency, John Kerry has rewritten history, again. After spending only four months in the country of Vietnam, John Kerry testified before Congress in 1971 with these exact words about incidents he supposedly witnessed or heard about from other vets: "They personally raped, cut off ears, cut off heads, taped wires from portable telephones to human genitals and turned up the power, cut off limbs, blown up bodies, randomly shot at civilians, razed villages, shot cattle and dogs for fun, poisoned food stocks, and generally ravaged the countryside of South Vietnam."
I was a green beret officer who volunteered for duty in Vietnam and fought in the thick of it in 1968 and 1969 on a Special Forces A-team on the Ho Chi Minh Trail, just for starters. We were the elite.. We saw the most action. Everybody in the world knows that. But we did not just kill people, we built a church, a school, treated illnesses, passed out soap, food, and clothing, and had fun and loving interaction with the indigenous people of Vietnam, just like our boys did in Normandy, Baghdad, Saigon, and everywhere American soldiers ever served. We all gave away our candy bars and rations to kids. Our hearts to oppressed people all over the globe.
My children and grandchildren could read your words, and think those horrendous things about me, Mr. Kerry. You are a bold-faced, unprincipled liar, and a disgrace, and you have dishonored me and all my fellow Vietnam veterans. Sure, there were a couple of bad-apples, but I saw none, and I saw it all, and if I did, as an army officer, it was my obligation to stop it, or at the very least report it.
Why is there not a single record anywhere of you ever reporting any incidents like this or having the perpetrators arrested? The answer is simple. You are a liar. Your medals and mine are not a free pass for lifetime, Senator Kerry, to bypass character, integrity, and morality. I earn my green beret over and over daily in all aspects of my life.
Eight National Guard green berets, and other National Guard soldiers, have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, and you totally dishonored their widows and families by lumping National Guard service in with being a draft-dodger, conscientious objector, and deserter, just so you can try to sabotage the patriotism of our President who proudly served as an Air National Guard jet pilot. I have a son earning his green beret at Fort Bragg right now, and his wife serves honorably in the Air National Guard, just like President Bush did, and I am as proud of her as I am my son. I volunteered for Vietnam and have no problem whatsoever with President Bush being our Commander-In-Chief. In fact, I am proud of him as our leader.
John Kerry, you personally derailed the Vietnam Human rights Bill, HR2883, in 2001, after it had passed the House by a 411 to 1 vote, and thousands of pro-American Montagnard tribespeople in Vietnam died since then who could have been saved, by you. Earlier, as Chair of the Senate Select Committee on MIA/POW Affairs, you personally quashed the efforts of any and all veterans to report sightings of living POW's, when you held those reins in Congress. You have fought tooth and nail to push for the US to normalize relations with Vietnam for years.
Why, Mr. Kerry? Simple, your first cousin C. Stewart Forbes, CEO, of Colliers International, recently signed a contract with Hanoi, worth BILLIONS of dollars for Collier's International to become the exclusive real estate representative for the country of Vietnam."Hanoi John," now that it works for you, you beat your chest about your Vietnam service, but to me, you are a phony, opportunistic, hypocrite. You are one of those politicians that is like a fertilizer machine: all that comes out of you is horse manure, and you are spreading it everywhere. Medals do not make a man: morals do.
[Don Bendell served as an officer in four Special Forces Groups, is a best-selling author with over 1,500,000 books in print, a 1995 inductee into the International Karate Hall of Fame, and owns karate schools in southern Colorado.]
I want to personally extend a lot of gratitude to Jullian for this post. Most importantly, I want to commend Don Bendell for his service in Vietnam.
My father-in-law served in Vietnam as well. He was an MP in Saigon and did two tours of duty before he came home. To this day, he will not even mention the atrocities that the VC committed against our military personnel, U.S. civilians, AND THEIR OWN PEOPLE.
I find Kerry to be hypocritical and insulting to those who served their country with honor and dignity. They returned to the U.S. to fend off insults and disgraseful remarks made by a group ungrateful and vitriolic individuals of which the likes of Kerry and 'Hanoi' Jane Fonda. My father-in-law is an honorable and dignified individual who was terribly scarred by the events that took place while he was on duty. He returned to this country suffering from post-tramatic distress syndrome and became an alcholic, as a result of serving.
I can say for wife and myself that we were not born until 1975, and we cannot imagine the horrors this individuals have gone through. What we realize is that at least they stood for something that was righteous, even when it was run by a bunch of blow-hard politicians on BOTH sides of the aisle.
Kerry continues to insult my family and I because, we do have a family member serving. My uncle is a Cheif Petty Officer First Class in the Navy. His job is to service electonic guidance systems for Tommahawk missile systems. Last, I heard he was station in Baharain (spelling?). For all I know he could be back states side right now. His duty was not only ensure the weapon systems were function correctly, but he assisted with investigations when the missile systems suffered a malfunction. I am proud of my uncle, and Kerry's comments, though made 30 years ago, are still an insult for the men and women who have served and those who are on active duty.
This raises the issue of the individuals who ran the prison where charges were made on suspected tortures, mutilations, and the likes done on Iraqui P.O.W.s. These people do not represent the finest men and women the U.S. have to offer in service to others. These individuals, if found guilty, should be punished to the fullest extent of the law in front of the entire world.
The U.S. has never acted on or condoned such criminal behavior and we are not about to start.
In one of my postings I gave my rationale for supporting the war. The major point I had was the human atrocities that were taking place under Saddam's regieme. If what is reported is true, and their culpability is determined to guilty of said crimes, I equate these individuals to that of Sadam's regieme and place them amongst the animals we are trying to thwart.
The sad thing is that a few bad apples have ruined the bunch. Our imaged is tarnished and we need to reedeem our selves in the eyes of the world community and the people we are trying to help. I would never back a leader who condones this action from his troops.
Remember those who are serving honorably and faithfully. Those who are there upholding human rights laws and working to shed light on a people who have been in darkness for 40 to 50 years. They are the ones I am proud of. My uncle is one of them. For those who served in previous wars, I could never repay the debit for the sacrifice you gave. You are my heroes, everyone. In my family this would include both my grandfathers, who served in World War II and Korea, and my father-in-law, a battered but recovering Vietnam vet.
God Bless, and God Keep All of them. I can only hope when my time will come, I can exhibit the same courage, strength and honor they had.
by jardinier
I wouldn't know John Kerry from Donald Duck, as he rates barely a mention in the Australian media. Besides we have our own election coming up and we DO have a viable contender.
Anyhow, just to get in the spirit of things, here is a document sent to me by an American Republican friend:
AN OPEN LETTER TO JOHN KERRY
From Don Bendell Canon City, Colorado, March 25, 2004
My wife had rotator cuff surgery earlier this year, and the recovery is terribly painful. Then, she developed a staph-epi infection, and they had to cut the same scar open and operate on her again. Just thinking about the pain and anxiety of facing that painful surgery a second time in the same wound, makes me cringe. That experience, however pales in comparison to what I am going through right now, in my heart.
The old hurts are surfacing and the feelings of betrayal by fellow citizens, and their leader stirring them up, are breaking my heart again. I am being cut in the same scar. How did we who served in Vietnam suddenly become cold-blooded killers, torturers, and rapists, of the ilk of the Nazi SS or the Taliban? Most of us were American soldiers who grew up idolizing John Wayne, Roy Rogers, and all the other heroes. That was why I volunteered.
But for political expediency, John Kerry has rewritten history, again. After spending only four months in the country of Vietnam, John Kerry testified before Congress in 1971 with these exact words about incidents he supposedly witnessed or heard about from other vets: "They personally raped, cut off ears, cut off heads, taped wires from portable telephones to human genitals and turned up the power, cut off limbs, blown up bodies, randomly shot at civilians, razed villages, shot cattle and dogs for fun, poisoned food stocks, and generally ravaged the countryside of South Vietnam."
I was a green beret officer who volunteered for duty in Vietnam and fought in the thick of it in 1968 and 1969 on a Special Forces A-team on the Ho Chi Minh Trail, just for starters. We were the elite.. We saw the most action. Everybody in the world knows that. But we did not just kill people, we built a church, a school, treated illnesses, passed out soap, food, and clothing, and had fun and loving interaction with the indigenous people of Vietnam, just like our boys did in Normandy, Baghdad, Saigon, and everywhere American soldiers ever served. We all gave away our candy bars and rations to kids. Our hearts to oppressed people all over the globe.
My children and grandchildren could read your words, and think those horrendous things about me, Mr. Kerry. You are a bold-faced, unprincipled liar, and a disgrace, and you have dishonored me and all my fellow Vietnam veterans. Sure, there were a couple of bad-apples, but I saw none, and I saw it all, and if I did, as an army officer, it was my obligation to stop it, or at the very least report it.
Why is there not a single record anywhere of you ever reporting any incidents like this or having the perpetrators arrested? The answer is simple. You are a liar. Your medals and mine are not a free pass for lifetime, Senator Kerry, to bypass character, integrity, and morality. I earn my green beret over and over daily in all aspects of my life.
Eight National Guard green berets, and other National Guard soldiers, have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, and you totally dishonored their widows and families by lumping National Guard service in with being a draft-dodger, conscientious objector, and deserter, just so you can try to sabotage the patriotism of our President who proudly served as an Air National Guard jet pilot. I have a son earning his green beret at Fort Bragg right now, and his wife serves honorably in the Air National Guard, just like President Bush did, and I am as proud of her as I am my son. I volunteered for Vietnam and have no problem whatsoever with President Bush being our Commander-In-Chief. In fact, I am proud of him as our leader.
John Kerry, you personally derailed the Vietnam Human rights Bill, HR2883, in 2001, after it had passed the House by a 411 to 1 vote, and thousands of pro-American Montagnard tribespeople in Vietnam died since then who could have been saved, by you. Earlier, as Chair of the Senate Select Committee on MIA/POW Affairs, you personally quashed the efforts of any and all veterans to report sightings of living POW's, when you held those reins in Congress. You have fought tooth and nail to push for the US to normalize relations with Vietnam for years.
Why, Mr. Kerry? Simple, your first cousin C. Stewart Forbes, CEO, of Colliers International, recently signed a contract with Hanoi, worth BILLIONS of dollars for Collier's International to become the exclusive real estate representative for the country of Vietnam."Hanoi John," now that it works for you, you beat your chest about your Vietnam service, but to me, you are a phony, opportunistic, hypocrite. You are one of those politicians that is like a fertilizer machine: all that comes out of you is horse manure, and you are spreading it everywhere. Medals do not make a man: morals do.
[Don Bendell served as an officer in four Special Forces Groups, is a best-selling author with over 1,500,000 books in print, a 1995 inductee into the International Karate Hall of Fame, and owns karate schools in southern Colorado.]
by jardinier
Well I wouldn't know John Kerry from Donald Duck as he barely rates a mention in the Australian media and besides, we have our own election coming up and we DO have a viable contender.
Anyhow, just to get in the spirit of things, here is a document sent to me by an American Republican friend:
AN OPEN LETTER TO JOHN KERRY
From Don Bendell Canon City, Colorado, March 25, 2004
My wife had rotator cuff surgery earlier this year, and the recovery is terribly painful. Then, she developed a staph-epi infection, and they had to cut the same scar open and operate on her again. Just thinking about the pain and anxiety of facing that painful surgery a second time in the same wound, makes me cringe. That experience, however pales in comparison to what I am going through right now, in my heart.
The old hurts are surfacing and the feelings of betrayal by fellow citizens, and their leader stirring them up, are breaking my heart again. I am being cut in the same scar. How did we who served in Vietnam suddenly become cold-blooded killers, torturers, and rapists, of the ilk of the Nazi SS or the Taliban? Most of us were American soldiers who grew up idolizing John Wayne, Roy Rogers, and all the other heroes. That was why I volunteered.
But for political expediency, John Kerry has rewritten history, again. After spending only four months in the country of Vietnam, John Kerry testified before Congress in 1971 with these exact words about incidents he supposedly witnessed or heard about from other vets: "They personally raped, cut off ears, cut off heads, taped wires from portable telephones to human genitals and turned up the power, cut off limbs, blown up bodies, randomly shot at civilians, razed villages, shot cattle and dogs for fun, poisoned food stocks, and generally ravaged the countryside of South Vietnam."
I was a green beret officer who volunteered for duty in Vietnam and fought in the thick of it in 1968 and 1969 on a Special Forces A-team on the Ho Chi Minh Trail, just for starters. We were the elite.. We saw the most action. Everybody in the world knows that. But we did not just kill people, we built a church, a school, treated illnesses, passed out soap, food, and clothing, and had fun and loving interaction with the indigenous people of Vietnam, just like our boys did in Normandy, Baghdad, Saigon, and everywhere American soldiers ever served. We all gave away our candy bars and rations to kids. Our hearts to oppressed people all over the globe.
My children and grandchildren could read your words, and think those horrendous things about me, Mr. Kerry. You are a bold-faced, unprincipled liar, and a disgrace, and you have dishonored me and all my fellow Vietnam veterans. Sure, there were a couple of bad-apples, but I saw none, and I saw it all, and if I did, as an army officer, it was my obligation to stop it, or at the very least report it.
Why is there not a single record anywhere of you ever reporting any incidents like this or having the perpetrators arrested? The answer is simple. You are a liar. Your medals and mine are not a free pass for lifetime, Senator Kerry, to bypass character, integrity, and morality. I earn my green beret over and over daily in all aspects of my life.
Eight National Guard green berets, and other National Guard soldiers, have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, and you totally dishonored their widows and families by lumping National Guard service in with being a draft-dodger, conscientious objector, and deserter, just so you can try to sabotage the patriotism of our President who proudly served as an Air National Guard jet pilot. I have a son earning his green beret at Fort Bragg right now, and his wife serves honorably in the Air National Guard, just like President Bush did, and I am as proud of her as I am my son. I volunteered for Vietnam and have no problem whatsoever with President Bush being our Commander-In-Chief. In fact, I am proud of him as our leader.
John Kerry, you personally derailed the Vietnam Human rights Bill, HR2883, in 2001, after it had passed the House by a 411 to 1 vote, and thousands of pro-American Montagnard tribespeople in Vietnam died since then who could have been saved, by you. Earlier, as Chair of the Senate Select Committee on MIA/POW Affairs, you personally quashed the efforts of any and all veterans to report sightings of living POW's, when you held those reins in Congress. You have fought tooth and nail to push for the US to normalize relations with Vietnam for years.
Why, Mr. Kerry? Simple, your first cousin C. Stewart Forbes, CEO, of Colliers International, recently signed a contract with Hanoi, worth BILLIONS of dollars for Collier's International to become the exclusive real estate representative for the country of Vietnam."Hanoi John," now that it works for you, you beat your chest about your Vietnam service, but to me, you are a phony, opportunistic, hypocrite. You are one of those politicians that is like a fertilizer machine: all that comes out of you is horse manure, and you are spreading it everywhere. Medals do not make a man: morals do.
[Don Bendell served as an officer in four Special Forces Groups, is a best-selling author with over 1,500,000 books in print, a 1995 inductee into the International Karate Hall of Fame, and owns karate schools in southern Colorado.]
by jardinier
Well I wouldn't know John Kerry from Donald Duck as he barely rates a mention in the Australian media and besides, we have our own election coming up and we DO have a viable contender.
Anyhow, just to get in the spirit of things, here is a document sent to me by an American Republican friend:
AN OPEN LETTER TO JOHN KERRY
From Don Bendell Canon City, Colorado, March 25, 2004
My wife had rotator cuff surgery earlier this year, and the recovery is terribly painful. Then, she developed a staph-epi infection, and they had to cut the same scar open and operate on her again. Just thinking about the pain and anxiety of facing that painful surgery a second time in the same wound, makes me cringe. That experience, however pales in comparison to what I am going through right now, in my heart.
The old hurts are surfacing and the feelings of betrayal by fellow citizens, and their leader stirring them up, are breaking my heart again. I am being cut in the same scar. How did we who served in Vietnam suddenly become cold-blooded killers, torturers, and rapists, of the ilk of the Nazi SS or the Taliban? Most of us were American soldiers who grew up idolizing John Wayne, Roy Rogers, and all the other heroes. That was why I volunteered.
But for political expediency, John Kerry has rewritten history, again. After spending only four months in the country of Vietnam, John Kerry testified before Congress in 1971 with these exact words about incidents he supposedly witnessed or heard about from other vets: "They personally raped, cut off ears, cut off heads, taped wires from portable telephones to human genitals and turned up the power, cut off limbs, blown up bodies, randomly shot at civilians, razed villages, shot cattle and dogs for fun, poisoned food stocks, and generally ravaged the countryside of South Vietnam."
I was a green beret officer who volunteered for duty in Vietnam and fought in the thick of it in 1968 and 1969 on a Special Forces A-team on the Ho Chi Minh Trail, just for starters. We were the elite.. We saw the most action. Everybody in the world knows that. But we did not just kill people, we built a church, a school, treated illnesses, passed out soap, food, and clothing, and had fun and loving interaction with the indigenous people of Vietnam, just like our boys did in Normandy, Baghdad, Saigon, and everywhere American soldiers ever served. We all gave away our candy bars and rations to kids. Our hearts to oppressed people all over the globe.
My children and grandchildren could read your words, and think those horrendous things about me, Mr. Kerry. You are a bold-faced, unprincipled liar, and a disgrace, and you have dishonored me and all my fellow Vietnam veterans. Sure, there were a couple of bad-apples, but I saw none, and I saw it all, and if I did, as an army officer, it was my obligation to stop it, or at the very least report it.
Why is there not a single record anywhere of you ever reporting any incidents like this or having the perpetrators arrested? The answer is simple. You are a liar. Your medals and mine are not a free pass for lifetime, Senator Kerry, to bypass character, integrity, and morality. I earn my green beret over and over daily in all aspects of my life.
Eight National Guard green berets, and other National Guard soldiers, have been killed in Iraq and Afghanistan, and you totally dishonored their widows and families by lumping National Guard service in with being a draft-dodger, conscientious objector, and deserter, just so you can try to sabotage the patriotism of our President who proudly served as an Air National Guard jet pilot. I have a son earning his green beret at Fort Bragg right now, and his wife serves honorably in the Air National Guard, just like President Bush did, and I am as proud of her as I am my son. I volunteered for Vietnam and have no problem whatsoever with President Bush being our Commander-In-Chief. In fact, I am proud of him as our leader.
John Kerry, you personally derailed the Vietnam Human rights Bill, HR2883, in 2001, after it had passed the House by a 411 to 1 vote, and thousands of pro-American Montagnard tribespeople in Vietnam died since then who could have been saved, by you. Earlier, as Chair of the Senate Select Committee on MIA/POW Affairs, you personally quashed the efforts of any and all veterans to report sightings of living POW's, when you held those reins in Congress. You have fought tooth and nail to push for the US to normalize relations with Vietnam for years.
Why, Mr. Kerry? Simple, your first cousin C. Stewart Forbes, CEO, of Colliers International, recently signed a contract with Hanoi, worth BILLIONS of dollars for Collier's International to become the exclusive real estate representative for the country of Vietnam."Hanoi John," now that it works for you, you beat your chest about your Vietnam service, but to me, you are a phony, opportunistic, hypocrite. You are one of those politicians that is like a fertilizer machine: all that comes out of you is horse manure, and you are spreading it everywhere. Medals do not make a man: morals do.
[Don Bendell served as an officer in four Special Forces Groups, is a best-selling author with over 1,500,000 books in print, a 1995 inductee into the International Karate Hall of Fame, and owns karate schools in southern Colorado.]
by jardinier
Sorry fellers: I tried unsuccessfully three times to post this item, so I went to another computer and LO! A quadruple posting first go!
So in what little corner of cyberspace were those initial three attempts hiding?
TechRepublic is obviously under the control of a Gremlin, who causes all manner of unexpected and annoying tricks. Well at least he didn't turn my quadruple posting into bold type.
.
Julian,
Outstanding post. Thank you very much. I couldn't have posted it any better myself. (Unless, of course, I posted it SIX times over.)
by wrlang
Send our people in Iraq all the love and support you can. And don't forget Afghanistan.
Anyone who has paid attention to the news has seen everything mentioned in the soldiers letter. We are doing good and bad things there, its a tough job and our people are doing their best.
The facts are amazingly simple. The Iraqis who thank the soldiers want them there, and the Iraqis who shoot at them don't want them there. Its a sweeping generalization to say they don't want us there, and the same to say they do want us there.
The glass is half empty, but it is also half full.
.
What percentage, by the way, of Iraqis want us there versus the ones that don't? I really don't know the answer. Does anyone?
by wrlang
Ann Coulter would make a great stand up comic.
I love her rants, but I have sympathy for the people who take her seriously.
How 9/11 happened only goes back to when they got the idea and started planning it. DUH!!!
If you're going to look at history through republican colored glasses, you could at least go back to the real beginning to give us some more to laugh about.
.
Look at history through the color of your glasses, Democrat colored glasses, I presume, and share your view of the events that led up to it. The difference in views will be interesting to compare.
By the way, do you take Al Franken or Michael Moore seriously? You do? Well, enough said.
by maecuff
These threads are nothing more than people talking at people. It's a chance to post your particular belief, but no one will ever be REALLY willing to listen, and consider, what another person's view may be. Ann Coulter is dismissed out of hand..Michael Moore and Al Franken are in turn dismissed. There really isn't any room for change here, is there?
The few times I've heard Ann Coulter, she has completely turned my stomach. What stood out was a comment that she felt the US should go into any country that wasn't Christian and force them to be Christains (paraphrased). I would like to hear something from her that make sense to me, so I can understand HOW people can take her seriously. Same goes for Michael Moore and Al Franken..yes, many things they say are OUT there. But a lot they have to say makes all the sense in the world to me. Just watch Bowling for Columbine.
.
There's more basis in truth in what Ann Coulter says than in what Michael Moore says. For example, in the article above, name one thing that's not true. You may not like how she says it, but it's pretty much on the mark.
Michael Moore, on the other hand, manages to take an ounce of truth and spin it into a ton of lies.
And not only that, but Ann Coulter is a lot easier on the eyes - a LOT easier.
by oz_media
by cactus pete
Here's one person's site which lists plenty of questionable statements by the author of whom you spoke.
.
(Oz was right. It was a setup question.)
Vietnam:
Let's just leave that out of it. It's a scar on America, no question about it. The whole experience just sucked pond water.
Central America:
Are most CA nations better off now than they were 50 years ago? The answer is yes, so I rest my case.
Grenada:
This was the first real conflict after Vietnam, if you can really call it a conflict. (But 15 or so US soldiers died, so it was real enough.) However, it went by so fast, and it was relatively uneventful, and I don't recall too much opposition to it, so today not many people know much about it.
In a nutshell, here's how I remember it. The government of Grenada was sitting there, fat, dumb and happy (just an expression), minding their own business, doing whatever they do on the island nation of Grenada, when all of the sudden (or perhaps not too suddenly) they were overthrown in a vicious and bloody coup, a coup staged by their very own army - and an army, by the way, which had been strongly influenced and supported by the Marxist government of Cuba and the Sandinista government of Nicaragua. Cuba was gaining a lot of influence with this new Marxist government, and began using the Cuban military to build an air base on the island. Moreover, there were a bunch of American medical students on the island, and it was thought that they may (emphasis placed on "may") be in some sort of danger. Cuba, after all, doesn't think too kindly of Americans, you know. I have no idea why the medical students were in Grenada. Perhaps the tuition was cheaper.
So having set the stage, as I described above, President Reagan wasn't too thrilled about the prospect of Cuba gaining influence in the Caribbean, not to mention the fact that we frown upon the indiscriminate take-over of a government without the will of the people taken into consideration. You know, we kinda' prefer elections over coups. So we send in the Army Rangers (a couple thousand, I think), kicked a little Cuban butt, gave the government back to the people of Grenada, and we all lived happily ever after. Does that about sum it up?
Besides, we needed a new story line for Clint Eastwood. Dirty Harry was getting a little old.
by jacko4
your hero is george w,he is the one who I asked you about
as for clinton,I couldnt vote for him,not that I would have because im from uk
these arguments could go on forever as pointed out but looking from the outside you would be surprised to know the level of anxiety and even anti american feeling in the wider world,it seems that anyone who doesnt do things your way is just set upon,apart from more powerful nations of course ie the old ussr and china
by maecuff
by jacko4
FACT the us govt has funded,armed and trained terrorist groups across the world for decades through the cia
FACT thousands if not millions of ordinary americans have enthuiastically and openly supported a terrorist group for decades, the IRA
talk about double standards and hypocrisy
one final note,how did your hero dodge the draft for vietnam
.
As I said, I don't own one, but I don't think gun ownership should be prohibited. (Don't want to get into the "gun" discussion, however.) But think of the overall lunacy connected with that issue. And Columbine is a perfect example of skewed and crazy thinking. (I live only a few miles from Columbine High School, by the way, and personally know the family of one of the victims.)
On one hand, there's a movement to restrict handgun ownership and/or the right to carry one. Let law enforcement protect you, they will say. And most law enforcement agencies, agreeing with that sentiment, support restricted ownership and/or carry laws. Okay, fine and dandy. Go ahead and protect us. But on the other hand, can they really "protect" us?
Police call - shots fired at Columbine High School. First officers on the scene told to wait outside for backup to arrive (standard procedure, I suppose). Pow, pow - more shots fired. All officers on the scene told to wait for a field officer to arrive - wait who's in charge here, the city or the county? Pow, pow, pow - more shots fired, students fleeing. Dozens of officers on the scene told to wait for an assessment of what they were facing. Pow, pow pow - more shots fired, still no officers inside the building. The lives of the officers must be protected. Pow, pow, pow - we don't want any dead officers.
Wait a minute, I thought they were there to "protect"? Why didn't they enter the building, yes, putting their lives on the line, when they first arrived to "protect"? Why didn't they "protect"?
What if that dead teacher had a handgun instead? (Not that I'm suggesting guns in school is a good idea, but I'm not suggesting it isn't either.)
The next Columbine might be in a shopping mall or restaurant. If I'm in that restaurant, I'll sure pray that the guy at the next table has a handgun, because I know that by the time "law enforcement" arrives, waits for backup, assesses the situation, decides who's in charge, and protects themselves first and foremost, we may all be dead. We do indeed have a right, perhaps even an obligation, to protect ourselves.
by maecuff
We really almost agree. I agree that the police should have been there to PROTECT. I'd like to see more police do what they are paid to do, instead of using their power to intimidate. I think the only group that abuse their position more than the police are teachers. (And before I hear from the police and the teachers, I am not saying ALL or even MOST abuse their positions..but you have to admit, they are in a position to do so, and some do)
Columbine was tragic, I can't imagine living through that nightmare, but instead of hoping the guy next to me has a handgun to protect me in case some nutcase is shooting the place up, wouldn't it be better for the nutcase to NOT have a gun in the first place?
Just as the saying goes. You make points I have trouble refuting, but I have a few that you have to admit, make you think a little.
I sit here early Saturday morning, after reflecting on this whole mess and cannot help, but wonder. Why am I arguing this point? What you see as over-patriotic or over-zealous, I view as a deep concern of the direction of our place in the world and the responsibilities and how this all plays out on the world stage. Periodically, I have my doubts. My comment of in a previous posting has me feeling hypocritical after careful thought: "Those who refuse to see are eternally blind." You can say I have been a bit rash, well okay a whole lot.
It is amazing to me how much emotion can destroy a man's sensabilities and warp facts. What you say can be true, and I will take you at your word. I have not fully read the report, regretably and have relied on other media formats to form my decisions.
I still support this effort from begining in the end because it needed to be done. However, how much time did we really have before the next catastrophe? We probably will not know for sure. The fact this man had the capabilities is frightening in and of itself. The heinous acts this individuals carry out are totally unpredictable. I share the same setiments with what you said, "Haste makes waste," but when dealing with uncertanties there are times you must take a leap of faith and hope the decision made was the right one given the existing values of the variables in play.
I would be totally naieve to think that we were not using some of the Iraqi oil being funneled out of the U.N. program. That is just the way business happens. By the time that barrel of oil is traded about 20 to 30 times on the market, it is enitrely possible that the point of origin gets lost in the shuffle; or companies flat out by it, fudge the documentation, and process the material. All the same the oil made it to the market. The question that raises a specter of suspision over the whole program was, what happened to all that money? For those countries that were taking advantage of the program, it raises a conflict of interest when dealing with it on the international scene. The point that every interaction international politics is a conflict of intrest can be viewed as a conflict of interest, but what degree of conflict is involved.
BTW: no need to send a 60 pg. document, I haven't got caught up with documents I have to read already. Hence the reason I'll will take you at your word.
.
You asked, "how did (my) hero dodge the draft for Vietnam?"
I hate to break this to you, but Bill Clinton isn't my hero? By the way, did you vote for Clinton? Yea, I though so.
I am not saying we should close off our boards. I am not saying we should halt all imports and exports into our country. I am not going so far as to say that the U.S. can sustain itself without the rest of the world (and we can pretty well, after all the U.S. policies up to World War I pretty much had an isolationist slant).
Forgive me if I do not articulate this well (I think I have a running track record on this -- there will be no need to hid behind rocks when hand grenades are involved, he, he, he), so let pose this conjecture. From general observations, a few articles here and there, the people I find suffer the most from illegal immigration are the ones are going through the process. I think we put too much emphasis on those who are here illegally than those who are following the law. Every human is entitled to basic necessities in life and I sure am not for a program that has those attempting to enter illegally be shot on site if they continue the egress from there country. There has to be some way that allows them to go about doing this legally that is rational and reasonable. We pay taxes to the government to provide services to us. As citizen's we have the right to access these resources. If add illegal immigrants into the equation, who of course are not paying taxes for government services, there is an inequity for those that are citizens or are here legally.
We have limited resources to fund government programs, and it can be argued that most of these services are not required under the U.S. Constitution. As a nation of generally good people, we provide these services to help the whole of community especially those who need the help.
We need to do a better job on border security. If Bush was so gung-ho for making sure the country had better security, he should have focused on our porous borders. Mainly for the border in the southern portion of the U.S. Living in Texas for the past 14 years, I can tell you that there as been an overwhelming explosion of illegal aliens in my locality. It is so bad that many of the basic local resources, such as hospital districts, fire, police, and EMS services are stretched thin having to provide service to the citizens. The reason for this, by Texas State Law any individual who is need of emergency medical attention will not be denied such service regardless of insurance or immigration status. The last part of the clause is really eating our lunch. The localities are streched thin on the funding availble to keep up for the demand. Unlike most other areas of the U.S., Texas does not have an income tax. Much of the revenue recieved is through property taxes, sales taxes, and federal funds (which isn't much). When mixed all together, we are figuratively and literally being taxed out of house and home.
The one of the main purposes for our government is to provide protection along our boarder and enforce existing immigration laws. Our government is definitely not doing it down here. Granted, it would be ridiculous to believe we are going to have a mass migration of Canadians because the weather is too cold and the would like warmer climes. Sensibility, tells me that any form of border managment in the north does not have to be nearly as pervasive as it is really down here.
As a side joke that is sad but true: We may have remembered the Alamo and won our independence from Mexico, but we have lost the Alamo again and the Mexicans are coming back to reclaim the territory that was once theirs--one illegal immigrant at a time.
If you think this is xenophobic, I cordually invite you to visit my state, and go to San Antonio. The hispanic population makes up approximately 60% to 70% of the city. Can you guess how many are here legally and how many are here illegally?
Not to be a bigot, which I am not (I do not like people in general, and this includes myself so I am not discriminatory in any way shape or form when it comes to insults -- of course done mainly in jest), I have singled out hispanics mainly. However, the largest group of illegal aliens come mainly from Central and South America. Now this does not proclude people of other nationalities as well that are here illegally. I am for enforcing the law on all groups. If we have illegal aliens from the Czech Republic, I would expect them to be deported back to there country as well.
We need to support those who are here legally because they suffer the sterotypes for the individuals who choose a route that is not legal. Furthermore, we need to hold ALL BUSINESSES ACCOUNTABLE FOR THE HIRING OF ILLEGAL ALIENS. I would not mind seeing a stiffer penalty against companies who break the law, since what is in place is not a good enough determent.
If this means having to pay more for goods and services in my own country, I do not mind. I am supporting those who support the law.
...to be nearly as articluate as the supports of President Bush and the effort, even when I occasionally insert foot in mouth.
But what can I say, I guess I will have to settle on being your lovable, over-patriotic, over-zelous, white trash, red neck (not gun toting) from the great state of Texas in what I think and believe is the greatest country on the face of the earth, the U.S.
Living up to liberal sterotypes can be very exhausting. Do you guys mind if can take a few of these responsibilities off or combine them. For example, can I combine white trash and red neck for senseless arrogant hick. It kind of has a more catchy flare about it. Makes me feel more welcomed in political discussions. It helps me understand that my opinions have no weight because I am just as stupid as the president that I voted for, and will vote again for (oh well I am so fallible, when will this simple-minded Republican ever learn, gee whiz). I guess I lack gravitas, or some Frenchie world like that.
Oh, Oh!!! Can I be a big fat liar also. I think my goal in life has changed. I want to be called a big fat liar by Al Franken. Why should Rush Limbaugh have all of the good sterotypes? Well, shucks.
Don't forget, us uneducated, salt of the earth, religious fanatics want to do nothing more than see the elderly die and starve school children. Another thing, I like my air and water filthy. I want to get cancer and die a painfull and horrible death. Gee, I cannot wait for that!!!
Let me see what else did my simpleton mind leave out, hmmm.... Oh yeah, I want to make tax the poor out of existence, so that wealthy people can keep all of their money. Its not like they own businesses that provide jobs for the majority of middle class. Don't forget the medical benefits too.
I have erred, sorry Max, we have been blind and wrong for so long. We need a government that takes 100% of our paycheck, and gives us back what it thinks we can have. After all, its the governments money, not the peoples. How selfish of me, I am an insensitive goon.
Well since I am stupid and uneducated, I need to be indoctrinated into programs that help me find myself, to better diversfy my outlook in life. I need SENSITIVITY TRAINING!!!!! I am too much male for anyone to handle, so I need to go and learn how to be a little girl. There I go again being insensitive!!! Gee whiz, when will us wascally wepublicalns evwer learn, he, he he.
Oh yeah, just because I think abortion is murder of an unborn child, makes me an insensitive clod to women's rights. Let me see, my wife has the same feeling I do on this. Does this mean my wife needs to be reprogrammed to think more like a feminist? And I need, again, more SENSITIVTY TRAINING???!!!
I guess I should apologize for holding these deep seeded moral and ethical beliefs. Oh wait, fixed morals and ethics in a realtive moralistic and ethical world? What am I to do? Poor me. I guess I am victim of being a brain numb Republican robot who has the inability to make judgements for myself. OOPs did I say judgements, can't be judgemental in society today, that could get me in trouble!!!!
Besides why do I need to think when we have a bevy of leaders in the world and U.S. who would love to tell me how my life should be run. You now when I can or cannot use the facilities, and when I do what size toilet I can use. Can't use those rusty trusty 1.6 gallon tanks anymore, its agains the law!!!!! :))
I promise to do better at being my sensitive to others feeling. I also promise the first chance, I will strive to become a lock-step democrat voter, honest! That way I will never have to think for myself again, because BIG BROTHER will always be there to tell me how to think, what to do, how to do it, and what to do with (which can be painful at time without the astroglide).
Does this make me a male prostitute? or as the kids call it now: manwhore? (for those who are older I think the term is gigalo, correct me if I am wrong, wait I am always wrong so correct me anyway).
Oh BTW: I promise to twist the facts and help to cover up what might be potentially damaging for interest of the democrat party. After all we don't want anyone to know we are so fractionalized because be literally became the party of all special interests. I will fight for the rights of the MINORITY TYRANNY. After all the majority of individuals just want us all to get sick and die from strange diesease that Repbulicans have been figthing against for years.
Oh, don't forget I too believe ex-cons that have violent felonies on their record should have the right to own guns. While Joe American should not own a gun and should not vote, the insensitive clod. After do we really want Joe American to defend himself or should BIG BROTHER save the day again!!
I will convert promise, and when I do can I be trained to be a seminar caller for a lot of these wicked conservative talk shows? I really would like to give them an earful, even though its lying to them, but meerly looking at the issue from a different angle!!
by oz_media
Your post really doesn't warrant a reply because you know as well as I do you are simply trying to piss me off as always. I understand why you have this insecudirt and need to be correct i everything you say and can only shrug a response really.
As for Canadian troops, we are still tied up in Afghanistan from the lasy mess. As Canada doesn't have the numbers of expendable troops the Us seems to, it is no wonder we have stayed away from being involved in another conflict and therefore spreading our already minimal troops in Aghanistan even thinner than they already are and placing our existing efforts in further danger of failure.
Every time someone generalizes your thoughts, feelings or statements (or those of your mentor WB) you o into a detailed description of the exact wording you used as if in an attempt to discount the generalization.
I didn't say you weren't for charity, but it is VERY clear no matter how intricately you word it,you are strongly against 'government' handouts, you know as well as I do that these handouts are taken directly from your pocket and you are pissed that YOU can't control your mone yand are forced to support a government that does. Welcome to Earth. If it sucks so bad, we'll slow it so you can jump or you can quite and collect the handouts yourself if it is such a great and free way to live off of those who work.
I dare say that you wouldn't be imoressed with the pittance the government takes from rich people to help you and would soon be looking for more too.
I have never said this wasn't a coalition effort. The UK soldiers were there at the same tim eyou were. Others HAD to follow in the name of humanity, your own soldiers are incapable and untrained for policing, they do not have as much experiencein humanitarian efforts. Of course others will be needed for specialized work.
YOU made the decision to invade, YOUR president wouldn't wait for support. THAT is what I have always contested, not the need or he end result.
Stop trying to constantly twist people's words in order to create conflict so you can showboat your countless hours of time wasted following US politics from a US perspective. All you do is force me to reinforce my original points and aruments by constantly saying what I impled although I never said or impled such things to begin with, it's YOUR comprehension issue, get help or move on. This same issue efects your ability to see a generalization of your expressed thoughts that mirrors your exact quotes.
Perhaps this is why you love Bush so much, you constantly pick apart his sentences without seeing what is being implied.
Your like a living Speak-and-Spell, 'LACHINE. SPELL, LACHINE" Now you would spell it 'Lachine' and contest that is said L-achine not M-achine.
As for your troops statement, I supose you are trying to say that I DO see your troops as weak or ineffective. Perhaps you should talk to others here and have them explain that I have supported your troops, not the idiot who jumped the gun and sent them to die.
As for buying GI's meals, I will buy anyone a meal that is hungry. I don't 'selectively' choose people to reward with kindness, it just needs to be spread when possible. Yes it does feel nice to help people, I learned that the first time I helped someone at a very young age, nice to see you have reached this observation too.
So regarding your comments as a whole, you have simply repreated yourself once again while TRYING to take another's comments out of context, twist words and make yourself look righteous. Why don't you go kill a bunny or a kitty or something and get your little superiority boost from someone else. Your starting to look very pathetic and insecure, your points are so redundant that all I can say is "No Sh*T Sherlock, is that really how you feel? Who'd have guessed?."
by oz_media
Yes that was a much better explanation and one I can pretty much agree with entirely.
You mention tha companies that hire these immigrants should be held accountable and I couldn't agree more, supply and demand.
To segue a little, I have often voiced my hate for WalMart and the way that they do business by exploiting third world workers to obtain the lowest market price and highest margins but I won't go into details here.
This same policy of penalising a company for hiring an illegal immigrant should be applied to exploitation as well,well it sorta is but rarely enforced as it is easily masked by the local community gains as well as many other 'thwating' legal loopholes.
So I guess we do aree after all, I respect your humbleness and personal observation and cannot say that I am not guilty of the same as many others are too. It is the ability to recognize and work with our own faults that makes us improve as a society though one day everyone will be aware of themselves and their weaknesses and perhaps that will be the day we finally see true peace in the world. Oh, my alarm's going off, time to wake up.
by oz_media
Max you failed to answer yet another question that you couldn't actually answer and segued into your Clinton statement and a pot shot at the previous poster.
Well, I just want to ask why you are trying to be such a bitch in this thread?
If I go down the list you have been a bicth to everyone here including myself. When cornered you simply flame the previous posters integrity to discount their claims, very common characteristic you show here that is getting so annoying to read.
If you are having a tough week month or whatever, take a break or something. You show yourself to be polite sometimes and then come to bitching at everyone for their coments and discounting their intgrity.
for a while things were pleasant again, even political and relifious discussions were okay again, but now it has reverted to this defensive crap alinging.
Now it hasn't all been YOU as everyone here including myself has had a little paddy (excluding maecuff and Chas of course who are just naturally cool).
"Let's agree to Disagree"
It's not supposed to be a cop-out as much as a way to cease a dead end argument.
Count to five or have a glass of water or something.
by oz_media
Well that typos works two ways.
Did I men Crap 'aligning' or crap slinging?
I'm not telling.
by oz_media
Well I'll just stand well behind you on this one, or curl up in the fetal position, you mentioned BFC! uh, oh. :-P
Yeah he's pretty radical, pretty sensible too. I certainly wouldn't fear him.
by maecuff
by oz_media
Do you feel better now ?
I've agreed with your views since you started posting here pretty much . We share common religious and political views in many ways.
The BFC issue has not feared well on TR, too many Americans discount Michael Moore as a hard left liar. Which I suppose is the easiets way to discount anyone hard left if you are not yourself.
Unfortunately such a biased viewpoint offers no ability to evaluate both sides of an issue or hear some of the reality behind it.
I know there were a couple of instances where BFC was said to have stretched the truth, an example would be Charlton Heston's lawyers saying he was not of a sane mind when he was interviewed, that he wasn't prepared to answersuch questions etc.
Why would you have to be prepared to answer a question unless you intended to carefully word an answer to discount an accusation?
I think he has covered some really positive ground in having WalFart remove ammo from the shelves, he has spread a message that even though many will say it is all lies, hopefully some of today's children and tomorrow's leaders will see another side to things and seek a different resolution to protection other than hasty or senseless violence.
Have you ever heard any of Roger Waters solo albums since he parted from Pink Floyd? If not, find Radio Chaos, it is a really cool album and speaks volumes as all PF albums always have.
For any younger members who happen to be reading, an album is an old version of today's CD format. It consisted of a series of bumps etched into a vinyl disk to cause vibrations as a needle pased over them while trackng in a groove.
by jardinier
Thanks firstly for making me feel better with your duplicate posting, which suggests that the problem is at the TR end, and not in my computer.
Sometime this year, Australians will have to choose between John Howard and Mark Latham as their Prime Minister.
Much as I personally dislike Howard (mainly in relation to his domestic policies) I will give him credit where it is due.
With his Goods and Services Tax he has produced a surplus budget for the country.
He is a decisive leader, sharing the same positive quality attributed to George Bush in this discussion, of following through with any decision he makes.
As I mentioned in one of my little digressions in another discussion, I know through my personal contact with him that Latham is a man of integrity and vision.
Currently the polls (which are of course for the entertainment of readers, and prove nothing) show Howard as the preferred Prime Minister, but Labor as most likely to win the election.
So we have to choose between a strong leader and seasoned politician aged 64 (Howard has held various cabinet positions since 1975 (then aged 36) as well as being leader of the Liberal/National Coalition in Opposition) and has been Prime Minister since 1996). Latham is a newcomer to the scene but with age on his side (he is 42) it would seem certain that if he does not become Prime Minister at this election, he will inevitably do so in the future.
So yes, I am glad that I am Australian because we have the choice of two viable leaders.
by maecuff
I don't know about you guys. I'm really just listening to the words of Michael Moore and Ann Coulter..the package the words come in doesn't really matter to me.
Unless it is Johnny Depp.. then it matters.
by oz_media
Wen I was younger I worked on a few Jump Street episodes as they filmed in local schools arounf my neighbourhood.
At one cast party, Johnny Depp was all pissed that he couldn't get released from his contract and the writers were making him into a baby faced girl toy, when he wanted to be a tough guy.
We were ALL playing volleyball and Depp threw a fit, took the ball and went home.
He then took on the nickname locally as Johnny Dipsh*t, good thing he grew up and finally learned how to act, I actually like him as an actor now as he takes on challenging and very different roles, much like Dreyfus and Hoffman did.
Now Keanu, the monosyllabic moron is another wannabe Depp story!
by maecuff
.
Anyone who thinks that Michael Moore is not extremely biased and slants his words and pictures, is really uninformed. Some of his "suggestions", and I use that word lightly, are downright false. Now before you accuse me of just attacking the person because I disagree with him, let me give you an example.
http://www.bowlingfortruth.com/bowlingforcolumbine/scenes/lockheedmartin.htm
another:
http://www.bowlingfortruth.com/bowlingforcolumbine/scenes/blindshooter.htm
Here, look at all of them.
http://www.bowlingfortruth.com/
Also, he's a critic of corporate outsourcing, but his very own Web site was outsourced to a company in Canada.
I could go on, but I won't change any minds anyway, so what's the point?
by oz_media
I think that the person who wrote the site out has some valid points but is just as guilty of playing on words or focusiing on the wrong point as Michael Moore is, just like our media coveregae of the war. Extremes that are colored to both sides.
Michael Moore's objective in this show was to show some facts about gun ownership and history in the US and then raise some questions, which he does quite well.
Take what you want from it, but I don't feel you can discount Michael Moore as an individual or a voice just because of colored truth.
THe bank for instance is quickly discounted as not howing the ful process. Even with the FBI calls and bbackground checks, what is a bank doing using guns as a sales incentive? How is that a relevant offering that compliments the banks services?
by jacko4
Hello
Im not carrying on this argument its a lose,lose situation,but it was george w who dodgede vietnam
by jardinier
You'd better look it up in the dictionary Max, because this is the only type of viewpoint of which you appear capable.
Perhaps you can explain why your blatantly subjective view has any more validity than my "objective" view?
Now you have read lots of postings about Australian politics in many discussions. Perhaps you would care to present an objective view of the Australian political scene ... without the help of your friend Google, that is. Are you actually capable of having an original opinion?
Actually I think your President would be considerably embarrassed if he knew the vitriolic comments that you throw around in his defence.
I have NEVER heard George Bush or anyone in the top echelon of the administration defend America with the kind of caustic comments on which you seem to depend.
So why don't you at least try and emulate the manners of your revered President?
by jardinier
You'd better look it up in the dictionary, Max, because it appears to be the only kind of viewpoint of which you are capable.
You might like to explain why your "subjective" viewpoint is more valid than my "objective" viewpoint.
As there has been considerable input about Australian politics in many discussions, perhaps you would care to make an objective comment on the political scene in Australia -- without of course the aid of you friend Mr Google. In fact, have you ever had an original thought?
Actually I think your President would be embarrassed if he knew the type of vitriolic comments you throw around in his defence.
I have never heard George Bush, or any of the top echelon of the administration, resort to the caustic comments which are your trademark. As I observe him on TV he is always positive, cheerful, optimistic and shrugs aside any criticism with ease.
Perhaps the very least you could do would be to try and emulate the manners of your revered President.
by jardinier
You'd better look it up in the dictionary, Max, because it appears to be the only kind of viewpoint of which you are capable.
You might like to explain why your "subjective" viewpoint is more valid than my "objective" viewpoint.
As there has been considerable input about Australian politics in many discussions, perhaps you would care to make an objective comment on the political scene in Australia -- without of course the aid of you friend Mr Google. In fact, have you ever had an original thought?
Actually I think your President would be embarrassed if he knew the type of vitriolic comments you throw around in his defence.
I have never heard George Bush, or any of the top echelon of the administration, resort to the caustic comments which are your trademark. As I observe him on TV he is always positive, cheerful, optimistic and shrugs aside any criticism with ease.
Perhaps the very least you could do would be to try and emulate the manners of your revered President.
by maecuff
.
When you ask a question based on a false premise, it's easy to simply dismiss as nonsense. Besides, we've covered that kind of thing before, and going through it again won't change anyone's mind. Moreover, you are, in a way, attacking me, as well as GWB, with your presumptions and tone. However, I'll play along.
False premise number one: George W. Bush is my hero.
I never said GWB is my hero, and you don't know how I would even define a hero. No, he's not my "hero". Actually, I consider him someone who works for me. I "hired" him, so to speak, to act on my behalf, to make decisions that might be in my best interest, and to uphold the oath he took when he agreed to accept my vote. So no, George W. Bush is not my "hero", but I do believe he's doing an outstanding job acting on my behalf.
Has he been perfect? No, he hasn't. He's made some missteps; he's supported some legislation that I would prefer not to have passed; and he's said some things that I may have said differently. But on balance, I'm quite happy with my choice of employee, er, I mean president. And just like any employee, when you hire someone to do a job, the job performance must be judged on balance, and the employer needs to place some trust in them, and get out of their way and let them do their job. In this particular position, we have a job review every four years, and we'll let him know what kind of job he's doing.
False premise number two: George W. Bush was a draft dodger.
You know as well as I do that GWB was not a draft dodger, and you're either being disingenuous or simply trying to be cute. But being from England, you may not understand how we structure our military, and you may not understand the vital role our reserve forces play in the overall scheme of maintaining our standing military.
During the Vietnam era, I served in the active duty Air Force, one of my brothers served in the active duty Marine Corps, and another one of my brothers served in the Air National Guard. President Bush also served in the Air National guard. There's no dishonor in that, and it's certainly not "draft-dodging". To the contrary, it's supporting the military; it's supporting the military system; and it's actually the foundation on which our military was initially conceived. To consider our reserve forces anything less, much less criticize them, is doing them a grave disservice and is a slap in the face to the reserve forces that were called up to serve in Afghanistan and Iraq; and it's an insult to the families of the tens-of-thousands of reserve forces who were called into active duty, and the thousands who died in Vietnam. Yes, thousands of reserve soldiers died in Vietnam, including some from various Air National Guard units.
Here's how one person put it.
"I am saddened by the fact that Vietnam has yet again been inserted into the campaign, and that it has been inserted in what I feel to be the worst possible way.....The race for the White House should be about leadership, and leadership requires that one help heal the wounds of Vietnam, not reopen them; that one help identify the positive things that we learned about ourselves and about our nation, not play to the divisions and differences of that crucible of our generation.....We do not need to divide America over who served and how. I have personally always believed that many served in many different ways. Someone who was deeply against the war in 1969 or 1970 may well have served their country with equal passion and patriotism by opposing the war as by fighting in it."
"Are we now, 20 years or 30 years later, to forget the difficulties of that time, of families that were literally torn apart, of brothers who ceased to talk to brothers, of fathers who disowned their sons, of people who felt compelled to leave the country and forget their own future and turn against the will of their own aspirations? Are we now going to create a new scarlet letter in the context of Vietnam? But while those who served are owed special recognition, that recognition should not come at the expense of others; nor does it require that others be victimized or criticized or said to have settled for a lesser standard. To divide our....country over this issue today.....simply does not do justice to what all of us went through during that tragic and turbulent time."
"To all those currently pursuing the presidency in both parties, I would plead that they simply look at America. We are a nation crying out for leadership, for someone who will bring us together and raise our sights. We are a nation looking for someone who will lift our spirits and give us confidence........We do not need more division. We certainly do not need something as complex and emotional as Vietnam reduced to simple campaign rhetoric.......I hope and pray we will put it behind us and go forward in a constructive spirit for the good of our......country."
- John F. Kerry, Senator, 1992, Defending Bill Clinton, the actual draft-dodger
The disingenuousness and hypocrisy is enough to make a person want to throw-up.
I hope I answered your question.
.
I suppose you're right, I do tend to be a bit more, shall we say, blunt in my ramblings or writings, or whatever it may be. Would President Bush be the same way, you ask? Absolutely not. He's too much of a seasoned politician, and he's a much better leader than I could ever hope to be. I couldn't get elected to anything. If someone asked, for example, what will you do for me in exchange for my vote? I'd say not a damn thing. Get off your duff and take personal responsibility and stop expecting your elected officials to guarantee equality of outcome. If I had to say one thing that I'd do, it would be to get the government of your way so you can have life, liberty and pursue happiness, however that person may define it. No, I'd never be elected.
But that is primarily in the context of domestic issues. In the arena of foreign policy, I don't know any more about "the real story" than I read in the paper. Sure, a person can try to remain informed, as I try to be. Absolutely, a person can try to become educated in such matters, as I try to be. But I don't meet foreign leaders. I don't know what goes on behind the closed doors of foreign embassies. I'm not privy to intelligence information. And in the case of current circumstances, I trust President Bush and Secretary of State Powell to act on my behalf, and to make decisions that I am not qualified to make, and to do what they deem necessary to defend our Constitution " against all enemies, foreign and domestic". (And please don't twist that into something that was not intended.) You and I are no different, I might suspect, as to our access to "inside information" in regards to foreign policy.
On Australian politics, I'll have to plead ignorance. Who would I support? Whichever person and/or party that believes in smaller government, less taxes, taking personal responsibility, individualism instead of collectivism, maintaining a strong national defense, and one who puts the interest of my country before the interests of another (or the collective and inept United Nations). That pretty much sums it up. If I was pretty sure that his or her core principles were in line with mine, as described above, even if I would happen to not personally like that person for whatever reason, that's who I would support.
In your current election, who would that be? I really don't know. Perhaps you can tell me.
.
Whatever you think may be the case with you or me, or anyone else, for that matter, building one's opinions based on a core set of principles can be the most telling. Believing in individualism instead of collectivism, for example, most generally puts me in support of the conservative (Republican) side, instead of the liberal (Democrat) side of an issue. Does that mean I'm biased, or does that mean that I'm true to my principles? Does that mean I can't be objective? Everything I do, and anything I support will fall in line with those core set of values - those principles - and I'll just let the chips fall where they may. (I've touched on what those are in a couple of other messages, so I won't repeat them.)
Whether we're looking at Michael Moore, Ann Coulter, you or me, or whomever, it's very telling to know where they're coming from. Ann Coulter, for example, is as far to the right as Michael Moore is to the left. The difference, however, is that Coulter will admit it, while Moore dances around it. The same can be said for anyone.
What are your core set of values, your principles? Be specific, but be brief, and we can all reveal our own "biases". Admitted biases are good, but being evasive is not. And being true to your principles does not mean that you can't be objective. Or does it?
by oz_media
Judgin by previous posts about music and your political beliefs I figured you would either have it or heard it. I managed to get a prerelease when we met after a show he did during Vancouver's World Expo '86 (I did some local promo for his promo company).
THe concert itself was so cool, taking on the Radio Chaos theme of a young crippled buy manipulating the airwaves and airing a fake neuclear attck over the radio. He was on a plain stage with his band and a DJ Booth on one side and a huge teletype style board above him. They place a phone booth at the back of the audience and had a liave call session. Where you could phone the onstage DJ and request a Floyd song that Waters and his band would then play on the stage. The call would be teletyped onto a long banner board above the stage while you spoke with the DJ, it was so cool.
OM
by jacko4
by oz_media
Well there's no way that pulling out early would be a solution. You can't simply walk away at this point.
Pulling out early always leaves a mess to be cleaned up, usually not by the one who initiated it.
With so many countries citizens in danger while still helping with the policing and providing aid to the starving and deperate in Afghanistan, (and that was somewhat successful as far as war goes I guess)can you imagine how many years of death and destruction such humanitarian efforts would face if left to finish up in Iraq?
The fighting isn't over yet and won't be for some time. Hopefully the day will come where the numbers of troops needed will be fewer but at this point there is still an increasing demand for more troops and support from all those involved, which has now become a large allied force.
by oz_media
No need to become the next 'wacko jacko'.
We need to censor our comments here somewhat, thus all the evasive baiting instead of simply airing your trye feelings.
Like I said last week.
"Fruitless effort
If you showed proof in any form to support your beliefs, you will find the respondent will either:
A) Discount your sources
B) Play on words
C) Flame your own integrity if nothing can be contested
You are being baited and there's no end to it. "
.
It was approaching six in the morning on what was to be a warm summer day in late June of 1971, at a small and isolated radar installation somewhere in the Southeastern United States, when a young Airman, who couldn't have been more than twenty years old, approaching the end of an all-night shift, rubbed the tired out of her eyes to get a clearer look at the two faint blips that suddenly appeared on the radar screen she was monitoring.
These weren't the bright and distinct blips that would indicate a passenger airliner sending its transponder signal to an air traffic controller, but rather ones that were barley visible, ones caused by the radar signal being bounced back off of an object flying high over the Atlantic Ocean. Some quick calculations, for which the Airman had been well trained to perform, indicated that these two aircraft, or perhaps more, if they were flying in tight formation, were on a course that would take them directly over Charleston, South Carolina. And based on the aircraft speed, which the Airman calculated by determining the time it took to travel a given distance, it was estimated that these aircraft would enter United States airspace in thirty minutes, and be over Charleston in forty-five.
The Airman, per standard operating procedures, called to her commanding officer who was sitting across the room reading a book to pass the time. He was a First Lieutenant, not really that much older than the Airman he was commanding, who was actually studying the regulation manuals to prepare for his upcoming promotions test, his first shot at making Captain. He'd much rather have the two silver bars on his shoulders than the single one, but at least his was silver, and not the gold of the lower ranking Second Lieutenant. "Unknown aircraft, sir, bearing two-seven-zero degrees, heading southwest at a speed of six hundred knots". The Lieutenant quickly put down his book and looked over the shoulder of the Airman to verify what he had just heard. A quick look up to the flight board, the one that was constantly being updated by another Airman writing backwards from behind a large Plexiglas board indicating weather conditions and all FAA flight plans that had been filed for their particular monitoring area, revealed that no flights were scheduled for that location. The Lieutenant immediately called the regional FAA center, by using the "hot line" that was established to the facility, to verify that a passenger aircraft was not off-course, or perhaps experiencing some transponder malfunctions. "Yea, we see it, Lieutenant, but we don't know who it is", answered the seasoned controller.
Twenty nine minutes until the aircraft would be over American airspace. "Keep me updated every two minutes", the Lieutenant instructed the Airman as he picked up the other phone, the red phone that simultaneously sounded an alarm in both a ready room and the control tower at a regional Air Force base, as well as at NORAD, the North American Air Defense Command, which was located deep inside Cheyenne Mountain just west of Colorado Springs. NORAD would be monitoring the incident from this point on, and would be ready to assume full command of the situation should circumstances warrant such control. But for now, the identification of the incoming aircraft was in the hands of the young First Lieutenant, who just sat down in front of his own radar screen as he put on his headsets, and the two Air National Guard pilots who had just heard the horn blow - the horn indicating that they had just two minutes to get their F-102 Delta Dagger fighter aircraft into the air - and who would soon be following an intercept course as laid out by an Air Force officer yet to make the rank of Captain.
The F-102 was not the newest fighter in the Guard, but it was a good one. They weren't as fast and agile as their active duty counterparts, the F-4s, and they didn't have the weapons capacity of the F-4, but they were certainly up to the job. Most of the Air Force's F-4s were stationed in Southeast Asia, and the guard always had the "hand-me-downs". And this hard-to-fly fighter jet, affectionately called The Deuce, America's first delta-winged, all-weather interceptor, was the hand-me-down of the day.
The F-102 ground crews, who had been engaged in a friendly game of pinochle, upon hearing the alarm, ran out of their own ready room, which was really no more than a 15 foot by 15 foot shack just off the runway, to quickly get the two aircraft ready to scramble. Two fighter aircraft were always parked at the end of the runway, ready to take off at a moment's notice and be available in cases just as this. While one crew assisted the pilots with starting the single jet engine, removing the parking blocks, and helping the pilots get strapped in, the weapons crew pulled the safety pins from the pre-loaded weapons, a mixture of AIM-4 Falcon missiles on extendable launch rails, which would drop down when the weapons bay doors were opened, and two dozen 2.75 inch unguided rockets carried in pairs of tubes located in the bay doors.
Two minutes exactly, and the orange glow of the after-burner shined brightly in the dawn sky, quickly disappearing as the pair of Delta Daggers, piloted by men of the Air National Guard, roared out of sight.
To be continued (maybe)........
.
I didn't read all of it (there's much too much rhetoric to read it all), but this site did suggest that allied bombing of Germany was tantamount to allied war crimes. I suppose that may tell you where they're coming from.
But you didn't answer my question. I asked which one of the statements that were posted to begin this discussion were not true? Neither you or that Web site (or anyone else) has done that.
by cactus pete
I was just throwing in a contribution. I'll go back and see if I even recognize the statements. If they came from that woman - I probably never heard them. I see her, I turn the channel.
She's ugly in so many ways to me.
by maecuff
First a suggestion. You may want to change your profile name from your email to something else. Of course if you want people emailing you. I got this suggestion earlier and I thought it was a good idea.
Next, what we in America are facing is the 'lesser of two evils' scenario. I do like Bush because of many of his policies, and I'll admit bias in my decision. Kerry, on the other hand, has a suspicious voting record during his time in the U.S. Senate. He is for one thing, but against it in the next week. What I find in the Democratic contender for our Presidental elections is a seemingly waivering stance on hard issues in the face of opposition. Let's face it people respect leaders that stick to their principles whether or not they agree with the solutions. For me this defines the leader I would support.
I am pretty sure you would agree with the philosophy. I understand there are times when a leader must change his mind. All I would ask of a leader is that he provides a rationale for the decision. I may agree. I may disagree. As long as the decsion was based on some sound rationale.
The thing is that one of the 'lesser evils' has exhibited great conviction in the face of criticisim. The other seems to waffle or chooses not to take a stand and make a decision. What one would be the more appealing candidate, putting aside petty politics?
I see where you are coming from and being from one end of the spectrum (and trying not to fall off the deep end), govenrment must maintain a balance to ensure the rights of all people are not infringed upon. I would ask my fellows across the isle for constructive criticism, but I get vitriolic personal bashing.
It is all in the best for one's country. Bitter setiment leads to personal attacks. This is what I reflected on this weekend. We have gotten off the topic of discussing the merits and flaws of issues, and how leaders make decisions. There needs to be a refocus.
Today there are those who are of the same mind and opinion those who despised Clinton when he was President. I didn't like the guy's character, leadership, moral principles, and most of all policies. I do not dislike the man, just his opinions. There were those who despised him regardless in the American Republican Party. Likewise, there are those in the Democrat party who are exhibiting the same behavior. All of this must come to an end in order to defend the interests of the country of the whole and promote progress.
by cactus pete
by onbliss
...the weekend. As somebody said such discussions were water-cooler discussions...you guys must have been working during the weekend. That is sad. Me did not have to...HA ha he he....LOL...
In case you were telecommuting or stayed home, you still came here for spirited discussions. I commend your enthusiasm. Hope you got time to spend with family and other interests :-))
cheers ...and keep smiling....
by oz_media
Staying home is work for me. I managed to get a midday paddle in and a barbeque or two though.
If I sit at home and push a few updates over the weekend, visiting TR hardly means I'm working. While haveing a cold beer and waiting for updates to push down the pipe to a client network isn't REALLY work thoughis it?
I could be driving the kids to practoce, following the wife's chore list or running around on errands. If I CHOOSE to get some work done, it isn't work. Work is only when you're doingsomething you wouldn't normally choose to do I think.
So hee hee, ha ha ha!! You're at work now, I'm still at home with a cold beer.
by onbliss
....looks like you get paid for enjoying life. Muuuuuummmmmmyyyyy :-(((( that is not fair......
Can we trade? Wait a minute...my life is not bad either. I will keep mine and you keep yours...
keep smiling :-)))))))))
by mrbill-
****SARCASIM ALERT****
Is it any wonder we hate you? Getting to work from home while most, not all, have to trudge into work and spend the day with other people and socialize with folks who you only have work in comman with. `:[
Drink a brew for me ok!
****SARCASIM ALERT ENDS****
You may now resume your regularly scheduled rants and flames. Hey, Rants and Flames would be a great name for a Rock group (thanks Dave Barry)........
by jamesrl
Thanks for insulting an entire nation.
We see it differently.
If the UN had been able to come to an agreement to go in, we'd be there. Despite the fact we are already in Afghanistan(do you want us to go home), Kosovo, Bosnia, Cyprus and other places.
Our navy lead the patrols in the gulf to intercept weapons and people smuggling. We came back to Afghanistan, even though we were really stretched, and had 4 of our men killed by a US pilot. We contributed to the Haiti mission, even though we were stretched.
We tried hard to bring the UN to an agreement - one that would satisfy both the US, France and Germany. The US rebuffed our efforts, killing any chance of an agreement(which by the way would have resulted in an invasion by the end of May anyway).
And Canada is contributing funds to the rebuilding effort.
We continue to co-operate on border security. We just committed billions to improve our ability to patrol our ocean borders. We work together on NORAD and are starting work together on missle defense.
The US disagreed with us on WWI, WWII, Bosnia(we were there in the peace making stage, the US refused to get involved until an agreement between the parties was signed)and Rwanda(where the US used its veto power on security council to kill our proposal to intervene, even though we had troops on the ground).
Perhaps you should ask the General of the 101st Airbone in Afghanistan who paid high tribute to the Canadian contribution if he thought the Canadians were cowards. Perhaps you should understand that by increasing our committment in Afghanistan last year, we freed up US troops who went to Iraq.
James Linn
.
...that my message would be read by others, it was really intended for only one person, a person, as you well know, that has made it almost a sport, and perhaps his personal mission, to insult an entire nation - my nation - in hundreds of messages, including the one to which I replied.
If you keep my comment in that context, the "tit-for-tat" context of a discussion with that one person, and especially if it's kept in the context of considering the hundreds of insults on my nation that I've had to endure at the hands of this one person, then perhaps you'll understand.
But I must say, if you really cared about such things, perhaps you should have been trying to prevent your fellow countryman from lobbing the hundreds of "insults" our way instead of just the one and only time I lobbed one your way.
I offer that, not as an excuse, but as an explanation. No insult was intended. I apologize.
by oz_media
Ok Max, you've upset everyone else but apparently you were replying to MY post?
"...that has made it almost a sport, and perhaps his personal mission, to insult an entire nation - my nation - in hundreds of messages, including the one to which I replied."
Could you show me where in that post that I insulted an entire nation? You did say it was including the one to which you replied, which from what I see was my post titled. "OK Max"
I have read it several times before posting this message and don't see ANYWHERE where I have "insulted an entire nation".
IN fact I offered a very open response to your previous post to clarify that even though YOU see this as a US effort and everyone else is running away, the truth is it is an ALLIED effort as it should have been from the beginning. Not a US effort, you just invaded the front door while England invaded the back door. How is THAT an US effort and now that over 30 other countris have joined the Liberation attempt, how is that a US effort? I also explained very carefully that my post wasn't to defame your troops or the brave men and women who serve your country.
Where in the last post did I "insult an entire nation?"
by sullyman
by oz_media
Not to nitpick but just to clarify.
The issue with using an email address as an alias only really becomes a rpoblem if the website is bot crawled and addresses gathered for spam reasons.
Julian actually has a couple of websites where he posts comment from these discussions as well as thought from many friends and members of TR. THe use of an email adderss is his way of providing as link for people to forward such information to, as many of TR's members are also conributors to his various websites.
The issue of gettnig peer mail is not a problem, they used to have a contact link for you to send a peer an email without knowing the recipients actual address. Well this, as with most of the useful portions of TR, has been screwed up and is no longer working, so many people will offer an email address for peer correspondence.
I just wouldn't use my primary domain's email and open myself up to the junk. but ozmedia@excite.com, who cares?
by jardinier
I find it a very poor show when a website for computer professionals cannot produce a professional website.
I happen to know that a certain TR member creates top-class websites, and I have suggested that he offer his serives to TR, with payment of, say, 100,000 tech points.
by cactus pete
by sullyman
I see that even after a six month hiatus from this board that you are still marching to the same tune. The war in Iraq has opened a whole can of worms that the US in now realizing they can?t close alone. Its mind boggling to me how a president who was so quick to shun the UN is desperately seeking its help to clean up the mess it has created in Iraq. The unfortunate and sad part is that lives are being lost on a daily basis, because of an unprovable reason for invasion. You say that Canadians are either cowards or simply willing to sit by and watch as thousands of people die by the hands of world wide terrorists. You Mister Maxwell are very uninformed, and I cannot believe that you are so close-minded that you do not know the impact Canadians and other non-coalition countries are having on the international fight on terrorism. The fight on terrorism does not only have the vested interest of the bought and paid for allies of the red,white and blue. Before you blanket TR with your anti-non American rants, inform yourself about what happens outside of your borders??
It's good to be back!!
.
...that I posted for Mr. Linn.
You know, a big problem with these messages is that one person, such as myself, might make some off-the-cuff comment, but in the context of, and considering the hundreds of other messages I've made. Then someone, such as yourself, might only read that one and only comment, not considering everything that has been said over time, and draw in incorrect conclusion. (And then there are the ones who "conveniently" forget what was written in the past.)
It's kinda' like reading one paragraph out of a 600 page book and forming an opinion on the content and/or author, based only on that one paragraph. It's not very telling.
Good to see you again, Sully.
by cactus pete
I'm just pointing out the other sides of things. You often do not include your personal beliefs when throwing out information - I think you can afford me the same luxury.
That bit of information was, in my opinion, important for people to know when considering the facts and drawing their conclusions.
It is easy to flood others with tons of information, but to argue your side of it within the bounds of context - why that's how you can change minds.
by oz_media
Yes sir, you have a life (a good reason to be thankful for anything) and you are enjoying it and the country where you live, I do as well.
Cheers and enjoy your day!
OM
.
"....people saying you are an arrogant and stuck up bunch"......
"Hanging on by the seat of your pants and hoping for the best is OK ".......
I'm insulted.
But leave it to you to AGAIN focus in on only one excerpt from one message.
Do you deny that you have insulted my nation - EVER and often?
by mlayton
...the invasion of Iraq has resulted in some good for the country. However the methodologies used to get there were not exactly diplomatic, nor did they accomplish the mission of moving Americans out of harms way. To that end, I make the following points:
-Declaring war on individuals has seldom resulted in a success story for America, look back through history even to the point of Castro, we either lose them or later they become allies
-Declaring war on individuals in the case of religious zealotry will not eliminate the problem. If the individual goes into hiding, they become a folk hero - if they are effectively eliminated, they become a martyr to the cause. It doesn't make sense, but what it does do is fuel the flames of anger and revenge even further. This doesn't make us any safer
-Violating a United Nations Charter that requires countries to exhaust all peaceful means of maintaining global security before taking military action, and permitting the use of force in self-defense only in response to actual or imminent attack puts this nation at risk. What are we going to do when someone violates that same charter against us? Try to prosecute through the UN?
-Sitting back afterwards and blaming issues in the economy on the war - what, like that couldn't have been predicted?
-Having no real plan for reconstruction that the entire country of Iraq could get behind until after the invasion - well, that's just poor planning.
And finally, let's not ignore that around the world, similar atrocities such as those Saddam inflicted on his people happen every day. We don't invade those countries, and we don't have large scale operations to protect those people involved. We chose Iraq to protect our fuel interests - at least, let's be up front about it.
by oz_media
Then perhaps my comments would be proven wrong.
YOU were the one who said "...including the one to which I replied."
Now if you were referring to previous comments then perhaps you could also provide the venemous and personal attcacks on my character, country of origin and country I now live in that you have felt so inclined to offer in the past too.
I don't bite unless barked at.
But as for the current, shall we say relevant, comments you are referring to;
"....people saying you are an arrogant and stuck up bunch"......
Now nobody will read this as a personal attack on the US even though you have stripped most of the context. So here it is in full.
"This is the exact attitude that has people saying you are an arrogant and stuck up bunch while at the same time you thumb your nose at the rest of the world for not aiding your efforts."
Now can you disect and take that out of context to show that I have "personal mission, to insult an entire nation - my nation"
I am speaking from experience, not personal feeling.
As for;
"Hanging on by the seat of your pants and hoping for the best is OK ".......
Now to put that back in its full perspective.
What I said was;
"Hanging on by the seat of your pants and hoping for the best is OK when you succeed, but what if you didn't? "
This is simply a figure of speech used to cause questioning of the worst case scenario. Again, this is not a slam on anyone or any country.
You say you took offense, then perhaps your little rude and uncalled for email to my personal account was written by someone other than yourself, which I may say was far more offensive and in full context, don't even go there unless you are ready to see both sides Maxwell.
You also missed the part where I really laid into your country and it's troops!
" I am not trying to defame your troops, nor am I saying that they are weak or ineffective. I think ANY soldier who goes to war when he is told to is a great citizens and brave defender of his country, just don't forget the rest like you have done before. "
You're no better in any way then your friend Michael Moore, you insist that he takes everything out of context and doesn't show the true intent behind his comments. Well neither do you Maxwell, in fact there are MANY posts where you show this same narrow minded approach in an attempt to defame the opponent.
Grow up, there are plenty of people over 7 years old here who can see right through such weak attempts at character degredation.
NO I do not deny I have never insulted Americans or the US GOvernment. I have also been on the receiving end to. It's called free speech, freedom of expression or freedom of the press.
I seem to not be so upset when you bash Canada or England. Others were not offended by my comments you had said were so offensive, what is it with you? Are you really that different than a human?
Next time, make some sense or at least have a leg to stand on.
by oz_media
I like it!
I am not really flaming anyone here though, just offering observations rather than personal feelings, unless you are Max of course.
Rants and Flames! Yup, it works doesn't it?
Sort by Trending