Discussion Locked

Tyranny of the offended

0 helpful
299 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

299 replies

by sleepin'dawg

a part of a documentary piece on what is offensive to Muslims and how not to offend them. We've only seen the supposedly most objetionable cartoons, there were several others that were supportive not offensive. Like a lot of things, it was taken out of context and blown out of proportion. You didn't get a chance to see the others and/or the article.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

Wow, the dawg is byting today!

"Gangbangers"? Oh come on! We all know that there aren't any guns in canada because everyone is too busy hugging the trees! ;\ Crime? No, you must again be mistaken. pure as the wind driven snow it is! Any crime MUST be just a misunderstanding?

A few years back when I was in Toronto for my Unix training, a guy from New York and myself went walking down town and hit a few local pubs. The next day when talking to the receptionist (she wanted me) we told her and her reaction was "oh by, you shouldn't have been down there!"

Imagine my surprise?

That is a big difference between Canada and the US. Canadians are smart enough to downplay the problems, not glorify them for the whole world to see.

Oh, and as for the rest of your last few posts, just call it "satire" if anyone gets worked up. They will understand and have a grand laugh with you! :D

by tony hopkinson

I've said it before and I'll say it again. Your late arrival into to the war was a masterful piece of statemanship. The fact that you entered both world wars when you were in no major danger yourselves apart from a potential future one from a united europe is something I'll be forever grateful for. Would have been nicer if you came in earlier, maybe I'd have had a chance to meet my maternal grandfather for instance. May be it would have been over quicker. There again, maybe the phoney war would gave been the end of that part of the conflict, and Adolf could have devoted his entire force against those nasty commies (more than possibly with american help) and we could have been next door to a homicidal racist f'wit sociopath ruling the entire eurasian contintent.

Vietnam was a whole 'nother ball game. The russians must have been laughing their tits off when you went in there. Not sure that was a war you could win militarily either, not unless genocide was an option. Those guys weren't going to meet you toe to toe, and there is no way you could have forced them to do so.

Worse problem with radical islam, war is not the answer. Never seen any large group of people forced to be moderate by sticking a gun in their face. If we trundled across the water, stuck a gun in your face and told you it was for your own good because constitutional monarchies were a better way of doing things, what's the chance of you giving more than lip service to the idea before I took the rifle out of your face ?
Not a deal, I should think. What would you think of the interim government we installed while we threw away that written constitution foolishness ?
Not a deal I should think.
We would have used force to impose our beliefs on you and took away something that you place a high value on. Whether we were correct about monarchies would be immaterial, how long would it take for you to show gratitude for us 'helping' you out.
Silly example I'll admit, but I don't understand why you think tactics that wouldn't work on you would work on them. They may not see a chance to own a car, watch friends and give some lying self serving git a chance to bury his face in the public trough as that much of an improvement.

by maxwell edison

I'm not going to debate an issue (WWII), that happened years before I was even born, decades before many people around here were born, and out of the context of the political and global reality of the day. What an absolutely stupid thing you just said.

by sleepin'dawg

and cartoons but I'm damned if I can find it. They showed paintings, drawings, etchings and cartoons going back over hundreds of years, many of them by Muslim artists. So much for them being forbidden to paint pictures of their so called prophet. Talk about being hypocrites. If anyone else has this link please don't be afraid to post it. These clowns should be shown up for the hypcrites that they are.

[b]Dawg[/b]]:)

by jdclyde

something along "another link".

it is after 1 in the morning, so I just don't feel like finding it right now and after that superior crap, we will just SEE if I feel like it in the morning.... :O

by x-marcap

We lost political support at home. We kicked butt in Vietnam. The French didn't do as well as we did.

As a person who knows what perception is many peoples reality means that you bought the Communist lefts lies. Semper Fi

by x-marcap

Neil, we could have kicked the Nazis back to Germany earlier. What we did was put the best general in a theatre and not supply him. (MacArthur) Then, we let Montgomery be a field commander. (Really dumb he wasn't a good combat commander. Sandhurst sand tables prove that Montgomery consistantly made the worst of all choices...)

Then, we appoint George Marshall be Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff.(His endorsements and performance appraisals said he shouldn't be more than a company commander, but he was a friend of a President) MacArthur with the resources that Eisenhower had would have eliminated Germany's military by 1943... If MacArthur could've been let alone by Truman, China wouldn't have been communist, and they would've been calling him the Viceroy also as did Japan...

Next the Terrorists had been given a pass during Clinton's Presidency. If he had done his job, this President wouldn't have had to deal with this mess...

Tim

by sleepin'dawg

Sushi??? Thank you very kindly but would you mind cooking that before you put it on my plate. If you only knew the things that are in raw fish, it can be worse than raw pork. Thank you but no; I've had amoebic dysentry once before and I don't choose to have a repeat performance. Yup, I've had a tape worm also, again don't mind me, I'll pass on the sushi if you don't mind. A twelve foot long, live worm up my ass just doesn't make it on my list of fun things to have extracted from any part of my bod let alone my tush. I got off light; some of the guys I was with had even longer ones than that. I think the record for our gang was 21 feet. We acquired these from improperly cooked fish and you want me to eat some raw. Hey, I thought we were friends; what did I ever do to you, that you'd want to do that to me??? Some pal you turned out to be.

Seriously though, I have several friends who are doctors and when they had to turn in papers when they were sitting for their specialty boards, they'd called on me for my photographic skills. One of these friends was an opthalmologist and he asked me to take some shots through a retinascope. I was working on focusing the camera on one guy's retina and I saw something swimming across the guy's eye. I automatically assumed trichinosis, usually caught from eating improperly cooked pork but I was told it was some other disease, contracted by eating raw or improperly cooked fish. There wasn't much in the way of sushi around, outside of Japan, at that time but I was told it was a common disease amongst the Japanese. The first time somebody offered me sushi, I remembered that and other than a small taste, have never touched sushi since. I'm a photographer. I need my eyes, both of them. The idea of vision destroying worms swimming around in my eyes, doesn't particularly thrill me and to pay good money for an opportunity to go blind, thanks but no thanks. Maybe it only happens to someone once in a few thousand instances and while I'll risk my ass doing a lot of other dumb things eating sushi isn't going to be one of them.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by sleepin'dawg

in Vietnam, and that includes the Tet offensive of Mar/68 made by the combined forces of the Cong and North Vietnamese Army. The US even cleared the Cong and North Vietnamese from the city of Hue which was a former capitol of theirs back when there were kings of Vietnam and was symbolicly important to them. I wasn't there as a soldier, I was there as a photographer for a magazine and a press agency. They also sent me to North Vietnam later, I forget which year but Hanoi Jane, the b|tch, was around at the time I was there. They sent me because I was Canadian and on a Canadian passport. If the Americans only could have believed how effective their bombing was on the North Vietnamese morale, they would have kept at it and maybe could have arranged a better peace plan than the one they ended up with. BTW one of my friends in South Vietnam was a guy called David Duncan, one of the best photographers I have ever known and one of the ballsiest guys I've ever known for taking risks to get "the" shot. RIP. He taught me more about photojournalism in three months than I ever learned in a classroom in two years. He was there when I got there and he was still there when I left. I only wish that I had a fraction of his talent and guts. He won many prizes, I think more than one Pulitzer but no medals, all though he would have deserved them if he had. He had more than one LIFE cover to his credit. He was the one who encouraged me to take the North Vietnamese assignment. I don't forget him; you don't forget guys like that.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by jdclyde

better watch who your being offensive to! Turn your nappy ass over to the annoyance police! ;\

by jdclyde

how many people equate arabs with terrorist. But that is what the press does to a story, and the people against the violence are not as good of a story as the scum throwing a fire bomb.

by dr dij

with terrorists, just the ones who actually do horrid stuff like beheading people or throwing firebombs or roadside bombs or snipers.

and now, unfortunately, the govt of Iran is terrorist. kind of like a psychotic, who you look at him wrong, and he says: I'm going to get you, my pretty (and your little dog Toto too!)

The worst thing is that they are promulgating hate as a way to control their people and keep them from thinking about the problems in their life. the horrors of organized religion will now keep them from developing normally as a people and becoming materially comfortable.

they've been using withholding of energy shipments to Turkey in an effort to sway the politics of Turkey from helping with the anti-nuke effort.

by sleepin'dawg

how many quarts a day does she give and what do you charge for the milk??? I take it you would take exception to someone sneaking a glass or two, through the fence.

BTW lighten up. You are wrong about American participation in WW II, just as much as you are wrong about the Americans in Vietnam. In case you think I'm an American that would make you wrong for the third time.

I was born in 41 after the "real" war was well underway, in fact over there, for all that matters and I was in and out of both North and South Vietnam in the late sixties and early seventies, as a photojournalist and I [b]know what I saw[/b]. You are so wrong and full of it your eyes must be brown and it wouldn't surprise me in the least if you were an American bashing Labour git. Our exposure to guys like you makes most of the populations of the former colonies, under 75, want to dispense with the Brit royal family, aside from the fact they are absolutely bloody useless in this day and age. You could say about as useful as boobs on a boar.

Another thing, I know you must have heard about something called the Dieppe Raid. Ask why, after that little fiasco, the Canadians would have mutinied before they would ever again accept being led into battle by another Brit. They came very close to doing just that. You want to talk about WW I then ask how many men Sir Douglas Haig was responsible for getting slaughtered in stupid frontal attacks. The man is a sort of ancestor of mine, a fact I'm not proud to admit and if the man had lived in WW II he would have been court martialed for incompetence and stupidity but the Brits saw fit to knight the butchering SOB. If it weren't for Canadians, Australians, New Zealanders and Americans you would be talking English with a German accent now. It might also interest you to know that Canada declared war on Germany in 1939 one whole day before your guys worked up the courage to pull the finger out. I guess Britain was a bit surprised to be going to war over Poland seeing as how they found it so easy when it came to caving in over Czechoslovakia.

[b]Dawg[/b] ]:)

by x-marcap

The problem with our republic is Congress is the the opposite of Progress..

There will always be people opposed to war. It is popular to be for "Peace". I will tell you nobody hates war more than those who must fight it. When my Squadron was under attack, I hated combat and the need for combat. From what I see historically Neil and the appeasers are enough sand to slow the gears down from a full out victory and get a negotiated settlement.

These type of treaties (Versailles, Paris, etc.) set up a renewal of conflict quite often. If we aren't there our people don't care. North Vietnam and North Korea were treated differently. We did win both conflicts. The media portrays us as losers and we were big winners...

The media and other leftists believe if they tell the big lie We'll all believe it. Hitler was a socialist. So are the liars in the media.

by tony hopkinson

Personally I'd agree with you on that front. Blackadder Goes Forth image of him sweeping up his toy soldiers with a dustpan and brush always springs to my mind.
However, have you read Forgotten Victory By Gary Sheffield. Not wholly convinced by Sheffield's arguments, but it did put your ancestor in a different light.
As for WWII, in a stand up fight how many shermans were required to take out a Tiger II or a Panther.
With the bombing of their industry coupled with the security and size of your own you out massed them.

You didn't get the opportunity to apply that might in Vietnam on enough occasions though, nor were the vietnamese dependant of large industrial complexes for caltrops and pungi sticks.

Perhaps I should have said call my mum a cow, or said apple pie was unwholesome , you might have got the point then.
LOL

by mjwx

an average of 5 shermans for one tiger (thats a standard tiger not a king tiger).

by Member 25348569

"We lost political support at home"

In WWII there was a goal, something nice and easy to lay before your population - "them or us". In Vietnam and Korea it was less clear-cut "fighting communism" and, eventually, people started asking "what for?". The same will happen with the "fight against terrorism" if it hasn't already.

"Bought the communist left lies" - bollocks. Who are these "communists" and where are they?

by rob mekel

Lets do that and see how it has become as it does.

In sept 2005 a Danish news-paper printed cartoons.
These cartoons where an insult to the Muslims, as said by Ahmed Abu Laban, imam in Copenhagen.
http://www.nrc.nl/krant/article212086.ece (sorry all, those are Dutch pages, hope you can read them)

Ahmed Abu Laban complained about these cartoons to the news paper and the Danish government.
As they, news-paper - Danish government, did not take action to apologies to the Muslim community, the imam put together a delegation to visit Egypt and Lebanon.
From there on the cartoon incident escalated in to what it is now becoming (is, to be more accurate).

Why the imam send the delegation to Egypt and Lebanon he don't answers, but does says that he isn't responsible for the action taken in these and other country's by people who spoke to the delegations.

Let for one take that the cartoons are an insult to the Muslims, and I sure do believe that they're neither flattering to Islam nor nice and do can be an insult.
My question is: what should one do if being insulted. At first I would say make your complaints noticed to the insulting party. Wait on the outcome and if okay leave it to that.
If not okay, then go to court to get the apologies. A Judge will rule and whether you like it or not there it stops unless taken to a higher court. In the end the Supreme Court will rule and there, what ever the outcome, it ends.

So why didn't the imam do this, I think the answer lies within the why he send the delegation to Egypt and Lebanon but as the imam didn't answer that question, I can't tell.

My guess is that, he didn't have faith in the legal-system of Denmark / didn't believe that he would be done justice. My believe it is that this is the difference between the systems we have in the ?west? and those in the Arabic country?s. It took us more then 400 years to become to as where we are now. Does this mean that others should be given the same amount of time? I think not, as they can learn from us and our mistakes.
As for starters we, Dutch, had our freedom of religion fight in the late 1500?s early to mid 1600?s ( so called 80 year war) or Spanish inquisition, or Northern Ireland, a hum, and that is still going on (hopefully it will end soon) are not free of mistakes. That is why we have a law that forbids mocking of religion.

Rob

by maxwell edison

.
....unless one chooses to be insulted.

"If you're insulted, you can leave in a taxi. If that's not fast enough, you can leave in a huff. If that's too fast, you can leave in a minute and a huff."
- Marx (Groucho, that is)

by rob mekel

and yes Max you did take a step back to watch what the heck is going on.

And right you are, as was Groucho Marx, but then the imam didn't say HE was insulted but the Muslim community. As in they are .... whatever, doesn't make clear who is being meant!

Love the quote tho :)

Rob

by jdclyde

We don't have one in the US, and I don't recall where you are from.

Waiting 400 years? These countries and the people that are still just savages have been around longer than 400 years. Religious changes sure, but that doesn't make them a whole new country.

Again, Muslims should be shown the same tolerence they show others. Very little. Follow the laws of man or stay savages in their own craphole countries and don't even THINK about migratting to another country if your willing to be assemilated into that society.

You HAVE to live by the laws in the lands you move to as being a religious nutcase does not give you special rights.

We don't allow human or animal sacrifices here either, and THAT is a direct violation of someones religious beliefs. Think about it.

by rob mekel

but matter of fact is that may EU states have such laws. England had them renewed, as I correct recall, in the early 1990's. And you are right the USA does not have such law, but has its Constitution's Bill of Rights.

Tnx for agreeing on me on this matter.

Don't think, however, that if one does not agree upon matter put to paper, one has to move to an other country. (BTW did mis a not in the assemilated sentens, so i'm not clear about if you mean that they should assimilate or not, lol ]:))

didn't know what to do with us Dutch so they did the one thing they're good at, make it difficult to others to know who we mean.

And right you are again, that is just what I put in. No special rights for having a religion whatever the religion (or not) maybe.

I dunno about human sacrifices, hope there prohibited, but sure do know that the slaughter of animals on religious grounds is permitted in the USA. You could call that sacrifices. :O

Rob

Sure could use a laugh :D:D

by montgomery gator

..violate both freedom of religion and freedom of speech. If the Dutch do believe in freedom, they need to allow the marketplace of ideas to be free. My religion requires me to say that all other religions are wrong. I believe that Jesus is "the Way, the Truth, and the Light", no one can come to the Father (or be saved and have eternal life) except through Him and His mercy. I would not say that in a mocking way, but a Muslim, or a Hindu may be offended and accuse me of mocking his religion, and have me convicted because of my Christian beliefs. That is the danger of such laws.

I have strong faith, but I would not in any way restrict anyone else from practicing his faith, since my Christian faith teaches me that one can become a true Christian only by Free Will, by choosing to accept Jesus as the True Son of God and Savior, and believe in the Holy Trinity of Father, Son, and Holy Spirit. Any coercion (such as the Spanish Inquisition) would not result in a true conversion, and therefore, would be un-Christian.

by rob mekel

and yes forbidding something is always giving less room to another (thing). That is why we(in general) have to make choices.

Rob

by mirrormirror

On this path, we are not too far from having sharia imposed on us. It seems that we are all being forced by fear into some kind of shame for not being Mulsim by these radicals. How long before all other religions have to take a back seat to Islam with these kinds of tactics and the world's lack of backbone?

This editorial makes a good point and is worth thinking about.

http://www.washingtontimes.com/op-ed/dwest.htm

What do you think?

by hal 9000

All I saw in that Editorial as more Self Serving Holier than Tho Media BS!

So they don't want to print or show cartoons that may offend one religious group and have exercised some minor restraint. [b]RUBBISH![/b]

Go give the National Enquirer the Plans of any new as yet unbuilt Military Piece of Equipment does that give them the right to publish the specifications of that piece of equipment?

Does the Wall Street Journal have the right to print the way to make a Fission Weapon?

Each is possible but they don't because they are quite rightfully fearful of the response of the US Government which would only be acting correctly by putting all those involved in jail.

If it is correct not to print or broadcast the above why should it be OK to Print or Broadcast something that is going to stir up Religious Hatred?

Sorry but I see the editorial as nothing more than a Hypocritical Media attempting to defend itself for its actions after making as much money as possible out of this incident.

After all the Responsibility of the Media isn't to correctly report News but to make Money for the Share Holders.

[b]And nothing brings in money like a small war with those you already distrust.[/b]

Col

by Member 25348569

We have no laws protecting religion other than some ancient blasphemy laws that "protect" the Church of England. The government is presently engaged in trying to railroad through a law of this type that they state is to give Muslims the same protection presently held under the race-relations legislation by religious groups that are also races - Sikhs, Jews, etc.

In the UK, it is now illegal to describe an ethnic group as, say, "morons" and, to be honest, I wouldn't want to and wouldn't feel it ever justifiable. But, if the new law is passed, I couldn't call Christian or Muslim believers similarly intellectually challenged without risk of prosecution.

I hate that law!

Here's my standards. Race - and gender, disability - is something people cannot choose and it defines nothing about them as people. But your beliefs are what you choose to identify with. I want the right to call people stupid for their beliefs - even if it is, sometimes, unwise.

by rob mekel

I meant.

Hate it myself too cause it actually says: You people can't behave, so we will tell you how to behave.

:D:D

Rob

by jdclyde

is that you shouldn't be attacking an entire class of people, even if it is over something they choose to believe.

Race hate and religious hate have gone hand in hand for a long time. Many are not able to always make a distinction between the two.

Did Hitler try to wipe out the Jews because of their religious beliefs or because of their ethnicity?

by tonythetiger

at least not by the person who holds them. They are usually instilled by (or with the consent of) parents from a young age, and will be held until sufficiently compelling evidence to the contrary appears.

by jdclyde

[b]Puts women complaining about discrimination here in the US in a whole new light, huh? "glass ceiling" would be the LEAST of concerns in a Muslim nation.[i] (not justifying ANY discrimination, so don't start!)[/i]
Also note the age of consent to marry. (13) In the states we call these people pedophiles and perverts then lock them up. In other countries they call them "Muslims".[/b]

"The Quran permits men to use physical force against disobedient wives in some circumstances"

"In Syria, a wife can work without her husband's consent, if she renounces her claim on him for financial support"

"a Muslim woman cannot be married legally to a non-Muslim man, but a Muslim man can be married to a non-Muslim woman"

"in Iran, the age of consent is 13 for females and 15 for males, and younger with a court's permission. In Yemen, the minimum marriage age is 15"

"Divorce: Under sharia, the husband has the unilateral right to divorce his wife without cause. He can accomplish this by uttering the phrase "I divorce you" three times over the course of three months. If he does divorce her, he must pay her a sum of money agreed to before the wedding in the marriage contract and permit her to keep her dowry, Powers says. Classicalsharia lays out very limited conditions under which a woman can divorce a man--he must be infertile at the time of marriage; insane; or have leprosy or another contagious skin disease. Most Islamic nations, including Egypt and Iran, now allow women to sue for divorce for many other reasons, including the failure to provide financial support."

"Custody: In a divorce, the children traditionally belong to the father, but the mother has the right to care for them while they are young, Powers says. The age at which a mother loses custody differs from nation to nation. In Iran, the mother's custody ends at seven for boys and girls; in Pakistan, it's seven for boys and puberty for girls. Many nations, however, allow courts to extend the mother's custody if it is deemed in the child's interest."

"Inheritance: Mothers, wives, and daughters are guaranteed an inheritance in the case of a man's death. In the seventh century A.D., when the law was developed, this was a major step forward for women, Powers says. However, sharia also dictates that men inherit twice the share of women because, traditionally, men were responsible for women, Powers says."

by Member 25348569

that there were all sorts of "second class citizens". Women got the vote in both our countries much later than men and then only because their work during WWI made it obvious that they were equally competent.

Admittedly, the Muslim attitude is sick but we're not totally innocent not that long ago. Even now, the Catholic Church will not ordain women and if you listen to some of the weasely excuses...

by jdclyde

on religious grounds? Maybe for a nice steak, but not for religion.

You can get in more trouble for abusing a pet than for abusing a spouse here. :O

They even go so far as to make sure that the way livestock is raised and killed for food is all done "humainly".

There was a time when cattle were killed by a sledge hammer up side the head. This was seen as "cruel" so it is the last I heard a 22 cal shot in the head.

There even used to be a slaughter house in one of the local towns, right on the river. The river would be red from all the blood running into it. coooool! (not a small river either, but a shipping channel!)

MMMMMM, steak!

by montgomery gator

I have heard on the news that the Congress in the USA is trying to shut down slaughterhouses that slaughter horses for meat to sell to the Europeans. The proposal is to not fund the inspectors, so that the slaughterhouses will not get inspected, preventing them from doing their work.

Now, that is just crazy. At a time we have trade deficits, this will stop an export business. And what is the difference between slaughtering and eating horses, and doing the same with cattle and pigs? I see no reason to halt this other than some people get too emotional about horses in a way they don't feel about cattle and pigs. Even some Republicans are supporting this bill, which is contrary to the Republican principle of using reason instead of emotion. Let the slaughter houses continue to process horses, employ workers, and earn export income for the USA.

http://www.latimes.com/news/nationworld/nation/la-na-horses8feb08,0,5752618.story?coll=la-headlines-nation

by tonythetiger

should be held to higher standards, since what they do so greatly affects us and even changes our world.

They choose what to report and what not to report, and how they report it. They can control how important something sounds depending on how they want us to react to it. For example, if they headline "Oil prices set to sky-rocket", it's a sure bet that they will, irregardless of the presence of, or the accuracy of supporting data. They also can play up the negatives and downplay the positives to make something (or someone) worse than it actually is.

Now it's easy to say that it's politically motivated (we've all heard references to the 'liberal press'), but I don't think that's all of it. Bad news sells, plain and simple. And anything they think is going to generate bad news they are going to highlight. Oh, they give lip service to good news, and of course, any attempt to downplay the obvious stuff would be, well, obvious. But more headlines lean to the bad news side than to the good news side. The old saying, 'No news is good news' sprang from this, I think.

Not that there's much we can do about it. One of my pet peeves is the mention of 'anonymous sources' in a news story. I understand that there's some stories that would never seee the light of day without these anonymous sources, but there's also a lot of room for using them for deciet.

I would like to be able to expect that the news is 100% factual as well as fair and balanced. Unfortunately I don't think that it will happen in my lifetime.

by jdclyde

There should be much more accountability.

If someone runs a story that they KNOW is false or has no data to back it up but still present it like a fact, should be put in jail, and heavy fines for the media outlet that LET them run the false stories.

If they can fine someone a few hundred thousand for being a pervert and telling "fart jokes", why can't they apply some regulation for the TRUTH?

Run a story, be able to back it up. If you CAN't back it up SAY SO. "rumor has it" or whatever to let people know that this is NOT a fact. This will still get the word out on possible problems when it is needed to keep the governments in line, yet lets the readers/viewers know the level of crediblity to apply to a story.

I even heard a theory that much of the media is SO radically left leaning to intentionally make them look like nuts so you will vote Conservative. Funny, but I don't believe it.

by jdclyde

I wasn't implying YOU with that comment, and should have been clearer.

It was just an observation in passing on the state of things.

My humble apologies for not being more concise with my post.

by tonythetiger

"Around the world people, we are seeing the true face is Islam."

No, we are not. We are seeing what the press wants us to see, because it's what sells news. Most people like to see others' dirty laundry. They demand a front-row seat to see the misfortune of others (why do people slow down and stare at accident scenes?). The press is just giving us what we want.

by tonythetiger

"this is baby-ish and retarded. in a previous post, I blamed the mullahs. In all fairness, I did however see some mullahs trying to (ineffectively) stop the violence on tv segment."

One might wonder if they were trying to stop the violence, or trying to be ineffective.

by mjwx

The US suffered from extremely bad intelligence during the Vietnam war. The NVA/VC on the other had had an expensive spy network and a hidden base right under a US regional HQ. This combined with the restrictions you spoke of made Nam a lost cause (IMO).

P.S. the province the Aussie?s protected in Vietnam has one of the lowest levels of guerrilla activity throughout the entire war. 1st, 2nd or 3rd out of 47 at any one time. I was also told it was the most secure place during the Tet offensive (I don?t know how accurate my info is because it came from an Aussie Vietnam vet I met when I was working at a RSL club). Reason why Aussies were more effective than yanks in Vietnam, we were trained jungle fighters.

by mjwx

A war without clear and attainable objectives is impossible to win no matter how many of the enemy you killed. Kill Communism is not a clearly defined objective. JD touched on this in his post above by pointing out the restrictions placed on troops by the government.

by mjwx

Vietnam is generally accepted as the conflict between Sun Tzu?s principles of deception based warfare and Clausewitz?s principle of ultra-violence. While ultra-violence won almost every battle, deception ultimately won the war. The conclusion is that ultra-violence is a good tactic (if you don?t care about lives (Monty did and this was his problem)) while deception is a good strategy.

Beside?s the point who?s suffering insurgency in Iraq?

2 Aussie soldiers have died in Iraq. One was run over in a training accident and the other stepped on a land mine. I don?t want to think about American or British casualties.

The casualties suffered by all nations and by all non combatants should be on your head good sir. How many royal marines died? How many civilians have died? Did they deserve to die? How many mothers no longer have a son? You?re good at throwing about your opinions about what America should have done, but can you answer the hard questions.

Dawg, I heard reason coming from your post so I?m addressing this specifically to TJ and not to the US. I?ve talked to you about Sun Tzu before and I was wondering if you have read it? There are other ways to destroy fundamentalism than with a bomb. IMO the best way to defeat Islam radical?s is to separate them from mainstream Islam (I know, easier said than done).

by montgomery gator

And I guess I am going to get the Calvinists after me because I believe in the doctrine of Free Will instead of the Calvinist doctrine of Predestination. :-)

by montgomery gator

Hitler tried to wipe out the Jews because he was a twisted, insane, hateful, extremely evil nutter who was able to deceive the masses to go along with his diabolical plans.

by x-marcap

The best and IMHO the only way for Germany to win in WW II was for the US not to enter it until they had consolidated most/all of Europe. Germany was/is a country with resources less than the state of Texas. When Japan attacked the US Panay on the Yellow river, Hitler literally stopped Von Paulus's advances until he saw what the US would do.

We did nothing. So, Hitler and Japan were emboldened. We then allowed the Chi-Coms to take over China. (Another dumb mistake by politicians.)

The one thing that the British,French,Germans,all lack that the US has in quantity is bountiful natural resources and a population that can make use of them. While Hitler was putting 90% GDP into WWII The US used less than 20% GDP... And many Americans thought that was too much.

We have only fought one war all out. That was the civil war. Many of the greatest advances in warfare in a short time happened then. American's fought harder over state's rights and slavery than we did against the Axis powers. We lost more American men at Gettysburg than in some other wars. The step from Mine ball to brass cartridge and smokeless powder was a huge step... Armored ships and on and on (Barrels or Tanks) High power artillery...

In Charleston, There is what we call Mortars. (it is a fat round short Cannon) I saw one throw a load of shot far out into the Ocean. I have seen European battlefields. European lands had healed after 30 years. Some areas of the South may never really be healed after 140 years. Salt and Mercury poisoning...

Eisenhower wanted to perserve European istory. That was detrimental to "Total" war. Montgomery wouldn't use tanks to roll over resistance in graveyards.

The battle in the South Pacific was waged by MacArthur in a savage and successful manner. There is little doubt that had MacArther gotten supplied as well as Eisenhower, There wouldn't have been any resistance left in Asia before Eisenhower had even finished his war plans. Then The Germans would have faced Mac and the Russians in the East, with the Indians, Aussies and the rest of the world. We would have crushed Hitler. I am sure he'd have sued for peace very early on. Maybe I am overly impressed with Marines and The Southwest Pacific actions, but I have long thought that With the Selection of George Marshall to the Joint Chiefs of staff, and Eisenhower to European theatre commander FDR made so many horrid mistakes that it is a miracle WWII was ever won by the allies.

Another thing about Americans is that we aren't predictable. We retreated from Shanghai and China, but fought for every inch of the Philippines. I occasionally still thank God for both Douglas MacArthur, and Wendell Fertig.

Fertig was a highly decorated West Pointer who led Americans to resist and drive the Japanese out of Mindano. OOPS, scratch that. Fertic was a Civil Engineer, who fought back and went from a Lieutenant, was eventually promoted to Lt. Colonel, USAR and appointed himself Brigadier General and led troops so well that he was later recognized by the Green Berets. He drove the Japanese army off Mindano. He also had a military band to welcome Mac back to the Philippines.

The last point is Americans know we can fight. We just don't know if we will. That is the saddest part.We have the power and ability to stop terrorism...

Do we have the will? Politically and personally?

by Member 25348569

"The US has a habit of going to war way too late." It is still my opinion that you entered WWII at, luckily, absolutely the correct time for the outcome that we had.

Any attempts by the US to land in Europe before you were fully geared up would have resulted in a crushing defeat. The British Army, undertrained as any 1939/40 American Expeditionary Force would have been, was a packed lunch for the Wermacht which was, as you said, from a country fully geared for war. In 1939, Hitler had not opened the Eastern Front. Had you attempted some form of attack in Poland, you may well have brought the Russians in on the side of Hitler although, even had that happened, it wouldn't have lasted. Probably.

Anyway, it is certain that public opinion at home would have turned viciously against the political masters who took you into the war at such an early stage and engineered the defeat and you may have withdrawn into even greater isolationism that was apparent in 1939.

I would still dispute that you can stop terrorism. Anything that you do with your undeniable "power and ability" will likely make it worse!

Neil

by jdclyde

even " twisted, insane, hateful, extremely evil nutter"'s would have SOME reason to pick up the Jews like that.

I remember hearing something about his mother cleaned house for the Jews as he was growing up?

by dr dij

and they are all right. there is no 'right' spelling. they are all 'transliterated'. they are simply put to closest sounding names in english. same reason quadaffi is also spelled kadaffi and some other spellings.

by jamesrl

There is some more recent speculation among historians that Hitler didn't have any particular hatred of the Jews, at least during his formative years.

Hitler served in WWI, and from many Germans' perspective, after the eastern front closed (Russian Revolution) and the eastern troops moved west, everyone thought that the Germans finally had a chance for victory in the west. But there was a somewhat rapid decline over the course of 1918, with food and fuel shortages for the first time in the war.

Many Germans thought it was a little too rapid and were looking for someone to blame, a scapegoat, as they could not accept that Germany lost on "fair" terms. Anti-semiticism was popular among the audience that Hitler was after, so many speculate he adopted it in order to recruit his base. The speculation was that German jews in the financial sector sold out the Kaiser to get peace - nonsense of course, but it played into what the troubled masses wanted to hear.

It is very true that this may be a cynical perspective of history and may even paint Hitler in a more monstrous light. He knew that he could manipulate the feelings of both his ardent supporters and the masses to bend to his will.

He also knew that high in the Nazi party there were those who would push for the total annihilation of Jews in the Reich. If he didn't order the Wannesee conference (where the plans were drawn up for the death camps) he certainly was aware of it and did nothing to stop it.

Was this because of religion or ethnicity? I don't think anyone at that time made the distinction.

James

by tonythetiger

"Run a story, be able to back it up. If you CAN't back it up SAY SO. "rumor has it" or whatever to let people know that this is NOT a fact."

... are the words used when they can't back something up. But even using these words, a person's reputation can be irreparably damaged, because Joe Average glosses over that word, and there's very little recourse.

Even when they do get caught in a blatant lie, what usually happens is they are ordered to print a retraction (in two-point type at the bottom of the fourth column on page 19).

It's getting so bad that I run everything I read or hear through a litmus test of sorts. If it's not too controversial, and I can't think of a reason someone would lie about it, I will consider believing it.

by nz_justice

The media over exaggerate and over sensationalise reality. Teenage punks perform acts of violence every day the media blows it out of proportion and then everything turns political. A few pictures/video's with some sensational head lines and dramatic voice overs and every thing gets blown out of proportion. Muslims aren't demanding tolerance, the editors of the news shows and papers trying to get a reality TV show Emmy\more ratings\more sales are demanding tolerance. As much as the media wants us to believe that Muslims have gone out of control and turned into wild lunatics, It is not really what is happening.

Don't condemn the Muslims because the media is being their voice, condemn the media.

by mirrormirror

Do you have some proof that the media is blowing this out of proportion? I know that it happens all the time. However, I think that this time the Imans deserve some of the blame as well.

According to the media the world is on fire and will end soon. At least, that is what they would like you to believe...

by nz_justice

My mind is drawing a blank, every time I try to reply to your post "blank". I got "posters block" or something, maybe sleep would help.

Good reply

;)

by hal 9000

The Cartoon was originally Published in a Danish Newspaper.

Result a Small Demonstration against the News Paper.

Next Major Media Reporting of the Demonstration and vague references to the cartoon while each and every Media company was breaking their necks to get publishing rights.

The More that the Cartoon was published the bigger the Demonstrations got until they reached a stage where in the Gaza Strip the Danish Embassy was destroyed an Embassy which by the way was never considered as a threat prior to the publication of the Cartoon and more often than not was seen by those who live there as [b]Neutral.[/b]

Haven't you noticed yet that the more that the cartoon is published the greater the violence gets? And who is there to cover the Violence [b]The Media[/b] so they will be picking the best bits of footage and still pictures to use in their reporting won't they?

Col

by jmgarvin

Gah...I think the major problem is that it is considered ACCEPTABLE behavior.

When the moderates VOCALLY denouce the nut jobs, THEN we will see these radical idiots shut up and sit down.

by mjwx

When Hitler declared war on Russia. The US just ensured that Western Europe ended up free. Without the US continental Europe would be entirely Russian instead of half Russian. When the US entered the war, After El Alamein Rommel was in full retreat across North Africa and running out of fuel thanks to the royal navy?s submarine corp. Hitler had called a stop to the daylight raids on England, effectively conceding defeat in the battle of Brittan. Australian and dominion forces in the pacific were managing to slow the Japanese advance which would have stopped anyway as they were running out of oil. At the time however the then considerable Japanese navy was steaming eastwards towards the US because they needed oil that the US were denying them. If the US stayed out of the war Russia would own continental Europe and if Japan stayed out the US never would have entered.

WW II was fought in two halves, the first by British and dominion forces, the second by the US and her allies backed by US industrial might.

by jdclyde

was it that 13 year old girls were fair game? a few hundred years?

Do we just write this off as only culture? From Mae's response to the Japanese craving for younger girls, I would say we pretty much look down on them on this aspect? Becaues it is their culture, would we allow them to bring their 13 year old BRIDE[b]S[/b] here to the states to start a new life? Or take them to the UK? Would our governments look the other way or lock them up and put them on the sex offender listing as child molesters?

by mjwx

That rejected his applications to the Vienna academy of arts (in reality it was because he couldn't draw people).

Maybe not the decisive factor but certainly the beginning

by Member 25348569

was just that our own cultures' records with regards to women is not one of complete equality - even now. If were going to criticise them then we have to do it with the full knowledge that if we declare that we are better than the Muslims then we have to acknowledge our own shortcomings. Well, you do - I don't have any.

Trust me, I really, really don't like Muslims. With my anti-religion track record, how could I? I am still spitting chips of teeth over last Friday's demonstrations over here.

Neil

by jdclyde

No, it takes the full amount of time as long as she is cute and .. oh, thats not what you meant? oops!

I refuse to condon inapropreate behavior in someone today just because someone else did the almost as bad of behavior at some time in the distant past. (under 40, so for me it IS distant past! B-) )

The Crusades are done and over with. We LEARNED from mistakes and will not allow someone else to continue to make the same mistakes.

Tolerance? Two way street.

Innocent? Thats ME! So yes, the Muslim nations are sick twisted perverted child molesting savages that should be in chains.

(what was the old Charles Bronson show where he married a little girl and then brought her back to the states?)

by tony hopkinson

Can't see anything silly about it.
Not even with 100% support could you have won in vietnam, all you could have done was killed them all. If you want to call that winning fine !

Fighting terror is not the question, it's how. Options range from nuke and pave to conversion. Get 100% support for the method, not on this planet.
Nothing to do with resolve to fight, everything to do with how far you are prepared to go to win.

War on terror is never going to work, every enemy you defeat creates two more.

by tony hopkinson

Indeed you did. The butcher's bill was a vote loser. Without an immediate and aggressive opponent it's very hard for a democracy to prosecute a war.

I like the bought the communist lie bit by the way. Got to agree, some of us are bit poorer than others and it was the only one we could afford.

by tony hopkinson

Hilter breaking his treaty with Russia
Hitler backing the japanese
Attacking american shipping.
Hitler's belief in existing german miltary might translating to defeating russia before winter set in.
If he'd have left it to his generals, I'd be goose stepping to work. Fortunately he couldn't win a game of risk with ten dice.

As for the japanese, what did they get out of Pearl Harbour ? When they invaded china they should have picked up a few copies of the 'Art Of War'. That's got to be one of the dumbest strategic decisions ever made.

by tony hopkinson

has pretty much stopped the destestable practice of conversion by the sword, a sizable pecentage of the islamic world hasn't caught up. They are unable for various reasons to do one of the most sensible things in our constitutions, divorce church and state. Hence they see the invasion of western values into their societies as an attack on their values, which includes their faith. I'm in no way justifying terrorism, but until we understand the why of it, and attack that, we'll never beat it.

As for the oil argument, that's out fault we are addicted to it. We have loads of people who make vast profits out profit's use, and we are the people who think it's OK to pollute our planet in the names of 'progress'. Also we are the ones who promote that sort of selfishness, not their fault they have the oil and we need it. Western businessmen would have done exactly the same, made money hand over fist.

A famous quote in the western good book about beams and motes springs to mind. Or for the less well educated , Don't throw bricks about when you live in a glasshouse.

Was going to say greenhouse there, but that's another well visited thread.

by maxwell edison

I read only the first part of your message, the one in which you were rehashing political decisions of the late 1930s at it related to W.W.II, and the political climate of almost 100 years ago as it related to W.W.I. That's about as far as I read, deciding at that point that your message was just down-right silly. I didn't even mention Vietnam in my reply, did I? (I did mention Vietnam in a different message, but in a vastly different context and intent.) And I still contend that saying such a thing is not only silly, but stupid and ignorant as well. (And it pointed out Europe's dismal failures over the past 100 years.)

Not only that, but what friggin' point were you trying to make? That the USA is again entering the fight too late? Since we're the only one in the fight today (with England, Australia, and a few other nations, of course), and considering we are leading the way, I ask again, what point are you trying to make? The only possible point is to show how it's not the USA, but the rest of the world late on this one. So you appear to be criticizing the USA for entering those past wars too late as justification for your criticism of the USA for entering this one too ..... what, too early? Like I said, your message is just down right silly. And that's being kind.

But for the record, here's my opinion on the "war on terrorism".

I've said it before, and I'll say it again. We had war declared on us years, if not decades, before 9-11. For the past thirty or more years, radical Islamic fanatics have been at war with the west, in general, and the United States in particular, being met with only a tepid response, at best, to their tactic of choice, terrorism. The United Nations has been unable or unwilling to deal with it; and with the exception of Israel, every nation in the word, including the United States, has also been unable or unwilling to deal with the threat. We've all been paying only lip service, at best, to a grave threat. And not only have we been paying it no more than lip service, but in many ways, we (the world and the USA) have actually facilitated its growth.

President Bush is the only American president, and the only world leader, to FINALLY attack the real problem head-on -- in its entirety, seeing the bigger picture, not the usual and isolated lip service; and we FINALLY declared war back on them. However, I believe that the President and the U.S. Congress made a mistake in their approach to this thing, and the politicking going on in Washington and in the world wasn't making it any better. Terrorism is a tactic, not an enemy. And I think the president erred when he declared this a war on terrorism, a tactic, instead of a war on radical Islam, an enemy.

However, I can see why that wasn't a viable option, for many reasons. First of all, we certainly couldn't make this look like a religious war, per se. And quite frankly, if this war had been declared in a manner similar to others, we would have had to declare war on Afghanistan, Pakistan, Iran, Iraq, Syria, and Sudan, in the very least; and perhaps even Saudi Arabia, Indonesia, and a few other nations as well! It could be strongly argued that if the state governments of those nations either facilitated or even tolerated such fringe extremist groups to grow and operate within their nations, that the very state itself was culpable for their actions. If Pat Robertson and his ilk, for example, grew and espoused violence on others in the name of their religion, trained and deployed suicide bombers to kill and inflict terror abroad, stole airplanes and crashed them into buildings in downtown Tehran, then the rest of the world would indeed hold the United States government both responsible and culpable for their actions. But if such things did happen in the US, then the US government itself would be the first to step-up and put a stop to it, something those Islamic nations did not, or could not do. Those governments failure to stop it is tantamount to those governments condoning it.

But like I said, that just wouldn't be a viable option. So here we are, going it alone (at whatever you want to call it), and being criticized all the more for the efforts. And while we may be late getting into this particular fight against radical Islamic fanatics, much of the rest of the world is still stuck on never.

And go ahead, Tony. Rehash all that stuff from the past. Tell us all how the United Stated did this wrong, and that wrong, and everything else wrong over the past 100 years. (But it was Europe dragged down in war for those 100 years -- great job, guys.) Therefore what, Tony? How does that possibly have any bearing on deciding what to do next? (And please spare me the history lessons and the "doomed to repeat it" crap.)

How about posting a message that isn't dripping with silly and insignificant blabber. Maybe you can post some justification, for example, of why we should follow the lead of the inept, incompetent, and corrupt United Nations. Yea, right. Sarcasm alert: They've been doing such a good job combating this thing for the past thirty years, haven't they? Let's just do what they want.

by tony hopkinson

However I was and always will argue against the idea that the US entering WWII too late. That's a widely held British belief, but when you look at basic military doctrine, standard diplomacy and history compeletely fallacious.
First of all you won, if you'd have been late, it would have been over wouldn't it?
Why do people always miss the obvious ?

Sun Tzu, would have commended your strategy, because it would have been much harder and american losses would have been far greater if you'd entered earlier. The argument that Adolf might have piped down, if you'd have loomed over him I do not accept, man was too stupid to be afraid.

Clausewitz would also have been happy with your strategy, after the war, politically you were in an extremely strong position. In fact you still are, the only things making inroads into that are industrialisation of china and the rise of the EU.
10/10 for FDR and co, the fact that we ended up with the brown end of the stick, means we took our eye off the ball. No point in whining about it, you won, we lost. We'd have done the same to you given the opportunity and we'd have expected you to be grateful for it.
Why you won the war, well only a halfwit would say it was one particular factor. The single biggest one was definitely your economy in my opinion. Will and resolve I take as a given in any nation, after all without the desire to fight there won't we a war, just a surrender. Why did that desire occur?
Germany successes were beginning to be worrying
The abysmal stupidity in lining up with japan
German attacks on your shipping
America's desire to be the biggest dawg in the yard.
You know more about it than I, but everything I've read says that the american people were not interested in fighting 'our' war in 39. Not didn't have the balls, not too busy navel gazing, just not f'ing interested in dying for it. Why should you have been ? Until there was support for doing it, entering the war would have been madness.

Don't take everything as an attack MAX & 'Dawg. I aren't going to agree with you all the time, that would be boring. But only someone blinded by their own patriotism would say you entered WWII or I too late.

Vietnam.
I don't think you should have fought it.
I don't think you could have won
I know you didn't win
I'm positive if there had been real political support for that war, you would have fought it differently. Awe and Destruction mode was the way to go in there, to have a chance with a straight arm wrestle.
The reason I don't think you could have won? You remember that really bad film Red Dawn?. How many generations do you think the american people would have to be oppressed by a foreign power before they gave up their brand of freedom ? How much would it cost any invading power to maintain the level of effort required to fail slowly. Too different, you are never going to turn a vietnamese into an american, an american into a russian, an afghan into a russian, a brit into a german, or an iraqi into a westerner. Our values are our values because of what we are. Imposing them on someone else, denigrates everything that they value and everything that we value.

by maxwell edison

....because you didn't touch on a dang thing I said.

If you want to debate the historical accuracy of people's views of events that happened decades ago, you'll be arguing with yourself as far as I'm concerned.

And you wonder why I called your messages silly?

Okay, they just got promoted to absurd.

by hal 9000

But maybe a different bit of prospective might help you understand slightly better.

Forget the religious group in question here and ask your self how it is possible for a so called Highly Religious Person to sanction anything so reprehensible as acts like this?

Or how a So called "Right To Life Believer" doesn't find any problems in killing to get their way.

If I'm not mistaken several Doctors who perform Abortions in the US have been Murdered by these people haven't they? Do you know how many Abortion Clinics have been bombed by these people world wide?

Or to take it from a totally different prospective in Ireland the Catholic Church Followers had a small war going on for several decades over their belief in their Religion being the only right one and no one else having the right to appose them. These people who where supposed to be devoutly religious killed many people recklessly bomb Hotels nearly killing the then British Prime Minister and actually killing several Cabinet Ministers of the British Government.

They also killed many others just because they where suspected of something that the IRA didn't support, this organization didn't need proof but the merest hint of suspicion was enough to kill people and on numerous occasions in public where people not related to the violence got caught in the cross fire.

Then you have the so called Pacifist's Krishna's owning heavy armaments factories and securing their main compound tighter than most Military Bases.

Or a Lay Preacher for some minor sect telling their followers that the Devil was coming and getting them all to drink Poison to save their souls.

The problem with this Cartoon isn't so much Religious in Nature as Fundamentalists in nature and when ever you get Fanatical Fundamentalists with money to burn and oppressed people you have a recipe for disaster.

Personally I don't think that the actual cartoon/s was the real issue here but a good excuse to start something off and the Media in its [b]Righteous Indignation[/b] [i]"Fundamentalists Again"[/i] weren't happy with just printing the cartoon once but had to spread it all over the world under their Aspics of [b]Reporting News[/b] when in actual fact they knew exactly what would happen and where in the business of [b]Creating News[/b] rather than reporting it after the event.

If I remember correctly a comedy movie called the [b]Life of Brian[/b] stirred up a lot of controversy in the Bible Belt of the US didn't it? Now if those people where not the affluent people that they are and lived in a different country under constant repression no doubt you would have seen exactly the same things occur that are occurring now as a direct result of Stupidity on the part of the Media who are not happy to just report events but are driving them in this case.

Living in the US with News that gives you only what the Networks want you to see doesn't give you a balanced view of what is actually happening in the world. From the very little that I've seen of this mess the more that the Media pushes the right buttons the more it is that the Fundamentalists Muslims react.

Even here in Queensland Australia the one Big News Paper Chain has published this cartoon at least twice now in areas with minority Muslim Populations but at the same time make a big deal about the Freedom of the Press and allow the information that they are publishing the offensive Cartoon to be displayed on their Web Sites stirring the pot just that much more.

Is the cartoon offensive? Probably to some as I haven't seen it I don't know personally but from the reaction when it was originally published it's obvious to any sane person that it has offended at the very least some people and they have reacted.

What has the Media actually done here? Well they started off by making a big deal out of what started off as a relatively minor issue and have blown it out of all proportion and have kept stirring the pot by continually publishing the cartoon and instead of [b]pouring oil on troubled waters[/b] have actually feed the feeding frenzy and made things much worse than they ever needed to be.

I see a lot about [b]Freedom of the Press[/b] but so far I haven't seen one word printed about [b]The Responsibility of the Press.[/b] When it's all said and done the only reality here is the profit margin of the various media outlets so honestly it's in their best interests to stir things up as much as possible and in Gaza they have the perfect breeding grounds for this.

A country that has been occupied for well over 30 years through no fault of their own. A recently Dead Leader who can only be at best described as a Terrorist and other Muslim countries pouring in funds in an attempt to make restitution for the current situation that the Palestinians now find themselves in when they rolled over Palestine in an attempt to Invade and Conquer Israel.

In this particular case no one is beyond reproach and until things in that part of the world settle down it will remain the Boiling Point that it currently is. What is worse However is the way that this issue is being pushed around the world and attempting to involve other Muslim Fundamentalists in the cause.

The sad fact of this is that the Media Started this off and it will be left to others to fix it up while the Media reports all the gory details in a manner that suits their own ends.

Col

by maxwell edison

You can't compare the rare and isolated case of a right-to-life advocate who kills a doctor, to the Muslim fanatics who, in the name of their prophet, Mohammed, kill thousands and advocate violence and destruction against the rest of the entire world.

How many deaths have been inflicted by Muslim fanatics in the name of their prophet, Mohammed over the past 30 years? The answer is, undoubtedly, in the tens of thousands, perhaps even more. How many deaths have been caused by right-to-life advocates over the past 30 years? The answer is probably no more than ten.

And I'll further ask you this. How many existing (or recently existed) nation-states have not only condoned, but facilitated and encouraged those Muslim fanatics who, in the name of their prophet, Mohammed, kill thousands and advocate violence and destruction against the rest of the entire world? The answer is quite a few! And how many existing (or recently existed) nation-states have not only condoned, but facilitated and encouraged those right-to-life advocate who've killed doctors and bombed abortion clinics? Correct me if my answer of ZERO is incorrect.

And let's compare their respective numbers. We're talking about, perhaps, a number in the millions of Muslim fanatics compared to a mere handful of the fanatical right-to-life advocate.

Your comparison is like comparing the fastest and most powerful motorcycle to a roller skate. (Make that a single wheel of a single roller skate.) Or the size and power of a pebble compared to the size and power of the Sun, because they're both round.

And if you want to compare this to the Christian crusades of hundreds of years ago, that is, of course, a more accurate comparison; but the comparison in today's reality is rather meaningless, as it only shows that the Muslim fanatics who, in the name of their prophet, Mohammed, kill thousands and advocate violence and destruction against the rest of the entire world, are living in the dark-ages.

I don't even blame the press on this one. And I don't know of anyone who's more critical of the press than me.

by hal 9000

But the original poster asked how this was possible so I gave them an Option.

As you know I no more support the activities of these Radicals no matter what their Religion is but I can see the Media stirring up a major problem in Indonesia that simply should not exist because of these silly cartoons and here you have ripe pickings to recruit followers. Christians really don't offer anything to their followers that is overly appealing so if they live a good Life they'll go to heaven but when you have oppressed poor people without [b]HOPE[/b] and you are offering them that and more is it any wonder that they will follow?

The main reason that there is a massive difference in most of the Christian Based fanatics is that they live in Affluent Countries with a much higher Standard of Living and it would never be acceptable to turn away someone with a burst appendix from Medical Treatment and send them home to die without so much as an aspirin. This is what happens in the Philippines I have a friend there who walked into this exact position and all for $500.00 AU which the family didn't have so they where told to take the young woman away and leave the hospital unless they had the 20,00 Pesos to pay for her treatment and remember this is a predominately Christian Country with the majority being Catholic.

Indonesia on the other hand has a much higher proportion of Muslim people and they where not involved at all until the AU Media started pushing the Cartoons and it's got this nation now involved in the mess.

What started out as something totally stupid and I might add Illegal under Danish Law by a Danish Newspaper has now grown out of all proportion into something that is capable of starting off something that is going to be very difficult to stop once it has got rolling.

If the Media had left well enough alone right at the beginning and allowed the Processes of the Law to proceed I doubt that things would have grown to the extent that they have, but no what started out as a peaceful protest against one Danish Newspaper had to be picked up and circulated around the world in the name of [b]Freedom of the Press.[/b]

This is a perfect case of the Media driving the story rather than reporting on it once things have happened.

Col

by tony hopkinson

War on terror is doomed. You can laud your president's virtues 'til the troops come home. I don't believe in him, I don't have to believe in him.
I'm a Brit, I'm not being un-american, I'm not being unpatriotic, I'm not being a f'ing democrat.
Stop confusing me with the political opponents you despise.
I didn't bring in the too late argument nor did I stupidly compare vietnam or WWII to the war on terror.
You can't war on terror. The only way to 'fight' terror is to stop making people afraid, war is not the best tool for that, is it.
Forget how pissed off you are for the moment.
Ask yourself this question?
From the persepctive of the victim, what's the difference between a terrorist atrocity and unfortunate collateral damage. If you think there is one, cease all this preaching about the pursuit of freedom, liberty, justice and happiness and say it like it is. Vengeance, retribution and the imposition of american values on anybody who makes you unhappy.

All the visible successes in the war on terror have consisted of attacking visible opponents with a highly visible infrastructure after defining them as supporters of terrorism. They may have been supporting terrorists, certainly the Taliban did, but the damage done to them has been more than offset by the polarisation of the confict in nationalistic or even worse religious grounds. That created more supporters than we got rid of , dispersed our enemies, widened the theatre of operation and killed or negated any information assets we had. Political necessity perhaps, strategically advisable I doubt it, and tactical insanity.

So unless your president is giving us the current visible operation to lull his opponents (terrorists not democrats) into believing he's incompetent, then in my opinion he's incompetent or he's being driven by political expediency. The latter I find even scarier.
I'd be overjoyed to find out he's a master strategist, with a desperate need for domestic support so he can clandestinely undermine and defeat the terrorists. That with great regret he's thrown away the lives of his own troops and others to put his opponents off guard and stop his political opponents of charging him with doing nothing. I just find it hard to believe though.

by jdclyde

the timeline and how this all blew up.

A muslim in the area was outraged that he didn't have the burning demonstrations that he thought this should have received.

HE then made a case of copies which he went from group to group until he finally got a taker to pretend outrage and start the protests.

Remember, the places where the biggest protests are, are all places that never even SAW the cartoons.

My understanding is that the Dutch will be leading the security council and this is just an effort to show that the Dutch are really anti muslim for when Iran goes before them.

I will do my research tonight/tomorrow to do more than relay what I heard on the radio and start a NEW discussion on it.

by jdclyde

Is something I have been worked up about since they decided it was just peachy to post the pictures of charred American bodies hanging from a bridge with a bunch of scum celebrating over it. (yes, anyone that drags bodies through the streets, mutilates and then hangs them up for the world to see is SCUM.)

Then the pictures of the humiliation tactics (often refered to by the people that WISH to distort facts, as "torture".) that just HAD to be printed. Just WHAT was accomplished? More hate against the US.

When they got the LIE that the koran had been flushed down the toilet, they printed that as well. (think about what the plumbing is like there, and tell my you are going to flush a big book down it? Man, some people are went right beyond dumb and went right to stupid on this one!)

Freedom of the press has been seen as a free ticket to do anything they wish, and it will be nice when the realize that even though they have been willing accomplices with the terrorists, but it has been open season on journalists for YEARS anyways!

I would say they are getting what they deserve when you hop in bed with the enemy of the world.

by hal 9000

I agree!

But unfortunately it will be the people at the coal face who get it in the neck and not those sitting in their air conditioned offices who are running the show who are the ones getting killed and mutilated.

Here the AU press is still pushing for a major investigation of the disappearance of 3 of its members when Indonesia invaded Tumor all that time ago. Unfortunately then it was 3 Journalists who got killed and just disappeared of the face of the planet until it's their Bosses who are the ones to disappear it's going to continue to happen.

I'm reminded of the Old Newspaper Reporters Adage

[b]Never Allow The Truth To Get In The Way Of a Good Story.[/b]

Incidentally the plumbing in Iraq is brilliant you can flush elephants down the local toilets without a single problem. You have to give it to those Romans they built very good plumbing systems all those years ago. I read it in the newspapers so it must be true. :D

Col

by mjwx

GWB is still a Christian politician, not a Christian and a politician. There?s this big issue with an abortion pill here in Australia and the churchie politicians are pressuring the other members of parliament to vote against it (most of whom, are not medical professionals).

One of the female MP?s came into parliament wearing a t shirt that said ?Keep your rosaries out of my ovaries?. I?m not a fan of the church albeit I have never tried to destroy it.

by hal 9000

Was quite funny. The person in question got all offended but when he's called a outright lier in Cowards Castle that's nothing to him at all.

But tonight on commercial TV what was there a story about Religious Intolerance because a Aussie Born Muslim wanted to marry a Aussie Woman not of the same faith or racial background and the [b]Good Muslim Father[/b] told his son he would be disowned thrown out or even killed.

Good example of the media creating intolerance where very little exists again!

Col

by tony hopkinson

By the cheque book, advertising, legislation, peer pressure, indoctrination of minors, state sponsored evangelism are simply an indicator of the enormous progress the church has made morally.

Tee Hee.

by x-marcap

Do you understand there is a differnce between Sacred and Secular. Oh that's right you are an aetheist. You don't see anything as sacred.

The word means set apart,Holy. Since you don't recognise sacredness, no further discussion is possible with you on this manner. So I'll preach at you. 1. The foolishness of God is wiser than the wisdom of man. 2. If you can't see there is far greater intelligence than yours, re-read the posts in this thread alone. Max or I can help you understand fallibility either yours, or ours.

Tim

by x-marcap

Now doesn't it require Weaver combat stance?

Hipshots no longer legal. You have to go and shoot them again, the right way...

by tony hopkinson

Aside from the technical inferority of the Sherman, experienced panzer troops, especially survivors returned from the russian front were much better at it, until your own guys got blooded. Even then, going head to head was a losing proposition. Course a good tank is a bit useless with no ammo, fuel and spare parts, something the US only suffered temporary shortages of.

by Member 25348569

Why is it that so many people, when faced with the fact that they might have to accept an alternative viewpoint as valid, blindly level charges of "prejudice" without answering the questions posed? I seem to have upset you in some way - I suppose that I can live with it.

By the way, preaching at me will surely make me regard your arguments with a greater degree of consideration than I otherwise would have. (irony)

Truly, I don't see what you are getting upset about - at least in the post that you seem to be answering. I was merely pointing out to JD that, in my opinion, whilst we (The Christian West) are hugely better than the Muslims in our attitude to the equality of women, we are not perfect, especially with regards to the Catholic Church.

I was only referencing the Catholic Church from the point of view of an outsider and I can't speak for any of the American Fundy religions because I don't know much about them.

Secular? Oh, yes. You bet I am. Strangely enough, I do consider a number of things sacred. Human dignity, small children, the right to think for yourself...

As for "Max or I can help you understand the fallibility" - please do if it would make you feel better - although Max is perfectly capable of fighting his own battles.

by jamesrl

Gangbangers - yes we have em. There are those on both the right and the left who want to emphasize them - to get either more cops on the street or more money for preventative programs. We have had an upswing in gun violence in Toronto. But to see gangbangers I'd have to direct you to some very specific neighbourhoods, and I am sure its similar to cities in the US(and I've been to a few).

But as I've quoted before, on a per capita basis, we are safer than many smaller Canadian cities and very much safe than most US cities.

The papers have been doing a lot of reporting on the rash of thefts of handguns from gun collectors lately. Seems people have figured out where to find them, and how to break into the simple lockers/safes that are required by law for storage. One collector, a tow truck driver, was called to an isolated spot for a tow, on a foggy night, and of course no one was there. By the time he returned home, his guns were gone.

There are some places in Toronto, I would suggest you not go. Only one of them is within walking distance of downtown, and even then if you aren't alone you are pretty safe. But the problem here is that people don't know how bad the south side of Chicago, or parts of Philly or Detroit or wherever are, and they imagine that they are similar. The stats show a different story. Your reception must just have been hitting on you - making conversation.

James

by jamesg

You mean Prince George's Coalition of the Bribed and Deluded? The couple of hundred "troops" someone other then England has sent? That masterful anti terrorist unit from Samoa? We used to have allies before George pissed'em all off.