Discussion Locked

Primary or Secondar IDE for 2 cdroms

0 helpful
5 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I have 2 hard drives raided to there own controllers on the Motherboard. That leaves me with 2 open IDE slots, a primary and a secondary. Is it ok to put the 2 cd-roms in the primary and work fine?

Thanks

5 replies

by thechas

First, you will get more and quicker responses to technical questions if you post them in the Technical Q&A forum.

Not all systems will boot up properly if you have a CD-ROM drive as the Primary Master device.

If one drive is a regular CD drive, and the other is a CD-RW, you want to have them on seperate IDE controllers anyway.
The reason for this, is that you will be speed limited when copying CDs if both drives are on the same IDE controller.

Chas

by admin

:^) Listen to him.... even on an old system you can change it to do this in the bios, but why? if you have 2 jacks open, use them both. you will get better transfer rates.

by djent

A limitation to IDE is that you cannot access both devices on an controller channel concurently and you need to set some priorities. If you plan to dupe CDs often the CD drives should be on different channels. If you plan to read/write hard drive data too/from CDs they should on a different channel then the hard drives. So you make the choice that works best for you. If neither of these options is desireable get SCSI hard drives and setup CDs on both IDE channels, this does not impose any performance limitations, but is more expensive. There is always a price, be it money, performance, expansion slots or IRQs. Choose the lesser of the evils.

by admin

card and add that in... you don't HAVE to go scsi :) Some of the IDE RAID cards are even quite inexpensive now.

by djent

True but this will cost an interupt and still have limits to concurrent read/write and number of devices supported. Although SCSI is more expensive it imposes fewer compromises and is still the fastest, most flexible, interface available.

This discussion is closed to new replies.