Discussion Locked

Rant of the Week - Comcast says I'm a spammer (07/25/08)

0 helpful
26 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

On July 10th, 2008 while going about my normal work related stuff - sending out tons of emails from my work related Comcast email account I discovered I could no longer send out any email. I could receive email, but none would go out.

While trying to figure out what was going on - running some test sends from my other email accounts to see if it was related to Outlook, Outlook Express, etc... - I received this lovely email from Comcast:

[b] Dear Comcast Subscriber: [/b]
ACTION REQUIRED: Comcast has determined that your computer(s) have been used to send unsolicited email ("spam"), which is generally an indicator of a virus. For your own protection and that of other Comcast customers, we have taken steps to prevent further transmission of spam from your computer(s).
[b]Comcast.Net WebMail Users[/b]
If you use a web browser to access your email, this change will not affect your service. However, it is important that you take steps to remove the virus and secure your computer(s). This can be done by using the FREE McAfee Antivirus and Firewall software available from Comcast on the Comcast Security Channel or by using other popular antivirus solutions that are widely available.
[b]Third-Party Mail Client Users (Outlook, Outlook Express, etc.) [/b]
If you use Outlook Express, the steps we have taken to protect the Comcast network will not allow you to send email until you apply a simple one click fix available at http://www.comcastsupport.com/alternateport. While this will restore your ability to send mail it is still important to remove any possible viruses from your computer. This can be done by using the McAfee Antivirus and Firewall software (offered to Comcast.net subscribers at no additional charge) availa ble from Comcast on the Comcast Security Channel or by using other popular antivirus solutions that are widely available.
Note: this one click fix currently only works with Internet Explorer. If you use a different browser, please click here for steps to manually change your port.
If you are using a third-party client other than Outlook Express (Outlook, Eudora, Thunderbird, etc.), please click here for instructions.
Comcast is focused on providing a secure internet experience for all of our customers. Please visit the Comcast Security Channel regularly to stay up to date with the latest security threats, products, and services
If you have additional questions please visit (www.comcast.net/help).
Thank you for choosing Comcast!
Sincerely,
Comcast Customer Security Assurance

-------------------------------------------

Now I knew for a fact I had no virus, but I also knew I had and have always sent tons of email in a short period of time some containing several attachments and including several people in my send to. All high trigger flags for a "spammer".

Before I picked up the phone to call Comcast to give them a piece of my mind. I decided I'd first go ahead and do what they asked. I ran another Virus check using their suggested link, even though I had already ran three of these throughout the night (they are all auto scheduled). I didn't want Comcast claiming I didn't follow their email by the letter. So the new virus scan was ran - nothing was found. I then proceeded to change my port number for all 4 of my Comcast accounts (as all four of them were now blocked from being able to send out email) and marked the little box that says "My outgoing server (SMTP) requires authentication" as suggested since I run Outlook - I was back in business.

However, this whole process ticked me off that Comcast would have the nerve to flag me. So I first jotted them off a feedback. After waiting 24 hrs for a response which is the time frame one can expect to receive a response according to their website. I called them. I guess my email got blocked :-) The person I spoke with informed me that yes the large volume of emails in a short period of time would have my account(s) flagged/blocked - Especially if they contained attachments. The offending attachments that apparently got me labeled and flagged as a spammer were text and HTML files. They were newsletters. I asked if they could change my status but was told they were unable to do that.

Since I could now send out email, I decided to let the issue drop. That was my BIG mistake.

Starting today, I discovered all the emails I had sent that contained attachments weren't being received by the attended recipient. How did I discover this? When I was pinged by a co-worker asking when they could expect a file I had emailed 30 minutes prior. I emailed the file to them again, but it never arrived in their inbox.

So, I decided to do a little investigating. First, I tried sending an email with no attachment. Ok, that worked - email received. Then I tried sending out from each of my accounts with the same attachment I tried earlier to send - nope, not received. Then I tried to send using an attachment that had previously gone through fine - still not getting to where its suppose to go. Then I tried different attachments - text only, no HTML, a .JPG, a spreadsheet, etc... Nada - not one got to where it was going. So my next step - I tried sending the same attachment from earlier today from my Gmail account and guess what? The email with attachment was received by the intended recipient. So now I knew it was Comcast related. My final test before I started War World III with Comcast - I logged into my web based email client. After all the above email from Comcast said using the web based client wouldn't block outgoing email. Yeah right! All email with an attachment never arrived to the intended recipient. There it was in my sent folder claiming it was sent but where it went once I hit that send button? - Destination unknown. An error message would have been nice. But noooooooooo I wasn't afforded that luxury.

Now, I am ticked, pissed, completely and utterly moving quickly into rage mode. I followed all the rules that Comcast placed on me based on their previous email. Yet here they were blocking my attachments from being sent.

Had they ever taken the time to actually look at the emails (and I do know they have that ability to do so if they choose) that they were blocking they would have seen there was a full back and forth discussion that had taken place between myself and the intended recipient(s) within the body of the email that we had started BEFORE my final email back that contained the attachments that were blocked. Last time I checked - spammers don't have full back and forth discussions with a recipient. But then again - maybe they do.

Had they also looked further into my activities they would have seen there is roughly a handful of folks I email on a regular basis in a short period of time with attachments. All are the same people over and over. Last time I checked Spammers don't make money off of sending spam to just a handful of the same exact folks (but then again - maybe they do). But it could be a virus you say? Sure, but I have over 100 people on my Contact list - Viruses tend to either limit themselves to the first few listed in your contact list (none of my daily recipients are in the top 30 with two not being in my contact list at all), or they send to everyone in your contact list.

So, I decide to contact Comcast once again. This time I decide to try their live chat instead of an email since I could make a copy of the conversation. I log into their live chat room, and begin my chat with "Perry" my Comcast Tech assistance. I explain to Perry my past history starting with July 10th's email from Comcast all the way up to my now current problem of not being able to send an email that contained an attachment. After asking me a few questions, having me try a few tests (sending through my web based email client), he was unable to help. He gave me a reporting number and said someone would contact me in 24 hrs. Hmmm... where have I heard that before??

I then decided to call Comcast directly. My first few tries got me directed to a recording that stated - Service in your area on such and such blocks and roads is not working" well that is fine and dandy but I don't live anywhere near them areas. Buzzzzzzzz.... I was disconnected after the recording. So I call back again. After 4 hours, yes 4 hrs of trying to get a real live person - I press the button for "disconnect my service" - hmm.. seems that won't work - the recording says the office is not open call back during regular operating hours. Buzzzzzz... the call is disconnected once again. What to do what to do, as I now have steam coming out of my ears. I call once more and pick - Comcast pro (it sounded more important than just a customer) - ah ha! I got a real live person. I got so excited I almost dropped the phone and the poor guy on the other end had to listen to a loud - woo hoo!!!

I spoke with a young man named "Daniel" who listened to my story that I had already explained to the Chat tech guy. Daniel pulled up my account, reset the account, and had me try again to resend an attachment. Nothing - nada. So now it was back over to the web based email client for another test - nope nothing.

This young man explained that Comcast had a new system in place that they recently started to try and block as much spam as possible due to customer complaints over their spam issues. Well I can understand that, after all I have in the past forwarded spam to Comcast's spam team. He also asked me how many people I normally send to on a daily basis in a short period of time (as I had explained to him I do send to several people in a short period of time with attachements and I believe that is what caused all this mess to start with), he also asked how many people I had in my contact list, I told him that. He asked if I had changed my port number as requested - yes I did (I also mentioned I didn't think it was right I had to do this since I had done nothing wrong, nor did I have a virus on my system). We chatted for a good 30 minutes or so on what could be causing the problem. All he could find was that my account had been flagged for sending spam. After a few more tests of being unable to send an attachment including resetting my account(s) once again, he transferred me to their Customer Assurance Team. He said they should be able to find out exactly what was causing my attachments to be blocked.

The gentleman I got from the Customer Assurance team, did a few checks, did something else and finally asked me to send him an email from my web based email client with the attachments I was trying to send earlier that day. Once more I logged into my web based email client, and sent him the attachments - He came back and said he received the attachments just fine. Hmmm.. now that is weird??? So we did another send to myself using one account and sending to another - nothing - no email, no attachments received. I was then instructed to change some settings in my web based email client. Which I did. This did not help, however, I did find that all of a sudden attachments sent to someone who was not a Comcast customer could now receive my attachments. Now, we are getting somewhere - I thought. The gentleman said to give it another 24 hrs (there is that 24 hr thing again) and if the problem continued to call them back. He did explain that their new system they were now using was causing some problems (some?? I can bet I am not the only one being flagged as a spammer).

I tell him thank you, hang up and head off to test my limitations. I was successful in sending to my co-workers Gmail account a 3MB spreadsheet, a couple of text files, and then we ran into problems - the HTML file she needed would not go through - here we go again

To make a long story short - Comcast still has my account(s) flagged for spamming (I still must keep my port number set to 587 and I must have the little box that says "My outgoing server (SMTP) requires authentication" checked) . I still can not send an attachment to my other Comcast account(s) or send an attachment to another Comcast customer. I am once again unable to send a HTML attachment to someone who is not a Comcast customer (the very short brief time I could seems to have had its window closed). I still do not know how the tech guy got my attachments (his email addy was a Comcast one), yet I can not send one to myself.

Looks like Comcast and I have a phone date again tomorrow - anybody care to vouch for the fact I am not a spammer? :p

-Tammy :-)

26 replies

by boxfiddler Hot topic

nothing worse than Customer that isn't, and, if like Charter, costs an arm and a leg.

by ceespace

I can vouch that I have never received any email from you unsolicited or otherwise

will that do?

by Tammy.Cavadias

As I can now send attachements once again :-)

I will say though - I am looking forward to when Verizon finally its their FIOS in my area, as it stands now - we have Comcast or Bellsouth's DSL service. Unless you go dial-up.

-Tammy :-)

by jamesrl

You know I can understand that they are trying to help fight SPAM, surely a laudable goal, and that they are trying to be proactive.

But they really have to think through how they will handle the INEVITABLE false positives. If they haven't figured out a way to resolve them in a reasonable manner, and thats clear from your email, they should not have implemented their system yet.

You don't send me email :( (you don't bring me flowers, you don't sing me love songs...)

James

by Tammy.Cavadias

I sent flowers, sung a song - didn't you get my attachement? ;) :p :D

The new system did roll out roughly around the same time frame I received my nice lovely letter from Comcast. At that time it would had been nice to have Comcast respond to my email to them regarding that email.

What's weirder yet - in the last couple of weeks - the one account I use for subscribing to items onthe web (newsletters, forum boards, etc..) has actually started seeing a *Rise* in spam compared to what I use to receive to this account.

-Tammy :-)

by Tammy.Cavadias

Different levels for Business yes (but bear in mind now I've had Comcast for the last 4 yrs, and as a one person operation in my home, I qualify for a normal personal account). Now this post got rather long so I wasn't able to list everything the Tech folks mentioned on the phone - one being their new improved spam busters to catch legit spammers - is getting a high rate of false postives. Basically I was told the new system needs work.

As for CNet footing the bill - I pay my own access which is deducted in my taxes at the end of the year. Otherwise the IRS can consider it income.

The good news is - as of this morning - all attachments appear to now be going through again :-)

Still irks the heck out of me :-)

-Tammy :-)

by w2ktechman

from their servers, and a remote access account?

Using a public email address for private data is a bad practise.

by rfink

Don't use it. I hit it one by mistake. Now I don't recieve e-mails from the people checked. I called support and asked "How do I unreport someone as spam?". You can't, too bad, so sad.

Now all of my "important" e-mails go through a gmail account.

by tig2

Is completely on Gmail. She uses DSL from Qwest and has frequent outages because they have an underground cable that is hosed. At least with Gmail, she can check her email no matter where she is. And if there is ever a billing dispute with Qwest, they can't lock her out of her email account. I'm migrating everyone I support to this solution.

by Tammy.Cavadias

since it's newsletter content in most cases - otherwise items folks can already see from the website - just condensed into a one stop all - newsletter format.

And yes, I do have a cnet addy (and remote access) - you know that Scummy, you've emailed me :D And it is on their server where the private data per se is communicated.

-Tammy :-)

by Tammy.Cavadias

it makes me dream of the days where I actually felt like my business really mattered to services. I was a person and not just some account.

-Tammy :-)

by tig2

Once upon a time, I had Cingular as my cell provider. I hated them but had a two year contract. I used to regularly answer my phone with "Cingular sucks. Tell all your friends."

I feel your pain, Tammy. I had to call probably 30 times to get any help on a problem. They send tech after tech to my house. We KNEW how bad it was when their tech called in for trouble reports for the area and was told that no trouble reports had been filed for the area. We knew for a fact that a whole node had been out for two weeks.

I start any conversation with Comcast by saying, "You can't help me. Please let me speak with your supervisor." Sometimes it helps.

Good luck kiddo!

by the scummy one

AT&T broadband, then Comcast bought it from AT&T.
In the months leading up to the switch, I had cr@p service. Once Comcrap took it over I have been displeased with several aspects of it. However, the alternative is DSL, for slower speeds I would pay more :0

by tig2

Don't. And likely won't until they perceive their customers as being valuable to them. Pretty sad, really.

by Tammy.Cavadias

.. I've had them out for my actual cable service - every time it rains, I have two main problems - my cable TV goes in and out, and my Internet service either becomes extremely slow (9600 bauds slow) or goes out totally.

I tend to believe that the buried cables have some wires exposed and they are getting wet - Comcast however says this can't be so (yet they won't dig my cable line up)

A couple months ago, our living room TV all of a sudden had no service - all the other TV's had service fine. Taking a cable and running it from a different outlet to the living room TV restored service. OH thinking the outlet might be bad, replaced it, no luck still no service. So he climbs into the attic where the line comes into the house and discovers that the cable line that drops down the side of the wall into the living room, is so tight that over time the cable had broke at the point of where it connects to the outside connectors. He goes and snips the cable so he can attach a new end and hook it up - just to find that will not work, as not only was the cable too tight but so short there was no extra slack to create a new connector. Deciding to just pull the cable out of the wall completely and dropping in a new line - he then discovers that when the house was built and the cable installed - it was sealed completely down the wall with - Foam. You couldn't pull the old cable out. After a few choice words, he then goes back downstairs and decides to just drill through the wall and use a double connector on the bedroom outlet (since they are back to back - the living room one on one side of the wall and the bedroom one on the other) - this works, but its a route he shouldn't have had to take.

It is frustrating to say the least. It sure would be nice if cable providers had the same competetion that say - cell phone services have. Then maybe the service would be much better and they would actually act like they want your business.

-Tammy :-)

by nicknielsen

It was a couple of years back when TWC was in the middle of their "You don't lose cable in bad weather" advertising campaign.

"It's raining like h3ll here and every cable channel I've got has "Weak Signal" displayed. My cable is out and my neighbor's satellite TV still works. Your ads are lies!"

I really wish I'd recorded that call. I didn't get much of anything but sputtering for about half a minute

by notsochiguy

I go to the AT&T U-Verse site, and check to see if coverage is available yet for my neighborhood (it is in my general vicinity, just not my subdivision yet). Saw the preview for it at the AT&T store, and was thoroughly impressed (and seeing how I pretty much despise AT&T on the whole, that's saying something).

I'd go back to Dish Network (only subscriber service I can say I was ever 100% satisfied with) if I were allowed to have a satellite dish (d@mn you housing association).

Asides from the terrible support and brain dead technicians, the service just isn't all that good. The DVR partakes in massive amounts of suckage (compared to Dish and TiVo), the signal seems to pixelate randomly (actually, not randomly...only when I'm fully engrossed in what I'm watching, and the critical moment arrives...for instance, what was the big deal about Verbal limping out of the police station...I got Comcastic pixelation as he limped down the street).

The internet access is okay, but I live in an area with a lot of other heavy Internet users , so I rarely notice anything better than the DSL I used to have.

Of the three core services (TV, Internet, Phone), I'd say the phone service is the only one that is consistently working as expected. Never had any problems with echoes or static on the line.

Comcast's new sales line should be: Service so good, you'll look forward to flying again!

:)

by notsochiguy

...my patio is facing in the wrong direction to get a satellite reception. The roof was ruled to be 'shared area' of the building, which is how the rule got enacted (despite each unit actually having a distinct roof...argh).

On the patios it is fine, but not on the roof.

So, in other words, I'm SoL. At least, until Fiber arrives.

Thanks for the link, though. Appreciate the lookout!

by tr65

Tammy,

I am having the same problem that you described above. I can reach folks via email txt and html messages. But as soon as I attach a PDF file, the email gets blocked. Recipient never receives it.

Were you ever provided a solution?

Thanks
Tom

by Tammy.Cavadias

Thier so called solution is to always bcc yourself on outgoing email that contains attachements - if you don't receive it - they say to check your web based mail and look in the folder they have set up for junk (for some reason these don't get placed into your junk folder in outlook or outlook express) - then let them know.

Not much of a solution if you ask me, as I don't like using the web based version - its clunky - I like using my outlook and outlook express.

They also say to give them time as they are still working out the kinks in their newest software to combat spam.

Did you change your port by chance?

For now I have found the majority of my outgoing attachments will make it through, but sometimes there is a word in them attachments that gets it blocked - for example I recently sent an attachment that mentioned this new software download I found for viruses. For what ever reason it thought that link and mention was spam or something else and blocked the whole thing. But when I removed that part the attachement went through fine.

-Tammy :-)

This discussion is closed to new replies.