Ten words or less: "I don't use Linux because..."
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Desktop
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jmgarvin
1) Ok, why are you still using rpms? Why not yum (or god forbid, up2date?)
2) What "stupid problems?"
3) Gaming is Linux is possible with Cedega
www.transgaming.org
www.transgaming.com
www.transgaming.org/gamesdb
http://cedegawiki.sweetleafstudios.com/wiki/Main_Page
by jbush
From your original post it wasn't obvious that you had any linux familiarity (especially given that this is a "I don't use linux" thread).
If you're familiar with linux and use it sporadically for learning or out of interest then you're benifiting form the sorts of things I was talking about in my last post.
Knowing what you need to know now isn't a bad thing, but also knowing what you might need to know tomorrow is better.
We obviously live in different worlds, as my world is more than less a linux world.
In regards to proposals, if I had a client who wanted to roll out an entirely new infrastructure, I may hypothetically give them three separate proposals, one for an Apple based, system, a linux based system, and a Windows based system. I wouldn't expect them to pick all three.
(Realistically, I'd probably be tending more towards mixed networks, perhaps with *nix based servers and windows based clients)
by jbush
by jbush
Does the cost of your operating system factor into this (when spread across the years at $50 intervals (or less if you're buying something else that year)?
Do you use third party firewall or antivirus software? A packaged version of Norton AntiVirus with one year's subscription retails here for about the $75AU mark.
You claimed a "why bother" attitude towards free and open source software. Within that context if you use any spyware, antivirus packages or imaging software (such as Norton Ghost) those alone would put you above budget.
Linux sometimes has issues with dialup modems (mostly with 'winmodems' though), but unfortunately, without broadband, linux is far less feasible to use in terms of getting updates, software, etc.
Whether you check it out or not is your call. Gardening is good though.
The OS came with the computer. If I was a business and amoritizing the purchase, you would have a point. I'm not; I'm an individual who paid for the OS up front with the box. If you want to separate the cost of the hardware from the software (which Dell didn't do on the invoice), then I was over budget once, four years ago.
I'm using McAfee VirusScan 8 on the company license, negotiated to include employees' home computers including updates. The basic versions of ZoneAlarm, Search and Destroy, and AdAware are free, as are the updates. My copy of Ghost 7 is a legal copy with CD and license, taken home with departmental permission when we purchased a new version at work in exchange for a $10 donation to the employee scholarship fund. It is no longer in use on any machine at work. It's old but it does what I need. We frequently sell or give away older hardware and software.
I don't have a "why bother" attitude toward FOSS. I'm viewing this in Firefox right now. I love Gravity when I'm hitting the newsgroups. Free software is not limited to Linux apps. I don't care if it's open source since I wouldn't know what to do with the code anyway.
"without broadband, linux is far less feasible to use in terms of getting updates, software, etc."
Thanks for the info. I don't see myself getting broadband until the prices drop to under $25 U.S., without all those fine-print requirements that I also bundle TV cable and telephone service. I don't do enough to justify the cost.
by rkuhn040172
SBC/Yahoo...$12.99 a month if you sign up on-line. One year contract only. No strings attached other than being in their service area.
And many of the ISP's that I work with at work offer discounted or free internet access to our company employees.
The cable companies are good at this. They offer the commercial service to our employees for the residential rate.
That means same day, onsite tech support, 7Mb down and 1Mb up, and a static IP.
Work those relationships if you have them.
We have 23 remote locations and they usually give us free cable TV if we sign up for their internet service.
by rkuhn040172
I think his point is that free doesn't have to mean open source and free isn't equal to Linux.
There are tons of good software packages out there for Windows that are free in addition to what comes out of the box when you buy a PC.
For example, AVG, Spyware Blaster, Adaware, Spybot, Firefox, Opera, Netscape, Open Office, Diskkeeper Lite, HiJackThis, JAS Capture, NoAds, tons of games like America's Army, etc.
All are free, some open source, some not.
When you purchase a PC you typically get Windows, Works or Office, and some others. Compliment that with other free software and you have a good package that will last you for years.
Add to that student discounts (if you qualify) and company handouts and you have one hell of a system for very little money.
You can't characterize Windows systems by the generalization that everyone runs out to the store and pays full retail for everything they want.
Not fair and not realistic.
... I love winning free reboots from Microsoft
bonus awards: free checkdisk!!!
by hal 9000
The computer has a corupted HDD on the Boot drive. Makes it nasty when you leave something running 24/7 and come in one morning and find that this has happened even though you have a UPS that will keep it running for 3 hours.
But I got the best Error Message that I've ever seen last night I almost died laughing it read [b]Something Bad Has Happened[/b] I kid you not that's exactly as it appeared on the screen and then rebooted. If I wasn't laughing quite so Hard I could have just grabbed a Screen Dump before it restarted and as there are no error messages in the LOG I'm just going to have to wait for it to happen again so I can get a copy. :(
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Like all Live versions of Linux is slow running off a CD Drive.
Even for a Debian Deritive it's a particuarly easy Distro to play with and should work quite well for the market that it's aimed at.
Col
by hal 9000
You said Gaming on Linux is possible and refered to a well known site that produces a great Windows Emulator which in itself is fine.
But you should have said [b]Windows Gaming[/b] is possible on Linux as there are quite a lot of Native Nix games available it's just that a lot of people say [i]"I would switch to Linux in a Heartbeat but I need Windows for XYZ Game"[/i] :^0
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Currently they are attempting to force System Builders to install some form on Windows on machines that will never be loaded with any MS product and they insist that you as a System Builder don't allow blank boxes to leave the shop.
What I find particuarly distaseful with this is that with the cheap end of the Market you are paying more for the MS Products than for the hardware and even on the Business range the costs work out around the 50 50 mark with half the price of a new computer being the MS Products that are installed on it.
The real rubbish end of the market I can not buy Legal Copies of the MS products that are installed for the price that they are selling the complete package for. But MS doesn't offer discounts for buying in volume right. :^0
Col
by hal 9000
Although it has a death wish or how about these
Col ]:)
http://tinyurl.com/fz854
by jbush
First off, I believe you can create auto running CDs for Linux (I could be wrong on that as it's not the sort of thing I really pay much attention to)
Secondly, the key reason for such a different approach to installation is that without having to pay for licensing (most linux compatible software is freely available), and with a readily available internet connection (which I agree, not everybody has), there's not that much need for CDs.
If you look at models like Direct2Drive (an online service where you can legally purchase licenses to download and run software), you'll see that they work by similar principles.
Liken the (GUI based) package manager to the Add/Remove Programs applet in the Windows Control Panel. Imagine that it can also search for and download software for you, including any other pieces of software that the one you're after might require.
I see that as being simpler and more powerful than having to man-handle a stack of discs. That said, it was quite an alien concept when I first started using linux.
Step 1: Uninformed Windows user says he can't run his app (usually a game) under Linux.
Step 2: Linux advocate posts, "Yes, you can." and points to what I'll ignorantly call emulation software.
While the Linux advocate is 100% correct, compatibility with an existing app isn't going to motivate a home user to start learning a new OS.
by amnezia
by howards
by hal 9000
I don't use Linux Because
[b]It's way too easy & I need a challange.[/b]
Col ]:)
by absolutely
by hal 9000
It's just in something like this I do find it hard to be serrious as it's really all a joke. :p
Col ]:)
by ziskey
"I am not retarded."
If the title of the thread was "I don't use Microsoft because..." I'm guessing this type of drivel would have been in the first few posts.
To answer to the original question... I don't use Linux (at home) because I don't want to re-train the rest of my family on a replacement for something that already works sufficiently.
by tigerbright
by ajole
The Live CD would allow you to use Linux without doing anything to the laptop, so depending on the wording of your contract, you may be OK.
The joke they are referring to (in my take on it)is the idea that you need to save for a computer, as Linux will run on the $100 refurbs, $200 new white boxes, any box you presently have, etc. No big money costs there, and no loss of whatever OS you have now.
Good luck!
by ajole
It is too hard to install Apps without learning bunches.
Whew, made it in ten. I actually DO use Linux, but not enough to learn it well. Which means I always get stuck trying to take it beyond Mahjongg, browsing and text editing.
by smithtt
Linux is great, for many areas in the enterprise and provides stability for CIO's and CFO's willing to risk the initial naysayers ridicule. My belief is for server side you can not beat linux for TCO. Slowly many IT managers are listening to the advice the professional working for them provide.
However I use unix as my prefered desktop not linux, I feel that linux is really more directed toward the next generation of server platform and beyond, than the desktop.
FreeBSD -
http://news.zdnet.co.uk/software/linuxunix/0,39020390,39268549,00.htm
by scott
by sangraal
by jaqui
you have never looked at it.
Your comment shows that clearly, it is so full of complete gargbage it can't have been written by someone who has ever taken a look at it.
quit reading the microsoft advertisements and start reading what you screen displays when you investigate for yourself. Or are you to scared to think for yourself and use it, for 6 moths before opening your mouth and sticking both feet in?
by jmgarvin
I've explained it so many times, I think I've started to get lazy ;-)
Neverwinter Nights runs natively in Linux as well as a HUGE amount of FLOSS games and non-FLOSS games (RtCW: ET comes to mind as well).
by andy goss
"I don't use Linux because..."
M$ is the best bet to create a World Government!
Bill Gates is a really nice guy who cares about the world and wants to banish poverty and suffering. He would make a great World President, using Windoze all the time would be a small price to pay for global harmony.
Ummm ...
But then he gets usurped by Steve Ballmer and we are really in the poo.
Where's that Ubuntu CD?
by scouterdude
Thanks for the cedega link. Figured something like that was out there.
As to your learning curve comments, no. It's not THAT similar. Our users would notice bigtime. For myself, I'm reasonably adept with computing and the tools, and am still fairly low on the learning curve. But there are still simple things that I don't know how to do yet, things readily done in Win or Mac. It's probably just experience, but - most people don't like change.
I'm looking linux desktop stuff as a potential for our users. For the ones tired of all the virii, etc. It will be their choice (at least from my perspective as the service provider.)
by scouterdude
I'd change 'because' to 'yet'. It's just a matter of time for me.
Many of our servers will be migrating to linux in the next few years. And I'm learning what linux could be on the desktop, as an alternative.
Unlike others, I DO have an axe to grind with MS. Just really ticks me off for them to charge what they do for crapware. I'm not averse to capitalism, it's just their level of greediness, and all the barely-legal behaviours they use in contracts, etc to spread themselves.
Much of the fault does lie with the users, but that's getting into a whole other topic, and I think I'm over my 10.
by scouterdude
Mainly to Palmetto, but no reply button there.
You say Choice is Confusing. Yes, it can be. Especially if you're a support provider/helpdesk. But it' really comes down to skills, and how applicable they are. Ya think a Ford trained mechanic could fix a Chevy? Probably - the concepts are close enough. segue to...
Choice reduces transportable skills. Excuse me? How does learning multiple options make you less valuable? Agreed, Win/Office will remain in demand for the forseeable future. But how is knowing OpenOffice or other going to hamper you? When you learn multiple methods, you start working on a different level - you expect this product to do this function, you just have to find the 'how'.
by rkuhn040172
I don't use Linux because it isn't Windows.
There, I said it.
I have a nice job, decent living, good job security, work for a great company, enjoy what I do, and am darn good at it.
Why change any of that? Why spend my time learning something that I wouldn't use at work to make more money when I can spend that same time learning more about a company's products (Microsoft) that I do get paid to use?
It's kind of like learning another language. Sure, there are a lot of reasons to learn a particular language.
But if you are going for bang for your buck, learn English or Spanish or Chinese. Those are the languages that make the world go round and are spoken by the most people.
When I start seeing more jobs requiring Linux skills in the newspaper, I'll take note. But for now, if I were to need to change jobs, I would want more Microsoft knowledage not less.
I would want to know more about the products that are used in the most number of places and not the products that are used in the fewest number of places.
Now, to be fair, that includes knowledge of some non-Microsoft products like Apache.
But I'm in this for the money and Linux isn't paying my bills and keeping the lights on or putting food on the table.
Linux, for me, is just a toy or a curiousity. Again, to be fair, I'm sure it does pay the bills for others. Just not me.
But the whole point here is choice is good. I've made my choices and you've made yours.
by apotheon
You had me up to the point where . . . well, the point where you lost me. Let's see here:
"[i]I would want to know more about the products that are used in the most number of places and not the products that are used in the fewest number of places.[/i]"
Being used on fewer corporate desktops than MS Windows doesn't constitute being "used in the fewest number of places". Your point here is made, though -- you work with networks that involve a lot of desktop computers that you have to support, at least indirectly, and your career is focused in that area. Windows still holds the lion's share of the market in that area. Thus, what you say makes sense, with the exception of the unfortunate use of the word "fewest".
All in all, this is the single most reasonable thing I've ever seen you say. Kudos. I'll just assume "fewest" was hyperbole or a typo.
by jerome.koch
and made the mistake of asking a question on an IRC Channel(cannot repeat what they said), I vowed I would never learn it. That was 7 years ago.
Use Linux (SuSe) at home- not at work (Windoze, Netware). Would never reccomend Linux to novice again (most had no intention of learning it).
I will puke the next time I hear a Linux begin a sentence with:
"Real Network Admins...."
by apotheon
by hal 9000
Who only open the OS and then a couple of apps like a Word Processor E-Mail Client and Web Browser and maybe a Spread Sheet or DBase I very much doubt that any would really notice any differentce at all.
They could only start to experience problems if they attempted to instll some softwate which the Corporate Usage Policy should not allow. But for Opening Office Applications and Web Browsers and Mail Clients other than the different Icons used they would see very little difference and most would be none the wiser. One End User grabed my NB with Debian Loaded and it had the Matrix Screen Saver working and some strange Desktop Theme and their only comment was [i]Where Do I find that Screen Saver/Desktop combination on my work computer?[/i]
But they managed to use it without a problem and even sent some word processor documents from Open Office 1 to their printer without a single problem. The file was saved to their server as a DOC format file and while the formating might not have been correct when opened in Word it would have still been readable and easy to alter to suit their needs.
Col
by jfmarten3
by apotheon
by absolutely
by hal 9000
Will get you everywhere. :^0
But even the folks at TR accept this. :p
Col ]:)
by jerome.koch
by pkr9
Come on now, you know better than to drag that old horse out on the track again.
I've used Linux for 5 years now privately, and we recently set-up 2 RH enterprise servers at work. I have no clue about how to compile the kernel. Once it was needed for my video card, and it was done automatically. I never use a command line either.
Users can use any OS. All they need is to press icons.
When the Reply button is missing, go to the message on the next-to-the-last level and Reply to it. This results in a bunch of entries at the bottommost level, so be sure to put the name of the intended reader in the subject.
"Especially if you're a support provider/helpdesk ... "
I'm not looking at the question of choice from a support point of view (although that sucks too; that's why companies try to standardize on one app for each purpose), but as an end user.
"Ya think a Ford trained mechanic could fix a Chevy? Probably ..."
The auto repair analogy is nice. Imagine that same mechanic is not already trained on Fords, but is new to the field. He'd like to start learning skills, but there are over 100 different car models (representing distros in this analogy). Where to start?
"But how is knowing OpenOffice or other going to hamper you? When you learn multiple methods, you start working on a different level - you expect this product to do this function, you just have to find the 'how'."
It won't hamper you at all, but it may not help. Let's say you take the time to add OpenOffice to your MS Office skills. But in a "choice is everything" world, how do I know I'm going to wind up working with OpenOffice when I'm job hunting? How do I know which GUI I'm going to be looking at? Do I have to learn them all? Even if I know what I want to do, I'm still going to lose some productivity every time I have to learn how to exercise those old skills in a new app. A common standard app makes it easier to transport my knowledge.
I'm not opposed to having choices, but along with the good that comes from it there are negatives that many pro-choice advocates seem to be unaware of.
by apotheon
Palmetto . . . those of us who are worth addressing on the issue (since there are people only worth ignoring in every camp -- even mine), even as advocates of greater choice, realize that there are always trade-offs. In the matter of whether or not to have more (good) choices, however, the negatives are pretty much confined to a largely imagined increase in convenience. Even if these convenience costs were all completely relevant, the things you have to trade away for that convenience constitute a far greater cost.
There is a convenience cost in learning a new application's way to do the same old things, of course. In the real world, as it commonly exists, that cost comes when learning a non-Microsoft office productivity application like OpenOffice.org Writer instead of MS Office Word. There's a downside in convenience, however, in that because MS doesn't play nicely with others, there will always be people who are inconvenienced by your choice, and you'll be inconvenienced whenever you deal with them. This is the sort of thing the Open Document Format (ODF) is meant to solve.
With a common, standardized document format that is maintained independently of any corporation trying to leverage everything under the sun for market dominance, free to be implemented by any office suite, you can use whatever application you like to read and write documents. Unfortunately, this sets long-term convenience against short-term convenience: since many people have to use MS Word at work at this time, it's sort of a necessity to learn to use it. It becomes inconvenient in the short term to learn to use something like OpenOffice.org or Star Office as well. In the long term, continuing to support the Microsoft near-monopoly on office productivity suites by refusing to learn how to use a competing application, thus ending up having to get more copies of MS Word everywhere you do word processing, continues to support Microsoft in its efforts to marginalize everything else by fighting compatibility at every turn. If MS Office were dragged into the realm of fair competition so that it would have to support the same document formats as everyone else (by way of actually making competitors popular enough that MS can't just ignore them or try to shut them out), people would be able to pick whatever office productivity suite they liked and use it always. Once again, we'd be in the position of only really needing to learn one office productivity suite for most purposes, but your documents would now be fully portable across all major applications, and the vendor of your application wouldn't be trying to "embrace, extend, and extinguish" widely compatible document formats.
In other words . . . yes, we're (where "we" means "most advocates of greater choice") fully aware of the "negatives" of increased choice. We just also realize that, overall, those negatives are mostly illusory and shortsighted.
Choice is good, no argument there, I want choice in flavor of Soda, Color of Car...
On the other hand, I don't want a choice in the arrangement of the Gas, Break and Cluth pedals in my car. I want them to be in the same place, no matter what car I get in.
I wish there wasN'T choice when it came to credit card transaction handling at stores. I get really annoyed trying to remember which procedure to use in which store (swipe the card first, push the red button first, push the credit button first, give the card to the cashier...).
I don't want a choice of a dozen different GUI's. I just want one that works.
Choice for the sake of choice... just not a compelling argument.
by jmgarvin
Pick an install and go with the defaults. OO mirrors most of what MS Office looks like. Gnome (and I'm sure KDE) can be made to look EXACTLY like XP.
Linux doesn't "rearange pedals" as you would state. MS does this with every "new" product.
The FLOSS world tries to make it easier to move to *nix by creating tools that look like the tools from MS. But MS never did design anything properly. Apparently nobody at MS has read "The Design of Everyday Things."
So, if you don't like the choice, remove it from YOUR install, not mine.
We've gone from OSS to FOSS to FLOSS. What's the 'L' stand for?
Hopefully FLOOZIE is next. You open source people generate acronyms like Windows generates Blue Screens of Death :-)
by apotheon
Palmetto, regarding FLOSS: Free/Libre/Open Source
shardeth, regarding GUI choices: If you want a GUI that just works, and don't care about how it's arranged, then use whatever's put in front of you. I don't care. What I do care about is the GUI that I -- not you, I -- am using. I use a window manager called WindowMaker. Most people don't -- most people are happy with GNOME, KDE, XFCE, or IceWM. There's a fairly strong contingent that likes the various *box window managers (Fluxbox, Blackbox, et cetera). There are some who prefer FVWM, and some who like really obscure options like PekWM. Enlightenment is really popular with a particular subset of Linux users. I'm still happiest with WindowMaker, though.
Your lack of imagination shouldn't interfere with my options. The fact that I am more productive with a window manager that doesn't get in my way shouldn't prevent you from having a crufty, bloated thing like KDE or Windows Explorer to satisfy your desire for clicky buttons and animated little whirligigs.
Something a lot of people seem to be missing is this:
Open source software (like many of the available window managers for Linux and other unices) is created because somebody wants it. All that choice you say is unnecessary exists specifically because someone wanted it. It's not gratuitous or redundant. It's something someone wanted and needed.
About 98% of distributions default to either KDE or GNOME, though. Is two choices too many for you, shardeth?
by nz_justice
by apotheon
Like I said, NTFS write support exists. It's just reportedly a little sketchy. In other words, I wouldn't recommend using it unless you have to -- chances are good you won't have any problems, but I prefer to avoid taking unnecessary risks with my data.
It also doesn't help that every time there's a new Windows release, the filesystem is different.
It's my opinion that when a person is buying a new Computer, the unit will always come out of the store with a fully functional system.
I feel that "the Client" should be the one to make that decision. Which system do they want? MS or Linux?
This nonsense of Microsoft being the only ones auto-installed on all the units is ridiculous and misleading.
It creates the impression that they are the only one out there and that the other systems are just MS wanna be's.
This of course is wrong.
I feel quite strongly that the client should be made aware of all the facts and whatever system they choose is the on to be installed. Be it Microsoft or Linux.
As things are right now, this is the edge that Microsoft has and should lose.
The retailers should smarten up and start selling units that already come with pre-installed MS or Linux, all in the interest of fair play.
Something Microsoft knows very little about.
There is where the"Real" Problem lie's with Linux, it's not the product, it's the fact that most people automatically get MS and don't even know Linux exists or for that matter care..
Change this and get the retailers to stop pre-loading MS.
Then add to that, "Give us or Disks" instead of hiding all the info in an EISA partition and then we would begin to see an evening out of the playing field. The EISA Partition belongs to the client, therefore should not be used by the seller as a holding space out of the reach of the said client. This should be illegal.
But as long as MS is allow to Monopolize the Sellers market, they will always come out the winner.
Time for Linux to start taking them on in thier own back yard, on the bloody hard drive. ;)
Regards
Aaron :)
"I feel quite strongly that the client should be made aware of all the facts ... "
Who do you think should be responsible for making the buyer aware of these facts? The zit-faced kid behind the electronics counter? The one who was selling paint last month and will be transferred to lawn and garden next month? Few manufacturers and retailers of any products are responsible for educating the consumer as to their product options, at least not in the U.S. McDonalds doesn't give out a copy of "Supersize Me" before taking your order for a Happy Meal. The consumer is responsible for educating himself.
" ... most people automatically get MS and don't even know Linux exists or for that matter care."
Right. Since they don't care, they won't educate themselves.
"The retailers should smarten up and start selling units that already come with pre-installed MS or Linux, all in the interest of fair play."
Retailers aren't concerned with "the interest of fair play". They're responsible to their shareholders to maximize profits. Nothing requires a manufacture to carry every brand, version, or option for every product they sell. There is nothing monopolistic about choosing to stock only those products the retailer thinks are the most profitable.
" ... get the retailers to stop pre-loading MS."
Retailers don't load operating systems, manufacturers do. Retailers sell those products they feel will bring in the most money. Right now they think the most profit can be made selling systems from manufacturers that pre-load Windows.
Easy there fellas, no one is trying to take away your specific desktop floral arrangement. I am not talking about removing choice. I am talking about unnecessary choice. A physical example.
Let's say I don't like the Black,Brown,Red,Orange,Yellow,Green,Blue,Violet,Grey,White Coding scheme for Resistors. I Think it makes so much more sense to just do the primary and secondary colors in order around the color wheel: Red, Orange Yellow Green Blue Purple (and then finish up with Black,Brown,Grey,White). It is easier to remember that way. So what happens if I start producing my own resistors with my choice of color scheme? Now you have to test every resistor to see if it really is the value you think it is.
There is no value in having a choice as to whether the RC files are in /etc or /etc/rc.d
and I don't think I really need a choice as to the appropriate place to stick various binaries (/bin /sbin /usr/bin /usr/sbin /usr/local/bin /usr/local/sbin). I would much rather be able to depend on a specific binary being in a specific location so that I don't have to go hunting for it.
You want 2 billion ways to organize your icons, play your music files, or display your scantily clad girlie pictures, be my guest, but why not standardize the underlying API so that what works here, works there? (Gnome and KDE are making progress in this area, so apparently I am not the only one who thinks so)
That you will get from the majority...
Who cares? It works! ;)
by apotheon
Sure, it "works", if your definition of "works" is "I can plug it in, and it will limp along at half-functionality for a while, until it suffers a catastrophic failure from which I can't recover it because I don't understand the technology."
In any case, the question I was answering was "Since when is AD difficult to understand?" As such, your response to me is irrelevant.
by apotheon
"Pick an install and go with the defaults"
Hell, picking an install is the hardest part!!!
by apotheon
What you said is pretty much what I'm saying...
" is pretty much standard for everything except the big RPM distros -- which all do some things their own damned ways without regard for common sense or standardization"
"If you don't understand how they're organized, don't assume that means they shouldn't be organized."
If they actually were organized/consistent, it wouldn't be a problem. I have seen the same app wind up in different directories, from one distro to the next. Evidently the folks making it are struggling with the definitions too.
by apotheon
There are a couple distros (Fedora and Mandriva come to mind) that can't keep things straight, but in general the filesystem hierarchy is quite well organized across different distributions. You just need to understand that, for instance, the same application might appear in /usr/bin on one install and /usr/local/bin on another, depending on whether it's part of the standard configuration in a given network. The differing locations indicate differing purposes within differing networks.
Here:
http://www.pathname.com/fhs/pub/fhs-2.3.html
Read about the Filesystem Hierarchy Standard.
by sleepin'dawg
by apotheon
[b]$ apt-cache stats
Total package names : 22215 (889k)
Normal packages: 17021
Pure virtual packages: 261
Single virtual packages: 1138
Mixed virtual packages: 162[/b]
Gee willickers. That's more than 22,000 packages available via a quick shell command or a couple clicks in a GUI application (namely, Synaptic). How many applications do you have available within, say, a week's time on Windows? Keep in mind that every single one of those software packages is a few minutes away from installation for me.
by rkuhn040172
A thing that was invented called the internet that allows me to download probably just as many programs for free as you.
And probably just as many of mine are just as crappy as those of ours.
I mean really, how many of those 22,000 are really worth having?
You throw around that 22,000 number all the time like some holy grail, yet really, how many do people really use?
I'd love a study of how many programs are used by the public at large. I'd bet that the top 100 programs or so would fulfill 99% of the publics needs.
I'm not against choice, don't get me wrong. But you are abusing statistics badly, you should become a politician.
by notoriousdog
It's possible he doesn't know/doesn't believe OpenOffice is a suitable M$ Office replacement. Or maybe he's a gamer.
Or maybe, like me, he does most of his work in Adobe/Macromedia products. I dream of a Photoshop (NO, gimp and imagemagik are not a suitable replacements) and Flash linux port. Ironic - PS started as a UNIX file translation app, and now OS X is BSD based - but still no Linux port.
by hal 9000
I've got about 12 Different Cd for each piece of hardware in it and I want to install XP which of the 7 versions should I pick?
Should I go with OEM or Retail?
What is Volume License and it's advantages?
All my new hardware is MS Certified and it's still [b]Plug & Pray[/b] not [b]Plug & Play![/b]
If you are only interested in buying off the self systems with the worst combinations of things installed in them then [b]Dell Hell[/b] would be ideal for you but personally I like to chose what goes into my system and have Decent Hardware that I know is going to continue working for quite a while unlike the Dell Box that I got delivered here Sunday as a urgent Repair that just had to be done now because it was 3 days out of warranty and the PS had failed because it was so underpowered I'm surprised that it lasted that long. Even them the 480 W Antec True Power Supply that I used was still cheaper than the Dell 250 W propriety unit that came with the computer.
If you think that all you need to install Windows is one Dell Box and the recovery CD you are living in [b]Ga Ga Land[/b] as very few real Windows Installations are achieved by just dropping in the Windows OEM CD and running it. After you finish the Windows Install you then start on all the hardware that Windows doesn't have the drivers for. Little unimportant things Video Cards, Sound Cards and Capture Cards not to mention Printers Scanners and any other USB Device that you plug in that needs it's own drivers.
MS isn't that easy to really live with unless you have the most basic box incapable of doing any real work and without an attached Printer or scanner and a LAN connection that has Windows Drivers which the higher speed ones don't.
Col
by hal 9000
Why did you need to change the Mail Client?
Would your mother have acted this way if you had of used Thunderbird initially as the default Mail Client?
It's not the fact that the new Mail Client is bad it's [b]change[/b] that your mother doesn't like along with the majority of end users. :p
Col
by rkuhn040172
"I've got about 12 Different Cd for each piece of hardware in it."
Complete bull and utter FUD. I've never seen a retail system sold with a 12 CD set to install. That's Linux you are confusing with. Do you even have 12 components in your system that require drivers?
"Should I go with OEM or Retail?"
Like the average user ever comes across this problem. Buy a prebuilt system, get OEM. Build your own or upgrade later, go retail. Now that was a simple answer.
Plug and Pray is so over used. Stop using Win 95/98 and use Win XP you'll see what Plug and Play is and how well it does work for the most commonly used components.
Open your Dell PC and I'd venture to say you'll see many of the same parts you buy retail to build your own system minus hours of work. They use Maxtor, Western Digital, Intel, Broadcom, ATI, nVidia, etc. Unless of course you buy the $299 system.
The only difference is they buy millions at a time thus save money and pass some of that onto you.
Dell also has one of the best warranties out there. Better than having to keep track of the various part by part warranties of a custom built system. With Dell, you can get a 3 year, all included warranty. Custom built you get some 90 days, some 1 year, some 3 year, some no year.
Every HP system I have purchased in the last 2-3 years only requires 2 CD's to reformat. One is the Windows CD and the other is the drivers and misc crap the manufacturer puts on there. I reinstall using the Windows CD only, download a current drivers, and skip the crap on the second CD.
The only part of your rant I would agree with is printers and that is the printer manfacturers problem. Most printers now have a CD full of about 400-500MB of crap. I don't make T-shirts, I don't want their crappy software, I don't care about photo editing (I use Photoshop), etc.
What I was saying was;
How do we create a level playing field. That was the bottom line question, however misstated.
I had indeed misstated when I said retailers instead of manufacturers but the bottom line doesn't change, unless someone out there wants it to.
My point was and still is, what do you think would happen if the "Retailer" was in a position to offer one or the other?
What choices would there be, would the public address them.
For the most part, I found that general consensus to be, "just give me keys and I'll figure out the rest later".
Problem with this is by the time they've " Figured out the rest" it's usually too late.
It makes perfect sense to me. It starts at the core i.e. the manufacturers then move on to the Retailers.
Linux is still very much an underground program, or viewed as such by many and this is wrong.
This is due to naivety on our parts. We simply do not know enough about it in order to render judgment one way or another.
I know this may seem silly to people like yourself who are fully versed in Linux, but if you look at it from the Novices' "My" ;) point of view, you can see what I mean.
I feel that Linux should be installed in the same way as MS, i.e. right at the manufacturer then the retailer could offer a greater choice, point out the salient points on both systems etc.
But judging by what I've seen behind most counters today, I seriously doubt that this will happen.
For the most part, all you get is attitude, arrogance ad if you actually ask an in-depth and intelligent question, they turn into little zombies. It's like they go into shock and then say, "Wait I'll get someone who can help with that"
So you see, my point is not that Linux is Bad, it's not. It's just that a lot better job could be done to promote this product and yes you're right, I still don't know all that much about it and it frustrated the hell out of me, because I don't know where to go to get the answers.
Not platitudes or "how great it is" but genuine answers to legitimate questions.
In the meantime, I'd still like to see an MS system setup and running and right next to it and Linux just as setup and also running .
I believe it would be interesting to watch the reaction and good for Linux.
Palmetto;
Apologies for being slow on the return,Just nuts right now.
Thanks for the comeback :)
Aaron
This may surprise you, but most of the major manufacturers and even some of the big box retailers already make systems available with a Linux distro pre-installed.
Unfortunately, they are usually available only on those manufacturers' / retailers' web sites. It takes some digging on the manufacturers' web sites to find a machine with Linus pre-loaded. I suspect they make it difficult to find for reasons related to their MS licensing agreements, but they will sell you one if you insist. For a while Wal-mart did stock a Linux box (running Lindows, I recall) in their brick-and-mortar stores but now they carry them only on the web.
by jmgarvin
"Complete bull and utter FUD. I've never seen a retail system sold with a 12 CD set to install. That's Linux you are confusing with. Do you even have 12 components in your system that require drivers?"
Let's see. I need CDs for my wireless drivers, my video card, my sound card, oh and don't forget Nero so I can burn CDs, along with my DVD viewing software (ala Interwin), and my DVD burning software. Oh, and the OS and application disks. Plus the plethora of other CDs vendors ship just to get your system running...
"Plug and Pray is so over used. Stop using Win 95/98 and use Win XP you'll see what Plug and Play is and how well it does work for the most commonly used components."
I just plugged my Hawking wireless card into my laptop...Why doesn't XP recognize it? I also bought this new video card, XP doesn't see that either...Oh and my USB devices aren't so universal either, I need a driver just to use them.
"Dell also has one of the best warranties out there. Better than having to keep track of the various part by part warranties of a custom built system. With Dell, you can get a 3 year, all included warranty. Custom built you get some 90 days, some 1 year, some 3 year, some no year."
A lot of parts come with a 3 year warrenty. So part by part, for free, I get the same warrenty as Dell. 'Course some only come with a 1 year, so I'll have to pay the extra $20 or $30 for the extented. While Dell makes managing your user desktops easier, I wouldn't say they produce a quality product. And E270s? 10 to 1 you have serious power supply issues....We do
by pkr9
No of course you should not change. Stay where you are.
This thing was good enough for my dad.
We have been throwing money at the supplier for 2 decades now.
The alternatives doesn't work
It is impossible to learn something new
We know what we have - we don't know what we get.
This time they will get it right.
.. the road to hell is littered with good excuses, and many more than the few listed here.
When the wind af change blows, some people build a shelter, others build a windmill.
by rkuhn040172
Windows is the shelter and windmill.
Linux is Don Quixote.
:)
by apotheon
by vetch_101
by a_fairb
... most staff have pirate copies of MS office at home.
Untill they can be weaned off their dependancy or MS office can be run reliably and simply on a linux desktop nothing will change. MS are not fool enough to prosecute home users for illegal software when their needs drive business decisions. The prospect of changing to an alternative is too painfull to contemplate for most SMEs. I've tried it. It hurt. For the record I'm an Open Office user by choice and on principle.
by vetch_101
I have to say - I have uttered a sentence very similar to "Yeah, I installed this new sCSI adapter in my system last night and Windows 98 just recognized it and it worked the first time." - I said it, cos I was utterly, utterly, utterly gob-smacked!
And, I hate to say it, but much as I love tinkering with OSes and the like, and am moving all my 9 home machines across to *nixes, I'm still finding that I have lots of problems with drivers - especially wireless cards.
I've got a PCMCIA wireless card that works fine on Windows, and seems to work ok on Linux, until I ifup the interface - when it literally hangs the system. I've also got a PCI wireless card which I'm trying to run with NDISulator on FreeBSD (a card that someone else seems to have got working on FreeBSD via the same method) and it pulls up a kernel panic... I'm getting tempted to move to FreeBSD for the laptop in order to make use of it's native driver for the PCMCIA card, and to Linux for the FreeBSD box, because I've got a linux driver for the PCI card... This may or may not be do-able, and it may or may not work...
I admit - I am not even a power user in Linux, but I could have installed about 1000 wireless cards in Windows with the time it's taken me to get it running so far, and two OS rebuilds to come I may still be looking at issues...
Much as I enjoy doing this sort of thing, and have (evidently) a scarey amount of free time to waste - I suspect most people would give up in frustration at this point...
But this is one of those issues about Vendor support... If more people used FOSS, there would be more demand for vendors to provide drivers, rather than relying on the community to make them.
by vetch_101
I have to say, I've always been extremely happy with the machines I've bought from Dell - I've worked in organisations that are exclusively Dell, organisations that are IBM, organisations that go with smaller online vendors, etc, etc...
I've never found a company that provides the kind of after sales support I get from Dell, and some have been down-right awful... I've waited for 30 mins on some calls just to report that the hardware is faulty and needs to be replaced.
I'm also consistently impressed with the suite of diagnostic tools they ship in their utility partition. I have a fairly good set of tools myself, but I don't always know which is going to be the best one in any given circumstance - with their diagnostic tools, Dell ask you what errors you are experiencing and then run the appropriate tests. I have to say it really impressed me first time I saw it...
Ok, Dell may not be bespoke, but for most of the companies I've worked with, that don't have limitless IT budgets, I would recommend Dell every time.
(Even if afterwards I install Linux over the Win XP, a lot of the time, even with the cost of the license, the cheapest boxes work out cheaper than I could buy the parts for separately...)
by 0ldan
I used to use Linux a lot. And OpenBSD and FreeBSD.
But then I started doing more work on video and audio - capturing, viewing, listening, combining, creating.
All the tools I need are easy to find for Windows (hard to find for Linux), easy to use on Windows (hard to use on Linux), easy to install and configure on Windows (hard... well, you get the idea).
When I want to play with an opeating system, I use Linux. When I want to get some other "real" work done, I use Windows. *sigh* I don't feel good about it. But I do it.
by rkuhn040172
Sure, you can easily get to 12 CD's to install a "base" system if you start counting all your programs that did and didn't come with the system.
I'd bet it takes about 50 CD's to get my "base" system at home up and running.
Here is Hal's quote though:
"I've got about 12 Different Cd for each piece of hardware in it and I want to install XP which of the 7 versions should I pick?"
Nowhere in there do I see anything about DVD viewing, Nero, and manufacturer crap. He was pretending to make it sound as though it takes 12 CD's to install Windows and it's related hardware, nothing else.
And what is this 7 different versions thing? Utter nonsense. Not to over simplify but here's the choice for 99% of the world...Win XP Home or Win XP Pro. That's it. Pretty simple.
Sure, it can get more complicated from there for an admin, but 99% of the world aren't network admins.
99% of the world does either Home or Pro, OEM or retail. Done. End of story.
by hal 9000
The system is for myself and I need a bulk amount of processing power so this is what in it.
1 X Intel SE7501 HG2 M'Board with build in SCSI
2 X Intel Xeon 3.2 GIG CPU's
1 X Video Card ATI Radeon 256 MEG
1 X Soundbalster Audigy 2
1 X Aver Media Studio 3 Video Capture Card
1 X SATA Controller Card
1 X DVD Burner/Player
Then there are the accessories that I'm using
1 X Creative Vista Web Cam
1 X Canon USB Scanner
1 X Samsung CLP-500N Laser network Printer
1 X Canon i965 Bubble Jet Printer
1 X XP Pro OEM CD
Now by my count just for the necessary drivers that is 12 CD's all of which are required to actually load the machine. Once Windows is loaded.
Windows Installs and the following [b]Do Not Work[/b]
The Gigabyte LAN Connections on the M'Board both of them, The Video Card unless you are happy with the Default drivers supplied by MS, the sound Card not at all, the Video Capture Card not at all, the SATA Card not at all, The DD burning Program which just isn't there, The DVD Player sort of if you will accept Media Player as the Default DVD Viewer which isn't really up to scratch, Both Printers require their own drivers and they are not supported in form for by the Native OS without supporting drivers, the Scanner doesn't work, the Web Cam doesn't work and most of all while the M'Board will work sort of it's much better once you install the Intel Drivers for all the bits on it and there is a [b]Really Cool[/b] monitoring program that comes with the M'Board so you can monitor both the Voltages and Temps.
It's in an Antec Server Case with a mix of several different HDD 2 PATA, 4 SATA, and 15 SCSI. I didn't fit the RAID controller as that would have been another CD required to install the proper RAID Configuration.
Could Dell make that for me? Well actually yes they could but not with my preferred Case and certainly not with all the HDD's that I have and they wanted more that what I actually spent on this unit to build it for my out of inferior parts with a smaller Case fewer HDD's and smaller SCSI's as well.
For $300.00 AU under Dell's quote I got this unit just as I wanted it and there are certainly more than just 12 CD's involved without the MS OS or any Software other than DVD Burning & Playing Software. If you include the Windows CD and Office CD there are another 2 to add to the count.
Now all of the Plug In cards have the Plug & Play Logo on them but not one of them will actually Plug & Play the only one that sort of works is the Video Card all the rest have these little Yellow Circles beside them in the System Manager and need their install CD's to actually work otherwise they are all just a waste of money if you where to rely on MS to provide the necessary support.
I'm also not including the Monitor or Case CD's in the list or some of the others for devices that sort of work but work properly when the correct drivers are installed.
Now that you have the Facts [b]Who's Full of It?[/b]
The Aver Card had to be used because the Life View one wouldn't allow the system to boot and even that if used doesn't load the necessary 7 drivers from the Windows CD and then you need to think about the actual program which is another load & reboot.
Col
[i]Edited[/i] for Rick. At the last MS Partners Meeting MS specifically states that they have 7 versions of XP currently on sale and these are available in both OEM and Retail forms. In Volume License Forms that only have XP Pro but for the others there are currently [b]7 versions of XP Available[/b] and while you may only think of Home & Pro there are others that you just haven't considered as XP available like Media Centre & CE just off the top of my head so that's 4 without even trying to look up all the currently available Windows XP derivatives Versions available. You should really [b]Keep Up To Date With MS Products. [/b] :^0
I also forgot to add to the list of components the Digital Video Capture Card another Aver product. but that just makes thing even worse from a setup point of view. :p
"I've never seen a retail system sold with a 12 CD set ... "
rickk, HAL was not discussing a retail system, he's talking about a "white box".
HAL, I've never build a machine from scratch although I don't doubt I could do it if I tried. Like using Linux, it's just something I've never had a reason to do. But, c'mon, get real. Someone capable of doing all the research to select the best parts going into a system, making sure they're compatible, etc. isn't going to have any trouble distinguishing between OEM or retail versions of Windows, or between Linux distros.
Yes, we do buy Dell here, recently switching to them from HP / Compaq. We don't have the time to build systems and prefer to have one point of contact when a hardware component fails. I wipe the drives and install XP from a CD provided under our enterprise license. I pull the latest drivers off the web before installing our basic apps and creating a Ghost image.
My point was that I personally am confused by the huge number of Linux distributions. Your point appears to be that Windows is at least as confusing and that you don't like Dell. Don't look to me to defend Windows or Dell, but your post does nothing to clear my distro confusion.
by rkuhn040172
I was quoting you.
You mislead just as much as others on here.
How many people have a system like yours? You can't compare Windows on a custom built system and then generalize that to the rest of the world.
I have recently purchased 26 new PC's from HP and all of them came with 2 CDs.
And, just how many CD's or downloads does it take to get that sucker up and running with Linux?
You describe issues with that equipment under Windows, just curious...issues with Linux?
by dangi
...configuring it is too tough.
For those of you saying "wimp" or "Lazy", just try configuring a DCHP and DNS server in Windows Server 2003 and then try Linux. It takes about 1/3 the time and 1/10 the effort.
Then try installing an app in Windows, then in Linux. Also, about 1/3 the time and about 1/10 the effort.
Now, when I'm trying to keep 230 users running as part of a 3 man team, I'd rather have something take 1/3 the time and 1/10 the effort rather than something that 'sticks it to the man'. In this case, as with any case I have seen, Windows is far superior to Linux. There are likely more security holes in Linux, but they haven't been found because so few people, and none of consequence, use it.
by vetch_101
Instructions actually help the people who write the GUIs that enable you to do what you want to to write what you want them to...
Besides, the beauty of text-based config files is their portability. If you backup a few text files you can practically have a complete "identical" system running on another machine in minutes...
by tygyrtoo
I can also port many of my Windows settings in an easy file format. It's called .ini files (or .cfg files, or whatever).
I can also see all the settings, usually, in a convenient checkboxed, windowed and tabbed format which is usually self-explanatory and logically presented.
Should I need help I also have the option of using the help manual or function which usually has a searchable index complete with hyperlinks for cross-referencing.
UNIX config files don't do this. They're usually just a random mishmash of technobabbled explanations in amongst unintelligible "commands" arranged in no particular order.
I can set up several programs differently in Windows in seconds with the checkbox option. Under UNIX, with the scrolling and entering and checking-to-make-sure-there's-no-extra-spaces, it takes minutes.
With a full schedule and being hounded by bosses who are very much aware how much they pay me by the hour, those minutes mean a lot.
by hal 9000
I didn't have any trouble choosing the parts except for one of the Video Capture Cards the Free to Air one which was a bit of a nuisance and I also have 25 CD sets some have 4 CD's in them for Windows Programs to install on it after it's actually loaded. So it isn't a [b]Short Install Time[/b] and not something that can be expected to be Ghosted for the Initial Install though one of the removable SATA drives, is now a Clone of the Boot Drive of Windows but only the 32 bit version as I'm not bothered with the 64 Bit one as it's just a development platform.
As I'm running several different OS's on the same system Win XP Pro, Win XP Pro 64 [that ones a nightmare as there just are not the drivers available for it] Debian and SUSE.
I'll leave a few drive partitions clear to install Test OS on when I get around to needing to test something though but they will be the Cheap PATA ones that are partitioned to 50 GIG from the 200 GIG that they are.
But this is the main difference between the US and AU in the US I'm told at the MS Meetings almost every computer is sold by the Big Makers and here in AU most are sold by the small system builders who have the advantage of fast delivery times with the newest hardware available. I actually wanted a Quad Processor M'Board but there is no Windows Desktop product that will work correctly on it so I just settled for the Dual Xeon's and I'll put up with the slower performance when I'm running in XP.
The point was however that there are currently 7 versions of XP or its derivatives available from MS so there is a fair choice there as well even if only two are actually thought of being used [b]In Bulk.[/b]
s for what you might like to consider as a suitable Distro from a Nix supplier that really depends on what it is you need as they don't aim their product in an attempt to have [b]One Size Fits All[/b] which is the MS way of doing business.
If you just want a desktop that's easy to install Corel's Linux will suit you perfectly, it's so good that MS killed it off and though now dated is still brilliant for a new user, if you want a server OS then something like SUSE which ever is the Latest now or Red Hat again the latest and both are cheaper than Windows 2003 ES and have greater capacity less overhead and better scalability. Both have direct support from IBM who claim that they can have fixes available within 48 working hours for any of these products installed on one of their Servers. IBM has their own teams working on both Distro's as well as direct contact with the makers.
MS on the other hand doesn't allow IBM access to the Source Code so if you use any MS product on an IBM Server you'll be stuck waiting for MS to come up with a fix as IBM is not in a position to help you out. That's probably why IBM claims that their Server Sales are 60% Nix and 40% MS and when you start loooking at even the small Blades like the 500 CPU ones I can not think of many people who can afford the MS Licensing for one of these as the cost would come very close to the Hardware cost and IBM isn't noted for being cheap. Then if you start looking at one of the really big Blades with several K's CPU's that is a thing that just isn't worth thinking about with MS Licensing.
Col
by ewischmann
Occam's razor
"entia non sunt multiplicanda praeter necessitatem"
by tygyrtoo
Right - and to get those GUIs working, I have to do... guess what? Yes, config those files.
My first experience with RedHat, back in the day, involved trying to get X up and running. Sounds simple, right? I couldn't get it to display in more than 640x480, even though the settings were perfect. Many hours of cursing and three weeks later I FINALLY discover the VERTICAL refresh rate of my standard monitor (again buried in a vast and commented text file) was exactly 1Hz out and this was causing the issue.
GUIs under UNIX? Ha!
by hal 9000
Currently I'm still installing the apps for XP Pro 32 and I haven't even thought about the 64 Bit version as there are not enough drivers for it to work properly, but on that system Debian installed without a problem from the 15 install CD and while I did install just about everything except Server or Domain items from Debian I think that I only needed something like 8 of the CD's and then drivers for the Sound card and Video Capture Cards. Less than 4 hours to have it up and running perfectly with Debian and I'm still installing XP Pro although the initial Install and loading the necessary drivers and software that came with the hardware took about 4 hours as well.
The difference is that with the Debian Install I have all the necessary programs that I want and I'm still installing and rebooting the XP Pro one which dictated the hardware that I could use as XP will not support a Quad Processor M'Board let alone one with HTT on each CPU. Even now it's only running each CPU as one without HTT so it's actually slower than the Nix install.
After I finish the XP install I'll throw the latest SUSE that I got from Novell at it and see what happens. But the one that I'm not looking forward to is the 64 Bit XP version that MS gave me. I can see a lot of problems cropping up there even if the CPU's do have the 64 Bit Extensions in them. There just isn't mush software available and even fewer drivers so I can see most of the 32 Bit drivers being used for the time being at least and if the 64 Bit ones ever become available I'll install them then.
Col
by grouper1
BUT I still run FC5 at home. I'm switching to Suse 10.1 in a week or 2. Even though i'm more interested in unix/linux administration, I have a little box I run win2003 server on at home just because I cant escape it. I also run solaris 10 and osx at home too.. yeh I have way too many computers at home.
I also take in my ubuntu livecd with me to work whenever I wanna tinker around with my machine.
by cweb
by apotheon
Even if it provided an accurate representation of the situation, it still wouldn't be even slightly clever. Go back to the drawing board.
Do you have anything non-trollish to contribute to the discussion, or are you just here for the flaming?
Sort by Trending