Wardriving - Legal or not?
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
Networks
This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post
by stargazerr
He wants examples in which no one does anything physically ...
But who cares ... He isnt a bum .. so why the argument ... ??
]:)
by ejd
by d
by sven thirion
by cumminsd
I think some tend to get ethics and legality confused. To say it isn't illegal so it must be ok is just plain wrong. We don't create laws to define ethics. We create laws to protect our rights.
It's not right to say that if someone leaves their front door open it's ok to go in their house and watch tv. No one is hurt. It doesn't cost the home owner anything. But it still isn't right. Not because it's against the law, but because it's an invasion of privacy. It also isn't right to say that the home owner should lock his door if he doesn't want anyone to come in, otherwise it's his fault. The person entering uninvited is at fault, regardless.
However, that doesn't mean that everyone should stop locking their door. It just means that I feel better knowing that locking my door is to prevent the relatively few bad guys that might enter instead of locking it to keep everyone on the planet from entering.
Techies who think ethics don't exist until someone else defines them cause people to be afraid as much as crackers who are actually doing illegal activities.
by purecoffee
There are applicable laws that state that this is indeed Illegal and one can receive fines and or jail time.
Intereting note are the various laws by state. I believe Minnesota states something to the effect that if you are not smart enought to protect your access than it is fair game.
Bottom line it varies by state.
Here is the link: TITLE 18 > PART I > CHAPTER 47 > ? 1030 Prev | Next
? 1030. Fraud and related activity in connection with computers
by jaytmoon
Unless you were raised by wolves, It really doesn't take the Pope or a Supreme Court
ruling to tell you that jacking into another's wifi connection without permission IS STEALING. EG: you would not take someone's paper off their lawn early in the morning "Just because its There", or someone's cloths off a laundry line, "Just because its There!".
Its absurd questions like this that makes me question the direction society is taking.
by purecoffee
Jaytmoon,
I totally agree that is doesn't take the Pope or the Supreme Court.
People obviously have not been reading the news where there have been arrests and convictions of this very act of war-driving.
I guess they have been too busy stealing to read.
It should be Boneheads since there are more than one.
Sheesh!
by warwizard
Well from the frontier justice of hanging horse thieves, shooting a car thief is in our culture. I suppose there are other places where deadly force can be used to prevent property crimes, and cleaning your shotgun on your front steps is an accepted method of deterring would be thieves.
Now on the discussion at hand, I personally will not use a wireless connection unless specific permission is given. The person that sets up the open access can be held responsable for misuse of the connection, (spamming emails from a wardriver perhaps) possiably resulting in the ISP terminating service. Granted that misuse was from a person with evil greed in their heart, but that is what will drive the legslation, that makes it illegal, so that law enforcement agencys can put a stop to it.
I endorce the policy of knocking on the neighbor's door and informing them that their wireless network is not secure, however I would not tell them to "secure it or I will use it" I might tell them that their signal is strong enough that my portable's wireless card perfers their wireless router over mine. (I use a wired network)Then offer to send them links on to how to secure their wireless network.
warwizard
Did you miss the point? Should i put up some pictures and bribe you to pay attention with blues clues?
I wasnt arguing ethics, i was arguing legality.
Of course its unethical, but its legal.
Oh and forget the bartender annology, because you decide what you want before you ask him. If you cant hold it then you shouldnt be drinking.
You know this is black and white right?
Panerea's know that they will have non-customers accessing their wifi but they have that luxury anyway to satisfy customers.
Everyone in this place is confusing ethics with legality. Just because something is not ethical doesnt mean that it isnt legal.
And just to give you a nice rebudtle, Starbucks has a way of satisfying customers by offering a secured login. no outsiders and the customer gets the wifi.
Back to responsibility.
by wordworker
by fjames1
What's wrong with doing something which benefits somebody else, at no cost to you?
As far as I'm concerned, if I lived in a rural area, I would be perfectly happy to have a water faucet by my front gate, that anyone could use for a drink or to fill a radiator.
I think home wireless routers should have a "public access" option, where anybody driving by could connect, access only the public internet (viz, have not access to the LAN), and use up to 25% of the bandwidth, provided that the LAN users have priority.
by nickinsd2004
by deb.napier
by blueknight
I don't know about other states, but I'd say it's a safe bet they have laws similar to [b]California Penal Code section 502[/b] et seq. Here are a number of snippets of PC 502:
[b]Definitions: [/b]
[pre] (b) For the purposes of this section, the following terms have the
following meanings:
(1) "Access" means to gain entry to, instruct, or communicate with
the logical, arithmetical, or memory function resources of a
computer, computer system, or computer network.
(2) "Computer network" means any system that provides
communications between one or more computer systems and input/output
devices including, but not limited to, display terminals and printers
connected by telecommunication facilities.
(3) "Computer program or software" means a set of instructions or
statements, and related data, that when executed in actual or
modified form, cause a computer, computer system, or computer network
to perform specified functions.
(4) "Computer services" includes, but is not limited to, computer
time, data processing, or storage functions, or other uses of a
computer, computer system, or computer network.
(5) "Computer system" means a device or collection of devices,
including support devices and excluding calculators that are not
programmable and capable of being used in conjunction with external
files, one or more of which contain computer programs, electronic
instructions, input data, and output data, that performs functions
including, but not limited to, logic, arithmetic, data storage and
retrieval, communication, and control. [/pre]
[b]Illegal acts: [/b]
[pre] (c) Except as provided in subdivision (h), any person who commits
any of the following acts is guilty of a public offense:
(1) Knowingly accesses and without permission alters, damages,
deletes, destroys, or otherwise uses any data, computer, computer
system, or computer network in order to either (A) devise or execute
any scheme or artifice to defraud, deceive, or extort, or (B)
wrongfully control or obtain money, property, or data.
(2) Knowingly accesses and without permission takes, copies, or
makes use of any data from a computer, computer system, or computer
network, or takes or copies any supporting documentation, whether
existing or residing internal or external to a computer, computer
system, or computer network.
(3) Knowingly and without permission uses or causes to be used
computer services.
(4) Knowingly accesses and without permission adds, alters,
damages, deletes, or destroys any data, computer software, or
computer programs which reside or exist internal or external to a
computer, computer system, or computer network.
(5) Knowingly and without permission disrupts or causes the
disruption of computer services or denies or causes the denial of
computer services to an authorized user of a computer, computer
system, or computer network.
(6) Knowingly and without permission provides or assists in
providing a means of accessing a computer, computer system, or
computer network in violation of this section.
(7) Knowingly and without permission accesses or causes to be
accessed any computer, computer system, or computer network.
(8) Knowingly introduces any computer contaminant into any
computer, computer system, or computer network.
(9) Knowingly and without permission uses the Internet domain name
of another individual, corporation, or entity in connection with the
sending of one or more electronic mail messages, and thereby damages
or causes damage to a computer, computer system, or computer
network.
(d) (1) Any person who violates any of the provisions of paragraph
(1), (2), (4), or (5) of subdivision (c) is punishable by a fine not
exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or by imprisonment in the
state prison for 16 months, or two or three years, or by both that
fine and imprisonment, or by a fine not exceeding five thousand
dollars ($5,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding
one year, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(2) Any person who violates paragraph (3) of subdivision (c) is
punishable as follows:
(A) For the first violation that does not result in injury, and
where the value of the computer services used does not exceed four
hundred dollars ($400), by a fine not exceeding five thousand dollars
($5,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding one
year, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(B) For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an
amount greater than five thousand dollars ($5,000) or in an injury,
or if the value of the computer services used exceeds four hundred
dollars ($400), or for any second or subsequent violation, by a fine
not exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or by imprisonment in
the state prison for 16 months, or two or three years, or by both
that fine and imprisonment, or by a fine not exceeding five thousand
dollars ($5,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding
one year, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(3) Any person who violates paragraph (6) or (7) of subdivision
(c) is punishable as follows:
(A) For a first violation that does not result in injury, an
infraction punishable by a fine not exceeding one thousand dollars
($1,000).
(B) For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an
amount not greater than five thousand dollars ($5,000), or for a
second or subsequent violation, by a fine not exceeding five thousand
dollars ($5,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding
one year, or by both that fine and imprisonment.
(C) For any violation that results in a victim expenditure in an
amount greater than five thousand dollars ($5,000), by a fine not
exceeding ten thousand dollars ($10,000), or by imprisonment in the
state prison for 16 months, or two or three years, or by both that
fine and imprisonment, or by a fine not exceeding five thousand
dollars ($5,000), or by imprisonment in a county jail not exceeding
one year, or by both that fine and imprisonment. [/pre]
There's a lot more following that but you get the idea... it is illegal to access anyone's network or computer system without permission -- period.
by ziskey
jdclyde,
Good topic, might go over 1000 posts by the time it's over.
In the original post in the "user stories" thread you mentioned you "fixed" the config when you used the connection. Would you care to elaborate? If I were to fix an insecure connection, I would do things like set a wep key, implement wpa, lock down access by macs, change the default password etc... Any of these would have locked out the owner of the wap.
The other issue I could see is virus propagation. Some people that consider themselves a "techie" are certainly capable of connecting to someone else's wifi connection, but they're the same people who download without discretion. If one of these people were to infect an innocent insecure connection, does that change the legality?
by jdclyde
there are so many "what if's" people could throw at this.
The answer is "I don't know".
That is why I started this in the first place. I was hoping for more MEAT in the discussion than someone throwing their own analogies at me to justify if this is legal or not and NONE of them have done a very good job so far (Except for M_A_R_K and Dawg. They have made some real HEADWAY.... :O )
I had done some searches and had found very little, and had HOPED someone that works in this field would have heard of new legislation or enforcement of existing laws.
As for being a techie to connect to someones OPEN wifi, I remember a few years back on the news they had a 10 year old kid walking down the street showing the reporter how easy it was to get in. And if MY users can do WiFi, just about anyone can.
No, I did nothing to lock the owner out of their own box. I think it was dns was set incorrectly? That and a reset later.....
Glad you like the topic. B-) Trying to keep this open, but find myself getting a little short with people that come in and start the attacks. I byte back! :D It seems some people just can't keep things in perspective, nor at a professional level.
By the way, do you STILL think I am a zealot? :^O
by murjo08
The answer to this issue is deceptively simple. Unauthorized use of the connection is theft.
At the heart of the ethical question is NOT whether the Wi-Fi user harms any one in the use of another's connection, but whether or not the user is entitled to the benefit of the resource. In short, is the resource (the connection) theirs to use?
Ethical use of the benefit of the resource comes under one of the two following conditions: 1. Procuring the rights directly from the service provider (paying for the connection), or, 2. Procuring the permission from the person paying for the connection. (Of course, the granting of that permission must be in accordance with the agreement between the connection subscriber and the service provider).
If neither of these conditions exists, then the use of the connection is unauthorized, and the user commits theft. Simply stated, theft is the unjust taking of something that does not belong to you, and the ethical and ethical answer is clear. The connection owner pays for a certain amount of network access, and the unauthorized user diminishes that amount of access, even though it may be only by a miniscule quantity.
The legality of harm done by the theft is the ultimate political issue. Law establishes sanctions based upon the amount of harm done. In this case, is the loss suffered by the connection owner from an individual unauthorized connection was probably very small. As a matter of actual practice, the decision to prosecute or not is based solely moral grounds, it is a political and economic call. However, great loses can be created by many small ones.
My feeling is that a well formed individual moral compass should know that taking what is not yours is wrong, no matter what the amount of loss or hardship it creates. This is the same for Wi-Fi connections as it is for illegal copies of software and music sharing. Stealing from Bill Gates is still stealing as much as taking a homeless person?s blanket. The only difference is the amount of hardship made by the theft.
by mwatch
Very well stated.
ALL of the posts to the contrary are nothing but self serving rationalizations of THEFT. How many more levels of rationalization are required before you end up saying that attractive women that wear sexy clothing can be groped, after all it is not as bad as rape. She was walking on a public street shouldn't you be able to touch all the parts you can see.
It is impossible to legislate correct behavior in every aspect of civilized society. Morality and Ethics should be the FIRST guiding principals.
by sb4
Nothing is ever that simple.
Broadcasting your network over my property is trespassing. You drove you car onto my lawn, leave it unlocked, then complain because I take some gas.
If I could call the police and force you to keep your radio waves inside your property, maybe I'd refrain from using them.
Just a hypothetical.
by paymeister
Murjo08's post was extremely well-written, thoughtful, and mature - a breath of fresh air! And much of the tone of the note suggests that he or she indeed has a strong moral compass.
The remarks about provider agreements was highly pertinent here - they might not like it, and they call the tune.
Murjo08 wrote, "theft is the unjust taking of something that does not belong to you" I am curious about the use of the word "taking" with respect to WiFi access. If someone "takes" my hammer, I can't use it. If someone listens to my stereo, I still have the use of it and nothing has been taken *FROM* me. How does WiFi access remove the ability for the owner to use his own system? If it doesn't remove from him the ability to enjoy his own possession, how is it theft? Obviously, heavy downloading would bog him down, and would indeed be "taking" - but I'm talking about the occasional email.
Steve, you are absolutely correct in most states it is illegal to use the wifi, but it is LEGAL to view the waps.
1 problem, Theft of services isnt a law in all 50 states.
by issinho
I think that the point of the whole "ethical" argument is that You are using something that doesn't belong to you. That being said, you could argue that you are stealing.
On the other hand, there is no real "law" is there? About the whole thing about not missing anything at the end of the day, that would really depend on how you look at it. From a malicious standpoint, an open Wireless AP is an invitation for a spam server, or keylogger, or bank account snatching program. From an inocent standpoint, all I did was check my e-mail and no harm done, right? Well, these are your neighbors. They don't know, obviously, that someone could potentially steal the money out of their bank account. In order to have a "better" world, we need to look out for each other. My opinion goes along with the Network Admin that says "end-user education". Let your neighbors know that their AP is open. Then, offer to help them close it. You never know, they might let you access it from time to time just for letting you help them out.
by eric.p
by techanduser
What you are all failing to realize is that you are accessing more than just the radio waves. The use of some else's network involves the use of their ISP connection and possibly the use of their computer. Any data which you transmit goes through their ISP connection and therefore is definitely an illegal use of the connection. If someone was able to connect to my system, they would be using my phoneline, which is covered by several laws....
[on soapbox]
To sound off on another aspect, the concern about what is illegal vs. just plain wrong is one of the major problems with US society. We wouldn't need so many lawyers and laws, and live with ridiculous lawsuits if people were more concerned about doing the right thing and taking responsibility for their own actions, than doing something they know or suspect is wrong but is legal. We need to teach ourselves and our children in order to get over our current trend. And yes, I am a US citizen.
[off soapbox]
by eric.p
by zeppo9191
by rtomlin
by jafa
by rajanke
Anyway, even jdclyde did not question the legalities in his initial post . . .
He asked . . .
If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is u-n-e-t-h-i-c-a-l?
by fatboy1271
by ksat
I think it would be even better to have each manufacturer include a "setup wizard" of sorts that walks the user through setting up the router for the first time. In this, I believe the manufacturer should include setting security aspects of the router and make a fair recommendation for the situation or environment in which that router is being located.
While I don't believe the manufacturer should be responsible for the security of the device or network, they can easily play a leading role in ensuring their routers are configured appropriately and securely.
by kim luck
by fvrba
This seems like a good analogy.
If you leave the keys in the Jag and it's unlocked, is it legal to take it for a spin? Or maybe the question is, is it illegal? I'm not saying it's a smart thing to do, leaving the keys in the car, and no one I know would do it intentionally. Kind of like not knowing or realizing their wireless access point is open to the outside. You do loose some fuel unless the joy rider puts gas back in for you.
So maybe the problem hinges on the value of the asset that's being used. Without a specific law covering it, it seems it all boils down to what an individual perceives as being OK. Personnally, I'm against using other people assets without them knowing.
On that note, jdclyde, let me know your address so when I'm in the area I don't need to find an R/V park. I'll put my motorhome in your yard and, oh yeh, when the garage door opens I'll borrow some tools because I want to build a picnic table. I won't be done before lunch though so I'll be using your grill and patio. I'll use my own propane though because I don't want to cost you anything.
by jdclyde
As this particular thread goes, I would never take your sheep or cows, with or without your permission and do unthinkable things to them. that would be just wrong! Things don't work like that here in Michigan. I would have to move down to Texas if I wished to take you up on this offer. :O
And just WHO WERE you replying to anyways?
And no, if there is not a law forbidding something, it is not illegal. Which gets back to the whole point of this discussion of asking for what people know about new laws and enforcement of that law.
If you want to throw your OPINION around, that would be in the discussion asking about if it is ETHICAL, not this one that is asking about legal.
If you WERE intending to discuss the LEGAL aspects of this, I would hope you would be more informed than to try to determine if something is legal simply because you THINK is MIGHT be? Show a case, or a law and be part of this discussion, or go get your own cow and be a part of this thread.
by phil.sobol
by eric.p
In the law "intent" is always important. Most people who leave their system open as you describe have no intent to leave it open -- they just don't know how to secure it. Therefore, it would still constitute unauthorized access. Of course, even if they did intend to leave it open, then you would still be faced with the problem of stealing from the internet provider.
A lot of these replies remind me of a bunch of 11-year old kids I used to teach. They thought they were really clever in always coming up with "Well, what if...". You could get sucked into an eternal discussion of unimportant stuff that totally misses the point.
by dryflies
I remember back in the early 90s where I worked they had an RF lab for checking a device we were designing to see if it was producing interference. kind of a first step before doing full Art. 15 testing. Well one day I took a device into the lab and the techs were in there listening (on the spectrum analyzer) to a young woman and her boyfriend having, Umm, an intimate conversation. Apparently they did this almost daily.
As to war driving, wardrivers are stealing unless there is an open and explicit invitation to use the service. A passive device uses less electricity than an active device. Also, it is unauthorized access to a network, which is clearly illegal.
When I first got DSL,(before my IT career) one day I went into my "network neighborhood" and saw all of these other computers. at first I did not understand it, then I thought what the heck, and started looking around. Well there was an engineering firm and an investment broker. Several individuals and various other businesses. The ISP was completely unsecured! Wow! I contacted the ISP and they did nothing.
when I thought about it, I was as vulnerable as the other clients of this ISP. Finally, I rooted around until I had enough information to contact a couple of the larger clients telling them that their computer systems were wide open and the response I received from the ISP. I got two different responses. The engineering firm thanked me and the investment banker threatened me with a lawsuit. I did not bother to contact any individuals. 3 weeks later there was only me in the network neighborhood and my bandwidth improved remarkably.
by tim_barrett
So, what if your neighbor installs an overhead security light outside? If the light also shines on your property, and you use that light to read your newspaper, do you consider that stealing?
What if you buy a pay-per-view video and leave the window shades open while you watch it on your big screen TV. If your neighbors can see 'Smack Down' on your TV from their home and hear it because you're cranking the 5.1 audio, is that stealing?
I agree that running a coax cable across your lawn and jacking into your neighbor's cable box is theft. But if they are transmitting (knowingly or unknowingly) something beneficial that you can use, be it light, music, radio signals or broadband access, aren't they ultimately responsible for securing it?
Everyone agrees that it's a crime to drive away with someone's automobile without permission. So does that mean that the car owner should leave the keys in the ignition or not lock the doors?
It all boils down to reasonable precautions folks. Law or no law - protect what's yours, or don't whine about people 'hacking' your Linksys router with an out-of-the-box configuration.
You have keys to your car, keys to your house, and keys to your wireless. Use them. Because if you don't, someone may take them without your permission - regardless of what 'the man' says.
by eric.p
by eric.p
by nickinsd2004
<< I think most people that do this (myself included) would not if it was clear that there actually is a law against it. How close do you think we are to that? >>
Obviously you do not know the difference between right and wrong if your personal morality requires there be a law to tell you what you can and cannot do. To answer your question, probably a lot closer thanks to the likes of you.
<< If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical? Based on what? The person that left their open access point is missing what at the end of the day? They have been harmed in no way and nothing has been taken from them. >>
Would you like some cheese with your whine?
<< I guess I would also not include a home user that doesn't have their own connection and goes off a neighbor full time. >>
It is the moral equivalent of tapping your neighbor's phone line without their permission and using it to make phone calls. That IS illegal AS WELL AS unethical.
You want wireless access? Park outside a Starbucks!
by hlsathaven
by nickinsd2004
<< ask yourself this: if what I'm doing to the next guy (or gal!) was to be done to me by them, how would I feel? >> That is the golden rule. I would not like it if someone were trying to gain access to the internet through my (assumed) wireless router (unsecured or not) without my permission.
<> To simplify and clarify my feelings: Wardriving (actively driving around in search of an unsecured wireless link to use) is wrong. It is a thief walking down the street looking for an unlocked door. Is that honest enough?
<< Legality aside... >> Legality is not in play here. As the originator posted there appears to be no law against it. The fact that he searched for a law tells me he does have a conscience but he chooses not to use it. Wardriving may not be illegal, but it is immoral.
<< ... it might crystallise in your mind what YOU really ought (or ought not) to be doing. >> Ah... It appears you don't have a problem with wardriving.
by jdclyde
First you STATE as if it were a fact that "It's steaking alright".
Cool, I figure you will back this up with a specific law informing us exactly WHAT is illegal and when. I was saddly disapointed.
Then you go off and say it isn't a matter of law, but ethics?
Ethics conflicts do not equal stealing.
Not sure exactly when you are talking about with the locks, but people have had locks on their doors for over a century.
I guess they wouldn't have had a lock on their cave or TeePee, huh?
Can you restate this, and stick with one or the other. Either the on-topic discussion of legality and refernce the law that makes it so, or the off-topic discussion of ethics, and how doing absolutely no harm to someone is unethical. If I go through the trash they put out at the curb and take stuff, is that unethical too? It IS still theirs until the appointed trashmen take it, after all.
by zeppo9191
If I invite someone to park their RV on my driveway, I would expect that they might be using/borrowing a few things (without explicit permission) that I own. This would include, but not be limited to, my patio, b-b-que, picnic table, bathroom, livingroom couch, television, etc., etc., etc.
However, if you're an uninvited guest who started using these things, this would be considered criminal trespass, because you physically entered my property.
Since someone who taps into my open WAP isn't performing physical trespass to complete the task, it doesn't fit under the legal definition of criminal trespass, and your analogy doesn't quite work.
The question posed by jdclyde is whether it's legal. Too many people are approaching the morals of the issue.
In the first discussion mentioned by jdclyde (the one centered on funny users), I placed a post stating that the moral argument may never be resolved, irrelevant of whether laws are enacted addressing this topic. Everybody's morals are different, and each believes theirs to be correct; otherwise, they wouldn't follow them.
To address your initial question, jdclyde, I don't know of any laws that have been used to successfully prosecute someone for using an open WAP for the sole purpose of accessing the public Internet.
Of course, there have been several cases that were returned with guilty verdicts where someone used open WAPs to do other (esp. malicious) things, but that wasn't how your question was presented.
by rajanke
To quote http://home.flash.net/~bob001/basics.htm
Ethics Explains What's Good and Bad
Ethics is the science that explains the valuing process. It provides a theory for explaining why conduct is considered good or bad. It attempts to answer the questions "Why is this good?" and "Why is that bad?"
. . .
Ethics explains why you believe something is right or wrong.
Ethical theories are the reasons we give for judging one action good and another action bad. These theories are the ultimate reasons we give in answer to the question "Why ought you to do this?"
This does not mean that by knowing about ethics you will make proper moral choices. All it means is that you will be better able to explain why you make the choices you do.
. . .
Moral Absolutism
Right is right and wrong is wrong.
Actions are inherently good or bad, regardless of the consequences.
. . . You may not agree with everything the government does, but cheating on your income taxes is wrong.
. . .
Ethical Relativism
Circumstances alter cases. Everyday standards are good, but exceptions are also right and good. The judgment of good or bad is based upon the result or consequence of the act rather than the act itself. An action is right if it tends to produce the greatest good for the greatest number.
Ethical relativism claims that when two individuals or two cultures disagree on their moral views of an act, both can be right.
. . . "Cheating on your income tax is OK as long as you don't get caught."
So, does jdclyde's NEIGHBOR think it is unethical?
by paymeister
Historically, the question is not "what does the neighbor think?" but rather, "what does God's Word say?" Please save your flames - I ain't preaching, and jclyde asked for justification for one's ethical judgement.
Historically the assumption is that a God exists (regardless of how close we agree on attributes), and that there are standards to meet. The standards are there and are unchanging regardless of whether we like them, follow them, agree with them, know of them (etc.), and the issues of life consist not just of "what is the rule" but also "which rule fits best" and "how does it apply".
For example, Jewish law says that if you hire a man with an ox and it dies, it is the other guy's problem. But if you borrow an ox and it dies, you get to buy him another one. Today's application would be for me to buy you an new chain saw (or repair it). Oxen aren't the big deal, but we still borrow or hire.
So there may be a moral absolute that would apply - though it would seem that there is no "stealing" going on here, and the closest I could come to in a quick inspection of the Westmister Larger Catechism (well-respected in many conservative Christian circles) is the admonition to avoid idleness - supporting jclyde's comment that Joe User shouldn't just mooch off his neighbor. But the use of a neighbor's wireless system (unless you bog it down) doesn't fall under the "theft" or "receiving that which is stolen" or "taking or withholding from our neighbor that which belongs to him" categories. Still, I would encourage the study of Luke 16:10-12, which speaks of being faithful in small things, and Amos 8:5, which speaks of false dealing (streching it, to be sure, but you're still getting through the revolving door on someone else's push).
Perhaps a phone call to the fellow asking if he minded would be in order? Scripture also tells him to "give freely"... though you might start with offering him a beer instead of a Bible quote.
Of course, we all break a goodly portion of the ethical rules every day (of any system you pick), and we desperately need grace and mercy by the truckload. My job is to try not to create the need for the extra truckload...
Again, this probably really IS on-topic, but thanks, all, for your patience.
-Tim
by tim_barrett
Is the bone of contention here access to the WAP, or 'free' access to the internet?
Hypothetically, what about a strip-mall office scenario? Suppose John has DSL from BellSouth with a wireless modem in Suite A, and so does his neighbor Roy in Suite B. They both use Linksys wireless access points. And when John roams his office with a laptop, in some parts of the building Roy?s WAP signal is actually stronger than John?s.
Now, if John?s laptop jumps to Roy?s stronger (and unsecured) WAP, and they?re both using the same ISP, paying the same amount of money per month to the same company, is John stealing? John?s consuming bandwidth from BellSouth, right? And he pays for that bandwidth each month. Whether it comes across a twisted pair or through the air, BellSouth still gets their money. John?s a happy camper.
Personally, I still think that's stealing, simply because even though John is using what he paid for, he?s preventing Roy from getting the bandwidth he paid for. Encumbering him, as it were. But what if Roy already left the office for the day? He?s not using any of his bandwidth at all, right? Is John stealing now? Because he?s not encumbering someone who isn?t even there.
You can argue circles all day long about this kind of stuff... wi-fi, swimming pools, street lights, music, whatever. The point is, if the neighbor secured his wireless (like he does with his vehicles and physical building) then we wouldn't even need to have this discussion.
If your friend?s motorcycle got stolen because he left the keys in it, it?s true that a theft occurred. But it?s also true that your friend is a dork for leaving the keys in the ignition. And he should expect that sort of thing to happen in this world. (That?s why we have locks).
Bad things happen to good people who do stupid things. If you want all of your bandwidth or if you don?t want people browsing your ?Shared Documents? folder (and don?t even get me started on *that* one) then lock it up. It?s that simple. It?s not Best Buy?s fault for failure to instruct the soccer mom who bought the Dlink if someone deletes her Quicken folder. It?s hers. Caveat emptor.
by jdclyde
there are people that sit at a Barns and Nobles or some other open access point and sniff the traffic.
First thing I do is start my vpn. Sniff away. :D
Speaking of "interesting", have you heard of a "Tarpit"? THAT is cool stuff!
by rajanke
You cited . . . "3 people who CHOSE to leave their access points open" . . . and would intentionally use a neighbor's bandwidth to avoid inconvenient trips to the library "if the neighbor doesn't MIND" . . . finally "What harm is it to SHARE what is YOURS with your neighbors ASSUMING no malicious intent?"
You've argued your point using THEIR CHOICE and saying THEY DON'T MIND - - - but then how do you know - - - if you are doing so WITHOUT their knowledge?
Ethically, regardless of any applicable laws, without your neighbor's explicit INTENT or PERMISSION, I don't see any difference between accessing
- - - your neighbor's wireless signal for your personal Internet connection
- - - your neighbor's unguarded outdoor phone jack to make phone calls
Either way THEY have paid for the service. Either way YOU COULD ASK!
by garnerl
1. You're trespassing by walking across the front lawn without permission, not only by entering the house.
2. Using another's wireless is *exactly* like "going into someone's unlocked house" and using their resources.
Whether you break into a home and crack a safe, or take an unattended wallet from someone's desk at work, it's stealing. If you do it and are aware that you're doing it then it is, or should be, illegal. It's definitely unethical in any case.
by marathoner
by garnerl
by joe_t
Call the cable company and ask if they mind. They will tell you that it is theft of service.
Is it illegal to sneak on to an airplane and take an empty seat that, after all, wasn't going to be used anyway?
How about sneaking into an amusement park? Who's losing, they were open anyway, right?
Or perhaps a movie theater.. The movie is going to be shown if you used that empty seat or not, right?
Is it OK if I go into your house and sit on your couch while you watch TV? I mean, come on, that seat WAS empty.
Better yet, let me rifle through your closets.. That outfit isn't being used - I'll help myself!
It's the same thing, and that's the end of the arguement. It's not yours to decide what to do with.
you said the network was secured to break in to that is wrong in any outlook, but that was not the question, the question was unsecured wifi, not secured wifi, it is your responsibility to secure your stuff. if your house or car is broken into the first question the police ask is "did you lock the door" and the insurence, the same question.
the shame is on the manufactures who built the equipment for not makeing it easy and stright foward to set up the privicy also note laws are only followed by good guys ... bad guys break laws so makeing a law only stops what? the bad guys? no.
by jdclyde
The first person to provide a link to validate their claim on the legal vs illegal discussion.
While it DID cover if I had been using that access point to up/down load porn or illegal material it would be illegal.
It also offers the idea that going on that open access point might be tresspassing, thus illegal, but admits that it hasn't gone through the courts yet.
As for "free open access points".
http://www.wififreespot.com/
by zeppo9191
Again, jdclyde's question didn't ask about morals or costs - he asked about legalities.
You're still approaching the morals of the issue, not the legalities.
The point that jdclyde asked about, and the one I am trying to make, is that I know of no laws regarding this issue.
If you'd like to address the issue presented in the original post, I'll debate with you about it.
by jdclyde
the people taking software home from work and loading it on their personal systems?
Oh, but I am just being silly now because that is completely different..... ;\
by zeppo9191
jdclyde DIDN'T ask us to analyze the morals of this issue. He asked about the legalities.
Can ANYBODY answer the question as presented? Does ANYBODY have any DOCUMENTED proof of a successful prosecution of someone using an open AP for the sole purpose of accessing the Internet? I'd be very interested in reading about it.
Please don't post things regarding someone using open APs for malicious purposes. I think most of us agree that there are specific laws that address these situations. Besides, I believe those situations are outside of jdclyde's intended parameters when he started this discussion.
Feel free to correct me if I'm mistaken, jd.
by kim luck
by nickinsd2004
The two (morals and legalities) go hand in hand. Many laws have been written because someone with a diminished/non-existant sense of right and wrong (morals) adopted the position that if it isn't illegal it's OK.
<< Can ANYBODY answer the question as presented? Does ANYBODY have any DOCUMENTED proof of a successful prosecution of someone using an open AP for the sole purpose of accessing the Internet? I'd be very interested in reading about it. >> Don't tell me, let me guess. If there isn't any DOCUMENTED proof, you're going wardriving and if there is, you're not.
We all (supposedly) have a conscience. We all (supposedly) can reason things out. We all (should) know the difference between right and wrong. Just because something is not illegal doesn't mean it's moral or ethical.
by nickinsd2004
The two (morals and legalities) go hand in hand. Many laws have been written because someone with a diminished/non-existant sense of right and wrong (morals) adopted the position that if it isn't illegal it's OK.
<< Can ANYBODY answer the question as presented? Does ANYBODY have any DOCUMENTED proof of a successful prosecution of someone using an open AP for the sole purpose of accessing the Internet? I'd be very interested in reading about it. >> Don't tell me, let me guess. If there isn't any DOCUMENTED proof, you're going wardriving and if there is, you're not.
We all (supposedly) have a conscience. We all (supposedly) can reason things out. We all (should) know the difference between right and wrong. Just because something is not illegal doesn't mean it's moral or ethical.
by rajanke
I post this again . . . jdclyde wasn't looking for the "legal" spin on this. Look back on his original post. He makes the statement "I think most people that do this (myself included) would not if it was clear that there actually is a law against it. How close do you think we are to that?"
Then he specifically asks "If it not against the law, how can anyone claim it is unethical? Based on what?"
So - I think it is OK for the respondants to argue ethics one way or another. The LEGAL questions may or may not be the issue. - I personally wouldn't want to have my decision to use my neighbor's bandwidth without his/her permission come back to haunt me - - - If I ask them and they say its OK, it is no longer a legal or moral problem as far as I am concerned. - - - Now it may violate their ISP's rules, but that would be the neighbor's problem.
An analogy legal -vs- ethical . . . it was legal for SONY to put a rootkit on their audio CDs but was it ethical if the rootkit is installed unknowingly on their computer - possibly damaging the system? That's been discussed to death too - - - In the end, SONY got bit . . .
So the question is(was)Ethics . . . JD asks "how can anyone claim it is unethical? Based on what?"
by rajanke
by realgem
Do you need a law to tell you that something is right or wrong? You're using someone else's property without their permission. Hmmm...what do we call that? Oh, wait! I believe that's called theft!
You're masquerading as someone else in order to get something for free. Hmmm...what do we call that? Oh, wait! I believe that's called fraud.
The name "wardriving" gives it away, doesn't it. It's an attack. It's people like you that cause laws to be required in the first place. Don't play all innocent and say "I didn't know that was illegal". Give me a break.
by gprinsloo
Like a MALL, Train station etc. Unless they have signs, warnings or fences up you CANNOT trespass.
It IS LEGAL to enter ALL public places/spaces in all countries as long as you abide by the laws which govern your behaviour therein.
Same thing applies to your face, its public domain, you dont want it in a photograph then dont go into a public place with it. You dont want anyone on your wireless lan, shut the gates, put up the fences and if someone then enters KICK THEIR BUTTS.
Otherwise if you back yard is open then accept that the kids WILL play ball and the dogs will do their thing all over your lawn.
by tim_barrett
by ziskey
I haven't seen the zealot for a while... maybe in-training?
I hope you didn't think I was referring to you with the example. I was using the word "techie" as a sarcastic example of people who know just enough to be dangerous.
Judging by your posts, I can assume you know what you're doing. I'm guessing your system is probably Linux or at least a protected Windows box. I was pointing to the legal issue. If said "techie" connects and causes virus damage, I believe there would (or should) be legal recourse.
I can honestly say I did the same thing 8 months ago while visiting Wyoming. At the time I didn't think a thing about it. I certainly didn't feel like a criminal, nor did I feel like I just took a joyride in someone's car.
Sit back and enjoy the analogies, they're hilarious.
by dustintabor
It is my understanding that in the USA, we are allowed to transmit on some frequencies without a license. These are, for instance, CB (Citizen Band) as well as the 2.4GHz and 5GHz frequencies as long as they do not exceed 1 watt output..
I would take this to mean that unless the data being transmitted is encrypted, that it is available to the public. Also, if your receiver is set to receive any signal, that is not the senders issue. So I don't think there would be any legal issues as far as using the medium is concerned.
by jafa
by mvmughal
Connection to the internet is not the issue here... it's connecting to the wireless frequency. Wireless is running on public channel free for all to use and paied by tax payer.
It's like listning to the emergency channels on the scanner and that picks up the local emergency folks. They in turn are connected via a paied connection (Trunk) to state and federal. When you hear the local you also hear the state and federal.
When someone does NOT want you to hear they scramble. Why is 2.4 and or 5 Mhz frequencies any different huh! Huh! HUH!
by dohnotgood
by jafa
by rajanke
by cwoolley
JAFA - You live in Tremonton, Utah and have the temerity to call someone else's home 'hicksville'?
Do you know the difference between 'then' and 'than'? Perhaps you shouldn't be correcting grammar and spelling until you learn it yourself...
(Sorry to the rest of you, I couldn't resist ;-)
by dohnotgood
by jafa
Typical....
Most adults have the abilty to exchange differences of opinions without resorting to sensless name calling.. so since that's all you seem to understand... hence my previous reply.
;-)
by dohnotgood
I wonder if you could talk to someone in person about an issue.
Or would you rant like your message?
by dohnotgood
we are getting a kick out of you here.
tell us more
by mvmughal
by lando56
There is a lil' difference between private property and public access. I'm just replying to the comparison attempted regarding this issue.
Wardriving does not involve illegally breaking into someones home and using their computer.
I feel this issue, at its present state, is more of an ethical issue than a legal one. Emphasize - 'at its present state'.
If the legal issue becomes more concrete, e.g. specific laws passed and prosecuted, doesn't the 'owner' of the wireless broadcast (which is broadcasting into the PUBLIC domain) become more responsible? There is a slight problem with the 'expected privacy' concept (why a solid Acceptible Use Policy is needed in companies to be sure the employee knows what is expected considering 'their privacy rights' and what rights the employer has.)
My suggestion to users who set up a wireless access; there just happens to be certain security measures that can be implemented. Granted WEP is considered pretty lame, but at minimum it is an attempt for 'expectewd privacy', and if someone deliberately hacks WEP (for example), then there could be a legal issue (IMHO).
How do I make people aware that they are welcome to use my wifi for internet access, that I am not just someone who was too lazy to read the instruction manual and lock my router down after install?
I agree with you, it is important to treat other people's things with respect. But that shouldn't prevent me from sharing if I want to.
In the physical world, you put up a "keep out" sign to let people no you don't want people in what might be a publicliy accessible location, and then you depend on peopleto respect that. In the Wifi world, WEP is the closest thing to a keep-out sign (Particularly, since it is practicaly useless as a security measure).
Thenmake sure you spread the word to all your neighbors to put up their sign...
by unitrip
There is a very fine line of being unethical or illegal in this case. If I am downtown in some city and just need to check my email or verify I won or sold an item on an online auction is it wrong to use a business connection to do that? I would say no. They did not secure the connection to prevent me from doing it. However, if I leave my car door unlocked that doesn't mean that someone should be able to open the door and sit down to rest after a long walk through the city! I think when it comes down to it, it will be illegal to do and therefore unethical. Until then unless other laws are being broken feel free to use it for small task on their unsecured wireless network.
I am sure the courts will see this differantly!
by dohnotgood
In your scenario, I am tresspassing, invading your private property with the intention of taking something you clearly own (you pay the water bill) without asking or compensating you for it. When a person leaves their access point open, THEY are the ones who are trespassing... their radio waves are zipping by and impinging on someone else's wifi antenna. It is no more unethical to use that than it would be to hear a conversation you were having at the table next to mine at the restaurant. If you are speaking loud enough for me to hear, and not doing anything to guard your voice, I have every right to listen. in fact, YOU are disturbing my peace, as I may be trying to enjoy a quiet meal.
In the wi-fi scenario, perhaps I am a HAM radio operator experimenting with a device in an unlicensed part of the spectrum, which is where wi-fi signals reside, and your noisy access point is screwing up my experiment. Maybe you should turn it off and stop trespassing on MY airwaves! If you can't control you equipment maybe you shouldn't be allowed to have said equipment. Which is what it really boils down to. Equipment manufacturers have made it quite simple to protect your wi-fi signal... if you don't take advantage of that it is your own fault.
That being said, I generally try to let the owners know when I find open access points, but if it was an emergency and I had access to an open access point I would have no qualms about using it.
by jafa
by killerb
by fxef
Here is the computer crime laws listed by states, not all states are listed. I guess some states do not have computer crime laws on the books. You make the call!
by csr-tech
by mpitt
by jyotko
by zig zag
One point that is missed here is that the isn't whether you are stealing, but from whom. If your neighbor were selling access, his ISP would have an issue with it. In the case above, you are still stealing from the ISP. The neighbor does not have the right to disseminate "his" access unless the ISP specifically allows it. Most specifically deny it. Just because you arenot stealing from the neighbor, does not mean that you are not stealing.
I use a rule that I call the "5 year old" rule. As you may or may not know, 5 year olds are very "balck & white" and they keep asking until they understand. So the rule is this: if you can't explain why it is OK in terms that a 5 year old can understand, it probably isn't OK. For example, if you can't explain the why it is OK to illegally copy music and not OK to take a CD from the store, you shouldn't do either. Both are stealing in a very real sense and any 5 year old would understand that. And keep asking "Why?" until you finally give up.
If you can't explain why it is OK to grab a signal out of the air and use it (either a little or a lot) and not OK to dial into an ISP (or tap into their bandwidth some other way), then it probably isn't OK.
This 5 year old rule usually really clears up ethical issues.
by smadge1
https://www.techrepublic.com.com/5208-6230-0.html?forumID=9&threadID=185648&messageID=1903778
if you are operating a wireless network without securing it, that is offering a public service, whether you are ignorant or not...
by mwatch
Yes it is that simple!
If you dropped your wallet on the street is it no longer yours?
by hlsathaven
I believe war-driving is wrong (period).
What is interesting, and believe me, I'm NOT being judgemental here, is how easy it is for (different) people to interpret other people's statements in different ways! I thought I was making it clear that I was against war-driving, but there you go, you thought differently. Just goes to show how careful one has to be in stating one's views. (I nearly used 'you' instead of 'one' there, then realised that could be mis-interpreted!)
Sort by Trending