Discussion Locked

vista is a DUD ! (wham baam thankyou maam!)

0 helpful
1,924 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 6 of the discussion. Read the opening post

1,924 replies

by arizmendi

I was thinking of getting a PhD, but I don't know where to mail my $15 for the certificate. Maybe I'll get a Doctor of Divinity and another one for Sex Therapy - I need a hobby now that I'm retired. Why do you suppose that the multiple "Doctor" thinks he is the only person that has tried Vista? My first Alpha and Beta test work was in 1960 for Ibsys - I was one of the 45 people that got IBM to implement the first commercial operating system. Do you suppose he knows the difference between prest and squoze decks? And what a "Beta" system release means? Maybe he prefers DRDOS or likes S3 hardware. Vista Beta 2 configured my hardware better than XP, although the sound card and graphics drivers were rocky. It will be an improvement, but I'll probably hang on to XP Pro for a while until I figure out if what I'll gain for the bucks spent is worth it.

by gsaravin9

I do not claim to be superior to the decent people
at tech republic.I'm claiming superiority to the rat bag element who just appear out of the blue & criticise people for the sake of it. DR ARIZMENDI
GO AHEAD & MAKE YOUR DAY & GET YOUR DOCTORATES.I don't mind at all !!
ta Mick, to the decent people of tech republic

by onbliss

I thought the talk about operating systems would be so over the top of my head and I would not understand much of what the experts discussed. So after the first few reads, I abandoned the thread. Little did I know that this would develop into a hilarious thread :-)

LOL... WOW...

by arizmendi

For one person to think that they can comprehensively test a multi-million lines of code modern operating system is ludicrous. It couldn't be done even when operating systems were 300,000 lines of code, but could be when a mainframe "operating system" was 256 words (1K bytes). One can test a tiny portion (without even knowing exactly what you are testing), and hopefully find a bug that can be reported to Microsoft to help us all out. After a few hundred thousand people do the same, most of the key problems can probably be found. That is what Beta testing is for. When the successor system is released, there are probably still a few thousand unsolved or unknown bugs in the old one. Having said that, quality is infinitely better than back when I ran a 35-person in-house operating systems group in the 60s. Back then, my management thought that running one test program a thousand times was as good as running a thousand different ones once.

by arizmendi

Of the thousands of problems that "gsaravin" has uncovered, how many has he documented and reported to Microsoft? Or does he just e-mail them and say Vista's crap? If it's the former, then good for him. If he hasn't documented problems, then he is one of the problems.

by gsaravin9

welcome aboard as long as we don't have it out this can be like a watering hole for our problems etc.
A biit of respect won't go astray as well.Im not perfect.To be human is to err.So no one is perfect we can all have our opinions & be heard I'm also
suprised at this thread myself.
ta Mick

by michael l hereid sr

I only have a AA Degree in Electronics that I earned in 1966-heck IC's were just coming out at this time-my first computer was a Sinclair ZX81 Kit. In 1985 I started using IBM computers and in 1987 building mine. There weere not that many people at that time doing this so I had to learn on my own. Since that time I have built 25+ computers for myself and others. In 1997 I started beta testing for MS and since that time I have been on the beta team for 98/Plus98/98SE/Me(sorry on that one)and Xp.Now Vista.
So I have seen the worst and the best-Vista is not as bad as you say. From what I've seen in the last 2 builds after Beta 2 - I think Vista will be b fantastic OS.
Mike

by jonathan h

I wish sincerely that the discussions were started by individuals more like yourself who, in the interest of learning and sharing knowledge joined this community. Thus far the posts I have made have been for mere entertainment.
I am quite new to the IT world and for the most part just get to "fly by the seat of my pants". Learning tools such as TechRepublic have been invaluable.

by txtopgun

You have become the laughing stock of this place. I don't think you have any idea how stupid you sound. If you indeed have a PhD in any field whatsoever you have singlehandedly done more to damage its credibility than all your predecessors combined. I am truly amazed they let creatures in padded rooms have computers! Your idiotic posts are no longer worth my time.

by gsaravin9

if that's all you can do well you are wasting my time & everyone elses so
go away
piss off
Ta Dr Mick

by arizmendi

As one of my bosses at JPL told me back in the sixties (paraphrased): "Some people have 29 years experience, some have one years experience 29 times".

by gsaravin9

we are all on the same boat.The only reason qualifications come up to shut up the idiots who like to question everything.At no point do i quote rank to normal decent people who have a right to express their opinion.Not the idiots who come out of the blue the only thing they have to contribute is to criticise me personally.
ta Mick

by michael l hereid sr

About my experiance. You remind me of a supervisor(a young kid about 2years out of college)he wanted me to do a job his way-I told him it would not work and what he needed to do to make it work. So he tried it his way-guess what it did not work and when I did it my way it did. He only lasted a year- he had the degree but he did not know how to use it. I'm sorry but you sound just like him on every thing he would say he had the degree and no matter what he was right and I was wrong. He would never admit he was wrong even if you showed him he was. He could never prove he was right either.
Before you say I'm just a kid - I'm 64 been in electronics for nearly 48 years.
Ta, Mike

by arizmendi

I would hire you (you have the right attitude), but (sorry kid) not "gsaravin". I couldn't work with him no matter how good or smart he might be. Although maybe he is not like this in person; the print and "real" personas are sometimes different. In 22 yrs of management, I never fired anyone I hired (but I was tempted sometimes), so my track record speaks for itself. I'm 73, and played with computers in high stress environments since 1959.

by gsaravin9

& make a comment on vista.Do you like it or do you hate it? Remember you opinion is valued,It doesn't matter if it is wrong or right.
Ta mick

by txtopgun

What I do remember was when I had a hard drive go down in a Z100 (Zenith)in the Air Force and had to wait over a year just to get a replacement. That is when I first learned you can actually move the boot sector to another physical location on the drive to get past the bad blocks. Oh those were the days!

by hal 9000

Back in the 286 Days we would buy 50 MEG HDD for about $300.00 AU and thought that was so cheap. Mind you at the same time or slightly latter we where paying $25.00 AU Per CDR and that was so cheap at the time on a $700.00 + SCSI Burner. Now I pay about $20.00 AU for a spindle of 50 CDR and don't use them much any more as I'm using DVD R to do a lot of the storage and they are even cheaper than the CD's.

Currently I'm waiting for the price of Dual Layer DVD R's to drop to a reasonable level currently over here when you can get them they are still asking around the $10.00 AU per Disc Wholesale.

Actually my first personal PC was a 486 that I had to fight to buy a 500 MEG HDD for as it at the time was supposedly [b]Unfillable.[/b] But I also had a bit of trouble with the RAM as well as I wanted 8 X 16 MEG Sticks and they where well over $100.00 AU per MEG of RAM so each stick cost close to 2K AU and there where 8 of them. Now I couldn't give away that RAM if I wanted to. :D

I've a couple of the old 50 MEG HDD's lying around here as well which are effectively only good for [b]Paper Weights[/b] now and I don't know if you ever saw them but most are not the IDE Interface they have 2 Ribbon Leads to them the IDE's came latter and even then they where RAM Drives which where inherently unreliable.

I can still remember my first company supplied LT which was the size of a medium suitcase which I was supposed to carry with me at all times. It was a joke at the time but I'd love to have it now as it was different with the fold out speakers and the Green Screen CRT people just had to have a play with it when it was new and I was caring it to all the Mainframe work that I was going to. I didn't carry it around much because it was heavy and limited the amount of stuff that I could carry into a job in a Secure Position so it was mostly left at the office. Particularly as it looked fragile to me and I didn't want to destroy one of the first available before they even went on sale here. I think that the company thought that if they where reliable enough to allow Mainframe Techs to carry around they where going to be good. I think that I was mostly using [b]Dumb Terminals[/b] till I bought the 486 but I had bought the parts for a 286 for my Mother and assembled the unit for her long before I bought a PC for myself. It was then I learnt all about Incompatible Hardware and coming from the Mainframe side this was a problem for me at least. The company couldn't understand why I bought the bits myself and made the computers that I wanted rather than but a preassembeled unit that they where supplying. Mine always worked better and I didn't have any of that nasty MS Software that came bundled on the prebuilt systems that they where selling at the time. Even the company supplied PC's where upgraded to hell and all the MS stuff removed and replaced with something that worked. :0

Col

by txtopgun

I had forgotten about the Burroughs systems I worked with in the very beginning. The B25 systems ran up to 8 workstations (dumb terminals) and they only had a 10MB hard drive. Nobody could figure out what to do with the XE520 system (renamed from B29 so it could be sold in Japan!) so I wound up with one of them sitting behind my desk. It was called a mini-mainframe...it was about the size of an apartment sized fridge. It had a whopping 50MB of storage space not including the 5MB syquest drive to power its 32 terminals (which by the way had to be hardwired to it no matter where they were located). I will have to say though the word processing program it used, Write 1, was one of the best I have ever encountered. I have often wished I still had a copy. These were the predecessors of the PCs.

My first experience with a laptop didn't come until around 1990. When I took it with me to Desert Storm it caused quite a stir every time I went through security...they just weren't used to seeing people actually carrying them around yet. You didn't dare check them as baggage. At the time it was state of the art, a 286.

by michael l hereid sr

and the differance from beta 2 and this is like the differance between night and day.
The only bugs I've found so far is in MCE of Home premium version. They are very minor bugs compared to the ones I found in Beta 2 and previous versions.
All the hardware in both of my computers were detected and installed.
One thing I will recommend once it goes RTM that people buy the Home Premium version.
ta, Mike

by gsaravin9

there is a thread that says "I have had enough of all you so called self taught people. Why are you in your job?

You have no right to be there.

What gives you the right?

You never bothered to study the foundations of your profession. You make me sick.

Pray the day you entrust something to these wannabes!"

Ta Mick

by arizmendi

I never thought it would happen, but I agree with "gsaravin" completely. Us elderly nerds HAD to be self taught since there were NO computer classes. I used to be in charge of user computer education at JPL (among other things), so instead of taking classes, my group taught them.

by arizmendi

Newbies probably don't know that in early days, Operating Systems support was done by programmers whose function was mainly to correct errors in OS source code. Every site had the OS source, so you learned a lot after looking for bugs all day for years on end. Now, Operating Systems support is done by administrators, who configure systems but don't ever look at code. Both can be difficult, and I have done both. I can't say one or the other takes more skill, but the skill set is totally different. Current systems are much more sophisticated, but also much more stable so no one needs an OS programmer on site. Maybe that is why I changed from applications to Operating Systems to Data Center Manager to data communications (LANs and WANs) as each job became obsolete in turn.

by michael l hereid sr

the best is a person with a PHD and the ability to recognize he does not know it all. Thing is nobody can know it all, People need to realise that with that PHD they need to get experiance to use that knowledge and the ability to combine the 2.
Nothing turns people off faster than the person who says he's right and everybody else is wrong. gsarine you sound like that person or at least in here you do-you say you have proof that Vista is crap but you won't give that proof-you say you have test all versions of Vista but won't give Build numbers of the ones you test, so what are people supposed to think.
I'm not attacking you I am just asking for proof of what you say.
MIke

by arizmendi

It used to be that self-taught was the ONLY way you could learn due to NO classes; it was not the "right" way. The title of "programmer" did not exist, which was why programmers were Math, Physics, or Engineering majors. Now, sufficient classes and proper theoretical knowledge is available in schools, and taking a class for a semester is a lot quicker than spending a couple of years on your own to learn the same thing. You are right. You need a Computer Science degree now, preferably an advanced one. I (and thousands of others) were self taught since that was the only way to learn about computers - along the way we learned a lot of other stuff due to studying the wrong things so we at least got to be well rounded. I wish I knew a compelling reason why I need Vista. Maybe in two or three years.

by gsaravin9

has major problems with the search engine.
ista search - not all it's cracked up to be

Desktop search is one of the areas supposedly getting a major revamp in Windows Vista, according to Microsoft. But if my experiences with the Beta 2 release are anything to go by, users are likely to be disappointed.

While trying out Vista, I did a quick search for a particular executable file. To my surprise, Vista couldn't find it. Trawling through the hard drive manually, I soon found the file was there after all. What was going on?

Microsoft seems to have optimised its Search tool in Vista chiefly for multimedia files. I'm sure that IT managers out there will be pleased to know how much easier it is for workers to find the digital photos and music they've stockpiled on their work PC, but what about other files?My experience shows this to be true.

Searching for anything else seems to have become a much more complicated and long-winded process than is currently the case with Windows XP.

Search1_1 For example, this is the process I went through to search for the install file for VMware's Player, which I had already downloaded to the PC. All seems well at first; Vista now puts an Instant Search box in the Start menu. Typing 'vmware', however, comes back with 'No items match your search'.

Trying the main search function, now called the Search Folder, elicits the same response. At this point, the inexperienced user will probably assume the file isn't there and give up.

Search2_1 However, you can choose a specific search location from the drop-down Search Index. Selecting the C: drive and clicking OK starts a search that eventually locates the VMware install file, but not until nearly thirty seconds have passed.

Search3_1The search tool under Windows XP is often maligned, but is much easier to use and finds files much faster by comparison. Just select Search from the Start menu, click 'All files and folders', type 'vmware', and Windows finds the file almost instantly.

You may argue that the average office worker has little need to search for executables and other system files, but IT staff and other professional users will often need to. Why make it so tricky?

You don't need phd to work that out
ta mick (you notice that i don't use my qualifications when i talk to you)
Only when i respond to idiots!
ta Mick

by gsaravin9

Ms said that vista system is the most secure system in the world.Microsoft has admitted that the August mega patch included two patches intended for the beta versions of Vista that are currently under test around the world.Of the seven critical Windows updates released in August, two - MS06-042, which is a cumulative patch for Internet Explorer, and MS06-051, which fixes a vulnerability in the Windows kernel - also affect Windows Vista Beta 2 or later. .
Ms warns that beta testers should not be lulled into a false sense of security by the addition of Vista.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

goes a long way.Just because my opinion is different
doesn't mean i'm wrong As there is no right or wrong.there is a saying we can agree to disagree but i will defend your right to express your opinion!
It's good to have an opinion we don't have to agree on all things.Also these people who come on & are rude to me how would you react you probably would give them a job & they don't have an opinion.!
ta mick

by arizmendi

I have run Vista Beta 2 with the updates of a couple of weeks ago. Limited testing at that, since I have to re-cable hard drives each test. I did have driver problems (my obsolete Santa Cruz sound card and non-obsolete MSI 6600GT AGP graphics card). My last real Beta testing was with Windows 98, and think I remember that there were thousands of patches between the Beta and RC1 release. I'll reserve further judgement until I install another hard drive and RC1. Looking at it from a marketing perspective, Vista is prettier and seems to install easier; especially Internet access. I don't know if MS can think of a reason why everyone should switch to Vista, unless they drop support for enough legacy systems to make people start worrying - that will be their main hope. Windows 3.1 to 95 was a big jump, but XP to Vista will seem pretty tame to the casual end-user and to me (so far). Remember that sales of anything is perceived value, NOT real value and value is whatever (if anything) someone will pay for your product.

by txtopgun

I haven't taken the time to try it yet...so far I have no clients that even have an interest in it and I don't really care personally. I just came on here to read what others had to say about it and maybe learn something. Unfortunately, most of this particular thread is taken up by your complete lunacy.

by gsaravin9

this comment was more to topgun to make comment.As regards to your comments i have to agree with you but like to add that Vista started off with a lot of good things & then canned them along the way.I was speaking to some senior it's & they said vista will turn out like a bloated XP.
ta Mick

by gsaravin9

I suppose what's going to matter MS is going to thrust it's software on us whether we like it or not
At least here we can get it off our chest.As long as we don't take it out on each other.For a minute there you were getting on my goat.See that's the thing when you don't know the people visually & not having met you i assumed the worst.So underneath that skin there beats a heart of gold!Sorry to upset you!.
This thread i would like it to be like a watering hole where people from IT can let it all hang out.
Speak your mind & don't be afraid to say it!
ta Mick love ya all.

by mark

Or XP, or Unix, or any other O/S? A computer with an O/S is relatively useless, you need applications to make it actually do useful work. Whether or not you "need" Vista depends on the applications you need to run. Eventually, (more than two or three year) you'll be forced to run Vista if you want to use the applications that are written to run on it. If you can find suitable apps that run on Unix or XP or whatever that fulfills your needs, then you don't need Vista.

by michael l hereid sr

YOU it you want
Better security(it's there)- IE more standardized-more protection visiting web sites(IE in a sandbox)- WinFS(huh yep it's there(renamed .net3(beta form but it's there)) better/faster search -yep-Aero display engine(yes it will help developers design better graphics be it games or work applications-improved NTFS file system-MCE (fantastic-you can record a tv show/movie and burn to dvd)-ready boost(improves performance)-setup on my 2 pc's one setup in 20 minutes, other in 30 minutes-boot up time faster than XP- there is more that is not even seen in this version
Mike

by hal 9000

On Board with Digital Signing for Vista. If they don't MS is going to have a big problem with their new OS come the first major Service Pack about 2 years after the production release of Vista.

Also the recording of TV shows only applies to the 32 Bit version as the 64 Bit version is going to have Copy Protection to prevent the copping of DVD Media and the like.

This might be a big improvement for Home users but I'll sit on the fence a bit longer when it comes to Business Systems as I've yet to see any real benefit and things like Apples Quick Player to get Digitally Signed will have to be a Windows Only System with no Cross Platform Support, [b]Sorry But I can Not See things like this happening.[/b]

Col

by gsaravin9

& symantec proves what a poor system vista is .With serious security breaches & Ms simply denying Symantecs reports.You don't need to be an einstein or some dude with a phd to work out that vista is a dud system.A lot of people have simply been taken for a ride about vistas bells & whistles,when in reality it's a huge mess.In what appears to be a last ditch effort by MS as vista will be it's last of the windows operating system before it hopes to move on to some other platform.
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

Beta 2 was still a beta just as RC1 is still a beta. There were 2 beta's between Beta 2 nd RC1 during that time don't you think MS was refining search and all other things in Vista since features are set and won't change-they are now spending time fixing any bugs that are found and increasing the performance.
I just hunted for a exe file on my computer-it found it in less than 1 second and this was on a hd of 80gigs- I also searched for another exe on this computer that was in a partion of just one of the harddrives
1 hd 120 gigs divided into 3 partitions of 40 gigs each
2 2 S ATA 80 gig hd's
This search took 10 minutes but considering how much hd space I have not bad.
Mike

by michael l hereid sr

imperfect humans-there well always be imperfect or bugs in software that is designed by us poor humans.
Because of this you have to take an active part in helping the OS to keep secure. The software can only do so much.
But then as a person with a Ph.D you already know this -RIGHT
Mike

by gsaravin9

on the semantec website it's got Symantec saying vista is a load of crap as far as security is concerned.Practically the vista kernel is hackeable.Also Ms has virtually excluded third party software like symantec.ther is a huge furore going on with symantec accusing Ms of outright lying about
vista.
ta Mick

by gsaravin9

I have spoken to MS & the say that they cannot reveal the exact release date so that they can allways change it.I said to them that i felt that january 07 did not seem right for a release more like june 07 given the massive problems.They said there won't be any more beta releases & it's going to be final candidate.They did agree about the massive problems they are facing,huge technical hurdles.They seem to just shrug them off.I did mention to them about the calling off the release of vista completely they just laughed & said they
don't intend to call it off.There is too much at stake to do that.They did agree on a lot of the issues that i have raised on this thread.The other thing hardly anyone knows what the hell is going on down there!

Ta mick

ta Mick

by michael l hereid sr

I'm using RC1 right now and see only minor (very minor) problems. This computer runs 24/7 and is very stable. As I said there are only minor problems and I think when RC2 comes out those minor problems will be gone.
On symantec- I have seen the products that they make and I have also worked on problems they cause. Recntly I worked on a Desktop that had their product on it. It had major stability problems and was very slow. After removing the Symantec software and getting him programs that do the same thing only better. It was no longer unstable and running better than when he bought it. A week later he called me and thanked me for giving him a better computer.
The main thng Symantec i hollering about that because of the way Vista prevents any kernal changes which means they can not add their own code there, which to me is stupid. Now they will have to design their product the correct way.
I would like to know what issues you are talking about in eveery comment you have made in this thread you have never mentioned even one of the issues, all you ever say is that there is issues.
Mike

by wolf13

I have spoken to MS & the say that they cannot reveal the exact release date so that they can allways change

I'M SURE MS WOULD TELL YOUR "ALL IMPORTANT SELF" SOMETHING LIKE THAT.

I said to them that i felt that january 07 did not seem right for a release more like june 07 given the massive problems

IM SURE MS COULD GIVE A CRAP ABOUT WHEN YOU THINK THAT VISTA SHOULD BE RELEASED

BOW DOWN TO THE "COMPUTER MASTER" A GURU TO THE IT WORLD A MAN WHO KNOWS IT ALL AND "HAS DONE IT ALL" A PERSON WITH A SUPPOSED MASTER'S THAT CAN NOT SPELL- YOUR JUST A BLOWHARD WHO IS TRYING TO MAKE HIS SMALL UNIMPORTANT LIFE SEEM LIKE IT MEANS SOMETHING, BUT IN ACTUALITY IT JUST DEMEANS IT EVEN MORE WITH EACH POSTING THAT YOU MAKE.

by gsaravin9

Why not spill the beans & let us know that your it job sucks.I love my it job because it offers variety & challenges!

Ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

After over 50 years of working I figure I deserved to retire. Having worked those years in electronics I am still fasinated by what electronics can do and the possiblities of the future.
I have worked with computers since 1981 and I am reading all the time trying to learn as much as I can about them.
Mike

by gsaravin9

from day to day different challenges come up you have to face them square & without avoiding the hard ones,you accept them all & apply your knowledge & experience.I can say i have thoroughly enjoyed my time working in the it sector.I wouldn't give up my job for anything.
ta mick

by wolf13

WOW - GEEZ -- The Computer Buddha-- I think we should all bow down, for this man has done it all.
First and foremost go back to school where you got yor masters and ask them to teach you to type.
Now if you can get over your self without tripping over your inflated ego take your much vaunted (http://www.thefreedictionary.com/vaunted) skills and develop your own operating system so I can install it on my computer systems, which would im sure would make me the envy of the computing world

by gsaravin9

a release of a product why hide & lie .MS has done itself a major diservice by misrepresenting to the consumer of when they will release.They must know
why is it just guesswork.What's the big deal we all want to be told the truth is it or isn't it & stop lying to us for a change.Delaying & lying is not going to help it in the long run.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

When i first enetered it i was interested in the electronics side & repairing individual components.When i found out that you don't replace individual components but replace the boards i did'nt bother with that.
I pursued a career in IT you name it i've done it.
I still say us oldies should keep going as we need to stimulate the younger people by setting them an example.Who would've beleived a 10 meg hardrive sold in 1982 for $2500.Now you can get a 350 gig hardrive for $120.I'd hate to think the advances we'll make in 5 to 10 years it's all too mindbogling.I'll just keep going when my firm doesn't want me & i'll retire when i'm good & ready.
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

Your link on MS not knowing what they're doing does not work.

On not devulging the release of a product- Vista is not ready for release-it is only a RC-even at RC something may happen to delay the product and no manufacturer will announce when a product is at this stage but then you know that right -you have been in IT for so many years that you should.
Mike

by michael l hereid sr

As I have said I have worked for 50+ years in that time I have done all kinds of jobs from electronic repair to plant maintaince. My body is wore out. I was ready to retire to enjoy my hobbies of electronics(designing and building projects)-Amatuer radio and computers. Oh and enjoying my grandkids.
I still enjoy working on computers from building my own or for others to working on other peoples computers and showing them how to take care of them. Plus I get to beta test for MS to help them make better products.
I remember in 1997 buying a 640 meg hd for $200 and thinking this thing is so big that I'll never be able to fill it. Thing is I can now buy a 250 gig hd for $110.
Mike

PS I can now buy a 500gig hd for that same $200

by hal 9000

How much RAM used to cost when the 286/386 Systems where new?

I can remember having a system with 4 MEG of RAM installed and back then it was considered as overkill needing that much RAM.

The first computer that I built for myself has 128 MEG of RAM 8 X 16 MEG 30 pin sticks installed and I had to wait for that RAM to come in as it wasn't something that was carried only listed. Back then I think that we where paying around $100.00 AU per MEG and we all thought that was so cheap. :D

Now I'm using 2 GIG RAM sticks and think nothing of it and it costs far less for all the RAM in the entire system than what 1 of those 16 MEG RAM sticks used to cost. :)

Col

by rob

I have bene running Vista under VMWARE Workstation and have 512mb allocated to it.

It runs OK. I haven't really seen much special, new or innovative. Office 2007 running on it is kind of nice. MANY visual changes, Vista and Office seem kind of dumbed down. Kind of an Adobe type look to the tools in Office.

Performance is OK, nothing special but then again I'm running VM on a Core Duo 2.0ghz. I'd like to see it native on my laptop.

I CAN tell you this, WE ALL HAVE MORE JOB SECURITY. The visual changes are enough to completely confuse the masses, especially in Office. I think comapnies should wait to deploy this puppy until at least SP1. The learning curve for the masses on this one is going to be steep.

by michael l hereid sr

But then I've been beta testing Vista since July of 2005. For another I've tried to record TV shows/Movies since Windows 98. At last with Vista I can do this and even burn to dvd with no problems.
As far as performance Vista boots faster-applications startup faster than XP.
The learning curve is just about the same as when Windows came on the market(Windows 3.1 anyone).
Before you mention software compatibility-remember when XP came out it took a while but evenually it got pretty good-once Vista goes RTM - MS will still be working on that and by the time you can buy it there will be many improvements. I've not seen Office 2007 so I have to take your word on that.
Mike

by hal 9000

It's totally different in the user interface, that's what I think the above poster is referring to. Unlike the previous versions of Office the tools are laid out differently and what was previously second nature takes some finding now.

If it takes off people will initially have a fairly steep learning curve to go through but eventually will probably like the new interface though to be honest it's totally different to the previous versions of Office that have been available and for that reason alone will make the transition harder for many people particularly the ones using it for Business as they will initially be much slower till they have used it for some time.

Col

by michael l hereid sr

I have not used this beta but then I'm in 6 other betas. :) But every windows beta I have been in-the interface has been in some way differant.
Like with Vista-I'm still learnng the interface and sometimes I have to hunt for what I want to do.
Mike

by michael l hereid sr

The first time I built a pc. After I assembled all the pieces, it sat on my bench for an hour before I got the courage to turn on. If it had smoked I would have also gone up in smoke-my wife would have made sure of that.
Mike

by hal 9000

Vista RC1 and the 32 Bit version is only about 2.5 GIG so it's much smaller than the previous Vista Beta Releases.

I've got it coming down now but unfortunately the main machine that I was going to try it on is being used to recover data off 2 HDD so I'll be playing with it on smaller less powerful systems till I have recovered all the data off the drives. :(

Col

by michael l hereid sr

So far since Friday I have found only minor problems with it. I have both of my pc's installed with Home Premium and I'm using Vista 99% of the time-it is that good-only reason I go to XP is because I'm still in 6 other betas.
Mike
PS as soon as I get 256 of memory and a better video card-it will be on my granddaughters pc-total cost $65.

by gsaravin9

but i reckon that you should get kninston ddr2 chips
as they are the best.A good graphics card is definitely a must.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

I've just installed rc 1 on a hp pavillion intel 3 gig duo processor when low & behold my dynalink 56 k modem caused a stop error of which there is no recovery from.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

than the others but there are a few niggling problems.Different hardware seems to cause sporadic
crashes.
Ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

quality results. Plus it helps when the manufactures make the correct drivers for those parts and that particular software.
Mike

by gsaravin9

i've just tried some of the generic ram ddr 2 chips
they don't seem to work with vista properly,i've had to settle with kingston,that seems to work!
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

I do not use a generic brand anything. When I get ram I use what the manufacturer recommends -I have found that Kingston works very good for me. When I chose other parts I find if I read reviews from other people that have used them and websites that review those parts- my computers work much better.
Mike

by gsaravin9

when manufacturers provide us with the right drivers then maybe we'll get some stability back in our systems.It's a wait & see.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

Microsoft did not confirm the pricing then, but its latest announcement shows it to be in line with Amazon.com prices. Upgrades will cost between $100 for the basic version and $259 for the ?ultimate? version. Without an upgrade, the software will sell for $199 to $399.

Vista is estimated to have more than 50 million lines of code and has a complete overhaul of key components of the operating system.

?Windows Vista makes a whole lot of plumbing changes?kernel, graphics, etc.?that are almost certain to require some tweaking somewhere,? said Joe Wilcox, an analyst with JupiterResearch. ?It?s one reason why I suspect Microsoft provided the pre-RC to 100,000 volunteer testers before issuing the release candidate to potentially millions of people.?
It could also be the reason why Microsoft?s race to the finish line with Vista has opened up the program to 5 million testers.
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

This is where MS does the tweaking of performance removing all of the debug code as I have said before I have found few bugs in this build mostly needing tweaking of the performance issues.
Mike
PS this is my main OS on this pc.

by gsaravin9

Vista?s Outlook Gets Cloudier,& cloudier

Gartner predicts Microsoft will ship its upcoming Vista operating system later than the January 2007 target.
Microsoft?s upcoming operating system Windows Vista is unlikely to ship until the second quarter of 2007, research firm Gartner said Wednesday, suggesting another potential delay that would be profoundly embarrassing for the software giant despite having little long-term impact.
Gartner said it now expects Vista to hit the shelves anytime between April and June of next year, instead of January, which is when the company last said it would roll the OS out. Microsoft still has plenty of work to do on the product, said Gartner.
Analysts estimate it will take another nine months to turn that into a final product.
Vista is the first major operating system to come out of Redmond in nearly five years and is regarded as the most important one since Microsoft released the Windows 95 OS nearly a decade ago.

ta mick

by gsaravin9

Microsoft Explains Vista Build Numbers

The Microsoft official responsible for releasing Windows Vista builds explained in an interview published on the Vista Team Weblog this week some of the intricacies of how the build numbering scheme for Release Candidates works.

In the interview, Sven Hallauer, director of release management for Windows Vista, said the company currently has parallel build cycles in play for builds numbered 5400 through 5699 which are reserved for Release Candidates (RC). At the same time, it also has reserved builds numbered 5700 and above for Release to Manufacturing (RTM) -- the step following the last RC build and the code that will ultimately be released to customers.

"So does this mean that MS is working on builds for RC1 and RTM in parallel? You bet!" says the posting that accompanies the interview online.
you bet mick

by gsaravin9

I originally stated that vista had more security problems than you can poke a stick at!
Look at the following story:
EU Warns Microsoft About Vista Security Market

by The Associated Press

September 12, 2006

European Union officials warned Microsoft Corp. on Tuesday not to shut out rivals in the security software market as the company plans to launch its Windows Vista operating system with built-in protection from hackers and malicious programs.

EU spokesman Jonathan Todd told reporters that the European Commission is "ready to give guidance to Microsoft" concerning Vista but added that it was up to the U.S. software maker "to accept and implement its responsibilities as a near monopolist to ensure full compliance" with EU competition rules.

Microsoft, meanwhile, warned EU regulators to avoid attempting to block the in-house security upgrades it is making to the long-delayed Windows upgrade now scheduled for release to companies in November and consumers in January.
ta
mick

by michael l hereid sr

Because Vista does not allow changes to the kernal. Symantic wants to be able to add it's own code to the kernal but just like Apple and Linux the kernal is protected against that.
I am one of those that will never allow Symantic products near my computers. I have worked on too many computers that have been messed up by those products.
There are other individual products that so the same thing as Symantic products but they just do them better without adding code to the kernal.
How can EU commision give guidance to MS on things it has no knowledge about.
Mike

by gsaravin9

Special Report

Vista Deployment ? As in Hollywood, Image Is Everything

Stuart J. Johnston

September 11, 2006

With the debut of Windows Vista Release Candidate 1 (RC1) last week, Microsoft has begun the final test phase before releasing its new desktop operating system to the marketplace. From previous experience, it?s clear many IT shops will spend as many as 18 months testing the final code before moving forward. But now is the time to begin planning how to best deploy Microsoft?s first major upgrade to Windows in five years.

Additionally, there are always early adopters who want to get in at the bleeding edge of the technology curve in hopes of gaining competitive advantage over rival companies.

One prime example: Microsoft?s internal IT department ? in the company?s longstanding tradition of ?eating its own dogfood? ? has already garnered plenty of experience deploying Vista over the past three or four months. MSIT began deploying Vista to users? PCs with the beginning of Beta 2 last spring. To date, they have rolled out more than 25,000 copies.

Key to Microsoft?s own deployment and, the company believes, to simplifying rollouts for corporate customers, is a new system imaging format called Windows Image format or WIM as well as tools that work with it. Unlike previous Windows releases, WIM enables administrators to deploy a single system image for virtually all PCs.

?While we don?t really know quite yet whether the reality will live up to the promises, [WIM] should certainly save IT a lot of time in prepping the images, and [constitute] a substantial savings in time managing multiple images,? said Rob Enderle, principal analyst for the Enderle Group. ?Up until now, it?s been very difficult to deploy [new operating systems].?

Vista?s Image Manager tool enables IT managers to compress binaries into one file that?s easy to manipulate -- it?s componentized and can be used offline.
ta mick

by michael l hereid sr

But tells how it will allow to easly and cheaply deploy Windows Vista in a enterprise setting. Which makes Vista even more valuable for enterprise.
Mike

by gsaravin9

Special Report

Vista Deployment ? As in Hollywood, Image Is Everything

Stuart J. Johnston

September 11, 2006

With the debut of Windows Vista Release Candidate 1 (RC1) last week, Microsoft has begun the final test phase before releasing its new desktop operating system to the marketplace. From previous experience, it?s clear many IT shops will spend as many as 18 months testing the final code before moving forward. But now is the time to begin planning how to best deploy Microsoft?s first major upgrade to Windows in five years.

Additionally, there are always early adopters who want to get in at the bleeding edge of the technology curve in hopes of gaining competitive advantage over rival companies.

One prime example: Microsoft?s internal IT department ? in the company?s longstanding tradition of ?eating its own dogfood? ? has already garnered plenty of experience deploying Vista over the past three or four months. MSIT began deploying Vista to users? PCs with the beginning of Beta 2 last spring. To date, they have rolled out more than 25,000 copies.

Key to Microsoft?s own deployment and, the company believes, to simplifying rollouts for corporate customers, is a new system imaging format called Windows Image format or WIM as well as tools that work with it. Unlike previous Windows releases, WIM enables administrators to deploy a single system image for virtually all PCs.

?While we don?t really know quite yet whether the reality will live up to the promises, [WIM] should certainly save IT a lot of time in prepping the images, and [constitute] a substantial savings in time managing multiple images,? said Rob Enderle, principal analyst for the Enderle Group. ?Up until now, it?s been very difficult to deploy [new operating systems].?

Vista?s Image Manager tool enables IT managers to compress binaries into one file that?s easy to manipulate -- it?s componentized and can be used offline.
ta mick

by gsaravin9

We can essentially move to one global image per major platform such as x86 or x64,? said Chad Lewis, program manager in charge of Vista deployment in MSIT, in an interview. The same image can be deployed to both tablet and non-tablet PCs as well as both desktops and laptops ? thus eliminating custom images, which are complicated to manage.

For Microsoft, that?s a big deal. The company has 340,000 PCs with 121,000 separate user accounts in 98 different countries or regions and a total of 441 buildings. The largest numbers of those are in the US, but the second largest are in Japan. So, as in any global corporation, localization is an important detail.

?WIM allows us to go to two images worldwide ? x86 and x64 ? with all the localization . . . It makes our versioning control easier and [results in] smaller binaries.?

The same is true with language packs for the new operating system. ?[WIM] lets you componentize the language and localize it at install time ?on the fly?,? Lewis added. That applies to both the default language as well as the user interface language. ?You can have English as the default and then inject Japanese into the merge.?

WIM also supports unattended scripting, another important capability for reducing the amount of time IT administrators have to spend per deployment. ?It?s not just the raw binaries that need to be compiled and installed ? the bulk of the install time is the copy time from the server.?

Microsoft has also done a few more things to make Vista deployment easier for enterprises. For instance, a new Windows Deployment Services updates and replaces Windows Server 2003?s Remote Installation Services. Coming in Windows Server 2003 Service Pack 2 (SP2), WDS provides a pre-boot execution environment (PXE ? pronounced ?pixie?) for remote PCs.

Basically, WDS updates RIS to enable remote deployment of Vista -- in fact, WDS is required for Vista deployment. One of the enhancements Lewis noted is a full graphical user interface mode. It provides native support for Windows Imaging format. It also includes a snap-in for the Microsoft Management Console.

?WDS will [automatically] install users? credentials into the correct domain [which is] a big jump ahead of RIS,? Lewis said. Windows Server 2003 SP2 began ?privately? beta testing in July. (See ?Microsoft Reveals Additions to Windows Server 2003 SP2,? August 3, 2006.) It is slated for release later this year.

For new PCs that are being brought in to replace aging computers, MSIT is using capabilities in Vista itself to migrate users? applications and settings to the new machines. Windows Easy Transfer is a wizard-based tool for migrating individual users? files and settings ? a simpler to use tool than the Files and Settings Transfer Wizard that it replaces.

?It?s seamless and the user doesn?t have to do anything [and] they end up with a new OS,? Lewis said. Microsoft also has the enterprise-oriented User State Migration Tool (USMT) in work. Version 3, which is currently in beta test, was designed for migrating users? settings from Windows XP or Windows 2000 to Vista on an enterprise basis.

Among its features, USMT saves users? state data to a server and restores it to the desktop after installation and also upgrades users state data and applications in place.

?[WIM and WDS] should reduce the need for special tools for deployment . . . Though we don?t have any data yet, they may be good enough to deploy Vista without third-party tools,? Enderle added.

No third party tools just yet oh haha why not!
ta mick

Ta mick

by gsaravin9

From Paul Pherotts super window's
He says "OK, there is one caveat. If you try to install an x64 version of Windows Vista, well, God help you. I have no idea what Microsoft was thinking with these products, but after getting over my initial euphoria at how good the hardware support was, I descended quite quickly into software compatibility hell. So unless I mention it explicitly, all the good news here applies solely to standard 32-bit (x86) Vista versions. The x64 stuff is still a nightmare. My guess is that it will always be a nightmare. So unless you have some specific workstation-type needs for more than 4 GB of RAM and very specific applications, please just skip out on x64 Vista versions entirely. There's no happy ending there and your sanity hangs in the balance."
So stay away from 64 bit o/S for a while.

Ta mick

ta mick

by gsaravin9

Nero 7.2.7.0 cannot install on vista by a web installer>You can install it from a cd.
Ta Mick

by gsaravin9

On vista rc1 there are problems that some of the elements will not work.Windows Vista RC1 is a huge improvement over previous Vista versions, and compatibility plays a big part in that success.More needs to be done to show that the os is more compatible.

ta mick

by gsaravin9

when downloading stuff with vista you can experience freezups,loss of connections as the webinstaller is incompatible with vista.
ta mick

by ronaldmcatee

Windows in general is crap! I have had enough with Microsoft and their operating systems! I had never used Linux before and had a big learning curve, but after loading a few versions of Linux based operating systems I have fell in Love with Ubuntu. It loads easy and seems to have most of the programs I need and use as a package... best of all is that it is FREE, and the working group actually supports the product!! If everyone would just give it a try, then we could make Microsoft just and GO AWAY!

by pdschofield

After reading about half of this thread, it looks like the same arguments are being reiterated constantly by the same people - if not, I apologise to whoever is concerned, but I got fed up of reading the same quotes time and time again.

My take on the Vista position is at the moment you have to install it for what it is - Currently Release Candidate 1, it is NOT for a production environment, it is for testing. Microsoft are putting it out there for us to test as there is no way that they can economically test every one of the millions of potential hardware and software combinations that the final relase of Vista will be exposed to. Microsoft want the feeedback, good or bad to rectify any problems or issues before final release.

Seeing supposedly knowledgable people discuss this issue with the closed minded manner that people discuss sports or religion just makes me wonder if the 'Computer Geek' image - who has hardly any social skills and talks in technical language that practically no one can understand - is completly justified.

s for those of us who market ourselves as 'Consultants' surely our position should be that of open minded competency. There is no perfect solution, if there was we would all be using it. Everything has its pros and cons. We should be using our position as learned advisors to ensure that the solution that meets a clients needs best is implimented. It takes a great deal of courage for a consultant to tell a client that they do not know the ins and outs of a proposed solution, but here is a consultant who does. I for one would rather have a happy non client than an unhappy client.
Let the Flames Begin.........

by lavinmansukhani

this is beta. the vista site clearly states the requirements, if u dont have the resources then dont install it.
its good that its not backward compatiable. that way legacy applications
show me one security hole.
i have vista on my pc and it has given me no problems and it works fine.

by moira

I've now installed RC1 64 bit edition which won't even install the CD containing the Biostar SFF fan control program, never mind run it! It seems that Vista will only install programs with signed drivers as well ....

This is a major disadvantage as I don't want to run the computer I've installed Vista on with the fans spinning at 100% all the time, apart from the energy waste it's noisier.

I had a program called SpeedFan recommended, however this too needs a signed driver. IMHO we're miles away from a usable operating system, even now RC1 is out.

by michael l hereid sr

is the drivers do need to be designed for Vista 64 and signed so MS is sure there are no surprises with the drivers.
Mike
PS Fan control needs 64 bit drivers.

by rndmacts

I have been running Vista since April on my machine, I have used Beta 2 and now am using RC1.
True it is beta software and sometimes there are a few gotchas but then thats what the testing program is all about. You report the gotchas to MS so they can figure what went wrong. You don't apply a Beta and expect the finished product.

I haven't met a software program that has balked at being run in Vista either natively or in compatability mode. So far I like it and will buy Ultimate when available.

All you are spewing is things that pro Apple and pro Linux commentators have been saying, no facts just spew. You obviously have no first hand experience as RC1 is not bloated and as Georg Ou stated previously it uses the resources available and manages them to give the best computing experience. I will declare that yes I am running Vista on hardware designed to take full advantage of Vista, but then again it is a real world test. You are convinced that there are major problems in the source code, but where is your empirical proof of such a statement. If there is a problem, point it out, you can't because there isn't one and so there is nothing for MS ot state.

If you wish to slag something, provide proof of your statements because from the general composure of your post you ain't as bright as you profess to be. Unless your original language is not english, I don't know a university that hands out masters to someone bordering on illiterate.

by rndmacts

Digital Signatures don't have anything to do with whether manufacturers can support other technology, that would be illegal in 70% of Microsofts marketplace. If you sat through a partners meeting you would know that Digitally Signed Hardware can only be obtained from Microsoft and is more costly to obtain than earlier liscences. Too many past security flaws and other problems were due to poorly written drivers, that won't happen again. There is another option and that is to have your hardware use universal driver support built into Vista, which also means that some functionality could be lost.

I find it strange you say you are a partner but by the info you are claiming is real are saying that MS is going to break every monopoly law on the books. I have sat through partner meetings and never heard any of what you claim.