Discussion Locked

President Obama says chance for healthcare overhaul is slipping away

0 helpful
324 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

324 replies

by tonythetiger

[i]They use as much as they can, because they don't pay more than a small fraction of the actual cost.[/i]

They pay it, or the consumers do, however you choose to look at it, but businesses don't pay for anything!

by jdclyde

and neither showed any short comings of the private option. Ask any teacher and you will hear how they hate standardized testing (NCLB).

The advantage of the private over the public is the expectations on the kids is higher and the more you expect, the more you get.

In the public we hear about how school systems are getting away from having a class valedictorian because it makes the kids that don't achieve high grades feel bad. Awwww.

http://www.mlive.com/flintjournal/index.ssf/2008/04/no_more_valedictorians_in_lind.html

by delbertpgh

It seems obvious that if somebody is in the same insurance pool with you, you pay their expenses. And, since the insurance company can't go broke, they get by with either raising prices to you or denying expensive care to somebody else.

You, and others, have got this delusion that every problem in health insurance is caused by greedy union and government employees soaking up the benefits. Not everybody with a bargaining agreement has a rich insurance deal. The ones that do can't explain why one dollar in six of our national account goes to health care.

The heart of the problem is that nothing works well, it all costs too much money, and the present private insurance system only provides incentives to spend more.

Can't look my parents in the eye and deny them end-of-life care; mom died from a brain tumor this year, and dad from kidney failure, a complication of type 2 diabetes, 12 years ago.

But, here's a question you really should answer: when would you deny, based on cost, treatment that would give somebody one more month of life? At $2,000? $20,000? $200,000? $2,000,000? $200,000,000? Pretend you are in charge of the payment authority, whether it be an insurance company, or Medicare, or Medicaid, or some future government health expenditure guideline writing agency. Pretend you have a responsibility not only to the sick person asking for 200 million dollars, but also to every other customer of the insurance plan. If you're a government bureaucrat, pretend you have additional responsibility to the whole society; if an insurance bureaucrat, to your shareholders. Where does JD the Magnificent say no? Never?

By the way, most insurance policies have a lifetime cap of between $500k and $1 million, beyond which you have to resort to your own checkbook. So, the most expensive patients are already price-rationed to the graveyard, unless they have recourse to a whole lot of cash.

by delbertpgh

When companies pay for health insurance, it complicates their business plan. It's like a big payroll tax. They can raise prices to cover expenses only just so far before consumers will stop buying.

High health care costs, like high taxes, reduce the volume of business that can be done, or make the expected profits so much less compelling that entrepreneurs will find less justification for risking their money.

by oz_media

You managed to write one line in plain English, well done!

It's not a matter of what you give a flock about, it's a matter of your comment that quality health care will go down the chute, which is absolute horsecrap, as seen in similar systems in other nations.

You don't exactly have a health care system worth bragging about now, just drop your ego an inch and you'll realize that you could be better off. If you think what you have now works, why do you have a lower mortality rate and fewer people with coverage than other free nations? Uncontrollable costs and unaffordable premiums, but you should be sharp enough to see that yourself.

Tax increase, waaah. pshaw, cry me a river.

by oz_media

Obama's numbers, like the same daily ticker all US presidents face, a play by play scorecard means squat. Of course his numbers are down now, he's making changes and people in America fear government and fear change.

Your scoffing at what the world thinks, is exactly what got you sucked in to begin with, wake up for god's sake. To proud of your nation to see relity? You don't rememer the endless arguments about what a crock of s**t Bush was saying compared to the reality shown around the rest of the globe but selectively edited for US news networks? The debates over who was being censored and how Americans stated that other nations wer ejust showing the worst to make Bush lok bad? You lot will believe anhything it seems, unless common sense or logic is involed.

Bush had hit numers because he scared the crap out of Americans and pulled the wool over your eys for years, despite the rest of the world seeing more realistic, uncut views and calling his bluff. "We are right, we know what's going on, you don't know what it's like to be terrorized!" Sure.

And so far your war has resolved......? Right, squat again.

But bush managed to yank you all along and feel he was saving your lives, in essence he lied and scammed his way into approval, just as everyone around the world was saying for 8 years.

America was like a Bugs Bunny cartoon when he screws over Elmer Fudd and Fudd turns into a heel or a donkey. EEEEaaaawwwww .

As for lies...I said you took his words out of context and parroted them like Steele.

I said you sound like Steele, however his values are so different from your own.

You can make up whatever you like to think I said though, nothing new coming from the reading impaired.

by oz_media

Not the sharpest tool in the shed, are you?

MY desire to argue? Of course your baited post had no such intention of stirring controversy, not you, noooooo.

Who the hell are you to talk about expressing onesself in a logical fashion?

You took a typical one sided view in order ot generate comtroversy and hit it home with your selectively worded title.

I can't believe you think anyone can't see it, I'm not the first to point it out here either.

Now when others play your little game, you grab your bat and ball and run home to sulk.

by jdclyde

and having reasonable conversations with reasonable people. And then there are the posts from you.

by oz_media

This brand new concept that has never been given consideration in America before? This old horse has been eaten a thousand times with no resolve, its about time someone did something other than wade through
beaurocratic red tape for a change. He;s finally getting something done instead of cowering and playing lip service until election time.

People in America don't ssem to realize that this IS in the better interest of othrer nations too. The sooner your country is back on it's feet, the sooner you start paying fair prices for your imports, instead of playing the sick brother in need role and crying for lower prices on life.

by jdclyde

if what you are doing is not going to be a workable solution, but that is a little more thought into this than you are willing to invest.

Making sweeping changes, damn the price, will not improve our situation financially or medically and we end up with just one more government poorly run program heading for destruction.

by tonythetiger

to study the consequences of this specific legislation.

BTW, do the math. 2.1 trillion divided by 40 million uninsured. That comes to $52,500 per person per year. $4,375 per person per month.

How many people do you know who would require that much medical treatment in a month? I've personally only had about twice that in my entire life!

by av .

Getting a healthcare bill done before the August recess of Congress as Obama had planned is unrealistic. Maybe the end of this year is more like it. I admire Obama immensely for his focus on the hard problems and his sincerity.

I like "eaten a thousand times with no resolve" because that describes our healthcare dilemma in this country. The biggest consideration is how we will pay for it.

AV

by tig2

My disagreement with both the British and Canadian systems are more rooted in specifics than generalities. Those specifics pertain to roughly 10% of the population so I can't say how meaningful they are when the whole is considered.

It may well be that the Canadian model is the better of the options for us. I haven't really given it the thought it is due. I will.

by Member 25348569

US healthcare spending was $2 trillion in 2007. If you took that money - it's probably closer to $3 trillion by now - and just directed it properly, it would more than pay for what you need and, probably, what most of you all want as well.

:)

I do, however, see a few problems in "just" and lots of problems in "properly".

by tonythetiger

[i]High health care costs, like high taxes, reduce the volume of business that can be done, or make the expected profits so much less compelling that entrepreneurs will find less justification for risking their money. [/i]

... why business should get out of the business of offering health insurance. Give the employee the money instead.

by tonythetiger

(more like $3.5 by the time it gets going) is just for those who currently are not covered!

That's over $50,000 ($80,000 using the $3.5 trillion estimate) a year for each uninsured man, woman, and child in the country.

That is not affordable, by ANY country!

by jdclyde

well, actually, you rarely attempt to rationally defend what TheObama says or does. You just make excuses based upon others actions.

by delbertpgh

Giving the employer's health insurance contribution directly to the employee instead of to an insurance company will not result in extra money for the employee. The employer would simply reduce pay by a corresponding amount.

These guys aren't suckers, you know.

by tonythetiger

they're paying it anyway. But if you're concerned that employers would try to cheat, mandate it.

They won't have the administrative costs associated with it either. Somehow I don't think you'll get much resistance to companies reducing their costs.

by delbertpgh

Medicaid, Medicare, the VA, and Social Security meet national needs. If you didn't have these programs you'd have old people suffering poverty in increasing misery, and every illness would be a disaster. Same with disabled veterans. If you think an America without these safeguards would be humane or agreeable, then I admit we have irreconcilable differences about civilized life.

The biggest problem with Social Security is that so many people are retiring, we don't know how to pay for them all. The talk about 401k plans or private accounts being reforms that would make it possible to finance Social Security without pain is just so much moonshine. Look at it from a systems point of view: if you have people cashing in savings to pay for food and rent in their retirement, where does it come from? Out of the American economy, displacing the food and rent or other uses of money that currently working people would otherwise be enjoying. Very similar to what a payroll tax does. One difference: when it comes to disbursing money and paying costs of administration, Social Security is far more efficient than any mutual fund.

The biggest things in need of "reform" among your programs are Medicare and Medicaid, which pay health care costs for the old and poor. And guess what the problem is? Out of control health care costs, brought on by a private insurance system that drives up consumption and has no means of putting on the brakes.

by tonythetiger

At the time of Social Security's enactment, it it was to start paying at 65, but at the time, the average life expectancy was 62.

by delbertpgh

People used to conveniently die and stop drawing Social Security after a couple of years, if they even survived to get on it at all. I think the average person spends close to 15 years on Social Security these days.

A lot more retire early than actually plan to. More than half of the people who retire before 65, I read somewhere, do so because health problems tripped them up and forced them to stop working.

I won't be eligible for "full" benefits until I'm 66; my wife, not until 67. The benefit payment keeps rising with every year that you continue to work, though, even past your full benefit year.

by jdclyde

set EVERY wage at $60 an hour.

That way no one will feel left out that someone is better than they are at something.

It will solve every problem in the world, minimum wage, if you are dumb.

I personally don't care that someone doesn't make a "living wage" working at burgerworld as a cashier or pulling fries.

by delbertpgh

Apart from being young and strong, and being less likely to need expensive medical care, you knew that if you got smashed up somehow, your society wouldn't let you die just because you'd chosen to skip paying.

It's unlikely that money you banked instead of paying premiums would have been sufficient to cover anything beyond office visits. I remember in 1987, when my daughter broke her femur and was in traction for three weeks, the bill was $20,000. I was stunned that a broken leg could cost more than half my annual pay, but luckily I was insured then. It would probably be $60 or $100k today. Actually, when we had the daughter in 1977 we were uninsured. Then, the doctor was only $300, and the hospital $1100. I scraped together money from odd jobs and sold two guns and paid it.

Most Americans today don't believe in socialized medicine, but don't believe in letting uninsured people suffer or die from inattention, either. That means that most of the country, at some level, believes health care is a right.

by tonythetiger

my stepson (can't be on my insurance) broke his ankle last spring and the total cash cost was only $1,700. Of course, that was at Urgent Care rather than the ER.

Many health professionals give a discount for cash. My doctor charges $45 for an office visit without insurance, $115 with. There was one not far from here just retired, but offered visit, prescription, and even x-ray, all for $25! He refused to accept insurance.

There are problems in the system (most of them CAUSED by government), but it's not as dire as the alarmists make it out to be.

by oz_media

That Canada's system is VASTLY different from the UK's heathlcare system, in fact our system is probably closer to your own, with the exception of premiums and insurer's.

by oz_media

But are you not using a computer and have access to Google? I know you are not interested, which is amusing as you both share similar views on this issue and he is just as adamantly opposed to The Obama as you are. You never know, you could have been drinking buddies!

by oz_media

YOu start a purposely inflammtory thread, by takign yuor presidents words out of context and raising questions that wer clearly answered in his speech. Then get all poopy pants when someone calls yuo on your game.

Reasonable people? You mean those who agree with you. You aren't clever, you aren't 'above me' you are just another Yankee peon who thinks his s**t don't stink and the rest of the world who opposes his views are all wrong. Narcissistic putz/textbook American, comes to mind.

by oz_media

You? You haven't been privvy to his plans and ideas all along? Does he owe it to you to let you sit and ponder/qualify his every move ? What makes you think this hasn't been a focus from day one of his campaing, I fnot before. Perhaps all he needed to see was a revision of actual stats and numbers unavailable to him until in office.

Do you really think he just took office, had an idea and is now throwing it into unplanned action?

Yuo throw out all of these baseless arguments as if yuo know what he is doing, thinking and working on.

What do yuo base such opinions on other than your own personal bias towards him?

And you call that reasonable discussion? Get real. It's only reasonable if people agree with you, if not you will make up whatever you need to to instill yoru own views in a pathetic attempt to show you are right and they are wrong, as if you have even the foggiest clue to begin with.

by oz_media

try it again with some real numbers, your simplistic math doesn't cut it.

Even then your numbers are wrong, in 2005 there were over 46.6 million Americans uninsured, which is an increase of mroe than 15% that year, even higher than the previous years increase of 14%. So with an increase of uninsured Americans of 15+% when there was a greater empolyment rate that number will escalate again, realistically you are looking at about 16-17% ANNUAl increase today. Which puts you at over 50 Million, more than teh entire population of Canada is uninsured, unale to afford insurance in teh USA. You have an increase of approxinamtely 330,000 additional CHILDREN each year that are uninsured, and yet you feel confident that your system is effective and doesn't require fast action to turn it around, nice ot see it works for you as an individual anyway. Why should anything in YOUR life change for the betterment of others in your nation. That would be unselfish!

by tonythetiger

Obama used in his speech.

I'm not saying people should be uninsured, I'm saying it can be done a lot less expensively than with $2.1 trillion dollars of tax money!

So let's use really bad numbers... say 100 million were uninsured. Let's say a that 10% are single, and the rest required family coverage.

Now, what's decent private insurance cost, $8,000 a year for single, and $12,000 for family?

So that's 10 million times 8 thousand plus 90 million times 12 thousand... That comes up to a little over 1.1 trillion. What's the other trillion for?

by oz_media

Are you actually equating a total cost of providing insurance to people with a cost per person for teh actual premiums? Or are you also allowing for administrative and development costs in yoru tally? Personally I think that would be a great part of such an expense, well beyond each individual's personal costs.

If a company took on 10 people to work in a warehouse and the estimated cost was 800,000yr. Would that be a number to illustrate simply their wages at 80K a year or would it include administrative costs, pension costs, computer costs, sick time, training costs etc. and a wage of around 25K/yr? if so, where does the other $15K go? Work that out and it should answer your question.

by tonythetiger

In the 2,000 census, 93% of the "uninsured" said that their health was either excellent, very good, or good. Let's say that that number has dropped to 80%

So let's pay for 3 well visits per year, at $200 per, that's $600 a year plus 1200 a year for "catastrophic coverage" making $1800 a year for 80 million people, that's $144 billion, and $10,000 a year for traditional insurance for the other 20 million, that's 200 billion, for a total of 344 billion. That's a hell of a lot less than $2.1 trillion!

by oz_media

they are so speculative that you can find ANY end result you choose.

On another angle though, it's like making fine measurements along a 40' length, if you are out by .08 inches at one end you will by out by several inches the time you are done.

You must realize that such made up figures mean absolutely nothing and hold absolutely no weight at all.

93% SAID their helth was excellent, they also don't have insurance or see a doctor, how many are really sick or in early stages of cancer and simply don't know it ecaus ethey can't afford to find out. Such a claim has no bearing at all, it is an unqualifie dconclusion on your part, thus making all subsequent calculations irrelevant and inaccurate also, but it was a ncie excercise all the same. Where do you estimate the figure of $1200.00 for catastrohpic coverage? Based on whom with what catastrophe? Heart transplant? Ongoing care for a head injury? Loss of a limb?

You facts and figures are not even qualified speculation.

When Bush would constantly ask for more and mroe of your money to support his war in Iraq. I never saw you crunching HIS numbers and questioning the ridiculously exorbitant amounts of your tax dollars that he wasted there.

When it comes to saving lives and increasing the average life span of Americans (which is nothing to brag about as it is) out comes your little mental calculator to calculate fictional figures and question the amount and motives. Why?

I seriously doubt you see the flaw in such action though.

You didn't know, nor take a moment to begin to question why he needed THAT much money in Iraq, you just support it regardless, 'he knows' and that's all that matters; but you feel you have it all worked out as to how much health care will cost and seeing as it costs less than your fruitless efforts in Iraq, how can you justify your complaint, or even your sudden concern for spending.

How much did the nearly 700 billion spent on Iraq increase your taxes and step on your livelihood?

by oz_media

If yuo are going ot have yoru own opinion and not simply agree with jdclyde's rant, you will just have to accept the fact that your ocmments are deemed irrational unil you agree with him, then you'll be speaking clear volumes of common sense.

JDClyde - I can't believe you even take yourself seriously sometimes. Such baseless opinions full of personal disgust towards the man you chose to vote against, yet you consider all other supportive comments unrealistic.

Get a life you sad, sorry, pathetic excuse for a human being.

by jdclyde

why would I have to look him up to see what he is saying?

Maybe his is reading my posts to get his information? I could see that.... :D

by oz_media

You are far too predictable, not very clever and surely everyone knows what you are going to do, deny anyone who disagrees with you.

You never have anything semi-relevant to say in your replies, ever. You just reply, end of.

If someone agrees you go to great length to keep them posting down the line with you, agreeing with you all the way like some sad teenager seeking approval of peers. If someone disagrees, you simply shoot down their comments as baseless and unqualified no matter how well supported or qualified they may be.

You are just an idiot, face it, curl up in bed and cry; you are simply pathetic and worthless to anyone in the world, at least that's America's downfall not mine though.

What a complete moron and utter putz you illustrate yourself as. You contradict yourself, you show nothing but sheer hypocrisy and lack of true values, you take biased opinions and put them forth as qualified and reasonable judgements, yet you aren't even qualified to be the village idiot, far too ignorant and unaware of your own words for that gig.

I seriously don't know how you can sit there all day, believing nobody sees just how ridiculous your senseless and childish arguments are, how weak your rebuttals are and yet you still post and think you are actually being clever or witty (half-witted more like it).

If I was your mother, I'd tell you to get out of the basement and do your homework before you embarrass the entire family with your complete drivel.

I can only imagine that poor woman's constant embarassment and dismay as she raised you.

I actually don't know whther to believe that you take yourself seriously or not, you must be just knobbing along with this, knowing how completely idiotic your replies are. I know you don't read or comprehend too well, but still, your lunacy is in plain English you should be able to see the flaws and gaping holes in your one-sided but two-faced claims.

If you can't see how your efforts to discount other opinions essentially discount your own, then you are beyond help but that's not news to me, I've unfortunately read loads of your codswallop for long enough now.

I would reply to this myself, on your behalf, but to echo such senseless drivel and blatant hypocrisy is best left to yourself. That way your little brain will actually think you are one up and got the last word in as you drive so hard for.

Very honestly, and IMHO, you really are the asolute dumbest poster I have ever read on TR. I've seen some real nut-jobs try for that spot over the years but nobody could take that way from you when you post such pointless crap as you have here.

by oz_media

Face it you just aren't very bright at all. You wouldn't know agreement if it hit you in the face, obviously.

I don't think you even know what you say yourself, if he was saying the same thing as you, you'd probably call him unresonable and dismiss his comments, not knowing they were your own.

Yes, it appears you really are that dumb.

by oz_media

You find flaws in two systems and equate that to a flawed government.

Are you suggesting public schools are a bad thing and that private schools are the answer? Only the rich get educated, well I see from your own lack of intelligence that not all private schools are a worthy investment, but then again there's just no hope for some. To think of teh money your parents pi$$ed away on private schools when the MacDonalds playground would have been just as effective.

The sky is falling, it will be the end, in fact I think the best thing you can do for yourself as well as America, is to move out of the country and off to a far away land where someone just MAY buy into your crap.

by jdclyde

as you have already stated what I waste of time my posts are for you, yet you hunt each one down and post to them all?

You love me, admit it.

by nicknielsen

I didn't say they made my point.. The requirement that public schools accept all applicant exists in US Code. The only exception are those students expelled for misbehavior.

I should probably tell you at this point to do your own research, but I've already seen how much you did on this subject.

by jdclyde

hostile?

You made a point, implying an unfair advantage private has over public about being able to cherry pick only the best students, leaving the undesirables in the public system. If you don't have anything, either references or personal experience to back that up, that is fine. I have not seen such practice.

by jdclyde

since when do you take anything posted in a web discussion seriously? You have repeatedly vented how it doesn't mean anything and derailed people that think otherwise.

If you don't take it seriously, why would you expect me to?

by jamesrl

Now that Oz has declared JD to be the dumbest poster on TR, Balthor, Nodice and others will just stop trying. Sad isn't it....

James

by oz_media

The highest rate of premium paid by residents of British Columbia is $54/month. That includes pretty much unrestricted access to any doctor, specialist, emergency room, surgery, and even things like physio and chiropractors (the last two do charge a nominal fee upon visiting, around $5-$10 per visit and you are limited to a half dozen visits gratis).

Medication, is MOSTLY covered also, for 30 Tylenol 3's I pay about $7, it is basically just the dispensing fees, the drugs themselves cost pennies. There are more expensive medications of course, but again MOST of that cost is covered. A friend of mine was taking several hundred dollars worth of meds each month after a nasty accident. He ended up paying about $20 per refill, which is then tax deductible anyway.

Over the last few years, the ambulance service has privatized, so unless you have private insurance it'll cost you $80 for the ride, but given the reduced cost of everything else, it is nothing to contend with. It's not like its on top of other exorbitant costs.

If you are disabled, unemployed etc. You don't pay premiums at all, if you are low income or on hardship of some sort, you get a subsidized cost that is just under $20.00/month.

Having grown up with some acute spinal issues, Sherman's disease and mild scoliosis between my shoulders, I have been through extensive surgeries and extended hospital visits with some of the best spinal surgeons and doctors around. I have undergone numerous CAT scans, MRI, EEGs etc. Not to mention several car accidents when younger, one putting me in a come for 61/2 weeks.

To date neither I nor my parents (when I was younger) spent a single red cent on anything other than heavily discounted costs for medications and a TV for private rooms.

Even private rooms are covered by medical here, if you actually needed one. As for full hospitals and no beds, I have yet to be turned away. In fact many times I have had a room to myself, with three other empty beds in it, of course at ho additional cost.

I did find one year, during a major flu epidemic that the emergency room beds were full and they had patients in the waiting room, but those were odd circumstances and the hospital itself had many beds.

Another thing that also stands out is that no matter how often I go to hospital, whether I have a self inflicted life threatening disease or not, I am covered, I am seen to and my premiums never change, unless by a provincial hike for everyone, which is rare and minimal at that. I smoke cigars but I don't pay more than a nonsmoker.

Even if I don pay my premiums, I STILL get free coverage. Sure I will still be billed for my monthly fees, they just get added up as a debt, but I don't get denied or my level of care does not change. I just have a bigger debt for the $54/mo I don't pay. (Hypothetical of course, my premiums are paid up). I do know someone who owes over $3K in premiums now though, and if he gets sick or has an accident, he is still treated as anyone else and just sent a monthly statement with another $54 added to his debt each month.

You cant opt out, which is the one downfall I see in our system. Whether you like it or not, you owe $54 every month, unpaid you just owe more and more money. But its so cheap it doesn't even register on the expense radar. I can spend $54 in a few hours at the track, beers etc added and its even more.

There's no way you could get me to pass that all up for a system where I paid more and chanced the level of care I could get for it.

The concept of leaving hospital or a doctors office with ANY sort of bill is just unfathomable to me.

by oz_media

Seeing as this whol ethread that you started is a joke, how about you add that to your original post so others know too. It certainly seems like yuo are taking it VERY seriously and are PO'd at anyone who doesn't take it seriously, I mean doesn't agree with you.

by oz_media

And zip up your trousers at work.

I make a comment and you rush right in to shoot it down with lies, BS and then some hyporcisy sprinkled on top.

by tonythetiger

the private insurance industry charging $1.1 trillion to insure 100 million people vs. the government charging $2.1 trillion to insure 46 million (the number you provided and I'll assume is correct).

For private that's $11,000 per person. For government that's $45,652.17 per person.

It appears that government is less than one fourth as efficient.... or four times as corrupt!

by jck

won't tell you what parts of Florida have been more frequented by hurricanes, why hurricanes tend to steer clear of Cape Canaveral, etc.

They're good for seeing them go in when they're on the move tho!!! :^0

by jck

Because they can't decide how to spend that money?

If your mom gives you money to go to the store for her to get some milk and you can't spend it on anything else, is that losing your humanity?

Not sure why they lost sovereignty.

by jck

Kinda funny.

My neighbor, who is in relatively good health (he wears hearing aids from ear damage from Vietnam, and takes a cholesterol med as a preventative measure) was denied by all insurance carriers for basically no ill health conditions.

Of course, I'm overweight and all and could have insurance because I'm on a group plan.

Individuals are getting screwed daily by insurance. Just go talk to hospitals sometime about the uninsured they have to take in for emergency treatment and get nothing for it.

Plus, I know that when I had COBRA from my last insured job I was paying over $600 a month just for health...no dental or vision or life or disability...for 1 person.

It's crazy. It really is. And, I couldn't have gotten insurance without the COBRA mandate.

So, the single person is getting the screws to them.

by jck

I've tried to make sense to you.

You always criticize the man.

Yet he has had barely 6 months of time to do things.

You haven't given the programs time to work.

And you have consistently (as has been said many times) use fear mongering of the unknown and incomplete to drive fears that all he is doing is trying to ruin things (like TheBush hadn't already).

I gave you a case where an ARRA highway project in FL was driving new jobs, local economies, etc.

If you think that's not rational defense and a real-world example of how it's doing good, then you need to go see someone about learning rational thought.

by jck

been one to go with "the in-crowd". That's why I have never been to a Republican or Democratic fund raiser, precinct meeting, etc. Because, I don't believe in conforming like a lemming to one ideology.

We have the right to free thought...both from government...and public idealisms.

I never would think to totally agree with jd or you on everything.

But, jdclyde just has this abhorance for Obama that seems to have no rational basis. Obama has been in office 182 days, yet jdclyde thinks that all the things passed since Jan 20th, 2009 should have cured 8 years of Republican presidency and 6 years of Republican control in the United States.

Sorry jd, but it's gonna take Obama more 6 months to turn around 8 years of actions by another administration.

by jck

That's what they did with the banking system here.

Look at all the good it did.

by jck

If someone is able-bodied and won't work, let them starve.

If they have kids and can't feed them because they refuse to work, then take the kids away and give them to people who will care for them and feed them.

Lazy a$$ syndrome is cured REAL F***ING QUICK by starvation.

Nuff said.

by jck

SSI is getting to be pitiful.

Of course, it doesn't help that congress leveraged more and more debt over the decades against the SSI trust.

That's why I'm looking to either get into a better paying job with better benefits at some point and start throwing as much money into the bank (around $25k a year probably) as I can so that by age 60, or move overseas and get onto a 2nd retirement plan like in the UK.

I already worked almost 30 years here. So maybe a 2nd full pension would work best for me. Especially if the pound/euro stay as strong against the dollar as they have been.

by nicknielsen

If I remember, the utterance of those words is usually followed almost immediately by a large, self-immolating explosion...

by tonythetiger

50 million uninsured (that's probably a little high)

Private insurance: Pretty good can be had for $12,000 a year. That's $600 billion. Democrats want $2.1 trillion. What's the other $1.5 trillion for?

by nicknielsen

Might have been a little hostile, but then you've shown often enough that on certain issues it's your way or the highway and public schools (because of teacher unions?) is one of those issues.

Allow me to qualify the statement about public schools: they are required to accept all students [u]who live inside their attendance area[/u]. In practice, of course, highly desirable schools in districts that allow parents to choose the school, often turn students away because they are at capacity. School choice fanatics use such incidents to show the "lie" in the claim that public schools must accept all students.

School choice is ONE answer, but there is no single answer. One of the primary requirements for fixing public schools, IMO, is to get the parents involved. Regardless of income, regardless of school, regardless of anything else, the children who are succeeding in public schools (and there are many) are succeeding because their parents are involved in their education. It's not so much that private schools can cherry pick, but that the parents who care enough about their children's education to pay for private schools were already involved in that child's education in public schools.

I've been there. Some of my worst students lived in named subdivisons with houses starting at $250k-$300k and some of my best students lived in trailer parks that I wouldn't keep my dogs in. What was the difference? The parents of my successful students worked with me because they saw the opportunity; the parents of the failing students gave me crap because they saw "public school."

by shellbot

that be boring though??
]:)

Sadly I'm sure some people would love that though wouldn't they.

by jdclyde

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/us_health_care_overhaul

[i]"The president also has vowed that the legislation will not swell the deficit, although a senior administration official told reporters Tuesday that the pledge does not apply to an estimated $245 billion to increase fees for doctors serving Medicare patients over the next decade."[/i]

of course a certain non-American will snivel about this being a lie too.... :^0

by delbertpgh

Is that everything the country currently pays for health insurance or something? Is it a budget number for a single year or multiple years? I don't know where this number comes from or what it describes.

by jdclyde

Like for meeting the NCLB testing, so the "best" students can get grouped together for a favored teacher while another gets what is left.

An overpriced administration that sucks up a lot of the money that should go to the kids.

A teachers union that blocks every attempt to improve schools that continue to do worse and worse every year.

School of choice forces schools to compete. The private ones I was referring to (as I said a few posts back) was actually the religious based schools. They focus the basics while public schools worry about "social education".

I had stepped in a year ago because the SCIENCE teacher was showing ThingTwo's class the AlGoreShow. It has known inaccuracies, yet she was letting it all go out as if it were true and a fact. When I demanded she set the record straight, instead she stopped showing it. I have seen many dishonest examples such as that.

I have been the concerned parent, giving my cell number and email address in case there is ever an issue, never hear a word, because many of the teachers just don't care anymore.

Yes, there are a lot of good teachers that still care and try to make a difference, but the system is corrupt and with the alliance with the Democratic party and the only offered solution is to continue to throw more and more money at the problem, it just isn't going to happen. THAT is what makes the dollars spend per student at the religious schools very relevant to what the public schools do and the results that are achieved.

Yes, I have heard of schools filling up, but have never heard of it being anything but first come, first serve? I drive my boys 15 miles to school because of the issues at the school that is 2 miles away.

What IS the solution? There are a lot of useless people that just don't care about their kids. Do we write them off? Or instead of worrying about hurting their little feelings, so we challenge them to be more? The current trend is to challenge them LESS, and that is the road to destruction.

by jdclyde

is all your ranting just a copy/paste from what you post to Dawg? Sounds like you are just repeating the same thing over and over, no matter who it is you are trying to show that you are superior to.

Oh yeah, it isn't working either.

by nicknielsen

At least not with the political strength of those in the North. How, then, does that explain the failing schools in the South? I've been there and still have no idea.

I think, though, that you and I agree on at least one point: [i]The current trend is to challenge them LESS, and that is the road to destruction. [/i]

by santeewelding

The one, plain line was that because I spoon-fed you, at your pace.

At your rate, this could take a while.

by oz_media

First of all I don't dislike you so I'll try and keep insults to friendly banter instead.

As for you dumbing it down, I'm not the only one here who has complained of your cryptic messages. Say what you have to say in plain English, I don't want to take time to seek meaning on your posts, if you can't offer a straight opinion, don't bother posting to me at all.

I certainly wouldn't want you to feel a need to stoop to my level in order to communicate.

by oz_media

Who says he is beyond it yet continues to reply with more and more BS as if it will instill your pointless assertion based on personal opinions of government and not fact.

As for defense, when someone puts forth an argument and you continually post and debate it, you are thus defending your views.

Seriously and with all the sincerity I can muster, you really aren't too bright, are you? I suppose you are probably a college grad too?

by oz_media

There's no present tense intended, based on your inability to understand what you post yourself, it is clearly accurate. I'm not suggesting something to come, it is a clear observation of something that simply is.

by oz_media

But that's what you do today, you simply buy insurance if you can afford to. Do you really think the solution is to just have the government pay for people's premiums instead? Why would YOU continue to pay premiums yourself?

While you often mention the horrors of tax dollars supporting others who scam the system and don't NEED help, how well do you think such a system would work if it wasn't government regulated? Insurance companies falsify documents all the time, that will be effective at a government level! Why would ANYONE pay insurance premiums if they were paid out by the government?

It would be no different than people scamming the government system, except on a much grander scale.

by av .

But think about all the issues he faces. Two wars, the economic meltdown, jobs, housing crisis, healthcare, immigration, etc.

The bag.

AV

by Tammy.Cavadias

Ice cold water bucket waiting to dump over a few heads ;-)

Now now boys (men) - let's each go into our corners and then come out and just agree to disagree.

Geeee... what's a gal got to do? :p

-Tammy [_]3

by jdclyde

after all, "they" can afford to foot the bill for this as well.

And that is a big key to the Democrats, using words like "they" or "the rich". A faceless group, ripe for the plunder. Ripe until they get chased off shore like Dems did with many businesses with their punitive taxes. It all started as a tax break. It wasn't till later that the outsourcing to get rid of the Democrat mandated benefits and lower wages and no unions that the actual labor was moved off.

by tonythetiger

where do the top ten percent get their money?

From the other 90%

Raise their taxes, raise your prices... dollar for dollar!

by tonythetiger

just pointing out that it would cost less...

Personally, I'm for barring employers from offering insurance... pay the employees the money instead. Then with 70+ million new customers on the open market, competition would be fierce, and prices would plummet... to the point where more people could afford it.

by jdclyde

until they found that the currency would be valuless and while they have a higher dollar number on their check stub, they still can't afford to get anything more than before.

That is what happens when people that feel instead of thing start being generous with other peoples money.