Discussion Locked

Technical Recuiters Who Don't Fully Read Resumes

0 helpful
11 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.
I'm sure this topic has come up time and time again and has been the source of many threads, but here is my 2 cents on this matter. Lately, I've seen an increase in the amount of unsolicited emails from I.T. recruiters...aka...headhunters. I'm personally annoyed at all the email, which I flag as SPAM and junk, from so called "I.T. Recuiters" who send me positions which are completely irrelevant to my area of expertise or are so entry level for my skill set that it's just laughable and insulting at the same time. Where are these recruiters getting their training for their jobs, if any, and are they really that desparate to just send anyone to a job interview when it's clear that they have no clue about the technology or skill sets needed for the position they are working to fill? Perhaps they need to slow down and read the resumes thoroughly before sending a server O/S engineer a job posting seeking a Cisco expert. I'm not saying that the recruiters need to have the same technical skills as we do, but at the least, they should understand the difference between a CCNA, MCSE, and a SQL DBA.

11 replies

by tony hopkinson

and email address, you are dealing with a good one.

All they do is word search, spam you and then leave the decision on suitability to the 'expert'. That's us.

Normally management would have caught on, but of course it's HR on the other end of the deal. They couldn't even master word search.
:D

by dr dij

there's alot of people collecting resumes for reasons other than looking for people:
companies trying to decide if they can get away with paying less for a position, etc.

by bblacklock

Actually I have worked with both recruiters and HR types who have a clue. Unfortunately they are in the minority.

I generally find that the HR types who know how to read the resume, generally will not let the recruiters look for people for them, but prefer to do their own search for people.

The recruiters are pushed to "improve their numbers" and those who actually try to match resumes to positions are penalized for it. Most of them leave the field after a while due to frustration.

The rest of the recruiters skim your paperwork and push as many emails out as possible. I have been "offered" positions for pennies, in other cities, in other countries and on other continents (only once). Needless to say, I now filter the recruiters email directly to the junk file. Until the people who actually do the hiring realize how their positions are being offered to the general public, I don't see that there will be any change.

by thinckerman

Yes, most recruiters are just paper pushers making 1/10th of the salary of the people whose lives they are "tweaking".

The other side of the coin is that today's job websites just require a clik or two for any perosn to apply to any job thereby filling the recruiter's inbox with tons of trash.

The reality is that by last accounting the average "hiring authority" (not recruiter...) spend less than 45 seconds looking at your paperwork!

And that is the guy/gal who you are probably going to work for - "reality" what a concept!

RSC

by rclark2

But I really think that they should at least know enough not to ask for 5 years experience with Vista or ASP 2.0.

by why me worry?

when the two products have only been out for less than a decade?

Just goes to show that these headhunters and/or the morons in HR who write up these job requirements are completely clueless.

by thegooch1

I usually am contacted for something relevant relative to a keyword ( say, I put Oracle 10g client on my resume ) in my resume. My beef is with 'recruiters' who are trying to fill a position 100 miles or more away from where I live, and its a 4-month contract, to boot.

Hello, I am employed full time, just bought a house, and am involved in many activities in my area that are outside of work . Guess what? I have no intention of trading all of that for a short-term contract with a company and location I am not familiar with.

Like the OP said, recruiters need to get a grip ( "Recruiter, meet reality. Reality, meet recruiter. I'll leave you two alone to get to know each other." )

Regards,

John Gooch

by why me worry?

I got an email about some short term 3 month contract in Detroit, MI. Mind you, I live in NY and have no interest in doing anything out of my immediate area, but just out of curiosity, I asked what they are paying per hour. The recruiter emailed me back an insulting reply of only $30/hr. For someone to have to travel nearly half-way through the USA, pay for his own lodging and meals for 3 months, and only make $30/hr would have to be pretty crazy. As a consultant, I would charge no less than $85/hr for such a short term assignment, simply because I won't make any money otherwise and because I have to offset the expense of paying for my own lodging and transportation while working away from my home area. I guess the ideal idiots they are targeting are H-1B visa holders who don't have any families or obligations here, but I am not one of those people. I work for real money, not peanuts.

by bethehammer

Similar to you, I get contacted based on one general keyword. With the capabilities that these guys have when searching on Dice or Monster, you would think they would at least review their hits or use some kind of weighting before sending out emails. As for the distance thing... I contract with several folks that work for me parttime and remotely. The key is for so called recruiters to pay attention to the locations desired or contract lengths you are willing to accept which are attributes that are available on most job sites.

by gsg

In the far, far past of the dark ages (late 80s), I worked for a recruiter. No, not for IT, though she would place IT people, but for Engineers and Management for the food production industry. If we didn't have an applicant on file to fit a job, we'd send out mailings listing various jobs that we'd gotten requests for along with a list of the types of people that we usually placed. It was just a way to expand our offerings. However, we didn't send a listing for a CEO to a packaging engineer. We were more generic than that. We'd do the reverse for our client companies as well. Send them "mini-resumes" of about 50 words with 5 or so to a page in a 5 page mailer. We placed more people that way than any other way.

by kalwein

Having seen the interface for the recruiter side of several job boards, I can give you an idea of what might be happening in some cases.

Just like many job boards allow job searchers to setup agents, many recruiters run searches on specific keywords and then blast out a req. to a subset target population based on that.

If you are basically a database programmer, but happened to mention working with project managers on a specific line of your resume, you now match the project manager profile as well. Be prepared to receive reqs for both. This problem gets progressively worse the longer your resume/experience.

This discussion is closed to new replies.