Discussion Locked

vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)

0 helpful
1,924 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 4 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,924 replies

by gsaravin9

hey col there are too many complications just yet.
I have spoken to a number of companies & they said that vista drivers for new equipment will be delayed well beyond next year even later.So i'm not holding my breath on vista.I've also spoken to insiders in MS & they said to me what i've been
saying that they are still grapling with source
code & that could be till the cows come home.
Another problem is they are working on the development of the vista kernel to stop viruses attacking it.There are other things associated
with the whole vista project that it has major complications.He said to me it will be a wonder how the whole thing will work out in the end.He said to me if you like being dazzled by vista & it's features then you will like it as he said there aren't any reasons for change because of changes'sake.
I said to him that vista is more or less a copycat of the mac os system & people have grown to hate the transparency feature they know that allready!

by gsaravin9

dear mick,
I'll have to agree with you on many respects.
I've had nothing but problems with a couple of seagate drives they will not allow installations of vista.I have contacted seagate & they said they are aware & are modifying their software accordingly.I've had trouble using photoshop
as it will totally not work with vista.
There are numerous software i have tried vista does not recognise the exe files.I've had problems with dynamic link libraries not working
or failing to install.I have also lost two databases of data as they crashed,backup sofware does not work with vista.I suppose speed
& a few cosmetic changes is all that it has going for it.

yours mick

by gsaravin9

Ever since VIsta has been available as a beta release i have had nothing but crashes & problems.
What i'm saying is whil'st unix is more stable
windows is more prone to problems & it comes at a cost.
You hit the nail on the head as you mentioned linux
as it is a more stable system than windows & is as closer to unix than windows.
All i'm saying is the problems with vista are huge & as compared to previous releases.
In my organisation we have totally gone from windows to linux due to the stability problems.
Also if MS comes up with the goods i for one will be the first to convert to windows.
Aso think of the poor home user will they have
$700 or more to spend on a vista vista o/s.
I know beta is beta but i have just lost two data
bases of data due to crashes with vista.Back up failed as the software is not compatible.
My job entails evaluating systems & software for bad or worse without prejudice i'm not going to waste good hard earned money on something that will not work properly.!
mick

by gsaravin9

In regards to vista & unix the answer seems to be linux.It has to do with stability & reliability & also cost.
I have just lost two data bases of data due to vista crashes & backup failed due to software incompatiblity.Also photoshop doesn't even work!

by hal 9000

Some more [b]Major Flaws[/b] in Vista and removed it from the Download site till they have them worked out.

The 5472 version wasn't there for long and they don't seem to be rushing to get the thing pushed out for Beta Testing any time soon. Looks as if the Launch Date has been put back to Feb- March next year if this is the way that things are going. :D

Col

by bengt

Stop complaining about gsaravin@... 'His' posts are generated automatically using a buzzword generator, which also looks to be the case for most other OS posts on most discussions everywhere...

Why does nobody admit that an OS is only a necessary evil, and that only applications matter? Will Vista run everything XP can, including old DOS data bases?

by gsaravin9

In my reply to george ou i mentioned security problems with vista & he said how wonderfull vista is.I said straight from the beginning that i fear there would be severe security problems with vista.In my contact with various people with MS.They said to me that vista is more complex than before & they can't guarrantee security.Security comes at a price!
mick

by 2shane

Windows Longdong umm no make that Vista; yeah Vista is Satan Incarnate., upgrade to Win 3.11.

by gsaravin9

perhaps everyone needs to go back to square one maybe even windows 2.1 i still have the two diskettes to go!
mick

by w.j.eichler

I am using Linspire and have only had some minor problems with it. The best part is their software installation process. As long as you have a fast internet connection it works very well. They have many free products in their CRM warehouse and they install without much user interaction. The downside is that you have to pay for the OS and the service. When you consider value for the dollar though it is pretty cheap. For about $49.00 a year you download and install all of the free applications you want, including Open Office, Firefox, Opera, Realplayer, etc. The OS can be purchased for about $49.00 also.

Their tech support is knowledgeable and responsive, much more so than MS. When I needed them they provided support not a way to find support. The fix worked the first time.

If you are looking for an alternative give them a try. Until some OS other than MS starts getting paying users, they will always be second rate. Linux is a strong kernel and with some standardization and funding could put MS on the run. This would result in better MS products. Look at Intel; until they were pushed by AMD they made slow progress, as they felt it was profitable. When they started to get their butt kicked, they came up with Conroe.

As for Mac being competition, didn't Gates bail out Mac not too many years ago? Does anyone remember the Godfather?

by unclerob

nothing in my post suggested that I didn't know what the required specs for vista are, on the contrary I've tested the recent vista beta on a few machines, each of them with more than capable specs (both of them still falling short performance wise which is why I guess this discussion has flourished some much)

In fact, I've also installed the vista transformation pack on one of my winxp machines to get a handle on the vista gui experience, so far I'm undecided but at least I know what windows will look like when the next os is finally release (whenever that is)

.... rob,wpg

by moira

I installed the latest beta and discovered it was going to need activating within 3 days, which I couldn't do.

Resigned to going back to the earlier beta, I logged on to it and got the expected message that Windows couldn't activate. It then proceeded to load as normal, download and install some Windows updates and run everything perfectly (except system fan control which Biostar just don't seem to have vista drivers for yet).

Avast AV updated itself as well - basically everything still works, which is a bit strange. I'll never spend much time in it while I can't set system fan control though, but I don't want to install it on this PC because it only has onboard graphics.

I guess I'll be using XP for a while yet. I agree about the stability of linux, if it wasn't for having to use Windows for softwear reasons, I'd be happy to spend the majority of my time using something like Ubuntu.

by gsaravin9

Theres a lot to be said on the function of drivers you made a good point that under vista using existing drivers will produce weired results like hardware crashes.Also i have noticed current drivers
don't allow laptops to switch off & they still keep working in their bags.Maybe even catch fire.I also noticed whils't testing different graphic cards they can get exceptionally hot under vista.I can vouch that i have come up with similar problems when testing the vista Beta releases.
The other thing i would like to add is a lot of the technical people that have spoken so highly of
vista in their reviews have changed their mind now as it is not ready to be released.
The other thing is the main reason why i have this view of vista as crap is that i have gone through the various testing problems plus i have contacts
in the industry.

ta mick

by rebelflag

AVG now will install under the Beta 2 of Vista, so there is an anti-virus option available.

by rebelflag

For someone who is allegedly a code writer, could you please learn to edit your posts. It really is not necessary to keep posting the same thing over and over again. Please. If you want to get real adventurous you could also give spelling and punctuation a run.

by gsaravin9

it's more when you are on the fly,rush rush,keys on key board sometimes stick,kids spilling drinks.
point taken much appreciate it.
ta mick

by rebelflag

You say that Vista is krap. You speak highly of OS X. Then you say that Vista is a knockoff of OS X. Wouldn't that make either OS X krap, or Vista good (depending on which way you are leaning at the time?)

by gsaravin9

you make sense in what you say.I,m not anti windows
but why introduce something that is with someone else &claim it's new.Why can't we get something new
for a change,why duplicate.Given the huge resources of ms why can't they create something new.I could get stuck into mac os as a system but i don't evaluate such systems & they have their place.What i'm saying is we can get lost in the actual trickery
of functionality call it gimmicks what you like & yes you could apply it to other systems as well.
good point ps I'm not saying that's good to call vista crap & not the other.I also think that crap is in a subjective way.I say it more to stimulate response. ta mick

by gsaravin9

a big IF it comes out at all it would be the biggest
operating system disaster ever unleashed on the gullible consumer.Like i said before i'm not impressed by what i've heard from MS insiders that the whole project has gotten too big & it's out of hand & no one seems to know what the hell is going on.In regards to the 5472 i heard that they weren't so keen to push it as there are huge technical problems
involved.I would say that the whole project was headed for disaster from the start.The beta releases have huge problems & even ongoing source code problems.
TA Mick

by gsaravin9

I don't know, but i know that a lot of things have been hastily taken down from The MS website including a review on specs.As vista will not install on some hardware & MS knows full well that
they cannot make sham specs for the sake of it.
A big IF is it's continual release of betas is under review as it's plagued by huge technical problems.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

all those people who said i don't know what i'm talking about arenow totally wrong & who attacked me personally will eat mums humble pie.
I have just found out from insiders from MS that the
VISTA project may have to be either ditched or postponed indefinitely due to huge insurmountable problems.So all you technical people you know who i mean who wrote really nice things about vista & made huge promises when in fact it was a HUGE GIGANTIC FLOP will eat humble crow!
ta MIck

by michael l hereid sr

Vista has not been ditched or postponed. I do have multi-contacts at MS and they say you don't know what yur talking about.
Mike

PS I have 10 years of contacts at MS.

by gsaravin9

Now that we know that MS is ditching vista,did you all know that plans were a afoot that MS had plans for 128 bit right through to 728 bit operating systems the mind just boggles.I'm quite happy with 32 bit windows xp thankyou!
Imagine that 728 bit systems probably in 1000 years i hate to think even about it,
ta mick

by hal 9000

That the Vista Bets 2 will be released some time within the next 3 weeks which it has and since been withdrawn from Beta Testers, but far more importantly.

Vista represents 1,000,000 Man Hours of development and that they are still finding 5,000 problems in the Kernel per day. Vista Ultimate was slated for product Release sometime in November 06 but that now seems to have been put back to some time in 07 at the very least and currently MS has stopped sending out Beta Testers Newsletters to all of those signed up as Beta Testers but are continuing to accept problems as people who are testing it report them.

Somehow by the way that information from MS has completely dried up over the last couple of weeks I would tend to agree that the launch has been placed back again and with more limited functions being incorporated into the OS. If everything was going smoothly at MS with Vista it must be getting very close to Finial Release Version by now as it's supposed to be shipping in a little over 3 months so they have to get the Master Copy to the DVD Makers and press the DVDs package them and have them dispatched World Wide by November so the finial Release Version should only be days away 14 at the absolute tops as any longer than that MS wouldn't be able to get stock to the shops in time for the November Launch not to mention the Big PC Makers like Dell, HP, Gateway and their ilk.

At the very least the 32 Bit Version has been put back and the 64 Bit Version placed even further back in it's projected release time because it doesn't work properly.

But MS has a Problem here as the new Sharepoint will only run on a 64 Bit Platform what is going to be available to run it on 2003 64 Bit which is already suffering from a lack of available drivers?

Col

by gsaravin9

I'm sorry to tell you that i have some bad news for you i was right for a change.I have just received some news from an insider at MS that the VISTA project is to be ditched or postponed indifinetly.The project had been a disaster from the start behest with many insurmountable technical
problems.There you have it a lot of people including
you will have to eat humble pie or humble crow.I was right all along!!
ta Mick

by steve.marshall

... Please check your sources...

http://forums.wincustomize.com/index.aspx?forumid=202&aid=109570&c=1

Yes, ok, I know I said I would never post on this thread again, but I'm afarid I could not allow the train wreck that is gsaravin to wallow in self proclimation without retort...

Any chance we can see gsaravin being scrapped in the near future ? if anything was full of bugs, bad coding and poor performance its him, makes MS products look absolutely perfect on first release !

by gsaravin9

Now that we know tha MS is ditching vista most pc manufacturing is going to be curtailed as there won't be a proper operating system especialy the much touted 64 bit system.In conversation with George Ou who asked me which betas have i tested in may he assured me that
vista was working quite comfortably in the 64 architecture.I explained to him that it is the opposite & that there are major hitches to overcome.So now we know that vista is not able to function properly in the 32 bit architecture due to lack of drivers & other hardware problems.Next i discover straight from MS that they are having source code problems & ongoing problems complicate things further.MS was buying
more time. I explained that on the surface it appeared that MS had tightened security problems but the opposite was the norm & so on & on.So
the project has gone from the ridculous to the sublime.I pointed out that i had major reservations on vista coming out at all.Lo & behold i was right.A lot of people will now have to eat both crow & humble pie too!It got to the stage
that even at the launch of the new Mac os they
had a dig at how vista is a copy cat of mac os & a poor one at that.
I have been totally vindicated.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

Now that we know that MS is ditching vista,did you all know that plans were a afoot that MS had plans for 128 bit right through to 728 bit operating systems the mind just boggles.I'm quite happy with 32 bit windows xp thankyou!
Imagine that 728 bit systems probably in 1000 years i hate to think even about it,

ta mick

by hal 9000

At the Prototype Stage and are currently working on 256 Bit CPU's it's only to be expected that the [b]Biggest OS Maker in the World[/b] will follow where the hardware is leading. Of course I very much doubt that they'll manage to get it right unless they somehow rebadge a SCO Unix with MS Windows 64 Bit and give Gnome all the [b]Eye Candy[/b] that is associated with Windows. :^0

Of course if MS tried this they would somehow manage to muck it up completely by rewriting the code so that the average user would constantly run as [b]Root.[/b] :D

To prevent others having access to the [b]Source Code[/b] they would have to substantially alter the SCO Unix to something completely different as any Linux would just be way to similar and the Enterprise Versions who offer a Better Support Service than MS does would have to be done away with because they would give MS a [b]Bad Name.[/b] So places like SUSE, Red Hat & Mirvinda would have to go but I'm not quite sure how MS would deal with Debian as there is no company behind it just a bunch of developers who have no direct ties to the project other than donating their time and effort the [b]Software Equivalents of Terrorists at least in M$ eyes.[/b] :D

Col

by gsaravin9

vista is a DUD !
Recent release of vista has proven to a lot of people that it is a complete waste of time.VISTA=DUD!
MS have pretented to show by using terms like vista ready & packing features that people don't realy need & using catch words like "killer product" with complete abandon when in fact it has been a complete DUD!
There are no real benefits attached.Compared to xp it is much slower.Heaps of people have tried the os & have gone back to XP just as i had predicted!
Microsoft also has attempted to cut
Support Time for Some Vista queries...
Vista will go the way of Windows ME and I think Microsoft knows it that is why they have allready announced a ... Gee, do ya THINK MS knows Vista is a dud? ...
When compared, test results actually show vista to be outperformed by xp.

ta mick

by gsaravin9

What is it with these free invites to launches,freebies for
technical writers they come out praising vista & singing it's praises.I come out telling the truth
& i get shot down in flames.I said exactly what you are saying & that vista in it's current form of development & delays etc as a product is not going to last.Judging from the contacts at MS i have unofficially asked & they said vista is ready for the S-crap
heap.MS has allready pulled the rug from the beta testers & said screw you were not ready.To top it all of if ever they release vista to the consumers are going to stay away.Vista is completely dead & buried as far i'm concerned.Also from speaking to quite a number of beta testers they told me in no uncertain terms they are pissed off with MS & the way they treat them like complete fools.
I agree with you that the only hope vista had in the credibility stakes was to get it all finalised
within a certain period & certainly release it before christmas to maximise sales.
I simply don't like their chances of a release in
january as it has taken too long & i don't like their chances.
ta Mick

by gsaravin9

If intel & amd can get ahead in the bit architecture
why can't someone as big as MS.Frankly if i were
a developer i'd walk out cosidering the stress etc they are in.Clearly MS has shown they can't even keep up with the next level let alone 128 bit.I cannot even begin to fathom what were going to encounter with 128 bit.Speaking with a few of the developers they are completely pissed off with MS &
being a developer is not a easy task i'd like to be in.Imagine the source code needed to just finish off vista.It is just absolutely mind bogling the time spent on vista.
Given MS track record they are simply ducking & weaving for cover & cant't keep up with the pc manufacturers who are simply going to stop development.
mick

by michael l hereid sr

Are you calling the people who downloaded Vista Beta 2(build 5384-Preview Release), Beta Testers?? If so they are not Offical MS Beta Testers.
Most of the REAL Beta Testers have been downloading and using Vista since July of last year. They have, also since Vista Beta 2 was released to the public, downloaded and have/are using 2 differant builds since that time.
They are also in constant communication with MS via private newsgroup.
Mike

by hal 9000

Get access to any form of Vista?

They had to register with MS to get access to the product and allow themselves to be called Bets Testers.

Besides the Forums the newsletters have completely dried up that are coming from MS. I used to be getting them about twice a week now I haven't seen one for ages a little over 1 month. And while the Vista Forums are hosted by MS they are not actually supported by MS have you noticed much MS input to these forums recently?

Do you remember the time that MS would send you the Beta Versions Free? I do now they are expecting you to pay for the Post & Shipping and then put in your time to tell what's wrong with the product. If MS expects you to pay for their Beta products even if it's only Postage & Packing they should be willing to pay for the feedback that they are getting after all this is only befitting MS and no one else when it comes to money. Personally from the way that MS is heading I'm seriously beginning to think that I'll drop out of the Beta Testing program that I've been in since it began and just confine my play time to writing Linux Applications & improving the code base that is being used. At least that way I'm not spending my money for no reason and then have MS claim to have done it all when they release a new product.

Michael if you like being a MS stodge you're welcome but I'm rapidly tiring of it and am currently wondering why I'm a member of the MS Certified Partners Team and more importantly why I pay for so much stuff that is next to useless to me. One day I might even use something from the Action Pack that I religiously pay for each year but personally I find that I get better value for money from Volume License product and the contents of the Action Pack make excellent Drink Coasters.

Col

by michael l hereid sr

of Vista Betas and I do not get them from Microsoft dot com- I get them from a non-public website and server. I pay no money getting any beta I have or am in. When ever there has been a cd/dvd they send out -I pay no money for it-MS does.
I can tell you this-watch the MS website after September 4th-you may see RC1 Preview then.
Tell you what also- goto http://connect.microsoft.com you may find something there. Also every once in a while go there-you may find something you may want to volunteer for. ;)
Also I have never worked nor probably never will work for MS. I have beta tested for MS since December of 1997. On some of the betas I have even started with the Alpha builds-again paying no money.
If I ever get a scanner I will scan a few of the 75 cd's I have recieved from MS to you.
And by the way one of the things I beta tested was SP1/SP2 for Windows XP. Plus a few of the rollup's for same.
Mike

PS When the public gets a Preview of a beta OS-they are just previewing the beta-if they report problems to MS so much the better for us all.

by rkuhn040172

I won't hold my breath for the 128 bit nor the 256 bit hardware to come out anytime soon.

First off, neither Intel nor AMD will release it anytime soon as they haven't made enough money on the 64 bit versions to pay for the research and development...you act as if these things come free.

Intel and AMD are a for-profit business too just like Microsoft.

Second of all, for many years now hardware has been ahead of software so what is your point? A 1.0 Ghz processor is more than enough for the average, everyday user except for gamers, developers, etc.

Which way do you want it? One of the things Linux users always talked about the most is that Linux will run fine on an old x486 and Windows won't. Now, you ranting and raving about 256 bit PC's. Geesh.

Sometimes you get so far ahead of yourself, I don't think you even realize what you are saying.

Lastly, just about all makers of OS's steal ideas from each other. That is the competitive market working.

Few Linux users will admit it, but until the day comes that Linux looks like Windows, their market share will be limited.

And to be fair, until the day comes that Windows has the security of Linux, they will be under constant assault.

No one company or group has a patent on perfection. Every OS has its strenghts and every OS has its weaknesses.

I would expect all companies and groups to steal ideas from each other.

by rkuhn040172

Why do you keep saying November?

Have I missed something or do you live under a rock?

Microsoft has already come out (a long time ago) and said that it won't be released until after the 1st of the year (2007).

by michael l hereid sr

That is you will be able to go out and buy a copy at your local retailer. Here is the time line for you.
1 Before end of October RTM(release to manufacturing)
2 November/December release to corperations
3 then january release so you can buy one.
Mike

by gsaravin9

i think we are above ourselves as we worry more about the hardware & software but we forget that it's all about money in the end & whether the poor old consumer will buy it.I think we are too
pre-occupied at present worrying about the uncetainties.I think it will be a wait & see whats around the corner.
ta mick

by hal 9000

That's why AMD pours so much money into Ferrari, HP pours so much money into Williams and why Intel was the first to market with a 64 Bit CPU which they have since dropped like a hot potato as it wasn't backward compatible like the AMD 64 was.

As well as Profit there comes [b]Bragging Rights[/b] which both companies want more than the other as this sells their product. So Currently AMD is saying that we had the First True Multipurpose 64 Bit CPU and Intel is saying well you might have had the first 64 Bit CPU that was accepted by the consumer but we had the fastest that is currently available.

I've been to both AMD & Intel meetings and the one sure thing that comes through is that they are creating their own markets and people are buying this stuff not so much because they need it but because they want it even if the software of choice doesn't support their Current Generation Hardware.

Once upon a time the catch cry from the Linux Brigade was we can use old hardware to do the same job now it's changed quite a lot as they are saying 64 Bit we've had it as a fully working version for years what's MS been doing all this time? Currently when it comes to 64 Bit Architecture and above Linux is leading the path by a long way and MS is constantly playing Catch up not very well. Just have a look at how long the Major Distro's out there have had complete 64 Bit Packages available and granted while most are geared to the AMD 64 Architecture more and more are coming on line that support Intel's EMT 64 Bit as well while MS is plodding along with it's 64 Bit versions of XP Pro and 2003 that support piratically nothing in the way of hardware.

Personally I'm getting sick & tired of telling people that their new beaut printer which they are attempting to connect to a 2003 64 Bit Enterprise Server will not work because there are no 64 Bit drivers for it. I really wouldn't mind if they just accepted the truth of the matter but instead they throw abuse at me because I tell them the truth which they don't want to hear.

Lets face it MS is now holding back Technology not leading it. :D

Col

by hal 9000

Actually I was in there yesterday downloading a copy of ISA to have a play with on a new system that I'm building for a company who are insisting that they don't need ISA. :D

I'm betting that after 120 day time trial they will have a different attitude.

Currently MS is talking about charging people for Office and with the last round of Vista Releases if you chose to get the DVD you paid for the shipping which is something new that MS has never had previously. I've been doing testing since the prior to the 98 days if not earlier it's really too long to remember back and I have a heap of Beta CD's as well as the [b]Time Bombs[/b] that MS hand out as release versions to wet the appetite with. At the 2003 ES launch they insisted on giving me another set of something like 15 CD's for 2003ES and all the associated software that comes with it. It didn't matter that I already had a copy they where just throwing them away like they where going out of fashion.

Previously MS would send you the CD's and give you the option to download so you have it now instead of waiting a couple of weeks about 4 mostly and in those days they allowed you to download and they sent you a copy as well. Besides the Time Bombs that MS hand out I have heaps of the Pre Beta & Beta copies of different MS Software as well. Does this page look familiar?

http://tinyurl.com/sx4wj

I generally don't post links to closed sites as it confuses too many people but this particular page is a very useful starting point to get what you need and is my Default Tech-net Page.

[b]Rick[/b] you can join up and get the [b]Good Oil[/b] on everything MS or at the very least MS view on it. I don't know how they do it now but they used to require you to have an active E-Mail address and they would send you out an e-mail with the activation code your password so you could access the site. Since I've been a member of this prior to Hot-mail I'm not quite sure how things are done today at one stage they where asking you to create a Hot Mail Account but I think that you have a choice now of either using one of your existing e-mail account or a Hot-mail account. :)

Col

by michael l hereid sr

I don't have Technet as I could never afford it. I am just a Home user that when MS needed some new Beta Testers to test a Home user of Windows 95-they want some who had 95 and 3.1 to see how Windows 98 Beta 3(i still remember some of the painful experiance of that) did on upgrading same. At the time I had 2 computers one of which had 3.1 on it and the other 95. I got lucky and was accepted and have Beta Tested ever since.
The only windows I did not test was 2K.
With vista I am lucky in that I can test all versions of the os from Vista Home Basic to Vista Ultimate. :p The only one I don't is the Business version as I'm not in business and don't know what business's need.
Mike

by hal 9000

MS Partners get involved in Beta Testing they want to sell the product but know [b]Bugger All[/b] about it. Actually I got a funny one yesterday I was asked again to register for Tech Net but this time it came up as the UK Tech Net not the US or AU so I'm not overly sure what's going on. It was defiantly a MS Site and all the details where correct but why MS is breaking up Tech Net so much is a little beyond me. Last year we only had to re-register once and where connected directly to the Local Country and the US Tech Net sites now it seems that we need to register on every Tech Net Site. I've just got another [b]Registration Reminder[/b] from MS in one of the routine newsletters so I'm not overly sure what's happening that's now 3 in 3 days.

From MS there are several different versions of Vista Basic which is equivalent to XP Home, Premium which is the equivalent of XP Media Centre and Ultimate which is sort of something like XP Pro but there are 2 more the Business & Enterprise versions and this is where things get a bit funny it's only with the Enterprise Version that you can have Software Assurance and you can get Volume License with Ultimate, Business and Enterprise. MS licensing is a Nightmare at best and until a lot more information becomes available I really don't know what's what in the Vista Lineup and then you have to remember that all of these will be coming in both 32 & 64 Bit Versions and somewhere in this is supposed to be a Server Version as well but as yet we haven't seen hide nor hare of that one but it's supposed to be running the new 64 Bit only Exchange which allows more Mail Boxes and much more room for stored E-Mail but this needs to run on a Server Application so there is a problem there with the lack of 64 Bit drivers that are currently available.

I don't currently know what MS is doing along these lines either as they have stopped sending Notices out as to how things are progressing. But I'm still thinking that the proposed November Launch date is more than a bit optimistic on MS behalf. :)

Col

by gsaravin9

while booting from a cd vista 2 & clean isntall
on a western digital hdd 80 gig drive i had an error "file setup sys could not be loaded"
"the error code 4"
what do you think i can't get beyond this.Is the drive ruined???
ta mick

by gsaravin9

i thought peole know better.My reasearch is much, much thorough by the way what is your email if your a good sort i can email the special secret software i have on hand.
I have looked at all the source code for vista & all i can say ,the way it is compiled it will not be ready by january 07.Vista fails on many fronts & particularly there's hardly any software or drivers around.Most of the hardware doesn't even function properly.Yes i have extensively tested all the vista betas & they are all short of abysmal in performance standards.Also i have a masters in computer science & currently attend uni & i do a Phd.
If you are a good sort we may even extend this coversation!

by gsaravin9

we all need a break & need to chill out dudes!
ta mick

ps we need it as we all work hard & deserve more money!

by gsaravin9

Just hang inthere the proof will come when there is anouncement that MS will not release vista because it's such a flop.
ta mick ster

by gsaravin9

after booting off a cd when i was clean installing vista beta 2 on a 80 gig hdd western digital drive i had an error come up"file setupdd Sys could not be loaded"
I think the harddrive is ruined any way out of this ?? I defintely think that's the end of the drive.
ta mick

by steve.marshall

You truly believe that MS would scrap something they have invested so much money in, even to the point of distributing BETA's ?

You know nothing of projects do you, certainly of something of this scale, if it was going to be scrapped it would have been done way before the BETA stage.

Anyway... more to the point... what kind of perverse little man are you that takes great pleasure in seeing MS downed (Not that its going to happen) ?

None of your posts have contained one iota of positivity unless you have been trying to massage the ego of a previous poster by telling them "Yes.. you are right !" without actually grasping what they were posting anyway ! Just a vain attempt of gaining some support from a large group of people that already know your nothing but an idiot without a point to prove...

Anyway, broken my promise to myself twice now and made two posts after suggesting I would no longer entertain it... I'll leave it at that, but may start a campaign to ban the gsaravin from these boards as you obviously have nothing to contribute other than random banter, self promotion, unrealistic and poorly constructed rants about a company/product you know nothing about.

by gsaravin9

You just prove to me that you are the real cretin.
I have checked some of your postings & i have to say that they are crap & you are crap.Remember you are the one that's attacking me .You don't know anything as you are brainwashed whatever other people dish out to you. you can't think for yourself,you can't grasp reality.You are the real cretin.Whereas we are maintaining a sense of reality when someone like you comes along & spoils it for everyone.
I challenge you to write in response how much you have tested vista I stake my claim on 29 years of testing in IT.I have a Masters in Computer science
& i'm half way through my Phd.
So there CRETIN go away!
Mick

by steve.marshall

... of the 100's that you have made that is a constructive one regarding Vista and it's BETA status...

I have seen many from HAL, Michael and others that actually attempt to deal with some of the inadequacies in Vista.

All I see from you is child like posts quoting again and again that you have 29 years of experience and that you're studying for you Phd yadda yadda to infinitum...

I started many weeks ago requesting (politely) that maybe you need to review your debating techniques, but you chose to ignore that and continue your inane and nonsensicle ramblings quoting your resume again and again which basically means or achieves nothing other than re-enforcing the rest of the posting world that you have absoultely no idea what you're talking about at all...

A child can sit at home and profess they have walked on the moon, only their actions publicly can re-inforce that as fact, all you have displayed is an obvious lack of understanding of how OS's are launched (Read Hardware driver problems) and no understanding of any kind of programme management.

I have not actually commented directly on my experience of Vista as a tester because I have no experience of it, and frankly don't personally want to... What I am interested in is the view of the technical public on its flaws and posible implementation requirements for a global rollout programme for the organisation I am responsible for, which, (as you're so keen to enforce your CV, ill give you a little detail of mine) I will be responsible for the implementation of Vista (for my sins) for over 38,000 desktops globally for a Fortune 500 organisation, and thus my interest and why it's important for me to have your worthless crap filtered off what otherwise is an interesting thread.

Just do me one small favor and consider the value of your posts before you make them, there is absolutely NO NEED to continue telling people you have 29 years experience, because a) nobody cares, b) it has no impact on the subject, c) nobody believes you anyway.

We don't care if you have a PhD or even trying for one for the same reasons.

I won't bother answering your call of my intelligence as again it holds no relevance and the fact (or fiction) that I may (or may not) be a member of "the1000" or "mensa" has nothing to do with the subject anyway...

by hal 9000

[i]Microsoft's own blogger Richard Scoble checked into the story and got a denial from an executive at Microsoft's PR firm,[/i]

Why ask a PR Firm? They would know as much about the technical side of things as asking a Politician about the price of bread for the working class. Surely if there wasn't some truth to this story MS would be denouncing it at every opportunity and not relying on an outside company who knows nothing about the technology involved to answer questions.

As they say in the BBC Series [b]Absolute Power[/b] [b]Never Shake the Hand of a Gynaecologist or ask a PR Person for the Truth![/b]

Col

by gsaravin9

col of course they would deny to minmise any colatoral damage.You have every man & his dog coming
out of the woodwork in denial.I have 29 years of experience in IT.Some people think that i make brash
statements.But in reality i do my homework,i research things through.I would base my comments
on that but i can tell you the rumblings are correct.
I tested all the betas & they are totally crap.
I base my research on checking some of the
source code & that's why MS is abandoning ship
it's a juggernaut & it's going to sink.
You would think that MS is paying people to say nice things the way it's reported.

I know i'm right as i'm not trying to give a positive spin.
ta mick

by rkuhn040172

"Surely if there wasn't some truth to this story MS would be denouncing it at every opportunity and not relying on an outside company who knows nothing about the technology involved to answer questions."

However, some would also argue that defending oneself against purely speculative or flat out false information only lends a sense of credibility to that information.

For example, few would try to argue against the conspiracy theorists that Elvis is still alive or that Hitler is alive and well somewhere in South America.

It just doesn't make sense to defend oneself against completely false acquisitions.

by hal 9000

But I think you mean when Booting from a DVD not CD as Vista doesn't come on a CD.

I generally don't use WD Drives as I haven't found them overly reliable but you could try flashing he Firmware on the WD Drive or making a copy of the Vista DVD as the original may be damaged.

It also wouldn't hurt using a wiping program that writes zero's to every sector of the drive as well.

Col

by gsaravin9

Definitely not, this is the first time i've seen the above i have had first hand experince with the crap betas.Also i have had a chance to check some of the
source code that is currently been loaded.Coupled with the fact that i have a few Ms contacts & what they told me that they feel that vista is history & i smell a rat.MS have basically said that stuff you were
not ready.I don't think that vista will be released by jan 07.Also given that the proverbial rug has been pulled from under our feet.You only have to see that there is hardly anything on the MS site now.There's no beta testing,theres no specs.
steve if you bother to check that i have been right all along that vista is crap & a majority of
postings on this thread agree with me, all you have
is a personal attack on me.Just remmber it's people like you that readily accept without question all the rantings & ravings of technical writers, writing positive spins on vista were in fact wrong as vista misses the mark totally.
Steve you know i'm right,you remind me of a fly who is never there,who shits around & flys away.Thats because you have not done any research along the way.You find one posting & say that is what i base everything which is bullshit.
Unless you have something constructive
to say please stay away.(buzzaway)

ta mick
A good many people at tech republic agree with me,& youll see that i'm right when vista is totally scrapped.

by gsaravin9

as hearsay.You know nothing about checking things for yourself you have to rely on win customise sites
to tell you about vista & some sort of hearsay to convince you that vista is crap.
i have done hundreds of hours of testing,I have got countless contacts from all over the place.you have none except some shit website!I have more credibilty
than you as i base my views on good hard experience & genuine feel for the product,Wherea's you go to shit websites like win customise to help
you decide.You are fence sitter steve & you are just jealous because you aren't really intelligent.Just think apart from criticising me you have not made any comment on vista that one would consider intelligent regardless if it was wrong or right.Your threats to start a campaign will nothing short of backfire on you because
if you try it you will find yourself on your arse!

That's the sort of dopy things you have to resort
like the child that you are because you don't have anything intelligent to say.Pretty soon i'm
going to get my Phd & i have to deal with idiots like you. please go away!
mick

by michael l hereid sr

Vista. You say you have tested all the builds for Vista - how about listing some of the builds you tested?? Also how about listing the Motherboard/cpu you are testing on??
Mike

by gsaravin9

i found out it was the bios on the motherboard.I managed to hoodwink the installation as it was looking for harware by pressing f7 & that's it!
ta mick

by gsaravin9

I'm right.All along you have been expecting me to be all technical with my reviews but i decided not to post any technical details as i feel that too much data will confuse people.The basic tenet has been that vista beta is crap & i 've proved it & all the senior people have now agreed.Note people like George Ou no disrespect to him thought that like you that i don't know what i'm talking about.But i have researched with my contacts,tested the Betas of which were a pain to work with as they would not even install properly.I lost 2 databases with vista due to backup software not working under vista.
Different motherboards & bios not working properly,& drivers not working,new drivers not available etc etc Do i need to be more technical to say thats Crap.Also I have contacts that informed me that they think VISTA is totally
finshed as far as an operating system.If 'i'm
wrong i'll eat humble pie.Note also some of the IT chicks are even cracking on to me!
personally dude i mean you no harm!
Sorry dude If you want technical stuff you have to resort to mike or Hal(col)
cheers dude
mick
Also don't expect grammar or spelling on these
posts as i'm lazy & write on the fly.

by rkuhn040172

No one is asking you to confuse people.

What we do want is for you to prove your credentials.

George and Michael are very reliable sources of info and, as much as I hate to admit to it as I disagree with him as often as I agree with him, HAL is also a reliable source for the most part.

You, on the other hand, give nothing to this conversation other than your own opinion, and as the saying goes, opinions are like #$%^^^&, everyone has one.

by gsaravin9

No one said you can't run vista on it's own using all sourts of setups but what was mean't that if you wan't to run other software on vista you better get some decent size hardware as anything less might not work with vista.It just depends what you trying to run.I couldnt get some of the software to work under
vista & some hardware did'nt work well either.
I hope this answers your question.
ta george

by rkuhn040172

Tech Republic is getting full of people like him.

I think TR should implement a new system where the users can vote comments to be stricken from the record.

by michael l hereid sr

How about this question - how did you get each version? Did you get each version off individual dvd's or what.
Also you say you need a 3 ghz cpu then how come I can run it on a AMD XP2800+(1.8ghz)or you say 100 g hd-I'm using a 40g hd-you say 1 gig of memory - I'm using on one of my test pc's 512m and it runs just fine.

Mike

by gsaravin9

I have various friends & i got it directly of a server.You can run it on it's own fine no one said you can't run it at all .we said when you have other software running as well that's when you have hiccups.I would recommend at least 80 to 100 gig as 40 gig is very low on the spectrum.When running vista with other software i found problems galore.If you were just running vista on it's own that should work .I even found different combinations of hardware did not work well with vista either not installing or hdd not being recognised at all.ther problems of compatiblity
of bios etc was present.
i hope that answers your question.
ta Mick

by michael l hereid sr

2001- a lot of people could not install XP unless they updated their BIOS and a lot of hardware would not either, there are litterally millions of differant hardware-MS can not be expected to write drivers for these-the manufacturers have to write them if they don't -MS can not do anything about that.
I do have other software running and as I said it works great here in both 32 bit and 64.
Mike

by gsaravin9

again no one said you can't run it on 512 meg & no one said you can't run it on 2800 amd.
what was intended to say you would do better with 1
gig ram & 3 gig speed.It would be necessary as you also running other software as well.Why bother just running vista if you are not adding the software.
I hope you got that.
ta Mick

by jmgarvin

Vista is the same ol' same ol' and things like XGL blow DirectX 10 out of the water.

We're going to see a HUGE shift in the efforts vendors make to accomodate MS and their inability to follow standards.

by steve.marshall

People may find it more useful to know what "software" you have been unble to run, rather than being "informed" that no software works...

Are you suggesting that the Office suite wont work, or that a specific VPN client is inoperable under the testing environmentyou work under...

Is the performance of CADCam on a system with less than 12gig of ram unresponsive ? Or does it simply not install...

Suggesting that "software" simply doesnt work or gives poor performance is about as much use as being informed that "a car tested in a controlled environment and will make 12 miles/gallon"... something that in the real world just never transpires...

To refer back to your repeated issues with Hardware, again, specifics would be useful, although this is a vendor related issue and not a fainling of Vista (As I have mentioned before). Prior to it going to release the vendors will supply MS with their driver sets, you will find rudimentary compatibility only with most vendors during BETA as there is simply no point in asking a vendor to write a driver database for a system still in development as their requirements may change continually. It's MS's responsibility to indicate the pipeline requirements and specifications NOT to provide hardware compatability and connectivity.

Anyway... to summarise, add more related content to your posts and you will be taken more seriously !

by gsaravin9

I have to agree that perhaps i could've supplied
specific details.I thought simply commenting was enough & i can see that it puts some people off as they need something tangible.I suppose i owe you an apology for that.I just thought people would be bored stiff if i got all technical.Steve i see where you are coming from ok & i'm sorry to let you down & the tech republic team.I think i learned a valuable lesson in that you have to back up your argument with specifics otherwise people will think of you as an idiot & not take you seriously!
thanks Steve
ta Mick
ta mick

by gsaravin9

I have to apologise to you nice folk as i have not added much specfic details to my statements.In my
wisdom & rushing around i thought that you guys are interested in just opinions.Yes you are but you would like to see specific details.After all this time it has taken to click in the old brain I'm so sorry will you forgive me.Also despite what i've said about vista i hope MS pulls it through,don't you think that it deserves to make it after all the hardship?.I think it deserves to do well & i wish Ms well & i'm genuinely sorry that i called vista crap will you all forgive me.
also good to meet so many technical people who have a genuine desire for IT you know who you are.Also that George Ou is simply amazing isn't he?
thanks
Mick
ta mick

by drossi

Hey Everyone

Not trying to start World War III on here or provoke it any further as i normally don't reply to these things but guys come on its a beta! - thats why its buggy! - i've said it and everyone else has said it here.

XP and every other operating system that has been released was the same when it was a beta, If it wasnt id be very scared! as for why alot of programs at the moment don't work on it - well like i said and everyone else on here has said its a beta!, how can programmers make viable working programs if the operating system it has to run on isnt "finished" yet? Also how can hadware developers make fully working drivers for their equipment if the operating system is still evolving in front of them?

Every few years they make a new OS that requires newer/faster hardware to drive people to spend more money to get newer machines in order to run it. If they didnt do that then why would people want to buy new machines if what they got is lightning fast and rock solid? then sales of hardware would drop and all the computer related companies out there wouldnt be making half the amount of money that they do right now.

Like anything if you have your doubts, keep with your windows xp system for a minimum of 12 months after vista comes out so that anything critical that has been found by customers/security firms has been fixed and then you should have a better experience with the operating system. Or if you are really picky wait a few years till microsoft release a service pack!

What i find absolutely hilarious is i have met alot of people in real life that say XP is the biggest load of crap and everything else they can think of but at the end of the day Guess what they are running - you guessed it! Windows XP! As far as im concerned, if you dont like XP keep your thoughts to yourself or do what some people do and switch to a Mac or run Linux and be done with it.

As it has been said before on here 99% of all software out there is written for a microsoft based system so unless a viable alternative comes out then you are just going to have to put up with whats on offer. If you think you can do microsofts employees jobs better then maybe you should be employed by them.

Also there is nothing worse when i have to deal with people that jump on the i hate this an that OS bandwagon when they haven't even used it or can prove what they say to be true.

I apologise if this offends anyone as that is not my intentions in any way shape or form i am just expressing to the public (and ranting i suppose) what i feel and what i have to deal with nearly everyday at my workplace! you can only take soo much!!! I am not trying to insult anyones intelligence or anything like that either i am just expressing myself....

by gsaravin9

are just frustrated that we are literally taken for a ride.As consumers of be it hardware or software including operating systems do not perform the way we expect.Also the products become obsolete so quickly. i agree that some of us will hold on to our existing systems for a while.you don't need to apologise you are simply expressing yourself.
By the way who do you prefer out of the chip makers
amd or intel & why please explain.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

when i have been right.The first reference paint's a rosy picture of vista as much better than xp.But i would question what software have they run to test vista to give them that result??
You can run the operating system fine but until you load a particular software you may never know.
Also on the issue of drivers there's hardly any around
also theres no mention of 64 bit at alll.
The other reference is an it forum basically anything happens & they can just about say anything on vista.
Ta Mick

by gsaravin9

have you tested any of the dual core chips what's you opinion.I don't think they are cracked up to be.
ta mick

by hal 9000

Most of the people that I do work for ignored it completely and went from 98SE to XP and even then waited a while before they switched to XP.

Y2K and ME where probably the most Ill [b]Fated MS Products Ever.[/b] And while XP had problems when its first production version hit the streets it was a relatively easy workaround for me at least. I still have one company using a Volume License copy of the Original XP though to be fair they didn't take it up till it had been available for quite some time and if they had of waited a bit longer they would have got the SP1 version.

Col

by rkuhn040172

It is pretty much a universal feeling that Windows 2000 was solid, stable, reliable, etc.

Most of the needed features of XP without the eye candy and bloat.

Compared to 98 or ME, 2000 was great. 98 was good to a degree, but in a business environment, 2000 was better.

by gsaravin9

people are still on win2000 & they swear by it.They say how stable it is even if they are given a free
copy of xp they will not change.Theres less things that can go wrong.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

I remember when i installed beta 2000 it would notrecognise my lexmark printer & also it did not have
signing.i remember it was brand new just released
& lexmark did not have win 2000 drivers & i had to use win 95 drivers i ended up going back to win 98
instead.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

you would expect drivers to be readilyavailable it's like
bringing the cart after the horse has bolted.I think one get's frustrated when the operating system will not work properly.No one seems to care whether it be the manufacturer or the maker of the operating software.THey probably care only asbout the$.
ta mick

by rkuhn040172

"No one seems to care whether it be the manufacturer or the maker of the operating software"

Same can be said about Linux driver issues.

To me, that is the most frustrating thing about Linux...less so nowadays but certaintly a huge ploblem in the past.

Driver support is/was awful.

But like you said, "No one seems to care whether it be the manufacturer or the maker of the operating software".

Therefore, for me at least, until recently, Linux was not an option.

by hal 9000

While it doesn't matter who is at fault it's always the Maker of the OS that gets the blame. In todays world that's mostly MS so if you buy something it should just plug in and virtually work. Many people don't even want to install drivers so it works properly and then complain that the New piece of Hardware doesn't work with that OS be it Windows, OS X, Linux, BSD or whatever.

I suppose that is the cross that IT people have to bear at one place the people paid a small fortune for some Garman GPS Software for Europe and they where complaining like hell when they plugged in the Memory Card that it was blank. When I got there they had a Card Reader the Memory Card and Destruction manual but they somehow misplaced the CD, well actually they hadn't taken it out of the box that everything came in and thrown the box out when I retrieved it from the rubbish I loaded the European Map on the Memory card then easily inserted the Memory card and it worked a treat. The only problem was that by that stage the person in question had decided that it didn't work so he had to try it out and insisted that it wasn't working because it would only give him a distance from Brisbane AU to Madrid Spain with no route to travel to drive there. I just asked him how he planed to drive out of AU onto the Sub Content so he could continue to drive to Madrid it then struck him that he was asking the unit an impossible question but it took about 30 minutes of him complaining that it wasn't working properly before he shut up long enough so that I could ask the proper questions so he understood why it couldn't give him the directions that he wanted. :D

He did the same thing with an I Pod which came up as External Storage so to him it was working even if it didn't play he songs that he had saved onto his XP computer. :)

Col

by drossi

what really is frustrating is you can go out and buy the best of the best right now and find that in 3 days time it is superseded!!!! just unfortunate we live in a world where it is a big rush job in making the hardware and then we have to download firmware updates or software updates every 5 minutes just to get the item to do what it was advertised to do!!!!

by gsaravin9

i was planning to upgrade but i sttalled until now waiting for chips to improve in speed.Amd describes its dual core chips as 4600 & it's not 4.6 gig speed real clock speed is 2.4 gig they said it operates better than a 3.2 gig dual core
intel.Also previously you bought a 2.8 gig amd xp
or sempron they operate at 1.6-1.8 gig.
if you upgraded now which would you choose.
ta mick

by drossi

I used to be a AMD "Fanboy" lol but id go back to intel seeing they have faster FSB more cache etc etc

by gsaravin9

col i agreewith you entirely you vividly paint a true picture of what's going on.On a different
topic related to the full moon jus announced that pluto is no longer classified as a planet.If pluto was circling around the earth,what would you call it as it's not a moon !
I can see allready i'm growing a beard.
ta mick

by hal 9000

You don't have the compatibility issues that you get with some AMD M'Boards that will just plain & simple not work with some Video Cards.

Compatibility issues with M'Boards made for AMD CPU's are a real Minefield to wade through. A nightmare if you are building them to suit your needs rather than buying an [b]Off the Shelf[/b] system that you have to modify the way you work to make it work properly.

Col

by gsaravin9

as intels are at a higher levels.Do you go for a particular motherboard & graphics card or due you just settle whatever is available??
ta mick

by hal 9000

But I never use the [b]All in One M'Boards[/b] Ever as the Systems are not much cheaper a lot slower and less reliable once the graphic chip goes you can not generally speaking get into the BIOS and disable it so unless you have already disabled the On Board Video your stuck with a dead M'Board. This will also happen if you flash the BIOS as it will default back to Factory Standard and lock you out again.

As for the Celeron's even Intel at the Chanel Partners Meetings doesn't talk about these and at one Channel Partner Meeting that I went to when someone asked about the Celeron's the Presenter just said [b]We don't talk about those.[/b] Personally I don't like them either as the limited amount of Cache on the chip doesn't make up for the difference in performance when every thing is considered and the money saved is negligible in comparison to the slower performance. If you use a Celeron on an All in 1 M'Board you are getting the worst possible of everything available.

I tend to use a lot of the ATI Video Cards personal Preference maybe but from previous experience they seem to work better for the people that I make computers for. Now it comes down to the interesting bits whenever I make an AMD unit on special Order they specify the basic hardware that they want and quite often the Video Card will not work with the M'Board. This gets quite annoying when it's the same company who is making both units like A Bit with some of their AMD M'Boards their ATI Video Cards will not work actually what happens is that the computer fails to start you hit the on switch and besides the lights & Fans coming on nothing happens. Lately I've only been using the 256 MEG Video cards or bigger depending on the work that the workstation is going to do but even with some 1 Gig Video Cards I've had the same problem. My main Wholesale Supplier has several different brands available so I have a range to chose from something like 5 Brands of M'Board and 7 Video Card Makers. So far I've always been able to get a working system but what's frustrating is the fact that one brand of Video Card will not work on an AMD M'Board while another that is the same Chip Set will.

That is something that I've yet to have with an Intel Chip Set M'Board and it may be a non issue when and if AMD buys out ATI to be the main maker of chip Sets for M'Boards for AMD CPU's just at the moment with all the different Chip Set Makers around it makes things hard particularly when you are using things close to the Top of the Range and they don't work together.

Actually I do us some all in one M'Boards but these are only for Custom Built NB and here you really don't have much choice available there are only a limited number of available Chassis that you can chose from so you pick the one that best suits your needs at the time but even here these have their own dedicated Video Ram installed and although this may be limited to 64 MEG it gives you decent performance and then install the required CPU. RAM, HDD and any Optical drives that are required but on the last I tend to use Dual Layer DVD Burners as they don't cost much more and give a far more versatile NB when it's all said and done.

Col