Discussion Locked

Why is IT nearly all male?

0 helpful
630 replies
Closed to new repliesThis discussion is closed. It stays readable, but it takes no new replies.

This is page 3 of the discussion. Read the opening post

630 replies

by m_a_r_k

maybe he's really trying to flirt with you. :D

girli, all kidding aside, you do seem to have a love-hate relationship with several people here. I've noticed that some guys jump all over you no matter what you say. You know, the ol' "sky is blue; sky is orange" thing. I guess that's the price you gotta pay for being such a controversial little lightning rod. ;) That's OK. You can't please all the people all the time, and all people can't please you all the time. And I have no business giving anybody any kind of advice about that sort of thing because I can be as prejudiced and bigotted (?) and hate-mongering as anyone. But I digress...I think you're cool. Keep up your controversial lightning roddedness. :D

by jck

I won't address you in any way from now on...until the point you make roundabout comments involving me or my comments.

Then, I'll start again and after that I won't hold back words and will probably get removed as a user.

Again, I'm clamming up. We'll see how long it takes you this time.

Enjoy the peace while you let it last.

by jck

Trust me. Your hypothesis is wrong about me and my intentions.

I know you're jesting, but I don't want to leave any doubt.

by jaqui

in emergency situations 90% of people, both male and female, have an automatic emotional response, called panic.
of the 10% remaining, 9.8% are trained to the point of overriding that automatic response.
the other 0.2% are freaks that do not react normally.

any sudden realisation of a problem causes this reaction, it's the ancient fight or flight reflex kicking in.

by djhuff

I'm a woman who's been in the IT field for about 20 years and I've seen women come and go. Here's the thing - it's just not that sexy of a job. It really isn't. I'm a CCIE, MCSE, CNE and I've been the only woman in many of my organizations. As a matter of fact, I'm now a Global Director of Networks and I'm the ONLY woman in the organization in management. I've been to DeVry classrooms and technical colleges to speak, and seen many more women than men sitting in those chairs. However, I've seen so many women graduate with an associate or bachelor's degree in IT, take their first IT job and INSTANTLY hate it. The thing is, this job is work. Constant, demanding work. It's about keeping up with trends, new technologies, constantly studying to either gain or maintain a cert or keep up with those who have that cert. It's a lot more time than most women have to devote to a career, because outside of our career, we usually have a family to take care of, much more so than a man. Not to be sexist, but in a traditional family role, the woman is usually the prime caregiver - chief cook and bottlewasher (that's a whole other discussion, let's just leave that one alone). It's tough to spend your downtime from work reading the latest Cisco manual, if there are dishes to do, baths to give, etc. And above all else, the job is just not that sexy. Hardware upgrades? Router configurations? Intrusion detection? Just not that sexy. Marketing, Human Resources - now that's sexy and fun! Check out those departments, guys. That's where you'll find the ladies. Am I being sexist? Maybe. I'm a woman, I can do that against my own kind, huh? But being a woman in a man's world, I can tell you that although men don't always make it easy for us, it's usually our choice to bow out. You guys like those Cisco manuals, or the latest Red Hat guide. It's light reading for you. I'd rather read a good book.

by apotheon

That's the point I've been making elsewhere: you have to love IT for its own sake, else your sticktoitiveness is going to suffer significantly. If you're not a computer geek at heart that finds the O'Reilly [u]Linux Network Administrator's Guide[/u] and Asimov's [u]Robots of Dawn[/u] equally fascinating, you're going to discover that IT is a lot more work than you'd bargained on when you first got started. The reason long-time successful IT professionals come across as such high-octane experts in esoteric fields of knowledge is that they spend a [b]lot[/b] of time learning about their field and applying that knowledge. It's about shell scripts, network topologies, and hardware compatibility lists, not pinstriped suits, client meetings, and your own parking space.

You're absolutely right: there's nothing glamorous for the usual careerist inside the IT field. If you don't love it, you'll hate it. If you're not a workaholic, you'll be out of work. Companies demand more from their IT employees for less compensation than just about any other department's employees, but the people that are really good at IT will do it anyway because, to them, it's fascinating subject matter. The heyday of $80k starting salaries straight out of college are over: people are starting to notice that IT is Real Work.

Women tend to notice that more than men, or at least are more willing to admit that realization to themselves.

As I've said elsewhere, you'll get a higher woman to man ratio in IT careers when you've got a higher woman to man ratio of people who just love computer systems administration enough that they'd do it whether they were paid or not. Until then, you're SOL for your career field statistics.

by surflover

Girli probably said it better, but I have to say that's probably the most insightful post in this thread... although there were a lot of posts that claimed that the ratio was more balanced, my experience has always been one of a very male heavy environment... and as girli said, I concur, you rock! :-)

by jdclyde

and more than half were keeping their jobs because they were eye candy instead of anything that they actually did.

The few that were left made me feel like I need to go take some more classes!

To balance this out. Many men in IT are useless too and have their job because they are pretty boys, yes men, or son of the boss.

It is so nice that MOST I talk to in here are not the bimbos of tech.

The one woman I work with is NOT a tech. Petty and insecure are the two words that perfectly describe her. Too bad she isn't at least eye candy. :(

by m_a_r_k

Sounds to me like you're perpetuating the old female stereotype. You say there aren't many women in IT because the job is not sexy, it's too demanding, working with hardware is only a man's domain, etc. Are you saying that women run from unsexy, demanding jobs? I beg to differ. And yes, that does sound sexist. IT is not more demanding than many other jobs. I think it is LESS demanding and stressful than most jobs. Sure, there are more trends and technologies to keep up with than most jobs (and that keeps it interesting) but who says women in general find constantly changing jobs boring or too demanding? What about medical care? Nursing is dominated by women. It is an extremely demanding job that changes as fast or faster than IT. And nursing has loads of technical equipment that has to be mastered.

by apotheon

Come down here on the ground with the rest of us who have to live in the real world. Whether or not something is considered "sexist" by the political correctness cops has no effect on whether it's an existing social pressure. I don't think djhuff was saying that women are intrinsically incapable of being interested in "unsexy" jobs, only that the tendency is for women to avoid them. Like it or not, we live in a world where women pigeonhole themselves according to gender stereotypes as much as they accuse men of doing so, and that may well include avoiding a job that isn't "sexy", or that is "too demanding" in some way.

As for your claim that IT jobs are less demanding than other jobs, that all depends on what you consider to be a demanding characteristics. While IT jobs don't usually involve hauling lumber all day, swinging hammers, grubbing around with drain snakes, or scrubbing floors, those jobs have a specified set of hours after which the workers typically just go home. On the other hand, as my employer's network and systems administrator, I clock about fifty or more hours a week and spend probably an additional twenty hours or so doing things that improve my work-related skills. More than seventy hours a week is definitely "demanding" in some ways, even if I spend more time at a desk than away from it during the workday.

You seem to have missed the fact that djhuff's statements were about perceptions and social trends, not inherent capabilities. There's nothing sexist about noting what people seem to be thinking. Hiding from the truth doesn't make you a better person, just more ignorant.

by av .

If you're responsible for a network or project, you have to be willing to put your life on hold as needed. Many women can't do it because they are the primary caregivers to their families. Thats probably why there are more men in the field than women.

I don't have children, so I can be more flexible. I love IT, but I didn't love the long hours and have to say after I was downsized from my fortune 500 corporate job, I didn't want to ever go back.

It just wasn't worth it to me and after my 20 years in the field, I have finally found a balance in an IT job that is not purely technical. I would say my job is now 50% managerial and administrative and %50 technical. I also work for a smaller company.

I think IT can be sexy. You have alot of certifications, but I've always approached IT from an experience point of view. To me, there is nothing more exciting than implementing software or hardware that exceeds expectations. Planning, implementation - when it all works like you thought, it is just extremely satisfying. Very sexy.

by ldyosng

of a genuine geek girl? I'm really more tech than geek - an aircraft mechanic by training, a data wonk by necessity (and because it's FUN.) I'd much rather play with computers than airplanes, though. But women like ITGrli make me look like a moron by comparison. I'm pretty good at what I do, but I still feel like a rank amateur so often.

by apotheon

A genuine geek, as opposed to a wannabe or pseudo geek (to sorta coin phrases, perhaps), is someone that is absorbed by the technical aspects of a thing. To put it in the most common "geek" terms around here (computers), a computer geek is someone that habitually has the sides off his system case, extra cables and parts lying around his bedroom, learns a scripting language, reads system administrator manuals for fun, and is easily led into lengthy discussions of the comparative advantages of various operating system architectures. A faux geek is someone that knows what the best benchmarking 3d graphics card on the market is at a given time, buys Alienware systems without ever opening them up, and spends all his time playing Diablo.

There can certainly be some crossover between the two, but the salient point is that a "genuine" computer geek doesn't just use a computer as a tool for entertainment: to a geek, the computer [b]is the entertainment[/b].

You can apply much the same principles of identification to other areas of geek interest, of course: a band geek loves learning and playing music while a mere band member loves the fact that the sax gets the girl; a literature geek can get lost in books for hours and will spend inordinate amounts of time thinking about the characteristics of various writers' styles rather than simply aiming to be well-read so he can impress others with his skillful application of deconstructionism to the task of criticism and analysis; an autoshop geek will fix others' cars for free, while a mere autoshop student thinks it might get him a job some day and help him spiff up his car so it'll look cool and make loud noises.

That's my take, anyway.

by ldyosng

Thanks, apotheon. Maybe I am a real geek. Just not an uber-geek. Either way, playing with this electronic lego is fun.

by becky roberts

The fact that many IT jobs demand out of hours work and/or travel may also be a factor as many women with children prefer to be at home with them in the evenings.

by carole-y

TinyURL... I dig it. It's so cute I just want to scoop it up and put it in my pocket.

:)

by surflover

anyone who has seen an ER nurse deal with a guy who planted a motorcycle on the pavement at better than a safe xway speed can attest that they can be cool as cucumbers in a crisis... I don't think women "act" from emotions as much as their frame of reference is founded in the emotional realm... when I speak to female colleagues about a situation, I'm much more likely to get information about the participant's feelings and reasons for actions than I would from a guy... and I've seen many more incidents where a guy will blow up at a situation, where a female does not (although I've also seen them fall apart in private after the fact)... perhaps it's because they consider the feelings of the person they'd like to blow up at before they do (I don't think we (guys) think about the feelings of those around us very often, certainly not often enough)...

by surflover

I'm glad this wasn't done on paper, the rain forests would have suffered a significat loss :^O

by cuteelf

It included whips and duct tape...remember?

IMO, the reason why women aren't in IT as much as men are:
Back in CHILDHOOD we are not as encouraged as the boys are for science and technical work.

During HighSchool we are not as encouraged & enthusiastic- we learn about "glass ceiling" "discrimination" and existing, hanging prefabricated roles for males and females.

During College we are welcomed, but feel..outside the group.

I recall being asked many times as a child what I wanted to do. School teacher? Stay at home mom? Nurse? (mostly female-filled positions).
I said no, I want to be an 18-wheeler truck driver. I got REALLY strange looks from adults for that one.

During HS there was a 60/40 breakdown of boys vs. girls in the Honors classes- early geeks. Not too bad, but a lot of the girls didnt stay with science/logic/technical.

During college I felt out of place sometimes, being the ONLY FEMALE IN A CLASS OF 30 PEOPLE. Its not that I was ridiculed, its that it was FREAKING OBVIOUS I was the only woman.

I have been welcomed in my jobs and appreciated for my skills so far in this field. This is something I want: equality. And, you know what? I think IT is a lot more equal than...Police & Firefighters for example.

I think this job I'm doing ATM actually hired me because I'm female- Only girl in the office! And, yes, I'm critiquing, troubleshooting, documenting, and really working to make it smoother for all of us. I'm using logic, thought, process, and technical writing.

But I do expect the men to be a bit..harsher judging me and my skills, so I'm trying more at home to study and be a good learner. I have detected a bit of..slack..towards me, as deference to a woman. (guys will let me cut in, open doors...small things like that)

I am glad that I'm a woman: I get noticed. One decent looking chick in a field of geeky men with gadgets?? Sheesh, put me in a bikini and yall's would be melting! I get noticed. I have skills. I get a job.

I wish more women were involved, and I hope schools will push the girls a bit towards logic/thought/technical skills.

My 2nd grade teacher Mrs. Duffy told me "Girls play with girls, boys play with boys". I told her to stuff it, because I liked boys better. They weren't whiney and they had cool ideas, compared to the stupid Barbie dolls and home-making stuff.
I got in trouble, of course, but look where I'm at now? Kiss my 4$$, Duffy.

CuteElf

by apotheon

Are you sure it wasn't that attitude that got you hired? If I were the hiring manager, that'd be high on my list of reasons to consider you, I think.

by mgordon

The T/F axis on Myers-Briggs MBTI is, by some reports, gender aligned about 60%/40% with men tending to be "T" (Thinker) and women tending to be "F" (Feeler).

Inasmuch as we are talking about INFORMATION technology, a thing that by its very nature deals with facts and data, I would expect overall to have about a 60/40 ratio.

CuteELF reports this very ratio in high school, but it falls apart after that. Why shall we suppose this is so? We have seen some pretty silly reasons but not much deep thought.

Public service is not a reliable indicator of preferences because those employments are "tweaked" by affirmative action policies. I worked for a GS-13 black woman, team leader of the LAN team at a large government installation, who had spent several hours trying to get a PC to boot up. It kept saying, "No operating system." There was a floppy in the slot.

Besides the 60/40 ratio on the T/F axis, we also have management styles. Women tend to set up a mode called "Democratic" or management by consensus; the fallback of which (in case consensus fails) is Coercive.

So far so good; but what has it got to do with ratios in the workplace? It is this: We all work for someone; even the entrepreneur works for customers. Conflict is more or less unavoidable, also, someone must schedule the work and someone must do the work. Men and women generally have very different methods of doing these things with the result being a type of vertical gender alignment from the boss down; if the boss is a man very likely the downstream chain of command will be men. If a woman, very likely the downstream chain of command, such as it might exist in that case, will tend to be women. It is so even in the Navy which is supposed to be gender-blind. This is sexist on the face of it, but it is also more efficient, and inefficient companies cannot survive.

Finally, in a free world, it doesn't take much preference shift to capture ALL of an audience. I remember when "Flash Gordon" came out at the same time... well I cannot remember it, a movie by and about a famous song writer, I can even play the elevator music in my head -- Jazz Singer or something like that, came out. The line for "Flash Gordon" was 99.9 percent men, with one girlfriend dragged along; and for Jazz Singer, the line was entirely women, except for one boyfriend. (The Old Mill Theaters in Los Altos, California). When someone spoke to it, the misfit boy and girl exchanged places, making the "Flash Gordon" line 100 percent men, and the line for Jazz Singer, 100 percent women. Does that mean I prefer Flash Gordon 100 percent more than Jazz Singer? No, my preference was only SLIGHT; but mirrored by everyone in the line.

Men sometimes want power over machines. Since a computer is the ultimate machine, that kind of man is attracted to Information Technology. Those men that want power over people do not usually choose I.T. as a profession.

Women very seldom want power over machines. It's stupid. If they want power, and they usually do, it will be over people or animals.

Consequently, such women as you find in I.T. will more often than not be in management or customer service; or even a truck driver installing cable modems -- anything where human contact and perhaps control is a factor. Women sitting invisibly behind a tall rack, laptop computer plugged into a Aux port on a Cisco router, typing in IOS commands -- I've never seen it -- but by definition, how would I? She's invisible, just as I am when I am doing that very thing. So it may be more common that we men suppose.

by why me worry?

sheesh, IT departments could use some more techie hotties to give us geeks some eye candy to drool over...LOL

by edycus

My reasoning is mixed. I think everyone can pretty much agree that Women are more emotional then men. And Men are more logical (OK logic minded) then women. Both are needed in every work place. The technical side of IT is a very logical world. You trouble shoot from start to finish in a logical fashion. Let me just say up front. I know some IT women how can kick my work in the IT field and make me look I was in IT kindergarten playing with my abc toys. I feel it some by women?s choice and little bit of logical design. Men love logic women love puzzles.

by apotheon

If you "think everyone can pretty much agree that [w]omen are more emotional than men," you probably haven't been reading the rest of the discussion.

by jdclyde

stop applying logic to an emotional statement! People are stating OPINIONS, which describe how THEY FEEL about something. Is that logic or emotion?

Now that the dog is done chasing it's tail, while YOU quite obviously do not fit in the "generalizations", how do YOU think other NON-IT women fit? Are YOU the exception or the rule? My personal OPINION is the first.

by mustang sally

Puzzle logic is more big picturish and relational in nature than pure a--->b--->c linear logic. And yes women see relationships better than men. Obviously you see this more in a social setting but it's equally as applicable in relational database design, for instance.

FTR I think the logic vs. emotional mindedness explanation is way too simplistic anyway. That presumes that only logical (and very linear) minds excel in IT and that's not the case. IT requires lots of different skillsets - a purely linear thinking logical mind can be an asset only in a very specific function. In many others it's actually quite detrimental. You need non-logical, touchy feely people skills in IT too - to provide quality (and non condescending) tech support, accurately capture user requirements, organizational skills to successfully see an implementation project through, verbal/communication skills to provide good documentation and effectively communicate with other team members, other departments, etc.

But those ather skills are not recognized/advertised well enough to potential female recruits.

by absolutely

There are no rational reactions from either gender, so I'll rephrase: do you see women (in real life, not TV) lose their tempers as often and as badly as men? Males and females may have tendencies to express different emotions, but there is nothing rational about your premise that thinking logically and expressing emotion are mutually exclusive. Logical people still have emotions. Mr. Spock was [b]fictional[/b].

by jdmercha

I've studied the martial arts for over 15 years. I've noted that women are much more likely than men to get angry when sparring.

I would agree that there is no rationality to it. It is only the result of a statisitcal analysis. And only an interpretation of the analysis at that.

by maecuff

And when a male and female get into a fender bender situation, who gets more emotional? It seems that more often than not, men come out with their hands in a fist. I would say that is emotional. The only thing you are proving, is that humans react emotionally in given situations. Men and women.

by jdmercha

I got this information off a show on the Science Channel. And there are many examples to disprove it. I can relate to your child example. I too would freak out, while my wife took care of the injury. But I would definately classify my wife as having more of a tendancy to act from emotions. Still it is only a tendancy and she will act 90% of the time from logic.

by m_a_r_k

You misintrepred what I said. Go back and read djhuff's post, then read mine. I basically repeated what she said and followed up with comments or questions. If my asking a logical question or offering my comment means to you that I'm on a high horse, then that's not my problem. You're attitude is typical of many people here. I have little patience or tolerance for people like you who do not allow someone to ask questions of another person. If that's your cup of tea, then join the Taliban. Personal dialogue and objective debate is the greatest learning tool there is. Get your nose out of your Cisco manuals and ask questions of people and learn about the real world.

djhuff herself brought up the point about being sexist. And do you think that IT jobs are the only ones where people work long hours? hah! Talk about riding that stupid horse of yours! Open your eyes, pal. I used to work for a public accounting firm. Most demanding job of my life. It was a 24x7 job. And we didn't haul concrete or shovel sh!t. Tons and tons of paperwork, long hours, a lot of travel, demanding deadines, unbelievable pressure from our management and from clients, explain and document every single thing you do for the client and be ready to back up every stinking decision with a thorough answer, zero tolerance for f-ing up. I don't know about your IT jobs, but most of mine have been 40-45 hours a week with the occasional busy week or two to meet a deadline. You brought up social trends? djhuf rebuked current social trends. Women are moving TOWARD male-dominate professions, not away. Twenty years ago you saw very few women "swinging hammers", as you put it. Today it's not at all surprising to see a hammer-swinging woman. If they can swing a hammer or click an icon with their mouse or do any other demanding job such as that, more power to them.

by apotheon

"[i]I basically repeated what she said[/i]"
. . . with spin on it.

"[i]If that's your cup of tea, then join the Taliban.[/i]"
Ooh, the new form of the "You're a Nazi!" argument.

"[i]Get your nose out of your Cisco manuals and ask questions of people and learn about the real world.[/i]"
Try arguing against my statements rather than insulting me.

"[i]do you think that IT jobs are the only ones where people work long hours?[/i]"
No. What gave you that silly idea? I said it has long hours, not that no other job does. You're the one making unrealistic statements about the IT industry, like the fact that it's not a demanding career field. It damn well is a demanding career field, and I was simply pointing that out.

I've been in more demanding career fields with longer hours, but like the way Alaskan natives sometimes tell Californians to stop complaining about the cold when it's 45 degrees F. Guess what: 45 is cold. It's just not as cold as -30. By the same token, my 75-hour work week is long. It's just not as long as the 140-hour work weeks I sometimes had when I was in the army. I said the hours in IT were demanding: I didn't say they were the most demanding hours of any career field. Exaggerating my statements so you can make fun of them doesn't make for much of a valid argument.

"[i]rebuked current social trends. Women are moving TOWARD male-dominate professions, not away.[/i]"
. . . and yet, IT careers have seen a decrease in the percentage of women in recent years. It peaked in the '90s, then dropped off significantly. At one point, it was close to 50% women in IT, and now it's closer to 20%.

by m_a_r_k

Thanks for calming down and replying in a somewhat adultified manner. :D

[i] . . with spin on it.[/i]
Of course I did. Why repeat verbatim what ol' Hillary Duff said? And I don't believe in plagiarism.

[i]Ooh, the new form of the "You're a Nazi!" argument.[/i]
Quit complaining. I could have accused you of being a Democrat.

[i]Try arguing against my statements rather than insulting me.[/i]
Not a Cisco fan? Sorry for insulting you...let's replace "Cisco manuals" with "Windows Update Release Notes".

[i]You're the one making unrealistic statements about the IT industry, like the fact that it's not a demanding career field. It damn well is a demanding career field, and I was simply pointing that out.[/i]
That's a personal judgment about any job. Depends on who you are, what kind of work you do and who you work for. Hasn't been extremely demanding for me. Especially considering the salaries compared to other equally demanding jobs. Great pay, decent hours, little travel, variety, lots of cool gizmos, a sense of accomplishment. Only bad thing is not many women in IT. Only 20% according to one industry expert. ;) If you wanna know the truth, I left the good ol' IT world for a while, took that awful job at the accounting firm and realized how good I had it back in good ol' IT. By the way, long hours is not the only thing that makes a job demanding.

[i]At one point, it was close to 50% women in IT, and now it's closer to 20%.[/i]
Seems like a huge drop for any industry. I trust you like my best friend, but I'll need at least two reputable sources verifying this number before I'll believe it. You're talking about tens of thousands of female employees. Even more astounding considering the entire IT work force has shrunk in the last five years (recession, tech bust and outsourcing). Unlike a certain someone, I don't have specific numbers.

:^O

by maecuff

to point out the painfully obvious.

Actually, I have a younger sister who is a corporate trainer and she is extremely logical. Then again, I have another younger sister who acts on emotion only. My point, that I've tried so hard to make, is that it depends on the PERSON not the GENDER.

I think that we are all conditioned from a very young age to accept that boys are rough and tough and don't cry and that girls are touchy feeling and get all emotional. And while I'm sure that does help mold people into who they become, it doesn't necessarily mean that is who they ARE.

Yes, I will say there are differences between men and women. Thank god. But I do not accept the whole emotion vs logic. That smacks way too much of weak vs. strong. And someone else, can't remember who, pointed out that you can't really compare the two things anyway. It's apples and oranges. All people are emotional. All people have potential for logical thinking. My sister, the emotional one, man..I don't think she's had a logical thought in her life. She's extremely talented and very smart, but very flaky. On the other hand, my ex, who IS in IT, really wasn't much of a logical thinker. In fact, I've often wondered why it took him so long to make the transistion from being a programmer to going in to sales.

by mustang sally

"We're people that, if we got pregnant (assuming the biological equipment to do so), would spend a lot of time on maternity leave reading O'Reilly texts because that's what we think of as fun. We're the people that, if kept out of work on disability leave for several months, wouldn't fall behind at all in our understanding of emerging technologies because we don't just "do IT" when getting paid for it"

So while you're taking all this hypothetical free time on maternity leave reading up on O'Reilly and keeping up with emerging technologies, who, pray tell is breastfeeding the small, helpless, screaming infant every 2-3 hours? Changing his/her poopy diapers? And in the precious hour or two you MAY get in between feedings, trying to you know... SLEEP let alone get some form of sustenance down your own throat (and that of your partner), dishes washed, groceries bought and clothes cleaned?

Contrary to popular belief, maternity leave is not a vacation. New moms do not sit around eating bon-bons while the adorable child coos happily in their crib for extended periods of time. It's more like a gruelling extended marathon. You come to understand why sleep deprivation is considered a form of torture.

Design a line of diapers that has paragraphs of technical text on the butt instead of Elmo and you may get some of that reading done. The only technical manual I was interested in reading while on maternity leave, however was written by a pediatrician on the subject of how to coax a few more precious hours of sleep out of the screaming child so I could get 30 minutes to either shower or nap. And believe me it's a complete tossup. I have never been so exhausted, so physically and emotionally drained as I was during the 5 weeks I took off. I was THRILLED to come back to work to get a break. And that was WITH my husband also being off work during that time and shouldering a huge load of the household chores. Most new parents don't have that luxury.

This comment, however I agree with: "If you want more women in IT, you need to find the girls who are naturally inclined toward working with computers and encourage them to enjoy it."

It's about early socialization. Once puberty hits girls are taught that their self-esteem should be dependent upon not only being found physically attractive by boys, but being romantically involved with a boy. And "Boys don't make passes at girls that wear glasses." Next time you're in a 7-11 take a look at the magazine rack. Do you see any glamorous pictures of geeky girls in front of a computer screen? Not unless they've got doubleD cleavage (pointy ears helps) and a come-hither look on their face. Even the geeky boys prefer the hot cheerleaders to the shy, mousy girl sitting in front of them.

When I was in high school I was 1 of only 2 girls taking AP Physics. There were perhaps 6 taking Calculus. This needs to change.

The #1 thing you could do to encourage girls to love computers? Market computer games to appeal to them. For most boys, computer games are the vehicle that drives this early love of computers you want to encourage. But most games are violent, gory shoot-em ups that don't appeal to girls. Nevermind how women are portrayed in them. They're proportioned even less realistically than Barbie, and that's saying a lot.

by maecuff

Okay, you don't have fender benders. But I'd be willing to bet that you still get my point.

by lesko

wish we had more women here in IT who had the attitude of cutelf

hehehe

by surflover

Why'd you even give him close? (definately no cigar)... When my grandson was born, I took a couple weeks off to help my daughter out (I never had an infant of my own, all my kids were adopted)... and I never went without so much sleep in my life... I don't know how women who have a succession of kids survive it... if she has another one her husband's relative will have to pull floor duty, I don't think I've got it in me :-)

by mustang sally

is all part of that touchy-feely chromosome I'm suposed to have 2 of. So I try to read generously. And I do agree with most of what he says - just feel he's being a bit obtuse on this one issue and too proud to concede the point. That's supposed to be another male female thing, I think - women are more interested in developing consensus, men in winning the argument no matter who they alienate in the process. Some men, even when they atually agree with 90% of what everyone else is saying will continue to exaggerate the remaining 10% they don't agree with (or just as common - start arguing with the WAY someone else said something) in order to see themselves as "winning".

by apotheon

I'm not too proud to concede a point when it's warranted. I just know better than to believe that there's no leisure time at all in raising a child. If that was the case, we'd all have been neglected, underfed waifs without parental guidance. Yes, you lose sleep. Yes, you have to (for instance) breastfeed every few hours. Yes, you have to change diapers. On the other hand, if you can spend fifteen minutes every three hours reading, maybe you should. I know I've seen women read while breastfeeding, have people over to visit while watching their children play, and watch television while their children sleep.

If new parents really truly never had any time to do anything but take care of the kid, they'd commit suicide far more often. Stress levels of the sort that occur with child-rearing aren't sustainable to the degree you're suggesting. People break down if they go too long without any relaxation time.

Yes, it's hard work. It's not 100% of your time, though, and sometimes you can do more than one thing at a time.

If you really want to go on believing that it's impossible to ever read anything at all while raising a child, though, you go with that. It looks to me like it's [b]you[/b], of the two of us, that is looking for a way to "win". You're the one that created a point of contention here, by exaggerating the hard work of child-rearing to the point where one hasn't the ability to do all the things people do with their time while child-rearing.

If you have time to watch Oprah and daytime soaps while raising kids, you have time to read. You just need to give up some TV to do it. If computers aren't more important to you than television, you've just proven my point.

by maecuff

And again, I think it's just easy to accept the stereotypical IT person. I have developers (2 female, 1 male) who are all very good at what they do. And they can effectively communicate with users, vendors, whoever. They are all responsible for their own documentation, at one point or another, they all head up meetings. And you can't tell the difference between them and anyone else in the company. I do have one employee who is horrid at communication. He is also NOT my most technical person. He's just an ass.

by apotheon

. . . but men getting angry when people run into them isn't any indicator that they're more emotional than women. I imagine that women, thanks to their unequal upbringing, often burst into tears. I know they tend to exhibit strong emotional reactions more often when pulled over for speeding, at least from what I've seen.

Anger isn't the only emotion.

by maecuff

Neither is crying the only outcome of an emotion. Fear, surprise, loathing, hatred, love, disgust... all emotions. All humans are capable of feeling and reacting to any of these and many more.

The whole bursting in to tears thing..sheesh. Bursting into tears isn't the only outcome to any emotional feeling. Okay, it's not to say that it doesn't happen, but I don't know many women who burst in to tears easily. There are some, but I've known men who were prone to tears also.

The point is not so much HOW people react to emotions, but rather women reacting EMOTIONALLY versus LOGICALLY.

by lauracs

...they are tired of having to work twice as hard to be considered half as good, and still get paid 79 cents on the male dollar, and then be called beotches because they aren't happy about it. Personally, I try my best to get along with every one, but I definitely understand where the angry women are coming from.

Anyone who believes that affirmative action is discrimination is probably not looking at the true mechanism, or how it is applied in most circumstances. There are plenty of anecdotes out there about white men passed over for incompetent minorities, but personally, I have never, ever, seen this happen. Laws and policies around affirmative action almost always only require that a concerted effort be made to outreach to diverse groups, not to hire from them at the expense of white men who are better qualified. The evidence is obvious. In spite of affirmative action and "quotas", the field is still predominantly white and male. Women still have to be twice as talented to be considered half as good. I have been working in IT for years, and haven't seen much of a change in that. In my opinion, 1 women to every 5 men is never "a lot" if you are looking at the numbers in a meaningful way.

by apotheon

The Supreme Court found it unconstitutional to enforce affirmative action quotas. When quotas were mandatory, better qualified people were being passed up all the time for people who were hired on the basis of helping reach the quota. It was so bad in some industries that companies were having to aggressively recruit minority individuals who weren't even looking for that type of job, and put a freeze on hiring for other purposes, just to get compliant.

Since the lifting of mandatory quotas in those areas, things have settled down and gotten sane again. Now, only a few governmentally regulated organizations and educational institutions use a quota system, and their quotas are considerably less aggressive.

Affirmative action outreach programs are great. I'm all for it. Affirmative action quotas are terrible, and should go the way of the dodo.

by mustang sally

"If you really want to go on believing that it's impossible to ever read anything at all while raising a child, though, you go with that."

Where did I say it was impossible? This would fall under "exaggerating points of contention to feel like a winner". I was speaking of my experience during 6 weeks of maternity leave. Not a lifetime raising a child. The first 3 months are the hardest. After that your body somehow learns to cope with no more than 4-5 hours of sleep at a time. The funny thing about being a new parent though is you get kind of attached to the little bugger - makes committing suicide much harder. Otherwise you would see the rates go up. When older parents tell you "having a kid is the hardest thing you'll ever do" it's no exaggeration. I thought it was - afterall, any dumb idiot can have a kid (and they do)- what kind of special talent could be involved? Stamina, that's what.

Your initial point made *new* parenthood sound like an absolute cakewalk (though I see you've backpedaled from that elsewhere a bit). I could care less about winning - I care about understanding. My point was to correct your misunderstanding.

If you choose to continue to perpetuate a negative stereotype of technically minded new moms though (watching Oprah & daytime soaps) go right ahead. Be part of the problem and not part of the solution.

As much as I hate to prove you wrong, I've somehow managed to attain a successful career in IT without spending every conceivable free moment reading manuals. Same thing goes for the other women I know in IT. And amazingly enough - applies to quite a few of the men I know as well. Even more amazing, most of the time the last thing I want to do when I get home is dink around with my home PC. Kind of like the professional carpenter whose own house is falling apart. I do love to play with new software on the company's dime/time though.

When I do have time to watch daytime TV I much prefer the Discovery channel and PBS. But then I'm funny that way. I agree with you that instilling a great technical curiosity in young girls is necessary to get them into IT. I'm a perfect example of that. But that's just the start - it's nowhere near the total solution.

by cibreez

It takes a logical, detailed-oriented, problem-solving mindset, which are mostly characteristics of men. Being female and new to the IT world, other women around me want nothing to do with the details of a computer, etc. Those of us who aren't into the barbie, miss-prissy, gossipy, mindset enjoy other interests. I enjoy the challenges and was told it takes a "thick skinned" female to make it in this industry. My response....bring it on :)

by crabbyabby86

I like this discussion. It's got quite a few different points of view, and quite a few different points in general, which only makes sense. This trend isn't caused by just one reason.

Yours is definitely my favorite post. And I'm glad you pointed out the problem-solving mindset. That's monumentally important.

However, I got a new one to add.

Girls aren't getting excited about computers from the beginning.

My high school had a two 12-student classes of the CISCO networking academy, and when I was a senior, it was just me and two other girls out of the total. Now I'm a freshman at university, and I'm one of three girls from the fifteen or so new computer science majors (and the other two are currently considering other majors). I understand this is a national trend at four-year colleges and universities.

My school's computer science department as a whole has declining recruitment AND declining retention. Just fifteen new CSc majors at a campus with 5000 students is worrisome from the start. It's looking like just six of us are sticking with it through this year. We've got a very literal 5:1 guys-to-girls ratio.

In a recent discussion with some fellow computer nuts on campus, a point was made that maybe the media's scaring us about outsourcing is one reason recruitment and retention are so low. And it's true that outsourcing is a problem, but as a whole IT people are in more demand than ever. But media scares are pretty tought to fight.

And that would also make sense as to why more guys are willing to see it through: guys are simply more willing to take the risk. Women like security, and we'll recognize outsourcing as a risk to that security, at some level or another.

So... I guess one of our problems is that we're not very savvy advertisers. As higher education becomes standard for employment, more ladies (and more people in general, really) need to be recruited to the computer science departments at four-year colleges and universities. And it's just not happening.

I was really lucky to be so thoroughly supported in my tech geek goals through high school and currently. And I was even luckier to have attended high school at one of the best public schools anywhere, with the best tech department in the state. I had lots of opportunity to dabble in the field before I even got to university, and I loved the challenge.

'bring it on' pretty much sums it up for me too. :P

by apotheon

I never said bursting into tears was the only emotional reaction. I just pointed out that your reference to men being angry in fender benders was hardly an indicator that men are more emotional, since anger isn't the only possible reaction.

The truth of the matter is that men are "trained" by social pressures to tend more toward anger than women, and women are "trained" by social pressures to tend more toward tears than men. Thus, if you see a bunch of men shaking their fists at traffic accidents, I suspect there are as many women sitting in their cars crying under the same circumstances. Everyone's going to have an emotional reaction to a car accident: everyone. It's a scary, adrenaline-starting event.

What makes the difference is not whether someone is having an emotional reaction, but whether that emotional reaction is affecting the person's ability to make a sound decision under pressure. I don't care much if you're shaking your fist or have tears streaming down your face: if you jump in your car and drive away, leaving the scene of the accident without at least talking to the other person, you screwed up.

by apotheon

"[i]Where did I say it was impossible? This would fall under 'exaggerating points of contention to feel like a winner'.[/i]"
Actually, it falls under the heading of "this must be what she meant, because otherwise she hasn't said anything that disagrees with me, and she was definitely disagreeing." See, I wasn't saying mothers have all the time in the world and that maternity leave is just a vacation. I was just saying that someone that really loves the subject matter as much as some of us serious computer geeks won't go cold turkey.

I'm still not sure why you're digging so hard for a point of contention. Are you just looking for a reason to disagree so that I, being a male who suggests that there aren't more women because women aren't trying as often to make careers of IT, can be wrong?

"[i]I was speaking of my experience during 6 weeks of maternity leave.[/i]"
Six weeks isn't enough to really fall behind, anyway, so I don't see how that's relevant.

"[i]Your initial point made *new* parenthood sound like an absolute cakewalk[/i]"
Only if you were looking for a reasons to disagree with me. Go back and read it again. I never suggested any such thing. Period.

"[i]My point was to correct your misunderstanding.[/i]"
The misunderstanding was yours. In fact, if you go look at some of that "backpedaling" you say I did a little more closely, you might find that some of it happened [b]before[/b] the comment in which you seem to think I said motherhood is a vacation.

"[i]If you choose to continue to perpetuate a negative stereotype of technically minded new moms though[/i]"
You're a real piece of work. You just really, really want me to be a bad guy, I guess. If that's what you want to believe, I can't stop you.

"[i]I've somehow managed to attain a successful career in IT without spending every conceivable free moment reading manuals.[/i]"
Speaking of exaggeration to try to "win" . . .

I was pointing out that part of the reason there aren't [b]more[/b] women in IT is that there aren't [b]more[/b] women who love it enough to do it in their free time. I never said everyone in IT has to spend 100% of their free time doing IT-related things. That's your exaggeration talking.

"[i]I agree with you that instilling a great technical curiosity in young girls is necessary to get them into IT. [. . .] it's nowhere near the total solution.[/i]"
I never said it was.

You're having an argument with someone that doesn't exist. I never made the claims or suggestions you seem to think I did.

by apotheon

"[i]Thanks for calming down and replying in a somewhat adultified manner.[/i]"
I've been calm the whole time. I, for instance, never accused anyone of being a member of an authoritarian sexist despotic regime of religious tyrants because they disagreed with me. You, on the other hand, have done just that to me.

"[i]Quit complaining. I could have accused you of being a Democrat.[/i]"
Them's are fightin' words. Take 'em back, or I'll make you scream "uncle".

"[i]Not a Cisco fan? Sorry for insulting you...let's replace 'Cisco manuals' with 'Windows Update Release Notes'.[/i]"
The problem was with the fact that you chose to imply the only reason I disagreed with you was the fact that I was a socially inept dork who spent all his life in a [foo] manual rather than spending any time in the "real world". Besides, Windows is far worse than Cisco could ever be.

"[i]Great pay, decent hours, little travel, variety, lots of cool gizmos, a sense of accomplishment.[/i]"
Your experience with one or two jobs doesn't constitute the norm for a career field. I guess you're just lucky.

"[i]By the way, long hours is not the only thing that makes a job demanding.[/i]"
I never said it is. In fact, I very specifically pointed out that it is.

"[i]I'll need at least two reputable sources verifying this number before I'll believe it.[/i]"
I'd start with Wikipedia, but this Cogent vs. Level 3 pissing match is screwing with my Internet connectivity here at work.

"[i]Even more astounding considering the entire IT work force has shrunk in the last five years (recession, tech bust and outsourcing). Unlike a certain someone, I don't have specific numbers.[/i]"
As things got more nasty in the IT industry, with wages dropping and getting hired becoming more difficult, the rate of women getting in has dropped faster than it has for men, and the rate of women dropping out has increased faster than it has for men. Makes sense to me. As for outsourcing, keep in mind that this only reduces the overall workforce numbers in the US. The offshoring/outsourcing is largely going to countries where societal pressures making IT a male-dominated field are much stronger than here, contributing to an increasing gender divide in the industry, as long as you're willing to count more than one country in your statistics gathering.

"[i]National Science Foundation researchers reported last year that women?s share of IT jobs dropped from 33 percent in 1990 to 26 percent in 2002.[/i]"
http://www.fcw.com/article88536-04-11-05-Print

I don't recall where I saw a figure closer to 50%, but I've seen figures indicating it was up to about 41% in 1996:
http://www.awise.org/?q=node/1179

As I poke around, it looks like the percentage of women in IT might be doing a dead-cat bounce, and we may be up to about 30% now, but that's still not what it once was, and I think it's a US-market statistic that doesn't count other nations where it's less than 10% or, like India, it's on the rise and was closing in on 20% a couple years ago.

by maecuff

I guess it was to point out that 'tears' aren't the only reaction to emotions, just as you pointed out that anger isn't the only emotion. And again, I'm trying to get away from the 'why women cry and why men don't' thing, that's a different discussion. What I'm trying to get back to, is no matter what has been said thus far, I don't see a compelling argument that proves women usually act on emotion instead of logic.

I guess if we go by sit-coms, romantic comedies and romance novels, we have all the proof we need. I just don't believe that an entire gender falls into that role. I don't think it is gender based.

by apotheon

There are studies whose "professional" interpretations seem to contradict your opinion, but such interpretations have been wrong before, and such professionals sometimes overlook some important detail that would be obvious to just about anyone else. The only reason I really even got involved in the discussion of the studies in question, for the most part, is the fact that I tend to be put off by people making accusations of chauvinism just because someone dared to quote research.

The whole deal is clearly more complex, it seems to me, than a mere case of emotion vs. logic.

by m_a_r_k

...the name Hillary Duff. It's "djhuff", not "hjduff". I bet you thought I was gonna admit to being wrong about everything else I said. Not on your life! haha

[i]Your experience with one or two jobs doesn't constitute the norm for a career field.[/i]
One or two jobs? Oh hardly! I gotta stop a second and count up all the places I've worked since college...I'm at my eighth company. I'm pretty good at math and one thing I can tell you is that 8 is a lot more than 2. Of those eight companies, only three have sucked. And only two have been demanding. Lucky or the norm? I'd venture to say I'm in the norm. Maybe a "demanding" job depends on the job function. I've spent most of my career in engineering as a software developer. My detour into public accounting as an IT auditor was the most demanding, most suck-ass job I've ever had.

[i]National Science Foundation researchers reported last year that women?s share of IT jobs dropped from 33 percent in 1990 to 26 percent in 2002[/i]
I'd like to know what is defined as an "IT job". I've never really thought of my work doing R&D as an software engineer as being IT. To me, IT is database administration, network stuff, help desk, etc. and not necessarily design and development. That's just me though. Some people don't consider golfers to be athletes. So who's to say? I didn't see a drop in female software developers or managers in the 1990's. But even a drop from 33% to 26% wouldn't be that noticeable. Only 3 or 4 fewer women in a typical department of 40 or 50 developers. Those numbers of 25% or 30% seem about right.

by maecuff

I wouldn't presume to understand or even claim to have read such 'studies', I can only go by my own personal day to day experiences, including my own and the people around me.

My stepdaughter and I were walking last night and we discussed this issue. She asked why someone couldn't be emotional and logical? Which kind of gets back to the point that it's hard to compare these two things.

by apotheon

1. If it went from 33 in '90 to 26 in '02, and it was 41 in '96 (as another statistic I indicated), that means that it has dropped from 41 to 26 between the mid-'90s and 2002. Thus, the drop is rather more than 33 to 26, from the peak to a point more recent. I saw several references to a drop of 18 or 20 percent, too, but never found the specific percentage numbers of women in IT that went with that.

2. If your jobs have all been software development, and you don't consider software development to be IT, then I have no idea why you're trying to use your own job experience as an example of how IT jobs aren't very demanding. Are you arguing just to sow contention and disagreement?

by m_a_r_k

[i]"If your jobs have all been software development, and you don't consider software development to be IT, then I have no idea why you're trying to use your own job experience as an example of how IT jobs aren't very demanding. Are you arguing just to sow contention and disagreement?"[/i]
You're quite the little antagonist, aren't you? [b]I[/b] don't consider s/w development to the [i]prototypical[/i] IT job but most people probably do lump in that category. It's kinda the same thing as most s/w developers not wanting to be called a "programmer". But a lot of job statistics list "computer programmer" but not "software developer" or "software engineer". I'd be willing to bet that s/w developers are included in those statistics that you pointed out.

by tink!

There are way too many posts to read on this discussion, but I think that there are more women in IT than is widely known by the public.
I've noticed that technology commercials are showing more women. Plus if you read articles in magazines, you'll see a lot of women in the upper IT Management positions.
We're out there, believe me!
Tink

by tink!

Ok, I as an IT Professional, personally do NOT know many women in IT. I've actually only met 1 other woman so far who can build a PC from scratch, and knows the ins and outs of publishing softwares and color printers.

But that does not prove that there aren't a lot of women in the profession. I work in a small environment. I'm sure the big cities boast plenty of knowledgeable women in high-tech positions.
Tink

by itjunkie

Same reason why they aren't custom car buffs, sports fans, racing fans. Computers are to most poeple are tools, but to those of us that know all about them. They are like custom cars or sports teams...

In all my career thus far I have never worked w/ a female IT person. My guess is they just don't see computers they way most men do. Believe me it's not becuase they wouldn't get hired. =)

by acp2g

I came to this site for technical solutions, direction, conversation, etc., etc.

Didn't realize it was a debate site.

by apotheon

If you want technical discussions, you probably shouldn't be in the "miscellaneous" section. Check out Tech Q&A.

All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy. All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy.

by stuzzi

I have been working in this field since 1986 when there were virually no women. Early on when I talked to a vendor about buying parts I was asked if they could speak to the person in charge. I said "I am the person in charge". They assumed since I was female I must be a sectrary or don't know what I was taking about I put them in there place and only dealt with vendors who did not do those kind of things.
Other times people would ask me why I was in this field, like it is inconceivable that a woman could love the IT field.
Things ahve changed for the better but we still have a long way to go. And for those who are wondering, I am not a feminist.

by jeffhunta

Since this is an IT forum so I should explain that the above title is a JOKE! So take a deep breath and smile. Everything will be ok. There are women in IT who are just as qualified as the next guy while there are other women who are about as useful as floppy disc. Sure. There might be more men in the field but couldn't that just be a reflection of the entire workforce in general? Or better yet, maybe chicks don?t dig computers?
It is my personal theory that fewer women choose to pursue a career IT resulting in fewer women in the industry. Why anyone would actually chose to enter the IT industry is totally beyond me. After 10 years of this crap, I am so ready to move on. But seriously, let?s think about it.
I think most people would agree that men and women think differently. MOST women tend to think emotionally and MOST men tend to think logically. I know I am treading on thin ice here, but these are generalities. There are always exceptions to the rule. So hear me out.
If we follow the line of thought that women are emotional and men are logical, we can presume that most women would not be attracted to a career in IT where logical thinking dominates. I mean really? Isn?t everything in IT painstakingly specific and precise? Doesn?t everything have to follow exact protocols? Hell! We use words like protocol. That should be proof enough. It all boils down to ones and zeros. I mean? Doesn?t that just sum up most men?s thought process?
Take my previous employer as an example. I used to work for a large apparel company as a programmer. How many men were in the Design Department? 1 out of 14 and he was gay. How many men were in the Art Department? 4 out of 12. How many women in IT? Zero. The team was made up of 8 dorky guys, all in love with the Art and Design Departments. Truthfully, most teams of IT guys would welcome the possibility to work with qualified females in their industry. I?ve seen a lot of you guys out there and working with a woman on your team might prove to be the only contact with the opposite sex you?re ever going to get. I kid, but not really. Anyhow?
If there is indeed a shortage of females in IT, I say it?s only because women generally aren?t satisfied with working in the dull, anti-social, cold, world of bits and bytes. And if you ask me, they are smarter for it.

by maecuff

And so original!! I don't think I've heard too many 'men are smarter than women' jokes before.

Again. Logic and emotions are apples and oranges. You can have an emotional person who thinks and works in a logical fashion. These are not mutually exclusive things.

Dull, cold, antisocial world of bits and bytes. What a stereotype. My employees and I are rarely bored. In fact, not too many days are the same as the day before.

All humans are emotional. There are degrees, but we are all emotional, it is how we are built. If you feel no emotions, then you are dead. All humans have the potential to think logically. It isn't gender based.

by itamazon

While there is a higher percentage of males in the IT world, I have worked in the IT industry for over 15 years. I have worked with many women, myself included that are very interested in the nuts and bolts of computing and have held engineering and management positions. Many may not think that women are interested; however, that wouldn't be true.

by afigment

In the last company I worked for about 1/3 or the IT staff were women. We worked in all positions - programers, system analysts, IT mgmt & field services. The CIO is a woman. I worked in field services and for some reason, all of the women that worked in my department had the busiest zones that we were responsible for. Whenever a man had those zones, they could not handle the pressure. LOL

My zone was one of the busiest zones that consisted of 25 medical clinics & hospitals scattered around NE Florida that I was soley responsible for their computers & printers. Plus, if one of my coworkers was out or needed assistance, I would help in their zones also. Just call me Wonder Woman!!!!

by why me worry?

Forgive me if I sound cheuvanistic, but many IT jobs specifically state that the candidate must be able to lift and move heavy equipment (e.g. servers) and be able to work in a fast paced and highly stressfull environment. Unless this woman has arms like those of some bodybuilder or is shooting up steroids, I doubt many will be able to even budge a 300lb server. Granted, I did work with a female systems administrator in a public sector job I held over 4 years ago, and when it came to hauling 300lb servers around, she always asked me to do it because she would kill herself or crap her pants if she tried to lift that thing up by herself. She was a nice lady and had nothing against her, but the problem I saw with her was when systems were crashing and the situation turned chaotic, she would panic, have a bitch fit, and simply run off somewhere to avoid the madness, leaving me to solve the problem. Is this the kind of IT professional that this industry needs? The IT industry needs people, whether they be men or women, who will take on the task at hand and deal with the challenges, not emotionally charged people who will throw a fit and hide under a desk when the going gets tough. A previous poster did say it correctly that men think logically, while women think emotionally.

by maecuff

We have very little need to constantly haul 300 lb servers in our shop. We did take delivery of a 1034 pound server and rack, but we let the IBM guy unload that and move it around.

In my shop, I have one person who is quick to react emotionally and wants to walk (or run) from the situation. This person is one of the 3 males in my department. The 7 females in my department have proven to be calm and collected when faced with any situation.

People believe that woman think 'emotionally' because it's convenient. Oh..and we're also more manipulative and deceitful. The truth is, while men and woman may traditionally act a certain way in given situations, women aren't more or less emotional. I've never felt the need to yell and scream and curse when things go bad, or when I'm angry. I've seen a lot of men react that way (very emotional, eh??) I've seen women break down and cry over the silliest things. But that is definitely the exception, not the rule. We don't all stand around with hankies in our hands waiting to squirt out tears at the first sign of adversity, any more than every man is just waiting to scream and yell.

This whole logic versus emotion is ridiculous.

by why me worry?

I'm not generalizing or trying to stereotype, but was simply describing my own personal experiences working with a woman in IT. My latest jobs rarely have any women involved in IT, as most of them are in the HR and Finance dept, as a previous posting mentioned. I think that the traditional role of women is somehow burned into women as young girls, so they tend to shy away from predominantly male roles for fear of being called a "Tomboy" or looking too masculine. There is nothing wrong with if women work in IT. Us geeks could use a few more ladies in this field, because we rarely get to interact with women in the workplace and it would be nice to see a woman's perspective on IT issues.

by oz_media

Sound chauvenistic that is.

I have yet to meet more than a handful of pasty skinned geeks that could move a 300lb server. You claim that a woman would have to have the arms of a bodybuilder to move heavy IT equipment, now I don't know what planet your employees are from but geeks and IT nerds RARELY have the arms of a bodybuilder. Perhaps the age 30 something waist of the Goodyear guy but rarely the arms of a body builder.

Now as far as women I've worked wit hin IT, I've heard women grunt and groan while lifting heavy hardware, but generally only when their skinny dork of a manager can't do it himself.

To generalize women as weak was wrong too, I have done a lot of work for a Professional womens wrestling tour and would say that some women are MUCH more capable than men when it comes to brute strength, but not all of course. Just as not all men are stringer than women.

The whole physical issue is not one that can be generalized that way, this is not a reason there are more men than women in IT.

by why me worry?

I was always a computer geek, since I was a teen and starting building my own computers from scratch. In my teen years, finding a date was quite difficult because no girl I knew of wanted to be seen with a "geek", "dork", or "nerd". Simply because us guys know the inner working of a computer does not make us any less desirable or less sexy. The teenage girls were all drooling over the braindead jocks and football players and didn't even give us the time of day. With this said, I believe this whole "computer nerd" image is why girls avoid this industry because they are somehow being given a negative or unpopular image of IT and what it's all about. No girl I knew of wanted to associate herself with dull dorky guys or guys whose only interest were computers and nothing more. Well, fast forward 20+ years later and these same dorks are now wealthy business leaders and the popular jocks are now auto mechanics and plumbers barely supporting their families, assuming they have one. The toy industry is partly to blame as well, because they keep pushing their traditional barbie doll mentality and not enough gagdets and techie stuff that would appeal to girls. My sister had a PC when she was a teen, but she barely touched it nor had any interest in learning how to use it. Like I said, this industry needs a facelift to become more appealing to the opposite sex.

by oz_media

"Simply because us guys know the inner working of a computer does not make us any less desirable or less sexy. The teenage girls were all drooling over the braindead jocks and football players and didn't even give us the time of day."

You didn't like the nerd generalizations. Yet you generalize 'jocks' as brain dead? I know exactly what you are saying, it was the same when I was in school. I was a headbanger, that played sports and fit across several social groups though. Each one generalized the other and more often than not, incorrectly.

Why didn't girls hang out with nerds? Many reasons, nothing in common would be a biggie, girls liked to go out and do things socially, nerds wanted to sit in the basement working bugs out of moonlander. Girls wanted to be with strong men that would care for them (this is a genetic instinct bred into women many thousands of years ago), nerds didn't fit that bill. Nerds isolated themselves from the social aspects of school, cute girls usually embedded themselves in the social side of school.

If you feel that nerds were given an unfair rap when it came to cool, it wasn't unfair. Nerds DID isolate themselves and turned their noses up at girls they 'figured' they couldn't get, they called althetic guys "braindead" just to make it all seem like someone else's fault other than their own that they chose not to develop social skills and instead sit at a computer.

And yet another assumption and generalization:
"Well, fast forward 20+ years later and these same dorks are now wealthy business leaders and the popular jocks are now auto mechanics and plumbers barely supporting their families, assuming they have one."

Wrong, I became a mechanic by choice, I am also an MCNE, I am also a business development manager,can't pigeonhole that one. And in most cases, the mechanic and plumber make more than you do anyway.

"No girl I knew of wanted to associate herself with dull dorky guys or guys whose only interest were computers and nothing more."

YOu said it, they wer DORKY GUYS and those who's only interest was incomputing. Is that a stereotype or simple reality?

In order to find your social match, you need to find common interests, if you have nothing in common how can you blame society for creating animage that is accurate?

What a heap of self pity, perhaps you need more than a discussion forum to get over these scars and realize that you had a choice which social group you chose in school, if you chose to be with one isolated group you cannot blame others for not choosing it also. Another question you need to ask is did these girls avoid you JUST because you wer einto computers? Or was it how you dressed, what you read and watched, who you associated with and what you found interesting? You are being just as shallow as the women you accuse of being shallow.

by Member 25348569

Seems like you've been missing over the Summer. Nice to see you back and - wow - how you've mellowed. Time was when you'd have really told that w@nker what for!

Neil

p.s. Have you got yourself a spell-checker?

by rayjeff

I didn't even think of that. You have made a very valid point. I'm not harping against women going into IT, but...

by apotheon

Why should I give a hot damn whether I get a "woman's perspective" in IT? I don't want to hear a woman's perspective. I don't want to hear a man's perspective, either. What I want is a clear-headed, intelligent, thoughtful, well-informed perspective that addresses the needs of the moment and the needs of the future. Last I checked, a projected technology needs analysis for the coming year, printed out in twelve-point font, doesn't get any better or worse just because it has a few extra X chromosomes in the epithelials smeared on the page.

I'd rather judge by the individual than the gender.

It's very much worthwhile to examine the social forces that are keeping women out of IT, and to analyze trends. I don't agree, however, that it's worth my time go about mooning over the need of a "woman's perspective". Show me the job candidate, and I'll let you know whether I think [b]it[/b] is qualified: I say [i]it[/i] because, while I think it's a good thing we're hiring people, I don't think performance of the job really depends a helluva lot on gender.

That aside, I can think of two reasons it might matter to me whether more women get into the IT industry, and neither of them has anything to do with "a woman's perspective":

1. If more women get into the field, the field gets more competitive. I welcome competition in the field, though, so this won't bother me much.

2. If more women get into the field, it means there are more women interested in computers, which might be a positive indicator for my dating life. Frankly, I'd like to date a girl at some point who knows what unix is without having to be told, and who doesn't consider my computers competition for her affection just because I spend a lot of time with them.

by oz_media

"so they tend to shy away from predominantly male roles for fear of being called a "Tomboy" or looking too masculine."

Between your comments abotu being body builders and now that it is a masculine field I am just rolling!

Since when was being a geek cool?
Since when was a being a computer nerd a masculine role?

We aren't talking firefighter here, we are talking about a field plastered with pasty skinned dorks with no social skills.

I don't knw anyone who sees IT as a MASCULINE field at all. It isn't cool, it isn't seen as a field for hard working, well built men at all.

It's where all the kids we beat up in school for being misfits ended up.

You don't see too many calendars with shirtless, IT guys holding hard drives while flexing their muscles. Masculine field! :D

by oz_media

First of all, in response to your post, get bent.If you camn't follow the simple truth then it's no wonder that you are still dwelling on the fact that you never got laid in school.

The original post here pi55es me off more and more when I read it. It's a completely ignorant and stereotypical comment To read comments that evenfurther elaborate that pig headed andcompletely baskward train of thought is just plain scary. It's like reading the Deliverance memoirs "or sumthin' laak thayat" I didn't think anyone with such a retarded mindset still existed in the new millenium, you have proven me quite wrong indeed.

But the mentality behind it is also shown in your eloquent reply, way to prove your point!

by gkchege

Where I come from, it is difficult to find a gal that copes with maths, physics, electronics or other science that is pre-requisite to most I.T courses. They consider these subjects difficult and simply lock their very capable minds to these subjects.
This throws them out even before they can put one foot forward. Affirmative action does not help either, it only makes it easier for the few that decided to take maths seriously to get jobs. Gals must learn to appreciate these high school course or be prepared to do a lot of pre-university college/foundation courses.
In any case, the IT of today is not 100% dependent on how good you are at maths/physics or other high school course. We have 14-yr olf CCNAs in record! Why not that well capable ladies?
I stand corrected, my take is that it's their own fault! Failing to try after all is exactly equal to trying to fail!

by maecuff

I LOVE cliches, they really get the point across. Failing to try is trying to fail..if you fail to plan you plan to fail..what else can we come up with??

What the hell is this? The Twilight Zone? Is the Midwest really ALL that different from the rest of the world? I've been a consultant and have been in and out of MANY IT shops and I haven't seen this whole 'not too many women' phenomenon.

We gals can't cope with math and physics or electronics? What school did you go to?? The Ward Cleaver school of Technology?

You know, just because you heard the sound bite "Girls find math difficult" at some point in your life, doesn't make it true.

Why is it that we don't see posts that start out.. "Why aren't there less men in IT?" Perhaps it's because we women aren't quite as threatened by another gender? Maybe some of you see this as us gals muscling in on your territory?

by Member 25348569

It's just that these post from Oz are almost readable so I have to reckon that he's either got a spell-checker or a better keyboard!

Happy Monday

by pete1978

This is a good question, but, so far, there is not a single answer. My wife is working on her PhD in Education. She has presented papers on gender equity on more than once (don't worry, she isn't an extreme feminist ... her research also asks the question about why more males do not go into fields like language arts and social sciences). Since I proof her papers (including presentations) for her, I've read her research.

There are many factors that seem to influence this. But most of the research seems to point to social gender bias as the primary source of this and most of the bias seems to come from the family and home. Most of the research points out that, until more families believe thinking that females can be engineers and scientists, we will continue to have a preponderance of men in engineering and science fields. I know that many people don't like the idea that the family is blamed so often, but consider how much time a person spends at home compared to the time they spend anywhere else and it quickly become clear that the home is the major source of influence on a young person.

Good news ... there is a trend toward more female students entering these fields. But, like all other bias, it will take time to overcome these problems.

Most recently, I've been teaching classes at a technical college. About 1/3 of my students have been female. That is an improvement over the past when fewer than 1/10 of the students in technical classes were female. Times, and bias, are changing.