Discussion Locked

Tyranny of the offended

0 helpful
299 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

I am looking for understanding, not flames. Seriously. I do not know any Muslims who can explain things to me. My son is putting himself in harms way to help bring freedom to Muslims. I have a serious stake in understanding what is going on.

Muslims around the world are offended by cartoons and are making threats of boycotts and violence. I have been watching this unfold, wondering where it would lead and am very dissapointed at the reaction from the Muslim world.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/11097877/

If the media and the world gives in to the insane Muslim response then we will all have a much more difficult time in the future defending ourselves from anyone else who makes demands because they are "offended". Lots of things offend me, but I know that I cannot go around threatening people and governments over them.

Let me state that I do not believe that the Muslim reaction that is being shown in the media is the norm. However, where are the moderate Muslims denouncing the extremists? Someone, please, give me something to show me that there is reason and tolerance in the Muslim world.

When Pat Robertson stuck his foot in his mouth not too long ago with his insensitive remarks about Ariel Sharon, Christian moderates all over denounced what Robertson said. Is is possible that most Muslims believe that they should kill someone over a CARTOON? Take a look at the signs on Michelle Malkin's site...http://www.michellemalkin.com/

I do not understand how Muslims can seriously demand tolerance for themselves but will not tolerate anyone else. That is just plain delusional. All I can say is, support the Danish and anyone else who is not cowering down to threats.

299 replies

by dr dij

threatening to kill people for making fun of your religion threatening to kill people is simply re-enforcing stereotypes of many (not all) muslims as vicious intolerant terrorists.

the taliban spread their cause in afganistan by terror: join them and get rewarded with a wife and a couple acres, don't join them and die!

this is the yoke of religion using the common people. so in essence it is the fault of the mullahs in whipping up hatred. In the US we have separation of church and state. In the muslim world I'm hoping they can separate church and HATE!

by dmambo

I'm too lazy to look it up, but there was an artist who depicted a crucifix in a vile of urine. This guy had received money from the National Endowment for the Arts. There were demands that the NEA be abolished. That's about it - calls for the government to stop funding an agency. No fatwah, no asassinations.

Religion should be about love, not hate. I know next to nothing about Islam, but your questions about who's calling for calm and tolerance are right on the mark.

by mirrormirror

It was called "Piss Christ". That was offensive. But, it was called art and protected as freedom of expression.

I am having a hard time believing that Islam can be twisted to be so hateful. I have a harder time believing that so very many people in the world will stand by and allow extremists to take over their religion.

I am really hoping that there are sane Mulsims out there. Will they allow the world to be forced into conflict because they refuse to reign in the negative forces in their midst?

I know that you, DMambo, cannot answer my questions. But, I just have to ask them otherwise I will never know.

by jamesrl

In no way do I support anyone killing anyone, or issuing a fatwah or whatever for a comic.

These cartoons are inflamatory, no doubt. And they do nothing at all to contribute to generating understand and tolerance between Islam and other groups.

If you want to turn moderates into radicals, keep publishing this kind of thing, and you will succeed where are the terrorists have failed, by isolating western progressive muslims and making them identify more with their radical brothers than with their Christian next door neighbours.

And the Artist image is not an apt comparison - publishing a cartoon in a newspaper reaches potentially millions, and after it has been republished, tens of millions - and that does change the impact to the Muslim community.

But, and its a big but, the bigger evil would be to impose such strict censorship on everyone in the west that would prevent such things from being published.

Frankly what I have seen in reaction is not much condemnation for publishing such material. I don't believe that those picture on Malkin's website represent the views of the many progressive muslims living and working in my community. But in publishing that as the "muslim response" you further generalize and marginalize all muslims.

I'm not going to support the Danes for publishing cr@p. But I defend their right to do it.

James

by dr dij

I don't see how you can say this deserves an inflamatory response.

You are saying muslims 1) have no sense of humor, 2) it would turn moderates into radicals? only if they were really stupid or brainwashed. unhappily I see this reponse of violence to indicate that the radical muslims ARE brainwashed by oppressive religion (and oppressive govts as 45 of 47 muslim countries are considered dictatorships).

If someone published a cartoon about the Pope? So what! doesn't matter how widely it is read. I don't see catholics rioting or the country of Ireland asking for another country's apology.

To raid the danish embassy? really bizarre and stupid. Are the mullah's really stupid enuf to think the danish govt instigated this? or that denmark is a dictatorship like their country where the govt can force censorship (so as not to offend people)?

Get a life, radical muslims. If they tried to build their country as hard as they are trying to kill people they'd be happy people. Moderate muslims: rise up and stop these radical horrors from rotting your religion and turing it into a world war.

by jamesrl

I said I didn't support the inflamatory response, but nor do I think we should be publishing cartoons that are inflammatory in the first place. But thats a matter of taste, I don't advocate censorship either, but people have to understand and be responsible for their actions.

The publishing of an image of Mohamed is forbidden in the Koran. And Mohamed is not the Pope, he is closer to Jesus for them.

As for turning moderates into radicals, let me ask you - if you were part of a small minority in your country, and someone published cartoons mocking your religion, would you feel more or less likely to engage in a dialogue with those who are of the majority opinion. If you are honest and thoughful about it, you would feel isolated and not as much a part of the country.

I don't support raiding the embassy or calling for anyone's death, and I was very clear about that.

Don't make the mistake of thinking that Islam is organizaed like say the Catholic church, it isn't as hierarchical and there is a wide range of opinion in the different sects. There are no official spokespeople.

I've seen enough people here get enraged when someone makes a comment about Bush, this to them is far worse.

The more you harangue about Radical muslims, the more the moderates think you are slamming all muslims.

James

by montgomery gator

I do want to point out that some Muslim leaders are speaking out against the militant protests.

http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,183686,00.html

This article states: "In Iraq, the country's top Shiite cleric, Grand Ayatollah Ali al-Sistani, decried the drawings but did not call for protests.

"We strongly denounce and condemn this horrific action," he said in a statement posted on his Web site and dated Tuesday.

Al-Sistani, who wields enormous influence over Iraq's majority Shiites, made no call for protests and suggested that militant Muslims were partly to blame for distorting Islam's image.

He referred to "misguided and oppressive" segments of the Muslim community and said their actions "projected a distorted and dark image of the faith of justice, love and brotherhood."

Al-Sistani has been a voice of reason and moderation in Iraq, for the most part. He previously said that it was the duty of people of Iraq to vote in the elections instead of boycotting them.

by montgomery gator

I found what the militant Islamicists are doing to be offensive. The Danish flag has a cross, so that means they are burning a Christian symbol.

Also, I have some Danish ancestry, so I find it offensive for that reason.

And as an American, I support Denmark, because Denmark has been a very strong ally of the United States in the War on Terror, including the liberation of Iraq and the effort to defeat the terrorists there. We must stand strong with our Danish allies. Denmark is a nation of courage and strength, unlike the French and other weasel nations.

by jamesrl

...A couple of French and German newspapers re-published all of the cartoons.

James

by mjwx

I assume this support is not just for demark, but reaches unilaterally across all your allies.

If so might I say cheers.

by mirrormirror

I am so glad to hear that he is being reasonable. I can only hope that others will follow in his footsteps on this issue.

by tony hopkinson

Doesn't mean you accept being offended, it's means you don't go around offending people. Why did they need to use the prophet to make the joke ? They wanted a reaction they got one. Proved the radicals point and pissed off the moderates, so what's their agenda ?

Non muslims might find these cartoons funny, but that's because they aren't the butt of the humour isn't it.
Imagine the anger if a hundred and fifty years ago anyone had published a cartoon of Jesus as black or gay to make a point for toleration. People would have died, wouldn't they. Three hundred years ago they would have been in the dungeons in the vatican pointlessly begging for mercy while bits of them got pulled off with red hot pincers.
You've got to remember it's that sort of gap in 'advancement' of civilisation if not larger, that we are dealing with here.
Fundamentalist islamics decry us as corrupt, decadent and immoral. Christian clerics not too long back would have wholeheartedly agreed with them.
Might as well have taken a dump in a mosque, wiped their arse with their right hand and then gone around offering food to the people in there.

by mirrormirror

The literal definition of tolerance is:
a : sympathy or indulgence for beliefs or practices differing from or conflicting with one's own
b : the act of allowing something

And that is more of how I view tolerance. Not offending someone is just common sense. Especially now.

I can understand what you are getting at though. The Muslim fundamentalists sensibilities and common sense are stuck somewhere centuries in the past. I have to say that they need to catch up then. And fast! They are doing nothing good for modern and moderate Muslims. And, the media needs to seek out the moderate point of view as a counter point to the fundamentalist.

But, what about the Islamic cartoons that are anti-Jew, anti-American and anti-everything else? Since the culture engages in the same activity the fundamentalists are decrying, then that is hypocracy. It is ok for them but not ok for anyone else?

My son is left handed and in a Muslim country. He has had to learn to not do much with his left hand since he might offend someone. That is common sense and tolerance on my son's part. If they (Iraquis) were tolerant over there, wouldn't they understand (especially when TP can be found in the Middle East as well as soap and water) that there is nothing unclean about the left hand to Americans? That would be tolerant and common sense.

by tony hopkinson

However using your left hand to offer food or to touch somebody is sometimes used as a deliberate insult, by islamics who want to demean or to simply cause a fight. So they have to curb their inborn instinct in that regard, just as your son has to think about not using his left hand. It's as hard for them as it is for him.

These danish fools are a different matter entirely, they knew what they were doing, they did it deliberately, so whatever reaction they get is deserved. As long as it's against them, not some bus load of innocents who happen to be the same colour, nationality or creed.

It's no different to calling my missus a cow in front of me. I would n't automatically think someone was having a joke if they did that, I'd be thinking they wanted to chew on my right boot, they'd be getting their wish too.
It'd be too late to mumble "It was only joke " at that point.

by x-marcap

We have tolerated too much. The West has played nice in the hopes of not interrupting oil supplies. Since the Arabs want to interrupt the oil supplies creating price surges, there is no surprise that we have been too tolerant.

You must not have heard of a piece of performance art called Piss Christ.

The issue is not civilization, but nature. Islam in the early days did convert people by the sword. Didn't the followers of the Prophet do that to people as recently as last month in Somalia?

The violence started by Islamists may have become the kick off of the martialization of western civilization. Until militarism became popular in the West, there was little advancement of our own civilization. I hate to say thank you to them for anything except algebra and zero.

Tim

by Member 25348569

Freedom of Speech. One of the most precious rights that we have in the West. One of the rights that our forefathers fought and died for. OK, so I'm being a little ironic here but it is nice to be able to say what you want when you want. I do think, though, that what we say ought to be worth hearing.

So, what do they do with Free Speech (tm) in Denmark? They print a bunch of pathetic, childish - and they are pathetic and childish - cartoons lampooning the central figure of a religious group that they [b]know[/b] has no sense of proportion and certainly no sense of humour. Then everyone is surprised when the Muslims react the way they did. Then the French follow suit and print them too. With their Muslim population, they ought to know better.

The culture editor of the newspaper that first published the cartoons says he did not ask the illustrators to draw satirical caricatures of Muhammad. He asked them to draw the Prophet as they saw him. He has insisted that there is a long Danish tradition of biting satire with no taboos, and that Muhammad and Islam are being treated no differently to other religions. Well, if this is "biting satire" then the Danish define it differently to me! One of the cartoons depicted Mohammed with his turban in the shape of an Acme bomb, black, round with a fizzing fuse. How crap. I was looking around for the Road-Runner.

All that has been achieved is that the Muslims now know that if they burn a few flags and invade a couple of embassies they'll get editors fired and politicians apologising all over the place. The time may come when we have something really important to say to the Muslims but they'll remember this little escapade and probably not listen on an occasion when the might really need to pay attention to the message.

Funny old thing, freedom of speech. The leader of the Far-Right British National Party Nick Griffin was cleared just yesterday of incitement of racial hate charges declaring this was simply freedom of speech. Griffin was cleared despite saying that Islam was a violent faith and of describing Asians as evil and asylum-seekers as cockroaches.

So, the most right wing racist party in the UK can't even get convicted of racism. What a pathetic bunch [b]they[/b] are, too.

Still, at least I can say that. Thank you, forefathers.

Neil

by maxwell edison

.....blows people up in the name of their religion and in the name of their prophet Muhammad, it is THEY who should "know better", and it is THEY who are "pathetic".

by Member 25348569

of course I don't disagree with you but the Islamist bombers are a completely different subject.

I no problems with the [b]theory[/b] of Free Speech. The practicalities of it, however, are generally quite different. Most people take Free Speech to mean that they should be able to say exactly what they want with complete disregard for the accuracy of what they are saying and for the sensibilities of their audience. Most people also only want free speech for people who agree with them.

The Muhammed cartoons were crass - all of them. They were certainly not good satire. I'm not sure that countries that do not have a culture embracing satire would notice the difference. So - I ask again - why is anyone surprised at the reaction in Islamic countries? We've seen many times their tendency to react in ways that are totally alien to us. But it's what they do! It's [b]their[/b] culture in [b]their[/b] country. The problem is that incidents such as these cartoons will just result in more bombers. We're just not dealing with people who think like us.

They've gone a bit over the top in Syria, though.

We don't like them and they don't like us. It doesn't make us right. It doesn't make them right.

What has angered me, however, is that there was a demonstration in London on Friday with Muslim protestors carrying inflammatory placards advocating violence. This is illegal but the police made no arrests. I'd have put them all in the slammer straight away. What will really screw up relations in this country is when we see one law for the Muslims and one law for the rest of us.

I have no answers as to how we deal with Muslims. I don't understand them, either.

by jdclyde

you had four fathers? Here in the US we are able to do it with one! Much easier on the missus that way! :D

by m_a_r_k

[i]"The time may come when we have something really important to say to the Muslims but they'll remember this little escapade and probably not listen on an occasion when they might really need to pay attention to the message."[/i]

And the time may come when Muslims actually have something worthwhile to say and the rest of the world will remember this over-reaction and the hundreds of other over-reactions in the past. And just like the story of the boy who cried wolf, no one will pay attention. And that will send the Muslims into yet another blind fury and cause them to burn a few more more flags and torch a few more buildings.

by jdclyde

you are just suppose to feel guilty for the poor picked on and misunderstood Muslim. It is perfectly reasonable to go into a violent rage anytime something hurts your feelings.

Now just because any of us would be thrown in jail for committing an act of war by attacking the embassy of another country, we are suppose to (like Neil pointed out) give the poor savages special concideration and not hold them to the same laws as the rest of the CIVILIZED world.

by av .

I saw the cartoons and they are in poor taste, but Muslim fundamentalists don't need much of a reason to be violent and shed blood in retaliation anyway. They hate everyone that isn't a Muslim - all in the name of the Prophet Mohammed. Its absolutely scary to me because they don't value human life. Moderate muslims, and not just the ones from America, need to strongly condemn the violence. We all live in this world together and Muslims need to become more tolerant of the rest of us.

I know the most tasteless thing to do is make fun of someone's God in a cartoon, but isn't beheading someone on video while wearing a mask absolutely beyond words? How about suicide bombers?

The fundamentalist Muslims have gone totally mad. Moderate Muslims everywhere need to condemn them. I always thought that Muslims were supposed to be peaceful, devout people; but these last few years have changed my mind. I'd like not to believe that the majority of Muslim people share their views.

I wish the media would give more time to moderate Muslim opinions to help people understand that their religion is more than just hatred of everyone else who isn't a Muslim. Thanks to you and your son for bringing freedom to a Muslim land that doesn't know what freedom means. I hope it is a beacon of light in the darkness for them and a better world for all of us in the future.

by montgomery gator

I really enjoyed the ones done as a response to the original controversy, particularly the one entitled "Mohammed the Prophet Answers your E-mails 54".

The medieval one from Bologna's Church of San Petronio is also interesting. Call me politically incorrect if you must, but this portrayal is much like how I imagine the fate of the prophet.

by jdclyde

vs responsiblitiy of the press.

What was the point of intentionally insulting people you already know are criminally insane? To show you can?

There was no benifit of showing burned bodies hanging from bridges. An act carried out by the same criminally insane people.

There was no benifit of showing the humiliation tactics in the military prisions (no, it was NOT "torture", torture was criminally insane muslims that cut peoples heads off)

Why reprint this same intentionally insulting "cartoon"? Again, just to show you can?

I agree that the same Muslims that WANT tolerance are completely incapable of GIVING tolerance to anyone else and thus UNDESERVING of it for themselves.

Around the world people, we are seeing the true face is Islam. The wild-eyed distruction that takes very little to set it off, not the moderates peacefully expressing their displeasure at this deliberate insult to all muslims.

It is sad anyone that makes ANY excuses for the criminal behavior on a global setting.

Yes, dumbasses will continue to intentionally insult other people with their "satire". To bad this tool "satire" is as funny and sensitive as starting to tell black jokes or polock jokes. Nothing quite so funny as a good slave joke, right? Freedom of speech allows you to be an idiot. That doesn't mean you HAVE to be that idiot.

Progressives of the world, you are that idiot.

Fundimentalist of the world that react violently to the idiots are criminals and should be dealt with as such. You destroy an embasy, that is an act of war on that country.

Quit making excuses for either the satireist or the rioting scum of the world. Neither represent what is good in freedom of speech, nor the Islamic faith, but rather they are showing us the worst of the worst.

by maxwell edison

(Disclaimer: I know I'm grouping ALL press together, which is obviously a flawed view, but only for the sake of discussion.....)

My dilemma: I despise both sides -- The radical Muslims who invite and condone violence, and the press who, in this case, incite violence. It begs the question, what else might the press incite?

It's no secret around here what I think of the press, in general, and the freedoms they take with the truth. (Note: Actually, in this case, I think the press is right-on. Thus, my further dilemma.) They get away with things that would otherwise be libel, slander and defamation, all in the name of freedom of the press. The obvious answer is a regulated press, but that's even worse.

In my opinion, Neil, you have a more critical view of the United States and our current president because of an irresponsible and inaccurate press inciting ____ (fill in the blank). And what really gets my goat is when you and/or people like you apply a dual standard to the press. You think they're irresponsible, in this case, but you give them a free pass in others. (Am I doing the same thing? Am I getting my own goat?) The press has defamed our president, for example, in your country (and in mine as well), shown him in an inaccurate light, but you "believe it", so to speak.

Not too long ago there were some absolutely disgusting editorial cartoons depicting Dr.Condalisa Rice (current Secretary of State and former National Security Advisor) dripping with racist stereotypes and slurs. Well, the press gave the press a free pass on this one. Why is that? What if they would have depicted Maxine Waters in such a way? (I realize that you probably don't know who Maxine Waters is.) The New York Times actually ran the Condalisa Rice cartoons, but that same newspaper would have surely condemned the Washington Times had that newspaper done a similar thing with Maxine Waters.

(Reference for those who don't know: http://www.house.gov/waters/ - Democrat Representative from California.)

I just can't decide if "they" are doing more harm than good.

I guess I'm in the same boat as you in this case, Neil. Except, of course, I'll apply my disgust with the press equally, in all cases, not selectively. At least I try to. (Or my dilemma, maybe I'm not!)

However, I'll fall on the side of the press on this one. Not only is it an accurate depiction of what's going on in the world, but those who are targeted are actually proving it to be true.

by Member 25348569

I have a "more critical view of the United States and our current president" not necessarily because of the press but because of the ill-considered reaction to 911. Tony Blair is even more culpable in this by the way because, under British law, the invasion of Iraq was probably illegal. But that's all for other discussions.

Most goverments, yours and mine included, find it useful on occasions to foment hatred of a particular internal or external target for political expediency. Islamic governments use The West with particular reference to the USA although their more ignorant population now probably think that Denmark is one more of the States. Your government currently use, nominally, International Terrorists but everybody knows you mean radical Islam. That's interpreted by some of your citizens as any person with a turban.

Unfortunately, you/we invaded a Muslim country (still there) and then we invade another one and impose our ideas of democracy on them. Then we shout and stamp our feet at a third Muslim country for wanting to do what we all already do - have nuclear plants and weapons - whilst at the same time we ignore North Korea. Doesn't anyone realise how much more easy, more obvious that demonisation of The West and the USA becomes. I also have to admit that it actually starts to seem legitimate for Muslims to fear the west! As an aside, I would suspect that the majority of the riots are government instigated although some of those governments are probably a bit upset at how out of hand it's all got.

None of the press here published any of the cartoons in question and I don't think that any will, now. I'm going to wait and see what the reaction is to the demonstrations here - especially the one of Friday and I'm hoping for some serious condemnation of the Muslims who demonstrated and the police who let them do it. As for hitting at political figure. Here, anyone is game but I would normally expect the government of the day and its members to be the primary target so, in the case you mentioned, Ms Rice would be the logical target here. We have our partisan press here, too, although most are anti- the current government and many more are right rather than left-wing (our right!). The press are out to sell papers and it's the government that people are interested in.

by x-marcap

I am a conservative ex-Marine captain...

What I have percieved is that the press is anti-conservative no matter where they come from... Bush said much of what Clinton did on the same info. Clinton gets a pass and to call Bush a liar without getting gigged by the press. Clinton is probably a rapist, certainly a perjurer, and he is loved by the majority of the press.

Truth is in short supply, or slanted when gleaned from the mass media outlets. Slander such as Bush lost in 2000 has not been punished... The point is we have an Electoral college for many good reasons. The press doesn't know how to read about it. The court selected Bush... The Florida Supreme court tried to unfairly pull a quick one in heavily Democratic areas. The answer was to allow all military votes, not have their votes wait until they would not be counted. (They should have been counted as being absentees)not flushed as Dems around Florida petitioned. The final military vote put Bush firmly ~5000 ahead. There was a large ~4500 majority for Bush that had been mobilized to the Enterprise and the Independence Sunday before the election...

Pensacola Marines will now vote absentee...

by jdclyde

Read that article and you will be able to.

Big time back stepping going on, and none of it sounds true.

They probably all had a big laugh at how clever they are in their "satire" (translation - hate) cartoons. They have been able to say all kinds of hateful things before and hide behind the shield of the press to say it is ok for them to be hateful jerks.

Can anyone else say "the Satanic Verse"?

by jaqui

It's not all Muslims that are offended, or making such threats, it's the extremists. [ the fringe elements ]

When the Western Press report such as being typical of Muslims, the PRESS become liable for the religous war that follows.

An Article of the Muslim Faith is that if they die in defense of the faith they are guaranteed heaven. By dropping bombs on a Muslim country, you start a "Holy War" where every ciisen will fight to the death, because they are "Defending the Faith."

Blaming all Muslims for the actions of terroists is like blaming all of christianity for the Spanish Inquisition. [ it was only the Roam Catholics that were driving it. Started by the Spanish branch, hense the name, but adopted by Rome as official Church Policy and Procedure after a few years ]

and no, the Crusades were the British Baptists, not all of Christianity, and it also was a war with Islam [ like Bush started ]

by jdclyde

They just shouldn't be allowed to go into a rage over an offense. It is good that they are better than that.

And yes, the main question to ask is, what exactly would be gained by attacking anyone elses religion? And that is EXACTLY what started this all, an attack. It isn't being some great hero to sit back and call people names or tease people. They decided to tease the rabid dog that they already knew would bite and then act surprised that the dog bit again.

Now the brave "artists" are in hiding, fearing for their own pathetic lives because they thought it would be great sport to tease the cur.

Two editors in jail so far, a good start.

by montgomery gator

Why is that good? The Jordanian editors were jailed for reproducing the cartoons. To jail them violates freedom of press. To say it is OK for Jordan to violate freedom of the press holds them to a lesser standard than that held to the USA and the European democracies.

by montgomery gator

The Baptists did not exist at the time of the Crusades. They started with the Anabaptists in Switzerland following the teachings of Zwingli, during the Protestant Reformation in the 16th century.

The Crusades was declared by the Pope in the 1090s. The first Crusades were mainly Germans and French, and they captured Jerusalem from the Turks. The British (actually the English) did not get involved in large numbers until the Third Crusade under Richard the Lionhearted (in response to Jerusalem being conqured by Saladin), but they were all under the authority of the Pope and the Church of Rome, not the Baptists. The only "Crusades" that Baptists have been involved with are evangelical efforts and large mutimedia events designed to bring the message of hope and salvation through Jesus, such as the "Billy Graham Crusades".

The movie "Kingdom of Heaven" is actually a reasonably accurate (if dramatized) depiction of the events leading up to and including the capture of Jerusalem between the 2nd and 3rd Crusades by Saladin. The only major innacuracy in the movie was the siege of Jerusalem. The city did surrender to Saladin after he guaranteed them free passage to Crusader cities on the coast (as portrayed in the movie). The people of Jerusalem were able to negotiate their surrender by threatening to destroy the Dome of the Rock (an Islamic holy site) unless Saladin allowed them to leave the city unharmed (as portrayed in the movie). But there was no actual attack of the city as protrayed in the movie before the surrender. But a siege with giant trebuchets firing flaming projectiles and armies storming the walls make for a much more dramatic and exciting film than a bunch of diplomats negotiating a surrender.

by mirrormirror

Did you ask your Muslim friends why there is not more of them standing up to the extremists? If they don't do it then Muslim extemism runs rampant. If we (meaning non-Muslims) stand up to extremists in any way at all, then we are attacking all Muslims. This is a no-win situation for all non-Muslims. How do we turn this into a win-win situation? Please ask your friends for me.

by jaqui

"Church matter". the Imans are responsible for bringing the extremists in line.

and if done right, anyone who is not "of islam" can bring them to justice. the only way to do so that will stop the extremists from gathering recruits:

surgically remove their right hands, then return them to their home country.
in Islamic beleifs, using your left hand to feed yourself is a deadly sin.
[ it's the "hand of Shaitan" used only for cleaning privy parts. { aka wiping your a$$ after going to the bathroom } ]

By leaving them without a right hand for commiting an act of terrorism, you are stating that their actions were influenced by the devil, making the extremists a very unattractive option.
[ to add insult to injury,, they only get pork to eat while in custody, since pork is not an allowed food in islam ]

make sure that it is well broadcast that anyone of islam found guilty of any terrorist activities will be treated so, and they will, by the laws of islam, be killed when returned home.
the rest of islam cannot take offense, as no-one not of islam took the life of someone from islam. you only made it clear that the terrorist activities are inspired by the devil, in terms that the church must respond to.

and guess what, I did actually send this to the White house, within a week of 9-11. the actual war on terrorism is only creating more people motivated to become terrorists.

by m_a_r_k

The cartoon was in poor taste. It was certain to offend a whole class of people. But this is certainly not the first or last time a whole class of people (race, religion, whatever) have been or will be offended. Burning down buildings because some wise guy drew a cartoon? Isn't that a bit of an over-reaction? I could see a 3-year old getting upset like that. Or someone who's been living in a cave for the last thousand years. They're a bunch of close-minded, intolerant, egotistical, backward idiots. All "infidels" should be killed, huh? Yeah, whatever. Those morons blame the west for all their self-inflicted problems. They should find a hobby, read books other than the Koran for a change, get an education, find a job and earn an honest living, raise a family and take a bit of responsibility for themselves instead of expecting the world to kiss their ass.

I'm a Christian. I don't burn down a building or rant about evil infidels when someone I don't know and never met says something offensive about Jesus. I don't care if someone else thinks the Easter Bunny is the supreme being. To each his own. Just don't try to cram your beliefs down my throat. And don't sentence me to death if I tell you that the Easter Bunny doesn't lay eggs.

by Member 25348569

Admit it. OK. So all of the Muslims still to burn it down but I bet I could find a few Christians who'd be in there with the matches if they thought they'd get away with it.

by jdclyde

It is exactly that kind of appling logic to a problem that angers them so.

You aren't suppose to THINK or remember. You are suppose to just feel bad that the Muslim nations of the world which SHOULD be the most prosperous because of their oil, are all dirt poor and have no reason to live. That is why some idiot will blow himself up to get to paradise because they are living a hell now. (thanks entirely to THEIR leaders, not oppression from ANY outside forces.)

Why do the mindless masses hate the US? Because it is easier to keep the mindless in line if they have a common enemy OTHER than their own governments so they are fed this crap locally and being the good brainwashed masses they are, they believe it. Yes, it is the fault of the evil US that they are all so poor and have no prospects.

Or so we would be led to believe.

No, I guess I don't have any sympathy for scumbags of any walk of life that go on violent rampages, from the riots in Detroit to these latest rampages because the poor stupid muslim got his feelings hurt. A criminal is a criminal, and we see that a large part of the muslims in the world are criminally insane.

by Member 25348569

I'll try and confirm where I read it but the idea of Paradise for the martyr is not the only incentive. The main incentive for suicide bombers - certainly in Palestine - is a promise from their controllers that their families will be looked after. The promise of fifteen virgins is hardly going to entice a teenage girl to kill herself.

This doesn't explain the London suicide bombers though who were all apparently perfectly normal guys from Leeds.

Another fact that's probably not really been grasped. They aren't all Arabs, you know, The largest muslim countries don't have oil. Indonesia at 200m, Pakistan at 160m and Bangladesh at 130m. India has 150m Muslims but there, at least, they mostly keep their heads down.

by m_a_r_k

Ooops! This will just give Muslims yet another reason to riot. As if they need that. But Jaqui, you got it wrong too. wikipedia spells it "qur'an". And of course wikipedia is never wrong. "Koran" is a transliterated spelling, whatever transliterated means.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Koran:
[i]"The Qur'an (literally "the recitation"; also called "The Noble Qur'an"; also transliterated [u]Quran[/u], [u]Koran[/u], and less commonly Alcoran) is the holy book of Islam. Muslims believe that the Qur'an is the literal word of God in Arabic and the culmination of God's revelation to mankind, revealed to Muhammad, the final prophet of Islam, over a period of 23 years through the angel Jibreel (Gabriel)."[/i]

by jdclyde

most Christians today use lighters.

I have the marshmellows! :D

The roof, the roof, the roof is on fire,
The roof, the roof, the roof is on fire,
The roof, the roof, the roof is on fire,
We don't need no water let the motherf####r burn,
Burn motherf####r burn.
[i]by the BLOODHOUND GANG

by montgomery gator

Denmark is courageous because they are part of the coalition in Iraq, fighting for freedom and against the terrorists, unlike France or Germany.

You misunderstood my post. Crow seems to be on your plate. :-)

by montgomery gator

"They've gone a bit over the top in Syria, though."
==============
Yep, burning the Danish embassy is over the top, and that is an understatement. Burning an embassy is an act of war. Denmark, a member of NATO, has had its sovereign territory (its embassy) attacked in Syria. NATO must do its duty and stand strong with Denmark. NATO must put pressure on Syria to make amends for this action, or face NATO sanctions. NATO must unite behind Denmark and threaten military action if necessary against Syria. I hope that it would not result in military action against Syria, that Syria will make reparations to Denmark, but we must stand strong with Denmark if necessary.

Acceptable amends by Syria, would be, in my opinion:
1. A full apology for allowing the mob to burn down the Danish embassy
2. Bringing the instigators and the members of the mob to justice.
3. Monetary payments to Denmark to pay for the damage to the embassy.

by Member 25348569

Trust me, it won't unless your Prez goes even more barmy than last time. You are immediately ramping up the conflict with some sort of implication that the burning was instigated by the Syrian government. Although they may have not discouraged - or even encouraged - the riots I cannot believe that their government would have wished the embassies of two European nations be burned.

Go on then, lets all invade the f*ckers. That's what you usually do isn't it? A quick hop over the border from your Middle East base in Iraq.

What does Denmark want? Let's find out what they're after before you head on in with the cluster bombs.

by x-marcap

Those who don't study History are doomed to repeat it. Go read some Clauswitz...

War is nothing but a continuation of politics with the admixture of other means.

Tim

by x-marcap

I know about tens of thousands of pounds, Kilos for Euro types of Poison Gas Pre-cursers caught between Iraq and Syria.

Why doesn't NATO (US,CANADA,GB,Turkey,etc)rally to end these acts of war? NATO hasn't actually stomped on a Muslim Country, since Turkey joined.
Does that have a significance? The Turks and the Kurds didn't like Iraq, but Turkey didn't allow Kurds to relocate away frome Husein...

by maxwell edison

.
In his recent book, [i]Inside CentCom: The Unvarnished Truth About the Wars in Afghanistan and Iraq[/i], General DeLong reveals some stunning opinion about those "missing" WMDs.

http://www.command-post.org/oped/2_archives/015496.html

Everyone should read the book, or at least read the transcripts of some of the interviews he's given.

It's quite chilling to consider the bigger picture. I can't help but believe that more is known about this than we are privy to, but it just can't be released for public consumption.

by Member 25348569

I never said that they should be given special treatment. I am absolutely livid that Friday's London demonstration by Muslims carrying placards inciting murder was not stamped on hard and all of them arrested and prosecuted. It was against UK law and the police's softly-softly approach will, in the end, be couter-productive.

However, in the case of Gaza, Syria, etc, like it or not, it's [b]their[/b] law and [b]their[/b] country. If the people, even the authorities in any Muslim country choose to do something you don't like on their own soil then all you can do is go and firebomb the Syrian Embassy.

I suppose that you could invade them. Personally, I favour nuking Mecca to radioactive glass...

by sleepin'dawg

you caught them at the height of the Hajj season, which, if I remember correctly is around Ramadahn, which I think, almost coincides with Passover. I probably have that all mixed up but you get the idea; nail as many of them as we can. I however, wouldn't want to waste good plutonium, which would go a long way in fueling some Iranian power plants. I'd prefer the use of several of those airburst aerosol petroleum bombs, using Saudi oil naturally, to burn them all to hell. That would be more fitting given their penchant for the fire bombings of embassies and whatnot.

You might even want to consider buying all those peaceful Muslims I saw demonstrating in London on TV, a day or so ago, a oneway ticket to Mecca. Think of it as the UK government practicing some religious toleration and helping all those poor downtrodden Muslims complete their Hajj, which every Muslim is supposed to do at least once in their lives. No need to purchase round-trip tickets, they won't be returning, if everything goes according to plan. Hey, can it still be called sarcasm if you mean it??? ;\ :^O

It was nice seeing all the bobbies enfocing UK law so assiduously. I would like to say it makes one's heart pump purple piss with pride to know his ancestors had the great and good sense to be from over there but then you might think I was being sarcastic. Good thing my ancestors weren't Russian or they'd have ended up standing before firing squads or getting gunned down on the streets. Now, there's an idea. Send them over to Canada and turn them all loose in downtown (edited, from downtrodden) Toronto. I'm sure the gangbangers would welcome them for target practice. It would make the gangbangers into contributing members of Torontonian, if not Canadian, society.

Geez, multiple scores on the old sarcasm meter. Not too bad even, if it was a touch infantile.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by montgomery gator

I may consider you to be a godless Heathen, but I would not want to burn down your house. You seem like the kind of guy who would offer me a beer even though we disagree on much, and that we could have a very heated, but friendly discussion of the issues in the pub. :-)

by Member 25348569

Not yet, anyway. I'm enjoying the debate too much. How can I insult a man who is offering me beer?

:D

Tomorrow. I'll be nice to you tomorrow.

Or maybe Tuesday.

by montgomery gator

Is that better? :-)

No, just because you disagree with me doesn't make you a wanker. However, I reserve the right to call you a wanker if we ever do meet face to face, and it turns out you are one after all. :-)

by Member 25348569

Woah! Back off a minute!

It is illegal in Jordan to insult religion under their press and publications law. Whether you or I think that is right or wrong - and I, as an atheist, couldn't give a damn about any religion - it is, nonetheless, their law. For you to decide that they somehow have a lesser standard than "The Land of the Free" is incredibly arrogant.

by jdclyde

to hold them to NO standards, just like we do here in North America. We should have no standards and let them do as they wish, because they are the PRESS!

We have seen in the last few years that this is painfully so. Stories going out without any accountability to the facts AND no consideration on weighing the publics right to know vs the damage that will happen if you do.

With these hateful biggoted cartoons, we have found out just how much damage they can do.

NOTE: "the profit" with a bomb on his head? Not funny, and not terribly clever.

by montgomery gator

To say that it is OK for Jordan to violate Freedom of the Press holds the Jordanian government to a lesser standard than the government of the USA and the European democracies. It is not arrogant to stand up for freedom of the press and speech. To say that it is OK for Jordan to oppress their media outlets but not OK for Western democracies is saying that Jordanians are not worthy of freedom, and that is truly arrogant. Europeans and Americans are not superior to Jordanians and other Arabs. They are just as worthy of freedom as we are.

by jck

Freedoms that citizens have in any country are determined by the law of that country...not the emotion of the world.

In most Islamic states, "law of man" is intricately intertwined, to various stringency, with the "law of Allah".

If they are being held accountable to the law of their country, then it is legal and an right exerted by the law enforcement of that country to arrest them for a legal offense...whether we condone it or not.

Most of Europe thinks our death penalty is barbaric and outlandish, but we're not suiting our law to fit their standards...are we?

I agree with my "dad", the right honourable gentleman NeilB from Britain.

It is somewhat arrogant to think they do not have true freedom simply because their law does not facilitate our ideological concept of freedom, and our rights are not what is granted under their legal system.

And besides, they are welcome to come to the USA and have more freedoms if they so desire. Millions do it a year.

by sleepin'dawg

hellbent on proving otherwise.
Arabs(s) has now almost become synonymous with, barbaric, uncivilized, reactionary, fundamentalist, terrorist, racist, Muslim, scumbags; need I go on.
An Arab: one, who upon attaining puberty, removes his diaper from his butt and wraps it around his head. Upon completing that ceremony, he jumps upon his camel and rides off in all directions, one of which is to become a taxi driver in France or some other supposedly civilized nation of the west. Dumb gets as dumb is, if you don't mind my paraphrasing Forest Gump.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

freedom of the press is not and should not be a permit to do as you wish.

There is a law here, "Incite to riot". If you intentionally inflame a situation till there is a riot they YOU can be held accountable for YOUR actions.

There is no freedom or benifit to anyone to make hateful cartoons, even if you hide behind the word "satire". This shouldn't be condoned any more than the klan doing the same thing against blacks and asians here. Last week there was two asswipes brought up on charges of ethinic intimidation for putting lighting a cross in a families front yard. I was surprised that would still happen today.

It is the same kind of hate that serves no purpose, and if there is no value then it should be condemned for the hateful expression that it is.

This was definately incitement to riot.

But I am not saying the actual rioters should be cut ANY slack either. lock them all up together like one big hateful family.

by dr dij

at least the bulk of those who rioted were in countries where it was not published.

and if you'd re-read my post I specifically harangued only radical muslims. so we should just ignore radical muslims, hoping they'll go away, because we might offend moderates? that is the 'tyrrany of the offended'.

anyway, if I was a small minority, and the cartoon didn't advocate violence against me, I'd think it was dumb and say 'so what?' didn't you ever hear 'sticks and stones will break my bones but words will never hurt me?'

so there are equivalents here: images of jesus in art gallery in non-flattering way. Am I going to riot? no. We have blasphemy laws in some states and last person to be prosecuted was in something like 1933 and it was overturned (see wikipedia entry on this event with links to history of free speech, blasphemy laws, etc.

by m_a_r_k

[i]"It is somewhat arrogant to think they do not have true freedom simply because their law does not facilitate our ideological concept of freedom, and our rights are not what is granted under their legal system."[/i]

How can it be arrogant to to think they do not have true freedome when they are so prejudiced against women's rights? Basically, women have no rights at all in some Muslim parts of the world. Is that freedom? Or even worse, how about the areas that are under control of fundamentalists which espouse the same regulations that the Taliban did? Is it true freedom when you cannot listen to the kind of music that you want to? Or read a book written by a non-Muslim?

by jdclyde

as long as they weren't unfortunate enough to be more a woman.

Again, who are we to judge?

by absolutely

Babble

Bible

Who's offended now?

Burning a cross is considered inherently threatening, although when I burn crosses I'm only expressing my contempt for the christian superstition. Every religion is irrational. Islam is not even uniquely violent among religions. It just happens to be the state religion in the region where the psychotic criminal bin Laden began, and where the resource petroleum is located, motivating manipulative powers to take advantage of the irrationality of some "common people". Islam just happens to be the variety of irrationality practiced most in the Middle East. If there were petroleum reserves in Europe instead, we might have Protestant suicide bombers exploding in Greek Orthodox neighborhoods, or vice versa, instead of Muslims exploding in Jewish neighborhoods.

by jdclyde

that it is the oil that has made them the religious fanatics that the rest of the CIVILIZED world see?

This is a flawed theory. (oh, not offended by the booble babble in the least).

In CIVILIZED parts of the world that ALSO have oil (Canada, US) the people are not religious fanatics that go around killing anyone but fetuses and abortion doctors. oh wait, that isn't religious fanatics that kill the fetuses......

Oil is NOT what the problem it. Living in a country where the RULERS are corrupt while blaming everything on the US is their problem. It isn't the US buying oil that makes the standard of living so low there. if anything, that SHOULD make this the most prosperous place on the face of the planet, instead of the pit it is.
[b]
My theory is, the number one thing that the muslims HATE about the US, is our crazy idea of equal rights for women and the empowerment of them. What were we thinking, treating people as equals? Oh wait, that WAS a good idea!

by absolutely

You misrepresent my assertion.

"In CIVILIZED parts of the world that ALSO have oil" there was civilization before the oil was found. That is the difference, not any religious superiority of christianity over islam. The west discovered oil because industry had advanced enough that a better fuel than coal was needed. At the time that oil was discovered in the Middle East, there was no similar industry, and the wealth of oil was dropped like manna from heaven on them. It displaced their economy, and their entire society, through the corrupt actions of opportunists like the Sauds. Islam is the tool those corrupt opportunists use. Christianity was equally effective for stirring masses of people to a moronic frenzy during the Crusades, the Inquisition and the Salem witch trials.

Muslim fanatics don't perform abortions. I welcome you to emigrate to Saudi Arabia if women's right to abortion bothers you.

by tonythetiger

How many Muslims actually read the cartoon themselves, as opposed to having it shown to them by another Muslim (whose intent, obviously, is to inflame and enrage)? How many are protesting and participating in the violence who never saw it at all? Finally, if you know something is offensive, why would you deliberately offend another person with it?

by tonythetiger

But when somebody cuts me off in traffic, it would make more sense to follow them and beat them up than it would for me to go home and kick my own dog!

by montgomery gator

Cheers in return. Yes, I believe the USA should come to the support of our allies, and vice versa.

I am a strong supporter of Australia, also. Your country has been a very good ally of the USA. American and Australian troops have fought together in many wars, from WWI to the current wars in Iraq and Afghanistan.

And I am glad we now have Japan as a good ally instead of the situation over 60 years ago, when the USA and Australia (along with the UK, NZ, and a few other nations) had to fight Japan.

Now, lets hope we can continue to develop and strengthen the alliance with India, also. They are well on the way to becoming a major power, and could be a good ally of both Australia and the USA.

And I hope the new prime minister of Canada can help strengthen the strained relations between them and the USA.

by m_a_r_k

I read an interesting article in the newspaper a couple of days ago that summarizes the problems facing Middle East now and, even worse, in the future.

65% of the Middle East's population is under 25 years of age. The region's under-25 age group is the fastest growing under-25 age group of any region in the world. The Middle East's unemployment rate is 15%. Just to keep pace with their population growth, they must create 100 million new jobs by 2020--nearly doubling today's total employment. That pace of job growth would be twice what the U.S.'s was during the boom years of the late '90s. China and India are already creating tons of jobs. Will there be any room at all in world economic growth for the Middle East to create new jobs?

Half of the Middle East's unemployed are between 15 and 24 yrs of age. 65 million adult Arabs are illiterate. Two-thirds of them are women. A World Bank study shows that a woman working raises family incomes by 25%, lifting millions of families across the world out of poverty. Half of all Arab women are illiterate. 10 million Arab children between 6 and 15 yrs of age are not enrolled in any schooling. This number is expected by 40% over the next decade.

The Middle East region accounts for a measly 2% of world exports and attracts less than 2% of foreign investment.

They have big problems. Unfortunately, their religion encourages them to focus the blame elsewhere rather than upon themselves.

by mirrormirror

So, if this is a church matter, then are the Imans doing anything about the extremists? Are the Imans urging calm to the masses? I know that it has been reported that some Imans are using the cartoons to incite more violence. Hopefully this is a minority of Imans doing this.

Are you saying that the western world should step aside and let Islam deal with the extremists? If so, there are a bunch of Imans who need to get to work.

Or, are you saying that the western world can bring these people to justice by cutting off their right hand and feeding them only pork, then returning them home? So far the western world cannot do anything to a Muslim (extremist or not) without being accused of torture.

And, do you mean that the everyday Muslim does not understand the word terrorism does not equal Islam? We have an issue with terrorists not Islam. Don't they have an issue with terroists too? If so, then they need to stop the terrorists.

I'm sorry. The statment you have given leads to more questions.

And, as far as the war on terrorism creating more terroists...I think that what we are seeing now has been there all along. We have simply called attention to and exposed the extremist/terrorist world and it's church led and government led enablers to the light of day.

by x-marcap

The US with our oceans protecting us for 150 years has now the habit of getting into a war late.

1. We should have stopped Hitler in Poland.
2. We should have stopped Japan at their incursions into China in 1937.
3. We should have aided France in Vietnam.
4. We should have crossed the Yalu river and kicked the North Koreans and the Chicoms into the stone age.

This is in just a 15 year period. The mistakes are being repeated over and over...

Tim

by Member 25348569

The Germans would have whipped your asses in Poland.

Two things that contributed to the German defeat were the Russians entering the war against the Germans - which they weren't at the time of Poland - and the Battle of Britain which stopped any German invasion of Britain. When you entered the war it was exactly the right time and you had the opportunity to tool up your war materiel factories and train your men with a secure base.

[b]Then[/b] you could move into France and beyond. Up against the Wermacht in 1939, you'd have been buried just like we and the French were!

The Vietcong whipped you and the French separately and would have done you together.

The only way to have defeated China would have been to nuke them. There are rather too many of them What you got in treaty terms was the best you could have got.

Dream on...

by jdclyde

recent battles were lost is because of dumbass politicians armchairing the war and not wanting to look like bullies so they launched a "limited campaign".

Forced to fight a jungle war by city rules. Never work.

by maxwell edison

I'm not a war historian by any stretch of the imagination. But I do know (or believe) this. With 100 percent support at home, I don't believe there's any enemy we couldn't defeat. We did not have 100 percent support at home during Vietnam, nor do we have it against radical Islam.

And don't misinterpret my meaning, either. By saying there's no enemy we couldn't defeat, I don't say that in the sense of attempting to dominate and/or oppress, and/or permanently occupy a land. We just don't do that.

If Vietnam had been waged with the same resolve that the USA and Britain showed in W.W.II, the outcome would have been vastly different. And if the current war against radical Islam were waged with the same resolve the USA and Britain showed in W.W.II, things would be different even today.

Opposition at home actually results in the unintended consequence of providing an ally to the very enemy we're fighting. And we can't fight an enemy with unwavering resolve if we're fighting amongst ourselves.

When a war becomes yet another pawn on the chess board of political expediency, there's going to be a lot of losers. And if we don't win this war against radical Islam, it won't be because we couldn't, but because we didn't want to do it at the expense of overlooking political expediency. Without the 100 percent resolve, the best we can hope for is a stalemate. (And it's not too late to rally behing the "cause" of defeating radical Islam.)

by jdclyde

And yes, there are acceptions, but in most cases:

Democrats:
people that believe in casual abortions are generally against capital punishment, yet FOR "mercy killings".

Republicans:
The other way around is also true, but they believe in aborting OVER devoloped fetuses, not under developed, and also fear abuse with mercy killings.

Dems - Capital punishment = afraid of a mistakes and abuse.
Rep - Mercy Killings = afraid of mistakes and abuse.

(funny how Dems relate more with criminals than the elderly?)

Democrats:
very vocal about invasion of privacy, civil rights, and freedom of speech, yet would have every one of my guns melted down in a second if they could legally get away with it.

Republicans:
Stay out of my home, equal rights and freedom of speech, yet the second amendment is respected as well as the first.

Democrats:
Raise taxes on the rich. Not because it is fair, but because "they can afford it".
Remove all taxes on the poor poor. Because it isn't fair that they don't have anything.

Republicans:
If you work hard to advance yourself, you should be able to enjoy the rewards of your own hard work.

If I lived in Saudi Arabia, I would have also been able to save myself a LOT of money on my divorce thanks to the ability to just bury her up to her neck and throw rocks at her until she is dead dead dead. What fun? Key word I used, civilized. The muslim states do NOT advance their civilization, and then blame the US for their problems.

by jdclyde

that ACLU and all the bleeding hearts out there that say America DESERVED to be attacked on 911 would NEVER allow this to happen.

"Cruel and unusual punishment" and "religious violations" would be foaming from their hate filled mouths.

But I do agree that it IS only right to counter people by following their own beliefs. I just know that screaming liberals would NEVER allow this to happen.

by montgomery gator

Saddam sent the WMDs to Syria. The attack on the Danish embassy should be a rallying cry to our the USA and our allies to pressure Syria to give up the WMDs or we will take them away from Syria.

by Member 25348569

At least I spell it correctly...

Describe, with or without annotated diagrams, what you could actually [b]do[/b] in military terms to further American political aims in the Middle East. That is the normal translation of Clausewitz' original German. (It's not actually what he meant, by the way).

You are already in another Vietnam situation in both Afghanistan and Iraq. "doomed to repeat it" indeed. The body count is rising. "a party resorting to war should do so with a clear idea as to what it means to accomplish and how it intends to proceed toward that goal". Another of Carl's sayings.

Also, describe how, if you were to somehow bring under your control the full oil production capability of that region, you would deal with China. Or, for that matter, the EU. India? Oh, and 2 billion enraged Muslims?

Neil

btw. Welcome to TR. We will meet again, timezones permitting.

by dr dij

to my beliefs of secular humanism. If those beliefs were violent, I would go on a jihad against the senseless idiotic death threats and killings. how does one person or one company printing a cartoon translate into a whole country guilty (which is what firebombing embassies and boycotting a totally different company does)?

this is baby-ish and retarded. in a previous post, I blamed the mullahs. In all fairness, I did however see some mullahs trying to (ineffectively) stop the violence on tv segment.

The actions of those people are desecrating Islam, making it look like their religion promotes violence.

by sleepin'dawg

and this is what the US has been trying to do since WW II. Unless a nation is prepared to go all out, they shouldn't get involved. The classic example: Vietnam. The US tried repeatedly to restrict the war to South Vietnam, only to fail. People forget that in the Vietnam War the US never lost a battle; they did lose the war. Russia wasn't bothered by such moral restrictions in Hungary or Czechoslovakia in either 1956 or 1968 but by the time they got involved in Afghanistan they were paying more attention to world opinion and as a consequence suffered dearly. Clausewitz wrote and taught; that when one nation goes to war with another and [b]intends upon winning[/b] there can be no limits placed upon the armed forces involved, even though that may involve the killing of innocent civilians. It is war!!! Sherman said, "War is hell" and Robert E. Lee said it was a good thing war was so terrible, otherwise man could grow too fond of it.

Long before Mohammed popped up with his rantings, the people of that corner of the world were a nuisance to the Egyptians, the Babylonians, the Persians, the Greeks, the Romans and the Turks. After WW I they became a problem or responsibility of the western democracies and since WW II, especially the US.

Will anyone ever work up the courage to ignore morality and put a permanent end to the trouble these people cause. I seriously doubt it but The Chinese are probably the best candidates, still, for taking this task on. Back in the 13th century, under the leadership of Genghiz Khan, a Mongol, they had a go at it and might have succeeded where all others had failed but unfortunately poor old Genghiz up and kicked the bucket. He did almost make it to Jerusalem. Given sufficient time he might have cleaned out all of North Africa. For an example he leveled more than one city and made mountains of skulls of the inhabitants of those cities and people who resisted him. He seemed to have had a particular dislike for Persians and Arabs because he never did that anywhere else for the record. Even the Romans didn't attempt this, not out of any qualms of morality but simply because their soldiers got tired of the butchering.

If Hitler were alive today, with his penchant for genocide, would he be content to restrict himself to picking on Jews and Judaism or given present technology, would he change his focus to the Arabs, who are also Semitic people. Would he not want to wipe them all out with a few well placed nukes. Just an idle thought but in light of present day morality on the sanctity of life what other kind of nation or leader would have the stomach for something like that. If the middle east problem hasn't been settled in 3500 years of recorded history why, especially now, with our moral outlook, should we expect it to be resolved now. Unreasonable emotionalism and radical fundamentalism seems to be hardwired into the DNA of these people eapecially the followers of Islam and I for one, see no solution to the problem, short of the most distastful of extreme measures. The world will never have peace as long as we accept the emotional black mail and threats these people pose. Oh yes, I know, someone is going to spout some sort of blather about all the "peaceful" Muslims around the world. Where do you think all the fundamentalist Muslim radicals come from and why aren't the words and tongue in cheek condemnation from the these "peaceful" Muslims having any effect. Remember old Osama comes from one of the richest families in both Yemen and Saudi Arabia. They haven't managed to rein him in, neither have they spoken out against him, except for some cousin of his in New York, with her heart set on becoming some sort of celebrity model. Even her words weren't against him specifically but more of a rationalization of her choice of lifestyle, which is contrary to Islamic teachings for their women.

The only solutions are either we learn to live under the constant threat of terrorism or we forget this business of calling it a war c/w with the taking of prisoners under the Geneva Convention and hunt these guys down and kill them wherever and whenver we find them. If a few innocents get in the way, tough; they shouldn't have been so near to this scum in the first place and that is precisely what they are; the scum of the world. If some Muslim hothead takes exception to my words, come and get me, I'm not too hard to find, if you are fanatical enough but understand this; you won't be the first Muslim I've killed and given the opportunity, I wouldn't mind performing that kind of public service, once again. What do I call 10,000 dead fundamentalist Muslims??? A start; and note, I said fundamentalist Muslims, I've got nothing, so far, against your more reasonable, peaceful brethren. With those, I would expect to be able to discuss and find some sort of peaceful compromise but with you, one between your eyes is the only compromise I'd be willing to make with you and/or your kin.

I've studied Clausewitz and that's the conclusion, as I see it. Even if it means the wholesale slaughter of your innocents; because your wholesale slaughter of our innocents doesn't seem to mean anything to you at all. You are like a rabid dog, I say this because I understand followers of Islam dislike being equated with animals. You know what we do with rabid dogs, for which there is no known cure??? Rrrrright!!! We put them down.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:) [i]the emoticon is by choice not by accident.[/i]

by absolutely

There is no such thing. Medical risks include permanent infertility. Nobody has ever had a "casual abortion". Only fools believe that abortion is used as birth control.

by jdclyde

that know that the vast majority of abortions are NOT because of a medical complication that threatens the mothers life, or rape/incest.

An abortion for any other reason IS birthcontrol.

And truly only a moron would feel differently?

You can argue they have a RIGHT to use an abortion as birthcontrol, but don't be deceitful enough to lie about what it is. Yes, based on the rulings by the courts it is legal, but that doesn't change what it is. I am not talking legality.

Abortion for non-life threatening reasons, or the rape/incest IS birthcontrol because that is the only function being performed. Controlling birth.

Your letting your emotion on this hamper your logic. If this isn't controlling the birth in these situations, what IS it doing? Shame on you.

by sleepin'dawg

Why don't they want to stay there where they all have a chance to blow themselves up or burn down the embassy of some country who has managed to offend there tender little feelings.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)