Discussion Locked

vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)

0 helpful
1,924 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 5 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,924 replies

by hal 9000

I've used about 5,000 Intel Dual Cores 300 Intel Dual Cores with HTT and I think 4 AMD Dual Cores.

Yes I know I mostly use Intel CPU's as thats what the customer requires in the area that I work. The Dual Core Intel's work a treat on Windows XP Pro as do the AMD's I actually built one for my son to play games on and as an idea of it's performance Ripping a DVD takes about 28 minutes as apposed to over an hour on a P4 3.2 GHZ both have 2 GIG of RAM and are on similar spec M'Boards.

Of the Dual Core with HTT I haven't used as many of these mainly because Windows XP doesn't support the 4 Threads and every one of these has gone into a Nix Box for Graphic processing they really rock and push Linux along quite nicely. The jobs that where taking days to render can now be finished generally speaking within 1 day or slightly more depending on the particular job that is being done. Most of these have gone into a CG environment so they get a lot of heavy use.

The Dual Core AMD's that I've used have all been for Home Development machines where the people involved wanted the higher processing power without breaking the bank and they have all been difficult builds mainly because of Video Card incompatibles, but once you get parts that work together they work fine.

Although from experience any Dual Core isn't anywhere near as good a a Dual Processor System they are slightly slower but a Lot cheaper so I suppose it depends on what you want from a system as to how you rate them.

Currently when I get the time I'm putting together a Dual Xeon 3.2 for myself with 2 GIG of RAM per CPU but I've been trying to finish the assembly since November last year and every time that I try to get down and bolt it together something urgent crops up so it gets left behind in the rush to do some paying work. :D

Col

by gsaravin9

to see what experience people have had whether it's better to upgrade now with dual core or wait for the quad core or something else to come up.What do you think i recon something is going to come up that will be a quantum leap on the rest! you could be left behind & do your dough!You know i know these people & they are the cheapest around check them out
msy technology.com they are the cheapest in parts!
ta mick

by hal 9000

With the current Dual Cores without HTT XP Pro will run them to 100% capacity but if you use a Dual Core with HTT XP will still only see 2 Cores not the 4 data streams so you are buying more hardware than is necessary for the Software available. To get best usage of these new Multi Core CPU's you need to either use one of the Nix's or go with a MS Server product as none of MS's current OS will support anything better than a Dual Core or a Single Core with HTT.

The current Vista Enterprise does the same but this may change as the hardware is now becoming more available and MS needs to keep up with the available Hardware so that could very well be part of the reason why things on Vista have been put back again.

It all depends on how MS is going to define a CPU. Is that 1 Core or 1 Core that Supports HTT or 2 Cores, or 2 Cores that Support HTT and so on as things get bigger and better. Currently the Hardware Makers are leaving MS behind as they seem unable to keep up with the pace of change. But that would be a very good reason to put back Vista again to rewrite the code for these Multi Core CPU's that are now so freely available.

Currently the Quad Core will only work with a MS Server product and something like 2003 isn't ideally suited for the desktop so a Dual Core with HTT or a Quad Core will not be used to it full capacity. The best current option is a Dual Core without HTT as that works quite well with XP Pro and Vista at it's current Beta stage but that could change very quickly in a short time.

The current Pentium Extremes or the AMD Equivalent could be the next hottest thing available if Vista supports 4 Data Streams or even a Quad Core without HTT when they eventually hit the markets. But at the moment they are not available so it really depends on what you need to do.

About 2 years ago I suggested to someone who asked should they buy a computer now or wait for Longhorn to become available I said buy now as Longhorn will not be around for a long time and I was hauled over the coals because I was being [b]flippant.[/b] :D

But from what he had read in the Mags he thought that Longhorn would be out within 6 months and nothing that anyone could say to him would make him think otherwise and that was back when [b]WinFS[/b] was supposed to be an integral part of what is now known as Vista. Maybe he's still waiting to buy a Vista computer but I personally think that he would have bit the bullet a long time ago now and brought something new. :^0

Col

by hal 9000

As it's much more a [b]Server[/b] platform as MS will tell you to a great degree. I'll be multi Booting it and running several different OS's on it one of which will be Windows but that will only work with Half the available Computing capacity as it will only see 2 Data Streams or 2 CPU's if you like and these are 2 CPU's that support HTT so there are effectively 4 Data Streams available for use. Maybe I brought the wrong M'Board as the one I got doesn't support SATA Drives just IDE & SCSI but at this point in time I can't see any major difference between one of the faster IDE and SATA drives in Real Time but maybe that's changing as with 6 SATA Drives you could maybe setup a decent RAID configuration but as the M'Board will support 30 High Speed SCSI Drives straight from the On Board Controller That's what I wanted as they are much faster than either the IDE or SATA drives that are available and with a Plug In card can be configured as a RAID if required. The down side is that the SCSI Drives are smaller and much more expensive than the available SATA Drives. Actually the entire thing is expensive as nothing about it is cheap but I've been using Dual Processor M'Boards since the Pentium Days and even the occasional Quad Processor setup and they have the advantage of not having all the cores on one chip so heat isn't so much of a problem but even these things do run hot and standard they have massive Heat Sinks fitted. I naturally have gone with better & Bigger Heat Sinks so they are big and both have 2 80 MM Fans on them to blow air through the Heat Sink to shed as much heat as possible. They add a lot of weight to the M'Board and it's safer to carry the M'Board with the CPU's and Heat Sinks around by one of the Heat Sinks or you run the risk of breaking the M'Board because of the weight of he Heat Sinks.

Col

by rkuhn040172

First off, I see you as number 73 not 2.

Second, congrats on accomplishing absolutely nothing.

It is clear that you have added nothing meaningful to this conversation and most would suspect that you had started out in a quest only to increase your rank and not have a meaningful discussion.

To that end, you have been successful...at nothing.

by gsaravin9

I'm true to my word I have merely displayed news items for comment.What i have found that if I reply to someone else's comment people try to pick the eyes out of it & take it out of context.The news items are about vista & are pertinent!.AS to the number of replies. I'll do my best it's not my fault
people are replying is it?I'm finding that things are taken out of context.For example Mike snr quotes me one guy saying nice things about Vista then i quote to him another quote where the person negates it .Then i get someone like march red responding
I don't even know him.
So there you have it i mean no disrespect to anyone all i want is a healthy discussion steve over to you.We have to reach 500.!
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

Tech testers and some technet testers have recieved an interm build of Vista plus in the next 2 weeks they will be releasing RC1. So I still think your wrong.
Mike

by gsaravin9

is biased towards intel & some towards amd i don't know the whole kit & kabbotle of reputable websites!
i aLLREADY USE TOMSHARDWARE.
TA MICK

by mavmin2

I have heard this similar comment about every version of Windows since 3.0. Yet, it always seems that one man's crap is another man's main course as I fullly expect to read many other raving testimonials to VISTA's glory. In the end, we shall all migrate to it and wait to revile and praise the next version. In the Army, we had a saying that a bitching soldier is a happy soldier. Methinks that can be modified to a bitching SYSADMIN is a happy SYSADMIN. ;-)

by gsaravin9

again. What does it matter we'll cop it in january 07.Regards your army thing you are 110% right that's so true the more bitchin the more happier uou are!
ta mick

by gsaravin9

video editing some people are saying that amd dual core 4600is the same as intel 3.2 gig dual
core performance??
tamick

by gsaravin9

i di d not say what i am that's not my question i merely said that col is no 2 ,but if you want quote my number 73 then i'm in the top 100 & youre not.Rickk i don't know of your accomplishment at tech republic,if you have any then i'll beleive it.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

i di d not say what i am that's not my question i merely said that col is no 2 ,but if you want quote my number 73 then i'm in the top 100 & youre not.Rickk i don't know of your accomplishment at tech republic,if you have any then i'll beleive it.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

Businesses are holding off on buying PCs and servers because they're waiting for Vista, Caughey said, referring to Microsoft's newest version of its Windows operating system. She expects corporate spending on PCs to rebound once Vista is released later this year.If it is released at all???
ta mick

by gsaravin9

Amazon.com Reveals Windows Vista Prices

By ALLISON LINN
AP Business Writer
Last Updated:August 29. 2006 7:25PM
Published: August 29. 2006 7:25PM

SEATTLE

Article Tools
Print

E-Mail Article

Bookmark

Discuss

Microsoft Corp. will charge $239 for the version of the Windows Vista operating system it hopes most consumers will buy, according to prices listed on Internet retailer Amazon.com's Web site.

Amazon.com, which has begun taking pre-orders for Vista, also reveals list prices for two other versions. Those prices will be similar to what Microsoft currently charges for comparable versions of Windows XP, the current system.

According to Amazon.com's Web site, the version of Vista geared toward work use, Windows Vista Business, will cost $299, similar to the price for Windows XP Professional. The consumer version, Windows Vista Home Basic, will cost $199, the same as Windows XP Home.

But Microsoft is hoping most consumers will embrace Windows Vista Premium, which offers entertainment capabilities such as the ability to record live television. That version is listed at $239. Similar functionality is available in the Media Center edition of Windows XP, but that is only available pre-loaded onto a computer, so comparable pricing is not available.

The company also is hoping to sell consumers on another version of Vista, called Ultimate. That version, geared toward home users who also want to do some work from the family den, is listed for $399 on Amazon.com's Web site.

The prices listed on Amazon.com's Web site are for those users who choose to buy the operating system on its own. Many consumers, however, buy Windows as part of a new computer purchase.

It's also generally cheaper to upgrade a machine from the current version of Windows to the new one. Amazon.com is selling the upgrade to Windows Vista Home Premium for $159, and the upgrade to Home Basic for $99.95.

Microsoft declined comment on the prices. Kevin Kutz, a director in Microsoft's Windows client unit, said the company will officially make prices public when it releases a near-final test version, called release candidate 1, which is expected by the end of September.

Amazon.com spokesman Sean Sundwall said the Seattle-based online retailer posted the listings and began taking pre-orders two or three weeks ago because consumers were asking for that option. He said the prices are from the latest price sheet that Microsoft provided.

"The one thing we were certain on is the price," Sundwall said.

But Sundwall said Amazon.com can't be certain when Vista will be released. The retailer lists the ship date as Jan. 30, which Sundwall said was an estimate based on Microsoft's public assertions that it plans to release the consumer version of Windows in January.

Kutz said Microsoft is still on track to deliver the much-delayed Vista to big business clients in November and to consumers in January. But he reiterated that the company will not hesitate to delay Vista's release if any problems crop up.

"Quality is the ultimate determinant," he said.

Goldman Sachs analyst Rick Sherlund, who was among the first to note the Amazon.com listings, said in a research note that the prices listed on the Web site, if accurate, could provide some boost to Microsoft's earnings. But he wrote that it was hard to judge exactly how Vista will affect Microsoft's earnings because details such as the exact release date aren't yet clear.

---

by gsaravin9

Apple is already gearing up for a major marketing campaign for the holidays, and if they're able to ramp up demand, and then deliver the system when they say it will be delivered, it could trump Microsoft in a way that Apple's CEO Steve Jobs would crow about for years.

by rkuhn040172

And that's about it.

When all you have is 3% of the market, a better holiday campaign isn't enough.

Apple could do that for the next 10 X-Mas's and it wouldn't matter.

by gsaravin9

Microsoft released a near-final version of its Internet Explorer 7 browser on Thursday, and the company said the free Web-surfing software is on track for completion by the end of the year.

Internet Explorer 7 Release Candidate 1 contains all the features Microsoft hopes to include in the final product, its first major update for the program in years. Among the bells and whistles is the ability to open multiple "tabs" in the same browser window - a popular function in rival Mozilla's Firefox browser - plus updated security functions.

The near-final release is aimed at industry professionals and tech experts who may help the world's largest software company spot last-minute kinks and bugs.

Microsoft won't say how many people have downloaded previous test versions.

Tony Chor, a group program manager with Internet Explorer, said the company also has not decided whether it would put out one more test version before the final product is released. He said Microsoft is currently planning to make the final version of IE7 broadly available in the last three months of this year, barring any unexpected problems.

IE 7 will be available for download for people using Windows XP, and it will be included in the forthcoming version of Windows, called Vista. After many delays, Vista is currently scheduled to be available for business users in November, and for consumers in January.

by gsaravin9

Microsoft refused to elaborate on the potential discounts. But Michael Silver, research vice partner at analysts Gartner, said it was likely that the scheme would involve consumers who buy PCs before the holidays being given vouchers that will get money off a Vista upgrade when the software is released next year.

Delays to the next generation of Windows, which accounts for 90 per cent of the market, are expected to hit PC and processor manufacturers as consumers delay buying new computers until the latest software is available.

The voucher system would be designed to mitigate those effects but could also hit Microsoft's bottom line.

"It has become pretty clear that Microsoft was going to have to do something to help out retailers and PC manufacturers over the holiday," Mr Silver said.

It is thought the company had pencilled in a retail price of as much as ?400 for the consumer version of Windows, and that an upgrade from a previous version would cost as much ?100.

Consumers can expect to pay less if they buy a new machine that has the operating system pre-loaded.

News of the potential Vista discount comes as rivals predict that high costs associated with migrating from Windows XP to Windows Vista will spur companies to switch to rival systems like Linux.

Novell, which builds applications to work on the open source system, would benefit from such a move.

Widespread migration would hit Microsoft's earnings hard. Combined with Office, the suite of office software, Windows accounts for the lion's share of profits at the world's largest software developer.

Vista discounts could also signal the pressure Microsoft is under to maintain its traditional markets and muscle its way into new ones. Rumours have circulated in recent weeks that Microsoft is considering giving away music tracks in a bid to attract users away from Apple?s iTunes to its own online music store.

Vista has already been more than four years in the making and has been postponed several times amid security concerns. The latest delay came earlier this year when quality problems put back the consumer version until early 2007.

Fears were raised again last month when Microsoft said it was dealing with Vista "milestone by milestone" but refused to give a more detailed timetable.

by gsaravin9

Microsoft's latest announcement gives all 32-bit system owners a good reason for not upgrading to Vista. The company said at TechEd 2006 in Sydney that high-definition protected content would not be supported by the 32-bit versions of Windows Vista.

In other words, people eager to see HD DVD and Blu-ray movies on their computers would have to upgrade to x64 edition of Vista. Needless to say, most of them would also require to upgrade their hardware to 64-bit systems.

According to APC Magazine, Microsoft tried to soften the news by claiming that time will be the miracle cure for the situation and that 64-bit systems would have widespread adoption by the same time the HD DVD and Blu-ray formats would.

However, Microsoft ?forgot? to mention a one more arising issue: x64 editions of Vista will require drivers signed by Microsoft. In order to get Microsoft's signature, every driver must undergo extensive testing, thus leading to a long and costly process for every manufacturer.

This would put Microsoft in a privileged position, as the company can strike preferential deal with some of the manufacturers, leaving other to wait their turn in line, which would prove disastrous for their businesses.

On the other hand, even if Microsoft would work side by side with some developers, there's still a big chance that drivers would arrive on the market later than the public was used to.

As far as the 32-bit versions of Vista were concerned, Microsoft said it would leave them to run unsigned drivers because of application compatibility problems. While customers would get drivers much sooner, unsigned drivers would also allow users to employ software able bypass any copy protection on the discs. In conclusion, Microsoft's decision should be a blow against piracy.

Microsoft stressed out that the restrictions wouldn't apply to HD DVD or Blu-ray in terms of storage capacity, but only to commercially produced movies:

?you could put an MPEG-4 movie on them and play them on a 32bit Vista PC just fine.?

The statement is rather futile. If the next-gen formats are not compatible with 32-bit Vista, why should anyone choose HD DVD or Blu-ray discs as storage when it can use the current-gen (and much cheaper) DVD format?

by gsaravin9

The computing industry's culture is also partly to blame. Firms have long tried to ship products as fast as they possibly can, and they may have set less store by quality. They used to mock the telecoms industry's ethos of ?five-nines??99.999% reliability?because it meant long product cycles. But now they are gradually accepting it as a benchmark. That is partly why Microsoft has taken so long to perfect its new operating system, Windows Vista.

by gsaravin9

It just seems to get worse for for Microsoft on the Windows security front. Now the software company has been forced to create a patch for a patch released earlier this month which has introduced a new critical security vulnerability in Internet Explorer.

The bug in the MS06-042 security update causes Internet Explorer 6 with Service Pack 1 to crash due a buffer overrun if the user visits certain websites. However, Microsoft now admits that flaw is exploitable and could allow an attacker to gain control of a computer if the user visits a website specially designed for that purpose.

To make things worse, Microsoft has got into a public slanging match with security company eEye for disclosing publicly that the MS06-042 security update itself creates an exploitable flaw. eEye has been making a name for itself in recent months by discovering security flaws in the products of large security vendors such as Symantec and McAfee.

According to Microsoft, eEye, which notified Microsoft of the vulnerability in MS06-042, should have stayed quiet until Microsoft had its fix for the patch completely ready for distribution.

However, eEye in its own advisory on its website refutes Microsoft's criticism and accuses Microsoft of originally misrepresenting the vulnerability saying:

"This information is already known in various research circles and also with exploit writers. So it is important that IT administrators understand the true threat of this problem that this is not simply a crashing bug as Microsoft has been incorrectly misrepresenting it but in fact that it is an exploitable security bug. Researchers and exploit developers know this, therefore it is extremely important that IT administrators are told what really is going on."

At last report, Microsoft had still not released a new fix for MS06-042 because it found problems in a fix that was supposed to be released on Tuesday.

The news of the latest bug comes in a month where Microsoft software security has been in the spotlight constantly. The Department of Homeland Security issued an alert highlighting the serious nature of a critical vulnerability in Windows addressed by security update MS06-040 and then Microsoft had to issue a fix for a problem discovered with that patch.

In addition, it was revealed that two of the seven critical bugs revealed by Microsoft in August also affected the Beta 2 version of its upcoming replacement operating system Windows Vista. That news in itself was surprising because Microsoft has put a lot of work into making Vista bullet proof.

by gsaravin9

Extract from Is Windows Vista Ready? by Paul Thurrott

There's been a lot of speculation and opinion about Windows Vista lately. Many claim that Microsoft's next generation operating system isn't ready and can't be made ready in time for the software giant's self-imposed October 2006 Release to Manufacturing (RTM) deadline.

Who are these people? And what are they really worried about?

Some have said that Microsoft should wait until sometime in mid-2007 to ship Vista, because businesses aren't lining up to deploy the new operating system any time soon. Heads up, guys: Businesses have never lined up to install a new Microsoft operating system. They always install new Windows versions gingerly and years after the fact. We're all familiar with the "wait for Service Pack 1 (SP1)" mantra that many enterprises extol.

Others have said that Microsoft should add a Beta 3 release between Beta 2 (which, yes, was lousy) and Release Candidate 1 (RC1), which presumably will ship by late August or early September. But that's just arguing semantics. Who cares what the next milestone is named? What we should worry about is that the next milestone be more representative of the final product than was the previous milestone. Based on my experience with the last two interim builds, that will definitely be the case.

Many beta testers tell me and their fellow testers that Windows Vista isn't ready. But beta testers never think any Windows version is ready: If we left the ship decision to testers, we'd still be testing Windows XP. (OK, that one is an exaggeration, but one with a point behind it. Many beta testers simply like their exclusive little clique to continue as long as possible. Only they, after all, are qualified to determine when Windows is ready.)

And then there are the online pundits, many of whom are barely old enough to legally buy alcohol. These guys are classic. Let's just say that a lack of experience and a strongly worded opinion don't result in the most coherent of arguments and leave it at that.

So what's left?

I can't speak for any of these people, but I do listen to what they have to say. I even agree with some of it. But I've been working with Windows Vista for a long, long time, and I've seen how it's evolved. Heck, I've been working with Microsoft OS betas for over 12 years now, and while it's very clear that Vista hasn't exactly followed a trajectory that's at all similar to any of the other betas, it's also true that each OS beta has its own vibe. We might call Windows Vista a "train wreck" for simplicity's sake. But it's getting better. Seriously.
Is Windows Vista ready?

No. God, no. Today's Windows Vista builds are a study in frustration, and trust me, I use the darn thing day in and day out, and I've seen what happens when you subject yourself to it wholeheartedly. I think I've mentioned the phrase "I could hear the screams" on the SuperSite before. My wife said that to me one day, and she was referring to the sound of me barking some primeval curse at my desktop PC as it succumbed to Vista's stupid slowdowns, crashes, and hang ups for the umpteenth time. She, more than anyone, knows the frustration I've experienced because of Windows Vista. But even she doesn't know the details. They would bore her, frankly. She's normal like that.

Here are some examples. I'm navigating around in Explorer and suddenly realize I need to access a file on a network share. In XP, this is easy as My Network Places is also available from the Task Pane. In Windows Vista, there's no Task Pane, and there's no link to Network in the new Favorite Links pane (though you can, admittedly, add one if you want, or add links to any network shortcuts). So you open Network from the Start Menu and wait ... and wait... and wait... while the damn thing finds all your networked PCs and servers. In XP, this process is instantaneous.

Here's a more insidious one. In Windows Vista Beta 2, Adobe Photoshop Elements 4 would install but issue a warning when you ran it, noting that it was incompatible with Vista. You could ignore the warning and everything worked fine. However, in the subsequent two interim builds, Photoshop Elements 4 has literally gotten worse over time. Now, some key functionality simply doesn't work or, oddly, only partially works. Save for Web, for example, now only saves in GIF format. I have no idea why. But because I use this product every single day, it's impacted me in a big way. It's annoying.

Or take IE 7. Please. I use IE for one thing and one thing only: The magazine's Web portal requires IE to post articles, and because I post WinInfo articles every day, I need to use IE. Every day. In IE 7, the rich edit control that forms the basis of the third party ActiveX control we used to post article bodies not only doesn't work, it is actually deprecated in Vista so that it will never work, even if you manually install it. That means I will have to use an older version of IE, in a virtual machine, to post WinInfo articles for the foreseeable future. Stupid.

And then there's that wonderful "Recent Items" entry on the Start Menu. I can't tell how it decides to cache stuff, but I can tell that it does not--ever--list the actual documents I most recently use. It's infuriating.

And why does the screen have to "pop" so violently when it switches between Aero and Windows Standard ("Windows Stupid," as I've grown to call it) because I need to run an application that, for some reason, won't let Aero continue running? (That application, by the way, is Virtual PC, which is required because of the IE issue mentioned previously. Auuuuugghhhhhh! It's a re-entrant annoyance!)

Why did I just waste four years making nice album art for music folders and custom folder art for photos? Microsoft changed folders completely in Windows Vista, and all that work just got flushed down the virtual toilet. (Microsoft calls this toilet the "Recycle Bin " as opposed to Apple's toilet, which was called "Mac OS 9.")

I like the way the Start Menu complains about no email application being set as the default every time I use the Search Box. I also like the way my machines jump to the logon screen every ten minutes despite the fact that I've configured Power Management not to do that. I especially like the way I can't delete certain items from the desktop (randomly, it seems, like a game) unless I either reboot my machine or manually crash Explorer.exe. But my favorite Windows Vista behavior--and believe you me, this was a tough contest--has to be the weird COM object errors I get while cutting and pasting between Paint and Word 2007. (And yes, frankly, this could be an Office 2007 bug. But let's face it, Office 2007 and Vista are "Better Together" as Microsoft likes to point out.)

Let's recap. Paul uses Vista every day as his only OS on each of his desktop and notebook machines. Paul has begun screaming a lot and it's not because he's taken up an anger management form of yoga. (That's what Kabbalah really is, right?) Why is Paul now referring to himself in the third person? I can't remember.
Will Vista be ready in time?

Honestly, who cares? After five years of delays, another six months isn't going to make a difference. But just for the sake of argument, let's say I have a stake in this and am being forced to render an opinion about Vista's ship readiness for October. Will it be ready in time?

Actually, I think it could be. I think that Microsoft will actually make this date, and as I write these words I'm acutely aware that Microsoft will announce another delay within minutes of its publication if only to discredit me. I can live with that because, as I said, I don't really care. It's just an opinion. Everyone has one.

Do I think that Microsoft will finalize Windows Vista by the end of October 25? Yes, but I also believe they will release a massive series of patches between October 2006 and January 2007 if they do arbitrarily hit their latest release promise because of issues that crop up after Vista gets shipped out to all those businesses that won't be installing it anyway. (Which brings me to a side issue: Why ship Vista to enterprises with volume license agreements before shipping it to consumers? Businesses are not going to install Vista anyway. Why waste the effort?)

Windows Vista is huge and complex and a major change from Windows XP despite some high-level similarities between the two operating systems. Users are going to freak when their hardware and software doesn't work right. They're going to lose it when they can't do things that were easy in XP but impossible in Vista. On the other hand, some things have improved enough to trigger instantaneous smiles. Microsoft should ship Vista when those smiles outnumber the screams. It's simple math. Even a Pentium could do it correctly.
The real question: When will Microsoft figure out what's important?

Here's the thing. Microsoft was fooled into announcing a ship date because it felt that its customers were losing faith in the company's ability to deliver. What Microsoft didn't realize is that the way to win back customers' hearts isn't to make bold proclamations; it's to actually do the right thing. (Reference: The Bush administration.)

In other words, Microsoft should have simply pulled an Id Software and said they'd ship Windows Vista when it was ready. Period. They should have then begun actively educating people about all the wonderful stuff they've released between Windows XP and Windows Vista and pointed out that all those wonderful freebies (which naturally require Windows Genuine Advantage) are still coming as we speak. And look, can't you see how Vista is getting better and better with each beta milestone?

I don't know how long Microsoft will need to finalize Windows Vista. Ultimately, I just want them to get it right. But if that means January, May, or even August 2007, so be it. But really, who cares what I think? At the end of the day, I'm just an online pundit/beta tester who likes technology a bit more than is healthy. And I really need to work on the screaming.

ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

this is what he wrote as a conclusion
Conclusions
There's no doubt about it: Windows Vista has taken too long to ship, and the first major milestone that Microsoft shipped to the public, Beta 2, was a disappointment. Since then, the company has shipped three promising interim builds to testers. The latest one, build 5536, an RC1 escrow build, is simply wonderful. If this build represents the quality, performance, and functionality that users can expect to see in RC1 and the final release, then Microsoft will have gone a long way towards making up for its mistakes and miscalculations. My only question is why we had to wait so long to see a build this good. If you can get your hands on 5536, enjoy it. If not, RC1 will be publicly available. Either way, you likely won't be disappointed.

--Paul Thurrott
August 25-26, 2006

by gsaravin9

extract from ohmey technology news
Next year will be very special for computer users because Microsoft will release a new operating system called Windows Vista.

Windows Vista will be the latest version of Microsoft Windows. It can be used in desktops, laptops and media centers.

Microsoft has said that it will introduce the business version of Vista in Nov. 2007 and the consumer version in Jan.

Five years after the successful release of Windows XP, Microsoft is adding hundreds of new features to Windows Vista. Vista will be helpful in file sharing, password setting and other areas.

To make Vista secure from viruses, Microsoft has held discussions with more than 300 experts in the Information Technology sector.

Even people who aren't very technological like their computers to look pretty. The interface of Vista is named Windows Aero and is supposed to be more visually attractive than XP.

According to Microsoft, Windows Vista will have an expanded search capacity. The sidebar will follow the same format as that used on Apple Computers. Internet Explorer 7 and Windows Media Player II can also be used in Vista.

The new operating system will also have Windows Mail, which will please everyone who hates Outlook Express.

In a move that brings Star Trek to mind there will also be speech recognition software. This will allow the computer to recognize the voices of the users and follow commands!

Citizen reporters and other writers will be happy to hear that more fonts are available in Vista than in XP Windows. Budding filmmakers will be over the moon with the Windows DVD maker.

There are two categories to run Vista. One is "Vista Capable" and the other is "Vista Premium Ready." Both categories need different hardware capacities.

For Vista Capable, 800 MHz Processor and 512 MB RAM is needed whereas for Vista Premium Ready 1 GHz processor and 1 GB RAM is needed.

However, IT researchers claimed that there are some weaknesses in Vista. They say that Vista and the Mac OS X operation system for Apple computers are the same. They also say that the codes used for the manufacture of Vista aren't strong.

The reviewers criticize Vista, saying that Microsoft is not giving enough attention to digital content management and user account control.

There are five months until the product launches. Let's hope that will be enough time to solve these problems.

by marchred

I've seen a lot of comments in this thread from you gsaravin (mostly cut 'n' paste), but very little substance to support this assertion.

Most organisations strive to be on the leading, rather than bleeding, edge of technology and hence IT Managers use fora such as Techrepublic to assess what is the future direction they may wish to consider heading, based on the actual expereinces of other IT professionals. Unsupported diatribes are of no assistance whatsoever and only flag a particular poster as someone whose comments are to be skipped.

I found the comments posted by mypl8s4u2 (on 07/05/06) to be very useful - factual and documenting actual experiences encountered. You may care to take time to read it and learn what people seek in here.

You may have provided some evidence in subsequent posts, gsaravin, but frankly I have neither the time nor interest in wading through the seaweed to get to the clear water.

by gsaravin9

for you but for mike snr as he sent me a quote to say how i was wrong that vista will come good when the whole question is A BIG IF .You have taken it out of context.It was more for info only .We don't know each other so how can you respond to it.I have provided info to adnauseum that vista has got fundamental source code problems & i have info from ms to prove it.You can agree to disagree.
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

You have never given any proof of what you say you qoute many times that you have been in IT for 29 years-your getting a PHD in computers but that is all you say, Oh you do day that Vista is crap but give no proof. You give other peoples opinions as proof but usually you put on is something that agrees with your opinion no matter is it several months out of date.
Mike

by gsaravin9

August 21, 2006 9:55AM

"I have been testing Microsoft operating systems since Windows 95, and this is the buggiest OS I've seen this late in development," says Joe Wilcox, an analyst with Jupiter Research. "Look at the older operating systems, and by Beta 2 there is a stable foundation on which the [independent software vendors] can build. Right now, Vista is like a ship on stormy seas."
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

which by the way beats Vista all to hxxx on being buggy. During beta 2 of XP it was in about the same state as Vista is now. Even RC1 of XP had bugs and needed them fixed before going to RC2-at RC2 only a few minor bugs. Which I think will happen in Vista.
Mike

by gsaravin9

August 21, 2006 9:55AM

A survey of 207 companies released by Jupiter Research last week shows that nearly 50% of these 100-plus-employee outfits will wait at least 13 months after release to deploy Vista -- or won't deploy it at all.

Microsoft's traditional advocates also are questioning the viability of the software and its release schedule. Robert McLaws, a popular blogger and a Microsoft MVP (non-employees who offer expert analysis on products), said in his blog entry titled "The entry I didn't want to write," "Beta 2 was a disappointment on many levels. It was nowhere near as stable as it should have been." McLaws says pushing the launch back four to six weeks with a release in February, adding another beta cycle and coming clean publicly with the new delay may be the best solution for producing "the best version of Windows ever."
He wasn't the only one with stern advice for Microsoft. Former Microsoft blogger advocate Robert Scoble used his blog to say, "This sucker is just not ready It feels like it needs a good six more months, . . . which would mean a mid-year release next year."(ha ha says mick)

After five years between major client operating system releases, Microsoft needs a home run, experts say.

"It's ready when it's ready, but it better be good when it's ready or there'll be hell to pay," says Tom Henderson, principal researcher for ExtremeLabs and a member of the Network World Lab Alliance. He says there are a lot of issues with the code floating around among testers.My sentiments Mick!

Others see additional red flags.

"Put the testing aside, I can't find a valid antivirus software that works with it," says Michael Cherry, an analyst with research firm Directions on Microsoft. "That is a key application and runs at a core level. If the antivirus vendors, who work closely with Microsoft, can't get Vista working, then the core is not stable."My sentiments exactly Mick!

Cherry says it might be time to reset expectations because an operating system no longer should be a groundbreaking piece of technology.

"I am impressed with Apple OS and I like the way over the last couple of releases they have made a series of incremental improvements. It has not been earth-shattering," he says.
Their words not mine! I don.t want to say i told you so!
ta Mick

by todd

Vista is still in BETA stage..... because its full of code that wont be in the final release, it crashes cause again BETA STAGE, drivers are also in BETA STAGE, have a look at beta releases of XP... same deal... not quite to this extent but thats to be expected. Considering Intel and AMD constantly try to get fast speeds from cpu's, and Nvidia and ATI release cards that have phenominal processing speeds, why should vista be called 'crap' cause it utilises the hardware? Im not a MS fanboy, but give vista a chance, at least to get to the release stage.

by gsaravin9

Vista as it stands is crap because it as an operating
system where there is hardly any drivers at the moment & there is confusion as to whether any will be supplied.Comments from MS being made that they will not rigorisly test any drivers for anyone.THe manufacturers have not provided any & have not made plans to do so.That's why i will not change to vista
next year.Also there are huge compatibility issues
The other matter i have heard from people within ms that they are having continuous source code
problems both in the betas & theymay continue when If released should cause major concern.No one in their right mind would contemplate releasing an operating system with major faults.
MS has simply brushed asside these problems & is still going ahead despite stability warnings.
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

The only problems I have had with Vista are performance problems-which by the way I report to MS.
The latest build (which by the way is 2 builds after Beta2) I have is very good on performance-stability and like I said I at this time only see minor performance problems.
Mike

by todd

Vista is still in BETA stage..... because its full of code that wont be in the final release, it crashes cause again BETA STAGE, drivers are also in BETA STAGE, have a look at beta releases of XP... same deal... not quite to this extent but thats to be expected. Considering Intel and AMD constantly try to get fast speeds from cpu's, and Nvidia and ATI release cards that have phenominal processing speeds, why should vista be called 'crap' cause it utilises the hardware? Im not a MS fanboy, but give vista a chance, at least to get to the release stage.

by gsaravin9

i mean that the same law of gigo garbage in garbage out applies to ms as it does to everyone else.WE as consumers base our expectations on the past & we hope that ms delivers on the promises as i for one will not easily part with my money.Whils't ms has a virtual monopoly on windows software there will be other players like mac or even google getting in on the act.What's needed is some more healthy competition.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

steal your thunder.Whils't he has a point to make IF
Vista comesout like it should then it would more than make up for the shortfall.But it is a BIG IF.But what is mentioned more of the functionality of vista but what is ommitted is the ongoing problems with the source code.
so all is not so rosy.
ta mick

by steve.marshall

Gsaravin, now I know that all of your previous claims of having some intellect, experience and maturity is complete and utter rubbish...

I had actually taken your earlier apology at face value and thought to give you the opportunity to redeem yourself, instead, you claim some kind of superiority for being able to post x number of comments with absolutely no value, no content and certainly totally out of context and think this makes you special ???

I'm disapointed but not suprised.

OK... I agree... Your special... very special..........

Think about what your boasting about, are you so insigificant in life, your career and your personal environment that you get a kick from a high post count?

This is not an insult, its a question, and can only be viewed as an insult if its true (as we all know the truth hurts right ?)

TAKE A SECOND AND THINK ABOUT WHAT YOU POST, PLEASE !!!

by gsaravin9

I think the ultimate stranglehold on the software market will only be the test of time, you also have google throwing their hat into the operating software ring.
ta mick

by mark

Then don't buy it when it's released. I would think someone with a "masters in computer science" would be able to write a cogent, factual statement as opposed to "Well, I just don't like it nyaaa nyaaa nyaaa..."

by gsaravin9

If you bother to read ALL i have written you will see
that i'm qualified in Masters in computing plus I'm a PHD in the field of operating systems. My experience in IT has been 30 years.I was playing with punch cards when you were in nappies!.Also you suffer from selective seeing as you fail to understand that vista is totally crap as most of the good things of vista have been canned.Also if vista
ever comes out it will be like XP plus bloat.
I have quite a number of contacts at ms that i have known & they say that vista is all washed up as far as an operating system.

ta Dr MICK

by john.madden

Of course, i have to preface this with the fact we are still in Beta. I am a developer trying to rewrite some application code for th Vista.

1. Graphics need some work. Looks great, but I still occasionally get grayed out Dialogs that work fine in XP. This seems to coincide with network activity so this may be a threading problem that they will fix. On rarer occasions the video burps and the machines needs to be rebooted.

2. Network access, like shares and drive mappings appears a tad slow, but I think this is due to debug code in Beta 2. Real performance should be better (hope so).

3. There are some issues with AD - one where the SAM account format, i.e. domain\username logon request is returned with "path not found." This happens if the username is all numeric. Interestingly, is the format is qualified, i.e.
username @ domain, it works fine.

by gsaravin9

My impressions of vista is that it still crashes,& there are still wsource code problems & heaps of bugs.This scenario with ms trying to push it out regardless is going to take a long time for the consumers to accept.
There seems to be a lot of people who simply load the vista op system & say that hey it works while others say it is not working properly.
I say that you have to consider the software that is going to run as well under load.
I may be crazy for saying this but vista is plagued with too many problems & all the good things have been canned so far.
ta Dr Mick

by michael l hereid sr

from the same person you qouted but a newer opinion in fact it was almost a month later. From what he seen in a later build than Beta 2. So from my point of view you are taking things out of context.
Mike

by pell.luke.h

HeHe...
I was running beta 2 on my one-year-old laptop for a month as a test. By the way, its only got a 1.5 Celeron m, was running with 348 mg ram, after 128 was split to graphics and a 40 gig hdd. And, by the way, it ran ok. Driver support was good; in fact all drivers not already part of the system were downloaded in my first windows update!
Of course its still a little shaky, but as everyone else has pointed out, its still only a beta! I see vista as a step forward for Microsoft.

by gsaravin9

the problem is when combining motherboards ,drivers etc with software etc that it causes problems.i did not say it's totally
unusable!
ta mick

by mark

As per usual, you need to get your facts straight before spouting your tripe. I've got you beat by five years in the industry, fella. Unless you're going to post factual information about your observations, it's just YOUR OPINION which is worth exactly what we're paying for it: NOTHING, which, coincidentally, is exactly how much impact you'll have on Microsoft's sales.

Your posts would also tend to indicate that you skipped the English and grammar courses on the way to your alleged degrees.

by gsaravin9

what does a product resseller know when a product is crap!
my qualifications are masters in computing & phd in operating systems!
ta Dr MICK

by mark

I see through great effort you managed once again to throw in a mention of these alleged degreed you claim to have. It's getting a little old. Perhaps if you mention it enough times, it'll actually come true.

How did you get these degrees when you obviously failed English, spelling, and grammar?

What schools granted those degrees? When? These things are verifiable.

What does a reseller know? Obviously quite a lot more than you. I see many systems in varied production environments. The systems I manage are not academic lab toys, they're doing real work.

Your qualifications are dubious at best.

by gsaravin9

I use software that other developers use called klocwork,which perform a detailed source code & design analysis.i can even look at complex situtions involving millions of lines of code.
Also i use Seapine's testtrack pro software ,it allows detailed tracking of any bugs.I also have usedmicrosoft's sourcesafe .As well as automated
checking & verification i can select manual checking
of codeor any software.I also use testtrack pro from seapine which is a cross platform software
which can quickly analyse any source code control integration.
I also use a source code analyser from fortify software is called source code analysis 3.5It allows software developers to identify,priortise,
& resolve any flaws in software applications before the operating system is deployed.There is
a built in structural analiser for finding flaws or definition of a program.
TA Dr MIck

by mark

Explain your testing methods and precisely how you do your "research." Faulty methods produce erroneous results. Back up your claims. And exactly where did you get the source code and how much time did you spend looking at millions of line of it?

Keep telling us about all your degrees. I suggest that you research the the following quote from Hamlet: "The lady doth protest too much, methinks" Whom do you REALLY need to convince you have these degrees, hmmmmm?

by gsaravin9

Unlike you guys there just downloading the software.You only decide on a go no go basis.Where my tools of trade are developer tools.The only reason why i will not divulge my methods & techniques is it can get very boring to quote technical crap.
I use a program called klocwork You can have it all
automated checking source code or any other software goes into detailed source code & design & analysis.It even guides the developer to develop better code.You can even get complicated source code that runs into millions of lines.It allows you to look at code defects etc.Other software i use is the qa wizard from testtrack pro which allows you to detect & manage bugs in any system.
I use a source code analyzer from fortify software called source code analysis 3.5 with this software you can identify & resolve problems before an application is deployed.You can look at the whole structure of a given program & see how it is going.You can use it visual basic 6.0,visuaL C++6.0 & visual studio.I even use microsoft software sourcesafe in checking things.
I hope that satisfies you, I don't do this for everyone you know.
ta Dr Mick

by mark

This line in particular throws your "qualifications" into serious question:

"have recently tried all versions & i'm convinced that there are major problems in the source code."

Well, Duh! Where else would it be? In the CD maybe? Or perhaps it's in the object code? Oh, wait, that's derived from the source code! Maybe this "problem" is in the hard drive! Yes, it must be, because that's where the code is!

Moron.

by mark

By the way, "crap" is spelled with a "c" not a "k."

Time to take your nappie now.

by hal 9000

RC1 was made available last night my time and has already reached it's 100K limit so it's not available to anyone any more.

What's MS playing at only issuing 100,000 copies for testing? It might work well for US people but others don't stand a chance of getting a look in. :(

Col

by michael l hereid sr

They allowed only 100,000 downloads of this to public then took it down- it was on the website-I heard about it from my REAL sources at MS campus. But don't worry you will be able to get RC1 in about a week or so(if they don't hit a snag)since you have TechNet you should see it just about the same time I get it.
By the way build 5536 is pretty good-still needs a little work.
:)
Mike

by hal 9000

I've got a customers Dual Processor system in here that for various reasons needs to be reloaded. Nothing special a P3 650 MHZ unit with a GIG of RAM and [b]XP Will Not Install![/b] However the Beta 2 of Vista installs perfectly without a problem. :^0

Apparently he has upgraded it from 98 to XP Pro and of course the [b]One Upgrade CD[/b] that I have here I couldn't easily find. After about 3 Hours of looking I found what I thought was the Upgrade CD and quite happily walked out to the computer and opened the CD Case only to find it empty. :(

Only been a couple of years since I've had to use one so I've got no idea where the thing has got to I've most likely left it in a repair some time ago so now I'm waiting for the guy to bring in his Copy of the CD so I can load the unit. I'm not even going to try to figure out what's happening here just roll with the punches. :D

But just to make sure I've put a copy of 98SE onto it and beside not having drivers for the Video Card it's working perfectly so it's not hardware related. :)

Col

by gsaravin9

yep you seem to know everything there is to know on vista so why do we bother.
ta Dr Mick

by mark

No, Mr. Alleged Degrees, I do not claim to know everything. Unlike you, however, I keep an open mind. I've seen tons of beta software, and now, some of it is the most stable stuff around.

by gsaravin9

anyone else,If you look at other replies show the developer tools software that i use & my methodology
that i use.I use other peoples opinions only to highlight the ones you guys so readily adopt as your own to prove that vista is not what it is going to be.
ta Dr Mick ps please address me as Dr in future as anyless is insulting.
Ta Dr Mick
Also please note my phd was on design & analysis of operating systems!

by gsaravin9

you probably enjoy it all otherwise you would not be commentingon vista.My opinion is more all is not what it seems to be.
Ta DR Mick

by gsaravin9

i'm still not convinced that this release is better than any other release.He does paint a rosy picture i have got stability problems & other bugs.If this is the way it's going to be then vista started with a lot of good features only to have them canned.If itcomes out finally it will be like xp with bloat because that's all it is.
ta Dr Mick

by gsaravin9

All i know is that i'm not satisfied with what has been done.Until such time as they can assure me that stability has been resolved & the majority of bugs removed i will not upgrade for quite some time.
My company has decided not to upgrade to vista for
at least 12 months.
I agree with what you are saying but from what i've seen call it my opinion then i'm not totally convinced.
ta Dr MIck

by hal 9000

And back when I started there where no PC's we used [b]Mainframes[/b] with [b]Dumb Terminals[/b] now they call them [b]Thin Clients[/b] and are using a decent sized [b]Server[/b] that is most likely far more powerful that the mainframe that I started with ever could hope to be. :(

Col

by txtopgun

We have read your illiterate remarks enough already. If you don't have something new, or at least in genuine english, to say, then shut up and color (I am sure you still have your crayons close by.) I don't have a master's in computer science or a PHD but at least I can spell and know when I have already said the same stupid things several times.

by gsaravin9

your black hole You should change your name txtopgun arseabout.You know jackshit you can't even spell Phd properly.You show no respect to your elders & you don't deserve any jack shit!
Did anyone say ashit head like you can make any comment as you know buggerall.
piss off
Dr Mick

by txtopgun

I would venture to say I am probably your elder for that matter. I started working with computers in earnest around 1982. Can you post the link to your pHD (yes I did it on purpose dummy) so everyone else can have one for their wall too?

by gsaravin9

your black hole You should change your name txtopgun arseabout.You know jackshit you can't even spell Phd properly.You show no respect to your elders & you don't deserve any jack shit!
Did anyone say ashit head like you can make any comment as you know buggerall.
piss off
Dr Mick
ps your so perfect you don't make spelling mistakes!!

by mark

"You know jackshit you can't even spell Phd properly"

And for someone who allegedly has one, it appears that you can't either. It's Ph.D.

And who in the hell are you to criticize someone else's spelling?

by den2010

At the risk of feeding a troll, I would have to say that calling Vista crap at this stage of testing seems to indicate an axe to grind. Vista has some rough edges, sure, but it is still in beta. I've done several installs of Beta 2 (Build 5384) and just now of Build 5536, and the most aggravating thing I've encountered has been the UAP nag boxes. I've gotten Firefox and Thunderbird to run with minimal difficulty, as well as OpenOffice.org. and some other applications. Printers have been created without a lot of drama, and you can customize your desktop within pretty wide limits.

I don't know if there's sufficient new stuff in Vista to justify an early upgrade for the general user. The hardware requirements are pretty heavy, but then, a tricked out Windows XP installation with some bells and whistles isn't a lightweight either. The newest build (5536) runs nicely on a 2.4 GHz Pentium 4 with 1 GB of RAM, and has a memory footprint of about 415 MB. That said, for those individuals who are willing to deal with the delay in getting Vista-compliant drivers for some hardware devices, and upgraded versions of some programs, I think Vista would be an appropriate OS to have on a new PC (or a recently upgraded existing PC) early next year. If one is comfortable with a Microsoft-based computing platform, the combination of Vista and MS Office 2007 should meet their needs quite nicely. The learning curve with the new user interfaces could be pretty steep, but the eye-candy does look nice. We'll have to wait and see how Vista holds up on the security front, but I'd say it will be a lot better than XP was right out of the gate in 2001.

And for all you posters out there who rant on about this or that--Vista or IE7 or Linux or any other topic that people here find worthy of discussion--will you for heaven's sake learn how to spell and punctuate? People with doctorates shouldn't come across in writing like hillbillies or illiterates...

by arizmendi

In my computer career (since 1959) I have NEVER seen anyone who describes themselves an "expert" to actually be one, or to even know very much about anything. Keep this in mind when reading rants and raves. I used to have a couple of PHDs working for me when I ran an operating systems group (one also had a Cal Tech advanced degree). Most people didn't know they had PHDs, and neither said they were experts, but they were.

by drchips

I'm not an 'Expert" like most of you guys are. I do not Have A PHD. What I do have is:

I've been in computers since the 1970's.
4 degrees in programming languages (Basic,C,Fortran and Colbolt.

Degree in Radio, Color TV and VCR's.
Degree in computer repair.

Add it all up = Experince. (can't spell either)

Anyway back to Vista.

To the person that says Vista is crap. I have to assume that he is using the A64 version of Vista. I don't have an A64 up and running right now so I can't check it out, but I am running the X86 version of Vista.

Yes - Vista's a bit crappy - It's a beta.
Yes - Vista has hardware and software incompatibility problems. - It's a beta. That's what bug reports are for.

I tried to install My Visual Studio 6.0 and Vista came up with Setup cannot be run error.
I sent in a bug report and most of my microsoft programs will now install (after updating).

Vista seems to run on my computer just fine. It has only crashed once because I was trying to make it crash and had to reinstall. That's what beta testing is all about.

We'll see how much Vista's been fixed after the new beta comes out.

My System:

AMD Septron 2200 (1.5mhz) cpu
1 G ddr ram
Nvidia 6200 256mg video card
240 G hhd

Thanks
DrChips also
A.K.A. TheGameKing

by hal 9000

I've had more practise than others when it comes to describing my qualifications as the Education doesn't count in the [b]Real World[/b] at best it only gives you the right to start to go out and [b]Learn Your Trade.[/b]

At one of the places that I used to work they insisted on calling me DR which was more of a nuisance than anything else particularly when on an aircraft once I was approached by one of the flight crew to help a person having a Heart Attack, because I was called DR on my ticket I must have known all about [b]Medical Things[/b] well that's how many people see it anyway and I avoid ever using the term unless it's for Legal Reports that are ending up in a Court. Besides as I say anyone who's going to be impressed with all those silly letters after your name isn't worth impressing in the first place. I also say that PHD is the sound that you make when you hit the floor after tripping over that whatever that was going to be fixed 2 years ago but is yet to be done. :D

Although I do like the Honorary PHD that I was awarded by one of the Peers here at TR now I officially have 4 PHD's and the only one worth mentioning is the Honorary One on the [b]Erogenous Zones of Sheep[/b] because I see a lot of Kiwi's around the place here and observe them. :^0

Col

by gsaravin9

i don't claim to be an expert just someone who knows
at least i can comment not like some fence sitters.
ta Dr Mick

by marchred

I do apologise to those in here actually trying to contribute worthwhile input on the question of where Vista is at, but there are some things that just niggle and one has to respond ....

While I am not the slightest bit interested in whether you have or do not have any experience or qualifications, gsaravin - sorry Dr Mick, I am a little confused by your assertion that you are a PhD. On 21 August 2006 you were only half way through your doctorate and I quote from your post "you prove that you know nothing (403 of 482)"

"... I challenge you to write in response how much you have tested vista I stake my claim on 29 years of testing in IT.I have a Masters in Computer science & i'm half way through my Phd.
So there CRETIN go away!
Mick

Posted by: gsaravin@... Date: 08/21/06 ..."

Just wondering if you got your doctorate from the Khaosan Road University in Bangkok?

Cheers

Marchred

by txtopgun

Maybe we could get him to post a link to the PHD template...maybe I we could all print one for our walls too.

by gsaravin9

you guys make it sound so easy.All the hardearned money i have poured into it would amaze you.not counting the blood & sweat to earn the doctorate.
Ta Dr Mick

by gsaravin9

was on operating systems.I'm now half way through
my second thesis,so in essence i'm getting 2 doctorates!!!
Those of you that think you know everything & show no respect will soon see that i'm right in what i say.
Ta Dr Mick (also half way throgh second doctorate thesis.)

by gsaravin9

due to the overwhelming evidence that there are so many things wrong with the operating system.I have tried it & i'm not satisfied with it far from it.
I'm entitled to my opinion.
Ta Dr Mick

by arizmendi

I personally am two classes short of a Masters in Theoretical Mathematics, so I presumably can't know anything about computers. Long ago, I realized that degrees don't mean anything except to indicate that you might have a good starting point. One of the best computer guys I ever saw didn't have any degree (he did end up with a PhD) - he worked full time, went to school full time and took care of a 5 yr old since his wife was dying. I won't mention my background, except that once upon a time I did have overall responsibility for a complete mainframe operating system design and implementation back in spooling systems days. A Univac/Unisys vice pres once told me my operating systems group was the best in the Country, so I had great people working for me. What counts is what you accomplish, not what your PR is. As soon as we heard that someone was an expert, my group would let out a collective groan: "Oh no! Not another expert!".

by hal 9000

Originally I built [b]Race Cars[/b] why back when and I did Electronic Engineering to learn about how I could design an Engine Management Systems back before they where available.

So The most that I ever say in Day to Day life is that [b]I'm Still Learning Maybe One Day I'll Get It Right![/b]

But actually I enjoy the work way to much so I'll just have to keep learning. :)

Col

by pkr9

BYE, just to be able to turn off e-mails from this silly 'discussion'. Like talking to a 10-year old who learned 5 sentences.

You give absolutely nothing to this. EOD.

by mark

I asked him to post when he got these alleged degrees and from what university so that they could be verified, but he hasn't. Hmmm... I wonder why?

by gsaravin9

I started in IT in 1976,that's 30 years ago.You obviously can't count.Also you did not intentionally
misspelt PHD as it stands for Poor Head Dunce.
If you started in 1982 you dunce you would be 24 years. HA HA
Ta Dr Mick Phd
ps you can go suck eggs

by gsaravin9

You are a dumb arse idiot go play with yourself somewhere else as you have nothing to contribute here.
Ta Dr Mick Phd

by gsaravin9

at least i speak my mind & i have tested the betas you show up nothing to add.You are silly for coming to this discussion .You know jack shit !
DR Mick Phd

by revsmileyg

... you made it to 500! And you all got me to pen my first (and probably last ever) post.

I'm relatively new to the world of IT (a mere 15 years) and so I use this site to gain informative insights from my peers on a variety of subjects that I've been asked to look into.

I have to say that I've learnt absolutely nothing new from this thread. It was funny for a while, but not anymore.

I'm sure even my post will get an automated, duplicated and nonsensical reply from you know who, but it really won't matter because I won't be reading it.

Have fun in the sandpit everyone, I'm off to see the world....