Tyranny of the offended
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Community archive
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by jamesg
by dr dij
They are not 'offended', they are simply brutal 'Islamofascists', which is I think the best word for them I've heard.
Radical clerics have been on a campaign of spreading agitprop lies to whip up support. The rioting was well planned, hardly 'spontaneous'. The radical clerics made up cartoons in addition to the 3 showing Muslim's prediliction for violence. And also spread lies such as saying the Danish don't allow Muslims to build mosques.
There have been hundreds of depictions of Mohammed including a Mohammed jokes book which we hardly heard a peep about. This is just made up BS, apparently an 'at will' re-interpretation of the Koran as other sects and at other times in history their prophet has been depicted many times. Instead it is really about hitting a nerve: the cartoons depict the reality that the radicals ARE very violent. Bizarre how threatening to be-head tourists would convince us otherswise.
The libertarian think-tank, CATO institute (cato.org) has an article where they see this as simple totalitarianizm rearing its ugly head.
Many Muslim country govts are very corrupt and brutal. But replacing them with brutal radical sects, whose idea of a fun day is lobbing grenades at priceless buddha statues, representing a religion that has never killed in its own name, is outlandish.
the moderates are spooked by the extremists. some have fled countries where they are likely to be killed simply for speaking their thoughts and calling for moderation.
by dr dij
in NO way did the media stir this up. the media has been printing stuff like this for ages, offensive to every religion, including Muslims. mostly just ignored or seen as the humor or irony that they sometimes are.
Now you're sounding as bad as Max's post blaming the media, in that they published reports of pentagon torture (which turned out to be true tho minor compared to what the radicals are doing) that started riots in pakistan killing people.
WE will NOT give up freedom of the press simply because ISLAMOFASCISTs use it as an excuse to murder and mayhem. In fact the original cartoon exercise by the Danish was to see if there was 'defacto' censorship, i.e. cartoon publishers were scared to write the truth about the horrors of radical Islam.
The riots were NOT spontaneous but instead orchestrated over months by scummy radical immams and mullahs, spreading lies. The 3 cartoons were not enuf, they made up more. And told people you could not build mosques in EU countries, another lie.
The base problem is a shift from agronomy to industrialization in many of the countries leaving people unsettled. Similar things happened in britain during industrial revolution.
Combined with horrid oppressive local govts who mistreat their people, many turn to the only obvious option, the even more horrible butchers of radical islam. People need an option and need to be guided with better govts and institutions thru the changes brought by the modern world.
by hal 9000
The Danish newspaper that started off this whole mess specially commissioned the drawing of 12 cartoons to [b]Push The Envelope.[/b]
Guess what? They got exactly what they wanted unfortunately they will unlikely be responsible for paying to rebuild the destroyed buildings and the costs involved in evacuating the Embassy staff or replacing them at some latter stage either.
Col
by hal 9000
Knew months in advance of this particular newspapers action right? :)
What you are forgetting here is that this discussion was not started off about the entire Muslim items that are currently happening and asked specifically what was going on with the current crop of demonstrations that resulted from the publication of these cartoons.
If you want to go back to Yugoslavia and look at what was done to the Muslims there you just might think that at the very least some of them have valid complaints.
Col ]:)
by dr dij
that radical Islam has turned from the 'religion of peace' into the religion of brutal horrors and terror.
I'd go protest in a Muslim country, waving a banner decrying the radical's violence if I had the slightest wiff that I wouldn't be immediately kidnapped, tortured and killed (in the name of god!)
Cartoons are an excellant way to make people face up to the truth. In the 1800's in New York, an incredibly corrupt polition was blatantly grafting to his buddies to build a courthouse at 3 times the cost. Newspaper articles about his corruption were ignored. Cartoons published in a NJ newspaper, which showed him as a huge greedy pig, to the common folk who clamored for and got him canned or jailed.
I think it is a fallacy that if the cartoons were not published that the radical islamofascists would tone down their torture and killings.
by x-marcap
Ridicule only works with reasonable people. The Tammany ring was corrupt, but not a ring of killers that try to kill everyone who disagreed with them. Also the Tammany ring wanted to be left alone so it could continue feeding at the public trough.
At least in the Tammany situation we got something for the money expended. even if it was the $100.00 hammer.
by mirrormirror
I never asked about the media. I asked about the moderate Muslim. Sure, the media doesn't do anything but stir it up in order to sell. Nothing new in that.
What I am scratching my head over is the one sidedness of the Muslim idea of tolerance. Something is not right with it. I am trying to figure out if threats of violence is "ok" with moderate Muslims.
by hal 9000
That what is going on currently is [b]Not the Teachings of Allah or in any way related to the Muslim Faith[/b] But are an off shoot from the main faith and are nasty people who do tend to kill anyone that doesn't totally agree with them.
So you have almost all the moderate Muslims either shut up or become refugees just like the IRA in Northern Ireland did to the Catholic's who didn't blindly follow them in the bad old days at the height of the [b]TROUBLES.[/b]
Many years ago I was asked to attend an Irish Meeting and when I got there they had one of the recruiters from the IRA talking about the way that the poor Irish where treated by the terrible British and referring the the Potato Famine of 16 whatever as if it was yesterday.
Guess what these terrorists where not prevented from attending here, raising money here, attempting to gain new recruits or anything else they where accepted by out then Government.
But the reason that I replied that way was mainly because the News Paper in Question specifically sought to promote trouble by having 12 cartoons made up and see if they could get away with it. As you where only referring to the result of the publishing of those cartoons I replied in kind and didn't bother to bring up any of the other issues that could have been used.
Actually I told a story about a Muslim father threating to kill his son because he wants to marry outside the faith and even worse outside the racial background that the family originally came from and there where several Muslims who where prepared to go on TV and say this was not the [b]True Teachings of the Muslim Faith.[/b] But they live in Australia where they are very unlikely to be tortured and eventually killed I very much doubt it if they would be willing to say the same things to the Media in places like Gaza though.
The main problem in the Middle East is that the way things have been done for centuries are expected to stay that way and no one wants what we in the West have nor do they want to be like they currently are what they want is to be the leaders with all the money and power and be able to lord it over the masses and do as they please.
As was said in one episode of Star Trek the Ferengies don't want change they want to be at the top and keep things as they always have been. That is a very good description of the way that many of the Fundamentalists Muslims want their lives to remain. They already have some degree of Power and are unwilling to loose what they have the [b]Moderates[/b] in these countries either escape to a life of uncertainty or become cannon fodder for the Zealots.
You could just as well ask [b]Where where the Moderate Germans during WW11?[/b] They most certainly existed but didn't shout this from the roof tops. Goering's Brother so violently disagreed with both Hitler and his Brother that he helped Jews Escapes all through the war and because of his name was virtually unemployable after the war ended although he had no connection with the atrocious that his brother was involved in, just his name was more than enough to label him as a Rabid Nazi.
Col
by jamesg
by jamesg
by jamesg
If they can fine someone a few hundred thousand for being a pervert and telling "fart jokes", why can't they apply some regulation for the TRUTH?
Wing nuts can't handle the TRUTH.
Because Rupert Murdoch would be out of business, along with Rush the Junkie fuck.
by jamesg
by onbliss
I thought the news - 'Epilepsy jokes stir up anger' had some relevance here.
URL: http://news.yahoo.com/s/usatoday/20060213/ts_usatoday/epilepsyjokesstirupanger
by jdclyde
you and freaks like you are going to ensure that Republicans are voted in again, because no one will want to be associated with someone so obviously mental.
Many I would try to address to discuss this, but you can not reason with unreasonable people.
You are unreasonable and irrational. Run off and take your meds freak.
by mjwx
by sleepin'dawg
The asininity of his drivel has now reached epic proportions. This is not a person; this is a piece of a poor, stupid, ignorant, idiotic, uneducated, wing nut liberal, stinko, pinko, piece of commie trash. We do not dignify the likes of this, by calling it a person. It is more akin to something you would scrape off the sole of your shoe, having stepped in something vile. Give me a break; a person??? Not bloody likely. He's merely an anal retentive wannabee who probably can't walk and chew gum at the same time and constantly trips over his own dick.
[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)
by jamesg
by mjwx
by jellimonsta
by hal 9000
The Precepts of which it was founded are so radical that it isn't funny.
This one was brought home to me tonight looking back on the way that the Serbs carried on 10 + years ago. Killed all the men and male children above a certain age and raped all the women until they where well and truly pregnant and then returned then in their thousands to their side of the artificial drawn lines so that they could have their babies without being a drain on the resources of the side that captured them persistently raped them and then washed their hands of them. Of course all the women in this case where Muslim.
I don't see the point in this but for some perverted reason at the time the Serbs did.
One could not call the Catholics a [b]Radical Religion[/b] but they where involved in the [b]Troubles[/b] in Northern Ireland and actually where the main instigators of it. The only requirement to be a member of the IRA was to be Catholic. That was a perfect example of the way a religion can be warped to suit the ends of those who have a vested interest and unfortunately it's only one example of a Christian Religion going right over the top into stupidity.
Despite what you have been lead to believe [b]Stupidity[/b] isn't only found in Muslims it is every Religion and group of people.
Col
by beads
Well, I'm sure there are some in India. I get some of the hate politics a bit confused in that country. (Edit): Of course I forgot the Amish. There bunch there. Extreme? Yes, but hardly dangerous. Actually, they can have phones in the 'workshop' but not in the house and drive non-inflated rubber wheeled tractors because buggies don't have inflated wheels. Atleast thats what the elders tell me now. Not that I am supposed to talk to them, anymore - lol.
As a retired soldier I can say that I whole heartedly agree with the passage: 'Blind faith in anything will get you killed.'
Some things never change and if they do; its still the same.
- beads
by mjwx
by mjwx
but there was a saying amongst german tankers that they could take out 9 Shermans but there was always a 10th.
In order for a Sherman to destroy a tiger with its standard 75mm cannon the shot had to hit the rear of the tank (where the armour was weakest).
by jdclyde
After all, we don't want to frighten away Fake James yet. How else will the rest of the world see EXACTLY what his type have to offer if they can't see it first hand? They surely wouldn't believe us if we just TOLD them that there are animals like this out there!
I do wonder if MAYBE MAX had a point. He is actually TOO wacked out. Could he REALLY be a Conservative ACTING like an id10t intentionally just to make Dems look bad? It is hard to believe that someone is really that mental!
by jdclyde
by x-marcap
I did my time eliminating Sandanistas and other enemies of James Carter. He turned his back on people we had supported to prevent communism from having a toehold on the North Ameican continent. He turned on our allies. Would I kill a terrorist?
You betcha, and the old Captain would love to take you along for the fun. Except, a puling coward like you would be more likely to shoot the leader than the enemy because they were shaken.
I am a combat vet with two stars on a CIB.
George W. Bush was no more AWOL than I was when I got sent to Med School. It is verbal detached duty. Not at all uncommon. He was never AWOL. That is a lie and you expect others to be dumb enough to believe it. If an officer is AWOL he can be court martialed. He actually had a distintive record for a NG puke. He could really fly!!! He got extremely high marks on his airborn activities. He was an instinctive pilot. He was a pilot of F105s he applied in writing 8 times for active duty.
They had determined that with his father being (another fighter pilot),and the CIA director. George W. would be to great a bargaining chip if ever caught by the enemy.
by x-marcap
Really, the socialists have not sent men. Germany, France, and Russia didn't send men to either side.
The Poles, the Aussies, the non-russian, ex-soviet countries, Spain until they got a socialist into office. Many non-totalitarian societies with the exception of Isreal, whom we told to butt out have dent men to Iraq.
Even if we were the only ones in Iraq, I'd stay the course. I'd not be as gentle as GW has been. The Marine Captain in me would salt their lands, and burn out the terrorists, and shoot them as they come out of the smoke saving the expense of trials... If they hid in Mosques and shot a BB at my men they'd have orders to call in air strikes.
I have no use for the French, anyway. We should have sent DeGaul to Morrocco, and put Admiral Vechy in as President, instead of funding DeGaul. He hated the US because we were able to beat the Germans. We saved them in two wars in a row, and he hated us for it.
The manpower of other countries is very nice to have.
by jamesg
Wow! This is one seriously different perspective on things!
"salt their lands" "burn out" "saving the expense of trials" "Mosques (...) air strikes"
You shouldn't be in their country in the first place!
As for your attitude to the French, and all just because they disagree with you - "I have no use for the French, anyway". Thus you condemn an entire country.
"We saved them in two wars in a row".
We've already had discussions about your partisan history of WWII and agreed - I hope - that more than one country did their bit.
I really do think that you're pushing it, though, claiming WWI as and American victory!
Incontrovertible fact - on the Allied side, the French had 8m combatants with a casualty rate - killed and wounded - of 73%, the British had 9m and 36%, the Russians, 12m and 76% and the US had 4.3m men and 7% casualties. I'll let the numbers do the talking.
Semper Fidelis? Not, it would seem, always to the truth.
What about us Brits. Even our conservatives are left wing compared to republicans, but it's the troops of a socialist government over there with your boys.
DeGaul did indeed resent americans, british even more. Couldn't have sponsored that nazi symp Vichy though, my grandad would get out of his war grave and kick my ass up the back of my neck. Deservedly so as well.
If you see a ghost in a commando uniform, a strategic withdrawal might be in order.
LOL
I should point out, I don't agree with the way we went into Iraq, but that's spilt milk. All we can do now is get the best out of a complete screw up and make the lives it's cost on all sides mean something.
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
Actually Aetheists are never immoral.
They are amoral.
They determine what is right, and acceptable. They accept no higher authority than themselves. They are in effect their own God, but lack the power of God...
by x-marcap
With the efficiency of the Greeks (Helenes) who successfully fought off the Russians and Turks. We would at least have PAX Greco. What they currently lack is the population, the resources, and the craziness willing to blow themselves up. The next meal is too important. (UMM ,Lunch,Dinner)
Absolutely Wrong as usual. Quit hating and start thinking. Get some Chibatta bread and olive oil and talk to a Greek. Before you talk about absolutists, you must meet one.
by jamesg
by x-marcap
They merely stopped selected county recounts. They said that the state of Florida had to use the same rules in recounting that were on the books at the time of the election.
If the same rules were to be applied Statewide, The recounts could have continued. Gore didn't win, and there was just a ruling that made changing the rules to favor Gore in selected heavily democratic areas illegal.
The funny thing is that when they finally did the recounts Bush still won Florida. The Miami Herald funded the recount, and Bush won by, if I remember correctly, about 120 more votes after the Dade and Broward county recounts. Not to waste their money, or to validate Bush,(Pick your choice) The Herald pulled the funding. Bush legally, properly won the state, and the electoral votes.
County by county Bush won by far the most territory. States by state, he wone more states. The places he lost were big cities. They went overwhelmingly for his opponents both elections.
This isn't the first time a President won the Electoral College and not the popular vote. The point is this is a ballanced manner to select a leader. Would you have liked President Aaron Burr more than Thomas Jefferson? Burr may have been a much better President. Jefferson was selected in the House of Representatives, and it was legal then and now.
Read the Constitution. Then you will be far ahead of our congressmen.
by dr dij
They just now realize that the westerners realize this and the horror of it. The riots are staged in attempt to make us SUBMIT to their idea of a totalitarian press controlled society where they can continue to commit genocide (the terror groups on the islands of indonesia for example are wiping out any minorities not muslim and their govt is doing nothing)
If you had po'd hitler and he started requiring his people to riot against this would you back off and say "well maybe I should stop my freedom of speech so I don't offend him?"
These psycho radical killers deserve to die, not to be submitted or catered to (or are you French?)
by dr dij
publishing cartoons doesn't kill anyone. radicals making death threats do.
they published the cartoons as an experiment to confirm that people were being censored by thoughts that they might be killed for publishing the truth about the radical muslims. They apparently confirmed this.
editors and cartoonists have gone into hiding and LOTS of death threats have been made, including MANY against people TOTALLY UNRELATED in any way to those who published the original cartoons.
Are you such a woos that you think you and others should be bossed around by islamofascist fanatics? I can understand that moderate muslims in the same country would be cowed.
by hal 9000
The Wall Street Journal should be printing the plans for [b]FISSION WEAPONS?[/b]
Or the National Enquirer have the right to publish as yet unmade Military Equipment. [b]Under the Guise of Freedom of the Press they should be perfectly correct to do this right?[/b]
Col ]:)
by jamesrl
Is that those cartoons, make fun of the Prophet Mohamed, who is beloved by ALL muslims, not just the terrorist radical ones.
I've heard lots of moderates being interviewed in Canada, or calling in to talk shows, who don't approve of violence, or even the protests, but feel insulted by the cartoons.
And in Alberta, a prominent conservative maganzine has published them all over again.
I think the press must take responsibility for their actions. They don't need to republish these cartoons to tell the story.
I'm not for censorship (unless its self censorship) or being cowed by terrorists, I am for doing things in a thoughful and responsible manner.
James
They read the situation wrong, in which case they are stupid.
They didn't know that drawing the prophet was blasphemous, in which case they are at a minimum ignorant.
They couldn't careless how offensive they are, in which case they are guilty.
Take your pick.
Tell me If I successfully published derogatory cartoons of say people of the african persuasion using the N word as an experiment to see if censorship existed, would I have acted responsibly ? Would you have any sympathy for me, if a big fella called Leroy gave me a serious slapping. Would you expect my defense of ignorance, to do me any good in court ?
by jdclyde
It turns out this is an OLD story, the should of and WOULD have faded away before we or the majority of the world ever heard about it.
A nutcase kept taking this to venue after venue until he got the outrage he was seeking.
The origianal posters didn't take it that far, but after seeing what happened with the prisoner humiliation pictures, there is no way any rational person could NOT expect this out of the irrational people known as the extreme funamentalist islomics of the world.
When you INTENTIONALLY insult someone to the very core of their existence, what do you think will be the answer?
Compare this to me walking up to a VERY drunk man in the bar and telling him his wife is a W H O R E. You will find yourself in a very similar situation because YOU were intentionally provocating. This does NOT excuse the drunk, but you deserve whatever happens to you.
by dr dij
they portrayed the radicals as they actually ARE!
In fact I don't hate them because of the cartoon, I PITY them!
Again, the cartoons DID NOT RIOT and damage buildings and kill people. Religious FREAKS did. (My definition of religious freaks is ANYONE of ANY religion who would mindlessly riot and kill and destroy based on something that was printed.) I guess the truth hurts, radicals!
We had a very long debate about whether you can be moral without being religious.
Amoral is making no distinction between right and wrong.
Immoral is knowing right from wrong and doing wrong anyway.
Moral is knowing right from wrong and at least making an effort at doing right.
Course defining right and wrong is the next argument.
You struck me as more of an us and them guy anyway.
by jdclyde
and go tease it anyways, don't cry when you get bit.
"portrayed the radicals as they actually are!"
Mohommed with a bomb for a turbin is not hateful, steriotypical and acurate?
Your mistake is trying to defend one side or the other.
They both were wrong, completely out of line and should both pay the price. Each for their own stupidity.
Don't make excuses for biggotry and hate, hiding behind freedom of the press. NOTHING in freedom of the press says to support being a biggot. It is about freedom of political expression without the government shutting them down (like they do NOW in China).
Very unbecoming of you.
by jdclyde
Reading Fake James' posts makes me see him described as a patron.
"You will never find a more wretched hive of scum and villany."
by mirrormirror
Since the I posted the original question I have continued to look for the moderate Mulsims out there. I have also been trying to understand why we are not HEARING from moderate Muslims.
Here is what I found.
The protests are being over reported by the world media. Reports of protests that are small in comparison to the population are sometimes portrayed as large. For instance, recently 3000 students in Pakistan demonstrated against the cartoons. The interesting thing to me is that in Pakistan, there are over 15 million Muslims. Out of this there were 3000 protesters? Uh, seems kinda small to me. When crowd estimates are printed they usually number in the hundreds or thousands. Where are the massive crowds that we are led to believe are out there? The was one in Lebannon but that started off as religous ceremony and turned into a protest.
Moderate Muslims are afraid to speak out because they will be threatened by the extremists or they are apathetic to the controvery and will not speak out. I have started to find references (mostly in blogs) to moderate Muslim opinion and moderate Muslim groups being formed. It is comforting to know that all Muslims are not like the extremists. I think it will be interesting to see how the moderate point of view is received by the Imans.
by jellimonsta
by mirrormirror
Thanks for catching my population error. :)
Note to self: Re-check statistics before posting.
Note to self#2: Use spell checker more often.
by onbliss
... their daily survival.
As far as Pakistan, many experts believe things were NOT that bad (relatively speaking) prior to the 1980 invasion of Afghanistan by the U.S.S.R. So feels a common man, too, in Pakistan:
http://www.nytimes.com/2006/02/16/opinion/16thu4.html
I have read in "Foreign Affairs" about the role of USA in aiding/creating religiously motivated army of men to fight USSR.
Grand Ayatollah Al-Sistani of Iraq has been a voice of moderation in that country for the Shiites. He has denounced the violence and excesses of the protests. He is also a strong supporter of Iraqi democracy, urging his followers to vote and participate in the government.
There may be some voices of moderation on the Sunni side of Islam, but I am not familiar of any with the stature of Al-Sistani in the Shiite community.
by dr dij
latimes has a very good summary of the islamic conference and anti-western rants.
Just don't run over your Dogma with your Karma. And don't beat your Dogma with a Stigma. :-)
As an Anglican, my branch of Christianity draws from a combination of Roman Catholic, Protestant (particularly Lutheran and Methodist traditions), and Orthodox traditions. The "Free Will" part comes from the Roman Catholic and Methodist influences in Anglicanism.
Ethics are rules and reasons for behaviour put forward by someone who holds that they are based on and may be defended by reason.
Morals are rules and reasons for behaviour put forward by someone who simply insists that they be obeyed.
In this, Islamic Sharia Law and The Ten Commandments are both good examples of moral codes but not necessarily good examples of an ethical code. The difference between ethics and morals explains why people complaining of irregular sexual behaviour between consenting adults in private denounce it as 'immoral', never as 'unethical'.
It is moral codes - not ethics - that sets down the behavioural norms and the punishments for immoral behaviour. 'Sin' or 'moral crimes' and their punishments can only be justified by referencing it back to the source.
If you believe that the source of your moral code is unimpeachable then your moral code is sacrosanct. Good for you. I don't.
by mjwx
Consider, for a moment what is power. Power in my reckoning (and in this context) is the raw application of one?s will. So the power of god is the ability to project your will onto others and to have it obeyed (I am thee lord thy god. Thou shalt have no other god before me). This power is not beyond one?s grasp nor do people, especially religious leaders resist grasping it.
As for accepting a higher authority, I find the idea of submitting to god (any god) insulting. There are religions that exist where a higher power is not to be obeyed or submitted to and I will submit Buddhism as an example. Not believing in god is not to say you don?t believe in something greater than yourself, once again taking Buddhism as an example by pointing out Nirvana which (for those of us playing along at home) is a state of enlightenment achieved through denial of the self (not to be confused with self-denial).
I have often found God (Allah or any other of its forms) used as an excuse by people who do not wish to better themselves and will never admit that they do not wish to better themselves but to get a free ride to something greater. A man who is content with who he is does not need god, but he may or may not choose god.
by rob mekel
stigmas ain't a good thing, so all you can do is get ride off it.
Anglican, was thinking that it came cause of Henry VIII, who wanted to, and did, marry 6 wives.
Rob
by dr dij
how many people in the US saw the cartoons, then (without hearing about the atrocities threatened by muslims) went on a rampage against muslims? NONE!
Most people view cartoons and say "isn't it true!"
So if there is a remote chance that someone a 1000 miles away, unknown to me, might be offended at what I say, I better not say it?
this goes against all tenets of free speech. and despite the fact that clever islamofascists have come up with banners saying 'free speech is terrorism', it is NOT!
islamofascists waving banners is OK but when they start destroying property and threatening to kill (and actually killing - Van Gogh (artist's descendant) was killed to protest a short movie that showed what muslim women are subjected to) - to protect their intolerant beliefs, this is terror. I don't even care if they burn a few flags.
My ancestors died to protect this country's freedom of speech. The protestors petrified beliefs will die off. Even Max seemed to indicate he didn't agree with you.
Henry VIII did separate from Rome, because the Pope would not grant his annulment to Catherine of Aragon. From Henry's point of view, it was mainly political, and he still considered himself a loyal Catholic, just not to the Pope.
Anglicanism developed more to the work of Cranmer, Ridley, and Latimer, 3 bishops of the Church of England during the reign of Henry VIII and his son Edward VI, than due to the efforts of Henry VII, who left the details to the bishops. These bishops had Protestant leanings, and were influenced by Martin Luther. However, they did not want to go to the extremes of the Calvinists, and kept the liturgy of the Roman church, but translated it into English instead of using Latin. They also removed the prohibition against priests and bishops getting married. They were executed by Mary I (sister of Edward VI who became queen after he died), because she wanted to restore the Roman Catholic church in England. Elisabeth I, the younger sister, restored the Protestant nature of the Church of England. Since then, the Anglican Church has incorporated influences from many Christian traditions, calling it the "Via Media" or middle way in between the Catholic, Protestant, and Orthodox branches, and using the 3 principles of Scripture, Tradition, and Reason, with Scripture being primary.
by rob mekel
Henry VIII gave the bishops the opportunity to develop their believes into a new christian group. http://www.stjohnsroslyn.org.nz/guide_to_the_anglican_church.html ==>
"Wasn't the Anglican Church formed by Henry VIII so that he could annul his marriage?
Ouch. Yes, it was, but leaders in the Church of England took the opportunity to make a number of reforms which the central authorities of the Roman Catholic Church opposed. Something like the Anglican Church would probably have happened without Henry VIII?s political interference, but it might have taken longer. King Henry's main concern was simply independence from Rome."
Before Henry VIII this was al suppressed by the "worldly" powers, at least they tryed (reformation, Luther, Calvin).
Does sound like what is happening today, doesn't it?
Rob
by rob mekel
Was installed in RC by pope Gregorius VII (1073-1085).
As it is not part of any documentation from start of christianity it can be questioned if it was right to be installed.
But who am I to judge.
Rob
by hal 9000
http://www.abc.net.au/news/newsitems/200602/s1574390.htm
But I suppose that Israel cutting off funds to a known Terrorist Organization which is now the Government of the Palestinians will only make things far worse.
After all there is nothing to drive any moderate person to perform outrageous things if they are hungry and seeing their family stave.
Col
by x-marcap
No government has no justification for ever feeding you if you are working to destroy it.
What most of us want is for a government to leave us alone so we can make money and feed our family...
by hal 9000
And no I'm not thinking of the Military but the Public Servants and Police who are supposed to control the situation.
Without an effective Police Force in the Palestine part of the Middle East just how fast do you think things will go the way that most people in the West want? They are already supporting Iran in their Nuclear industry and if that country was to make Fissionable material it would be the desperate Palestine Government who would be only too willing to take it and use it for their own ends.
Remember once the Politician's Screw it up it is the Grunts who have to go in and sort it all out so that the Politician's can screw it all up again!
What is currently happening in the Middle East is a perfect Example of [b]What Not To Do.[/b] If the promises had been kept by the Western Nations to the Arabs during WW11 that where made it is very unlikely that the current distrust would exist.
Col
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
by x-marcap
Apparently you don't ascribe to the straw that breaks the Camel's back theory. The fresh troops were inexperienced, but did rather well.
There is no virtue in getting wounded, or killing vast amounts of the enemy.
The purpose of the war is to enforce political will. Not to decimate a generation, although it may do that. You really seem to hate to admit that the Europeans would be speaking Deutch if not for the "colonials" The real purpose is to defeat, or control the enemy or its territory.
I remember hearing the "overpaid, ..., overhere" lines. Especially from British people. For people who couldn't survive without our aid, you certainly wanted to tell us how to fight in the past. Black Jack Pershing had it right... "The Brits can do wonders with nothing. The way they treat us they deserve no more..."
In WWII the British expected the Americans to blindly follow their "educated lead"
They wanted the US OSS to basically augment their staff. Read the notes of Wild Bill Donovan some day. Ian Fleming who wrote James Bond was sent to liase with the Americans about making a covert commando type force. For some reason you Brits want us to fight your battles, but under your mantle of control...
We have been independent for 200 years. Neither Btitain or the French could defeat Hitler. The French Joined Hitler willingly. They were more Fascist that the Nazis.
by x-marcap
I don't want to belittle anything that the Americans did in WWI but, honestly, I have to point you to the simple numbers again. I do not believe that it was the "final straw". I do believe that possibly it helped shorten the war by a small amount. Significant numbers of American troops only arrived in Europe in the summer of 1918 when the Germans were close to defeat after the second Battle of the Somme. By the way, if you want to check on whether "we" tried to order the US troops around, check out some of the appalling decisions by Gen. Pershing to use frontal assaults and wonder if you should have listened. We had finally given up that "over the top, boys" approach a while before.
As for WWII. I don't take anything away from the contribution made by America but, if you read back, you'll see that my objection has been to posts that suggested that either the US could have stopped Hitler in Poland or that the US was the primary, even the only power responsible for the defeat of Hitler. Neither of these scenarios stands up to scrutiny. For some reason, we are more honest in our books about the contribution of Russia although we, also, tend to play it down.
Regarding D-Day, usually regarded as a US triumph, the nation that demands the most respect for their contribution - more than both of ours - is Canada.
Maybe we just read different histories. Mine describe the wars as 1914-1918 and 1939-1945.
Can we stop this? It isn't achieving anything.
Neil
by dr dij
ANYTHING that offends 'radical' muslims is met with death threats. Even in the country of Indonesia, 'JIL' a Muslim group promoting tolerance is harrased with death threats.
THEY'RE worried about their image in the west? give me a break, their actions CAUSE their image in the west.
Long before these cartoons, including Salmon Rushdie as one of most famous, but including any who speak out for moderation, are targetted.
This is the bastion of the radical 'Islamofascists'. Their way is the only way that will be tolerated and all others will be beaten into submission. And you are an 'infidel' and worthy of death simply for not being a believer in their branch of Islam.
by hal 9000
The Dali Lama being described as [b]Just Another Misguided Pagan[/b] by one of the TR Peers here?
Yes with tolerance like that we don't need enemies do we? :p
I don't know if this was reported in the [b]Land of the Free[/b] but apparently some German Newspaper reprinted the same cartoons and the German Government shut them down. So much for the Freedom of the press. :D
Col ]:)
by dr dij
(this is paragraph from the link below at washington post)
have we disrespected islam: NO!
"But if a believer demands that I, as a nonbeliever, observe his taboos in the public domain, he is not asking for my respect, but for my submission. And that is incompatible with a secular democracy."
"As a former correspondent in the Soviet Union, I am sensitive about calls for censorship on the grounds of insult. This is a popular trick of totalitarian movements: Label any critique or call for debate as an insult and punish the offenders. That is what happened to human rights activists and writers such as Andrei Sakharov, Vladimir Bukovsky, Alexander Solzhenitsyn, Natan Sharansky, Boris Pasternak. The regime accused them of anti-Soviet propaganda, just as some Muslims are labeling 12 cartoons in a Danish newspaper anti-Islamic."
and it works both ways:
"I am offended by things in the paper every day: transcripts of speeches by Osama bin Laden, photos from Abu Ghraib, people insisting that Israel should be erased from the face of the Earth, people saying the Holocaust never happened. But that does not mean that I would refrain from printing them as long as they fell within the limits of the law and of the newspaper's ethical code. That other editors would make different choices is the essence of pluralism."
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2006/02/17/AR2006021702499_2.html
by x-marcap
We are talking the people who survive on the taxes of others without working, or trying to work.
Perhaps the US has been made more socialistic than other countries in some respects. The US was built on the concept of a strong Federal government with limited powers. As long as the Federal government couldn't tax either wealth, or income, and was surviving on tarriffs the gov't was small due to lack of resources... We could pay more for everything else easily if the bloated spider of entitlements / socialism was gone from our backs.
I would now hate to live through the transition back to the small limited government of Pre - Civil War America. I suspect that the riots of the Muslims would be far more peaceful than those of Americans being weaned from tax money...
by dr dij
for things like abusing their women. Van Gogh, a filmmaker in EU was assassinated for making a film depicting how many Muslims mistreat women.
And the intolerance evidenced of any other religion by the radicals is bound to bring conflict.
Plus the fact that many of the Muslims in Europe went there because they were kicked out by (possibly repressive) regimes in their own country who didn't want them stirring up trouble and running around assassinating people, like the fellow in charge of Egypt a while back, tourists visiting the pyramids, etc.
So EU's extending a helping hand, to these people, who probably claimed persecution in their homeland, or who just came in under worker's visas has sometimes backfired on them.
Plus the fact that EU is largely a welfare state where stagnant job creation makes it hard to find a place in society, and tolerant expression laws let the radicals babble on about killing for quite a while.
by hal 9000
With the Israeli Government refusing to return Tax collected from the Palestine's to the new Hamas Government it is the Public Servants and Police who are directly affected.
When this story broke the Australian Broadcasting Corporation had an Interview with a Palestine Policeman who was certain to be paid this month but was uncertain if he would be paid next month or any of the following months for his work. Once they can no longer pay their Police Force things will degenerate into a total farce there.
Col
by mirrormirror
Very telling and chilling. There is something afoot here. Why are the moderate voices being repressed? Journalists jailed for reporting on issues is ridiculous. I know that some people say that the journalists should be responsible with what they are reporting. I think they should be responsible with HOW they are reporting things.
Muslim vs Muslim on this...I wonder where this will go?
by hal 9000
My sister worked in Saudi for quite awhile a few years ago as a Foreign Nurse at one of the main hospitals.
Over there, there are 2 types of Police the [b]Real Police[/b] who are well trained and act accordingly and then you have the [b]Religious Police[/b] who are poorly educated know very little about the actual Laws but can act on what they see fit.
One British nurse was approached by a Religious Policeman in the actual hospital confines and told to wear the Berka? [i]not quite sure how you spell that one[/i] which she wasn't required to wear in that particular area as it was mainly for foreign workers but that meant nothing to this particular policeman who just had to throw his weight around improperly so in an act of desperation she decked the Religious Cop leaving him unconscious on the ground. She was deported by the end of the day back to Britain.
That is just one example of the stupidity that passes for Law Enforcement there. :D
Col
by mirrormirror
She decked the guy!?!? Wow, don't make your sister mad, Col. Do you remember when we used to pick sides when we were kids playing a game?...I want your sister on my side!!! ;) I'll take you on my side too, Col.
Actually, she took a huge risk. I'm glad she was only deported. I wonder what that guy told his fellow religious cops about being knocked out by a woman? I bet that guy thinks twice about throwing his religious weight around at foreign women.
by sirlanse
The Times article misses a point.
The mullahs that went on a road trip to whip up
hatred for the cartoons had a couple more made up.
They were not sure that the danish pics would
do the job, so they made up some themselves.
These are the worst ones and have been effective.
Rioting about the destruction of 1000yr old mosque,ok
Rioting about comics printed thousands of miles
away, STOOOOPID!
by jdclyde
by jdclyde
by jdgeek
What a wonderful use of the internet. I'm proud to see that mad'dawg and James are standing on the shoulders of giants and using this wonderful medium for such sophisticated civil discourse. Surely consensus is built in such ways.
Since the discussion seems to have degraded into ad hominem attacks, I thought I would try to add some actual information. Then you guys can go back to calling each other sissy and bully.
First here is the "coalition of the willing" from wikipedia:
http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/en/3/3b/Original_coalition.JPG
Notably absent are countries that another poster mentioned including China and Russia. It should trouble the hawks and the doves that relations with these countries are strained.
Another question raised during this discussion concerned early intervention. I believe we should intervene early in wars of aggression. I can only hope that the Russians and Chinese do not agree.
Make no mistake, the war in Iraq is a war of aggression. Consider that none of the 9/11 attackers were in any way connected to Iraq (http://www.suntimes.com/special_sections/sept11/attacks/thehijackers.html). They were from Saudi Arabia, Egypt, and UAE. Consider that there were no WMDs and US officials knew or should have known there were none (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scott_Ritter). Consider that pre-ware intelligence was so flawed that only gross incompetence or malfeasance can explain the deficiencies (http://www.washingtonpost.com/ac2/wp-dyn?pagename=article&contentId=A39500-2003Aug9¬Found=true).
If you still believe the US is defending anyone's rights in Iraq especially those of US citizens, you are severely mis-informed. George H Bush fought in WWII, and it was the right thing to do. Since then, powerful, priveleged US citizens have essentially stopped serving in US wars. I believe this is because our leaders don't want their sons and daughters to die for what passes as a cause for war these days.
Incidentally dawg, it is interesting that you included poor among your list of adjectives describing James. Was that intended as an insult?
by shraven
Me, I AM slamming all Muslims. If the reasonable ones aren't going to stand up to the radical one's, then they're just fanatics without the balls to carry out their convictions. (If you're not a part of the solution, then you're part of the problem.)
Nothing is hurting the Muslim community more than the Muslims themselves. Yes, we know they all don't want to decapitate all westerners, but they aren't doing anything to fix the problem. As a result westerners are having to go over and fix the problem, which of course just stirs up the radicals even more.
Any group which will not tolerate free speach - especially when spoken outside their soveriegn land - and retaliates with violence deserves to wiped from the face of the earth.
The Muslims (at least the radical ones) cling to an Old Testament view of right/wrong and punishment. So be it. In the Bible, when nations went to war, they killed every man woman and child from the enemy nation or enslaved the rest. So let's get busy. There is no doubt who has the might, so let's follow the Bible and kill them all...
Unless of course, they'd like to take a more reasonable approach and join the rest of the world in striving for peace and prosperity.
Hopefully you will catch the sacrasm in my "solution" but the fact stands that there is no excuse for their actions and somebody needs to stop them. If it won't be the Muslims, then they're in for a long period of foreign occupation as the rest of the world works to put and end to the threat of the jihad.
by rob mekel
the problem. Muslims can't condemn Jihad "warriors" because of this lies within their believes. To them it is the same as condemning Bush for the operations at Quantanamo bay prison. (why is it that this prison is not situated within a state of the USA)
They can, however, denounce the terrorists/terrorism and that they should do.
Rob
First of all I don't know which bits of your little rant were intended to be ironic and which are not. That, by the way, is your fault. I'm assuming it's not all ironic otherwise my post is a waste of time. I also have no idea where you're from and that's a nuisance as well because it's also relevant.
Anyway, one big assumption that you're making is that Muslims perceive that they have a problem. I'm absolutely sure that they don't see it your way and it's naive for you to think, for a second, that they might! If their holy book tells them different things from their holy book then you don't have a chance of "stopping them".
I have to agree with Rob. They don't have a problem with us as much as we seem to have a problem with them.
"westerners are having to go over and fix the problem". Typical arrogant western opinion. Hmmm, smacks a bit of "Untermensch". Trust me. It won't work and it isn't working. e can see that in Afghanistan and Iraq. What do you propose to do about Pakistan? They're next. Hey, but they don't have oil and do have nukes...
by jdclyde
and let them kill each other instead of us.
As soon as there aren't Americans around to rally against, the different factions will do everything they can to become the only faction there.
Let them work that out on their own, and try to become a trade partner of who ever is left alive.
by krose
Both France and Germany are present and fighting in Afghanistan - Iraq is not the only islamic country under occupation.
N.B. Canada is also in Afghanistan, currently taking over operations around Khandahar.
None of these three chose to go into Iraq, despite being in Afghanistan before the invasion.
Maybe there are reasons for this choice - some related to the manner in which the US conducts operations in Afghanistan - I can think of four: four Canadian soldiers killed when an American jet bombed a Canadian training exercise near Kabul.
by bitmeister
It's obvious you have serious issues and try to compensate with inflamatory drivel. You love the right to bitch and complain, and call people names, but you aren't willing to fight for it when it counts. I suppose, to make yourself fell better, you would just respond that you're simply smart enough not to jump in front of an enemy bullet. The reality is that your a coward hiding behind words and anonimity. I'm so impressed.
The US response to the 9/11 attacks were well justified. We may have gone into Iraq too soon, but it should have happened many years earlier. As for the bad intelligence/WMD issue in Iraq, one can take a look at what our friends in Congress did to the intelligence budgets after the collapse of the Soviet Union. These continual budget cuts resulted in significantly crippled human intelligence (HUMINT) programs, precisely what is needed to gather info in closed societies as Iraq was. Of course we wouldn't want anyone in congress to accept any responsibility for their actions. Bush may not be perfect, but given the options during the last two elections, he was the best available for the job. Sadley, the weak-minded, pot-smoking, liberal idiots of the USA are all too willing to accept to garbage pumped into their minds by the liberal press, and the boneheads lecturing in the majority of our colleges and universities.
Thank God for those of us that have volunteered to wear the uniform of our country and defend the right to live free, express ourselves freely, worship without fear, and enjoy all the blessings the USA and the world has to offer. Thank God for all our true Allies who stand beside us to defend those same freedoms around the world. I hope that others in this world that don't enjoy these freedoms can someday do so.
by hal 9000
That Saddam as nasty as he was had them all under control and if not liking it they could at least live together without too many problems.
Col ]:)
by hal 9000
Why Iraq?
What did they ever do to you or your country?
They didn't support Bin Laden had no direct connections with him and none of their citizens where involved in 9-11. If the [b]War on Terror[/b] was so well thought out why was Iraq Invaded and not Saudi Arabia? Where most of those directly involved in the 9-11 attack originated from.
The money certainly originated from there at the very least!
The USA lost the backing of most of the free world when they went off on a tangent and invaded Iraq for no decent reason quite rightly I might add as well. Having WMD that's [b]Weapons of Mass Destruction[/b] not the [b]Weapons of Mass Deception[/b] that was invoked by the US Government doesn't mean diddle squat unless you have a delivery system and I hardly think that FedEx would be considered as a reliable delivery system to the US.
That would have been Saddam's only way to directly attack the US and after all while he postured a lot that is all it was. If his actions where justification for an invasion what ever happened to Libya? As well as most of the Middle East?
Surely they should all be candidates for invasion after all most have said nasty things against the US so if Iraq was a justified invasion then finish it off and completely invade every country in the Middle East that has ever said something nasty about the US of A.
Leave North Korea alone however if you really where in uniform you should know that that war is still going on there has been no [b]Peace Treaty[/b] just a [b]Cease Fire Agreement.[/b] Which for quite good reasons has not been broken by the South or its Allies for over 30 years now GWB wouldn't even actually need to declare war on North Korea as you both are still in a state of [b]War.[/b]
Col ]:)
And if we hadn't gone into Iraq can you imagine how Saddam Hussein would have been reacting to the Iranian nuclear programme?
But they [b]do[/b] have us to rally against. In fact, we're lower than you at the moment since one of our newspapers kindly released a video of our soldiers slapping a few stone-throwing kids around.
by rob mekel
Back in the 1980's the USA financed Iraq and equipped them with a lot of weaponry to be a very nasty country in the Middle East region.
Guess what happened ... they weren't that trustworthy already in 1990 that was when they invaded Kuwait.
As they (Iraq) couldn?t win the war with Iran and Saddam needed the victory (as a lot of so called leaders do) to help the Iraqi to believe in themselves they are not losers. Back then GB sr. did a wise thing (the 1990's)and as soon as he could, got the hell out of there. Cause a guerrilla war is not to be won by invaders. As history does tell us.
Rob
by bitmeister
I may not have communicated my thoughts as well as I had hoped. While I believe there may have been indications that Iraq was a threat, I firmly believe we should have maintained our focus in Afghanistan. The coalition forces there were making pretty good progress, and - more importantly - were gaining the trust and partnership of most of the Afghan nationals. I personally feel we let them down when we ran off to Iraq.
Iraq is a whole different animal... Saddam was a known issue to governments around the globe for decades, but no one had the balls to insist the UN take any type of action. True, Iraq was/is a soveriegn nation, but that doesn't give the leadership the right to exterminate huge numbers of it's population. I believe the timing of our going into Iraq was wrong based upon what I know. I also believe that the vast majority of what is reported by the press is heavily slanted crap intended to create news to sell papers and advertising rather than unbiased reporting of all pertinent facts associated with an event.
Military action against Saudia Arabia would have been foolish even with the known links between Bin Laden and members of the royal family. We (Western Nations) are fortunate to have pretty strong political and economic ties to SA, and have been very successful dealing with issues through diplomatic means. They may not have a democratic form of government, but they aren't whack jobs either, they know how to sit down and work things out intelligently. We could even consider this as an option in Iraq or Afghanistan (under the Taliban).
As for Iraq's lack of a proven delivery system, there was plenty of work going on to develop or purchase a delivery system. As the saying goes, 'An ounce of prevention is worth a pund of cure' You're right that Iraq may not have been able to directly attack the US. But they would have been able to target countries and military installations in their region. This type of capability would have been a major threat to the delicate balance of powers in the region and this would not have just been a threat to the US. The lack of some type of ICBM to deliver an atomic or chemical payload to the US or anywhere else in the world doesn't prevent these types of weapons from making their way to a target.
One must remember we are dealing with radical idealism which a mighty powerful weapon in it's own right. Those who subscribe to these extreme beliefs will accept any level of risk to achieve their goals. FedEX would be the last method of delivery they would select as it would not allow them to get their virgins in heaven.
As for the other nations you mention, this isn't a US against Arab nations issue. It's not a US against anyone that says something nasty about us. This is, and should be, a confrontation of all free nations of the world against extreme fundamentalists who are attempting to use violence and terror to impose their will on the rest of the world.
Regarding Korea, it is a Cease Fire Agreement. Given the nut case in charge there, and the alliances North Korea has, it would be insanity to attack. Also, North Korea isn't the issue in this thread.
by jdclyde
Saddam had it right in the way he controlled the people.
The only way to control ignorant savages is by being more savage.
That is where the Liberals in the US and Canada are making a MAJOR mistake in the ideas of thinking you can reason with unreasonable people, and that if you just let them do as they please the bloody savages will leave you alone.
I would personally take the same approach with gang wars. Fence in miles of desert where gang members can go to settle all differences any way they want, as often as they want.
Why risk useful human lives in trying to separate the dredges of the world? Let them ALL die at their own hands.
If nothing else, we have learned that Iraq was not WORTH saving from anything.
by x-marcap
This discussion is closed to new replies.
Sort by Trending