Discussion Locked

Unionize IT Now!

0 helpful
725 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 2 of the discussion. Read the opening post

725 replies

by michaelpo

Assuming you could organize and affiliate for strength, get past the right to work states to get sufficient numbers to support negotiations, then figure out how to stop wholesale outsouring, are you personally willing to pay the price?

This battle would be extremely hard fought. How may paydays will you go without? Will you give up your career, if the job action fails? Will you walk out to support a slacker who carries a union card? Are you OK with someone who is less competent making more than you because they started before you?

It has happened to highly skilled workers who did not think they could be replaced. I am a member of the PATCO graduating class of 1981 as well and I remember the cost.

I make more money, have better benefits and working conditions now than I ever did in any of my Union supported jobs. I will negotiate for myself.

by nogeekhere

I have been in IT prior to any MS certification appeared in our world. I do not have any certificate and probably never will. Why? Well there are two many paper certified technician, which devalues the whole concept. And too hire only those that have a certificate would be the wrong practice too. I for one would never get hired again and I have over twenty years experience working in IT. There is a balance, we just have to find it.

by evisscerator

I agree with you. I have 24+ years experience (Since 1978)in the IT career fields and feel that Certs are not worth my time and money now. I could come up with a test that I promise no noobie would be able to pass because they lack the knowledge and experience that no CERT program can deliver.

We have been duped by Microsoft, Novell and other companies who have used the Certifications programs as a means to get "FREE MONEY" and build their CAPITOL for other projects. CERTS were supposed to be an equalizer in the war on College BA's, BS's, MA's and Doctorate programs. It is a test that has failed miserably. You cannot create a CERT and then say its EQUAL TO a college degree .... its not!

And as I said in an earlier post, the only one's who profit by the CERT process are Microsoft, Novell and other companies who offer certification programs. Its kinda like Insurance .... a legalized form of Extortion.

by doug

I can see a place for this, but it would take some serious organizational work.

by jabamonte

You wanted a rebuttal, here it is:

Nissan just changed the way it structures its pension plan for health care. They are a non union shop and the employees voted against bringing a union in. So what did Nissan do, they offered there future retirees (note that current retires still get full health care coverage) an option, an annual stipend to offset purchasing of supplemental health coverage once they have retired and receive medicare. This amounts to 2500.00 annually (This is structured as a health savings account so it is not taxable) or they can pay an increased amount for the employees share of the health care coverage.

On the surface it appears that Nissan is trying to dodge its commitment to its employees, but health care costs have started to level out. Health care costs rose more than 14% in 2001, 11% in 2003 and 9% in 2005. Nissan has stated that payment to buy supplement coverage is adjustable for inflation. Also, the current cost of buying supplement insurance is less than 2500.00 annually. My source is the business section of the Cleveland Plain Dealer from February 19, 2006.

by richard

Well maybe not since your description says
Executive IS/IT Management

So what do we have here a sheep in wolf clothing?
You are still probably labor, I doubt you are a large investor and owner where you work.

Stupid is thinking that unions kill the auto industry. Let me say that there are things wrong with unions. Members need to participate.
However what killed the auto works was politicians.

First there is nothing wrong with machine-shop workers and factory personnel. They are Americans with families and deserve to make a living. I don't think it is "fair market conditions" when you move the factory to Mexico or somewhere even less developet, polute the environment, pay the lowly labor 25 cents per hour or less. Then politicians quoting fair compitation and fair market conditons remove import tariffs so your neighbors can compete for the 25 cents per hour.
this is politics and oppression. Those same politicians also get into the unions and cause their damage there. What you don't even know, mister Executive IS/IT Management is that you are already indirectly benefiting form unions and you may tink about this. When business gets real bad, who is more expendable you or the guy who can actually make IT work?

by techiemikee

The days of starting a job down at the factory and retiring 30-40 years later are gone. Companies go under, they consolidate, they merge and they make these decisions based upon the demands of share holders.

If you have a corporate merger, one work force is union the other workforce isn't who are the shareholders likely to keep?

It is public knowledge that corporations have shut down entire divisions and moved to other cities because they could not operate profitably or compete with the competition in a unionized shop.

by cactus pete

I wouldn't determine which work force to keep or let go (if those are the only options I have) based solely on which one is unionized or not.

by richard

you need a union and you need to vote.
I don't disagree with a thing you said.
if we don't want to compete with those who make 25 cents an hour or a day we have to have labor laws, import taxes. At home we need fair labor laws. They come and they go. I will be the first to admit that it is not simply this way or that. Those who think that they don't have to produce because they are in a union are those that kill the union.
What ever happened to a fair days pay for a fair days work?

by wbblack1

I work for Verizon. I?m a telecom/IT tech and a member of IBEW local 827. We have a good contract and job security. The company just took the pensions away from the non-union ?management? folks. They have no recourse. We still have ours -- at least until our next contract -- but we have collective bargaining and the right to fight for our wages and benefits. Last year the top 5 executive made almost $58 million at Verizon and they pillaged the pension of 30- year employees.

Workers in companies that have unions make 25 to 30 percent more than non-union companies in the same industry. Of course this means that management folks get paid more also. All workers benefit from a union. Unions desperately need to grow and IT would be a great place to start. Techs of the world unite.

by startech

... and we don't need you to tell us what our problems are! We already know. But at least we take care of ourselves and have since 1492! BTW, ours is the only way ( just thought I'd turn up the flame a notch ).

We're not a country without problems. But we know that our problems aren't solved by unions. In fact, unions put us in the position we are now. You think that we're all looking out for ourselves? Where do you think that ideology came from? It comes from every union worker out there that seems to think he (or she) is owed a living and ought to be paid $25.00/hour to install a 'fricking screw. Give me a break PLEASE! Look at the cost of cars today. You can't get a decent American car now for anything less than $30,000. All that for less than $2000 in material?

I agree that it's every man for himself -- but you'll find that everywhere in the world. Everybody wants to survive -- and if you ain't lookin' out for yourself, you'll soon perish. Somebody's already said it but it's Darwinism at its best. On the other hand, you won't find a country that's more generous than the US. That's right -- look at all the sacrifices WE have made on your (the world's ) behalf. And, without thanks for it I might add! I don't know what country you're from, but how many of your people have or are dying to protect the world's right to be free. Talk about having a social conscience? You have no clue!

So, let's open our eyes and look at the reality of it -- shall we? It's people who think like the original poster that will bring this country down. "Oh, we've got to unionize because I'm not being paid fairly...." Stop whining and find yourself another job. You're being paid what you're worth. If you're whining about unionizing, then I bet you're whining on the job too. And, your employer is seeing that and is saying you're not worth investing in! Period! If that's not true, then I dare you to post your resume and go live somewhere else.

I've been in IT for a very long time. It's had its ups and downs. I've loved every minute of it. I've come up the ranks by paying my dues, endless learning (BTW, life is an endless learning adventure -- you got to keep up to stay up), and a positive attitude. I've changed jobs only three times in my life. But, I've always been willing to move up, or try different things. Some I liked more than others, but keeping a positive attitude has always moved me forward. No, I'm not in management, I'm a Techie. But, management is not out of the question anymore (it was at one time).

Unionizing is not the answer! There are many jobs out there that pay you what you're worth. Are you worth $50.00/Hr.? Really? Are you sure? Forcing your employer to pay you $50.00/hr when you're only worth $10 (and you are if you're a whiner) is going to hurt you, the company, and the country in the long-run.

BTW, I am an American -- naturalized! Am proud to be an American, and have served this country -- in the military -- for over 21 years! I loved every minute of that too. And, I am still serving this country through the skills I have learned over the years and the knowledge I posess and keep refreshing. Am I worth $50.00/hr.? You bet I am. Am I worth even more? At least double that! I don't need a union to tell me what I should be paid.

To hell with unions! And God Bless the USA.

by tonyackerman

You forget your history. You live in a nation that from it's very inception is the union of states that comprise it. The reason for this union is that the founding fathers realized they had no chance, NO CHANCE against the military might of England unless they banded together to see their grievances addressed.

If you're as good as you say, then prove it. Unions bring the standardization levels that show to a company that this individual meets these criteria and must be justly compensated. Otherwise it's your word against the kid from geek squad and then it's a matter of salesmanship.

by davew

StarTech: I think you made my point better than I did..

One thing that frustrates me is the responses about American policies, to American people, on American message boards..

If you think that we are not doing things the right way vote with your mouse and find some local place to whine and complain.

I dont know of any American that runs around other countries techy message boards complaining about the way they run their country..

Things are really simple in our world folks, there are many many different countries and cultures, if you dont like ours then dont interact with us. Isn't is kind of 2 handed to complain about the way that we run our country on one hand but take our money and provide services on the other hand?

Come on wake up take a look in the mirror, If I dont agree with a particular countries policies I will simple discontinue my relationship with them be it purchasing goods and services or interacting with them.

by giannidalessismo

examine this statement "look at all the sacrifices >we< have
done on >your< (the world's) behalf." IE the US is SEPARATE
from the world as a whole. 'Protect your right to be free'? Where
exactly does this miraculous phenomenon take place currently?
Before you accuse another of having 'no clue' per socail
conscience study some history. Look at the news, and not the
managed news, which is parallel to a fascist regime's version.
Also gotta love assertions about someone else's situation, based
on your ideological preference, and not much else, like 'blah
blah blah PERIOD'. Darwinism and Amerkanism at its worst.

by oldjags

Could not have said it any better. Where do people get the idea that 'society' owes them something?? Aside from a safety net to protect the incompetent and disabled, everyone is expected to pull their own weight in this world. If you're not contributing to the greater good by generating income and creating wealth, then you're essentially a leech feeding off the hard work of others. Others that are struggling to make a decent life for themselves, which is hard enough without the burden of having to lug dead-weight like you around with them.

The US has the highest per-capita rate of charitable contributions in the world, so don't believe all that crap about Americans being selfish and materialistic.

Socialism is a proven failure as an economic model. Why is it that federal tax revenues actually increase in the years following a reduction in the tax rates?? It's because it's removed some of the overwhelming burden that hard-working people and businesses have to bear, and allows the economic growth that in turn, creates jobs, which in turn increases demand and more jobs. The way out of poverty and misery is not more government projects and spending and higher taxes; it's jobs and economic growth and capitalism!! Without capitalism, where do the tax revenues come from that the socialists want to spend on all their favorite projects??? And, who gets to decide what those projects are? I much prefer donating money to charities of my choice; where I know and support what the money is being spent for; than to give it to some government, involutarily I might add, to be squandered in some vast and unaccountable bureaucracy.

The US has spent enough tax money over the years in the 'War on Poverty' to give every poor man, woman, and child in America a small fortune. And what do have to show for it?? Not much.

Socialism is akin to drug addiction. Once you're addicted to life on the public dole, it's hard to cut if off and start taking care of yourself again. Every government project that gives somebody something they haven't worked for and earned individually is just another addictive drug. A drug that I have to pay for!

If you take a lion cub and raise him in captivity - feed him twice a day, pamper him, give him a nice warm, heated cage every day until he's fully grown - then turn him loose in the wild, he'll be dead of starvation within a month. Why is that?? A lion is the king of beasts, he should have no trouble catching and eating whatever he wants, but he'll starve nonetheless.

Why are people any different than lions? If we're raised in a form of 'socialist captivity', then we'll never be able to take care of ourselves out in the real world; we'll always be back to feed from the hand that now controls us.

America may be many things, but 'perfect' is certainly not one of them. It is, however, a place where your skills and ambitions and desires, or lack thereof, will take you as far as you wish to go. If you're poor in America, and are neither mentally or physically challenged in any way, then you've got nobody to blame but that guy in the mirror.

by neocarpetbagger

It's too late. We accepted the high pay, stock options, unpaid overtime, and flagrant H1-B violations over the years. We had the opportunity and capacity to shut down IT production all over the country when this job hemorrhage started and yet we did not.

If we really want to make a difference now, we need to organize the offshore IT worker force so they can preserve their new-found way of life.

You want fries with that?

- LPJ

by tonyackerman

Interesting comments in this thread wrt compensation. I side with the unionists at this stage of my career, tho' I didn't always. I too thought that as an individual that my opinion was valued and that I could make my voice heard through reasoned arguements. I thought that by making my voice heard and when my arguements were evaluated, I would be justly compensated, and initially that seemed to be the case.

Then my education began. The initial promotions and rewards were the bait to get me in deep enough to where the company felt they had control over me and my life. I was blinded to what was happening, and when you're in a position like this, you work even harder to get that level of recognition and reward response back. It's like a drug, you gotta have it. When you don't get it, you'll prostitute yourself in unimaginable ways to get it back.

When you finally reach the point of realization, you think you can again approach those in charge and reason with them, and THAT'S when you come to find out that you're all alone. Classic divide and conquer strategy, the individual against the machine. You have no leverage since there are now others who can step into your position (you did your job well and trained your subordinate(s) to do your job) and since you've already prostituted yourself before, the company knows that if push comes to shove, you'll fold.

People in our business have to quit thinking that they can make all on their own when dealing with management. You don't stand a snowballs chance alone.

by spadata

you want to unionize (the havens of total incompetents) I suggest first you join the Socialist Workers Party, the American Communist Party, MoveOn.org, and the Democrat Party.

Once you have sworn total allegiance to your MASTERS there, you can attempt to overthrow the Constitutional representative republic of the United States of America.

As the heroes of socialist thought have stated ...

The American people will never knowingly adopt socialism. But, under the name of "liberalism," they will adopt every fragment of the socialist program, until one day America will be a socialist nation, without knowing how it happened. --- Norman Thomas, U.S. Socialist Party

"We cannot expect the Americans to jump from Capitalism to Communism, but we can assist their elected leaders in giving Americans small doses of Socialism, until they suddenly awake to find they have Communism." --- Nikita Kruschev, USSR

by jle

Unionize the whole IT field may be a little bit too extreme. If you just finish training and have no experience, you can't charge $50/hour. Even when you charge $12/hour and no one wants to hire you. Sometimes you offer to do for free, and people still say no. Getting experience at the beginning is hard.

However, I think there should be some sort of union either within a company or a more specific field such as government contractor union. My salary is totally at the mercy of my project manager. My salary is a lot lower than other members in my team because I was not a very good negotiator even though my skills are higher than some. Now to me that is unfair, I think your salary should not depend on your ability to negotiate. It should depend on your skills. So a union would help in this case.

by jabamonte

Going back to the automotive world, unions are not the scapegoat, but neither is the car company. Both carry a share of the problem and blame. Unions became so powerful, that car companies stopped running themselves and the union started running the companies. Unions do have the problem of keeping lack luster people because of senority. Car companies have the problem of keeping their head in the sand and not adjusting to the needs/wants/desires of the consumer. Car companies also suffer from arrogance, in that for so many years they had a captive consumer who did not have any real choice other than Curly, Mo, or Larry (collectively the Big 3).

Is there a solution? Sure there is! Are we willing to make the necessary sacrifices to reach the solution? No not yet, but I feel we will get to that point.

Unions are not evil, but come very close. The IT world changes way to often for a union to be a viable solution.

by wbblack1

Union workers are better trained, more productive and have less work place related injuries. You don?t know what you?re talking about. You also don?t understand much about economics from the perspective of the average person.

by techsupport79

union promotes ultimate job security which fosters laziness. I have a coworker who constantly call in sick (called in and said "I WILL be sick next week" !?) yet he is still here after 8-10 years.

by mike_goff

Its true that a company answers to the owners and that they risked the money. Nobody will deny that. But you also can't deny that there would be no company at all without its workforce. Most employees understand that if they are not producing to make a company money, the company either shuts down or will no longer need their services. Neither option benefits the worker and most do their part to be an asset to the company. As with any organization with one or more people in it, your going to get your share of "deadwood". But I'm sure you've looked into unions deep enough to know that a contract is 'negotiated between the owners and the union'. I have yet to see a contract that states that a company is forced to keep its "deadwood". Every one of them that I have seen states that an employee can be laid off and sent back to the hall or fired for "JUST CAUSE" Without a contract or union representation an employee can be fired without just cause and the NLRB will not back them. While I don't know for a fact, I assume that you get some sort of perk or bonus as an executive/management position employee. Being a fair minded person I'm sure that you share this bonus/perk with the men and women that do the actual work involved in helping you achieve whatever goals needed to get that bonus/perk. Or do you feel that you are "owed" or have earned that bonus/perk? Perhaps you even negotiated it in your wage package? I don't know where you have gotten your information about unions, perhaps from the company owners that would love to see every employee work for minimum wage and no overtime or benefits in order to bolster their bottomline profit margin. Is this really supply and demand or just outright greed? Negotiating with a union can benefit both parties. Perhaps the union rep says "my people want $20 an hour" the company can return with the reply "fine, but everyone employed with us must have these certs and they must be updated yearly to remain in our employ" The employee gets a "liveable" wage and benefit package and the employer gets an educated workforce thats happy. Sounds like a win/win situation to me.

by mikefromco

Maybe you've yet to see a contract that literally protects dead wood, but I've seen a few that make it damn near impossible to get rid of anyone. And unions don't truly negotiate with the owner of a company, unless that company is massive. They negotiate with a group of smaller companies, treating them as one.
I actually saw a union president turn down a contract for greater than the amount they were asking because it was with one company and the other companies wouldn't go for it! Who were they watching out for??
The real problem I see in this thread that people seem to assume that unions set minimum standards. In most cases this is not true; union contracts are absolutes and many prohibit rewarding people beyond the base compensation.
So be careful what you ask for...

by stan20

I could not afford to work for $20/hour. I wouldn't even return calls from someplace offering twice that. If you are alive you already have a "liveable wage".

by tomaaa19

T be effective a union must cover a large number of workers.

I cannot see this happening in IT unless you get a number of very large number of shops organizing at the same time.

At this time the attitudes of potential members is too divided for large scale unionizing to happen

Also concerns about striking, dues etc will depend on the particular union and who actively participates in the running of your local......get involved or be prepared to be bossed around by another level.

Regards

by nogeekhere

A degree and/or certification is a good start, however they will never out weigh good old fashion working experience. Too many companies and IT managers put too much weight on paper qualifications and over look the work experience.

by techiemikee

They don't necessarily provide an accurate means to measure a person's knowledge on a subject, but they offer a baseline and they are quite useful for a consulting company tries to procure new work by presenting creditials of the professionals working there.

When you go to restaurant you want the food to not only taste good but you expect that it will look good as well, Certs are like plating a good meal.

by fractalzoom

Unfortunately, this Eugene Debs, 1920's-era call for all IT workers to swarm to the ramparts is nullified by the new realities of globalization and offshoring. There is a very large IT workforce available in places like India that would eagerly do your job for less money and without unions -- to make a play for unionization of IT would be to push management into the arms of a less-expensive outsourced, offshored option.

as Frieman says in his book, "The world is flat." This means that your notion of IT as the next great labor movement is based on sadly obsolete notions of the workforce, like whip-and-buggy manufacturers uniting to retake the transportation system.

by davew

Why would your word have anything to do with your Track record and Professional experiance?

If you dont have professional experiance your entry level, thats all there is to it.

by deaton

50+ years ago, there were little or no labor laws. That caused the union movement out of desperation. Now that we have labor laws that make the workplace safe and sane, the job is done.

What we need to do is spread the ideas of labor laws like ours to other countries that don't have them, like India. Humans are greedy and would like similar treatment. That would level the playing field.

by box_15

Its not about hard work at all. We all put in more than our share to keep things running. The only way we are going to survive is to unionize.

by cactus pete

Actually, I have an old college degree in Economics, so I know plenty about this topic.

Unionizing a field where the work is so easily moved to another sector is a terrible idea.

But a lot of firms actually don't mind having unions! The total cost of the labor force actually decreases when you have a completely unionized labor supply. And you don't have to negotiate every hire, because the costs are known and set. Thus, you save money on the cost of labor.

So, the original poster wants more money. Unionizing isn't about money. If you want more money, negotiate for it.

Let's take the original statements and look at them:

"I just saw an ad in the paper here for a lan tech for $12/hour!"

So what? Maybe they are looking for an entry level position. Perhaps they need a lan tech helper, not an architect. We don't know the whole story, just a factoid and some angry venting.

"When I first started in this industry I was making very good money. I had a new cert and a master's degree."

Again, so what? You mean you're being paid less now? Perhaps the cert and the degree, both paper products, indicate a level or proficiency higher than what you actually prove to have. The jobs won't last long!

"I say we apply rules of work that apply to a 40 hour work week and serious overtime."

If your employer is failing to pay you overtime, check your state's laws on the topic. You might have a case!

Personally, I have a 35 hour work week and get paid for overtime (above 40). The other 5 hours are paid straight time. This is a common setting for positions in my firm where overtime is not rare. (We get paid double time only on holidays.)

"I say we demand $50/hr for any IT related work, as a minimum."

I know many 'techs' who aren't worth that much. Most aren't, in my opinion. How did you come up with that number? Is it just what you wish you made? Is it based on some data?

Go ahead, people - rip me one for this. But unionizing IT ain't a great idear...

by simonjester

Remember them?
What does the "U" stand for?
"power to run this world!"?
Perhaps you meant to say;"Hold it hostage!"

Shirkers of the world unite, you have nothing to lose but your brains!

by rmyers

Oh I cans see there is the diverse interest in being part of large union. Unions are more than just pay pushers. I am a large anti-union person, but believe they do have a purpose in building 2nd and 3rd world economies. The conditons in Asia and other countries that exploit workers need a unified front to lobby better benefits, working conditions, hours, etc. Most IT people I work with each day typically work in environmentally controlled offices or computer rooms. Drive to work in good cars. Make a pretty decent living. Most have medical benefits, are offered retirement benefits, have two weeks or more of vacation each year. Well, what do you expect the Union is going to do for these guys, negotiate more money, come on, dudes and duddettes!

Before you brandish the flag and go unionizing read the stories of GM and Ford. How is the Union Protecting their jobs now? Did it stop the 30k+ of people that will lose their jobs? and the communities, what about them?

America has always been the land of opportunity where people can mover freely between jobs to better themselves, move about the country finding better cities or places to live. If you don't like the hours or the pay or the people you work with, YOU have an OPPORTUNITY TO DO SOMETHING ABOUT IT! DO IT!

by wbblack1

Why shouldn?t a forklift driver make a living wage. You?re an elitist. Us cars suck. That?s why people don?t buy them, and that?s one reason the companies don?t ?make money,? even though their executives take home tens of million. Another reason the auto industry is not making money is because we don?t have national health care. In Canada GM makes money. They have national health care. The U.S. spend 14% of its GNP for health care. No other country in out of the single digits. We have the worst health care in the industrial world: raked 37th by the World Health Organization.

by cactus pete

I threw out a 25% rate as something so over the top you wouldn't take it literally. But you did anyway. I don't know everyone's dues rates, and I won't guess at an average or even a median.

That said, I'd rather negotiate my own pay. I'm above average, and I expect to be paid a wage commensurate with my abilities. I work hard at my job, and I like it. So I don't mind a few extra hours, and I might be paid less than my true value ack to the company. But that's OK. I enjoy my work and it pays enough to support what I enjoy outside of work.

A set union wage doesn't allow me that flexibility. And I don't want to pay someone else to tell me when to strike, or what part of the job I am allowed to perform.

See, I like computer stuff, and I like helping people. So I get a nontangible reward in my job. Try to set that across the board for all employees.

Also, if I'm striking, I'm not helping people who need it.

If you'd rather strike than do your job (for whatever reason), then find a job elsewhere! If I ever feel like I'm being taken advantage of, I'll leave. It's a mobile society. You have the freedom to work when and where you want. Exercise it!

by the.erinyes

Actually, we do not want you here. This is America, a country founded on the principle that individuals make up the country. This means that we are free to compete for jobs from a price/productivity point of view. We are also competing globally and trying to protect/guarantee a particular wage will spell disaster for the US. Wages are already being driven by foreign markets such as China and India. These people can work much cheaper than most US IT workers. Low level programming jobs will always try to go to lower wage earning markets just like manufacturing jobs. In order to keep our job market strong across the board we have to quit belly-aching about how bad it is and work on productivity innovation which is our strong area and where we compete best with the rest of the world. Look at our automotive manufacturing companies being eaten alive by foreign competition and on the brink of going out of business. Guess what they are unionized and it is hurting their ability to compete in the world market. So is that what you want to do to IT as well, bankrupt it on the World stage? My advice is to quit complaining and start innovating so we can continue to compete, otherwise there will not be an IT sector to worry about; unionized or not!

by noyoki

How is it that you are STOPPING companies from laying off all of their employees and outsourcing?

I suppose you can take the example of a union near me, (this is all hearsay as I was in the IBEW of a borough 'next door'.) If you were a non-union jobsite, expect to find your gangboxes thrown out the window, tools stolen, sites wrecked... Would you do that?

You could picket, hold out a rat I suppose... Would it make a difference? Are the secretaries going to strike with you? The reason that striking works is that if you have union electricians, carps, laborers, and tilers, however, non-union steamfitters... If all the unions on that jobsite struck, the site grinds to a halt.

I work in a lawfirm now. Are the attorneys, secretaries, and paralegals going to strike with me? I doubt it.

I have no idea how you think that creating unions will STOP outsourcing. If you can't compete with india, you need a new set of skills. Not a union.

by yinbig

It's because Microsoft has trained way too many MCSE's and/or we are letting people into the industry without MCSE's????

My Degree in Computer Scienece with Honours blows an MCSE out the water. Takes 5 Years to get a Honours Degree, 3 weeks an MCSE.

by donengene

The best thing a union can do is to lobby congress against sending jobs over seas.

I was recently thinking about taking some classes on ERP so that I could get a better paying job. My IT instructor told me the best place to do that kind of work is in India. I'm not planning on moving to india anytime soon to get training. We need to keep the jobs and work here. There are plenty of places that can support a union.

I belong to an educational institution which has a union but it does little or nothing to protect IT workers,t hey really only protect instructors/faculty. We need out own representation. I have an MCSE 2003 and 9+ years of expereience and am still finding it hard to find jobs that pay over $30,000 when the average is somewhere around $65,000. Most of the jobs out there I am over qualified for so I'm not even considered even if it pays more than my current possition. I am thinking about joining a temp agency just so that I get paid what I'm worth and have someone that is working to get me the pay I deserve.

by noyoki

And the transit workers? The transit union struck for 3 days. Where did it get them?

A worse contract than the last that was offered, 3 days lost pay, millions in fines for the union, $150,000 (or more) in fines PER PERSON, and the leader tossed in jail.

Unions do not have the power they once had. This was the transit workers. NYC depends on them for the most part. 3/4 of people do not have cars. Granted, I doubt the Taylor law would apply to IT workers (as they aren't really critical, like Drs., etc) but you aren't going to move mountains, no matter how hard you try.

by budziaszek

Hi All,

A Union across the IT industry is a good idea for many reasons which include Seniority/Job Security for these employees. Not to mention being the scapegoat for Poor Management. I worked at IBM Global for approx. 10 Yrs. where I saw the worst work conditions. Was fired after being harrassed by a Quebec Seperatist and subsequently fired while I had stress leave papers in hand. I settled at the Normes de travail (workers rights in Quebec). To this day they have violated that agreement and I have no recourse, My own lawyer lied to the Quebec bar. I still have not found work in my profession. I do not wish to see anyone go through what I have by believing in a Company and their Policies and that the Government will protect these rights as well as your civil rights atleast here in Quebec.
So by all means Unionize and Unionize NOW! Unions will ensure that as a senior your the last to be cut vs. here's your package (If applicable) thanks for the last 10 yrs of your life sorry we're not letting you retire from our company cause it's cheaper to let you go and hire a paper cert.

by cactus pete

So you're saying it's supply and demand. The AMA holds back the number of doctors, thereby increasing each doctor's wages.

That's terrible. If such a scheme could be proved in court, I'd have them broken up! Letting people die or even just suffer a bit more so your members can make more money is horrendous.

And I believe the government would find fault with that, as it would be running up bills they have to pay.

Lawyers negotiate their rates with their clients up front. Not all make a ton of money (but most do make at least $60 an hour based on 40 hour weeks).

And believe me, lawyers in Boise don't make as much as lawyers in NYC.

But your model doesn't fit all. IT support can easily be managed from anywhere in the world. It's somewhat more difficult to have a surgeon perform on you from the next room, let alone anywhere else. Lawyers need to be present for most of their procedings as well.

by pickleman

> But your model doesn't fit all. IT support can
> easily be managed from anywhere in the world.

No, actually it can't be.
Stop talking shit. It just makes you look more retarded than you actually are.

> It's somewhat more difficult to have a surgeon
> perform on you from the next room, let alone
> anywhere else.

And it's equally as difficult for someone in India to fix your database server problems when the machine that holds the data won't even power up. That's just one example. I have a thousand others I can give you where the person doing the work has to be on-site.

> Lawyers need to be present for most of their
> procedings as well

I'm guessing (based on your naive statements) that you seem to believe that "I.T. support" is nothing more than working in a call center, answering the phones from people wanting to know why their rebate checks haven't arrived yet. If that's your view of I.T., then yes, that type of work can certainly be done from someone in India.

But for those of us that understand what real I.T. means, we're not the least bit worried about outsourcing because we perform REAL work that our clients can't possibly outsource no matter how much they may want to.

by startech

Frankly, I let my resume speak for me. I then re-enforce those statements at my interviews. But, I haven't had too many interviews to speak of. I've received favorable replies after my very first interview with each of them.

Regardless, the reason I'm against unions is that they lower standards -- not raise them. In IT, I don't need an idiot who'll do only what the unions tell him to do -- or even less. I need someone to be innovative, find a way to do something better and faster, reduce costs, willing to learn new things, and move up the ladder because of his knowledge and leadership abilities not because he's had 10 years "screwing in a bolt." I'm tired of seeing union members put in their 9-5, go home and live the good life as a couch potato, or spend endless hours at the local pub drinking with other losers, only to repeat the same old crap the next day. No desire to learn or make the company better, so that it too can make a better product, make more money and pass it down to its employees.

If people are as good as they want to be paid for, there are plenty of jobs out there. You just have to look for them. Yes, you may have to move. Yes, you may have to stand up for yourself and show the prospective employer you're worth it. Yes, you have to sell yourself. If you can't, then maybe you do need someone to do it for you. But then, again, employers are looking for people who can communicate well. So, if you can't find something about yourself to sell -- then maybe you're not worth it.

As for my history, perhaps you're living in history. We had to do that back then because that was the tool of the time. Today, everyone has an equal opportunity to prove him/herself (largely because of our history). That doesn't mean we have to use old tools to bring about change. Times are changing. Time to use new tools.

by cactus pete

In NYC, none go lower because they can't.

Does anyone there hire "LAN techs" for under a certain rate?

Also, remember what your'e comparing. You're saying an in-house LAN tech should make certain wages. Would you pay more or less than that number for someone who is a consultant?

Basically, attorneys and doctors are consultants. They are specialist who you need every once in a while. If you needed one constantly, you would try to negotiate a decent rate for 2000 hours a year.

Now this also presents a problem. Most in-house attorneys are at the high level. So it's like hiring a CIO, then outsourcing all of the other work, and then only when you need it.

by evisscerator

Here it is in a nutshell .....

If you were to organize and build up an IT Union (American Only), your bosses would shuffle you out the door while shuffling in some IT dim wits from the Eastern part of the globe that don't speak fluent English and will take your job for 1/3 of what you are being paid.

Unionize Globally and force Corporations into negotiations Globally .... That way we all might make the same money no matter where we work and live.

You can thank all of this to our Government who got bought and sold on NAFTA/GATT.

Here Here !

by ruffnredy

I understand your concerns....I work for a major airline and I think that I can speak from experience about how a union works or supposed to work. Unions are supposed to protect wages and benefits, but in the last 20 years I have been on my job, it has been all about hiring as many people as possible and keeping them on the payroll because it(the more, the merrier theory) seems to be the style of business. Remember this, "Unions are a business; no more no less" before you unionize study what has happened to the airlines and auto workers. I am here because I took a hell of a paycut(and benefit reduction) to keep everyone employed and now we are doing more work for less pay with too many people (Management and Union Rep) standing around reaping the rewards from our (the Union membership's)hard work. I don't want to dampen your hope I want you to make a fully informed decision. Good Luck!

by cactus pete

A union will tend to stretch across corporate lines. That gives the union more power against each individual company. This lowers the "free market" of labor...

In a market, each exchange is independent of the previous or next one. When there is collusion or monopoly you don't have the liquidity necessary for competitive rates. Competitive rates permit fair market value for each resource.

Companies see the workforce as a cost of business. If Joe is worth more to them than Jack, why not permit the firm to pay the workers respective to their contributions?

by contradancer

Wages, certification standards, healthcare, retirement plans, visas and offshoring are just a few of the issues we all care about. Instead of endlessly debating the value of working together on our common causes, why not try creating a powerful tech union and see where it leads?

If we join together and build a movement that stands for our concerns, we can control the actions that movement takes. Only by standing together can we be an equal negotiating partner with management for our concerns.

In 2001, WashTech launched TechsUnite as a national face for high-tech worker organizing. By joining for just $11.00 a month, or $120.00 a year, you will help build the movement and build our voice.

Washtech has a proven track record of success. For more information, see http://www.washtech.org/

by stechipp05

Unions were good back in the day. With other countries threatning our finacial well being here, unionizing would further put us in the hole. I think the only reason they advertise jobs at $12 an hour here is because they know they can easily hire someone in India for half that price. Unions in the auto industry has kept the prices of vehicles rising everyday so they can make their profit margin. As more and more jobs go overseas and the cost of manufacturing these vehicles go lower and lower, we the consumer still have to pay the inflated price so the automakers can have a bigger profit. I believe if we started crying "We want a Union, none of us may ever find a job unless we moveed to India."

by ojeda

not gonna happen with republicans running the show - they're union busters - good luck - hahahahahahahahahaha

by tommy higbee

Sorry, but as much as everyone sometimes feels stepped on by management, unionizing just won't work. The first thing that the company will do is outsource the entire IT department to an outside company, and unless you can get the government to FORCE the business to do otherwise, there's no more jobs.

I'm ignoring the ranting here about "people starving in the wealthiest country," since it's not true. As for social conscience, Americans give more to charity than just about any nation in the world. Why does that money have to be administered by a government bureaucracy before we get credit for a social conscience?

by rw17

So, you think that consulting is where the money is...? Not anymore! Not unless you are an independant!
I'm a Canadian working for a large SAP consulting firm. I have 9 years of SAP experience and still make far less than $100K Canadian per year!
There is no training in SAP (thus, no one ever seems to get certified in it anymore) offered by my company - they tell you there is but then they say "You can't get training when between clients and when you are on a client there is no time for you to get training!".
There is no pension offered!
Bonuses are tied to world-wide sales and max out at less than $4K per year... not even worth working for!
Overtime is not paid until you pass 48 hours per week.
I was billable 155% per week last year... that's 62 hours per week... not including 10 hours of unpaid travel per week and administration hours unpaid (time reports, etc).
3 weeks vacation! (IF you are allowed to go!)
Stress, stress, STRESS!!!!!
I was on the road 100%
I was pressured to cross the border for work illegally - without a Trade Nafta Visa.
It is expected to work early, work through lunch, and work later than my client to show them my "good work ethic".
AND MORE!!!!

I think that SAP consultants should unionize!!! We get billed out at some rediculous rate which we receive less than 15% of! We aren't trained anymore! The turnover rate at my company is 100% in less than 3 years at the consultant level! Burnout is a huge factor! Travel is rediculous!
I got into the consulting to create a nest-egg... there is no way I would have sacrificed so much for so little... I have no life outside of work and all work and no play has made me a depressed man in my 30's!

I hate unions! But, in cases of slave labour, I understand the need for unions!

by dabinns

I do not beleive that people working for the government should be in a union......

by bg6638

You don't recognize the laws of supply and demand. If you think $12/hr for a lan tech is bad, how about $9/hr for a Help Desk I position where the employer wanted a Master's, virtually every cert offered by Citrix, Cisco, Msoft, and Redhat AND 5 yrs exp? And you think that forming an IT union will help? I really don't think so. You are fighting changing business evolution. Consider what unions have done for me: three of the last four of my past employers *closed* as a direct result of strikes!

by crabbyabby86

I'll just be honest: I don't like the idea of unionizing IT. For a lot of the same reasons already posted--and the limiting of innovation is right at the top of the list. What is IT if it is not innovative?

But I'm not too worried. Go ahead and create your wonderful union and hope it saves your ass. I'm going to work. Almost half the states in this country are Right to Work States, and those of us who are NOT going to join your fantabulous union are going to be just fine, even if your idea actually works.

by questor1

I read that you believe the USA should give away any and all trade secrets or proprietary information to foreign countries with lower labor costs. Prominent economists have stated that outsourcing jobs for lower wages are merely the temporary lowering of an opportunity cost and not a competitive innovation. Lowering IT wages or outsourcing does not make any company more innovative. Perhaps you should transfer to work in a foreign country where your ideas are more accepted than here.

The real problem is that the business playing field is stacked against the American worker and Unions in both the USA and the foreign country... Corrupt governments here and abroad block the formation of Unions because they are often viewed as a poltical threat to that government. IT workers througout the world continue to be abused because they often are not allowed to organize unions.

When IT is outsourced to foreign countries, particularly Asia, there are no "trade protections" to US citizen personal data like bank or financial records. The US Courts have no jurisdiction in Asia. This is why most companies are hesitant to outsource R&D to foreign countries - they are afraid their technology secrets will be stolen by competitors in foreign countries with no legal recourse. Outsourcing personal financial data service and management from banks and brokers in overseas markets is a bad accident just waiting to happen to US citizens. Unions create a stable work environment where there may be less incentive to cheat clients if their workers needs are already fully met.

You claim the USA is doing well with a robust economy, but why are IT people not benefiting and why is the general public's attitude so negative? American & IT workers do not feel they are getting their fair share of the American economic pie. Income levels of the rich have risen far higher than the median American family income that has declined $1700 over the past several years in buying power. IT wages have fallen in some segments in the USA up to 30% while the cost of living keeps going up. Perhaps this is why IT college enrollment has declined an estimated 35% in the past several years where IT is no longer considered viable by grdaduating college students. Why go to college when it does not have a positive impact on IT wages? Unions establish a negotiated and agreed set of rules between Union members and the company to make sure that workers are fairly treated on wages and hours.

The United States used to set the standard that other countries looked to for leadership in human rights and benefits in the workplace. Sadly, this is no longer true when some foreign counties abuse their workers with slave wages and conditions to lower prices. IT workers are not benefiting when jobs are moved overseas and wages decline in the USA. Why has the USA government abandoned these basic protections in favor of lowering wages at any cost to the worker?

More IT workers in the USA are getting sick or dying from work-related stress. The growth of the American economy trying to do more with less is killing american workers because more stress is thrust upon the American workforce. The USA is currently ranked 12th in the world among modern western countries for population longevity. We used to be ranked in the top three nations. Unions protect members from overwork abuse companies impose to supposedly be "competitive" in a race to the bottom.

If you say that Unions are obsolete, just look around... the federal and state governments do not adequately protect the rights of workers in the USA. Unions help protect the rights of workers where the government has failed to do so. The current Congress has taken a "pro-business" attitude that is forcing US workers into lower wages in a race to the bottom of a economy solely based on services.

We need to level the playing field for workers and businesses. I say that if counties based in foreign countries want to sell products in the USA, they should be forced to adhere to the same wage, benefit, and government regulations that countries in the USA have to follow. Companies that outsource operations to overseas markets should be held by the government to the same rules and regulations that companies within the USA follow. If you want to sell products in the USA, you have to play by USA rules.

by robinson_hawks

Unionizing has its perks, higher wages, and a unified voice. The dillema is that it ultimately limits the total number of employees a company can hire. Simply put, $50 an hour would be fantastic but you can get entry level CS employees fresh out of top tier engineering programs who will jump on $25 an hour. There are far too many individuals willing to take lower wages given the limited amount of available work (.. and dont get my started on outsourcing.. the suits seem to like it, but it is not the magical solution). Jacking up the wages would simply force a smaller number of employees to bear a greater amount of work. In addition it costs money to run a union. Your $50 an hour would not be representative after you pay your union dues. The final straw that will inhibit unionization is the lack of a finite credentialling system. You can get certified in JAVA, Novell, Ab Initio.. you name it. Certifications are a dime a dozen at this point in time. Healthcare and other fields requiring licensure have a much clearer line in terms of defining who is qualified to provide services. Right now the IT profession lacks the demand for employees or a industry wide structured credentialling system. It is difficult to have a unified voice when the IT profession itself if such a diverse mosaic of skilled professionals.

by nicknielsen

Which jobs will be taken away to outsourcing companies? Anything that involves a hardware interaction _can't_ be outsourced. It's awfully hard to troubleshoot a network outage or change a power supply over the telephone. I can hear it now:

Help Desk (accented): Now you have cover off, disconnect power cable from component.

User: Which ones are the power cables?

Help Desk (accented): Power cable are wire connect at power supply.

User: Where is the power supply.

Help Desk (accented): Is box in back.

User: Box in back of what?

Help Desk (accented): Box in back of PC.

User: There's no box connected to the back of my PC.

Help Desk (accented): The box the line cord plug into.

User: That's the PC!

by cactus pete

If the company is doing nothing illegal, then you chose to work there, no one is forcing you to.

If they are doing things illegally, then you have a duty and an obligation to report it. Only then should you expect to be compensated in the correct manner.

Would unionizing stop that? As corrupt as your employer sounds, I doubt it. They'd likely own the union leaders anyway...

by pkr9

OK.
Scenario 1
EACH person should sue their employer privately with own private money against a corporation with own lawyers and a much bigger wallet. Even being able to subtract lawyer expenses. Or sacking the employee if it looks like they're losing.

Scenario 2
The employee contacts his/her union and the UNION - the sum of all employees nationwide, take up the battle, hiring legal advise ad needed and acting with the full power of the entire union. With the threat of a strike or blocade behind them.

Do you really believe scenario 1 is the best?

by cactus pete

Imagine a small shop having to hire a union guy, and not being able to fire him. It goes both ways.

But now we have labor laws. So if law suits are your thing, any company up against the federal government... which do you think is bigger and has more power?

I'm not naive. I just don't like unions for IT.

by flowahpla

It is statements like that, that strengthen the need for unions.
The employers know that there are dozens of individuals "on the street" that are capable of doing the same job I do.
By denying them, you open yourself up to being let go in a "creative manner"

by Member 25348569

Hey, pal. If you can't take a bit of constructive - or even destructive - criticism then it doesn't say much for your strength of character.

You're the one that's whining! "Ooooo. Nasty foreigners saying bad things about us. What did we do to desrve it?" Why do you assume that any of us who aren't American take your money? I don't take any of your money! If you don't like what I've got to say then [b]you[/b] go somewhere else.

Now, you have a nice day. We, in France, know how to behave on the world stage. Americans? Pah! I fart in your general direction!

by davidlburkett

I just re-read your posting. I think that you've said it all.

I hate to be so negative, but I simply don't see any light at the end of the IT employment tunnel. I would NEVER advise anyone to choose IT as a career path.

I too have credentials and a lot of experience. Fortunately, I've found a way to support myself that is not IT-centric.

by cactus pete

What do we know about the position that was advertised in the paper? It was for a "LAN tech" and paid $12/hr in Boise, Idaho.

If this were for an entry level position at a small(ish) company, in a low cost of living area, you think $24,000 a year is bad?

We don't know if they required anything more than a High School diplaoma for this position. It might be that the LAN Admin needs an assistant, and wants someone he (or she) can train. Perhaps this person is biased against college educated people or simply prefers someone completely new and doesn't want to "untrain" bad habits.

If no one wants the job, they will either go without filling it, or they will raise the offered wage. It's that simple.

by phildwish

Too many agencies control the basic IT job function and are ripping off the worker, making a huge profit at the expense (lower wages) of the worker. Most workers are to chicken-chit to speak up for fear of no job, or loss of a job, or being black-balled (black-listed) agency-wide. At this point it is time that we IT workers collectively join together to either remove agency-dominance, or somehow control the abuses without severe monetary and career wise black listing as a penalty. The bottom line is that people in IT want to work unencumbered by reckless profiteers and for a reasonable living wage.

by blueknight

The AMA is not a union as you suggest, but an organization "to promote the art and science of medicine and the betterment of public health." There's a big difference there.

Likewise for the ABA whose mission statement says it "is to be the national representative of the legal profession, serving the public and the profession by promoting justice, professional excellence and respect for the law." The "national representative of the legal profession" part sounds kind of [i]unionish[/i] but when you read their goals, there is nothing union about it.

We don't need to unionize IT. What we need is for those who work in IT to become more intelligent with respect to their rights as workers and have the [i]brass[/i] to stand up for those rights. Overtime is NOT mandatory, and if you work overtime, you must be compensated for it. If you're going without lunch, you're screwing yourself. Has your employer called you a manager to avoid paying you overtime? Guess what -- if you don't manage anybody, you're not a manager and you must be paid for the overtime. If your local labor laws aren't strong enough, then you need to contact your legislators and push them to make the laws tougher. You still have federal labor laws behind you so do your part to see they are observed by your employer.

One thing you overlooked in your comparison to doctors is that doctors are exposed to malpractice lawsuits, thus they command a higher price to offset the cost of malpractice insurance.

Those who promote the idea of unionizing IT scare me. It's like promoting offshoring and outsourcing. You [u]know[/u] what happens to your job then. You're telling them "Hey, over here... send my job to India." Not me!

I've worked several places that were "closed shops" during my 39+ years in IT and the unions don't do a darn thing for employees except take their dues. Sure they make a lot of promises when the shop wants to unionize, but once they're in you don't make any more money... you get a "step" increase setup and COLAs and once in a great while they may step in to save some turkey's job if he did something stupid and got into trouble. Once the luster wears off, you almost literally can never get the union out... they keep sucking up your dues and the union bosses get rich.

If you're into unions so much why not become an electrician or a plummer... or even a truck driver.

by pkr9

Those who promote the idea of unionizing IT scare me. It's like promoting offshoring and outsourcing. You know what happens to your job then. You're telling them "Hey, over here... send my job to India." Not me!

If your afraid of what happens to your job if you unionize - then you need to unionize.

My union got me a full years salary in compensation. My boss developed a psychological illnes and turned the workspace into a mental battlefield - and sacked me because I was the ONLY one daring to tell him he had problems and should seek counselling.

I saw how many binders of papers were written, and the countless number meetings that were held to solve this. I would NEVER had the power, money or energy to drive that through to a succesful end myself.

If you think you're more worth than a truck driver, plummer or electrician, I think you have more than a problem with more than your social attitude. You might be a bit surprised if you looked up just how much a plumber actually makes - in normal working hours.

I have been an IT manager for 20 years, worked in the business for as long as you. I respect anybody working, we are all needed to keep society running.

by dusterman

The companies will merely do to you , what they have been dreaming of doing to the unions for years .
Massive layoffs .........cry wolf ......... write off some of the most inventive bookkeeping ever thought up [ that came from a government employee that I flew with ] .........
We all asked for easier , more reliable components ...... we got what we asked for .... da* it !
Was offer a job , when they decided they wanted to cut expenses , offered ........ ready $11.30 an hour ....... here in Denver ...... why ?
Because they can ......... my competitors [sp] have seen to that here in the Denver market !
We all understood that there were over 3K new unemployed it folks here ......... what we didn't expect was .... them to run out of money and then become independent business morons , that priced the market down to $35/hr billable ........
When I try to explain that these "newbie's" can't even run their service vehicle for that hardly .... the customer doesn't care ........
They don't care until they get someone who flubs it up and then walks away , still demanding to be paid ....... just like when they were an employee ! .
Well , my friend ....... try to hang on a little longer ..... and do what I did ....... quit giving away your "secret tools" ...... we've all done it but now it's time to stop !
A short story .........
My small office , all around computer ,printer and floor sweeper employee calls ......
Mike , he says , they just laid me off .... I did find some work down the hall [ my customer ] they said that their regular guy charges too much and would I fix a printer that he said was junk for cheap ?
I say , well Bob here is the way it is ..... I am that person that you referred to and to make a livable income I have to be able to bill @ $70.00/hr to cover all the "stupid time" .....and I have that ever present nasty ole guvment agency - the tax man breathing down my neck .... so when you do the work for $10.00/hr you really hurt those who don't have the luxury of unemployment or welfare to subsidize [sp] our income !
He then says ........ you don't understand "buddy" I need your expertise and no one else will help me ....... and I have got a promise to fulfill here ......
Well says I , Bob ....... you will need to become an apprentice to someone or go to school to learn about these things and by then the wages should be back up to where an existing business like mine is back to making money and then I won't mind giving you that "priceless" free advice :-)
.
.
Hello , hello Bob are you there ..... bzzzzzzz

by startech

...And the stench from your country is well noted!

But, right or wrong, DaveW has the right to say anything he damned well pleases because America protected that right for him to do so. As it has for anyone on this Message board to speak his or her mind, or to unionize or not. Yes, even you.

I wonder if you would have the same sentiment 50+ years ago?

In the meantime, we'll just spray some air freshner in your genral direction -- you seem to need it.

by problemslayer

When many labor unions got their start during the ensuing years of the industrial revolution, their purpose and need were very clear. Many factories provide horrid working conditions, long hours (with no extra compensation) and low pay. Since that time however there have been many changes in the world, the economy and in the realm of labor laws.

Labor unions have become politically charged entities more concerned with garnering power in the political arena than in truly helping their constituents. And look at the results they are currently getting. Labor unions have almost ruined GM and Ford is not far behind. Did you know that GM spends more on the insurance plans for its employees than it does on making cars??!

And where are all those jobs going from the Ford and GM layoffs? Overseas of course, as people buy more and more foreign cars because they are cheaper and more reliable. It is clear to me that unions are not the way to go if we want to prosper in our field.

Too often we as human being want someone else to guarantee our prosperity, be it the government or trade unions. We have to take responsibility for ourselves and our own prosperity and not depend upon others to do it for us.

by startech

Well said, ProblemSlayer!

See my other post "I don't need a union to speak for me -- I speak for myself."

We don't need a union. The only one's that do are those that can't speak up for themselves nor have the experience to back up their pay "wishes!"

Come on! Give me a break. Stop relying on others to do what you should be doing for yourself. We've got enough lazyness and welfare. We don't unions to promote even more.

If you don't have the experience to demand the wages you want, then suck it up, and go learn some more and show'em your worth it. Otherwise, go learn to be a forklift operator -- how hard can that be -- then you can have your union life.

by pickleman

> Labor unions have almost ruined GM and Ford is not far behind.

Exactly right.
GM would still be the number one car manufacturer in the world if their "unions" hadn't destroyed the company.

A couple months ago when they were announcing those massive layoffs, they were saying on the news that a typical worker on the assembly line at Ford or GM makes $65,000 per year. I nearly fell off my chair.

Are you f*cking kidding me!? They're paying these people $65K per year to basically stand there, wait for the robots to bring things to them, and then all they do is essentially push them into place. I mean, come on...is it any wonder why the American car industry has gone into the toilet? And of course, who can we thank for those $65K salaries? You think GM wants to pay these uneducated, unskilled people that kind of money to stand there and push stuff around? No, of course they don't. But that's what the unions demand...so that's what GM has to give.

Way to go Unions!
Keep it up, and soon you won't even HAVE a GM plant or Ford plant left in North America in which to do all your whining and bitching.

by jamesrl

Roughly within 100 miles of downtown Toronto, we have 5 major auto manufacturing plants; GM, Ford, Chrysler, Toyota and Honda.

The first three are unionized. The last 2 are not. Because we have an open labour market, all three pay fairly comparable wages and benefits. All of the plants are safe to work in. But if you polled the workers, if they were honest, most of the workers would prefer to work in the non-union plant, and it shows in the number of applications that come up when a plant undergoes expansion.

Ask yourself why. The unionized plants have a troubled management/labour history, while the non-unionized plants are trouble free. The non-unionized plants are not under the threat of strike every few years. They all produce decent cars.

James

by jamesrl

Roughly within 100 miles of downtown Toronto, we have 5 major auto manufacturing plants; GM, Ford, Chrysler, Toyota and Honda.

The first three are unionized. The last 2 are not. Because we have an open labour market, all three pay fairly comparable wages and benefits. All of the plants are safe to work in. But if you polled the workers, if they were honest, most of the workers would prefer to work in the non-union plant, and it shows in the number of applications that come up when a plant undergoes expansion.

Ask yourself why. The unionized plants have a troubled management/labour history, while the non-unionized plants are trouble free. The non-unionized plants are not under the threat of strike every few years. They all produce decent cars.

James

by dnellis74

Boise is in IDAHO. IT people with such a poor understanding of basic geography shouldn't be giving relocation advice.

by ssl648

I dont even know where to begin. To suggest that any union would ask 25% of its members salaries is asinine. The actual cost of union membership is 1) about 1.5% of salary and 2) the freedom of negotiating directly with your company. Which means no more used car salesman approach to promotions for the underqualified, and no more low balling for the ambitious. Which can definately be bad if fall into either of those categories. But the point here is that IT has become the labor industry of the 21 century, we are where manufacturing was 40 years ago. If you feel that unions are bad for the labor industry then they will look just as bad here. On the other hand, when was the last time you bought something that was 'Made in the USA', now think about how easy it is outsource IT functions vs manufacturing.

by cactus pete

First, I mentioned in an earlier repost that the 25% is meant to be so extraordinary that you don't accept it as reality. I'd take more flack from more people if I stated 2% and someone had 1.5% and another had 1%. How dare I double it!

Next, you have no clue if you think buying everything "Made in the USA" actually ensures you a job. There's a little concept called "Competitive Advantage". If you don't know it, take a few international economics courses.

Perrsonally, I'm worth more than most other people in this field. I don't want my wages lowered because of some sliding scale limiting me to X dollars over Y years. If my value to the company is not proven, they can fire me. If they don't reward my efforts, I leave. THAT is a free market.

I buy things no matter where they are made. I weigh the cost, quality, and how it fits to my needs and desires - and then I make my decision.

Quite honestly, if the US only makes crap I won't buy it.

Then again, there's that "competitive advantage" concept again... All unionists should be forced to take econ courses...

by stan20

...another identical, replacable part, in the larger organization. And you prefer that?? Now thats pathetic and sad.

Thats why I would never live in whatever country you are from. (no location specified)

by pickleman

> We do not want a free market, and no business
> wants a free market. You want a market that you
> control, and until we all realize this we will
> continue to work for $12/hour while Doctors and
> Lawyers make $200-$600/hr.

Utter nonsense.
The people who are charging $12/hour are doing so because that's what they're worth. The lawyers charging $600 are doing so, because that's what they're worth.

If you have serious legal problems, are you going to head over to Bill & Bob's Legal Service for $50/hour, or are you going to hire someone with an established reputation for winning cases? If you want Bill & Bob, go for it, and see where that gets you. If you want to win your case, you'll be heading over to the high-priced lawyers you've seen on TV who make the nightly news.

The I.T. sector is no different. If a company wants to bring in some kid for $12/hour to solve their problems, I just sit back and laugh and wait until they call me after several days of realizing they're getting nowhere. It's not the first time I've seen it. I'm self-employed, and I definitely DON'T charge $12/hour. With my established clients, they've learned not even to waste time bothering to call someone else. But my new clients, they always do something stupid during the first few months that I'm with them. They'll call me up to describe a problem they're having...at which point I'll either tell them on the phone exactly what it will cost, or I'll have to come in to look at the problem and then tell them afterwards. Sometimes, there's always that know-it-all office manager who moans and whines and tells me that he thinks he can bring in someone for $15/hour to do the job. My immediate reaction is always the same - I look him right in the eyes, I smile, and I say "Be my guest. You have my number.."

In every such case, I have always proven to each and every one of my clients that the I.T. business is just like any other business or service or product -- YOU GET WHAT YOU PAY FOR.

Unions in I.T.?
ROFL

by stan20

I charge by what a job is worth. And how much I want to do it. And, I get from $50/hour to $250/hour.

$27.10 per hour would barely pay my mortgage.

And, from time to time, I hire people to help out on some jobs. And I pay them more than $27.10 per hour.

by mignered

Unions do not make the strategic decisions that drive growth and productivity.
Toyotas and Hondas are built in the United States and many of the workers are represented by a union.
Unions helped to build the great American middle class.

by dlyons

In the late 1800's one of the highest paying jobs in the US was telegraph operator, you know MORSE code, dots, dashes. etc. That was the equivalent of today's IT. Alexander Bell spoiled the whole thng. As we've all seen, much of the work we IT people do today is replaceable, almost low skill level. Anybody who ever setup up a WINCHESTER hard drive in the 1980's, complete with entering the error map, knows the changes that have occured.

by cactus pete

I'm not retarded. I'm not naive.

In fact, I'm anti-outsourcing. But the argument to unionize to prevent that fails.

Yes, the datacenter can be managed remotely. Should it be needed, a tech can be dispatched to the site to provide hands on support.

Get this, I manage office sites in Chicago, Washington DC, NYC, Albany, and Milwaukee. Along with some people having VPN access from anywhere. How can I do this if you can't provide remote support? I have support people in DC, but only because the numbers dictate it. I don't need people in the other offices (at this time) so I don't put them there.

I build my systems to withstand most outages, and if I need someone to physcially be there, we talk someon through it, I go, someone else goes, or we pay for someone to show up. (That is, of course, if the vendor support isn't applicable.)

Now, I can run most of my remote offices from one centralized location, and I'm not talking about being a call center.

Yes, there are thousands of reasons someone may need to be at a kayboard or hold a screwdriver in their hands right there... But how many days can't you work from home over a high speed connection?

Great, if you need to be in front of the machine, physically, ever moment of every day, then that's your situation. I don't need to be on every server every day. I don't even need to be at the users' desks to fix most of their issues.

So compare apples to apples. I'm sticking to the argument, and you're calling names and providing narrow cicrumstances when generalizations don't fit.

Stick to it or move on, please.

by cactus pete

If you don't get paid fairly, move on or affect the situation.

But I don't think unions for IT will positively affect the situation.

by richard

his own government removed the import tax that was designed to give him a fair chance against a 25 cent per hour worker.
did he vote, did he challenge this?
even a large company can't help alone. If Ford or GM decided to be different they would simply cost more then the guys who pay 25 cents per hour. You have to have a union and labor laws, they have to be fair, the company needs and deserves a profit.
they don't deserve to pay 25 cents per hour and dump oil into the river. Not every company is against unions. Many like to hire good trained help.
Id you are a programmer at, say Microsoft, do you really profess to know what one of your hours is worth in the grand scheme of things? I think you don't. I do think you know if you know how many hours a week you will work and how much you will be paid and how much per hour that comes to, OR do you really know.
Or are you a "professional" "exempt" = translation, fixed fee, open ended supply. You give as much as I demand when I decide but I don't owe you more for working more. Sounds pretty stupid doesn't it.

by cactus pete

Which american companies made hybrid cars more than 2 years ago?

So, if I wanted a hybrid, what should I have done?

by techniquephreak

I have one, just because I fell for the hype... But an MCSE is a useless cert that the majority of folks don't give a rats ass about. And I'm in Seattle. A monkey could get an MCSE.

I don't even put weight in the Cisco certs...

These buggers who go to some tech school and get certified and think that makes them a net guru are the problem...

If I were forced to work for $50, I would be taking a major pay cut. Unions work for some industries, but I really don't think we're the right one. Go back to the drawing board and come up with some compelling reasons... Then I might reconsider.

by richard

Most of your statement is correct, but we do not all think that way. One big part of the problem is greed, many of the youg are not educated well, they are taught to type setup and push a button, but they don't see the big picture. Those that hire them tell them how smart they are and they believe it, while the give away their future.

Yep - that is inflamatory - please keep it up, it helps.

by startech

Let's just say I make more than than now. Am I worth more than that? At least twice so.

Do I ask for it? I think you answered this one in one of your other posts.

The basic problem with America is greed. I may have my faults, but that's not one of them.