Discussion Locked

Terry Childs and City of San Francisco Network

0 helpful
8 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

Anyone ever design a complex network and figure if someone who really doesn't know what they are doing can seriously mess up the network so you take steps to make sure they cant?

According to this article from PC World, that's what Terry Child did, rather than what the media is saying he did. A rogue, disgruntled network admin locking down the network to cause chaos and mayhem.

http://www.pcworld.com/businesscenter/article/148669-1/the_story_behind_san_franciscos_rogue_network_admin.html

8 replies

by nicknielsen

I wouldn't be a bit surprised to find this is much closer to reality than the sensational stories I've been seeing until now.

by dr dij

but in the end these networks need to be managed by multiple people. As they said, 'what if he gets hit by a truck?'

(or my fav - I'll get hit by a beer truck on the way to the health food store :)

There needs to be managers who understand the network to the degree that they can make sure it is:
recoverable if anyone leaves / dies /etc
(him being the only one able to change things)
secure but not to the point of being unusable (not flashing configs, etc)

We had engr mgr of unix box who left on vacation for two weeks (to another country). He had not previously let anyone have admin password, and the box then became unusuable after problem (power out maybe, can't remember).

Finally we had to have his mgr tell him to give up the pwd or leave the company.

What would be the ideal setup? I guess that could vary depending on size and people employed in any setup. At least the managers should be trained to not let megalomaniac techies get out of control. On the other hand, if the network is so complicated that only one person can manage it and will crash if he lets someone else in then they need change control, documentation, automated testing, and quite possibly simplification. If he setup a complicated kludge just for brilliancy's sake that only he understands, that is worthless!

by captbilly1eye

The tricky part will be for his attorneys to convey those ideas to a jury or judge that have little to no understanding of networks, routers, switches, permissions and such. It will be far easier for the prosecution to paint him as a 'rogue control freak with a vendetta.'

by hal 9000

All the Defense has to do is emphasis the Security Aspect of this and from that point Child's is being Secure to the point of complete Paranoia maybe but after all when everything is said & done isn't that exactly what we expect these people to do?

After all if the M$ Security Principal was accepted as Good & Useful just how much data would be protected from Prying eyes? That one is a easy answer [b]NONE![/b]

So here we have an important Network that needs to be secured and that is exactly what has happened here it is so secure that no one but the person responsible for it can get in and make changes. Not my idea of an ideal system as if something happens to the controller there is no one who can go in and continue the work and keep it as secure.

Col

by hal 9000

Reporting elsewhere. Sounds much more like [b]Bad Management by people who just don't understand what is involved[/b] than a actual breach of the system.

If I was forced to work in a position like this I would behave exactly the same way to protect the integrity of the system particularly if I was the one who built it from scratch as it then would be my baby and my responsibility and working in a environment like that I would of course be convinced that no one else there wouldn't mess it up completely as they themselves wouldn't be well enough trained not to.

Still think it's strange behavior to Photograph a person that is doing a Security Audit unless of course it was CCT Coverage of the Secure Components of the Network that was being tampered with. Then it's not Child's actually photographing the person brought in but the Organization doing it and Child's just has access to the footage to see what was done to break the system that was working perfectly well before it was messed with.

Col

by leadfromthefront

What culpability does the media have in over reporting this story? Isn't it amazing how bad the writing and reporting is when you have non-technical people attempting to piece this together? I expect that within the week Bin Laden will somehow be linked to Terry Childs and we will have be the root cause of IndyMac going under. More importantly shouldn't the city attorney be held responsible for the obviously erroneous slant of the charges and wild bond amount? Kamala Harris is the biggest joke in the country right and this is just the latest instance. She is indicative of San Francisco's less than stellar city leadership and should be forced to resign when this case falls apart just like that clown in the Duke case.

by hal 9000

Is to the Stockholders or Owners and then they have to make as much money as possible with as little as possible being outlaid.

The Media has no responsibility to Report Accurate News just something that sells Newspapers or Advertising Space, to that end [b]Bad News Stories[/b] are always the best so if a thing can be read one or more ways it is always the Worst Case Scenario that the Media choses to report.

Of course this also works for the person bringing the charges against this guy when the case falls apart here and Child's is exonerated she and those feeding her information will be the fools wasting bulk amounts of Public Money and the Media in it's Self Rigorous Rage will hound these people just as badly. :D

So it just might do some good, but doing things this way is a massive waste of public funds which the Bureaucracy is very good at achieving. However I'm not holding my breath expecting any good outcome.

Col

by cg it

he didn't just one day get a bug up his butt and change em, the system was operating like that for quite some time. City management probably wanted access and Terry thinking that if someone who doesn't know anything mucks with the network down it will go [which it probably would]...He refused to let anyone get in for fear the whole City network would crash. probably will one they get in. From the email none of the configurations were saved to flash so.... they turn off the routers or reboot good bye network....

I've been faced with something similar. None network people with authority want access simply because they gotta prove their the big weenie... I gave them access and well...bam there goes the network.... did I get blamed? nope... documented everything...

This discussion is closed to new replies.